Letter Name Learning in Early Childhood Literacy Letter naming is a strong predictor (along with phonological awareness) of phonics acquisition and reading fluency (Evans, Bell, Shaw, Moretti, & Page, 2006; National Reading Panel, 2000; Treiman, Weatherston, & Berch, 1994; Stage, Shepard, Davidson, & Browning, 2001). Letter Name Learning is a Constrained Reading Skill. Scope – Finite set of 26 letters (52 with upper and lower case) Learning curve is steep Time period is relatively brief Importance – Centrality to process of becoming a reader Typicality of the process of becoming a reader Range of Influence Limited to the process of developing decoding automaticity Found in the earliest stages of literacy development Letter Name Learning is a Constrained Reading Skill Unequal Learning – Some letter names and sounds are learned more easily, quickly and deeply than others. Result of unequal exposure rates to letter names and sounds. Mastery – Letter name learning is mastered early, quickly and completely. Universality – Letter name learning needs to be learned by all learners. Letter name learning is composed of identical information or learning elements. Letter Name Learning is a Constrained Reading Skill Codependency Previously reported positive correlations between “constrained” early reading skills and later acquisition of “unconstrained” reading skills are not shown to remain stable at later points in reading development or skill acquisition. Letter Name Learning time should be constrained Letter name learning is not the end-all, be-all of early literacy instruction. Copious amounts of instructional time also be allocated for students to build rich networks of world knowledge and word meanings . Six Stances or Guided Principles for Letter Name Learning 1. Letter name learning is both universal and important for young students. Because of this, letter name instruction is vital for young students to learn to make progress in early reading. 2. Letter name learning is a “constrained” reading skill. Because of this fact, instructional time and attention given to letter name learning should be similarly constrained to allow for other learning to take place. 3. Letter names are learned “unequally.” Because of this classroom letter name instruction should give increased time and attention to those letters that are learned less easily and quickly. Six Stances or Guided Principles for Letter Name Learning 4. Letter name learning should be taught regularly to promote students’ complete mastery of the entire set of 26 letter names and the commonly associated letter sounds in kindergarten and first-grade. 5. Letter name learning has a limited range of influence and because of this is codependent with learning other constrained and unconstrained reading skills. Teachers should assure that the reading instruction program gives adequate attention to learning phonemic awareness, concepts about print, word meanings, and listening comprehension. 6. Letter name learning requires students to actively process a variety of information about letters including recognition of letter forms (upper and lower case), formation of letters in writing, and the speech sounds commonly associated with specific letters. Theories and Research Reutzel, D. R. (In Press, 2015). Inside Track - Early Literacy Research: Findings Primary Grade Teachers Will Want to Know. The Reading Teacher, 70, xxx- xxx. Jones, C. D., & Reutzel, D. R. (2012). Enhanced alphabet knowledge instruction: Exploring a change of frequency, focus, and distributed cycles of review. Reading Psychology: An International Quarterly, 33(5), 448-464. Jones, C. D., Reutzel, D. R., & Clark, S. K. (2012). Enhancing alphabet knowledge instruction: Research implications and practical strategies for early childhood educators. Early Childhood Education Journal. DOI 10.1007/s10643-012-0534-9. Justice, L. M., Pence, K., Bowles, R. B., & Wiggins, A. (2006). An investigation of four hypotheses concerning the order by which 4-year-old children learn the alphabet letters. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 21, 374–389. National Early Literacy Panel. (2008). Developing early literacy: Report of the National Early Literacy Panel. Washington, DC: National Institute for Literacy. Piasta, S. B. & Wagner, R. K. (2010). Developing Early Literacy Skills: A Meta- Analysis of Alphabet Learning and Instruction. Reading Research Quarterly 45(1), pp. 8-38. Multi-Componential Letter Name Instruction is the Most Powerful and Effective sounds graphic image name critical features transcription categories discrimination Discriminate this symbol from others Categories into Recognize which this graphic symbol can be symbol sorted Name the Motor codes symbol used in transcription Paired Made from Associated Associates: x number of sound Objects critical Pictures features Pattern Recognition Theories Template Matching Theory Prototype Matching Theory Critical Feature Analysis Theory Template Matching Theory Is there a match? D Template for upper-case D What the eye sees. in the brain. Prototype Matching Theory Does the prototype look like this letter? Flexible, Prototype What the eye sees. for upper-case D in the brain. Critical Feature Analysis Theory All letters are analyzed into and constructed a small set of critical features shown below . | / \ Critical Feature Analysis Theory Shared critical features make some letters confusable. Young children don’t understand the identity change that occurs in the 2 dimensional print world. Unlike their previous 3 dimensional object world experience. d p b m n u This doesn’t mean kids are dyslexic! What does research have to say about factors that affect how young children learn letter names and sounds? Research has shown that learning letter names is facilitated through six different “advantages” (Justice, Pence, Bowles & Wiggins, 2006): Own-Name Advantage (where letters occur in children’s names) Alphabetic order (where letters are taught in alpha order) Letter pronunciation effect (where the sound of the letter is also in the name) Letter frequency effect (letters that occur most frequently in written language) Consonant Phoneme Acquisition order effect (order of sounds the child first learns to articulate in oral language. Letter Writing Advantage : (where explicit letter formation is taught and practiced) Research has shown that learning letter names can be facilitated in a variety of ways (Justice, Pence, Bowles & Wiggins, 2006): Letters that occur in children’s names (Krech, 2000) Research has shown that learning letter names can be facilitated in a variety of ways (Justice, Pence, Bowles & Wiggins, 2006): Alphabetic order Teaching the Alphabet as a serial list in order can lead to “list learning effects” as shown by the bowed serial position curve below: Figure 1 Using Alphabetic Order and Read Aloud Reading aloud alphabet books and discussing S letters (Brabham, Murray, and Bowden, 2006). o r t Singing and writing alphabet songs can be used to B o support children’s learning of letter names (Smith, o k s 2000). b y : Research has shown that learning letter names can be facilitated in a variety of ways (Justice, Pence, Bowles & Wiggins, 2006): Letter name pronunciation effect (where the sound of the letter is also in the name) in Naming the Letters Saying the names of letters not only reinforces the names of letters but also many of the sounds (except g (hard g sound), h, q, w & y): Vowels – a, e, i, o, & u Consonants – b, c, d, f, j, k, l, m, n, p, q, r, s, t, v, x, z Letters where the sound of the letter is at the beginning of the letter names are learned easiest, then at the end of the letter names, and then not in the letter names (Treiman, et al., 1994; 1997; 1998; 2003). Research has shown that learning letter names can be facilitated in a variety of ways (Justice, Pence, Bowles & Wiggins, 2006): Letter frequency effect (how often letters are found in written or printed language) Using Letter Frequency (Fry, 2004) Consonants in order of frequency: r, t, n, s, l, c, d, p, m, b, f, v, g, h, k, w, th, sh, ng, ch, x, z, j, qu, wh, y Vowels in order of frequency: Short i, a, e, schwa, long o & e, short u & o, long a, u, & i, r controlled a & o, ou, oo, oi, air, ar Research has shown that learning letter names can be facilitated in a variety of ways (Justice, Pence, Bowles & Wiggins, 2006) Consonant Phoneme Acquisition order effect (order of sounds the child first learns to articulate in oral language. Using Consonant Phoneme Acquisition Order: Normative, developmental order of consonant phoneme acquisition includes the consonant phonemes of n, m, p, h, t, k, y, f, ng, b, d, g w, and s during the first four years . The consonant phonemes acquired after age 4 include: l, r, v, z, sh, ch, j, zh, and th (voiced sound as in that and unvoiced sound as in think). Writing the Letters Explicit teaching and guided practice of letter forms facilitates writing and letter naming fluency (Graham, Harris & Fink, 2000; Schlagal, 2007). Writing the Letters Short daily practice sessions are most effective Teacher demonstrations of how to form a letter while describing how it is formed is best for younger children. Writing the Letters Copying or tracing a letter from a correct model is helpful for children’s practice. When doing this children should use a “look, say, cover, write, check” technique. Using pictographs in story or song-based instruction for introducing letters such as is found in the British Letterland approach is helpful. Letter Dictation Supplies needed: Markers, pencils, or other writing supplies, gel boards, white boards, kleenslates, etc. for choral response or lined/numbered paper. Stop watch or wrist watch with second hand. Dictate random letters using upper and lower case. Begin slowly about 10 seconds per letter. Increase speed during the year. www.kleenslate.com What does recent research say about the instructional pacing and review of letter names and sounds? Breaking the Letter a Week Tradition Teaching a letter a week in Kindergarten is a long standing tradition. But the real question is this – “Is it effective to teach a letter a week?” Letter a week must be effective to some degree otherwise teachers would abandon the practice.