A T O N E M E N T. An Exchange between BARTON W. STONE and ALEXANDER CAMPBELL in The Millennial Harbinger, 1840-1841. I. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement." MH (June 1840): 243-246. Alexander Campbell: "A. C.'s Reply to B. W. Stone." MH (June 1840): 246-250. II.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. II." MH (July 1840): 289-293. Alexander Campbell: "Letter II--To B. W. Stone." MH (July 1840): 294-298. III.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. III." MH (September 1840): 387-390. Alexander Campbell: "Letter to B. W. Stone." MH (September 1840): 391-396. IV.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. IV." MH (October 1840): 464-470. Alexander Campbell: "Letter III--To B. W. Stone." MH (October 1840): 471-473. V.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. IV." MH (January 1841): 12-18. Alexander Campbell: "Letter IV--To B. W. Stone." MH (January 1841): 18-24. VI.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. V." MH (February 1841): 59-65. Alexander Campbell: "Letter V--To B. W. Stone." MH (February 1841): 65-69. VII. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. VI: Review of Letters First and Second." MH (March 1841): 113-118. Alexander Campbell: "Letter VI--To B. W. Stone." MH (March 1841): 118-122. VIII. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. VII: Review of Brother Campbell's Third Letter." MH (April 1841): 156-163. Alexander Campbell: "Atonement--No. VII: To B. W. Stone." MH (May 1841): 234-237. IX.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. VIII: Review of Brother Campbell's Third Letter-- Continued." MH (June 1841): 248-252. Alexander Campbell: "To B. W. Stone." MH (June 1841): 253-258. X.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. IX: Review of Brother Campbell's Letter III." MH (July 1841): 295-300. Alexander Campbell: "To B. W. Stone." MH (July 1841): 300-304. XI.Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. X: Review of Brother Campbell's Letter VI." MH (August 1841): 369-372. Alexander Campbell: "A Note to B. W. Stone." MH (August 1841): 373. XII. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. X: Review of Brother Campbell's Letter VI-- Continued." MH (September 1841): 389-393. Alexander Campbell: "To B. W. Stone." MH (September 1841): 394-402. Related Documents: Barton W. Stone. "Communication." Millennial Harbinger (January 1840): 21-22. Alexander Campbell. "Embryo Heresy." Millennial Harbinger (February 1840): 68-69. Alexander Campbell. "Heretical Periodicals." Millennial Harbinger (February 1840): 69-70. Alexander Campbell. "Definitions and Answers to Questions--No. I." Millennial Harbinger (February 1840): 81-83. P. Russell. "Atonement" [From The Christian Herald]. Millennial Harbinger (April 1841): 163-167. Barton W. Stone. "Note to My Patrons" [From The Christian Messenger]. Millennial Harbinger (November 1841): 537. Alexander Campbell. "Note" [on B. W. Stone's "Note to My Patrons"]. Millennial Harbinger (November 1841): 538-539. ABOUT THE ELECTRONIC EDITION OF ATONEMENT BY BARTON W. STONE AND ALEXANDER CAMPBELL Alexander Campbell's proposal for the epistolary exchange on the subject of atonement was that Barton W. Stone would "write four pages per month for the Harbinger; and should any difference occur, I will occupy four pages in biblical criticism upon such terms as may not be by us understood in the same sense." He further proposed that this discussion be published only in The Millennial Harbinger so that "the matter can have a more extensive hearing in this paper than in any other" and because he objected "to a discussion going on in two papers as holding opposite sides on any question whatever" (MH, 1840, pp. 82-83). For his part, Barton Stone had planned to dispose of the matter in "four numbers on the Atonement" (MH, 1841, p. 113). Thus, the exchange should have consisted of eight letters and occupied thirty-two pages in The Millennial Harbinger. However, the published exchange consists of twenty-two letters, occupying some 128 pages of that periodical from June 1840 through September 1841. In the pages of The Christian Messenger, the discussion consists of twenty-one letters, occupying about 168 pages from September 1840 through June 1841. If the related articles and notices are included, the discussion then occupies 145 pages in the Harbinger and 193 pages in the Messenger. The following table catalogue the letters that comprise the "Atonement" exchange. It will be noticed that the letters appear in a significantly different sequence in the pages of The Christian Messenger; four of Alexander Campbell's replies to Barton W. Stone's "reviews" (rejoinders) are omitted; a "review" of Campbell's fifth letter (erroneously called the sixth in the published title) is included, as well as Barton W. Stone's "A Synopsis of Atonement." These last two items were not published in the pages of The Millennial Harbinger. A T O N E M E N T. An Exchange between BARTON W. STONE and ALEXANDER CAMPBELL Part The Millennial Harbinger The Christian Messenger I. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement." MH (June Barton W. Stone: "Atonement. No. I." CM 1840): 243-246. 11 (September 1840): 3-8. Alexander Campbell: "A. C.'s Reply to B. W. Alexander Campbell: "A. C.'s Reply to B. Stone." MH (June 1840): 246-250. Stone." CM 11 (September 1840): 8-14. II. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. II." MH Barton W. Stone: "Atonement: No. II." CM (July 1840): 289-293. 11 (September 1840): 14-21. Alexander Campbell: "Letter II--To B. W. Alexander Campbell: "Letter II.--To B. W. Stone." MH (July 1840): 294-298. Stone." CM (September 1840): 21-28. III. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. III." MH Barton W. Stone: "Atonement No. III." CM (September 1840): 387-390. 11 (October 1840): 37-42. Alexander Campbell: "Letter to B. W. Stone." Alexander Campbell: "Letter III.--To B. W. MH (September 1840): 391-396. Stone." CM 11 (October 1840): 42-50. IV. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. IV." MH Barton W. Stone: "Atonement No. IV." CM (October 1840): 464-470. 11 (November 1840): 73-82. Alexander Campbell: "Letter III--To B. W. Alexander Campbell: "Letter III.--To B. W. Stone." MH (October 1840): 471-473. Stone." CM 11 (November 1840): 82-86. V. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. IV." MH Barton W. Stone: "Atonement: No. IV." CM (January 1841): 12-18. 11 (October 1840): 50-58. Alexander Campbell: "Letter IV--To B. W. Alexander Campbell: "Letter IV:--To B. W. Stone." MH (January 1841): 18-24. Stone." CM 11 (January 1841): 145-154. VI. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. V." MH Barton W. Stone: "Atonement No. III." CM (February 1841): 59-65. 11 (November 1840): 87-96. Alexander Campbell: "Letter V--To B. W. Alexander Campbell: "Letter V.--To B. W. Stone." MH (February 1841): 65-69. Stone." CM 11 (March 1841): 219-225. VII. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. VI: Barton W. Stone: "Review of Letters, First Review of Letters First and Second." MH and Second." CM 11 (December 1840): (March 1841): 113-118. 109-118. Alexander Campbell: "Letter VI--To B. W. Alexander Campbell: "Letter VI.--To B. W. Stone." MH (March 1841): 118-122. Stone." CM 11 (April 1841): 272-279. VIII. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. VII: Barton W. Stone: "Letter II. Review of Review of Brother Campbell's Third Letter." Brother Campbell's 3d Letter." CM 11 MH (April 1841): 156-163. (January 1841): 157-169. Alexander Campbell: "Atonement--No. VII: Alexander Campbell: "Atonement--No. VII: To B. W. Stone." MH (May 1841): 234-237. To B. W. Stone." CM 11 (June 1841): 325-329. IX. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. VIII: Barton W. Stone: "Letter III. Review of Bro. Review of Brother Campbell's Third Campbell's III Letter (Continued)." CM 11 Letter--Continued." MH (June 1841): (February 1841): 180-189. 248-252. Alexander Campbell: "To B. W. Stone." MH (June 1841): 253-258. X. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. IX: Barton W. Stone: Review of Bro. Review of Brother Campbell's Letter III." MH Campbell's IV Letter (Continued)." CM 11 (July 1841): 295-300. (March 1841): 225-232. Alexander Campbell: "To B. W. Stone." MH (July 1841): 300-304. XI. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. X: Barton W. Stone: "Letter VI. Review of Review of Brother Campbell's Letter VI." MH Bro. Campbell's VI Letter." CM 11 (May (August 1841): 369-372. 1841): 289-303 [289-296]. Alexander Campbell: "A Note to B. W. Stone." MH (August 1841): 373. Barton W. Stone: "Atonement--No. X: Review Barton W. Stone: "Letter VI. Review of of Brother Campbell's Letter VI--Continued." Bro. Campbell's VI Letter." CM 11 MH (September 1841): 389-393. (May 1841): 289-303 [296-303]. Alexander Campbell: "To B. W. Stone." MH (September 1841): 394-402. XII. Barton W. Stone: "Review of Bro. Campbell's V Letter (Page 219)." CM 11 (April 1841): 261-272. Related Documents: Barton W. Stone. "Communication." MH (January 1840): 21-22. Alexander Campbell. "Embryo Heresy." MH (February 1840): 68-69. Alexander Campbell. "Heretical Periodicals." MH (February 1840): 69-70. Barton W. Stone. "Notice" [on Publication of Exchange] CM 11 (September 1840): 2-3. Alexander Campbell. "Definitions and Answers to Questions--No. I." MH (February 1840): 81-83. Bartpm W. Stone. Notice on the Exchange. CM 11 (March 1841): 246-247. P. Russell. "Atonement" [From The Christian P. Russell. "Atonement" [From The Millennial Herald]. MH (April 1841): 163-167. Harbinger]. CM 11 (May 1841): 303-310. Barton W. Stone. "Notice" [on P. Russell's "Atonement"]. CM 11 (May 1841): 310-312. Barton W. Stone. "Note to My Patrons" [From Barton W. Stone. "A Note to My Patrons.” The Christian Messenger]. MH CM 11 (June 1841): 329-330. (November 1841): 537. Barton W. Stone. "A Synopsis of Atonement." CM 11 (August 1841): 397-415. Alexander Campbell.