WISDOM CHAPTER NINE OF SHANTIDEVA’S BODHICHARYAVATARA THE WAY OF THE BODHISATTVA SOURCE BOOK For internal use only Exclusively for the Rime Shedra NYC Core Texts Program A program of Shambhala Meditation Center of New York First Edition – 2013 Sourcebook Table of Contents Course Materials Syllabus with schedule Chants Tonglen instruction (abridged version) by Pema Chodron Outlines of the Bodhicharyavatara: The Full Text The Ninth Chapter Core Texts Wisdom, The Way of the Bodhisattva, Translated by Padmakara, with outline Wisdom, The Nectar of Manjushri’s Speech, Kunzang Pelden, pp. 313‐389 plus notes Supplementary Readings Some Remarks on the Bodhicaryavatara and Pawo Rinpoche’s Commentary, The Center of the Sunlit Sky, Karl Brunnholzl: A Brief Account of Shantideva’s Life, pp. 601‐604 The Entrance to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life and Its Ninth Chapter, pp. 604‐605 Shantideva’s Presentation of the Two Realities, pp. 605‐611 Buddhist philosophy, Daniel Cozort and Craig Preston: What are Buddhist tenets, pages 12 to 18 What are the Buddhist schools, pages 19 to 28 What is ignorance, pages 29 to 36 What is the person, pages 37 to 43 What are the two troops, pages 54 to 59 What is valid cognition, pages 66 to 73 Emptiness: Foundations of Buddhist Thought Volume Five, by Geshe Tashi Tsering: Insight, pp. 30 ‐34 The Object of Negation, pp. 77‐89 Levels of Selfhood, pp. 39‐50 Relative Truth, Ultimate Truth, by Geshe Tashi Tsering: The Vaibhashika School, pp. 35‐52 Special Insight: The Perfection of Wisdom, The Easy Path, Illuminating the First Dalai Lama’s Secret Instructions, Gyumed Khensur Lobsang Jampa: Page 1 Emptiness of Persons, pp. 243‐257 Meditation on the Emptiness of Phenomena, pp. 258‐264 Self, Reality and Reason in Tibetan Philosophy, by Thupten Jinpa: Identifying the object of negation, pages 49‐63 An analysis of the concept of intrinsic existence, pages 93‐104 No self as the emptiness of intrinsic existence, page 104‐106 The nature of the I consciousness pages 123‐135 Emptiness Yoga: the Tibetan Middle Way, Jeffrey Hopkins False Appearance, pp. 78‐81 The Reasoning, pp. 192‐203 (included in Inducing Realization, pp. 187‐203) Unfindable and Yet Being Validly Established, pp. 252‐262 (included in Bringing the Reasoning to Life, pp. 249‐262) Moonshadows: Conventional Truth and Buddhist Philosophy, by The Cow Herds Identifying the Object of Negation in the Status of Conventional Truth: Why the dGah Bya Matters So Much to the Tibetan Madhyamakas, Jay Garfield and Sonam Thakchoe, pp. 73‐87. Page 2 RIME SHEDRA NYC SMCNY ADVANCED BUDDHIST STUDIES CHANTS ASPIRATION In order that all sentient beings may attain Buddhahood, From my heart I take refuge in the three jewels. This was composed by Mipham. Translated by the Nalanda Translation Committee MANJUSHRI SUPPLICATION Whatever the virtues of the many fields of knowledge All are steps on the path of omniscience. May these arise in the clear mirror of intellect. O Manjushri, please accomplish this. This was specially composed by Mangala (Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche). Translated by the Nalanda Translation Committee THE FOUR IMMEASURABLES May all sentient beings enjoy happiness and the root of happiness May they be free from suffering and the root of suffering May they not be separated from the great happiness devoid of suffering May they enjoy the great equanimity free from passion, aggression and prejudice. DEDICATION OF MERIT By this merit may all obtain omniscience May it defeat the enemy, wrong doing. From the stormy waves of birth, old age, sickness and death, From the ocean of samsara, may I free all beings By the confidence of the golden sun of the great east May the lotus garden of the Rigden’s wisdom bloom, May the dark ignorance of sentient beings be dispelled. May all beings enjoy profound, brilliant glory. Translated by the Nalanda Translation Committee Page 3 CHAPTER NINE ‐ WISDOM OF THE BODHICARYAVATARA BY SHANTIDEVA 13 Tuesdays from September 17. 2013 through January 7, 2014 MAIN SOURCES PW: Practicing Wisdom, HH The Dalai Lama and Geshe Thupten Jinpa SB: Sourcebook Sources, including primarily: o BCA: The Way of the Bodhisattva, Translated by Padmakara o NMS: The Nectar of Manjushri’s Speech, Kunzang Pelden READINGS SYLLABUS I) 9/17/13: Introduction and Overview A) The Center of the Sunlit Sky, Karl Brunnholzl, Some Remarks on the Bodhicary›vatara and Pawo Rinpoche’s Commentary, pp. 601‐605 1) A Brief Account of Sh›ntideva’s Life 2) The Entrance to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life and Its Ninth Chapter 9/25/13 – No Class, Only Readings What are Buddhist tenets, Buddhist philosophy, Cozort & Preston, pp. 12‐18 What are the Buddhist schools, Buddhist philosophy, Cozort & Preston, pp. 19‐28 What is ignorance, Buddhist philosophy, Cozort & Preston, pp. 29‐36 What is the person, Buddhist philosophy, Cozort & Preston, pp. 37‐43 What are the two truths, Buddhist philosophy, Cozort & Preston, pp. 54‐59 II) 10/1/13: Background for the Text A) PW: Introduction pp. 1‐5 B) PW: The Buddhist Context, pp. 5‐15 C) Insight, Emptiness, by Tashi Tsering, pp. 30‐ 34 III) 10/8/13: Ignorance & wisdom, v. 1‐5 A) BCA: v. 1‐5 B) NMS:, pp. 313‐322 = 10 C) PW: The two truths, pp. 16‐30 IV) 10/15/13: The two truths in the four tenet systems ‐ Realists, v. 6‐15 A) BCA: v. 6‐15 B) NMS: pp. 323‐326 C) PW: Critiquing the Buddhist Realists, pp. 31‐45 D) What is valid cognition, Buddhist philosophy, Cozort & Preston, pp. 66 to 73 Page 4 THE WISDOM CHAPTER OF THE BODHICARYAVATARA BY SHANTIDEVA COURSE SYLLABUS V) 10/22/13: Background on Tenets and Emptiness A) The Vaibhashika School, Relative Truth, Ultimate Truth, Tashi Tsering, pp. 35‐52 B) The Object of Negation, Emptiness, by Geshe Tashi Tsering, pp. 77‐ 89 VI) 10/29/13: The two truths in the four tenet systems ‐ Cittamatra, v. 16‐29 A) BCA: v. 16‐29 B) NMS: pp. 326‐332 C) PW The mind‐only viewpoint, pp. 46‐57 D) Levels of Selfhood, Emptiness, Tashi Tsering, pp. 39‐50 VII) 11/5/13: Authenticity of the Mahayana, v. 30‐40 A) BCA: v. 30‐40 B) NMS: pp. 332‐336 C) PW: The mind‐only viewpoint , pp. 57‐61 D) PW: The authenticity of the Mahayana, pp. 62‐74 VIII) 11/12/13: The Necessity of understanding emptiness, v. 41‐55 A) BCA: v. 41‐55 B) NMS: pp. 337‐345 C) PW: Emptiness according to the middle way school, pp. 75‐89 IX) 11/19/13: Meditation on the emptiness of the self of persons, v. 56‐77 A) BCA: v. 56‐77 B) NMS: pp. 346‐357 C) PW: Emptiness according to the middle way school, pp. 89‐92 D) PW: The nature and existence of self, p. 93‐108 11/26/13 No Class; Reading Only Special Insight: The Perfection of Wisdom, in The Easy Path, Illuminating the First Dalai Lama’s Secret Instructions, Gyumed Khensur Lobsang Jampa . Meditation on the Emptiness of Persons, pp. 243‐257 . Meditation on the Emptiness of Phenomena, pp. 258‐264 Unfindable and Yet Being Validly Established, Emptiness Yoga, Jeffrey Hopkins, pp. 252‐262 Excerpt from False Appearance, Emptiness Yoga, Jeffrey Hopkins, pp. 77‐81 X) 12/3/13: Not finding anything, v. 78‐105 A) BCA: v. 78‐110 B) NMS: pp. 357‐369 C) PW: The nature of phenomena, pp. 109‐126 XI) 12/10/13: Continuing to Not Find Anything, v. 106‐115 Page 5 THE WISDOM CHAPTER OF THE BODHICARYAVATARA BY SHANTIDEVA COURSE SYLLABUS A) BCA: v. 78‐110 (continued) B) PW: Countering objections, pp. 127‐142 C) Self reality and reason and Tibetan philosophy, by Thupten Jinpa 1) An analysis of the concept of intrinsic existence, pages 93‐104 2) No self as the emptiness of intrinsic existence, page 104‐106 XII) 12/17/13: Reasoning into emptiness, v. 116‐150 A) BCA: v. 111‐150 B) NMS: pp. 370‐383 (top) C) PW: Key arguments refuting intrinsic existence, pp. 142‐157 12/24/13 No Class; Reading yet to be Determined 12/31/13 No Class; Reading yet to be Determined XIII) 1/7/14: The benefits of realizing emptiness, v. 151‐167 A) BCA: v. 151‐167 B) NMS: pp. 383‐389 C) PW: Key arguments refuting intrinsic existence, pp. 157‐166 D) The Reasoning, from Inducing Realization, Emptiness Yoga, Jeffrey Hopkins, pp. 192‐203 Page 6 TONGLEN INSTRUCTION BY PEMA CHODRON The Tonglen practice is a method for connecting with suffering‐‐ours and that which is all around us‐‐ everywhere we go. It is a method for overcoming our fear of suffering and for dissolving the tightness of our heart. Primarily it is a method for awakening the compassion that is inherent in all of us, no matter how cruel or cold we might seem to be. We begin the practice by taking on the suffering of a person we know to be hurting and whom we wish to help. For instance, if you know of a child who is being hurt, you breathe in with the wish to take away all the pain and fear of that child. Then, as you breathe out, you send the child happiness, joy or whatever would relieve their pain. This is the core of the practice: breathing in other's pain so they can be well and have more space to relax and open, and breathing out, sending them relaxation or whatever you feel would bring them relief and happiness. However, we often cannot do this practice because we come face to face with our own fear, our own resistance, anger, or whatever our personal pain, our personal stuckness happens to be at that moment.