Table 4: ANOVA Models Indicating Order of Variables Used for the Analysis

Table 4: ANOVA Models Indicating Order of Variables Used for the Analysis

<p> Table 3: SOC stocks according to forest age and forest type for organic layer, mineral soil,</p><p> and total SOC stocks.</p><p>SOC stocks (in kg C m-2) according to forest age categories and forest type (means ± standard errors) SOC stocks < 60 60-120 > 120 Forest type Organic Layer 1.1±0.2 1.4±0.2 0.9±0.06 Broadleaf (n=32) (n=87) (n=296) 3.6±0.7 4.3±0.6 3.6±0.3 Conifer (n=35) (n=107) (n=278) Mineral Soil 13.4±1.7 12.2±0.7 10.2±0.3 Broadleaf (0-120 cm) (n=32) (n=87) (n=296) 11.8±1.1 10.6±0.6 10.9±0.4 Conifer (n=35) (n=107) (n=278) Total C stocks 14.5±1.7 13.6±0.8 11.1±0.3 Broadleaf (n=32) (n=87) (n=296) 15.3±1.1 14.9±0.7 14.5±0.5 Conifer (n=35) (n=107) (n=278)</p><p>1 Table 4: ANOVA models indicating order of variables used for the analysis. </p><p>ANOVA (with function aov.ko) Organic layer summary(model <- aov.ko(log-transformed(organic layer) ~ Region*Soil group + BC*Soil group + Forest age*Soil group + MAT + pH*Forest type, data=Forest age) Mineral soil summary(model <- aov.ko(log-transformed(mineral soil) ~ Region*Soil group + Forest age*Soil group + MAP + Slope + Altitude + Sand content + BC*Soil group + Soil type*BC + Forest type, data=Forest age) Total C stocks summary(model <- aov.ko(log-transformed(total C stocks) ~ Region*Soil group + Forest age*Soil group + BC + BC*Soil group + Relief + Forest type + Slope + MAP + MAT, data= Forest age) The sign “*” denotes an interaction between two covariates. Fitted models are not shown.</p><p>Table 5: Results from Post hoc TukeyHSD tests comparing the means of the three forest age</p><p> categories.</p><p>TukeyHSD post-hoc tests Tukey multiple comparisons of means 95% family-wise confidence interval Forest age Diff Lwr Upr P adj comparison Organic layer Medium - Young 0.23 -0.22 0.68 0.5 Old - Young -0.06 -0.47 0.35 0.9 Old - Medium -0.29 -0.56 -0.03 0.03 Mineral soil Medium - Young -0.03 -0.21 0.16 0.9 Old - Young -0.11 -0.27 0.06 0.26 Old - Medium -0.08 -0.18 0.03 0.17 Total Medium - Young -0.02 -0.19 0.15 0.9 C stocks Old - Young -0.15 -0.30 0.00 0.05 Old - Medium -0.13 -0.23 -0.03 0.006 Confidence level is 0.95, data presents lower and upper limits, their average and the adjusted p-values.</p><p>Table 6: ANOVA results on the effect of forest age and other variables on SOC stocks for the five biogeographic regions of Switzerland.</p><p>Region Organic Layer Mineral Soil Covariate Df SS (%) F Covariate Df SS (%) F Jura Soil group 2 19.2 F(2,65) = 9.952 Soil group 2 14.6 F(2,66) = *** 7.847 ***</p><p> pH 1 3.1 F(1,65) = 3.191 BC 1 12.3 F(1,66) = . 13.218 ***</p><p>Soil group x 3 14.9 F(3,65) = 5.164 Forest type 1 5.1 F(1,66) = BC ** 5.493 *</p><p>- - - - Slope 1 6.3 F(1,66) =</p><p>2 6.775 * Residuals 65 62.8 - Residuals 66 61.7 - Swiss Soil group 2 14.4 F(2,264) = Soil group 2 8.2 F(2,263) = Plateau 33.476 *** 16.311 *** BC 1 9.5 F(1,264) = BC 1 5.5 F(1,263) = 44.422 *** 21.924 ***</p><p>MAT 1 1.0 F(1,264) = Slope 1 8.8 F(1,263) = 4.536 * 35.189 ***</p><p> pH 1 7.3 F(1,264) = MAP 1 5.6 F(1,263) = 33.867 *** 22.325 ***</p><p>Forest type 1 3.5 F(1,264) = Soil group x 2 2.7 F(2,263) = 16.415 *** BC 5.412 **</p><p>Soil group x 2 5.9 F(2,264) = Soil group x 6 3.3 F(6,263) = BC 13.784 *** Forest age 2.171 *</p><p> pH x Forest 1 1.7 F(1,264) = - - - - type 7.842 ** Residuals 264 56.7 - Residuals 263 65.9 - Pre-Alps Soil group 2 13.3 F(2, 248) = Soil group 2 5.0 F(2,251) = 38.980 *** 8.551 ***</p><p>BC 1 18.3 F(1,248) = BC 1 4.7 F(1,251) = 106.945 *** 16.126 ***</p><p>MAT 1 4.2 F(1, 248) = Forest type 1 6.9 F(1,251) = 24.537 *** 23.534 ***</p><p> pH 1 9.0 F(1, 248) = Slope 1 3.0 F(1,251) = 52.696 *** 9.904 **</p><p>Forest type 1 1.7 F(1, 248) = MAP 1 6.8 F(1,251) = 9.826 ** 23.293 ***</p><p>Soil group x 2 7.7 F(2, 248) = - - - - BC 22.472 ***</p><p> pH x Forest 1 3.3 F(1, 248) = - - - - type 19.088 *** Residuals 248 42.5 - Residuals 251 73.6 - Alps Soil group 2 8.4 F(2, 156) = Soil group 2 5.9 F(2,155) = 9.176 *** 7.190 **</p><p>BC 1 10.9 F(1, 156) = BC 1 13.7 F(1,155) = 23.876 *** 32.795 ***</p><p>MAT 1 2.3 F(1, 156) = Forest age 2 2.5 F(1,155) = 4.902 * 3.032 .</p><p> pH 1 3.4 F(1, 156) = Slope 1 2.7 F(1,155) = 7.431 ** 6.397 **</p><p>Forest type 1 3.7 F(1, 156) = MAP 1 10.6 F(1,155) = 8.190 ** 25.347 *** Residuals 156 71.3 - Residuals 155 64.6 - Souther MAT 1 23.0 F(1,65) = Soil group 2 6.4 F(2,65) = n Alps 26.568 *** 2.756 . pH 1 8.0 F(1,65) = 9.227 MAP 1 3.4 F(1,65) = ** 2.935 .</p><p>Soil group x 3 12.7 F(3,65) = 4.880 Soil group x 2 14.7 F(1,65) = BC ** BC 6.330 ** Residuals 65 56.3 - Residuals 65 75.5 - The abbreviation df stands for degrees of freedom, SS represents the sum of squares in %, F represents the F-value. The annotation (“-”) means that the variable was not present in the final model fit.</p><p>3 Figure 8: TukeyHSD plots comparing the means of the three different forest categories for C stocks in organic layer, mineral soil (0-120 cm soil depth), and total C stocks (top to bottom).</p><p>Lines represent the differences in means between forest age groups (from top to bottom: medium vs. young, old vs. young, and old vs. medium, respectively). If a line crosses the 0.0 dashed mark, there is no significant difference between the means of the examined groups, if it does not – there is a significant difference.</p><p>4 Figure 9: Distribution of SOC stocks (kg C m-2) according to the five bio-geographic regions of Switzerland (top dashed: organic layer, bottom grey: mineral soil at 0-120 cm soil depth), subdivided by forest age categories. Whiskers indicate standard errors, numbers above forest age categories – number of sites per forest age category. The category ‘young forests’ was not present in the region of Jura.</p><p>5 Figure 10: Distribution of SOC stocks (kg C m-2) according to a more detailed separation of forest age (top dashed: organic layer, bottom grey: mineral soil at 0-120 cm soil depth).</p><p>Whiskers indicate standard errors, numbers above forest age categories – number of sites per forest age category.</p><p>6</p>

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    6 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us