Review: Dizziness, Vertigo, and Psychotherapy

Review: Dizziness, Vertigo, and Psychotherapy

<p>Appendix: Additional Tables Table I. Summary of Reviewed Case Reports.</p><p>Study Study design Sample, Intervention, duration Measurements Results Quality diagnoses assessment ratinga Schwöbel Case report; n=2 women (43 Psychoanalysis; After treatment: no vertigo 11 (23.9%) (1954) assessment and 59 years); duration: case 1: 1.5 years (52 symptoms, no social points: before Menière’s disease hours); case 2: 3 months withdrawal, happy mood, and after working treatment; follow-up one year later Fowler et Case report; n=1 woman (58 Behavioural therapy (in- In-patient: daily At discharge: able to walk 13 (28.3%) al. (1971) assessment years); positional patient): positive and negative records of progress; 1200 feet; points: before nystagmus reinforcement; distance in feet Two months later: no and after in- (peripheral) physical therapy (in-patient): walked per day; more usage of wheelchair; patient standing in parallel bars, walking; After discharge: 12 months later: able to treatment; duration: 55 days (in-patient); daily records of walk and to conduct follow-ups: two after discharge: meetings with walking and homemaking activities and 12 months physical therapist and homemaking psychologist activities Elwood et Case report; n=1 man (42 Behavioural treatment: Control over vertigo One year after treatment: 11 (23.9%) al. (1982) assessment years); Menière’s relaxation techniques twice daily; attacks, time off more control over vertigo points: before disease and meditation; when anxious: graded work, social activities, and Menière attacks; less treatment; anxiety behavioural tasks; biofeedback; coping with stress; anxiety; not many time off follow-ups: duration: 12 months work; better stress coping monthly until abilities one year after treatment Shutty et Case report; n=1 woman (26 Behavioural treatment: Psychophysiologic After treatment: reduced 16 (34.8%) al. (1991) assessment years); mild head education about BPV; self- measures; frequency and severity of points: before injury after monitoring; gaze-fixation; recordings: frequency dizzy spells; reduced and after accident, BPV, desensitization; biofeedback- and severity of dizzy muscle tension; increased treatment, and avoidance assisted relaxation training; stress spells; activity and peripheral blood flow; follow-ups: 2, management; cognitive well-being increased confidence in 4, and 8 weeks strategies; ability to manage dizzy duration: 9 weeks spells; increased social </p><p>1 activities; less psychological distress; Follow-ups: increased activity and well-being Andersson Case report; n=1 woman (68 CBT and VR: education about Questionnaire: After treatment: 18.5 (40.2%) & Yardley assessment years); dizziness, dizziness; balance / movement VHS; neuro- improved balance, (1998) points: before fear of falling, and exercises; relaxation for difficult otological testing: equilibrium score, and and after avoidance situations; positive / negative eye movements, behaviour provocation; treatment; thoughts; vicious circles; reflexes, caloric test, Pre to post to follow-up: follow-up: expectations; dynamic Improved VHS three months duration: 10 weeks (five posturography; sessions, one phone call) behaviour provocation test Hägnebo Case report; n=1 woman (62 CBT: relaxation training; Clinical interview; After treatment: no more 19 (41.3%) et al. assessment years); Menière’s desensitization of anxiety- recordings: number vertigo attacks; (1998) points: before disease and provoking situations; cognitive of vertigo attacks and At 24 months: no more and after anxiety / worries restructuring; behavioural task of positive / negative vertigo attacks; normal treatment; setting; enhancement of bodily events social functioning, less follow-ups: 3, awareness; worries 6, 10, and 24 duration: 9 weeks (in addition: 2 months Booster sessions at 6 months after treatment) Sareen Case report, n=1 woman (35 Behavioural treatment: episodes of dizziness After treatment: no more 9 (19.6%) (2003) assessment years); dizziness, education about dizziness; daily dizziness; points: before anxiety, and exposure to dizziness; Follow-up: maintained and after avoidance Duration: 4 sessions improvement treatment; follow-up: 6 months Whitney et Case report; n=1 man (37 Behavioural therapy: exposure Expert interview; After behavioural 17.5 (38.0%) al. (2005) assessment years); fear of to virtual height scenes; questionnaires: therapy: reduced anxiety points: before heights and duration: 8 sessions; CAQ, ATHQ, SitQ, and avoidance of heights; treatment, dizziness Followed by vestibular therapy: IIRS, DHI; SF-36, increased quality of life; after exercises; duration: 8 weeks behavioural persistent symptoms of behavioural avoidance test; dizziness and discomfort of therapy and optic flow testing space and motion; after vestibular After vestibular therapy: therapy reduced anxiety and avoidance of heights; less </p><p>2 perceived dizziness handicap; less visually dependent; improved quality of life; better daily functioning Goto et al. Case report; n=1 man (51 Psychotherapy and AT (three Questionnaires: After a few weeks: no 13 (28.3%) (2008a) assessment years); Menière’s times daily); duration: 6 SDS, STAI, CMI, Y-G more vertigo, tinnitus, and points: before disease, anxiety, sessions, every three weeks insomnia; and during and insomnia At follow-ups: no more treatment; vertigo and insomnia follow-ups: 6 and 9 months Goto et al. Case report; n=1 woman (37 Medication: antidepressant, Questionnaires: After 2 weeks: symptoms 13 (28.3%) (2008b) assessment years); PPV, herbal medicine; SDS, STAI, CMI, slightly improved, points: before anxiety, insomnia, Psychotherapy and AT (three MAS, MOCI medication was stopped; and during headache, and times daily); duration: 6 sessions After a few weeks: no treatment; tinnitus (à 45 minutes), every three weeks more dizziness, insomnia, follow-ups: 6 and headache; and 9 months Follow-ups: no more dizziness, insomnia, and headache Sardinha Case report; n=1 man (17 Cognitive-behavioural therapy: Patient’s reports: At the end of treatment: 11 (23.9%) et al. assessment years); vestibular cognitive interventions, making frequency and no more dizziness, (2009) points: before neuritis and plans for the future, information intensity of dizziness increased activities and and during subsequently PPV about associations between episodes, anxiety, well-being treatment avoidance / hypervigilance and mood, well -being, problem maintenance, increase of activities activities, exposure to avoided activities; duration: 18 weeks (one session per week) a The quality assessment rating score (Moncrieff et al., 2001) could range between 0 (very poor study quality) and 46 (excellent study quality); in parentheses the proportion (in per cent) is reported. Abbreviations: AT=autogenic training; ATHQ=Attitudes Towards Heights Questionnaire; BPV=benign positional vertigo; CAQ=Cohen Acrophobia Questionnaire; CBT=Cognitive-behavioural therapy; CMI=Cornell Medical Index; IIRS=Illness Intrusiveness Ratings Scale; DHI=Dizziness Handicap Inventory; MAS=Manifest Anxiety Scale; MI=Mobility Inventory; MOCI=Maudsley Obsessional-Compulsive Inventory; PPV=Phobic postural vertigo; SitQ=Situational Characteristics Questionnaire; SDS=Self-rating Depression Scale; STAI(-t)=State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (trait form); VHS=Vertigo Handicap Scale; VR=vestibular rehabilitation; Y-G=Yatabe-Guilford personality test</p><p>3 Table II. Summary of Reviewed Psychotherapy or Follow-up Studies.</p><p>Study Study design Sample, diagnoses Control Intervention, duration Measurements Results Quality group assessment ratinga Huppert et Follow-up N=303 were sent a No Initial: self-controlled Self-reported Symptom-free or 21 (45.7%) al. (2005) study; questionnaire behavioural therapy: changes: considerably assessment  n=106 (35%) explanation of PPV; symptom-free / improved: 75%, points: before completed it (n=42 decoupling of catastrophic considerably independently of treatment; women, n=64 men; thoughts; exposure to improved, no age, sex, prior follow-up: 5 to mean age 44.3 vertigo triggering change organic vertigo, or 15 years years); PPV situations; regular other subsequent physical activity; therapies; duration: 2-3 sessions; most improvement During follow-up within the first year period: psychotherapy after initial (not specified); treatment; pharmacotherapy, physiotherapy; alternative therapies; Heinrichs et Psychotherap Initially: n=398 No CBT (individualized): Questionnaires: After 6 weeks: 21.5 (46.7%) al. (2003) y study (natural (n=266 women, Information about the BAI, BDI, BSQ, improvement in all design); n=132 men; mean disorder and therapy ACQ, MI, SCL-90-R measurements; assessment age 35.5 years); procedure; intensive in- After one year: points: before vertigo and vivo exposure with anxiety effects remained treatment; agoraphobia triggering stimuli up to 12 stable follow-ups: 6 6 weeks post: hours daily; self-control weeks and one n=398 (100%) period; duration: > 3 year One year post: weeks n=300 (75.4%) a The quality assessment rating score (Moncrieff et al., 2001) could range between 0 (very poor study quality) and 46 (excellent study quality); in parentheses the proportion (in per cent) is reported. Abbreviations: ACQ=Agoraphobic Cognitions Questionnaire; BAI=Beck Anxiety Inventory; BDI=Beck Depression Inventory; BSQ=Body Sensation Questionnaire; CBT=Cognitive-behavioural therapy; MI=Mobility Inventory; PPV=Phobic postural vertigo; SCL-90(-R)=Symptom Checklist 90 (revised);</p><p>4</p>

View Full Text

Details

  • File Type
    pdf
  • Upload Time
    -
  • Content Languages
    English
  • Upload User
    Anonymous/Not logged-in
  • File Pages
    4 Page
  • File Size
    -

Download

Channel Download Status
Express Download Enable

Copyright

We respect the copyrights and intellectual property rights of all users. All uploaded documents are either original works of the uploader or authorized works of the rightful owners.

  • Not to be reproduced or distributed without explicit permission.
  • Not used for commercial purposes outside of approved use cases.
  • Not used to infringe on the rights of the original creators.
  • If you believe any content infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately.

Support

For help with questions, suggestions, or problems, please contact us