Minutes of 256 th SEAC Meeting Date 16/01/2016 The 256 th meeting of SEAC was held in Directorate of Environment, U.P. on 16/01/2016. Following members were present in the meeting along with Secretary, SEAC: 1. Dr. M. S. Khan, Chairman 2. Dr. S.N. Singh, Member 3. Dr. S.K. Upadhyay, Member 4. Dr. D. C. Gupta, Member 5. Shri Ajay Kumar Shukla, IAS Secretary, SEAC / Director, Environmemt The Chairman welcomed the members to the 256 th SEAC meeting. The Members of SEAC unanimously taken following decisions on the agenda points discussed: 1. M/s Radha Krishna Ent Udyog,Gata no.251,111,287/1,245 Vill:Dabhaura, Kol, Aligarh. Sri Janakpal Singh, S/o Mr. Tikshnapal Singh, Vill:Dabhaura, Kol, Distt: Aligarh. 4.1019 File N0.-391/Ent/ OSD(T) The committee noted that an application dated 19/10/2015 was made by the project proponent for environmental clearance of Brick earth mining at Gata No. 251, 111, 287/1 & 245, Vill: Dabhaura, Tehsil: Kol, District: Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh (Leased area 4.1019 ha.)., M/s Radha Krishna Eint Udyog. A presentation was made by Mr. Janak pal Singh, project proponent along with their consultant M/s Geogreen Enviro Pvt. Ltd., Lucknow. The proponent, through the documents submitted and the presentation made, informed the committee that:- 1. The Environmental Clearance is sought for Brick earth mining at Gata No. 251, 111, 287/1 & 245, Vill: Dabhaura, Tehsil: Kol, District: Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh (Leased area 4.1019 ha.), M/s Radha Krishna Eint Udyog 2. Salient features of the project is as follows: TOTAL AREA 4.1019 Ha Total Mineable area 3.8968 Ha Total Clay to be excavated (5 years) 58452.00 cubicmt Annual Production 11690.00 cubic mt/season Excavation depth 1.5 m Safety zone width 0.75 meter Safety zone (area) 0.20 50 Ha Method of mining Manual using hand tools Man power 42 workers Period of mining 5 years as per agreement with lease owners Cost of project 16 Lakhs CSR 1,10,000.00 Other mines within 500 mt. No Wild Life Sanctuary No Wild Life Sanc tuary within core & buffer zone. Nearest Highway Aligarh – Kashganj Road is 1 Km in SW direction. Nearest Sea/River/Water Body No water body exists within core zone Method of Mining Opencast manual Water Requirement 3 KLD & will be supplied from water tankers. Minutes of 256 th SEAC Meeting Dated 16/01/2016 3. Land Details Sno. Khasra Area Owners Village Excavation Depth No/ Gata Hactare Period in No. (Ha) (Years) metre (mt) 1 251 1.760 Ha Mr. Kunwarpal S/O Mr. Chandan Dabhaura 5 1.5 Singh, Mahendra Singh S/O Mr. Turran Singh Chandra Wati W/O Bhagwat Dayal, 2 111 0.5999 Ha Mrs, Omvati W/O Mr. Mahendra Dabhaura 5 1.5 pal. 3 287/1 0.4290 Ha Bhagwan Singh,S/O Suraj pal Dabhaura 5 1.5 Singh 4 245 1.3130 Ha Harveji W/O Girendra Singh , Dabhaura 5 1.5 Girendra Singh S/O Shiv Singh, Omvati W/O Bhagwan Singh Total 4.1019 Ha 4. Gata-wise production details with corresponding period (Chart form- Gata No. vs. production details for complete agreement period), duly considering the safety provisions Sno. Khasra Area Owners Village Excavation Depth No/ Gata Hactare Period in No. (Ha) (Years) metre (mt) 1 251 1.760 Ha Mr. Kunwarpal S/O Mr. Chandan Dab haura 5 1.5 Singh, Mahendra Singh S/O Mr. Turran Singh Chandra Wati W/O Bhagwat Dayal, 2 111 0.5999 Ha Mrs, Omvati W/O Mr. Mahendra Dabhaura 5 1.5 pal. 3 287/1 0.4290 Ha Bhagwan Singh,S/O Suraj pal Dabhaura 5 1.5 Singh 4 245 1.3130 Ha Harveji W/O Girendra Singh , Dabhaura 5 1.5 Girendra Singh S/O Shiv Singh, Omvati W/O Bhagwan Singh Total 4.1019 Ha 5. Distance Between Excavation Sites Gata No. Distance in meters 111 and 245 170 mt 245 and 251 100 mt 251 and 287/1 300 mt 6. Distance From Brick Kiln to Excavation Site Gata no. Dist ance from Brick Kiln /Chimney in metres 251 70 mt 111 220 mt 287/1 320 mt 245 110 mt 7. Distances among Mining sites and distance from mining sites to brick kiln is within 500 m. 8. This project does not attract any of the general conditions applicable on mining projects specified in EIA Notification 14/09/2006. 9. Regarding the project no litigation is pending in any court. Page 2 of 90 Minutes of 256 th SEAC Meeting Dated 16/01/2016 10. An affidavit dated 21/10/2015 has been submitted by the proponent regarding compliance of provisions given in MoEF OM dated 24/06/2013. 11. Undertaking, that the data and information given in the application, enclosures and other documents are true to the best of my knowledge and belief has been submitted by the project proponent and Consultant has been submitted. 12. A letter from Mining Officer, dated 11/01/2016 has been issued through which it has been informed that there is no other Soil Mining lease has been sanctioned within 500 m periphery of the proposed sites. 13. The project proposal falls under category 1(a) of EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended). The committee discussed the matter and directed the project proponent to submit following information: 1. Resubmit a copy regarding the agreement between the land owners Mr. Kunwarpal S/O Mr. Chandan Singh, Mahendra Singh S/O Mr. Turran Singh Chandra Wati W/O Bhagwat Dayal for Gata No. 251 (lease area 1.760 Ha) also for Mrs, Omvati W/O Mr. Mahendra pal (lease area 0.5999 Ha.) between soil excavator, M/s Radha Krishna Eint Udyog today itself Dated 16/1/2016 The committee deferred the case and directed the project proponent that matter shall be considered after the submission of information as above. 2. M/s Maa Jagdamba Ent Udyog, Gata no. 11 Vill: Kasimpur, Tehsil Kol, Distt: Aligarh & Gata no.183,184,185,229, 230,241,242,243 Vill: Kheria Harchand, Tehsil Kol,Distt:Aligarh. Sri Madal Lal Gupta, S/o Mr. Durga Prasad Gupta, Vill: Kheria Harchand, Tehsil Koil, Distt: Aligarh. 4.022 File N0.- 392/ Ent/ DD(Sh) The committee noted that an application dated 17/10/2015 was made by the project proponent for environmental clearance of Brick earth mining at Gata No.-11, Village- Kasimpur, Tehsil-Kol & Gata No.- 183, 184, 185, 229, 230, 241, 242, 243, Village-Kheria Harchand, Tehsil-Kol , District-Aligarh,U.P. (Leased area 4.022 ha.)., M/S Maa Jagdamba Ent Udyog. A presentation was made by Mr. Madan Lal Gupta, project proponent along with their consultant M/s Geogreen Enviro Pvt. Ltd., Lucknow. The proponent, through the documents submitted and the presentation made, informed the committee that:- 1. The Environmental Clearance is sought for Brick earth mining at Gata No.-11, Village- Kasimpur, Tehsil-Kol & Gata No.- 183, 184, 185, 229, 230, 241, 242, 243, Village-Kheria Harchand, Tehsil-Kol , District-Aligarh,U.P. (Leased area 4.022 ha.)., M/S Maa Jagdamba Ent Udyog. 2. Salient features of the project is as follows: TOTAL AREA 4.022 Ha Total Mineable area 3.8201Ha Total Clay to be excavated (5 years) 57313.5 cubicmt Annual Production 11,460.00 cubicmt/annum Excavation depth 1.5 m Safety zone width 0.75 metre Safety zone (area) 0.1976 Ha Method of mining Manual using hand tools Man power 41 labors Period of mining 5 years as per agreement with lease owners Cost of project 14 Lakhs CSR 1 Lakh Other mines within 500 mt. No Critically polluted area No Plot area /cluster area in more than 5 hectare No Page 3 of 90 Minutes of 256 th SEAC Meeting Dated 16/01/2016 Wild Life Sanctuary No Wild Life Sanctuary within core & buffer zone. Nearest Highway Aligarh- Kasganj highway is 1 km SW. Nearest Sea/River/Water Body No water body exists within core zone Method of Mining Opencast manual Water Requirement 3 KLD & will be supplied from water tankers. 3. Land Details Sno. Khasra No/ Area Hactare Owners Village Excavation Depth Gata No. (Ha) Period in (Years) metre (mt) 1 11 1.132 Kunvar Pal S/O Nannu Kasimpur 5 1.5 2 183 0.606 Maan Singh S/O Komal Kheria 5 1.5 Singh Tejpal S/OMorari Harchand 3 184 0.320 Maan Singh S/O Komal Kheria 5 1.5 Singh Tejpal S/OMorari Harchand 4 185 1.333 Hari Singh S/O Nannu Singh Kheria 5 1.5 Netra Pal Singh,Gulab Harchand Singh,Shiv CharanS/O Dalchand 5 229,230,241 0.6310 Kunvar Pal Singh,Vijay Pal Kheria 5 1.5 ,242,243 SinghS/O Raghuveer Singh Harchand Total 4.022 4. Gata-wise production details with corresponding period (Chart form- Gata No. vs. production details for complete agreement period), duly considering the safety provisions S.No. Khasra/ Lease area Depth Excavation Mining Safety Total Gata No./ Hectare metre period area zone Excavated Arajee No. (Ha) (mt) (years) Hectare (Ha) Soil (Ha) (Cubicmt) 1 11 1.132 1.5 5 1.0754 0.0566 16131.00 2 183 0.606 1.5 5 0.5757 0.0303 8635.5 3 184 0.320 1.5 5 0.304 0.016 4560.00 4 185 1.333 1.5 5 1.266 0.06665 18995.25 5 229 0.1390 1.5 5 0.13205 0.00695 1980.75 6 230 0.0730 1.5 5 0.06935 0.00365 1040.25 7 241 0.0730 1.5 5 0.06935 0.00365 1040.25 8 242 0.0770 1.5 5 0.07315 0.00385 1097.25 9 243 0.269 1.5 5 0.25555 0.01345 3833.25 Total 4.022 3.8201 0.2011 57313.5 5.