Effect of the inner horizon on the black hole thermodynamics: Reissner-Nordstr¨om black hole and Kerr black hole G.E. Volovik1, 2 1Low Temperature Laboratory, Aalto University, P.O. Box 15100, FI-00076 Aalto, Finland 2Landau Institute for Theoretical Physics, acad. Semyonov av., 1a, 142432, Chernogolovka, Russia (Dated: July 26, 2021) For the Schwarzschild black hole the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is proportional to the area of the event horizon. For the black holes with two horizons the thermodynamics is not very clear, since the role of the inner horizons is not well established. Here we calculate the entropy of the Reissner- Nordstr¨om black hole and of the Kerr black hole, which have two horizons. For the spherically symmetric Reissner-Nordstr¨om black hole we used several different approaches. All of them give the same result for the entropy and for the corresponding temperature of the thermal Hawking radiation. The entropy is not determined by the area of the outer horizon, and it is not equal to the sum of the entropies of two horizons. It is determined by the correlations between the two horizons, due to which the total entropy of the black hole and the temperature of Hawking radiation depend only on mass M of the black hole and do not depend on the black hole charge Q. For the Kerr and Kerr-Newman black holes it is shown that their entropy has the similar property: it depends only on mass M of the black hole and does not depend on the angular momentum J and charge Q. PACS numbers: I. INTRODUCTION not coincide with the conventional Hawking temperature related to the outer horizon. The modified Hawking tem- For the simplest black hole the Bekenstein-Hawking perature does not depend on the charge Q, and thus is entropy is proportional to the area of the event horizon, the same as in case of the Schwarzschild black hole with ˜ 1 S = A/4G. However, for the black hole with two or the same mass M, i.e. TH = 8πM . more horizons, such as the rotating and charged black In Sec.IV it is shown that this result can be written holes and the black holes in the de Sitter space-time, the as the product of the thermal factors, determined by the E thermodynamics is not well established, since the role Hawking temperatures of two horizons: exp ˜ = − TH of the inner horizon remains unclear. The inner horizon E E 1–8 exp exp . This demonstrates that the may experience instabilities, which may or may not T+ T− − × − produce singularity at the horizon, or even prevent the Hawking radiation in the presence of two horizons is the formation of the inner horizon. correlated process, which is similar to the phenomenon of If the inner horizon is present it may contribute to the cotunneling in the electronic systems, when an electron entropy of the black hole. However, the total entropy of experiences the coherent sequence of tunneling events: the system is not necessarily the sum of the entropies of from an initial to the virtual intermediate states and then the horizons, since the correlations between the horizons to final state state.20,21 In our case the virtual intermedi- are possible, see e.g. Refs.9,10. There are the other hints, ate state is in the region between the two horizons. The which suggest that the black hole entropy is not necessar- cotunneling also takes place in the process of Hawking ily determined by the area of the outer horizon, see e.g. radiation of massive particles with energy smaller than 11–13 mass, E <m.19 In this case the particle first tunnels arXiv:2107.11193v1 [gr-qc] 21 Jul 2021 extremal surfaces in Refs. and references therein. Here we consider the charged black hole (the Reissner- across the horizon, and then tunnels to the detector. Nordstr¨om black hole) and the rotating black hole (the In Sec.V the entropy is considered in the approach Kerr black hole). We ignore the possible instabilities of based on the method of the singular coordinate trans- 22 the inner horizons of these black holes. The most part of formations, which was developed in Ref. In this ap- the paper is devoted to the spherically symmetric black proach, the probability of the macroscopic quantum tun- hole with two horizons – the charged Reissner-Nordstr¨om neling between the black hole and white hole is calcu- (RN) black hole. We calculate the entropy and the cor- lated, which allows to find the entropy of both the black responding temperature of the thermal Hawking radia- and white holes. The result for the entropy of RN black ˜ 2 tion using several different approaches. All of them give hole, SRN = 4πM , also does not depend on charge the same results, which demonstrates the correlations be- Q and is the same as for neutral black hole with the tween the inner and outer horizons. Then one of these same mass. This result, which was considered puzzling 22 approaches is applied to the Kerr black hole. in Ref. , now has got the support from the modified In Sec.III the radiation from the RN black hole is con- Hawking temperature: it is in agreement with the ther- 2 dM 14–19 modynamic relation dS˜RN = d(4πM )= . sidered using the semiclassical tunneling approach. T˜H When both inner and outer horizons are taken into ac- The independence of the entropy on charge Q suggests count, one obtains that the temperature of radiation does that the states with different Q can be obtained by the 2 adiabatic transformations. However, this would contra- obtained in Ref.23 (see Eq.(68) therein). In the SdS case, dict to the charge conservation. In Sec.VI we consider S+ and S− are the entropies of the cosmological horizon the adiabatic transformation, which does not contradict and the black hole horizon correspondingly. The general to the conservation of the charge Q. It corresponds to concept of temperature in multi-horizon spacetimes with adiabatic change of the fine structure constant α to its application to SdS metric is discussed in Ref.24. zero value. When α slowly decreases to zero the two hori- Similar result takes place for the total entropy of the zons move slowly with conservation of the charge number Kerr black hole (including that of the inner horizon). It Q and energy M. Finally the inner horizon disappears is determined by the mass M and does not depend on and the black hole at α = 0 becomes neutral, in spite the black hole angular momentum J.25 of the finite value of charge Q. In such slow process the First we explain such behaviour of the entropy for the entropy does not change, and is the same as the entropy spherically symmetric RN black hole, We shall use several of the neutral black hole. different approaches. Then in Sec.VII we apply one of In Sec.VII the adiabatic approach of Sec.VI is extended these approaches to the Kerr black hole. to the Kerr black hole. Here the adiabatic process is con- sidered in which the angular momentum J of the black hole is conserved, while the angular velocity of rotation III. HAWKING RADIATION FROM TWO approaches zero value. This adiabatic process demon- HORIZONS strates that the entropy of the Kerr black hole depends only on mass M of the black hole and does not depend The Eq.(5) can be obtained from the temperature of on its angular momentum J. the thermal Hawking radiation, which can be found using the method of the semiclassical quantum tunneling.14–18 II. REISSNER-NORDSTROM¨ BLACK HOLE Now we have two horizons, and thus the Hawking radi- ation temperature can be modified. For RN black hole the PG metric is not well defined. In the semiclassi- The metric of Reissner-Nordstr¨om black hole with the cal method the process of Hawking radiation is typically event horizon at r+ and the inner horizon at r−: studied using the Painleve-Gullstrand (PG) metric.26,27 However, the existence of the inner horizon does not allow 1 ds2 = dt2a(r)+ dr2 + r2dΩ2. (1) for the well defined PG metric to exist,28 and its exten- − a(r) sion is required. The proper extension of the PG metric 29 where is obtained by the following coordinate transformation: 2 (r r−)(r r+) √2Mr r a(r)= − 2 − . (2) dt dt fdr , f = . (7) r → ± r2 + Q2 (r r−)(r r+) − − The positions of horizons are expressed in terms of the p mass M and charge Q of the black hole (G = c = 1): This leads to the black hole and white hole states without singularities at horizons: 2 r+r− = Q , r+ + r− =2M. (3) Q2 1 ds2 = dt2 1+ + (dr vdt)2 +r2dΩ2 , (8) The conventional entropy of RN black hole is typically − r2 Q2 ± 1+ r2 related to the area of the outer horizon: 2 where the shift velocity is: 2 2 2 SRN(r+)= πr+ = π M + M Q (4) p − 2M Q2 v2 = 1+ . (9) However, in Ref.22 the different result was obtained, i.e. r r2 the entropy does not depend on Q: In this extension of the PG coordinates, the shift veloc- 2 S˜RN =4πM . (5) ity is real for all r. This is distinct from the conventional (non-modified) PG coordinates,30,31 where the shift ve- This entropy can be written in the form: locity becomes imaginary for r < r0 = r+r−/(r+ + r−). 2 The tunneling trajectory for massless particle can be S˜RN = S+ + S− , (6) found from the energy spectrum of a particle.