COMMUNITY GOVERNANCE REVIEW: – BARROW UPON TRENT, TWYFORD & STENSON AND STENSON FIELDS - STAGE ONE CONSULTATION RESPONSES Appendix 4 Key: L = letter; E= e-mail Date No. Title First Name Surname Address Comment In favour Against Unknown Code rec’d / Initial 14.07.16 1 G Powell 55 Swarkestone Rd I have received a letter from yourselves attempting to explain Y E Barrow-upon-Trent the above review, I find the document confusing and actually DE73 7HF explains nothing, it is a 9 page document of waffle. So I would like to explain my position. I AM IN SUPPORT OF THE REQUEST BY BARROW-UPON-TRENT PARISH COUNCIL TO SDDC FOR THE CHANGE OF OUR PARISH BOUNDARY AS PROPOSED IN FEBUARY 2015. 14.07.16 2 A G Eley OBE AE 6 Beaumont Close I am a long-term resident of the village of Barrow on Trent Y E MRCGP Barrow on Trent and I am responding to the call for consultation regarding the Derby community governance review of the parish. Barrow on Trent DE73 7HQ is fortunate in having a Parish Council which reflects the feeling of the local residents. The Parish Council have been proposing to transfer the land in question to Stenson Fields Parish over a number of years Changes within the parish over the last 20 years have resulted in the parish becoming isolated from the north- eastern portion of the parish. This followed directly from the construction of the A50 road which cut across the parish and isolated the portion of the land which is contiguous to the parishes of Stenson Fields and the City of Derby. Adoption of South Derbyshire District Council Local Plan Part 1 means that this land will be developed over the next 20 years as residential accommodation comprising some 2000 units. This would place an unreasonable change on the character of the Parish of Barrow on Trent which currently has a population of only some 500 souls. The new residential accommodation will be contiguous to both Stenson Fields and the City of Derby and will have no connection with the parish of Barrow on Trent and will be physically separated from the remainder of the parish by both the A50 road and the Trent and Mersey Canal. The proposed new development is separated by road from the built environment of the village of Barrow on Trent by a distance of 1.5 kilometres It will also look for its services towards the existing centre established within the Sinfin District Centre. These proposals have been discussed repeatedly at Parish Council meetings in Barrow on Trent and the Parish Council have established a clear view that they wish the land indicated on map Date No. Title First Name Surname Address Comment In favour Against Unknown Code rec’d / Initial http://www.south- derbys.gov.uk/Images/Area%20map_tcm21-281679.pdf to be transferred from the Parish of Barrow on Trent to the Parish of Stenson Fields It is also my understanding from attending Parish Council meetings that both the Parish Councils of Barrow on Trent and Stenson Fields support this proposal. I fully support the proposal for the Parish of Barrow upon Trent to divest around 153.5 acres of land in the north-west area, with Stenson Fields to incorporate this into its area. 15.07.16 3 Victoria Lucas 17, Hall Park As a resident of Barrow on Trent, I am in support of the Y E Barrow on Trent request by Barrow upon Trent Parish Council to SDDC for the 4 Ian Lucas Derby change of our parish boundary as proposed in February 2015. Y DE73 7HD 15.07.16 5 Anne Heathcote 7 Chapel Lane Will you please take this e-mail as my support for the Y E Barrow upon Trent proposed boundary change for Barrow upon Trent / Stenson Derby. DE73 7HE Fields as requested by the Parish Council in February 2015, and as illustrated in the recent Community Governance Review 2016 map. 18.07.16 6 Mrs M E Garratt 59 Swarkestone Road I am in support of the request by Barrow upon Trent Parish Y L Barrow on Trent Council, to SDDC, for the change of the Parish boundary as Derby proposed in February 2015. DE73 7HF 18.07.16 7 Mrs Diana Eley 6 Beaumont Close I am a long-term resident of the village of Barrow on Trent Y E Barrow-on-Trent and I am responding to the call for consultation regarding the Derby community governance review of the parish. DE73 7HQ Barrow on Trent is fortunate in having a Parish Council which reflects the feeling of the local residents. The Parish Council have been proposing to transfer the land in question to Stenson Fields Parish over a number of years Changes within the parish over the last 20 years have resulted in the parish becoming isolated from the north- eastern portion of the parish. This followed directly from the construction of the A50 road which cut across the parish and isolated the portion of the land which is contiguous to the parishes of Stenson Fields and the City of Derby. Adoption of South Derbyshire District Council Local Plan Part 1 means that this land will be developed over the next 20 years as residential accommodation comprising some 2000 units. This would place an unreasonable change on the character of the Parish of Barrow on Trent which currently has a population of only some 500 souls. Date No. Title First Name Surname Address Comment In favour Against Unknown Code rec’d / Initial The new residential accommodation will be contiguous to both Stenson Fields and the City of Derby and will have no connection with the parish of Barrow on Trent and will be physically separated from the remainder of the parish by both the A50 road and the Trent and Mersey Canal. The proposed new development is separated by road from the built environment of the village of Barrow on Trent by a distance of 1.5 kilometres It will also look for its services towards the existing centre established within the Sinfin District Centre These proposals have been discussed repeatedly at Parish Council meetings in Barrow on Trent and the Parish Council have established a clear view that they wish the land indicated on map http://www.south- derbys.gov.uk/Images/Area%20map_tcm21-281679.pdf to be transferred from the Parish of Barrow on Trent to the Parish of Stenson Fields It is also my understanding that both the Parish Councils of Barrow on Trent and Stenson Fields support this proposal. I fully support the proposal for the Parish of Barrow upon Trent to divest around 153.5 acres of land in the north-west area, with Stenson Fields to incorporate this into its area. 27.07.16 8 Dr Jill Scarfe 39 Church Lane, I Jill Scarfe, Barrow upon Trent, support the proposed change Y E Barrow upon Trent to the Barrow upon Trent boundary. DE73 7HB 28.07.16 9 Mr Ronald Scarfe 39 Church Lane, I, Ronald G M Scarfe support the proposed change to the Y E Barrow upon Trent Barrow upon Trent boundary DE73 7HB 28.07.16 10 Mrs Louise Brown By e-mail My husband and I are in support of the request by Barrow Y E upon Trent Parish Council to SDDC for the change of our 11 Mr Ian Brown parish boundary as proposed in February 2015. Y 29.07.16 12 Mr Vaughan 37 Church Lane We support the proposed change to the Barrow upon Trent Y E Barrow Upon Trent parish boundary. 13 Mrs Vaughan DE73 7HB Y 29.07.16 14 K Bottrill 17 Chapel lane, Barrow I support the proposed change to the Barrow Upon Trent Y E Upon Trent boundary. 01.08.16 15 Mr Robert Thomas By e-mail My name is Robert Thomas I am a 20 year old that has lived Y E in Barrow upon Trent for my entire life and I support the proposed change to the parish boundary of Barrow upon Trent. Date No. Title First Name Surname Address Comment In favour Against Unknown Code rec’d / Initial 01.08.16 16 Mr G V Scott 45 Twyford Road We wish to support the proposed boundary change to the Y E Barrow-on-Trent parish of Barrow upon Trent. 17 Mrs P A Scott DE73 7HA Y 02.08.16 18 Dr Jennifer Ashworth By e-mail I support this motion. Y E Dr Jennifer Ashworth, resident of Barrow on Trent for 18 years 03.08.16 19 Mr John Peat Hayside I support the proposed changes to the Barrow upon Trent Y E Twyford Road boundary. 20 Mrs Denise Peat Barrow upon Trent. Y 03.08.16 21 Mr David Thomas 1 Walnut Close I am writing to support the proposed boundary change at Y E Barrow on Trent Barrow On Trent. I feel this is very important to maintain the Derby DE737JL. rural nature of the parish. 05.08.16 22 Debra Maddock By e-mail As a resident of Barrow On a Trent I wish to advise you that I Y E agree with the proposals jointly put forward by the parish councils of BOT and Stenson Fields to change the boundaries of the 3 parishes as shown in the map included in your recent correspondence. 06.08.16 23 David Stone 3 Walnut Close We are well aware that there has been considerable debate Y E Barrow upon Trent over changes to the existing Parish Boundary in respect of the 06.08.16 24 Nina Stone DE73 7JL proposed developments at Stenson Fields.