ATTACHMENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS FORESHORE LICENCE APPLICATION Fenit Harbour, Tralee, Co. Kerry ATTACHMENT CONTENTS Attachment A Figure 1 proximity to sensitive shellfish areas Attachment B B.1 Sediment Chemistry Results Attachment B.1(I) Dumping at Sea Material Analysis Reporting Form Attachment B.1(II) Copies of the laboratory reports Attachment B.1(III) Comparison to Irish Action Level B.2 Characteristics /Composition of the Substance or Material for Disposal Attachment B.2 Sediment Characterisation Report (AQUAFACT, 2018) Attachment C Assessment of Alternatives Attachment D D.1 Purpose Of The Operation D.2 Loading Areas D.3 Details Of The Loading Operations Attachment E E.1 DUMPING SITE SELECTION E.2 GENERAL INFORMATION E.3 DETAILS OF THE DUMPING OPERATION Attachment E.1(I) Attachment E.2(I) Marine Benthic Study Fenit Harbour Dredging and Disposal Operations (Aquafact 2018) Attachment F F.1 Assessment of Impact on the Environment Appendix 1 Assessment of Risk to Marine Mammals from Proposed Dredging and Dumping at Sea Activity, Fenit Harbour, Co. Kerry. Appendix 2 Underwater Archaeological Impact Assessment Report Fenit Harbour and Tralee Bay, Co. Kerry. Appendix 3: Nature Impact Statement Attachment G G.1 Monitoring Programme Attachment-A FIGURE 1 SHELLFISH WATERS FORESHORE LICENCE APPLICATION Fenit Harbour, Tralee, Co. Kerry Legend Foreshore Licence Area Shellfish Area 5091m Proposed Dump Site 4 89m Fenit Harbour Map Reproduced From Ordnance Survey Ireland By Permission Of The Government. Licence Number EN 0015719. 0 1.5 3 km Ü Project Title: Fenit Harbour Client: Kerry County Council Drawing Title: Foreshore Licence and Shellfish Areas Drawn: JK Checked: CF Date: 15-10-2019 Scale (A4): 1:85,000 Attachment-B MATERIAL ANALYSIS DUMPING AT SEA PERMIT APPLICATION Fenit Harbour, Tralee, Co. Kerry Attachment B MATERIAL ANAYSIS CONTENTS B.1 SEDIMENT CHEMISTRY RESULTS Attachment B.1(I) Dumping at Sea Material Analysis Reporting Form Attachment B.1(II) Copies of the laboratory reports Attachment B.1(III) Comparison to Irish Action Levels B.2 Characteristics and Composition of the Substance or Material for Disposal Attachment B.2 Sediment Characterisation Report (AQUAFACT, 2018) Attachment B MATERIAL ANAYSIS B.1 SEDIMENT CHEMISTRY RESULTS B.1.1 Sampling Locations Consultation was undertaken with the Marine Institute of Ireland to determine the optimum locations and number of samples to be attained to ensure the proposed loading locations were adequately tested. A total of 12 sediment stations were sampled for physical and chemical analysis as per a request from the Marine Institute. Figure 1 shows the sampling station locations and Table 1 shows the sampling station coordinates. Full details of the sampling undertaken and methodology, including the correspondence from the Marine Institute on the sampling schedule, is provided in Attachment B.2 Sediment Characterisation Report (AQUAFACT, 2018). Figure 1 Location of chemistry sampling sites Table 1: Coordinates of stations sampled for physical and chemical analysis. Station Latitude Longitude Depth (m) 1 52.2702 -9.86316 2.7 2 52.2713 -9.86313 3.3 3 52.27 -9.86274 4.8 4a 52.2701 -9.85977 7.4 5 52.2713 -9.86214 4.4 6 52.2703 -9.86194 4.0 7 52.2699 -9.8618 3.1 8 52.2716 -9.86177 1.4 9 52.272 -9.86104 3.4 10 52.2711 -9.86087 2.7 11 52.2704 -9.86028 8.5 12 52.2722 -9.8602 3.3 Attachment B MATERIAL ANAYSIS Attachment B.1(I) Dumping at Sea Material Analysis Reporting Form EPA Dumping at Sea Permit Application - Material Analysis Reporting Form (Version 1.0) Sheet 1. Instructions Instructions As part of an application for a Dumping at Sea (DAS) Permit, sediment chemistry results must be submitted using this form. When completing this form, please ensure that you: * Complete all worksheets in full - i.e. sheets "2. Project Info", "3. Results" and "4. QA". * Report all results in the units specified (e.g. mg kg-1 versus mg kg-1). * Do not alter the format of this spreadsheet by changing units, by moving columns or by inserting new columns amongst the existing used columns. * Insert additional rows as necessary at the end of the existing rows in sheet. "3 Results" * Insert other determinants as necessary in the empty columns to the right in sheet. "3 Results". * Any additional information should be included as inserted comments or in the Notes column in sheet. "3 Results". * Provide a brief description of methodology used in sheet "2. Project Info". * Enter the measured value (as well as the certified value) for Certified Reference material in sheet "4. * If in-house reference material is used, insert the measured value and the range normally achieved. * Refer to the Dumping at Sea Application Form Guidance Note for further relevant information: http://www.epa.ie/downloads/forms/lic/das/name,30267,en.html Key Location Name of area e.g. Cork Harbour, Dublin Bay CRMs Certified reference materials used in analyses for metals, organics & TBT Specify which fraction of sediment was analysed. < 2mm is requested, but Fraction analysed some labs use < 63um Analysing laboratory Main laboratory where samples were sent to for analysis Sub-contract lab Sub-contracted laboratory where samples were sent by main laboratory Sample ID code Sample number assigned by sampler Lab Report ID Code assigned by analysing laboratory Give lat/long coordinates in degrees & decimal minutes (dd mm.mmm) of the Position (dd/mm.mmm) position where the sample was taken. List also the datum & projection. Sampling depth (m) The depth below the seabed surface at which the sample was collected. <2mm Grain size % < 2mm <63um Grain size % < 63mm OC Organic carbon (NOT organic matter) TEH Total extractable hydrocarbons Cu Copper Zn Zinc Cd Cadmium Hg Mercury Pb Lead As Arsenic Cr Chromium Mn Manganese Ni Nickel Li Lithium Al Aluminium DBT Dibutyl tin TBT Tributyl tin S TBT + DBT Sum of di-butyl tin & tri-butyl tin Sum of the seven ICES polychlorinated biphenyls: PCB 028, PCB 052, PCB S 7 PCB 101, PCB 138, BCB 153, PCB 180, PCB 118. Sum of US EPA 16 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons: Naphthalene, Acenaphthylene, Acenaphthene, Fluorene,Phenanthrene, Anthracene, S 16 PAH Fluoranthene, Pyrene, Benzo(a)anthracene, Chrysene, Benzo(b)fluoranthene, Benzo(k)fluoranthene, Benzo(a)pyrene, Dibenzo(ah)anthracene, Benzo(ghi)perylene, Indeno(123-cd)pyrene. g-HCH 1α,2α,3β,4α,5α,6β-hexachlorocyclohexane (Lindane) HCB Hexachlorobenzene Sheet 1. Instructions (Page 1 of 1) EPA Dumping at Sea Permit Application - Material Analysis Reporting Form (Version 1.0) Sheet 2. Project Info 1. General Information Applicant (company name) Kerry County Council Location (port/harbour) Fenit Harbour Dredge Quantity (tonnes) Permit Application Reg. No. (to be assigned by EPA) 2. Survey Information Survey Company Sampling Date 23/11/2017 Analysing Laboratory ESG Sub Contract Lab Analysis Date 28/11/2017 3. Methods Information Fraction analysed <2mm Water content of sample (reported as %) Air dried 105°C Are results reported as wet weight or dry weight? Dry Weight Granulometry method Particle Size by Laser Diffraction · Total Hydrocarbons: (GCFID) TNRCC method using gas TEH method chromatography with flame ionisation detection. carbonate removal and sulphurous acid/combustion at Organic carbon (OC) method 800°C/NDIR. Metals (incl. mercury & arsenic) extraction type using HF boric extraction followed by ICPMS (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Methods of detection (metals, incl. mercury & arsenic) Pb, Hg, Ni and Zn) and by ICPOES (Al and Li). Organics extraction types • Organotins: Documented in-house method OGSNSED • OCP & PCB analysis: Documented in-house method using Methods of detection (PCBs / PAHs / TBT / DBT) GCQQQ. • PAH analysis: Documented in-house method using DTI specification by GC-MS. Sheet 2. Project Info (Page 1 of 1) EPA Dumping at Sea Permit Application - Material Analysis Reporting Form (Version 1.0) Sheet 3. Results Sampling Sampling Sample appearance Sample ID Sampling Position Latitude Position Longitude Company Name Location date depth Lab Report ID (e.g. colour, texture, signs of code Location ID (dd mm.mmm) (dd mm.mmm) (dd/mm/yyyy) m life) Kerry County Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.7896 Light brown surface/ anoxic Council 1 1 52˚ 16.2120000000002 2.7 S18_1025 black below , Mud/fine sand Kerry County Light brown surface/ anoxic Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.7878 2 Council 2 52˚ 16.2779999999998 3.3 S18_1025 black below, Mud/fine sand Kerry County Light brown surface/ anoxic Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.7644 3 Council 3 52˚ 16.2000000000002 4.8 S18_1025 black below, Mud/fine sand Light brown surface/ anoxic Kerry County Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.5862 7.4 black below, Mud/medium 4 Council 4 52˚ 16.206 S18_1025 sand Light brown surface/ anoxic Kerry County Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.7284 4.4 black below, Mud/fine sand, Council 5 5 52˚ 16.2779999999998 S18_1025 Sabella sp. tubes Kerry County Light brown surface/ anoxic Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.7164 4 6 Council 6 52˚ 16.2179999999999 S18_1025 black below, Mud/fine sand Light brown surface/ anoxic Kerry County Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.708 3.1 black below, Mud/fine sand, Council 7 7 52˚ 16.194 S18_1025 Sabella sp. tubes Kerry County Light brown surface/ anoxic Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.7062 1.4 8 Council 8 52˚ 16.296 S18_1025 black below, Mud/fine sand Kerry County Light brown surface/ anoxic Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.6623999999999 3.4 9 Council 9 52˚ 16.3199999999999 S18_1025 black below, Fine sand/mud Light brown surface/ anoxic Kerry County Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.6522 2.7 black below, Mud/fine sand, Council 10 10 52˚ 16.2659999999998 S18_1025 Rag worms Light brown surface/ anoxic Kerry County Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.6168 8.5 black below, Mud/medium 11 Council 11 52˚ 16.2240000000001 S18_1025 sand Light brown surface/ anoxic Kerry County Fenit Harbour 22/11/2017 9˚ 51.612 3.3 black below, Mud/medium 12 Council 12 52˚ 16.3319999999999 S18_1025 sand <insert more rows as necessary> Sheet 3.