Oglethorpe Journal of Undergraduate Research Volume 4 Issue 1 Oxford University Tutorial Papers by Article 2 Oglethorpe Univeristy Students July 2014 The Orkney Islands in the Viking Age Moira Speirs MS Oglethorpe University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.kennesaw.edu/ojur Part of the Cultural History Commons, European History Commons, Medieval History Commons, and the Scandinavian Studies Commons Recommended Citation Speirs, Moira MS (2014) "The Orkney slI ands in the Viking Age," Oglethorpe Journal of Undergraduate Research: Vol. 4 : Iss. 1 , Article 2. Available at: https://digitalcommons.kennesaw.edu/ojur/vol4/iss1/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by DigitalCommons@Kennesaw State University. It has been accepted for inclusion in Oglethorpe Journal of Undergraduate Research by an authorized editor of DigitalCommons@Kennesaw State University. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Speirs: Orkney Island in the Viking Age 1 At the height of the Viking Age the seas around northern Europe were a pas- sage for war and trade. Viking longships ruled the seas and today the tales of the power, might and influence of these Norsemen still fascinate us. A small group of islands to the north east of Scotland, the Orkney Islands, played a crucial role in supporting the Viking network in the tenth to thirteenth century. The history of the islands and their relationship with both Scotland and Nor- way illuminate the discussion of the Scandinavian influence in the North Sea region. The Orkneys are now part of Scotland but the history of the islands show that they were part of the Norwegian Scatterlands in The Viking Age1. Norway was certainly the most powerful of the three and although Scotland was al- ways independent the links between the two countries were strong. Orkney as an outpost of Norway was a focal point which played a large part in shaping their shared history. An accurate description of the situation would be that Norway, its province, Orkney, and its close neighbor, the land of the Scots, shared affiliations, treaties and trade agreements which were influenced by the circumstances in all three regions. Orkney’s importance grew beginning from being a Scandinavian outpost used for winter quarters through a thriving set- tlement, a source of supplies and manpower for Norway and at its height to a semi independent earldom capable of hosting diplomatic meetings between 1 I.P. Grohse, “From Asset in War to Asset in Diplomacy: Orkney in the Medieval Realm of Norway”, Island Studies Journal, 8, no.2 (2013) : 255 Published by DigitalCommons@Kennesaw State University, 2014 1 Oglethorpe Journal of Undergraduate Research, Vol. 4 [2014], Iss. 1, Art. 2 2 heads of state or their representatives. It is clear that Norway, Orkney, and Scotland shared a relationship that was not entirely that of conquerors and conquered. How and when did Orkney become such a key player in the rela- tions between Norway and Scotland? Were the Earls of Orkney a barrier to war between the nations? The answers to these questions will show that Ork- ney was a hub of commerce and diplomacy in The Late Middle Ages. Orkney’s geographical position is perhaps the first point which should be ex- plored. It is difficult to pinpoint exactly when Orkney became a Scandinavian province. We have evidence that the islands were known to be inhabited be- fore the Viking Age. In Roman times the name Orc or Cape Orkas was rec- orded on maps of the British Isles2. There are a few very early mentions of the people who inhabited these northernmost islands. Two distinct early tribal peoples for which we have evidence are the Picts and the Papar. One early source states that “these islands were inhabited by the Picts, who were only a little bigger than pigmies, worked great marvels in city building each evening and morning, but at noontide they were utterly bereft of their strength and hid 3 for fear in little subterranean dwellings” 2, W.P.L. Thomson, The New History of Orkney. (Edinburgh: Birlinn,2 008) 4. 3 C. Phelpstead and D.I. Kunin, A History of Norway and the Passion and Miracles of Blessed Óláfr ( London: Viking Society for Northern Research Text, 2001) 8. https://digitalcommons.kennesaw.edu/ojur/vol4/iss1/2 2 Speirs: Orkney Island in the Viking Age 3 The same source describes the Papar as “Africans who practiced Judaism” which seem to our modern senses entirely unbelievable, it may be that some- thing of the essence of that bold statement is lost in translation 4. The earliest note regarding attacks in the area is from Dicuil around 825 C.E. He mentions islands about two days sail away from Norway which were inhabited by Irish hermits but then abandoned because of Norse raiders5. It is not specifically noted which islands but it is probably the Faros or the Western Isles. Orkney is a little further off, however it is very unlikely that those Norse raiders who had found the northernmost islands had not discovered Orkney and Shetland as well; two days sailing is inconsequential for a Viking ship. Sagas and myths can give clues to what was happening in the world when they were written, or sung, but, there is more than likely a great deal of poetic li- cense contained in the fabulous stories. The truth probably lies between the lines and they can be most useful for details of everyday life which would be unnecessary to embellish. A perfect example is Einar, regarded as the first in a line of successful Earls of Orkney6. In Harold Fairhair’s saga we hear of King Harold Fairhair (of Norway) giving the title of Earl (of Orkney) to Rongvald of Mœr. The fact that the Norwegian King granted the earldom is strong evidence that Orkney was regarded as an integral part of Norwegian 4 ibid 5 Ducil , The Northern Isles, ed. F.T. Wainwright, (New York: Thomas Nelson, 1962), 131 6 Heimkringla C890, in Anderson, Alan Orr (ed. and trans.), Early Sources of Scottish Histo- ry: AD 500–1286, vol. i (Edinburgh, 1923) p.373 Published by DigitalCommons@Kennesaw State University, 2014 3 Oglethorpe Journal of Undergraduate Research, Vol. 4 [2014], Iss. 1, Art. 2 4 territories. A small number of winter shelters seem hardly likely to need an Earl to oversee them. It is more likely that Norway had so large a number of citizens on the Islands that the King needed his representative in place to en- sure Norwegian law and his rule was being upheld. A snippet in the Orkneyinga saga, tells the tale of Rongvald's son Einar. He is sent off by his father to rid Orkney of Vikings who had taken over some settlements there. The Orkneyinga states ‘Einar sailed west to Shetland to gather forces7’. If Einar was sure he would find manpower on the Shetland Isles it is safe to as- sume that there were already some Norwegian settlements on those islands. He must also have been sure that they would be ready to fight with him for Orkney. This suggests that both Shetland and Orkney were well established as territories of Norway. A few years later the Orkneyinga also mentions a quar- rel resulting in Einar fleeing to Caithness, evidencing a Norwegian settlement there8. The saga finishes his tale by telling that he was a good ruler for many years and died in his bed. This is such an unusual end for a Norse hero that historians may be justified in believing it to be based in fact9. In the absence of written records and reliable sources it is understandable that historians interpret what sparse evidence is available. One of theses sources of evidence is the examination of the linguistic roots of place names. The prem- 7. Edwards & and Pálsson H. (Ed) Orkneyinga Saga:The History of the Earls of Orkney, Harmondsworth, (1981) p.29 8 Edwards and Pálsson, Orkneyinga p.32 9 ibid https://digitalcommons.kennesaw.edu/ojur/vol4/iss1/2 4 Speirs: Orkney Island in the Viking Age 5 ise is that tracing the Norse language in place names and dating when each name was used will map the course of Viking settlement10. It can not be con- sidered a precise way of making a timeline for the History of the rise of the Vikings. Until the late 800’s C.E. several different peoples each with a differ- ent language existed in the northern hemisphere. An early note attached to the Ravenna Cosmography written in the eight century refers to the confusion of place names which already existed in the islands: ‘Also in the same ocean are thirty-three islands called the Orchades not all of which are inhabited. Nevertheless we would wish, Christ willing, to name them, but because of the confusion resulting from this land be- ing controlled by different peoples who, according to the barbarian fashion, call the same islands by different names, we leave their names unlisted11’. A collection of three letters at the beginning or end of a name which may have been used on some maps and not on others can only be regarded as cir- cumstantial evidence. Place names are useful in defining the geographical po- sition of settlements which bear out comments in the sagas, e.g. the 10 W.F.H. NIcholaisen. ‘The Viking Settlement of Scotland: The evidence of Place Names’. in Farrell, R.T. The Vikings London (1982), Crawford B (ed) Scandanavian settlement in Northern Britain: Thirteen Studies of Place -Names in their Historical Context. London (1995) 11 Ravenna Cosmography in Thomson (2008) p.42 Published by DigitalCommons@Kennesaw State University, 2014 5 Oglethorpe Journal of Undergraduate Research, Vol.