FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY (FOUO) THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK THE FIRST COMMAND A REVIEW OF THE 47TH FLYING TRAINING WING OFFICER MISCONDUCT AND 19TH AIR FORCE FLYING TRAINING CULTURE 31 OCTOBER 2018 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY (FOUO) THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK CDI TASK 2A ............................................................................................................................... 90 Overview ................................................................................................................................... 90 Gender Demographics ............................................................................................................... 91 Survey Methodology .................................................................................................................. 95 Discrimination ........................................................................................................................ 95 Sexual Harassment ................................................................................................................. 96 Reporting/Preventing Mistreatment....................................................................................... 96 Unwanted Workplace Experiences ......................................................................................... 97 Bullying .................................................................................................................................. 98 Analysis ..................................................................................................................................... 98 Survey Results, ....................................................................................................................... 98 Observed Hostility Score. .................................................................................................... 98 Bullying. ............................................................................................................................. 99 Focus Groups and Individual Interviews .................................................................................. 99 Benevolent Sexism. .......................................................................................................... 101 Social Policing. .................................................................................................................. 101 Gender Micro-Aggressions. ............................................................................................... 102 The Importance of Leadership Action. ............................................................................... 102 Reporting Mechanisms. .................................................................................................... 103 No-Notice Visual Inspection of Squadron Areas .................................................................... 103 Equality Opportunity (EO) Database ..................................................................................... 104 Defense Equal Opportunity Management Institute Organizational Climate Survey (DEOCS) ... 104 Unprofessionalism in the Simulator Environment. .................................................................... 105 Findings ................................................................................................................................... 107 CDI TASK 2B ............................................................................................................................. 110 Overview ................................................................................................................................. 110 Survey Methodology ................................................................................................................ 111 Toxic Leadership Scale – Supervisors .................................................................................... 111 Toxic Leadership Scale – Instructors ...................................................................................... 112 Analysis ................................................................................................................................... 112 Survey Results ...................................................................................................................... 112 3 - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY (FOUO) DEOMI Organizational Climate Survey (DEOCS)/Unit Effectiveness Inspection Data ............... 113 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................... 113 Findings ................................................................................................................................... 114 CDI TASK 2C ............................................................................................................................. 116 Summary ................................................................................................................................. 116 Alcohol in the Formal Training Environment ......................................................................... 116 Reporting ............................................................................................................................. 117 Accountability ...................................................................................................................... 118 Qualities of a Professional .................................................................................................... 119 Analysis ................................................................................................................................... 119 Findings ................................................................................................................................... 121 CDI TASK 3 ............................................................................................................................... 124 Overview ................................................................................................................................. 124 Assignment Process ................................................................................................................. 124 Analysis ................................................................................................................................... 127 Findings ................................................................................................................................... 134 RECOMMENDATIONS .............................................................................................................. 136 Organizational and Training Culture ......................................................................................... 136 Recommendation 1: ............................................................................................................. 136 Recommendation 2: ............................................................................................................. 136 Recommendation 3: ............................................................................................................. 136 Recommendation 4: ............................................................................................................. 136 Recommendation 5: ............................................................................................................. 136 Leadership Environment and Oversight .................................................................................... 136 Recommendation 6: ............................................................................................................. 136 Recommendation 7: ............................................................................................................. 137 Recommendation 8: ............................................................................................................. 137 Barriers to Reporting by Students and Instructors .................................................................... 137 Recommendation 9: ............................................................................................................. 137 4 - FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY (FOUO) Recommendation 10: ........................................................................................................... 137 Recommendation 11: ........................................................................................................... 137 Institutional Policies and Safeguards ........................................................................................ 138 Recommendation 12: ........................................................................................................... 138 Recommendation 13: ........................................................................................................... 138 Recommendation 14: ........................................................................................................... 138 Recommendation 15: ........................................................................................................... 138 Recommendation 16: ........................................................................................................... 138 Recommendation 17: ........................................................................................................... 138 Recommendation 18: ..........................................................................................................