CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT
COMMUNITY BOARD MEETING FEBRUARY 16, 2021 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE GATEWAYS TO CHINATOWN
Chrystie Street at Hester and Grand Streets
Canal Street Triangle Manhattan Bridge Landing
Worth Street at Foley Square
Chatham Square Division Street
Franklin Arch
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 2 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE GATEWAYS TO CHINATOWN: DECADES IN THE MAKING
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 3 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE PROJECT LOCATION
Canal Street
Baxter Street Walker Street
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 4 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE INTRODUCTION
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 5
Canal Street Triangle CANAL STREET TRIANGLE COMMUNITY OUTREACH AND PRIORITIES
PUBLIC DESIGN FORUM (2016) REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS (2017)
WAYFINDING AND ORIENTATION
CULTURAL IDENTITY
COMMUNITY INFORMATION AND DIGITAL CONNECTIVITY
GREEN SPACE
SOCIAL INTERACTION
Design Priorities Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 6 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE ProposalRFP RESPONSE: 2019 UAP DESIGN PROPOSAL (REFERENCE ONLY)
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 7 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE COMMUNITY OUTREACH AND PRIORITIES (2018-2019)
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 8 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE ROUNDTABLES (2019)
COMMENTS DESIGN GOALS AND OBJECTIVES Circulation Facilitate and optimize east-west pedestrian flow through • “The Dragon’s Roar” by UAP does not resonate the site to afford better circulation and movement and to with or suitably represent the Manhattan create a sense of gateway procession. Chinatown and Little Italy communities. Buffer Provide a buffer along Canal Street integrating trees, • Design should focus more on spatial organization vegetation, seating and structures to safeguard users from and function rather than sculptural iconography. the traffic and noise along Canal Street.
• The effort should yield a simpler, more informal Flexible/Programmable Areas place of exchange. Inscribe gathering spaces that afford space for community demonstrations and programming. • The ground plane should be flexible to afford Cultural Identity/Space of Exchange interactive programming that engages residents Establish a framework to storyboard the complex cultural and visitors. history of the neighborhood, focusing on the pride and contributions of American-Chinese who have forged Manhattan’s Chinatown.
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 9 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDER MEETING DECEMBER 2ND, 2020 COMMENTS
• Over 22 active attendees
• Representatives from CBs, City Hall and elected officials as well as neighborhood stakeholders, previous roundtable participants and residents
• Webinar presentation of three options: Webinar Presentation Kiosk, Bosque, Procession
• Polling about key aspects and preferences
• Facilitated breakout sessions
Breakout Session
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 10 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: COMMUNITY STAKEHOLDER MEETING TAKEAWAYS
• Acknowledgment of response to community and stakeholder feedback
• Preference for planted area along Canal Street and bosque of trees
• Space is more a meeting point and east-west circulation portal rather than a place for relaxation
• Existing kiosk is not significant draw and does not serve the greater community
• Strong preference for interactive, digital interfaces with current and engaging information and exhibitions
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 11 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: PUBLIC DESIGN COMMISSION DECEMBER 14, 2020 - TAKEAWAYS
• “Bosque” option is most successful and preferred DESIGN DIRECTION
• Existing trees are healthy, providing the only • Add as many trees as possible, such as cherry vegetation along Canal Street trees
• Existing kiosk obstructs circulation and would • Strengthen east-west circulation and connection not provide the interactivity or content that the community is seeking • Study alternatives for the kiosk that are more dynamic and allow for greater community Option 2: BOSQUE engagement and collaboration
• Provide more details (e.g., materiality, siting and height) about the panels
• Work with a local organization such as MOCA to develop and manage the content on the panels
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 12 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT: BOSQUE
Existing Condition Design Development: BOSQUE
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 13 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT: BOSQUE - CIRCULATION
LITTLE ITALY LITTLE ITALY NOLITA NOLITA SOHO SOHO
SUBWAY SUBWAY SOHO SOHO
MANHATTAN BRIDGE MANHATTAN BRIDGE LES LES
COLUMBUS PARK COLUMBUS PARK COLUMBUS PARK CIVIC CENTER COLUMBUS PARK CIVIC CENTER CIVIC CENTER CIVIC CENTER
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 14 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT: BOSQUE Flexible program area Catenary Lighting System w/ multipurpose support pole
Digital Information Kiosk Screen A Radius: 9.47’ Canal Street 7.5’ Planted Canal Street buffer with additional gingko trees
B a x t e r S 8’
TYP. 4’
Existing gingko tree bosque Bench with integrated with permeable decomposed Walker Street Proposed digital component granite ornamental tree
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 15 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT: BOSQUE
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 16 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT: BOSQUE
Perspective: Crossing Walker St
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 17 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DESIGN DEVELOPMENT: BOSQUE
On triangle looking west at bosque/permeable pavement On triangle looking east at digital screen
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 18 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE 1 DESIGN DEVELOPMENT: BOSQUE 2
3
View 1: Crossing Canal Street View 2: Crossing Baxter Street View 3: Crossing Walker Street
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 19 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DETAILS: DIGITAL INFORMATION KIOSK STRUCTURE Precedent: LED Video Walls/Digital Screens
Screen A (Radius: 9.47’) 7’
16.73’
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 20 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DETAILS: DIGITAL INFORMATION KIOSK STRUCTURE - CONFIGURATIONS
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 21 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DETAILS: DIGITAL INFORMATION KIOSK CONCEPTUAL CONTENT
Cultural Content Interactive Kiosk/Wayfinding Sponsorship
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 22 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DETAILS: DIGITAL INFORMATION KIOSK DISTRICT-WIDE APPLICATION
Chrystie Street at Hester and Grand Streets
Canal Street Triangle Manhattan Bridge Landing
Worth Street at Foley Square
Chatham Square Division Street
Franklin Arch
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 23 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DETAILS: PERMEABLE PAVEMENT
Proposed Existing 1’ high curb Four Freedoms Park, Roosevelt Island curb
Suspended paving system; Permeable bonded- Loam soil to supports paving and provides aggregate paving support plant high-quality soil for plant growth material; color TBD growth Silva Cells Install Structural Soil Install
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 24 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE DETAILS: LIGHTING
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 25 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONSTRUCTION PHASING: EXISTING CONDITION
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 26 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONSTRUCTION PHASING: PHASE 1
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 27 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONSTRUCTION PHASING: PHASE 1 - CIRCULATION
LITTLE ITALY NOLITA SOHO
SUBWAY SOHO
MANHATTAN BRIDGE LES
COLUMBUS PARK COLUMBUS PARK CIVIC CENTER CIVIC CENTER
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 28 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONSTRUCTION PHASING: PHASE 1
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 29 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONSTRUCTION PHASING: PHASE 1
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 30 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONSTRUCTION PHASING: PHASE 1
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 31 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONSTRUCTION PHASING: PHASE 2
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 32 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE BOSQUE
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 33 2 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE APPENDIX
PREVIOUS CONCEPTS FROM DECEMBER 2ND STAKEHOLDER MEETING & DECEMBER 14TH PDC HEARING
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 35 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPTUAL DESIGN OPTIONS Legend
Flexible/programmable space Existing Tree
Buffer Zone Existing Kiosk
KIOSK BOSQUE PROCESSION
• Preserve existing kiosk • Preserve existing trees • Clear the triangle • Buffer integrated with existing kiosk creates • Planted buffer that could include interpretive • Larger buffer afforded with the removal of a respite from busy Canal Street signage, history, or other programming the trees and kiosk. Can include interpretive • Multiple flexible/programmable spaces • Existing trees are preserved, but create a signage, history, or other programming created while improving circulation space for gathering and circulation • Large flexible/programmable space • Preserve existing kiosk to provide • Large programmable space now afforded information and other community services with the removal of the kiosk
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 36 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: KIOSK
Existing kiosk wrapped with resin panels Integrate planting with kiosk Planted Canal Street buffer Community storyboard with narratives, images, etc. Canal Street
10.25’ B a x t e r S
9’
Walker Street Flexible program Fixed seating area
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 37 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: KIOSK
RENDERING
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 38 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: BOSQUE
Flexible program area
Community storyboard with narratives, images, etc.
Planted Canal Street buffer with flowering trees 7.5’ 18”
Canal Street B a x t e r S
8’
TYP. 4’
Fixed seating Existing gingko tree bosque with permeable decomposed Walker Street granite
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 39 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: BOSQUE
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 40 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: PROCESSION
Pedestrian Walk Signal Canal Street buffer with trees and vegetation Canal Street Wide bleacher style seating 18” Resin screen solid panels with text and images and slatted panels. B a x t e r S 9.5’
8’
9.5’
7.25’
Walker Street Flexible program areas
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 41 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE CONCEPT DESIGN: PROCESSION
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 42 CANAL STREET TRIANGLE KIOSK CONCEPT DESIGN OPTIONS
Circulation Facilitate and optimize east-west pedestrian flow through the site to afford better circulation and movement and to create a sense of gateway procession.
Planted Buffer BOSQUE Provide a buffer along Canal Street integrating trees, vegetation, seating and structures to safeguard users from the traffic and noise along Canal Street.
Flexible/Programmable Areas Inscribe gathering spaces that afford space for community demonstrations and programming. PROCESSION Cultural Identity/Space of Exchange Establish a framework to storyboard the complex cultural history of the neighborhood, focusing on the pride and contributions of American-Chinese who have forged Manhattan’s Chinatown.
Gateways to Chinatown • February 16, 2021 43