Appendix 22.1 Other Users Consultation Log

Consultation Responses Received

Date Recreational User Communication Response Notes Email sent with information on Information provided that project and seeking any offshore works are is not used 22nd June 2011 Kinghorn Sailing Club information that could be 6th July 2011 by Kingshorn Sailing Club and provided and any early so on objections raised. feedback. Email sent with information on Confirm that the area is not project and seeking any used by members apart from 22nd June 2011 Royal Forth Yacht Club information that could be 5th July 2011 potential transit during a bi- provided and any early annual race to Orkney. feedback. Pleased with level of consultation. Provided information that Thortonloch Email sent with information on is not a commonly used project and seeking any anchorage, but that yachts 22nd June 2011 Forth Yacht Clubs Association information that could be 29th June 2011 can passage through the provided and any early offshore site. Transit through feedback. offshore site encouraged, given appropriate safety and navigational marking etc. Encourage individual members and club as a whole to participate in consultation. Email sent with information on Raised issues of yacht passage project and seeking any (have some concern regarding 22nd June 2011 Aberdour Boat Club information that could be 28th June 2011 identification of structures, provided and any early particularly in fog) through feedback. offshore site, referring to RYA consultation. Provided information that Thorntonloch is an occasional Date Recreational User Communication Response Notes anchorage, and encourage minimal disruption at Thorntonloch to ensure continued anchoring allowed. Email sent with information on Do not expect proposed project and seeking any development to have a 22nd June 2011 Forth Canoe Club information that could be 27th June 2011 significant effect on this Club's provided and any early activities. feedback. Provided information that Thorntonloch is used by Email sent with information on surfers and have some project and seeking any concerns on impact on wave 22nd June 2011 Coast to Coast Adventure Sports information that could be 27th June 2011 climate at site from offshore provided and any early site and export cable. Would feedback. like continued consultation and information on impacts on hydrodynamics. Through the project website some correspondence was received from interested parties such as Various Anonymous surfers raising queries on impacts on the wave climate. Meeting held with local surfers and surf school to explain initial information on likely impacts on 27th March 2011 Anonymous – various wave climate and any arising from intertidal construction. Relevant information incorporated into the ES Chapter.

Consultation Carried Out (No Responses Received)

Date Recreational User Communication Sailing Clubs Dysart Sailing Club Port O`leith Motor Boat Club Burntisland Sailing Club Fisherrow Yacht Club Forth Yacht Clubs Association Royal Eastern Yacht Club Forth Corinthian Yacht Club Largo Bay Sailing Club Elie & Earlsferry Sailing Club East Lothian Yacht Club Anstruther Sailing Club Email sent with information on project and seeking any information that could be 22nd June 2011 St Andrews Sailing Club provided and any early feedback. Dunbar Sailing Club University Of Dundee Sailing Club Wormit Boating Club Dundee Sailing Club Tay Corinthian Boating Club Carnoustie Yachting And Rugby Club Berwick-Upon-Tweed Sailing Club Tay Yacht Clubs Association Royal Tay Yacht Club Arbroath Boating and Sailing Club Canoe Clubs 22nd June 2011 British Canoe Union Email sent with information on project and seeking any information that could be Scottish Canoe Association provided and any early feedback. East of Open Canoe Club Date Recreational User Communication Fife Canoeing Activities Group Kinross Canoe Club Kirkcaldy Canoe Club St Andrews University Canoe Club Tweed Canoe Club University Canoe Club Dundee University Canoe Club Angus Canoe Club East Neuk Outdoors Centre Kirkcaldy Canoe Club North Berwick Kayak Club Berwickshire Kayak Club Lothian Sea Kayak Club Edinburgh Kayak Club Fife Sea Kayak Club Volunteers Surf Kayak Club Tayside Sea Kayak Club Tayjet Personal Watercraft Club Surf Clubs and Associations Surf and Watersports Club Scotland Elie Watersports St.Vedas Surf Shop Thorntonloch Caravan Park Email sent with information on project and seeking any information that could be 22nd June 2011 Braveheart Boat Charter provided and any early feedback. Forth Logistics and Marine Services Seahunter Marine Forth Charters East Lothian Angling Association Flying Clubs 22nd June 2011 Edinburgh Flying Club Email sent with information on project and seeking any information that could be Date Recreational User Communication Fife Flying Club provided and any early feedback. Diving Clubs Scottish Sub Aqua Club & District Sub Aqua Club Border Sub-Aqua Club Aquastars Dive Centre East Lothian Divers Edinburgh University Sub Aqua Club Dive Safari Scotland Deep Blue Scuba Email sent with information on project and seeking any information that could be 22nd June 2011 Deep Blue Scuba provided and any early feedback. Dive Bunker Pegasus Diving University of St Andrews Sub Aqua Club Dundee Sub Aqua Club British Sub-Aqua Club Kirkcaldy Sub-Aqua Club Dunfermline Sub-Aqua Club Angling Clubs Buccaneer Sea A.C. East Fife Shore A.C. St. Serf's Sea A.C. Civil Service Sports Association - Sea A.C. Lothian & Borders Police Sea Angling Section Letter sent with information on project and seeking any information that could be 20th June 2011 North Berwick Sea A.C. provided and any early feedback. Port O' Leith Sea A.C. Commercial Inn Sea A.C. Angling Trust Buckhaven & District Sea Angling Club East Fife Shore Angling Club Date Recreational User Communication Forth Sea Angling Club Nairn Thistle Sea Angling Club Rosyth Civil Service Sea Angling Club Bell Rock Sea Angling Club Broughty Ferry Ex-service Club Sea Angling Club Carnoustie & District Sea Angling Club Scottish Anglers National Association Arbroath Angling European Federation of Sea Anglers Army angling federation sea