Final CHER Salem Bridge, Woolwich Rd. W., Salem, Centre Wellington
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CULTURAL HERITAGE EVALUATION REPORT SALEM BRIDGE COUNTY SITE No. B18050 (LOTS 15 & 16, CONCESSION 11 GEOGRAPHIC TOWNSHIP OF NICHOL) WOOLWICH STREET WEST (WR 18) SALEM, TOWNSHIP OF CENTRE WELLINGTON COUNTY OF WELLINGTON, ONTARIO April 2018 Prepared for: WSP Canada Group Limited Prepared by: CULTURAL HERITAGE EVALUATION REPORT SALEM BRIDGE COUNTY SITE No. B18050 (LOTS 15 & 16, CONCESSION 11 GEOGRAPHIC TOWNSHIP OF NICHOL) WOOLWICH STREET WEST (WR 18) SALEM, TOWNSHIP OF CENTRE WELLINGTON COUNTY OF WELLINGTON, ONTARIO April 2018 Prepared for WSP Canada Group Limited 610 Chartwell Road Suite 300 Oakville, ON, L6J 4A5 Prepared by: Unterman McPhail Associates Heritage Resource Management Consultants 540 Runnymede Road Toronto, ON, M6S 2Z7 Tel: 416-766-7333 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1 1.1 Project Description 1 1.2 Public Interest and Heritage Recognition 2 2.0 HISTORICAL SUMMARY 4 2.1 Introduction 4 2.2 Nichol Township 4 2.2.1 Salem 7 2.3 Salem Bridge, County Bridge No. B018050 9 2.4 Structure Type: Steel Through (Half) Pony Truss 11 2.5 Bridge Designer/Builder 12 2.5.1 William H. Keith, P. Eng. 12 2.5.2 Hamilton Bridge Company Limited 13 2.5.3 Albert Reeves 14 3.0 CULTURAL HERITAGE LANDSCAPE DESCRIPTION 14 3.1 Area Context 14 3.2 Site Description 15 4.0 BUILT HERITAGE RESOURCE DESCRIPTION 17 4.1 Salem Bridge, County No. B018050 18 4.1.1 Modifications 20 4.2 Comparative Analysis 20 4.2.1 Conclusion 21 5.0 CULTURAL HERITAGE RESOURCE EVALUATION 22 5.1 Introduction 22 5.2 Evaluation 23 5.3 Summary of Cultural Heritage Value 26 5.3.1 Statement of Cultural Heritage Value 26 5.3.2 Description of Heritage Attributes 27 6.0 CONCLUSION 28 SOURCES APPENDIX A: Salem Bridge, MEA Municipal Heritage Bridges, Cultural, Heritage and Archaeological Resources Assessment Checklist, February 23, 2016 APPENDIX B: Historical Maps, Photographs and Drawing APPENDIX C: Salem Bridge, Survey Form APPENDIX D: List of Comparative Structures, Steel Pony Truss Bridge, County of Wellington (Current as of January 2015) APPENDIX E: List of Projects, William H. Keith, County of Wellington Engineer (1933-1965) LIST OF TABLES Page Table 1. Evaluation of the Salem Bridge, Woolwich Street West (WR 18), Township of Centre Wellington, County of Wellington under “Criteria for Determining Cultural Heritage Value or Interest”, Ontario Regulation 9/06. 24 LIST OF FIGURES Page Figure 1. The Salem Bridge, Site No. B18050, is located on Woolwich Street West (WR 18) in Salem, Township of Centre Wellington, County of Wellington, Ontario. 1 Figure 2. WCMA ph6570, Woolwich Street, Salem, showing Allan’s Mill, Salem School and bridge, ca. 1890. This view looks west across the bridge at the Irvine Creek on Woolwich Street West. 10 Figure 3. WCMA, Slide 13363, view of the Woolwich Street Bridge, Salem, looking southeast and down river from the park, July 1968, photograph by Gordon Couling of Guelph. Note the residence at 25 Woolwich Street West on the right and 16 Woolwich Street West, the Salem (Wissler) Mill, in the background on the left. 10 Figure 4. This aerial view shows the immediate vicinity of the Salem Bridge [Google 2017]. 16 Figure 5. This view looks south along the Irvine Creek to the north elevation of the Salem Bridge. Note the Salem (Wissler) mill in the background. 18 Figure 6. This view shows the south elevation of the Salem Bridge, 1952 [As adapted, County of Wellington Roads Department, The County of Wellington Salem Bridge, 1952]. 19 Figure 7. This view shows the south elevation of the Salem Bridge, 1952 [As adapted, McCormick Rankin Consulting Engineers. County of Wellington Contract for Repairs to Structure No. 18059, Irvine Creek Bridge, County Road 18, Town of Salem, Contract No. 86-90. April 1986]. 19 Cultural Heritage Evaluation Report: Salem Bridge, County Site No. B18050 Page 1 (Lots 15 & 16, Con. 11, Geographic Township of Nichol), Woolwich Street West (WR 18) Community of Salem, Township of Centre Wellington, County of Wellington, Ontario 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Project Description WSP Canada Group Limited retained Unterman McPhail Associates, Heritage Resource Management Consultants, to undertake a Cultural Heritage Evaluation Report (CHER) on behalf of the County of Wellington for the Salem Bridge, County Bridge No. B018050. Completed in 1953, the Salem Bridge comprises a steel through (half) pony truss structure described as a Warren truss with verticals. It is located on Woolwich Street West (WR 18) in the community of Salem about 0.10 km east of WR 7 (Figure 1). The site survey was undertaken in August 2017. A bridge inspection in 2015 found the Salem Bridge to be in an advanced state of deterioration. A Municipal Heritage Bridges Cultural, Heritage and Archaeological Resources Assessment Checklist (Revised April 11, 2014) was completed in February 2016. The County of Wellington has commenced a Class Environmental Assessment Study (Class EA) for the Salem Bridge, which is being conducted as a Schedule “B” project in accordance with a Municipal Class Environmental Assessment (MCEA), Municipal Engineers Association (June 2000, amended 2007, 2011 and 2015) to address, confirm and document existing structural deficiencies of the subject bridge and identify alternative solutions including rehabilitation or replacement of the bridge. Figure 1. The Salem Bridge, Site No. B18050, is located on Woolwich Street West (WR 18) in Salem, Township of Centre Wellington, County of Wellington, Ontario. Unterman McPhail Associates April 2018 Heritage Resource Management Consultants Cultural Heritage Evaluation Report: Salem Bridge, County Site No. B18050 Page 2 (Lots 15 & 16, Con. 11, Geographic Township of Nichol), Woolwich Street West (WR 18) Community of Salem, Township of Centre Wellington, County of Wellington, Ontario This CHER includes a historical summary of the area and bridge site, a description of the bridge and its setting, an evaluation of the cultural heritage value of the bridge, a summary of cultural heritage value and recommendations. The site was evaluated using the criteria set out under Ontario Regulation 9/06, which was developed for the purpose of identifying and evaluating the cultural heritage value or interest of a property proposed for protection under Section 29 of the Ontario Heritage Act (OHA). Ontario Regulation 9/06 describes the three criteria as design value or physical value, historical value or associative value, and contextual value. Appendix A contains a copy of the Municipal Engineers Association’s (MEA) Municipal Heritage Bridges, Cultural, Heritage and Archaeological Resources Assessment Checklist (April 11, 2014) completed for the MCEA process for the subject bridge. Historical maps, photographs and a drawing are included in Appendix B. Appendix C contains a bridge survey form with current photographs of the bridge and it’s setting. Appendix D includes a list of comparative bridge structures in the County of Wellington as of 2015. Appendix E provides a list of projects attributed to William. H. Keith, Engineer for the County of Wellington. The Salem Bridge is oriented in a southwest to northeast direction. For the purposes of this CHER, the structure direction will be referred to as being oriented from east to west to correspond to the description used in the bridge inspection report. 1.2 Public Interest and Heritage Recognition Municipal The Township of Centre Wellington was contacted. It indicated the Salem Bridge is not included on the Township Heritage Register as a registered heritage property and it is not a municipally designated property under Part IV or Part V of the OHA. The bridge is not the subject of a municipal heritage easement. There are municipally recognized heritage resources on all four corners of the Salem Bridge that are included on the Township of Centre Wellington Register, namely: o 16 Woolwich West located on the southeast corner of the bridge containing the former Salem (Wissler) Mill, a two storey stone gristmill building dating from 1852-53; o 20 Woolwich Street West, a two storey stone residence built in 1870 on the southwest corner; o 25 Woolwich Street West, a one and-a-half storey stone residence built in 1850 on the northwest corner; and o 480 Washington Street that includes a two storey brick building built as a hotel, on the northeast corner. Unterman McPhail Associates April 2018 Heritage Resource Management Consultants Cultural Heritage Evaluation Report: Salem Bridge, County Site No. B18050 Page 3 (Lots 15 & 16, Con. 11, Geographic Township of Nichol), Woolwich Street West (WR 18) Community of Salem, Township of Centre Wellington, County of Wellington, Ontario As well, the two (2) properties at 31 and 33 Woolwich Street West, immediately west of 25 Woolwich Street West, are included on the Township of Centre Wellington Heritage Register. The property at 481 Washington Street, which extends to the east bank of the Irvine Creek, is a municipally designated property under Part IV of the OHA on the Township of Centre Wellington Heritage Register. Grand River Conservation Authority The federal, provincial and territorial governments in order to recognize outstanding rivers and ensure protection of significant heritage values established the Canadian Heritage Rivers system. The Salem Bridge that spans the Irvine Creek, a tributary of the Grand River, is included within the Grand River Watershed, which was designated as a Canadian Heritage River in 1994. The Grand River Conservation Authority is responsible for the management of the Canadian Heritage River. Information on heritage