City Research Online

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

City Research Online Rowden, C. (2001). Massenet, Marianne and Mary : Republican morality and Catholic tradition at the opera. (Unpublished Doctoral thesis, City University London) City Research Online Original citation: Rowden, C. (2001). Massenet, Marianne and Mary : Republican morality and Catholic tradition at the opera. (Unpublished Doctoral thesis, City University London) Permanent City Research Online URL: http://openaccess.city.ac.uk/7611/ Copyright & reuse City University London has developed City Research Online so that its users may access the research outputs of City University London's staff. Copyright © and Moral Rights for this paper are retained by the individual author(s) and/ or other copyright holders. All material in City Research Online is checked for eligibility for copyright before being made available in the live archive. URLs from City Research Online may be freely distributed and linked to from other web pages. Versions of research The version in City Research Online may differ from the final published version. Users are advised to check the Permanent City Research Online URL above for the status of the paper. Enquiries If you have any enquiries about any aspect of City Research Online, or if you wish to make contact with the author(s) of this paper, please email the team at [email protected]. Massenet, Marianne and Mary: Republican Morality and Catholic Tradition at the Opera Clair Rowden Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, Department of Music, City University, November 2001. Contents List Examples 3 of Musical ................................ Acknowledgements 4 ..................................... Abstract 5 ...................................... Introduction 6 ...................................... Chapter One: Marianne Mary 21 and ........................ The Cult Republican Motherhood 25 of ..................... Religion versus Philosophy and the Place of Religion in Society 30 The Clergy Confession 39 and ............................. The Feminisation Catholicism 42 of .................. .... Proudhon, Michelet, Legouve 48 ........................... Marriage Family 56 and the ............................... Separation Divorce 62 Adultery and Prostitution, and ........... Education Employment 66 and .............................. Civic Duties 74 Political Rights and ......................... Suffrage Depopulation 76 Emancipation,Female and ........... Fin de Siecle 82 ......................................... In Conclusion 85 ........................................ Chapter Two: Le Pretre, la femme la famille 87 et ............... The Genesis Herodiade 90 of .............................. History Biblical Opera 92 A Brief of ........................ Critical Reception 98 ..................................... Religion, Exoticism Eroticism 105 and ........................ Jean Baptiste Salome 113 and ............................... Salome, Herodiade Motherhood 126 and ...................... Herodiade 131 ........................................... JeanBaptiste (and Phanuel) 137 ............................. In Conclusion 150 ........................................ Chapter Three: Dreams of Decadence, or the Death of Positivism 153 Artistic Decadence Social Degeneration 154 and ................ Herode Figure Decadence 162 as of .......................... Athanael's Visions 169 .................................... Athanael's Temptation Ballet 176 ............................. GeneralReception Thais 180 Decadenceand the of .............. The Libretto 189 ......................................... In Conclusion 195 ........................................ Chapter Four: La Pornocratie 198 ............................ Femme Fatale Ecstatic Mystic 201 and ....................... Thals's Religious Culture, Mystical Sensuality, Hysteria 206 and ... Symphonic Interludes, Meditation religieuse and Musical Extase 215 Athanael ............................................. 231 In Conclusion 243 ........................................ Conclusion 248 ............................................ Sources 258 ............................................ Press & Periodical Sources 266 .............................. Operatic Sources 274 ...................................... Bibliography 276 Appendix1 .......................................... 292 ............................................ Appendix 2 293 ............................................ Appendix 3 295 ............................................ Appendix 4 299 ............................................ Appendix 5 309 ............................................ 2 List of Musical Examples Chapter Two Example la Herodiade. Opera trois 108 en actes et cinq tableaux. ..... Vocal score. Paris: Hartmann, n. d. [1881], 193. Example lb Herodiade. Opera 109 en quatre actes et sept tableaux. .... Vocal score. Paris: Heugel, 1909,82. Example 2a Herodiade. Vocal d., 196. 110 score,n. .................. Example 2b Herodiade. Vocal 1909,85. 111 score, .................. Example 3 Herodiade. Vocal 1909,63. 116 score, .................. Example 4 Herodiade. Vocal 1909,70-1. 122 score, ................ Example 5 Herodiade. Vocal 1909,189. 129 score, ................. Example Vocal 1909,135-6. 135 6 Herodiade. score, ............... Example Herodiade. Vocal 1909,137. 136 7 score, ................. Example Vocal 1909,162-4. 141-2 8 Herodiade. score, ............... Example 9 Herodiade. Vocal 1909,166. 143 score, ................. Example 10 Herodiade. Vocal 1909,242-3. 146 score, ............... Example 11 Herodiade. Vocal 1909,255. 148 score, ................. Chapter Four Example Ia Thais. Comedie lyrique en trois actes et sept tableaux. 211 Vocal score. Paris: Heugel, 1922,111. Example Thais. Vocal 1922,245. 213 lb score, ..................... 2 Thais. Vocal 1922,113. Example score, ...................... 221 Example 3 L'Avant-SceneOpera. MassenetThai's, 109, May 1988,49. 222 Example Thais. Vocal 1922,263. 228 4 score, ..................... Example 5 Thais. Vocal 1922,267-8. 229 score, ................... Example 6 Thais. Vocal 1922,10-11. 233 score, ................... Example Vocal 1922,94. 236 7 Thais. score, ...................... Example 8 Thais. Vocal 1922,99-100. 237, score, ................... Example 9 Thais. Vocal 1922,107. 240 score, ..................... Example 10 Thais. Vocal 1922,217. 243 score, ..................... 3 Acknowledgements The funding for the last two years of this thesis has been provided by the British Academy and the Fondation internationale Nadia et Lili Boulanger whose support I acknowledge with gratitude. My heartfelt thanks go to Annegret Fauser who, over the last five years, has watched me and my work mature, and never ceased to encourage and stimulate my intellectual curiosity and progress. Her support as tutor and friend has been invaluable and I cannot thank her enough. Sincere thanks are also due to Steven Huebner who has constructively criticised my work for the past two years, and to Joel-Marie Fauquet who has followed my progress from the time I was a Masters student. He is of extremely `bon conseil', and has not hesitated to share with me his vast knowledge of nineteenth-century French artistic history. I would like to thank Jeanne and Jacques Barlier for their constant affability in answering all my queries and questions on French cultural life, past and present. To my parents, Michael and Cynthia Rowden, I am indebted not only for financial support in the early years, but also for their unswerving and absolute faith in me and my capabilities. It is hard to find the words to express the gratitude I feel to my husband, Pierre-Maurice Barlier who continually encourages me to fulfil my potential and who willingly and tirelessly provides me with the intellectual, material and moral support. to be able to do so. Merci du fond de mon caeur. Declaration. I hereby grant powers of discretion to the City University Librarian to allow this thesis to be copied in whole or in part without further reference to the author. This permission covers only single copies made for study purposes, subject to normal conditions of acknowledgement. 4 Abstract The social and political practice of the French Third Republic resonated with a variety of contrasting ideologies which were reflected in cultural products and their reception, including opera. The operas of Jules Massenet, the most successful Parisian opera composer of his time, provide a good example of this kind of cultural mediation. A close examination of Massenet's operas will thus allow a re-evaluation of the complex interaction between art and society in musical culture at the end of the nineteenth century in France. Representative case-studies have been chosen, and the works are read in the contemporary Parisian context of moral and political debate. I examine the operas with respect to the choice of subject matter, the libretto and its genesis (especially transformations made in the process of creating a libretto), the music (both in its relation to the specific drama and musical convention of the time), the staging and its messages, and the critical reception in the press. The main chapters are dedicated to the following issues: 1. Mary or Marianne? The social, moral and cultural context, particularly regarding women, is explored via a close reading of sources from the second half of the nineteenth century. 2. Le Pretre, la Femme et la Familie. Anticlericalism and Republicanism as reflected in Massenet's opera Herodiade and its reception history are addressed. Also discussed
Recommended publications
  • Disclosure Guide
    WEEKS® 2021 - 2022 DISCLOSURE GUIDE This publication contains information that indicates resorts participating in, and explains the terms, conditions, and the use of, the RCI Weeks Exchange Program operated by RCI, LLC. You are urged to read it carefully. 0490-2021 RCI, TRC 2021-2022 Annual Disclosure Guide Covers.indd 5 5/20/21 10:34 AM DISCLOSURE GUIDE TO THE RCI WEEKS Fiona G. Downing EXCHANGE PROGRAM Senior Vice President 14 Sylvan Way, Parsippany, NJ 07054 This Disclosure Guide to the RCI Weeks Exchange Program (“Disclosure Guide”) explains the RCI Weeks Elizabeth Dreyer Exchange Program offered to Vacation Owners by RCI, Senior Vice President, Chief Accounting Officer, and LLC (“RCI”). Vacation Owners should carefully review Manager this information to ensure full understanding of the 6277 Sea Harbor Drive, Orlando, FL 32821 terms, conditions, operation and use of the RCI Weeks Exchange Program. Note: Unless otherwise stated Julia A. Frey herein, capitalized terms in this Disclosure Guide have the Assistant Secretary same meaning as those in the Terms and Conditions of 6277 Sea Harbor Drive, Orlando, FL 32821 RCI Weeks Subscribing Membership, which are made a part of this document. Brian Gray Vice President RCI is the owner and operator of the RCI Weeks 6277 Sea Harbor Drive, Orlando, FL 32821 Exchange Program. No government agency has approved the merits of this exchange program. Gary Green Senior Vice President RCI is a Delaware limited liability company (registered as 6277 Sea Harbor Drive, Orlando, FL 32821 Resort Condominiums
    [Show full text]
  • Semaines Points
    SEMAINES POINTS 2013 - 2014 Guide d’information Le présent document comporte des renseignements sur les centres de villégiature participant au Programme d’échange de Semaines RCI et au Programme d’échange de Points RCI exploités par RCI, LLC et donne des explications au sujet des modalités et de l’utilisation de ces programmes. Vous êtes prié instamment de le lire attentivement. Le présent document comprend les Guides d’information portant respectivement sur le Programme d’échange de Points RCI et sur le Programme d’échange de Semaines RCI, étant donné que l’adhésion au Programme d’échange de Points RCI donne accès au Programme d’échange de Semaines RCI. Le Guide d’information sur le Programme d’échange de Points RCI est présenté à la partie A, et le Guide d’information sur le Programme d’échange de Semaines RCI, à la partie B du présent document. Partie A Guide d’information sur le Programme d’échange de Points RCI GUIDE D’INFORMATION Geoffrey Ballotti Président du conseil et chef de la direction SUR LE PROGRAMME D’ÉCHANGE DE 14, Sylvan Way, Parsippany, NJ 07054 POINTS RCI Marcus A. Banks Le présent Guide d’information sur le Programme Vice-président principal, Affaires juridiques et secrétaire d’échange de Points RCI (le « Guide adjoint d’information ») donne des explications au sujet du 22, Sylvan Way, Parsippany, NJ 07054 programme que RCI, LLC (« RCI ») offre aux Philip S. Brojan Propriétaires de droits de séjour. Les Propriétaires Vice-président principal de droits de séjour sont invités à le lire attentivement 14, Sylvan Way, Parsippany, NJ 07054 et à s’assurer de bien comprendre les modalités et le fonctionnement du programme.
    [Show full text]
  • Ceriani Rowan University Email: [email protected]
    Nineteenth-Century Music Review, 14 (2017), pp 211–242. © Cambridge University Press, 2016 doi:10.1017/S1479409816000082 First published online 8 September 2016 Romantic Nostalgia and Wagnerismo During the Age of Verismo: The Case of Alberto Franchetti* Davide Ceriani Rowan University Email: [email protected] The world premiere of Pietro Mascagni’s Cavalleria rusticana on 17 May 1890 immediately became a central event in Italy’s recent operatic history. As contemporary music critic and composer, Francesco D’Arcais, wrote: Maybe for the first time, at least in quite a while, learned people, the audience and the press shared the same opinion on an opera. [Composers] called upon to choose the works to be staged, among those presented for the Sonzogno [opera] competition, immediately picked Mascagni’s Cavalleria rusticana as one of the best; the audience awarded this composer triumphal honours, and the press 1 unanimously praised it to the heavens. D’Arcais acknowledged Mascagni’smeritsbut,inthesamearticle,alsourgedcaution in too enthusiastically festooning the work with critical laurels: the dangers of excessive adulation had already become alarmingly apparent in numerous ill-starred precedents. In the two decades prior to its premiere, several other Italian composers similarly attained outstanding critical and popular success with a single work, but were later unable to emulate their earlier achievements. Among these composers were Filippo Marchetti (Ruy Blas, 1869), Stefano Gobatti (IGoti, 1873), Arrigo Boito (with the revised version of Mefistofele, 1875), Amilcare Ponchielli (La Gioconda, 1876) and Giovanni Bottesini (Ero e Leandro, 1879). Once again, and more than a decade after Bottesini’s one-hit wonder, D’Arcais found himself wondering whether in Mascagni ‘We [Italians] have finally [found] … the legitimate successor to [our] great composers, the person 2 who will perpetuate our musical glory?’ This hoary nationalist interrogative returned in 1890 like an old-fashioned curse.
    [Show full text]
  • Ye Intruders Beware: Fantastical Pirates in the Golden Age of Illustration
    YE INTRUDERS BEWARE: FANTASTICAL PIRATES IN THE GOLDEN AGE OF ILLUSTRATION Anne M. Loechle Submitted to the faculty of the University Graduate School in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Department of the History of Art Indiana University November 2010 Accepted by the Graduate Faculty, Indiana University, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Doctoral Committee _________________________________ Chairperson, Sarah Burns, Ph.D. __________________________________ Janet Kennedy, Ph.D. __________________________________ Patrick McNaughton, Ph.D. __________________________________ Beverly Stoeltje, Ph.D. November 9, 2010 ii ©2010 Anne M. Loechle ALL RIGHTS RESERVED iii Acknowledgments I am indebted to many people for the help and encouragement they have given me during the long duration of this project. From academic and financial to editorial and emotional, I was never lacking in support. I am truly thankful, not to mention lucky. Sarah Burns, my advisor and mentor, supported my ideas, cheered my successes, and patiently edited and helped me to revise my failures. I also owe her thanks for encouraging me to pursue an unorthodox topic. From the moment pirates came up during one of our meetings in the spring of 2005, I was hooked. She knew it, and she continuously suggested ways to expand the idea first into an independent study, and then into this dissertation. My dissertation committee – Janet Kennedy, Patrick McNaughton, and Beverly Stoeltje – likewise deserves my thanks for their mentoring and enthusiasm. Other scholars have graciously shared with me their knowledge and input along the way. David M. Lubin read a version of my third chapter and gave me helpful advice, opening up to me new ways of thinking about Howard Pyle in particular.
    [Show full text]
  • Boston Symphony Orchestra Concert Programs, Season 45,1925-1926
    PRoGRJWYE 124.1 M>/ ITS HERE! It is the world's first electrical reproducing instrument. There is no other like it. It is the result of a joint effort of the Radio Corpo- ration of America, the General Electric "Company, the Westinghouse Electric and Mfg. Co., and Brunswick. See and hear it before you purchase any musical instrument for your home. Convenient Terms CCHarvey® 144Boylston Street Boston SYMPHONY HALL, BOSTON HUNTINGTON AND MASSACHUSETTS AVENUES Branch Exchange Telephones, Ticket and Administration Offices, Back Bay 1492 INC. SERGE KOUSSEVITZKY, Conductor FORTY-FIFTH SEASON, 1925-1926 WITH HISTORICAL AND DESCRIPTIVE NOTES BY PHILIP HALE COPYRIGHT, 1926, BY BOSTON SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA, INC. THE OFFICERS AND TRUSTEES OF THE BOSTON SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA, Inc. FREDERICK P. CABOT ...... President GALEN L. STONE Vice-President ERNEST B. DANE ....... Treasurer FREDERICK P. CABOT ARTHUR LYMAN ERNEST B. DANE HENRY B. SAWYER M. A. DE WOLFE HOWE GALEN L. STONE JOHN ELLERTON LODGE BENTLEY W. WARREN FREDERICK E. LOWELL E. SOHIER WELCH W. H. BRENNAN, Manager G. E. JUDD, Assistant Manager 1933 After more than half a century on Fourteenth Street, Steinway Hall is now located at 1-09 West 57th Street. The new Steinway Hall is one of the handsomest buildings in New York on a street noted for finely designed business structures. As a center of music, it will extend the Steinway tradition to the new generations of music lovers. \t THE INST%U<ZMENT OF THE IMMORTALS 1934 Bostoi Forty-fifth Season, 1925-1926 SERGE KOUSSEVITZKY, Conductor Violins. Burgin, R. Hoffmann, J. Gerardi, A. Hamilton, V. Gundersen, R.
    [Show full text]
  • Personnages Marins Historiques Importants
    PERSONNAGES MARINS HISTORIQUES IMPORTANTS Années Pays Nom Vie Commentaires d'activité d'origine Nicholas Alvel Début 1603 Angleterre Actif dans la mer Ionienne. XVIIe siècle Pedro Menéndez de 1519-1574 1565 Espagne Amiral espagnol et chasseur de pirates, de Avilés est connu Avilés pour la destruction de l'établissement français de Fort Caroline en 1565. Samuel Axe Début 1629-1645 Angleterre Corsaire anglais au service des Hollandais, Axe a servi les XVIIe siècle Anglais pendant la révolte des gueux contre les Habsbourgs. Sir Andrew Barton 1466-1511 Jusqu'en Écosse Bien que servant sous une lettre de marque écossaise, il est 1511 souvent considéré comme un pirate par les Anglais et les Portugais. Abraham Blauvelt Mort en 1663 1640-1663 Pays-Bas Un des derniers corsaires hollandais du milieu du XVIIe siècle, Blauvelt a cartographié une grande partie de l'Amérique du Sud. Nathaniel Butler Né en 1578 1639 Angleterre Malgré une infructueuse carrière de corsaire, Butler devint gouverneur colonial des Bermudes. Jan de Bouff Début 1602 Pays-Bas Corsaire dunkerquois au service des Habsbourgs durant la XVIIe siècle révolte des gueux. John Callis (Calles) 1558-1587? 1574-1587 Angleterre Pirate gallois actif la long des côtes Sud du Pays de Galles. Hendrik (Enrique) 1581-1643 1600, Pays-Bas Corsaire qui combattit les Habsbourgs durant la révolte des Brower 1643 gueux, il captura la ville de Castro au Chili et l'a conserva pendant deux mois[3]. Thomas Cavendish 1560-1592 1587-1592 Angleterre Pirate ayant attaqué de nombreuses villes et navires espagnols du Nouveau Monde[4],[5],[6],[7],[8].
    [Show full text]
  • Francesco Cherubini
    FRANCESCO CHERUBINI. TRE ANNI A MILANO PER CHERUBINI NELLA DIALETTOLOGIA ITALIANA Consonanze 14 Un doppio bicentenario è stato occasione di un’ampia riflessio- ne sulla figura e l’opera di Francesco Cherubini: i duecento anni, nel 2014, del primo Vocabolario milanese-italiano, e gli altrettanti, compiuti due anni dopo, della Collezione delle migliori opere scritte in dialetto milanese. Dai lavori qui raccolti si ridefinisce il profilo di uno studioso, un linguista, non riducibile all’autore di uno stru- FRANCESCO CHERUBINI mento lessicografico su cui s’affaticava spesso con insoddisfazio- ne Manzoni. Il mondo e la cultura della Milano della prima metà dell’Ottocento emergono dalle pagine dei vocabolari cherubiniani TRE ANNI A MILANO PER CHERUBINI e ne emerge anche più nitida la figura dell’autore, non solo ottimo NELLA DIALETTOLOGIA ITALIANA lessicografo ma anche dialettologo tra i più acuti della sua epoca, di un linguista che nessun aspetto degli studi linguistici sembra allontanare da sé. Ma rileggere Cherubini significa anche non sot- ATTI DEI CONVEGNI 2014-2016 trarsi a una riflessione sulla letteratura dialettale: a partire dunque dalla Collezione la terza parte del volume è dedicata ai dialetti d’I- talia come lingue di poesia. A cura di Silvia Morgana e Mario Piotti Silvia Morgana ha insegnato Dialettologia italiana e Storia della lingua italia- na nell’Università degli studi di Milano. Sulla lingua e la cultura milanese e lombarda ha pubblicato molti lavori e un profilo storico complessivo (Storia linguistica di Milano, Roma, Carocci, 2012). Mario Piotti insegna Linguistica italiana e Linguistica dei media all’Università degli Studi di Milano.
    [Show full text]
  • TREASURE HUNT – CONCURS JUDEȚEAN DE LIMBA ENGLEZĂ Ediția a IV-A, 26.05.2017 Proba Scrisă - Clasa a VI-A Varianta 2
    ŞCOALA GIMNAZIALĂ INSPECTORATUL ŞCOLAR „TUDOR VLADIMIRESCU” JUDEŢEAN TG-MUREŞ MUREŞ http://tudor20.wordpress.com/ V ânãtoarea de comori www.edums.ro TREASURE HUNT – CONCURS JUDEȚEAN DE LIMBA ENGLEZĂ Ediția a IV-a, 26.05.2017 Proba scrisă - Clasa a VI-a Varianta 2 USE OF ENGLISH (80 POINTS) SUBJECT 1. a. The phrases and sentences below (A-J) have been removed from the following text. Read the text and insert them into the correct spaces (1-10). (10 points) 1____; 2____; 3____; 4____; 5____; 6____; 7____; 8____; 9____; 10____; I’m a descendant of the great Welsh pirate Bartholomew Roberts, [...1...]. He was the most successful pirate of the Golden Age of Piracy and he captured more than 450 vessels. After his death in 1722, his most valuable possession passed on to his elder son. It [...2...] was marked with a cross (✗ ). His son spent all his life looking for the treasure, and so did his children. However, they couldn’t find it. Some years ago, my grandmother showed me the map [...3...]. After years of study, she had concluded that the cross [...4...] was misleading. It had been a trick played by Black Bart to discourage treasure hunters. However, he had left some clues for us [...5...]. There was an inscription at the back of the map, [...6...] where the following words could be read: “Shipwreck Island was my home. [...7...]. I visited Dead Man Creek and swam in the Blue Lake, but I left my gold where the sun sets. [...8...], you can hear the sound of the soothing waves.
    [Show full text]
  • Appropriations of Gregorian Chant in Fin-De-Siècle French Opera: Couleur Locale – Message-Opera – Allusion?
    Journal of the Royal Musical Association, 145/1, 37–74 doi:10.1017/rma.2020.7 Appropriations of Gregorian Chant in Fin-de-siècle French Opera: Couleur locale – Message-Opera – Allusion? BENEDIKT LESSMANN Abstract This article compares three French operas from the fin de siècle with regard to their appropriation of Gregorian chant, examining their different ideological and dramaturgical impli- cations. In Alfred Bruneau’s Le rêve (1891), the use of plainchant, more or less in literal quotation and an accurate context, has often been interpreted as naturalistic. By treating sacred music as a world of its own, Bruneau refers to the French idea of Gregorian chant as ‘other’ music. In Vincent d’Indy’s L’étranger (1903), a quotation of Ubi caritas does not serve as an occasional illustration, but becomes essential as part of the leitmotif structure, thus functioning as the focal point of a religious message. Jules Massenet’s Le jongleur de Notre-Dame (1902) provides a third way of using music associated with history and Catholicism. In this collage of styles, plainchant is not quoted literally, but rather alluded to, offering in this ambiguity a mildly anti-clerical satire. Thus, through an exchange, or rather through a bizarre and unfortunate reversal, church music in the theatre is more ecclesiastical than in the church itself. Camille Bellaigue1 In an article in the Revue des deux mondes of 1904, the French critic Camille Bellaigue described the incorporation of church music into contemporary opera, referring to anticipated examples by Meyerbeer and Gounod; to works less well known today, such as Lalo’s Le roi d’Ys (which quotes the Te Deum); and also (quite extensively) to Wagner’s Parsifal, the ‘masterpiece […] or the miracle of theatrical art that is not only Email: [email protected] I am grateful to Stefan Keym for his support and advice with my doctoral studies and beyond.
    [Show full text]
  • The Mezzo-Soprano Onstage and Offstage: a Cultural History of the Voice-Type, Singers and Roles in the French Third Republic (1870–1918)
    The mezzo-soprano onstage and offstage: a cultural history of the voice-type, singers and roles in the French Third Republic (1870–1918) Emma Higgins Dissertation submitted to Maynooth University in fulfilment for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Maynooth University Music Department October 2015 Head of Department: Professor Christopher Morris Supervisor: Dr Laura Watson 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page number SUMMARY 3 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 4 LIST OF FIGURES 5 LIST OF TABLES 5 INTRODUCTION 6 CHAPTER ONE: THE MEZZO-SOPRANO AS A THIRD- 19 REPUBLIC PROFESSIONAL MUSICIAN 1.1: Techniques and training 19 1.2: Professional life in the Opéra and the Opéra-Comique 59 CHAPTER TWO: THE MEZZO-SOPRANO ROLE AND ITS 99 RELATIONSHIP WITH THIRD-REPUBLIC SOCIETY 2.1: Bizet’s Carmen and Third-Republic mores 102 2.2: Saint-Saëns’ Samson et Dalila, exoticism, Catholicism and patriotism 132 2.3: Massenet’s Werther, infidelity and maternity 160 CHAPTER THREE: THE MEZZO-SOPRANO AS MUSE 188 3.1: Introduction: the muse/musician concept 188 3.2: Célestine Galli-Marié and Georges Bizet 194 3.3: Marie Delna and Benjamin Godard 221 3.3.1: La Vivandière’s conception and premieres: 1893–95 221 3.3.2: La Vivandière in peace and war: 1895–2013 240 3.4: Lucy Arbell and Jules Massenet 252 3.4.1: Arbell the self-constructed Muse 252 3.4.2: Le procès de Mlle Lucy Arbell – the fight for Cléopâtre and Amadis 268 CONCLUSION 280 BIBLIOGRAPHY 287 APPENDICES 305 2 SUMMARY This dissertation discusses the mezzo-soprano singer and her repertoire in the Parisian Opéra and Opéra-Comique companies between 1870 and 1918.
    [Show full text]
  • Berliner Operngruppe and Bertelsmann Present Berlin Premiere of Puccini's 'Edgar'
    PRESS RELEASE Berliner Operngruppe and Bertelsmann present Berlin Premiere of Puccini’s ‘Edgar’ Parts of the original score and other historical documents are housed at the Group’s own Archivio Storico Ricordi in Milan Berlin, January 21, 2019 – The Berliner Operngruppe and the international media company Bertelsmann continue their series to highlight rare operas with a performance of Giacomo Puccini’s early work “Edgar” in Berlin on February 4, 2019. First performed in Milan in 1889, this opera about love, loyalty and betrayal will be staged in the last version from 1905 – for the first time in Berlin, and as one of the first performances ever in Germany. Puccini’s early dramma lirico already hints at the musical genius that he would later reveal to perfection with operas such as “La Bohème,” “Tosca,” “Madama Butterfly,” and “Turandot.” With this performance of “Edgar,” the Berliner Operngruppe and Bertelsmann once again draw attention to lesser-known operas by great composers whose works are documented in Bertelsmann’s own Archivio Storico Ricordi in Milan. The Berlin-based opera group started doing so nine years ago; this marks the third time it has received active support from the media group. “Among the treasures in the Ricordi archive that Bertelsmann is indexing, digitizing, and restoring are world-famous masterpieces as well as musical rarities. It is important to us to revive these often unjustly forgotten works. We have found an ideal partner for this in Berliner Operngruppe,” said Karin Schlautmann, Head of Corporate Communications at Bertelsmann. The Berliner Operngruppe specializes in rare operas and will perform “Edgar” in semi-scenic form.
    [Show full text]
  • I Fantasmi Del Palcoscenico Puccini Tra Wagner E Strauss Di Michele Girardi
    I fantasmi del palcoscenico Puccini tra Wagner e Strauss di Michele Girardi Il programma di stasera ruota compatto intorno alla figura del Puccini europeo – sottratto alle strettoie di quell’Italia che stava divenendo mu- sicalmente, sul finire del secolo, uno ‘strapaese’ –, messa a fuoco grazie a una panoramica di ampio respiro su un ‘genere’ particolare all’interno della composizione teatrale ottocentesca, legato alla scena e al tempo stesso in grado di esprimere anche valori autonomi: la musica orchestra- le che si ode nel preludio oppure che funge da intermezzo, collegando due parti (scene o atti) di un lavoro teatrale per musica. La critica italiana fece genericamente risalire a Wagner l’abitudine di inserire brani in stile sinfonico-descrittivo nelle opere, ed è l’ennesima dimostrazione della sua cronica inadeguatezza nell’afferrare le evoluzio- ni estetiche in atto. Anche se scorci orchestrali con funzione di raccordo fra due momenti drammatici sono contenuti un po’ dappertutto nel teatro wagneriano (come il funerale di Sigfrido nella Götterdämmerung, ad esempio) tale pratica deve piuttosto essere messa in relazione con l’accorciamento dei tempi drammatici che caratterizza la produzione operistica a partire dagli anni Ottanta del secolo scorso. Di qui in poi sinfonie, preludi, Vorspiele, intermezzi e quant’altro perdono la loro fun- zione di mere componenti della struttura formale, per adeguarsi alle istanze di sempre crescente drammaticità dei lavori fin de siècle. Inoltre, poiché rallentano il decorso del tempo, questi scorci aumentano la ten- sione, ottenendo anche l’effetto di rafforzare l’atmosfera dell’opera che, privata dai condizionamenti della parola, esce dallo sfondo per affian- carsi alle altre componenti della narrazione.
    [Show full text]