DOCSLIB.ORG

Observations and Modelling of Super-Luminous Supernovae

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Observations and Modelling of Super-Luminous Supernovae Observations and modelling of super-luminous supernovae A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Matthew Nicholl, M.Phys. (Oxford University 2012) Faculty of Engineering and Physical Sciences School of Mathematics and Physics Department of Physics and Astronomy Queen’s University Belfast Belfast, Co. Antrim, Northern Ireland September 2015 For Ashley Acknowledgements I would like to start by thanking my supervisor, Professor Stephen Smartt. I can’t imag- ine a better supervisor than Stephen, who gave me space to pursue ideas, but was always available (despite his many other commitments!) to discuss progress and push me in the right direction. It was a real privilege to be able to draw on a wealth of knowledge and academic nous from such a respected researcher. So thank you, Stephen; I don’t think I could have achieved half as much without your help and encouragement. And of course thank you for all the travel money and opportunities to further my career. I have received invaluable assistance from the supernova group here. I’d especially like to thank Drs. Cosimo Inserra, Anders Jerkstrand, Stuart Sim, Morgan Fraser, and my second supervisor, Rubina Kotak, who between them have taught me most of what I know about astronomy. Thanks to Janet (now Dr. Chen) for being a great person to work alongside on SLSNe, and for all the Taiwanese treats! To all the other members of the SN group and ARC, thank you for making Queen’s such a stimulating – and most importantly, fun – place to work. In particular, I’d like to thank my fellow PhD students. The burritos, curries and nerf wars were an essential part of my Queen’s experience! One of the great things about coming back to Northern Ireland for these three years has been the chance to spend more time with my amazing family. Thank you, Mum and Dad, for making home such a thoroughly enjoyable place to spend a weekend – and not just because of the free food! Your encouragement during my PhD studies is just the tip of the iceberg when I think of the love and help and support that you’ve always shown me. And it would be remiss of me not to mention that Mum bravely proofread this entire thesis! I have also found myself in the lucky position to have a brother, James, who I count among my best friends. I’m proud of you and can’t wait to see you fulfil your own ambitions, be it in music, software, or something totally unexpected! To all of the friends I have made in Belfast, Derry and Oxford: thank you for all of the fun times over the years. You’ve helped me to remain a rounded person whenever science has threatened to take over! I know we’ll continue to stay in touch, and hopefully have many more reunion weekends. Special thanks to James and Susie Dickey for being the best possible housemates, and to Ryan Nicholl (no relation) for first introducing me to Stephen Smartt and the QUB physics department back in 2011. Finally, I want to thank Marisa. I met you at the halfway point in my PhD, and I don’t think it’s a coincidence that I’ve enjoyed the second half so much more than the first (not that it was bad before!). Thank you for the love and adventures, and for being as interested in my studies as I am in yours. To the rest of the McVey family: I cannot thank each of you enough for the warmth and hospitality you’ve shown me; it’s been like having a second family here in Belfast. M.N. July 2015, Belfast i Abstract In the last decade, supernova science has undergone a revolution. Technological ad- vances have made it possible to search for transients over the whole sky with no inher- ent galaxy bias. This strategy has revealed a population of extremely bright explosions – in otherwise anonymous galaxies – that are now known as super-luminous super- novae (SLSNe). While this discovery has increased our knowledge of the diverse ways in which massive stars end their lives, it is still unclear what conditions lead to a SLSN (though low metallicity seems to be required). Even more fundamentally, we do not know the power source underlying their luminosity. The nature of these explosions is one of the biggest outstanding questions in stellar astrophysics. If we wish to build a complete picture of massive-star evolution, it is essential to understand the properties of SLSNe. Moreover, their intrinsic brightness and blue colours will offer a new window into the high-redshift Universe with next-generation instrumentation. In this thesis, we present the results of extensive ground-based monitoring cam- paigns for a number of hydrogen-poor (Type Ic) SLSNe at relatively low-redshift (0:1 < z < 0:35), making these some of the best-observed examples of this class in the literature. We use photometric and spectroscopic data, primarily in the optical but also in the UV and NIR, to constrain their luminosities, velocities and temperatures. We measure the characteristic diffusion time for all objects in the literature with rea- sonable light curve coverage and use this to infer ejected masses, showing that masses are typically larger than in normal-luminosity hydrogen-poor supernovae (including GRB supernovae). High ionisation may also be a factor in broadening the light curves of SLSNe Ic. However, we show that even for the slowest-evolving objects, the light curve rise time and inferred ejecta mass are well below the predictions for hypothetical pair-instability supernovae (PISNe). This is true even for slowly fading SLSNe identi- cal to the well-studied SN 2007bi, an object caught during the decline phase and that was thought to be a strong candidate for a PISN. We therefore argue that no SLSNe observed so far are PISNe. For one SLSN Ic caught soon after explosion, a double- peaked light curve seems to indicate a surprisingly extended progenitor, which may be an important new clue. These properties are modelled using a semi-analytic code that we have adapted and helped to develop as part of this work. Three possible power sources are investigated: ii radioactive 56Ni; a central engine such as magnetar spin-down; and interaction with a massive circumstellar medium. We find that the latter two can reproduce the light curves of all objects reasonably well, but that 56Ni-powering requires unrealistic model parameters, even for slowly fading objects. The observed spectra of SLSNe Ic may be able to break the degeneracy between central engine and interaction models. The lack of narrow emission or absorption lines, the presence of broad lines well before light curve maximum, high velocities with little sign of deceleration, the overall similarity to SNe Ic, and agreement with literature models for magnetar-energised ejecta all suggest that a millisecond magnetar (or possibly black hole accretion) engine is the most probable power source in SLSNe Ic. iii Contents Acknowledgementsi Abstract ii List of Tables viii List of Figures xi Publications xii 1 Introduction1 1.1 Novae and Supernovae..........................2 1.2 Observational properties of supernovae..................2 1.3 Energy generation in supernovae.....................3 1.3.1 Thermonuclear supernovae....................4 1.3.2 Core-collapse supernovae....................6 1.4 Supernovae and gamma-ray bursts....................7 1.5 Super-luminous supernovae........................9 1.5.1 Discovery.............................9 1.5.2 Hydrogen-poor SLSNe...................... 10 1.5.3 Hydrogen-rich SLSNe...................... 12 1.6 Proposed models for SLSNe....................... 12 1.6.1 Central engine.......................... 12 1.6.2 Pair instability.......................... 13 1.6.3 Circumstellar interaction..................... 14 1.7 Thesis structure.............................. 16 2 Methods 17 2.1 Sky surveys................................ 18 2.1.1 Pan-STARRS1.......................... 18 2.1.2 PESSTO............................. 20 2.1.3 La Silla QUEST......................... 22 iv 2.2 Other large programs and data pipelines................. 24 2.2.1 VLT and X-Shooter........................ 24 2.2.2 Las Cumbres Observatory Global Telescope Network...... 24 2.2.3 The Liverpool Telescope..................... 25 2.3 Manual data reduction.......................... 25 2.3.1 Reducing data with iraf ..................... 25 2.3.2 Photometry with SNOoPY.................... 26 2.3.3 Absolute magnitudes and K-corrections............. 28 2.3.4 Bolometric light curves...................... 29 2.4 Models.................................. 30 2.4.1 Nickel-powered models..................... 31 2.4.2 Magnetar-powered models.................... 32 2.4.3 Interaction-powered models................... 33 2.4.4 Exploring the models....................... 37 3 Three SLSNe Ic from PESSTO year one 39 3.1 Introduction................................ 40 3.2 Discovery and classification....................... 40 3.2.1 LSQ12dlf............................. 40 3.2.2 SSS120810............................ 42 3.2.3 SN 2013dg............................ 42 3.3 Spectroscopy............................... 44 3.3.1 Data aquisition and reduction.................. 44 3.3.2 Spectral evolution........................ 44 3.4 Photometry................................ 51 3.4.1 Data aquisition and reduction.................. 51 3.4.2 Light curves........................... 52 3.4.3 Bolometric light curves...................... 55 3.5 Modelling................................. 57 3.5.1 LSQ12dlf............................. 59 3.5.2 SSS120810............................ 61 3.5.3 SN 2013dg............................ 62 3.5.4 CSM configuration........................ 64 3.6
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Outstanding Animated Program (For Programming Less Than One Hour)
    Keith Crofford, Executive Producer Outstanding Animated Program (For Corey Campodonico, Producer Programming Less Than One Hour) Alex Bulkley, Producer Douglas Goldstein, Head Writer Creature Comforts America • Don’t Choke To Death, Tom Root, Head Writer Please • CBS • Aardman Animations production in association with The Gotham Group Jordan Allen-Dutton, Writer Mike Fasolo, Writer Kit Boss, Executive Producer Charles Horn, Writer Miles Bullough, Executive Producer Breckin Meyer, Writer Ellen Goldsmith-Vein, Executive Producer Hugh Sterbakov, Writer Peter Lord, Executive Producer Erik Weiner, Writer Nick Park, Executive Producer Mark Caballero, Animation Director David Sproxton, Executive Producer Peter McHugh, Co-Executive Producer The Simpsons • Eternal Moonshine of the Simpson Mind • Jacqueline White, Supervising Producer FOX • Gracie Films in association with 20th Century Fox Kenny Micka, Producer James L. Brooks, Executive Producer Gareth Owen, Producer Matt Groening, Executive Producer Merlin Crossingham, Director Al Jean, Executive Producer Dave Osmand, Director Ian Maxtone-Graham, Executive Producer Richard Goleszowski, Supervising Director Matt Selman, Executive Producer Tim Long, Executive Producer King Of The Hill • Death Picks Cotton • FOX • 20th Century Fox Television in association with 3 Arts John Frink, Co-Executive Producer Entertainment, Deedle-Dee Productions & Judgemental Kevin Curran, Co-Executive Producer Films Michael Price, Co-Executive Producer Bill Odenkirk, Co-Executive Producer Mike Judge, Executive Producer Marc Wilmore, Co-Executive Producer Greg Daniels, Executive Producer Joel H. Cohen, Co-Executive Producer John Altschuler, Executive Producer/Writer Ron Hauge, Co-Executive Producer Dave Krinsky, Executive Producer Rob Lazebnik, Co-Executive Producer Jim Dauterive, Executive Producer Laurie Biernacki, Animation Producer Garland Testa, Executive Producer Rick Polizzi, Animation Producer Tony Gama-Lobo, Supervising Producer J.
    [Show full text]
  • A Pragmatic View of Proper Name Reference
    A Pragmatic View of Proper Name Reference Peter J. Ridley King’s College London Submitted for the degree of PhD in Philosophy June 2016 1 To my friends in the King’s Philosophy Department, 2006–2016 They have inspired and influenced my thinking more than anything else 2 Proper names are poetry in the raw. Like all poetry they are untranslatable. —W.H. Auden And we must at all costs avoid over-simplification, which one might be tempted to call the occupational disease of philosophers if it were not their occupation. —J.L. Austin 3 Abstract I argue, in this thesis, that proper name reference is a wholly pragmatic phenomenon. The reference of a proper name is neither constitutive of, nor determined by, the semantic content of that name, but is determined, on an occasion of use, by pragmatic factors. The majority of views in the literature on proper name reference claim that reference is in some way determined by the semantics of the name, either because their reference simply constitutes their semantics (which generally requires a very fine-grained individuation of names), or because names have an indexical-like semantics that returns a referent given certain specific contextual parameters. I discuss and criticize these views in detail, arguing, essentially, in both cases, that there can be no determinate criteria for reference determination—a claim required by both types of semantic view. I also consider a less common view on proper name reference: that it is determined wholly by speakers’ intentions. I argue that the most plausible version of this view—a strong neo-Gricean position whereby all utterance content is determined by the communicative intentions of the speaker—is implausible in light of psychological data.
    [Show full text]
  • I Lys Av Perspektiver På Postmodernisme Og Kvalitet I
    Postmoderne sitcom? Linn Cathrin Lorgen Masteroppgave, Institutt for informasjons- og medievitenskap Universitetet i Bergen Vår 2009 Innhold TAKK ........................................................................................................................................................... IV INNLEDNING ................................................................................................................................................. 1 KAPITTEL 1, PERSPEKTIVER PÅ POSTMODERNISME OG TV-FIKSJON ................................................................ 6 MODERNITET OG POSTMODERNITET ............................................................................................................................ 6 Modernisme og postmodernisme .................................................................................................................. 7 Postmodernisme og tv ................................................................................................................................... 9 KONVERGENS-TV: FLIGHT OF THE CONCHORDS I ET PRODUKSJONSPERSPEKTIV ................................................................... 14 Endringer i tv-industrien på 80-tallet ........................................................................................................... 14 Merkevaren HBO ......................................................................................................................................... 16 Konvergens-tv og strategier på nett ...........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 10-Year Review of Gender and EMMY Nominations
    INVESTIGATION: 10-YEAR REVIEW OF GENDER & EMMY NOMINATIONS womensmediacenter.com WOMEN’S MEDIA CENTER ABOUT THE WOMEN’S MEDIA CENTER In 2005, Jane Fonda, Robin Morgan and Gloria Steinem founded the Women’s Media Center (WMC), a progressive, nonpartisan, nonpro!t organization endeavoring to raise the visibility, viability and decision-mak- ing power of women and girls in media and, thereby, ensuring that their stories get told and their voices are heard. To reach those necessary goals, we strategically use an array of intercon- nected channels and platforms to transform not only the media landscape but also a culture in which women’s and girls’ voices, stories, experiences and images are neither suf!ciently ampli!ed nor placed on par with the voices, stories, experiences and images of men and boys. Our strategic tools include monitoring the media; commissioning and conducting research; and undertaking other special initiatives to spot- light gender and racial bias in news coverage, entertainment !lm and television, social media and other key sectors. Our publications include the book “Unspinning the Spin: The Women’s Media Center Guide to Fair and Accurate Language”; The Women’s Media Center’s Media Guide to Gender Neutral Coverage of Women Candidates + Politicians”; “The Women’s Media Center Guide to Covering Reproductive Issues”; and the Women’s Media Center’s annual “The Status of Women in the U.S. Media” report. Our WMC Women Under Siege project investigates sexualized violence. Our original content channels — WMC Features, WMC FBomb, WMC Speech Project and the “Women’s Media Center Live with Robin Morgan” radio program — provide women’s perspectives on both headline stories and timely events that are ignored, not wholly captured or misrepresented in the mainstream media.
    [Show full text]
  • Susie Porter
    Do your loved ones depend on you? AUSTRALIA POSTAGE PAID POSTAGE 100007351 POST PRINT You can’t control the future, but with Real Life Insurance you can do one simple thing to make sure your loved ones are taken care of, no matter what. Choose cover from $100,000 to $1 million^ - which is paid quickly to your family Apply quickly and easily over the phone Get back 10% of the premiums you have paid after the first 12 months of your policy For award winning insurance call 1300 177 325 today! Visit realinsurance.com.au ^ Depending on your age. This is general information only. Please consider the PDS available from realinsurance.com.au. This information is provided by Real Insurance, a trading name of Greenstone Financial Services Pty Ltd ABN 53 128 692 884, AFSL 343079. Real Family Life Cover is issued by Hannover Life Re of Australasia Ltd ABN 37 062 395 484. H1456_Real_L _Foxtel_11/18 If undeliverable, return to: If undeliverable, NSW 2211 162 PADSTOW PO Box Magazine Foxtel DECEMBER 2018 favourites Celebrating an incredible year in TV – and why the best is yet to come THE HEAT IS ON Adam Gilchrist talks simmering rivalry as the India Test series fires up MUSICAL TRIBUTE Exploring the final steps and enduring legacies of rock’s biggest icons From 28 November New to rent From From From From 21 November 28 November 28 November 12 December *Available on internet enabled and connected Foxtel iQ STUs. ISP and data charges may apply. Some services not available to all homes. store The latest movies to rent.
    [Show full text]