Challenges for ΛCDM : An update L. Perivolaropoulos1, ∗ and F. Skara1, y 1Department of Physics, University of Ioannina, 45110 Ioannina, Greece (Dated: May 20, 2021) A number of challenges of the standard ΛCDM model has been emerging during the past few years as the accuracy of cosmological observations improves. In this review we discuss in a unified manner many existing signals in cosmological and astrophysical data that appear to be in some tension (2σ or larger) with the standard ΛCDM model as defined by the Planck18 parameter values. In addition to the major well studied 5σ challenge of ΛCDM (the Hubble H0 crisis) and other well known tensions (the growth tension and the lensing amplitude AL anomaly), we discuss a wide range of other less discussed less-standard signals which appear at a lower statistical significance level than the H0 tension (also known as 'curiosities' in the data) which may also constitute hints towards new physics. For example such signals include cosmic dipoles (the fine structure constant α, velocity and quasar dipoles), CMB asymmetries, BAO Lyα tension, age of the Universe issues, the Lithium problem, small scale curiosities like the core-cusp and missing satellite problems, quasars Hubble diagram, oscillating short range gravity signals etc. The goal of this pedagogical review is to collectively present the current status of these signals and their level of significance, with emphasis to the Hubble crisis and refer to recent resources where more details can be found for each signal. We also briefly discuss possible theoretical approaches that can potentially explain the non-standard nature of some of these signals. CONTENTS II.2.9. Cosmic chronometers 21 II.2.10. HII galaxy measurements 21 I. Introduction2 II.2.11. Combinations of data 22 II.2.12. The current status - Historic II. Hubble Crisis6 evolution 23 II.1. Methods for measuring H0 6 II.3. Theoretical models 24 II.1.1. Standard candles as probes of II.3.1. Late time deformations of the luminosity distance7 Hubble expansion rate H(z) 24 II.1.2. Sound horizon as standard ruler: II.3.2. Late time modifications - early time calibrators9 Recalibration of the SnIa II.1.3. Time delays: gravitational absolute luminosity 29 lensing 12 II.3.3. Early time modifications 31 II.1.4. Standard sirens: gravitational waves 12 III. Other Tensions - Curiosities 35 II.1.5. Megamaser technique 13 III.1. Growth tension 35 II.1.6. Tully-Fisher relation (TFR) as III.1.1. Methods and data 35 distance indicator. 14 III.1.2. Theoretical models 38 II.1.7. Extragalactic background light III.2. CMB anisotropy anomalies 41 γ-ray attenuation 14 III.2.1. Hints for a closed Universe II.1.8. Cosmic chronometers 15 (CMB vs BAO) 41 II.1.9. HII galaxy measurements 15 III.2.2. Anomalously strong ISW effect 41 II.2. Observational data - Constraints 15 III.2.3. CMB cold spot 42 II.2.1. SnIa 15 III.2.4. Cosmic hemispherical power II.2.2. CMB 16 asymmetry 42 arXiv:2105.05208v2 [astro-ph.CO] 18 May 2021 II.2.3. Baryon acoustic oscillations 17 III.2.5. Quadrupole-octopole II.2.4. Strong gravitational lensing 18 alignment 42 II.2.5. Gravitational waves 20 III.2.6. Lack of large-angle CMB II.2.6. Megamaser data 20 temperature correlations 43 II.2.7. Tully Fisher 20 III.2.7. Anomaly on super-horizon II.2.8. Extragalactic background light scales 43 γ-ray attenuation 21 III.2.8. The lensing anomaly 44 III.2.9. High-low l consistency 44 III.2.10. The preference for odd parity correlations 44 ∗ [email protected] III.3. Cosmic dipoles 44 y [email protected] III.3.1. Velocity radio dipole 45 2 III.3.2. Quasar dipole 46 • There are six independent (free) parameters: the 2 III.3.3. Fine structure constant α baryon !b = Ω0bh and cold dark matter !c = 2 −1 dipole 47 Ω0ch energy densities (where h = H0=100 km s III.4. BAO curiosities 47 Mpc−1 is the dimensionless Hubble constant and III.5. Parity violating rotation of CMB linear ΩX ≡ ρX /ρcrit is the density of component X rel- 2 polarization (Cosmic Birefringence) 47 ative to the critical density, ρcrit = 3H =8πG), the III.6. Small-scale curiosities 48 angular diameter distance to the sound horizon at III.7. Age of the Universe 49 last scattering θs, the amplitude As and tilt ns of III.8. The Lithium problem 49 primordial scalar fluctuations and the reionization III.9. Quasars Hubble diagram 50 optical depth τ. III.10. Oscillating signals in short range gravity experiments 50 • The spatial part of the cosmic metric is assumed III.11. Anomalously low baryon temperature 51 to be flat described by the Friedmann-Lema^ıtre- III.12. Colliding clusters with high velocity 51 Roberson-Walker (FLRW) metric ds2 = dt2 − a(t)2(dr2 + r2dθ2 + r2sin2θdφ2) (1.2) IV. Conclusions-Discussion-Outlook 51 which emerges from the CP. Acknowledgements 57 Assuming this form of the metric and Einstein's References 57 field equations with a Λ-term we obtain the Fried- mann equations which may be written as a_ 2 8πGρ + Λc2 I. INTRODUCTION H2 ≡ = (1.3) a2 3 The concordance or standard Λ Cold Dark Matter (ΛCDM) model [1,2] is a well defined, predictive and a¨ 4πG 3p Λc2 = − (ρ + ) + (1.4) simple cosmological model (for a review, see Ref. [3]). It a 3 c2 3 relies on a set of simple assumptions: 1 where a is the scale factor a = 1+z (with z the • The Universe consists of radiation (photons, neutri- redshift). The cosmological constant may also be nos), ordinary matter (baryons and leptons), cold viewed as a cosmic dark energy fluid with equation (non-relativistic) dark matter (CDM) [4{10] being of state parameter responsible for structure formation and cosmologi- p cal constant Λ [2], a homogeneous form of energy w = Λ = −1 (1.5) which is responsible for the late time observed ac- ρΛ celerated expansion. The cosmological constant is where ρΛ and pΛ are the energy density and the currently associated with a dark energy or vac- pressure of the dark energy respectively. uum energy whose density remains constant even in an expanding background (for a review, see Refs. • A primordial phase of cosmic inflation (a period of [1, 11, 12]). rapid accelerated expansion) is also assumed in or- der to address the horizon and flatness problems • General Relativity (GR) [13] is the correct theory [14{17]. During this period, Gaussian scale in- that describes gravity on cosmological scales. Thus, variant primordial fluctuations are produced from the action currently relevant on cosmological scales quantum fluctuations in the inflationary epoch. reads Fundamental generalizations of the standard ΛCDM Z p 1 S = d4x −g (R − 2Λ) model may be produced by modifying the defining ac- 16πG tion (1.1) by generalizing the fundamental constants to 1 dynamical variables in the existing action or adding new + F F µν + L ( ; A) (1.1) 4α µν m terms. Thus the following extensions of ΛCDM emerge: where α is the fine structure constant, G is New- • Promoting Newton's constant to a dynamical de- gree of freedom by allowing it to depend on a scalar ton's constant, Fµν is the electromagnetic field- field Φ as G ! G(Φ(r; t)) where the dynamics of Φ strength tensor and Lm is the Lagrangian density is determined by kinetic and potential terms added for all matter fields m. to the action. This class of theories is known as • The Cosmological Principle (CP) states that the 'scalar-tensor theories' with its most general form Universe is statistically homogeneous and isotropic with second order dynamical equations the Horn- in space and matter at sufficiently large scales (& deski theories [18, 19] (for a comprehensive review, 100 Mpc). see Ref. [20, 21]). 3 • Promoting the cosmological constant to a dynami- s−1Mpc−1 [53] while the local measurements using cal degree of freedom by the introduction of a scalar Cepheid calibrators indicate H0 = 74:03 ± 1:42 km field (quintessence) with Λ ! V (Φ(r; t)) and the s−1Mpc−1 [57] (4:4σ, 9%). A wide range of local introduction of a proper kinetic term. observations appear to be consistently larger than the Planck/ΛCDM measurement of H0 at various • Allowing for a dynamical Fine Structure Constant levels of statistical significance [58, 59]. Theoretical (Maxwell Dilaton theories) with α ! α(Φ(r; t)) models addressing the Hubble tension utilize either [22{26] (for a review, see Ref. [27]). a recalibration of the Planck/ΛCDM standard ruler • Addition of new terms to the action which may be (the sound horizon) assuming new physics before functions of the Ricci scalar, the torsion scalar or the time of recombination [60{62] or a deformation other invariants ((f(R); f(T );::: )) [28{34]. of the Hubble expansion rate H(z) at late times [63, 64] or a recalibration of the SnIa absolute lu- The ΛCDM model has been remarkably successful in ex- minosity due to late time new physics [65, 66] (for plaining most properties of a wide range of cosmologi- a review, see Refs. [67, 68] and for a relevant talk, cal observations including the accelerating expansion of see Ref. [69]). the Universe, [35, 36], the power spectrum and statistical properties of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) • The growth tension (2 − 3σ): Direct mea- anisotropies [37], the spectrum and statistical properties surements of the growth rate of cosmological per- of large scale structures of the Universe [3, 38] and the turbations (Weak Lensing, Redshift Space Distor- observed abundances of different types of light nuclei hy- tions (peculiar velocities), Cluster Counts) indicate drogen, deuterium, helium, and lithium [39{42].