Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1. Meetings of the Commission
From the period starting from 01.04.2018 to 31.03.2020, the following meetings of the Commission were held: 2018-19 and 2019-20 Table 1.1 Dates of Meetings 4th Meeting 23.10.2018 5thMeeting 12.03.2019 6th Meeting 03.09.2019
State Level Review Meeting Table 1.2 Date of Review Meeting - 2018-19 Rajasthan 23.05.2018 Dates of Review Meetings -2019-20 Maharashtra 29.08.2019 & 30.08.2019 Madhya Pradesh 05.09.2019 Gujarat 16.12.2019 Karnataka 13.02.2020 Bihar 18.02.2020
Review Meetings of Departments/Public Sector Undertakings (PSUs) Table 1.3 Dates of Review Meetings 2019-20 Western Railway 29.08.2019 Northern Railway 11.12.2019 GAIL 12.12.2019 Power Grid 13.12.2019 NTPC 19.12.2019
1 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
BPCL 19.12.2019 BHEL 26.12.2019 HPCL 27.12.2019 SAIL 08.01.2020 IOCL 09.01.2020 ONGC 28.01.2020 NBCC 28.01.2020
Meeting to monitor disbursement of loans under Mudra and Stand-up India schemes by Public Sector Banks Table 3.4
Meeting to monitor disbursement of 19.11.2018 loans under Mudra and Stand-up India schemes by Public Sector Banks
BRIEF SUMMARY OF MAJOR DECISIONS:
1.1 Meeting dated 23.10.2018
4thMeeting of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) was called for on 22.03.2018 under the Chairmanship of Dr. (Prof.) Ram Shankar Katheria, Chairman, NCSC. The following important agenda items were taken up for discussion & decisions were taken thereon:
Agenda Item No. 5.3.1: 1(a) Recent judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court viz. direction in the case of Dr. Subhash Kashinath Mahajan against the Bombay High Court Judgment on misuse of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (Amended Act 2015) and 1(b) other decision dated 08.12.2017 regarding implementation of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (Amended Act 2015).
2 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Decision Taken: The Commission approved the following action on the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s recent judgments: Commission may write a detailed letter to the Hon’ble President of India and Prime Minister detailing its views and concern on the above judgements. The Government is to be requested to file a revision petition against the judgements at the earliest so that the implementation of the Act is not diluted. Commission may also seek an appointment with Hon’ble President and Prime minister for personal briefing by the Commission on the issue. Original petitioner may be called in and discussed this issue in the ensuing hearing.
Agenda Item No.5.3.2: Order issued on 5.3.2018 by UGC on changing the guidelines for reservation in Universities/Colleges despite out Commission letter on 01.11.2017 advising UGC/MHRD to not formulate any policy without consultation of NCSC.
Decision Taken: The Commission approved that Ministry of HRD, UGC and DoPT may be advised to file a review petition in Hon’ble Supreme Court at the earliest, in the Special Appeal (c) no. 16515/2017. UGC may be asked to withdraw its order dated 05.03.2018. MSJE may also be requested for the same. Further, Ministry of HRD and UGC may be asked to inquire into the matter as to how the instructions/orders dated 05.03.2018 on preparation of reservation roster for Universities were issued without considering the Commission’s letter dated 01.11.2017 and without consultation of NCSC under Article 338(9) of the Constitution of India.
Agenda Item No. 5.3.3: Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment’s reference to Amendment of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (Amended Act 2015).
Decision Taken: The Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment has requested to offer the views of the Commission on the Amendment in Section 9 of the Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of atrocities) Act, 1989 by 31.01.2018.
Section 9 of the POA Act relates to conferment of powers of arrest, investigation and prosecution, on any officer exercisable by a police officer under the Code, in regard to cases under the POA Act, by the State Government by notification in the Official Gazette; Rule 7(1) of the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) (POA) Rules, 1995, made by the
3 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Central Government, in exercise of powers conferred by sub-section (1) of Section 23 of POA Act, specifies that an offence committed under the Act shall be investigated by a police officer not below the rank of a Deputy Superintendent of Police.
In regard to validity of Rule 7 of the POA Rules, the crux of the judgment dated 23.3.2017 of the Supreme Court of India in SLP(C) No. 27524-27 of 2011, with Civil Appeal No. 4401 of 2017, is as under:-
. In regard to validity of Rule 7 of the POA Rules, keeping in view of the serious and harsh consequences emerging from any violation of the provisions of the POA Act, the Central Government was fully competent and justified, in requiring that the investigative process be conducted by an officer not below the rank of a Deputy Superintendent of Police. The Central Government had exercised its jurisdiction within the framework of the authority vested in it. Therefore, the validity of Rule 7 of the POA Rules is affirmed. (As stated in Para 12 of the judgment).
. As against the national character of the Rule making power vested with the Central Government under Section 23 of the POA Act, the delegated power contemplated under Section 9 of the POA Act, is State specific. The power exercised by a State, keeps in mind the circumstances prevailing in the concerned State. The legitimacy and validity of the exercise of the instant delegated power vested in a State Government, has therefore, to be determined, with reference to the peculiar facts and circumstances prevailing in an individual State. In case the State Government found it necessary and expedient, for an effective implementation of the provisions of the POA Act, it had the right and the responsibility, to vest the power of arrest, investigation and prosecution, in additional personnel. (As stated in Para 18 of the judgment)
. As regards, whether the State Government could in its discretion, in furtherance of the power vested with it under Section 9 of the POA Act, relax the provision made by Rule 7 of the POA Rules; each individual State Government in exercise of the power vested under Section 9 of the POA Act, had the authority to extend to any officer of the State Government, powers of arrest, investigation and prosecution. The provision made under a Rule of the POA Rules can not negate a right extended through the parent Legislation (POA Act). Thus, the power conferred on the State Government under section 9(1) (b) of
4 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
the POA Act cannot be neutralized by any rule of the POA Rules framed under section 23 of the POA Act. By way of a notification published in the Official Gazette under section 9(1) (b) of the POA Act, the State Government was competent to relax Rule 7 of the POA Rules. (As stated in Para 17, 18 of the judgment)
The aforesaid judgment seemingly leads to an inference that existing provisions of Section 9 of the POA Act and Rule 7(1) of the POA Rules are not in harmony and rather incompatible, notwithstanding the emphasis stated in para 3 (i) above. It is, thus, considered essential that to establish in principle amongst all concerned State Governments/Union Territory Administrations, a uniform applicability of investigation of the POA Act related cases by an officer not below the rank of Deputy Superintendent, existing stipulation of Section 9 of the POA Act needs to be amended to distinctly specify therein that an offence committed under the POA Act shall be instigated by a police officer not below the rank of a Deputy Superintendent of Police (as presently provided under Rules 7(1) of the POA Rules) and to do away with the existing provisions wherein states by notification in their Official Gazettes can confer it to any officer holding the ranks below the rank of the Deputy Superintendent of Police.
Existing provisions of Section 9 of the Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of atrocities) Act, 1989:-
Section 9: (1) Notwithstanding anything contained in the code or in any other provision of this Act, the State Government may, if it considers it necessary or expedient so to do- (a) for the prevention of and for coping with any offence under this Act, or
(b) for any case or class or group of cases under this Act, in any district or part thereof, confer, by notification in the Official 50 Gazette, on any officer of the State Government, the powers exercisable by a police officer under the Code in such district or part thereof or, as the case may be, for such case or class or group of cases, and in particular, the powers of arrest, investigation and prosecution of persons before any Special Court.
(2) All officers of police and all other officers of Government shall assist the officer referred to in sub-section (1) in the execution of the provisions of this Act or any rule, scheme or order made there under.
5 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
(3) The provisions of the Code shall, so far as may be, apply to the exercise of the powers by an officer under sub-section (1)
Proposed amendment in Section 9 of the Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of atrocities) Act, 1989 are as under:-
● The State Government/Union Territory Administration shall notify in the official Gazette that notwithstanding anything contained in the Code of Criminal Procedure or in any other provision of this Act, an offence committed under this Act shall be investigated by a police officer not below the rank of a Deputy Superintendent of Police/Assistant Commissioner of Police. The investigating officer in the rank of the Deputy Superintendent of Police/Assistant Commissioner of Police, shall be appointed by the State Government/Union Territory Administration/Director General of Police/Commissioner of Police/Additional Director General of Police/Special Commissioner of Police/Inspector General of Police/Additional Commissioner of Police/Deputy Inspector General of Police/Senior Superintendent of Police/Deputy Commissioner of Police, after taking into account his/her past experience, sense of ability and justice to perceive the implications of the case and investigated it along with right lines within the shortest possible time.
● All officers of police and all other officers of Government shall assist the Investigating Officer referred to in sub-section (1) in the execution of the provisions of this Act or any rule, scheme or order made there under.
In this regard, clarification was sought from the M/o Social Justice & Empowerment whether Section 9 (1), 9(1)(a) and 9(3) of the existing Act will remain or are they being replace by Section 9(1) and 9(2) only.
The M/o Social Justice & Empowerment has clarified that the draft formulation of the Section 9 of the POA Act is towards substituting the entire existing Section 9 of the POA Act.
The Commission approved to support the amendment to Section 9 of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989.
6 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Agenda Item No. 5.2.4: Further amendments in the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (Amended Act 2015) and Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Amendment Rules 2016.
Decision Taken: The Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment has requested to offer the views of the Commission on the further amendments in the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (Amended Act 2015) and Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Amendment Rules 2016. In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section 23 of the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (33 of 1989), the Central Government had made the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) {POA} Rules, 1995, which were last amended by the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Amendment Rules, 2016 notified in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary, on 14.04.2016.
The following amendments in the POA Rules are being further considered in the POA Rules, which are primarily based recommendations received from National Commission for Scheduled Castes:-
Table 1.5
Rule Sub- Clause Existing provision in Proposed amendment in existing rule the POA Rules provision in the POA Rules
2 - (i) - “Voluntarily” means a person is said (new) to cause an effect “voluntarily” when he causes it by means whereby he intended to cause it, or by means which, at the time of employing those means, he knew or had reason to believe to be likely to cause it. (as in IPC 39).
12 5 - The relief provided to The relief provided to the victim of the victim of the the atrocity or his/her dependent
7 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
atrocity or his/her under sub-rule (4) in respect of dependent under sub- death, or injury to, rape, gang rape, rule (4) in respect of voluntary carnal intercourse death, or injury to, or against the order of nature with damage to property any man or woman, voluntarily shall be in addition to causing grievous hurt by use of any other right to claim acid, voluntarily throwing or compensation in attempting to throw acid, or respect thereof under damage to property, shall be in any other law for the addition to any other right to claim time being in force. compensation in respect thereof under any other law for the time being in force.
16 1 - “of not more than 25 To be deleted members”
Annexure-I to the Schedule
Sr. No. Existing provision Proposed amendment in existing provision
24 Section 326B of the India Penal 326 of the India Penal Code (45 of Code (45 of 1860)—Voluntarily 1860)-Voluntarily causing grievous throwing or attempting to throw hurt by use of acid, etc., Section acid. [Section 3(2)(va) read with 326B of the Indian Penal Code (45 Scheduled to the Act] of 1860)—Voluntarily throwing or attempting to throw acid.” [Section 3(2)(v), 3(2)(va) read with Schedule to the Act.]
44(i) Rape of Gang rape. Rape or Gang rape, voluntary carnal
Section 375 intercourse against the order of nature with any man or woman
8 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Section 375, 376(A to E), 377
In this regard, the proposed amendments are due to the recommendation of the Commission on the same i.e. at Sl. No. 44 (i) in the existing provision Section 375 “rape and gang-rape” as proposed “section 375, 376 (A to E), 377” and Ministry has proposed the further amendments.
The Commission approved to support the further amendments in the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (Amended Act 2015) and Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Amendment Rules 2016.
1.2 Meeting dated 12.03.2019
5thMeeting of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) was held on 12.03.2019 under the Chairmanship of Dr. (Prof.) Ram Shankar Katheria, Chairman, NCSC. The following Agenda items were taken up for discussion & decisions were taken thereon:
Agenda Item No.1: Approval of the Draft Annual Report 2017-18.
Decision Taken: The draft Annual Report was placed before the Commission and the Commission approved it with the some modifications/additions.
Agenda Item No.2: Inclusion of Namasudra, Pond, Poundra etc. (Bengali displaced persons) community in the list of Scheduled Castes of Uttar Pradesh Decision Taken: The Commission concurred the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment and approved ex-post-facto. Agenda Item No.3: Draft Note for Cabinet regarding “Constitution of Development and Welfare Board for Denotified, Nomadic and Semi-nomadic Communities (DWBDNCs)
Decision Taken: The Commission concurred the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment and approved ex-post-facto. Agenda Item No.4: Approval for the Centrally Sponsored Scheme of Rashtriya Gram Swaraj Abhiyan (RGSA) from 01.04.2018 to 31.03.2022.
9 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Decision Taken: The Commission concurred the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment and approved ex-post-facto. Agenda Item No.5: Draft note for the Cabinet for creation of one post of Member in National Commission for Karamcharies (NCSK) as Vice-Chairperson.
Decision Taken: The Commission concurred the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment and approved ex-post-facto. Agenda Item No.6: Draft Note for the Cabinet for extension in tenure of the National Commission for Safai Karamchries-beyond 31.03.2019 for the three years.
Decision Taken: The Commission concurred the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment and approved ex-post-facto. Agenda Item No.7: Proposal for introduction of the Unaided Private Educational Institutions (Reservation in Admission) Bill, 2019.
Decision Taken: The Commission concurred the proposal of the Ministry of HRD and approved ex-post-facto. Agenda Item No.8: Memo for Expenditure Finance Committee (EFC) for revision of the funding pattern under the Centrally Sponsored Scheme, Post Matric Scholarship to students belonging to Scheduled Castes for studies in India-comments.
Decision Taken: The Commission concurred the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment and approved ex-post-facto. Agenda Item No.9: Any other item with the permission of the chair.
Decision Taken: The Chairman directed that there should be accurate date of atrocities cases particular rape and murder cases and it should be checked with NCRB data. The death of SC persons due to manual scavenging should also be reflected and exact number of such cases may be obtained from the various States. For this purpose, a draft D.O. letter from Secretary, NCSC may be written and if required, Secretary, NCSC may talk with the Chief Secretaries of the States/UTs for complete data on manual scavenging.
10 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.3 Meeting dated 03.09.2019
The Sixth Meeting of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) was held on 03.09.2019 at 3.00 P.M. under the Chairmanship of Dr. (Prof.) Ram Shankar Katheria, Chairman, NCSC. The list of participants is at Annexure-I. The following Agenda items were taken up for discussion and decisions as taken thereon are enumerated below:- Agenda Item No. 1: Confirmation of minutes of 5th meeting of the Commission was held on 12.03.2019.
Decision Taken: Minutes of the 5th meeting of the Commission were approved unanimously.
Agenda Item No.2: Action taken on the minutes of the 5th meeting of the Commission was held on 12.03.2019.
Agenda Item No. 2(a): Action Taken: The Annual Report (2017-18) was finalized and submitted to the Hon’ble President of India on 20.06.2019.
Agenda Item No. 2(b): Action Taken: Agenda item nos. 5.5.2 to 5.5.8 were regarding ex-post- facto approval of Commission & no further action was required.
Agenda Item No: 3(c): Action Taken: (i) Letters were sent to MSJE & details called for. A meeting of Secretary, MSJE, Secretary, Urban & Secretary, Jal Shakti was also held on 26.07.2019 regarding details of persons while cleaning sewers. Minutes of meeting were issued vide letter No. 6/02/Sewer Cases/Hearing/2019-ESDW dated 29.08.2019.
(ii) Action on Rape & Murder cases: No NCRB data of 2017 & 2018 is available. However between 26.6.2019 to 22.7.2019, a special drive for disposal of rape & murder cases was carried out in the Commission and a total of 804 cases & 740 cases were heard & minutes issued for giving relief to the petitioners and for taking the necessary action by the State authorities.
Agenda Item No.3: Proposal for revision in the fee structure for the examinations and recruitments conducted by the Union Public Service Commission (UPSC).
Decision Taken: The Commission did not agree to the proposal of Department of Personnel & Training, to introduce an application/examination fee @ Rs.25% from the Scheduled Castes categories. Accordingly, DoPT may be communicated the same.
11 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
(Action: ESDW) Agenda Item No.4: Memorandum for Standing Finance Committee (SFS) for revision of Centrally Sponsored scheme “Pre Matric Scholarship for Scheduled Castes students studying in Classes 9th and 10th” - reg.
Decision Taken: The Commission accorded ex-post-facto approval on the concurrence to the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment sent on 16.05.2019 to Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment vide letter No. 4/7/Pre-Matric Scholarship (SFC)/2019-ESDW. (Action: ESDW)
Agenda Item No.5: SFC Memorandum for “Provision of Scheme in Dr. Ambedkar International Centre”.
Decision Taken: The Commission accorded ex-post-facto approval on the concurrence to the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment sent on 28.02.2019 vide letter No. 4/6/DAIC/SFC/2019/ESDW. (Action: ESDW)
Agenda Item No.6: Revision in funding pattern of the Centrally Sponsored Scheme ‘Post Matric Scholarship to students belongs to Scheduled Castes for studies in India (PMS-SC) with effect from 2019-2020.
Decision Taken: The Commission accorded ex-post-facto approval on the concurrence to the proposal of the Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment sent on 12.07.2019 vide letter No. 4/13/PMS Cabinet-2017/ESDW. (Action: ESDW)
Agenda Item No.7: Comments of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes on the Jammu and Kashmir Re-organization Act-2019
Decision Taken: The Commission considered the proposal of the Ministry of Home Affairs. Since all provisions of the Constitution, as amended from time to time, shall apply in relation to the Constitution (Application to Jammu and Kashmir) Order, 2019 dated the 5th August, 2019 of para-2 and provisions of Article 338, 14 15, 16 of Constitution of India will automatically apply to the new UT of Jammu & Kashmir & Laddakh. The PCR Act 1955 already had a jurisdiction in whole of India & the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocity) Act, 1989 (as amended), The Employment of Manual Scavengers and Construction of Dry Latrines (Prohibition) Act, 1993 and “The Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their
12 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Rehabilitation Act, 213” are included in Table 1 of Vth Schedule of the draft Jammu & Kashmir Re-organisation Act, 2019. Hence Commission concurs with the proposal and has no further comments on the proposal. The same may be sent to Ministry of Home Affairs. (Action: C.Cell)
Agenda Item No. 8: The removal of area restriction in respect of Mangali Community for entire State of Odisha.
Decision Taken: The Commission decided to get clarification from Government of Odisha with regard to the impact of removing area restriction in respect of Mangali community for entire State of Odisha on the original Mangali community of the Koraput and Kalahandi districts of the State of Odisha. (Action: SSW-I)
Agenda No.9: Ex-post-facto approval of 19 proposals for De-reservation received from Ministry of Culture, CAG and Ministry of Electronics and IT (for 47 posts)
Decision Taken: The Commission accorded ex-post-facto approval on the concurrence to the proposal of the different Ministries/Departments/CAG sent to the respective Ministries/Departments earlier vide letters No. 39/De-reservation-1/2019/SSW-I dated 20.02.2019, No.39/De-reservation-2/2019/SSW-I dated 16.04.2019, No. 39/De-reservation- 3/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No.39/De-reservation-4/2019/SSW-I dated 03.05.2019, No. 39/De-reservation-5/2019/SSW-I dated 08.03.2019, No. 39/De-reservation-6/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No. 39/De-reservation-7/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No. 39/De- reservation/8/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No. 39/De-reservation-9/2019/SSW-I dated 29.4.2019, No. 39/De-reservation-10/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No. 39/De-reservation- 11/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No. 39/De-reservation-12/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No. 39/De-reservation-13/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No. 39/De-reservaation-14/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No.39/De-reservation-15/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019, No.39/De- reservation-16/2019/SSW-I dated 16.04.2019, No.39/De-reservation-17/2019/SSW-I dated 16.04.2019 , No. 39/De-reservtion-18/2019/SSW-I dated 16.04.2019 and No. 39/De-reservation- 19/2019/SSW-I dated 29.04.2019. (Action: SSW-I)
Agenda Item No. 10: Public hearing at Bangalore for Exclusion of 04 castes from Scheduled Castes list of Karnataka State.
13 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Decision Taken: The Commission has decided to form a committee consisting of Vice- Chairman, Member (KR), Director, State Office Hyderabad and Director Shri C.S. Verma Hqrs. to examine the order of Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka dated 23.08.2012 and dated 27.03.2019 and to suggest the effectiveness of the public hearing in this regard. The committee will submit the report within one month. US(SSW) Shri B. Saha will pursue from Ministry of Law & Justice for any advice in this regard. (Action: ESDW) Agenda Item No. 11: Any other item with the permission of the chair.
(i) Hon’ble Member (YP) raised the issue of income limit for the Scheduled Castes students in getting scholarship, he stated that a restriction of 2.5 lakhs has been imposed for releasing scholarships in the State of Bihar which needs to be enhanced. Letters regarding the same may be sent. (Action: ESDW) (ii) Hon’ble Chairman desired that details of sewer death cases are not available in the Hqrs. State-wise details of all sewer death cases/cases of manual scavenging may be collected from the States and if necessary hearing in these cases may be conducted for giving justice and relief to the victims. (Action: ESDW) (iii) Hon’ble Chairman directed that details of State Level Vigilance Monitoring Committee may be obtained from the State Offices and if the meetings are not conducted by any State as per prescribed time line and if representatives of NCC are not invited well in time for these meetings then send to the concerned State Government. (Action: C.Cell)
(iv) Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs is allotting new space for a tribal tower to house NCST. A letter may be sent to Secretary, Housing and Urban Affairs forsimilar space so that NCSC building may be constructed. Ministry of SJ&E to also be asked to help in this regard like the Ministry of Tribal Affairs following up for NCST.
(Action: Admn.)
14 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
(v) It was decided that the concerned attached officers and Hon’ble Members will take care to ensure no directions, injunctions etc. are given from the Commission during making of the minutes of hearings in the Commission as such directions are not in the mandate of the Commission. The Commission should give only recommendation in terms of relevant rules and regulations. If any CMD/CEO or any authority of the PSUs/Banks and Government Institutions do not attend the hearing of the Commission, the concerned Administrative Ministry/Departments should informed of the same & called for the next hearing. Detailed Instructions to be issued by C.Cell. (Action: C.Cell)
1.4 Review of Rajasthan–23.05.2018
1.4.1 Minutes of state review meeting held on 23.05.2018 in Jaipur with Chief Secretary and other senior officers.
Minster of Social Justice, Government of Rajasthan (GoR), Chief Secretary, Rajasthan, Additional Chief Secretaries, Principal Secretaries, Secretaries, Commissioners, Directors etc. of Government of Rajasthan participated in the review.
The Chairman / NCSC in his opening remarks said that the Commission has come to Rajasthan as a part of its Constitutional mandate to monitor the implementation of safeguards and rights of the Scheduled Castes in the state SC population which constitutes 17.81% of total population of the State. The review is an exercise undertaken to point out the areas of concern of NCSC and to sensitize the Government towards the same. The Commission had sent detailed proforma to the State Government for submitting detailed information on work done by state on schemes for welfare of SCs, Central Sector Schemes, Central Schemes & State Sector Schemes, other GOI schemes like PMAY, Ujjawala, Mudra, Stand Up, Jan Dhan, MNREGA etc, action taken regarding prevention of atrocities, payment of compensation to victims of atrocities, action taken regarding prohibition of Manual Scavenging etc.
15 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Analysis of the replies to the various proforma and questionnaires of the Commission, data of NCRB, MSJE etc has been made by the Commission. Detailed discussions will be held after a brief presentation by the Commission on the findings and concerns of the Commission on the core sectors mentioned. Responses of the State Government will be invited on the findings in the presentation during detailed discussions.
In the presentation the main issues highlighting the areas of concern of the Commission were: 1.4.2 Findings Action on Schemes to alleviate SC poverty : . Only 211,238 & 238 SCs were trained in dairy & animal husbandry schemes in 2014- 15,2015-16 & 2016-17. . 229 &251, SCs were trained by handloom development board and fisheries deptt respectively between 2014-15 to 2016-17. . 546,1394 & 1121 SCs were trained by SC /ST Finance and Development Cooperative Corporation in 2014-15,2015-16 & 2016-17. It was seen that the target and achievements by the Corporation has been reducing from 2014-15 to 2016-17 and achievement has come down to 43.38 % in 2016-17 from 76.52 % in 2014-15 Expenditure on schemes for welfare of SCs is much below the norm Table 1.6
Year % of SC % of allocation of % of Exp. on SC specific scheme funds under SC specific schemes to the Exp. to the specific scheme to total plan allocation total SCSP the total state plan Expdt. allocation
2015-16 2.12 2.53 0.34
2016-17 6.96 6.95 1.13
2017-18 (Upto 8.41 6.62 0.54 Sep., 2017)
16 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
SCA unutilized funds were Rs 37.61 crore upto 2016-17. Expenditure on Schemes for welfare of SCs (Rs in crore) Table 1.7
Year Total Allocatio % of Expenditu Allocation Expendit % State n SCSP Expenditu re SCSP to SC ure expendit Allocation re to total total SCSP Specific under SC ure State outlay Scheme to specific under Outlay SCSP scheme SC Allocation to SC specific specific scheme scheme to SCSP Allocatio outlay n 2015- 111784.03 20022.46 17.91% (89.45%) (2.53%) (74.99%) 2.21%
16 17910.23 506.55 379.87
2016- 95052.95 17106.94 17.98% (90.08%) (6.95%) (90.22%) 6.96%
17 15410.91 1188.91 1072.62
2017- 81157.98 14432.25 17.78% (36.77%) (6.62%) (46.73%) 8.41%
18 5307.86 955.48 446.54
1.4.3 The Commission noted that in 2016-17 : No allocation made for: . Soil and water conservation &running of college level hostels, hostel Bicycle Schemes , AmbedkarPeethYojana (SC specific schemes) There was low expenditure by the following: . Agriculture deptt (453.30 vs 611.32 cr) . PMAY ( gramin) (61.12 vs 217.23 cr) . Irrigation deptt (182.37 vs 238.90 cr ) . NRHM (4.23 vs 12.57 cr) There was no expenditure on : . National Rural Livelihood Project
17 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
. DDU Gramin Skill Yojna . Placement based Skill Development Project . PM KrishiSinchaiYojna (spl component) . Running of Girls Hostels . Development of Samble Village (SC specific schemes) . There was expenditure booked under some schemes under SCSP like : . DRDA Administration ,CAMPA ,Building of polytechnics ,Grant to DISCOMS of Jaipur , Jodhpur , Ajmer etc ,Directorate of Information & technology , Civil Aviation which are not SC specific.
Reason for expdt on these schemes booked in SCSP may be elucidated by GoR. 1.4.4 The Commission noted that in 2017-18 :
No allocation made for- . Soil and water conservation , subsidy for solar projects, Running of College level hostel.
Low expenditure : . Agriculture deptt (120.47 vs 693.12 cr) . NavjeevanYojna (30.28 vs 2 cr) (SC specific scheme) . MNREGA (271.15 vs 438.90 cr) . Forestry deptt (6.57 vs 19.55 cr ) . SSA (631.18 vs 843.85 cr) . Elementary education ( 785.29 vs 1116.16 cr) . PM KrishiSinchaiYojna ( 47.37 vs 96.16 cr) . RD & PR deptt ( 1121.64 vs 1854.55 cr) . Women development (23.94 vs 54 cr) . Nutrition ( 224.04 vs 325.39 cr) . Running of girls hostels ( 2.65 vs 6.01 cr) 1.4.5 The Commission noted that in 2017-18
No Expenditure: . Janashree BimaYojna , hostel bicycle scheme(SC specific schemes)
There was expenditure booked under some schemes under SCSP like
18 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
. DRDA Administration, University for animal & veterinary sciences ,Tourism department ,Grant to DISCOMS of Jaipur , Jodhpur , Ajmer etc ,Directorate of Information & technology ,Civil Aviation etc which are not SC specific.
Reason for expdt on these schemes booked in SCSP may be elucidated by GoR. . The GoR is to give reasons for no allocation, non / low expenditure in schemes for welfare of SCs, esp. the schemes mentioned above for 2016-17 & 2017-18. 1.4.6 Literacy Rate Table 1.8
General SCs Difference All India vs. Rajasthan
Male Female Male Female General SCs
All Raj All Raj All Raj All Raj Male Female Male Female India India India India (Raj) (Raj)
82.14 80.51 65.46 52.66 75.2 61.37 56.5 37.32 1.63 12.8 13.83 19.18
Literacy rate of SCs are below All India literacy rate of SCs Difference between all India rates & state rate for SC males is 13.83%. Difference is much higher for SC females (19.18%). Decline in total no. of students in primary and middle school level between 2014-15 to 2017- 18 which indicate high drop outs. Steps taken to reduce drop outs may be informed. No of SC graduates show an increasing trend which is good. 1.4.7 Pre Matric Scholarship Total no. of students 1663191; 1795477& 1947488 during 2014-15, 2015-16 & 2016-17 respectively in secondary school. Total SC students enrolled 386279; 419416 & 467334 during 2014-15, 2015-16 & 2016-17 respectively.
19 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Details of SC students provided pre matric scholarship during 2014-15, 2015-16 & 2016-17 respectively are 234486; 181992 & 148946 show a continuous decrease. 1.4.8 Post Matric Scholarship Total no. of students enrolled 713504, 756915 & 936264 during 2014-15, 2015-16 & 2016- 17 respectively. Total SC students enrolled 114843,120871 & 149277 during 2014-15, 2015-16 & 2016-17 respectively. As per information 1,51,621 & 1,43,602 SC students received Scholarship during 2014-15 & 2015-16. 3,10,639 SC students received the scholarship during 2016-17. Reasons for the sudden increase to double the number of students paid scholarship in 2015- 16 is not clear especially since the total enrolled SC students is given as 1,49,277. In 2014- 15 & 2015-16 also more students than enrolled are shown as having given scholarship. The Government of Rajasthan may give the reasons for the same.
Details of students given pre and post matric scholarship in 2017-18 were not supplied even though the academic year has finished, Government of Rajasthan may furnish the details as well as give the reasons as asked for above.
1.4.9 SC hostels Table 1.9
Type of hostel No. of hostels Observations
Girls 67
Boys 347 However 327 , 326 & 350 hostels were shown asnon functional during 2014-15, 2015-16 & 2016-17 respectively.
The reasons for so many residential schools being non functional may be given by GoR.
20 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.4.10 National Rural Health Mission : Table 1.10
Year Total beneficiaries No. of SC beneficiaries % SC
2014-15 15596343 2651698 17.00%
2015-16 13858223 2647598 19.01%
2016-17 26096598 4436741 17.00%
2017-18 5067351 858930 16.95%
The % is good. 1.4.11 Land Schemes Table 1.11
Year Total Patta issued SC beneficiaries % SC
2014-15 26229 7150 27.26
2015-16 16229 5459 33.63
2016-17 32269 8722 27.03
2017-18 850216 176020 20.70
Average size of pattas is not known and may be supplied by GoR.
Figure of 2017-18 appears highly suspect as there is a huge jump in figures. The GoR may recheck these figures and let the Commission know the actual figures.
1.4.12 Pradhan Mantri Jan-DhanYojana (PMJDY) 2463441 accounts opened during 2016-17 and 3438 accounts have been opened during 2017- 18.
21 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Details SCs with JD accounts under the scheme has not been given. Government of Rajasthan may supply the figures. 1.4.13 Stand Up Scheme ( 1 SC per bank branch) 215 SC applicants given loan out of total 1638 during 2016-17. The average SC loan size Rs 15.81 lakh ,whereas the average loan size is Rs 19.10 lakh for general. 399 SC applicants were given loan out of total 1425 during 2017-18 - average loan size Rs 23.80 lakh. Total no of bank branches of 14 PSU banks not given.
( SBI has sanctioned only 46 loans in 2 years)
1.4.14 Mudra Loan In 2015-16 - 59698 SC applicants were given loan , total loans - 299566. Average loan size Rs 32580/- In 2016-17 - 73012 SC applicants were given loan , total loans 305120 . Average loan size Rs 41,734/- 2017-18 - 53793 SC applicants were given loan , total loans 375141 . average loan size Rs 56512/- The average loan size of general category loans are Rs 104665/- , 143073 & 147811/- in 2015-16, 2016-17 & 2017-18 which is approx 3 times the SC category loan.
Details of monitoring of these schemes by GoR and the reasons for the low number of Stand up and Mudra loans to SCs, lower average loan size may be taken from the banks and submitted to the Commission. Data from all PSU banks for all branches wrt Stand up scheme especially may be taken.
State Government may work on a system of regular monitoring of these schemes and inform the Commission of the same.
1.4.15 Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojna 49365 & 61181 houses to sanctioned SCs persons in PMAY gramin and ,365, 132 and 187 houses in PMAY urban respectively during 2015-16, 2016-17 & 2017-18.
22 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
% of houses allotted to SCs in urban areas is 7.05,7.56& 6.18% respectively - below the SC population %.
How many SC houses out of these allocated have actually been constructed may be informed.
1.4.16 Ujjawala Yojana 466445 (27.07%) and 276047 ( 30.57%) connections to SC women out of total 1722694 & 902940 LPG connections were given during 2016-17 & 2017-18, which is good . 1.4.17 Education Loan 12100 and 6391 education loans - sanctioned during 2016-16 & 2017-18 (upto July, 2017). 639 & 202 SC students given education loan which is only 5.2% & 3.1% of total loans given. 1.4.18 MNREGA Scheme Table 1.12 Households No of No. of Person Avg days Year issued job Households days generated (in lakh) cards in provided (in lacs) (lacs) employment (lacs) Total SC Total SC Total SC Total SC
2014-15 98.46 17.93 36.87 7.38 1686.19 332.34 17 18
2015-16 99.19 18.02 42.21 8.56 2341.25 487.83 23 27
2016-17 95.78 17.60 46.35 9.44 2596.75 537.59 27 30
2017-18 95.95 17.71 9.25 2397.75 500.08 25 28
As per MNREGA Act, 100 days employment p.a is mandated. The average no of days of employment is 25 days p.a – much below the norm. Reasons for low employment and action plan to increase the same may be informed to the Commission. 1.4.19 Data on Services like : Representation of Scheduled Castes in services, backlog vacancies, number of cases of false caste certificates, redresssal of grievances etc. have not been furnished despite several reminders/telephonic reminders. The details may be furnished to the Commission.
23 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission noted that while reservation in services given to SCs is 16%, the population of SCs in the State is actually 17.83%. 1.4.20 Atrocities on Scheduled Castes : Police were found to be registering cases under the unamended sections of the SC/ST Prevention of Atrocities Act (PoAAct ) despite the fact that the Act and Rules thereof have been extensively amended in 2015 & 2016 respectively. There are delays by DM to sanction monetary compensation at FIR &chargesheet stages, as per sections applicable of the SC/ST Prevention of Atrocity Rules, 2016. DMs & SSPs are required to make spot visits in cases of murder & rape of SC victims, the visits are not being made. District administration is not drawing compensation component from Dr.Ambedkar Foundation/Jagjivan Ram Foundation to assist the victims &families or utilizing Central Victim Compensation Fund (CVCF) to help victims get additional assistance. In cases against minors, the compensation as per POCSO act not being paid. As per Rule 46 of the SC/ST Act, the additional relief like pension to the widow, education up to graduation level of the children of the victim, 3 month ration etc. has not been provided in even a single case. Compensation to the victims / families is not being paid as per rules and is delayed. Between 2014-15 to 2017-18 alone Rs6737.85 lakh was the minimum due to be paid. Only Rs5307.72 lakh has been paid in past 4 years (between 2014-15 to 2017-18). The cases need to be reviewed on a priority and the balance compensation of Rs 1430.13 lakh paid to the victims on a priority. The compensation should be paid as per the new Rules in cases from 2016 -17 onwards. In 2017-18 the action to sanction compensation has shown great improvement. The State Government needs to take action as per the provisions of the amended PoA Act and Rules and issue necessary instructions to the District Administration , District Police , SC/ BC and the women and child development departments for the same and also ensure the same are monitored by the State Nodal officer. 25 Special Courts set up - necessary as per Section 14 of PoA Act, as per data sent it was not clear as to whether they are exclusive courts or designated courts .However the GoR now made it clear that these are exclusive courts. Action plan for setting up exclusive courts in the remaining 8 districts may be elucidated.
24 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
No exclusive public prosecutors - necessary as per Section 15 of PoA Act Action plan for appointing exclusive public prosecutors may be given. 1.4.21 State Level Vigilance & Monitoring Committee under the Chairmanship of Chief Minister is to meet twice in a year as per Rule 16(2) of the POA Rules.
No meeting was held, SLVMC constituted on 23.12.2016. The Chief Secretary may take immediate steps to hold the SLVMC meeting at the earliest and ensure regular meetings in future. 1.4.22 District Level Vigilance And Monitoring Committee Quarterly meetings are to be held . In 33 districts a total of 132 meetings required annually. In 2014 only 82 meetings were held In 2015 only 96 meetings were held In 2016 only 112 meetings were held In 2017 only 86 meetings were held 1.4.23 Illogical DLVMC data as below has been supplied to the Commission : 2014 :Baran(10),Bundi(7),Pali(5) 2015 : Baran(5), Bundi(9), Pali(10),Chittorgarh(5) 2016 : Baran(13), Bundi(10), Pali(11),Chittorgarh(5), Bikaner(9),Udaipur(7) 2017 :Bundi(6),Churu(7),Dausa(6),Jaipur(10),Jodhpur(7),Pratapgarh(7)
The data supplied has many errors and the same should have been checked and rectified prior to sending it to the Commission. Corrected data may be furnished. 1.4.24 Implementation of Prohibition of Manual Scavenging Act :
The above Act & the Judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court has not been properly implemented.
Details of FIRs lodged , MS Act & section 3(i) (j) of PoA Act if applied & arrests made have not been informed in the following cases : 1.4.25 2015-16 : 3 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Ajmer, Rs 5 lakh / family compensation has been given to 3 families 2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Jaipur,Rs 10 lakh / family compensation has been given to 3 families .
25 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Jaipur– no compensation 1.4.26 2016-17 : 3 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Bikaner, Rs 5 lakh / family compensation has been given to 3 families. 2 deaths in Udaipur – nil compensation 1.4.27 2017-18 : 4 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Udaipur– Rs 10 lakh / family compensation has been given to 3 families 2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Dholpur– Rs 10 lakh / family compensation has been given . 4 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Alwar – no compensation 1 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Barmer - no compensation 2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Jaipur- Rs 2 lakh / family compensation has been given by State Govt. &Rs 2.5 lakh / family compensation has been given by Mandi Administration 1.4.28 Implementation of Prohibition of Manual Scavenging Act Details of compensation paid in 2,2,2,& 2 deaths in 1995-96, 1996-97 , 2009-10 & 2014-15 respectively have not been given. In 2 deaths in 2013-14 compensation @ Rs 10 lakh per family has been paid. The SC/ST PoA Act has not been applied in the cases whereas section 3(i) (j) of Act applies Provisions of the MS Act also have to be applied in FIRs . workers have to be fully equipped with safety apparatus & oxygen masks etc ,in case they have to clean sewers manually. hence the FIR have to be lodged against officials responsible / contractors responsible for sending un equipped persons for manual cleaning of sewers. In case the victims are SCs additional compensation to families as per Rule 46 of the PoA rules needs to also be paid. All municipal corporations etc have to take a policy of Rs 10 lakh sum insured / worker as per Hon’ble Supreme Court’s directions. The workers have to be fully equipped with safety apparatus in case they have to clean sewers manually.
26 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The State Government needs to issue comprehensive instructions to the District Administration and other officers concerned , including Police officers. 1.4.29 Response of State Govt. to NCSC :
Cases pending in NCSC (HQs) In majority of cases the officers called have not come or sent very junior officers for hearings. The State Government needs to issue directions to the District Administrations and other officers concerned, including Police officers to be regular and prompt in responding to the NCSC and attend the hearings with full details . Detailed discussions were held on the issues raised by the Commission in its presentation: 1.4.30 Literacy & education:
In the detailed discussions the Commission desired to know measures taken by the State Government to improve literacyrates , reduce drop out rates, especially as about 50% of the total students enrolled in primary drop out in middle school and a further 50% of the middle school children drop out by secondary school level. Reasons for the sudden increase to double the number of students paid scholarship in 2015-16 was asked especially since the total enrolled SC students is given as 1,49,277. In 2014-15 & 2015-16 also more students than enrolled are shown as having given scholarship.Reasons for non payment of scholarships to students in 2017-18 and to left over students of previous years were also asked.
Response of Govt. of Rajasthan :
The officers of Govt. of Rajasthan were unable to give the specific details asked for and stated that they will supply all details within 2 months to the Commission. They gave details of the Palanhar scheme where orphan children (including approx. 52000 SC children ) are taken care of.The Commission appreciated the same. 1.4.31 Expenditure on Schemes for welfare of SCs :
It was seen that departments / schemes like agriculture, PMAY (gramin), irrigation , MNREGA ,forestry, elementary education , PM KrishisinchaiYojna ,RD & PR deptt, women development , nutrition etc had not spent most of the allocation in 2016-17 & 2017- 18. SCA funds were unutilized were Rs 37.61 crore upto 2016-17. Poverty alleviation schemes helped only approx. 4500– 5000 beneficiaries between 2014-15 to 2016-17. CSS
27 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
schemes with low expenditure especially from state component were food security, sustainable agriculture, MNREGA, Swach Bharat, SSA, NHRM & smart city. The Commission asked for reasons for the same.
Response of Govt. of Rajasthan :
The CS agreed that the allocation has been low and expenditure on SC specific welfare schemes has been very low when compared to allocation. However some departments stated that it appears that some wrong figures of expenditure of 2017-18 have been communicated by the SW Department to the Commission. The CS committed that the correct figures will be compiled and resent within 2 months. He assured that the Government will take steps to increase both allocation and expenditure on SC specific schemes. It was informed that the SC hostels are functional and incorrect data of nearly 350 non functional hostels was sent to Commission. Regarding installation of hand pumps, the GoR officers informed that 878 habitations with SC majority population will be targeted for providing of safe drinking water.
Regarding electrical connections the GoR officers informed that electric connections for agricultural to SC /STs are given on demand , there is no waiting list or waiting period& connections are subsidized to 4/5th cost.
The CS and other senior officers committed to ensure speedy expenditure, improved planning & regular monitoring in 2018-19 regarding schemes for welfare of SCs. 1.4.32 Implementation of GoI schemes on employment & skill/ entrepreneurship development :
Implementation of Central Government Schemes like Mudra loan, Ujjawala Yojna, PM Jandhan Yojna, Stand up scheme, Education loans:
1.4.33 Mudra loan , Jandhan Yojna , Stand up scheme : Details SCs with JD accounts under the scheme has not been given. GoR may supply the figures. Detailed reasons for the low number of Stand up (total 514 loans in 2016-17 & 2017-18) and low loan size of Mudra loans to SCs , lower average loan size in both stand up & Mudra schemes found by the Commission may be taken from the banks and submitted to the Commission .
28 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Commission desired that the implementation by Banks of these important schemes be monitored by GoR regularly so as to ensure that SC beneficiaries are receiving the due benefits. Data on how many bank branches have given Stand up scheme loan to SCs / SC women out of total no. of bank branches in 2016-17 & 2017-18, how many SCs had applied for the loan ,average loan size etc need to be collected and analysed and sent to the Commission within 2 months. Similarly for Mudra scheme, data on how many SCs have received loans of Rs 10 lakh, how many between Rs 5-9 lakh & how many below Rs 1 lakh need to be collected, analysed and sent to Commission.
Response of Govt. of Rajasthan: CS agreed that the monitoring mechanism was lacking as they were dependent on the supply of information by the Bank . He assured that a monitoring mechanism will be put in place and data collected from implementing banks & sent to NCSC within 2 months.
1.4.34 Ujjawala Yojna :
27.07% & 30.57 % the total beneficiaries of this scheme were SC women.
GoR informed that from April 2018,Seven new categories were being included in the beneficiary target of approx 20 lakh in the 599 gram panchayats.
The Commission appreciated the work done in the scheme. 1.4.35 PMAY
Of the 6.37 lakh houses sanctioned under PMAY (gramin) 2.97 lakh houses have been constructed. While the GoR gave the Commission the total number of SCs sanctioned PMAY ( gramin) houses , the details of actual SC houses constructed under the scheme was not available. The CS committed that the actual figures will be compiled and sent within 2 months. Government of Rajasthan agreed that in PMAY (urban ) the progress was slow but added that under the affordable housing scheme 18000 houses are to be constructed , out of which 8.69% have been allotted so far in 2017-18. 1.4.36 Reservation of industrial plots for SCs:
To the queries of Commission regarding reservations in industrial plots / estates and allocation done to SCs, the GoR states that there are 342 plots / estates , but details of SC
29 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
allottees was not known . The said information will be sent to NCSC within 2 months. The GoR further informed that there is a Bhamashah Swarozgar Yojna . The Commission suggested that this yojna and the Standup / Mudra yojnas can be linked so as to help SCs
1.4.37 Service related issues : The GoR informed that 1,08,000 vacancies ( including 669 backlog vacancies) are in the process of being filled by 15.08.2018. In Education sector of the 3.36 lakh vacancies including 36,000 SC vacancies (13%) are in the process of continuous recruitment. The progress in the same may be informed to the Commission within 2 months. Regarding outsourced work details of whether contractors of municipal corporations, municipal councils and other outsourced agencies supplying manpower to Government departments etc. contribute to EPF & ESIC to be reported to the Commissionafter verification. The contractors & outsourcing agencies may be asked to employ as many SCs as possible.
1.4.38 Action to reduce Atrocities and status of compensation to victims / families:
The Commission emphasized a few aspects needing the attention of the CS, PS (Home) and District Magistrates and desired that instructions on the concern raised by the Commission should be issued to all concerned.
The issues were : Timely and proper payment of financial compensation as per the amended SC/ ST Prevention of Atrocity (PoA) Rules 2016 .At least Rs 14.13 crore compensation is due to be paid to victims/ dependents from 2014-15 to 2017-18. The Government should take steps to release the same and in future regularly monitor the same and ensure the stage wise compensation as per the POA Rules 2016 is paid timely to victims / families. Compensation as per POCSO act not being paid where victim is a minor. As per Rule 46 of the amended PoA Rules 2016, the additional relief like pension to the widow, education up to graduation level of the children of the victims, 3 month ration etc. is not being provided.
30 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
DMs & SSPs are required to make spot visits in cases of murder & rape of SC victims, the visits are not being made.
Instructions should be issued to all DMs and SSPs and the Commissioners / IG zone as well as the SW and Women and Child Welfare Departments to ensure all of the above. The CS assured that necessary instructions will be issued on a priority and steps will be taken to release the pending compensation of previous years. The Director SW, gave a brief presentation on the recently developed net based programme by which the details of the PoA cases at thana level are available to the SW officers for sanction of the compensation amount as per the PoA Rules. This programme has helped in the timely sanction of the compensation amount in 2017-18.
The Commission commended the GoR for is initiative and asked that a brief presentation on the programme may be sent to the Commission so that it may be showcased by Commission to other State Governments for implementation as a good practice.
The CS assured that necessary instructions regarding the handling of atrocity cases will be issued on a priority and steps will be taken to release the pending compensation of previous years as well as for the regular holding of the SLVMC & DLVMC meetings.
1.4.39 Implementation of Prohibition of Manual Scavenging Act :
The Commission had found that the above Act & the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court has not been fully implemented. The amount paid to families of victims is less than stipulated or not paid at all as pointed out in detail in its presentation .
CS agreed to issue necessary instructions on all the above points to the officers concerned. He assured that the implementation will be monitored and action as per rules will be taken in all the cases of death / injury during manual cleaning of sewers as mentioned by the Commission, compensation released and action taken report will be sent to NCSC within 2 months.
Summing up the discussions the Chairman, NCSC appreciated the efforts of officers. He stated that there are shortcomings in implementation of Government Schemes, Centrally Sponsored Schemes etc. which have been pointed out during the review, there is need to regularly monitor
31 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20 the same to ensure that the benefits of these schemes reach the target SC population and help in their economic and social upliftment. He urged Chief Secretary to review the SCSP urgently as the state was lacking in the implementation of the same. CS should monitor action taken under the POA Rules and also regarding implementation of the MS Act, regularly in his regular meetings with officers also. The Principal Secretary (Home) should also regularly follow up the action taken by the police in cases of atrocities against SCs. There is need to urgently issue necessary instructions as pointed out by the Commission.
He asked CS also take steps to immediately arrange meeting of the State Level Vigilance & Monitoring Committee. He desired that the details asked for by the Commission may be compiled and sent to the Commission in the committed time frame.
Chief Secretary Rajasthan assured the Commission that action as desired by Commission on various issues will be taken and the detailed reports as asked for will be submitted to the Commission in the time frame as fixed.
1.5 Review of Rajasthan – 23.05.2018 ( Prevention of atrocities)
Review of Prevention of Atrocities on Scheduled Castes held with the Principal Secretary, Home, DGP, Addl. DGP, IG and other senior Police Officers of Government of Rajasthan held on 23.05.2018
1.5.1 The DG Police, Rajasthan, Additional Chief Secretary, SW Rajasthan, Addl. DGP, IGs and other senior Police Officers of Rajasthan participated. The DG Police, Rajasthan welcomed the Commission.
The Chairman / NCSC in his opening remarks said that the Commission was in Rajasthan as a part of its Constitutional mandate to monitor the implementation of safeguards and rights of the Scheduled Castes in the state. The review is an exercise undertaken to point out the areas of concern of NCSC and to sensitize the Government and State Police towards the same. The Commission had sent detailed proforma to the State Government and DGP for submitting detailed information on action taken regarding trends in atrocity cases, investigation, action taken for prevention of atrocities, payment of compensation to victims
32 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
of atrocities, action taken by police on cases regarding death / injuries during manual cleaning of sewers / manual scavenging etc .
Analysis of the replies to the various proformae and questionnaires of the Commission, data of NCRB, MSJE etc has been made by the Commission and detailed discussions will be held after a brief presentation on the findings and concerns of the Commission is given to the officers present. Responses of the State Government and DGP will be invited on the findings in the presentation during detailed discussions.
The main issues highlighting the areas of concern of the Commission in the presentation were:
1.5.2 Atrocities
Reluctance of police to register cases and apply the sections of the amended PoA Act. Old provisions applied in many cases of 2017.
Delay by District Administration to sanction monetary compensation at FIR stage, as per sections applicable.
Recommendation for paying compensation as per POCSO Act not being made to DM
Police not registering case under SC/ST PoA Act ( as amended 2015) in cases of deaths during manual cleaning of sewers when victim is SC. As per Rules 46 of the SC/ST Act, the additional relief like pension to the widow , education up to graduation level of the children of the victim , 3 month rasanetc , has not been provided as recommendations not sent to DM by police. Setting up of exclusive Special Courts - necessary as per Section 14 of PoA Act Appointment of exclusive public prosecutors - necessary as per Section 15 of PoA Act. Outcome - Trial is completed in only 10-12% of pending cases p.a. 1.5.3 The total no of crimes against SCs show an decreasing trend from 2014 to 2017.
Table 1.13
33 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Yr. Total Cases Rate of Crime Murder Cases Rape Cases Other Cases
All All Raj. All Raj. All Raj. All Raj. India Raj. India India India India
20 55.1 704 83 2233 348 21541 6122 2014 40401 6735
19.2 48.3 707 71 2326 318 22632 5358 2015 38670 5911
20.3 42 786 66 2541 327 24328 4569 2016 40801 5134
33.1 61 282 3597 2017 NA 4046 NA NA NA NA
6.3 19 71 1010 2018 NA 1164 NA NA NA NA
25 Exclusive special Courts have been set up , but status of 8 districts is to be ascertained. No exclusive public prosecutors - necessary as per Section 15 of PoA Act 15.60 % and 12.6 % of total crimes against SCs in India were found committed in Rajasthan in 2015 & 2016. State was ranked at no 3, 3 and 2 in crimes against SCs in 2014, 2015 & 2016 respectively. 13 districts are identified as sensitive. DM & SSP do not visit the spot where atrocities against SCs occur, while Rule 12 of the SC /ST PoA Rules mandates the visit.
1.5.4 Jaipur details : Jaipur ranks at no 1,2& 3 respectively in 2014, 2015 & 2016 in no. of atrocities among cities in India.
In 2016 out of 219 cases of atrocities , 157 were closed and charge sheets filed only in 93.
Of the 4 cases where trial finalised - 3 were acquitted.
1.5.5 Cases registered under section 156(3) of atrocities against SCs:
34 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
2014-15 – 3147 cases ( c/s in 618 cases )
2015-16 – 2786 cases (c/s in 538 cases )
2016-17 – 1777 cases (c/s in 359)
2017-18 – 697 cases (c/s in 83 cases )
Alwar , Bharatpur & Hanumangarh are top 3 districts with 156(3) cases in all the 4 years
This data shows that the SCs have to resort to approaching the Court for registering cases of atrocities against them. 1.5.6 Cases pending with Police
% of cases closed as final without charge sheets is very high ie. >50%
Table 1.14
Year Total Cases Total Cases Pendency Pendency Percentage Cases Charge Cases Pending Percentage Percent- of cases for sheeted with Investigation age(All closed/ FR Investi- final at the end of India) gation report the Year
2014 7723 2794 4041 488 11.5 25.1 52.32
2015 6799 2420 3639 732 10.8 29.7 53.52
2016 5866 2391 2953 521 8.9 29.6 50.34
2017 4121 1885 1775 461 11.18 NA 43.07
The percentage of cases which are closed or in which final reports are filed is very high ranging from 43 % to 53.52 % , while % of cases chargesheeted ranges from 35.5% to 45%. 1.5.7 Cases Pending in Court
Trial is completed in only 10-12% of pending cases p.a
35 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Table 1.15
Year Total Cases in Cases Cases Cases Pendency Pendency Conviction Cases which Convi Dispose Pendin Percenta rate %(All for Trials cted d off by g Trial ge Rajasthan( Trial were Courts at the India) All India ) Durin Complet end of g the ed the Year) Year 2014 12855 1691 750 1846 11009 85.6 85.5 44.3(28.2) 2015 13429 1866 755 2009 11420 85.0 87.8 40.46(27.1) 2016 13811 1215 541 1305 12506 90.6 89.6 44.5(25.6) 1.5.8 District Level Vigilance and Monitoring Committee Quarterly meetings are to be held. In 33 districts a total of 132 meetings required annually. SSPs must participate in the DLVMC meetings to . inform DM of the stage wise progress of FIRs of atrocities against the SCs in the district
. cases with minor victims so that the DM can release the compensation due as per rules.
1.5.9 Compensation given Table 1.16
Year Total Total Total Other Compensa Compensatio Expenditu No. of Less Murde Rape (other cases tion due as n due as per re(in victims / Compensatio r cases ( where C/s per Rules Rules Arson Lakh) dependents n paid (in (murd rape filed) & received Lakh) er cases {murder& /Actual as compensatio cases where rape } Other cases per rule n where C/s filed) (in lakh) (in lakh) C/s filed)
2014-15 83(51) 348(204) 6122(2239) 701.64 230.50 847.36 2097 84.78 932.14
2015-16 71(54) 318(179) 5358(2103) 618.48 476.16 897.75 1536 196.89 1094.64
2016-17 66(33) 327(166) 4569(1821) 1770.75 406.62 999.99 1440 1177.38 2177.37
2017-18 61(7) 282(41) 3575(399) 1560.75 972.95 2562.62 3054 28 2533.70
36 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.5.10 Cases wise Information
2014-15 . 83 cases of murder - charge sheets have been filed in only 51 cases. . 348 cases of rape - charge sheets have been filed in only 204. . 20 case of Arson - charge sheets have been filed in only 11. . 6122 cases of other - charge sheets have been filed in only 2239.
2015-16 . 71 cases of murder - charge sheets have been filed in only 54. . 318 cases of rape - charge sheets have been filed in only 179. . 21 cases of Arson - charge sheets have been filed in only 9. . 5358 cases of other - charge sheets have been filed in only 2103.
2016-17 . 66 cases of murder - charge sheets have been filed in only 33. . 327 cases of rape - charge sheets have been filed in only 166. . 11 cases of Arson - charge sheets have been filed in only 4. . 4569 cases of other - charge sheets have been filed in only 1821.
2017-18 . 61 cases of murder - charge sheets have been filed in only 7. . 282 cases of rape - charge sheets have been filed in only 41. . 5 cases of Arson - charge sheets have been filed in only 2. . 3575 cases of other - charge sheets have been filed in only 399. 1.5.11 Implementation of Prohibition of Manual Scavenging Act
Sections of the Manual Scavenging Act and PoA act are not being addedin FIRs where there are cases of death / injury during manual cleaning of sewers, despite the issue being emphasized by NCSC State Office ,Ahemdabad. Between 2015-16 and 2017-18 there have been 25 deaths caused due to manual cleaning of sewers, and the proper sections were not added in the FIRs. The above Act & the Judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court has not been properly implemented.
37 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Details of FIRs lodged , MS Act & section 3(i) (j) of PoA Act if applied & arrests made have not been informed in the following cases :
2015-16 . 3 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Ajmer , . 2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Jaipur . 2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Jaipur
2016-17 . 3 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Bikaner. . deaths in Udaipur
2017-18 . 4 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Udaipur. . 2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Dholpur . . 4 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Alwar . . 1 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Barmer . . 2 deaths during manual cleaning of sewers in Jaipur .
1.5.12 Details of FIRs in 2 deaths in each year , in the following districts respectively have also not been given : . 1995-96 ( Naguar), . 1996-97(Jodhpur) , . 2009-10 ( 1 each in Jhunjhunu&Alwar) , . 2013-14( Nagaur), . 2014-15 ( Alwar)
1.5.13 Implementation of Prohibition of Manual Scavenging Act . The SC/ST PoA Act has not been applied in the cases whereas section 3(i) (j) of Act applies. . Provisions of the MS Act also have to be applied in FIRs . . Workers have to be fully equipped with safety apparatus & oxygen masks etc ,in case they have to clean sewers manually. Hence the FIRs have to be lodged against officials
38 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
responsible / contractors responsible for sending un equipped persons for manual cleaning of sewers. . DM has to be informed of the post mortem and other stages of investigation in order that the compensation is paid in time.
1.5.14 The DG Police then gave a presentation on crime against Scheduled Castes, as the detailed data in both the NCSC presentation & the Rajasthan Police presentation were based on NCRB statistics , the conclusions were essentially the same.
Response on the points raised by NCSC :
1.5.15 DGP agreed that the state has a very high number of FIRs filed after the orders of court ie after 156 (3) CPC but stated that the same is now showing a declining trend from 2015 onward due to strict monitoring. Pendency % was 9.54 in 2017 and rate of conviction was 25.4 % in 2017 . 1.5.16 DGP stated that the number of charge sheets filed ( atrocity wise ) as stated by the Commission does not tally with the details available with them. When shown that the data was taken from the information supplied by the State Government to the Commission, he agreed that there was some error and promised to send the year wise details to the Commission within 1 month. 1.5.17 There was a detailed discussion with each IG range on the action taken and status of grievious cases of atrocities like murder & rape as well as cases filed u/s 156(3) and the officers gave the details as follows : 1.5.18 Bikaner ( Bikaner , Churu,Hanumangarh & Sriganganagar):
2017: 8 pending cases of murder & 2 of rape, 106 cases of 156(3) 1.5.19 Bharatpur ( Bharatpur, Dholpur , SawaiMadhopur, Karoli ): In 2017 out of 3 cases of murder in 1 case F/R was filed & in 2018 out of 6 cases of murder, FR was filed in 5 cases – reasons for FRs in murder cases need to be informed. Charge sheets were filed in only 6 out of 15 rape cases in 2017 & 3 out of 12 rape cases of 2018 . The outcome of the remaining 9 cases of 2017 is not known despite the time limit of 2 months for investigation having ended several months ago.
39 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
There are 221 cases of 156(3). 1.5.20 Kota – [Kota (city ) Kota ( rural ) , Bundi , Jhalawar & Bala]: . 8 cases are pending and FR has been filed only in 15 cases of rape in 2017 out of a total of 45 FIRs registered. Of the 6 cases of murder in 2017 final report has been filed in 1 case.
. 2018 data was not available.
3.5.21 Udaipur :
. In 40 cases of rape in 2017 charge sheets have been filed in 27 only &final reports have been filed in 12 cases. Charge sheets have been filed in all 3 cases of murder. In 11 cases of rape in 2018 , charge sheet has been filed in 6 cases & 1 has been closed & charge sheets have been filed in 2 cases of murder.
. There are 19 cases under 156(3). 1.5.22 Ajmer ( Ajmer , Tonk , Nagaur, Bhilwara): . In 46 cases of rape in 2017, chargesheets have been filed in 25 cases only & details of the remaining 21 cases were unknown. Charge sheets have been filed in 8 cases of murder& details of the remaining case was unknown. In 17 cases of rape in 2018 , chargesheet has been filed in 6 cases .
. There are 173 & 49 cases under 156(3) in 2017 and 2018 respectively.In 48 out of these 173 and 16 out of 49 cases ,charge sheets have been filed . 1.5.23 Jodhpur (city): . Details of murder & rape cases were not available.
. There were 19 & 37 cases under 156(3) in 2017 and 2018 respectively.In 5 out of these 19 and 2 out of 49 cases , charge sheets have been filed . 1.5.24 Jaipur ( Alwar , Sikar , Dausa & Jhunjhunu): . In 69 cases of rape in 2017, chargesheets have been filed in 29 cases only, in 26 cases final reports have been filed , details of the remaining 14 are not known . Chargesheets have been filed in 3 out of 11 cases of murder , final reports in 3 cases & details of the remaining 5 cases was unknown.
. The officers did not have 2018 data.
40 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
. There are 294 cases under 156(3) in 2017.In 32 out of these cases ,charge sheets have been filed . 1.5.25 Jaipur ( city): . In 17 cases of rape in 2017, chargesheets have been filed in 8 cases only, in 9 cases final reports have been filed. Chargesheets have been filed in both cases of murder .In 10 cases of rape in 2018 , chargesheet has been filed in 3 cases and final report in 3 cases .
. There are 62 cases under 156(3) in 2017.In 7 out of these cases ,charge sheets have been filed . 1.5.26 Jodhpur Range : . There are 117 cases under 156(3) in 2017. In 24 out of these cases ,charge sheets have been filed. 1.5.27 Commission expressed its concern on the large number of final reports in rape & murder cases and the lack of information displayed by the officers on the fate of a number of even such henious crime cases. The officers were also unable to give details of the number of cases where cross FIRs have been filed against SCs in cases registered by the SCs. Chairman, NCSC explained to the officers that the cross FIRs are often used by opposite parties to intimidate and harass the SCs in cases where SCs file cases of atrocities. The police should take into account this aspect during investigation of such cross FIRs. DGP assured that the data on cross FIRs and the outcome of all the henious crime cases of 2017 and 2018 ( up to March ) will be collected & sent to the Commission within 1 month. 1.5.28 A list of 33 cases of serious atrocities being pursued by the State office of the Commission pertaining to 2017 and 2018 had been given to the officers and the outcome was called for in the meeting . However the officers were unable to give upto date status. The DG, Police assured an uptodate report on these cases will be sent within 1 month. 1.5.29 Regarding the action to be taken by the Police in cases of deaths / injuries during the manual cleaning of sewers , the officers were unaware of the action taken by the field level officers in the year wise cases highlighted by the Commission. 1.5.30 The DG Police assured that detailed instructions will be issued to all districts for application of relevant sections of SC/ST PoA Act ( as amended in 2015) and MS Act in cases of death / injury of SC persons engaged in manual cleaning of sewers / manual
41 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
scavenging. He also committed that an uptodate report on the status of action taken in these cases will be sent within 1 month
Summing up by the Chairman NCSC :
1.5.31 Chairman NCSC stated that the PoA Act ( as amended in 2015) and Rules ( as amended in 2016) need to be implemented in Rajasthan and there should not be any delay in the completion of the investigations and in filing of charge sheets. The 60 day time limit as per the PoA Act should be adhered to.
1.5.32 All FIRs should be lodged and no persons should have to resort to approaching courts for lodging of FIRs. The senior officers of Police should work towards reducing the large number of cases lodged u/s 156(3).
1.5.33 Cross FIRs against SCs should be reexamined to ensure that they are genuine and not lodged for the simple purpose of pressurizing the SC complainants.
1.5.34 He further urged that the Police should send details of the stage wise progress on the cases of atrocities to the DM in time, so that the monetary compensation as per the Prevention of Atrocities Rules, 2016 can be paid in time to the victims / families.
1.5.35 The DMs and SSPs should visit the spot where atrocities against Scheduled Castes occur. This is mandated as per Rule 12 of the Prevention of Atrocities Rules.
1.5.36 He urged Director General of Police , Rajasthan and Principal Secretary ( Home ) to review the action taken under the PoA Act and Rules regularly, and asked them to ensure that the commitments made to the Commission today may be compiled with and reported to the Commission within the committed time frame.
1.6 Review of Maharashtra-- 29.08.2019
1.6.1 Minutes of the Maharashtra State Review by National Commission for Scheduled Castes with Chief Secretary and senior officers of Government of Maharashtra (GoM) on 29.08.2019.
42 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Minister of Social Justice, Government of Maharashtra (GoM), Chief Secretary, Maharashtra, Additional Chief Secretaries, Principal Secretaries, Secretaries, Commissioners, Directors etc. of Government of Maharashtra participated in the review.
The Chairman National Commission for Scheduled Castes at the outset in his opening remarks pointed out that the Commission has come to Maharashtra as a part of its Constitutional mandate to monitor the implementation of safeguards and rights of the Scheduled Castes in the state SC population which constitutes 11.81% of total population of the State. The review is an exercise undertaken by the commission to focus on the areas of concern of NCSC and to sensitize the Government towards the same. The Commission had sent detailed Performa and questionnaires to the State Government for submitting detailed information on work done by state on schemes for welfare of SCs, Central Sector Schemes, Central Schemes and State Sector Schemes, other GOI schemes like PMAY, Ujjawala, Mudra, Stand Up, Jan Dhan, MNREGA etc, action taken regarding prevention of atrocities, payment of compensation to victims of atrocities, action taken regarding prohibition of Manual Scavenging etc.
The Commission has made the analysis of the replies to the various Performa and questionnaires, data of NCRB and MSJE Govt of Maharashtra etc. The Commission made detailed discussions on the core sectors mentioned, the response of state Govt was invited on the observations/Findings of the Commission.
In the discussions held the main issues highlighting the areas of concern of the Commission were: Education – Literacy Rates , dropout rates and status of scholarships MNREGA- job cards, SC job cards, man days created Performance in key self employment schemes like : MUDRA, Start-up, Stand-up. Allocation and expenditure for schemes of welfare of scheduled castes, progress of central schemes like PMAY & Ujjawala Land related issues Atrocities on Scheduled Castes – crime rate , pendency with police & courts , conviction rate & timely and correct payment of compensation Service Safeguards and issue of Caste certificates
43 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
deaths due to manual cleaning of sewers and action taken thereon
Findings
1.6.2 State SC population- 11.81%
Table 1.17
Population State All India
Literacy Total 82.12 Male: 80.88% Rate Female: 64.63% Literacy SC 79.66 Male: 75.17% Rate Female: 56.46%
The Literacy rate of Maharashtra is 82.12% whereas SC literacy rate is 79.66% which is higher in the state of Maharashtra in comparison to All India Literacy rate for SCs. The information of male & female literacy rate was asked by the Commission separately. Response of Government of Maharashtra
The officers of Government of Maharashtra were unable to give the specific information asked and stated that they will provide all the details to the Commission at the earliest.
1.6.3 Enrolment of SC children
Table 1.18
Year Primary Upper primary Secondary Higher Secondary
Total SC Total SC Total SC Total SC
2016- 1000210 1284721 5983603 804695 3754149 53449 2860505 386690 17 9 9 2017- 1001286 1271252 5899239 778386 2417160 52816 2876114 388512 18 8 2
44 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The data for 2018-19 and 2019-20 was not available. It was observed that no. of SC students have been decreasing in primary level from 12.71 lakh to Upper primary 7.78 lakh , Secondary 5.28 lakh and Higher secondary level 3.88 lakh in the year 2017-18. Very high dropout which is almost 1/4th of SC students drop out by the time they reach Higher Secondary. The no. of SC students have also been decreasing from primary level to upper primary level i.e. there is a difference of 480026 SC students between primary level and upper primary level during 2016-17. Similarly the differences are noticed from upper primary to secondary and secondary to higher secondary in 2016-17 and 2017-18. Response of Government of Maharashtra:
The officers of Government of Maharashtra assured the Commission that the reasons for drop out will be examined at appropriate level and steps will be taken to improve the same.
1.6.4 Graduates:
Table 1.19
Year Total no. of SC Graduates Total No. SCs out of Graduates (%of SC Prof. them graduates Graduates (%of SC Prof against Total graduates No. of against Total Graduates) No. Of Prof Graduates) 2016-17 1620999 196656 68048 6512 (12.13%) (9.57%) 2017-18 1582140 209591 71023 7001 (13.25%) (9.86%) 2018-19 1852285 209954 88977 8633 (11.33%) (9.70%)
The no. of SC graduates were increased from 2016-17 but it was decreased from 2017-18 to 2018-19. The reasons for the same was asked from the State Govt.
45 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
It was noticed that the number of graduates & professional graduates are 2.18 lakh whereas 3.88 lakh SC Students were enrolled in the Higher Secondary level. The State Government was to ask clarify the same.
1.6.5 Pre matric Scholarship
57214 SC students received the Pre-matric scholarship during the year 2016-17 whereas total 534499 SC students were registered in 2016-17 in Secondary level, hence State Government was asked to clarify as to why Pre-Matric Scholarship was not been given to 4.7 lakh SC students. 59244 SC students received the Scholarship under Pre-Matric (Unclean occupation during 2016-17). The details of the No. of SC students getting Pre Matric Scholarship from the year 2017-18 to 2019-20 has not been given the same was asked from the State Government. Under Pre Matric (Unclean occupation has also not been given from the year 2017-18 to 2019-20) the same was asked from the State Government. Response of Government of Maharashtra: It was reported that since year 2017-18 the central assistance is due for said scheme and academic year 2018-19,2019-20, the said scheme was implemented offline as it was not implemented through Maha DBT Portal and hence the data compilation for the said years is under progress and shall be furnished once it is availed at Commissionerate, Social welfare, Pune.
1.6.6 Post Matric Scholarship
489278 No. of SC students received the Post matric scholarship during 2016-17, whereas 527387 SC students applied for the Scholarship. 354724 No. of SC students received the Post matric scholarship during 2017-18, whereas 370530 SC students applied for the Scholarship. 402373 No. of SC students received the Post matric scholarship during 2018-19, whereas 563949 SC students applied for the Scholarship.
46 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The State Government was asked to clarify as to why the 38109(2016-17), 15806(2017-18) and 1.6 lakh (2018-19) SC students who applied for the Scholarship were not given the Scholarship. The number is increasing. The State Government was also asked to clarify as to why the no. of SC students who received the Scholarship were decreased during 2017-18. Response of Government of Maharashtra:
The officers of Government of Maharashtra assured the Commission to provide the details at the earliest.
1.6.7 Hostels Total No. of SC hostels (break up for boys and girls hostels district wise), capacity and actual children per hostel during the year 2018-19.
Table 1.20
Type Total no. of hostel Total sanctioned Actual enrolled strength strength
Girls hostel 210 20400 17212 Boys hostel 229 22958 21332
The total capacity of SC students are 43358 for the total 439 hostels in the State of Maharashtra, whereas only 38541 students are enrolled during the year 2018-19. The State Govt. was asked to explain why less no. of SC students are enrolled in the hostels. The State Govt. also running total 1989 SC hostels aided by Social Justice and Special Assistance Department and 88 Govt. residential schools. 10 SC Primary Ashram School also run by Social Justice and Special Assistance Department. Response of Government of Maharashtra:
The officers of Government of Maharashtra assured the Commission to provide the information at the earliest.
47 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.6.8 Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojna
The State Govt. of Maharashtra has sanctioned 63339 (28.19%) houses out of total 224675 houses to SC persons in rural area during 2016-17 . Sanctioned 34687 (24.45%) houses out of total 141884 sanctioned houses to the SC persons in rural areas during 2017-18. Sanctioned 5426 (8.36%) houses out of total 64884 sanctioned houses to the SC persons in rural areas during 2018-19. Sanctioned 6194 (3.79%) houses out of total 163373 sanctioned houses to the SC persons in rural areas during 2019-20 Upto July 2019. State Government was asked to inform that how many houses out of sanctioned houses have actually been built. The State Govt . of Maharashtra also implemented Ramai Awas Yojna scheme and also providing the benefits of this scheme to the victim or deceased dependents in atrocities cases. The State Govt. has sanctioned adequate no. of houses which is higher than prescribed % of the SCs under Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojna during the year 2016-17 & 2017-18 the Commission appreciated the same.
1.6.9 National Rural Health Mission
Table 1.21
Year Total Beneficiaries Covered
2016-17 1864806 2017-18 1857101 2018-19 1825376 2019-20 (Upto June 2019) 472426
The State Govt. has not given the No. of SC beneficiaries. The Commission asked the no. of SC beneficiaries under the National Rural Health Mission and beneficiaries of Ayushman Bharat.
48 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Response of Government of Maharashtra:
It was reported that since caste status is not collected while admission to OPD and hospitals, Number of SC beneficiaries cannot be ascertained by the Public Health Department of the State. However allocation done under SCSP is spent on Notional basis prorate to the population of SCs in the State.
1.6.10 Details of Hand pumps
The State Govt has installed 2516, 4643 and 3489 hand pumps during the year 2016-17, 2017-18 and 2018-19 respectively for the SCs. The Commission asked from the State Govt. whether these Hand pumps were installed in the area of SC persons.
1.6.11 Land Schemes
Table 1.22
Year Total allocated land to SC (In Total No. of Beneficiaries acres) 2016-17 660.83 209 2017-18 736.29 220 2018-19 852.18 310
Tehsil wise data on regulation as per rule of residential and agricultural land possessed by SCs are NIL as there is no policy in the State.
1.6.12 Programme under MNREGA
49 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Table 1.23
Year Households issued No. of Person days Average days of job cards provided generated (in lacs) SCs to SCs SCs %SC 2016-17 806451 6254189 11.33 2017-18 7987841 10.33 2018-19 8920073 9.48
The job cards issued to the SC persons for the last 3 years have not been given. As per MNREGA Act, the maximum 100 days job is to be provided to the weaker section of society. Even though Number of person days generated for SCs are increasing during the last 3 years but the average days for SCs are decreasing . The State Govt. was asked to clarification the same.
1.6.13 MUDRA LOAN Table 1.24
Year Applications accepted Total % of Sc Amount distributed by banks (Sanctioned) applications (Rs. in lacs) accepted General SC SC 2016-17 1294124 578930 578930 100 16976.76 2017-18 1753502 565029 565029 100 22266.2 2018-19 2467040 610846 610846 100 25741.99 2019-20 445607 128828 128828 100 4193.03 (up to June 2019)
100% SC persons received the loan under Mudra scheme for the last 4 years. Bank of Maharashtra which is lead bank in Maharashtra had disbursed the maximum loan under Mudra Loan scheme followed by Central Bank, State Bank of India, and Allahabad Bank. Total 23 public sector banks which are disbursing loan, 7 private banks and 2 Gramin banks disbursed the amount.
50 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission asked that how many Scheduled caste and how many SC women have received Rs.10 lakh and how many SCs received loan of 5 lakh and above under the Mudra loan.
1.6.14 Stand Up
Total 1664 no. of loans out of 2387 sanctioned loans were disbursed during 2016-17 under the scheme. Total 3203 no. of loans out of 4392 sanctioned loans were disbursed during 2017-18 under the scheme. Total 3717 no. of loans out of 5368 sanctioned loans were disbursed during 2018-19 under the scheme. Total 5427 no. of loans out of 5427 sanctioned loans were disbursed during 2019-20 (upto31.06.2019) under the scheme. No separate information for the SCs has been provided under the scheme. The objective of the Stand up India Scheme is to facilitate bank loans between Rs.10 lakh and Rs.1 crore to at least one Scheduled caste (SC) or Scheduled tribes (ST) borrower and at least one woman borrower per bank branch for setting up a greenfield enterprise. This enterprise may be in manufacturing, services or the trading sector. In case of non-individual enterprises at least 51% of the shareholding and controlling stake should be held by either an SC/ST or woman entrepreneur. The Commission desired to know that how many Scheduled Castes have received Rs.10 Lakh and how many SCs received loan of 10 lakh to 1 crore under the Mudra loan. Response of Government of Maharashtra: The officers of Government of Maharashtra assured the Commission to provide the details at the earliest.
1.6.15 Education loan
212399 no. of education loan have been provided during 2016-17. 1731436 no. of education loan have been provided during 2017-18. 204099 no. of education loan have been provided during 2018-19.
51 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
It is not clear whether above education loan have been provided to the SC students only, the Commission advised the State Government to confirm the same and to submit the data.
1.6.16 PM UjjawalaYojna
It is observed that no. of SC beneficiaries under the scheme is higher as per % SC population of the State of Maharashtra. The Commission appreciated the same.
1.6.17 Details of % of expenditure under SCSP to the Total Plan expenditure, Total plan Expenditure and total SCSP expenditure 2016-17,2017-18, 2018-19 (upto July 2019). The % of SC population in the State is 11.8% whereas the SC SCSP outplay to the State outlay is 12%,9% and 10% respectively i.e. less than the population % of SCs in Maharashtra during the year 2016-17,2017-18,2018-19 respectively. The expenditure of under SCSP is 8%, 6.38% and 8.75% with reference to the State plan allocation is also very low during the year 2016-17,2017-18 and 2018-19 respectively. % expenditure under SC specific scheme to the total plan allocation is also very low i.e. 6.16% in 2016-17, 6.78% in 2017-18 and 5.27% in 2018-19. NIL expenditure under centrally sponsored schemes It was informed during the discussion that the norms notified by the State Government for SCSP is that the allocation should not be less than the last year as per the advise of Niti Ayog. The Commission advised the State Govt. to increase the SCSP outlet as per % population of the State of Maharashtra.
1.6.18 Death due to Manual Cleaning of sewer and Compensation provided since 2014: As per information provided by the State Govt. 20 death cases due to Manual Cleaning of Sewers and Septic tanks have been reported in which only in three cases, at Pimpri Chinchvaad, Umred and Bhandara, the compensation of Rs. 10 lakhs as per Supreme Court guidelines have been paid and Only Rs. 5 lakh in each two death cases at Aurangabad have been paid.
52 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission had found that the above Act & the judgement of Hon’ble Supreme Court have not been fully implemented. The amount paid to families of victims is less than stipulated or not paid at all as pointed out in detail as per available information. The State Govt. may to provide the compensation and Rehabilitation of the Family of the victim in all the 17 cases of death due to manual cleaning of Sewers / Septic tanks immediately as per Supreme Court Guidelines. Whereas As per rule 7 (v) of the Prohibition of employment as manual Scavengers and their rehabilitation rules, 2013 (PEMSR, Rules 2013), the employer shall ensure that the assigned person has life insurance policy of at least Rs.10 lakh and the premium of such shall be paid by the employer. Regarding reply to the queries number 2-10 of the question 15 (e) at page 178 to 194. The 12 Municipal Corporations have not been provided the information and other Municipal Corporation have also given incomplete information. If the SC/ST PoA Act has not been applied in the cases of death cases of SCs Safaikaramcharies/ labourers whereas section 3(i) (j) of Act applies. In case the victims are SCs additional compensation to families as per Rule 46 of the PoA rules needs to also be paid. The detail of number of SCs died and details of FIRs lodged with sections of PoA Act and compensations provided under the SCs & STs (PoA), Rules, and houses, pension, Government job etc. to families of victims. Details of Provisions of the PEMSR Act also applied in FIRs may also be given. Workers have to be fully equipped with safety apparatus & oxygen masks etc ,in case they have to clean sewers manually. Hence the FIR have to be lodged against officials responsible / contractors responsible for sending un equipped persons for manual cleaning of sewers. All municipal corporations etc have to take a policy of Rs 10 lakh sum insured / worker as per Hon’ble Supreme Court’s directions. The workers have to be fully equipped with safety apparatus in case they have to clean sewers manually. The State Government needs to issue comprehensive instructions to the District Administration and other officers concerned, including Police officers.
53 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission observed that the above act and judgment of Supreme Court need to be implemented in to.
Response of Government of Maharashtra:
The Chief Secretary agreed to issuing necessary instructions on all above points to the officers concerns. He also assured that the implementation will be monitored and action as per rules will be taken to prevent cases of death/injuries during manual cleaning of sewers.
1.6.19 Service Matters It was informed that there is no backlog vacancies in State Government departments except some in Municipal Corporation for Safai karamcharies.
The Commission observed that all the backlog vacancies needs to be filled up through a special recruitment drive. The officers of State Government assured the Commission to clear the backlog.
1.6.20 The following action points were identified by the Commission: The State Government to provide the information of male and female literacy rate of SCs separately in comparison with overall literacy rate of Maharashtra State. The State Government shall analyze and share with the Commission the enrollment, dropout rate etc of SCs as compared with overall figures. What percentage of SC target group of school going age remained un enrolled in the last 03 years as compared to corresponding overall figures. The State Government to provide complete information on pre-matric and post-matric scholarship with clarifications as to why total number of students who applied for scholarship were not given scholarship. The State Govt. to provide the information as to why less no. of SC students are enrolled in the hostels. The State Government to inform that how many houses out of sanctioned houses have actually been built for SCs in Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojna . In National Rural Health Mission the State Govt. has not given the total No. of SC beneficiaries. This may be provided.
54 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The information on total number of SCs beneficiaries under the National Rural Health Mission and information on beneficiaries of Ayushman Bharat be provided. The detailed information regarding how many Hand pumps were installed in the SC concentrated population or in SC area during last 3 years be provided. In MNREGA the State Government has to provide information on total job card issued and number of days granted to SC persons during last 3 years. The State Government to provide information on applications of stand up schemes mentioning over all application received in general and in SC cases, application sanctioned, loan disbursed and rejection rate. State Government to analyze the reasons of rejection of SC applications and compare with over all rejection rate. The State Government to share the minutes of last 03 SLBC meetings and ATR there upon with the Commission. The representative of National Commission for Scheduled Castes from State Office may be invited in every SLBC meeting. The Commission desired to know that how many Scheduled Castes have received Rs.10 Lakh and how many SCs received loan of 10 lakh to 1 crore under the Mudra loan. It was not clear whether the education loan were provided to the SC students only, the Commission advised the State Government to confirm the same and to submit the data. The Commission advised the State Govt. to increase the SCSP outlay as per % population of the State of Maharashtra. The Chairman, NCSC advised that trained Teams of person on the lines of Disaster Management Team may be maintained in all local bodies to handle sewers etc. in such cases where mechanical cleaning is not possible. The State Government to provide the information on total information of death due to Manual Cleaning of sewer and Compensation provided since 2014 as per the provisions of Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013 (PEMSR Act, 2013) and POA Act 1989 (As amended). The State Government to ensure that the provisions of PEMSR Act 2013 are implemented in toto. Workers have to be fully equipped with safety apparatus & oxygen masks etc ,in case they have to clean sewers manually.
55 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The FIR should be lodged against officials responsible / contractors responsible for sending un equipped persons for manual cleaning of sewers. All municipal corporations etc have to take a policy of Rs 10 lakh sum insured / worker as per Hon’ble Supreme Court’s directions. The workers have to be fully equipped with safety apparatus in case they have to clean sewers manually. The State Government needs to issue comprehensive instructions to the District Administration and other officers concerned, including Police officers on the provisions of Prohibition of Employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013 (PEMSR Act, 2013) and POA Act 1989 (As amended).
Summing up the discussions the Chairman, NCSC said that there is need to regularly monitor the schemes of welfare to ensure that the benefit of these schemes reach the target SC population and help in their economic and social upliftment. He advised the Chief Secretary, Home Secretary and other senior officers to review / monitor SCSP and cases of PO Act 1989 (Amended) time to time. He desired that the details asked for by the Commission may be compiled and sent to the Commission within one month.
The Chief Secretary, Government of Maharashtra assured the Commission that action as desired by the Commission on various issues will be taken and detailed reports as asked will be submitted to the Commission at the earliest.
1.7 Review of Maharashtra – 30.08.2019 ( prevention of atrocities)
State Review Meeting of NCSC regarding Prevention of Atrocities on Scheduled Castes held with the Principal Secretary, Social Justice, DGP, Addl. DGP, IG and other senior Police Officers of Government of Maharashtra on 30.08.2019.
1.7.1 The Principal Secretary, Social Justice, Maharashtra, DG Police, Maharashtra, Addl. DGP, IGs and other senior Police Officers of Maharashtra participated. The DG Police, Maharashtra welcomed the Commission.
56 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Chairman / NCSC in his opening remarks pointed out that the Commission was in Maharashtra as a part of its Constitutional mandate to monitor the implementation of safeguards and rights of the Scheduled Castes in the state. The review is an exercise undertaken to point out the areas of concern of NCSC and to sensitize the Government and State Police towards the same. The Commission had sent detailed Performa to the State Government and DGP for submitting detailed information on action taken regarding trends in atrocity cases, investigation, action taken for prevention of atrocities, payment of compensation to victims of atrocities, action taken by police on cases regarding death / injuries during manual cleaning of sewers / manual scavenging etc. The analysis of the replies to the various Performa and questionnaires of the Commission, data of NCRB, MSJE etc was done by the Commission. The IG, PCR made a presentation and detailed discussions was also held with the DGP & other senior officers present during the Review Meeting. The responses of the State Government and DGP was invited on the findings of Commission during detailed discussions. The main issues highlighting the areas of concern of the Commission during the discussion were as follows: 1.7.2 Atrocities Reluctance of Police to register the cases and apply the Sections of PoA Act, 1989 (as amended). Police not registering case under SC/ST PoA Act ( as amended 2015) in cases of deaths during manual cleaning of sewers when victim is SC As per Rules 46 of the SC/ST Act, the additional relief like pension to the widow, education up to graduation level of the children of the victim, 3 month rasan etc, has not been provided as recommendations not sent to DM by police. Setting up of exclusive Special Courts - necessary as per Section 14 of PoA Act Appointment of exclusive public prosecutors - necessary as per Section 15 of PoA Act.
1.7.3 Cases disposed of by Court During the month ending June, 2019, 7274 cases involving SCs were pending for disposal in the Special Courts. The performance of the Exclusive Special Prosecutor needs to be
57 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
reviewed by the concerned District Collectors. Relief and protection provided to the victims and witness during the trial in the Court has not been provided.
1.7.4 Conviction Rate Rate of conviction in the cases involving Scheduled Castes was 10.91 against national average 25.78 in the year 2016. Rate of conviction is lower than the national average. (Source: NCRB)
As per figures supplied by the State Govt., during the year 2016 the conviction rate was 6.81, in 2017 6.29, in 2018 8.13 and in 2019 (up to June) was 7.03 The performance of the Exclusive Special Public Prosecutor needs to be reviewed by the concerned District Collector of the District. Reason for low conviction rate may be analysed by the State Govt.
1.7.5 SC/ST Protection Cell The DGP, Maharashtra is the controller of the SC/ST Protection Cell. This Cell is headed by an officer of the rank of IG (Police) to assess law and order situation in the area and to monitor the implementation SC/ST (POA) Act in the cases registered. However, details asked for by NCSC could not be supplied hence the cell appears ineffective.
1.7.6 Training/Workshop
The State Govt. has organized 838 regular training/workshop sessions in 2016, 847 in 2017, 973 in 2018 and 401 in 2019 (upto June, 2019) to enhance the capacity of the investigation and other police officers. What is the duration of Training?
1.7.7 Appointment of Nodal Officer for SCs and STs
Principal Secretary, Minority Affairs, Govt. of Maharashtra has been designated as Nodal Officer to monitor the implementation of SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989 (as amended) and SC/ST (POA) Rules, 1995 (as amended). However, data regarding the compensation given to victims could not be supplied. Hence, it appears no monitoring is being conducted.
58 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.7.8 State level Vigilance Monitoring Committee
No meeting held during the year 2016-17, 2017-18, 2018-19 and 2019 (upto June). Whereas, two meetings should be held under the chairmanship of Chief Minister in the month of January and July to review the implementation of the provisions of the Act, scheme for the right and entitlement of the victims and witness in assessing justice are mandatory as per the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (POA) Act, 1989 (as amended).
1.7.9 Recommendations: Two Meetings in a year are mandatory as per Rules 16 (2) of the SC/ST (POA) Rules, 1995. The State Level Meetings should be held timely.
1.7.10 District level Vigilance Monitoring Committee
All the District Collectors are the Chairman of the District Vigilance Monitoring Committee. The State Govt. has provided dates of the Meeting not the details of the Meetings. There may be error.
Recommendations: Four Meetings in a year are mandatory as per Section 17 (3) of the SC/ST (POA) Rules, 1995 (as amended).
1.7.11 Cases registered u/s Cr.PC 156(3) 52 cases (21 cases chargesheeted, 2 cases acquittal and 29 cases pending in Court) in 2016, 41 cases (11 cases chargesheeted and 11 cases pending in Court) in 2017, 40 cases (12 case chargesheeted, 1 case acquittal and 11 cases pending in Court) in 2018 and 12 cases (3 cases chargesheeted, 3 cases pending in Court) upto June, 2019 registered u/s 156(3) – which shows that Police is not sensitive in the cases against the Scheduled Castes.
The Commission desired to know the number of cross FIRs filed in the cases where FIR was registered u/s 156(3) and action taken against the Police officials u/s 4 of PoA Act 1989 (as amended). The officers were also unable to give details of the number of cases where cross FIRs have been filed against SCs in cases registered by the SCs. The Chairman, NCSC explained to the officers that the cross FIRs are often used by opposite parties to intimidate and harass the SCs in cases where SCs file cases of atrocities. The police should take into account this aspect during investigation of such cross FIRs. DGP assured that the data on cross FIRs and the outcome of all the heinous crime cases will be collected and sent to the Commission within 1 month.
59 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.7.12 The cases registered under POA Act and compensation provided to the victims/dependant of deceased during last 3½ years.
It is observed that the less compensation under Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995 (as amended) provided to the victims/dependant of deceased during last 3½ years by the State Govt. Details are as under:-
. An amount of Rs. 329 lakhs was provided in 46 cases of murder and Rs. 469 lakhs in 220 cases of rape whereas Rs. 379.5 lakhs for 46 murder cases and Rs. 1815 lakhs for 220 rape cases were to be paid during the year 2016 as per the prescribed amount.
Recommendation: The remaining amount of Rs. 50.5 lakhs for murder and Rs. 1346 lakhs for rape cases be paid immediately to the victims/dependant of deceased. . An amount of Rs. 382 lakhs was provided in 48 cases of murder and Rs. 686 lakhs in 230 cases of murder whereas Rs. 396 lakhs for 48 murder cases and Rs. 1897 lakhs for 230 rape cases were to be paid during the year 2017 as per the prescribed amount.
Recommendation: The remaining amount of Rs. 14 lakhs for murder and Rs. 1211 lakhs for rape cases be paid immediately to the victims/dependant of deceased. . An amount of Rs. 708 lakhs provided in 315 rape cases whereas Rs. 2598.75 lakhs for 315 rape cases was to be paid during the year 2018 as per the prescribed amount.
Recommendation: The remaining amount of Rs. 1891 lakhs for rape cases be paid immediately to the victims. . An amount of Rs. 78 lakhs was provided in 32 cases of murder and Rs. 175 lakhs in 177 cases of rape whereas Rs. 264 lakhs for 32 murder cases and Rs. 1460.25 lakhs for 37 rape cases were to be paid during the year 2019 (upto June, 2019) as per the prescribed amount.
Recommendation: The remaining amount of Rs. 186 lakhs for murder and Rs. 1285 lakhs for rape cases be paid immediately to the victims/dependant of deceased.
1.7.13 No additional relief being paid
It appears that the State Govt. has not taken any cognizance of the D.O. letter No. 3/2/2007- APCR dated 21.6.2017 of the Chairman, NCSC to the Chief Minister, Maharashtra and a
60 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
subsequent letter dated 05.10.2016 of Secretary, NCSC to Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra to publish Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (as amended) and Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995 (as amended) in their official Gazette and to sensitize the Police Personnel and District Officials about the provision of the Act & Rules, since, the compensation paid to victim is much less than as per the Rules.
1.7.14 The following action points were identified by the Commission:
The State Govt. to provide correct data on total number of crime registered against Scheduled
Castes as there is discrepancy in figures supplied by the State Govt. and NCRB. The senior police officers need to review the cases periodically. The reason for low conviction rate may be analysed by the State Govt. as the rate of conviction is lower than the national average. The performance of the Exclusive Special Public Prosecutor needs to be reviewed by the concerned District Collector of the District. It was revealed during the review meeting that none of the Exclusive Special Court has actually started functioning therefore, the Commission recommends that the State Govt. should expedite the process so that Exclusive Special Court can function properly at the earliest. The Exclusive Public Prosecutor has been appointed in 23 Districts out of 36 Districts of the States. The State Govt. to provide the reasons for not appointing Exclusive Public Prosecutor in remaining 13 districts. The State Govt. to provide the details of SC/ST Protection Cell. The State Govt. to provide the number of training/workshop organised and their duration for training/workshop to sensitise the police officials and to create awareness about SC/ST PoA Act, 1989 (as amended). The State Govt. to provide the information regarding compensation provided to victims of atrocities.
61 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission recommends that two meetings of the State Level Vigilance Monitoring Committee, should also be held in a year which are mandatory as per Rules 16 (2) of the SC/ST (PoA) Rules, 1995. The State Level Meetings should be held timely. The Commission recommends that four meetings of the District Level Vigilance Monitoring Committee, should be held in a year which are mandatory as per Section 17 (3) of the SC/ST (POA) Rules, 1995 (as amended). The District Level Meetings should be held timely. The State Govt. should provide the data on bonded labours. The Commission desired to know the number of cross FIRs filed in the cases where FIR was registered u/s 156(3) and action taken against the Police officials u/s 4 of PoA Act 1989 (as amended). The State Govt. to provide the details of the number of cases where cross FIRs have been filed against SCs in cases registered by the SCs. The State Govt. to provide the details of cases registered under SC/ST PoA Act,1989 and compensation provided to the victims/dependant of deceased during last 3 years. The State Govt. to provide the details of action taken against the erring police officials u/s (4) of SC/ST PoA Act, 1989 (as amended). It appears that the State Govt. has not taken any cognizance of the D.O. letter No. 3/2/2007- APCR dated 21.6.2017 of the Chairman, NCSC to the Chief Minister, Maharashtra and a subsequent letter dated 05.10.2016 of Secretary, NCSC to Chief Secretary, Govt. of Maharashtra to publish Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (as amended) and Scheduled Castes & Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Rules, 1995 (as amended) in their official Gazette and to sensitize the Police Personnel and District Officials about the provision of the Act & Rules, since, the compensation paid to victim is much less than as per the Rules. The State Govt. to provide action taken and present status in the matter. The Commission recommends that complete and timely payment be made to the victims of atrocities. All level Police Officers be sensitized and trained. The SC and ST (POA) Act, 1989 (as amended) and SC and ST (POA) Rules, 1995 (as amended) be published in a Hand Book and uploaded on website by the State Govt.
62 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The State Govt. to display the provisions of SC and ST (POA) Act, 1989 (as amended) and SC and ST (POA) Rules, 1995 (as amended) at prominent places like Police Stations and Collector’s Office without losing further time. The State Govt. to provide additional assistance like pension, job, agriculture land, house, patta to the victim/family of the deceased victim as per the Sr. No. 46 of SC and ST (POA) Rules, 1995 (as amended).
1.7.15 Summing up by the Chairman NCSC:
Chairman NCSC stated that the POA Act, 1989 (as amended) and Rules (as amended in 2016) need to be implemented in letter and spirit. There should not be delay in the completion of the investigations and in filing of charge sheets. The 60 day time limit as per the PoA Act should be adhered to. The senior officers of Police should work towards reducing the large number of cases lodged u/s 156(3). Action under Section (4) of PoA Act may be initiated against the Police Officials where the FIR was registered after the intervention of the Hon’ble Court. Cross FIRs against SCs should be reexamined to ensure that they are genuine and not lodged for the simple purpose of pressurizing the SC complainants. All FIRs should be lodged and no persons should have to resort to approaching courts for lodging of FIRs. The DMs and SSPs should visit the spot where atrocities against Scheduled Castes occur. This is mandated as per Rule 12 of the Prevention of Atrocities Rules. He urged that the Police should send details of the stage wise progress on the cases of atrocities to the DM in time, so that the monetary compensation as per the Prevention of Atrocities Rules, 2016 can be paid in time to the victims / families. He further urged Director General of Police, Maharashtra and Principal Secretary, Social Justice to review the action taken under the POA Act and Rules regularly, and asked them to ensure that the commitments made to the Commission during the Review Meeting may be compiled with and reported to the Commission within the committed time frame.
1.8 Review of Madhya Pradesh-05.09.2019
63 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.8.1 Minutes of the State Level Review Meeting of Madhya Pradesh by National Commission for Scheduled Castes with Chief Secretary and other senior officers of Government of Madhya Pradesh.
The National Commission for Scheduled Castes team headed by Prof. (Dr.) Ram Shankar Katheria, Hon’ble Chairman; Dr. L. Murugan, Hon’ble Vice-Chairman; Shri K. Ramulu, Dr. Yogendra Paswan and Dr. (Ms.) Swaraj Vidwan, Hon’ble Members; Shri Pritam Singh, IAS, Secretary, NCSC and other officers from Delhi and Hyderabad visited Bhopal and held State Level Review of Madhya Pradesh State.
The Hon’ble Minister for Scheduled Caste Welfare, Chief Secretary and other senior officers of the level of Additional Chief Secretaries, Special Chief Secretaries and Principal Secretaries, Secretaries, Commissioners, Directors, etc. of Government of Madhya Pradesh participated in the review meeting conducted by the National Commission for Scheduled Castes.
The Commission also met with the Hon’ble Chief Minister of Madhya Pradesh and discussed the policy matters which are being implemented in the state as well as in the Central Government.
The Chief Secretary, while welcoming the Commission stated that the Madhya Pradesh Government is set for fast development in various sectors and looked forward for Commission’s pro active observations and advises to strengthen their activities for upliftment of the socio-economic conditions of the Scheduled Castes.
The Hon’ble Chairman in his opening remarks briefed about the mandate of the Commission. He stated that, the benefits will reach the target people if there is a good coordination between the policy makers and the implementing agencies. In this context, he mentioned that nearly 5,000 crores were unspent by 10 departments in Uttar Pradesh and the developmental activities have been drastically hampered due to this. He also pointed out that 40% of total budget allocation for SCs in Maharashtra was not spend and these unspent amount can be used for laying roads, providing drinking facilities, establishment of schools, etc. It is all done due to lack of proper planning and coordination. He emphasized that proper planning,
64 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
monitoring, execution and evaluation of the Schemes are very essential at every stage of performing the activities.
The Principal Secretary (SC Welfare Department) gave a presentation highlighting the status of schemes of the Madhya Pradesh Government.
Observations & Recommendations:
1.8.2 Literacy:
The Hon’ble Chairman noted that, the female literacy rate is very low and enquired about the measures taken for increasing the literacy rate. In response to this, the Principal Secretary (SCW) stated that the Madhya Pradesh Government is the first state in the country which is implementing compulsory education long back before implementation of Right to Education Act. He stated that the special schools are being opened up in the localities, where the number of SC/ST students are 25, whereasit is 40 in the case of general category. Accordingly, more than one lakh schools are being functioning in the state.
The Hon’ble Chairman, NCSC emphasized that providing education is the most vital element for upliftment the socio-economic conditions of the downtrodden society of the people.
Hon’ble Member, Shri K. Ramulu advised that theintroduction of English Medium Schools are very essential in villages from First Class itself. He gave the successful story of Gurukul Education in Telangana State. The Hon’ble Chairman also stated that there are nearly 50 English Medium Schools in each district of Uttar Pradesh.
In response to these queries, the PS (SCW) stated that the Madhya Pradesh Government has started Gyanodhya Residential Schools, which are giving good results and these are functioning at regional level and they wanted to start at district level also.
Hon’ble Member, Shri K. Ramulu advised for establishment of study circles for preparing competitive examinations.
The Secretary, NCSC stated that the enrollment of admissions are being decreased from primary to middle and also from middle to high school and the same is also noticed in the
65 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
case of Graduate and Post Graduate enrollment and asked the reasons for it.He further requested to analyze reasons for poor admissions. He suggested that the secondary schools might be located far away from the households. He also advised them to verify Child Birth Register records of last 6-7 years.
In response to these remarks, PS (SCW) stated that they wanted to conduct special drive for increasing the enrollment. He also mentioned that low birth rate is also one of the reasons for poor admissions.
The Government of Madhya Pradesh expressed the difficulty pertaining to Post Matric Scholarships. The Government of India is involving in sharing the burden of Post Matric Scholarships, if the expenditure exceeds the committed liability. The Secretary, NCSC informed the august house that the Commission has recommended 100% sponsorship of committed liability by the Government of India and advised the Government to address a letter to the Commission for pursuing the same with the Government of India.
The Secretary, NCSC also recommended the Government for providing good infrastructural facilities in schools and colleges. The Secretary, Higher Education stated that Government is planning to close small colleges by starting big colleges so as to avoid transportation problem also.
The Secretary, NCSC asked for details about the SCs BPL families and number of exclusions of SC families from BPL families. The PS (SCW) told that no one was left out of BPL and as per the latest guidelines the numbers are small.
1.8.3 PMAY:
The Hon’ble Chairman expressed displeasure that the percentage of houses allotted to SC population are declining from 2016-17 onwards. He recommended that the number of beneficiaries is to be increased.
The Secretary (Housing) informed that the percentage of allocation of houses to SC population is at par with their percentage of population i.e. 15.6%
66 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Hon’ble Chairman mentionedthat the percentage of SC population below the poverty line (BPL) is 22.5% and accordingly allocation of houses are also to be done. The Chief Secretary stated that he will look into the matter and will take care of the recommendation of the Commission.
The Hon’ble Chairman stated that, the Hon’ble Prime Minister wanted that everybody should have their own house and accordingly the Government has to take steps to achieve the objective.
1.8.4 Health:
The Government of Madhya Pradesh has not provided the beneficiary list of SCs under NRHM, Ayushman Bharat. The Hon’ble Chairman asked to furnish the percentage of SC beneficiaries to the Commission. The Chief Secretary noted the remarks of the Hon’ble Chairman and he replied that he will submit the information. He also informed that nearly 1.15 crore people have been provided with gold cards and all groups of BPLare being covered under this programme.
The Hon’ble Member (KR) advised that the infrastructural facilities of Government hospitals are also to be on par with private hospitals and accordingly the M.P. Government has to take measures, to improve the facilities.
1.8.5 MUDRA& Stand Up India Loans:
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman pointed out that there is huge difference between the applications received and accepted by Bank in all the three years and it is more significant in the year 2016-17. He also enquired about the number of bank branches in the State and list of beneficiaries of availing loans of one crore or more than one crore under Stand Up India loans. He also enquired about the pending cases to be provided with loan even after subsidy was granted by the Government of India. He also recommended that at least one beneficiary with one or more than one crore loan from SC should be covered by each branch of the Bank. He asked to furnish the beneficiaries list. The Convener, SLBC informed that there are 4 parallel schemes are operating in the state.
67 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Secretary, NCSC asked to furnish the list of beneficiaries in all the schemes. The Secretary, NCSC also asked to furnish the minutes of the SLBC meetings along with action taken report for the last 3 meetings.
1.8.6 Hand Pumps:
The Commission observed that the installation of handpumps are very less. On this point the Secretary (Housing) informed that most of the villages are covered with Ground Water Supply Schemes or Individual Water Supply Schemes.
1.8.7 Hostels:
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman enquiredabout the hostels, which are well equipped with CCTV, RO Water, Dining tables, library facilities, computer and internet facilities and video conferencing facilities and also whether they are implementing biometric attendance or not. The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman also enquired about the number of times that eggsare provided to the hostel mates.
In response to these queries, the Chief Secretary informed that the biometric attendance will be introduced in all the hostels and the installation of CCTV in Boys Hostels will also be undertaken. He also informed that with good protein food like soya beans is a part of diet.
The Commission asked the State Government to furnish the action taken report on introduction of biometric attendance, CCTV in Boys Hostels also to the Commission.
1.8.8 Land Scheme:
The Government stated that Bhuadhikar Patra (Ownership paper) is being given to the house owners. The Commission also wanted detailed information on it.
1.8.9 MNREGA:
The Hon’ble Chairman also advised that the authorities should ensure that the job cards are in possession of the beneficiaries and not held with Panchayat officials.
68 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman enquired about the percentage of SC families, which were provided with 100 days work.
The Chief Secretary replied that they are providing 100 days work or more than it to the extent of nearly 13.31 lakh families and it is around 17% of the total work force.
The Secretary, NCSC asked about the average man working hours as well as the number of minimum working days and maximum working days provided to the beneficiaries.
The Chief Secretary informed that the minimum and maximum working days are nearly 100 and 150 days respectively. He also said that the payment of wages is done within 15 days of the execution of the work. The payment is also done based on Aadhaar.
The Chief Secretary informed that the Government is taking more plantation work with less machinery work under this scheme.
In reply to Secretary, NCSC, they informed that the overall average wage rate per day is Rs. 255.86, whereas the prescribed rate is Rs. 174.
1.8.10 SCSP:
The Hon’ble Chairman pointed out that the allocation amount to the SCs is 14.21% of total allocationin 2016-17, but the expenditure incurred is only 11.28% and around Rs. 3,000 crore were not spent and the same trend is observed in 2017-18. He instructed the Government to see that the expenditure has to be incurred as per the allocation and also find out the reasons for not incurring the amount.
The Chief Secretary stated that, there is a special Tribal Welfare Department for Scheduled Tribes, whose population is only 8% of the total population, but no special department for SCs even though their percentage of population is 16% of the total population. He also informed that the Government is planning to have separate department for Scheduled Castes, which may be coming as an agenda in the upcoming cabinet meeting.
The Commission also observed that there is a huge gap between allocation and expenditure of the Central Sector Schemes and the expenditure is only 50% of the total allocation in 2018-19.
69 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Chief Secretary informed that Madhya Pradesh Tribal Area Development Project gives money to STs and SCs and now the Government is considering a proposal to separate both within 15 days.
The Vice-Chairman asked the reasons for less expenditure when compared to allocation in SC Specific Schemes also. In response to this, the Chief Secretary informed that the amount is not spent due to vacancies in the teaching posts and will submit the report to the Commission.
1.8.11 Manual Scavenging:
The Hon’ble Chairman asked about manual scavenging. The Chief Secretary replied that there is a ban on manual scavenging in Madhya Pradesh from the last 15 years and they are provided with other alternate employment like Taxi, Auto, etc. by providing loans to them.
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman enquired about the number of contract/outsourcing labourers of SC Community, who are working as Sweepers. The Addl. Commissionerdid not have complete information and said that he will furnish the information to the Commission. The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman instructed to call Urban Development Secretary, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh to NCSC, New Delhi, with data on manual scavenging.
1.8.12 Service Safeguards:
The Commission observed that there are nearly 2464 backlog vacancies in the Government and asked the reasons for not filling up of the vacancies. The Addl. Chief Secretary answered that there is a stay in the Hon’ble Supreme Court and it is posted for hearing on 15.10.2019 and the Government will put all efforts to lift the stay. The special recruitment drive for filling up the backlog vacancies will be done by June 2020.
The Commission also observed that the percentage of SCs representation in Group ‘A’ cadre is very low and instructed the Government to take up special drive for filling up these posts.
The Principal Secretary (SCW) informed that they will fill up all the backlog vacancies in Group ‘A’ and Group ‘B’ cadre.
70 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman asked about the action on false caste certificate cases and also pointed out that the number of cases are also more (138). The Chief Secretary replied that the Tribal Research Institute (TRI) is conducting field level enquiry and he told that he will expedite the action and will submit the report within 3 months.
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman enquired about the implementation of reservation in the Industrial Department and the Government replied that they were implementing reservation and now they are going to adopt new policy. The Commission asked them to furnish new policy.
Hon’ble Vice-Chairman asked the Government that any innovative measures are being adopted by the State Government to uplift the socio-economic conditions of the SCs. The Principal Secretary (SCW) informed that the Government has established Gyanodhya Residential Schools, where the admission starts from 3rd class onwards.
The Hon’ble Member (KR) advised that the compassionate appointments are also to be undertaken while filling up of the backlog vacancies.
Points identified for action
1.8.13 Education:
The Commission observed that the literacy rate among female SC is far below the national average. The enrollment of students admission are declining in primary, middle, secondary, under graduate and post graduate courses. The Commission advised the Government to take measures for improving the situation.
The State Government stated that they wanted to introduce special drive measures for enhancing the enrollment of students, details to be informed to the Commission.
The Commission recommended for establishment of English Medium Schools in villages.
The Government stated that Gnanodaya Residential Schools are being functioning at regional level and now they wanted to start at district level. The action taken on this will be submitted to the Commission.
71 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.8.14 Scholarships:
The Government wanted that the Post Matric Scholarships (PMS) should be sponsored by Government of India.
The Commission informed that it recommended 100% sponsorship by the Government of India and also instructed the Government to address a letter to the Commission for taking further necessary action.
1.8.15 PMAY:
The allotment of houses to SC population was low and measures to improve the same to at least 22% of total allocation are to be communicated to the Commission.
The Government said that it will look into the matter and the allotment of the houses will be taken in future, as per the recommendations of the Commission.
1.8.16 Health:
The percentage of SC beneficiaries under NRHM and Ayushman Bharat to be furnished to the Commission.
1.8.17 MUDRA Loans& Stand Up India Scheme:
To furnish to the Commission list of beneficiaries, who availed one and more than one crore loan from each branch of the banks, and the minutes of the last 3 SLBC meetings.
1.8.18 Hostels:
Action taken to introduce biometric devices in all the hostels along with CCTVs in all the boys and girls hostels.
1.8.19 Land Schemes:
72 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission wanted detailed information on it and the Government said that the information will be provided to the Commission.
1.8.20 SCSP:
The Commission felt that the allocation amount is very low and the expenditure incurred out of the total allocated amount is also very low and asked the reasons for it.
The Government informed that they wanted to create separate department for Scheduled Castes and it will be coming as an agenda in upcoming cabinet meeting for monitoring, execution and implementation of the Sub Plan.
1.8.21 Manual Scavenging:
The Commission wanted the number of contractlabourers, who are working as Sweepers. The Government is lacking information on it and informed that they will furnish the information on it.
The Urban Development Secretary, Govt. of Madhya Pradesh will come to NCSC, New Delhi, with data on manual scavenging and action taken on cases of deaths due to manual cleaning of sewers.
1.8.22 False Caste Certificate Cases:
The Commission felt that the number of false caste certificate cases are more and enquired about the action that was taken on this issue.
The Government told that it will expedite the action and will submit the report within 3 months.
1.8.23 Industrial Department:
The Commission enquired about the implementation of rule of reservation in the Industrial Department.
73 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Government replied that they are going to launch new policy and the same will be furnished to the Commission.
1.8.24 Service Safeguards:
The Commission observed that the number of backlogs are more, the percentage of SC employees in Group ‘A’ and ‘B’ are low.
The Government stated that there is a stay in the Hon’ble Court and they are working to get the stay vacated and after that they would take up promotions in Group ‘A’ and ‘B’ cadre.
The Government also stated that they will fill up all backlog vacancies by June 2020.
1.9 Review of Madhya Pradesh – 05.09.2019 ( prevention of atrocities)
State Level Review Meeting of Madhya Pradesh with Principal Secretary (Home), DGP, Addl. DGP (AJK) and other senior Police Officers of Government of Madhya Pradesh held on 05.09.2019.
1.9.1 The Principal Secretary (Home), DGP, Addl. DGP (AJK) and other senior Police Officers of Government of Madhya Pradesh participated.
The DGP welcomed the Commission and started with a short film regarding awareness about POA Act.
The Hon’ble Chairman in his opening remarks said that the Commission was in Madhya Pradesh as a part of its Constitutional mandate to monitor the implementation of safeguards and rights of the Scheduled Castes in the State. The review is an exercise undertaken to point out the areas of concern of NCSC and to sensitize the Government and State Police towards the same.
74 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Principal Secretary (Home) informed that 50 districts are having exclusive Anusuchit Jati Kalyan (AJK) Police Stations out of 52 districts. There are 7 Special Courts and 43 designated Courts functioning in the State for trialing the SC cases.
1.9.2 Observations & Recommendations:
The Hon’ble Chairman noticed that the rate of conviction is very low and asked the department to take measures for increasing the rate of conviction. He also asked the department that the time taken for filing the charge sheet in the Hon’ble Court. The department answered that the charge sheet is usually filed within 60-75 days. The Hon’ble Chairman also asked that about the number of cases charge sheeted out of 85 murder cases in 2016. The department answered that 81 cases were charge sheeted.
The DGP informed the house that the number of cases registered under 156(3) are very low and they are registering all the cases, as per their genuinity instead of getting orders from the Court for registering the case. The police department also informed that, the SHO will be fined to the extent of Rs. 25,000/- if he cannot register the case. The Hon’ble Chairman, NCSC, desired the information about the number of cases charge sheeted, arrests made in 93 murder cases during the year 2017. The DGP informed that the information will be submitted to the Commission.
The Hon’ble Chairman also asked the reasons for increasing the number of rape and murder cases from 2015-16 to 2018-19. The Addl. DGP replied that it is due to enactment of POA Amendment Act. Due to this, the victims of the rape are registering their cases in the concerned Police Stations for getting relief. The Hon’ble Chairman asked to submit the details of named FIR in case of murder & rape.
The Hon’ble Chairman asked the police department to furnish the details of action taken u/s. 4 of POA Act.
The Secretary, NCSC asked as the reasons for long pending cases. The Addl. DGP informed that 13 cases of 2016 are pending.
75 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Hon’ble Member (KR) enquired about the number of cases pending in the Hon’ble High Court and arrests made. They replied that 934 cases are pending and out of which 519 cases are pending for arrests.
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman asked about detailed bifurcation of pending cases. The Addl. DGP replied that they will submit the report very soon.
The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman instructed the police department to issue a circular to the concerned authorities for issuing caste certificates and also fix the time bound for issuing caste certificate. The PS (Home) stated that he will issue circular within one or two days.
The Secretary, NCSC asked information about the number of State Level and District Level Vigilance and Monitoring Committee meetings were held and also asked to furnish the minutes of the last three meetings. The Secretary, NCSC also asked about the report of the Parliamentary Committee meeting. The PS (Home) replied that the information will be submitted to the Commission. The Hon’ble Vice-Chairman informed that the State and District Level Vigilance and Monitoring Committee meetings are to be held once in every three months.
The Addl. DGP informed that they started Victim Protection Scheme to enhance the conviction rate.
The Hon’ble Chairman asked to furnish the detailed list of convicted cases. The Addl. DGP told that they will submit the report later.
The Hon’ble Member (KR) asked about the number of murder cases relating to land issues. The Addl. DGP told that they will furnish the information.
The Addl. DGP informed that Gwalior, Sagar and Chhattarpur Divisions are more atrocity prone areas and the crime rate in these divisions are also more. The Hon’ble Chairman asked the reasons for high crime rate in these divisions and also desired a report. The PS (Home) informed that a report will be submitted along with measures to be taken for reducing the crime rate in these divisions.
Hon’ble Member Dr. Yogendra Paswan informed to Police authorities that the financial compensation can be given to the victims of rape cases without waiting the medical report.
76 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.9.3 Points identified for action and submitting of details by Govt. of Madhya Pradesh:
Measures for increasing the rate of conviction and detailed list of cases where there was conviction.
The time taken for filing the charge sheet in the Hon’ble Court.
The number of cases charge sheeted out of 85 murder cases in 2016.
The information about the number of cases charge sheeted, arrests made in 93 murder cases during the year 2017.
The reasons for increasing the number of rape and murder cases from 2015-16 to 2018-19.
To submit the details of named FIR in case of murder & rape.
To furnish the details of action taken u/s. 4 of POA Act.
The reasons for long pending cases with bifurcation of types of atrocities.
The number of cases pending in the Hon’ble High Court and arrests made.
Issue of a circular to the concerned authorities for issuing caste certificates and also fix the time bound for issuing caste certificate.
Information about the number of State Level and District Level Vigilance and Monitoring Committee meetings were held and furnishing the minutes of the last three meetings.
The report of the Parliamentary Committee meeting.
The number of murder cases relating to land issues.
The reasons for high crime rate in Gwalior, Sagar and Chhattarpur divisions and report on action taken to reduce the same.
1.10 Meeting to monitor disbursement of loans under Mudra and Stand-up India schemes by 22 Public Sector Banks
77 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Minutes of the Monitoring meeting on 19.11.2018 regarding disbursement of loans under Mudra Scheme, Stand-up India scheme and Educational Loans to the SC persons by Nationalized Banks.
1.10.1 The Commission held a Monitoring Meeting on 19.11.2018 regarding disbursement of
loans under Mudra Scheme, Stand-up India scheme and Educational Loans to the
Scheduled Castes persons by Nationalized Banks.
1.10.2 The meeting was organised to monitor progress of loans to scheduled castes persons under
the newly launched schemes like Stand-up India and Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojna as these
schemes had special emphasis on development of Scheduled Castes entrepreneurs and
other underprivileged groups. Discussion was also centred on the issues related to
educational loans which effects up-liftment of socio-economic status of Scheduled Castes.
1.10.3 Objectives
The objectives of the meeting was to bring all the Nationalized Banks at one platform to
know and monitor progress and mythodology adopted to encourage, locate and give loans
to SC entrepreneurs under Mudra, Stand-up India scheme and progress of granting
Education loan to scheduled caste students. The basic purpose of these schemes is to attain
development in an inclusive and sustainable manner by supporting and promoting SC
entrepreneurs in achieving economic success and financial security.
1.10.4 At the outset, Secretary, NCSC welcoming the guests, emphasised the inclusive nature of
the schemes of (1) Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojna (Mudra) and its 3 sub categories (i)
Shishu, (ii) Kishore and (iii) Tarun; (2) Stand-up India scheme (3) Education Loan and the
fact that Scheduled castes must be given their due representation in all these schemes.
78 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.10.5 Inaugurating the discussion, Chairman, NCSC gave a brief about role and functions of the
Commission and the relevance of monitoring of these schemes to the welfare of Scheduled
Caste. Unless banks implement these schemes in proper spirit, inclusive growth for the
poor including SCs, STs, OBCs etc. is not possible. He added that the analysis of the data
that are made available to the Commission by various banks was not very encouraging
picture with respect to the Scheduled Caste. The issues the Banks need to tackle are how
to reach out to and motivate potential SC entrepreneurs directly and reduce all middle men.
Interaction and feedback from elected representatives is also necessary as well as
involvement of State Government Department. In the reviews of State Governments by
NCSC, all the State Governments stated that they are not aware of the progress of these
schemes as they are not involved. This needs to be addressed and lead banks in Districts
must involve the District Authorities and public representatives in their outreach
programme.
1.10.6 NCSC then gave a brief presentation highlighting status of three loan schemes namely, (i)
Stand-up India, (ii) Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojna and (iii) Disbursement of Educational
Loans.
1.10.7 The issue that emerged out of the Commission analysis of data presented by Banks,
Department of Financial Services (MOF) showed that:
1.10.7.1 In Mudra Scheme:
SC loans where approx 6.3 % of the total Rs. 14.56 Crore loans sanctioned and accounted for about
2.9% of the total amount sanctioned. The Scheduled Caste population is greater than 16% of the total population of the country hence the figures were well below the expected percentage of loans to SCs.
79 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The highest percentage of loans given to SCs were in the lowest category of Mudra i.e Shishu
and only in 02 Banks IDBI(20.62%) and Allahabad Bank (15%) the percentage and amount
of loan given in this category was at par/above the expected percentage.
In all other Banks the percentage of loans given to SCs was lower than the norms of the SC
population percentage.
In the higher loan amount category of Mudra i.e Tarun and Kishore, the percentage of SC
loanees ranged from 0.75% SBI (Tarun ) to 3.57% United Bank (Tarun) and 1.2% Punjab &
Sindh Bank (Kishore) to 9% Andhra Bank (Kishore).
SC category loan size is maximum in Shishu (average loan of Rs. 30,000/-). In SBI, Central
Bank of India, however the loan size of Shishu to SCs is to were and between Rs. 10,000/-
to 15,000/-.
In Kishore category, the average SC loan size is between Rs. 50,000/- to Rs. 60,000/- i.e
towards the lower limit by all Banks.
In Kishore category, the average SC loan size is half that of overall loan size in Canara Bank,
SBI and Corporation Bank.
In Tarun category except of Corporation Bank, in all other Banks the loans size of SCs were
much below the overall loan size. Within SCs, the percentage of SC women availing of
Mudra Loans is significant with more than 50% share in Shishu category in loans by
Syndicate Bank, Bank of Maharashtra, Canara Bank, IDBI Bank.
In Tarun category SC women had 65% of the total SC share in Bank of Maharashtra and
48% in Canara Bank Mudra loans.
1.10.7.2 Stand up India Scheme:
80 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Scheme envisages loan to at least 01 SC/Woman entrepreneur per Bank Branch. There are more than 1.2 lakh Bank Branches in India. Of the 61482 loan sanctioned upto October, 2018, loans to
Scheduled Caste are 9174 with SC women forming 27% of these i.e 2555.
Hence loans to SCs are only 13.9% of total loans, whereas 01 SC entrepreneur/Branch was
the target.
The range of loan to SCs, Bank wise is 1 SC per 50 Branches by SBI, Union Bank, 01 SC
per 15-22 branches in Bank of Baroda, Bank of India, IDBI, Syndicate Bank, Allahabad
Bank, UCO Bank etc to 1 SC per 05 Branches in Andhra Bank.
1.10.7.3 Education Loan:-
About 2.2% of the 5.4 lakh education loans have been given to SCs. Amount wise about
1.9% of the total Rs. 40423/- crores given as Education loan has been given to SCs.
Average loan size of SC is around Rs. 3.6 lakhs which is approximately half of overall
average loan size.
Loans to SC girls account get approximately 50% of the total loans sanctioned to SCs.
1.10.8 The Banks in their presentations agreed with the above findings of the Commission, they
are also gave assurance to improve their outreach and RCT programmes with special focus
towards SC loanees. Some of the steps taken by Bank/Unique methodologies adopted by
them and success stories shared during the meeting are:
1.10.8.1 Andhra Bank
Tie up with river community for improving the fishing business and also on Solar rooftop
scheme and fibre net yojana of Government for better coverage.
1.10.8.2 Bank of Baroda
81 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Tie up with Baroda Tankers and gave 05 SC entrepreneurs loans, signed MoU with DICCI
and FICCI.
1.10.8.3 Bank of Maharashtra
Tie up with Mahila Mandals of 10 Districts for Training Women entrepreneurs and loaning
to trainees. Tie up with NGOs to identify potential loanees.
Awarding top 03 performing Branches.
1.10.8.4 United Bank
. Tie up with Tripura Government for their schemes.
1.10.8.5 UCO Bank
Organising credit camps with e-Rickshaw, beauty parlour and other potential loanees, giving
wide publicity.
1.10.8.6 Union Bank
Tied up with LCV manufacturers.
1.10.8.7 Punjab and Sind Bank
They have 03 RCTs which have programmes focusing on SC beneficiaries to increase
absorption capacity.
1.10.8.8 Indian Bank
Linked with oil companies for loans to entrepreneurs wanting tankers/Trailors.
Tieing up with construction companies/contractors which need JCBs, tippers etc.
1.10.8.9 Canara Bank
Focused on Trippur industrial area where they found a number of loanees.
82 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
1.10.8.10 State Bank of India
Planning to tie up with professional colleges, e-rickshaw scheme, OYO hotels for better
outreach.
1.10.9 Additional Secretary, Department Of Financial Services (MoF) emphasised on the need for
involving State Govt. departments and public representatives, need for banks to associate
themselves with various skill and entrepreneur development programmes of State and
Central Government and the need for government banks to focus on training and awareness
camp for budding entrepreneurs.
Vice Chairman, NCSC thanked all participants for their valued participation and sharing
their experience in the schemes. He pointed out that the banks should examine reasons why
the loans are not being disbursed even after sanctions and release of subsidy. There is a
need to gear up the implementation of the schemes.
1.10.9.1 Conclusions & Recommendations:
More credit camps may be organised particularly at rural areas through outreach programmes
to make new entrepreneurs aware about opportunities in business.
Associate with public representatives on a regular basis for their training and awareness
campaigns.
The Banks and financial institutions may consider locating and associating with SHGs to
encourage SC and women participation in income generation schemes.
Tie up with State Govt. Departments which have launched schemes like solar rooftop
installation, fibre optic installation etc.
83 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Opening of more training centres at regional levels and focussing on camp and campaigns
mode to make rural entrepreneurs aware about availability of loans and hand hold them
through loan process.
Banks need to organize a system to provide handholding support to unemployed youth in
preparation of the project. All banks in a district can consider to pool their efforts.
The Government of India has a central sector scheme- SAMPADA (Scheme for Agro-
Marine Processing and Development of Agro-Processing Clusters). The Banks can finance
under this scheme to increase investment credit.
NABARD has prepared area specific model bankable projects. Bankers can take training to
evaluate and appraise different types of projects at Bankers Institute of Rural Development
(BIRD), Lucknow.
The Banks may tie up with gramin women Self Help Groups (like Bank Of Maharashtra),
with Oil companies (like Indian Bank), OYO ( like SBI), NGOs ( Bank of Maharashtra )
professional / Management colleges, Schemes of e-rickshaw, Solar roof top, fiber net yojna
of Govt. ( like Andhra Bank )etc. under MUDRA scheme to fulfill the obligation of the
Government of the schemes, encourage entrepreneurs as well as to grow/boost their business.
Tie up with it is, DICCI, NSCFDC, etc and training schools, who teach make up, hair styling
etc. for locating entrepreneurs.
In view of the critical role played by Lead District Managers, it may be ensured that officials
posted as LDMs possess requisite leadership skills. They should be competent and go the
extra mile to discharge his/her duties effectively.
Bank Branch Managers should have live contact with the residents of their area. They may
identify good prospective borrowers themselves for financing under government sponsored
84 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
schemes. This will lead to qualitative financing by banks and can make change the districts.
Banks need to evolve a training schedule to create a favourable ecosystem.
Rejection of applications on small grounds may be re-looked and efforts be made to arrest
rejection rate in future. Automation may be brought into to analyse business applications to
reduce possible errors in rejections.
1.10.10 For Education Loans :
The banks can evolve a short term loans ( at lower interest rates) as a bridge loans to SC
students studying in Private Colleges/ Universities to tide over the gap between payment of
fees to colleges and the fee reimbursement of the same by the State Governments.
1.11 Review of PSUs / departments :
During the review of PSUs and Departments the main points of concern noted by the Commission are as follows : 1.11.1 Representation of SCs in Group A : Representation of Scheduled Castes in the higher management levels of Group A across all PSUs and was well below the norm. The PSUs were advised to take steps to ensure that SCs find adequate representation in the higher management levels. 1.11.2 Representation of SCs in contractual / outsourced personnel : The representation of SCs in the persons working on contract basis / outsourced / daily wage basis was not known to the management in most PSUs / Departments. The Commission drew the attention of the CMDs of all PSUs / GMs of the Railways to the fact that the MHA and DoPT orders1 regarding contractual personnel reservation rules need to be followed . In case
1 MHA OM No. 27/4/67(II)-Estt.(SCT) dated 24.09.1968 and DoPT OM No. 36036/3/2018-Estt. (Res.) dated 15.05.2018.
85 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
of the outsourced personnel , the spirit of the DoPT orders should be kept in mind and the agreements with the outsourced personnel contractors should incorporate a clause regarding the same. The CMDs of all PSUs / GMs of the Railways have agreed to take necessary steps for the same and keep a database of SCs engaged as contractual / outsourced personnel. 1.11.3 Procurement from SCs as per MSME guidelines : The Commission observed that the percentage of procurement from SC suppliers / contractors in all PSUs / Departments reviewed was in the range of 0.02 to 0.2 % , or the data was not available with the management. The procurement percentage was negligible when compared to the norms set by the MSME circular of at least 4-5 %.Details of SC vendor development programmes showed lack of serious and concentrated effort made by the PSUs in this aspect. The Commission appreciated the initiative of HPCL in their vendor development efforts, lowering of the first order limits and the hand holding by HPCL to improve the percentage of SC vendors in their organization. The Commission recommended that all PSUs should adopt ( with variations ) the methodology of HPCL so as to improve the percentage of SC vendors in their respective PSUs. The PSUs may also immediately start by ensuring maximum SC vendors / suppliers in the non- technical works like housekeeping , maintenance , horticulture , office supply etc and develop vendors for technical work / equipment supply . The CMDs of all PSUs / GMs of the Railways have agreed to take necessary steps for the same. 1.11.4 False caste certificates: The Commission noted that all PSUs / Department have cases of employees who have been accused of submitting false caste certificates. The enquiries of such cases are pending for long in most cases. The Managements in all organisations stated that reports from the concerned District Magistrates were pending in most cases despite reminders. The Commission recommended that all such cases need to be followed up expeditiously and in case the DMs do not respond within 2 months the PSU should consolidate such matters of each state and take up the matter with the concerned Chief Secretary of the State. Long pending matters where reports have not been received from DMs can also be listed and the Commission informed so that the Commission may take up the issue with the state Governments concerned. 1.11.5 Employee grievances :
86 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Commission noted that there are a number of SC employee complaints of discrimination pertaining to each PSU , pending in NCSC. Lists of pending cases were handed over to the Management and the CMDs of all PSUs / GMs of the Railways have agreed to take necessary steps for resolving the same within next 2-3 months and reporting the action taken to the NCSC. They also agreed to ensure that regular meetings with SC staff associations are held as per rules. 1.11.6 CSR : Commission noted that most PSUs are doing excellent CSR work . The Commission recommended that the PSUs take up an outcome tracking of all skill development / education related CSR works so that the outcome of such CSR activities in providing gainful employment / improving standard of living etc can be kept in sight and minor modifications, if any needed, can be made in the CSR programmes to render them more effective. The CMDs of all PSUs / GMs of the Railways have agreed to take necessary steps for the same.
2. Activities of the Commission
2.1 Activities as per Mandate
The Commission has a wide charter in terms of functioning relating to the overall policy, planning, coordination, evaluation and review of the regulatory framework and developmental programs relating to the Scheduled Caste community. NCSC draws its strength from the Article 338 of Indian Constitution which is the backbone of its functioning.
In order to fulfil the above obligations and mandate, the Commission conducts review meetings, hearings, spot visits, studies etc. A gist of the activities performed during the year 2018-19 is as below.
2.2 Complaint Investigation and resolution in NCSC
87 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Rules of Procedure of the Commission do not prescribe any time limit for investigation and enquiry of grievances / cases/ individual complaints received in the Commission. Also, as per mandate of the Commission, though the Commission has all the power of Civil Courts trying a suit, the disposal of the cases depends on both the nature and gravity of the complaints as well as on the response from the Public Authorities who are entrusted with ensuring that the rights as guaranteed in the Constitution of India regarding Scheduled Castes are safeguarded. Hence the speed and adequacy of response from the Authorities concerned are the defining factors which determine the actual disposal of the grievances / cases/ individual complaints. The grievances / cases received in the Commission (both at headquarters and in its State Offices) are classified into three main categories viz: Those related to service matters are handled by Service Safeguards Wing, Those related to economic and social development matters are handled by the Economic and Social Development Wing (ESDW), The cases related to atrocities, are handled by Atrocities and Protection of Civil Rights Wing (APCR).
The details of grievances / cases handled by the Commission Headquarters and its State Offices are as under:
2.2.1 Grievances / cases handled at the Commission 2.2.1(a): 2018-19 Table 2.1(a)
Nature of Opening Received Total case Total cases Closing cases Balance during received Disposed balance as as on April, 2018 (col.2&3) on 1.4.2018 to 01.04.2019 March.2019 1 2 3 4 5 6 1.Agartala State Office : Jurisdiction - Tripura SSW 04 07 11 0 11 APCR 07 02 09 0 09 ESDW 07 03 10 0 10 Miscellaneous 179 04 183 0 183 Total: 197 16 213 0 213
88 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
2.Ahmedabad State Office : Jurisdiction-Gujarat, Rajasthan, Daman and Diu, Dadra & Nagar Haveli SSW 240 92 332 12 320 APCR 528 373 901 12 889 ESDW 303 178 481 08 473 Miscellaneous 55 15 70 01 69 Total: 1126 658 1784 33 1751 3.Bangalore State Office: Jurisdiction -Karnataka SSW 159 73 232 10 222 APCR 166 38 204 18 186 ESDW 199 45 244 12 232 Miscellaneous 77 06 83 03 80 Total: 601 162 763 43 720 4.Chennai State Office: Jurisdiction-Tamil Nadu, Puducherry SSW 1645 542 2187 369 1818 APCR 2461 734 3195 784 2411 ESDW 2093 1078 3171 59 3112 Miscellaneous 315 229 544 24 520 Total: 6514 2583 9097 1236 7861 5.Chandigarh State Office: Jurisdiction-Punjab, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, J&K, Uttarakhand & UT of Chandigarh SSW 401 125 526 0 526 APCR 1083 858 1941 0 1941 ESDW 309 54 363 0 363 Miscellaneous 548 133 681 0 681 Total: 2341 1170 3511 0 3511 6.Guwahati State Office: Jurisdiction-Assam, Manipur, Mizoram, Nagaland, Meghalaya and Arunachal Pradesh SSW 32 16 48 0 48 APCR 00 1 01 0 01 ESDW 02 0 02 0 02 Miscellaneous 16 22 38 0 38 Total: 50 39 89 0 89 7.Hyderabad State Office: Jurisdiction-Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh SSW 1314 512 1826 12 1814 APCR 1271 544 1815 06 1809 ESDW 1314 460 1774 07 1767
89 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Miscellaneous 0 0 0 00 00 Total: 3899 1516 5415 25 5390 8.Kolkata State Office: Jurisdiction-West Bengal, Odisha, Sikkim and A&N Islands SSW 246 164 410 39 371 APCR 277 101 378 69 309 ESDW 147 118 265 51 214 Miscellaneous 152 87 239 48 191 Total: 822 470 1292 207 1085 9.Lucknow State Office: Jurisdiction-Uttar Pradesh SSW 763 208 971 0 971 APCR 1355 1311 2666 0 2666 ESDW 2220 913 3133 0 3133 Miscellaneous 438 137 575 0 575 Total: 4776 2569 7345 0 7345 10.Patna State Office: Jurisdiction-Bihar and Jharkhand SSW 541 173 714 455 259 APCR 893 408 1301 696 605 ESDW 392 99 491 250 241 Miscellaneous 231 73 304 158 146 Total: 2057 753 2810 1559 1251 11.Pune State Office: Jurisdiction-Maharashtra and Goa SSW 1547 154 1701 98 1603 APCR 1177 182 1359 107 1252 ESDW 812 53 865 33 832 Miscellaneous 18 25 43 27 16 Total: 3554 414 3968 265 3703 12.Thiruvananthapuram State Office: Jurisdiction-Kerala and Lakshadweep SSW 48 40 88 0 88 APCR 140 303 443 14 429 ESDW 143 120 263 17 246 Miscellaneous 61 46 107 09 98 Total: 392 509 901 40 861 Total (all 12 State Offices 26329 10859 37188 3408 33780 of NCSC) NCSC Headquarters APCR 7379 2276 9655 284 9371 ESDW 2036 826 2862 241 2621
90 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
SSW-I 2771 795 3566 74 3492 SSW-II 2117 401 2518 279 2239 Total (NCSC Hqrs.) 14303 4298 18601 878 17723 Grand Total (all State Offices + NCSC Hqrs.) 40632 15157 55789 4286 51503
As can be seen 15157 cases were received in 2018-19. The closing balance of pending cases is 51503 as on 31 March 2019.
2.2.1(b): 2019-20
Table 2.1(b) Nature of Opening Received Total case Total cases Closing cases Balance during received Disposed balance as as on April, 2019 (col.2&3) on 01.04.2019 to January 31.01.2020 2020 1 2 3 4 5 6 1.Agartala State Office : Jurisdiction - Tripura SSW 11 09 20 00 20 APCR 09 05 14 00 14 ESDW 10 05 15 00 15 Miscellaneous 183 05 188 00 188 Total: 213 24 237 00 237 2.Ahmedabad State Office : Jurisdiction-Gujarat, Rajasthan, Daman and Diu, Dadra & Nagar Haveli SSW 320 88 408 17 391 APCR 889 184 1073 17 1056 ESDW 473 133 606 08 598 Miscellaneous 69 15 84 01 83 Total: 1751 420 2171 43 2128 3.Bangalore State Office: Jurisdiction -Karnataka SSW 222 101 323 05 318 APCR 186 92 278 14 264
91 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
ESDW 232 83 315 11 304 Miscellaneous 80 07 87 00 87 Total: 720 283 1003 30 973 4.Chennai State Office: Jurisdiction-Tamil Nadu, Puducherry SSW 1818 520 2338 399 1939 APCR 2411 648 3059 606 2453 ESDW 3112 848 3960 504 3456 Miscellaneous 520 179 699 01 698 Total: 7861 2195 10056 1510 8546 5.Chandigarh State Office: Jurisdiction-Punjab, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, J&K, Uttarakhand & UT of Chandigarh SSW 526 611 2552 1 2551 APCR 1941 138 664 1 663 ESDW 363 30 393 14 379 Miscellaneous 681 66 747 0 747 Total: 3511 845 4356 16 4340 6.Guwahati State Office: Jurisdiction-Assam, Manipur, Mizoram, Nagaland, Meghalaya and Arunachal Pradesh SSW 48 11 59 00 59 APCR 01 01 02 00 02 ESDW 02 01 03 00 03 Miscellaneous 38 13 51 00 51 Total: 89 26 115 00 115 7.Hyderabad State Office: Jurisdiction-Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh SSW 1814 279 2093 02 2091 APCR 1809 504 2313 83 2230 ESDW 1767 271 2038 96 1942 Miscellaneous 00 0 00 00 00 Total: 5390 1054 6444 181 6263 8.Kolkata State Office: Jurisdiction-West Bengal, Odisha, Sikkim and A&N Islands SSW 371 141 512 177 335 APCR 309 148 457 148 309 ESDW 214 39 253 124 129 Miscellaneous 191 70 261 152 109 Total: 1085 398 1483 601 882 9.Lucknow State Office: Jurisdiction-Uttar Pradesh SSW 971 112 1083 18 1065
92 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
APCR 2666 911 3577 1394 2183 ESDW 3133 1001 4134 1213 2921 Miscellaneous 575 85 660 00 660 Total: 7345 2109 9454 2625 6829 10.Patna State Office: Jurisdiction-Bihar and Jharkhand SSW 259 96 355 05 350 APCR 605 393 998 80 918 ESDW 241 114 355 15 340 Miscellaneous 146 85 231 14 217 Total: 1251 688 1939 114 1825 11.Pune State Office: Jurisdiction-Maharashtra and Goa SSW 1603 250 1853 71 1782 APCR 1252 348 1600 108 1492 ESDW 832 188 1020 66 954 Miscellaneous 16 96 112 29 83 Total: 3703 882 4585 274 4311 12.Thiruvananthapuram State Office: Jurisdiction-Kerala and Lakshadweep SSW 88 46 134 15 119 APCR 429 173 602 8 594 ESDW 246 78 324 81 243 Miscellaneous 98 62 160 3 157 Total: 861 359 1220 107 1113 Total (all 12 State Offices of NCSC) 33780 9283 43063 5501 37562 NCSC Headquarters
APCR 9371 1327 10698 385 10313 ESDW 2621 541 3162 130 3032 SSW-I 3492 566 4058 112 3946 SSW-II 2239 319 2558 231 2327 Total (NCSC Hqrs.) 17723 2753 20476 858 19618 Grand Total (all 12 State Offices + NCSC Hqrs.) 51503 12036 63539 6359 57180
93 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
As can be seen 12036 cases were received in 2019-20 (upto 31.01.2020). The Commission disposed off 6359 cases upto January 2020 .The closing balance of pending cases is 57180 as on 31 January 2020.
2.3 Some important and successful cases on Service Safeguard issues
1348 and 1053 cases dealt in the Commission (Headquarters and State Offices) relating to service safeguards issues were closed in the Commission in 2018-19 and 2019-20 . These cases were on issues like denial of promotion/MACP, denial of appointments, denial of appointments on compassionate grounds, non payment of pension & terminal/pensionary benefits, dismissal/reinstatement cases, harassment in transfer/posting and other harassment cases on caste grounds etc.
Out of these, 165 ( 97 of 2018-19 and 68 of 2019-20 ) of the interesting and successful cases are tabulated and further detailed below. As a result of the intervention of NCSC in the 165 mentioned cases, 29 persons were promoted, 24 persons received their pension and arrears of Rs 161.76 lakh , 14 persons were appointed in services, 13 persons received compassionate appointments , 20 persons were reinstated after termination / suspension etc and received Rs. 18.74 lakh as miscellaneous payments, 43 persons were transferred or upgraded in posts and received Rs. 1.49 lakh as arrears , miscellaneous benefits etc were also received by 16 other persons .
Table 2.2 Sr Subject Interesting Interesting benefit amount (Rs.) no cases at Hqrs. cases at State Offices
1 Promotion matters 12 17 Nil
2 Up-gradation of Pay 00 01 33,241/- Scales
3 Appointment matters 00 12 Nil
94 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
4 Pensionary/Terminal 07 16 1,55,36,094 + Benefits matters 6,40,000/-
5 Transfer matters 10 21 1,45,602
6 Compassionate 05 08 Nil appointment matters
7 Suspension and re- 03 29 18,74,000/- instatement in services, payment of salary, caste certificate, harrashment and miscellaneous matters.
8 Appointment of Contract 00 02 Nil workers
Total 37 60 1,82,28,937-
2.3.1 NCSC Headquarters
Promotion matters:
File No.-R-31/Delhi-122/2016/SSW-I
The promotion of petitioner Shri Ram Dass Executive Engineer, O/o Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Broad (DUSIB), New Delhi was withheld by DUSIB .With the intervention of the NCSC petitioner was promoted w. e. f 01.01.1999.
File No.-V-1/Delhi-10/2017/SSW-I
Shri Vijay Kumar Rakesh, Librarian, State Council of Education Research & Training (SCERT), Government of NCT Delhi alleged that he was not provided equal pay grade to other Librarians. On 10.04.2018, the Department submitted that the pay of petitioner was re-fixed.
File No.-M-13/Home-8/2017/SSW-I
95 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri Mahesh Kalawat, Commandant, I.T.B.P. ,Shivpuri Madhya Pradesh alleged that his Annual Performance Assessment Report (APAR) for the period of 03.07.2014 to 31.03.2015 was downgraded The MHA vide their letter No. - 1-17012/15/2018 APAR Cell-554-57 dated 04.09.2018 stated that the APAR of petitioner has been upgraded.
File No.-P-24/Delhi-142/2016/SSW-I
The petitioner Shri Prakash Chandra, Joint Commission, (Labour) Delhi Government complained of denial of promotion for DANICS selection grade. On 29.10.2018, the authorities informed the Commission that the grievances of petitioner have been settled.
File No.-J-4/Rly-13/2018/SSW-I
Shri J.P. Ragier Zonal Secretary, All India SC/ST Railway Employee Association of Modern Coach Factory Lalganj Raibareli complained regarding non promotion in various cadres. After the intervention of NCSC the Railways informed the Commission during the hearing on 08.09.2018 that all the candidates named in the petition have been promoted.
File No.-R-22/Delhi-71/2017/SSW-I
Shri Ram Jatan, Teacher in South Delhi Municipal Corporation stated that he was discriminated by denial of promotion. The SDMC intimated vide their letter no.- D/2602DDE/WZ dated 19.09.2018 that Shri Ram Jatan has been promoted as Principal and has joined on 18.09.2019.
File No.-R-1/Uttarakhand-2/2018/SSW-I
Shri Rajiv Kumar, R/o Dehradun, Uttarakhand working as Sales Supervisor in Dehradun Dugda Utpadak Sahkari Sangh requested for promotion as Lab Assistant. After the intervention of NCSC, the petitioner has been promoted as Lab Assistant as intimated by Secretary, Uttarakhand Government vide letter No.-464/XV/2/07 (05) 2016 (TC-1) dated 24.07.2018.
File No. G-3/Delhi-23/2016/SSW-I
Shri Girdhar, UDC, North Delhi Municipal Corporation, New Delhi requested for fixing seniority. After the intervention of the Commission, his seniority was fixed vide o/o No. ASO-IV/SO-I/CED/NDMC/2018/02 dated- 03.04.2018.
96 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. L-4/HFW-16/2017/SSW-II
Petitioner Smt. Lalita, Administrative Officer, Lady Harding Medical College & Smt. S.K. Hospital, New Delhi regarding non-regularization of her adhoc promotion as Administrative Officer. The Director, LHMC has informed that the petitioner has been promoted on regular basis as Administrative Officer.
File No. H-10/HFW-31/2015/SSW-II
Shri Hawa Singh, AAO, 204, Administrative Block, JIPMER, Puduchery regarding non issue of appointment letter as Administrative Officer in JIPMER. The Petitioner has been appointed and joined w.e.f. 24.11.2015 as Administrative Officer in JIPMER, Puducherry.
File No. G-8/Insurance-8/2017/SSW-II
Shri Gauri Shankar S/o Late Shri Deep Chand and others, H.No. 2/60 Harijan Basti, New Rohtak Road, New Delhi regarding non appointment & harassment.. The LIC has informed that in appointment letters have been issued.
File No. R-12/Bank-40/2017/SSW-II
R. Anand Kumar, H. NO. 284/2, Railway Qtrs. Near New, Bridge North Lalaguda, Secunderabad, Andhra Pradesh represented regarding non appointment in Syndicate Bank. The management of Syndicate Bank reported that he has been given post of house keeper- cum-attender which has same salary & emoluments of an attender. The petitioner was satisfied.
Compassionate Appointment Cases : File No.-A-30/Defence-25/2015/SSW-I
Smt. Asha W/o Late Shri Om Prakash claimed compassionate ground appointment for her daughter, in place of her late husband was working as Laskar at Air Force Station Tuglakabad, Delhi. After intervention of NCSC her daughter Ms. Raksha was appointed on compassionate grounds on 22.06.2018.
File No.-P-17/Coal-12/2018/SSW-I
97 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Km. Promila Bhuia, D/o Late Smt. Kausalia for appointment on compassionate ground in Coal India Ltd. The petitioner was appointed as T.W. Loader in District Jamui (Bihar) on 30.8.2018.
File No.-N-6/Rly-25/2018/SSW-I
Km. Neha Rambaboo Bharthi D/o Late Shri Ram Baboo, R/o Meerut (U.P) sought compassionate appointment in Northern Railway. Northern Railway, New Delhi vide their letter no. 220E/1258/14-NCSC DLI/18/RP dated 31.01.2019 stated that Km. Neha has been appointed as clerk and joined duty on 14.01.2019.
File No. A-26/HRD-28/2012/SSW-II
Shri Krishan Gopal, 195/7 Solani Kunj, IIT Roorkee, Haridwar requested appointment on compassionate grounds in IIT Roorkee. The petitioner has been appointed as Junior Laboratory Assistant and joined his post on 30.10.2018.
File No. P-2/UP-22/2018/SSW-II
Shri Pramod Kumar, Assistant Storekeeper, Employees State Insurance Corporation, Sasni Gate, Aligarh, Uttar Pradesh represented regarding compassionate appointment. The grievance of the petitioner has been redressed and he is satisfied.
Transfer and harassment :
File No.-S-75/Coal-28/2018 (SSW-I)
Smt. Sobhagiri Naik W/o Shri Jagatanada Naik. SOE (Civil), Mahanadi Coal Ltd. (M C L), Basundhara (Odisha) for represented for transfer of her husband from Basundhara area to Hingula Area Talcher Coalfield Ltd. M C L.After the intervention of NCSC her husband has been transferred to Hingula area vide order No. 488 dated-25.09.2018. File No.-B-26/Rly-51/2018 (SSW-I)
Shri Baljinder Singh T.T.I of Firozpur Division of Northern Railway, represented for non payment of TA bills from November, 2016 to September, 2017. The Railway concerned paid all pending bills of the petitioner as intimated vide their letter no.-1. STE-30-TTI- FZR-16 dated 10.12.2018.
98 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No.-A-13/Rly-23/2018 (SSW-I)
Shri Ashok Kumar, Station Master, Kashipur Junction requested shift to Murshan Station, The petitioner has been transferred to Murshan Station vide letter No.-50/2/Ashok Kumar/Estt./ Railway Board dated 30.05.2019. File No. P-5/Haryana-5/2017/SSW-II
Shri Pyare Lal S/o Bhula Ram, Utla, Panipat, Haryana complained regarding harassment. The Deputy Commissioner, Panipat has submit a report that an amount of Rs. 0.60 lakh & other benefits has been paid to the petitioner. Petitioner was satisfied.
File No. H-6/Bank-27/2018/SSW-II
The Commission received the representation dated 27.02.2018 from the Petitioner Shri Harishankar Ram, Branch Manager, Branch-Dighi Ramaship Chowk, Sadar Thana, Hajipur, Vaishali, Bihar regarding discrimination and harassment. During the hearing with CMD, Central Bank of India, Mumbai & Chairman, Uttar Bihar Gramin Bank, Mujaffarpur, Bihar on 17.05.2018 , the bank submitted that the grievance of the petitioner has been redressed.
File No. V-8/Bank-42/2017/SSW-II
Shri Virendra Kumar Singh, Deputy Manager, State Bank of India, Mathura Branch, Uttar Pradesh represented regarding transfer. After a hearing with Chairman, State Bank of India on 27.08.2018,the Bank informed that he has been posted at Firozabad .
File No. O-1/Food-1/2017/SSW-II
Shri Om Parkash, WAG-I, Central Warehousing, Kirti Nagar Now at ICD-Loni, represented regarding transfer. After a hearing with MD, Central Warehousing Corporation, New Delhi on 28.08.2019, the petitioner has been transferred.
File No. P-1/UP-2/2018/SSW-II
Dr. P.N. Parya, Flat No. 5, Ratandeep Apartment, 127/293, U Block, Nirala Nagar, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh represented regarding transfer. After a hearing with Principal Secretary, Medical Health & Family Welfare, Lucknow on 09.07.2018, the petitioner has been transferred to choice place.
99 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. R-16/Bank-46/2018/SSW-II
Shri Rajeev Kumar, 136, IInd Arya Nagar, Dehradun, Uttarakhand represented regarding transfer. After intervention of the Commission , UCO Bank, Calcutta responded on 24.09.2018 that petitioner has been transferred from Doiwala to Rajpur Branch , near to his residence.
File No. D-6/Bank-37/2018/SSW-II
Smt. Divya Chaurasiya, Plot No. 71, Mahakaushal Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur, Madhya Pradesh represented regarding transfer. After intervention of the Commission, Central Bank of India has transferred her to her requested place , ie Bhopal.
Suspension and re-instatement of services : File No.-K-7/Uttarakhand-11/2018/SSW-I
Shri Krishan Kumar, Department Sports Officer (DSO) was suspended by Director of Sports Uttarakhand. After the intervention of NCSC, Shri Krishan Kumar D.S.O. was reinstated w.e.f. 22.05.2018.
File No.-B-11/Coal-11/2018/SSW-I
Shri Brij Kishore of Coal India SC/ST Employees Coordination Council ,Syal, Ramgarh Jharkhand filed a case for reinstatement of Shri Jai Ram Dusadh who was dismissed from service in 2003. Shri Jai Ram Dushad has been re-instated w.e.f. 22.02.2019 as intimated by Eastern Coal Field Ltd. vide their letter no. ECL.CMD/C-6/E-8/VIP-769/1599 dated 30.4.2019.
File No. N-7/Rajasthan-7/2016/SSW-I
Shri Neki Ram, Block Elementary Education Officer (BEEO) in Education Department of Rajathan alleged that he was suspended and transferred to Barmer 700 K.M. away from his native place. He was reinstated and pending dues paid to him as per report of Rajasthan Government letter No. P-17 (18) 2016 dated 19.01.2019.
Pensionary /terminal benefit matters & payment of other dues: File No.M-2/UD-7/2018/SSW-I
100 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Murati Devi W/o Late Shri Ram Mehar, R/o District Sonepat, Haryana. represented regarding non disbursal of pensionary benefits of her husband. The petitioner received pension of last 13 years amounting Rs. 13.84 lakh and DCRG of Rs. 0.53 lakh from Delhi Development Authority (DDA).
File No. G-7/Bank-22/2016/SSW-II
Ms. Geeta Devi, PF No. 33031, Ex-Employee UCO Bank, Gurgaon Main Branch R/o H.No. 9, VPO-Samspua, Sector 51, Gurgaon represented regarding her compulsory retirement from Bank service. After a hearing with CMD, UCO Bank the petitioner has rejoined her service on 04.04.2018. The Bank also agreed for clarifying date of reinstatement and the gap period.
File No. B-4/Bank-28/2017/SSW-II
Shri B.Y. Nandeshwar, General Secretary, All India Central Bank SC/ST/OBC Employees association Calcutta represented regarding grievances of several employees. The Central Bank of India reported on 13.12.2018 and stated that an ex-gratia amount of Rs. 7,00,000/- has been sanctioned to Smt. Sangita Bhaladhare in lieu of compassionate appointment. Transfer of Shri Kiron Das Sr. Manager, has been considered. And Shri Kailash Bansod, Manager, has been promoted to Scale II on 30.04.2016.
File No. S-10/UP-18/2018/SSW-II
Smt. Sunita w/o Shri Amar Singh, C-10, Aavaagh Colony, Mainpuri, Uttar Pradesh represented regarding non-payment of salary. After a hearing with DM, Mainpuri on 08.05.2018., her salary was paid.
File No. S-3/UP-7/2018/SSW-II
Shri Shantanand, H.No. 87, Shrinagar Colony, Firozabad Road, District-Agra, Uttar Pradesh represented regarding non-payment of terminal benefits & harassment. After a hearing with MD, Uttar Pradesh Scheduled Castes Finance & Development Corporation, Lucknow on 23.07.2018., the grievances of petitioner were redressed.
File No. R-38/HFW-16/2016/SSW-II
101 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri Rishi Kumar, Conductor, B.No. RCC-321, Token No. 85986, Rohini Depot, 04, Delhi represented regarding non co-operation by the department/ESIC after his accident and for its treatment. After a hearing with DG, ESIC, New Delhi on 30.08.2018. Rs. 0.182 lakh has been paid to the petitioner against his treatment claims.
File No. M-18/AE-8/2018/SSW-II
Shri M. Raju, H.No. 4-129/A, Kamala Nagar, Sainikpuri (PO), Secunderabad Telangana represented regarding integration with driver cadre and MACP. After the case was taken up the petitioner, was integrated with transport cadre and also granted ACP, with retrospective effect.
2.3.2 NCSC State Offices 2.3.2.1 State Office, Ahmedabad
Promotion matters:
File No. NCSC/ABAD/R/02/SSW-I-2018
The represention for promotion of Shri Bhavarlal Varma to senior compiler was taken up with Directorate of Census Operation, Rajasthan on 30.08.2018. The Directorate intimated that the petitioner has been promoted to senior compiler.
Upgradation of Pay:
File No. NCSC/ABAD/R/01/SSW-I-2016cdd
The case of Shri Sohanlal Verma regarding the benefits of third grade pay of Rs. 6600/- was taken up with Ministry of Home Affairs, Govt. of India. The MHA responded that petitioner was granted 3rd financial up gradation under the MACP Scheme in PB-3, Grade pay of Rs. 6600/- with effect from 19/10/2013.
Appointment matters:
File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/48/ESDW-2018
102 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Smt. Rashmi Chandrakantbhai Limbola on 04/09/2018 regarding injustice in recruitment of MEGA Company Limited was taken up .The Company intimated on 15.02.2019 that the petitioner has been offered the post of Customer Relations Assistant.
File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/02/SSW-I-2017
The case of Shri Kamalesh Kumar Patel regarding job in Western Railway was taken up. Petioner was offered appointment as Assistant Loco Pilot in BCT Division .
File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/61/SSW-III-2017
The case of Shri Laljibhai Merubhai Rathod on 04/01/2018 regarding injustice in job was taken up with CMD, Dena Bank,. The petioner was given a permanent job order.
Pensionary/Terminal Benefits matters: File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/59/SSW-III-2017
The case of Shri Manoj R. Solanki, on 19/01/2018 regarding retirement benefits.was taken up with Chief Officer, Kapadwanj Nagarpalika, who responded taht Nagar Seva Sadan, Kapadvanj paid him PF Rs.0.81 lakh-on 01.02.2108 and gratuity Rs. 1 lakh on 13.03.2018.
Transfer matters: File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/09/SSW-I-2017
The case of Smt, Namrata Kumari, on 04/08/2017 regarding transfer in Western Railway was taken up .The Railway replied that petitioner was transferred as per request.
File No. NCSC/ABAD/R/28/SSW-III-2017
The case of Shri Maliram Regar 23.02.2018 regarding mental harassment was taken up with the department of Ayurved, Rajasthan on 10/04/2018.The department replied on 10.04.2018 that as per request the applicant was posted to Chittorgarh .
File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/05/SSW-II-2017
The case of Shri Rameshchandra Muljibhai Chauhan regarding third transfer within span of 19 months was taken up with State Bank of India, Ahmedabad. The reply received from SBI stated that the petitioner has been posted as Chief Manager, Modasa branch .
Miscellaneous matters:
103 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/55/ESDW-2018
The case of Smt. Kalavatiben Kantilal Solanki, regarding charge of midday mea was taken up with the District Collector ,Surendranagar The midday meal charge was re- handed to petitioner. 2.3.2.2 State Office Bangalore (2019-20)
Transfer matters: File No. 41/GOI PSU/19/2019-RU: Dr.R.Bhagya, Scientist-D, Central Silk Board, Mysore represented regarding discrimination in transfer. After intervention of this office a reply dated 05.02.2020 received from Central Silk Board stated that the transfer order has been modified and he is posted at Mysore in different unit.
2.3.2.3(a) State Office : Chennai 2018-19
Promotion matters:
File No. 9/22/2017 Rep (CG)
The case of Shri.K. Solairajan, Pharmacist-cum-Clerk, Government Medical State Depot, Chennai regarding promotion to the post of Depot Superintendent was taken up with the Secretary, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, New Delhi on 29.05.2017. The petitioner was finally promoted as Depot Superintendent w.e.f 21.12.2014.
File No. 9/10/2017 Rep (CGU)
The case of Shri.P.Samynathan, National Insurance Company Limited (NICL), of denial of promotion as Deputy Manager was taken up with the CMD, NICL on 13.12.2017, 14.02.2018 and 05.03.2018. The petitioner was promoted w.e.f November, 2017.
File No. 9/8/2016 Rep (CGU)
The case Shri.M.Krishnamoorthy, FTS, NICL regarding non-promotion as Assistant was taken up with the NICL on 12.02.2016 and continuously followed up and hearings conducted. The petitioner was promoted to Assistant cadre .
104 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Appointment matters:
File No. 5/87/2017 Rep
The case of Shri.V.Pandiyarajan, Madurai regarding delay in appointment as Police Constable after selection was taken up with the Secretary, Tamil Nadu Uniformed Service Recruitment Board, Chennai on 25.10.2017 and also with the Director General of Police, Tamil Nadu, Chennai on 13.12.2017. The petitioner was appointed as Police Constable.
Transfer matters:
File No. 9/10/2017 Rep. (P & T)
The case of Smt. R. Nandhini, Junior Engineer, BSNL, Chennai regarding transfer to native place Udumalpet, Tiruppur District was taken up with Chief General Manager, BSNL, Chennai on 20.11.2017. The petitioner was transferred to Udumalpet on 16.4.2018.
File No. 9/135/2015 Rep. (SG)
The case of Shri.K.Kaliraj, Teacher, Tuticorin District regarding his transfer from Ramanathapuram School to Kuruvikulam School, Tirunelveli was taken up with the Principal Secretary, School Education Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, on 22.05.2015. The petitioner was transferred to a nearby school at Tuticorin.
Compassionate ground appointment matters:
File No. 9/274/2017 (SG)
The Commission received the representation dated 9.11.2017 from Shri.T.Sathishkumar of Ramanathapuram regarding his non appointment on compassionate grounds in Social Welfare Department, Government of Tamil Nadu. After the case was heard , the petitioner was appointed as Junior Assistant in Social Welfare Department, Government of Tamil Nadu. 2.3.2.3(b) State Office : Chennai 2019-20
Promotion matters
File No. 9/35/2015 Rep (CG)
105 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri M Gunalan, LDC (Adhoc), CGIT-Cum-Labour Court Chennai vide his representation dated 05.05.2015 requested for regularization to the post of LDC. The case was vigorously pursued with the Secretary, Ministry of Labour & Employment, New Delhi and with the Presiding Officer / Registrar, CGIT-Cum-Labour Court, Chennai . As per intimation of of the petitioner, he was regularized in the post of LDC due to the intervention of NCSC .
File No. 9/301/2019 Rep (SG)
The Commission received representation dated 15.11.2019 from Shri S Shanmugasundaram, Assistant Regional (Audit Committee), Office of the Joint Director, Health Department, Tiruchirapalli , TN regarding denial of his promotion since 2017. The matter was taken up with the Secretary, Health & Family Welfare, Chennai . As per the reply received from the department the petitioner was promoted to the post of ‘Superintendent’ on 05.02.2020. Up-gradation of Pay Scales
File No. 9/227/2019 Rep (SG)
The Commission received representation dated 24.08.2019 from petitioner Shri S Saravanan, Anna University, Chennai regarding non-payment of his pending salary. The matter was taken up with the Registrar, Anna University, Chennai on 19.09.2019 and was followed up by a reminder on 31.10.2019. The petitioner was paid the pending salary of Rs.21,000/- . Pensionary / Terminal Benefits matters
File No. 9/197/2018 Rep (SG)
The Commission received representation from Shri Era Krishnasamy, Tirunelveli regarding denial of his retirement benefits by the Treasury & Accounts Department. The issue was taken up with the Principal Secretary School Education Department, Chennai and with the Director, Treasury & Accounts Department, Chennai . As per the reply of the petitioner, he was disbursed with the retirement benefit of Rs.52,650/-.
Transfer matters
106 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 9/47/2018 Rep (CG)
The Commission received representation dated 18.01.2018 from the petitioner Smt Vanitha Jayakumar, Madurai regarding request for transfer for her husband on medical grounds. The matter was taken up with the Chairman, Central Board for Excise & Customs, on 17.09.2018. The petitioner’s husband was transferred and posted to Tiruchirapalli Customs (Preventive) Commissionerate .
File No. 9/222/2018 Rep (SG)
The Commission received the representation from Smt C Kavitha, ANM, Government Public Health Centre, Nallur, Tiruppur regarding request for transfer. The matter was taken up with the Director, Public Health & Preventive Medicine, Chennai on 24.07.2018. The petitioner was transferred to the place of her request viz., Palladam Urban Primary Health Centre in 2019.
File No. 9/11/2019 Rep. (Bank)
The Commission received representation from Shri C Jeyaraj, Senior Manager, Punjab National Bank, Chennai regarding harassment in the form of transfer. The case was taken up with the General Manager, Punjab National Bank, Zonal Office, Chennai on 11.06.2019. As per the reply received from the Bank, ,the petitioner was posted in Chennai itself .
Suspension and re-instatement into services, payment of salary, caste certificate, harassment and miscellaneous matters
File No. 9/288/2017 Rep. (SG)
The Commission received representation from Shri K Aiyyasamy, Erode with a request to revoke his suspension order. The case was taken up with the Principal Secretary, Social Welfare Department, Chennai on 10.09.2018 and continuously followed up on 01.11.2018 and 31.12.2018.As per the reply received from the petitioner he was re-instated into service.
File No. 9/37/2019 Rep. (SG)
107 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission received representation from Smt Sivagami, Ramanathapuram ,TN with a request to include her name as a nominee in the service register of her husband ,a Government Teacher. The case was taken up with the Director, School Education Department, Chennai on 18.02.2018 .As per the reply received from the Director, the petitioner’s name was entered into service register of her husband as nominee.
File No. 9/190/2018 Rep. (SG)
The Commission received representation from Smt C Kalpana, Pudukottai,TN for reinstatement into service. The matter was taken up with the Secretary, Health & Family Welfare, Chennai on 06.07.2018 and as per the reply received from the Department, Chennai, the petitioner was re-instated in service .
File No. 9/14/2019 Rep. (SG)
The Commission received representation from Ms Kalaivani, Chennai,TN regarding illegal termination of employment by a private school. The case was taken up with the Principal Secretary School Education Department, on 10.01.2018 and was continuously followed up . As per the reply received from the Department, Chennai during 2019 stating that the petitioner was re-instated into service .
File No. 9/21/2019 Rep. (CGU)
The Commission received representation from Shri J Vasanthakumar, United India Insurance Company Limited, Chennai with a request for re-instatement into service. The case was taken up with the CMD, United India Insurance Company Limited, Chennai on 23.05.2019 .The petitioner was re-instated into service.
File No. 3/92/2019 Rep.
The Commission received representation from Shri S Sivaramakumar, Salem ,TN on the delay in issue of relieving order and experience certificate by a Private Engineering College. The issue was taken up with the Principal, Muthayammal College of Engineering, Rasipuram on 18.06.2019 . As per the reply of the petitioner he was issued with experience certificate and relieving order.
File No. 9/123/2019 Rep. (SG)
108 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission received representation from Shri S Murugesan, Tuticorin ,TN on the alleged atrocity by Chief Health Officer of Tuticorin Health Corporation. The case was taken up with the Principal Secretary , Municipal Administration & Water Supply Department, Chennai on 17.05.2018 .The petitioner was re-instated into service.
File No. 9/214/2019 Rep. (SG)
The Commission received representation from Shri S Sakthivel, Salem ,TN with a request to revoke his suspension order issued by TAHDCO. The case was taken up with the Principal Secretary, Adi Dravidar & Tribal Welfare Department, Chennai .The petitioner was re-instated into service.
File No. 9/201/2019 Rep. (SG)
The Commission received representation from Shri M Panchatcharam, Chennai with a request to revoke his suspension order. The case was taken up with the Managing Director, Tamil Nadu State Marketing Corporation Limited on 14.08.2019 .The petitioner was re- instated into service.
2.3.2.4(a) State office :Hyderabad 2018-19
Promotion matters:
File No. 1/157/18/TS-Ser.:
The case of Smt. D.V. Padmavati, Sr. Assistant of HACA, Hyderabad regarding denial of promotion was taken with MD, Hyderabad Agricultural Co-operative Association Ltd. After the hearing petitioner was promoted as Business Manager in March 2019.
Pensionary /Terminal Benefits Matters & Others Dues:
File No. 1/129/18/TS-RU:
The case of Shri Ramala Pullaiah, Support Man SCCL, Kothagudem regarding not getting retirement benefit since 2013 and dependent employment to son was taken with General Manager, Singareni Collieries Company Ltd . The PSU paid full retirement benefits of Rs. 29.50 lakh to petitioner.
109 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 1/177/18/TS-RU:
The case of Shri Sudha Kumar, Joint Director, Tourism Department, Telangana regarding non-payment of salary and pension contribution during deputation period was taken up with Principal Secretary, concerned who informed vide their letter dated 12.11.2018 that petitioner has been paid his retirement benefits of approximately Rs. 40 lakh. File No. 1/7/19/AP-RU:
The case of Shri D. Srinivasarao, Kakinada, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh regarding denial of regularization of his services was taken up with Chief Post Master General, who responded on 11.02.2019 that his services were regularized and arrears of Rs. 0.84 lakh paid.
File No. 1/27/17/AP-RU: The case of Smt. T. Kumari, r/ o Marrippalem, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh complained of denial of VRS amount was taken up with Naval Dockyard who submitted a report on 16.05.2018 that dues of Rs. 11.05 lakh have been cleared and a monthly pension of Rs. 23,440/- also sanctioned w.e.f. April 2017.
File No. 6/18/18/AP-RU:
The case of Shri P. Subrammanyam, MTS,TTD, Tirupati regarding more than 2 years delay in settlement of pension and retirement benefits was taken with CEO TTD, Tirupati, Andhra Pradesh who replied on 21.07.2018 that his retirement benefits of Rs. 14.29 lakh were settled and he is getting regular pension from July 2017 onwards. File No. 1/7/19/AP-Ser.:
The case of Shri D. Srinivasa Rao, Postman, Kakinada, regarding non regularization of service, non fixation of pay allowance, non grant of 1st financial up gradation was taken up with Chief Post Master General, Andhra Pradesh who replied vide their letter dated 11.02.2019 that petitioner has been given MACP.
File No. 1/86/18/MP-RU:
110 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri S.L. Khare, SI, retired regarding not getting his MACP was taken up with Census Director, Madhya Pradesh who submitted a report regarding grant of MACP to Shri S.L. Khare.
Harassment & discrimination matters:
File No. 1/163/18/TS-RU:
The case of Shri Ch. Veerraju, ex-contractual Junior Lecturer, regarding discontinuation from teaching work was taken up with Commissioner of Intermediate Education, Telangana who informed that petitioner was given appointment in another government college and he joined service on 09.03.2019.
Transfer matters: File No. 1/73/18/AP-Ser: Shri S. Kotaiah of Ashok nagar, Kurnool, AP, complained of harassment by transfer by Superintendent Engineer, Irrigation, Kurnool. The case was taken up and SE stopped his transfer on humanitarian grounds.
File No. 1/164/18/AP-Ser.:
The case of Shri B. Babu, DE, BSNL, regarding discrimination in transfer and medical grounds was taken up with BSNL who vide their letter dated 30.11.2018 stated that his request has been accepted.
File No. 1/180/18/TS-Ser.:
The case of Shri B. Shravan Kumar, Dy. Manager, SBI, Marripeda Branch, Mahabubabad , Telangana, regarding transfer to Hanumakonda, Warangal on health grounds was taken up with CMD , SBI and,he was posted at his choice place.
File No. 1/13/18/MP-Ser.:
Shri Kanhiya Lal Chowhan, Postal Assistant, Mandsaur, Madhya Pradesh complained of discrimination in transfer and posting. His case was taken up with PMG on 21.03.2018 and he was given posting of choice.
111 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 1/4/17/MP-Ser.:
Shri J.P. Nayak, Administrative Officer represented his case regarding indiscriminate transfer. The case was taken up and the Ministry of Water Resources transferred him to his home town.
Compassionate Appointment matters:
File No. 1/13/17/TS-RU:
The case of Smt. B. Sarojini, safaiwali, Hyderabad requesting for compassionate appointment to her daughter, as she had suffered an acid burnt accident while on duty. The matter was taken up with Director, Advanced Training Institute, EPI, Hyderabad. her daughter received an appointment order from ATI-EPI in January 2019.
Suspension , re-instatement and miscellaneous issues:
FileNo. 1/73/18/TS-Ser.:
The case of Shri R. Anandkumar , Secunderabad, Telangana regarding anomaly inrecruitment process and regularization as attender in Syndicate Bankwas taken up and Bank vide their letter dated 02.07.2018 stated that his services have been regularized.
File No. 1/62/18/TS-Ser.:
The case of Shri Narender Jannu, Manager, Indian Bank regarding delay in relieving him to join higher post was taken up with CMD of the Bank. The petitioner has been relieved for higher post.
File No. 1/90/18/TS-Ser.:
The case of Shri K. Srinivasarao of Godavarikhani, Peddappalli ,Telangana regarding appontmant as Jr. Assistant was taken with CMD, Singaneri Collieries, who vide their letter dated 04.01.2019 informed that petitioner has been given appointment as Jr. Assistant against reserved quota.
2.3.2.4(b) State office :Hyderabad 2019-20
112 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Promotion matters:
File No. 1/157/18/TS-Ser.:
The representation by Smt. D.V. Padmavati, Sr. Assistant of HACA, Hyderabad was regarding denial from promotion. The matter has been taken with MD, Hyderabad Agricultural Co-Op. Association Ltd., Hyderabad. After a hearing she got promotion as Business Manager. F. No. 1/71/19/TS-Ser.:
Representation was received from Shri G. Prasad Rao, Assistant Director, O/o.D.P.R.O., Collectorate Complex, Durajpally, Suryapet, Telangana regarding discrimination and non- implementation of rule of reservation in promotion. After follow up, Commissioner, Information and Public Relations Department, Government of Telangana agreed to consider the candidature of the petitioner for promotion to the post of Dy. Director in the ensuing DPC. F. No. 1/128/19/TS-RU: Representation was received from Dr. T. Brahmanandam, Associate Professor, Centre for Multi Disciplinary Development Research, Dharwad, Karnataka regarding promotion. After pursuance by NCSC, Management agreed to conduct Career Advancement Scheme and the consider the case of the petitioner on merits.
Pensionary /Terminal Benefits Matters & Others Dues: F. No. 1/118/18/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Shri. Venkata Ramana, H.No.16-1-187, Saidabad, Near Harijanbasti, Hyderabad, Telangana was regarding enhancement of remuneration. After follow up, authorities enhanced his pay and paid him arrears.
F. No. 1/112/19/TS-Ser.: Representation from Sri. N. Yadagiri, H.No: 4-137, Pedda Amberpet, Hyathnagar, Ranga Reddy, Telangana was regarding inclusion of name his second wife, Smt. Indira in the pension records. After pursuance, South Central Railway has issued the revised Pension Payment Order (PPO) and updated the records.
113 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
F. No. 1/50/19/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Shri Dharshanapu Prasad, Physical Education Director, Polytechnic College R/o. Mirjalguda, Secunderabad, Telangana was regarding delay in giving salary and increment. After follow up, Commissioner, Technical Education, submitted a report that the petitioner’s increments were released duly regulating his pay.
F. No. 1/147/19/TS-Ser.: Representation from Smt Godugu Manga, w/o. Late G. Shiva Kumar, H.No. 1-690/4, West Marredpally, Near Kasturiba College, Hyderabad, Telangana was regarding non-payment of gratuity. After follow up, gratuity of Rs. 1.93 lakh was paid to the petitioner.
Appointment Matters: F. No. 1/7/19/AP-RU: Shri D. Srinivasarao, Kakinada, East Godavari, AP submitted a petition regarding regularization of his services. The mater was taken up with Chief Post Master General, AP. Reply received that his services were regularized and arrears paid. F. No. 1/126/19/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Dr. M. Goverdhan, President, PJTSAU SC & ST Teaching and non-Teaching Employees Association, Rajendranagar, Hyderabad, Telangana regarding relaxation of essential qualifications in recruitment of University Officers. After follow up, University relaxed the criteria for UG & PG Degree as essential qualification. F. No. 1/163/18/TS-RU: As per the action taken report of Commissioner of Intermediate Education, Telangana , the petitioner Shri Ch. Veeraraju was given appointment in another government college and he joined service on 09.03.2019.
F. No. 1/29/19/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Shri K. Kumar, Malkajgiri, Hyderabad, Telangana was for regularization of services in Air India Engineering Services, where he worked as casual labour for 28 years. After intervention of Commission, he was appointed and joined as Handyman on 17.05.2019.
114 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Harassment & discrimination matters:
F. No. 1/96/19/AP-RU: Representation from Shri P.H. Sriramulu, Junior Assistant, D.No.6-4-24, Narayanappa Street, D.L.Road, Hindupuramu, Ananthapuramu, AP was regarding cancellation of deputation and caste based discrimination and harassment. Department has replied that out of 8 allegations, action is being taken on 6 allegations.
Transfer matters: F. No. 1/42/19/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Shri P. Shiv Raj, Administrative Officer, DMRL, Hyderabad, Telangana was for retention in DMRL, Hyderabad. After interference of Commission, his transfer order was cancelled and is retained in DMRL, Hyderabad.
F. No. 1/180/18/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Shri B. Shravan Kumar, Dy. Manager, SBI, Marripeda Branch, Mahabubabad, Telangana requesting for transfer to Hanumakonda, Warangal on health grounds. He was posted at his choice place.
F. No. 1/189/18/TS-Ser.: Representation was received from Shri K. Rajasekhar, Senior Manager, RailTel Corporation of India, Secunderabad, Telangana requesting for retention at Secunderabad on promotion. He was retained at Secunderabad on promotion .
F. No. 1/61/19/AP-Ser.: Representation received from Smt. B. Bhagya Lakshmi, Asst. Audit Officer, RGS Reports, O/o. Prl.A.G.(AU), Hyderabad, Telangana was regarding request for retention in Hyderabad. After intervention, her transfer out of Hyderabad has been cancelled .
Compassionate Appointment matters: F. No. 1/143/19/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Smt. M. Usha Kiran, W/o late M.S.A. Kumar Sridhar, (Employee No. 4905 Plant CFFP(A)) R/o H.No. 11-3-1023/2, Gokul Nagar, Hyderabad,
115 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Telangana was for appointment on compassionate grounds in Nuclear Fuel Complex. Nuclear Fuel Complex is taking action to issue appointment orders.
Suspension and re-instatement in services, Payment of Salary, Regularization, Caste Certificate, harassment and Misc. matters:
F. No. 1/46/19/AP-Ser.: Representation of Shri D. Reddappa, Asst. Manager, The Chittoor District Coop. Central Bank Ltd., Chittoor, AP was regarding extension of superannuation age from 58 years to 60 years, as he was due to retire on 30.06.2019. After intervention by Commission, he was reappointed in service.
F. No. 1/199/18/TS-Ser.: Representation dated 13.12.2018 received from Shri G. Suresh Kumar, S/o. G. Yadagiri (Late), Emp.No.221277, Conductor, Uppal Depot, Hayathnagar (Division), RR, Telangana was regarding reinstatement into service. After follow up, he was reinstated into service.
F. No. 1/70/19/AP-Ser.: Representation received from Shri L. Bangaraiah, Senior Assistant, Rajahmundry Campus, P.S. Telugu University regarding caste-based harassment and non-payment of salary from August 2018 to May 2019. After follow up petitioner received all the arrears and now getting his salary regularly like other employees.
F. No. 1/153/18/AP-Ser.: Representation received from Shri G. Srinivasulu, S/o. G. Guramma, Shantinagar, Guntakallu, Anantapur, AP regarding the matter of his compassionate appointment in South Central Railway. Railway authorities considered the our recommendation for re- medical examination and also identified an alternative post of Peon with lower medical classification in Guntakal , on being found fit, he will be given appointment.
F. No. 1/150/18/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Shri K.S. Kenadi, Chief Manager, SBI 5th floor, Rear Block of HMWSSB Compound, 6-2-915, Khairatabad, Hyderabad, Telangana regarding non-
116 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
payment of salary and harassment. The petitioner was paid all the salary and other allowance and his absence was regularized.
2.3.2.5(a) State Office:Kolkata 2018-19
Promotion matters: File No.- 8/36/2015-gen/WB
Shri Pradip Saha, LDC, O/o the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Jalpaiguri submitted representation regarding non promotion. After issue was followed up petitioner got notional promotion w.e.f 17.09.2003.
File No.-9/28/2017- Gen/WB
Shri Gadadhar Saha, Superintendent Engineer, KMDA, GoWB submitted representation on 29.12.2017 alleging non promotion as Additional Chief Engineer in spite of having the eligibility. After the matter was taken up petitioner as promoted w.e.f. from date of eligibility i.e 29.12.2017.
File No.-9/28/2017- Gen/WB
Shri Subhash Samadder, Asstt. Assessor Collector, Kolkata Municipal Corporation represented that he was not considered for promotion as Dy. Manager though his junior was promoted. After matter was taken up petitioner got promotion w.e.f. from 30.11.2017.
File No. -8/16/2018-Gen/WB
Shri Sekhar Mallick, Technical Officer, IACS submitted representation to the Commission alleging that he was not considered promotion to the post of Technical Officer-I. The matter was taken up with the authority and petitioner was promoted.
Appointment matters: File No.8/7/2017-Gen/OR The case of Shri Ghasiram Das, ex- Development Officer, LIC alleging that he has been terminated from the post of Development Officer due to not fulfilling the target was taken up with the Executive Director (Marketing /PD), LIC, Mumbai informed on 06.06.2018
117 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
that the Shri Ghasiram Das has been re-appointed as Assistant and posted at Nuapada, Odisha on 01.8.2018.
File No. 9/10/2017-Gen/WB
The case of Shri Goutam Bhuiya Nepalganj, South 24 parganaa, West Bengal alleging that the govt. of West Bengal is not following the Reservation in appointment of Head Master of Grant-in-aid High/HS School was taken up with the School Education Department again as the post of Head Master is not single cadre post. After number of Correspondences the School Education Department who informed vide letter No. 880-SE/S/ 10M-95/17 dated 04.09.2018 that the reservation for the post of Head Master of Government aided and sponsored institutions will be implemented hence forth.
Transfer matters: File No. 14/3/2017-Gen/Sikkim
The case of Shri Bhim Bahadur Sewa (Darjee), Bering, East Sikkim with request to transfer his only son a work-charged group ‘C’ employee of, Central Water Commission, Bhopal on humanitarian grounds was taken up and his son was finally transferred to CWC, East Sikkim.
Harassment matters: File No.- 8/3/2018- Gen/OR
The case of Shri Trinath Naik, Supdt. Grp-II , alleging he was harassed and man handled by Shri Biplob Jena, working President , NSCU, NALCO was taken up with the NALCO Management the petitioner was called for hearing and the matter has been solved as informed by the petitioner.
Miscellaneous matters: File No. 4/1/2018- Gen/WB
The case of Shri Amit Mondal, Bhaktinagar, Jalpaiguri regarding sanction of education loan was taken up with the MD, West Bengal SC/ST Development and Finance Corporation. The educational loan of Rs 1.28 lakh has been sanctioned.
File No.6/7/2018 – Gen/WB
118 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri Ramprasad Biswas, retired assistant security Officer, DGOF, OFB, Kolkata alleging that his pay fixation has not been done by OFB authority was taken up. ,payment of Rs11 lakh as arrear and revised pension of Rs.26,400/- pm is now being paid. 2.3.2.5(b) State Office:Kolkata 2019-20 Reinstatement matters:
6/6/2018-Gen/WB (SER) Shri Akhil Chandra Biswas, SMR/Jhalda, Ranchi Division, SER complained about removal of service on disciplinary ground. Matter was taken up and subsequently, the removal order was revoked and Shri Biswas allowed to join his old place of posting.
Pension matters:
File No. 6/7/2018-Gen/WB (OFB) Shri R.P. Biswas, Ex-ASO/OFB complained about enormous delay in allowing pension. Matter was taken up and subsequently, the pension order was released and the pensioner now getting his pensions w.e.f. 11.07.2018. File No. 6/7/2/2018-Gen/WB (ER) Shri Pintu Biswas, Ch.OS/TRS/Sealdah Division, Eastern Railway, Kolkata had complained about non-fixation of his current scale / pay band by his office. Matter was taken up and subsequently the scale was correctly fixed and also promoted him due to his seniority in the cadre.
Salary / Arrear Payment matters:
File No. 9/31/2017-Gen/WB (Edu. Deptt.) Smt. Sristry Ghimiry, Asstt. Professor, Department of English, Budge Budge College complained about withholding of her salary by the College. Matter was taken up and subsequently she has been paid all her salary with arrears amounting to Rs. 5,60,784/-. File No. 8/38/2018-Gen/WB (ECL)
119 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri Tanku Bhuiya, Ex-UG Loader, Shyamsundar Colliery, ECL complained about non- payment of pension. Matter was taken up and according to an action taken report received, Shri Bhuiya is being paid Rs. 1,417/- as monthly pension and Rs. 1,38,893/- as arrears of pension by ECL. File No. 6/26/2019-Gen/WB (SER) It was complained that MACP was not granted to Shri Chitta Sahis, MSW (H.K.A.) Med/ADA, S.E. Railway due to D&A case against him. Matter was taken up and subsequently the case was decided and Shri Sahis was allowed MACP and his pay was re- fixed. File No. 8/4/2019-Gen/OR (EPFO) Shri Jitendra Kumar Jena, AO (Retd.), EPFO, Bhubaneswar complained about non-receipt of part pension payment. Matter was taken up and subsequently EPFO, Bhubaneswar informed that due payment of Rs. 3.08 lakh was paid to his bank account. File No. 8/13/2018-Gen/OR (OGB) Shri Karunakaran Sethy, Retd. Employee of Odisha Gramya Bank complained about non- payment of his retirement dues by the bank. Matter was taken up and subsequently the Bank informed that all his residual claims of Rs. 7687/- were paid to his bank account. Transfer matters:
File No. 8/16/2019-Gen/WB (IB) Ms. Narayani Biswas, Special Assistant, Indian Bank, Seerampore Branch, West Bengal complained about her denial of promotion and home posting. Matter was taken up and the Bank vide letter dated 23.09.2019 informed that she has been promoted as Assistant Manager and posted at Chinsurah Branch which is nearest to her home. File No. 8/23/2019-Gen/WB (IB) Shri Shashi Bhusan Halder, Sub-staff, Indian Bank, Bankura Branch sought his transfer at Kolkata zone owing to personal reasons. Matter was taken up and the Bank vide letter dated 18.12.2019 informed that his request has been considered. File No. 9/5/2017-Gen/WB (Edu.Deptt.) Smt. Chaitali Sarkar, Assistant Teacher, Sultannagar Hasina High School submitted her prayer for transfer to another school nearer to her home. Matter was taken up and s
120 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
tubsequentlyhe Education Department, Government of West Bengal informed on 22.07.2019 that her prayer has been considered favourably.
Promotion matters:
File No. 9/2/2019-Gen/OR (VSSUT) Shri Chandan Kumar Seth, Junior Assistant, Vir Surendra Sai University of Technology, Burla, District Sambalpur, Orissa complained about denial of his promotion to the post of Senior Assistant. Matter was taken up and subsequently it has been informed that Shri Jena was promoted to the post w.e.f. 20.04.2019.
Harassment matters:
File No. 810/2019-Gen/OR (SBI) Shri Ashok Kumar Behera, Manager (FI), State Bank of India, LHO, Bhubaneswar complained about mental harassment. Matter was taken up and the Bank report informed that Shri Behera has been transferred as Bank Officer at E.O.W., Crime Branch, Bhubaneswar vide Order dated 17.09.2019.
Miscellaneous matters:
File No. 6/23/2018-Gen/WM (NATMO) Smt. Bandana Sur, Scientific Officer, NATMO, Kolkata complained about non-granting of Child Care Leave due to her. Matter was taken up and subsequently the office informed that her leave was regularised as child care leave. File No. 8/17/2019-Gen/OR (Berhampur Univ.) A mass representation was received from the SC/ST teaching faculty regarding denial of re-designation of posts from Lecturers to Assistant Professor by the Berhampur University, Orissa. The matter was taken up and the University vide letter dated 24.12.2019 informed that all posts of lecturers re-designated as Assistant Professors in the University as per UGC guidelines.
121 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
2.3.2.6 State Office : Lucknow 2019-20
Reinstatement in service matters: File No. 2/178/2016- Gen. Services of Shri Manish Kumar were terminated by Dr. A.P.J. Abdul Kalam Technical University, Lucknow. Matter was taken up with Chancellor/Governor of AKTU. After intervention of the Commission NCSC, the termination order was quashed and Shri Manish has been reinstated in service in AKTU.
Payment of Retirement Benefits matters:
File No. 1/10/2019-Gen. The case of Shri Ram Dulare , Trackman , NE Railway regarding payment of his pension in low pay scale despite of pay his up gradation in scale of Rs 5200-20200 GP 2000, was taken up with the Sr. Divisional Finance Manager, Lucknow. His pension was upgraded to the new pay scale.
Transfer matters: File No. 1/12/2019-Gen.
Transfer of Shri P.S.Ratan K. Rao, S.S., NER was cancelled and he was reinstated in his earlier position and place.
File No. 1/16/2019-Gen.
Smt. Neelam , Northern Railway complained of caste based harassment and transfer. S After intervention and pursuance by this office, petitioner Smt. Neelam was posted near her home town.
HBA Loan No Dues Case. File No. 1/11/2019-Gen.
Shri Surendra Nath Ram , SSO in O/o Sr. Divisional Finance Manager, Northern Railway, Lucknow submitted an application to this office regarding issue of no dues for HBA Loan
122 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
.The matter taken up and the No Dues for HBA Loan sent by his previous office was obtained and the issue resolved.
2.3.2.7 State Office : Patna 2019-20
Appointment matters:
File No.-6/1/2018-J
Shri Santosh Bhuiya S/o Dasiya Bhuini (Ex. Wagon loader), Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. Dhanbad had given a petition to the commission requesting for compassionate appointment. After the intervention of NCSC, he had been appointed as trainee as per requirement in UG/Surface on initial basic wage of category 1.
False caste certificate:
File No.-8/2/2018-B
A representation from Shri Ram Prawesh Ram resident of road no- 14 Adarsh Nagar, New Dashratha, Anishabad, Patna was received in this office regarding a person named Mahesh Prasad S/o Krishna Prasad who was working as Higher Grade Assistant, Branch office II, Chapra under Patna II division with LIC on the basis of false caste certificate. Due to intervention of the Commission it was found that Shri Mahesh Prasad had gained wrongful employment in the service under reserved category though he did not belong to the reserved category. His caste certificate was later cancelled by the competent authority, his service has been terminated by LIC, proper departmental proceedings have been initiated and a chargesheet has also been filed against him.
File No.-12/40/2019-B
Ms. Anita Kumari, D/o Shri Vishesh Ram Kaler, Arwal, Bihar complained regarding non payment for her cultural performance at Auliya Adhyatmik Anusandhan Kendra conducted by Art, Culture and Youth Department, GoB. The matter was taken up and a letter to this regard was issued to the Secretary, Art Culture and Youth Department, GoB. Due to the intervention of the commission full payment for the cultural performance has now been made to Ms. Anita Kumari.
123 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
2.3.2.8(a) State Office : Pune 2018-19
Promotion matters: File No. – NCSC/Pune/12/2017-SSW-II The case of Shri. S. J. Khobragade, Senior Manager, Bank of Maharashtra, regarding APAR report and non promotion was taken up with CMD of the bank who reported that the petitioner was promoted to the post of Chief Manager.
File No – NCSC/Pune/18/2017-SSW-II The case of Smt. Rekha Satpute, Supervisor, PWD ,Government of Maharashtra (GoM), was taken up and petitioner was given promotion and transfer and posting at Pune.
Compassionate appointment matters:
File No NCSC/Pune 9/2017-SSW-I The case of Smt. Radhadevi Koli, regarding compassionate appointment of her son in group III post was taken up with the Western Railway ,Mumbai. Her son was given appointment to the post of Jr. Account Assistant . File No NCSC/Pune/18/2018-SSW-II The case of Shri Ranjana J Moon, regarding compassionate appointment was taken up with Secretary, Social Welfare, GoM and the,petitioner was appointed as a helper.
Pensionery /terminal benefits ,other dues/ miscellaneous matters:
File No. NCSC Pune/14/2017-SSW-I
The case of Shri S. R. Kamble regarding non receipt of terminal benefits from CDA Allahabad was taken up on 22.10.2018. Petitioner intimated that he had received the terminal benefits of Rs 36 lakh. File No. NCSC Pune/ 30/2017-SSW-I
124 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri Rajesh Mandpe regarding non payment of pension from Principal Chief Income Tax Commissioner was taken up on 04.04.2018 who intimated that all the terminal benefits were released.
Transfer and harassment matters:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/17/2017 SSW-II The case of Shri Dharvendra Kumar regarding transfer on health ground was taken up with AAI. The authority intimated that the petitioner is transferred to Allahabad on health grounds. File No. NCSC/PUNE/16/2017 SSSW-II The case of Smt. Darashana Rangari, regarding transfer to Pune was taken up with IDBI Bank who intimated that she was transferred to Pune.
Suspension , re-instatement and miscellaneous matters:
NCSC/Pune/01/2017-SSW- IV
The case of Shri Bharat Reshwal, regarding non-payment of regular pay scale of Assistant Teacher was taken up with the CEO, ZP Jalgaon and Education Officer Jalgaon. The Education Officer replied that his services were regularized as Shikshan Sevak and he was given the regular pay scale of assistant teacher . 2.3.2.8(b) State Office : Pune 2019-20
Non-payment of salary:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/11/2018/ SSW-IV
Shri. Umakant Shelke, Assistant Teacher in Pratibha Pawar Vidya Mandir, Pune, Maharashtra complained on 02.06.2018 regarding non-payment of change in pay scale and redesignated post of Shikshan Sevak to assistant teacher. Due to our intervention on 19.09.2018 with Education Department, Pune Division the Department intimated on 22.05.2019 that his payment till April 2019 was released , and his designation was changed to Assistant Teacher.
125 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Compassionate Appointment matters:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/30/2018/SSW-III
Smt Seema Balram Lakhan, Somwarpeth, Pune, Maharashtra complained on 19.01.2019 regarding compassionate appointment in Sasoon Hospital Pune. The matter was taken up with Secretary Medical Education and Drug Department who replied on 25.02.2019 that the petitioner was appointed on compassionate grounds on 21.07.2019 as a junior clerk on pay band Rs. 19900-63200.
Transfer matters:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/08/2019/SSW-II
Shri Uddhav Madhav Deshmukh, Savedi, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra requested on 03.09.2019 for modifying his transfer orders. The matter was taken up with General Manager, Central Bank of India on 03.09.2019. The petitioner was transferred to Wambori Branch, Ahmednagar on 24.09.2019.
Pre-promotional Training
File No. NCSC/PUNE/02/2019/SSW-II
Shri Ramesh Tupe, Secretary, Bank of Maharashtra, complained on 30.03.2019 regarding not providing of pre-promotional training for promotion from Scale I to IV. Bank intimated that pre promotional training was organized in the 2nd week of April 2019.
Re-instate in Service
File No. NCSC/PUNE/18/2018/SSW-IV
Shri Prakash Kamble , Barshi, Sholapur, Maharashtra on 20.11.2018 requested reinstatement as part time teacher. The matter was taken up with Secretary of Barshi Education Society, who on 22.08.2019 intimated that the petitioner was reinstated in service as a part time assistant teacher and the due payment of 1 month salary was released.
2.3.2.9(a) State Office: Trivandrum 2018-19
Up-gradation of Pay Scale matters:
126 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No: KL/12/2/2018
The case of Shri.K.K.Velayudhan, Retired Assistant Engineer ( C ) regarding up gradation of pay scale was taken up with Director, Lighthouse and ships who granted eligible financial up gradation and paid the eligible amount of Rs.3241/- to petitioner.
to petitioner.
Appointment matters: File No: KL/12/29/2017
The case of Shri Praveen Kumar appointment of adhoc Office Assistant was taken up with Registrar, National Institute of Technology, Calicut who then conducted special drive for recruitment of candidate from SC/ST category for engaging them on contract as office assistants.
File No: KL/15/O/SEP/9/2018
The case of Shri. Sahjumon Thrissur regarding non implementation of reservation in appointment of Assistant Engineers and Data Entry Operators etc for the National Rural Employment Guarantee Programme was taken up with Principal Secretary, SC/ST department . Secretary, Local Self Government issued an order pertaining to implementation of reservation in appointment of contract workers i.e 8% for SCs and 2% for STs.
Transfer matters: File No: KL/12/24/2017
The case of Shri. K.Biju, Lavanam, Ambalappuzha Devaswom regarding transfer was taken up with Secretary, Devasom department who transferred petitioner to Trivandrum Devasom board on medical ground.
File No: KL/12/36/2018
127 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Smt. Omana hails from Kannur regarding transferwas taken up with District Medical Officer, Kannur who promoted her in the cadre of Hospital attendent grade –I and posted her at Thalassery hospital.
Compassionate appointment matters: File No: KL/12/8/2017
The case of Smt. Anila , Trivandrum regarding compassionate appointment in Homoeo department was taken up. After the intervention of this office, the department offered appointment on compassionate ground to petitioner. 2.3.2.9(b) State Office: Trivandrum 2019-20
Appointment matter: File No.KL/12/5/2019(HQrs)
The petitioner Ms. Ananda.S., Sabrukaje, Nettanige Post, Kasaragod requested action to fill up the post of High School Assistant, Social Science (Kannada Medium) from SC pending list in the district. After the intervention of this office, Principal Secretary, General Education Department appointed the petitioner in G.H.S.S. Pandi as HAS in Kasaragod.
File No.KL/12/49/2018
Shri.Sandeep.S., H.No.48/59(N), Saskrithi Garden, Pottakuzhy Road, Elamakkara PO, Ernakulam complainedregarding denial of candidature as Probationary Station Master , Southern Railway due to inconsistent vision standards.After our intervention, the case was referred to AIIMS, New Delhi for conducting vision test. and on examination and his vision was recorded within normal limits. Southern Railway accepted the findings of AIIMS and proceeded with appointment/training procedure for recruitment.
Transfer matters:
File No.KL/12/36/2018
The petitioner Smt. Omana.V.K., Mohanam, Cherickal, Narathu PO, Kannur requested for transfer on medical ground. After intervention of this office, District Medical Officer,
128 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Kannur reconsidered the case and transferred the aggrieved petitioner to Kannur as Nursing Assistant.
File No.KL/12/13/2017
Shri. V. Raghavan, Vadakkothu (H), Kozhikode requested transfer to home town. Due to the intervention of this office Chairman & Managing Director, KSRTC, transferred the petitioner to his hometown.
Suspension and reinstatement in service matters: File No. KL/12/18/2018
The petitioner Shri.K. Satheesh Kumar, Top division, Gundmalai, Munnar P.O., Idukki requested regarding reinstatement into service of Kerala Hydel Tourism Centre. Due to the intervention of this office, Director, Kerala Hydel tourism Centre finalized the disciplinary proceedings initiated against the petitioner and he was reinstated as cashier on 26.9.2019 at Idukki Unit.
Payment of Wages matters: File No.KL/12/31/2017
Smt. Anandabeena, Madthiparambil house, Ayodhya Nagar, Thrissur and Smt. Saraswathy represented regarding denial of EPF, minimum wages, gratuity and bonus by the agency through which they have engaged for cleaning work for seven years in the Institute of CEMET. After the intervention of this office, Labour Enforcement Officer, Kochi issued show cause and the contractor has paid the difference of wages and bonus of an amount of Rs 0.60496 lakh to petitioners.
Closure of GPF and get back amount matters: File No.KL/12/25/2017
129 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Smt. K.K. Thankamma, Punthala, Kizhakethil, Ennakkad, Changannur, Alappuzha requested regarding payment of her GPF account. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Department initiated action for payment of her GPF of Rs 2 lakh.
2.4. Economic and Social Development cases :
The Commission received a large number of cases in the economic and social development sector and a total of 2940 cases ( 678 in 2018-19 and 2262 in 2019-20 respectively )relating to this sector were disposed off by the Commission in 2018-19 and 2019-20 .
In 180 cases of the economic and social sector wing, after the intervention the NCSC ,09 students got admission in courses of their choice , 10 students received due scholarship /tuition fee reimbursement , 20 students received their held back degree / certificates , 70 persons got possession of land / plots /flats , 29 persons received benefits under the various welfare schemes of the Central/ State Governments. 41 persons received miscellaneous benefits like loans etc matters like loans etc , 1 person received a petrol pump , leading to a total monetary benefit of Rs 1041.94 lakh.The details are as below :
Table 2.3
Sr. Subject NCSC Hqrs NCSC State Office No.
No. of Benefits to No. of Benefits to Interesting beneficiary Interesting beneficiary cases in Rs. cases 1. Admission 01 - 08 - matters 2. Scholarship 06 12,24,600/- 04 15,95,000 matters/fee concession 3. Possession of 09 - 61 land/plot/Flat 8,29,70,000/-
130 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
4. Benefit under 01 50,000/- 28 Rs. SC Schemes 20,62,000/- 5. Allotment of - - 1 - petrol pump 6. Education/Degr - - 20 8,26,000/- ee and certificate issuance matters 7. Miscellaneous 04 20,94,488/- 37 1,33,72,000/- matters like Loan etc Total 21 33,69,088/- 159 10,08,25,000 /-
2.4.1(a) NCSC Headquarters: 2018-19
Scholarship matter/fee concession:
File No. 16/58/Delhi/2017/ESDW
The case of Shri Jitendra Kumar R/o WZ-232, Lajwanti Garden, New Delhi-46 regarding non payment of scholarship to his daughter for the session 2015-16 for the course B. Tech (IT) was taken up with Department SC/ST/OBC Welfare, GNCTD. After intervention of the Commission, a difference of Rs 2160/- of scholarship has been released. File No. 16/51/Delhi/2017/ESDW
The case of Shri Govind Paswan, R/o B 308, Rajiv Gandhi Camp, ChitraVihar, Delhi regarding denial of Rajiv Gandhi National Fellowship for PhD due to gap year was taken up with Vice Chancellor, Jamia Hamdard University and University Grant Commission. UGC released the scholarship.
Possession of land/ plot/ flat:
131 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 14/107/Bihar/2017/ESDW
Shri Amarjeet Paswan R/o Lodipurkhurd, Post Sadar, Bhagalpur, Bihar represented regarding denial of possession of a land in the village. The matter was taken up District Magistrate, Bhagalpur, Bihar and the petitioner has been provided possession of a land.
File No. 14/137/U.P/2018/ESDW
The matter of Shri Mahesh Chand Chaudhary R/o H.No. 59, B, Havelaram Ki Bagiya, Friends Colony, District Etawah, UP regarding nonpayment of retirement benefits was taken up with Principal Secretary Department of Revenue, GoUP, DM Etawah & Commissioner Consolidation, Lucknow. The retirement benefits of Rs. 3.34 lakh and Rs. 0.64 lakh leave encashment have been paid.
File No. 14/3/U.P/2017/ESDW
The case of Shri Fakir Chand R/o 709/18, Aadarsh Nagar, Bulandshahar, UP, regarding denial of possession of a land was taken up with DM Bulandshahar. The possession of the land has been given to the petitioner.
File No. 14/36/Raj./2018/ESDW
The matter of Shri Sonuram R/o Snchaud, Alwar, Rajasthan regarding non demarcation of land and possession was taken up with District Collector Alwar, Rajasthan. After intervention of Commission petitioner has been provided possession of land.
File No. 14/173/Bihar/2017/ESDW
The matter of Shri Rajuram R/o Kochar, Aurangabad, Bihar regarding non demarcation of land and possession was taken up with DM Aurangabad, Bihar. After intervention of Commission petitioner has been provided possession of land.
File No. 14/205/UP/2018/ESDW
The matter of Shri Jawar Singh Katheria, R/o Jawapur, Mainpuri, UP regarding dispossession from land was taken up with the DM Mainpuri. After intervention of the Commission the petitioner has been given the possession of the land and his grievance has been solved.
132 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 14/82/UP/2018/ESDW
The case of Shri Amar Singh Katheria R/o Jaranikalan, Jalesar, Etah, UP regarding encroachment of land was taken up with the DM Hathras, UP. The possession of land has been given to the petitioner after intervention of the Commission.
File No. 24/292/Misc/UP/2018/ESDW
The case of Shri Birendra Prasad R/o Type 3, H. No. 31, Uttarakhand regarding allotment of Government Accommodation was taken up the Secretary, State Sampatti Anubhag, Uttarakhand. After intervention of the Commission , the petitioner has been allotted a type 4 house.
File No. 14/161/Bihar/2018/ESDW
The case of Shri Sunil Kumar, Baliya, Kothi, Chhapra(Saran), Bihar regarding non demarcation of land was taken up with DM, Chhapra (Saran) and after intervention of the Commission the demarcation of the land has been completed.
Miscellaneous matters like Loan etc:
File No. 24/2/Misc/U.P/2018/ESDW
The case of Smt. Anita W/o Shri Mahendra Pal R/o Pabi Sarakpur, Silver City, Loni, Gaziabad, UP regarding payment of compensation on death of his niece due to shock from loose electrical wire was taken up with DM and SSP, Gaziabad and MD Paschimachal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd.. The Paschimachal Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd made a payment of Rs. 5 lakh as compensation. File No. 14/164/UP/2018/ESDW
The case of Shri Satish Kumar R/o 24, Hanuman Nagar, Bodla Road, Agra, UP regarding rejection of consignment and denial of NOC by the Animal Quarantine & Certification Services, (AQCS), Kapashera, Delhi was taken up with Joint Secretary (Trade) & JS (LH) DADF. After intervention of the Commission the rejected consignments have been released and NOC has been given to him.
File No. 4/79/Misc/UP/2018/ESDW
133 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri Shiv Kumar R/o Akhtalyarpur Dhaukal, Bhanmi, Shahjahanpur, UP regarding fake electricity bill and fake loan taken by unknown person in his name was taken up with the DM Shahjahanpur and Secretary, Department of Cooperatives. After intervention of the Commission his electricity bill and loan matter were settled and possession of land has been provided to him.
File No. 16/92/Jharkhand/2018/ESDW The case of Shri Krishna Paswan R/o NBC Coloni, Dhanbad, Jharkhand regarding correction of date of birth certificate in service record was taken up with Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. Dhanbad, Jharkhand. After intervention of the Commission petitioner's date of birth has been corrected in service record. 2.4.1(b) NCSC Headquarters: 2019-20
Admission matters:
File No. 16/79/Delhi/2019-ESDW
Shri Hardhik Kumar, s/o Shri Rajesh Kumar, H.No.40A, Pocket-C, Siddhartha Extension, New Delhi submitted representation that Mahavir Swami Institute of Technology (MSIT) cancelled his admission in B.Tech (CS) and had not refunded admission fee of Rs.0.96 lakh The matter was taken up with Managing Director (MSIT). Admission amount was returned to the petitioner.
Scholarship matter:
File No.16/83/UP/2018/ESDW
Shri Ankit Verma, s/o Shri Jagatnarayan Verma, Vill-Asoha, Unnao, UP submitted a representation that he has not been given scholarship for Commercial Pilot Licence (CPL). Matter was taken up with the Principal Secretary, Social Welfare Department, GoUPand the District Magistrate, Unnao. Scholarship amount of Rs. 10.995 lakh was paid to the petitioner.
Miscellaneous matters:
File No.18/5/Delhi/2018/ESDW
134 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri Mahendra Singh and Shri Tara Siingh, s/o Shri Master Aaskaran, 8871/14G.F., Shidipura, Karol Bagh, New Delhi submitted representation that they had taken a loan of Rs.12 lakh from Central Bank of India, Shaliar Bagh Branch, New Delhi but due to slump in market they could not succeed in their rozgar and so could not pay all the EMI in time, bank has taken possession of the house mortgaged. The matter was taken up with the CMD, Central Bank of India. As against the bank’s claim of Rs. 10.50 lakh for one time settlement (OTS), the matter was solved for OTS at Rs. 10 lakh but paid in installments. Petitioners made payment of Rs.10 lakh and bank returned papers of the house and gave NOC.
File No. 24/31/Misc./HR/2019/ESDW
16 Persons from Dr.Ambedkar Dali Samaj Sangathan, Naya Gaon, Birbarktabad, Jhajjhar, Haryana submitted representation that supply of drinking water has been stopped. The matter was taken up with the DM Jhajjhar. Drinking water water supply was provided to the petitioners.
File No. 24/102/Misc./Delhi/2019/ESDW
Shri Tika Ram, 135-C, Pocket-A, Phase-02, Mayur Vihar, Delhi submitted a representation that Canara Bank has wrongly deducted amount from his account for Life Insurance Policy. Matter was taken up with the CEO, Canara Bank. Entire amount of Rs. 2 lakh was refunded by Canara HSBC OBC Life Insurance Company Limited to the petitioner.
File No. 24/238/Misc./UK/2018-ESDW
Smt. Meenakshi, w/o Shri Naresh Kumar, Tunalka, Naugaib, Uttarkashi, Uttarakhand submitted representation that she has not got incentive for inter-caste/inter-religion marriage. The matter was taken up with DM ,Uttarkashi. Incentive amount of Rs. 0.50 lakh was paid to the petitioner.
2.4.2 NCSC State Office
2.4.2.1 State office: Ahmedabad
Scholarship matters/Fee concession:
135 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. NCSC/ABAD/R/46/APCR-2018
The case of Shree Arjun Shih S/o Shree Shanakar Lal on 23.06.018 regarding non refund of fees was taken up with Oasis Sainik School. The school, on 01.10.2018 had intimated that fees Rs. 0.79 lakh have been refunded.
Miscllaneous matters , loans etc:
File No. NCSC/ABAD/R/31/ESDW-2018
The case of Shri Hariram Balai on 24.06.2018 regarding financial assistance was taken up with the DC Sikar. The petitioner received Rs. 4.67 lakh as compensation from CM financial assistance.
Possession of land/plot/Flat :
File No. NCSC/ABAD/R/14/ESDW-2017
The case of Smt. Shumitradevi w/o Shree Ratanlal, regarding non possession of land was taken up with the district collector of Alwar on 12/09/2018, The replay received from the DC Alwar stated that the matter was solved and possession of land given to the petitioner.
File No. NCSC/ABAD/R/104/APCR -2018
The case if Shri Mangalala Chogalala Balai on 28/09/2018 regarding illegal grabbing of his land was taken up with DC, Bhilwara. The reply received that the matter was solved and the petitioner requested to close his case file.
2.4.2.2(a) State Office : Bangaluru 2018-19
File No. 46/ESDW/30/18-RU Petitioner Smt. Pilla Nagamma, r/o Bengaluru( rural) submitted a petition regarding land based harassment was resolved amicably after we refeered it to the police. File No. 46/ESDW/25/18-RU Smt. Manjula, w/o Ravikar, r/o Gangavati Taluk, Bidar submitted a petition regarding land dispute and cheating of Rs.36 lakhs .The case was referred to SP, Bidar. Report received
136 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
that police held meeting with accused and victim and settled the dispute with the accused agreeing to pay Rs 40 lakhs and also paid an advance of Rs. 10 lakhs.
2.4.2.2(b) State Office : Bangaluru 2019-20
Possession of land/plot/Flat:
File No. 47/ESDW/7/2019-RU: Smt.Kanakamma, Mandya represented regarding un-authorized construction on her site at Siddaharatha Nagar, Mandya. After intervention of this Commission, Revenue officials have verified the land documents and registered the land to Smt.Kanakamma. File No. 02/APCR/37/19-RU: Shri M.A.Venkatesh, s/o.Late Muniswamy, Bangalore represented regarding nonpayment of wages for his labour work by Shan Bhogh Hotel Management, Bangalore. The matter was taken up with DCP, Bangalore West Division & District Labour Welfare Officer, Bangalore. After intervention of this office the petitioner received his payment of Rs.0.10 lakh.
2.4.2.3 State office: Chandigarh
File No. 5-Hry/9/2019
Sri Kailash village Road Tehsil , Kaithal, Haryana brought to the notice of this Commission that SC BPL family who are sanctioned small loans have to pay Rs 8000/- as stamp duty to complete the formalities for disbursement of loans. Matter was referred to Chief Secretary, Haryana. After our intervention Government of Haryana issued a notification on 09.03.2019 exempting the borrower of SC BPL families from paying stamp duty.
2.4.2.4(a) State Office: Chennai 2018-19
Admission matters:
File No. 4/41/2018 Rep.
137 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Kum. N. Jayachithira, Salem ,regarding permission for registering Ph.D in was taken up with the Registrar, Periyar University, Salem on 22.5.2018. The petitioner has joined Ph.D course in the Department of Computer Science in the University on 13.6.2018.
File No. 3/14/2018 Rep.
The case of Kum.P.Puratchiselvi, Cuddalore, regarding admission in Government Adi Dravidar Welfare Girls Hostel, Saidapet, Chennai was taken up with the Director, Adi Dravidar Welfare, Chennai on 25.1.2018. The petitioner has been admitted in the Government Adi Dravidar Welfare Girls Hostel, Saidapet, Chennai
Possession of land / plot / flat / house:
File No. 6/94/2017 Rep.
The case of Shri.S.Murugesan, Thiruvannamalai regarding denial of funds for construction of house under Group House Scheme was taken up with the DC, Thiruvannamalai.The petitioner on 01.02.2019 informed that Rs 1.80 lakh has been sanctioned for construction of his house.
File No. 6/145/2018 Rep.
The representation of Smt.Pavithra, Coimbatore regarding allotment of houses to 54 SCs was taken up with the Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board, Chennai and the District Collector, Coimbatore. 54 SC beneficiaries including the petitioner were allotted tenements at Coimbatore.
Education / Degree and Certificate issuance matters:
File No. 4/37/2018 Rep.
The case of Kum.S.Jaishree, Krishnagiri regarding delay in issue of Transfer Certificate by Adhiyaman College of Engineering, Hosur was taken up with the Principal. The petitioner has been issued Transfer Certificate on 08.06.2018.
Miscellaneous matters:
Loan matters:
File No. 8/76/2018 Rep.
138 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri. E. Sivaraj, Thiruvallur regarding non-sanction of TAHDCO loan by Andhra Bank, Manavala Nagar Branch was taken up with the Zonal Manager of the Bank,. The petitioner has been sanctioned TAHDCO loan on 21.06.2018.
File No. 8/73/2018 Rep.
The case of Shri.N.Arumugam, Pallikaranai, Chennai regarding repayment of education loan of his son to SBI, Alwarpet Branch, Chennai was taken up with the Chief General Manager, SBI Chennai on 29.05.2018. The petitioner was allowed to pay back the education loan in eight monthly instalments.
File No. 8/96/2018 Rep.
The case of Shri.M.Kandeepan, Thiruvannamalai regarding delay in sanction of TAHDCO loan by Indian Bank, Kilkodungalur Branch was taken up with the Managing Director, Indian Bank,. The petitioner was sanctioned Rs 9.13 lakh loan on 01.02.2019 for centering work materials business.
File No. 8/131/2017 Rep.
The case of Shri.A.Aravindan, Thiruvallur regarding non sanction of TAHDCO loan by SBI, Thirunindravur Branch. The matter was taken up with the Chief General Manager, SBI. The petitioner was sanctioned a loan of Rs 5.55 lakh for purchase of a car for transit purpose.
File No. 8/163/2018 Rep. The case of Ms.S.Keerthana, Salem regarding non-sanction of education loan by Indian Bank, Salem was taken up with the Managing Director of the Bank. The petitioner was sanctioned a loan of Rs 0.63 lakh as fourth and final year education loan on 26.12.2018.
E.B connection:
File No: 10/133/2018 Rep. The case of Shri.Sadhappa, Krishnagiri regarding delay in providing electricity connection to his agricultural land under TAHDCO scheme was taken up with the District Collector,
139 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Krishnagiri. The petitioner has been given E.B connection under fast track power supply scheme on 29.09.2018.
Subsidy for Temple:
File No: 10/278/2017 Rep The case of Shri A.K.Sivaraman, Tiruppur regarding non-disbursement of Rs.1.00 Lakh for temple construction by the Hindu Religious Charitable & Endowment Board was taken up with the Commissioner, Board, Chennai. The subsidy amount of Rs.1.00 Lakh was sanctioned for the construction of temple as requested by the petitioner.
Sanction from CMs Relief fund:
File No: 10/7/2018 Rep The request of Smt.V.Karpagam, Vellore for financial help from CM relief fund for death of her husband due to snake bite was taken up with the DC, Vellore .The petitioner has been paid Rs 0.50 lakh from the CMs Relief Fund on 09.01.2019.
2.4.2.4(b) State Office: Chennai 2019-20
Admission cases: File No. 4/69/2019 Rep.
Smt Rajitha, Chennai submitted a representation regarding denial of registration in Ph.D Program in University of Madras, Chennai. The matter was taken up with the Registrar, University of Madras, Chennai on 11.07.2019 and was continuously followed up. As per the reply of the Registrar, the petitioner had been admitted and joined Ph.D program in the Department of Bio-Chemistry in University of Madras, Chennai
Possession of land / plot / flat / house
File No. 6/145/2018 Rep.
Smt Pavithra, Sithaputhur, Coimbatore, TN in her representation dated 08.11.2018 complained that 54 persons were left out in the list of beneficiaries for provision of houses
140 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
through Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board (TNSCB). The matter was taken up with the Managing Director, Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board, Chennai and with the District Collector, Coimbatore on 19.11.2018. During the hearing at NCSC on 07.12.2018, it was informed that all the 54 SCs were allotted with tenements by the Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board at Coimbatore.
Miscellaneous matters:
Loan:
File No: 8/129/2019 Rep.
Shri M. Sundaram, Chennai,TN complained on 07.10.2019 on the unwarranted delay in sanction of education loan to his son for his overseas studies by Indian Bank. The matter was taken up with the Managing Director, Indian Bank, Chennai on 23.10.2019. As per the reply received from the Deputy General Manager (Retail Assets), Indian Bank, Chennai, the petitioner’s son was sanctioned an education loan of Rs.18.00 lakh.
File No: 8/155/2018 Rep.
Shri G.Vijayakumar, Nolambur, Chennai,TN complained to NCSC on the denial of TAHDCO loan by Indian Bank, Nolambur. The case was taken up with the Chairman & Managing Director, Indian Bank, Chennai on 07.11.2018. As per the letter dated 31.03.2019 of the petitioner, it was learnt that he has been sanctioned a TAHDCO loan of Rs.6.59 lakh for purchase of vehicle.
File No: 8/42/2019 Rep.
Shri Mariyappan, Salem , TN represented regarding non-sanction of TAHDCO loan by Indian Overseas Bank, Udiyapatti Branch. The matter was taken up with the Managing Director, Indian Overseas Bank, Chennai on 16.04.2019. As per the reply dated 24.05.2019 of the Deputy General Manager, Indian Overseas Bank, Chennai, the petitioner was sanctioned TAHDCO loan of Rs.9.86 lakh for a diary unit.
File No: 8/111/2019 Rep.
Shri Dilli Babu, Chennai complained on 05.09.2019 regarding denial of TAHDCO loan by Indian Bank, Chennai on caste grounds. The matter was taken up with the Commissioner
141 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
of Police, Chennai and with the Managing Director, Indian Bank, Corporate Office, Chennai on 05.09.2019. As per the reply received from the Assistant General Manager (MSME), Indian Bank, Corporate Office, Chennai, the petitioner was sanctioned TAHDCO loan of Rs.9.18 Lakh by the concerned branch of Indian Bank.
File No: 8/141/2019 Rep.
Shri D.Sundararajan, Thiruvallur District represented on 23.10.2019 on the delay in sanction of TAHDCO loan by Indian Bank, Tiruttani Branch. The case was taken up with the Managing Director, Indian Bank, Corporate Office, Chennai on 12.12.2019. As per the reply dated 07.01.2020 received from the Officers of Indian Bank, Corporate Office, Chennai, the petitioner was sanctioned Rs.11.21 Lakh TAHDCO loan by the concerned branch of Indian Bank
Disability pension:
File No: 10/11/2018 Rep.
Smt G.Shanthi, Kundalapuliyur, Villupuram ,TN represented on 21.12.2017 on the denial of disability pension to her mentally retarded daughter. The matter was taken up with the District Collector, Villlupuram and with the Secretary, Differently Abled Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, on 16.01.2018. A reply was received from the District Differently Abled Persons Welfare Office, Villupuram District stating that the petitioner’s daughter was sanctioned Rs.16,500/- i.e the pending pension amount from Feburary to December 2017 @ Rs.1500/- per month for 11 months.
Marriage assistance:
File No: 10/4/2018
Shri Mylan, Kundalapuliyur, Villupuram ,TN complained regarding the delay in sanction of marriage financial assistance for his son under the ‘Uzhavar Padhukappu Scheme’. The plea was taken up with the District Collector, Villupuram on 02.01.2018 and was followed up. A reply was received from the DC, Villupuram stating that the petitioner was sanctioned Rs.8,000/- as marriage financial assistance .
Empanelment as member in the District Child Welfare Committee:
142 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No: 3/218/2019 Rep.
Shri B. Pandiaraja, Madurai had represented for nomination as member in the District Child Welfare Committee, Madurai. The matter was taken up with the Secretary, Social Welfare Department, Government of Tamil Nadu, on 20.11.2018 and was continuously followed up with reminders. The petitioner vide his letter dated 25.10.2019 informed that he has been appointed on 19.09.2019 as a Member in the District Child Welfare Committee, Madurai.
Inclusion of water & sewer plan in the corporation map:
File No: 10/158/2018 Rep.
Shri S. Mohan, Padi, Thiruvallur ,TN complained on the non-inclusion of SC area of Kamaraj Nagar, Padi in the Chennai Tamil Nadu Water Supply & Drainage Board map. The matter was taken up with the Managing Director, TNWS&D Board and with the Commissioner, Chennai Corporation, on 14.11.2018. MD – TNWS&D informed on 29.01.2020 that the request of the petitioner was accepted and the Kamaraj Nagar area was included in their map for water and sewer plan.
Death Certificate:
File No: 3/12/2019 Rep.
Smt A. Kaleeswari, Dindigul, TN complained on the delay in issue of death certificate of her father who passed away in 2005. The case was taken up with the District Collector, Dindigul on 11.01.2019. As per the reply of the DC, the death certificate has been issued.
2.4.2.5(a) State Office: Hyderabad 2018-19
Admission matters:
File No. 5/7/18/TS-RU:
143 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri P. Srisailam regarding denial of admission to his child by Hindu Public School under best available School Scheme was taken up on 18.06.2018 with the Principal of the school .The child was admitted in class 1. File No. 6/31/17/TS-RU: The case of Kum. Swarnalatha, Nursing student regarding denial of allowing in examination, caste based abuse and harassment by College Principal was taken up on 13.11.2017 with the Commissioner of College Education,Telangana.The department vide their reply dated 30.08.2018 informed that the student was permitted by Dr.NTR Health University to appear for 3rd year nursing course in a private college, Suraram, Hyderabad.
File No. 5/1/18/CG-RU: The case of Kum. Jyoti Verma, M.Tech. student of National Institute of Technology, Raipur, Chhattisgarh regarding not being allowed to appear in M.Tech II semester exam was taken up with the Director, NIT, Raipur. The Director submitted a report that they have re-admitted petitioner.
Possessin of Land plot/flat:
File No. 2/40/18/TS-RU:
The case of Shri Vanam Sreenivas regarding filing of false complaint by police and seizure of his land documents was taken up with the Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad . The false case was closed and all original documents of property were handed over to petitioner. The market value of the property is approximately Rs. 7 crores, as informed by the petitioner.
File No. 2/123/18/TS-RU:
The case of Shri Palle Nadipanna of Bandarpally Village, Chinthakunta Mandal, Mahabubnagar , Telangana, regarding not getting possession of land in Sy. No.53 of Bandarpally (V) was taken up with the DM, Mahabubnagar . The petitioner got physical possession of his land . The market value of the property is approximately Rs. 1.25 crores, as informed by the petitioner.
144 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Benefits under SC Schemes:
File No. 2/7/18/MP-RU: The suo-moto case has been taken up regarding PMAY benefit denial with the DM, Vidisha on 14.02.2018. Commission received the information from DM,Vidisha Madhya Pradesh that they sanctioned PMAY assistance to 49 beneficiaries under PMAY.
Education/Degree and Certificate Issuance Matters:
File No. 5/8/18/AP-RU:
The representation of Dr R. Sukumar of Vijayawada, a PG student of Maharaja Institute of Medical Sciences regarding not being allowed to attend his examination by HoD was referred to Dr. NTR University of Health Sciences, Vijayawada. University solved the issue and submitted a report dated 18.09.2018 that the petitioner has been allowed to appear for exam after submission his dissertation.
File No. 5/2/19/TS-RU:
The case of Shri Salla Rameshwar Rao regarding loss of academic year and financial loss of his son a Class 12 student in Medak Campus of GTGS was taken up with DM Rangareddy, District Education Officer Keesara and the school . The reply dated 11.04.2019 received from the Principal, Geethanjali, Global School, Rangareddy, Telangana, stated that they arranged examination for the student which saved him two precious academic years in ICSE syllabus.
Miscellaneous matters like loans/ pensions etc.:
File No. 6/37/18/TS-RU:
The case of Smt. S. Madhavi, Hyderabad, Telangana regarding not receiving widow pension was taken up with DM Hyderabad The District Revenue Officer, Hyderabad replied vide their letter dated 03.12.2018 that her pension has been sanctioned.
145 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 5/10/18/AP-RU:
The case of Smt. Nathala Anitha, proprietor of Anitha Traders Ongole, regarding non sanction of loan by Manager, Bank of Maharashtra, Ongole Branch was taken up with CMD, Bank of Maharashtra. The Bank re-examined loan application and informed vide their letter dated 30.01.2019 that loan of Rs 29.75 lakh has been sanctioned to petitioner.
File No. 6/44/18/AP-RU:
The case of Shri Boddu Kotaiah, Somarajupalli, Prakasam regarding not getting the physically handicapped certificate and old age pension was taken up with DM Prakasam who informed that the disability certificate has been issued and pension of Rs. 1,000/- p.m. was also sanctioned to the petitioner from November 2018 onwards. 2.4.2.5(b) State Office: Hyderabad 2019-20
Scholarship/Fee Concession: F. No. 23/20/19/TS-RU: Representation received from Shri G. Krishnaiah S/o. Venpataiah, Kalamanaidupeta, Satyavedu (M), Chittoor, AP was for fee reimbursement for his son studying MBBS. Director , Social Welfare AP, sanctioned and disbursed fee reimbursement.
Possession of Land plot/flat:
F. No. 2/123/18/TS-RU:
Shri Palle Nadipanna of Bandarpally Village, Chinthakunta Mandal, Mahabubnagar , Telangana got physical possession of his land. F. No. 2/49/19/TS-RU2:
Representation from Smt. T. Saiamma, w/o. Late Gangaram, Nyalkal (V), Mopal (M), Nizamabad, Telangana was for removing encroachment of 3 acres of assigned land in Sy.No. 830/120. The district administration gave her possession of her 3 acres land vide report dated 13.01.2020. F. No. 2/47/19/TS-RU:
146 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Representation from Shri P. Jyothi Raju, s/o. Sattaiah, Nehrunagar (V), Yadapalli (M), Nizamabad, Telangana was regarding land matter. A case in Cr. No. 34/2019 U/s. 323, 506 IPC, Sec. 3(1)(r)(s)(g) and 3(2)(va) of PoA Act was lodged at Nizamabad Town VI PS. First instalment of monetary relief Rs. 0.50 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 2/141/16/AP-RU:
Representation received from Shri Beri Srinivasulu, Patturu (V), Khajipet (M), YSR Dist., Andhra Pradesh regarding financial assistance in Cr. No. 105/2016 of Khajipet PS u/s. 341, 506 r/w. 34 IPC and Sec. 3(1)(r)(s) of POA Act, 2015. Out of total monetary relief of Rs. 1,00,000/-, first instalment of Rs. 75,000/- paid to the victim on 02.01.2019. F. No. 2/83/19/TS-RU:
Representation from Shri Sarangi Nadipi Gangadhar, S/o.Pedda Sandanna, R/o.H.No.1- 1/3/8, Chepur, Armoor (M), Nizamabad District, Telangana – Regarding request to fix boundaries in Sy.No.375/A/7, S.No. 375/E/9/2 and Sy.No. 375/A/30 in Chepur as well as protection from harassment by Shapur Chinna Gangadhar vide FIR No.133/2019-Armoor PS u/s. 324, 323, 427 r/w. 34 IPC and Sec. 3(f)(s) of POA Act. After our interference, 75% of monetary relief of Rs. 75,000/- each to two victims and boundaries were also marked. F. No. 2/107/18/TS-RU:
Representation from Shri Banghi Lakshmanana, Kodangal Villge @ Mandal, Vikarabad Distrit,Telangana regarding land matter. a case in Cr. No. 67/2018 u/s. 447,427,506 IPCand 3(1g) of PoA Act was lodged at Kodangal PS, Vikarabad, Telangana. First instalment of monetary relief Rs. 0.50 lakh was paid to the victim and possession of land was given to petioner.
Benefit Under SC Scheme: F. No. 6/44/18/AP-RU: DM, Prakasam, AP issued disablity certificate and pension to Shri Boddu Kotaiah, Somarajupalli, Prakasam , AP who approached us for resolving his grievance.
F. No. 6/26/19/AP-RU:
147 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Representation from Sri. B. Babu Rao, S/o. Late B. Sri Ramulu, H.No. 10-106, Sowbhagya Nagar, Opp. to IDPL Colony, Quthbullapur Mandal, Medchal-Malkajgiri, Telangana was non providing basic amenities like drinking water and pipeline for drinking water supply and other facilities in SC Colonies of Boutlagudur village of Prakasam, AP. Rural Water Supply & Sewage Circle repaired the hand pumps and also proposals were made to provide water storage facility and to appoint pump operator.
Education/Degree and Certificate Issuance Matters:
F. No. 5/2/19/TS-RU:
After being taken up, Geethanjali Public School arranged examination for 12th class student Master Salla Anurag of Hyderabad, Telangana. This saved him two precious academic years in ICSE syllabus. F. No. 23/20/19/TS- RU (TTD Cases):
Representation received from Shri A. Anand Student, TTD Music, Dance, Arts College, Tirupati, Chittoor, AP was for removing bad credentials in his conduct certificate. The College rectified this and issued fresh conduct certificate.
Miscellaneous Matters : F. No. 1/169/18/TS-Ser.: Representation of Shri Sangala Padma Rao, R/o. Qtr. No. C2-18/B, Gouthampur, Rudrampur Kothagudem, Bhadradri Kothagudem, Telangana was about not returning the maturity amount of NSC Bond by Welfare Officer, Singareni Colleries Ltd. Report dated 14.06.2019 received stated that the matured amount with interest was paid on 19.03.2019.
F. No. 6/4/19/TS-RU: Representation received from Smt. K. Padmavathi w/o. Late Narsing Rao R/o. H. No. 1- 5-162/4, Musheerabad, Jamistanpur, Hyderabad, Telangana was for payment of widow pension, which was sanctioned.
F. No. 22/16/19/TS-RU:
148 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Case of suicide by student Master K. Ratnam, by hanging himself to a tree due to stress, at Social Welfare Hostel, Girmapur (V), Kondapur (M), Sangareddy, Telangana was taken up suo moto. DM paid Rs.0.60 lakh (@ Rs 0.10 lakh funeral expenses and Rs. 0.50 lakh exgratia ) to the parents of the deceased student and also assured to provide employment on outsourcing basis to one of the parents.
F. No. 1/92/19/TS-Ser.: Representation received from Shri V. Hanumantha Rao, Ex-Member of Parliament, H.No.2-2-185/56/14 B, Bagh Amberpet, Hyderabad, Telangana regarding caste discrimination and harassment by authorities by delaying or stopping payments due to SV Constructions, Hyderabad. After pursuance by this office Railway authorities cleared contractor’s payment worth Rs. 15.50 lakhs.
2.4.2.6(a) State office : Kolkata 2018-19
Issuance of Caste Certificate:
File No. 11/6/2018-Gen/WB
Smt. Sabita Sardar Ganti, Sardar Pally, West Bengal submitted representation to the Commission alleging that caste certificates are not being issued by the authority for her and and her sister Ms. Arpita Sardar. The caste certificates have been issued on 27.12.2018.
File No.- 11/5/2017-Gen/WB
The case of Shri Swapan Kumar Sarkar, New Barrackpur, North 24 Parganas alleged non receipt of caste certificate of his two daughters was taken up. The certificates were issued.
Scholarship matters:
File No.- 4/4/2018- Gen/WB
The case of Km. Riya Mondal, class-IX alleging that she was not paid the granted scholarship despite fulfilling all the formalities was taken up with the DM/ Nadia,who reported that payment of Rs. 5400 /- was made.
Land matters:
File No. 3/6/2017-Gen/OR
149 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Sri Suresh Sahu, Ganga Sahi, Angul, Odisha regarding land dispute was taken up with the DM, Angul who informed that the matter has been settled amicably.
File No.- 3/10/2017- Gen/OR
The case of Shri Abhin Patra , Korai, Jajpur regarding land dispute was taken up with the DM, Jajpur, who informed that the matter has been settled after demarcation the land.
2.4.2.6(b) State office : Kolkata 2019-20
Land related matters: File No. 3/6/2018-Gen/WB (North 24 Parganas)
Smt. Bisakha Biswas of Ghoshpur, Baduria Block, North 24 Parganas , WB complained about non-earmarking of her land in the District land records. District Magistrate, North 24 Parganas informed that the land records have been updated in favour of the SC petitioner.
Caste Certificate related matters:
File No. 11/9/2019-Gen/WB (N 24 Pgs)
Shri Nayan Biswas of Haridaspur, P.S. Bongaon, District North 24 Parganas, West Bengal complained about non-receipt of SC Caste Certificate. The SDO, Bongaon subsequently issued SC Certificate on 05.11.2019.
File No. 11/1/2019-Gen/WB
Shri Arup Kumar Biswas, F/o Ms Aishani Biswas , Durgapur , WBcomplained about delay in issuance of SC Certificate in favour of his daughter. The SDO, Durgapur vide letter dated 14.01.2020 informed that the requisite certificate stands issued.
2.4.2.7(a) State Office : Pune 2018-19
Land Matter/houses :
File No. NCSC/Pune/47/2016- APCR-II
150 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri Pralahd Bhaguji Jagtap regarding correction in mutation entry was taken up with Collector Pune and DSLR Pune. The mutation entry was rectified.
Miscellaneous Matters:
File No. NCSC/Pune/09/2019-APCR-I
The representation from Shri. Sopan Panchal Waydande, regarding non-payment for work, by a party.Due to our intervention amount Rs 1 lakh payment was received by the petitioner. 2.4.2.7(b) State Office : Pune 2019-20
Mutation Entry:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/13/2018-APCR-II
Shri. Ravindra Ghadge, Nimche, Taluka Hatkangale, Kolhapur, Maharashtra complained on 07.03.2018 for non entry of heirs name entry in land record register. The matter was taken up with DC Kolhapur. Due to our intervention the mutation entry of the heirs was recorded.
Encroachment on approach road:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/21/2018/APCR-II
Shri Santosh Maruti Gaikwad, Zendewadi, Taluka Purandar, Pune, Maharashtra had complained regarding the encroachment on approach road. Notice was issued to DC and SP on 24.06.2019. Due to our intervention revenue authority intimated that the encroachment on approach road was removed on 26.08.2019.
Reservation of Burial Land:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/3/2019-ESDW
Shri. Ramchandra Shivaji Sakat, Pune, Maharashtra complained on 10.12.2018 reservation of burial (samshan bhomi) land to be provided. Notice was issued to DC, Ahmednagar on 03.03.2019. The District Administration vide letter dated 29.03.2019 had communicated that as per the survey. No. 16 land is reserved as burial land.
151 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. NCSC/PUNE/07/2019-ESDW
Shri Akash Shejwal, Village Shirdi, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra dated 08.01.2019 requested for rehabilitation as per PoA Rules as his elder brother was murdered in an atrocity in 2015. Notice was issued to DC and Assistant Commissioner Social Welfare, Ahmednagar 14.06.2019. Petitioner was appointed as a Peon in the Social Welfare department Ahmednagar on 03.07.2019.
Encroachment on land and re-measure land:
File No. NCSC/PUNE/18/2018/ESDW
Shri Balbhim Ramu Sarkar, post Akoli, Latur, Maharashtra complained on 07.08.2019 regarding encroachment on his agriculture land. Notice was issued to DC and CEO Latur on 10.08.2018. Collector Latur dated 08.01.2019 intimated that the encroachment on land was removed and the land was re-measured on 26.04.2019.
2.4.2.8(a) State office : Trivandrum 2018-19
Possession of land /plot etc:
File No: KL/15/13/2015
The case of Smt.Thankabhai, Trivandrum for proper pathway was taken up. After the intervention of this office district administration provided the pathway to petitioner.
File No: KL/15/4/2017
The case of Smt. Kumary Trivandrum for land and house was taken up. After the intervention of this office, District Administration included petitioner’s family in the livelihood inclusion and financial empowerment mission of government of Kerala.
File No: KL/15/11/2017
The request of Shri. Bhaskaran for land allocation was taken up . After the intervention of this office, the petitioner has got ten cents of land.
Benefits under SC schemes:
File No: KL/15/O/H/1/2017
152 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The request of Smt.Ragini Sivan Ernakulam for including her in housing schemewas taken up and the SC department sanctioned Rs 2 lakh to petitioner.
File No: KL/15/O/H/16/2017
The request of Shri. Mohanan.K Ernakulam to include him in housing scheme and to provide medical assistance was taken up. The SC department sanctioned Rs 0.10 lakh as medical assistance and also included him in life mission project of GoK for housing.
File No: KL/15/O/F/14/2017
The request of Ms. Aparna Surendran and Ms. Poornima Surendran Idukki district reg. medical assistance was taken up . After the intervention of this office, SC department sanctioned Rs 0.15 lakh each to both the petitioners.
File No: KL/15/O/F/18/2017
The case of Shri.Manipushpa Ernakulam district for financial assistance for House maintenance was pursued. The Scheduled Caste department sanctioned Rs 2.5 lakh to petitioner for housing.
File No: KL/15/O/F/40/2017
The case of Shri. S. Subhash Trivandrum for financial assistance for housing was pursued. The SC department sanctioned Rs 2.5 lakh for housing.
File No: KL/15/O/SEP/3/2017
The case of Smt. Kamalakshi Ayyappan Ernakulam to waive off loan amount and medical assistance was pursued. The Registrar ,Co-operatives relaxed interest of loan as per rule to petitioner and also Rs 0.1 lakh for medical assistance.
File No: KL/15/O/SEP/3/2018
The case of Smt.Syamala Kottayam district for inclusion in any welfare scheme was pursued. he District Development Officer Kottayam included her in life mission project of Government and also sanctioned Rs 0.1 lakh medical assistance.
File No: KL/15/O/SEP/21/2018
153 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The grievances of Smt.Sundary Palakkad such as road facility, street light facility and non sanction of old age pension was pursued. Director, SC department sanctioned enhanced old age pension, drinking water connection and street light.
File No: KL/15/O/WEL/1/2017
The case of Shri Reghu K.A Ernakulam for medical assistance was pursued. SC Department sanctioned Rs 0.50 lakh as medical assistance. File No: KL/15/O/WEL/6/2018
The request of Smt. Bhawani Madhavan, Idukki to construct compound wall was pursued. Taluk surveyor surveyed the property and SC department reconstructed compound wall. File No: KL/15/O/WEL/21/2018
The case of Shri.M.A.Thankappan Pathanamthitta for treatment assistance was pursued. SC department, Pathanamthitta sanctioned Rs 0.45 lakh for treatment assistance. File No: KL/15/O/WEL/25/2018
The request of Smt. Sunila Santhosh ,Thrissur to include her in welfare schemes was pursued. SC department included the petitioner in housing scheme, sanctioned widow pension, sanctioned subsidy for self employment and also sanctioned Rs 0.5 lakh aid. File No: KL/15/O/WEL/29/2018
The case of Shri. M.Jayapalan , Trivandrum district for get old age pension and medical assistance was pursued. SC department sanctioned old age pension and medical assistance of Rs 0.1 lakh . File No: KL/15/O/WEL/37/2018
The request of Shri.Krishnan.K , Kozhikode for drinking water connection was pursued. The petitioner informed to this office that he was provided drinking water connection on 14.11.2018.
Education/Degree and certificate issuance matters:
File No: KL/12/Edn/4/2018
154 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Smt.Ambili ,Kollam district for educational assistance was pursued. General Manager, Canara Bank, Pooyapally sanctioned Rs 4 lakh as education loan .
File No: KL/12/Edn/5/2018 (HQRS)
The case of Smt. Rejani Santhosh , Alappuzha for sanction of educational assistance was pursued. SC department sanctioned Rs 4.26 lakh as educational assistance through e- grants.
Miscellaneous matters:
File No: KL/15/O/EM/3/2018
The case of Smt.Letha.K.K , Kozhikode for employment assistance was pursued. Director of Employment included the petitioner in the Class IV select list for 2019-20. File No: KL/15/O/F/2/2018(HQRS)
The case of Shri. Srinivasn Malappuram for non sanction of loan was pursued . The Gramin Bank, Malappuram sanctioned Rs 2.5 lakh vehicle loan. File No: KL/15/O/F/37/2017
The case of Shri. Anilkumar , Ernakulam for waiver of loan was pursued. The Registrar Co-operative societies agreed to write off the interest amount considering the poor economic background of petitioner. File No: KL/15/O/Misc/74/2015
The case of Shri. K.Balan , Thrissur for solving problem due to illegal construction of boundary wall was taken up. After the intervention of this office, the other party agreed to increase width of drain out pipe and also decided to construct drainage to solve the problem. File No: KL/15/O/Misc/23/2017
The request of Shri. Nijamudeen , Palakkad for resolving various grievances like colony improvisation, providing drinking water facility , education and ensure law and order in Govindapuram Ambedkar colony of Palakkad was taken up. SC department sanctioned financial assistance for housing, repair of the house, construction of toilet, MP fund sanctioned for drinking water project and initiated mobile medical unit etc. in the colony. File No: KL/15/O/Misc/24/2017
155 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of Shri. Kannimuthu Palakkad for inclusion in BPL list was taken up. After the intervention of this office, Taluk Supply officer has given eligible weightage for ration card renewal as BPL. File No: KL/15/O/Misc/37/2017
The request of Shri. K.P.Sasidharan , Malappuram for old age pension was taken up. Deputy Director of Panchayath sanctioned old age pension of Rs.10,000/- pm to petitioner . File No: KL/15/O/Misc/60/2017
The case of Smt. E.Jayanthy , Trivandrum district for removal of hindrance in pathway was pursued . District administration provided the pathway to petitioner. File No: KL/15/O/Misc/61/2017
Shri Sajeev Kumar, Ernakulam complained of abuse. After the intervention of this office, Chief General Manager, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited initiated disciplinary action against the accused employee. File No: KL/15/O/Misc/48/2018
The request of Shri. S.Majeendran , Trivandrum for compensation amount was taken up. Petitioner received Rs.3,000/-incurred towards medical treatment through Police station from the accused bus driver and conductor . File No: KL/15/O/Misc/49/2018
The case of Shri.Ashokan , Kollam district for non repayment of money taken for visa purpose was taken up. Theaccused person handed over Rs.1 lakh to petitioner in the presence of police. File No: KL/15/O/Misc/99/2018
Suo motu action was initiated on news of 04.08.2018 about ragging of SC girl by senior students at School of Drama and Music , Kozhikode University. The Registrar of suspended the accused students from the college and hostel. Further a committee of University recommended taking proper proceedings to stop all scholarship to the accused and to debar them from the coming semester examinations. Police registered the case under sec. 294(b), 354, 34 & sec.4 of Kerala Prohibition of Ragging Act 1998.
156 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Issuance of Caste Certificate:
File No: KL/12/8/2017
The case of Smt. Koyilath Mini Kannur on hindrance for getting a caste certificate was taken up. After the intervention of this office Tahsildar, Kannur issued caste certificate.
2.4.2.8(b) State office : Trivandrum 2019-20
Scholarship matters:
File No. File No.KL/12/Edn/3/2019
Ms. Greeshma.K. J. Thrissur requested sanctioning of postmetric scholarship. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Development Department sanctioned an amount of Rs. 0.38740 lakh towards scholarship.
Possession of land/plot/Flat (house):
File No. KL/15/O/F/288/2017
Smt. Sarasa Kuttappan, Ernakulam requested for to inclusion in housing scheme. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Department included her in IAY Scheme and Rs. 4 lakh was sanctioned.
Benefit under SC schemes :
File No. KL/15/O/Wel/2/2018
Shri.R. Raveendran, Trivandrum requested financial assistance under SCSP schemes, as his daughter had died due to ill health. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Development Department sanctioned Rs. 0.50 lakh to the petitioner.
File No. KL/15/O/F/2/2019 and KL/15/O/Wel/11/2018
Smt. Lakshmi Vally, Wayanad and Smt.S. Lilly, Idukki requested medical treatment assistance. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Development Department sanctioned an amount of Rs. 0 .75 lakh and 0.10 lakh respectively to the petitioners.
File No. VC/KL/15/O/H/1/2017
157 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Smt. Ragini Shivan, Ernakulam requested financial assistance for housing. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Delopment Department sanctioned an amount of Rs.4 lakh.
File No. KL/15/O/SEP/20/2016
Shri.K.A. Anil, Thrissur requested action against illegal road construction. After the intervention of this office, Deputy Director of Panchayath, Thrissur, took stringent action against the culprit and the encroachment was removed.
File No. KL/15/O/F/8/2018
Shri.N. Subramanian , Palakkad requested waiving off his loan amount. After the intervention of this office, Branch Manager, SBI, Valayar Branch, Palakkad waived off Rs. 4,45,117 /- as per bank’s extant norms to help the petitioner.
File No. KL/15/O/Wel/2019
Shri. Jineesh.P.U. hails ,Thrissur requested sanction of medical assistance for his mother. After the intervention of this office, DDO, Thrissur sanctioned Rs. 1.50 lakh to petitioner as medical assistance.
File No. VC/KL/15/O/F/17/2017
Shri. Vikraman.N.K. , Ernakulam requested to include his name in house maintenance scheme and treatment assistance. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Development department included the petitioner in life mission plans for housing and also granted Rs. 0. 195 lakh as medical assistance.
Allotment of Petrol Pump:
File No.KL/15/O/Misc/57/2017
Shri. Rajendran A.K., Kottayam requested action in case of non allotment of dealership of retail outlet by HPCL. After the intervention of this office, Chief Regional Manager, HPCL extended one more chance to select alternate land and commissioned the outlet.
Miscellaneous matters:
File No. KL/15/O/F/3/2019
158 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri.N. Sasikumaran Thampi, Trivandrum requested action in non sanction of housing loan. After the intervention of this office, Chief General Manager, SBI sanctioned Rs.25 lakh as housing loan.
File No. KL/15/O/SEP/27/2018
The Commission (State Office, Trivandrum) initiated suo-motto action on the Hindu news dated 07.10.2018 about irregularities detected in SC/ST hostels. After the intervention of this office, Director, SC Department carried out inspection into the alleged discrepancies, disciplinary proceedings initiated against concerned officials and issued a circular for proper maintenance of Registers, proper maintenance of hostel atmosphere, provide food as per menu, convening of hostel advisory committee meeting etc.
File No. KL/15/O/Misc/76/2015
Shri.K. Mallaya, President, Kerala Chakkiliyan Samithi, Puthiyara P.O.Calicut complained regarding non issue of community certificate.After the intervention of this office, Principal Secretary, SC/ST Development Department decided to extend SC status to Chakkiliya community people from Kollam, Kannur, Kozhikode and Kottayam districts considering the fact that they migrated from Tamil Nadu before 1950 i.e. before the constitution of Kerala State.
File No. KL/15/2/2017
Smt. Paru Kannanchi Ernakulam requested action on non survey and demarcation and survey of her property. After the intervention of this office, Tahsildar, Kanaganoor Taluk, Ernakulam resurveyed the property and demarcated the same.
2.5 Atrocity related matters
The Commission received a large number of cases of inaction on atrocities on Scheduled Castes and a total of 4834 cases ( 1990 cases of 2018-19 and 2844 cases of 2019-20 ) relating to this sector were disposed off by the Commission in 2018-19 and 2019-20 respectively.
159 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
After the intervention of the NCSC in 1162 cases (786 cases in 2018-19 and 376 cases in 2019-20 ) of atrocities against Scheduled Castes 1035 FIRs (657 in 2018-19 and 378 in 2019-20 ) were registered, 1248 accused (779 in 2018-19 and 469 in 2019-20 ) were arrested and 693 chargesheets (439 in 2018-19 and 254 in 2019-20) have been filed. Monetary relief of Rs 2682.60 lakh (Rs 1250.42 lakh in 2018-19 and Rs 1612.18 lakh in 2019-20 ) have been paid to the victims as monetary relief. In addition in 21 cases (06 in 2018-19 and 15 in 2019-20 ), family members were sanctioned pensions, 14 family members (4 in 2018-19 and 10 in 2019-20) family members got jobs, 14 (03 in 2018-19 and 11 in 2019-20) house/land patta/agriculture land were given to families of victims.
Table 2.4 (a):2018-2019
S. Subject Interesting Monetary relief (Rs. Additional relief sanctioned No cases in lakhs) . Hqrs. State Hqrs. State Hqrs. State Offices Offices Offices 1. Rape/Gang rape 05 49 12.225 168.0285 - - 2. Grievous - 05 - 13.25 - - hurt/Kidnapping 3. Miscellaneous 10 42 11.50 340.125 - 01 house 4. Murder/Attempt 20 74 123.125 558.42 03 02 pension, 03 to murder pension, job 01 job, 01 house patta and 01 land patta 5. Arson/Robbery 02 - 23.75 - - - Total: 37 170 170.60 1079.8235 Grand Total: 207 1250.4235 05 pension, 04 job, 02 house patta and 01 land patta
160 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Table 2.4 (b): 2019-2020
S. Subject Interesting Monetary relief Additional relief sanctioned No cases (Rs. in lakhs) . Hqrs. State Hqrs. State Hqrs. State Offices Offices Offices 1. Rape/Gang rape 50 84 156.84 219.45 01 family 01 job, 02 pension house and 01 and 01 job land 2. Grievous 13 14 22.75 92.875 - - hurt/Kidnapping 3. Miscellaneous 17 57 20.125 130.287 - - 4. Murder/Attempt 72 67 485.521 476.58 06 08 family to murder pension, Pension, 05 Job, 03 job and 02 house and 04 02 house land 5. Arson/Robbery 01 01 0.75 7.00 - Total: 153 223 685.986 926.192 - Grand Total: 376 1612.178 15 family pension, 10 job, 06 house and 05 land patta
2.5.1(a) NCSC Headquarters :2018-19 File No. UP/317/2017-APCR
House of Shri Bablu, Alampur, P.S Vasai, Mohammadpur, Firozabad, UP was set on fire by the accused and his sister died in the fire. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under 3(2)V PoA Act & 306 IPC, 1 accused arrested ,chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was sanctioned. File No. UP/298/2017-APCR
Smt. Hirakali, Bilsanda, Pilibhit, UP was brutally beaten her 17 year daughter was murdered by villagers. Suo moto notice was issued, FIR under 3(2)V PoA Act and 336/304/323 IPC was lodged . Monetary compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh was sanctioned.
File No. UP/422/2017-APCR
161 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Smt.Ramvati, Sehson, Etawah, UP was brutally beaten her son was murdered by villagers. Suo moto notice was issued, FIR was lodged under 3(1)rsw PoA Act and147,149,323,504 IPC, 7 accussed arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was sanctioned to deceased’s wife. In addition, monetary compensation of Rs. 0.75 lakh was granted to deceased’s mother.
File No. UP/12/2018-APCR
Shri Sanjay, Auchha, Mainpuri, UP was brutally attacked with attempt to murder him & his brother. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under section 147/323/504/506 IPC & 3(1)10 PoA Act,5 accused arrested, charge sheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs.1.50 lakh (@ Rs. 0.75 lakh per victim) was sanctioned .
File No. UP/574/2017-APCR
Sister of Shri Sunder Singh, Jawan, Aligarh, UP was kidnapped and raped. Suo moto notice was issued and FIR was lodged u/s 363/354/376/IPC & 3(2)V of PoA Act, case was chargesheeted. Monetary compensation of Rs.3.75 lakh was sanctioned.
File No. UP/7/2018-APCR
Smt. Sushila, Jaithra, Etah, UP and family was beaten, abused & received threats to be killed. Suo moto notice was issued , 3 FIRs were lodged as per details below: 1. FIR u/s 376/313/120B,504 IPC & 4 POCSO Act 2. FIR u/s 147,323,452,504,506 IPC & 3(1)(r) PoA Act 3. FIR u/s 147,323,326,504 IPC & 3(2)V PoA Act .
3 accused arrested, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 3 lakh , Rs 0.75 lakh and Rs 0.50 lakh was sanctioned to victims of the above FIRs.
File No. UP/218/2017-APCR
Smt. Kishori Devi, Belipaar, Gorakhpur, UP had complained of attempt of illegal encroachment on her land, caste based abuse & threatening to kill. Notice was issued and illegal encroachment was removed.
File No. UP/146/2018-APCR
162 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri Netrapal, Shamsabad, Agra, UP complained of beating, caste based abuse and threatening. Notice was issued, FIR was lodged u/s 323/504 IPC and 3(1)r,s PoA Act . Monetary compensation of Rs. 0.25 lakh was granted.
File No. Har/82/2017-APCR
Smt. Runa Devi, Karnal, Haryana, complained of murder of her husband. Notice was issued, FIR lodged, u/s 304(A), 506 IPC and 3(1)(r) PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs.5 lakh from CM Kishan Khetihar Majdoor Jeevan Suraksha Yojana & Rs.0.25 lakh from Red Cross was sanctioned. File No. Raj/38/2016-APCR
Km. Babita, Panlawa, Sikar, Rajasthan complained of rape & kidnapping. Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 452,363,365,366,376,(2)(N)IPC & 3(1)(12),3(2)V PoA Act and 5(B)(L)/6 POCSO Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 1.125 lakh was granted. File No. UP/87/2018-APCR
Shri Mahender Singh Mahor, Sasni Gate, Aligarh, UP complained of murder of his minor son. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR u/s 302 IPC and 3(2)V PoA Act, 4 accused arrested, chargesheet was filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted. File No. UP/231/2018-APCR
Smt. Rekha, Badaun, UP, complained of murder of her husband due to beating and lack of treatment. Notice was issued, FIR was lodged u/s 279,337,338 IPC and monetary relief of Rs. 5 lakh under Sarvhith Bima Yojana was granted. File No. UP/516/2017-APCR
Smt. Premvati, Shahganj, Agra, UP complained of murder of her husband. Suo moto notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 304 IPC and 3(2)V PoA Act, 2 accused arrested, chargesheet was filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted. File No. UP/412/2017-APCR
163 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri Samarpal, Saharanpur, UP, complained of beating. Notice was issued, FIR was lodged u/s 323/324/325/504/ IPC, 3(2)(V)(a) PoA Act, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh was granted. File No. UP/113/2018-APCR Shri Ramesh Chandra Mathur, Mainpuri, UP, complained regarding murder of his wife. Notice was issued, FIR registered u/s 147,149,302,323,504 IPC and 3(2)(V) PoA Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted. File No. Har/202/2018-APCR Smt. Rubi, Panipat, Haryana, complained of rape of her daughter. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR u/s 34,363,506 IPC, 5 POSCO Act and 3 PoA Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed . Monetary compensation of Rs 3.75 lakh was granted. File No. UP/571/2018-APCR & UP/532/2018-APCR Shri Ramsevak, Etawah, UP complained of murder of his wife. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR u/s 147,148,149,307 IPC, 3(2)(V), 3(2)(V)(a) PoA Act, 2 accused arrested, chargesheet filed . Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted. File No. UP/597/2018-APCR Shri Pradeep, Mainpuri, UP, complained of caste based abuse & receiving death threats. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR u/s 419,420,468,469,471,406,504,506, IPC and 3(1) (s) PoA Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh was granted. File No. UP/149/2018-APCR Shri Ram Prasad, Banda, UP, complained of beating & receiving death threats. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR u/s 147,148,307,323,504,506, IPC and 3(2)(V) PoA Act, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 1.50 lakh was granted. File No. Bihar/38/2018-APCR Smt. Jai Prakash, Kaimur, Bihar, complained of murder of his son. Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 302/201/120B IPC and 3(2)(V) PoA Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed . Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted.
In addition, pension of Rs.5,000/- pm , dearness allowance of Rs.57,250/-, ration for 3 months was granted to the wife of the deceased. File No. Bihar/40/2018-APCR
164 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Smt. Maya Devi, Punpun, Patna, Bihar, complained of murder of her husband. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR u/s 302,353,224,120B,34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(2)(V) PoA Act, 3 accused, arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs 4.125 lakh was granted.
File No. MP/16/2018-APCR Shri Sanjay Singh, Morena, MP, complained of encroachment of land, atrocity and facing threat of life. Notice was issued, special team was sent, clear cut demarcation of land was done matter was resolved successfully. File No. MP/24/2018-APCR Shri Barelal Kori, Chhatarpur, MP, complained of murder of his son. Notice was issued, FIR was lodged u/s 307,302 IPC & 3(2)(V) PoA Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed . Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted. File No. TN/21/2018-APCR In the case of murder of Shri Kamraj, Ammpettai, Thanjavur, TN Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 294(b),302 IPC and (3)(2)(V) PoA Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed . Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted. File No. MP/18/2018-APCR Shri Maniram Valmiki & other residents of Khaniyadhana, Shivpuri, MP, complained of looting and setting their houses on fire. Notice was issued, FIR lodged, 11 accused arrested, chargesheet filed . Monetary compensation of Rs 15.50 lakh was granted. File No. MP/16/2017-APCR taking suo moto cognisance of news report captioned “Dalit girl forced to pick poop in MP, notice was issued, leading to FIR u/s 374,504 IPC, 23 POSCO Act & 3(1)(j) PoA Act, 1 accused arrested, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh was granted. File No. UP/455/2018-APCR Shri Bhupinder Pal Singh, National President, Vishva Dalit Parishad, Bijnor, UP complained of harassment by police. Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 392,323,504 IPC and 3(i)(x) PoA Act, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 1.75 lakh was granted. File No. TN/17/2017-APCR
165 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Ms. Selvin Bharathipriya, Villupuram, TN complained of murder of her mother & her younger brother. Notice was issued, FIR u/s 304,135(i)(a) and 3(2)V of PoA Act was lodged. 1 accused arrested, Monetary compensation of Rs 5.50 lakh was granted. File No. Kerala/2/2017-APCR Shri Kummanan Rajesekharan, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerela complained of death of Shri. Kunjumon under police custody. Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 174 CrPC, 4 accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.50 lakh was granted to the mother of the deceased.
.File No. Kerala/5/2017-APCR
Smt. Mahija, Kozhikode, Kerala, complained of rape by Shri Rigesh. Notice was issued, FIR was lodged, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 3 lakh was granted. File No. Bihar/14/2017-APCR Shri Umesh Paswan, Madhubani, Bihar, complained of murder of his father. Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 302 IPC & 3(2)(V) PoA Act, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 5.625 lakh was granted. File No. TN/1/2017-APCR Smt P.Kalishwari, Dindigul, TN, complained of murder of her husband. Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 341,307,302,120(b),147,148,294(B)/IPC, 3(2)(V), 3(1)r, 3(1)(S), of PoA Act, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was granted. File No. Kerala/3/2017-APCR Taking suo moto cognisance of news report regarding assault of minor granddaughter of Smt. Pappothy, Thrissur, Kerala, notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 294(b), 323,354 r/w 34 IPC, Sec 8 r/w 7 of POCSO Act and, 3(2)(Va) PoA Act, chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs.1.5 lakh was granted. File No. TN/18/2017-APCR Taking suo moto cognisance of news report of “14 year old honour killing case”, notice was issued. FIR was lodged u/s 147,302,201 IPC. Monetary compensation of Rs.8.25 lakh was granted. File No. TN/8/2019-APCR
166 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The case of murder of an SC youth in Kemmankuppam village, Vellore , Tamil Nadu was followed up.
FIR u/s 294(b), 324, 307, 302 & 3(1)s, 3(2)(V )PoA act was registered and chargesheet was filed in 2017 but the family has received no help . After follow up by the Commission, monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh , Rs.56,318/- as arrears of family pension from 14.08.2017 to 30.06.2017 was also paid. The wife of the deceased was given a Government job.
File No. TN/5/2017-APCR
The case of murder of Shri Ramkumar , Kalakkad, Tirunveli, Tamil Nadu was followed up.FIR was registered and chargesheet was filed in 2017 but the family has received only partial help. After follow up by the Commission, 2nd installment of monetary compensation of Rs 4.125 lakh , Rs 0.75 lakh to Shri Arun ( brother of victim ) was also paid.
2.5.1(b) NCSC Headquarters :2019-20
File No. TN/10/2019-APCR
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident reported in New Indian Express.com dated 08.05.2019 regarding an SC farmer assaulted and fed excreta in Tiruvarur District, Tamil Nadu a notice was issued and case followed up.
FIR No Cr. No. 97/2019 was registered u/s 341, 294(b), 352, 506 (ii) IPC , PoA Act. Two accused arrested, charge-sheet submitted on 23.06.2019 and admissible financial relief amounting to Rs. 0.50 lakh was paid to the victim.
File No. MP/38/2018-APCR
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident dated 11.09.2018 captioned about a SC lynched over land feud in Madhya Pradesh in Shivpuri District, a notice was issued and case followed up. FIR No Cr. No. 228/2018 was registered u/s 307, 324, 323, 321, 147, 148, 149, 302 IPC and 3(1)(r) (s) and 3(2)(v)(a) of PoA Act. Two accused arrested, charge-sheet No. 207/2018 dated 11.12.2018 was filed and admissible financial relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the victim’s family.
167 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. MP/10/2019-APCR: Smt Anuradha w/o Late Shri Kamlesh Jatav R/o Tehsil Porsa, Morena, MP complained of murder of her, a notice was issued and case followed up. FIR No. 32/19 dated 09.02.2019 u/s 452, 294, 323, 34, 302 IPC and 3 (2) (v) of PoA Act was lodged , one accused arrested, chargesheet No 114/2019 was filed on 27.05.2019. Monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was provided to the victim/family of the deceased victim. In addition, job as a cook was provided to the widow. File No. Bihar/54/2019-APCRSmt. Chandpati, Post Dayalpur, Saran, Bihar complained of murder of her son (Narayan Ram). a notice was issued and case followed up. FIR No. 222/2014 dated 12.09.2014 u/s 147, 148, 149, 302, IPC and 3 (2) (v) PoA Act was lodged, 8 accused arrested, chargesheet No138/2014was filed on 30.11.2014. As per report dated 17.05.2019 of S.P Chhapra, monetary relief of Rs. 5.625 lakh was provided to the family of the deceased victim. In addition, Rs. 2.68 lakh as family pension was sanctioned to the widow. File No. Bihar/6/2019-APCR
Shri Ankit Manjhi S/o Late Shri Dharmender Manjhi, R/o Pirari, Saran, Bihar complained of murder of his mother a notice was issued and case followed up. FIR No. 111/2016 dated 23.06.2016, u/s 302, IPC and 3 (2) (v) PoA Act was lodged, 2 accused arrested. ChargesheetNo. 64/2017 was filed on 31.05.2017. As per report dated 04.05.2019 of DM, Chhapra, monetary relief of Rs8.25 lakh was provided to the victim/family of the deceased victim. In addition, Rs. 1.706 lakh as family pension to the provided to the victim’s son. File No. MP/23/2019-APCR
Shri Murari Lal Jatav S/o Shri Jhamman LalJ atav, R/o Village Ratnupura, PS-Ater, Bhind, MP complained of caste abuse and beating. Notice was issued, FIR No. 115/2019 was lodged, u/s 324, 323, 294, 506, 34, IPC and 3 (1)(r)(s) 3 (2) (v) PoA Act, 4 accused were arrested and chargesheet No. 135/2019 was filed on 26.10.2019. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. Bihar/111/2018-APCR
Smt. Rani Kumari W/o Shri Kanhai Ram, R/o Murarpur, Shekpura, Bihar complained of unnatural death of her husband. Notice was issued and FIR No. 1/2015 was lodged. Murder
168 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
charges were not proved, as per report dated 15.07.2019 of DIG (Administration), Patna, Bihar, a job was provided to the victim’s wife on compassionate grounds. File No. Jharkhand/42/2018-APCR
Smt. Sobha Kumari W/o Shri Anil Kumar, PS Golmuri, Jamshedpur, Jharkhand complained of non payment of rent. Notice was issued and FIR No. 09/2018 dated 22.09.2018 was lodged u/s 341, 323, 504, 506 IPC and 3 (x) PoA Act, 2 accused were arrested. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.75 lakh was sanctioned to victim. File No. WB/10/2018-APCR
Devshri Chaudhary, West Bengal, submitted application regarding inaction in case of murder of Shri Shaktipada Sardar S/o Shri Neduranjan Sardar R/o Village Khorda, PS, Mandir Bazar, South 24 Parganas, West Bengal. Notice was issued, hearings were held and FIR No. 280/2018 dated 28.07.2018 which was lodged u/s 302/34 IPC was modified with addition of section 3 (2) (v)of PoA Act. 1 accused was arrested, and chargesheet submitted. Monetary relief of Rs8.25 lakh was provided to the family of the deceased victim. In addition widow pension of Rs. 11,250/- p.m was to his widow. Further Rs. 0.75 lakh as house grant under house scheme Geetanjali was sanctioned and Rs. 0.50 lakh under grocery scheme was sanctioned to the widow. File No. Odisha/6/2018-APCR
Shri Dhirender Nath Manjhi R/o Post Sailashree Vihar, Bhubaneswar, Odisha complained of murder of his daughter (Amrita Manjhi). Notice was issued and FIR No. 101/2016 dated 27.12.2016was lodged u/s 493, 420, 302 and 34 IPC and 3 (2) (v) of PoA Act. 1 accused was arrested and charge sheet was filed on 31.07.2017. After our pursuance the report dated 16.09.2019 of DIG, Southern Range, Behrampur, stated that monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned to petitioner. File No. Bihar/26/2017-APCR
Beju Ram R/o Village Jhilli Chowk Mathurapur, PS-Mathurapur, Samastipur, Bihar complaint of harassment. Notice was issued, FIR No. 286/2016, dated 18.12.2016 Thana Mathurapur, U/s 341,323,504, 406, 379, 34 IPC and 3 (1) (r )(s ) and 3(ii)(va) SC/ST Act, charge sheet No. 11.2017 dated 05.03.2017. As per report dated 30.03.2019 of DM, Samastipur, monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was provided to the victim.
169 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. Delhi/137/2019-APCR
Shri Parvesh Kumar, R/o Ashok Nagar, Delhi complained of murder of his father. Notice was issued and FIR lodged u/S 147, 323, 504, 506, 427 IPC and 3(1) (n) of PoA Act, chargesheet No. 263 was filed on 07.08.2019. Monetary relief of Rs. 1 lakh was provided to the family of the victim. File No. UP/446/2019-APCR
Ms. Archana, R/o Sultanpur, UP complained of gangrape. Notice was issued, FIR was lodged u/S 34, 376D, 504, 506, 323, 452 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, 06 accused were arrested, chargesheet No. A-22 and A-01 were filed on 16.06.2014 and 30.12.2017. After our pursuance the report dated 16.11.2019 of SP, Sultanpur stated that monetary relief of Rs.3 lakh ( @ Rs 0.75 lakh x 4 victims) was provided to the all 4 victims. File No. UP/494/2019-APCR
Shri Tejpal, R/o P.S. Binoli, District Baghpat, UP complained of kidnapping and rape of his daughter. Notice was issued, FIR lodged u/s 363, 366, 376 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act and ¾ POCSO Act, 01 accused was arrested. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.25 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. UP/364/2019-APCR
Smt. Savitri Katheria, R/o M.L.A. Bharthana, Etawah, UP complained of being threatened and caste based abuse. Notice was issued, FIR No. 21/19 lodged u/s 147, 336, 353, 504, 506 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, 07 accused arrested. File No. UP/635/2019-APCR
Smt. Bhagwati, W/o Sh. Tota Ram, R/o Village Jav, P.S. Kosikala, Mathura, UP complained of rape. Notice was issued and FIR lodged u/s 376-D, 504, 506 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, Final Report No. 153/2019 filed on 02.12.2019. Monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. Delhi/333/2018-APCR
Shri Bachchu Singh, R/o Sultanpuri, Delhi complained of rape of his daughter. Notice was issued and FIR No. 623/18 was lodged u/s 363, 366, 376 IPC, 6 POCSO Act and 3(2) (v) of PoA Act. 01 accused arrested and chargesheet filed on 04.11.2018. As per report dated
170 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
30.04.2019 of Dy. Director, SC/ST/OBC Welfare Department, GNCTD monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. Delhi/150/2018-APCR
Smt. Meena Devi, R/o Sangam Vihar, New Delhi complained of caste abuse. Notice was issued, FIR No. 403/18 was lodged u/s 323, 325, 427, 34 IPC and 3(2)(va) of PoA Act, chargesheet filed on 19.03.2019. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. UP/573/2018-APCR
Shri Bhuri Singh Katheria R/o Vill. Banipura, Firozabad, UP complained of kidnapping and rape of his minor daughter. Notice was issued and FIR No. 36/18 was lodged u/s 363, 366, 376, 506 IPC, ¾ POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, 01 accused arrested, chargesheet was filed on 18.07.2018. As per report dated 26.07.2019 of SP, Firozabad, monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. UP/524/2018-APCR
Shri Pavanvir, S/o Sh. Ramsaran, R/o Village Gesupur Shumali, Meerut, UP complained of murder of his brother. Notice was issued and FIR No. 258/18 was lodged u/s 302, 201, 120B IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, 02 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 356/18 filed on 29.08.2018. The compensation shall be released after the decision of custody of child by the Court. File No. UP/393/2018-APCR
Smt. Budhna, R/o Vill. Chamaranpura, Baharaich, UP complained of murder of husband and attempted murder of her son. Notice was issued and FIR was lodged u/s 302, 207, 201 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 02 accused arrested, and chargesheet No. 1441/16 filed on 27.07.2017. After our pursuance on 18.07.2019 , monetary relief of Rs 9.45 lakh (@Rs. 8.25 lakh as per PoA rules & Rs 1.20 lakh additional ) was provided to the family of the deceased victim. File No. UP/451/2018-APCR
Shri Dhanpal, S/o Shri Phundan, R/o Village Kamala, Baghpat, UP complained of murder of his son. Notice was issued, FIR was lodged u/s 377, 342, 364, 302 IPC, ¾ POCSO Act
171 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 11 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 262/18 filed on 03.07.2018. After our pursuance on 15.07.2019 monetary relief of Rs. Rs 9.00 lakh (@ Rs 8.25 lakh & Rs 0.75 lakh additional ) was provided to family of the deceased victim. In addition Rs. 28 lakh was given by opponent to the family. File No. Maha/21/2019-APCR
Shri Ravikant Das Savale Das Kamble R/o Nagpur, Maharashtra complained of murder of his mother and daughter. Notice was issued and FIR was lodged u/s 302, 364, 120B, 201, 34 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 03 accused were arrested and chargesheet No. 15/18 was filed on 17.05.2018. As per report dated 25.07.2019 of DCP, Nagpur ,monetary relief of Rs. 16.50 lakh was provided to the family of the deceased victims. File No. Raj/24/2019-APCR
Shri Lakhan Lal R/o Sahida Ka Pura, Dausa, Rajasthan complained of accidental death of his son due to electric shock. Notice was issued and FIR was lodged u/s 174 Cr.PC Act on 17.07.2019 . Rs. 8.521 lakh monetary relief and Rs 2.00 lakh as GOIS was provided to the family of the deceased victim. In addition, ESIC pension , EPF pension and a job as Commercial Assistant in DISCOM, Jaipur was also given to the widow of victim. File No. UP/429/2018-APCR and UP/505/2018-APCR
Shri Vijaydeep R/o Thana T.P. Nagar, Meerut, UP complained of murder of his brother. Notice was issued and FIR No. 278/2018 was lodged u/s 306 IPC and 3(2) (v) of PoA Act. 01 accused was arrested and chargesheet No. 516 was filed on 07.12.2018. Monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was provided to the family of the deceased victim. File No. UP/85/2018-APCR
Smt. Champa Devi, R/o P.s. Nababganj, Bareilly, UP complained of rape of her daughter. Notice was issued and FIR No. 623/2017 was lodged u/s 328, 364, 376 IPC, 4 POCO Act and 3(1)(x) of PoA Act. 02 accused arrested and chargesheet No. 111 was filed on 09.04.2018. After our pursuance, the report dated 21.10.2019 of Commissioner , Bareilly stated that monetary relief of Rs 6.18 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. Har/61/2018-APCR
172 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Smt. Mamta R/o Sapera Basti, Kaithal, Haryana complained of gangrape with her and her friend. Notice was issued and FIR lodged u/s 323, 354, 376D, 325 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 06 accused arrested and chargesheet filed on 01.03.2018. After our pursuance the report dated 21.08.2019 of DC, Kaithal stated that monetary relief of Rs. 12.375 lakh (@ Rs 6.187 lakh x 2 victim ) was sanctioned. File No. Har/239/2018-APCR
Shri Virpal R/o Dalbir Nagar, Panipat, Haryana complained of rape of his daughter. Notice was issued and FIR lodged u/s 363, 366A IPC, 6 POCSO Act and IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 01 accused arrested and chargesheet filed on 25.02.2019. Monetary relief of Rs 3.75 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. UP/686/2018-APCR
Shri Munesh, R/o Vill. Nagla Ajmeri, Sambhal, UP complained of murder of his daughter. Notice was issued and FIR lodged u/s 302, 504 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 03 accused were arrested and chargesheet filed. Monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was provided to the family of the deceased victim on 08.07.2019 after our pursuance. In addition, pension was also sanctioned. File No. UP/587/2018-APCR
Shri Sagar, R/o Village Bhagwanpur, Meerut, UP complained of unnatural death of his son. Notice was issued and FIR lodged u/s 306, 323, 504 IPC and 3(2)(v) PoA Act, Final report No. 287/18 filed on 08.09.2018. Monetary relief of Rs 4.125 lakh was provided to the family of the deceased victim on 23.07.2019 after our pursuance. File No. Raj/29/2019-APCR
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of gangrape of a woman and beating of her husband on 26.04.2019 at Thana Ghazi, by pass road, Alwar, Rajasthan. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 92/19 u/s 147, 149, 323, 341,354B, 376D IPC and 3(1)(w), 3(2)(v) PoA Act and 67 IT Act was lodged. 06 accused arrested, chargesheet filed, admissible financial relief amounting to Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the victim . In addition, pension of Rs. 5,000/- p.m and job as constable in Rajasthan Police was also given to the victim. File No. Har/217/2018-APCR
173 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Smt. Sonia, R/o Mohan Nagar, Palwal, Haryana complained of murder of her husband in 2017 in a train and no help for her from any source. Notice was issued , hearings were held and FIR No. 106/2017 lodged u/s 302, 307, 341 IPC, 145 Railway Act was modified and and section 3 of PoA Act was added on 06.10.2018, 03 accused arrested, chargesheets filed on 17.10.2017 and supplementary chargesheet filed on 12.10.2018 . Monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was provided to the family of the deceased victim on 26.10.2018 . Additional amount of Rs 8.94 lakh ( @Rs. 6.71 lakh to the petitioner and Rs 1.094 lakh to the victim’s mother) was paid by the Railways on 19.11.2018 and 31.05.2019 respectively. In addition, pension of Rs. 5,450/- pm and Rs. 6,000/- for ration money, free education to the children upto 12th standard was also sanctioned.
The Commission conducted special hearings in June & July 2019 , December 2019 and March 2020 and also held follow up review meetings in February – March 2020 in cases of heinous atrocities. In 121 cases2 action taken reports were received where 124 FIRs were lodged ( 44 in rape / gangrape cases , 56 in murder / attempt to murder cases,13 in kidnapping cases , 11 arson and other cases ),129 accused were arrested , 102 charge sheets were filed and monetary relief of Rs 473.18 lakh was paid to victims / families of victims. 2.5.2 NCSC State Office 2.5.2.1 State Office: Ahmedabad File No-NCSC/ABAD/R/26-Press Clipping-2018
Suo moto cognizance was taken of press report dated 25.06.2018 regarding rape and murder of Ms Jalpa d/o T Meghwal. FIR No.30/18, was lodged against one accused u/s 366k ,450, 376(1), 302 of IPC and 3(I)(B)(i)(ii), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act in Girab Police Station, Barmer, Rajasthan. Chargesheet No.12/18, was filed on 28.06.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs.8.25 lakh was sanctioned on 02.07.2018 to family of victim.
File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/62/PressClipping-2018
Suo moto cognizance was taken of press report dated 09.10.2018 of rape of a minor girl Km J, Merau, Mandavi, Kutch, Gujarat. FIR No.78/18, u/s 363,376(1),506 IPC, 5,6 of
2 List of cases at Annexure VIII
174 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
POCSO Act and 3(2)V of PoA Act was lodged, accused arrested, chargesheet submitted and Rs.5.00 lakh monetary help was given to victim. The case is on trail in POSCO Court Bhuj.
File No.NCSC/ABAD/G/21/PressClipping-2018
Suo moto cognizance was taken of press report dated 14.06.2018 of rape of a minor girl Km R….,., Amirpura, Radhanpur, Patan, Gujarat. Notice issued and FIR No.I-82/2018, was lodged u/s 363,366,376,506 IPC, 3/4 of POCSO Act and 3(2)V of PoA Act, accused has been arrested, charge sheet filed. Rs.8.25 lakhs monetary help given to victim . File No-NCSC/ABAD/R/32/-Press Clipping-2018
Suo moto cognizance was taken of press report on 25.06.2018 of murder of Shri Khatram,s/o Chataram, Ramsar, Barmer, Rajasthan. FIR No.71/18, dated 21.07.2018 was lodged against one accused u/s 147, 148, 149, 323, 365, 302 of IPC and 3(2)(V) of PoA Act. Chargesheet No.86/18 was filed before trial court on 16.10.2018. Government sanctioned Rs.8.25 lakh monetary help to family of victim. File No-NCSC/ABAD/R/88/Press-Clipping-2018
Suo moto cognizance was taken of press report on 28.01.2019 of murder of Shri Fusaram s/o Anaramji Meghwal, Gudayendala Police Sation, Pali. FIR No.12/19, was lodged u/s 390, 302/34 of IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act.Chargesheet No.25/19, was filed before trial court on 12.04.2019. Monetary compensation Rs.8.25 lakh was samctioned.
File No. NCSC/ABAD/G/82-APCR-2018
Shri Kantilal U Parmar representation regarding murder of Mahes Ratilal Zala was taken up with DM and SP, Amereli. Five accused were arrested and chargesheet filed. Monetary compensation of Rs.8.25 lakh was paid as well as contingency of Rs.4,500/- to family.
2.5.2.2(a) State Office : Bangaluru 2018-19
File No. 49/APCR/25/18-RU: The case of Sri. Pappanna, Maddur Taluk, Mandya regarding tresspass of his farm Sy no180, by other caste people was taken up and police registered FIR no 19/19 u/s 323,144,
175 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
3(1)(s) of PoA Act and arrested all accused , charge sheet was submitted . Monetary compensation of Rs 5000/- was also paid. File No. 49/APCR/26/2018-RU. The case of Kum.Savitha of RT Nagar, Bengaluru regarding caste abuse and beating was taken up. Police registered FIR no 268/18 under section IPC 506,34, 3(1)9r of PoA act and arrested the accused. The case was charge sheeted and compensation of Rs 0.50 lakh was paid.
2.5.2.2(b) State Office : Bangaluru 2019-20 File No. 49/APCR/03/19-RU: Shri.D.Narasimalu, S/o.D.Hanumanthappa, Asst. Teacher, Bangalore submitted a representation stating that he is facing untouchability by his colleagues (teachers). The petitioner has not satisfied with the police enquiry and he approached NCSC for intervention. After intervention of this Commission the a re-enquiry was conducted and FIR No.198/2019 u/s 3(1) (q) 3(1) (r), 3(1) (s) of POA Act was filed on 22.11.2019. The case is now under trail. Monetary relief Rs 0.25 lakh was paid to victim. File No. 49/APCR/41/19-RU: Kum M.B.Anusha, d/o.Shri.M.H.Basavaraju, Mysore submitted a representation stating that one Shri.C.S.Balarama, JSA(G), CFTRI, Mysore committed rape and cheated her on the pretext of marrying her. After the intervention of this office.FIR No. 147/2019 u/s 376 506 & 417 IPC 3(1)(r)(s), 3(1)(v) of PoA Act has been registered and accused was remanded for 48 hours. He has also been suspended from CFTRI. Monetary relief Rs 0.25 lakh was paid to victim.
2.5.2.3(a) State Office :Chandigarh 2018-19
File No. 25/80/2018-Res
Taking suo moto cognizance of news reports of 3 shepherdss killed and flock of sheep looted in Kurukshetra, Haryana on 22.05.2018 , notice was issued leading to lodging of
176 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
FIR under PoA Act and monetary compensation of` Rs 24.9 lakh (Rs. 8.25 lakh + 5000 per victim) was sanctioned.
File No. 25/91/2018-Res
Vicky R/o Majra Mehtab, Panchkula, Haryana was murdered on 03.07.2018. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under PoA Act and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned. File No. 25/115/2018-Res
Nisaan Singh S/o Sh. Dhram Singh r/o Khudan , Fatehabad, Haryana was murdered on 07.08.2018. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under PoA Act and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned. File No. 25/150/2018-Res
Davender r/o Mohan Nagar, gali no. 5, Palwal, Haryana was murdered on 17.09.2018. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under PoA Act and monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned. File No. 28/24/2018-Res
Smt. Sahani Devi r/o Village Sakoh ,Kangra, HP was raped and murdered. Suo moto notice was issued, FIR was registered under PoA Act on 15.03.2018, accused was arrested and charge sheet was sent to court on 14.06.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the victim's family. File No. 28/47/2018-Res
Sh. Kedar Singh ,Village Paad, Tehsil Shillai, Sirmour ,HP was murdered. The matter was taken up with the concerned authorities, FIR registered on 07.09.2018 in the PoA Act, charge sheet submitted on 19.11.2018. District Administration has provided monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh and regular monthly pension of Rs. 12,200/- to family of victim. File No. 28/52/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Shri Rajat , Dohar, Tehsil Nerwa, Shimla ,HP, being beaten to death , leading to lodging of FIR under appropriate sections including
177 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
PoA Act, chargesheet was filed. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned to his family. File No. 25/51/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Miss K….. (minor 14 years old) R/o Dharniya , Fatehabad ,Haryana being raped on 02.04.2018, notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under sections of IPC, POCSO & PoA Act . Monetary compensation of` Rs 3 lakh was sanctioned. File No. 25/89/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Miss P….. (minor 17 years old ) r/o Rangdan , Hisar Haryana being raped on 24.06.2018. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under sections of IPC, POCSO & PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned.. File No. 25/109/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Miss. M……. r/o Khedad , Hisar, Haryana being raped on 31.07.2018. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under sections of IPC, POCSO & PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 2.5 lakh was sanctioned . File No. 25/20/2019-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Smt. Amarjit Kaur ,Hathiyanwali, Ganganagar Rajasthan being raped on 30.01.2019. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under sections of IPC & PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned. File No. 28/15/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Ms. S……. , Chadiar, Hamirpur , HP being raped by her teacher by keeping her in confinement. Notice was issued and FIR was registered on 15.02.2018 under sections of IPC, POCSO & PoA Act. The accused was arrested and charge sheet was sent to court on 28.04.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 3.75 lakh was sanctioned . File No. 28/28/2018-Res
178 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Ms. Nirmal d/o Sh. Ratan Singh r/o Village Gundah,Tehsil Shillai, Sirmour,HP alleged that she was raped on the pretext of marriage. The matter was taken up with DC and SP, Sirmour. The accused was arrested and charge sheet was sent to court on 30.08.2018 and monetary compensation of Rs. 0.25 lakh was paid to the victim under POCSO Act. File No. 28/62/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Smt. Ritika Chouhan ,r/o VPO Moginand, Tehsil Nahan, Sirmour, HP being raped.Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under sections of IPC & PoA Act. The accused was arrested and charge sheet was sent to court. Monetary compensation of Rs 3.75 lakh was sanctioned . File No. 25/54/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Shri Sunil and Shri Dholu of Fatehabad, Haryana being thrashed and paraded on 08.04.2018. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under IPC and PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh was sanctioned . File No. 25/157/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Smt. Meena , R/o Jharokadi , Nuh, Haryana being beaten and hurt on 24.09.2018. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under IPC and PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh was sanctioned. File No. 24/84/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Harwinder Singh r/o Katron, Sangrur, Punjab was being beaten /hurt on 21.06.2018. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under IPC and PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 3 lakh was sanctioned . File No. 24/02/2019-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Kuldeep Singh, r/o Vill. Dera Meer Miran ,Fatehgarh Sahib, Punjab being beaten / hurt on 04.01.2019. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR under sections of IPC and PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 1.275 lakh was sanctioned. File No. 28/18/2018-Res
Shri Modhu Ram , r/o VPO Khamadi, Mandi HP was beaten up in January 2018. On taking up the matter was DC and SP, Mandi and FIR under sections of IPC and PoA Act was
179 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
registered on 01.03.2018, accused were arrested and challan was submitted in court on 27.08.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh was sanctioned on 12.12.2018. File No. 28/29/2018-Res
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of on 17.05.2018 that Smt. Santa Devi , r/o Vill. Chunar, Tehsil Pachhar, Sirmour, HP was threatened. The matter was taken up with the DC and SP, Sirmour and police registered a FIR under sections of IPC and PoA Act. Police arrested the accused and submitted challan in court. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.90 lakh was sanctioned on 12.12.2018. File No. 28/51/2018-Res
Shri Tek Singh , r/o Chohat Thunag, Mandi ,HP stated on 24.09.2018 that his wife was beaten up on account of construction of their house on the basis of they belong to SC community. The matter was taken up with DC and SP, Mandi, an FIR registered on 24.09.2018 with the PoA Act chargesheet submitted. Monetary compensation of Rs 1.50 lakh was sanctioned on 12.12.2018. 2.5.2.3(b) State Office :Chandigarh 2019-20
File No. 25/89/2019-Res :-
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Ms Kusum d/o Tilak Nuh , Haryana being raped on 09.07.2019 notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no. 561, dated 07.07.2019 u/s 376 IPC and section 3(2)v of PoA Act was lodged and monetary relief of Rs 2.50 lakh was paid to victim. File No. 25/133/2019-Res :-
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of rape of daughter of Harneder ,Rayahdwa ,Hisar , Haryana on 29.10.2019 notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no. 526, dated 27.10.2019 u/s 376 IPC and section 3(2)v of PoA Act was lodged and monetary relief of Rs 2.50 lakh was paid to victim. File No. 25/65/2019-Res :
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Budh Raj s/o Sunehra Ram ,Gumthala Gadu , Kurukshetra , Haryana on 30.05.2018 notice was issued and the case was
180 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
followed up . FIR no 263 was lodged u/s 302 IPC and 3(2) 5 of PoA Act and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 25/72/2019-Res:
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Pinky d/o Sh. Khem Chand , Faridabad , Haryana 17.06.2019 notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no 86, was lodged u/s 302 IPC and 3(2) 5 of PoA Act and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 25/33/2019-Res :
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Ritu d/o Wazir village Kuchrana Kalan, Jind , Haryana on 08.04.2019 notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no 66 was lodged u/s 302 IPC and 3(2) 5 of PoA Act and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 25/53/2019-Res :
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Pooja d/o Sh. Anggad ,Panipat , Haryana on 15.05.2019 notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no 347 was lodged u/s 302 IPC and 3(2) 5 of PoA Act and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 25/82/2019-Res:
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Dhani Ram s/o. Ram Prasad ,. Jhajjar , Haryana on 20-06-2019, notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no 75, dated 20.06.2019 was lodged u/s 379-B, 302, 412, 34 IPC & 3(2)5 of POA Act and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 25/75/2019-Res :
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Ramkishan s/o Jeevan Ram village Paluwas , Bhiwani , Haryana on 21.06.2019 , notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no 477 was lodged u/s 302, 328, 365, IPC and 3(2)5 of PoA Act at P.S. Sadar Bhiwani and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 25/130/2019-Res:
181 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Ravi s/o. Ram Kishan , Sheikhpura , Karnal , Haryana on 16.10.2019, notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no. 714 was lodged u/s 148, 149, 295, 302, 307, 323, 324, 427, 452 IPC , Arms Act. & 3(2)5 PoA Act at P.S. Assandh and monetary relief of Rs 5.175 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 25/110/2019-Res :
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Rakesh s/o Balbir Singh , Hisar , Haryana on 24.08.2019, notice was issued and the case was followed up . FIR no. 320, was lodged u/s 302, 34 IPC & 3(2)5 of PoA Act at P.S. Hisar Civil Lines and monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim.
2.5.2.4(a) State Office : Chennai 2018-19
File No. 1/134/2018 Rep.
Smt.Kumari, Thiruvannamalai submitted a representation regarding attack on her. The matter was taken up with the SP, Thiruvannamalai on 23.2.2018, an FIR was lodged alongwith sections of PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh was sanctioned to the victim on 10.07.2018. File No: 3/17/Krishnagiri/2018 Res.
Suo-motu cognizance was taken of the news reports of suicidal death of Kum.Tamilarasi (SC) studying IXth class, due to harassment by 2 non-SC boys. Notice was issued on 31.07.2018 leading to timely filing of FIR and chargesheet. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was sanctioned to family. File No: 1/664/2018 Rep. Smt. Chinnaponnu, Salem District submitted a representation regarding proper action in the rape and murder of her daughter. The matter was taken up with the SP Salem on 02.11.2018, due to which an FIR was lodged under IPC, PoA Act and POCSO Act. Monetary compensation of Rs 4.13 lakh was sanctioned to family on 13.12.2018.
2.5.2.4(b) State Office : Chennai 2019-20 Table 2.5
182 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
S.N File No. Nature FIR details No. of Charge Monetary o. of crime and accused sheet relief victim arrested filed on 1. 1/410/20 Sexual 14/2018 of Theni 1 19.08.2018 Rs. 3.00 18 Rep. exploitation of AWPS, Theni u/s lakh Smt. P. .3(2)(v) & 3(2)(va) Geethalakshmi of PoA Act 2. 1/478/20 Attack on Shri 66/2018 of 7 N.A Rs 8.25 18 Rep. A. Vattathikottai P.S, lakh (@ Ravichandiran Thanjavur u/s 3.00 lakh 3(2)(va) of PoA for 2 Act victims and Rs. 0.75 lakhs for 3 victims 3. 1/353/20 Caste abuse of 09/2018 of 2 28.05.2018 Rs. 0.75 18 Rep. Smt. Selvi Vaniambadi P.S., lakh Vellore u/s .3(1)((r)&(s) of PoA Act 4. 1/662/20 Caste abuse of 629/2018 of 4 23.10.2018 Rs. 0.75 18 Rep. Shri S. Alwar Theevattipatti P.S, lakh Salem u/s. 3(1)(r)(s) of PoA Act 5. 1/106/20 Caste abuse of 73/19 of Thusi P.S, 9 06.06.2019 Rs. 0.75 19 Rep. Shri A. Thiruvannamalai lakh Mathiazhagan u/s .3(1)(r)(s)(t) of PoA Act 6. 1/337/20 Attack and 97/19 of Kottur 2 02.09.2019 Rs.1.50 19 Rep. urination over P.S, Thiruvarur u/s lakh body of Shri P. .3(2)(va) of PoA Kollimalai Act 7. 1/624/20 Photo shop of 77/2018 of -- Yet to be Rs. 7.00 19 Rep. Shri Guru set Jayamangalam P.S, filed lakh on fire Theni u/s .3(2)(va) of PoA Act 8. 1/710/20 Attack on Shri 438/2019 of 2 30.11.2019 Rs. 1.50 19 Rep. Sundar Palanichettipatti lakh P.S, Theni u/s 3(2)(va) of PoA Act 9. 3/1/Then Murder of Sc 02/2020 of 15 Yet to be Rs 4.125 i/2020 person Jayamangalam filed lakh Res. P.S., Theni
183 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Sec.3(1)(r), 3(1)(s), and 3(2)(v) 10. 3/3/Tirun Murder of 2 11/2020 of 3 Yet to be Rs 8.25 elveli/20 SCs ( 1 male & Melapalayam P.S., filed lakh ( 20 Res. female) Tirunelveli District @Rs 4.125 – 3(1)(r), 3(1)(s) lakh x 2 and 3(2)(va) victims) 11. 3/7/Villu Mob lynching 13/2020 of 7 Yet to be Rs 4.125 puram/2 of an SC man Periyathachur P.S., filed lakh 020 Res. Villupuram District – 3(2)(v) 12. 3/10/Tuti Murder of SC 31/2020 of 1 Yet to be Rs 4.125 corin/20 man Kazhugumalai filed lakh 20 Res. P.S., Tuticorin District – 3(2)(v)
2.5.2.5(a) State Office: Hyderabad 2018-19
F. No. 3/16/19/MP-RU:
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of rape of Class 9 student at Chhapiheda PS, Rajgarh , MP on 20.01.2019. Notice was issued and FIR no. 19/2019 u/s 376, 376D 342 IPC, 3 & 4 POCSO Act, 3(1)(wi), 3(2)(va) of PoA Act was registered,3 accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 5 lakh was paid on 28.01.2019. F. No. 3/50/17/AP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of rape of SC minor girl by pastor at Kuravakaluva (V), Renugunta, Chittoor on 27.09.2017. Notice was issued and FIR no. 175/2017 was registered at Gajulamanyal PS u/s. 376(1) IPC, 6 r/w. 5(m) of POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3.75 lakh was paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/14/18/TS-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of attempted rape on 4 year old child in Jawaharnagar, BJR Nagar, Hyderabad, Telangana, on 18.02.2019. Notice was issued and FIR no. 156/18 was registered at Jawaharnagar PS u/s. 376 IPC, Sec. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Accused was arrested and charge sheet submitted. Monetary compensation of Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to the victim’s family.
184 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
F. No. 3/11/19/TS-RU: Representation received from Kum Jagruthi Chethana, D/o Yadagiri, Nadivani Gudem Village, Nalgonda, Telangana regarding rape and harassment by G. Mahesh. Notice was issued and FIR no 20/2019 of P.S. Nalgonda I Town was registered u/s. 323, 344, 366, 376, 506, 504 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, , accused arrested on 19.03.2019 and charge sheet submitted. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3.00 lakh has been paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/14/19/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports regarding woman abducted and raped for 3 days at Khajuri PS, Bhopal, MP on 23.12.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 503/18 was registered at Khajuri PS u/s. 363, 366, 376, 506 IPC, 3(2)(v), 3(1)(w)(i) of PoA Act,accused was arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3 lakh was paid to the victim on 21.02.2019.
F. No. 3/61/18/TS-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports regarding a woman gang raped by 4 persons in Kalwakurthy, Nagarkurnool, Telangana on 18.06.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 139/2018 u/s. 341, 376D r/w. 34 IPC, 3(1)(e)(r)(s)(w), (1)(2) and Section 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Kalwakurthy PS. 04 accused arrested on 19.06.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs. 6.187 lakh has been paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/15/19/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of gang rape of SC minor girl at Sanjay Nagar, Jaura PS, Morena, MP on 15.01.2019. Notice was issued and FIR no 23/19 u/s. 376, 506, 3&4 POCSO Act, 3(2)(va) of PoA Act was lodged and accused arrested,chargesheet submitted on 26.03.2019. As per information received from DM Morena rape has not been established in medical report. Monetary compensation of Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/100/18/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of rape of 15 year old girl in Dewas MP, on 22.07.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 135/18 was registered at Nemawar Town PS u/s. 376(2), 376D IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. As per information received rape has not been
185 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
established in medical report. Monetary compensation of Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/27/18/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports on 06.04.2018 of a SC woman gang raped for months in Satna MP . Notice was issued and FIR no 158/18 was registered u/s. 366, 376(2), 201, 506, 315, 316, 34 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act at Civil Lines PS, Satna,accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 2 lakh was paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/31/18/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports on 17.04.2018 of gang rape of SC woman and videography of same at Hata PS limits, Damoh MP. Notice was issued and FIR no 180/18 was registered at Hata PS u/s. 376(2), 3(1)(w)(ii) of PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3 lakh has been paid.
F. No. 3/156/18/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports on 01.10.2018 of gang rape of SC girl at Hadhwas (V), Piperia, Hoshangabad MP. Notice was issued and FIR no 364/18 u/s. 376D IPC, 5 & 6 of POCSO Act, 3(1)(w), 3(1)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Piperia PS and 4 accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 6.1875 lakh has been paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/28/19/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports on 25.03.2019 of rape of SC woman in Datia ,MP. Notice was issued and FIR no 35/19 u/s. 376 IPC, 3(1)(w)(1), (2) of PoA Act was registered at Badoni PS. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3 lakh has been paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/149/18/MP-RU: Representation dated 21.05.2018 received from Smt. Samvidha Srigothri, R/o. Sukludana, Kundipura PS, Chindwara MP regarding rape. Notice was issued and FIR no 152/2018 u/s. 376 (1), 506 IPC, 3(2)(v), 3(2)(va), 3(1)(w)(2) of PoA Act was registered at Ashokagarden PS. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3 lakh has been paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/113/18/MP-RU:
186 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports on 07.03.2018 of a teenager accused of sodomising three year old girl at Tikamgarh MP. Notice was issued and FIR no 153/18 was registered at Tikamgarh PS u/s. 377 IPC, 3(1)(b), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. and 5 and 6 of POCSO Act and accused arrested on 20.09.2018. First instalment of monetary compensation of Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to the victim.
F. No. 3/73/17/TS-RU:
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of Shri Darelliyesu a farmer of Dhaniyapadu , Kothagudem , Bhadradri Kothagudem, Telangana committing suicide due to outstanding loans repayment pressure.. The matter was taken up and followed up with DM . Monetary compensation of Rs.4.125 lakh sanctioned to family. F. No. 3/78/16/TS-RU: Representation from Shri Vampu Komuraiah, H.No. 3-51/1, Seetaramapuram, Gundala, Janagam Dist., Telangana regarding murder of his son Shri Vampu Mahender was taken up. Notice was issued and FIR no 44/2016 of P.S. Gundala u/s. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered, accused arrested, charge sheet submitted. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the father of victim.
F. No. 3/12/18/TS-RU:
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 10 year old boy in social welfare hostel at Bhadradri-Kothagudem, Telangana on 06.02.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 47/2018 was registered at Manuguru PS u/s. 304A IPC, 3(2)(vii) of PoA Act. Government gave employment to mother of Master D. Jaswant, , who died due to negligence of doctors. F. No. 3/110/18/TS-RU:
Shri K. Vinod Kumar of Medchal Dist., Telangana submitted a petition about murder of his father. Notice was issued and FIR no 392/2018 u/s. 302 IPC, 3(2)(va) of PoA Act was registered at Balanagar PS, 3 accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh has been paid to family. F. No. 3/8/18/TS-RU:
187 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of an SC lady being burnt to death (Smt. Durgam Savantha Bai ,Marthidi (V), Bejjur (M), Kumaram Bheem , Telangana) on 31.01.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no. 12/2018 u/s. 302 IPC, 3(2)(v) PoA Act was lodged, charge sheet submitted. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the family of victim.
F. No. 3/9/18/TS-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of suicide of Kum. Sai Deepthi, student of Jyothi High School, Malkajgiri, Hyderabad, Telangana on 02.02.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no. 101/2018 i registered. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the family of victim.
F. No. 3/59/18/TS-RU:
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of stalker slitting throat of Ms. Vootla Roshini R/o. Hanuman Nagar, Godavarikhani, Peddapalli , Telangana on 15.06.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no. 247/2018 u/s. 354-A, 354-D, 302 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered, accused arrested on 15.06.2018. , charge sheet submitted. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the mother of victim F. No. 3/24/18/TS-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of murder of Shri Erragalla Sudheer , Kukatpally, Hyderabad, Telangana on 12.03.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no.226/2018 of Kukatpally PS was registered u/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC, 27(2) of Indian Arms Act, and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. All 5 accused were arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh has been paid to the father of victim on 20.06.2018.
F. No. 3/72/18/TS-RU: This office has received a representation from Smt. Drupati, W/o. Late Narsappa, H. No. 1-107, Yesgi (V), Nagalgidda (M). Sangareddy, Telangana regarding murder of her husband on 16.05.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no.. 17/18 u/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Nagalgidda PS. Two accused were arrested. charge sheet submitted. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the family of victim..
F. No. 3/9/19/TS-RU:
188 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of man (non-SC) killing wife (SC), son and setting the bodies ablaze. Notice was issued and FIR no. 63/2019 u/s. 302, 201, 498-A IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Ghatkesar PS, Hyderabad, Telangana. All accused were (03) arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the mother of the lady victim on 22.03.2019.
F. No. 3/78/16/TS-RU: DM Jangaon, Telangana sanctioned Rs. 8.25 lakh to the family of murder victim Shri V. Kumaraiah, Gundala Village, Jangaon after NCSC took up the matter.
F. No. 3/15/18/AP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of suspicious death of Shri Vijay Kumar R/o. Buddayapalle (V), Khajipet (M), Kadapa on 11.03.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no.46/18 was registered at Khajipet PS u/s. 174 Cr. P.C., 302, 201 IPC, 3(2)(va) of PoA Act. Two accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the family of the deceased.
F. No. 3/84/16/AP-RU: Representation received from Smt. Bala Narsamma W/o. Shri G. Balaiah R/o. Peddapalle (V), Siddavatam (M), Kadapa ,AP regarding murder of her husband. Notice was issued and FIR no.74/2016 was registered at Siddout PS u/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC, 3(2)(r) of PoA Act. Accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the wife of the deceased her son was given a job.
F. No. 3/97/16/AP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of alleged suicide of Shri Kiran in front of Collectorate, Kurnool, AP on 05.10.2016 due to land issue. Notice was issued and FIR no.393/2016 registered at Kurnool III Town PS u/s. 324 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the family of the deceased.
F. No. 3/64/17/MP-RU: Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of an old lady being beaten to death in Guna MP. The case was taken up for investigation police registered case under PoA Act and
189 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
arrested all accused. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the family of the deceased.
F. No. 3/116/18/MP-RU: The DM, Neemuch ,MP paid Rs. 3 lakh compensation to family of Shri Sunil Dhanak, who committed suicide. The case was taken up by this office suomoto, based on a press clipping.
F. No. 3/13/18/MP-RU: This is a suo-motto case regarding minor girl burnt during attempt to rape her in Rajgarh ,MP, as per news on 12.02.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no . 27/18 was registered at Khujaner PS u/s. 354, 450, 307 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, Sec. 3 of POCSO Act and accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh has been paid to the family of deceased.
F. No. 3/148/18/MP-RU: The case pertaining lynching of an SC at Shivapuri,MP was followed up , 11 accused arrested and it was ensured that Rs 8.25 lakh compensation was disbursed to the family of victim.
F. No. 3/129/18/MP-RU: This is a suo-motto case regarding SC student stoned to death for not withdrawing sexual harassment case in Seoni, MP, taken up after news reports on 20.08.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 458/18 u/s. 341, 307, 302, 195A IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Kothwali PS. Rs 8.25 lakh compensation was disbursed to the family of victim.
F. No. 3/84/18/MP-RU: This is a suo-motto case regarding SC farmer who set on fire over land dispute in Bhopal ,MP on 22.06.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 374/18 u/s. 302, 447, 34 IPC, 3(2)(v), 3(2)(va) of PoA Act was registered at Bairasiya PS and accused arrested. Rs 8.25 lakh compensation was disbursed to the family of victim.Son of victim was given a daily wage job.
F. No. 3/59/19/MP-RU:
190 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
This is a suo-motto case regarding death during police firing in Morena MP, based on press reports of 09.06.2019. Notice was issued and FIR no 381/19 was registered. Monetary compensation of Rs. 5.125 lakh was paid to the family of deceased.
F. No. 3/33/19/MP-RU: This is a suo-motto case regarding burning of minor girl by for refusal to marry accused in Vidisha ,MP, taken up after press reports of 04.04.2019. Accused was arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh provided to family of victim.
F. No. 3/165/18/MP-RU: Representation dated 20.08.2018 was received from Smt. Kamala Bai Ahirwar R/o. Narsinghpur ,MP regarding murder of her husband Shri Premlal Ahirwar. Notice was issued and FIR no 438/17 was registered at Madotal PS u/s. 302 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh provided to family of victim.
F. No. 3/29/19/MP-RU: This is a suo-motto case regarding murder of Shri Bahori R/o. Chotipathariya (V), Batiyagad PS, Damoh ,MP on 22.03.2019. Notice was issued and FIR no 71/19 u/s. 302, 294, 506B, 147, 148, 149, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Batiyagad PS. Accused arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh provided to family of victim.
F. No. 3/84/17/TS-RU:
DM, Hyderabad sanctioned Rs. 4.25 lakh to parents of Kum.Deepthi, Secunderabad who had committed suicide for want of payment fees and insult by principal. F. No. 3/73/17/MP-RU:
Newspapers reported that SCs of Bachrowli Village, Bhind ,MP were beaten up by OCs on 06.10.2017. After NCSC took up the case, district administration took action , registered a case under Section 3(2)(v) (a) of PoA Act and accused were arrested. The case was followed up vigorously and report dated 14.05.2018 received from DM that Rs. 3 lakh (@Rs1.50 lakh each ) were paid to the victims. F. No. 7/2/19/TS-RU:
191 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
This is a suo-motto case of social boycott of SCs at Marampally (V), Nandipet (M), Nizamabad on 02.01.2019. Notice was issued and FIR no 6/2019 u/s. 384 IPC, 3(1)(r)(s)(zc), 3(2)(va) of PoA Act was registered at Nandipet PS. 25 accused were arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs. 80 lakh was paid to 80 victims. F. No. 7/22/17/AP-RU:
A social boycott was reported on 26.06.2017. After constant persuasion, DM West Godavari AP submitted a written report that Rs. 63 lakh had been given to 63 victims @ Rs. 1 lakh each and free ration, 20 pensions, community hall, MNREGS work,etc was also sanctioned. F. No. 3/3/18/TS-RU:
Social boycott of Smt. Jakkula Mamata, woman sarpanch of village Bassapur, Nizamabad was taken up. Due to follow up by NCSC, the FIR has been registered u/s 3(1)(s) & (zc) of PoA Act and Rs. 2 lakh compensation has been paid to the victim. F. No. 3/86/18/AP-RU:
DM Prakasam disbursed Rs. 32 lakh to 32 SC children of orphanage, who were sexually molested by a pastor. F. No. 3/15/18/MP-RU:
This is a suo-motto case regarding SC person was burnt in holy fire at Rahatgarh PS limits, Sagar MP on 02.03.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 86/18 was registered at Rahatgarh PS u/s. 308, 34 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Accused was arrested. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid to the victim and the matter is being pursued to pay remaining monetary relief. F. No. 3/96/18/MP-RU:
This is a suo-motto case regarding sexual exploitation of 10 years old girl by doctor at Neemuch, MP was taken up after, press reports on 12.07.2018. Notice was issued and FIR no 365/18 was registered at Neemuch PS u/s. 323, 3(1)(w), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs. 0.75 lakh was paid. F. No. 3/2/19/CG-RU:
192 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
This is a suo-motto case regarding “Chhattisgarh child’s bad touch lesson reveals daily rape horror” taken up after news reports on 07.02.2019. FIR No. 1/2019 u/s. 376 IPC, 3(2)(v), 3(1)(b) PoA Act, Section 6 of POCSO Act was registered at Pakhanjur PS, North Bastar Kanker , Chhattisgarh. Accused arrested on 05.02.2019. Monetary relief of Rs. 3 lakh has been sanctioned.
1503 cases more were taken up as suo-motu, 163 FIRs were lodged, 78 cases were charge sheeted and 187 persons were arrested. Monetary relief of Rs. 223.82 lakh . 2.5.2.5(b) State Office: Hyderabad 2019-20
F. No. 3/21/19/AP-RU:
Shri Bakki Srinu, was beaten to death for stealing mangoes at Rangampeta PS, East Godavari, Andhra Pradesh , case was followed up and FIR No. 96/2016 u/s. 302, 342 r/w. 34 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, 1989 was registered on 30.05.2019. Out of 12 accused, 10 accused were arrested on 30.05.2019 and remaining two were arrested on 03.06.2019. Rs. 4.125 lakh as monetary relief was sanctioned in favour the widow and pension of Rs. 5,000/- per month also sanctioned. Action has been initiated to provide permanent employment to the widow , house site also sanctioned and patta was issued to her and to provide education facilities to the children of the deceased viz., Master Bakki Sathvik (5 years) and Master Bakki Mahidhar (3 years). F. No. 3/15/18/AP-RU:
Suspicious death of Shri K. Vijaykumar R/o. Buddayapalle (V), Khajipet (M), YSR, AP was followed up. FIR No. 46/2018 Khajipet PS was registered u/s. 302, 201 IPC and 3(2) (va) of PoA Act. Relief Rs. 8.25 lakh was sanctioned to grandmother of the deceased on 16.11.2018 and amount transferred to her account on 02.01.2019. F. No. 3/84/16/AP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of murder of Shri G. Balaiah, Pedapalli (V), Sidhout (M), YSR, AP notice was issued and case followed up. FIR No. 74/2016 u/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC and 3(1)(r) of POA Act was registered. Monetary relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh
3 File wise details at Annexure IX
193 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
was paid on 16.03.2017 and 13.07.2017. In addition, pension of Rs. 1,000/- per month was sanctioned to the wife of the deceased. After follow up employment to his son as office subordinate in DEO office was provided on 28.02.2019. And proposal for allotment of 2 acres of agricultural land is under consideration. F. No. 3/75/18/AP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of a man in Nellore, AP burning wife, her lover alive after seeing them in compromising position . Deceased Shri Madapaka Haribabu was SC. FIR No. 195/2018 u/s. 342, 436, 302 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Muthukur PS. Monetary relief Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid the wife of the victim. F. No. 2/141/16/AP-RU:
Representation received from Shri Beri Srinivasulu, Patturu (V), Khajipet (M), YSR, AP was for non payment of monetary relief in FIR No. 105/2016 of Khajipet PS u/s. 341, 506 r/w. 34 IPC and Sec. 3(1)(r)(s) of PoA Act, 2015. The case was followed up and first instalment of Rs. 0.75 lakh was paid to the victim on 02.01.2019. F. No. 3/60/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports on four SC youth beaten by upper caste men in Dewas, MP and case followed up. FIR No. 172/19 147, 148, 323, 307, 294,506, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered. As per the report of SP dated 07.09.2019, out of four persons, one died and Rs 8.25 lakh compensation was paid to the wife of deceased. The remaining 3 victims were paid monetary relief of Rs. 4.50 lakh ( @ Rs. 1.50 lakh each ). F. No. 3/29/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports on murder of SC person Shri Bahori , Choti Pathariya (V), Batiyagad PS limits, Damoh, MP and case followed up. FIR No. 71/19 u/s. 302, 204, 506B, 147, 148, 149 and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Batiyagad PS. Monetary relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to victim’s family on 06.07.2019. F. No. 3/33/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports on 04.04.2019 regarding burning alive of SC girl by 17 year old boy for refusing to marriage at Hydergarh, Vidisha, MP and case
194 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
followed up. FIR No. 69/2019 was registered u/s. 457, 376, 506, 307, 302, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Accused arrested. Monetary relief Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid on 10.06.2019. F. No. 3/84/18/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of Shri Kishorilal Jatav being burnt alive in front of his wife at Parsoriya Ghatkedi, Bairasiya Tahsil, Bhopal, MP, notice was issued and case followed up. Case is charged sheeted and pending for trial. Monetary relief Rs. 4.125 lakh was was paid to the widow on 01.08.2019. F. No. 3/57/18/TS-RU: :
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of SC farmer, son murdered over land Kandikatkoor Village, Rajanna Sircilla, Telangana on 14.06.2018 and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 57/18 U/s. 302, 307 r/w. 34 IPC and Sec. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Ellanthakunta PS. Two accused arrested , case is charge sheeted and pending for trial. Monetary relief of Rs. 16.50 lakh for two victims was paid to the wife of the deceased. As additional relief, another son was given government employment as village revenue assistant at Pothur Village and agriculture land to the extent of 2.00 acres in Sy. No. 433 situated at Dacharam Village of Ellanthakunta was assigned to wife of the deceased in addition to 3 months ration and widow pension. F. No. 3/9/19/TS-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports on 10.02.2019 of man killing wife and son, setting the body ablaze and case followed up. FIR No. 63/2019 was registered at Ghatkesar PS u/s. 302, 201, 498-A IPC and 3(2) (va) of PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs. 16.50 lakh was paid to mother of the deceased lady. F. No. 3/8/18/TS-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of Smt. Durgam Savantha Bai being burnt alive by pouring kerosene in Marthidi , Bejjur, Kumurambheem, Telangana and case followed up. FIR No. 12/2018 U/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC, 3(2)(v)(a) of PoA Act was registered at Bejjur PS. Case charged sheeted. Monetary relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to family. Victim had 3 sons and as additional relief her first son was sanctioned with basic monthly pension of Rs. 5,000/- with allowances w.e.f. 01.01.2020, 2nd son was allotted with 2BHK house and 3rd son was given 3 acres agriculture land.
195 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
F. No. 2/83/19/TS-RU:
Representation from Shri Sarangi Nadipi Gangadhar, s/o.Pedda Sandanna, R/o.H.No.1- 1/3/8, Chepur, Armoor (M), Nizamabad, Telangana was a request to fix boundaries in Sy.No.375/A/7, S.No. 375/E/9/2 and Sy.No. 375/A/30 in Chepur as well as protection from harassment by Shapur Chinna Gangadhar vide FIR No.133/2019-Armoor PS u/s. 324, 323, 427 r/w. 34 IPC and 3(f)(s) of PoA Act. 75% of monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh (@ 0.75 lakh x 2 victims ) was paid to the victims. F. No. 3/98/19/TS-RU:
Representation was received from Smt. Mondi Suguna, w/o late Shri Pedda Sayanna, H.No. 3-61/2, Sikindrapur(v) Bheemgal(m), Nizamabad, Telangana regarding murder of her son on 23.01.2019. FIR No. 9/19 of Bheemgal P.S. u/s. 306, 107 r/w. 34 IPC and 3(1)(r)(s) & 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was lodged. After pursuing the matter with monetary relief of Rs. 3 lakh was sanctioned. F. No. 22/17/19/AP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape of UKG girl in Guntur, AP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 349/2019 was registered u/s. 376(2)(i) IPC, 4 POCSO Act &. 3(1)(w)(i) of PoA Act. Accused arrested. District administration sanctioned Rs. 7.25 lakh (@ Rs 5 lakh under CMs Relief Fund, Rs. 2 lakh towards education of the victim and 0.25 lakh assistance under POCSO Act) , provided employment to the mother of the victim as ANM, house site and house in Guntur Municipal area was sanctioned . F. No. 3/56/17/AP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of gang rape of minor SC girl in Jaggaiahpet PS limits of Kirshna, AP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 172/2017 of Jaggaiahpet PS u/s. 376-D, 506 IPC , 5 r/w. POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered. Case is charged sheeted and monetary relief Rs. 6.19 lakh was paid in July, 2019 and additional relief measures like sanction of agriculture land, sanction of house, free education and provision for utensil and provisions for 3 months are being provided. F. No. 22/1/19/AP-RU:
196 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports on 30.07.2019 of 7 year old student sexually assaulted by H.M. in Guntur, AP and notice issued , case followed up . Case is registered under FIR No. 226/2019 of Thulluru PS u/s. 376 AB IPC, 5(f), 5(l), 5(m) r/w 6 of POCSO Act and 3(1)(w)(i), 3(1)(w)(ii), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to the victim’s mother. F. No. 22/5/19/CG-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of minor girl gang-raped by three boys in Rajnandgaon, Chhattisgarh, Bandatola on 16.09.2019 and notice issued , case followed up. FIR. No. 123/19 u/s. 456, 366(A), 376(D), 354, 506, 34 IPC, 4, 5 of POCSO Act & 3(2) (va) of PoA Act was registerd at Mohla PS on 17.09.2019. Accused was arrested and case is under trial. Monetary relief Rs 4.00 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 3/3/19/CG-RU:
The case of rape of SC girl, was followed up. FIR was registered u/s 376 and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. The accused was arrested. Monetary compensation Rs 2.5 lakh was paid to the victim by DM, Sarguja, Chattisgarh. F. No. 3/65/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape and murder of a minor girl in Ujjain, MP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 324/2019 was registered at Mahakal PS, Ujjain, MP u/s. 363, 302, 201, 449, 366, 376(A-B) of IPC, 5/6 POCSO Act & 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Accused arrested. Total monetary relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the family members of the deceased. Court gave sentence of life imprisonment of the accused. F. No. 3/50/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of a minor SC girl gang raped in Prithvipur P.S, Jalandhar village, Niwari, MP on 20.05.2019 and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 192/19 u/s. 376(2)(n), 376D, 312, 313, 315 IPC, 3(2)(v), 3(1)(w) of PoA Act & 5/6 of POCSO Act was registered. Monetary relief Rs. 6.19 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 3/159/18/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of sexual exploitation of 13 year old minor girl at Kothwali PS, Bairavganj area, Shivni, MP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR
197 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
No. 611/18 u/s. 376D, 376(2)N, 376(2)(c) , 3(2) PoA Act & 5,6 of POCSO Act was lodged at Kothwali PS. Monetary relief of Rs. 33.00 lakh was paid on 22.07.2019 . F. No. 3/95/18/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of sexual assault of SC minor girl and making video viral in Sheopur, MP and notice issued , case followed up. As per the report received from the DM dated 19.08.2019, FIR was registered u/s. 376 of IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act and monetary relief Rs. 3.00 lakh was sanctioned and paid to the victim on 02.08.2019. F. No. 3/133/18/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape and beating of SC girl and relatives on 04.09.2018 in Datia , MP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR in Cr. No. 141/18 u/s. 3(1)w of PoA Act was registered at Badauni PS. Victims Kum. Reena Ahirwar d/o. Shamlal Ahirwar and Smt. Parvati Ahirwar and Shri Kashiram Ahirwar r/o. Basdakhurd, Badauni, Datia, MP. Monetary relief of Rs.3.00 lakh ( @ Rs 1.50 lakh, Rs. 0.75 lakh and Rs. 0.75 lakh respectively) was paid to the victims. F. No. 3/16/19/MP-RU:
DM paid Rs. 2.50 lakh as monetary relief to rape victim, a 9th class student of Chhapiheda PS limits, Rajgad, MP after we took up case. Charge sheet is being followed up. F. No. 3/104/18/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports on 25.07.2018 regarding sexual exploitation of SC girl in the name of marriage in Betul, MP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 1056/17 was registered u/s. 376(2) IPC and 3 (1) (w-ii), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to victim. F. No. 3/17/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of rape attempt by ASI on woman SI in Chindwada, MP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 56/19 at Harda PS u/s. 376 (2) 323, 506, 109, 3(2) (i) of PoA Act eas registered. Monetary relief of Rs. 1 lakh was sanctioned and paid to the victim. F. No. 22/2/19/MP-RU:
198 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of rape of minor girl at Narsinghpur , MP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 448/19 u/s. 363, 366, 376(3), 376A, B, 323, 324 IPC, 3 (2) v(a) & 4, 5 of POCSO Act was registered at Station Ganj PS. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.75 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 3/46/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of rape of SC woman by house owner r/o. Khatipura Elaka, Heeranagar PS, Indore, MP on 06.05.2019 and notice issued, case followed up. FIR No. 353/19 u/s. 376, 450, 506, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered at Heeranagar PS. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.00 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 3/15/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of gang rape of SC girl of Sanjay Nagar, Jaura Police Station, Muraina, MP on 15.01.2020 and notice issued, case followed up. FIR. No. 23/19 was registered at Jaura PS u/s. 376, 3/4 of POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Case is charged sheeted and pending for trial. Monetary relief Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 22/27/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of 3 year old girl raped by 53 years old man at Barwani, MP on 13.11.2019 and notice issued, case followed up. FIR No. 434/2019 U/s. 376AB IPC, 3/4, 5 of POCSO Act & 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. was registered Barwani AJK PS. Accused arrested, case charged and pending for trial. Monetary compensation Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 3/45/19/TS-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of 16 year old Kum. Perla Geetha D/o. Chandraiah, 18th Ward, Bapujinagar, Miryalaguda Town, Nalgonda , Telangana being assaulted and notice issued , case followed up. Case in Cr. No. 105/19, P.S. Miryalguda I Town was registered u/s. 376 of IPC & 3(1)(w)(i) & 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 3 accused arrested. Monetary relief of Rs. 5 lakh was paid and proposals processed for admitting her in Ashram schools/ residential college for providing free education up to graduation level. F. No. 3/11/19/TS-RU:
199 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Representation was received from Kum. Jagruthi Chethan, d/o Yadagiri, Nadivani Gudem Village, Nalgonda, Telangana regarding rape and harassment by a G. Mahesh. FIR No. 20/2019 of P.S. Nalgonda I Town was registered u/s. 376 of IPC and 3(1)(w)(i) & 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary relief Rs. 3.00 lakh was paid to the victim. Case is charged sheeted and pending for trial. F. No. 3/107/19/TS-RU:
Representation was received from Ms. Chekuri Nagalakshmi, d/o Thandra Venkataiah, Kondapuram(v), Chanduru(m) Nalgonda, Telangana. FIR No. 150/2018 of Chandur P.S. was registered u/s. 376 of IPC & 3(2) (va) of PoA Act. Case is charged sheeted and pending trial. Monetary relief Rs. 3.00 lakh was paid to the victim. . F. No. 3/32/19/TS-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports on 17.05.2019 regarding gang rape of 16 year old girl at Siddipet, Telangana and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 50/2019 of Jagadevpur PS was registered u/s. 376(D), 366(A), 386 IPC , 5(1) of POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.00 lakh was paid on 18.05.2019. F. No. 3/14/19/TS – RU:
Representation regarding rape of Kum. Begari Laxmi d/o. Shri Mallanna r/o. Rukmapur (V), Nyalkal (M),Medak, Telangana was received and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 66/2015 of PS Hadnoor was lodged u/s. 376(2)(i) IPC, 6 of POSCO and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act, 1989). Case is chargesheeted. Monetary compensation Rs. 1.80 lakh was paid to victim. F. No. 3/9/19/AP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of sexual assault on 8 year old girl by teacher in Government School in Nuzvid, Krishna, AP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 30/19 u/s. 324, 354 IPC, 10 POCSO Act and 3(2) (va) of PoA Act, was lodged. Monetary relief of Rs. 1 lakh was sanctioned and paid. F. No. 3/10/18/AP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of a 15 year old girl raped at Cheedikada, Thuruvolu (V), Visakhapatnam , AP and notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 2/2018
200 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
u/s. 324, 506 IPC, 3(1)(s) of PoA Act was registered at Case is charged sheeted and pending for trial. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was sanctioned and paid to the victim. F. No. 3/150/18/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of skin of Shri. Sardar Singh Jatva,. Mahoba Village, Shivpuri, MP being removed by accused , notice issued and case followed up . FIR No. 204/18 of Narwar PS was registered u/s. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.80 lakh was paid to the victim. F. No. 3/89/17/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of 10.11.2017 regarding grievous hurt to the SC people in Shivpuri, MP. 04 FIRs have been registered viz, No. 353/17, No. 354/17, No. 356/17 & No. 357/17 u/s 3(2)(V), 3(1)r, s, z of PoA Act & IPC 452, 436, 433, 427, 147, 148, 149. Monetary relief of Rs. 15.50 lakh has been provided to all 39 victims. F. No. 3/20/18/TS-RU:
Representation of Smt. K. Lakshmi r/o Plot No. 1/2, Bandlaguda, RC Puram, Hyderabad, Telangana was received regarding cheating, sexual exploitation by one Shri K. Anvesh and refusal of police to register FIR , notice issued , case followed up. FIR No. 199/2018 of Ramachandrapuram PS was registered u/s. 498-A IPC and 3(1)(r)(s) of PoA Act. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.75 lakh was paid in 2 instalments on 18.05.2019 and 29.06.2019 respectively. F. No. 3/2/18/TS-RU:
Acid attack on Smt. Saldhi Sandhya w/o. Shri Rakesh , Vannel-B(V), Balkonda (M), Nizamabad, Telangana was followed up. FIRNo. 211/2017 was registered u/s. 307 IPC, 3(1)(a), 3(2) (va) of POA Act. Monetary relief Rs. 3.0 lakh was paid in 2 instalments on 03.01.2018 and 22.06.2019 respectively. F.No.3/62/18/TS-RU:
Representation from Shri V. Srinu s/o. Mysaiah, Shaligouraram (V) & (M), Nalgonda, Telangana was received regarding attack on him and his family, demolition of his hotel and abuse in the name of caste by OCs. Notice issued and case followed up . FIR No.
201 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
53/2018 was registered u/s. 143, 427 IPC and 3(1)(r)(s) of PoA Act. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.75 lakh was paid in 2 instalments on 18.06.2018 and 30.06.2019 respectively. F. No. 7/37/19/TS-RU:
Representation received from Smt. Alivelu, w/o. Kalyan, R/o. H.No.8-2-293/82/GTM, Gautam Nagar, Film Nagar, Hyderabad, Telangana regarding threatening and beating by Sri. Manikyam, Dhanraj, Kumar and 20 others for property was pursued. After follow up, FIR No. 409/2019 u/s. 354, 506 IPC was lodged and the accused paid Rs. 4 lakh to the victim and settled the matter in Lok Adalat. F. No. 3/41/19/AP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of 17.08.2019 regarding abuse, humiliation, harassment of minor dalit girl by YSR CP leader in Panchayat at Anantapuram, AP . Victim was Kum. Harijana Vannuramma d/o. H. Yellappa, KP Doddi (V), Gummagatta (M), Anantapuramu, AP. FIR No. 71/2019 u/s. 323, 355, 509, 354, 109 r/w. 34 IPC, 75 of Juvenile Justice Act, 8 of POCSO Act and 3(1)(r)(s)(w) (va) of PoA Act was registered at Gummagatta PS and accused arrested. Case charged sheeted and pending for trial. Monetary relief of Rs. 2 lakh was sanctioned to the victim in addition to providing essential commodities/utensils to the victim’s family. F. No. 3/25/18/AP-RU:
Representation was received from Mrs. Varalaxmi Devi, w/o Jooturu Peda Balaiah, Uppukuntapally (v), Mydukuru , AP regarding cheating physical abuse and attack by her non SC husband . Case in Cr. No. 276/2018 was registered at Mydukur P.S. u/s. 420, 506, 509 IPC, 3(1)(s)(w) of PoA Act, accused arrested and case charged and pending for trial. Monetary relief of Rs. 3.25 lakh was paid to the victim on 04.12.2019. F. No. 3/3/18/TS-RU :
FIR No. 98/2018 u/s. 384 r/w 34 IPC, 3(zc) of PoA Act registered at Kammarpally PS, Nizamabad, Telangana regarding social boycott of SCs was pursued. Monetary relief of Rs 2 lakh (@Rs. 1lakh each x 2 victims ) was paid to victims Shri Sunkari Vijay Kumar and Shri Neerati Harish on 05.07.2019. F. No. 3/58/19/TS-RU:
202 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of reports of 10 year old girl dying in fire due to short circuit at NSP SC Girls Hostel, Khammam, Telangana. FIR No. 221/2019 u/s. 174 Cr.P.C. was registered. Hostel Welfare Officer was placed under suspension. Rs. 5.20 lakh have been sanctioned as ex-gratia relief to the family of the deceased. Deceased’s mother Smt. B. Laxmi was appointed as Kamati in Government SCDD Boys Hostel, Noothankal and brother B. Ganesh was admitted in 6th Class in Government Residential School, Suryapet, Telangana. In addition, the DM has proposed to provide 2BHK house and 3 acres of agriculture land in their native place in Suyapet, Telangana. F. No. 3/32/18/TS-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of drunk college girl running over SC man sleeping on footpath in Hyderabad. After regular follow up for financial assistance with DM, wife of the deceased has been taken on job as outsourced basis as day watch woman at SC development girls hostel, Kapra, Hyderabad, Telangana and also sanctioned Rs. 10 lakh under SCAP 2018-19 for foot wear unit through Telangana SC Cooperative Development Corporation. F. No. 3/49/19/TS-RU:
Representation was received from Sri. Bakka Judson, #207, Kancherla Towers, Golconda Cross roads, Musheerabad, Hyderabad regarding social boycott of Scheduled Caste families. Issue was taken up. FIR No. 58/2019 u/s. 290, 323 IPC, 3(1)(r)(s) (za-A & E) & (zc) of PoA Act was registered at Lingampet PS. Both accused arrested. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.25 lakh was paid to the victim.
Cases of earlier years pursued in 2019-20:
21 atrocity cases of previous years , where FIRs were lodged but the SC victims were not receiving justice / help as per PoA Rules were pursued in 2019-20. In all these cases we were able to ensure monetary relief as per rules was sanctioned. The details are :
FIR No. 45/2018 of Gummadidala PS registered u/s. 366, 376 (2)(I)(O) IPC , 5(1) of POCSO Act and 3(1)(w)(i) of PoA Act regarding rape of Kum. P. Rekha R/o. H. No. 2- 15/2, Bonthapally (V), Gummadidala (M), Sangareddy, Telangana was taken up . Monetary relief Rs. 0.50 lakh was paid on 19.06.2019.
203 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
FIR No. 03/2014 of Sadasivpet PS registered u/s. 376(D) IPC and 3(1)(xi), 3(2)(v) of POA Act regarding gang rape of Smt. Barvadi Manjula R/o. Thimmapur (V), Marpally (M), Vikarabad, Telangana was taken up. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.20 lakh was paid on 18.05.2019. FIR No. 17/2019 u/s. 302, 201 IPC, Sec. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act registered at Bheemgal PS regarding murder of Shri Kune Pedda Rajeshwar s/o. Pedda Gangaram , Siddpally (v), Bheemgal (M), Nizamabad, Telangana was pursued. Monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to 3 legal heirs on 05.07.2019. FIR No. 17/2018 registered u/s. 302 IPC and. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act at Nagalgidda PS regarding murder of Shri G. Narsappa s/o. Ramappa , Yesgi (V), Nagalgidda (M), Sangareddy, Telangana was followed up. Monetary relief Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the victim’s legal heirs on 08.07.2019. FIR No. 142/2019 was registered at Manthani PS u/s. 3(1)(v)(vii) of PoA Act and Smt. G. Narsamma, w/o. Rajamallu, R/o. Eklaspur (V), Manthani (M), Peddapalli, Telangana regarding death of her son was followed up on petitioner’s request. Monetary relief Rs. 4.125 lakh was sanctioned and paid on 23.09.2019. FIR. No. 378/2018 u/s. 376, 506, 323 IPC, 5(l)(m)(o) r/w. 6, 21 of POCSO Act, & 3(r)(s), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act registered at Godavarikhani PS regarding rape of Kum. Rapaka Akshita R/o. Mallreddypalli (v), Veenavanka(m), Karimnagar, Telangana was pursued . Monetary relief of Rs. 2.50 lakh was paid on 02.07.2019. FIR No. 10/2017 was registered at Kalher PS u/s. 366A, 376IPC, & 3(1)(s), 3(2) (va) of PoA Act regarding kidnap and rape of Kum. V. Vijaya, d/o. V. Nayak, Nagankunta Thanda, Bachepally (V), Kalher (M) Sangareddy, Telangana was pursued. Monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 lakh was sanctioned and paid on 22.08.2019. FIR. No. 84/2018 u/s. 376, 417, 313 r/w. 34 IPC, 3(1)(s), 3(w)(ii) of POA Act was registered at Ramagundam PS regarding rape of Kum. Eku Priyanka AC Reddy Nagar, Shivanagar, Warangal, Telangana was pursued. Monetary relief of Rs. 2.0 lakh was sanctioned on 02.07.2019.
FIR No. 65/2018 registered u/s. 376 (2)(j) IPC and 3(2) (va) of PoA Act at Indalwai PS on rape of Smt. Patthi Narsamma w/o. Shri Mallaiah, Sirnapally (V), Indalwai (M),
204 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Nizamabad, Telangana was pursued. Monetary relief Rs. 3.0 lakh was paid to the victim on 11.07.2019. FIR No. 319/2019 registered at Godavarkhani I PS u/s. 3(1)(r)(s), 3(2) (va) of PoA Act regarding sexual harassment of Kum. M. Sravanthi, d/o. Yellaiah, R/o. Gandhinagar (V), Godavarikhani, Ramagundam (M), Peddapalli, Telangana was pursued. Monetary relief Rs. 1.00 lakh was sanctioned and paid on 15.09.2019. FIR No. 84/2019 registered at Ramagiri PS u/s. 3 (s), 3(2) (va) of PoA Act regarding sexual harassment of Kum. R. Mounika, d/o. Rayalingu, R/o. Kalavacherla (V), Ramagiri (M), Peddapalli, Telangana was followed up. Monetary relief of Rs. 1 lakh was sanctioned and paid on 15.09.2019. FIR No. 168/2019 registered at Manthani PS u/s. 3(2) (va) of PoA Act regarding sexual harassment of Kum. G. Sindhuja, d/o. Mallaiah, R/o. Swarnapalli (V), Manthani (M), Peddapalli, Telangana was followed up. Monetary relief of Rs. 1 lakh was sanctioned and paid on 15.09.2019. FIR No. 319/2019 registered at Godavarkhani I PS u/s. 3(1)(r)(s), 3(2) (va) of PoA Act regarding sexual harassment of Kum. M. Sravanthi, d/o. Yellaiah, Gandhinagar (V), Godavarikhani, Ramagundam (M), Peddapalli , Telangana was followed up. Monetary relief of Rs. 1 lakh was sanctioned and paid on 15.09.2019. FIR no 15/2019 registered at Kammarpalli PS u/s. 290, 506, 341 r/w. 34 IPC & 3(1)(r)(s), 3(1) (zd) of PoA Act was followed up. As a result the 20 victims of social boycott were paid Rs 15 lakh monetary relief (@ Rs 0.75 lakh x 20 victims ) on 16.09.2019. F. No. 7/23/19/AP-RU: DM, East Godavari, AP paid Rs. 2 lakh to two atrocity victims of Agraharam, Rowthalapudi Mandal after our follow up. F. No. 3/98/18/MP – RU: Representation was received from Shri Charan Singh S/o. Gaya Prasad, R/o. Opp. to Police Chowki, Machhand, Raun PS, Bhindi, MP regarding inaction in murder of Shri Jagrup alias Dasharath Jatav. FIR No. 115/2018 u/s. 364, 302, 147, 149 IPC, & 3(2)(v) of POA Act at PS Raun was registered and action was pursued. Monetary relief Rs. 4.12 lakh was paid after our follow up. F. No. 3/24/18/TS-RU: Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of murder of Shri Erragalla Sudheer , Kukatpally, Hyderabad, Telangana on 12.03.2018 and case pursued.
205 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
FIR No. 529/2018 of PS Kukatpally u/s. 302 r/w 34 IPC, 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was filed . Monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh has been paid to the father of victim after our follow up. F. No. 3/72/18/TS-RU: Representation from Smt. Drupathi, W/o. Late Narasappa, H.No. 1-107, Yesgi (V), Nagalgidda (M), Sangareddy, Telangana was received regarding murder of her husband by upper caste people. FIR No. 17/2018 was registered at Nagalgidda PS u/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC and Sec. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the wife of the deceased after our follow up. F. No. 3/89/18/TS-RU: Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of honour killing of Shri Perumalla Pranay Kumar, Miryalaguda, Nalgonda, Telangana and case pursued. FIR No. 139.2018 was registered at Miryalguda I Town PS u/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. Charge sheet filed and monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the wife of the deceased after our follow up. F. No. 3/51/15/TS-RU: Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of murder of Shri Pagidimarri Srihari S/o. Bixamaiah R/o. Kanagal (V) & (M), Nalgonda, Telangana on 21.09.2015. After regular follow up by this office, now the case is charged and pending for trial. Monetary relief Rs. 5.62 lakh was paid to the wife of the deceased. F. No. 3/54/18/TS-RU: Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of murder of Shri Konaganti Chandraiah by stoning him to death in Hyderabad, Telangana in May 2018. FIR No. 138/2018 of PS Chandrayanagutta u/s. 302 r/w. 34 IPC and Sec. 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered. Compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the deceased family members.
2.5.2.6(a) State Office : Kolkata 2018-19
File No. 2/4/2018-Gen/OR:
A complaint dated 21.03.2018 regarding sexual harassment was received from the daughter of Shri Paramananda Behehera , Tanti Colony Jagannath Prasad, Ganjam, Odisha and followed up , SP Ganjam vide his reply dated 08.05.2018 confirmed that FIR no 185 was registered u/s 493,417,294,506,34 IPC and 3(2) va) Poa Act against 5 accused who were arrested. File No. 2/9/2018-Gen/OR :
206 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
A complaint dated 19.04.2018 was received from the Odisha Dalit Adhikar Manch (ODAM), Bhubaneswar enclosing a complaint of Smt. Pabani Pattanaik of ,Sinduria , Ranapur P.S., Nayagarh regarding forceful occupation of her dwelling unit by group of non-SCs. The S.P. Nayagarh vide his reply stated that proper demarcation of land will be done and a dwelling unit will be constructed at government expenses. Rs. 2 lakh compensation has been given to her under PoA Rules. File No. 2/10/2018-Gen/OR:
Suo moto cognizance was taken on a report of gang rape of a 14 year ols minor girl Km.P ...... D/o B. Sethy of Bhansara , P.S. Tirtol, Jagatsinghpur, Odisha on 26.04.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 106 u/s 376(D),363,307 IPC & 6 POCSO Act lodged. At the instance of the Commission, sections 3(1)(r)(w) and 3(2) (va) of PoA Act were added and compensation as per rules provided to the family of victim. File No. 2/12/2018-Gen/OR:
Suo moto cognizance was taken on a report of molestation of a minor girl Km.M ...... D/o J. Sunamajhi, Daringbadi, Kandhamal, Odisha on 02.05.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 65 dated 30.4.2018 u/s 354(a),341, 376(2)(F),376(2)(i),376(C)(b),10 IPC, 6 POCSO Act and 3(2)(vii) PoA Act was lodged, accused could not be arrested due to orders of Hon’ble High Court. Rs. 1 lakh compensation was paid to the victim on 30.07.2019. File No. 2/15/2018-Gen/OR (Bhadrak) :
A complaint was received from daughter of Shri Ananta Mallik of Narada, P.S. Bhandaripokhari, Bhadrak regarding continuous sexual assault on her under an assurance of marriage and subsequent abduction by a non-SC youth of her village. SP, Bhadrak, vide his report affirmed the incidence of rape followed by harassment and registered FIR No. 25 u/s 365,342,294,323,376,506,34 IPC and 3(1)(r)(s) ,3(2)(va) of PoA Act. While police arrested all accomplises involved, the main accused was killed in a road accident aftermath of the crime. File No. 2/22/2018-Gen/OR (Boudh) :
Suo moto cognizance was taken of report of physical assault of a minor girl Km. S ...... , D/o B. Mirdha, Bapujinagar, Boudh, Odisha 25.06.2019. Notice was issued and FIR No
207 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
34/dated 28.06.2019 u/s 364,302,376(2)(i) IPC, 4 POCSO Act and 3(2)(va) PoA Act was lodged. Monetary compensation of Rs. 2.5 lakh has been paid to the victim so far. File No. 2/27/2018-Gen/OR:
Suo moto cognisance was taken of news dated 28.06.2018 of attack on SC villagers in Nayagarh and notice issued. FIR no 249 was registered u/s 147,148,448,427,354-A,354- B,294,506,395,307,323,149 IPC and 3(1)(r)(s)(w)(i), 3(2)(Va) of POA Act, charge sheet No. 124 was submitted on 22.08.2019 against 52 persons . 32 displaced SC families also resettled in their village and Rs 128 lakh (@Rs 4 lakh per family) was paid for rehabilitation measures. File No. 2/13/2018-Gen/Assam :
Suo moto cognisance was taken of news dated 26.6.2018 regarding abduction of four SC workers from Guwahati, Assam in Arunachal Pradesh . The matter was taken up with DGP, Assam Government and according to a report received from AIGP(A), Govt. of Assam, all four workers were rescued from Roing, Arunachal Pradesh where they were detained .The workers returned home with the intervention of police .
In the cases taken up 223 FIRs were lodged, 171 accused persons were arrested, in 181 cases charge sheets were submitted and Rs. 39.125 lakh monetary relief provided.
2.5.2.6(b) State Office : Kolkata 2019-20 File No. 2/26/2017-Gen/OR (Cuttack)
Shri Kedarnath Behera of Kantilo, P.S. Jagatsinghpur, Odisha complained about his wrongful detention and physical torture in Olatpur Police Station. Matter was taken up and according to police report, Rs. 3.80 lakh was paid to the victim as per PoA Rules.
File No. 2/27/2018-Gen/OR (Nayagarh)
Based on a complaint received from Shri Gadadhar Naik of Village Pana Nuagaon (Badasa), P.S. Khandapada, Nayagarh, Odisha regarding group attack on SC villagers on 16.06.2018, a report was called for. Matter was taken up and according to police report, an FIR under IPC and PoA Act was lodged and 12 accused arrested. The Government has
208 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
paid Rs. 32.00 lakh to the 32 affected SC families besides making temporary shelters for them and proving food for 10 days.
File No. 2/56/2018-Gen/OR (Kendrapada)
Taking suo-motu cognizance of a news report captioned “11 years sexually abused by widower”, a report was called for from the authorities of Kendrapara , Odisha. Matter was taken up and according to report from the police the culprit was arrested and the victim has been paid monetary relief of Rs. 2.00 lakh as per PoA Rules.
File No. 2/61/2017-Gen/OR (Cuttack)
Taking cognizance on a news report dated 28.01.2018 captioned “Dalit women assaulted in public”, a report was called for from the Police. According to the report received, a FIR under relevant sections of IPC and PoA Act was lodged and monetary relief Rs. 2 lakh was paid to the victims.
File No. 2/65/2018-Gen/OR (Jajpur)
Complaint received from Shri Haladhar Sethy, President, Orissa State SCs, STs Youth & Student Council, Bhubaneswar regarding murder of one Kumari Sunita Jena, D/o Sri Bhagirathi Jena of Village Fazalpur, P.S. Korai, Jajpur, Odisha on 19.06.2018 by one Sk. Shakil due to failed marriage proposal, was taken up. As per police report, the culprit has been arrested, IPC and PoA Act imposed and a sum of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the victim’s father.
File No. 2/90/2018-Gen/OR (Jharsuguda)
Suo-motu action was taken up based on a news report that a minor Orissa girl from Jharsuguda, jumped from 1st floor of abductor’s house at Bhiwani, Haryana where she was confined. Matter was taken up and police reported t is reported that an FIR with sections of POCSO Act, Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, PoA Act, and IPC has been lodged. Monetary relief of Rs. 2.50 lakh was paid to the victim by Haryana Government.
File No. 2/93/2018-Gen/OR (Nayagarh)
Smt, Pramila Mallick, W/o Madhab Mallick of Village Lausena, P.S. Sadar, Nayagarh, Odisha, complained about physical attack in persons on her husband and two sons along
209 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
with other SC villagers by a group of goondas and destruction of their homestead. Matter was taken up and the Police reported that FIR No. 04, dated 07.01.2019 u/s 341/323/354(B)/294/436/427/506/34 IPC and 3(1) (r) (s)/3(2)(va) PoA Act has been lodged. Monetary relief of Rs. 14.00 lakh was paid to victims ( @ Rs 4 lakh to the SC complainant and Rs. 2.00 lakh x 5 other SC villagers whose properties were also damaged).
File No. 2/97/2018-Gen/OR (Kendrapara)
Suo-motu cognizance was taken a news report dated 22.1.2019 captioned “Man killed in firing, local hand over suspect to cops’ in Kandira Village, Rajnagar P.S. area under Kendrapara , Odisha. Police reported that a case has been lodged vide FIR No. 11, dated 21.01.2019 and relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to Jhumuri Sethi, W/o Lt. Kishore Sethi on 21.08.2019.
2.5.2.7(a) State Office : Lucknow 2018-19
Details of heinous crime cases taken up: Table 2.6(a) Sl. File No. Victim & Address Nature of Action No. offence 1- 14/1(1)/2017-RU Smt. Guddi Devi W/o Lt. Murder FIR lodged, 03 accused Nawab, R/o Jaupura arrested, Sikandra, Agra Monetary compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh sanctioned 2- 14/1(2)/2017-RU Smt. Guddi Devi W/o Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Munesh Kumar R/o arrested, Sikrahna, PS Monetary Puranpur,Pilibhit. compensation of Rs. 3 lakh sanctioned. 3- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Sri Ashish Kumar S/o Ram Murder FIR lodged, 03 accused Sajiwan, R/o Naruli, PS arrested, charge sheet Pailani, Banda. No. 10/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned.
210 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
4- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Bihari Lal Rawat, R/o Murder FIR lodged, 03 accused Karjhan, PS Kakori, arrested, charge sheet Lucknow No. Nil/2018, filed, Monitory compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 5- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Smt. Lalmati Devi W/o Rape & FIR lodged, 03 accused Ashok, R/o Semra buzurg, Murder arrested, charge sheet PS Badhalganj, Gorakhpur. No. A-90/2018 filed Monetory compensation of Rs. 2.5 lakh sanctioned. 6- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Sri Santosh Kumar Ahirwar Murder FIR lodged, 02 accused S/o Ram Ashre, R/o arrested, charge sheet Bhanwar Pur Mazra No. 68/2018 filed, Bilharka, PS Narini Banda. Monetory compensation of Rs. 13.65 lakh (@8.25 lak + 1.80 lakh each to 3 families / victims) sanctioned. 7- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Sri Kuldeep R/o Trikoliya, Rape & FIR lodged, 01 accused PS Nighasan, Khiri. Murder arrested, charge sheet No. 160/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 8- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Amit Kumar S/o Mangala Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused Prasad, R/o Meghipur, PS arrested, charge sheet Aurai, Bhadohi. No. 34/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 9- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Smt. Gilla W/o Lt. Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused Sankatha Prasad, R/o arrested, charge sheet Sathani Bala Khera, PS No. A-12/2018 filed, Barasagwar, Unnao. Monetory compensation of Rs. 9.125 lakh sanctioned. (5 lakh +4.125 lakh)
211 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
10- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Shiv Kumar S/o Bahadur Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused Pasi, R/o Chandi Belwa, PS arrested, charge sheet Tambaur, Sitapur. No. 128/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 11- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Hiralal S/o Dhanai Ram, Murder FIR lodged, 04 accused R/o Birua Sameda, PS arrested, charge sheet Sidhari, Azamgarh. No. A-18/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 12- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Sri Babban S/o Tulsi, R/o Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused Jajauli, Ps Bhimpura, Balia. arrested, Monetory compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 13- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Sri Premram S/o Birbalram, Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused R/o Devkathiya, PS arrested, charge sheet Jangipur, Gazipur. No. 01/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 14- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Sri Pramod Kumar S/o Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused Chotelal, R/o Chakiya, PS arrested, charge sheet Khakhreru, Fatehpur. No. A-18/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 1.5 lakh sanctioned. 15- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Sri Godhan Lal S/o Rape FIR lodged, Bangali, R/o Dilawar, PS Monetory Puranpur. Pilibhit. compensation of Rs. 3 lakh sanctioned. 16- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Km. Chandrakla Gautam Rape FIR lodged, Charge D/o Lt. Bahadurlal, R/o sheet No. 06/2018 Arjunpur, PS Chauri, Filed, Bhadohi. Monetory compensation of Rs. 3 lakh sanctioned.
212 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
17- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Smt. Laxmi Devi W/o Rape FIR lodged, 02 accused Prakash R/o Khakhara arrested, chargesheet Buzurg, PS Banda, filed, Shahjahanpur. Monetary compensation of Rs. 6.18 lakh sanctioned. 18- 14/1(1)/2018-RU Mahesh Chandra Saroj S/o Murder FIR lodged, Ramlal, R/o Bhulsa, Post Monetory Bhadri],PS Hathigawan, compensation of Rs. Pratapgarh 24.125 lakh (4.125+20 lakh) sanctioned. 19- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Smt. Malwati, Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused R/oGangadin Purwa, PS arrested charge sheet Nighasan, Khiri. No. 42/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 3.75 lakh sanctioned. 20- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Sri Jhinku S/o Bhulai, R/o Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Jadaipur, PS Hariya, Basti. arrested, charge sheet No. 65/2018 filed, Monetory compensation Rs. 3.75 lakh sanctioned. 21- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Sri Karan Singh S/o Tungal Rape FIR lodged, 02 accused Singh R/o Naya gaon arrested charge sheet Badshahpur, PS Kotwali No. 66/2018 filed, Dehat. Saharanpur. Monetory compensation of Rs. 1.5 lakh sanctioned. 22- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Laxmi D/o Murari, R/o Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Gairaha, PS Kapsethi, arrested, (M) Varanasi. Monetory compensation of Rs. 0.5 lakh sanctioned, 23- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Sangeeta Devi W/o Ram Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Bilaxan Kori, R/o Tindura arrested, charge sheet Chauki Oran, PS Bisanda, No. 33/2018 filed, Banda. Monetory compensation of Rs. 3 lakh sanctioned.
213 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
24- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Sri Santosh Kumar S/o Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Mahesh Singh R/o arrested charge sheet Chandaina Koli, PS No. 357A/2018 filed, Devband, Saharanpur. Monetory compensation of Rs. 1.5 lakh sanctioned. 25- 14/1(2)/2018-RU Shiv Shanker S/o Lt. Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Sumera, R/o Paduvi, PS arrested charge sheet Kotwali Nagar, Banda. No. 374/2018 filed, Monetory compensation of Rs. 3 lakh sanctioned. 26 3/275/2018-Gen Smt. Amla Devi W/o Sri Atrocity FIR No. 02/2018, u/s Hariram, R/o Vill. Pathna, 302, 201, 376 IPC & PS Sujanganj, Jaunpur. 3(2)5 PoA Act & 3/4 POCSO Act lodged, 2 accused arrested, charge sheet No. 82, dated 07.08.2018 filed, Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 27 3/344-45/2018- Smt. Poonam Devi W/o Atrocity FIR No. 189/2018, u/s Gen. Amar Dev, Vill. Jasauli, PS 354, 392, 504, 506, 376, Bisalpur, Pilibhit. 511 IPC & 3(2)5VA PoA Act lodged, 2 accused arrested, charge sheet No. 153/18, dated 27.06.2018 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 1.5 lakh sanctioned. 28 3/395/2018-Gen Annu D/o Bhadai Prasad, Atrocity FIR No. 413/2018, u/s H.No.281 New Basti 393, 323, 504, 506, 376 Mandi Lal Bangla, Ps IPC & 3(2)5 Chakeri, Kanpur Nagar. PoA Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, charge sheet No. 603- A/18, dated 31.07.2018 filed.
214 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Monetary compensation of Rs. 3 lakh sanctioned. 29 3/403/2018-Gen Sri Rambali S/o Kallu, Atrocity FIR No. 48/2018, U/S Vill& Post Lama, PS 363, 366, 376 IPC & Dehat, Banda. 3(2)5 PoA Act & 4 POCSO Act lodged, 2 accused arrested, charge sheet No. 106/18, dated 16.07.2018 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3 lakh sanctioned. 30 3/540/2018-Gen Smt Radha Devi W/o Late Atrocity FIR No. 618/2017, u/s Mahesh Chandra Jatav, 364, 302, 201, 34 IPC & Moh. Marwadi Kadri Gate, 3(2)5 PoA Act lodged, PS, Farrukhabad 1 accused arrested, charge sheet dated 15.11.2017 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 31 3/573/2018-Gen Sri Rajendra Prasad S/o Atrocity FIR No. 103/2018, u/s Muneshwar, Vill. 323, 504, 506, IPC & Mustfabad, PO. Bhagasa, 3(1)Da, Dha, PoA Act PS Sarpatha, Jaunpur. lodged, charge sheet No. 85/18, dated 30.07.2018 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 0.75 lakh sanctioned. 32 3/608/2018-Gen Smt. Ketki W/o Late Atrocity FIR No. 30/2018, u/s Jagatpal, Vill, Bhalia, PS 302 IPC & 3(2)5, PoA Kakori Lucknow Act lodged, 3 accused arrested, charge sheet dated 27.07.2018 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned.
215 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
33 3/654/2018-Gen Sri Ram Autar Kori S/o Atrocity FIR No. 311/2018, u/s Khem karan, Vill 302 IPC & 3(2)5, PoA Chaukhandi, PS Bisalpur, Act lodged, 2 accused Pilibhit. arrested, charge sheet No. 270/18, dated 27.07.2018 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 lakh sanctioned.
34 3/880/2018-Gen Sri Abhay Kumar S/o Atrocity FIR No. 293/2017, u/s Vinay Kumar, R/o Parsda, 302 IPC & 3(2)5, PoA PS Machrehta, Sitapur. Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, charge sheet No. 09/18, dated 17.01.2018 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 8.25 sanctioned. 35 3/1059/2018- Sri Rajit Ram S/o Atrocity FIR No. 227/2018, u/s Gen Ramsukh, Vill. Bhanbhari 376D, 342, 506 IPC & Bhagwanpur Post & PS 3(2)5, PoA Act lodged, Ikauna, Srawasti 1 accused arrested, charge sheet No. A- 105/18, dated 03.05.2019 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 36 3/1163/2018-Gen Smt. Vijay Laxmi. W/o Atrocity FIR No. 318/2017, u/s Late Rampal Vill. Dhanna 302 IPC & 3(2)5 PoA Khera, Post Madhapur, PS Act lodged, 2 accused F-84, Unnao arrested, charge sheet dated 21.05.2019 filed. Monetary compensation of Rs. 3.34 lakh sanctioned.
In all the above cases, 36 FIRs were lodged and 52 accused arrested and monetary relief of Rs 150.21 lakh was paid to the victims / families of victims.
216 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
591 other cases of atrocities were also taken up suomotu. 118 FIRs were lodged, 46 persons were arrested, in 57 cases charge sheets were submitted and Rs. 297.06 lakh monetary help was provided to the victims / families of victims.
2.5.2.7(b) State Office : Lucknow 2019-20
Table 2.6(b)
S. No. File No. Name of Applicant Type of Action taken with address offence
1 3/1307/2018-Gen Smt. Babli W/o Umesh Atrocity FIR no 32/2019 u/s R/o Vill Jarauli Kla, PS 323,504,506 IPC & 3(2) 5 a , Bilgram, Distt. Hardoi 3(1) D of PoA Act was lodged . Charge sheet no 48/2019 dated 19.02.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
2 4/05/2019-Gen. Smt. Munni Devi W/o Atrocity FIR No. 1293/2018, U/S Late Mangru R/o Vill. 323, 354, 506, 324, 504, Sundarpur, PS Lanka 354B IPC & 3(1)10, 3(1)11 Dist. Varanasi. PoA Act was lodged. Charge Sheet No. Nil Dated 01.02.2019 was filed . Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was paid.
3 3/235/2019-Gen Sri Arvind Kumar S/o Atrocity FIR No. 166/2019, U/S 147, Nathuram, R/o 452, 323, 504, 506, IPC & Dahiyapur, PS Ajitmal, 3(1)Da of PoA Act was Distt Auraiyya lodged. Charge Sheet No. 210/19, dated 13.06.2019 was filed . Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
217 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
4 3/296/2019-Gen Sri Devendra S/o Vijay Atrocity FIR No. 16/2019, U/S 323, Singh R/o Laler, Ps 324, 504, 506 IPC & 3(2)5 of Pahasu, Distt. Buland PoA Act was lodged. Shahar Charge sheet No. 26/2019 06.05.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
5 3/293/2019-Gen Sri Ramraj S/o Shiv Atrocity FIR No. 161/2019, U/S 323, Karan, R/o Khojan 504, 506, 342 IPC & 3(1)Da, Purwa, PS Unchahar, Dha of PoA Act was lodged. Distt Raibarelly. Charge sheet No. 179/2019 dated 19.04.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
6 3/320-24/2019- Sri Shiv Sharan S/o Atrocity FIR No. 63/2019, U/S 323, Gen Pusuwa, R/o Village & 504, 506, IPC & 3(2)5 of Post Simauni, PS PoA Act was lodged. Baberu, Distt Banda Charge sheet No. 156/2019 dated 30.07.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 4.50 lakh (@ Rs 1.50 lakh x 3 victims) was paid.
7 3/434/2019-Gen Sri Pravesh Kumar S/o Atrocity FIR No. 144/2019, U/S 323, Jokhuram, R/o Bharari, 504, 506 IPC & 3(1)Da, of Post Patti Chakesar, PS PoA Act was lodged. Shahganj, Distt Charge sheet No. Jaunpur 107/19dated 04.06.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
8 3/446/2019-Gen Smt. Gaura W/o Rame Atrocity FIR No. 77/2012, U/S 354, shwar R/o Majheewa 504, 506 IPC & 3(1)10, of Sani, Post Bisandi, PS PoA Act was lodged. Bisanda, Distt Banda. Monetary relief of Rs 18,750/- was paid.
218 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
9 3/537/2019-Gen Smt. Lali Devi W/o Murder FIR No. 81/2019, U/S 302 Late Shiv Kumar, R/o IPC & 3(2)5 of PoA Act was Kareem Patti, Faridpur lodged. Kla, PS Ibrahimpur, 2 accused arrested. Distt Ambedkar Nagar Charge sheet No. 75 /2019 dated 20.06.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid.
10 3/729/2019- Gen Sri Ghirrau S/o Beepat Murder FIR No. 450/2019, U/S 147, R/o Nasrapru, Post 323, 328, 302 IPC & 3(2)5 of Hariharpur, Distt PoA Act was lodged. Bahraich Monetary relief of Rs 4.125 lakh was paid.
11 3/46-50/2019- Sri Mangesh S/o Atrocity FIR No. 346/2018, U/S 323, Gen Bodhai Ram R/o Parsin 504 IPC & 3(1)Da, of PoA PS Shahganj, Distt Act was lodged. Jaunpur Charge sheet No. 20/2018 dated 07.03.2018 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
12 3/196/2019- Gen Smt Savitri Devi W/o Atrocity FIR No. 12/2019, U/S 147, Late Ram Soch. R/o 323, 504, 506 IPC & 3(1) Da Agauna, Ps Kalwari, of PoA Act was lodged. Distt Basti. Charge sheet No. A-1/19 dated 18.03.2018was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
13 4/14-15/2019- Sri. Ravindra Khatik Atrocity FIR No. 52/2019, U/S 323, Gen S/o Ramesh Khatik R/o 504, 506] 354, 452, 427, IPC Moh. Kanoon Goyan, & 3(1)Da, of PoA Act was Kasba & Kurawali, lodged. Distt Mainpuri Charge sheet No. 197/19 dated 27.06.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 1.50 lakh ( 2 0.75 lakh x 2 victims ) was paid.
219 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
14 4/185/2019- Gen Sri Jagdish Kumar S/o Atrocity FIR No. 94/2018, U/S 323, Ram Bharose R/o 506, IPC & 3(1)Da, Dha of Deviyapur, PS PoA Act was lodged. Sadarpur Distt Sitapur Charge sheet No. 114/2018 dated 30.05.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
15 4/350/2019- Gen Sri Sitaram S/o Atrocity FIR No. 268/2019, U/S 427, Siyaram R/o 323, 504, 506, IPC & Madrahwa, Ps Bhinga, 3(1)Da, Dha of PoA Act was Distt. Shrawasti. lodged. Charge sheet No. A-256/19 dated 25.10.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
16 3/921/2018- Gen Km. Gyanti D/o Rape FIR No. 170/2018, U/S 363, Amarjeet R/o Village 376, IPC & 3(2)5of PoA Act & Post Suithakla, PS & 5/6 POCSO Act was Sarpatha, Distt Jaunpur lodged. Act. 2 accused arrested. Charge sheet No. 161/2018 dated 01.12.2018 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 6.19 lakh was paid.
17 3/1059/2018- Gen Smt. Madhuri Devi Rape FIR No. 227/2018, U/S W/o Rajitram R/o 376D, 342, 506 IPC & 3(2)5 Bhambhari of PoA Act was lodged. Bhagwanpur, Ps 1 accused arrested . Ikauna, Distt. Shrwasti Charge sheet No. A-105/19 dated 03.05.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 6.19 lakh was paid.
220 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
18 3/151-57/2018- Smt. Butua W/o Ram Atrocity FIR No. 179/2018, U/S 323, Gen Bharosa, R/o Mahotra, 504, 506 IPC & 3(2)5 of Post & ps Atra, Distt PoA Act was lodged. Banda. Charge sheet No. 173/2018 dated 28.12.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 1.50 lakh was paid.
19 3/151-57/2018- Shri kripal verma s/o Atrocity FIR No. 86/2019, U/S 279, Gen shri Natthu verma, R/o 304A, 504, 506 IPC & 3(2)5 & Post hathauda, ps of PoA Act was lodged. kotwli dehat, Distt. Charge sheet No. 81/2019 Banda. dated 24.08.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 1.50 lakh was paid.
20 3/557/2019- Gen km. Mira d/o shri Ram Atrocity FIR No. 232/ 2019, U/S 147, Autar, R/o & ps 323, 504 IPC & 3(1) D,DH Rajpura, Distt. of PoA Act was lodged. Sambhal. Charge sheet No. 189/2019 dated 30.10.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 1.50 lakh was paid.
21 3/91/2019- Gen Sri Chotelal S/o Atrocity FIR No. 22/ 2019, U/S 323, Makhan Kori R/o 504, 506, 435 IPC& Usrhan Khera, Ps 3(1)D,of PoA Act was Khero, Distt lodged. Raibareilly. Charge sheet No. 93/2019 dated 07.03.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
22 3/950/2019- Gen Sri Govind S/o Prem Atrocity FIR No. 277/2019, U/S 323, Rawat R/o Katramau, 504, 506 IPC & 3(1) D,DH, Post & Ps Kursi, Distt 3(2)5A of PoA Act was Barabanki lodged. Charge sheet No. A270/2019 05.12.2019 was filed.
221 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Monetary relief of Rs 3.75 lakh ( @ 75,000/- X 5 victims was paid.
23 3/1008/2019- Gen Sri Ganesh Gautam S/o Atrocity FIR No. 123/2019, U/S 323, Ram Sundar Gautam 325, 504 IPC & 3(1)DH, of R/o Ambar Nagar PS PoA Act was lodged. Laliya, Balrampur Charge sheet No. CCTNS /19 dated 30.11.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
24 3/490/2019- Gen Smt. Kalli W/o Shiv FIR No. 54/2019, U/S 323, Mohan R/o Nai Basti 504, 506 IPC & 3(2)5, of Bhuredi, PS Mataundh, PoA Act was lodged. Distt Banda Charge sheet No. A-50 /2019 dated 30.10.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 1.50 lakh was paid.
25 3/165/2019- Gen Sri Jiyalal S/o Ram Atrocity FIR No. 30/2019, U/S 147, Bahal R/o Bajdahiya 323, 427, 504 IPC & 3(1)D, Paipur, PS Baskhari Dh, of PoA Act was lodged. Dist. Ambedkar Nagar Charge sheet No. 32/2019 dated 17.02.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 1.50 lakh (@ Rs 0.75 lakh x 2 victims ) was paid.
26 3/375/2019- Gen Smt. Ramrti W/o Bhure Atrocity FIR No. 28/2019, U/S 323, Paswan R/o Mankaura 504, 506 IPC & 3(1)D, Dh, PS Gilaula, Distt. of PoA Act was lodged. Shrawasti. Charge sheet No. 51/2019 dated 27.04.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
222 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
27 3/963/2019- Gen Smt. Sitara Devi W/o Atrocity FIR No. 174/2019, U/S 323, Lallu Nat R/o Prahlada, 504, IPC & 3(1)D, Dh, of Ps Sonwa Distt PoA Act was lodged. Shrawasti Charge sheet No. A153/19 dated 25.10.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
28 3/996/2019 – Gen Sri Sahaj Ram S/o Sri Atrocity FIR No. 233/2019, U/S 323, Ram Pyare R/o Shyam 504, 506 IPC & 3(1)D, Dh, Deoriya PS Ikauna of PoA Act was lodged. Distt Shrawasti. Charge sheet No. A-226/19 dated 13.11.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
29 3/122/2019 – Gen Sri Rajendra Prasad S/o Atrocity FIR No. 50/2019, U/S 354, Gannu Lal R/o 323, 504, 506 IPC & 3(1)D, Ismilpur, PS Gursahay of PoA Act & 7/8 POSCO ganj Distt. Kannauj Act. was lodged. Charge sheet No. 59/2019 dated 12.02..2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 1.50 lakh was paid.
30 3/440/2019 – Gen Sri Vikas Kori S/o Sri Atrocity FIR No. 223/2018, U/S 323, Pal Kori, R/o Ragipur, 504, 506 IPC & 3(1)D, Dh, Ps Gauri Ganj Distt & 3(2)5A of PoA Act was Amethi lodged. Charge sheet No. 284/2018 dated 30.10.2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid.
31 14/1(1)/2019-RU Shri Balakram,Mohalla Murder FIR lodged, Charge sheet –Dubey Ward no. no. A-212 dated 15.08.2019 02,PS- Bisalpur, Distt. was filed. Pilibhit Monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid.
223 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
32 14/1(1)/2019-RU Shri Rambir Singh S/o Murder FIR lodged, 02 accused shri Nathulal, Vill- arrested, Under Kukamai PS- investigation, Kurawali. Distt Monetary relief of Rs. Mainpuri. 4.125 lakh was paid. 33 14/1(2)/2019-RU Sri Sunil Kumar Jatav Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused S/o Rajaram, R/o Vill- arrested, Nagla bhajan, Ps Monetary relief of Rs. 3.09 bichchvan, Distt. lakh was paid. Mainpuri. 34 14/1(2)/2019-RU Kr. Anchal D/o Ankit Rape FIR lodged, 05 accused Kr., Vill- Foolat , PS- arrested, Charge sheet no. Ratanpuri, Distt. 49/2019 was filed. Mujaffarnagar Monetary relief of Rs. 6.18 lakh was paid.
35 14/1(1)/2019-RU Shri Mohan S/o Shri Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused Indrapal Nut,R/o Vill- arrested, Nayagaon Jat , Ps- Charge sheet no. 193/19 Pasgavan, Distt- dated 28.04.2019 was filed. Lakhimpur Khiri. Monetary relief of Rs. 4.37 lakh was paid. 36 14/1(3)/2019-RU Sri Hom Singh S/o Atrocities FIR lodged, Late. Fool Singh, R/o (M) Charge sheet no. 254/2019 Uttampur Bahlolpur, Ps dated 28.05.2019 was filed. - Majhola Distt. Monetary relief of Rs. 2.25 Muradabad lakh (0.75 lakh x3 victims) was paid. 37 14/1(2)/2019-RU Smt. Babita Jatav W/o Rape FIR lodged, 02 accused Sri Bunti Jatav,Vill- arrested Charge sheet no. Manoharpur Ps. 266/2019 dated 14.06.2019 Majhola Distt. was filed. Moradabad Monetary relief of Rs. 6.18 lakh was paid. 38 14/1(1)/2019-RU Smt. Parvati Kori W/o Murder FIR lodged, 02 accused Sri Ramkrishan Kori, arrested. R/o Patulki Majra Charge sheet was filed. Arwal, Ps-Baldirai, Monetary relief of Rs. 8.25 Distt. Sultanpur. lakh was paid.
224 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
39 14/1(1)/2019-RU Sri. Sunil Kr. S/o Sri Murder FIR lodged, 03 accused Amar Singh , R/o arrested, Chiraula, Ps Charge sheet no. 91/19 was Ganjdudwara, Distt. filed. Kasganj. Monetary relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid. 40 14/1(1)/2019-RU Sri Ramnath S/o Sri Murder FIR lodged, 06 accused Ramprasad, R/o arrested, Jamuhi, Ps Roja, Distt. Charge sheet was filed. Shahjahanpur Monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid. 41 14/1(2)/2019-RU Smt. Chandravati W/o Rape FIR lodged, 02 accused Sri Lalchand, R/o (M) arrested, Bhotaha, Ps- Charge sheet filed on Dhanghata, Distt. 03.06.2019 & 19.07.2019, Santkabirnagar. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.25 lakh was paid.
42 14/1(2)/2019-RU Smt. Renu W/o Anil Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Kumar, R/o arrested. Kandrawan, Ps- Charge sheet no. 93/18 was Unchahar, Distt. filed. Raebareilly. Monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 lakh was paid. 43 14/1(2)/2019-RU Sri Tanisha Kori D/o Rape FIR lodged, 02 accused Sri Sanjay Kr. , R/o arrested. Veerbhanpur, Ps- Charge sheet no. 92/2019 Salon, Distt was filed. Raebareilly. Monetary relief of Rs. 6.18 lakh was paid. 44 14/1(2)/2019-RU Pinki D/oSri Rape FIR lodged, 02 accused Ramsumiran, R/o arrested. Lakhnapur, Ps- Charge sheet no. 137 & Harchandpur, Distt- 137A was filed. Raebareilly. Monetary relief of Rs. 6.18 lakh ( @Rs 4.12 lakh & Rs 2.06 lakh ) was paid. 45 14/1(1)/2019-RU Sri Dharmendra Singh Murder FIR lodged, 02 accused S/o Sri Bhimsen, R/o arrest ed. Nayagaon Chandpur, Charge sheet no. A- Ps Kotwali Nagar. 556/20.08.2019 was filed. Bulandshahar. Monetary relief of Rs. 9.35 lakh was paid.
225 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
46 14/1(2)/2019-RU Sri Hiralal S/o Sri Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Chedi, R/o (M) arrested Charge sheet no. Baburi,Manjhra Taukli 08.03.2019, was filed. Ps Baundi, Distt- Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 Bahraich. lakh was paid.
47 14/1(1)/2019-RU Sri Ramkishor Paswan Murder FIR lodged, 05 accused S/o Sri Ratiram R/o arrested, Under Baijakhera, Ps- investigation, Maharajpur, Distt Kanpur Nagar. Monetary relief of Rs. 24.75 lakh (@Rs. 8.25 x 3 victims ) was paid. 48 14/1(1)/2019-RU Sri Ghanshyam Murder FIR lodged, Under Dwivedi ,Project Investigation, Manager, Jal Nigam Monetary relief of Rs. 12 Distt Kanpur Nagar lakh (Rs. 6 lakh x2)was paid. 49 14/1(1)/2019-RU Chandrapal Singh ( Murder FIR lodged, 03 accused Deceased Father), R/o arrested Charge sheet no. Khaladpur, Ps- 14/2019 was filed. Falavada, Distt- Monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 Meerut. lakh was paid.
50 14/1(1)/2019-RU Deceased Ajay S/o Sri Murder FIR lodged, 04 accused Rampal & deceased. arrested Charge sheet no. Ashok S/o Mahar 71/2019 was filed. Singh, Ps Pallavpuram, Monetary relief of Rs. 8.25 Distt - Meerut. lakh (@Rs. 4.125 lakh x 2 victims ) was paid. 51 14/1(2)/2019-RU Smt. Rajviri W/o Sri Murder FIR lodged, 08 accused Veerpal & Veerpal S/o arrested Charge sheet no. Phool Singh R/o 186/2019 was filed. Paltupuri, Ps- Monetary relief of Rs. 5 Hastinapur. Distt lakh was paid. Meerut. 52 14/1(3)/2019-RU 1.Jitendra S/o Atrocitiy FIR lodged, 02 accused Ramnath, 2.Sachin S/o (M) arrested. Under Rajendra 3.Nitin S/o Investigation, Ramvir 4.Amardeep Monetary relief of Rs. 4 S/o Ratanlal, R/o lakh was paid. Chirodi, Ps Daurala, Distt Meerut.
226 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
53 14/1(2)/2019-RU Bhpal Singh, R/o Ps Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused parikshitgarh, Distt. (M) arrested. Meerut. Charge sheet no. 170/2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.5 lakh was paid. 54 14/1(2)/2019-RU Kr. Arti D/o Rajaram Rape FIR lodged, accused Verma R/o Bhindora, surrendered in Court. Ps Tindvari, Distt Charge sheet No. A-90/2019 Banda. was filed. Monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 lakh was paid. 55 14/1(2)/2019-RU Kumari Priyanka D/o Rape FIR lodged, , Sri Lakhan, R/o Maata, Monetary relief of Rs. 5 Ps Tindvari, Distt lakh was paid. Banda.
56 14/1(2)/2019-RU Sri Manoj Kr. S/o Sri Rape FIR was lodged . Santosh Kr., R/o (M) Bhairai, Ps Nauhjheel, Final report filed. Distt Mathura. Monetary relief of Rs 1.00 lakh was paid . 57 14/1(2)/2019-RU Smt. Autari Devi W/o Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Sri Gangaram, Sunita (M) arrested Kumari D/o Sri Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 Gangaram R/o lakh (@Rs, 75000/- x 2 Mandarhawa, Ps victims ) was paid. Paikoliya, Distt Basti 58 14/1(2)/2019-RU Kumari Annu Paswan Rape FIR lodged, , 01 accused D/o Sri Vikram Prasad, arrested R/o Pratap pur, Ps Charge sheet no. A-01/2019 Bansi, Distt was filed. Siddharthnagar Monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 lakh was paid. 59 14/1(2)/2019-RU Shivkumar Kannaujiya Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused S/o Sri Motu, R/o (M) arrested. H.No. 20/22 Monetary relief Rs. 0.50 Rajmandir, Ps Kotwali lakh was paid. Varanasi, Distt. Varanasi
227 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
60 14/1(2)/2019-RU Kumari Sunita D/o Rape FIR lodged, 01 accused Late. Bhagirath Jatav, arrested. R/o Phoolpur, Ps Monetary relief of Rs. 3.75 Ujhani, Distt. Budaun lakh was paid.
61 14/1(1)/2019-RU Smt. Arti W/o Late. Murder FIR lodged, under Tarashankar Dubey, investigation. R/o Raipur, Ps Monetary relief of Rs. Akhandnagar, Distt. 4.125 lakh was paid. Sultanpur Monetary Relief. 1.Smt Manisha W/o Ravi Balmiki, R/o Hardwarinagar Ps. Hapur, Distt. Hapur
62 14/1(2)/2019-RU Unknown, PS Sarai Rape FIR lodged, 02 accused Ankil Distt. Kaushambi arrested. Charge sheet no. 196/2019 was filed. Monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid. 63 14/1(1)/2019-RU Sri Jagdish W/o Sri Murder FIR lodged, 01 accused Sukhlal, R/o Sivni, Ps arrested. Kurara, Distt Hamirpur Monetary relief of Rs. 10 lakh was paid under Rani Laxmibai Yojna & PoA Act relief awaited 64 14/1(3)/2019-RU Smt Urmila Devi D/o Atrocity FIR lodged. Sri Chotelal Mushar, (M) Charge sheet no. 59/2019, R/o Adhiyar, Ps Sureri, Monetary relief of Rs. 2.25 Distt Jaunpur lakh was paid.
65 14/1(2)/2019-RU Kumari Rekha urf Buta Rape FIR lodged, 05 accused D/o Sri Jeetnarayan, arrested. R/o Jagdishpur, Ps Charge sheet no. 120/2019 Mirganj, Distt Jaunpur was filed. Monetary relief of Rs. 6.18 lakh was paid.
228 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
In these 65 major cases 65 FIRs were got lodged , 72 accused were arrested and monetary relief of Rs 2,39,56,875/- was paid to the victims
2.5.2.8(a) State Office : Patna 2018-19
File No. 14/71/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of murder of a minor boy Rakesh Kumar S/o Shri Nandji Ram, Katar, P.S.-Piro (Hasanbazar), Bhojpur, Bihar on 09.05.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 159/2018 u/s 147/148/149/302 IPC and 3(2)(va) PoA Act was registered against 7 accused,3 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 61/2018 dated 06.08.2018 submitted against all accused. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 14/55/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape of a minor girl Km A……. D/o Nathuni Paswan, Majhaua, P.S.Nagar,Bhojpur,Bihar on 22.04.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 54/2018 u/s 342/376/504/506/34 IPC ,4/6 POCSO Act and 3(2)(va) PoA Act was lodged. Chargesheet No. 82/2018 submitted on 30.06.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 3.75 lakh was paid to victim. File No. 14/158/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of murder of Mohan Mushar S/o Jahil, Udwantnagar (Mushar Toli) P.S.Udwantnagar, Bhojpur, Bihar on 18.09.2018, Notice was issued and FIR No. 354/2018 was lodged u/s 302 IPC, 3(1)(r)(s)/ 3(2)(v) PoA Act ,1 accused arrested on 19.09.2018. Chargesheet in the case No. 324/2018 was submitted on 31.10.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim.on 07.01.2019. File No. 14/99/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape of a minor girl Km A…… D/o Mahendra Mushar, Sikrahta Kala, P.S. Sikrahta, Bhojpur, Bihar on 23.06.2018, Notice was issued and FIR No. 39/2018 u/s 376(D) IPC , 6 POCSO Act and 3(1)(r)(s)w(i)(ii)/3(2)(va) PoA
229 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Act was lodged against 4 accused. 2 accused were arrested and chargesheet No. 62/2018 was submitted on 18.09.2018 against all accused. Monetary compensation of Rs 6.187 lakh was paid to victim on 07.01.2019 . File No. 14/91/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape of a minor girl Km B…… ,D/o Bisheshwar Das, Nailly, P.S. Mahkar, Gaya, Bihar on 14.06.2018, Notice was issued and FIR No. 109/2018 was lodged u/s 376(B) IPC, 4/12 POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) PoA Act against one accused. The accused was arrested on 22.06.2018 and chargesheet No. 115/18 submitted on 31.07.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 3.75 lakh was paid to victim on 07.01.2019 . File No. 14/8/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of murder of Bhuwaneshwar Manjhi, Chainpura Musahari, Beur, Patna, Bihar on 24.01.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 20/2018 u/s 302/120(B)/34 IPC was lodged, section 3(2)v of PoA Act was added later. The accused was arrested on 27.01.2018, chargesheet no. 65/18 was submitted on 21.04.2018 . Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim on 24.04.2018. File No. 14/34/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape of a minor girl Km R…… ,D/o Suraj Ram, Andhari, Chauri, Bhojpur on 08.03.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 31/2018 u/s 376(D)/376(2)(i) IPC, 4/6 POCSO Act and 3(1)(r)(s)(w)(i)(ii)/3(2)(va) PoA Act was lodged against 4 accused, 3 were arrested and sent to judicial custody ,chargesheet No. 30/2018 was submitted on 30.04.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 6.187 lakh was paid to victim. File No. 14/41/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of murder of Raman Kumar S/o Ram Prasad Paswan, Panapur Langa, Sadar, Vaishali on 23.03.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 176/2018 u/s 302/34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(2)(v) PoA Act was lodged against one accused who was arrested, charge sheet submitted. . Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 14/11/2018-B
230 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of murder of Santosh Kumar S/o Viswanath Paswan, Baikathpur, P.S. Khusroopur, Patna,Bihar on 01.02.2018, Notice was issued and FIR No. 20/2018 u/s 302/34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(1)(r) ,3(2)(v) PoA Act was lodged against 5 accused. Chargesheet No. 30/2018 was submitted on 27.04.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to family of victim. File No. 14/120/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of assault on a minor girl Km N…..with intent to outrage her modesty in Rassi Bagan Mohalla ,Nawada P.S. , Bhojpur , Bihar on 12.07.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 475/2018 u/s 341/323/504/506/354(D)/34 IPC, 12 POCSO Act and 3(1)(r)(s) PoA Act was lodged. The main accused was arrested and sent to jail. C.S. No. 354/2018 was submitted on 31.08.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs lakh was paid to victim. File No. 14/143/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of stripping and parading in market of Smt Guriya Devi W/o Mithilesh Kumar Nat, Dafali, P.S. Bihia, Bhojpur, Bihar on 20.08.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No. 319/2018 u/s 147/148/149/341/323/354(B)427/435/436/504 IPC and 3(1)(r)(w)(s), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was lodged against 15 named and 100 unknown accused. 21 accused in the case were arrested. Chargesheet No. 358/2018 was submitted on 05.09.2018. Monetary compensation of Rs 1.5 lakh was paid to victim. File No. 14/26/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of rape of a minor girl Km M…… D/o Devendra Ram,Sheikhpur Dhab, P.S. Ahiyapur, Muzaffarpur, Bihar on 26.02.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No.213/2018 was lodged u/s 376/506 IPC, 6/10 POCSO Act and 3(1)(c)/1(e)/1(w) of PoA Act against one accused. Monetary compensation of Rs 1.5 lakh was paid to victim as per rules. File No. 14/89/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of murder of all 4 members of a SC family on 11.06.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No.147/2018 was lodged u/s 302/326(A)/120(B)/307/436 IPC and 3(2)(v) PoA Act on 11.06.2018 in P.S. Ajamnagar,
231 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Katihar, Bihar against 2 accused under section. Both accused were arrested on 11.06.2018 itself and chargesheet in the case was submitted for speedy trial of the case. Payment of financial relief could not be made as all members of the family were murdered. File No. 11/52/2018-B
Shri Rambarat Paswan S/o Late Deva Paswan , Darua Tola, P.S. Khaira, Aurangabad, Bihar submitted a representation to the Commission regarding non payment of financial relief to him even after submission of chargesheet in Khaira P.S. case No. 67/2017 which was registered on his complaint regarding harassment and caste abuse.. Due to intervention of the Commission, Rs 0.75 lakh as financial relief was provided to the petitioner. File No. 14/57/2018-B
Suo moto cognisance was taken of reports of gang rape of two minor girls on 23.04.2018 in Gopalganj, Bihar on 26.04.2018. Notice was issued and FIR No.18/2018 was lodged u/s 341/323/354(B) 34 IPC and 3(1)(r)(w) PoA Act against 7 named accused . Chargesheet in the case has been submitted and admissible financial relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh each paid to both the victims. File No. 11/68/2018-B
Smt. Mala Devi W/o Shri Bhuwaneshwar Rajak ,Laxmipur, P.S. Sahebpur, Kamal, Begusarai , Bihar submitted a representation regarding non payment of financial relief despite registration of FIR No. 158/2017 dated 07.06.2017 u/s 341/323/324/325/504/34 IPC acd 3(1)(r)(s) PoA Act and submission of chargesheet No. 266/2017 on 30.10.2017 .Case was taken up and DM, Begusarai informed that Rs. 0.75 lakh financial relief was paid to the petitioner on 06.06.2018.
2.5.2.8(b) State Office : Patna 2019-20
File No. 14/54/2018-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Mrityunjay Baitha in village Sawaiya, P.S Mirganj Gopalganj, Bihar, a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 105/18 dated 21.04.2018 lodged u/s 302/34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(2)(v) PoA Act was lodged. 2 accused arrested,
232 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
chargesheet No. 156/2018 filed on 30.06.2018. Admissible financial relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased. In addition, pension was also provided to the family.
File No. 14/21/2017-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Hemchandra Paswan in village Pir nagar, P.S. Dandari, Begusarai, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 29/2017 dated 21.05.2017 was lodged u/s 302/120(B)/34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(2)(v) PoA Act. 4 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 54/2017 was filed on 19.09.2017. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased.
File No. 14/3/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Indal Paswan in village Magdha, P.S. Deepnagar, Nalanda, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 05/2019 dated 02.01.2019 was lodged u/s 147/148/341/307/302 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(v) PoA Act. 1 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 72/19 was filed on 06.04.2019. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to Sangeeta Devi the wife of deceased. In addition, monthly pension has also been granted.
File No. 14/29/2018-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of violence and murder of Rajo Rajwanshi in village Dharampur, P.S. Sirdala, Nawada, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 71/18 dated 03.03.2018 was lodged u/s 147/148/149/354/354(A)/307/302/504/506/34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(2)(v) PoA Act. 3 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 110/18 was filed on 20.05.2018. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased. In addition, monthly pension is also being given.
File No. 14/127/2018-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of a minor boy Kaushal Manjhi in village Bhawani Bigha, P.S. Muffassil, Nawada, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 111/2018
233 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
dated 24.07.2018 was lodged u/s 302/201/34 IPC and 3(2)(v) PoA Act. 2 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 128/18 was filed on 22.10.2018. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased. In addition, monthly pension is also being given.
File No. 14/124/2018-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Tapan Ram in village Habibpur, P.S. Barharia, Siwan, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 227/2018 dated 19.07.2018 was lodged u/s 147/323/302/504/506/34 IPC, 3(i)(r)(s) and 3(2)(va) PoA Act. 3 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 318/18 was filed on 13.10.2018. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased victim. In addition, monthly pension is also being given.
File No. 14/146/2018-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of grievous hurt of Garib Prasad in village Phalugni, P.S. Thawe, Gopalganj, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 35/2018 dated 21.08.2018 was lodged u/s 341/323/504/34 IPC, 3(i)(r)(a)(s) PoA Act. 2 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 65/18 was filed on 22.12.2018. Admissible financial relief of Rs 0.75 lakh was paid to the victim.
File No. 14/73/2018-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Raj Kumar Manjhi in village Birnawa (Harihar Bigha), P.S. Kashichak, Nawada Bihar, a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 62/2018 dated 14.05.2018 was lodged u/s 147/148/149/302/504/ IPC and 3(2)(v) PoA Act. 3 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 101/18 was filed on 21.08.2018 and 2nd chargesheet no 113/19 was filed on 22.09.2019. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased. Monthly pension is also being given to the family.
File No. 14/125/2018-B
234 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Naresh Sada in village Gogar Bharna, P.S. Mahishi, Saharsa, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 164/2018 dated 21.07.2018 was lodged u/s 147/148/149/341/323/342/447/302 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(v) PoA Act. 3 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 160/18 was filed on 16.10.2018. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased. In addition, monthly pension is also being given.
File No. 14/179/2018-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Pawan Kumar in village Dihra, P.S. karakat, Rohtas, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 204/2018 dated 07.11.2018 was lodged u/s 147/148/149/341/323/307/302/448 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(v)/ 3(2)(va) PoA Act. 9 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 21/19 was filed on 10.02.2019. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased.
File No. 14/146/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Rohit Kumar in village Beri Tole Chaudhary Bigha, P.S. Salaiya, Aurangabad, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 55/2019 dated 19.03.2019 was lodged u/s 302/34 IPC, 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(v)/3(2)(va) PoA Act. 3 accused arrested, chargesheet submitted. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased.
File No. 14/174/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of rape of a minor girl in village Malpur, P.S. Khodawandpur, Begusarai, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 185/2019 dated 03.09.2019 was lodged u/s 376 IPC, 6 POCSO Act and 3(i)(w)/3(2)(v) PoA Act. 1 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 187/19 was filed on 28.09.2019. Admissible financial relief of Rs 3.75 lakh was given to the victim, In addition ration for three month alongwith utensils has also been provided.
235 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 14/67/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of 2 members of the same family in village Nadiyawa, P.S. Dipnagar, Nalanda, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 119/2019 dated 26.04.2019 was lodged u/s 302/34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(v) PoA Act. 3 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 185/19 was filed on 31.07.2019. Admissible financial relief of Rs. 8.25lakh was given to the dependent of deceased. In addition monthly pension is also being given.
File No. 14/12/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of Yamuna Ram in village Tilath, P.S. Piro, Bhojpur, Bihar, a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 23/2019 dated 17.01.2019 was lodged u/s 302/504/506/34 IPC, 27 Arms Act and 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(va) PoA Act. 1 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 57/19 was filed on 08.04.2019. Admissible financial relief of Rs 8.25 lakh was given to the dependent of deceased.
File No. 14/4/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of Grievous hurt of Raju manjhi in village Pathraura, P.S. Magadh Medical, Gaya, Bihar , a notice was issued and matter followed up. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 03/2019 dated 04.01.2019 was lodged u/s 341/323/374/425/427/429/436/504/506/34 IPC, and 3(i)(r)(s)(h)/3(2)(v) PoA Act. 2 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 136/19 was filed on 31.07.2019. Admissible financial relief of Rs 1.00 lakh was given to the victim.
2.5.2.9 State Office : Pune 2019-20
File No. NCSC/PUNE/81/2019-APCR-I
Shri Maruti Gangadhar Jamdhade, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra complained about non arrest of accused in the rape of minor girl in FIR No. 170/2019 dated 13.12.2019 . The FIR was registered u/s 376 (2) (K) (L)(M) (N), 363, 366, 342, 326 IPC, 6 POCSO Act and 3(1) (w), 3(2) (v), (3) (2) (va)of PoA Act. Due to our intervention the accused was arrested on
236 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
17.12.2019. The chargesheet no 29/2020 was filed in special court on14.02.2020. Monetary relief of Rs. 2.00 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. NCSC/PUNE/33/2019-APCR-I
Smt Rani.S.Khude, Varkute Budruk,Taluka Indapur, Pune, Maharashtra complained of non arrest of accused persons in FIR No. 379/2019 dated 22.06.2019. The FIR was registered u/s 354, 324, 504, 34 IPC , 3(1) ( r) 3(s), 3(2) (va), 3(1)(w) (i) (ii) of PoA Act , and PCR 7(d) (1) (d) of PCR Act. A notice was issued on 02.07.2019. Due to our intervention all accused were arrested. The chargesheet No. 94/2019 was submitted in special court on 31.07.2019. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. NCSC/PUNE/28 /2019-APCR-I
Shri Bhausaheb Kendale, r/o Ahmednagar, Maharashtra requested for arrest of accused in case of atrocity. A notice was issued to SP and DC, Ahmednagar and Assistant Commissioner of Social Welfare, Ahmednagar. A FIR No.207/2019 dated 17.05.2019 u/s 354, 506 IPC , 3(1) (w) (i) (ii) of PoA Act was registered. Due to our intervention the accused was arrested and chargesheet No. 9/2020 was submitted in special court on 04.01.2020.Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was provided to victim . File No. NCSC/PUNE/35/2019/APCR-I
Shri Vishnu Unawane, Chikhli, Pune, Maharashtra complained regarding non-registration of FIR by the Police. A notice was issued to CP, Pimpri Chinchwad Mahanagar palika Pune on 31.07.2019. FIR was lodged, on 17.10.2019 u/s 3 (1) (r) (s) of PoA Act & 504,506, 34 IPC. Monetary relief of Rs. 0.25 lakh was provided to the victim. Chargesheet is yet to be submitted to the court. File No. NCSC/PUNE/88/2019/APCR-I
Shri Rahul Salve, Talegaon Dabhade, Taluka Maval, Pune, Maharashtra complained regarding the non-registering of FIR by police. Notice was issued on 21.01.2020 to DC and SP Pune. FIR No.07/2020 was registered u/s 420,354 IPC with 3 (1) (r) (s) 3 (1) (w) (II) 3 (2) (va) of PoA Act on 24.01.2020. Accused was arrested. Admissible financial assistance to the victim is pending, due to non availability of funds. File No. NCSC/PUNE/76/2019/APCR-I
237 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Shri Sagar Uttam Randhave, Hingangaon, Taluka Karjat, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra complained on 25.11.2019 regarding non arrest of accused in FIR No. 116/2019 dated 27.02.2019 which was registered u/s 316, 323, 504, 506 IPC , 3 (1) (R) (S) (W) 3 (2) (va) of PoA Act. Notice was issued to DC and SP on 26.11.2019. Accused was arrested and chargesheet no 143/2019 was submitted.. Monetary relief of Rs. 1.50 lakh was provided to the victim. File No. NCSC/PUNE/09/2019/APCR-I
Smti Seema Sopan Waydande Panchal, Koregaonbhima, Taluka Shirur, Pune, Maharashtra complained regarding non-payment of Rs 6.25 lakh by the contractor on account of labour charges. Notice was issued to DC and SP Pune on 24.04.2020. Due to our intervention Rs. 2.50 lakh as monetary relief was released by the opponent on 27.05.2019.
2.5.2.10(a) State Office : Trivandrum 2018-19 Details of atrocity cases taken up :
Table 2.7(a)
Sl. File No. Victim & Address Nature of Action No. offence 1 KL/31/46/2018 Thirteen year old SC Rape FIR No.86/2018 girl, Kozhikode u/s 3(2)(5) of PoA Act District lodged, 1 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 1 lakh sanctioned. 2 KL/31/105/2018 Twenty year old SC Rape FIR No.1228/2018 girl, Kottayam District u/s. 3(2)(5), 3(1)(w)(i) of PoA Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs. Rs.3.75 lakh sanctioned. 3 KL/31/117/2018 Twelve year old SC Rape FIR No.1404/2018 girl, Trivandrum District
238 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
u/s 3(2)(5) of PoA Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 1 lakh sanctioned. 4 KL/31/144/2018 Twenty year old SC Rape FIR No.157/2012 girl, Palakkad District u/s 3(2)(5) of PoA Act lodged,1 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs. Rs 0.60 lakh sanctioned. 5 KL/31/7/2018 Press news dated Rape FIR No. 1415/2018 u/s 20.1.2018 broadcasted 376 & 3(2)(5) of PoA about SC woman Act lodged, 1 accused raped at Neyyatinkara arrested, monetary in Trivandrum District compensation of Rs. Rs 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 6 KL/31/101/2017 Shri.Madhu.K, Murder FIR No. 474/2017 u/s Karukathara House, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Thakazhi, Alappuzha Act, 3 accused arrested, Monetary compensation of Rs 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 7 KL/31/106/2017 Shri.Satheesan, Murder FIR No. 1453/2017 u/s Chakkanchath House, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Kaypamangalam, Act lodged, 5 accused Thrissur arrested, monetary compensation of Rs. Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 8 KL/31/8/2018 Shri.Kishore, Puthen Murder FIR No. 1653/2017 u/s kurish, Ernakulam 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, monetary compensation Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 9 KL/31/54/2018 Shri.Akash, Charuvila Murder FIR No 9/2018 u/s 302 puthen veedu, & 3(2)(5) of PoA Act Pallimon.PO , Kollam lodged, 4 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned.
239 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
10 KL/31/101/2018-I Shri. Biju, Murder FIR No.1238/2018 u/s Mullakulangara, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Alappuzha Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, charge sheet no 647/2018 filed, monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 11 KL/31/101/2018-II Shri. Sasikala Biju Murder FIR No.1238/2018 u/s Mullakulangara, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Alappuzha Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, charge sheet no 647/2018 filed, monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 12 KL/31/106/2018- Shri.Chandran, Murder FIR No.1238/2018 u/s Thiruthoth house, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Narath village, Act lodged, 1 accused Kozhikode arrested, charge sheet no 598/2018 filed, monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 13 KL/31/107/2018 Shri.Ullas, Karuvatta Murder FIR No.148/2017 u/s village, Haripad, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Alappuzha Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, charge sheet no 663/2017 filed, monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 14 KL/31/108/2018 Shri.Kannan, Murder FIR No.545/2018 u/s illathuparambil House, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Kattappana, Idukki Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, charge sheet no 419/2018 filed, monetary compensation of Rs 8.25 lakh sanctioned. 15 KL/31/128/2018 Shri.Rajan, Rejani Murder FIR No.992/2018 u/s Bhawan, Pathirikkal, 302 & 3(2)(5) of PoA Kollam Act lodged, 2 accused arrested, monetary
240 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
compensation of Rs 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 16 KL/31/17/2019 Shri.Sasi, Panavila Murder FIR No.48/2019 u/s 302 veedu, & 3(2)(5) of PoA Act Thekkumbhagom, lodged, 1 accused Kottappuram village, arrested, monetary Kollam compensation of Rs 4.125 lakh sanctioned. 17 KL/31/73/2016 Shri.Sanath, Physical FIR No.1854/2016 S.K.Bhawan, assault u/s 294(b), Vanyoor.PO, Attingal, 341,323,324,326,354, Trivandrum district 506(1) & 34 IPC and PoA Act lodged, 3 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh 18 KL/31/26/2017(HQRS) Shri.Gopakumar, Physical FIR No.1463/2016 Pallikunnil veedu, assault u/s 341, 323, 325 & 34 Varkala, Trivandrum IPC and PoA Act district lodged, 4 accused arrested, charge sheet no 889/17 filed, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 19 KL/31/27/2017 Shri.Natarajan, Physical FIR No.361/2017 Charuvila puthen assault u/s 294(b), 341,323, veedu, Navayikukalm, 324, 354 &34 IPC and Trivandrum district PoA Act lodged, 2 accused arrested, charge sheet no 2504/17 filed, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh 20 KL/31/30/2017 Smt. Matha, Kannan Physical FIR No.161/2017 kuttummel veedu, assault u/s 341,323, 324, 308, Puthoor.Po, 326 r/w, 34 IPC, 3(2)(5) Kozhikode of PoA Act lodged, 2 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 21 KL/31/39/2017 Smt. Bindu, Ani Physical FIR No.648/2017 Bhawan, assault
241 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Pathiyoor.PO, u/s 294(b), 34 IPC, Alappuzha district 3(1)(r)3(1) of PoA Act lodged, 1 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh sanctioned. 22 KL/31/44/2017 Shri. Nanu, Physical FIR No.914/2017 Kizhakekara puthen assault 3(2)(5) of PoA Act veedu, payanallur.PO, lodged, 1 accused Pathanamthitta district arrested, charge sheet no 15278/17, monetary compensation of Rs 4.15 lakh sanctioned. 23 KL/31/53/2017 Smt.Girija, Lalitha Physical FIR No.897/2017 Bhawan, Kollamkona, assault 3(1)(r) of PoA Act 2015 Vilappil, Trivandrum lodged, 6 accused district arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 24 KL/31/99/2017 Smt.Baby, Caste wise FIR No. 248/2019 u/s Anganwady Helper, abuse and 294 (b), 506, 34 IPC 3(I) Pullukad SMC, disconnect (g), 3(1)(r) 3 (1)(s) of Trivandrum drinking PoA Act lodged, no water accused arrested, connection monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 25 KL/31/3/2018 Shri Aneesh.T, Physical FIR No. 114/2018 u/s Kunnorkal Lakshom assault 143, 149, 323 IPC and veedu colony, 3(I)(r) of PoA Act Karakulam.PO, lodged, 2 accused Trivandrum arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 26 KL/31/49/2018 Shri.Baburaj, Palode, Physical FIR No Cr.No. 70/2018 Trivandrum assault u/s 143, 148,149, 341, 294(b)323, 324 IPC and 3(I)S 3(I) (za) (c) of PoA Act lodged, 2 accused arrested, monetary compensation
242 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 27 KL/31/71/2018 Smt.Karthika, Rajiv Physical FIR No. 1132/2018 u/s Mandiram, Idavarikkal assault 294(b), 341, 323, 326, colony, r/w 34 IPC & 3(2)(5) of Ummannur.PO, PoA Act lodged, 3 Kollam accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 28 KL/31/110/2018 Smt.K.Girija, Indu Atrocity FIR No Cr.No. Bhawan, Akkaravila, towards 1653/2018 sec. 3(1)(r) 5 Murukumpuzha.PO, SC of PoA Act lodged, 1 Trivandrum woman accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 29 KL/31/120/2018 Shri.Pranav, Nenmara Physical FIR No.847/2018 Boys High School, assault u/s.143,148, 341, 323, Palakkad 324 r/w 149 IPC and 3(2)(5) of PoA Act lodged, 4 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.50 lakh sanctioned. 30 KL/31/146/2018 Smt.Girija. K, Atrocity FIR No 20/2019 u/s Thiruvathira, shiva towards 451, 294(b), 323, 506, Nagar, Kollam SC 354 & 34 and PoA Act woman lodged, 2 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.25 lakh sanctioned. 31 KL/15/O/Misc/28/2018 Smt.Revamma, Atrocity FIR No 664/2018 u/s Puthusseri kizhakathil, towards 294(b), 34 IPC & sec. Cheruthana.PO, SC 3(1) (r) (s) of PoA Act Alappuzah woman lodged, 1 accused arrested, monetary compensation of Rs 0.75 lakh sanctioned.
2.5.2.10(b) State Office : Trivandrum 2019-20 Details of atrocity cases taken up :
243 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Table 2.7(b)
Monetary Name of S. Nature FIR No. of relief applicant Status File No. of registered and accused sanctione No with of case offences sections arrested d (Rs. in . address lakh) 1. KL/31/238 27 years old Rape Cr.No.14/2019 One Charge 3 lakh /2019 SC girl u/s 376 IPC & sheeted paid from 3(2) (v) of (DCRB) Kollam PoA Act. district 2. KL/31/241 21 year old Rape Cr.No.869/19 One Not 2 lakh /2019 SC girl, u/s 376(2) (n) charge paid (DCRB) Kollam IPC & sheeted district 3(2)(v)(a) of PoA Act. 3. KL/31/239 17 years old Rape Cr.No.154/19 One Not 2 lakh /2019 SC girl u/s 420, charge paid (DCRB) from 376(f)(k) IPC , sheeted Kollam 3 r/w 5(n) of district POCSO Act & 3(2) v (a) of PoA Act. 4. KL/31/287 SC woman Rape Cr.No.846/19 One Under 1 lakh /2019 from u/s 376 IPC & Investig paid (DCRB) Thrissur added Sec ation district 3(2)(Va) of PoA Act. 5. KL/31/284 28 years old Rape Cr.No.359/19 One Under 0.10 lakh /2019 SC girl u/s 376(2) (n), Investig paid (DCRB) fromThrissu 354, 506,34 ation r IPC & 3(i)w(ii), 3(2)(va) of PoA Act. 6. KL/31/299 10 years old Rape Cr.No.,217/19 One Charge 1 lakh /2019 SC girl u/s 354 (A) sheeted paid (DCRB) from IPC 10 r/w Wayanad 9(m) of POCSO Act
244 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
and 3(1), (w), 3(2)(va) of PoA Act. 7. KL/31/348 17 years old Rape Cr.No.1248/20 One Under 3.75 lakh /2019 SC girl 18 u/s Investig paid (DCRB) from 363,376,IPC , ation Pathanamthi sec 5(1)r/w 6 tta of POCSO Act 2012 and sec 75 of Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of children) Act and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 8. KL/31/347 SC girl Rape Cr.No.742/19/ One Under 2.50 lakh /2019(DC from 19 u/s 376 IPC Investig paid RB) Pathanamthi 4 r/w 3,6 r/w ation tta 5(I)(ii)(I) of POCSO Act & 3(1)(w)(i) of PoA Act. 9. KL/31/267 6 years old Rape Cr.No.124/201 One Charge 3.75 lakh /2019 SC girl 9, u/s 511 of sheeted paid (DCRB) from 376 IPC & Alappuzha 7&8 of POCSO Act 2012 & 3(1) (xi) of PoA Act. 10. KL/31/272 14 years old Rape Cr.No.981/19 One Charge 1.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 354, 451 sheeted paid RB) from IPC & 12 r/w Alappuzha 11(iv) 7 r/w 8 of POCSO Act & 3(1)w(1) of PoA Act. 11. KL/31/274 8 year old Rape Cr.No.369/19, One Charge 1.50 lakh /2019(DC sc girl from u/s 354, sheeted paid RB) Alappuzha 354(A) IPC , 9 & 10 of POCSO Act &
245 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
3(1)(w)(i) of PoA Act. 12. KL/31/276 15 year old Rape Cr.No.746/201 One Not 1.50 lakh /2014(DC sc girl from 9, u/s 7 & 8 of Charge paid RB) Alappuzha POCSO Act sheeted 2012 & 3(1)(w) (i) of PoA Act. 13. KL/31/269 17 year old Rape Cr.No.355/19 One Charge 3.75 lakh /2019 girl from u/s 376 IPC, 4, sheeted paid (DCRB) Alappuzha 3A,6 5j(ii), 51 of POCSO Act 2012 & 3(1)(w)(ii), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 14. KL/31/334 SC girl Rape Cr.No.1024/19 One Under 0.50 lakh /2019(DC from Kochi u/s 376 IPC & Investig paid RB) 3(2)(v) of PoA ation Act. 15. KL/31/337 SC girl Rape Cr.No.1187/20 One Under 1 .25 lakh /2019(DC from Kochi 19 u/s 376 IPC Investig paid RB) & 3(1)(w)(i), ation 3(2)(V) of PoA Act. 16. KL/31/332 SC girl Rape Cr.No.574/19 One Under 0.50 lakh /2019 from Kochi u/s 5 r/w 6 of Investig paid POCSO 376 ation IPC & 3(i), 3(ii), 3(v), 3(xi) of PoA Act. 17. KL/31/330 18 years old Rape Cr.No.409/19 One Under 1 lakh /2019(DC sc girl from u/s 376 354, Investig paid RB) Ernakulam 354A(1)(i), ation 354 B, 354 D, 509, 384, 323,324, 294(b), 506(i) IPC & 6 r/w 5I, 10
246 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
18. KL/31/259 15 year old Rape Cr.No.93/19 One Under 2.50 lakh /2019(DC Sc girl from u/s 363, 376, Investig paid RB) Malappura 2(n) IPC, 4 r/w ation m 3(a)6 r/w 5(I) of POCSO Act and 3(2) (v) of PoA Act. 19. KL/31/264 SC girl Rape Cr.No. 144/19 One Under 2.50 lakh /2019(DC from u/s 366,376(3), Investig paid RB) Malappura 109 IPC, 5I ation m r/w 6, 16 r/w 17 of POCSO Act ,3(2)(v) PoA Act.& 66(F) of IT Act
20. KL/31/257 7 years old Rape Cr.No.67/19 One Charge 3.75 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 376 AB sheeted paid RB) from IPC, 3(h)r/a 4, Malappura 5 (m) r/w 6 of m POCSO Act and 3 (l)(w)(l), 3(2) (V) of PoA Act. 21. KL/31/258 28 years old Rape Cr.No.88/19,u/ One Charge 2.50 lakh /2019(DC Sc woman s 376 (l) 506 sheeted paid RB) from IPC, 66 IT Act Malappura and 3(2)(V)(a) m of PoA Act. 22. KL/31/252 17 years old Rape Cr.No.1356/19 One Under 0.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 376(2)(n) Investig paid RB) from 366 IPC, 3 r/w ation Kottayam 4 of POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 23. KL/31/305 29 years old Rape Cr.No.1139/19 One Under 0.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 376(2)(n) Investig paid RB) from IPC and ation Kottayam 3(1)(w)(i),3(2) (v) of PoA Act.
247 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
24. KL/31/247 17 years old Rape Cr.No.143/19 One Charge 1 .60 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 376, sheeted paid RB) from 376(2)(n) IPC Kottayam & 3 r/w 4, 5 (l) r/w 6 of POCSO Act 2012, & 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 25. KL/31/304 37 years old Rape Cr.No.1030/19 One Under 0.50 lakh /2019(DC SC woman U/s 342, 376 Investig paid RB) from (1) IPC & ation Kottayam 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 26. KL/31/251 10 years old Rape Cr.No.492/201 One Charge 1.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl 9 u/s sheeted paid RB) from 376(2)(i)(n)(k) Kottayam of IPC, 5(l)(m) r/w 6,9 (l)(m) r/w 10 of POCSO Act 2012 & 3(1)(w)(i), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 27. KL/31/250 17 years old Rape Cr.No.453/19 One Charge 1.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 354(A) sheeted paid RB) from IPC, 7 & 8 of Kottayam POCSO Act 2012 & 3(1)(w)(i) 3(2)(va) PoA Act. 28. KL/31/111 18 year old Rape Cr.No.550/19 One Charge 1.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 450, 376 sheeted paid RB) from (2)(n) of IPC Kannur ,3(A) r/w 4,5(j)(ii)5(I) r/w 6 of POCSO Act & 3(1)(w)(i), 3(1)(w)(ii), 3(2)(va) of PoA Act.
248 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
29. KL/31/316 24 years old Rape Cr.no.443/18 One Not 2.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s Charge paid RB) from 366,376(2)(n) sheeted Malappura IPC and m 3(2)(v) PoA Act. 30. KL/31/255 15 years old Rape Cr.No.37/19 One Charge 1.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s 11(1) r/w sheeted paid RB) from 12 of POCSO Malappura Act and 3(2) m (va) of PoA Act. 31. KL/31/283 13 years old Rape Cr.No.369/19 One Charge 1.50 lakh /2019(DC SC girl u/s sheeted paid RB) from 376(2)(a)(i), Kannur 354A(1)(i), 354B IPC and 6 r/w 5(i)(n) 10 r/w 9(n), 12 r/w 11(iii), 18 of POCSO Act and 3(1)(w)(1), 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. 32. KL/31/112 42 years old Rape Cr.No.79/19, One Charge 1 .50 lakh /2019(DC SC woman u/s 354, sheeted paid RB) from 354(B), 376 Kannur IPC and 3(1)(w)(i)(ii), 3(2)(v)3(2(va) of PoA Act. 33. KL/31/132 17 years old Rape Cr.No.39/2019 One Charge 3 lakh /2019(DC SC girl , u/s 354 sheeted paid RB) from 354A(1), Kannur 354(B), 354(D)(1)(ii), 450, 376 IPC , 4 r/w 3(a), 8 r/w 7, 10 r/w 9(1), 12 r/w 11(iv) of POCSO Act and 3(1)(r), (w)(i)(ii),
249 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
3(2)(v), 3(2)(va) of PoA Act and sec 66(E), 67, 67(A) of IT Act 34. KL/31/35/ 42 years old Rape Cr.No.207/19 One Charge 1 .50 lakh 2019 SC woman u/s 341, sheeted paid (DCRB) from 294(b),451, Kannur 354, 354(b) IPC and 3(1)(s) and w(ii) of PoA Act. 35. KL/31/271 Renjith Grievous Cr.No.385/201 Six Not 0.75 lakh /2019(DC S/o hurt 9, u/s 143, 144, charge paid RB) Radhakrish 147, 148, 149, sheeted nan 294(b) , 324, 326, 307, IPC Palamutathu & 3(1) (s) of vadakkethil PoA Act. Taliradi Muri Vallikunna m 36. KL/31/300 Narayanan Grievous Cr.No.466/19 Four Charge 5.0 lakh /2019(DC S/o injury u/s 341, 34 sheeted paid RB) Ayyappan IPC & 3(1)(s), 3(2)(va) of Padinjarekk PoA Act. udi House, Methalathpa ra, Neriamanga lam 37. KL/31/249 Ajith Grievous Cr.No.284/19 Three Under 0.75 lakh /2019(DC Kumar Hurt u/s 447, 323, Investig paid RB) S/o 324, 308, 34 ation Krishnan IPC Pokkanezha thu House, Irumboozhi kkara
250 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
38. KL/31/233 Arun Murder Cr.No.535/19, Fourteen Charge 8.25 lakh /2019(DC Ganesan u/s 120(b), sheeted paid RB) S/o Ganesan 341, 323, 201, 364, 302 & 34 Orkkambil IPC & 3(2)(v), Veedu, TC 3(2)(v)(a) of 22/466, PoA Act. Konchiravil a, Attukal, Manacaud , TVM 39. KL/31/277 Pramod Murder Cr,No.242/201 Two Charge 8.25 lakh /2019(DC S/o 9, u/s 341, 323, sheeted paid RB) Ramachand 324, 364, 326, ran 302 r/w 34 IPC & 3(2)(V) of Vallithundil PoA Act. Mailadum mukam bhagam, Payyallur muri, Palamel 40. KL/31/266 Jayan Murder Cr.No.25/19 One Charge 8.25 lakh /2019(DC S/o Leela u/s 324, 302 sheeted paid. RB) IPC & Mukkidicka 3(2)V(a) of l Veedu, PoA Act. Vayalar panchayath u, Ward 2, Cherthala
2.6 Spot Visits
Spot visits in atrocity matters were conducted in 35 (18 cases in 2018-19 and 17 csaes in 2019-20) cases by the Commission. After the visits and intervention of the Commission, registration of 33 FIRs (20 in 2018-19 and 13 in 2019-20) have been ensured under PoA Act, 72 arrests made (50 in 2018-19 and 22 in 2019-20) and 15 chargesheets were filed ( 10 in 2018-19 and 5 in 2019-20).
251 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Total monetary relief of Rs 197.095 lakh (Rs. 105.05 lakh in 2018-19 and Rs 92.045 lakh) was also released to the SC victims. In addition 01 family received a house , 2 were given agricultural land , 5 family pensions ( 2 in 2018-19 and 3 in 2019-20) were sanctioned and 3 family members were given jobs.Medical airlift charges in one case of Rs 4.60 lakh were also got sanctioned. Brief details on some of the cases are detailed below:
2.6.1 NCSC Headquarters
File No. WB/8/2019-APCR & 2/27/2018-Gen/WB (Sundarban PD): Taking cognizance of E-news report dated 28.07.2018 and Ananda Bazaar Patrika dated 29.07.2018 regarding murder of Shri Shaktipada Sardar (SC) of Khorda Sadashibpur under Mandir Bazar Police Station, South 24 Paraganas, WB, a spot visit was conducted on 03.08.20184. After directions of the Commission and follow up the correct sections were added in the FIR and investigation completed. The following relief and rehabilatation measures were sanctioned : monetary relief of Rs.8.25 lakh was transferred to the account of wife of the deceased, gross pension of Rs.10000/- per month was sanctioned to her, food grains for 3 months sanctioned, family of deceased was enlisted in the scheme of khadyasathi for providing food grains at a subsidized rate, widow of deceased has also been sanctioned a grocery scheme under“Mahila Samriddhi Yojana” with subsidy & loan in soft term.
2.6.2 NCSC State Offices
2.6.2.1 State Office, Bangaluru
File No. 23/10/18-RU Taking cognisance of reports of Shri. Kariyappa dying in a quarry due to harassment, a spot visit was conducted5 on 25.10.2018 at village Srirangapatana in Mandya and the
4 By Prof. (Dr.) Ram Shankar Katheria, Chairman, NCSC , Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC and Research Officer, NCSC, Kolkata. 5 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC
252 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
bereaved family was met along with officers. Police registered a case invoking section 3(2) (5) of PoA Act also, charge sheet submitted. Rs 8.25 lakh monetary help has been sanctioned to the victim’s family.
2.6.2.2 State Office, Chandigarh
File No.2-Pb/150/2018 Taking cognizance of complaint from Smt. Rani W/o Late Sh. Ajay Kumar Dona r/o Valmiki Mohalla, Dakoha, Jalandhar, that her husband was shot by two masked men on 27-07-2018 and they escaped on a motorcycle, a spot visit was conducted to Jalandhar on 23-01-20196. After Commission’s intervention, the PoA Act was included in the FIR, 04 accused were arrested and 03 were declared P.O. and the case was chargesheeted. File No. 9/10/2018-Res Taking cognizance of complaints of SC atrocities in Bhagana Village and for the verification of the list of the SC families for the relief to be provided, a spot visit was conducted on 04-12-20187 which was followed up by the hearing in the Commission. On spot verification of the list of 88 persons, it was found that 51 families are living still out of the village, like some are at Dharna, some are doing work in other cities and it was also found that 33 families are living in the village and 04 people have expired. After Commission’s intervention, three FIRs were registered with the inclusion of PoA Act and Rs.10.65 lakh relief has been paid to the victims.
2.6.2.3(a) State Office : Chennai 2018-19
File No. 3/27/Sivaganga/2018 Res. Taking cognizance of news dated 29.5.2018 regarding 3 SC murdered and 5 SCs injured in an attack at Katchanatham village, Sivaganga, a spot investigation was conducted on 31.5.20188. FIR registered, 13 arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs 12.375 lakh (@Rs.4.125 lakh each to families of 3 murdered victims) and Rs 7.5 lakh (@Rs.1.50 lakh each to the 5 injured persons) was released.
6 By Director, NCSC State Office, Chandigarh 7 By Director, NCSC State Office, Chandigarh 8 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC
253 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 25/21/2018 Res. Taking cognizance of news regarding 13 people including 4 SCs killed in police firing at Thoothukudi due to Sterlite Copper Factory issue, a spot visit was conducted and hearings held on 28.6.2018 and 29.6.20189. In the hearing directions were given to the District Officials for speedy rehabilitation to the 4 families of SCs killed in the Police firing. File No. 25/39/2018 Res Taking cognizance of news in the media dated 17.11.2018 regarding murder of an SC male belonging to Krishnagiri, Tamil Nadu at Mandya, Karnataka, a spot visit was made on 21.11.201810. FIR was lodged in Karnataka and on reference received from Karnataka police, Rs.4.125 lakh has been paid as monetary relief to the victim’s family. File No. 25/39/2018 Res(2) Based on complaint received from SC people of Azhagumalai village, Tiruppur , regarding problems faced by SCs in Kailasanathar Temple in the village, a spot visit was conducted on 23.11.201811. Due to the visit, temple issue relating to SCs has been resolved.
2.6.2.3(b) State Office : Chennai 2019-20 File No: 3/6/Tiruchirapalli/2020 Res.
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder on 27.01.2020 of Vijay Raghu in Gandhi Market, Tiruchirapalli City, TN the Commission 12 conducted a spot investigation in the atrocity incident on 28.01.2020. Due to our intervention, FIR No: 76/2020 was registered in Gandhi Market Police Station u/s 302 IPC and 3(1)(r)(s) and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act and 3 accused were arrested. Monetary relief of Rs.4.125 lakh was paid to the victim family. Action on recommendations of the Commission is being taken by the District Administration for provision of additional relief / rehabilitation measures such as pension, job, house / patta etc. to the victim / family of the deceased. 2.6.2.4 State Office : Hyderabad 2019-20 F. No. 22/8/20/ MP & F. No. 23/3/20/MP-RU:
9 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC 10 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC 11 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC 12 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC
254 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of burning of dalit youth named Shri Dhan Prasad Ahirwar by pouring kerosene over his body. He was a resident of Mothi Nagar , Bhopal ,MP. A spot visit was conducted13 on 21.01.2020. FIR u/s 294,323,452,307, 34 of IPC and 3(2) V of PoA Act was registered. On the insistence of the Commission, the victim was shifted to Safdarjung Hospital, New Delhi by Air and the expenditure Rs 4.60 lakh was met by the State Government.Shri Dhan Prasad later died and section 302 IPC has been added in FIR. Rs 5.125 lakh monetary relief (@Rs 4.125 lakh as per PoA Rules and Rs 1 lakh by Red Cross) and also ration (100 kg. Wheat, 5 kg sugar, 4 kg pulses, 8 litre oil) was provided to family. F. No. 22/18/19/MP-RU:
Suo-moto cognisance was taken of press reports of murder of 02 children as they were defecating in the open in village of Sirsaud Police Station, Shivpuri, MP on 25.09.2019 and notice issued , case followed up. FIR u/s. 302, 342 r/w. 34 IPC and 3(2)(v) of PoA Act was registered. A spot visit was conducted14 on 01.10.2019. Rs. 5,000/- per family was given for performing last rites. Rs. 25,000/- per family was paid by Red Cross Society and Rs. 12,000/- for construction of toilet was also paid to the family of victims. Monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh (@Rs. 4.125 lakh x 2 victims) was paid to each family. 0.5-hectare land in Sy. No. 1699/2, Tekna (V) was assigned to the family. F. No. 22/14/19/TS-RU: Taking suo moto cognisance of reports of gang rape and murder of woman in Kumarbheem of Asifabad, Telangana, the Commission conducted15 a spot visit on 05.12.2019.FIR no 49/2019 u/s 376 D,302,34 IPC & 3(2)5 of PoA Act was registerd. Accused arrested. Monetary relief of Rs 8.25 lakh, monthly pension of Rs 5000/- pm ,3 acres agricultural land and a 2BHK house was sanctioned to her husband. He was also given a government job and her 2 children were admitted to SW residential school at Ichoda, Adilabad. F. No. 23/1/19/MP-RU:
13 By Dr L Murugan , VC , NCSC and Director NCSC State office , Hyderabad
14 By Dr L Murugan , VC , NCSC and Director NCSC State office , Hyderabad 15 By Shri K Ramulu , Member, NCSC, and Director, NCSC State Office Hyderabad
255 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Taking suo moto cognisance of reports of an attack on a SC wedding procession leading to the killing of 1 SC and three persons being injured, the Commission conducted16 a spot visit to Pipalarwa, Dewas, MP on 06.06.2019. As a result of the spot visit , monetary relief Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the widow of the deceased , the 3 injured were paid monetary relief of Rs. 4.50 lakh ( @ Rs. 1.50 lakh x 3 victims). In addition ration (@100 kg wheat, 5 kg sugar, 4 kg pulses, 8 litre oil) was also given to the victims / families by the District Administration as well as providing free medical treatment to the injured victims.
2.6.2.5(a) State Office : Kolkata 2018-19
File No.2/16/2018-Gen/W.B. (Murshidabad) &WB/6/2018-APCR Taking cognizance of e-news report in Fast Post dated 04.07.2018 regarding murder of Shri Dharmaraj Hazra , Taldanga, P.O. Shaktipur, Murshidabad, West Bengal, a spot visit was conducted on 18.07.201817 and directions were given to district authorities and police to include the family in BPL list,provide rations immediately to the family at least for three months and full protection to the school going children. Rs 0.15 lakh were also paid during cremation to family.
2.6.2.5(b) State Office : Kolkata 2019-20 File No. 22/1/2019- RU (Basirhat P.D)
Taking cognizance on a news report dated 9 /10.06.2019 regarding murder of Shri Pradip Mondal (SC), Shri Sukanta Mondal (SC) and abduction of SC villager namely Shri Debdas Mondal (SC) besides leaving residences by as many as 6 SC villagers of Village Nolkora under Nazat Police Station, Sandeshkhali Sub-division, Basirhat Police District, North 24 Parganas District, West Bengal by non-SCs on personal grudge, a team from the Commission18 conducted a spot visit on 14.06.2019.
As per recommendations of the Commission, appropriate sections under PoA Act, 2015 were also imposed, all accused have been arrested, the next kin of each of the two deceased
16 By Dr L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC, and Director, NCSC State Office Hyderabad 17 By Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC , Research Officer, NCSC, Kolkata. 18 Dr Ram Shankar Katheria , Chairman NCSC, Dr L Murugan , VC , NCSC, Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC and Shri Pritam Singh , Secretary, NCSC
256 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
were paid Rs. 8.25 lakh through bank transfer and Rs. 2.50 lakh have been given from the Disaster Management Fund. Besides Rs. 11,250/- pension per month has been released in favour of the two widows. The Ambedkar Foundation has also been approached for release of additional compensation as per Rules. Police however, failed to trace Shri Debashis Mondal who was abducted by the perpetrators during the act of crime on 09/10.06.2019.
File No. 2/64/2019-Gen/OR (Jagatsinghpur)
Taking cognizance of a news report appeared on 08.11.2019 regarding suicide of an unmarried SC girl Kumari Laxmi Priya Das on 07.11.2019 at her residence after her spurned lover of Tentoi village under Naugaon Police limit allegedly pasted her nude photos on the wall of her house at Tentoi village under Nugaon police limit and in the premises of her relatives at Narisima under Jagatsinghpur District..
Commission19 conducted a spot visit on 28.11.2019 and recommended imposing section 376 C IPC, Section 4 of PoA Act and Section 67 of IT Act, 2008 in the FIR. As per last report, pension to deceased mother, full rations to the family, allotment of surplus land and house under PMY which is under active consideration now. Rs. 0.50 lakh has been paid to victim’s mother so far.
File No. 2/43/2019-Gen/WB (S. Dinajpur) :
Taking suo-motu cognizance on a news report on 6/7.01.2020 about gruesome rape and murder of a 18 year SC girl Ms. P. Barman of Panchagram under Gangarampur P.S., South Dinajpur Commission20 conducted a spot visit on 11 & 12.01.2020. The deceased girl reportedly had gone to Fulbari under Kumarganj P.S., South Dinajpur on 05.01.2020 to purchase clothes, but never returned home. Police found her charred body under a culvert in Belghor field under same police station.
In compliance of recommendations of the Commission, sections 3(1)(w)(ii) and 3(2)(v)(va)(vi) of PoA Act have been added in the FIR No. 05/2020 dated 06.01.2020 apart from sections 376D/302/201 IPC under Kumarganj P.S., South Dinajpur. Monetary relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh has been released to father of victim and all three accused are arrested.
19 Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC 20 Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC
257 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 2/68/2017-Gen/OR (BBSR)
It was complained that Shri Golak Kandi had purchased a piece of land in 2009 from one Bharat Bhoi and Jenasa Bhoi and constructed a house in the Plot No. 210/2887, Upar Sahi, Jagamara, Bhubaneswar, ,Odisha. At that material point of time, the land was open all around since it was bari land and some lands were recorded as Government land but were occupied by three non-SC neighbours. The SC petitioner therefore, was using Government land and some land owned by one another non-SC neighbour with whom he entered into an agreement @ cost of Rs. 35,000/- for their personal movements which later not honoured by the same non-SC neighbour. And all such non-SCs surrounding neighbours of Shri Kandi, blocked their own boundaries preventing Shri Kandi to use otherwise common thoroughfare. Although the SC petitioner approached different Government authorities but to no avail.
A spot visit was conducted21 on 23.01.2020 with local police authorities and interacted with the SC petitioner and opponent parties who have vehemently opposed any move by the Government to open path for Shri Kandi. The findings of spot visit conveyed to the Odisha Government with a recommendation for early solution of the impasse.
2.6.2.6(a) State Office : Patna 2018-19
File No. 14/60/2018-B Taking suo moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of attempt to rape of an SC girl, shooting video and make it viral in village Irki, P.S. ,Jehanabad, Bihar a spot visit was conducted on 05.05.201822. Due to intervention of the Commission the accused were arrested, admissible financial relief amounting to Rs.1.50 lakh paid to the victim and chargesheet submitted on 29.06.2018. File No. 14/80/2018-B Taking suo moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of arson in village Mallickpur, P.S. Raghopur, Vaishali,Bihar a spot visit was conducted on 09.06.201823 to
21 By Director, NCSC, Kolkata 22 By Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC. 23 By Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC.
258 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
investigate the matter of 6 shops and uninhabited huts belonging to SCs being set on fire. Due to intervention of the Commission one accused was arrested and Rs 1.50 lakh (@Rs. 25,000/- each to all 6 victims) was sanctioned. File No. 14/100/2018-B Taking suo moto cognizance of news report regarding two SC women raped in two different villages namely Paradi and Jaitpur Kala under Bhagwanpur P.S. of Kaimur , Bihar spot visits were conducted in both villages on 07.07.201824. Due to intervention of the Commission all named accused in both the cases were arrested, chargesheets also submitted in both cases. financial relief of Rs. 0.50 lakh was paid to victim in 1st case and Rs 1.50 lakh to victim in 2nd case. File No. 14/142/2018-B Taking suo moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of rape and murder of an SC girl of village Lodhi, P.S. Muffasil,Rohtas, Bihar, a spot visit was conducted on 04.09.201825. Due to intervention of the Commission ,financial relief of Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the deceased family. File No. 14/161/2018-B Taking suo moto cognizance of news report regarding murder of an SC woman and two injured in firing in village Khaira, P.S. Akbarpur, Nawada,Bihar, a spot visit was conducted on 13.10.201826. Due to intervention of the Commission 2 accused were arrested, Rs. 8.25 lakh as financial relief was paid to the deceased family and Rs.1.00 lakh each paid to injured women. File No. 14/22/2019-B Taking suo moto cognizance of news report regarding gang rape of an SC girl of village Chillauri Tola, P.S. Tehta O.P., Jehanabad, Bihar, a spot visit was conducted on 11.02.201927. Due to intervention of the Commission chargesheet has been submitted against the accused. Proposal for financial relief has already been submitted to the District Magistrate, Jehanabad.
2.6.2.6(b) State Office : Patna 2019-20
24 By Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC. 25 By Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC. 26 By Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC. 27 By Dr. Yogendra Paswan, Member, NCSC.
259 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. 14/158/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of a SC person in village Raj Kharhor under Sadar P.S of Supaul ,Bihar, a spot vist was conducted28 on 07.09.2019. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 587/2019 dated 29.08.2019 u/s 147/148/149/341/323/324/302 IPC and 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(v) PoA Act instituted, 3 accused arrested, chargesheet No. 818/2019 filed on 25.11.2019. Admissible financial relief amounting to Rs. 8.25 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased. Monthly pension amounting to Rs. 5000/- plus admissible D.A. is also being paid to the deceased family.
File No. 14/99/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of rape of a minor SC girl in village Kalopur under Paliganj P.S of Patna ,Bihar, a spot vist was conducted29 on 06.07.2019. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. Mahila P.S. case no. 56/2019 dated 13.06.2019 u/s 376 (A)(B)/4/6 POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) PoA Act instituted, accused arrested, chargesheet No. 69/2019 filed on 31.07.2019. Admissible financial relief amounting to Rs. 3.75 lakh was paid to the victim.
File No. 14/212/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of a SC person in village Belchi under Ariyari P.S of Shiekhpura ,Bihar, a spot vist was conducted30 on 28.10.2019. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 158/2019 dated 23.10.2019 u/s 302/201/34 IPC and 3(i)(r)(s)/3(2)(va) PoA Act instituted and first installment of admissible financial relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased on 28.10.2019.
File No. 14/190/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of murder of a SC woman in village lakhapur under Sadar P.S of Jamui ,Bihar, a spot vist was conducted31 on 09.10.2019. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 520/2019 dated 04.10.2019
28 by Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC 29 by Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC 30 by Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC 31 by Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC
260 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
u/s 302/120(B)/34 IPC and 3(2)(v) PoA Act instituted and first installment of admissible financial relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the dependent of deceased.
File No. 14/202/2019-B
Taking suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding incident of gang rape and murder of a Scheduled Caste girl in village Rawaich under Bakhtiyarpur P.S of Patna ,Bihar, a spot vist was conducted32 on 22.10.2019. Due to intervention of the Commission, FIR No. 332/2019 dated 17.10.2019 u/s 376(D)/302/201/34 IPC and 6 POCSO Act and 3(2)(v) PoA Act instituted, all 3 accused arrested, chargesheet no. 523/2019 filed on 31.12.2019. First installment of admissible financial relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the deceased family.
2.6.2.7 State Office : Pune 2019-20 File No. NCSC/PUNE/Aurangabad Division/ RU-II- Ahmednagar
Taking suo-moto cognizance of new reports regarding incident of rape of Km Prema Dhende,Shrigonda, Ahmednagar, Maharashtra the Commission33 conducted a spot visit on 11.01.2020 . FIR No 708/2019 was registered u/s 376,323,504,506,334, (A) 307 IPC , 3 (1)(r)(s) of PoA Act. All the accused were arrested and chargesheet No. 15/2019 submitted in special court. Monetary relief Rs 1 lakh was provided to the victim. The allegation of demand of ‘Khandani’ by the victim was also investigated by the police and FIR was registered against the activist who demanded ‘Khandani’. Police protection was provided to the victim considering the threat. File No. NCSC/PUNE/Pune Division/RU-II Sholapur visit
Taking suo-moto cognizance of new reports regarding incident of gang rape at Sholapur city, Maharashtra, the Commission34 conducted a spot visit on 14.02.2020. Due to the intervention of the Commission, in FIR No.97/2020 of 11.02.2020, all the 11 accused were arrested and hargesheet No 25/2020 was submitted in special court on 07.04.2020. Monetary relief Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the victim along with 3 months ration.
32 by Dr Yogendra Paswan , Member , NCSC 33 Director State Office NCSC , Pune 34 Director State Office NCSC , Pune
261 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
File No. NCSC/PUNE/Aurangabad Division/ RU-II Vijapur visit
Suo-moto cognizance of news report regarding murder in the village Khandala, Taluka Vaijapur, Aurangabad, Maharashtra the Commission35 conducted a spot visit on 20.03.2020. In the case FIR No 105/2020, dated 14.03.2020 u/s IPC 302,449,307,34 with 3(2)va , 3(2) was lodged, accused arrested and chargesheet No 23/2020 was submitted in special court on 08.05.2020. Financial relief of Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the family members of the victim, along with ration for 3 months on 20.03.2020, during the visit of NCSC. 2.6.2.8 State Office : Thiruvananthapuram 2018-19
File No. KL/31/2/2019
Taking suo moto cognizance of newspaper report dated 02.02.2019 of murder case of Ananthu Mohan in Thiruvananthapuram, a spot visit was conducted on 07.03.201936. Due to intervention of Commission the case was registered, accused person was arrested and financial relief amounting to Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the family of victim. File No. KL/31/11/2019
Taking suo moto cognizance of news item dated 26.02.2019 regarding murder of Shri Vinayabose in Thiruvananthapuram, a spot visit was conducted on 07.03.201937. Due to intervention of Commission the case was registered, accused persons were arrested and financial relief amounting to Rs. 4.125 lakh paid to the family of victim. File No. KL/31/28/2019
Taking suo moto cognizance of newspaper report dated 04.03.2019 of murder case of Shri Vishnu, student of Government ITI, Attingal, Thiruvananthapuram a spot visit was conducted on 07.03.201938. Due to intervention of Commission the case was registered,
35 Director State Office NCSC , Pune 36 By Senior Investigator, NCSC, Thiruvananthapuram.
37 By Senior Investigator, NCSC, Thiruvananthapuram.
38 By Senior Investigator, NCSC, Thiruvananthapuram.
262 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
accused persons were arrested and financial relief amounting to Rs. 4.125 lakh was paid to the family of victim.
2.7 Deaths due to manual cleaning of sewer lines/septic tanks /STPs etc :
During 2018-19 the Commission’s Headquarter took suo-moto cognizance of 23 cases where there were 61 deaths of Safai Karamcharis, labourers who tragically lost their lives during manual cleaning of sewers/septic tanks etc and 4 were injured. Old cases (57 deaths) of Karnataka were also followed up. Manual cleaning of sewers/septic tanks etc is prohibited under the “Prohibition of employment as Manual Scavengers and their Rehabilitation Act, 2013” Act (MS Act). In 2018-19 , 23 cases of deaths due to manual cleaning of sewers / septic tanks /STPs etc were taken up by the Commission, after our intervention, FIRs were lodged against the persons responsible and Rs 1369.91 lakh was paid as compensation to the families of victims. This includes payment made under MS Act, payment made under PoA Act and other payments made on humanitarian grounds. Besides this, in some cases medical expenses of Rs 85.46 lakh were also paid. Families of 3 deceased were offered jobs, pensions were sanctioned in 3 cases and families of three deceased provided land. In 16 of the old cases of Karnataka payment of compensation of Rs 160 lakh was ensured
Table 2.8
Rs. in lakh
Compensation NCSC State Sr. No. NCSC Hqrs. Total under Office
1. MS Act, 2013 190.00 490.00 680
2. Insurance 40.00 109.90 149.90
3. PoA Act, 1989 37.12 99.00 136.12
263 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
4. Other payments 48.63 89.90 138.53
Mixed (where 5. bifurcation of - 179.90 179.90 compensation not given)
Medical 6. 85.46 - 85.46 reimbursement
Total 401.21 968.7 1369.91
2.7.1(a) : 2018-19
File No.13/3/Press Clipping/2018/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 3 labourers while cleaning sewage treatment plant at Hotel Taj Vivanta, New Delhi on 29.04.2018 {Shri Ravinder Kanojia, 52 years (SC); Shri Vikram Singh, 23 years; Shri Gaurav Sukheja, 40 years}. 2 labourers were also injured {Shri Nityanand Behera, 55 years and Shri Kamdev Patra, 61 years}. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No. 45/2018 u/s 304, 308 of IPC, 2(D) of MS Act,2013 and 4(1)(J) of the PoA Act. 02 persons were arrested. A hearing was held by the Commission on 29.05.2018. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation as detailed below to victim/victim’s family: To family of late Shri Ravinder Kanojia . Compensation of Rs. 19.51 lakh (@ Rs. 10.00 lakh under MS Act, @ Rs. 8.25 lakh under PoA Rules and ex-gratia Rs. 0.26 lakh by employer and Rs. 1.00 lakh by GNCTD ). . Further help by employer @ Rs. 5.00 lakh each for two daughters, education reimbursement of Rs. 1.17 lakh and 6 months training to elder daughter preparing her for future job. . Additional help of Rs. 1 lakh by GNCTD.
264 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
To family of late Shri Vikram Singh . Compensation of Rs. 18.45 lakh (@ Rs. 10.00 lakh under MS Act, @ Rs 8.25 lakh under PoA Rules, Act and ex-gratia Rs. 0.20 lakh by employer). . Rs.1.90 lakh hospital bills paid by employer. . Additional help of Rs. 1 lakh by GNCTD.
To family of late Shri Gaurav Sukheja . Compensation of Rs. 5.271 lakh (Rs. 5.00 lakh for the minor child and ex-gratia Rs. 0.271 lakh by employer). . Payment of Rs. 11 lakh hospital bills . educational reimbursement of Rs. 1 lakh per annum till 12th. . Family will also get Rs. 40.00 lakh (approx) in insurance once the court case of family is decided.
To Shri Nityanand Behera (injured) . Payment of Rs. 70 lakh for medical bills and . Regular payment of monthly salary by employer while he recovers.
To Shri Kamdev Patra (injured) . Compensation of Rs. 2.56 lakh for medical expenses . 10 months training to son by employer followed by job to son.
File No.13/4/Press Clipping/2018/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 3 labourers while cleaning a toilet tank in Behran, Agra on 29.05.2018 {Shri Hira Singh, 55 years; Shri Yashpal Singh, 35 years; Shri Hemant Kumar, 33 years}. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation as detailed below to victim’s family:
265 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
. @ Rs. 7.30 lakh to family of each victim {Rs. 5 lakh from Kisan Durghatna & Sarvahit Bima Yojna + Rs. 2 Lakh from Chief Minister’s Discretionary Fund + Rs. 30,000/- from National Family Benefit Yojna}. . Family of the victims also given land on lease by GoUP.
File No.13/7/Press Clipping/2018/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 3 labourers due to inhaling of poisonous during clearing of Sewage Pumping Station on 08.07.2018 in Loni, Ghaziabad {Shri Bulbul, 25 years; Shri Mahesh, 42 years; Shri Roshan Lal, 42 years (SC)}. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No. 1248/2018 u/s 304A of IPC; section 7/9 of MS Act and section 3(2)va of PoA Act. An on the spot inquiry was also conducted on 11.07.201839. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation as detailed below to victim’s family: . Compensation of Rs. 38.25 lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh under MS Act to family of each victim and @ Rs. 8.25 lakh under PoA Rules to family of late Shri Roshan Lal (SC)). File No.13/8/Press Clipping/2018/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 2 SC labourers inside manhole while cleaning sewer tank on 06.08.2018 in Shivamogga, Karnataka {Shri Anjanappa, 17 years; Shri Venkatesh, 35 years}. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No. 493/2018 u/s 304 of IPC; 3(1)(j) of PoA Act and section 7&8 of MS Act. 5 Persons were arrested. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation as detailed below to victim’s family:
. Compensation of Rs. 36.50 lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh under MS Act, @ Rs. 8.25 lakh under PoA Rules to family of each victim). File No.13/10/Press Clipping/2018/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 5 labourers while cleaning sewer on 09.09.2018 in Moti Nagar, New Delhi {Mohd. Sarfaraz, 19 years; Shri Vishal,
39 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice-Chairman, NCSC and officers of NCSC.
266 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
22 years (SC); Shri Umesh Kumar, 22 years; Shri Pankaj, 26 years, Shri Mritunjay Kumar Singh, 21 years}. An on the spot inquiry40 was conducted on 10.09.2018 Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No. 341/2018 under section 304A of IPC, section 7/9 of MS Act,2013 and section 3(1)j & 3(2)(v) of SCs/STs (PoA) Act, 1989. Five accused arrested. Subsequently a hearing was also held by the Commission on 18.09.2018. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation as detailed below to victim’s family: . Compensation of Rs. 75.75 lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh under MS Act, @ Rs. 3.5 lakh in lieu of insurance to family of each victim and @ Rs. 8.25 lakh under PoA Rules). . Further, family of all the victims got pension ranging from Rs. 6,100/- to Rs, 14,440/-. File No.13/11/Press Clipping/2018/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 1 labourer while cleaning sewer on 14.09.2018 in Dabri area, Delhi {Shri Anil, 27 years}. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No. 500/2018 under section 304 of IPC and section 7/9 of MS Act, 2013. Accused arrested. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation @ Rs. 10 lakh under MS Act.
File No.13/13/Press Clipping/2018/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 1 SC labourer while cleaning Delhi Jal Board sewer tank on 21.10.2018 in Jahangir Puri, Delhi {Shri Doman Rai, 37 years}. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No. 475/2018 u/s 304A of IPC, 7/9 of MS Act and 3(1)(j) of PoA Act.03 persons were arrested. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation of Rs. 20lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh under MS Act and ex-gratia Rs. 10 lakh by employer)
File No.13/01/Press Clipping/2019/ESDW
The Commission took up the suo-moto cognizance of the incident of news reports dated 21.01.2019 of death of a person {Shri Krishan Lal, 35 years} on 20.01.2019 while cleaning supplementary drain of I&FC Department at Sangam Vihar, Jharoda Chowki Near Golchakkar at Wazirabad Police Station. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of
40 By Prof (Dr) Ram Shankar Katheria , Chairman NCSC, Dr L Murugan VC , NCSC and officers of NCSC
267 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
FIR No. 14/2019 under section 304 of IPC and section 7/9 of MS Act. Commission’s intervention led to the payment of compensation @ Rs.10.00 lakh under MS Act. File No.13/2/Press Clipping/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 2 SC labourers of asphyxiation while cleaning the drainage system on 22.01.2019 at Thiru Nagar in Coimbatore {Shri Murugan, 37 years; Shri Pamdidurai, 39 years}. Suo moto notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No. 113/2019 under section 304A of IPC and section 7&9 of MS Act and 3(1) j of PoA Act. Our intervention led to the payment of compensation os Rs. 28.25 lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh under MS Act and @ Rs. 4.125 lakh under PoA Rules) .Family of the victim was also given employment in a government hostel.
File No.13/4/Press Clipping/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the media report of death of 2 labourer while cleaning sewer on 23.03.2019 in Rajouri Garden, Delhi {Shri Rakesh Kumar, 42 years; Shri Ajay Kanaujia, 19 years (SC)}. 02 labourers injured {Shri Pankaj, 26 years and Shri Raju Rai, 28 years}.An on the spot inquiry was conducted on 26.03.201941. Notice was issued leading to lodging of FIR No.116/2019 under section 304 of IPC and section 3(2)(v) of PoA Act. All the three owners of the hotel arrested. Commission’s intervention led to the payment of compensation as of Rs. 30.25 lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh under MS Act, 2013 to family of each victim, ex-gratia @ Rs. 1.00 and @ Rs. 8.25 lakh to family of late Shri Ajay Kanojia (SC) under PoA Rules
2.7.2(a) NCSC State Office State Office, Bangaluru
File No: 29/3/19-RU The report that 57 manual scavengers died in the Karnataka since 1993 and no compensation was paid was taken up for investigation. A meeting was held regarding the subject with Police and Officers of BWSSB. The BWSSB submitted report about death of six persons. In these six cases they have paid Rs. 10 lakh to each to the families victims as
41 By Joint Secretary, DS and Director of NCSC.
268 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
per Hon’ble Supreme Court order. Of 16 deaths reported since 2012 , compensation of Rs 160 lakh (@Rs 10 lakh each) has been paid. From the investigation of this office it has been clear that MS Act is not used and fate of these cases registered are not monitored by any agency.
State Office, Chandigarh
File No. 24/30/2019-Res: The Commission took suo-moto cognizance of press news dated 19.03.2019 of death of 2 persons Shri Vijay Partap s / o Shri Kulwant Singh r / o Dob Garh Colony, Rayya and Shri Suresh Kumar s / o Shri Kali Charan r / o Bhalaipur while cleaning a sewer line. Notice was issued leading to FIR under relevant sections of IPC, PoA Act and MS Act being lodged. After follow up and hearings, monetary relief of Rs. 37.30 lakh was sanctioned to the families of the victims. (@Rs 10 lakh each under MS Act, @ Rs 8.25 lakh each under PoA Rules and additional relief 0.40 lakh each). File No. 24/72/2018-Res: The Commission took suo-moto cognizance of press news dated 03.06.2018 of death of 2 SC persons (Shri Ravi Kumar s / o Shri Ram Prasad r / o Police Line, Ferozpur and Shri Krishan Kumar s / o Shri Shala Ram r / o Kariwala, SMS Nagar) who died while cleaning sewer lines. Policeman Shri Balbir Chand who tried to save them was also killed in line of duty.
Notice was issued leading to FIR under relevant sections of IPC, PoA Act and MS Act being lodged. After follow up and hearings, monetary relief of Rs. 47.50 lakh was sanctioned to the families of the 3 victims. (@Rs 10 lakh each under the provisions of MS Act, @ 7.75 lakh each for 2 labourers and @ Rs 2.5 lakh for the policeman). File No. 25/70/2018-Res: The Commission took suo-moto cognizance of press news dated 13.06.2018 of death of 2 persons (Shri Rajesh Kumar S / o Om Prakash R / o Nehru Colony, Bhiwani and Shri. Mukesh Kumar S / o Suresh R / o Maholla Jain Chowk),who died while cleaning sewers in Bhiwani. Notice was issued leading to FIR under relevant sections of IPC, PoA Act and MS Act being lodged. After follow up and hearings, monetary relief of Rs.36.50 lakh was
269 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
sanctioned to sanctioned to the families of the victims. (@Rs 10 lakh each under the provisions of MS Act, @ 8.25 lakh each under PoA Rules). In addition the department employees also took up a collection and handed over Rs 5 lakh (@ Rs 2.50 lakh each) to the families of the victims.
State Office Chennai
File No. 3/1/Thiruvallur/2019 Res.
The Commission took suo-moto cognizance of press news dated 06.01.2019 regarding death of two persons (Shri.Vivekanandan, driver of the cleaning vehicle and Shri.Veera, cleaning worker) in septic tank of a factory at SIPCOT, Thirumazihisai, Thiruvallur and issued notice dated 07.01.2019, due to which, Rs 28.25 lakh (@Rs.4.125 lakh each under the PoA rules and @ Rs.10.00 lakh each as per the MS Act ) was sanctioned to the families of the victims
File No. 3/2/Coimbatore 2019 Res & File No.13/2/Press Clipping/2019/ESDW
The Commission took suo-moto cognizance of press news dated 23.01.2019 regarding death of two SCs Shri. Murugan, S/o Shri Nagendiran and Shri. Pandidurai, S/o Shri Arumugam while cleaning a septic tank in Coimbatore and conducted a spot visit on 23.01.201942. Due to intervention of Commission:
FIR under PoA Act was registered Rs.28.25. lakh (@ Rs.10.00 lakh each under MS Act and @ Rs.4.125 lakh each under the PoA Rules ) was paid to the families of the victims. Wives of both victims were given jobs in government hostels.
State Office, Hyderabad
F. No. 3/18/18/AP-RU
42 By Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC , officers of NCSC, Chennai.
270 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The Commission took the suo-moto cognizance of the news reports of the incidence of news reports of death, due to manual cleaning of sewer of Gunja Gangaraju (37), Vambay Colony ,Vijaywada, Krishna, Andhra Pradesh on 20.03.2018. Notice was issued and case followed up. As a result, A FIR No. 146/18 was registered u/s. 304A IPC, Section 9 of MS Act and 174 Cr.P.C. and compensation of Rs 12 lakh has been paid to family of the victim. One flat at Vambay Colony and contract job as sanitation worker was given to widow of the deceased by Vijayawada Municipal Authorities vide their report dated 04.04.2019 F. No. 3/17/18/AP-RU
The Commission took the suo-moto cognizance of the news reports of death during manual cleaning of sewers of 7 persons viz, M Ramesh,SC (32 yrs), G Govinda Swamy,SC (35 yrs), B Ramachandraiah,SC (23 yrs), A Reddappa,SC (30yrs), R Babu,ST (30 yrs), Kesava (20 yrs) and B Venkata Rajulu (23 yrs) at Chittur, Andhra Pradesh on 17.02.2018.
A spot visit was conducted43 on 22.02.2018. During the spot visit, necessary instructions were given to the Government in the matter. As a result of the follow up by the Commission :
FIR has been registered in this case. Monetary compensation of Rs. 221.15 lakh was paid (@ Rs 10 lakh each as per MS Act,@Rs 15.70 lakh each as insurance and miscellaneous exgratia payments was paid to the families of all the victims, in addition @Rs 8.25 lakh each was paid as per PoA Rules to the families of SC & ST victims) Additional relief as per the PoA Rules ie.pension @Rs 5000/- pm plus DA to the widows of 3 married SC & one ST victi. Houses to the families of the 5 SC & ST victims have also been sanctioned.
F. No. 3/17/18/CG-RU
The Commission took the suo-moto cognizance of the news reports of the incidence of death of Somnath Sahu, Anjora, Durg, Chhattisgarh on 04.06.2018 while cleaning
43 by Dr L Murugan, Vice Chairman NCSC , Shri K Ramulu , Member NCSC and officers of NCSC , Hyderabad
271 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
sewer. After a hearing on 20.08.18, compensation of Rs. 14 lakh was provided to the wife of deceased as well as MNREGA card and ration card.
F. No. 3/55/18/TS-RU
Commission took suo-moto cognizance of death of two workers (Illapu Santosh 25 years and Vijay 25 years) in drainage at Uppal stadium, Hyderabad, Telangana on 30.05.2018. Notice was issued and case followed up.
Due to internvention of the Commission :
FIR no. 511/18 u/s. 304 II IPC,3(2)(v) of PoA Act and MS Act was registered. Three accused who engaged them were arrested. Families of deceased were sanctioned monetary relief of Rs. 20 lakh (Rs. 10 lakh each).
State Office, Kolkata
File No. 2/57/18-Gen/OR (Raygada)
The Commission took suo-motu cognizance of news report regarding accidental death of 5 persons namely, Shri Purna Takri, Smt Rasmita Ulaka (ST), Bairagi Kalka, Surya Narayan Patra (SC) , Banshidhar Patra (SC) & Kartik Goud (ST) while cleaning of a septic tank in Rayagada, Odisha. Notice was issued and case followed up.
Due to internvention of the Commission :
FIR no.15 – 19, dated 02.09.2018. u/s 174 Cr.P.C was registered. The Red Cross Society, Odisha, have paid Rs.10,000/- as compensation to the family members of each victim Rs 10 lakh (@ Rs.2 lakh each ) was paid to the family members of each victim from CM’s Relief Fund. File No. 2/31/18-Gen/WB (North 24 Paraganas.)
The Commission took cognizance of a news report regarding death of 6 persons namely, Shri Amit Kumar Yadav, Shri Bijoy Kr. Benbansi (ST), Md. Nazim, Mithun, Shri Uday
272 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Raj Singh, Ashok Boral (SC) all labour workers of IPP Paper Mill, Hazinagar Naihati, North 24 Pargans while entering in to a tank filled with waste materials . They died inside the tank due to asphyxia as per PM report. Notice was issued and case followed up.
Due to internvention of the Commission :
FIR no 223/18 dated 30.08.2018 was registered u/s 304 IPC, charge sheet no 808/18 submitted on 07.12.2018. Compensation of Rs 72 lakh (@ Rs. 2 lakh each paid by the SDO, Barrackpore and @ Rs.10 lakh each by the owner of the Paper Mill ) has been paid to the family members of each victim .
State Office, Lucknow
File No. 14/1/2019-R.U.
The Commission took cognizance of a news report regarding death of 2 persons ( S/Shri Chandan and Rajesh Paswan,) labour workers of Jal Nigam Ganga Pollution Control unit Varanasi, who were killed on 03.03.2019 inside septic tank due to asphyxia. Notice was issued and case followed up. Due to internvention of the Commission :
FIR No. 279/2019 under section 304A I.P.C. was registered in PS Cantt against the employer. Compensation of Rs. 20 lakh ( @ Rs 10 lakh each ) was paid to each family members of the victims.
State Office, Pune
File No. NCSC/ konkan division/2017-RU-II
The commission took the suo-moto cognizance of the news reports of the incidence of the death of 3 persons at a sewerage plant in Panvel Navi Mumbai (Vilas Hribhau Mhaskar 60 yrs, Santosh Ananta Waghmare 40 yrs and Praful Sabar 30 years). The matter was taken up on 11.01.2019 with CP Navi Mumbai .
Due to the internvention of the Commission :
FIR was registered u/s 3 (1)j of and MS Act.
273 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
All the accused were arrested. Monetary compensation of Rs 28.25 lakh ( @Rs 10 lakh each as per Hon’ble Supreme Court guidelines and @ Rs 4.125 lakh each) has been paid to families of the first two victims.
2.7.1(b) :2019-20
During the year the Commission’s Headquarter took suo-moto cognizance of 22 cases where 52 Safai Karamcharis, labourers tragically lost their lives during manual cleaning of sewers/septic tanks etc and 9 were injured.
In these 22 cases taken up by the Commission, after our intervention, FIRs were lodged against the persons responsible and Rs 538.92 lakh was paid as compensation to the families of victims. This includes payment made under MS Act, payment made under PoA Act and other payments made on humanitarian grounds. Families of 2 deceased were offered jobs and 2 were sanctioned houses.
File No. 13/06/Press Clipping/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death 02 persons viz. Deepak @ Limbo and Ganesh and 03 workers critically injured viz. Sher Singh, Rajesh @ Babloo and Rambir while cleaning the septic tank in a private house in Rohini, Delhi on 07.05.2019. Spot enquiry was conducted by the Commission44 on 09.05.2019. FIR No. 249/10 was registered u/s 304/34 IPC, 3(1)(j) PoA Act and 5/8 of MS Act at P.S. Prem Nagar, Delhi. House owner Shri Gulam Mustafa was arrested by the police. Compensation of Rs 20 lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh x 2 victims ) was paid to the family of both the deceased.
File No. 13/09/Press Clipping/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 2 persons viz. Bebal Khan and Mobin Khan after getting trapped in tank at flour mill at Lawrence Road Industrial Area in Keshavpuram, Delhi on 21.05.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and
44 by Director ESDW , Research Officer and A.S.O ESDW ,NCSC Headquarters.
274 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Commissioner of Police, Delhi, District Magistrate and Deputy Commissioner of Police, North West District, Delhi. FIR No. 170/19 was registered u/s 287/304A IPC. Two accused (owner and Supervisor of the flour mill) were arrested.
File No. 13/11/Press Clipping/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 2 persons viz. Ajaypal (SC) and Gautam Sahni (OBC) due to suffocation after entering borewell without safety measures in Noida, UP on 30.05.2019. Spot enquiry was conducted by the Commission45 on 04.06.2019. Notice was issued to CEO, NOIDA; DM and SSP, Gautam Buddh Nagar. FIR No. 474/19 was registered u/s 304 of IPC against the supervisor of M/S P.S. Construction. Both supervisors were arrested on 01.06.2019. FIR was also registered against Sanvidakar M/s Indus Towers Ltd., Lucknow at P.S. Sector-39, Gautam Buddh Nagar. A hearing in the case also held in the Commission on 10.06.2019. recommended that an FIR may also be registered against the senior officers of the principal employer by invoking relevant section of PoA Act and release compensation to the family of the victims as per Rules.
File No. 13/12/Press Clipping/Guj./2019/ESDW
NCSC State Office, Gujarat took suo-moto cognizance of reports of death of 07 persons viz. 03 SCs(Ashokbhai Becharbhai Harijan, Hiteshbhai Ashokbhai Harijan, Maheshbhai Harilal Harijan), 03 STs (VA Chaudhari, SR Vasava, AR Vasava) & 01 OBCs (M.R. Patanvadiya) while cleaning sewer at Darshan Hotel in Fartikui, Dabhoi, Vadodara on 15.06.2019. Spot enquiry was conducted by Commission46 on 19.06.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and DGP, Gujarat, DM and Commissioner of Police, Vadodara and Commissioner, Vadodara Municipal Corporation. FIR No. 1-73/19 was registered u/s 304 of IPC , 3(1)(j) and 3(2)(va) of PoA Act and 5(1)(B),8 of MS Act. Owner of the hotel was arrested. Details of compensation paid:- . Governemnt of Gujarat gave financial assistance Rs 28 lakh (@ Rs. 4 lakh x 7 victims ) to families of each victim.
45 by Director (ESDW) and Research Officer (ESDW) NCSC Headquarters.
46 Shri K. Ramulu, Member, NCSC and Director, NCSC State Office, Gujarat
275 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
. Compensation Rs 49.50 lakh (@ Rs.8.25 lakh x 6 SC & ST victims ) under PoA Rules to families of 3 SC & 3 ST victims. . Financial assistance Rs 14 lakh (@ Rs. 2 lakh x 7 victims ) to family of each of the 7 victims was given by Gujarat Safai Kamdar Development Corporation. . Financial Assistance Rs 0.15 lakh (@ Rs. 5,000/- to family of each SC victim) under Scheme of Antyeshti Sahay Yojana.
File No. 13/16/Press Clipping/UP/2019-ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 02 persons viz. Robin and Kallu alias Akbar while cleaning sewer line in Kanpur, UP on 19.06.2019. Notice issued to DM & SSP Kanpur. FIR No. 188/2019 was registered u/s 304 A of IPC. Contractor M/s Satishchandra Sachan provided compensation Rs 12 lakh (@Rs. 6 lakh x 2 victims ) to families of both victims.
File No. 13/19/Press Clipping/Delhi/2019-ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 03 persons viz. Shahrukh Devender and Ankit while cleaning sewers of Delhi Jal Board (DJB) in Khyala, Delhi on 26.06.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and Commissioner of Police, Delhi; CEO, Delhi Jal Board; DM & DCP West Delhi District. FIR No. 206/2019 was registered u/s 304A. DJB was executing the work through contractor M/s Engineers India Ltd. (EIL). EIL paid a token amount Rs 3 lakh (@ Rs. 1 lakh x 3 victims ) to family of each of the 03 victims. EIL also deposited 03 DDs of Rs. 8.68 lakh, Rs. 8.80 lakh and Rs. 8.91 lakh with Employees Compensation Commissioner. M/s EIL has also committed that remainder of Rs. 10 lakh each will be paid directly to families of the deceased. GNCTD has sanctioned compensation Rs 30 lakh (@ Rs. 10 lakh x 3 victims ) to families of each victim.
File No. 27/02/ Hapur/U.P/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 03 persons viz. Tarashankar Dubey, Jitu and Ravi (SC) and 02 workers injured viz. Ravi Dubey and Yusuf while cleaning tank of a Jeans factory in Hapur, UP on 19.07.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and Director General of Police UP , DM & SSP Hapur. FIR No. 338/19 was registered u/s 304
276 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
IPC and Section 3(2)(5) of PoA Act. Compensation Rs 15 lakh (@ Rs.5 lakh each x 3 victims ) was provided to family of each deceased from CMs Relief Fund. Compensation of Rs 16.50 lakh (@ Rs.8.25 lakh each x 2 SC victims ) was provided to family of late Ravi and late Jitu Yadav. Late Tarashankar Dubey was beneficiary of Employees State Insurance Corporation and his family was also sanctioned compensation of Rs.2 lakh by the employer on humanitarian grounds. File No. 27/03/U.P.(Ghaziabad)/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 05 persons viz. Damodar, Horil, Sanjeev, Shiv Kumar and supervisor Vijay Kumar while cleaning sewer at Nandigarm, Ghaziabad, UP on 22.08.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and DGP /UP , DM & SSP Ghaziabad. FIR No. 1300/2019 was registered u/s 304 of IPC, 3(2)5 of PoA Act and Section 3/7 of MS Act added. Accused was arrested on 24.08.2019. Compensation Rs 50 lakh (@ Rs.10 lakh each x 5 victims ) was paid to family of each victim. File No. 27/04/ Rajasthan/Udaipur/2019/ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 04 persons viz. Dharmchand Meena, Kansingh Panwar, Prahlad and Kailash while cleaning sewerage pipe in Udaipur, Rajasthan on 28.08.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and DGP Rajasthan; DM & SP Udaipur. FIR No. 347/2019 registered u/s 304A of IPC, 2(d), 7, 23 of the MS Act was added after Commissions recommendation. Accused arrested.
File No. 27/12/Rewari/Haryana/2019-ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 02 persons viz. Ramjas and Devender (SC) while cleaning a septic tank at Rewari, Haryana on 14.10.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and DGP/ Haryana; DC & SSP Rewari. FIR No.707 was registered u/s 304 of IPC ,9of the MS Act and 3(1)j of PoA Act . Accused Shri Manish was arrested.
File No. 27/15/Thanjavur/TN/2019-ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the reports of death of 01 person viz. Sadhik Batsha while cleaning Manhole in Kumbakonam, Thanjavur, TN on 14.11.2019. Notice was issued to Chief Secretary and DGP / TN, DM & SP Thanjavur. FIR No. 307/2019 was
277 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
registered u/s 304(A) IPC and Section 9 of the MS Act. Contracted Company M/s Infra En India (P) Ltd. provided compensation of Rs.10 lakh to family of the victim.
File No.27/17/Shakurpur/Delhi/2019-ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the reports of death of 01 person (Ashok) and 03 persons injured (Gore lal, Rohit and Sai) due to inhaling of poisonous gas while cleaning a sewer in Shakurpur , Delhi on 23.11.2019. Notice issued to Chief Secretary, Commissioner of Police, Principal Secretary (UD), Principal Secretary (PWD), Delhi; CEO Delhi Jal Board; Commissioner, North Delhi Municipal Corporation; concerned DM & DCP. FIR No. 421/2019 was registered u/s 304 of IPC & 7/9 of MS Act. Accused arrested.
File No. 27/20/Maharashtra/Mumbai/2019-ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 03 persons viz. Bishwajit Khagendra Debanath (OBC), Santosh Prabhakar Kalsekar (SC) and Shri Govind Sangram Chorotia while cleaning drainage tank in Govandi, Mumbai, Maharashtra on 23.12.2019. Notice issued to Chief Secretary and DGP/ Maharashtra; Commissioner of Police, Mumbai; District Collector, District Mumbai (Suburban). FIR No. 261/19 was registered u/s 304(a) of IPC and Section 7, 9 of the MS Act. And 1 accused was arrested.
File No. 27/21/Mah(Kurla)/2019-ESDW
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 02 persons viz. Dnyaneshwar Jadhav (ST) and Namdev Pawar (ST) while cleaning septic tank in Kurla West, Mumbai, Maharashtra on 16.12.2019. Notice issued to Chief Secretary and DGP/ Maharashtra; Commissioner of Police, Mumbai; District Collector, District Mumbai (Suburban). FIR No. 319/19 was registered u/s 304(2), 34 of IPC and Sec 7, 9 of MS Act. Accused arrested. Compensation Rs 30 lakh (@ Rs. 15 lakh x 2 victims ) was provided to family of each victim.
2.7.2(b) NCSC State Office
278 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
State office, Bangaluru Suo moto cognizance was taken of the reports of death of Shri Lalappa Somanna Madara on 02.04.2019 while cleaning the sewer tank at Amar International Hotel, INDI, Vijaypura, notice was issued and case pursued. Compensation Rs 10 lakh under MS Act was paid to wife of victim and she was appointed as a cook through out sourcing in Government Prematric Boys Hostel, Indi Taluk, Vijayapur under Social Welfare Department Vijayapura.Action to provide her with a residential site is in progress. Suo moto cognizance was taken of the reports of death of Shri Muniyappa 25.01.2020 while cleaning sewers at Jain Sanga Trust, Bangalore Urban, notice was issued and case pursued. Compensation Rs 4.125 lakh under PoA Rules was paid to wife of victim.
State Office, Chandigarh
File No. 25/46/2019-Res :-
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 3 persons viz, Pandu , Vinay and Deepak while cleaning a sewer at a private banquet hall in Sidharth Enclave on the Sonepat-Bahalgarh road, Sonipat, Haryana 01.05.2019, notice was issued and the case was followed up. FIR no. 185, dated 01.05.2019 under 3(1)j of PoA Act & MS Act was lodged .Monetary relief of Rs 54.75 lakh (@Rs 10 lakh as per MS Act & Rs 8.25 lakh as per PoA Rules x 3 victims ) was paid to the families of the 3 victims. File No. 25/77/2019-Res :-
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of 3 persons viz, Dharmendra s/o Dharampal, Sanjay s/o. Daya Ram from UP, and Ranjeet s/o Sh. Jagdish ,Rohtak , Haryana while cleaning sewer lines on 26.06.2019, notice was issued and the case was followed up. FIR no. 397 was lodged on 26.06.2019 under 3(1)j of PoA Act & MS Act. Monetary relief of Rs 54.75 lakh (@Rs 10 lakh as per MS Act & Rs 8.25 lakh as per PoA Rules x 3 victims ) was paid to the families of the 3 victims. File No. 25/114/2019-Res :-
Suo moto cognizance was taken of reports of death of Balraj s/o Bikhari , Gurugram , Haryana while cleaning a sewer line on 28.08.2019 notice was issued and the case was
279 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
followed up. FIR no 298 was lodged on 28.08.2019, u/s 3(1)j of PoA Act & MS Act and monetary relief of Rs 18.25 lakh (@Rs 10 lakh as per MS Act & Rs 8.25 lakh as per PoA Rules ) was paid to the family of the victim.
State Office Chennai File No: 3/42/Chennai 2019 Res.
An SC youth (26 years) was asphyxiated while cleaning sewage channel at a City Mall in Chennai as reported in the press news dated 13.11.2019. The NCSC State Office, Chennai took up case ‘suo moto’ on 15.11.2019 and a notice was issued to the District Collector, Chennai, the Commissioner, Chennai Corporation and the Commissioner of Police, Chennai City. A reply received from the concerned Officials stating that a case was registered under Cr.No: 515/2019 u/s 9 of the MS Act and 304 (i) of IPC read with section 3(2)(v) of the PoA Act. The contractor was arrested. Rs 14.125 lakh monetary relief ( @ Rs.10.00 under the MS Act and Rs.4.125 lakh as per the PoA Act) .
State Office, Hyderabad
F. No. 3/30/19/MP-RU:
Taking suo moto cognisance of reports of 02.04.2019 of the death of 2 labourers while manually cleaning a sewer at Sangam Nagar Zone, Indore, MP, notice was issued and the case was pursued. Reply was received from Indore Municipal Corporation that one labour (Safikul Islam) died during while cleaning sewer lines and Indore Municipality paid Rs.10 lakhs on 13.06.2019 to the family of the victim.
State Office, Pune
File No. NCSC/PUNE/Kokan Division/ 2019- RU- II Kurla
280 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Suo-moto cognizance was taken of the news reports of 27.12.2019 reagarding death of 2 hired labourers viz, Dynanreshwar Jadhav, Namdev Pawar and one labourer was also injured (Hari Chavan) while cleaning the sludge tank of Sweet Bengal company, khetani compound, Mumbai. Notice was issued to DC and CP Mumbai on 27.12.2019. FIR No 313/2019 was registered u/s 304 (B) IPC, 7, 9 of MS Act, 2 accused was arrested. Financial assistance of Rs 20 lakh (@Rs 10 lakh x 2 victims) was paid to the families.
2.8 Hostel Visits
2.8.1 State Office Agartala
The NCSC Team47 visited the Babu Jagjibanram Chhatriniwas at Aralia, West Tripura on 20.09.2018. During the visit the officers from NCSC interacted with the Headmaster of the School, Hostel in-charge and few students of the hostel. After visiting the hostel, the team met Secretary, SC Welfare, Government of Tripura and informed him of the problems and requirements of the hostel. The Additional Secretary to GoT, SC Welfare Department in his letter dated 05.04.2019 informed that they have taken necessary action on the matter.
2.8.2 State Office Chennai
NCSC Team48 conducted visits to 3 SC Welfare Hostels in Chennai District and 1 SC Welfare Hostel in Coimbatore during the year 2018-19.No major recommendations were made as situation was found satisfactory.
2.8.3 State Office Kolkata
NCSC team49 from State Office, Kolkata, visited the Akanksha, Urban Hostel Complex for Post- matric ST/SC students at Nuagan, Kalinganagar, Nuagan, Odisha on 04.03.2019. During the visit the officers from NCSC interacted with the hostel in-charge superintendent and few students
47 Director, NCSC, Agartala, officers from the Scheduled Castes Welfare Department, Government of Tripura
48 Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC , officers of NCSC, Chennai.
49 Officers of NCSC, Kolkata.
281 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20 of the hostel. The overall conditions of the hostel were found satisfactory. There were few issues like dirty bathrooms etc. which have been pointed out for rectification.
2.8.4 State Office Thiruvananthapuram
The NCSC team50 visited the following hostels :
i. Post matric girls hostel for SC, Poochedivila, Thiruvananthapuram on 17.10.2018 ii. Post matric girls and boys hostel for SC, Kozhikde on 16.12.2018 iii. Government SC Medical College Hostel, Palakkad on 12.2.2019
During the visit NCSC team monitored the infrastructure facilities extended to students and recommended that CCTV cameras be installed for ensuring the safety of students.
2.9 Jail Visit
State office: Chennai
NCSC team51 visited Central Prison, Puzhal, Chennai on 06.04.2018 to examine the facilities extended to the inmates of prison including SC prisoners. The team also visited the cell where Shri Ramkumar (SC) accused in murder case of Ms. Swathi, allegedly committed suicide.
2.10 Proposals seeking view of Commission on Policy Matters
According to the clause 9 of the Article 338 of the Constitution, “The Union and every State Government shall consult the Commission on all major policy matters effecting Scheduled Castes.”
50 Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC , Senior Investigator, NCSC, Thiruvananthapuram.
51 Dr. L. Murugan, Vice Chairman, NCSC ,officers of NCSC, Chennai.
282 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Three Ministries52 had consulted the Commission on 10 policy matters during 2018-19 as per brief details below :
2.10.1 Amendments in Section 3 of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, regarding committing of any offence specified under relevant sections of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012.
The proposal received from MSJE was deliberated in detail and approval of the Commission was conveyed vide letter no.3/2/2007-APCR (Pt. File) dated 06.07.2018.
2.10.2 Exclusion of creamy layer from amongst SCs and STs from the purview of benefits of reservation .
The Commission in its meeting resolved that concept of creamy layer should not be applicable for Scheduled Castes. The same was informed to DoPT vide letter no.2/Policy Matter-1/2018/SSW-II dated 27.04.2018..
2.10.3 Draft note of Cabinet to amend the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012.
The proposal received from MWCD53 of was deliberated in detail and approval conveyed vide letter no.3/1/2018-APCR dated 17.07.2018.
2.10.4 Promulgation of the Ordinance to enforce validation of all provisions the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 and subsequent inclusion of Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 in the Ninth Schedule of Constitution of India.
52 Ministry of Social Justice & Empowerment (8 matters), Ministry of Human Resource Development and Ministry of Women & Child Development (1 matter each)
53 MWCD : Ministry of Women and Child Development
283 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
The proposal received from MSJE was deliberated in detail and approval of NCSC was conveyed vide letter no.3/2/2007-APCR (Pt. File) dated 24.04.2018.
2.10.5 Inclusion of Namasudra, Pond, Poundra etc. (Bengali displaced persons) community in the list of SCs of Uttar Pradesh.
The proposal received from MSJE was deliberated in detail and approval of NCSC was conveyed vide letter no 35/I&E -1/2019 SSW-I dated 14.02.2019.
2.10.6. Draft Note for Cabinet regarding “Constitution of Development and Welfare Board for Denotified, Nomadic and Semi-nomadic Communities (DWBDNCs)
The proposal received from MSJE was deliberated in detail and approval of NCSC was conveyed vide letter no.40/Policy Matter-1/2019/SSW.I dated 21.02.2019.
2.10.7. Centrally Sponsored Scheme of Rashtriya Gram Swaraj Abhiyan (RGSA) from 01.04.2018 to 31.03.2022.
The proposal received from MSJE Was been deliberated in detail and approval of NCSC was conveyed vide letter no. 4/01/RGSA/2018/ESDW dated 23.04.2018.
2.10.8. Draft note for the Cabinet for creation of one post of Member in National Commission for Karamcharies (NCSK) as Vice-Chairperson.
The proposal received from MSJE was deliberated in detail and approval of NCSC was conveyed vide letter no.4/3/NCSK/2018/ESDW dated 28.06.2018.
2.10.9 Draft note for the Cabinet for extension in tenure of the National Commission for Safai Karamchries-beyond 31.03.2019 for the three years.
The proposal received from MSJE was deliberated in detail and approval of NCSC was conveyed vide letter no.4/3/Cabinet/NCSK/2019-ESDW dated 15.02.2019.
284 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
2.10.10 Proposal for introduction of the unaided private educational institutions (Reservation in Admission) Bill, 2019.
The proposal received from MHRD was deliberated in detail and approval of NCSC was conveyed vide letter no.4/5/Unaided Private Education Bill/2019-ESDW dated 15.02.2019.
2.11 De-reservation proposals
During years 2018-19 the NCSC received 22 de-reservation proposals for advice.. The action taken and advice of the Commission are detailed in the table below: Table 2.9 Sl.No. File No. Proposals for De- Commission’s Views reservation
1. 39/Dereservation- A proposal of De- The Commission vide its letter 1/2019/SSW-I reservation received from dated 18.02.2019 did not agree National Archives of India with the proposal and advised Ministry of Culture for De- Ministry to fill up the reserved reservation 01 Roster post by another mode available in Point in the post of the Recruitment Rules (RRs) till Archivist the SC candidate become eligible.
2. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 2/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation of 01 dated 15.04.2019 did not agree Roster Point for the post of with the proposal and advised to Assistant Audit Officer in fill up the reserved post by the O/o the Principal Director available mode in the
285 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
of Audit Central Railway Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Hazipur. SC candidate become eligible.
3. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 3/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation of 05 dated 11.04.2019 did not agree Roster Points for the Post with the proposal and advised to of Assistant Audit Officer fill up the reserved post by the in O/o Principal available mode in the Accountant General Audit, Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Patna, Bihar. SC candidate become eligible.
4. 39/Dereservation- A proposal received from The Commission vide its letter 4/2019/SSW-I Ministry of Electronics & dated 16.04.2019 did not agree Information Technology with proposal of and advised that for De-reservation of 01 the post may be filed after 09 post of Deputy Director. months when SC candidate become eligible for promotion.
5. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 5/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation of 02 dated 07.03.2019 did not agree Roster Points of SC for the with the proposal and advised to post of Audit Officer fill up the reserved post by the (Civil) in the O/o the available mode in the Principal Accountant Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the General Andhra Pradesh, SC candidate become eligible.. Hyderabad
6. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 6/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 01 dated 11.04.2019 did not agree Roster Point of the post of with the proposal and advised to Senior Accounts Officer fill up the reserved post by the in Accountant General available mode in the (AE), Assam Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the SC candidate become eligible.
286 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
7. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 7/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 01 dated 11.04.2019 did not agree Roster Point of the post of with the proposal and advised to Audit Officer in the O/o fill up the reserved post by the the Accountant General (G available mode in the and SSA) Tamilnadu, Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Chennai. SC candidate become eligible.
8. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 8/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 01 dated 11.04.2019 did not agree Roster Point for the post of with the proposal and advised to Senior Accounts Officer in fill up the reserved post by the O/o Principal Accountant available mode in the General (A&E) Haryana Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Chandigarh SC candidate become eligible..
9. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 9/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 06 dated 15.04.2019 did not agree Roster Points in the post with the proposal and advised to Assistant Audit Officer in fill up the reserved post by the the O/o the Accountant available mode in the General (G and SSA) Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Kerala SC candidate become eligible. Thiruvananthapuram.
10. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 10/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 04 dated 15.04.2019 did not agree Roster Points in the post of with the proposal and advised to Audit Officer in the O/o fill up the reserved post by the the Principal Accountant available mode in the General (Audit)-I, Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Maharashtra Mumbai SC candidate become eligible..
287 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
11. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 11/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 04 dated 15.04.2019 did not agree Roster Points in the post with the proposal and advised to of Audit Officer in the O/o fill up the reserved post by the the Principal Accountant available mode in the General (Economic) & Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Revenue Sector Audit, SC candidate become eligible. Gujarat, Ahmadabad
12. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 12/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 03 dated 09.04.2019 did not agree Roster Points of Sc for the with the proposal and advised to Post of Divisional fill up the reserved post by the Accounts Officer in the available mode in the O/o the AG (A &E) Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Uttarakhand Dheradhun. SC candidate become eligible..
13. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 13/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 01 dated 09.04.2019 did not agree Roster Point in the post of with the proposal and advised to Senior Audit Officer in fill up the reserved post by the the O/o the Principal available mode in the Director of Audit Southern Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Railway Chennai SC candidate become eligible.
14 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 14/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 05 dated 09.04.2019 did not agree Roster Points of SC in the with the proposal and advised to post of Senior Audit fill up the reserved post by the Officer in the O/o the available mode in the Principal Accountant Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the General (Audit)-I SC candidate become eligible.. Maharashtra, Mumbai
288 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
15. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 15/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for 01 dated 24.04.2019 did not agree Roster Point of Sc in the with the proposal and advised to post of Senior Accounts fill up the reserved post by the Officer in the O/o the available mode in the Senior Deputy Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Accountant General SC candidate become eligible.. (A&E) Sikkim (Gangtok)
16. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 16/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for dated 15.04.2019 did not agree 01 Roster Point of SC in with the proposal and advised to the post of Accounts fill up the reserved post by the Officer in the O/o available mode in the Accountant General Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the (A&E) Maharashtra SC candidate become eligible.. Mumbai
17. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 17/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for dated 15.04.2019 did not agree 01 Roster Point of Sc in the with the proposal and advised to post of Accounts Officer in fill up the reserved post by the the O/o the Principal available mode in the Accountant General Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the (A&E) Gujarat, Rajkot SC candidate become eligible..
18. 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 18/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for dated 15.04.2019 did not agree 01 Roster Point of Sc in the with the proposal and advised to post of Senior Audit fill up the reserved post by the Officer in the Principal available mode in the Accountant General Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the SC candidate become eligible..
289 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
(Audit) Uttrakhand Dehradun
19 39/Dereservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 19/2019/SSW-I for De-reservation for dated 15.04.2019 not agreed 03 roster Points for the with the proposal and requested post of Senior Audit to fill up the reserved post by Officer in the o/o the A.G. another mode available in the (G & SSA) Kerala, Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Thiruvanthapuram. SC candidate become eligible instead of De-reservation of reserved vacancy.
20 39/De-reservation- A proposal from Ministry The Commission vide its letter 22/2019/SSW-I of Electronics and dated 19.12.2019 agreed to a Information Technology temporary de-reservation of the For De-reservation of 01 post and condition that the next roster point for post of vacancy arising on 01.04.2020 Principal Private will be kept for the next eligible Secretary. SC candidate.
21 39/De-reservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 1/2020/SSW-I for De-reservation of 06 dated 14.02.2020 did not agree roster points for the posts with the proposal and advised to of Assistant Audit Officers fill up the reserved posts by the in the O/o the Accountant available mode in the General (G&SSA) Kerela, Recruitment Rules (RRs) till the Thiruvananthapuram. SC candidates become eligible.
22 40/De-reservation- A proposal from C.A.G. The Commission vide its letter 2/2020/SSW-I for De- reservation of 01 dated 20.02.2020 advised the roster point for the post of
290 Work done and success stories 2018-19 and 2019-20
Assistant Accounts Officer department to await the final in the O/o the Accountant advice of NCSC
General (A&E) Guwahati, Assam.
291