Anti-Capitalist Subcultures Online: from the Deliberative Public Sphere to Irony Politics

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Anti-Capitalist Subcultures Online: from the Deliberative Public Sphere to Irony Politics Anti-Capitalist Subcultures Online: From the Deliberative Public Sphere to Irony Politics Lucie Chateau 12288136 Completed on Thursday, 27 June 2019 MA New Media and Digital Culture University of Amsterdam Supervised by Dr. Davide Beraldo 1 Contents 1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 5 2. Online Politics ................................................................................................................................. 7 2.1. The Networked Public Sphere................................................................................................. 8 2.1.1. Filter bubble and Ideological Segregation ...................................................................... 9 2.1.2. Reactionary Politics, the Meme War and the Overton Window .................................. 10 2.2. Platform Ecologies ................................................................................................................ 11 2.2.1. Platform Affordances and Subcultures ......................................................................... 12 2.2.2. Reddit, Forums and Deliberation .................................................................................. 13 2.2.3. Instagram’s Radicalisation ............................................................................................ 16 2.2.4. Tumblr’s Subaltern Counterpublics .............................................................................. 18 2.3. Concluding Remarks .............................................................................................................. 21 3. Methodology ................................................................................................................................. 21 3.1. Digital Methods and Ethnography ........................................................................................ 22 3.2. Models of Online Communication ........................................................................................ 23 3.3. Platforms ............................................................................................................................... 24 3.3.1. Reddit ............................................................................................................................ 25 3.3.2. Tumblr & Instagram ...................................................................................................... 28 3.4. Limitations............................................................................................................................. 32 4. Findings ......................................................................................................................................... 33 4.1. Reddit .................................................................................................................................... 35 4.1.1. Aesthetics and Affordances .......................................................................................... 36 4.1.2. Referrals and Intra-ideological Questioning ................................................................. 39 4.1.3. Memes and Practices .................................................................................................... 42 4.2. Instagram .............................................................................................................................. 45 4.2.1. Top vs. Recent ............................................................................................................... 45 4.2.2. Clusters and Tagging ..................................................................................................... 48 4.2.3. Post-Left Meme Pages .................................................................................................. 49 4.2.4. Memes and Practices .................................................................................................... 52 4.3. Tumblr ................................................................................................................................... 54 4.3.1. Solarpunk ............................................................................................................................ 56 4.3.2. Leftblr and Freeblr .............................................................................................................. 58 4.3.3. Libertarians and Communists ............................................................................................. 60 4.3.4. Meme Grammars ................................................................................................................ 62 4.3.5. Laborwave ........................................................................................................................... 63 4.4. The Political Compass ........................................................................................................... 64 5. Conclusion: A Critique on Three Axes ........................................................................................... 67 2 5.1. Irony, Climate Change and Capitalist Realism........................................................................... 67 5.2. “Study the Theory” .................................................................................................................... 70 5.3. Rejection of the Mainstream ..................................................................................................... 72 5.4 Final Remarks ........................................................................................................................ 74 Works Cited ........................................................................................................................................... 77 Appendix ............................................................................................................................................... 88 3 TABLE OF FIGURES FIGURE 1. FREELON'S MODEL OF DELIBERATION ONLINE COMMUNICATION (2010: 7) ............................................................ 24 FIGURE 2. SEARCH RESULTS FOR "ANTI-CAPITALISM". ....................................................................................................... 26 FIGURE 3. REDDIT SEARCH RESULTS FOR "ANTI-CAPITALISM". ............................................................................................. 35 FIGURE 4. TIMELINE OF OCCURRENCE OF THE TERM "ANTI-CAPITALISM" ON REDDIT. .............................................................. 36 FIGURES 5 & 6. THE AESTHETICS AND AFFORDANCES OF R/LATESTAGECAPITALISM. ............................................................... 38 FIGURE 7. THE HOMEPAGE OF /R/CHAPOTRAPHOUSE INCORPORATES AESTHETICS FROM ITS INSIDE JOKES. ................................. 39 FIGURE 8. INTRA-IDEOLOGICAL RECIPROCITY IN THE /R/LATESTAGECAPITALISM REFERRALS. ..................................................... 40 FIGURE 9./ R/LATESTAGECAPITALISM’S ANTAGONISTIC REFERRALS TO /R/THE_DONALD TAKING THE FORM OF “SHITPOSTING”. .... 41 FIGURE 10. INTER-IDEOLOGICAL /R/CHAPOTRAPHOUSE REFERRALS. ................................................................................... 42 FIGURE 11. DEROGATORY /R/CHAPO REFERRALS TO /R/NEOLIBERAL. .................................................................................. 42 FIGURE 12. POPULAR IMAGES ABOUT HYPOCRISY ON /R/LATESTAGECAPITALISM. .................................................................. 43 FIGURE 13. /R/LSC MEMES ABOUT HEALTHCARE AND GLOBAL WARMING. ........................................................................... 43 FIGURE 14. ANTI-IMPERIALIST /R/CHAPOTRAPHOUSE MEMES. .......................................................................................... 44 FIGURE 15. /R/CHAPOTRAPHOUSE “READ THE THEORY” MEMES. ....................................................................................... 45 FIGURE 16. "#ANTICAPITALISM" SEARCH ON INSTAGRAM. ................................................................................................. 46 FIGURE 17. THE FORMAT OF A "TOP" POST..................................................................................................................... 47 FIGURE 18. NETWORK BUILDING IN MEME PAGES FOUND IN “RECENT” THROUGH AFFORDANCES. ............................................. 48 FIGURE 19 . CLUSTERS PRESENT IN #ANTICAPITALISM CO-TAGS ON INSTAGRAM ..................................................................... 49 FIGURE 20. THE CORE ISSUES BEING STRATEGICALLY TAGGED ON INSTAGRAM. ....................................................................... 49 FIGURE 21. MONOLOGUES AND PERSONAL REVELATIONS .................................................................................................. 51 FIGURE 22. DIALOGUE AND PEDAGOGY ON INSTAGRAM .................................................................................................... 52 FIGURE 23. SOCIAL ECOLOGY AND ANARCHO-PRIMITIVIST MEMES ....................................................................................... 53 FIGURE 24. A POPULAR MEME PAGE'S MEMES REFERRING TO THE COMMUNIST MEME PAGE NETWORK. ..................................... 54 FIGURE 25. SEARCHING FOR "ANTI-CAPITALISM" ON TUMBLR, OF WHICH THE FIRST RESULT OFFERS A SOLARPUNK BLOG. .............. 55 FIGURE 26. SOLARPUNK'S PRESENCE IN #ANTICAPITALISM CO-TAG GRAPH ............................................................................ 56 FIGURE 27. A RETURN TO NATURE AND FUTURISTIC ARCHITECTURE
Recommended publications
  • 40 Cultural Shifts Shaping Our World
    EDGES, 2021 40 Cultural Shifts Shaping Our World JANUARY 2021 ©2021 TBWA\Worldwide. All rights reserved. Proprietary and Confidential YEAR ZERO Every January brings talk of fresh starts, exciting trends, Within this story, you will find 40 meaningful cultural shifts and cultural phenomena. But this time, the implications shaping our world. These shifts are born from a global process are much larger. The pandemic has precipitated a that emphasizes the expertise of over 300 TBWA “Culture cosmic reshuffle of global realities, social norms and Spotters”—leveraging insight from Bogota to Berlin, Kigali to individual beliefs. A world is ending, and another is being Kuala Lumpur, New Delhi to New York. born. 2021 isn’t just another year, it’s Year Zero. And so this isn’t just a trend report. It’s a glimpse into a new chapter of our history. Culture is fast, often confusing, and sometimes misleading. We hope that these Edges bring optimism, inspiration for growth, and a clear direction forward. Culture is our story. And more In the face of seismic change, we find ourselves torn than ever before, it’s up to us to write a chapter we’ll be proud of. between fight and flight, dark and light, between the pullback of conservatism and the push forward of imagination. Radical transformation is never Welcome to 2021. Welcome to Year Zero. comfortable, but brighter tomorrows are ahead. Our 2021 Edges tell this hopeful story in six chapters: Chaos. Preservation. Advancement. Identity. Liberation. Rebirth. ©2021 TBWA\Worldwide. All rights reserved. Proprietary and Confidential Edges must be rooted in human values, be 1 recognizable through consumer behaviors, and lead to clear business implications.
    [Show full text]
  • 1616580050.Pdf
    СОДЕРЖАНИЕ СОДЕРЖАНИЕ СОДЕРЖАНИЕ 2 ВВЕДЕНИЕ 3 СОЦИАЛЬНЫЕ МЕДИА НА ВЫБОРАХ: НАЧАЛО ДЛИННОГО ПУТИ 4 Становление политических интернет-технологий 1996–2016 4 2016: интернет побеждает телевизор. Феномен Дональда Трампа 5 ПОЛОЖЕНИЕ СОЦИАЛЬНЫХ МЕДИА К СТАРТУ КАМПАНИИ-2020 8 ИСПОЛЬЗОВАНИЕ НОВЫХ ИНСТРУМЕНТОВ В ХОДЕ ПРЕЗИДЕНТСКОЙ ГОНКИ 10 Цифровая стратегия демократов на выборах-2020. «Барометр» 10 Цифровая стратегия Трампа на выборах-2020. Роботизация таргетинга 14 Полевая работа в условиях эпидемии 18 Растущая популярность мобильных приложений 19 Фандрайзинг 22 Предвыборный дискурс и цензура 25 TikTok. Фактор новых соцмедиа в политической агитации 27 КЛЮЧЕВЫЕ ВЫВОДЫ 31 СПИСОК ИСТОЧНИКОВ 32 2 ВВЕДЕНИЕ ВВЕДЕНИЕ Выборы 2020 года в США прошли в самых не- В этом докладе не ставится цель проследить обычных условиях из всех возможных – на фоне хронологию президентской гонки в США и не вы- глобальной пандемии, самого тяжёлого экономи- сказываются оценочные суждения о результатах ческого кризиса за более чем 80 лет и наиболее прошедших выборов. Он посвящён анализу того массовых уличных протестов за последние 50 лет. инструментария, что использовался в ходе пред- Политтехнологам приходится на ходу подстра- выборной борьбы. иваться под эти неожиданные обстоятельства, В самом ближайшем будущем эти технологии адаптируясь к новой реальности. Уже давно про- станут активно использоваться во всём мире. Сле- должающаяся цифровизация современной поли- дует внимательно изучить цифровые тренды в тики лишь ускорилась. планировании и проведении предвыборных кам- На фоне кризиса традиционных медиа и соцсе- паний, агитации, полевой работы и уличной ак- тей появляются альтернативные площадки, на- тивности, которые на деле показали себя в США. бирающие стремительную популярность. Пред- выборная активность уходит в онлайн, где проще и дешевле проводить виртуальные митинги, со- брания сторонников и заниматься мобилизацией избирателей.
    [Show full text]
  • Gatekeepers & Crashers
    InfluencerCon Presents Gatekeepers & Crashers: Thriving Or Dying? 1 2 Table Of Contents INTRODUCTION 05 CREDITS 06 ESSAYS Gate Keepers 11 Bayo Akomolafe 13 Michael Brooks 20 Sebastien Felix 22 Gilad Goren 25 Dowshan Humzah 28 Nick Seneca Jankel 34 Hortense Koster 38 Alnoor Ladha (Part 1) 41 Alnoor Ladha (Part 2) 46 Sara Shamsavari 48 3 INTRODUCTION 4 GATEKEEPERS/CRASHERS: Thriving or Dying? What is Influencer Conference? exactly what we are seeking to do. Convert ideas and Influencer Conference (InfluencerCon) exists at the insights into something larger, more connected, shareable intersection of values, culture, creativity & commerce. with universal elements. Alchemy allows us to go beyond our host cities and engage influencers who might not be able to InfluencerCon is a global content platform that identifies and attend or speak. supports influencer culture globally. Influencer culture is the unique space occupied by artist, entrepreneurs, innovators, “Gatekeepers/Crashers: Thriving or Dying?” philanthropist & technologist. By bringing tastemakers and The advent of technology and digital media was supposed to game-changers across industries and territories together, herald the end of the age of gatekeepers. The 21st century InfluencerCon establishes itself as the standard bearer for promised the democratization of communication and access. those who are pushing boundaries and creating Now, almost 15 years into a new century, it begs the question what is “NEXT”. whether that has that truly been the case? Has the power and privilege of gatekeepers subsided or, has the expansion of InfluencerCon breaks down traditional “silo-ed” thinking technology actually had the opposite effect, increasing their and encourage cross functionality.
    [Show full text]
  • BIS Hanoi Student Magazine
    NOVUS BIS Hanoi stud ent magazine CULTURE J A N U A R Y 2 0 2 1 Editorial Welcome to the 2nd issue of Novus, BIS’s student-led school magazine. Our objective is to bring you a new perspective on affairs which might have passed you by. In this issue, we invite you to engage with culture. It is indisputable that culture is a fundamental element of human life; it not only enriches life but also creates a connection between people. This fundamental nature relies on inspiration, which then becomes dispersed. Such sequence goes on and on, anytime and anywhere. Thus, it is inevitable that culture is created - unless humans stop thinking. When you define the term ‘culture’, it is likely that you will ponder an Interview with a Julliard Dance image of archaic historical products or traditional arts of a country. specialist However, if it brings people together and becomes a custom, it can be [page 18~22] considered as culture. New cultural affairs have sprung up in contemporary society - one example of this is K-Pop. If you are interested in how it became viral, see K-Pop Culture [page 3~4]. Another term which has developed in the recent COVID-19 era is Cottagecore, an aesthetic which celebrates rural life; see page 13~ 14 which provides a big picture of such Gen-Z subculture. Celebrating all the cultures which were created, it leads to an ultimate question of why culture is important. A key for that reason is provided in Why is culture important? [page 11~12].
    [Show full text]
  • Why Do People Seek Anonymity on the Internet?
    Why Do People Seek Anonymity on the Internet? Informing Policy and Design Ruogu Kang1, Stephanie Brown2, Sara Kiesler1 Human Computer Interaction Institute1 Department of Psychology2 Carnegie Mellon University 5000 Forbes Ave., Pittsburgh, PA 15213 [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] ABSTRACT literature that exists mainly derives from studies of one or a In this research we set out to discover why and how people few online communities or activities (e.g., the study of seek anonymity in their online interactions. Our goal is to 4chan in [5]). We lack a full understanding of the real life inform policy and the design of future Internet architecture circumstances surrounding people’s experiences of seeking and applications. We interviewed 44 people from America, anonymity and their feelings about the tradeoffs between Asia, Europe, and Africa who had sought anonymity and anonymity and identifiability. A main purpose of the asked them about their experiences. A key finding of our research reported here was to learn more about how people research is the very large variation in interviewees’ past think about online anonymity and why they seek it. More experiences and life situations leading them to seek specifically, we wanted to capture a broad slice of user anonymity, and how they tried to achieve it. Our results activities and experiences from people who have actually suggest implications for the design of online communities, sought anonymity, to investigate their experiences, and to challenges for policy, and ways to improve anonymity tools understand their attitudes about anonymous and identified and educate users about the different routes and threats to communication.
    [Show full text]
  • The Korean Internet Freak Community and Its Cultural Politics, 2002–2011
    The Korean Internet Freak Community and Its Cultural Politics, 2002–2011 by Sunyoung Yang A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Department of Anthropology University of Toronto © Copyright by Sunyoung Yang Year of 2015 The Korean Internet Freak Community and Its Cultural Politics, 2002–2011 Sunyoung Yang Doctor of Philosophy Department of Anthropology University of Toronto 2015 Abstract In this dissertation I will shed light on the interwoven process between Internet development and neoliberalization in South Korea, and I will also examine the formation of new subjectivities of Internet users who are also becoming neoliberal subjects. In particular, I examine the culture of the South Korean Internet freak community of DCinside.com and the phenomenon I have dubbed “loser aesthetics.” Throughout the dissertation, I elaborate on the meaning-making process of self-reflexive mockery including the labels “Internet freak” and “surplus (human)” and gender politics based on sexuality focusing on gender ambiguous characters, called Nunhwa, as a means of collective identity-making, and I explore the exploitation of unpaid immaterial labor through a collective project making a review book of a TV drama Painter of the Wind. The youth of South Korea emerge as the backbone of these creative endeavors as they try to find their place in a precarious labor market that has changed so rapidly since the 1990s that only the very best succeed, leaving a large group of disenfranchised and disillusioned youth. I go on to explore the impact of late industrialization and the Asian financial crisis, and the nationalistic desire not be left behind in the age of informatization, but to be ahead of the curve.
    [Show full text]
  • “No Left, No Right – Only the Game”
    “No Left, No Right – Only the Game” A Netnographic Study of the Online Community r/KotakuInAction Master of Arts: Media and Communication Studies – Culture, Collaborative Media, and Creative Industries Master’s Thesis (Two-year) | 15 credits Student: Oskar Larsson Supervisor: Maria Brock Year: 2021 Word Count: 15,937 Abstract This thesis examines how 'othering' discourse can be used to construct and negotiate boundaries and shape collective identities within online spaces. Through a mixed-method approach of thematic analysis and a netnographic study, and by drawing on theoretical concepts of online othering and identity formation, this thesis explores how the Gamergate community r/KotakuInAction can be understood in relation to Gamergate, the Alt-Right and society at large. The results show that the community perceive and construct the SJW as a common adversary – a monstrous representation of feminism, progressiveness and political correctness. The analysis also revealed how racist rhetorics and white male anxieties characterize the communitys' othering discourse. Through an in-depth study of user-submitted comment, this thesis argues that r/KotakuInAction's collective identity is fluid and reactionary in nature, characterized by a discourse that is indicative of Alt-Right ideology and white male supremacy. Future research should further explore the network of communities that r/KotakuInAction is part of, as well as examine how the community transform over time. Keywords: Gamergate, Reddit, Alt-Right, Online Othering, Collective Identity,
    [Show full text]
  • ASD-Covert-Foreign-Money.Pdf
    overt C Foreign Covert Money Financial loopholes exploited by AUGUST 2020 authoritarians to fund political interference in democracies AUTHORS: Josh Rudolph and Thomas Morley © 2020 The Alliance for Securing Democracy Please direct inquiries to The Alliance for Securing Democracy at The German Marshall Fund of the United States 1700 18th Street, NW Washington, DC 20009 T 1 202 683 2650 E [email protected] This publication can be downloaded for free at https://securingdemocracy.gmfus.org/covert-foreign-money/. The views expressed in GMF publications and commentary are the views of the authors alone. Cover and map design: Kenny Nguyen Formatting design: Rachael Worthington Alliance for Securing Democracy The Alliance for Securing Democracy (ASD), a bipartisan initiative housed at the German Marshall Fund of the United States, develops comprehensive strategies to deter, defend against, and raise the costs on authoritarian efforts to undermine and interfere in democratic institutions. ASD brings together experts on disinformation, malign finance, emerging technologies, elections integrity, economic coercion, and cybersecurity, as well as regional experts, to collaborate across traditional stovepipes and develop cross-cutting frame- works. Authors Josh Rudolph Fellow for Malign Finance Thomas Morley Research Assistant Contents Executive Summary �������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 1 Introduction and Methodology ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������
    [Show full text]
  • Mckinsey Quarterly 2015 Number 4.Pdf
    2015 Number 4 Copyright © 2015 McKinsey & Company. All rights reserved. Published since 1964 by McKinsey & Company, 55 East 52nd Street, New York, New York 10022. Cover illustration by Vasava McKinsey Quarterly meets the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) chain-of- custody standards. The paper used in the Quarterly is certified as being produced in an environ- mentally responsible, socially beneficial, and economi- cally viable way. Printed in the United States of America. 2015 Number 4 This Quarter It’s almost a truism these days to say that modern corporations must be agile. The pace of industry disruption arising from the digital revolution, combined with nimble, new competitors—including many from emerging markets—have raised the cost of complacency and rigidity. But what does it mean to achieve agility? This issue’s cover package tries to answer that question, starting with intriguing new McKinsey research. Using data from McKinsey’s Organizational Health Index, Michael Bazigos, Aaron De Smet, and Chris Gagnon show how organizations that combine speed with stability are far likelier to be healthy than companies that simply move fast. The utility sector is a striking example of one industry that needs to combine flexibility and stability. Although digital competitors, new data-based business models, and renewable-energy sources are changing the landscape in certain markets, the industry’s sprawl- ing base of heavy assets remains core to its future. Sven Heiligtag and his colleagues Dominik Luczak and Eckart Windhagen describe how a number of leading utilities are trying to straddle these two worlds, suggesting some lessons for companies in other sectors.
    [Show full text]
  • Don't Feed the Trolls: a Cautionary Tale
    Don’t Feed the Trolls: others (Linux, of course). In fact, the phrase originated as a reference to the A Cautionary Tale comic book the Fantastic Four, as one of the characters could turn himself DANA SAMUEL into a Human Torch. Chat participants would use the HTML‐styled, bracketed annotation to insult other participants online. In Eddo Stern’s Best. Flame War. Ever. we are presented with an online argu‐ <flame on> You’re pretty stupid for ment over seemingly insignificant not knowing what MMPORPG means. game‐playing topics that grows quickly Go look it up on Wiki. </flame off> out of proportion and out of the realm of online experience. Two collaged When the internet opened to the animated masks – each an amalgam of commercial world, and more people heraldry, knighthood, pixilated joined these groups, more language warriors, fantasy species, castles, and jargon was developed to describe shields and symbols – animate a flame the goings‐on in these communities. A war that actually took place online “troll” is one who writes nasty flames over the role‐playing game Everquest, just to make others angry and to be an MMPORPG. annoying. “Meat‐puppets” and “sock‐ Did I just make you feel like a total puppets” are those who are deceptive “newb”? about their identities or their true Online games, discussion boards and allegiances on a discussion board. communities have developed their How all very “D&D.” own language since these online It’s said, by several theorists, that worlds were first populated in people can be more uninhibited online, research and academia, and then, later they can change their personality, role‐ (post‐cold war, after the military had play and morph into who they no need for such a specialized perceive themselves to be.
    [Show full text]
  • Emhs 9Th Summer Reading 1
    Annotation Directions: EMHS 9TH SUMMER READING 1. Make a point of underlining the two most important ideas in each “column” of reading. Each year, students at EMHS do summer reading. You can underline a single phrase or a couple Reading over the summer keeps one’s mind “awake” of sentences, but please choose your selections and provides your class with an immediate platform carefully. to work on from the first day of school. The material for this packet was selected for its subject matter and 2. Of the two ideas you underline in each column, relevance to you. select the most important one and rephrase it at the bottom of the page in your own words. Please make a point of reading all six of the articles 3. When you finish an article, review your contained in this packet. Since there are several annotations. On a separate sheet of paper, different pieces, you can break this reading up as write down the “takeaway points” for each your summer schedule allows. All articles should article—the most important ideas. be read and annotated by the first day of school. Please bring this packet with you on There are many online sources to further explain the first day of school. how to annotate a text. When you come to school on the first day, this packet should be completely read This packet should be printed out and read carefully. and annotated. In addition, you should have You should always read with a pen or pencil and use your takeaway points on a separate sheet of annotation strategies to help yourself make sense paper completed.
    [Show full text]
  • Federal Political Parties and Party Ideology
    Government Federal Political Parties and Party Ideology I Basics for the Teacher I Overview See Activity Sheet 4-2: Political Ideologies Discussed for the basics for This lesson is focused on devel- this lesson. oping knowledge of and understanding about the core political ideologies as they I Student Handouts evolved in the 20th century. The lesson is not intended to Activity Sheet 4-1: Your Political Compass create significant depth on Activity Sheet 4-2: Political Ideologies Discussed each ideology but to expose Activity Sheet 4-3: Political Ideologies Chart students to the range of politi- cal ideas that have some cur- Activity Sheet 4-4: Town Hall Meeting rency in modern politics. The lesson is also expected to aid in the refinement of existing polit- Instructions for the Teacher ical thought held by the stu- The curriculum you will teach is contained in the various handouts dents in your class. and answer keys contained in this lesson. Activity sheets provide background details, knowledge components, directions and assigned work. The materials developed for this lesson use a vari- ety of strategies but emphasize active learning and listening and I Objectives presentation skills to help prepare students. Access to a computer, at home or at school, will be an important component of these les- Students will: sons. However, materials have been provided to allow the teach- • Identify and understand ing of this lesson without classroom computer use - with the excep- the political platform of tion of some extension activities. each major federal party. • Understand the funda- Activity 1: Your Political Compass mental tenets of each fed- • This activity is designed to introduce the concept of political eral party’s ideology and ideology to the students and have them recognize that they place each party within have already formed a core of beliefs related to a political ide- the political spectrum or ology.
    [Show full text]