APPENDIX 11 ATTACHMENT 1

TENDER 043/16 PENISTONE PARK COMMUNITY SPORTING FACILITY

SUMMARY OF TENDER SUBMISSIONS

Comment Against Criteria Tenderer & Is it Social and Evaluation Qualitative Description of Compliant? Demonstrated experience Demonstrated economic Price Score Response Yes or No Capacity in completing similar understanding of the effects on the Rank projects required tasks local community McCorkell Yes McCorkell Constructions has The company demonstrated The company Its WA office is 64.4% Option 1 1 Constructions been in operation for more substantial experience demonstrated a located in . $2,675,850 (W.A.) Pty Ltd than 85 years. Its head office completing projects of similar thorough understanding Option 2 is in Victoria and it has an scope and size. Six of the requirements. A All No specific $2,663,100 requirements office in Perth since 2011. It completed project examples project specific response was have been met. has 50 staff across Australia. were provided and these methodology submitted for The company and project included construction of addressing site set up, this criterion. organisation chart were Piara Waters sports pavilion materials handling and provided and supported by for the , cranage, building experience, qualifications and Collegians Football structure, external and role of the nominated Clubrooms for the City of internal walls, Construction Manager, Project Nedlands, Bramston Park sequencing of finishes, Manager and Site Manager. A Community Centre for the external works and list of current and future City of , Bertram services coordination. A commitments of the company Community Centre for the detailed list of was supplied. Three significant , Lathlain subcontractors sized projects (Dayton Community Centre for the including Community Centre, Sunscape and contingency/alternatives Office/Warehouse and Ocean Kingsway Baseball Club for was provided. A Gardens Palm Court the City of . The comprehensive Apartments) will be underway company is currently construction program at the commencement of this constructing Harrisdale and schedule of Contract. The company Sports Pavilion for the City of progress claims were operates an accredited safety Armadale and extension of also supplied. management system (AS/NZS the Wanneroo/ Joondalup 4801). A copy of its safety SES Facility and Warwick policy, safety statistics and Hockey Facility for the City table of contents of its quality, of Joondalup. safety and management system was supplied.

1

ATTACHMENT 1

TENDER 043/16 PENISTONE PARK COMMUNITY SPORTING FACILITY

Comment Against Criteria Tenderer & Is it Social and Evaluation Qualitative Description of Compliant? Demonstrated experience Demonstrated economic Price Score Response Yes or No Capacity in completing similar understanding of the effects on the Rank projects required tasks local community Pindan Yes Pindan has been in operation The company demonstrated Pindan Constructions Its head office is 60.4% Option 1 2 Constructions since 1977. It has 450 staff in considerable experience demonstrated a sound located in Perth. $3,226,677 Pty Ltd t/as its Perth Head Office and completing projects of similar understanding of the Option 2 Pindan regional South West Office in scope and size. Numerous requirements. A No specific $3,217,517 Constructions . The company and project examples were comprehensive response was All project organisation chart were provided and these included construction submitted for provided and supported by the requirements construction of Pearsall management plan this criterion. have been met. experience, qualifications and Hocking Community Centre addressing site role of six team members. A for the , facilities, site access, list of current and future Coogee Surf Life Saving material handling and commitments of the company Club for the City of storage areas, was supplied. Six significant Cockburn, Grenville Reserve preliminary construction sized projects will be underway Community and Sport methodology, site at the commencement of this Facility for the City of fencing and demolition Contract but the company has Stirling, Bridgetown Library and enabling works. A sufficient resources and for the Shire of Bridgetown- detailed list of personnel to carry out this Greenbushes, Centenary subcontractors and a project. The company operates Park Sports Pavilion for the comprehensive an accredited safety and construction program management system (AS/NZS Maylands Multipurpose were supplied but 4801). A copy of its safety Centre (The Rise) for the schedule of estimated policy, safety statistics and . The progress claims was not table of contents of its quality, company is currently provided. safety and management completing the extension system was supplied. works of the Wanneroo Civic Centre for the City of Wanneroo, Ellenbrook North Community Pavilion for the and Eaton Sports Pavilions for the .

2

ATTACHMENT 1

TENDER 043/16 PENISTONE PARK COMMUNITY SPORTING FACILITY

Comment Against Criteria Tenderer & Is it Social and Evaluation Qualitative Description of Compliant? Demonstrated experience Demonstrated economic Price Score Response Yes or No Capacity in completing similar understanding of the effects on the Rank projects required tasks local community The Trustee for Yes Alita Constructions has been in It demonstrated some The company The company is 48.4% Option 1 3 the Arkline operation since 2004. It is experience in completing demonstrated an based in $2,866,500 Hybrid Trust based in Forrestdale with similar construction projects understanding of the Forrestdale. Option 2 t/as Alita approximately 19 staff. The for local governments and requirements. The $2,858,100 Enterprises Pty company organisation chart private organisations. Five construction No response Ltd was provided and supported completed project examples methodology addressed was submitted All by the experience, were supplied supporting its contract for this criterion. qualifications and role of six experience but only the commencement, requirements have been met. team members. A list of construction of Byford & procurement, demolition current and future Districts Country Club for the and earthworks, commitments of the company Shire of Serpentine structure, construction was also supplied. Three Jarrahdale and Carey of external areas, car significant sized projects Baptist Community Centre parking and (Vincentian Retreat, John for Carey Baptist College are environmental controls Calvin School Capel campus of similar size and scope. during construction. A and Caversham Community Other three project examples construction program Centre) will be underway at the (construction of The Samoan and basic list of commencement of this Church for The Samoan subcontractors were Contract. Safety statistics and Independent 7th Day provided but schedule a safety management plan of Adventist Church, of estimated monthly the company were provided. Serpentine Jarrahdale progress claims was not Community Resource Centre supplied. and construction of three multi-purpose halls for John Calvin School) are of different scope and smaller scale. It is currently constructing Caversham Community Centre for the City of Swan and Capel campus for John Calvin School. A description of the scope of works, value and period and dates for all projects were supplied.

3

ATTACHMENT 1

TENDER 043/16 PENISTONE PARK COMMUNITY SPORTING FACILITY

Comment Against Criteria Tenderer & Is it Social and Evaluation Qualitative Description of Compliant? Demonstrated experience Demonstrated economic Price Score Response Yes or No Capacity in completing similar understanding of the effects on the Rank projects required tasks local community Bistel Yes Bistel Construction has been in Bistel Construction did not The company It is located in 44.4% Option 1 4 Construction operation for the past two demonstrate sufficient demonstrated an Osborne Park. $2,831,245 Pty Ltd years. It is based in Osborne experience in completing understanding of the Option 2 Park with an unknown number similar construction projects. requirements. A All No specific $2,824,377 requirements of staff. The company Only one project example detailed project response was have been met. organisation chart was (construction of Secret construction submitted for provided. Experience, Harbour Life Saving Club for methodology was this criterion. qualifications and role of the ) is a provided addressing Project Manager, Quality similar sized project to the pre-mobilisation to site, Advisor, Site Construction Penistone Park community construction of facility Manager and OHS Advisor for sporting facility. The building, tennis court, this project were supplied. The company also completed softball, basketball and company will have two ongoing Stage 6B Baseball Facility – cricket practice zones, residential projects (a two Kingsley for the City of external works and storey residence and 5 x Wanneroo and Alfred Skeet demobilisation from residential units) at the change rooms at Forrestdale site. The submission commencement of this for the City of Armadale. also addressed Contract. Safety statistics and residents interface, a safety management plan of pedestrian movements the company were provided. and care of existing facilities. A detailed construction program and an extensive list of subcontractors were provided but project and personnel commitments of the sub-contractors were not provided. A schedule of estimated monthly progress claims was also not supplied.

4

ATTACHMENT 1

TENDER 043/16 PENISTONE PARK COMMUNITY SPORTING FACILITY

Comment Against Criteria Tenderer & Is it Social and Evaluation Qualitative Description of Compliant? Demonstrated experience Demonstrated economic Price Score Response Yes or No Capacity in completing similar understanding of the effects on the Rank projects required tasks local community Macfield Yes Macfield Construction has Macfield Construction did not The company did not The company is 31.3% Option 1 5 Construction been in operation for more demonstrate experience in demonstrate an located in $2,610,886 Pty Ltd than three years. It is based in completing projects of similar understanding of the Nedlands. Option 2 Nedlands with eight full time scope and size. None of its requirements. The All $2,609,386 requirements and part time employees. The submitted three project submitted response No specific have been met. company organisation chart examples (ground was generic and lacked response was was not provided. Experience, preparation for two rugby details of the submitted for qualifications and role of four fields and supply of three construction methods to this criterion. staff were supplied. The netball courts at HBF be adopted. A basic list company has no current Joondalup for Venues West of sub-contractors was projects/commitments. Safety and construction of an eight supplied without their statistics and a safety unit apartment complex) are previous experience, management plan of the similar in scope to the project and personnel company were provided. Penistone Park Community commitments and Sporting Facility. financial capabilities. A provisional construction program and schedule of estimated monthly progress claims were provided.

5

ATTACHMENT 1

TENDER 043/16 PENISTONE PARK COMMUNITY SPORTING FACILITY

Comment Against Criteria Social and Tenderer & Is it Demonstrated Demonstrated economic Evaluation Qualitative Description of Compliant? experience in Price Capacity understanding of the effects on the Score Rank Response Yes or No completing similar required tasks local projects community Topend Living Pty Ltd t/as Buildon Construction No Non-compliant not assessed All requirements have not been met.

6