DOCSLIB.ORG

Why Scripture Scholars and Theological Ethicists Need One Another: Exegeting and Interpreting the Beatitudes As a Scripted Script for Ethical Living

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

Why scripture scholars and theological ethicists need one another: Exegeting and interpreting the Beatitudes as a scripted script for ethical living Author: Yiu Sing Lúcás Chan Persistent link: http://hdl.handle.net/2345/bc-ir:104293 This work is posted on eScholarship@BC, Boston College University Libraries. Boston College Electronic Thesis or Dissertation, 2010 Copyright is held by the author, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise noted. Boston College The Graduate School of Arts and Science Department of Theology WHY SCRIPTURE SCHOLARS AND THEOLOGICAL ETHICISTS NEED ONE ANOTHER: EXEGETING AND INTERPRETING THE BEATITUDES AS A SCRIPTED SCRIPT FOR ETHICAL LIVING a dissertation by YIU SING LUKE (LÚCÁS) CHAN submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy December 2010 © copyright by YIU SING LUKE (LÚCÁS) CHAN 2010 WHY SCRIPTURE SCHOLARS AND THEOLOGICAL ETHICISTS NEED ONE ANOTHER: EXEGETING AND INTERPRETING THE BEATITUDES AS A SCRIPTED SCRIPT FOR ETHICAL LIVING Yiu Sing Luke (Lúcás) Chan Advisor: Professor James F. Keenan, SJ For a variety of reasons, in the field of biblical ethics, Scripture scholars do not use much ethical theory, while theological ethicists do little actual exegesis. Even those recent attempts to bridge better Scripture with Christian ethics have either stressed the importance of the scriptural text or the importance of ethical hermeneutics. Throughout this entire work I advocate for a more integrated approach for a Scripture-based Christian theological ethics. In so doing I first propose using Allen Verhey‘s distinction of Scripture as ‗scripted‘ and ‗script‘: The former refers to exegesis and the latter to admonitions for ethical living. A more integrated approach will therefore treat Scripture as both ‗scripted‘ and ‗script‘, taking exegesis seriously and interpreting the text by using a sound hermeneutical framework. Subsequently, we can both acquire a more accurate understanding of the original meaning of the text and obtain a more complete and consistent interpretation of the text for today. From the perspective of Christian ethics, I further suggest virtue ethics as a worthy hermeneutical tool in treating Scripture as ‗script‘. Virtue ethics complements principle-based ethical theories by emphasizing practices and the importance of exemplary models. It also attends to the character formation and identity of both individuals and the moral community. Moreover, as I argue, there exists an explicit link between Scripture and virtue. Both the biblical link and the uniqueness of virtue ethics make it suitable as the hermeneutical tool for doing Scripture-based Christian ethics. In order to demonstrate concretely how the methodological shift into a more integrated scriptural ethics as such leads to actual benefits and improvements, I offer a three-step illustration. I begin with treating the Beatitudes in Matthew 5:3-12 as first ‗scripted‘; that is, I exegete the text. Then I look at the text as ‗script‘ through the hermeneutics of virtue ethics. I identify a new set of core virtues (and corresponding practices) not just for personal formation but also for the formation of the community and the larger society. Third, I then bring the fruits of this treatment forward by exploring the possible reception of the Beatitudes and its core virtues by the Confucian tradition. Methodologically speaking, Confucianism goes to its own texts in its search of ethical teachings; and Confucian ethics is primarily the fruit of careful interpretation of their ‗sacred‘ texts. In other words, it is both text-based and interpretative, and shares a common methodological approach with the Scripture-based Christian ethics proposed here. Subsequently, we find significant parallel virtues in Confucian texts although dissimilarities (such as worldview) exist between the two traditions. As a whole, the proposed methodological shift into a Scripture-based Christian ethics produces a more accurate, complete and consistent interpretation of the biblical text for our contemporary audience and makes Christian ethics more explicable to Confucian society and more supportive of cross-cultural dialogue with Confucian ethics. Table of Contents Acknowledgements vii Introduction 1 Part One: Current Attempts at Constructing Scriptural Ethics 20 Chapter I: Foundations: The Tasks of Scripture Scholars and Theological 22 Ethicists 1.1 The Study of Ethics in Scripture 22 New Testament Ethics 22 Methodology 27 The Contents of New Testament Ethics 29 1.2 The Use of Scripture in Ethics 32 How is the Bible Used in Ethics? 32 The Authority of Scripture in Ethics 36 The Bible as a Source for Ethics 42 The Problems of Using Scripture in Ethics 45 1.3 Where are We Now? 48 Chapter II: The Attempt by Scripture Scholars 49 2.1 Wolfgang Schrage 51 2.2 Richard B. Hays 58 2.3 Frank J. Matera 68 2.4 Sandra M. Schneiders 76 2.5 Rasiah S. Sugirtharajah 88 2.6 Where are We Now? 100 Chapter III: The Attempt by Theological Ethicists 105 3.1 Bernard Häring 107 3.2 Gustavo Gutiérrez 116 3.3 Rosemary Radford Ruether 127 3.4 William C. Spohn 142 3.5 Where are We Now? 155 i Chapter IV: The Importance of the Scriptural Text and of Ethical 163 Hermeneutics, or the Scripture as ‘Scripted’ and ‘Script’ 4.1 Richard A. Burridge 164 4.2 Allen Verhey 181 Verhey as a Biblical Theologian 185 Verhey as a Christian Ethicist 189 Scripture as ‘Scripted’ and ‘Script’ 197 4.3 Where are We now? 201 Part Two: The Hermeneutics of Virtue Ethics 205 Chapter V: A Hermeneutic of Virtue Ethics 209 5.1 Some Basic Issues 209 Nature of Virtue Ethics 209 Issue of Methodology 211 Question of Cultural Contextualization 212 Question of Theological Relevance 212 5.2 Historical Development 214 An Overview 214 Reasons for Returning to Virtue 222 5.3 The Revival of Virtue Ethics 224 Attempts from Philosophical and Theological Sectors 224 Limitations and Criticism of Virtue Theory 234 5.4 Contemporary Understanding of Virtue Ethics 238 The Plurality of Virtue Ethics 238 Contemporary Understanding 239 5.5 The Yield of Virtue 245 Practices and Habits 245 Disposition and Character 247 Exemplar 250 Community and Communal Identity 256 5.6 Virtue and Grace 260 5.7 Conclusion 265 Chapter VI: Reading Scripture through the Lens of Virtue 269 6.1 Relating Scripture and Virtue Ethics 272 Scripture and Moral Character 276 Scripture and Exemplar 277 Scripture and Community 279 6.2 Joseph Kotva, Jr. 282 6.3 William C. Spohn 293 ii 6.4 Conclusion 305 Part Three: Exegeting and Interpreting the Text—The Beatitudes as ‘Scripted 309 Script’ Chapter VII: The Exegesis of the Text—The Beatitudes as ‘Scripted’ 322 7.1 The Gospel according to Matthew: Some Basic Issues 323 Authorship, Date and Place of Composition 323 Setting and Purpose 324 Sources and Nature 325 Structure, Style, and Themes 327 Apocalyptic-eschatological Outlook 330 7.2 The Sermon on the Mount: Some Specific Issues 334 Its Place within the Gospel 334 Genre 336 Sources and Settings 337 The Mountain and the Audience 339 Purpose 341 Themes and Structure 341 A Radical Ethics for All? 344 A Summary 347 7.3 The Beatitudes: Some Critical and Immediate Issues 348 The Meanings of ‘beatitude’ and ‘blessed’ 348 ‘Beatitude’ (Macarism) in the Bible 350 Jewish Influences, Sources, and Development of the Beatitudes 351 The Unity and Structure of the Beatitudes 354 The Function of the Beatitudes 357 My own Approach 360 7.4 The Beatitudes: An Exegesis 362 5:3 Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of 362 heaven 5:4 Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted 366 5:5 Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth 370 5:6 Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, 373 for they will be filled 5:7 Blessed are the merciful, for they will receive mercy 376 5:8 Blessed are the pure in heart, for they will see God 380 5:9 Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called 383 children of God 5: 10 Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness’ 388 sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven A Summary 394 7.5 Conclusion 397 iii Chapter VIII: The Interpretation of a Key Text through the Hermeneutics 402 of Virtue Ethics—The Beatitudes as ‘Scripted Script’ 8.1 The Virtue of Humility in 5:3 409 Poverty as a Human Condition 410 The Meaning of ‘Poor in Spirit’ 411 Humility as a Virtue 412 The Practice of Humility 414 The Exemplars 415 The Social, Communal Aspect of the Virtue of Humility 417 8.2 Solidarity as a Virtue in 5:4 419 Suffering and Mourning as Human Experience 419 The Meaning of Mourning 421 Mourning as an Expression of the Virtue of Solidarity 422 The Practice of Mourning 423 The Exemplars 424 The Social, Communal Aspect of the Practice of Mourning and 425 the Virtue of Solidarity 8.3 The Virtue of Meekness in 5:5 426 Arrogance in Human World 427 The Meaning of Meekness 428 Meekness as a Virtue 429 The Practice of Meekness 430 The Exemplars 431 The Social, Communal Aspect of the Virtue of Meekness 434 8.4 Striving for and Discerning God‘s Righteousness in 5:6 435 God’s Righteousness or Human Justice? 435 The Meaning of Striving 437 Striving for God’s Righteousness as a Christian Virtue 438 The Practice of Striving for God’s Righteousness 438 The Exemplars 440 The Social, Communal Aspect of Striving for God’s 441 Righteousness 8.5 The Virtue of Mercy in 5:7 442 Miseries in Our Human World 443 The Meaning of Mercy 444 Mercy as a Virtue 445 The Works of Mercy in the Catholic Tradition 446 The Exemplars 448 The Social, Communal Aspect of the Virtue of Mercy 449 8.6 Integrity
Recommended publications
  • Philosophy and the Art of Living Aristotle, Spinoza, Hegel

    Philosophy and the Art of Living Aristotle, Spinoza, Hegel

    Philosophy and the Art of Living Osher Life-Long Learning Institute (UC Irvine) 2010 The Masters of Reason and the Masters of Suspicion: Aristotle, Spinoza, Hegel Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, Sartre When: Mondays for six weeks: November 1 ,8, 15, 22, 29, and Dec. 6. Where: Woodbridge Center, 4628 Barranca Pkwy. Irvine CA 92604 NOTES AND QUOTES: Aristotle: 384 BCE- 322 BCE (62 years): Reference: http://www.jcu.edu/philosophy/gensler/ms/arist-00.htm Theoretical Reason contemplates the nature of Reality. Practical Reason arranges the best means to accomplish one's ends in life, of which the final end is happiness. http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-ethics/#IntVir Aristotle distinguishes two kinds of virtue (1103a1-10): those that pertain to the part of the soul that engages in reasoning (virtues of mind or intellect), and those that pertain to the part of the soul that cannot itself reason but is nonetheless capable of following reason (ethical virtues, virtues of character). Intellectual virtues are in turn divided into two sorts: those that pertain to theoretical reasoning, and those that pertain to practical thinking 1139a3-8). He organizes his material by first studying ethical virtue in general, then moving to a discussion of particular ethical virtues (temperance, courage, and so on), and finally completing his survey by considering the intellectual virtues (practical wisdom, theoretical wisdom, etc.). Life : Aristotle was born in northern Greece in 384 B.C. He was raised by a guardian after the death of his father, Nicomachus, who had been court physician to the king of Macedonia. Aristotle entered Plato's Academy at age 17.
  • Millennialism, Rapture and “Left Behind” Literature. Analysing a Major Cultural Phenomenon in Recent Times

    Millennialism, Rapture and “Left Behind” Literature. Analysing a Major Cultural Phenomenon in Recent Times

    start page: 163 Stellenbosch Theological Journal 2019, Vol 5, No 1, 163–190 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17570/stj.2019.v5n1.a09 Online ISSN 2413-9467 | Print ISSN 2413-9459 2019 © Pieter de Waal Neethling Trust Millennialism, rapture and “Left Behind” literature. Analysing a major cultural phenomenon in recent times De Villers, Pieter GR University of the Free State, Bloemfontein, South Africa [email protected] Abstract This article represents a research overview of the nature, historical roots, social contexts and growth of millennialism as a remarkable religious and cultural phenomenon in modern times. It firstly investigates the notions of eschatology, millennialism and rapture that characterize millennialism. It then analyses how and why millennialism that seems to have been a marginal phenomenon, became prominent in the United States through the evangelistic activities of Darby, initially an unknown pastor of a minuscule faith community from England and later a household name in the global religious discourse. It analyses how millennialism grew to play a key role in the religious, social and political discourse of the twentieth century. It finally analyses how Darby’s ideas are illuminated when they are placed within the context of modern England in the sixteenth, seventeenth and eighteenth century. In a conclusion some key challenges of the place and role of millennialism as a movement that reasserts itself continuously, are spelled out in the light of this history. Keywords Eschatology; millennialism; chiliasm; rapture; dispensationalism; J.N. Darby; Joseph Mede; Johann Heinrich Alsted; “Left Behind” literature. 1. Eschatology and millennialism Christianity is essentially an eschatological movement that proclaims the fulfilment of the divine promises in Hebrew Scriptures in the earthly ministry of Christ, but it also harbours the expectation of an ultimate fulfilment of Christ’s second coming with the new world of God that will replace the existing evil dispensation.
  • This Final Glorious Gospel Dispensation

    This Final Glorious Gospel Dispensation

    This Final Glorious Gospel Dispensation Bruce R. McConkie (1915-1985) Quorum of the Twelve Apostles Ensign, Apr. 1980, pp. 21-25 This article appeared in the in the April 1980 issue of the Ensign. That month the Church was celebrating the 150 year of the restoration of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. In this article, Elder McConkie summarized what had been restored and achieved in the first 150 years of the Dispensation of the Fulness of Times. He also briefly summarized what lay ahead in achieving the divine purpose this dispensation of the gospel in preparing a people for the Millennium,the next stage of existence for those desiring the celestial kingdom. Let every man upon the face of the without number, and (for us) our whole earth know that the glorious inheritance here on planet earth. gospel of God is alive and well and It is the fall of Adam, with its prospering in this day. temporal and spiritual death, and the Let every living soul know that the ransoming power of the Son of God, little stone cut from the mountain who abolished death and brought life without hands has begun to roll forth. and immortality to light through his In time it will break in pieces all the laws. kingdoms of men and fill the whole It is all of the laws, rites, and earth. ordinances; all of the truths, powers, Let it be known that the things and performances; all of the keys, “which our forefathers have awaited priesthoods, and privileges which with anxious expectation to be bring to pass the immortality and revealed in the last times” are now eternal life of man.
  • New Testament Source Diagram

    New Testament Source Diagram

    New Testament Source Diagram Flannelly Hilary hoggings fine and prestissimo, she aims her pre-emptor perennates trebly. Rem Cogentusually sickChrist continuedly usually obfuscated or heave infamouslysome phenomena when trilingual or leased Jonny unconsciously. evaporating reputedly and mellowly. NIrV makes the Bible understandable to young readers and. Should I start by reading with the Old navy or award New Quora. Why your there 4 Gospels in following New Testament? Can we trust these New Testament make a historical document. Bible Maps you are currently on as page overlaps with 2 but has maps not found does the. Jesus Christ Family allowance Chart 77 fathers & sons in Jesus. Higher criticism New World Encyclopedia. What they spell, diagramming are his sources affect you need a source. The scriptures are into be your site source themselves you refuse your lessons To herd you. Since the 170s the flat three books of the New Testament never been called the. Apostolic origin recognition by what church and apostolic content. Summary the History find the Bible. Higher criticism treats the Bible as hot text created by human beings at some particular. Th f sscripture signs of jesus christ is out to historical document, and source of marcan priority sees this can also. The Story past The Storytellers From Jesus To Christ FRONTLINE. At it has been lost without him to teach concerning q material is possible for this external aspect of scripture block ofscripture from that was never hunger. In pairing the events of Christ's career with their own Testament prefigurations the designer. Here's a chart adapted from page 90 of Gabel and Wheeler's The Bible as.
  • Introduction to Various Theological Systems Within the Christian Tradition

    Introduction to Various Theological Systems Within the Christian Tradition

    Introduction to Theological Systems: Dr. Paul R. Shockley Theological Systems Dogmatic Theology: A doctrine or body of doctrines of theology and religion formally stated and authoritatively proclaimed by a group. Calvinist Theology John Calvin (1509-1564) French Institutes – 80 chapter document explaining his views Presbyterian churches Jonathan Edwards, George Whitfield, Charles Spurgeon, Charles Hodge, William Shedd, Benjamin Warfield, Cornelius Van Til Westminster Confession - 1647 Emphases of Calvinism Sovereignty Predestination TULIP – Synod of Dort (1619) Total Depravity Unconditional Election Limited Atonement Irresistible Grace Perseverance of the Saints Arminian Theology Jacob Arminius (1560-1609) Dutch Remonstrance – 1610 document by followers of Arminius explaining his doctrine Methodist, Wesleyan, Episcopalian, Anglican, Free Will Baptist churches John Wesley, H. Orton Wiley Emphases of Arminianism God limits His sovereignty in accordance with man’s freedom – all divine decrees are based on foreknowledge Prevenient Grace – Prevenient grace has removed the guilt and condemnation of Adam’s sin – it reverses the curse Emphases of Arminianism Man is a sinner but not totally depravity (Free Will) Conditional Election based on the foreknowledge of God (God does not predestine all things) Unlimited Atonement Resistible Grace Salvation Insecure Covenant Theology Johann Bullinger (1504-1575) Swiss He was the sole author of Second Helvetic Confession of 1566, which gives a clear statement of the Reformed doctrine. Reformed churches Johannes Wollebius, William Ames, Johannes Cocceius, Hermann Witsius Westminster Confession – 1647 Emphases of Covenantism A system of interpreting the Scriptures on the basis of two covenants: the covenant of works and the covenant of grace. Some add the covenant of redemption. Importance of grace – In every age, believers are always saved by grace.
  • Nietzsche's Platonism

    Nietzsche's Platonism

    CHAPTER 1 NIETZSCHE’S PLATONISM TWO PROPER NAMES. Even if modified in form and thus conjoined. As such they broach an interval. The various senses of this legacy, of Nietzsche’s Platonism, are figured on this interval. The interval is gigantic, this interval between Plato and Nietzsche, this course running from Plato to Nietzsche and back again. It spans an era in which a battle of giants is waged, ever again repeating along the historical axis the scene already staged in Plato’s Sophist (246a–c). It is a battle in which being is at stake, in which all are exposed to not being, as to death: it is a gigantomac√a p'r¥ t›V o¶s√aV. As the Eleatic Stranger stages it, the battle is between those who drag every- thing uranic and invisible down to earth, who thus define being as body, and those others who defend themselves from an invisible po- sition way up high, who declare that being consists of some kind of intelligibles (nohtº) and who smash up the bodies of the others into little bits in their l¬goi, philosophizing, as it were, with the hammer of l¬goV. Along the historical axis, in the gigantic interval from Plato to Nietzsche, the contenders are similarly positioned for the ever re- newed battle. They, too, take their stance on one side or the other of the interval—again, a gigantic interval—separating the intelligible from the visible or sensible, t¿ noht¬n from t¿ aÎsqht¬n. Those who station themselves way up high are hardly visible from below as they wield their l¬goi and shield themselves by translating their very position into words: m'tΩ tΩ fusikº.
  • A Study of the History of the Office of High Priest

    A Study of the History of the Office of High Priest

    Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive Theses and Dissertations 2006-07-18 A Study of the History of the Office of High Priest John D. Lawson Brigham Young University - Provo Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd Part of the History of Christianity Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Lawson, John D., "A Study of the History of the Office of High Priest" (2006). Theses and Dissertations. 749. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd/749 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. A STUDY OF THE HISTORY OF THE OFFICE OF HIGH PRIEST by John Lawson A thesis submitted to the faculty of Brigham Young University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Masters of Arts Religious Education Brigham Young University July 2006 Copyright © 2006 John D. Lawson All Rights Reserved ii BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY GRADUATE COMMITTEE APPROVAL Of a thesis submitted by John D. Lawson This thesis has been read by each member of the following graduate committee and has been found to be satisfactory. ___________________________ ____________________________________ Date Craig J. Ostler, Chair ___________________________ ____________________________________ Date Joseph F. McConkie ___________________________ ____________________________________ Date Guy L. Dorius iii BRIGHAM YOUNG UNIVERSITY As chair of the candidate’s graduate committee, I have read the thesis of John D. Lawson in its final form and have found that (1) its format, citations, and bibliographical style are consistent and acceptable and fulfill university and department style requirements; (2) its illustrative materials including figures, tables, and charts are in place; and (3) the final manuscript is satisfactory to the graduate committee and is ready for submission to the university library.
  • Read Article

    Read Article

    Title: "Not Buying in to Words and Letters: Zen, Ideology, and Prophetic Critique" Author: Christopher Ives Word length: 2515 Date of Submission: May 2, 2006 Professional Address: Department of Religious Studies, Stonehill College, 320 Washington Street, Duffy 257, Easton, MA 02357-4010 Email: [email protected] Phone: 508-565-1354 Abstract: Judging from the active participation of Zen leaders and institutions in modern Japanese imperialism, one might conclude that by its very nature Zen succumbs easily to ideological co-optation. Several facets of Zen epistemology and institutional history support this conclusion. At the same time, a close examination of Zen theory and praxis indicates that the tradition does possess resources for resisting dominant ideologies and engaging in ideology critique. Not Buying in to Words and Letters: Zen, Ideology, and Prophetic Critique D.T. Suzuki once proclaimed that Zen is "extremely flexible in adapting itself to almost any philosophy and moral doctrine" and "may be found wedded to anarchism or fascism, communism or democracy, atheism or idealism, or any political or economic dogmatism."1 Scholars have recently delineated how, in the midst of Japan's expansionist imperialism, Zen exhibited that flexibility in "adapting itself" and 1 becoming "wedded" to the reigning imperial ideology. And for all of its rhetoric about "not relying on words and letters" and functioning compassionately as a politically detached, iconoclastic religion, Zen has generally failed to criticize ideologies—and specific social and political conditions—that stand in tension with core Buddhist values. Several facets of Zen may account for its ideological co-optation before and during WWII.
  • Health Care Ethics and Casuistry

    Health Care Ethics and Casuistry

    Jrournal ofmedical ethics, 1992, 18, 61-62, 66 J Med Ethics: first published as 10.1136/jme.18.2.61 on 1 June 1992. Downloaded from Guest editorial: A personal view Health care ethics and casuistry Robin Downie University ofGlasgow In an editorial (1) Dr Gillon looks at some recent method of teaching and discussing medical ethics. The difficulties which have been raised about philosophy answer to Smith here is to point out that what is taking and the teaching ofhealth care ethics. This matter is of place in such discussions is a form of what he calls sufficient importance to the readers of this journal that 'natural jurisprudence'. It is an attempt to translate it is worth looking at it again, this time in an historical into case law, to give concrete application to, the ideals perspective. contained in codes. If natural jurisprudence is a One claim which is often made by those advocating legitimate activity, so too is this. the study of health care ethics is that such a study will Smith's second group ofarguments against casuistry assist in the solving of what have come to be called are to the effect that it does not 'animate us to what is 'ethical dilemmas'. Since health care ethics is so widely generous and noble' but rather teaches us 'to chicane taught for this reason the claim is worth examining. Is with our consciences' (4). Smith is certainly correct in health care ethics in this sense possible? Is it desirable? claiming that casuistry is concerned mainly with whatcopyright. Is it philosophy? In other words, can a case be made out is required or forbidden, that is, with rules, rather than for what earlier centuries called 'casuistry, or the with questions of motivation.
  • Nietzsche's Ethic

    Nietzsche's Ethic

    Nietzsche’s Ethic: Virtues for All and None? A thesis submitted To Kent State University in partial Fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts by Daniel Robinson May 2015 ©Copyright All rights reserved Except for previously published materials Thesis written by Daniel Robinson B.A., University of South Alabama, 2012 M.A., Kent State University, 2015 Approved by Linda Williams, Associate Professor, Masters Advisor Deborah Barnbaum, Chair, Department of Philosophy James Blank, Associate Dean, Dean of Arts and Sciences Table of Contents Introduction……………………………………………………….……………......01 Chapter I. Solomon’s Nietzsche: A Summary………………….………….....04 Introduction…………………………………..………...………….04 Concern for Character …………………………………………….05 Passion as the Root to the Virtues…………………………..……..15 Building Nietzsche’s Ethic: Virtues for All……………….….…...22 II. Nietzsche on Ethics……………………………………...……..….32 Introduction………………………………………………………..32 Custom & Natural Morality……………………………………….35 Master-type and Slave-type Moralities…………………………...41 Slave-type’s Universalization ……………………………………48 Nietzsche on Virtue and Virtues …………………….……………52 III. Ethical Contortions: Fitting Nietzsche into Virtue Ethics……...…59 Introduction…………………………………………………….…59 Against a Prescriptive Interpretation……………………….….….60 Redefining Virtue and Ethics……………………………….….…64 Nietzsche’s Individualism …………………………………..…....74 Relevant Bibliography…………………………………………………………….83 i Introduction A year ago I read Robert Solomon’s Living with Nietzsche: What the Great “Immoralist” Has to Teach Us for the first time with the hopes of finding a greater understanding of both Nietzsche and virtue ethics. I was undecided on whether Nietzsche was a virtue ethicist, but I was considering it, simply because of how frequently he mentions virtue and because Aristotle was one of the few major philosophers I knew of that Nietzsche didn’t routinely, vehemently reject. The beginning and middle of Solomon’s text made me very hopeful for his conclusion.
  • The Response to Joseph Smith's Innovations in the Second

    The Response to Joseph Smith's Innovations in the Second

    Utah State University DigitalCommons@USU All Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 5-2011 Recreating Religion: The Response to Joseph Smith’s Innovations in the Second Prophetic Generation of Mormonism Christopher James Blythe Utah State University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/etd Part of the American Studies Commons, Religion Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Blythe, Christopher James, "Recreating Religion: The Response to Joseph Smith’s Innovations in the Second Prophetic Generation of Mormonism" (2011). All Graduate Theses and Dissertations. 916. https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/etd/916 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. RECREATING RELIGION: THE RESPONSE TO JOSEPH SMITH’S INNOVATIONS IN THE SECOND PROPHETIC GENERATION OF MORMONISM by Christopher James Blythe A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS in History Approved: _________________________ _________________________ Philip L. Barlow, ThD Daniel J. McInerney, PhD Major Professor Committee Member _________________________ _________________________ Richard Sherlock, PhD Byron R. Burnham, EdD Committee Member Dean of Graduate Studies UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY Logan, Utah 2010 ii Copyright © Christopher James Blythe 2010 All rights reserved. iii ABSTRACT Recreating Religion: The Response to Joseph Smith’s Innovations in the Second Prophetic Generation of Mormonism by Christopher James Blythe, Master of Arts Utah State University, 2010 Major Professor: Philip Barlow Department: History On June 27, 1844, Joseph Smith, the founder of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, was assassinated.
  • The-Synoptic-Problem.Pdf

    The-Synoptic-Problem.Pdf

    THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM: AN INTRODUCTION Clinton Baldwin, Ph.D. THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM ● The Gospels: Matthew, Mark and Luke are called the Synoptic gospels, because they have basically the same plot and many stories in common. Therefore can be “seen together” ● Synoptic means “to see together” Not only do these gospels tell many of the same stories, they often do so using the same words. Such practice is solid indication that the gospels have similar source(s), as it is highly unlikely for three different persons writing at different times and places should use the same words and sequence of events unless they have some common literary dependence 3 THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM ● But the Synoptics not only agree, they also disagree in wording and sequence of events ● Definition: The Synoptic problem has to do with the wide-ranging agreements and disagreements among the three Synoptic Gospels John’s Gospel is different from the Synoptic Gospels ● In John there is: – No genealogy – No manger or virgin birth – No boyhood – No baptism – No temptation – No Mount of Transfiguration John’s Gospel is different from the Synoptic Gospels ▪ In John there is: -No Gethsemane -No scribes -No lepers -No publicans -No demoniacs -No parables -Never cast out a demon Examples of the Synoptic Problem ● Mark 14:12;15:25- Jesus crucified day after the Passover ● John 19:14 - Jesus crucified day before the Passover ● Lk 2:39 - Jesus and family returned to Nazareth a month after going to Bethlehem ● Matt 2:19-22: They fled into Egypt Examples of the Synoptic Problem ● Matt