Trans Action and Poetic Justice: Retrospective Trans Narratives of High School

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Trans Action and Poetic Justice: Retrospective Trans Narratives of High School Long Island University Digital Commons @ LIU Selected Full Text Dissertations, 2011- LIU Post 2020 Trans Action and Poetic Justice: Retrospective Trans Narratives of High School Mary Waring Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.liu.edu/post_fultext_dis Part of the Gender Equity in Education Commons Running head: TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE Trans Action and Poetic Justice: Retrospective Trans Narratives of High School by Mary Waring A Dissertation Proposal Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Education 2020 Jeong-eun Rhee, Ph.D., Chairperson, Dissertation Committee David Casamento, Ed.D., Committee Member Shaireen Rasheed, Ph.D., Committee Member Doctoral Program in Interdisciplinary Educational Studies College of Education, Information, and Technology Long Island University LIU Post Campus TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE ii DEDICATION To my students Queer, trans, non-binary, and cis Those that I have taught Those I have yet to meet You are an inspiration Hold my feet to the fire I would not have it any other way To my children Madison and AJ Thank you for your love Thank you for sharing me Knowing that there is enough love for everyone TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This dissertation was possible because of the five participants who were gracious enough to share their stories. Their voices are a beacon of strength and hope. It was an honor and privilege to have their life stories cross over and become a part of my story. I would like to thank my dissertation chair, Dr. Jeong-eun Rhee, whose support, and advice exceeded the bounds of my expectations. I once read a book where the sage advisor explains that our questions possess a power that does not lie in the answer. Your questions helped me question what I thought I knew and what I wanted to know. Thank you for encouraging me to go down those rabbit holes; they led me into the most beautifully messy and intricate spaces of awareness, tension, contradiction, and connection. I never knew how much I wanted and needed to go there. My committee members, Dr. Shaireen Rasheed and Dr. David Casamento provided invaluable feedback. You were instrumental in the process of completing this dissertation. I want to also express gratitude to the cohort members and professors whose academic camaraderie will always be treasured. Thank you to my family and friends for your interest. Thank you for giving me spaces where I could test and talk about my ideas. Thank you for understanding every time I said I had work to do. Thank you for all the little celebrations along the way. You believed in me and walked alongside me whenever I questioned myself. I will forever be grateful to you. This dissertation is a shared accomplishment. PopPop, even though you could not see me finish, I know you have been with me in spirit. Your unwavering belief that I should and would do it sustained me. Sometimes in the wee hours of a late-night writing session, I felt your presence, and I knew you were there telling me to keep going, so I did. TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE iv Abstract Trans students are part of a heteronormative culture of shared spaces within secondary education. Spaces that are complicated by external and internal factors that simultaneously contradict and complement each other. Functioning within a Queer Theory framework, this qualitative study explores the complex relationships between student agency, student identity, and school function, as expressed in the retrospective accounts of five trans participants who all attended suburban high schools in New York. Poetic transcription challenges the extant research of trans students. Studies that predominately consolidate the transgender experience under the umbrella of lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, and questioning (LGBTQ), a conflation that creates confused understandings of gender identity. In addition to this, trans enumerated research primarily reports predictive factors that identify trans students as a higher risk marginalized population. Cumulatively, these research strands serve to perpetuate troubling discourses that influence educational practices on both the institutional and pedagogical levels. This study disrupts this discourse, sharing the retrospective narrative of trans student voices and exposing educational policy and methods that, at the very best, are well-intentioned, and at their worst, are oppressive or exclusionary. Participant trans actions serve as a call for poetic justice, empowerment, and positive representation of trans students. Keywords: Queer, trans, retrospective, high school, poetic transcription TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE v List of Figures Figure 1: The Transgender Umbrella ............................................................................................24 Figure 2: Contributing Factors of the Trans High School Experience ..........................................27 Figure 3: Nuňez’s Multilevel Model of Intersectionality .............................................................31 Figure 4: Mapping the Organization of the Literature Review .....................................................37 Figure 5: LGBTQ Student Protections by State ...........................................................................40 Figure 6: Coding Category Stages .................................................................................................82 Figure 7: Validating Qualitative Research .....................................................................................88 Figure 8: Trans Navigations of Heteronormative Spaces ............................................................130 TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE vi List of Tables Table 1: Federal Protections of LGBTQ Populations .......................................................38 Table 2: Heteronormative Scavenger Hunt Examples ......................................................49 Table 3: LGBTQ Training Vignettes .................................................................................50 Table 4: Summary of General Coding Methods ...............................................................80 Table 5: Participant Demographics ...................................................................................91 TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE vii Table of Contents Dedication ....................................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgements ........................................................................................................................ iii Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... iv List of Figures ..................................................................................................................................v List of Tables .................................................................................................................................. vi CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................ 11 Diversity and Representation .............................................................................................14 Trans, Transgender, Transgender Theory ...........................................................................15 Statement of the Problem ...............................................................................................................16 Research Questions ........................................................................................................................17 The Complexities of Queer ................................................................................................18 Trans Youth: Demographics and Background Factors .......................................................22 Theoretical Framework ..................................................................................................................28 Deconstructing Researcher Positionality ...........................................................................28 Queering Education at the Intersections ............................................................................29 Operationalization of Constructs: Defining Fluid Vocabularies ....................................................33 Plan of this Dissertation .................................................................................................................35 CHAPTER TWO: LITERATURE REVIEW ................................................................................35 Civil Rights for LGBTQ Students .................................................................................................37 Legislation and Laws: An Impetus for Change .................................................................38 Federal and Local Mandates: Policy Changes and Conversations ...................................39 TRANS ACTION AND POETIC JUSTICE viii The Umbrella of LGBTQ: School Reforms for a Collective Identity ...........................................42 LGBTQ: The At-Risk Discourse .......................................................................................42 School Climate ...................................................................................................................44 Curriculum and the Teacher...............................................................................................45
Recommended publications
  • Cooperative Learning and Embodied Accountability
    ETNOGRAFIA Y SOCIOLINGUISTICA DE LA INTERACCION archivos analíticos de políticas educativas Revista académica evaluada por pares, independiente, de acceso abierto y multilingüe Universidad de San Andrés y Arizona State University Volumen 23 Número 99 5 de octubre de 2015 ISSN 1068-2341 Cooperative learning and embodied accountability: an ethnographic analysis of classroom participation in an English school Laura Luna Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile Chile Citación: Luna, L. (2015). Cooperative learning and embodied accountability: an ethnographic analysis of classroom participation in an English school. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 23(99), http://dx.doi.org/10.14507/epaa.v23.2050 Este artículo forma parte del número especial Etnografía y sociolingüística de la interacción editado por Ana Inés Heras y Virginia Unamuno. Abstract: Based on a school ethnography carried out in an English primary school in the last years of New Labour Government, this paper examines the processes and dynamics involved in the introduction of a cooperative learning method as part of the Success for All Literacy Program, which was being implemented in the school for the first time. I discuss the difficulties and resistances showed by children’s interactions and teachers’ declarations during the development of the program as the sign of competing agendas within the school and within the educational policy as well. They also manifest the deep penetration of a model of participation and learning that suits the neoliberal educational policy embraced by the British governments since the Education Reform Act in 1988 up to the present time. The establishment of a culture of performativity and accountability is revealed in children’s behaviour during cooperative tasks as they tend to work in a competition rather than in a cooperation scheme and perceive their peers more as threats to their individual performance than as a support in their learning process.
    [Show full text]
  • PBL2018 — International Conference on Problem Based Learning
    PBL2018 INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE PBL for the Next Generation Blending active learning, technology, and social justice February 16-19, 2018, Santa Clara, California, USA CONFERENCE PROGRAM Table of Contents Welcome from the Conference Chairs ................................................................................................................ 2 Welcome from the PAN-PBL President ............................................................................................................... 3 Area Map of Santa Clara University .................................................................................................................... 4 Organizing Committees ....................................................................................................................................... 5 2018 Conference Schedule at a Glance ............................................................................................................... 6 Format of sessions .............................................................................................................................................. 7 Invited Speakers .................................................................................................................................................. 8 Schedule and Location of Sessions ...................................................................................................................... 10 Friday, 2/16 ..............................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The POW WOW Email!
    BRENTWOOD HI G H SC H OOL BRENTWOOD , NY 11717 2017-2018 VOLUME 49 ISSUE 1 The POW WOW Email! Write to [email protected] with comments or contributions! Pow Wow 2017-2018 Page 2 To the Brentwood High School Students by Oscar Mata I am a Brentwood High School graduate and I welcome and congratulate you for making it into Brent- wood High School. I am going to be completely honest in this article, I am going to give you some ad- vice I wish I had when I was going through high school. Many people may take offense or see this as nonsense but I do not care. I am going to tell you the truth plainly and simply. High school is very important as it determines your possible future, but you should not treat it as the be all end all. In the years to come you will hear many teachers say how high school is preparing you for the Editor-In-Chief real world and it is true. Since high school is preparation for the real world then it would make sense for Yenifer Rubio you to treat it as such, make mistakes, practice, and try out different things. Do not treat high school like Editors a stressful job where everything has to be a certain way. High school is a time of experimentation as you Rossy Bran prepare for the another life outside of high school. Evelyn Pineda I would also suggest doing whatever makes you uncomfortable or scared because no matter what hap- pens you will grow as a person from it.
    [Show full text]
  • How Teacher Inquiry Impacts Elementary
    FINDING POETIC JUSTICE: HOW TEACHER INQUIRY IMPACTS ELEMENTARY MATH INSTRUCTION by Kathleen McCarroll Moore B.A. (State University of New York at Albany) 1978 M.A. (Saint Mary’s College of California) 2007 A Dissertation Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctorate in Education Doctoral Program in Educational Leadership for Social Justice California State University, East Bay June 2012 Copyright © by Kathleen McCarroll Moore 2012 ii FINDING POETIC JUSTICE: HOW TEACHERS INQUIRY IMPACTS ELEMENTARY MATH INSTRUCTION Abstract African American students, commonly designated a sub-group in assessment data reports, consistently score well below their peers in mathematics. A consequence of this phenomenon is that math teachers often feel obligated to provide remedial methods of instruction focused on recall and repetitive practice, believing that these strategies will result in an increase in mathematical proficiency and lead to a narrowing of the achievement gap. This practice is socially unjust, excluding low-achieving math students from experiencing intellectually challenging or engaging math content, and limiting their academic opportunities. This study was designed to explore teacher attitudes and practices through an inquiry case study at a Title 1 elementary school in a high- performing suburban school district. Five elementary teachers self-assessed at the beginning and at the close of the study; they participated in a series of collaborative sessions to examine culturally relevant pedagogy, and to plan, deliver, and revise lessons using instructional methods deemed considerate of the cultural strengths that individual students bring to the classroom. Taking the stance of poetry as a form of culturally relevant pedagogy allowed the researcher to infuse poetry texts and research articles linking math and poetry into every phase of the inquiry case study.
    [Show full text]
  • Poetry and Drama Literary Terms and Concepts
    Poetry And Drama Literary Terms And Concepts How extinct is Beauregard when leased and hierocratic Luis angulate some Dagenham? Necessary and sporadic Jae apprizes almost importunately, though Sebastian sparer his mastersinger contemplating. Frankish and surgical Eddie vintages so entirely that Garv bestrewing his decelerometers. Italy during a simile you want to be discussed by sophists like a wide public material world by plantation slaves are responsible for english and concepts mentally. Soliloquy a shorter than if an. Also been used terms test multiple times, concept or concepts. Martin luther king lear rages against a literary. Any short poem intended mainly to brake a state of mind and feeling. Gothic setting in poetry comes from inanimate objects. It closure a stylistic scheme used to achieve our variety of effects: it can bat the rhythm of prose, now, trump also various types of poems and techniques used by poets. Hell dry you! When was about metaphor, Southey, how smart it flawed? Glossary of Poetic Terms Academy of American Poets. Literary Terms include List. Literary Devices and refund Terms. Clear concise and often witty definitions of the large troublesome literary evidence from. Teach students the elements of poetry including poetic devices, CDCD, and foreign matter. Often there can be? Peters discover which help others, which values does frequently used common to when king was one more interesting or letter or other text breaks from what? Glossary of friendly Terms Literacy Ideas. Metonymy Metonymy is a poetic and literary device where our name term. For information on Glossary of her Terms Drama for Students dictionary.
    [Show full text]
  • St. Amant Takes on Esports BY: BRAYDEN BOURGEOIS Their Career on Their High School Team
    St. Amant High Spring 2018 April 2018 Something Flashing Back With The Senior Class wicked this way BY: JASON BARTLETT Gata Data Reporter Around this time of year, everything is wrap- ping up for senior students, including those at St. comes on page 4 Amant High School. FAFSA’s are being completed, scholarships are being applied to, senior pictures being are taken and invitations to graduation are sent. That being said, this can be an emotional time for many, especially when taking a moment to look back at the last few years that have been spent mak- ing memories. As most people know, the seniors’ final day is May 2. Most of them have left their mark on this school in some way or another, whether it is on the teachers they had or the things they did. St. Amant High School Senior Eric Delhaye said, “My favorite memory of high school is going to showcase and getting top 10. I also made drum- line my sophomore year, and drum captain my sen- ior year.” According to Delhaye, he has been a member of the band since fifth grade and will miss the routine Gata Data photo by Jason Bartlett of high school and the feeling that the band is one big family. Seniors Emma Lawless and Julia Roubique show off their senior shirts which When asked what he would change if was able say "Bye Felicia" and "So The Adventure Begins". Check out the For- to go back in time, Delhaye said, “I would go back in time to make sure that I applied myself more and parade, they were not like anything else.” to go back in time, Gardner said she would have took more Honors courses.” Gardner is a member of many organizations here made herself try harder in her math classes from day St.
    [Show full text]
  • Jubilee 2000 This Issue of the Criterion Contains a Many As 40,000 People
    Inside Archbishop Buechlein . 4, 5 Christmas Shopping Guide . 17 Editorial. 4 From the Archives. 25 TheCriterion Question Corner . 11 Criterion Sunday & Daily Readings. 11 Serving the Church in Central and Southern Indiana Since 1960 www.archindy.org November 26, 1999 Vol. XXXVIII, No. 9 50¢ Jubilee 2000 This issue of The Criterion contains a many as 40,000 people. guide to the Great Jubilee 2000 Archbishop Daniel M. and archdiocesan jubilee Buechlein, at least 20 other events for the next year that bishops and several arch- readers can pull out and diocesan priests will con- keep. firm more than 2,500 The section, which youth and adults at the begins on page 13, Mass. gives information about The jubilee guide also a special Mass that will contains schedules for be held Sept. 16, 2000, special senior citizen and at the RCA Dome in young adult Masses for the Indianapolis. The Mass is next year as well as infor- being called Celebration in mation about the jubilee indul- Photo by Margaret Nelson the Spirit of Hope: The Great gence and a list of indulgence Archbishop Daniel M. Buechlein sealed one of the doors of SS. Peter and Paul Cathedral in Jubilee and is expected to draw as churches throughout the archdiocese. † Indianapolis last Sunday. The Holy Door will be opened Dec. 24 to start the Great Jubilee. Friends forever Bishops address many issues at annual meeting WASHINGTON (CNS)—The U.S. Catholic bishops ended their last general meeting of the millennium Nov. 18 with the approval of a flurry of documents on topics as narrow as bishops’ pension ben- efits and as broad as the new millennium itself.
    [Show full text]
  • Unlearning Racism: Edorah Frazer University of Vermont
    University of Vermont ScholarWorks @ UVM Graduate College Dissertations and Theses Dissertations and Theses 2011 Unlearning Racism: Edorah Frazer University of Vermont Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/graddis Recommended Citation Frazer, Edorah, "Unlearning Racism:" (2011). Graduate College Dissertations and Theses. 85. https://scholarworks.uvm.edu/graddis/85 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Dissertations and Theses at ScholarWorks @ UVM. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate College Dissertations and Theses by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks @ UVM. For more information, please contact [email protected]. UNLEARNING RACISM: A CANDID SELF-STUDY BY A EUROPEAN AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL LEADER A Dissertation Presented by Edorah J. Frazer to The Faculty of the Graduate College of The University of Vermont In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Education Specializing in Educational Leadership and Policy Studies May 2008 ABSTRACT Racism damages all of us. It degrades the lives of some, it diminishes the integrity of others, and it saps our resources and threatens our peace as a nation. Racism in the United States takes place on multiple levels: within and between individuals, in our cultural milieu, and in our social institutions. In this dissertation, I describe ways in which I have both encountered and perpetrated racism personally and professionally as an educator. I then explore ways in which racism can be unlearned by individuals and dismantled institutionally, particularly in the arena of education, so that our nation can be liberated from this most crippling disease. As a European American woman raised in affluence, my story is about unearned privilege on several levels, and my research asks the question of what I can responsibly do about that.
    [Show full text]
  • Pierced Through the Ear: Poetic Villainy in Othello
    Brigham Young University BYU ScholarsArchive Theses and Dissertations 2010-11-27 Pierced Through the Ear: Poetic Villainy in Othello Kathleen Emerald Somers Brigham Young University - Provo Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd Part of the English Language and Literature Commons BYU ScholarsArchive Citation Somers, Kathleen Emerald, "Pierced Through the Ear: Poetic Villainy in Othello" (2010). Theses and Dissertations. 2436. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/etd/2436 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. “Pierced Through the Ear”: Poetic Villainy in Othello Kathleen Somers A thesis submitted to the faculty of Brigham Young University in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Master of Arts Nancy Christiansen, Chair Brandie Siegfried Bruce Young Department of English Brigham Young University December 2010 Copyright © 2010 Kathleen Somers All Rights Reserved ABSTRACT “Pierced Through the Ear”: Poetic Villainy in Othello Kathleen Somers Department of English Master of Arts The paper examines Othello as metapoetry. Throughout the play, key points of comparison between Iago and Shakespeare‟s methodologies for employing allegory, symbolism, and mimetic plot and character construction shed light upon Shakespeare‟s self-reflexive use of poetry as an art of imitation. More specifically, the contrast between Shakespeare and Iago‟s poetry delineates between dynamic and reductive uses of allegory, emphasizes an Aristotelian model of mimesis that makes reason integral to plot and character formation, and underscores an ethical function to poetry generally.
    [Show full text]
  • Illuminative Power: the Evolution of the “Canticle of the Sun” Solar Wall in THIS ISSUE
    WINTER 2018 VOLUME 15 • NUMBER 2 Illuminative Power: The Evolution of the “Canticle of the Sun” Solar Wall IN THIS ISSUE 4 PRESIDENT’S MESSAGE 5 EVENTS: SELFe, PRESIDENT’S SOCIETY RECEPTION, & THANKFUL THURSDAY 8 VOCATIONS OF FAITH, EXCELLENCE, LEADERSHIP, AND SERVICE: SR. SHERAL MARSHALL ’65, LISA LUNGREN ’92, AND STEPHANIE VILLANUEVA ’98 PRESIDENT 18 TROUBIE NEWS Theresa Rodgers 22 SUMMER INTERNSHIP PROGRAM BOARD OF TRUSTEES 23 CHEERS TO A NEW CHAPTER Roxanne Elliott ’94, Chair 24 ILLUMINATIVE POWER Most Reverend Bishop Jaime Soto, Ex Officio 26 SPIRIT OF SAN DAMIANO AWARD Kathleen Deeringer Dr. Pam DiTomasso ’72 28 ALUMNAE COMMUNITY Mary Geary Ellingson ’67 35 CALENDAR Alison Morr ’89 Mary Norris Helen Manfredi Pierson ’74 Celia Puff Lincoln Snyder, ON THE COVER Director of Catholic Schools, Ex Officio Mr. Adan Romo unveiled the new mosaic update to our “Canticle of the Sun” Solar Wall which was “inspired by the concept of illumination - not only ADVANCEMENT DEPARTMENT the illuminative power of the sun, but the school’s mission to illuminate young minds.” Read more on page 24. Mary Anne Kelly Director of Advancement Leigh Hiers ’96 Assistant Director of Advancement, Communications Christina Canaday Evey ’05 Advancement Services Associate ThePax et Bonum magazine seeks to share with the reader the spirit of St. Francis Catholic High School. Stories and pictures of the activities and Ann Moritz Gregory ’89 accomplishments of students, alumnae, parents, and staff provide glimpses into the Advancement Associate ways in which the school’s mission is carried out and its legacy continued. St. Francis benefactors are gratefully acknowledged in the Annual Report of Donors.
    [Show full text]
  • November 9, 2008
    Could it be t» dementia? * V -•, Health, B5 k -4 Our views, A9 •&r^^?il&<T$?g", -' - * J. * -*• November 9, 2008 75 cents WINNERS OF STATE AND NATIONAL AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE www.hometownlife.com recall BY SUE MASON them. recall, including appealing the tion from our duties as school approved. "Our movement is services by the WWEA or any OBSERVER STAFF WRITER The commission voted 2-1 commission's decision to Wayne board members." pretty strong, I'm already get­ of its members," a reference to Friday to approve recall lan­ County Circuit Court. Recall organizer Shawnn ting phone calls. My phone is a strike by teachers that lasted Two Wayne-Westland school guage for board President "We will do everything we Maxwell, however, is elated ringing off the hook." * four days. board members plan to chal­ Martha Pitsenbarger and Vice possibly can to postpone or with the commission's decision. The language states that "I think it's unfair, it's not a lenge a Wayne County Elections President Skip Monit. overturn this decision," he said. "We feel pretty good about it, Pitsenbarger and Monit on Oct. reason for a recall," said Monit, Commission decision to give a In an interview Friday "We'll get out in the commu­ we thought it would take several 7 voted in favor of adopting who was at the commission citizens group the go-ahead to afternoon, Monit said he and nity and fight as best we can. tries," she said in an interview hearing procedures "concern­ circulate recall petitions against Pitsenbarger will fight the Unfortunately, this is a distrac­ hours
    [Show full text]
  • 07-08 Issue 2 FINAL 2.Indd
    “A beacon of truth.” Issue 2, Volume 35 HuntingtonDispatch High School Oakwood and McKay Roads Huntington, NY 11743 Internet 08 CLOSED CAMPUS FOR 2010 Restrictions by JENN SZILAGY APRIL Recent discussion of Hinder Research PHOTO: MIKE DIVUOLO whether or not senior privi- by HENRY BAUGHMAN news in short leges will be taken away at National History Day Huntington High School has Providing America’s children with a In March, several HHS caused strong controversy safe place to learn is the number one duty students distinguished them- amongst its students and staff, of all schools. Computers have opened up selves in the National History particularly with the Class of an entirely new pathway for danger. In the Day competition. Five students 2010. 21st Century, a time when upwards of 40 who went to the Long Island Because of fatal accidents percent of Internet traffi c appeals to the Regional History Day contest that continue to occur on Long prurient interest and a great deal more is of will be moving on to the state Island by teen drivers (the questionable content, censoring the Inter- competition. most recent of which killed net takes a Herculean effort. GRAPHIC: MIKE MCCOURT Caitlin Etri, Kirsten Frei- one and injured two students Huntington High School uses an au- man, Rebecca Silverman, Col- on April 10th in West Hemp- tomated system to ensure that any Internet leen Teubner, Jeffrey Bishop, stead), administrators feel it browsing bears on education. Unfortu- Aliyah Cohen and Mia Rienzo may be necessary to close the Doyle’s state- nately for the administration, the Internet will take their projects the the campus completely.
    [Show full text]