Opening of Greenacre Park

GREENACRE PARK

A VEST-POCKET PARK IN MIDTOWN MANHATTAN

51ST ST BETWEEN 2ND AND 3RD AVE

MAY 2017 OPENING OF GREENACRE PARK

• Abby Rockefeller Mauze dedicated the Park in 1971 to the people of New York City “…in the hope that they will find here some moments of serenity in this busy world.”

• 1 of only 2 Private Gifts that created and maintained a park for the public in New York City with an endowment to maintain in perpetuity. GREENACRE PARK EAST MIDTOWN • Greenacre is a Park, not a Private Open Public Space (POPS) - NOT created for a building bonus

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 2 ORIGINAL SASAKI DESIGN EXISTS TODAY

Elevated several feet above sidewalk with 60 feet of street frontage

Three different levels • Central Area which is home to a grove of honey locust trees • Raised Terrace protected by a trellis roof with heating elements for cooler weather • Sunken Level at the rear of the Park

Water theme • 25-foot waterfall with a pool at its base • A fountain at the entrance • Water streams down the east wall into a brook which runs from the sidewalk entrance to the waterfall

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 3 SUMMARY OF INCREMENTAL SHADOWS EAST MIDTOWN REZONING SHADOW FROM EAST + CURRENT CONDITIONS WORST CASE HEIGHTS WORST-CASE HEIGHTS

MAY/ AUG 6 FROM EAST 1:45PM 1:45PM 1:45PM 4 hour 25 minutes

+ VS.

WORST-CASE HEIGHTS

INCREMENTAL SHADOW 7:15AM 5:18PM 5:18PM 5:18PM 1 hour 20 minutes

= TOTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 5 hour 45 minutes 6:27AM-7:15AM, 1:45PM-3:10PM, 4:25PM-5:18PM 3:10PM-4:30PM 7:15AM-11:40AM + 3:10PM-4:30PM

JUN 21 FROM EAST 4 hour 35 minutes 1:25PM 1:25PM 1:25PM

VS. VS.

WORST-CASE HEIGHTS INCREMENTAL SHADOW 7:15AM

6:01PM 6:01PM 2 hours 39 minutes 6:01PM

= TOTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 7 hour 14 minutes 5:57AM-6:45AM, 1:25PM-2:25PM, 5:15PM-6:01PM 2:36PM-5:15PM 7:15AM-11:50AM + 2:36PM-5:15PM

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 4 2ND & 3RD AVE GREENACRE PARK SUN/SHADOW ANALYSIS

1. Existing Shadows and Potential Rezoning Impacts 2. Building Height Analysis 3. Potential Additional Shading from East

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 5 1. EXISTING SHADOWS AND POTENTIAL REZONING IMPACTS

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study December, 2016 6 EXISTING SHADOWS

8AM 1:45PM 1:30PM

2:15PM 4:30PM 5:15PM

MARCH 21 / SEPTEMBER 21 (SPRING/FALL EQUINOX) MAY 6 / AUGUST 6 JUNE 21 (SUMMER SOLSTICE) EXISTING SUNLIGHT PERIODS EXISTING SUNLIGHT PERIODS EXISTING SUNLIGHT PERIODS 8AM-8:30AM 7:15AM - 1:45PM 6:45AM-1:25PM & & & 8:35AM-2:15PM 3:10PM - 4:25PM 2:25PM - 5:15PM

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 7 SHADOW STUDY AREA BOUNDARY One Vanderbilt potential shadow Potential DEIS identified sites and shadow range E E U U N N

E E E E

U U

V V The hatched areas can

N N

A EAST 58 STREET A EAST 58 STREET •

E E

V V

E E

A N A N

U U

E E

E E E E O O

N N

U U

U U U U T T

N N

E E

N N

N N N N G G

O O

V V

E E

E E E E

S N S N

A A potentially shade the

V V

V V V V I I

I I

A A

A A A A X X

D D

K K

E E

A A

R 3 R 3

5 5 2 2 L L

M M

A A

P P WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET Greenacre Park based on the methodologies in CEQR

WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET Technical Manual.

WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET

WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET

WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET

WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET K N WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET E U N

E E

U V

A EAST 58 STREET

V J E

A N

E E E O

U U U T

N N N G

WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET V

E E E

S N

V V V I

A A A X

R 3 5 2 L

P 7 11 WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET

WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET D C 10 WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET WEST 48 STREET EAST 48 STREET WEST 48 STREET EAST 48 STREET

TRUE NORTH WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET 6 9 WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET I M 5 WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET 4 WE16ST 52 STREET SUN/SHADOW STUDY FOR GREENACRE PARKEAST 52 STREET WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET Greenacre Park 3 L RADIUS = 4.3 X 1,400’ (BLDG HEIGHT) WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET WEST 43 STREET +108° EAST 43 STREET WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET Potential Blocks Can Shade Greenacre Park WEST 50 STREET 15 EAST 50 STREET

WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET

-108° WEST 49 STREET DCP EAST MIDTOWN REZONING EAST 49 STREET EAST 41 STREET EAST 41 STREET Proposed Greater East 2 B H 8 WEST 48 STREET Midtown Rezoning Boundary EAST 48 STREET WEST 40 STREET WEST 40 STREET Vanderbilt Corridor 1 A WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET

WEST 39 STREET WEST 39 STREET Projected Development Sites (RWCDS) N N WEST 46 STREET Potential Development Sites (RWCDS)EAST 46 STREET WEST 38 STREET WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 0 200 600 1,000 Feet Feet WEST 45 STREET Open Space EAST 45 STREET Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 8 WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET

WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET

WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET

EAST 41 STREET

WEST 40 STREET

WEST 39 STREET N

WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 Feet SITES FOR ADDITIONAL STUDY E E U U N N

E E E E

U U V V

N N

A EAST 58 STREET A EAST 58 STREET

E E

V V

E E

A N A N

U U

E E

E E E E O O

N N

U U

U U U U T T

N N

E E

N N

N N N N G G

O O

V V

E E

E E E E

S N S N

A A

V V

V V V V I I

I I

A A

A A A A X X

D D

K K

E E

A A

R 3 R 3

5 5 2 2 L L

M M

A A

P P WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET • Based on analysis of existing building shadows, six sites WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET identified in the DEIS have the

WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET potential to shade Greenacre Park under the proposed WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET rezoning

WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET

WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET

WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET J J WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET 11 7 11 WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET 10 10 E

D C U N

E E

WEST 48 STREET EAST 48 STREET WEST 48 STREET EAST 48 STREET U V

A EAST 58 STREET

A N

E E E O

U U U T

N N N G

E E E

S N

V V V I

A A A X

WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET R 3 5 2 L

P 6 WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET

WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET

WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET

WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET WEST 43 STREET WEST 54 STERAESET T43 STREET EAST 54 STREET

WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET

EAST 41 STREET EAST 41 STREET WEST 52 STREET SUN/SHADOW STUDY FOR GREENACRE PARKEAST 52 STREET

WEST 40 STREET WEST 40 STREET Greenacre Park WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET

WEST 39 STREET WEST 39 STREET Potential Blocks Can Shade N N Greenacre Park WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET WEST 38 STREET WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 0 200 600 1,000 MAY 6 / AUGUST 6 Feet JUNE 21 (SUMMER SOLSTICE) Feet WEST 49 STREET DCP EAST MIDTOWN REZONING EAST 49 STREET TIMEFRAME WINDOWS SHADED BY THE SITES TIMEFRAME WINDOWS SHADED BY THE SITES Proposed Greater East 3:10PM-4:30PM 2:36PM-5:15PM WEST 48 STREET Midtown Rezoning Boundary EAST 48 STREET Vanderbilt Corridor

NO NEED FOR FURTHER STUDY WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET - SITE 6: No need further study due to the long distance to the Park and the Projected Development Sites (RWCDS) Park will be shaded by this site less than 25 mintues. WEST 46 STREET Potential Development Sites (RWCDS)EAST 46 STREET

WEST 45 STREET Open Space EAST 45 STREET Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 9 WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET

WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET

WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET

EAST 41 STREET

WEST 40 STREET

WEST 39 STREET N

WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 Feet 2. BUILDING HEIGHT ANALYSIS

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study December, 2016 10 E U N

E E

U V

A EAST 58 STREET

A N

E E E O

U U U T

N N N G

E E E

S N

V V V I

A A A X

R 3 5 2 L

P WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET

WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET

WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET

WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET

WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET

WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET

WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET

WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET

WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET E U N

E E

U V

A EAST 58 STREET WEST 48 STREET E EAST 48 STREET

A N

E E E O

U U U T

N N N G

E E E

S N

V V V I

A A A X

R 3 5 2 L

P WEST 57 STRWEEESTT 47 STREET EAST 57 STERAESET 47 STREET

WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET

WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET

WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET

WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET DEIS BUILDING HEIGHTS WEST 53 STREET 53 st EAST 53 STREET DEIS BUILDINGS HEIGHTS ARE SHORTER THAN ALLOWABLE & NEW CONSTRUCTION WEST 52 STRWEEESTT 42 STREET EAST 52 STREEEATST 42 STREET

WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREEEATST 41 STREET J WEST 50 STRWEEESTT 40 STREET EAST 50 STREET 7 11

WEST 49 STRWEEESTT 39 STREET EAST 49 STREET N D C 10

WEST 48 STRWEEESTT 38 STREET EAST 48 STREET 480 st200 600 1,000 Feet

WEST 47 STREET key map EAST 47 STREET

WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET +1396’ +1500’ +1350’ WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET

WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET 1,000’ +1050’

WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET +818’ +803’ +720’ WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET +650’ +580’ +524’ +552’ EAST 41 STREET

WEST 40 STREET

WEST 39 STREET N

WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 SITE 7 SITE 10 SITE 11 SITE C SITE D SITE J 53 W 53 ST 111 W 57 ST 138 E 50 ST 432 PARK AVE 217 W 57 ST Feet

LOT AREA 20,900 SF 41,100 SF 24,700 SF 34,000 SF 21,100 SF 22,300 SF 18,500 SF 20,600 SF 11,900 SF 39,400 SF 40,700 SF

MAX FAR 25.0 21.6 23.0 21.6 18.0 18.0 8.0-15.0 15.0 12.0 15.0 15.0

GREAT EAST MIDTOWN REZONING DRAFT EIS (DEIS) CURRENTLY BEING DEVELOPED OR RECENTLY BUILT

18.0 - 25.0 8.0-15.0

MAX FAR > MAX FAR 552’-818’ > 803’-1500’ BLDG HEIGHTS BLDG HEIGHTS

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 11 E U N

E E

U V

A EAST 58 STREET

A N

E E E O

U U U T

N N N G

E E E

S N

V V V I

A A A X

R 3 5 2 L

P WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET

WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET

WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET

WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET

WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET

WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET

WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET

WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET

WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET E U N

E E

U V

A EAST 58 STREET WEST 48 STREET E EAST 48 STREET

A N

E E E O

U U U T

N N N G

E E E

S N

V V V I

A A A X

R 3 5 2 L

P WEST 57 STRWEEESTT 47 STREET EAST 57 STERAESET 47 STREET

WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET

WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET

WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET

WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET TRIGGER HEIGHTS AND WORST-CASE BUILDING HEIGHTS WEST 53 STREET 53 st EAST 53 STREET ESTIMATED BUILDING HEIGHTS CASTING 20-MINUTE AND MAX AMOUNT SHADOWS WEST 52 STRWEEESTT 42 STREET EAST 52 STREEEATST 42 STREET

WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREEEATST 41 STREET J WEST 50 STRWEEESTT 40 STREET EAST 50 STREET 7 11

WEST 49 STRWEEESTT 39 STREET EAST 49 STREET N D C 10

WEST 48 STRWEEESTT 38 STREET EAST 48 STREET 480 st200 600 1,000 Feet

WEST 47 STREET key map EAST 47 STREET

WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET 1,000’

WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET

WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET

WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET

WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET

EAST 41 STREET 818’ 715’ 840’ 580’ 650’ 1425’ 720’ 425’ 1116’ 650’ 915’ 1315’ 524’ 975’ 1230’ 552’ 660’ 230’

WEST 40 STREET SITE 7 SITE 10 SITE 11 SITE C SITE D SITE J WEST 39 STREET CURRENT HEIGHT 310’ 190’ 210’ 295’ 220’ 230’ N

WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 Feet

20 MINS MAX SHADOW SHADOW LEGEND CURRENT DEIS TRIGGER WORST-CASE HEIGHTS HEIGHTS HEIGHTS HEIGHTS DEIS HEIGHTS (THE PROJECTED SITES) SITE 7 310 818 715’ 840’ DEIS HEIGHTS (THE POTENTIAL SITES) SITE 10 190 580 650’ 1425’ TRIGGER HEIGHTS are measured when the SITE 11 210 720 425’ 1116’ potential buildings starts to cast shadow on the Greenacre Park and have an effect SITE C 295 650 915’ 1315’ of 20 minutes reduction in sunlight. SITE D 220 524 975’ 1230’ WORST-CASE HEIGHTS are measured when SITE J 230 552 230’ 660’ the potential buildings fully cast a shadow on Greenacre Park. Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 12 E E U U N N

E E E E

U U V V

N N

A EAST 58 STREET A EAST 58 STREET

E E

V V

E E

A N A N

U U

E E

E E E E O O

N N

U U

U U U U T T

N N

E E

N N

N N N N G G

O O

V V

E E

E E E E

S N S N

A A

V V

V V V V I I

I I

A A

A A A A X X

D D

K K

E E

A A

R 3 R 3

5 5 2 2 L L

M M

A A

P P WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET

WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET

WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET

WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET

WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET

MAX INCREMENTAL SHADOWSWEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET ANALYSIS ON MAY/ AUG 6 & JUNE 21 WITH WORST-CASE HEIGHTS BUILDINGS

WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET Note: The detailed shadow analysis uses Rhinoceros 5.0 3D modeling software in combination with other data sources, including New York City Geographic Information Systems (GIS) data, and a 3-D Building Massing Model and 2-ft contour line features of New York City by Department HONEY LOCUST TREES/ WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET of Information Technology & Telecommunications (DoITT) DAPPLED LIGHT

WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET

WEST 48 STREET EAST 48 STREET WEST 48 STREET EAST 48 STREET E E U U N N

E E E E

U U V V

N N

A EAST 58 STREET A EAST 58 STREET

E E

V V

E E

A N A N

U U

E E

E E E E O O

N N

U U

U U U U T T

N N

E E

N N

N N N N G G

O O

V V

E E

E E E E

S N S N

A A

V V

V V V V I I WEST 47 STREET I EAST 47 STREET WEST 47 STREET I EAST 47 STREET

A A

A A A A X X

D D

K K

E E

A A

R 3 R 3

5 5 2 2 L L

M M

A A

P P MAY/ AUG 6 WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET WEST 57 STREET EAST 57 STREET D | 4:30pm WEST 46 STREET D | 3:30pm EAST 46 STREET WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET WORST-CASE WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET WEST 56 STREET EAST 56 STREET

Madison Ave D | 2:30pm INCREMENTAL SHADOW WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET

- SITE 10 (1425’) WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET WEST 55 STREET EAST 55 STREET - SITE 11 (1116’) WEST 44 STREET Greenacre EAST 44 STREET WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET D | 1:30pm WEST 54 STREET Park EAST 54 STREET WEST 54 STREET EAST 54 STREET - SITE J (660’) WEST 43 STREET J EAST 43 STREET WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET

WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET WEST 53 STREET EAST 53 STREET

WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET 7 WEST 52 STREET 11 EAST 52 STREET WEST 52 STREET EAST 52 STREET

EAST 41 STREET EAST 41 STREET

WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET WEST 51 STREET EAST 51 STREET

WEST 40 STREET WEST 40 STREET

D C WEST 50 STREET 10 EAST 50 STREET WEST 50 STREET EAST 50 STREET 3rd Ave WEST 39 STREET WEST 39 STREET 48th st N N WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET WEST 49 STREET EAST 49 STREET

WEST 38 STREET WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 0 200 600 1,000 WEST 48 STREET Shadows from 1:30pm-4:30pm EAST 48 STREET Feet IncrementalWEST 48 STREET shadows at 3:30pm and 4:00pm EAST 48 STREET Feet Base map shows current shadow conditions at 4 pm on MAY 6 JUN 21 WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET WEST 47 STREET EAST 47 STREET WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET WEST 46 STREET EAST 46 STREET WORST-CASE WEST 45 STREET D | 4:30pm EAST 45 STREET WEST 45 STREET EAST 45 STREET INCREMENTAL SHADOW Madison Ave D | 3:30pm - SITE 7 (840’) WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET WEST 44 STREET EAST 44 STREET Greenacre - SITE 10 (1425’) D | 2:30pm Park - SITE 11 (1116’) WEST 43 STREET J EAST 43 STREET WEST 43 STREET EAST 43 STREET

- SITE C (1315’) D | 1:30pm - SITE D (1230’) WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET WEST 42 STREET EAST 42 STREET - SITE J (660’) 7 11 EAST 41 STREET EAST 41 STREET

WEST 40 STREET WEST 40 STREET D C 10

WEST 39 STREET 3rd Ave WEST 39 STREET 48th st N N

WEST 38 STREET WEST 38 STREET 0 200 600 1,000 0 200 600 1,000 Shadows from 1:30pm-4:30pm Feet Incremental shadows at 3:30pm, 4:00pm and 4:30pm Feet Base map shows current shadow conditions at 4 pm on JUN 21 Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 13 SUMMARY OF INCREMENTAL SHADOWS COMPARING DRAFT EIS & WORST-CASE INCREMENTAL SHADOW DURATIONS CURRENT CONDITIONS DEIS HEIGHTS WORST-CASE HEIGHTS

MAY/ AUG 6 DEIS INCREMENTAL SHADOW 1:45PM 1:45PM 1:45PM 42 minutes

VS. VS.

WORST-CASE HEIGHTS

INCREMENTAL SHADOW 5:18PM 5:18PM 5:18PM 1 hour 20 minutes

SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 6:27 AM-7:15 AM, 1:45 PM-3:10 PM, 4:25 PM-5:18 PM 3:30 PM-3:48 PM, 4:16 PM-4:42 PM 3:10 PM-4:30 PM

JUN 21 DEIS INCREMENTAL SHADOW 1 hour 41 minutes 1:25PM 1:25PM 1:25PM

VS. VS.

WORST-CASE HEIGHTS INCREMENTAL SHADOW

6:01PM 6:01PM 6:01PM 2 hours 39 minutes

SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 5:57 AM-6:45 AM, 1:25 PM-2:25 PM, 5:15 PM-6:01 PM 3:42 PM-5:23 PM 2:36 PM-5:15 PM

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 14 3. POTENTIAL ADDITIONAL SHADING FROM EAST

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study December, 2016 15 POSSIBLE ADDITIONAL MORNING SHADOW

T E 52TH ST 2A 2nd Ave

Subway| Phase Stop 1 2B 54th st 54th st 2ND AVE 2C C1-9

1A 2D E 49TH ST 1st Ave 3rd Ave 2nd Ave

1B 1C 1A

1B2E

2ND AVE 2F 1C Greenacre 1ST AVE Park 2A 1D E 51ST ST 2G 1D 1E E 43RD ST

2B 2C 1E

E 51ST ST

1E 2D 1F 1ST AVE SHADING IMPACTS1F FEASIBLE

49th st 49th st LESS FEASIBLE Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 16 POTENTIAL BUILDING HEIGHTS +1120’

54TH ST 54TH ST

1A 3RD AVE 2ND AVE AVE 1ST Section 4 1B 1C June 21 | 11:50am +525’ June 21 | 11:50am +530’

Greenacre Park 2A 1D Section 3 +310’ +310’ June 21 | 7:15am June 21 | 7:15am 2B 2C 1E

2B 2D 2B 2C 1F

2D GREENACRE PARK GREENACRE PARK Section 1 1F Section 2 2ND AVE 2ND AVE AVE 1ST

key map Section 1 Section 2

+1345’ +1355’ SUMMARY: - Potential incremental shadows from the +1135’ sites on 2nd Ave

- West side of 2nd Ave: New buildings taller2E than 310’ would1G cast additional shadow on Greenacre Park. 2F - East side of 2nd Ave: New buildings taller than 530’ would cast 2G additional shadow on Greenacre Park. June 21 | 11:50am June 21 | 11:50am

+305’ +305’ 42ND ST 42ND ST June 21 | 7:15am June 21 | 7:15am

SHADING IMPACTS 2A 1D 2A 1B 1C GREENACRE PARK GREENACRE PARK

FEASIBLE 2ND AVE AVE 1ST 2ND AVE AVE 1ST

LESS FEASIBLE Section 3 Section 4 Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 17 SUMMARY OF INCREMENTAL SHADOWS POTENTIAL ADDITIONAL 54TH ST 54TH ST CURRENT CONDITIONS SHADING FROM EAST

1A 3RD AVE 2ND AVE AVE 1ST

1B 1C

1:45PM 1:45PM Greenacre Park 2A 1D MAY/ AUG 6 4 hours 25 minutes 2B 2C 1E

7:15AM 5:18PM 2D 1F 5:18PM

key map SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 6:27AM-7:15AM, 1:45PM-3:10PM, 4:25PM-5:18PM 7:15AM-11:40AM

2E 1G

2F 1:25PM 1:25PM JUN 21 2G 4 hours 35 minutes

7:15AM

6:01PM

42ND ST 42ND ST

SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 5:57AM-6:45AM, 1:25PM-2:25PM, 5:15PM-6:01PM 7:15AM-11:50AM

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 18 2ND & 3RD AVE SUMMARY OF INCREMENTAL SHADOWS EAST MIDTOWN REZONING SHADOW FROM EAST + CURRENT CONDITIONS WORST CASE HEIGHTS WORST-CASE HEIGHTS

MAY/ AUG 6 FROM EAST 1:45PM 1:45PM 1:45PM 4 hour 25 minutes

+ VS.

WORST-CASE HEIGHTS

INCREMENTAL SHADOW 7:15AM 5:18PM 5:18PM 5:18PM 1 hour 20 minutes

= TOTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 5 hour 45 minutes 6:27AM-7:15AM, 1:45PM-3:10PM, 4:25PM-5:18PM 3:10PM-4:30PM 7:15AM-11:40AM + 3:10PM-4:30PM

JUN 21 FROM EAST 4 hour 35 minutes 1:25PM 1:25PM 1:25PM

VS. VS.

WORST-CASE HEIGHTS INCREMENTAL SHADOW 7:15AM

6:01PM 6:01PM 2 hours 39 minutes 6:01PM

= TOTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES INCREMENTAL SHADOW TIMES 7 hour 14 minutes 5:57AM-6:45AM, 1:25PM-2:25PM, 5:15PM-6:01PM 2:36PM-5:15PM 7:15AM-11:50AM + 2:36PM-5:15PM

Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 19 2ND & 3RD AVE Greenacre Park / Sun and Shadow Study May 2017 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT 20