Early and Middle Frasnian Brachiopod Faunas and Turnover on the South China Shelf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Early and Middle Frasnian brachiopod faunas and turnover on the South China shelf XUE−PING MA, RALPH THOMAS BECKER, HUA LI, and YUAN−YUAN SUN Ma, X.−P., Becker, R.T., Li, H., and Sun, Y.−Y. 2006. Early and Middle Frasnian brachiopod faunas and turnover on the South China shelf. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 51 (4): 789–812. The first appearance of the brachiopod Cyrtospirifer and related forms in the Late Devonian of South China significantly postdates the beginning of the Frasnian and the entry of the group in other parts of the world. Scattered data from different sections suggest that its first entry, associated with the emergence of other plicate spiriferids, such as theodossid and conispiriferid brachiopods, was late in the Middle Frasnian. At the same time, many rhynchonellids disappeared or be− came extinct locally in South China. This brachiopod faunal overturn near the Palmatolepis punctata–Early Pa. hassi zonal boundary is the most significant event in the Early–Middle Frasnian of South China, characterized by about a 35% loss of existing species and the flourishing of the plicate spiriferids, which was coeval with the end of a major biogeochemical perturbation recently recognized in the Pa. punctata Zone. By contrast, atrypid brachiopods do not seem to show any significant diversity change. The brachiopod faunal change was probably related to a (local?) transgressive event in South China, which also brought new pelagic faunas northwards into some intra−shelf deeper water areas, such as the Shetianqiao area in central Hunan Province. Fifteen brachiopod species are described and illustrated, which include some taxa that are first recorded or recognized in South China, e.g., the spiriferid Pyramidaspirifer, which is now known from both North America and South China. One new species, Desquamatia qiziqiaoensis, is erected. Key words: Brachiopoda, Cyrtospirifer, faunal turnover, Frasnian, Devonian, South China. Xue−Ping Ma [[email protected]], Hua Li [[email protected]], and Yuan−Yuan Sun [[email protected]], The Key Laboratory of Orogenic Belts and Crustal Evolution, Department of Geology, Peking University, 100871 Beijing, China; Ralph Thomas Becker [rbecker@uni−muenster.de], Geologisch−Paläontologisches Institut und Museum, Westfälische Wilhelms−Universität Münster, Corrensstraße 24, D−48149 Münster, Germany. Introduction and Sandberg 1990). This period covers zones 4–8 in the more detailed, globally applicable Montagne Noire (MN) conodont The Devonian was a period with evolutionary innovations, zonation of Klapper (1989). There have been already some re− for example, the flourishing of vascular plants, and emer− gional studies that reported various sedimentological, geo− gence of amphibians on land. Invertebrates also experienced chemical, and pelagic faunal signatures from that interval: major extinctions, for example the Frasnian–Famennian Becker et al. (1993) from Western Australia, House and Kirch− mass extinction (e.g., Racki and House 2002; Baliński et al. gasser (1993) from New York State, Morrow et al. (1998) from 2002; Racki 2005). In addition, many smaller−scale events or Nevada, House et al. (2000) from Timan, northern Russia, extinctions have been recognized (e.g., House 2002). Late Becker and House (2000) from Tafilalt, SE Morocco, Becker Devonian pelagic goniatite stratigraphy and event succes− (2002) from Boulonnais, northern France, Becker et al. (2004) sion have been summarized by Becker et al. (1993), Walliser from Dra Valley, SW Morocco, and Racki et al. (2004) from the (1996), and House (2002), and tied to transgressive episodes, Holy Cross Mountains, Poland. Currently a Timan Event in periods of hypoxia and deposition of black muds in specific MN Zone 4 (Pa. transitans Zone), a Middlesex Event or basal basins. The International Subcommission on Devonian Stra− Domanik Transgression at the base of MN Zone 5 (basal Pa. tigraphy (SDS) has proposed to place the base of a formal punctata Zone), and two pulses of the Lower Rhinestreet Event Middle Frasnian substage at the base of the MN 5 or Pal− around the boundary between MN zones 6–7 (around the base matolepis punctata Zone and this definition is adopted in this of the Palmatolepis hassi Zone) are recognized in widely sepa− paper (see Ziegler and Sandberg 2001 for example). rated basins. In addition, the Middle Frasnian “punctata event” Applying a lag−time multiple impacts hypothesis to the of Yans et al. (in press) (= Pa. punctata Event) corresponding Frasnian–Famennian mass extinction, McGhee (2001) sug− to a carbon isotopic perturbation, which has also been recog− gested that future searches for evidence of impact events in the nized in various continents including South China. Late Devonian should be concentrated in strata that occur in This paper deals with faunal response during the Early the Frasnian Palmatolepis transitans to Early Pa. hassi zonal and Middle Frasnian interval and reports brachiopod taxon− interval of the so−called standard conodont zonation (Ziegler omy and distribution from South China. Acta Palaeontol. Pol. 51 (4): 789–812, 2006 http://app.pan.pl/acta51/app51−xxx.pdf 790 ACTA PALAEONTOLOGICA POLONICA 51 (4), 2006 Fig. 1. Geographic map of China (A) and locations of the stratigraphic sections () investigated in this study (B). The Devonian of South China is well developed, with nas is a crucial question in this study. Therefore we first dis− sediments of various settings, and with relatively well pre− cuss the stratigraphy of the studied sections. served neritic and pelagic faunas (e.g., Hou and Wang 1988). The Early Frasnian Tuqiaozi Interval and its equiva− Some important studies that included Late Devonian brachi− lents.—Traditionally, the Middle–Late Devonian boundary opod faunas are those of, e.g., Grabau (1931), Tien (1938), in shallow water facies in South China has been defined by Wang (1956), Chen (1983, 1984), Hou (1988). Recently, a the disappearance of Stringocephalus and the appearance of series of papers have concentrated on material from across Cyrtospirifer. However, it has also been long recognized that the Frasnian–Famennian boundary, e.g., Ma et al. (2002), there is an interval between the levels of the last Stringo− Ma and Day (2003), and Ma et al. (2005). However, system− cephalus and the first Cyrtospirifer, e.g., as represented by atic studies of Early and Middle Frasnian brachiopod faunas the Hejiazhai Member in the Dushan section of Guizhou are still rare (see Chen 1983, 1984; Hou 1988), which deal Province (Liao et al. 1978), and the Tuqiaozi Formation (in with abundant material from the Longmenshan section of the sense of Chen 1984) in the Longmenshan section of Sichuan Province. This material collected from several other Sichuan Province. This interregnum, the Stringocephalus– important areas, including the Panxi section of Yunnan Prov− Cyrtospirifer interval Zone of Ji (1989: 307), is here termed ince, Dushan section of Guizhou Province, Caiziyan section the Tuqiaozi Interval for simplicity, and can be used for the of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, and Qiziqiao sec− same time interval in other sections. It has been considered to tion of Hunan Province (Fig. 1). be Early Frasnian in age by most workers, e.g., in Liao’s (1977) work on rugose coral faunas from the Dushan section Institutional abbreviation.—PUM, the Geological Museum and in Chen’s work (1984) on brachiopod faunas from the of Peking University. Longmenshan section. Conodont data in Hou (1988: 28–31) Other abbreviations.—DS, Dushan section of Guizhou Pro− suggest that the Tuqiaozi Formation (in the sense of Chen vince, China; GC, Caiziyan section in the vicinity of Guilin, 1984, which is different from the definition of Hou 1988 who China; PY, Panxi section of Yunnan Province, China; QZQ, puts the base about 84 m upwards and the top about 20 m up− Qiziqiao section of Hunan Province, China (see Fig. 1 for wards) can roughly be correlated with the earliest Frasnian section locations); MN, Montagne Noire conodont zones of (MN Zone 1) to early part of the Middle Frasnian (MN zones Klapper (1989). 5–6). As pointed out by Xiong et al. (1988: 39), the exact age of the topmost Tuqiaozi Formation in terms of conodont zonation cannot be determined because of the absence of Palmatolepis, and other index fossils. The early part of the Stratigraphy Tuqiaozi Formation (Beds 2–9 of Chen 1984, approximately equal to the upper 20 m of Bed 126 and bed 127 of Hou 1988) One of the major problems in the stratigraphic study of shelly yielded Ancyrodella binodosa, A. rotundiloba, A. rugosa, A. facies in South China is more accurate correlation with the pramosica, Mesotaxis ovalis, M. asymmetrica, and Play− “standard” faunal zones established chiefly based on pelagic fordia primitiva. This suggests the presence of MN zones conodonts and goniatites. The precise age of brachiopod fau− 1–4 (Frasnian part of early M. falsiovalis Zone to lower part MA ET AL.—FRASNIAN BRACHIOPODS FROM SOUTH CHINA SHELF 791 Fig. 2. Stratigraphy and distribution of Early and Middle Frasnian brachiopods in South China. Most but not all known brachiopods are described and illus− trated in this paper. For the distribution of atrypids in the Dushan section, for example, see Ma et al. (2005). The stratigraphy of Panxi and the occurrence of Cyrtospirifer sp. are based on Yunnan compiling group (1978) and the occurrence of Stringocephalus in the lower part of the Yidade Formation is as in Xian et al. (1988: 148). The stratigraphy of Dushan and the occurrence of Stringocephalus sp. are as in Liao et al. (1979); the Caiziyan section was re−measured by Long−Ming Wei, Xue−Ping Ma, and Hua Li (personal communication 2005), with coral identifications by Wei−Hua Liao. The stratigraphy of Qiziqiao is based on data of Z.−X. Hu and Z.−Q. Deng in Tan et al. (1987), and the occurrence of Yunnanella sp. is based on Zu−Han Liu (personal communication 2001).