Iron Man's and Captain Marvel's Anxieties and Defense
Total Page：16
File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb
K@ta Kita, Vol. 6, No. 1, January 2018, 98-104 DOI: 10.9744/[email protected]. 98-104 e-ISSN: 2598-7801 Iron Man’s and Captain Marvel’s Anxieties and Defense Mechanisms in “Civil War II” Saputro, L. English for Creative Industry, Faculty of Letters, Petra Christian University, Siwalankerto 121-131, Surabaya 60236, East Java, INDONESIA Emails: [email protected] Abstract: This thesis deals with the anxieties experienced by the leaders of superhero teams in Civil War II, Iron Man and Captain Marvel. Through their anxieties in Civil War II, I tried to reveal the causes of their anxieties and their ways to reduce these uneasy feelings. To analyze the causes of these two characters’ anxieties, I used two of the theory of anxiety, reality and moral anxiety. I found that there are two causes that make Iron Man feel anxieties which are the reaction of Captain Marvel towards Ulysses’ prophecies and his responsibility both as a superhero and as a leader to protect people from the outcome of Ulysses’ prophecies. On the other hand, Captain Marvel also feels anxieties from the blame of Iron Man and her responsibility both as a superhero and as a public officer to protect people from dystopian future. Iron Man uses two defense mechanisms, which are splitting and rationalization. On the other hand, Captain Marvel also uses two defense mechanism, which are idealization and rationalization. These defense mechanisms are used by both, Iron Man and Captain Marvel to ease their reality and moral anxiety. Key words: Reality anxiety, Moral anxiety, Splitting, Idealization, Rationalization. 1. INTRODUCTION Civil War II is a superhero comic book which is published by Marvel Comics in 2016. It is a sequel comic from the same title, Civil War. Generally, superhero comics happen to be one of the most common format for American comic books. Furthermore, Marvel Comics has also been known as one of the biggest superhero comic publishers. Civil War II written by Brian Michael Bendis, this issue is interesting to analyze because it has a different plot from any issue of ordinary superhero comics. In a common plot of superhero comics, the superheroes are pictured as strong or talented persons who fight super villains in order to protect civilians from threats like invasion, chaos, and many bad things which could possibly happen to destroy humanity. However, in the plot of Civil War II, the superheroes are pictured differently because they do not only fight super villains but they also fight among themselves because of their different opinions about the future. The story of Civil War II begins with Ulysses Cain, a student at Ohio State University who is exposed to the Terrigen Mist. The Terrigen Mist has turned Ulysses into an inhuman has an ability to see the future. His vision is a dystopia that the earth is in danger of being destroyed by aliens or greatest threats that may happen in the future. The vision of Ulysses has brought a different opinions from Iron Man as the Avenger leader and Captain Marvel the Ultimates leader. These two leaders have their own anxieties about Ulysses’ power, yet because of their different perspectives, they have started quarrel among themselves about either to use Ulysses’ power as an advantage to alter the future or not. From these texts, I would like to find the causes of Iron Man’s and Captain Marvel’s anxieties and the defense mechanisms they use to cope with their anxieties in these current situations of Civil War II. The purpose of this thesis is to see that the anxieties that Iron Man and Captain Marvel have are caused by their different reactions towards Ulysses’ prophecies and the pressures of being superheroes. Moreover, I also find that Iron Man uses two kinds of defense mechanisms which are splitting and rationalization while Captain Marvel’s defense mechanisms are idealization and rationalization. 98 Saputro: Iron Man’s and Captain Marvel’s Anxieties and Defense Mechanisms in Civil War II 99 In Marvel Comic, superheroes are pictured as same as human with their weaknesses when they are faced with struggles or problems that come from their situation, environment or even their personality. These superheroes also face the same thing as normal people because they feel anxious and starts to use defense mechanisms as their ways to overcome these anxieties. It can be seen that superhero in Marvel Comic is similar with normal human being who have troubles and struggles to solve their problems. They are not pictured as gods or even deities. Therefore, superheroes of Marvel comic are pictured as very human, so that they are able to make the readers relate themselves to their favorite superheroes. In making this thesis, I applied two theories of anxieties and defense mechanisms. Regarding the theory of anxieties, anxiety is known as a painful emotional experience that is produced by agitations that happen in the internal organs of the body. “Anxiety is different from any other painful states, such as tension, pam, and melancholy by some specific quality of consciousness” (Hall, 1999, p. 61). It is an unpleasant inner state that people seek to avoid. Sigmund Freud had divided three different types of anxiety, all of which are signals to the ego. First of all is realistic or reality anxiety, which is normally referred to as fear. Realistic or reality anxiety is a painful emotional experience resulting from the perception of danger in the external world (Hall, 1999). The second type is moral anxiety, this is what we feel when the threat comes not from the outer, physical world, but from the internalized social world of the superego. It is, in fact, just another word for feelings like shame and guilt and the fear of punishment. (Hall, 1999). The last type of anxiety is neurotic anxiety. This is the fear of being overwhelmed by impulses from the id. If somebody fells like he is about to "lose it;" lose control, temper, rationality, or even his mind, he experiences neurotic anxiety. In conclusion, there are three types of anxiety where the ego experiences are fear of the external world, fear of the id and fear of the super ego (Freud, 1923). Finally, I used the defense mechanism theory to analyze this thesis. Defense mechanism is a strategy developed by the ego in order to deal with the threats or dangers because of the oppression from id, superego, or reality. According to Hall, defense mechanism is an attempt to reduce anxiety by using rational methods such as deny, falsify, or distort reality and it will prevent the development of clash in personality (Hall, 1999). I will only use three defense mechanisms in this research which are rationalization, idealization, splitting, and humor. Rationalization occurs when a person attempts to explain or create excuses for an event or action in rational terms. In doing so, they are able to avoid accepting the true cause or reason resulting in the present situation (Hall, 1999). Second, Idealization, involves creating an ideal impression of a person, place or object by emphasizing their positive qualities and neglecting the reality that they might have negative sides (Lerner & Van-Der Keshet, 1995). Furthermore, the third defense mechanism, Splitting, occurs when the ego attempts to reconcile multiple aspects or rationales, but resorts to understanding the world in “black and white” terms (Goin, 1998). A person who experiences splitting may take an “either-or” approach when making evaluations of the world around them, including objects, situations, and people. All of these concepts of anxieties and defense mechanisms will be used to answer statement of the problems which are the causes of these two leaders of superhero teams, Iron Man’s and Captain Marvel’s anxieties and the defense mechanisms they use to cope with their anxieties. 2. THE CAUSES OF IRON MAN’S AND CAPTAIN MARVEL’S ANXIETIES AND THEIR WAYS TO DEAL WITH THEM 2.1. Iron Man’s anxieties and defense mechanisms. Iron Man is the leader of a superheroes team, The Avenger, and he is also one of the most respected man of science. In Civil War II, Iron Man starts to have an argument with Captain Marvel because of his opinion about Ulysses is totally opposite with Captain Marvel. Ulysses’ power to see future is considered as a dangerous phenomenon because Ulysses always has visions of dystopian future where there are threats and dangers that may approach the earth. In this issue, there are four main prophecies of Ulysses after his early prophecy about celestial villains attack on earth which are Thanos attack, Hulk rampage, Hydra’s undercover agent, and Spiderman will get to kill Captain America. These prophecies has brought fear for Iron Man. The fear is rooted in his consciousness which has caused Iron Man to feel reality and moral anxiety. 2.1.1. Iron Man’s Reality Anxiety Reality anxiety is known as a fear that comes from a person’s situation. One of these factors that can trigger reality anxiety is insecure environment. The insecure environment in Iron Man’s 100 K@ta Kita, VOL. 6, NO. 1, JANUARY 2018: 98-104 situation is coming from the situation of Captain Marvel who put her belief on Ulysses when he spells out his predictions about future. These actions have made Iron Man to feel anxious because of the outcome of Captain Marvel’s actions which are uncalculated attack on Thanos and unplanned approach on Hulk. In the uncalculated of Captain Marvel on Thanos has led to the death of War Machine and She- Hulk ending up in critical condition (Bendis, Civil War II Vol 1, 2016).