DOCSLIB.ORG

Cybersecurity: Is Technology Moving Faster Than Policy?

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Cybersecurity: Is Technology Moving Faster Than Policy? SDA Report Cybersecurity: Is technology moving faster than policy? January 31, 2011 Sofitel Europe, Brussels SECURITY & DEFENCE AGENDA 1 A Security & Defence Agenda Report Rapporteur: David Koczij Photos: Philippe Molitor Date of publication: February 2011 SECURITY & DEFENCE AGENDA Bibliothèque Solvay, Parc Léopold, 137 rue Belliard, B-1040, Brussels, Belgium 2 SECURITY & DEFENCE AGENDA Cybersecurity: Is technology moving faster than policy? CONTENTS At a glance—Speakers and moderator 2 Introduction 3 What challenges need to be overcome for a secure cyberspace? 3 Some issues and accomplishments for the European Union 5 Future developments for improved cybersecurity 7 Conclusion 8 List of participants 9 About Microsoft 11 About the SDA 12 The views expressed in this report by speakers are personal opinions and not necessarily the views of the organi- sation they represent, nor of the Security & Defence Agenda, its members or partners. Reproduction in whole or in part is permitted, providing that full attribution is made to the Security & Defence Agenda and to the source(s) in question, and provided that any such reproduction, whether in full or in part, is not sold unless incorporated in other works. SECURITY & DEFENCE AGENDA 1 Cybersecurity: Is technology moving faster than policy? Policymakers’ dinner Monday 31 January 2011 Sofitel Brussels Europe Cyberattacks in Europe and across the globe are at an all-time high and showing no signs of abating. Remote hijacking of computers for malicious purposes constitute an “electronic epidemic”. Faced with such rapid technological upheaval, Euro- pean policymakers seem slow to react. As EU member states rush to create the necessary national agencies, is it time for a European cybersecurity authority? What technical capabilities would such a body need, and who should provide them? Un- der which jurisdiction should cybercriminals be prosecuted? Is a stronger private-public cooperation framework needed to support such a system? Can the need to provide a safe cyber environment be balanced with privacy for the individual? Could investment in public education for “good hygiene” practices offer a low cost answer to the threat of viral infection? Speakers Mario Campolargo Craig Mundie Director, Emerging Technologies Chief Research and Strategy Officer and Infrastructures Microsoft European Commission Directorate General for Information Society & Media Jamie Shea Moderator Deputy Assistant Secretary General NATO Emerging Security Giles Merritt Challenges Division Director Security & Defence Agenda Policymakers’ dinners offer specialists in a defined policy area an opportunity to discuss issues with key officials of EU, NATO and diplomatic representations, and leading figures from NGOs, business and industry. The dinner format lends itself to free- flowing debate and an open exchange of views. 2 SECURITY & DEFENCE AGENDA Cybersecurity: Is technology moving faster than policy? Introduction “Cyberspace is another episode of the human saga of With the continuing increase in the number, scope and coming to terms with anarchic space, in the same his- severity of cyberattacks around the globe, it seems that torical vein as sea, air and space.” the EU, NATO and their partners are lagging behind in crafting effective policies to meet the demands required by ever-evolving threats emerging from cyberspace. The and Media. While the European Union provides a lot of participants at the Security and Defence Agenda policy- funding to the research and development of new infor- makers’ dinner on 31 January 2011, entitled mation and communication technologies (ICT) in order “Cybersecurity: Is technology moving faster than pol- to address existing and emerging problems, “security icy?”, agreed on the need for a common typology of cy- cannot rely solely on technology. In fact, policy must, berthreats and security policy responses, to be drafted in and will, play a crucial part in this area.” Referring to the collaboration with public and private actors. Digital Agenda for Europe launched by Commissioner Neelie Kroes last year, he added that “developing trust Over the past decade, began Craig Mundie, Chief Re- and security in the online environment is a priority for search and Strategy Officer at Microsoft, there has been the EU’s digital agenda.” a shift towards ever-increasing connectivity of networks around the globe. As the software technology on which “Cyberspace is another episode of the human saga of these systems run evolved in a secure and benign operat- coming to terms with anarchic space, in the same histori- ing environment, the systems have lagged behind from a cal vein as sea, air and space,” offered Jamie Shea, Dep- security perspective. uty Assistant Secretary General, NATO Emerging Security Challenges Division. Important details aside, he contin- “This remarkable internet connectivity,” he explained, ued, “the basic point is that we are all together in this “which has brought so many benefits, has also brought a world for the duration. What the EU, NATO and their set of risks from those who choose to use these tools to partner organisations need is an intellectual revolution exploit system weaknesses. While we who develop these and to find the strength to make the decision to relegate technologies are greatly improving the way we operate, more intellectual resources to questions of cybersecu- the community of ‘bad guys’ has become very efficient as rity.” well.” What challenges need to be overcome for a secure cy- “There is a growing awareness that cyberthreats can be berspace? detrimental to business, competitiveness and economic growth,” offered Mario Campolargo, Director for Emerg- As technology permeates society, security and trust in ing Technologies and Infrastructures at the European information and communication systems becomes a sig- Commission’s Directorate General of Information Society nificant factor in their development, participants heard. 3 Cybersecurity: Is technology moving faster than policy? Following his work on Microsoft’s Trustworthy Comput- The problems emanating from cyberspace go beyond ing Initiative, Mundie noted that there are four elements state actions, Shea continued, stating that “cyber has al- to maintaining users’ trust in computing systems: secu- lowed the private individual, organised crime, terrorist rity, privacy, reliability, and interoperability. Although groups, social misfits and hacktivists to get involved with the high-technology industry has worked diligently over areas that were previously state-controlled.” the past decade to create trustworthy systems based on these four criteria, the challenges in these areas remain, In fact, said Mundie, cyberattacks have evolved from he concluded. ‘malicious mischief’ committed by certain individuals seeking notoriety to The most potent emerging challenge attacks of a criminal “No matter where things like the Stuxnet program ema- in cybersecurity has to do with the nature – people seek- nated from, it should be a wake-up call that strictly soft- changing uses and capabilities of cy- ing economic and ware-based attacks on systems can now wreak real and bertechnology, Mundie explained. ideological gains substantial physical damage.” “Intelligence and defence services of rather then notoriety. many countries now realise that This has had the ef- these technologies are critical to fect of reducing the their mission on the intelligence-gathering side as well as visibility of such attacks while escalating the seriousness a serious threat on the operations side.” It is the respon- of their consequences. sibility of national and international agencies to engage themselves with the technology and policy surrounding The increasing severity of cyberthreats is closely linked to cyber in order to tackle the duality of the issue. the increase in connectivity that the world is witnessing through, for example, cloud computing, continued Speaking from a military strategist’s perspective, Shea Mundie. As it currently stands, mission-critical systems asked the participants to consider the fact that, while in can by and large continue to function if temporarily sev- the past cyber was used primarily for espionage and in- ered from the network. If, however, the current trends of telligence gathering, it has increasingly been used for connectivity and interoperability continue – connecting denial of access and even destructive attacks. “We must large-scale enterprises to super-scale activities – govern- consider how much cyber changes our thinking about ment and industry will have to carefully weigh potential conflicts,” he stated. “Will states now resort to the softer efficiencies and economic returns against the fact that power of cyber interventions where before military ac- consolidated system architecture is exponentially more tion was the norm?” vulnerable to cyberattacks than stand-alone or small, protected systems. “No matter where things like the Stuxnet program ema- nated from, it should be a wake-up call that strictly soft- “I think that the challenges, even as we seek to get a han- ware-based attacks on systems can now wreak real and dle on them in the traditional environment, are going to substantial physical damage,” agreed Mundie. accelerate quite dramatically, largely because the sys- 4 SECURITY & DEFENCE AGENDA Cybersecurity: Is technology moving faster than policy? tems comprising the mobile internet are in some ways comes from within their own security and organisational where we were a decade ago in terms of
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 2 537 40 75 Executive Master in International Politics
    CERIS - ULB Open Days Diplomatic by Zoom Videoconference School of Brussels Université Libre de Bruxelles - ULB OPEN DAYS – February 5th to March 6th, 2021 Registration ([email protected]) / phone: +32(0)2 537 40 75 www.ceris.be Executive Master in International Politics (MIP) Executive Master in Governance & Development Policy (MADEV) 05/02 18:00-19:30 The rise and fall of Donald Trump MIP Michael Cox (London School of Economics & Political Science- LSE, Director of IDEAS) 06/02 09:30-12:30 Prospects for the Biden Presidency MIP Michael Cox (London School of Economics & Political Science –LSE, Director of IDEAS) Professor Michael Cox is Director of LSE IDEAS and Emeritus Professor of International Relations at LSE. In addition, he is currently working on a history of LSE. He helped establish the Cold War Studies Centre in 2004 and expand it into IDEAS, a foreign policy centre based at the LSE, which aims to bring the academic, and policy words together, in 2008. In a 2014 nd international survey, IDEAS was ranked 2 in the world amongst the best university affiliated Think Tanks. Since joining the LSE he has also acted as Academic Director of both the LSE- PKU Summer School and of the Executive Summer School. In 2011, he launched a new Executive Masters in Global Strategy designed to teach senior foreign policy practitioners. 1 CERIS asbl / Phone : +32(0)2 537 40 75 / Email : [email protected] / Web Site : www.ceris.be Open Days by Zoom Videoconference 06/02 14:00-18:00 The climate change and the global politics.
    [Show full text]
  • XXXI MIT Global Change Forum in Collaboration With
    XXXI MIT Global Change Forum in collaboration with UCL-CORE and Chair Lhoist Berghmans 20-22 October 2010 SAS Radisson Blu Royal Hotel • Brussels, Belgium Confronting Domestic and Global Climate Strategies AGENDA Wednesday 20 October 2010 17:00–19:00 Registration Théâtre du Vaudeville, 13 Galerie de la Reine, Brussels 17:30–18:45 Reception Théâtre du Vaudeville, 13 Galerie de la Reine, Brussels 19:00 Welcome/Forum Overview Professor Ronald G. Prinn, Co-Director, MIT Global Change Joint Program, MIT and Dinner Professor Henry Tulkens, Université catholique de Louvain and CORE 20:00 Keynote Address Dr. Jamie Shea, Director of Planning, Office of the Secretary General, NATO Thursday 21 October 2010 All Meeting Sessions will be held in the SAS Radisson Blu Royal Hotel, 47 Rue du Fossé-aux-Loups, Royal Room 9:00–10:30 1. SESSION TOPIC: Lessons from Past Interglacial Climates Opening Statement Professor Michel Crucifix, Georges Lemaitre Centre for Earth&Climate Research, Université catholique de Louvain Opening Statement Professor Raymond S. Bradley, Director, CSRC, Dept. of Geosciences, University of Massachusetts at Amherst Discussion Moderator Dr. John Reilly, Co-Director, MIT Global Change Joint Program, MIT 10:30–11:00 Break: Refreshments served in: SAS Radisson Blu Royal Hotel, Foyer, 1st floor 11:00–12:30 2. SESSION TOPIC: Forecasting Climate at the Regional Level Opening Statement Dr. C. Adam Schlosser, Assistant Director for Research, MIT Global Change Joint Program, MIT Opening Statement Professor John Mitchell, Principal Research Fellow, Met Office, UK Discussion Moderator Professor Ronald G. Prinn, Co-Director, MIT Global Change Joint Program, MIT 12:30–14:00 Lunch: Served in : SAS Radisson Blu Royal Hotel, Capital Rooms, 1st floor 14:00–15:30 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Humanitarian Intervention and Independence the Proof of the Pudding Is in the Eating
    R2P, HUMANITARIAN INTERVENTION AND INDEPENDENCE THE PROOF OF THE PUDDING IS IN THE EATING Mient Jan Faber∗ Introduction The discourse surrounding humanitarian intervention has inspired a wide variety of legal, political and ethical assessments. Various authors have attempted to impose their own take on the subject. In recent times, the Canadian-sponsored ICISS and its R2P report – discussed in more detail in this issue by Ciarán J. Burke and Thomas G. Weiss - have provided fresh food for thought. However, one area which has been repeatedly overlooked and neglected has been that of the practical, on the ground, mise en oeuvre of these lofty principles. In this article, I argue that the international community must, as John F. Kennedy once promised “turn good words into good deeds”. Principles, frameworks and models based on justice and ethics are all very well, but if lives are to be protected and human security is to be ensured, states must begin to make good on the promises contained in the 2005 World Outcome Document. As I sketch below, with the aid of my own first-hand personal experience, this has not been the case in the recent past. The debate about humanitarian intervention has been overhauled by a debate on ‘The Responsibility to Protect (further: R2P)’. This shift in focus from ‘the right of humanitarian intervention’ to “the right of every man, woman and child threatened by the horror of mass violence to be protected”1 is significant in as far as it signals a constraint on the tendency of states to military intervene in other countries, in order to enforce their policies under the pretext of humanitarian arguments.
    [Show full text]
  • European Post Graduate School of International & Development Studies
    Centre Européen de Recherches Internationales & Stratégiques European Post Graduate School of International & Development Studies OPEN DAYS – February 2nd to March, 3rd, 2018. Registration ([email protected]) / phone: 02 537 40 75 www.ceris.be Venue : Campus Solbosch of the ULB ( Free University of Brussels), Building A (Entrance Y); 1st Floor- Auditorium: S.AY2.108 ; Avenue Franklin D. Roosevelt 50, 1050 Brussels. Executive Master in International Politics (MIP) 02/02 18:00-19:30 NATO and the Future of Transatlantic Relations. Jamie Shea (NATO-Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges) 03/02 09:30-12:30 NATO and the Future of Transatlantic Relations. Jamie Shea (NATO- Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges) Jamie Shea is NATO Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges. He has been working with NATO since 1980. Positions included Director of Policy Planning in the Private Office of the Secretary General, Deputy Assistant Secretary General for External Relations, Public Diplomacy Division, Director of Information and Press, Spokesman of NATO and Deputy Director of Information and Press, Deputy Head and Senior Planning Officer in the Policy Planning and Multilateral Affairs Section of the Political Directorate as well as Assistant to the Secretary General of NATO for Special Projects. Jamie Shea is a regular lecturer and conference speaker on NATO and European security affairs and on public diplomacy, political communication and many other areas of contemporary international relations. He holds a D.Phil. in Modern History from Oxford University (Lincoln College), 1981. Amongst his many associations and memberships, Jamie Shea is a member of the Advisory Board, Security and Defence Programmes at Chatham House, a member of the Policy Council at the World Economic Forum in Geneva and founder and member of the Board, Security and Defence Agenda Brussels and Friends of Europe.
    [Show full text]
  • Airpower and the Environment
    Airpower and the Environment e Ecological Implications of Modern Air Warfare E J H Air University Press Air Force Research Institute Maxwell Air Force Base, Alabama July 2013 Airpower and the Environment e Ecological Implications of Modern Air Warfare E J H Air University Press Air Force Research Institute Maxwell Air Force Base, Alabama July 2013 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Airpower and the environment : the ecological implications of modern air warfare / edited by Joel Hayward. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-58566-223-4 1. Air power—Environmental aspects. 2. Air warfare—Environmental aspects. 3. Air warfare—Case studies. I. Hayward, Joel S. A. UG630.A3845 2012 363.739’2—dc23 2012038356 Disclaimer Opinions, conclusions, and recommendations expressed or implied within are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of Air University, the United States Air Force, the Department of Defense, or any other US government agency. Cleared for public release; distribution unlimited. AFRI Air Force Research Institute Air University Press Air Force Research Institute 155 North Twining Street Maxwell AFB, AL 36112-6026 http://aupress.au.af.mil ii Contents About the Authors v Introduction: War, Airpower, and the Environment: Some Preliminary Thoughts Joel Hayward ix 1 The mpactI of War on the Environment, Public Health, and Natural Resources 1 Victor W. Sidel 2 “Very Large Secondary Effects”: Environmental Considerations in the Planning of the British Strategic Bombing Offensive against Germany, 1939–1945 9 Toby Thacker 3 The Environmental Impact of the US Army Air Forces’ Production and Training Infrastructure on the Great Plains 25 Christopher M.
    [Show full text]
  • Vesalius College Global Bas, Mas and Executive Programmes in The
    Vesalius College In affiliation with Brussels Global BAs, MAs and Executive Programmes in the Heart of Europe www.vesalius.edu Vesalius College is a unique educational institution in Brussels and beyond - a transatlantic liberal arts-style college with an interdisciplinary perspective. As of 2017, the College will expand its academic offerings at graduate and life-long learning (executive training) levels. The College is the oldest higher education institution in Brussels that offers Bachelor pro- grammes taught exclusively in English. Thanks to the influence of our founders, the Vrije Uni- versiteit Brussel and Boston University, we combine the strengths of both the American and European academic systems. We offer students an American-style curriculum with interactive teaching, small classes, personalised attention and guidance. We also offer a rich, stimulating and international environment distinctive of a college based in Brussels, the capital of Europe. Students from all over the world have been drawn to this unique environment: more than 60 different nationalities are represented among our student body. Our professors have been educated at the world’s leading universities, continue to excel in their fields as researchers or advisors and have a deep passion for teaching. Our classes are small and interactive, with dynamic class discussions and continuous assessment throughout the semester. Vesalius College not only offers a highly global and interdisciplinary education, but also an approach that carefully balances theory with practice. Students acquire the the- oretical and academic knowledge needed for further studies or a career in their field, but also develop key transferable skills and networks for professional success.
    [Show full text]
  • Civil-Military Interoperability in Support of Nato Emerging Security Challenges
    I&S CIVIL-MILITARY INTEROPERABILITY IN SUPPORT OF NATO EMERGING SECURITY CHALLENGES Jamie SHEA Abstract: A speech by the Deputy Assistant Secretary General, Emerging Security Challenges Division, NATO International Staff, to the Second Workshop on Multi- national Cooperation in Civil-Military Interoperability in Sofia, underlining the im- portance of civil-military interaction and multinational approaches in various frameworks, as well as their important contribution to allied and national capabili- ties to deal with new threats and challenges. Keywords: Counter-terrorism, cyber security, energy security, non-proliferation, defence against terrorism, CIED. Dear participants, First of all, thanks for inviting me to speak at your workshop. Your objectives are certainly on a par with the goals of the Emerging Security Challenge Division which are mainly to ensure that military and civilian worlds can better understand them- selves, find some areas of common interest and finally cooperate in a comprehensive manner. It is also in line with the comprehensive approach and the Strategic Concept. Never- theless to succeed we need to act in a rigorous framework: • What is our NATO expertise, what is our NATO add-value? • Who are the stakeholders we would like to work with? • What kind of complementary projects, cooperation would we like to pro- mote (keeping for each part our specificity)? • What do we want to achieve? • What will be the benefits? The scale of economy? INFORMATION & SECURITY. An International Journal, Vol.27, 2011, 22-24. Jamie Shea 23 Having said that, the ‘Multinational Approach’ is exactly what NATO should pro- mote now, in line with the multinational capability approach under the lead of Allied Command Transformation, the Voluntary Multinational Fund under the Conference of National Armaments Directors (CNAD) and with the support from the Defence Against Terrorism Programme of Work (DAT POW).
    [Show full text]
  • Cyber Defence
    NATO: Stepping up its game in cyber defence Received (in revised form): 10th May, 2017 Jamie Shea is NATO Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges. He has been working with NATO since 1980. Positions included Director of Policy Planning in the Private Office of the Secretary General, Deputy Assistant Secretary General for External Relations, Public Diplomacy Division, Director of Information and Press, Spokesman of NATO and Deputy Director of Information and Press, Deputy Head and Senior Planning Officer in the Policy Planning and Multilateral Affairs Section of the Political Directorate as well as Assistant to the Secretary General of NATO for Special Projects. Outside NATO, he is involved with several prominent academic institutions. He is a professor at the Collège d’Europe, Bruges, visiting lecturer in the Practice of Diplomacy, University of Sussex, Associate Professor of International Relations at the American University, Washington DC, where he also holds the position of director of the Brussels Overseas Study Programme. He also lectures at the Brussels School of International Studies at the University of Kent and at the Security and Strategy Institute of the University of Exeter, where he is an honorary fellow. He is also a senior transatlantic fellow of the German Marshall Fund of the United States and a senior fellow at the London School of Economics, where he teaches a course on crisis management and political communication. He is a regular lecturer and conference speaker on NATO and European security affairs and on public diplomacy, political communication and many other areas of contemporary international relations. He holds a DPhil in modern history from Oxford University (Lincoln College), 1981.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Here
    Connections: The Quarterly Journal ISSN 1812-1098, e-ISSN 1812-2973 Peter Rogers, Connections QJ 19, no. 3 (2020): 13-32 https://doi.org/10.11610/Connections.19.3.01 Research Article The Evolution of Resilience Peter Rogers Macquarie University, Australia, https://www.mq.edu.au/ Abstract: The concept of resilience has roots in many disciplines, making the pursuit of a unified theory very attractive but also very difficult. Yet this has not stopped scholars and politicians from attempting to claim resili- ence as their flagship concept and build a canon for the 21st century around it. This tendency to reduce or totalize resilience has spawned a host of taxonomies, each seeking to offer the final word on the definitional de- bate. I argue that this desire to create a unified theory of resilience misap- plies the concept, ignores the dynamics of its emergence and the poly- semic nature of its use in theory, policy, and practice. This malleability makes resilience at once both a very attractive logic for dealing with un- certainty and a dangerous pathway towards embedding untempered algo- rithmic systems of coercive prediction into the governance of everyday life. In understanding the emergence of the resilience concept, one must ap- preciate both the positive and negative potential of this flexible and adap- tive notion. I close by suggesting that resilience has gained such traction in recent years in no small part because it represents a shift in the onto-poli- tics of our time, but that we must be careful about which type of resilience gets enacted.
    [Show full text]
  • Protect! People, Economies and Infrastructure
    PROTECT! People, Economies and Infrastructure Summary Report of the EastWest Institute’s Fourth Worldwide Security Conference Saleem Vaillancourt William Boyd June 2007 This report is dedicated to the victims of terrorism IN COOPERATION WITH ABOUT THE RAPPORTEURS Saleem Vaillancourt is a freelance journalist, with by-lines in the Guardian, currently working as a project associate for EWI in New York. Educated in literature at the University of London and politics at the London School of Economics, his journalistic and policy interests are security, religious extremism, religion and politics in the Middle East, the political economy of development, and complex humanitarian emergencies. Of Persian, British and Canadian background, Saleem is happiest treating the world as one country and mankind its citizens. William James Boyd holds a MA in International Relations from the University of St. Andrews and was a Consultant to the EastWest Institute’s Global Security Program from 2005-2006. During this time he concentrated on the Security & Technology Project, working to develop public-private partnerships in the security field with a particular focus on counter- terrorism. This extended to helping with the coordination of a series of meetings on the subject under the G8 Presidency of the Russian Federation. He is currently project manager at the Security & Defence Agenda. EWI’S FOURTH WORLDWIDE SECURITY CONFERENCE EWI’s Worldwide Security Conference (WSC) began in 2003 as a response to concerns on both sides of the Atlantic to develop a more comprehensive and collaborative counter-terrorism effort. Today, the Conference has become a global event bringing together nations from all over the world to foster greater cooperation in the fight against terrorism and organized crime.
    [Show full text]
  • Improving Global Cyber Governance Report
    Improving global cyber governance Report Bibliotheque Solvay 30 January 2012 In partnership with: Improving global cyber-governance A Security & Defence Agenda Report Rapporteur: Jonathan Dowdall Photos: Philippe Molitor - Gleamlight Publisher: Geert Cami Date of publication: February 2012 SECURITY & DEFENCE AGENDA Bibliothèque Solvay, Parc Léopold, 137 rue Belliard, B-1040, Brussels, Belgium T: +32 (0)2 737 91 48 F: +32 (0)2 736 32 16 E: [email protected] W: www.securitydefenceagenda.org Programme Evening debate – 30 January 2012 Bibliothèque Solvay, Brussels, 17:30-19:00 This debate launched the SDA’s ambitious global cyber-security study “Cyber-security: The vexed question of global rules”, based on conversations with cyber-security experts around the world. The report takes a hard look at the state of play in cyber-security and will provide public and private sector decision-makers with food for thought and recommendations for concrete next steps. The debate focused on the current void in national and international governance of the cyber-security sector and brought together senior experts from NATO, the EU, the US and the private sector. Speakers: Brigid Grauman, Independent journalist and report author Demosthenes Ikonomou, Head of Secure Services & Project Support Activities, European Net- work and Information Security Agency (ENISA) Jeff Moss, Vice President & Chief Security Officer, Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) Raj Samani, Vice President & Chief Technical Officer, McAfee Europe, Middle East and Africa (EMEA) Jamie Shea, Deputy Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges, North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) The views expressed in this report are personal opinions of the speakers and not necessarily those of the organisations they represent, nor of the Security & Defence Agenda, its members or partners.
    [Show full text]
  • Leaders' Response to Hybrid Threats
    AUTUMN 2019 Leaders’ response to hybrid threats: a real-time case study REPORT Cover image credits: Rost-9/Bigstock, p.8/3 CC Flickr - EU2016 NL Friends of Europe’s Peace, Security and Defence Programme is supported by the United States European Command (EUCOM). Our work is firmly anchored in our expertise in a range of fields, including energy and climate change, geopolitics, international development, migration and health. We seek a holistic approach to European, transatlantic and global security policies. Security considerations are, in turn, mainstreamed into these areas of expertise, enriching the debate by encouraging experts to think outside their comfort zones. We are grateful to Facebook for their support for the exercise. With the support of Rapporteur: Paul Ames Publisher: Geert Cami Senior Fellow: Jamie Shea Director of Programmes and Operations: Nathalie Furrer Programme Managers: Elena Saenz Feehan, Antonia Erlandsson Programme Assistant: Katherine Pye Events Manager: Chris Irons Photographer: Philippe Molitor Editor: Arnaud Bodet Design: Elza Lőw We are very grateful to Chris Kremidas for his support in constructing the scenario and his inspiring can-do attitude. © Friends of Europe - November 2019 Table of contents Executive summary 2 Context 5 Nature of the threat 6 Aims of the exercise 6 The scenario 8 Conclusions and recommendations 10 The private sector 10 EU and NATO cooperation 13 Attribution 14 Civil-military cooperation 15 Enhancing cooperation between the EU, NATO and individual government public affairs and communication teams 15 Building a whole-of-society resilience 17 List of participants 20 Leaders’ response to hybrid threats: a real-time case study | Autumn 2019 2 Executive summary This report draws attention on the urgency to improve cooperation between the public and the private sectors in order to increase readiness and resilience to hybrid challenges.
    [Show full text]