Spectatorship and Fandom of the Roman Chariot Races
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SPECTATORSHIP AND FANDOM OF THE ROMAN CHARIOT RACES SPECTATORSHIP AND FANDOM OF THE ROMAN CHARIOT RACES By AMANDA M. M. DEVITT, B.HUM., M.A. A Thesis Submitted to the School of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy McMaster University © Copyright by Amanda M. M. Devitt, December 2019 McMaster University DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (2019) Hamilton, Ontario (Classics) TITLE: Spectatorship and Fandom of the Roman Chariot Races AUTHOR: Amanda M. M. Devitt, B.HUM. (Carleton University), M.A. (Newcastle University), M.A. (McMaster University) SUPERVISOR: Dr. Michele George NUMBER OF PAGES: (ix) (415) ii ABSTRACT This dissertation is concerned with the spectators of the Roman chariot races throughout the empire. It addresses how the sport was experienced and engaged with in the Roman context, with consideration of the everyday lives of circus fans, social networks and consumer patterns. By making use of a variety of sources, including the structural remains of circuses, material culture, epigraphic evidence, and both literary and historical writings, it is possible to gain a picture of a vibrant community of circus fans that as a group were able to make an impact on the sport as well as on Roman society and culture more broadly. Circus spectators were confronted with an array of stimuli from the moment of their arrival at the venue - from the sights to the sounds and even the feel of the seats - all of which added to their shared experience. Audience members engaged not only with the sport but also with one another, finding common ground in their collective interest in the races. Aside from the casual spectator, many audience members identified themselves to be within a community of fans with common views and beliefs concerning the popular spectacle. Fans of the races passionately followed the sport and its competitors, and offered their support when in attendance at the circus and in their actions outside of the venue. An examination of the phenomena of Roman sport spectators further reveals a rich sub-culture of racing fans that offered an active social experience at the circus and various methods of engagement with the sport at the venue and beyond. iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Foremost, I must express my sincere appreciation to my supervisor, Dr. Michele George, whose expertise and feedback have been instrumental throughout this process. I humbly extend my thanks to the respected members of my committee, Dr. Martin Beckmann and Dr. Evan Haley, and to my external reader Dr. Michael Carter from Brock University, all of whom have provided invaluable advice and contributed to the successful completion of this dissertation. The errors that remain are entirely my own. I would not have been able to complete this dissertation without the financial support given to me by McMaster University and by the Department of Classics. This dissertation was also written with the support of a J. B. McArthur Ontario Graduate Scholarship. I do not believe that I will ever be able to fully express how grateful I am to my parents, Cheryl and Girvin Devitt, whose love and encouragement has seen me through. I wish to thank them both for listening without complaint to rambling monologues about my studies, for reading drafts no matter their personal levels of interest, and for providing me with unwavering moral and emotional support. Without you both this dissertation would not have been possible. Per ardua ad astra, indeed. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ABBREVIATIONS vii LIST OF FIGURES viii INTRODUCTION 1 CHAPTER 1: THE ROMAN CIRCUS 13 1. 1. INTRODUCTION 13 1. 2. ORIGINS OF THE RACES 15 1. 3. DEVELOPMENT OF THE ROMAN RACES 23 1. 4. DEVELOPMENT OF THE CIRCUS MAXIMUS 30 1. 5. OTHER RACING VENUES 42 A. AT ROME B. BEYOND ROME 1. 6. ELITE ROMAN VIEWS OF SPECTACLE AND THE CIRCUS 53 A. SPECTACLE B. THE CIRCUS 1. 7. THE EMPEROR AT THE CIRCUS 85 CHAPTER 2: A DAY AT THE RACES 95 2. 1. INTRODUCTION 95 2. 2. ARRIVALS 99 2. 3. ACCESSING SEATS 104 2. 4. SEATING 111 2. 5. THE POMPA CIRCENSIS 122 2. 6. BETTING ON THE RACES 131 2. 7. EXPERIENCE IN THE STANDS 141 2. 8. SOUNDS OF THE CIRCUS 153 CHAPTER 3: SPECTATORS AND FANS 158 3. 1. INTRODUCTION 158 3. 2. CHILDREN AND THE RACES 160 3. 3. FACTIONS 170 3. 4. CHARIOTEERS 179 3. 5. STARS OF THE RACES 183 3. 6. THE POPULAR IMAGE OF THE RACES 189 3. 7. THE INFAMIA OF CHARIOTEERS 204 3. 8. HORSES 209 3. 9. FAN SUPPORT 216 v 3. 10. THE ‘HOME ADVANTAGE’ AND HOMETOWN HEROES 220 3. 11. THE EMPEROR AS A RACING FAN 228 CHAPTER 4: THE PSYCHOLOGY OF A CIRCUS FAN: A MODERN SPORT PSYCHOLOGY APPROACH 238 4. 1. INTRODUCTION 238 4. 2. SPORTS SPECTATOR MOTIVATIONS 240 4. 3. SPORTS FAN MOTIVATIONS 247 4. 4. THE PRIMARY MOTIVATIONS OF CIRCUS FANS 263 4. 5. THE ‘FANDOM-BOUND’ IDENTITY 269 CHAPTER 5: SPECTATOR PARTICIPATION & THE USE OF CIRCUS DEFIXIONES 294 5. 1. INTRODUCTION 294 5. 2. FANDOM TO FANATICISM 296 5. 3. EXPRESSIVE COLLECTIVE BEHAVIOUR 302 5. 4. THE INFLUENCE OF FANS 308 5. 5. CIRCUS DEFIXIONES 313 A. LOCATIONS B. INVOCATIONS C. CURSE REQUESTS D. THE TARGETS E. THE CREATION OF CURSES CONCLUSION 355 BIBLIOGRAPHY 362 APPENDIX: COLLECTION OF CIRCUS DEFIXIONES 390 vi ABBREVIATIONS N.B. Throughout the dissertation, a note (footnote or endnote) has been abbreviated: “n.”, and a catalogue number has been abbreviated: “no.”. Circus defixiones which can be found in the Appendix (Collection of Circus Defixiones) at the end of the dissertation have been abbreviated: “App. No.”. AE L'Année Épigraphique, pub. in Revue ArChéologique and separately (1888– ) BE Bulletin épigraphique, pub. in Revue des études grecques. CIL Corpus Inscriptionum Latinarum (1863– ) Graf. Pal. Väänänen, V., Solin, H., Itkonen-Kaila, M. Graffiti Palatino (1968) IG InsCriptiones GraeCae (1873– ) PGM Preisendanz, K. Papyri GraeCae MagiCae, 2 vols. (2nd ed. 1973-4) P. Oxy. Oxyrhynchus Papyri (1898– ) ILS Dessau, H. InsCriptiones Latinae SeleCtae (1892-1916) SEG Supplementum Epigraphicum Graecum (1923– ) vii LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1 Plan of stairway type 1, as seen at Lepcis Magna 104 Figure 2 Plan of stairway type 2, as seen at Lepcis Magna 105 Figure 3 Plans of series of rooms in remains of Circus Maximus 106 Figure 4 Analysis of circulation system at Circus Maximus 109 Figure 5 Evaluation of visual conditions in seating of Circus Maximus 116 Figure 6 Estimated venue seating capacity and measurements 146 Figure 7 Graffito of victorious charioteer 187 Figure 8 Graffito of two chariot teams and victor 187 Figure 9 Graffito of chariot team and presentation of palm 187 Figure 10 Silin mosaic 191 Figure 11 Foligno relief 191 Figure 12 Lamp depicting quadrigae race 191 Figure 13 Floor mosaic, Bell-lloc (Gerona) 193 Figure 14 Black and white mosaic, Ostia 194 Figure 15 Lamp disk 195 Figure 16 Lamp disk 195 Figure 17 Lamp 196 Figure 18 Fibula 196 Figure 19 Knife handle 197 Figure 20 Knife handle 197 Figure 21 Knife handle 198 viii Figure 22 Knife handle 198 Figure 23 Knife handle 198 Figure 24 Knife handle 198 Figure 25a Glass beaker, Corning Museum 201 Figure 25b Complete decoration of cup 201 Figure 26 Fragment of cup decoration 201 Figure 27 Mosaic, Cherchel 212 Figure 28 Mosaic detail, Tunisia 212 Figure 29 Mosaic, Hadrumetum 213 Figure 30 Lamp with procession 213 Figure 31 Mosaic of horses, House of the Horses 215 Figure 32 Jar depicting race of quadrigae 281 Figure 33 Glass vessel depicting race of quadrigae 281 Figure 34 Four-horse chariot team on an intaglio 282 Figure 35 Twenty-horse chariot team on an intaglio 282 Figure 36 Victorious charioteer on a lamp 282 Figure 37 Victorious charioteer on a money box 282 ix Ph.D. Thesis – A. Devitt; McMaster University - Classics INTRODUCTION Public games were presented regularly in Rome as a method of entertaining the masses, and as the spectacles (spectacula) continued to grow in popularity, they also grew in scale, with elite citizens funding them to reinforce their status and to gain popular support in politics. Although gladiatorial combat has been the basis of much scholarship, chariot racing in fact had the greater popularity in the Roman world. The Circus Maximus in Rome was far older and larger than the nearby Colosseum, and the races were beloved by devoted fans throughout the Roman empire, drawing crowds centuries after the gladiatorial games ended. The sport of chariot racing was an integral part of public entertainment that engrossed the majority of the Roman population, with popularity so great that it pervaded Roman society and politics. The Roman spectacle audience was lively and responsive; at the circus the spectators fervently supported their favourites and were devoted in their engagement with the sport. Fans of the chariot races were remarkably influential, as they not only sought to participate in the competitions from their places in the stands but also prompted the involvement of others with the increasingly popular sport. Studies of sports, both ancient and modern, tend to focus on the sport itself, its production and performance; seldom are the fans identified as the central subject for examination. In the ancient sources sports fans, particularly circus fans, are a group that is under- or unrepresented and often relegated to little more than brief anecdotes concerning their boisterous and immoderate 1 Ph.D. Thesis – A. Devitt; McMaster University - Classics behaviour. Yet questions concerning the interest and behaviour of sports fans, who themselves represent a significant aspect of Roman culture, are worthy of sustained attention.1 Modern scholars have often attempted to correlate the partisanship of circus fans to political parties or religious connections; while these possible connections do have value, they are by no means the only factors of merit in the discussion of these fan groups.