Using Force to Gain Voice: the Prospects and Limits of Using Coercive Mechanisms to Secure Deliberative Inclusion

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Using Force to Gain Voice: the Prospects and Limits of Using Coercive Mechanisms to Secure Deliberative Inclusion USING FORCE TO GAIN VOICE: THE PROSPECTS AND LIMITS OF USING COERCIVE MECHANISMS TO SECURE DELIBERATIVE INCLUSION by NICOLE PAULA CURATO A thesis submitted to The University of Birmingham for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY Department of Political Science and International Studies School of Government and Society The University of Birmingham April 2011 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. ABSTRACT USING FORCE TO GAIN VOICE: THE PROSPECTS AND LIMITS OF USING COERCIVE MECHANISMS TO SECURE DELIBERATIVE INCLUSION This thesis analyses the impact of marginalised groups using coercive mechanisms as a strategy for deliberative inclusion. It engages the literature on deliberative democratic theory that makes a case for using non-linguistic mechanisms to gain entry to exclusionary deliberative forums. This research explores its limits through a linguistic-based microanalysis of an ―extreme‖ case where marginalised political agents employed threats of force – the apparent antithesis of deliberation – in an attempt to secure inclusion. The case is that of a military mutiny in the Philippines in 2003, where a group of junior officers took over the central business district to publicly air their demands for reform to the military. This strategy opened up spaces for junior officers who did not have access to channels for grievance articulation to persuade government officials to launch reform programs that addressed their concerns in exchange for their peaceful return to barracks. The case highlights that the manner of gaining access to deliberative forums has an effect on the dynamic of the deliberative process. It is argued that while non-linguistic mechanisms can be constructive in opening deliberative spaces, they also risk limiting the deliberative process and outcomes that are borne of coercion. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This doctoral dissertation was made possible by the generous assistance of the Overseas Research Students Award Scheme and the University of Birmingham‘s Graduate Teaching Scholarship. The research was developed over three years under the supervision of Dr. Andrew Knops and Dr. Will Leggett and the continuous mentorship of Prof. John Holmwood and Rep. Walden Bello. The comments of Dr. John Parkinson and Prof. Peter Preston after the viva voce examination were also helpful in improving the final version of this piece. Integral to the completion of this research was the support provided by the Institute of Strategic and Development Studies (ISDS) in Manila and the Australian National University (ANU) Centre for Deliberative Global Governance. ISDS, under the leadership of Prof. Emeritus Carolina Hernandez and Prof. Herman Kraft, served as institutional host during the fieldwork in Manila, while ANU, with the support of Prof. John Dryzek, hosted a three-month institutional visit which provided the intellectual space to conduct data analysis and test preliminary ideas for the thesis. The hospitality and encouragement extended by the Department of Sociology in the University of the Philippines-Diliman as well as the editorial advice provided by Rodrigo Trompiz are deeply appreciated. As in any project, there are a number of individuals who indirectly yet indispensably contributed to the completion of this dissertation. Most of them are best thanked in person but the companionship and (in)sanity provided by André Palacios, Jonathan Ong and Kehinde Andrews deserve to be put on record. TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction Deliberative Theory: From what’s desirable to what’s possible 1 Deliberative inclusion: Connecting theory to practice 3 Research strategy 4 Aims 7 Main claims 7 Chapter overview 9 Chapter 1 Deliberating in a non-ideal speech situation 14 Classic deliberative theory 18 Process of exchanging reasons 17 Preference transformation 19 Inclusion 20 Criticisms and reformulations of the classic deliberative ideal 24 Strategies for inclusion 28 Overcoming exclusion during deliberation itself 37 Deliberation‘s linguistic roots 41 An important caveat: reason-giving as prerequisite to generating agreements 45 Chapter 2 Researching coercion and deliberative inclusion 51 Research question 52 Instrumental case study 53 Research design 55 Data gathering strategy 56 Primary data 57 Interview design 61 Research ethics 63 Secondary data 65 A note on translation 66 Data analysis 67 Grounded theory 67 Resolution-oriented reconstruction 68 Some limitations 75 Chapter 3 Marginalised Military Men 79 AFP as servant and author 81 AFP as servant (of elite interest) 82 AFP as author 88 Seeds of disagreement 92 Communicative channels in the AFP 99 Discredited communicative channels 104 Inauthentic channels 104 Inconsequential channels 108 Chapter 4 The road to Oakwood is paved with good intentions 115 Exploring other channels for grievance articulation 116 Gripes and pacts among peers 117 Joining a political campaign 120 Deliberative counter-publics 125 Formation of a counter-public 125 Deliberative meetings 129 The road to Oakwood 134 Deliberative activism? 137 Fidelity 139 Charity and exhaustion 141 Proportionality 143 Chapter 5 Gentlemen’s agreement, gentlemen’s argument 149 Confrontation stage 150 Communicating through force 152 Testimony 155 Violations 158 Opening stage 159 Discussion roles 159 Meta-discussion 163 Argumentation stage 171 Discussion rules 172 Topics of argumentation 174 Concluding stage 179 The mutiny as consequential 181 Violations of discussion rules 182 Diagnosing deliberative failure 187 The manner of gaining entry affects the dynamic of taking part 189 Epilogue 194 Chapter 6 Limitations of deliberation secured through coercion 196 Coercive tactics as justification for further exclusion 198 Challenges of building a communicative relationship 202 Speech cultures as deterrents of inclusion 207 Limits and prospects of deliberation secured through coercion 212 Directions for future research 215 Appendix 217 References 232 2 ABBREVIATIONS AFP Armed Forces of the Philippines CPP Communist Party of the Philippines DND Department of National Defence EDSA Epifiano delos Santos Avenue FFFC Feliciano Fact-Finding Commission ISAFP Intelligence Service, Armed Forces of the Philippines ISDS Institute for Strategic and Development Studies MILF Moro Islamic Liberation Front NICA National Intelligence Coordinating Agency NPA New People‘s Army NRP National Recovery Programme PDEA Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency PMA Philippine Military Academy PNP Philippine National Police PSG Presidential Security Group RAM Reform the Armed Forces of the Philippines Movement RSBS Retirement Separation Benefit System SWAG Special Warfare Action Group SWS Social Weather Stations INTRODUCTION DELIBERATIVE THEORY: FROM WHAT’S DESIRABLE TO WHAT’S POSSIBLE The literature on deliberative democracy has been a major intellectual force in the past two decades. It has shifted democratic discourse from an aggregative or ―vote-centric‖ tradition to a ―talk-centric‖ one where democracy is considered a matter of effective communication and not just preference aggregation (Dryzek, 1996, p.15). Deliberative theory maintains that democratic authenticity is achieved through deliberation: a ―special‖ process of political communication wherein ―deliberators are amenable to changing their judgments, preferences and views during the course of their interactions, which involve persuasion rather than coercion, manipulation or deception‖ (Dryzek, 2000, p.1). Democracy is considered more as a platform for publicly exchanging and weighing reasons to generate agreements and less as a market for pushing for private interests, as in the case of lobbying or bargaining (Parkinson, 2006, p.3). A major criticism of deliberative theory is its focus on conceptualising ―what is desirable rather than what is possible‖ (Phillips, 1995, p.190). Classic deliberative theory is viewed to have only identified the ideal conditions and principles that distinguish deliberation from other forms of political action. Its normative approach lacks an account of how its ideals translate to actually- existing circumstances. Questions are raised about the feasibility of having a cooperative and reason-based discussion under conditions of political exclusion, economic inequality and cultural marginalisation. Due to these criticisms, a number of deliberative democrats set off a theoretical trajectory focused on the complexities of deliberating under suboptimal conditions. Some have toned down the prominence classic deliberative theory has accorded to reason-giving as the ideal form of 1 political justification. Instead, reason-giving is considered just one of a variety of communicative modes acceptable in deliberation including rhetoric, storytelling, testimony and humour (e.g. Young, 1996; Dryzek, 2000; Parkinson, 2006; Chambers, 2009; Mansbridge et al., 2006). A model of deliberation that incorporates a diversity of speech styles recognises that some discourses, particularly disenfranchised ones, are best articulated through expressive means to generate
Recommended publications
  • Committee Daily Bulletin
    CCoommmmiitttteeee DDaaiillyy BBuulllleettiinn 17th Congress A publication of the Committee Affairs Department Vol. III No. 50 Third Regular Session November 19, 2018 BICAMERAL CONFERENCE COMMITTEE MEETING MEASURES COMMITTEE PRINCIPAL SUBJECT MATTER ACTION TAKEN/ DISCUSSION NO. AUTHOR Bicameral HB 5784 & Rep. Tan (A.) Instituting universal health care for all The Bicameral Conference Committee, co- Conference SB 1896 and Sen. Recto Filipinos, prescribing reforms in the health presided by Rep. Angelina "Helen" Tan, M.D. Committee care system and appropriating funds (4th District, Quezon), Chair of the House therefor Committee on Health, and Sen. Joseph Victor Ejercito, Chair of the Senate Committee on Health and Demography, will deliberate further on the disagreeing provisions of HB 5784 and SB 1896. The Department of Health (DOH) and the Philippine Health Insurance Corporation (PhilHealth) were requested to submit their respective proposals on the premium rate, income ceiling and timeframe to be adopted in relation to the provision increasing the members’ monthly PhilHealth premium. Other conferees who were present during the bicameral conference committee meeting were the following: On the part of the House, Deputy Speaker Evelina Escudero (1st District, Sorsogon), Reps. Jose Enrique "Joet" Garcia III (2nd District, Bataan), Arlene Arcillas (1st District, Laguna), Estrellita Suansing (1st District, Nueva Ecija), Cheryl Deloso-Montalla (2nd District, Zambales), and Ron Salo (Party- List, KABAYAN); on the part of the Senate, Senators, Ralph Recto, Risa Hontiveros, and Joel Villanueva. Also present were former Reps. Karlo Alexei Nograles and Harry Roque Jr., DOH Secretary Francisco Duque III, and Dr. Roy Ferrer, acting President and CEO of PhilHealth. Bicameral HB 5236 & Rep.
    [Show full text]
  • EIR Founder and Contributing Editor: Lyndon H
    EIR Founder and Contributing Editor: Lyndon H. LaRouche, Jr. Editorial Board: Lyndon H. LaRouche, Jr., Muriel Mirak-Weissbach, Antony Papert, Gerald From the Associate Editor Rose, Dennis Small, Edward Spannaus, Nancy Spannaus, Jeffrey Steinberg, William Wertz Editor: Paul Gallagher Associate Editors: Ronald Kokinda, Susan Welsh n the 28 years of its existence, EIR has gained the well-deserved Managing Editor: John Sigerson I Science Editor: Marjorie Mazel Hecht reputation as the magazine that tells you what you need to know, not Special Projects: Mark Burdman what you prefer to hear. Some people find that not to their liking; but Book Editor: Katherine Notley Photo Editor: Stuart Lewis with the world sinking each day deeper into economic crisis and war, Circulation Manager: Stanley Ezrol isn’t it about time to look for truth, rather than self-consoling delu- INTELLIGENCE DIRECTORS: sions? Counterintelligence: Jeffrey Steinberg, Michele Steinberg You’ll find a lot of truth, in this week’s jam-packed issue. Economics: Marcia Merry Baker, Let me suggest that you start with Lyndon H. LaRouche’s state- Lothar Komp History: Anton Chaitkin ment on page 66, “Who Did Kill Cock Robin, After All?” He sets Ibero-America: Dennis Small the record straight on Sept. 11, and makes a simple proposal: “The Law: Edward Spannaus Russia and Eastern Europe: Executive and Congress should make truth, not ‘spin,’ the standard Rachel Douglas for intelligence work. It would be a wonderful change!” United States: Debra Freeman, Suzanne Rose LaRouche and his associates worldwide are intervening to INTERNATIONAL BUREAUS: Bogota´: Javier Almario achieve a shift in the otherwise tragic trajectory of our age.
    [Show full text]
  • Meralco Millennium Foundation Inc
    September 2006 Meralco Millennium Foundation Inc.: Sharing the light MAYBE it has something to do with the high standards for phi- We are at Lopez’s 11th floor office at the Meralco building in lanthropy set by no less than the founder of the Lopez Group, Ortigas. The executive director of the Meralco Millennium but in Meralco, people take CSR, or corporate social respon- Foundation Inc. (MMFI), together with Corporate Social Re- sibility, very seriously. sponsibility Office (CSRO) head Christopher Yap, is explaining “In Meralco, sanay na yung mga tao sa mga medical mis- why Meralco employees are particularly keen about pitching in, sion, mga pagtulong. Like we’d learn that a particular office whether it is their time, money or other extras. spent a day at a certain depressed area, they brought along sup- Lopez, a grandson of Lopez Group founder Don Eugenio plies, donated old computers. So it’s really a way of life na rin,” Lopez Sr., grew up in a family where philanthropy is a tradition. Miguel “Mike” Lopez says. “We’ve witnessed the older generations engaging in philan- Turn to page 6 German Month festivities …p.12 Sagip Meralco Sibol School pupils render a song number Guimaras…p.9 during the MNTC-GK Village turnover in Bulacan 2 LOPEZLINK September 2006 1H 2006 financial performance FPHC wagi sa IPO ng power affiliate KUMITA ng P4.0 bilyon ang First Philip- Lumaki ng 18% ang consolidated rev- 1H 2006 Financial Results pine Holdings Corporation (FPHC) noong enues sa US$467.4 milyon mula unang anim na buwan ng 2006, mula P1.7 US$397.3 milyon dahil sa mas mataas na Period Total Revenues Net Income/(loss) bilyon noong unang hati ng nakaraang presyo ng natural gas noong unang anim January-June taon.
    [Show full text]
  • THE HUMBLE BEGINNINGS of the INQUIRER LIFESTYLE SERIES: FITNESS FASHION with SAMSUNG July 9, 2014 FASHION SHOW]
    1 The Humble Beginnings of “Inquirer Lifestyle Series: Fitness and Fashion with Samsung Show” Contents Presidents of the Republic of the Philippines ................................................................ 8 Vice-Presidents of the Republic of the Philippines ....................................................... 9 Popes .................................................................................................................................. 9 Board Members .............................................................................................................. 15 Inquirer Fitness and Fashion Board ........................................................................... 15 July 1, 2013 - present ............................................................................................... 15 Philippine Daily Inquirer Executives .......................................................................... 16 Fitness.Fashion Show Project Directors ..................................................................... 16 Metro Manila Council................................................................................................. 16 June 30, 2010 to June 30, 2016 .............................................................................. 16 June 30, 2013 to present ........................................................................................ 17 Days to Remember (January 1, AD 1 to June 30, 2013) ........................................... 17 The Philippines under Spain ......................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Reproductive Health Bill
    Reproductive Health Bill From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Intrauterine device (IUD): The Reproductive Health Bill provides for universal distribution of family planning devices, and its enforcement. The Reproductive Health bills, popularly known as the RH Bill , are Philippine bills aiming to guarantee universal access to methods and information on birth control and maternal care. The bills have become the center of a contentious national debate. There are presently two bills with the same goals: House Bill No. 4244 or An Act Providing for a Comprehensive Policy on Responsible Parenthood, Reproductive Health, and Population and Development, and For Other Purposes introduced by Albay 1st district Representative Edcel Lagman, and Senate Bill No. 2378 or An Act Providing For a National Policy on Reproductive Health and Population and Development introduced by Senator Miriam Defensor Santiago. While there is general agreement about its provisions on maternal and child health, there is great debate on its key proposal that the Philippine government and the private sector will fund and undertake widespread distribution of family planning devices such as condoms, birth control pills(BCPs) and IUDs, as the government continues to disseminate information on their use through all health care centers. The bill is highly divisive, with experts, academics, religious institutions, and major political figures supporting and opposing it, often criticizing the government and each other in the process. Debates and rallies for and against the bill, with tens of thousand participating, have been happening all over the country. Background The first time the Reproductive Health Bill was proposed was in 1998. During the present 15th Congress, the RH Bills filed are those authored by (1) House Minority Leader Edcel Lagman of Albay, HB 96; (2) Iloilo Rep.
    [Show full text]
  • Advisory No. 2021 – 04 : Temporary Suspension on the Processing Of
    ADVISORY NO. 2021 - 04 SUBJECT : TEMPORARY SUSPENSION ON THE PROCESSING OF REQUESTS OF FOREIGN NATIONALS FOR ENDORSEMENT TO THE DEPARTMENT OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS FOR TRAVEL BAN EXEMPTIONS TO THE PHILIPPINES This is with regard to the requests of Foreign Nationals (FNs) for endorsement to the Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) for Travel Ban Exemptions (TBE) to the Philippines. The Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT) refers to the following: (i) The Inter-Agency Task Force for the Management of Emerging Infectious Diseases (IATF- MEID) Resolution No. 103 dated 18 March 2021, wherein the entry of FNs into the country will be temporarily suspended from 22 March 2021 to 21 April 2021; (ii) The IATF-MEID National Task Force Against COVID-19 (NTF COVID-19) Memorandum Circular No. 6 dated 18 March 2021 on the Temporary Suspension of Travel into the Philippines, wherein the temporary suspension of entry of FNs into the country from 22 March 2021 to 21 April 2021 was also provided; and (iii) The Letter dated 19 March 2021 from DFA Undersecretary for Civilian Security and Consular Affairs Brigido J. Dulay on the Suspension of Processing of Entry Exemption Requests from 22 March 2021 to 21 April 2021, wherein National Government Agencies (NGAs) were advised not to send any endorsements during the said period as they will be disregarded. In line with the abovementioned, please be advised that the DICT will also be suspending the processing of requests of FNs for endorsements to the DFA for TBE to the Philippines from 22 March 2021 until 21 April 2021.
    [Show full text]
  • United Nations Juridical Yearbook, 1997
    Extract from: UNITED NATIONS JURIDICAL YEARBOOK 1997 Part Three. Judicial decisions on questions relating to the United Nations and related intergovernmental organizations Chapter VIII. Decisions of national tribunals Copyright (c) United Nations CONTENTS (continued) Page 13. Submission of proposals by intergovernmental organiza- tions in functional commissions of the Economic and Social Council—Rules of procedure 69 (3), 71 (2>) and 74 of the functional commissions of the Council—Council decision 1995/209 451 14. Restructuring of the Secretariat—Authority of the Secretary- General 452 15. Institutional aspects of the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development 459 16. Participation by Yugoslavia in international confer- ences—General Assembly resolutions 47/1 and 47/229 . 463 17. Practice of the United Nations in cases of chai lenged repre- sentation of a Member State—General Assembly resolution 396 (V) of 14 December 1950 465 18. Question whether the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO) could be considered part of the United Nations sys- tem—Agreement of 24 May 1949 between WHO and PAHO—Agreement of 23 May 1950 between the Organi- zation of American States and PAHO 468 Part Three. Judicial decisions on questions relating to the United Nations and related intergovernmental organizations CHAPTER VII. DECISIONS AND ADVISORY OPINIONS OF INTERNA- TIONAL TRIBUNALS International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea The M/V "Saiga" (No. 1) Case (Saint Vincent and the Grenadines v. Guinea) Jurisdiction of a State over the exclusive economic zone—Article 73, para. 2, of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea—Right of hot pursuit in accordance with article 111 of the Convention 477 CHAPTER VIII.
    [Show full text]
  • This Annual Report
    SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | 1 2 | SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORTSupreme 2005 Court of the Philippines The Davide Court Seated from left: Justice Angelina Sandoval-Gutierrez, Justice Leonardo A. Quisumbing, Justice Reynato S. Puno, Chief Justice Hilario G. Davide, Jr., Justice Artemio V. Panganiban, Justice Consuelo Ynares-Santiago, and Justice Antonio T. Carpio Standing from left: Justice Minita V. Chico-Nazario, Justice Adolfo S. Azcuna, Justice Conchita Carpio Morales, Justice Ma. Alicia Austria-Martinez, Justice Renato C. Corona, Justice Romeo J. Callejo, Sr., Justice Dante O. Tinga, and Justice Cancio C. Garcia The Panganiban Court Seated from left: Justice Antonio T. Carpio, Justice Consuelo Ynares-Santiago, Justice Reynato S. Puno, Chief Justice Artemio V. Panganiban, Justice Leonardo A. Quisumbing, Justice Angelina Sandoval-Gutierrez, and Justice Ma. Alicia Austria-Martinez Standing from left: Justice Cancio C. Garcia, Justice Dante O. Tinga, Justice Romeo J. Callejo, Sr., Justice Renato C. Corona, Justice Conchita Carpio Morales, Justice Adolfo S. Azcuna, Justice Minita V. Chico-Nazario, and Justice Presbitero J. Velasco, Jr. SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | 3 ANNUAL REPORT 2005 PREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 |SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 20 PREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 |SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL REPORT 2005 | SUPREME COURT | ANNUAL
    [Show full text]
  • Scared Silent RIGHTS Impunity for Extrajudicial Killings in the Philippines WATCH June 2007 Volume 19, No
    The Philippines HUMAN Scared Silent RIGHTS Impunity for Extrajudicial Killings in the Philippines WATCH June 2007 Volume 19, No. 9(C) Scared Silent Impunity for Extrajudicial Killings in the Philippines I. Summary............................................................................................................. 1 II. Methods.............................................................................................................7 III. Recent Military Relations with Government and Civil Society ...............................8 Military involvement in politics............................................................................. 8 Military campaign against the New People’s Army ...............................................10 The military and leftist political and civil society groups ...................................... 11 Recent Developments ......................................................................................... 17 Task Force Usig ...................................................................................................18 Melo Commission ...............................................................................................18 Visit by the Special Rapporteur on Extrajudicial Executions .................................22 IV. Extrajudicial Executions................................................................................... 25 Extrajudicial executions ......................................................................................28 Pastor Isias de Leon Santa Rosa.......................................................................29
    [Show full text]
  • TAMBULI Weekly Newsletter the Official E-Newsletter of the Federation of Philippine Industries
    aoa TAMBULI Weekly Newsletter The Official e-Newsletter of the Federation of Philippine Industries Volume 17 Issue No. 43 06 December 2013 _______________________________________________________________________________ FPI Power and Energy Forum - 12 December 2013 The Federation of Philippine Industries (FPI) will conduct a Power and Energy Forum on 12 December 2013 (Thursday), 1:30 P.M. at Club Filipino, Greenhills, San Juan City . The objective of the forum is to provide update information to FPI members who are Contestable Customers (CCs) under the Open Access Retail Competition (OARC). The forum will give light on the OARC status, to guide CCs on their actions in this early phase of the OARC scheme. Discussions will attempt to address the following concerns: 1) CCs without RES Contract are in quandary with the coming deadline in December 2013; 2) Experience/reactions, so far of CCs with RES contracts; and 3) Perceived tight Grid power supply, and measures that are and will be put in-place. It will also serve as a gathering to understand, share current and future policies by major energy stakeholders, to enable FPI members in the manufacturing industry to manage and be competitive in their power and energy resources. There will also be an open forum on specific topics presented by each resource speaker. Registration is FREE for FPI MEMBERS. Considering that space is limited, accommodation will be on a first to reserve, first to be served basis (‘walk-ins’ will not be entertained). For particulars, please contact the FPI Secretariat. COM. BIAZON HAS DELICADEZA The Federation of Philippine Industries (FPI), admired the decision of Com.
    [Show full text]
  • Pjr-APRIL08.Pdf
    2 APRIL 2008 PJR REPORTS EDITOR’S NOTE PUBLISHED BY THE CENTER FOR MEDIA FREEDOM & RESPONSIBILITY Good news, bad news Melinda Quintos de Jesus Publisher Luis V. Teodoro T’S A cliché in these parts, the idea that crisis brings out the indifference and the inherent weaknesses of the justice system. Editor best in people, but crisis can also, and does bring out, the If the boost in the number and depth of reports on the current worst in men and women. For every taxi driver who returns crisis is any gauge (see “Political Controversies: First Quarter Hector Bryant L. Macale I a laptop a passenger has left in his cab, for example, there must Shows Coverage Boost”, pp. 12-16) , at least part of the media is Assistant Editor be hundreds of other people who would not only grab any well on the way to recovery, and what’s more, many journalists opportunity to make a few dishonest pesos, but who would are quickly learning how to extract information, in behalf of Don Gil K. Carreon Jose Bimbo F. Santos even go out of their way to take something that doesn’t belong the public that needs and wants it, from an officialdom dedicated Melanie Y. Pinlac to them, often with the use of force or subterfuge. to concealing it. Official evasion, disinformation and even the Kathryn Roja G. Raymundo One can say the same of the Philippine media, which arrest of journalists appear to have taught the media the signal Kristine Joyce G. Magadia incidentally habitually play up every incident of people being lesson that their adversarial relationship with government, Apple Jean C.
    [Show full text]
  • Political Forecast: Mapping the Future Front Where We Are Today
    On the Occasion of the Lopez Group of Companies Economic and Political Briefing 3:20PM 15 September 2014 Manansala Tower Rockwell Center, Makati City Political Forecast: Mapping the Future Front Where We are Today delivered by LEILA M. DE LIMA Introduction Good afternoon! My heartfelt thanks to the Lopez Group of Companies for inviting me to be a part of the group-wide Economic and Political Briefing, aimed at assisting this collective in the preparation of your Five-Year Strategic and Annual Profit Plans. As honored as I am for this singular opportunity, I must admit that I am also surprised because I do not consider myself a political person. In fact, being politicized is one of the very first things we sought to change about the public's perception about the Department of Justice. We discharge our primary mandate and, hence, serve the public interest best, when we are conscious that the enforcement of laws, and the investigation and prosecution of their violation, ought not to be dictated by political considerations. We promote the Rule of Law and have vowed to deliver true and complete Justice - and there is a reason why Justice is depicted as being blind-folded. Be that as it may, having been a part of this Administration from its very first day, more than four years ago, and having served in the Commission on Human Rights more than two years prior that, I believe that the insights that I have gained, from such a productive, eventful and, you might say, even tumultuous six years (of my public life), might be of some assistance to the Lopez Group of Companies.
    [Show full text]