Government Defeat in Lords on Public Service Pensions Bill Tuesday 12/02/2013

On 12/02/2013 the government had a defeat in the House of Lords on an amendment to the Public Service Pensions Bill: To include the Defence Fire and Rescue Service under the category of fire and rescue services generally, so that they are no longer subject to the separate Ministry of Defence retirement age and pension scheme.

This was defeat number 13 in the parliamentary session. Breakdown For Govt Against Govt Total No vote Conservative 122 0 122 91 Labour 0 154 154 68 Liberal Democrat 60 0 60 30 Crossbench 9 52 61 117 Bishops 0 1 1 23 Other 2 9 11 21 Total 193 216 409 350

Conservative Votes with the Government Lord Ahmad of Wimbledon Baroness Anelay of St Johns Lord Ashton of Hyde Lord Astor of Hever Earl Attlee Lord Bates Baroness Berridge Lord Blencathra Lord Bowness Lord Brabazon of Tara Lord Brittan of Spennithorne Lord Brooke of Sutton Mandeville Lord Brougham and Vaux Baroness Browning Baroness Buscombe Baroness Byford Earl Caithness Earl Cathcart Lord Chadlington Lord Colwyn Lord Cope of Berkeley Lord Cormack Earl Courtown Lord Crathorne Baroness Cumberlege Lord De Mauley Lord Deben Lord Deighton Lord Denham Lord Dixon-Smith Lord Dobbs Earl Dundee Baroness Eaton Lord Eden of Winton Lord Elton Lord Faulks Lord Fellowes of West Stafford Lord Flight Baroness Fookes Lord Forsyth of Drumlean Lord Fowler Lord Framlingham Lord Freeman Lord Freud Lord Gardiner of Kimble Baroness Gardner of Parkes Lord Geddes Lord Glenarthur Lord Goodlad Lord Grade of Yarmouth Lord Hamilton of Epsom Baroness Hanham Lord Henley Lord Higgins Lord Hill of Oareford Lord Howe of Aberavon Earl Howe Lord Hunt of Wirral Lord Hurd of Westwell Lord Inglewood Lord James of Blackheath Baroness Jenkin of Kennington Lord Jenkin of Roding Lord Lang of Monkton Lord Lawson of Blaby Lord Lexden Earl Liverpool Marquess of Lothian Lord Lucas Lord Luke Lord Lyell Lord MacGregor of Pulham Market Lord Mackay of Clashfern Lord Mancroft Lord Marlesford Lord Mawhinney Lord Mayhew of Twysden Baroness Miller of Hendon Duke of Montrose Lord Moore of Lower Marsh Baroness Morris of Bolton Lord Moynihan Baroness Neville-Jones Baroness Newlove Baroness Noakes Lord Northbrook Lord Norton of Louth Baroness O'Cathain Lord Plumb Lord Popat Lord Renfrew of Kaimsthorn Lord Risby Lord Ryder of Wensum Lord Sanderson of Bowden Baroness Seccombe Earl Selborne Lord Selsdon Baroness Sharples Lord Shaw of Northstead Lord Sheikh Earl Shrewsbury Lord Skelmersdale Lord Spicer Baroness Stedman-Scott Lord Stewartby Baroness Stowell of Beeston Lord Swinfen Lord Taylor of Holbeach Lord Trefgarne Lord Trimble Lord True Lord Tugendhat Baroness Verma Lord Wade of Chorlton Lord Wakeham Baroness Warsi Lord Wei Baroness Wilcox Viscount Younger of Leckie

Conservative Votes against the Government -

Labour Votes with the Government - Labour Votes against the Government Lord Adonis Lord Ahmed Lord Alli Lord Anderson of Swansea Lord Bach Baroness Bakewell Lord Barnett Lord Bassam of Brighton Lord Bhattacharyya Lord Bilston Baroness Blackstone Baroness Blood Lord Bradley Lord Brooke of Alverthorpe Lord Brookman Lord Brooks of Tremorfa Lord Campbell-Savours Lord Carter of Coles Lord Christopher Lord Clark of Windermere Lord Clarke of Hampstead Lord Clinton-Davis Lord Collins of Highbury Baroness Corston Baroness Crawley Lord Davidson of Glen Clova Lord Davies of Oldham Lord Davies of Coity Lord Davies of Stamford Baroness Dean of Thornton-le-Fylde Lord Desai Baroness Donaghy Lord Donoughue Lord Dubs Lord Eatwell Lord Evans of Parkside Lord Evans of Temple Guiting Lord Evans of Watford Lord Falconer of Thoroton Baroness Farrington of Ribbleton Lord Faulkner of Worcester Lord Filkin Lord Foulkes of Cumnock Baroness Gale Baroness Gibson of Market Rasen Lord Giddens Lord Glasman Baroness Golding Lord Gordon of Strathblane Baroness Goudie Baroness Gould of Potternewton Lord Graham of Edmonton Lord Grantchester Lord Grenfell Lord Grocott Viscount Hanworth Lord Harris of Haringey Lord Harrison Lord Hart of Chilton Lord Haworth Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town Baroness Healy of Primrose Hill Baroness Hilton of Eggardon Lord Hollick Baroness Hollis of Heigham Lord Howarth of Newport Lord Howie of Troon Lord Hoyle Baroness Hughes of Stretford Lord Hughes of Woodside Lord Hunt of Kings Heath Lord Hunt of Chesterton Lord Hutton of Furness Lord Irvine of Lairg Lord Janner of Braunstone Baroness Jay of Paddington Lord Jones Lord Judd Baroness Kennedy of The Shaws Lord Kennedy of Southwark Lord Kestenbaum Baroness Kingsmill Lord Kinnock Baroness Kinnock of Holyhead Lord Kirkhill Lord Knight of Weymouth Lord Lea of Crondall Lord Leitch Lord Levy Lord Liddle Lord Lipsey Baroness Lister of Burtersett Lord Macdonald of Tradeston Lord MacKenzie of Culkein Lord Mackenzie of Framwellgate Baroness Massey of Darwen Lord Maxton Lord McAvoy Baroness McIntosh of Hudnall Lord McKenzie of Luton Lord Mitchell Lord Monks Lord Moonie Baroness Morgan of Huyton Lord Morris of Aberavon Lord Morris of Handsworth Lord Noon Baroness Nye Lord O'Neill of Clackmannan Lord Parekh Lord Patel of Bradford Lord Patel of Blackburn Lord Pendry Lord Peston Baroness Pitkeathley Lord Plant of Highfield Lord Ponsonby of Shulbrede Lord Prescott Baroness Prosser Lord Puttnam Baroness Quin Lord Radice Baroness Ramsay of Cartvale Lord Rea Baroness Rendell of Babergh Lord Richard Lord Rosser Lord Rowlands Baroness Royall of Blaisdon Lord Sawyer Lord Sheldon Baroness Sherlock Lord Smith of Leigh Baroness Smith of Basildon Baroness Smith of Gilmorehill Lord Soley Lord Stone of Blackheath Lord Taylor of Blackburn Baroness Taylor of Bolton Baroness Thornton Lord Tomlinson Lord Touhig Lord Triesman Lord Tunnicliffe Lord Turnberg Baroness Turner of Camden Baroness Wall of New Barnet Lord Warner Baroness Wheeler Baroness Whitaker Lord Whitty Lord Williams of Elvel Lord Woolmer of Leeds Liberal Democrat Votes with the Government Lord Addington Lord Alderdice Lord Ashdown of Norton-sub-Hamdon Baroness Benjamin Baroness Bonham-Carter of Yarnbury Lord Bradshaw Baroness Brinton Lord Burnett Lord Carlile of Berriew Lord Chidgey Lord Cotter Lord Dholakia Baroness Doocey Lord Dykes Baroness Falkner of Margravine Lord Fearn Baroness Garden of Frognal Lord German Earl Glasgow Lord Greaves Baroness Hamwee Lord Hussain Baroness Hussein-Ece Lord Jones of Cheltenham Lord Kirkwood of Kirkhope Baroness Kramer Lord Lester of Herne Hill Lord Maclennan of Rogart Baroness Maddock Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames Lord McNally Lord Methuen Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer Lord Newby Baroness Northover Lord Palmer of Childs Hill Baroness Parminter Lord Phillips of Sudbury Baroness Randerson Lord Razzall Lord Redesdale Lord Rennard Lord Roberts of Llandudno Lord Roper Baroness Scott of Needham Market Lord Sharkey Lord Shipley Lord Smith of Clifton Lord Stoneham of Droxford Lord Strasburger Lord Taverne Lord Thomas of Gresford Baroness Thomas of Winchester Lord Tope Lord Tordoff Lord Tyler Baroness Tyler of Enfield Lord Wallace of Tankerness Lord Wallace of Saltaire Baroness Walmsley Liberal Democrat Votes against the Government -

Crossbench Votes with the Government Lord Dear Lord Levene of Portsoken Lord Luce Earl Lytton Viscount Montgomery of Alamein Lord Oxburgh Lord Sutherland of Houndwood Lord Thomas of Swynnerton Crossbench Votes against the Government Lord Alton of Liverpool Lord Best Lord Bichard Baroness Boothroyd Baroness Butler-Sloss Baroness Campbell of Surbiton Earl Clancarty Lord Cobbold Lord Condon Baroness Coussins Lord Craig of Radley Baroness Deech Lord Eames Lord Elystan-Morgan Lord Greenway Lord Hannay of Chiswick Lord Haskins Baroness Hayman Baroness Hollins Baroness Howe of Idlicote Lord Kakkar Baroness Kidron Lord Laming Lord Low of Dalston Countess of Mar Lord Martin of Springburn Baroness Masham of Ilton Lord Mawson Baroness Meacher Baroness Morgan of Drefelin Lord Moser Baroness O'Neill of Bengarve Lord Palmer Lord Pannick Baroness Prashar Lord Quirk Lord Ramsbotham Lord Rees of Ludlow Lord Rowe-Beddoe Earl Sandwich Lord Singh of Wimbledon Lord St John of Bletso Baroness Stern Lord Stirrup Viscount Tenby Lord Walker of Aldringham Lord Walpole Baroness Warnock Lord Williamson of Horton Baroness Young of Hornsey

Bishop Votes with the Government

- Bishop Votes against the Government Bishop of Worcester

Other Votes with the Government Lord Empey Baroness Tonge Other Votes against the Government Lord Browne of Belmont Lord Elis-Thomas Baroness Ford Lord Rogan Lord Rooker Lord Smith of Finsbury Lord Stoddart of Swindon Baroness Uddin Lord Wigley

Ref: 1718