DOCSLIB.ORG

Direct Action Self-Help Groups in Uk Flood Risk Management

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Direct Action Self-Help Groups in Uk Flood Risk Management DIRECT ACTION SELF-HELP GROUPS IN UK FLOOD RISK MANAGEMENT JONATHAN SIMM MEng, BSc(Eng) CEng FICE Thesis submitted to the University of Nottingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy DECEMBER 2015 2 Abstract Given an emerging social turn in Flood and Coastal Risk Management (FCRM) towards wider involvement of local communities, this thesis critically evaluates the extent to which Direct Action Self-Help (DASH) groups are, or can be, viable and an efficacious, efficient and effective means of managing and monitoring FCRM assets (and to determine what makes them so). Within this overall aim, the nature and methods of assessment of the human dimensions of FCRM assets is also addressed. The research methods employed include a combination of semi-structured interviews and other ethnographic tools along with detailed case studies. Analytical tools employed include nVIVO textual analysis of interview transcriptions and engineering and economic analyses of the case study sites. Survey work is used to test the assessment of human dimensions on a semantic differential scale. The emergence of DASH groups to organise work on FCRM is found to be motivated by the need to deal with increasing flood risk in the face of reduced public funding, alongside sense of stewardship and community solidarity. These groups have tended to by catalysed by a few motivated individuals and without a clearly designed structure. There is very limited literature about DASH activity in FCRM. Examination of contextual literature has also enabled a previously unavailable conceptual framework to be developed of the different dimensions, contextual aspects and motivations for DASH activity and its support by government, which was further tested by case studies of river conveyance and sea wall management by DASH groups. Channel maintenance work by DASH groups can be effective and efficient at reducing some aspects of local fluvial flood risk for lower order flood events. Maintenance of existing sea walls by DASH groups is less efficient because of the need for significant expenditure on materials and only efficacious if the engineering is quality controlled; its longer term effectiveness is limited by sea level rise. DASH groups require nurture to be sustainable but can deliver community benefits. i Professional FCRM coordination and support of DASH activity is examined using a case study of an Environment Agency (EA) area coordinator and comparisons with alternative approaches. Support of DASH groups by FCRM professionals is essential to avoid unwise activities and involves not only controlling consents, but also in providing advice on the nature and extent to which DASH activity might be appropriate and in arranging practical support and seed-corn funding. The most effective form of DASH facilitation requires a quality and quantity of involvement that cannot readily be supplied by dispersed arrangements from a number of individuals. This research also proposes an approach for assessing and scoring the human dimensions of engineering assets in a manner consistent with visual assessment of their engineering performance. The dimensions of Sense of Security, Accessibility/Availability and Delight/Inspiration reflect insights from key thinkers from a wide range of disciplines. The framework is verified for the FCRM context using analysis of semi-structured interviews and other ethnographic materials. Evaluation of trials in which DASH and other community groups assess human dimensions on a semantic differential scale shows the method to be workable with further development. ii Acknowledgements I would like to gratefully acknowledge all those who have supported me in the endeavour of preparing this thesis. Firstly I would like to thank my supervisors Dr Susanne Seymour, Dr Mick Mawdesley and latterly Dr Martin Smith for their patient and encouraging supervision especially at times when completing the thesis in the midst of an almost full-time job seemed to recede from the bounds of possibility. The funding received in the form of EPSRC doctoral training grants via Nottingham University and associated with the FRMRC research programme is also gratefully acknowledged. This allowed me to take periods of time out of a busy professional life to focus on the research. Particular thanks go in this regard to Professor Colin Thorne for his unswerving support of me and his important role in securing the necessary funding. Then my thanks goes to all those who gave up time to be interviewed and the DASH groups who allowed me to join them from time to time. Thanks also go to all those involved in my case studies, especially members of the North East Hayling Residents Association, the Hanneys Flood Group and various Environment Agency staff. Particular individual thanks go firstly to Judy Clark for arranging for me to become part of the NEHRA DASH group (Hayling Island), for perseverance in the endeavour itself and for her record keeping and to her and her husband Dave for their frequent hospitality. Secondly, particular thanks go to Keith Lead who allowed me to pry into his challenging professional life, keeping diaries for me as he sought to act as a coordinator of DASH activity in the Thames West Area of the Environment Agency. I would also like to thank my employer HR Wallingford for allowing me to work reduced hours from time to time and by supporting me through payment of tuition fees. I would also like to thank various professional and academic colleagues who allowed me to ‘bounce’ them with my emerging ideas. Particular thanks go to Mark Davison who carried out some InfoWorks RS modelling for me under my direction for one of my case studies. iii Special thanks also go to Ruth Smith and Linda Poxon (and after her sad death her daughter Claire Lowe) who meticulously and efficiently transcribed the interviews which I recorded. Finally I would like to thank my family, friends and supporters. My deep appreciation goes to my family and especially my wife Jenny for their forbearance and patience with me and for allowing me to persevere through difficult times for us all. Many other friends and colleagues could be mentioned, but thanks would be incomplete without mentioning my friend Philip Mader-Grayson for encouraging me to start and persevere with the work; I hope the ‘joining up’ he envisioned is at least in some way reflected in the final product of this thesis. iv Contents Abstract.................................................................................................................... i Acknowledgements ............................................................................................... iii Contents .................................................................................................................. v Figures ................................................................................................................... ix Tables .................................................................................................................... xi Boxes .................................................................................................................... xii Key abbreviations ................................................................................................. xii 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Background and context of thesis .................................................................... 1 1.2 Aim, objectives and research questions ........................................................... 4 1.3 Contribution to knowledge .............................................................................. 5 1.4 Summary of chapters ....................................................................................... 6 2 Literature review and development of theoretical frameworks ............................ 11 2.1 Self-help in communities ............................................................................... 11 2.1.1 Citizen participation and the state .......................................................... 11 2.1.2 Policy and legislative support for public participation in FCRM........... 15 2.1.3 Funding and benefit issues ..................................................................... 17 2.1.4 Conclusion: self-help in communities .................................................... 17 2.2 Direct Action Self-Help groups ..................................................................... 18 2.2.1 Motivations ............................................................................................. 18 2.2.2 Dimensions of community and DASH groups ....................................... 24 2.2.3 Development and sustainability of DASH groups ................................. 26 2.2.4 DASH group leadership ......................................................................... 29 2.2.5 Knowledge, skills and expertise of DASH group membership .............. 30 2.2.6 Engagement: expertise into action .......................................................... 35 2.2.7 Alignment: DASH groups and the bigger picture .................................. 38 2.2.8 Conclusion: conceptual framework for DASH groups .......................... 39 2.3 Human dimensions of flood and coastal protection assets ............................ 42 2.3.1 Introduction ............................................................................................ 42 2.3.2 Approaches to assessing human dimensions .........................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Letcombe Brook Project
    The Letcombe Brook Project Achievements Report Spring 2003 - Summer 2009 rook rey B N Child East Hanney k combe Broo A338 t Le Grove A417 WANTAGE Letcombe k o Regis o r B e b m o c t e L Letcombe Bassett A338 Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................3 • Letcombe Brook chalk stream Letcombe Brook Project .......................................................................................................4 • Organisation Partnership in action Project report .............................................................................................................................5 Objective 1: Conserve and enhance the biodiversity and landscape of Letcombe Brook .............................................................................................5 • Biodiversity and landscape • Public open space improvements • Planning and developments • Species action Objective 2: Promote environmentally responsible land management practices amongst landowners and land managers. ...............12 • Working with landowners to protect the brook • Examples of small scale schemes carried out by residents Objective 3: Increase awareness of countryside and environmental issues through education and interpretation. .........................13 • Education and Interpretation • Environmental Education for schools • Interpretation • Public events and campaigns Objective 4: Involve all sectors of the community in caring for and appreciating Letcombe
    [Show full text]
  • Spanswick Farm, Letcombe Bassett, Oxfordshire Spanswick Farm on This Level
    Spanswick Farm, Letcombe Bassett, Oxfordshire Spanswick Farm on this level. On the second floor there are Letcombe Bassett three further bedrooms. Wantage, Oxfordshire Outside The house is set well back from the road, with a OX12 9LR driveway leading to the extensive gardens to the front, side and rear. The rear garden is south- facing and has lovely views over the paddocks A farmhouse in need of renovation on and countryside beyond. the edge of this sought-after village with lovely, southerly downland views There is a public footpath which crosses the field from Forsters Lane. Wantage 3.3 miles, Lambourn 6.5 miles. There is water to the field, also from Forsters Faringdon 10 miles, A34 10 miles, Didcot Station Lane. 13 miles, Newbury 17 miles, Oxford 18.5 miles. Didcot to London Paddington by rail from about Currently the western boundary of the paddock/ 40 mins. field is not fenced; the vendor will require a stock-proof fence post sale which will likely Drawing room | Sitting room | Dining room consist of post and three strand barbed wire, Kitchen | Utility | Cellar with sheep netting. 5/6 bedrooms | Bathroom Outbuildings | Parking | Gardens & paddock In all about 4 acres. In all about 4 acres EPC Rating F The property Spanswick Farm is full of character with spacious and versatile accommodation arranged over three floors. Whilst in need of renovation, the property offers the prospective purchaser an opportunity to create a delightful family home. The lay-out can be seen from the floor plans. The ground floor has three reception rooms, two of which are particularly light and enjoy the view.
    [Show full text]
  • Floods Review July 2007 Letcombe Regis, Wantage, Grove and East Hanney
    Floods Review July 2007 Letcombe Regis, Wantage, Grove and East Hanney An investigation into the causes and flood risk management options David McKnight February 2008 We are the Environment Agency. It's our job to look after your environment and make it a better place - for you, and for future generations. Your environment is the air you breathe, the water you drink and the ground you walk on. Working with business, Government and society as a whole, we are making your environment cleaner and healthier. The Environment Agency. Out there, making your environment a better place. Published by: David McKnight Flood Risk Management Environment Agency Red Kite House, Howbery Park Wallingford, Oxfordshire Tel: 01491 828664 Email: [email protected] www.environment-agency.gov.uk © Environment Agency All rights reserved. This document may be reproduced with prior permission of the Environment Agency. Executive summary Following the flooding of July 2007, which affected 137 properties in Letcombe Regis, Wantage, Grove and East Hanney, we have investigated options to improve the level of flood protection. This review aims to outline the extent of the recent floods, record the damage and document the response. Opportunities for any improvements that could reduce flood risk for local residents and businesses will be investigated. The keys findings are that an unusually wet May and June with rainfall up to 195% of the long term average combined with an exceptional level of rainfall on 19 and 20 July created unprecedented levels of flow in the Letcombe Brook and the wider land drainage system. Water levels and flows exceeded the capacity of watercourses, culverts and bridges, forcing flood water over and/or around the structures, into roads and residential areas.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ock Catchment Water Environment Improvement Plan
    The Thames floodplain near South Hinksey in January 20120166 The Ock Catchment Water Environment Improvement Plan A catchment plan for the River Ock and adjacent areas of the River Thames, which together comprise the Ock Catchment. The Ock Catchment is hosted by the Freshwater Habitats Trust. WWW: freshwaterhabitats.org.uk EEE:[email protected] About this document This document is a working draft for comment and modification. We have reused information from existing sources as much as possible, and tried to stick to the key points. We welcome active editing and addition – please either write the draft in track changes or, if you are short of time, pass on your comments to Hannah Worker who will edit the text for you. For this first draft we do not have the resources for a very glossy document so have focussed instead on simply getting the main points down that we think will make a practical difference. 1. Introduction NFUNFUNFU Ock Valley Flood Group 1.1 The River Ock Catchment Oxford and District Anglers Association Partnership Oxford City Council Oxford Flood Alliance The River Ock Catchment Partnership is an informal Oxford Preservation Trust grouping of organisations and individuals working to Oxford University protect and improve the water environment in the Oxford Urban Wildlife Group River Ock catchment and adjacent areas of the River Oxfordshire County Council Thames around Oxford. The partnership has been RSPBRSPBRSPB established under the auspices of the Catchment SandfordSandford----onononon----ThamesThames Parish Council Based Approach (CaBA), which is a community-led Steventon Parish Council approach, given seed-corn funding by the Thame Valley Fisheries Preservation Consultative Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs, South Abingdon Flood Awareness Group which engages people and groups from across society South Oxfordshire County Council to help improve our water environment.
    [Show full text]
  • Business-Plan-2019-2022.Pdf
    Letcombe Brook Project Charitable Incorporated Organisation Business Plan 2019-2022 Produced 30.12.2018 1 Contents 1. Executive Summary 3 2. Mission Statement and Aims 5 3. Operational Plan 6 4. Business Context 12 5. Financial Information 14 Appendix 1 Feedback 18 Appendix 2 Background 25 Appendix 3 Summary of Achievements 31 Appendix 4 Administrative Info 39 Appendix 5 Partners and Stakeholders 40 2 1. Executive Summary Letcombe Brook is a chalk stream, internationally rare and of considerable value to both people and wildlife. Flowing for 12km through the major settlements of both Wantage and Grove it contributes greatly to valuable green space and as a source of water for both business and communities. The LBP was set up in 2003 in response to concerns from public bodies that Letcombe Brook was a declining and undervalued community asset. Since then the Project has raised over £200,000 in funding for habitat and access improvements, flood alleviation measures and community engagement projects. It has raised the profile of Letcombe Brook within local communities and galvanised action to secure a reduced flood risk and increase its value at the heart of many community green spaces. Increased pressure due to large scale housing developments, the expectation of more regular severe weather events and potential for flooding alongside sustained cuts to local government services only increase the demand on, and relevance of, the Letcombe Brook Project. This business plan sets out the aims and objectives for the Letcombe Brook Project for the period 2019-2022. We have quite rightly, and purposefully, set wide charitable objectives.
    [Show full text]
  • Wantage Neighbourhood Plan 2015 - 2031
    WANTAGE NEIGHBOURHOOD PLAN 2015 - 2031 Published by Wantage Town Council December 2015 CONTENTS Foreword 3 Introduction 5 Wantage - The Place 6 The Planning Policy Context 8 Vision & Objectives 10 Land Use Policies 12 1. A Spatial Plan for the Town 13 2. Town Centre Policy Area 15 3. Town Centre Development 17 4. Protection of Employment Sites 21 5. Design – General Principles 22 6. Design – Character Areas 24 7. Design – Housing Types 26 8. Green Infrastructure Network 27 9. Green Infrastructure – Letcombe Brook 31 10. Green Infrastructure – Chain Hill Special Landscape Area 33 11. Green Infrastructure – Local Green Spaces 34 12. Infrastructure Investment 37 13. Community Facilities 38 14. Community Assets 39 Implementation 41 Policies Map & Insets 47 Glossary 50 Appendix 1 - Letcombe Brook Planning Guidance 56 Wantage Neighbourhood Plan 2015 - 2031 1 2 Wantage Neighbourhood Plan 2015 - 2031 FOREWORD This Neighbourhood Plan for Wantage is the Town’s plan for land use. The residents said that the best things about Wantage are: • The sense of community and friendliness of the town and the people • The local facilities, shops, schools, market, library etc. • Its rural nature with surrounding countryside • Its history (including King Alfred), heritage and character • The accessibility of and proximity to Oxford, London, Newbury and Swindon • The small market town feel. The residents said that over the next 20 years they wanted Wantage to maintain the good things and resolve the problems of: • The lack of good infrastructure • The scale of development with insufficient thought for facilities required • The lack of school places now and in the future • The limited range of shops and excess of charity shops • The traffic congestion, poor roads and parking • The poor bus service (with the exception of the Oxford service) • The state of the pavements and streets.
    [Show full text]
  • Hanney News Number 540 December 2020
    Hanney News Number 540 December 2020 Ho Ho Ho...here’s wishing all our readers a Happy Hanney Christmas ! Don’t forget your Hanney Calendar...all profits to good causes in our community. See page 4 for details and more Christmas gift ideas. Hanney Senior Citizens Club Members We wish you a very “Ere you lot! Happy Christmas and Did you know that you hope to see you all again can swap your Lego cards as soon as possible in in the Community Shop? 2021. Not a lot of people know that, Don’t forget we are just as my ole mucker Michael Caine once said! And I’ve got at the end of the phone if another question for you on you need anything. page 9...cor blimey guv, up the 01235 867461 apples and pears, luv a duck… With our best wishes I’m Jeremy, a well ‘ard Marcia and the cockney geezer! Committee. If you need help, ring 0808 123 0161 There is no charge for this call. You can email them here: [email protected] Editorial As I write, we are less than half way individual distributors who usually cover through the second lockdown, but as you the street or estate where they live. (Some read I hope we’ll be almost through it and do a lot more. ) We rely on these willing looking forward to a ‘sort of’, ‘kind of’ souls...not much point in churning out this ‘normal (ish)’ Christmas. nonsense otherwise...so massive thanks to Within these pages expect the usual smor- them.
    [Show full text]
  • In This Issue: * Most Events Shown in the Calendar Must Be Booked in Advance, and Could, Currently, Be Changed at Short Notice
    Issue 186 February 2021 VILLAGE DIARY Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat Sun 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Holy Communion Garden waste Junior only Tennis 10am on Zoom currently Coaching 10am for code suspended Book Buffs 8pm check click here check updates Zoom - for code click here 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Communion Garden waste Junior only Tennis 8am on Zoom currently Coaching 10am suspended Family Worship check 10am on Zoom check updates for code click here Communion 15 16 1711am on Zoom 18 19 20 21 for code Junior only Tennis Holy Communion Garden waste click here Coaching 10am 10am on Zoom currently Gardening Club check for code suspended 7.30pm on Zoom click here check updates code for paid up members only 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 Garden waste Communion Junior only Tennis 8am on Zoom currently Coaching 10am suspended check Family Worship check updates 10am on Zoom for code click here In this issue: * Most Events shown in the Calendar must be booked in advance, and could, currently, be changed at short notice. Please check the details before attending. PARISH COUNCIL 2 200 CLUB RESULTS & ADS 3 Past Registers are available to view, LADDERADS ETC (INCLUDING THANKS FROM PAUL THE POSTIE) 4 along with much more information, 200 CLUB INVITATION LETTER 5 on the Village Website: 200 CLUB APPLICATION FORM 6 www.letcomberegispc.org LETCOMBES CONSERVATION GROUP 7 LETCOMBE BROOK PROJECT - END OF YEAR REPORT 2020 8 IF YOU WOUD LIKE TO RECEIVE UPDATES ON LBP REPORT CONTINUED 9 LOCAL ISSUES, THE COBRA BULLETIN AND THE LBP REPORT CONTINUED 10 LETCOMBE REGISTER, DELIVERED DIRECT TO LBP
    [Show full text]
  • Letcombe Brook Project Project Officers Report Oct 2020 to April 2021
    Letcombe Brook Project Project Officers Report Oct 2020 to April 2021 1.0 Project Administration Blog overdue for website. Regular postings on Letcombe Brook Facebook Group (600 members now!) and Twitter (@LetcombeBP). Limited uptake of the Riparian Owners Group so far but will have another go at attracting further members when time allows. End of Year Report sent out to all Volunteers, Steering Gp members, Funders and Riparian Owners Group members. Website - Videos added and will be adding more photos under a Gallery format. 2.0 Water Quality and Quantity 2.1 Environment Agency – Summary monthly water reports, West Thames Area – Ock Catchment Oct – 4th wettest Oct on record, 2.5 x average rainfall Nov – Average rainfall and recharge of aquifer taking place due to wet previous month Dec- Above average rainfall but fell mostly on 2 days either side of Christmas Jan – 143% of long term average rainfall, river flows above normal February Thames Area received average rainfall for February, leaving all rainfall units normal for the time of year. · While the rainfall was average for the time of year, the affects from the previous months’ rainfall can be seen in the majority of river and groundwater levels still being above normal or higher for the time of year. · However as a result of the drier end of the month Soil Moisture Deficits increased slightly. March Thames area received 53% of Long Term Average rainfall during March. The month ended with a dry period with four days of little or no rain across Thames area. · Monthly mean river flows were normal across most of the area, with only the River Coln remaining above normal for the time of year.
    [Show full text]
  • East Hanney Trail
    Help look after the brook Letcombe Brook Project • Take your litter home and clear up after your dog. The Letcombe Brook Project is a charity which works with • If you would like to help on volunteer tasks to local people and organisations to enhance and protect the manage the brook contact The Hanneys Flood natural beauty of the brook and to help people appreciate Group. the environment. The project undertakes work to encourage native wildlife, improve the landscape, remove DISCOVERY TRAIL Lifestyle choices, population growth and rubbish and alleviate future flooding along the brook. East Hanney climate change are placing increasing You can learn more by coming on a guided walk/talk or demands on our water supplies. In this join in a conservation task. The project offers educational area the domestic supply comes from opportunities for local schools including river dipping. aquifers which feed the Letcombe Brook. Thinking about how we use water and reducing usage will help us to ensure that there is enough water for us and wildlife. Thames Water can supply information on saving water: www.thameswater.co.uk/save Please don’t feed the ducks as it can be harmful to them and cause: • Poor nutrition • Overcrowding and spread of disease amongst ducks River dipping • Unnatural behaviour • Pollution and environmental Letcombe Brook Project damage C/o Vale and Downland Museum • An increase in rats in the area Church Street Wantage If you care about the ducks then please do not feed them OXON – allow them to return to their natural habits. OX12
    [Show full text]
  • Design Guide March 2015 Foreword
    Design Guide March 2015 Foreword One of the best things about living in the Vale is its special mix of rural villages and thriving market towns, alongside high-tech and cutting edge businesses; all set against a backdrop of beautiful countryside with a rich history and heritage. As the Vale’s planning authority, an important job of ours is to protect all of that. One of the ways we’ll do so is by making sure housing developers build high-quality, well-designed homes and neighbourhoods. That’s where this Design Guide comes in. Our old Design Guide was only relevant for residential developments up to 15 houses. It now applies to all sizes and types of developments so we can make sure the larger new communities that are being planned will be designed to a high quality. It also means new employment areas or shops and community facilities meet the high standards we all expect. Councillor Michael Murray, We’ve redeveloped the approach of the guide too. Rather than just being a reference Cabinet Member for Planning Policy document, it is an interactive, step by step system that we’ll be insisting developers use when planning homes and neighbourhoods in the Vale. Each section is followed by a checklist so developers can make sure they’ve done everything they need to. Our planning officers will be using the same document and the same checklist when they’re assessing planning applications. The Vale is a reasonably diverse district, so we don’t believe in a one-size-fits-all approach.
    [Show full text]
  • DISCOVERY TRAIL Wantage
    Help look after the brook Letcombe Brook Project Please don’t feed the ducks The Letcombe Brook Project works with local people and Many people enjoy feeding ducks but this is harmful to organisations to enhance and protect the natural beauty of ducks and the environment. Feeding can cause: the brook and to help people appreciate the environment. The project undertakes work to encourage native wildlife, DISCOVERY TRAIL • Poor nutrition improve the landscape, remove rubbish and alleviate future • Overcrowding and spread of disease flooding along the brook. You can learn more by coming Wantage amongst ducks on a guided walk or joining a conservation task. Schools • Unnatural behaviour can come river dipping as part of their local river study. • Pollution and environmental damage • Increase in rats If you care about the ducks then please do not feed them – allow them to return to their natural habits. Save water Lifestyle choices, population growth and climate change are placing increasing demands on our water supplies. When we turn on the tap in this area we take water from local aquifers that supply the Letcombe Brook. To ensure that there is enough School group measuring the brook water for both us and wildlife in years to come please use water wisely. Letcombe Brook Project Contact Thames Water 0845 9200 800 C/o Vale and Downland Museum www.thameswater.co.uk/waterwise for free Church Street leaflets on saving water. Wantage OXON OX12 8BL Local information 01235 771447 [email protected] Wantage – www.wantage.com Volunteers Wantage Town Council – 01235 763459 Vale and Downland Museum – 01235 771447 Partnership www.wantage-museum.com Environment Agency Vale of White Horse District Council – Wantage Town Council 01235 520202, www.whitehorsedc.gov.uk Grove Parish Council Letcombe Regis Parish Council Environment Agency – For pollution and flood defence Vale of White Horse District Council A 3 mile (4.8km) walk, 1½ hours return, matters call 24-hour emergency hotline 0800 80 70 60.
    [Show full text]