Mahabharata Tatparyanirnaya by Prof. K.T.Pandurangi.

(ITranscode of Shlokas from RamyaTadipatri at www.dvait.org/list)

Chapter-I

Sri considers -Purana Prasthana also as a source of Philosophy along with Upanishad Brahmasutra and Gita Prasthanas. He gives utmost importance to as a source of Vedanta Philosophy and Vaishnava religion. This work helps the understanding of Vedanta Philosophy in two ways:

1) It contains all essential teachings of Vedanta Philosophy. 2) It helps to understand the purport of Veda and .

It is well-said that itihAsapurANAbhyAM vedaM samupabR^iMhayet.h. While and Upanishads teach the theory of Vedanta, the Mahabharata teaches the practice through appropriate illustrations. Therefore, Sri Madhvacharya attaches great importance to Mahabharata.

For the utilization of Mahabharata, both as a source and as an aid to the exposition of Vedanta Philosophy, two undertakings were necessary:

1) To fix an authentic Text of Mahabharata. 2) To unearth the in-depth meaning of it going beyond the mere story, episodes, events, and the personalities.

That is to say, to identify the moral and spiritual issues behind the story, episodes, etc. It is this that is achieved in this work viz., Mahabharata Tatparyanirnaya.

The work is neatly planned. It contains thirty-two chapters and has 5202 verses. The first chapter, designated as sarvashastrArthanirNaya, contains the central teaching of Vedanta philosophy viz., vishhNusarvottamatva. The second, designated as suvAkyoddhAra, affirms the same. The third explains the creation outside and within the Brahmanda. It mentions the ten avataras of the Supreme upto Sri 's avatara. Chapters 4 to 9 contain the entire summary of Sri Rama's avatara karya. The tenth chapter describes Vedavyasa avatara. The rest of twenty-two chapters give a gist of the entire Mahabharata. Some events and points of Harivamsha and are also included in these. Thus, Mahabharata Tatparyanirnaya is an exposition of , Mahabharata, Bhagavata, and Harivamsha. As stated earlier, it is an exposition of the entire Veda and Vedanta teachings. This work is not merely a gist of the above works but an evaluation of the moral and spiritual issues involved. Sri Madhvacharya, at the close of this work, records that he composed it under the instructions of Lord Himself. nArAyaNenAbhihito badaryAM tasyaiva shishhyo jagadekabhartuH (MBTN 32-157)

Sri Narayana Panditacharya declares in Madhva Vijaya that this work is a good guide to all God-loving persons. itihAsapurANAbdheH bhavachchittAdriloDitAt.h | j~nAtAM bhAratatAtparyasudhAM kaH san.h na sevate || 15-76||

The benedictory verse of Mahabharata Tatparyanirnaya viz., nArAyaNAya paripUrNaguNarNavAya, etc., gives the definition of the Supreme God Narayana given in the first and second of Brahmasutras viz., guNapUrNatva and sR^ishhTyAdyashhTakartR^itva respectively. The first chapter, which is designated as Tatparya Adhyaya, contains the essence of the teachings of Vedanta Philosophy viz., Supremacy of God Narayana.

At the outset, the purpose of the creation and the process of the creation are explained. The creation is a kind of sport for the Supreme God. However, it serves the purpose of providing an opportunity for the jivas to have the full expression of their original by undertaking appropriate means. It also provides an opportunity for Goddess to assume her different forms. so.ayaM vihAra iha me tanubhR^itsvabhAva sambhUtaye bhavati bhUtikR^ideva bhUtyAH || (MBTN I-5)

The God desires that those who are devoted to Him should attain the prosperity of liberation, and to enable them to achieve this end, he undertakes creation. bhUtyai nijAshrita janasya hi sR^ijyasR^ishhTau IxA babhUva | (MBTN I-3)

First, he himself assumes the forms of , Sankarshana, , and and makes Goddess Lakshmi assume the forms of , Jaya, Krti, and Shanti. He creates by His Pradyumna form, protects by His Aniruddha form, destroys by His Sankarshana form, and liberates by His Vasudeva form. Apart from these five forms (these and Narayana), He also assumes Keshava, etc. (twelve forms); , etc. (ten forms);Narayana, etc. (hundred forms); , etc. (thousand forms);Para, etc. (many forms), and Aja, etc. (infinite forms). He is only one though He assumes several forms. All his forms are Purna, i.e., full. He is impartite; there are no internal parts of Him. He has no Prakrta Sharira. He is absolutely free from any drawback. His body is that of bliss. He is Supreme and independent. He has no limitation of time and space. He has no growth of decay. None is equal or superior to Him. He is supreme. The Supreme God is introduced by such glowing tributes by Sri Madhvacharya at the very commencement of this work. This tempo is maintained not only all along this work, but in all his other works.

Sri Madhvacharya declares that this supremacy of Lord Narayana is proclaimed in all the Vedas, Ramayana, Mahabharata, Pancharatna, and all other works that followed the tradition of these. He also states that this purport of the scripture is determined by the Brahmasutras. He quotes from Veda, Upanishads, rahmasutras, Gita, Mahabharata, and Bhagavata a good many passages to substantiate the above features of the Supreme God.

We will notice only a few of them here:

1. nAsti nArAyaNasamaM na bhUto na bhavishhyati | etena satyavAkyena sarvArthAn.h sAdhayAmyaham.h || (Mbh I-1-18)

2. yasmAt.h xaramatIto.ahamaxarAdapi chottamaH | ato.asmi loke vede cha prathitaH purushhottamaH || (B.G.XV-18)

3. paro mAtrayA tanvA vR^idhAna | nate mahitvamashnuvanti | (R.V.)

4. neha nAnAsti kiJNchana | (Katha. III-4)

5. pR^ithagupadeshAt.h (B.S.I-3-28)

These quotations are incorporated in the very verses of Mahabharata Tatparyanirnaya. He is very emphatic that only such scriptures that declare the supremacy of are authentic, and others are not authoritative. Such works that declare , etc. other than Vishnu as superior are intended to mislead the undeserving. mohArthAnyanyashAstrANi kR^itAnyevAj-nayA hareH |

When the God assumes avataras in the mortal world, certain human drawbacks are displayed by Him. He pretends ignorance, he appears as having a human body, he appears to suffer from injuries and death, and he pretends to be in grief and without any self-control. All these are intended only to mislead the undeserving. There cannot be any drawbacks for Him who is supreme. The Brahmasutras give us the correct knowledge of , i.e., Vishnu. These declare that He is the same in all His forms, that is to say, He is guNapUrNa and nirdoshha in all His forms.

Sri Madhvacharya particularly points out that the Vedas declare the supremacy of Vishnu. He quotes a number of hymns of the Rg Veda and declares the supremacy of Vishnu. We will notice a few here.

1. asya devasya mILhushho vishhNoretasya prabhR^ithe havirbhiH | (R.V. VII-40-5)

2. stuhi shrutaM gartamadaM puvAnam.h | (R.V. II-33-11)

3. pradhAnvasya mahato mahAni satyAsatyasya karaNAni vocham.h | (R.V. II-15)

4. satyaH so.asya mahimA gR^iNe shavo yaj-neshhu viprarAjye |

From this, it is clear that those who hold the view that Vishnu is only a Puranic deity and not a Vedic deity are ignorant of the Vedas.

In order to bring home the supremacy of Lord Vishnu, Sri Madhvacharya mentions the fact that all others, i.e. all jivas right from , are pratibimbas of Vishnu, and they are in a hierarchical order.

AbhAsako.asya pavanaH pavanasya rudraH sheshhAtmako pavana eva cha shakrakAmau |

Vayu is the pratibimba of the Supreme God. and are the pratibimbas of Vayu, and and are the pratibimbas of Garuda and Rudra. In this way, the line goes on upto R^ishhi, , etc. This is the line of purushas. The line of women commences with ramA and moves in the order viz., Sarasvati Bharati, , Suparni, and so on.

The jivas are divided into three types viz., muktiyogya, nityasamsArin.h, and tamoyogya. Under each category, there are innumerable jivas. tasmAt.h samAptimapi yAnti na jIvasaN^ghAH | Anantyameva gaNasho.asti yato hi teshhAm.h ||

These jivas are distinct from the God. These are also mutually distinct. Both the God and jivas are distinct from the jadas. The jadas are also mutually distinct. Thus there are five principal categories of bheda- jIveshayorbhidA chaiva jIvabhedaH parasparam.h | jaDeshayorjaDANAM cha jaDajIvabhidA tathA || paJNcha bhedA ime nityA sarvAvasthAmu sarvashaH | muktAnAM cha na hIyante tAratamyaM cha sarvadA || (MBTN I-70,71)

The jiva attains liberation only by the grace of the God. yamevaishha vR^iNute tena labhyaH... (MBTN I-77)

The grace fo the God is to be obtained by knowledge and devotion. The knowledge should contain the following ingredients:

1. sarveshhAM cha harirnityaM niyantA tadvashAH pare (MBTN I-79)

God is the regulator of all, and all are entirely dependent upon Him.

2. tAratamyaM tato j~neyaM sarveshitvaM harestathA | (MBTN I-80)

The God is supreme, and all others are inferior to Him in a hierarchical order.

3. paJNchabhedAmshcha vij~nAya vishhNoH svAbhedhameva cha | (MBTN I-81)

The five types of differences and the fact that there are no internal differences within the God should be known.

4. avatArAn.h harerj~nAtvA nAvatArA hareshcha ye | (MBTN I-82)

One should know which are the avataras of the God and which are merely aveshas.

5. sR^ishhTiraxA.ahR^itij~nAnaniyatyaj~nAnabandhanAn.h | moxaM cha vishhNutastveva j~nAtvA muktirna chAnyathA || (MBTN I-82)

One can attain liberation by knowing the sR^ishhTyAdyashhTakartR^itva of the God. These are creation, protection, destruction, giving knowledge,regulation, causing ignorance, causing bondange, and bestowing liberation.

6. vedAshcha paJNcharAtrANi setihAsapurANakAn.h | j~nAtvA vishhNuparAneva muchyate nAnyathA kvachit.h || (MBTN I-84)

One can attain liberation by knowing that Veda , Itihasa Purana, etc., the sacred literature, declares the supremacy of Lord Vishnu.

This enumeration of the ingredients of knowledge covers four important aspects:

1. vishhNusarvottamatva 2. jIvapAratantrya, jIvatAratamya 3. paJNchabheda 4. sarvavedapratipAdyatva

This is exactly shAstratAtparyanirNaya, the theme of the first adhyaya.

Now, the above knowledge has to be accompanied by . The well-known definition of bhakti is given here: mAhAtmyaj~nAnapUrvastu sudR^iDhaH sarvato.adhikaH | sneho bhaktiriti proktastayA suktirna chAnyathA || (MBTN I-85)

The highest love of God that is accompanied by the knowledge of His supremacy is bhakti.

With the bhakti based on the firm knowledge of the glory of the God, one has to undertake upasana. Chaturmukhabrahma is eligible to meditate upon Lord Vishnu with all His attributes. The average muktiyogya men are eligible to meditate with only four attributes viz., sat, chit, Ananda, and Atma. This goes on, increasing according to each one's inner capacity and the position in the hierarchy.

While satvika jivas develop jnana and bhakti, the tamasa jivas develop dvesha, i.e. hatred for the God. anAdidveshhiNo daityAH |

The dvesha is expressed throught he following perverted knowledge: jIvAbhedo nirguNatvaM apUrNaguNatA tathA | sAmyAdhikye tadanyeshhAM bhedastadgata eva cha || prAdurbhAvaviparyAsaH tadbhaktadveshha eva cha | tatpramANasya nindA cha dveshhA ete.akhilA matAH || (MBTN I-111,112)

The thought that the God and the jivas are identical, the God is without any attributes, He has only a limited number of attributes, some other are equal or even superior to Him, the God has internal differences (between His mularupa and avatara rupa and between His avayavas), His gunas are different from Him, His avataras have certain drawbacks, and such other thoughts are the forms of hatred of the God.

The bhakti practiced by the muktiyogyas should be free from this perverted knowledge (dvesha). Such pure bhakti will lead to aparokshajnana and prasada of the Supreme God. The Supreme God will bestow the liberation. Mukhyaprana will remove . vishhNurhi dAtA moxasya vAyushcha tadanuj~nayA | (MBTN I-78)

Chaturmukhabrahma is the chief for all. A guru is one who possesses thirty-two features of a guru, who has no doubt in respect of right knowledge and who can remove the doubts of disciples. shhaNNavatyaN^gulo yastu nyagrodhaparimaNDalaH | saptapAdaH chaturhasto dvAtrimshairlaxaNairyutaH || asaMshayaH saMshayachchhid.h gururukto mavIshhibhiH | tasmAd.h gururmukhyaH sarveshhAmeva sarvadA || (MBTN I-121-122)

The thirty-two features are described as under: paJNchadIrghaH paNchasUxmaH paJNcharaktaH paDunnataH | tripR^ithustrishhu gambhIro dvAtrimshallaxaNastviti ||

The knowledge imparted by the guru possessing these features is true knowledge. samyag.hlaxaNasampanno yaddadyAt.h suprasannadhIH | shishhyAya satyaM bhavati tatsarvaM nAtra samshayaH || ( MBTN I-124)

As stated above, Chaturmukhabrahma is the chief guru for all. However, other superior persons are also in the respective order as per the features of a guru possessed by them. Sometimes, even lesser persons also may have to be taken as guru. They should also be duly respected. anye.api svAtmano mukhyAH kramAd.h gurava IritAH || kramAllaxaNahInAshcha laxaNAlaxaNaiH samAH |(MBTN I-123) svAvarANAM gurutvaM tu bhavet.h kAraNataH kvachit.h | maryAdArthaM te.api pUjyA na tu yadvat.h paro guruH || (MBTN I-126)

A muktiyogya jiva will get rid of all his sins as soon as he has aparokshajnana of the Supreme God. The muktiyogya jivas journeying through the ArchirAdi path go to Chaturmukhabrahma and then reach Lord .

The above tenets (including the ones given in previous postings) constitute the purport of the entire sacred scripture. Sri Madhvacharya informs that he has culled out these in the ShastratAtparya Chapter of this work under the instructions of Lord Hari Himself and closes this chapter: iti R^ig.hyajuHsAmAtharvapaJNcharAtretihAsataH | purANebhyastathA.anyebhyaH shAstrebhyo nirNayaH kR^itaH || 1\.135|| vishhNvAj~nayaiva vidushhA tatprasAdabalonnateH | AnandatIrthamuninA pUrNapraj~nAbhidhAyujA || 1\.136|| tAtparyaM shAstrANAM sarveshhAM uttamaM mayA proktam.h | prApyAnuj~nAM vishhNoretajj~nAtvaiva vishhNurApyo.asau || 1\.137||

[sarvashAstratAtparyanirNayo nAma prathamo.adhyAyaH]

Chapter-II

In the second chapter, designated as suvAkyoddhAra, the purport of the sacred scripture delineated in the first chapter is demonstrated by the verses in the Mahabharata: uktaH pUrvAdhyAye shAstrANAM nirNayaH paro divyaH | atha khalu bhAratavAkyAnyetairevAdhyavasyante || [MBTN II.2]

Before this task is executed, two points have to be clarified:

1) Whether the text of the Mahabharata that is handed down is authentic. 2) What the grounds to select the Mahabharata especially for this purpose are.

Sri Madhvacharya concedes that attempts are made to contaminate and mutilate the text of the Mahabharata. This has happened not only in the case of the Mahabharata, but in several other texts also. Therefore, he assures that he has collected the manuscripts of the Mahabharata from different parts of the country and has ascertained the authentic version of it. In doing so, he has not merely relied on manuscripts as the modern scholars do but also taken into consideration the entire tradition of the scriptural literature. The latter criteria is very important. Every text is a part of a tradition. Therefore, anything that is contrary to or contradicts the text is not likely to be the authentic portion of that text. Internal contradiciton within the text or contradiction with the tradition is likely to be the result of the interpolation or mutilation. In modern textual criticism, this vital point is ignored. The second criteria is stated by Sri Madhvacharya as: shAstrAntarANi saJNjAnan.h vedAmshchAsya prasAdataH

This is how the contamination and the mutilation of the texts and his efforts to ascertain the authentic text of the Mahabharata is regarded. His observations set very scientific guidelines of textual criticism. a. kvachidganthAn.h praxipanti kvachidantaritAnapi | kuryuH kvachichcha vyatyAsaM pramAdAt.h kvachidanyathA || anutsannA api granthAH vyAkulA iti sarvashaH | utsannAH prAyashaH sarve koTyaMsho.api na vartate || grantho.apyevaM vilulitaH kimvartho devadurgamaH | (MBTN II-3,4,5) b. deshe deshe tathA granthAn.h dR^ishhTvA chaiva pR^ithagvidhAn.h | yathA cha .h vyAsaH sAxAnnArAyaNaH prabhuH || jagAda bhAratAdyeshhu tathA vaxye tadIxayA | saN^xepAt.h sarvashAstrAryaM bhAratAryAnusArataH || (MBTN II-7,8)

After assuring that, the purport of the Mahabharata will be explained by a reference to the authentic text ascertaining it as stated above. Sri Madhvacharya states the special grounds because of which this work is especially selected for shAstratAtparyanirNaya | The treatment of this topic is quite elaborate in this chapter. We mention the most striking grounds, which will be stated in the postings that follow

1) The most important ground is that the Mahabharata declares the supremacy of Narayana emphatically, unconditionally, and as the total purport of the entire scripture. vAsudevastu bhagavAn.h kIrtyate.atra sanAtanaH | pratibimbamivAdarshe yaM pashyantyAtmani sthitam.h || (II-68) nAsti nArAyaNasamaM na bhUtaM na bhavishhyati | etena satyavAkyena sarvArthAn.h sAdhayAmyaham.h || (II-68,69)

AloDya sarvashAstrANi vichArya cha punaH punaH | idamekaM sunisshhpannaM dhyeyo nArAyaNaH sadA || (II-72) vAsudevasya mahimA bhArate nirNayoditaH | tadarthAstu kathAH sarvAH nAnyArthaM vaishhNavaM vachaH || (II-123)

2) The second important ground is that the Mahabharata declares the importance of Vayu. It clearly states that Vayu played the role of the chief assistant of Lord Narayana in His three of Rama, , and Vedavyasa, assuming the of , Bhima, and Madhva. The fact that Bhimasena plays a major role in the Mahabharata is fully brought out: a. tasmAd.h balapravR^ittasya rAmakR^ishhNAtmano hareH | antaraN^ga hanUmAmshcha bhImastatkAryamAdhakau || (II-34,35) b. priyashcha vishhNoH sarvebhyaH iti bhImanidarshanAt.h | bhUbhAraharaNe vishhNoH pradhAnAN^gaM hi mArutiH || mAgadhAdivadhAdeva duryodhanavadhAdapi || yo ya eva balajyeshhTaH xatriyeshhu ma uttamaH | aN^gaM ched.h vishhNukaAryepu tadbhaktyaiva na chAnyathA || (II-15,16,17) c. tasyAN^gaM prathamaM vAyuH prAdurbhAvatrayAnvitaH | prathamo hanumannAma dvitIyo bhIma eva cha || pUrNapraj~nastR^itIyastu bhagavatkAryasAdhakaH | (II-128,129) d. j~nAne virAge haribhaktibhAve dhR^itisthitiprANabaleshhu yoge | budhhau cha nAnyo hanumatsamAnaH pumAn.h kadAchit.h kka cha kashchanaiva || (II-155) e. vAyurbhImo bhImanAdo mahaujAH sarveshhAM cha prANinAM prANabhUtaH | AnAvR^ittirdehinAM dehapAte tasmAd.h vAyuH devadevo vishishhTaH || (II-163) f. tattvaj~nAne vishhNubhakto dhairye sthairye parAkrame | vege cha lAghave chaiva pralApasya cha varjane | bhImasenasamo nAsti senayorubhayorapi || (II-164,165) g. asmin.h yuddhe bhImasena tvayi bhAraH samAhitaH | dhUrarjunena voDhavya itaro janaH | (II-174)

In verses II-156-160, from baLitthAsUkta that highlight the glory of Mukhyaprana in his three incarnations are quoted.

Several events in Mahabharata clearly show that Bhimasena plays the most important role in Mahabharata guided by Lord Sri Krishna. The killing of and are two major instances. The purpose of God's incarnation is to remove the burden of the evil persons on the earth. In achieving this purpose, Maruti, i.e. Mukhyaprana, plays an important role as Bhimasena. The depiction oft his has made the Mahabharata a great epic.

3) The third important ground is that the Mahabharata narrates the glory of Sri Rama also: uktA rAmakathA hyasmin.h mArkANDeyasamAkhyayA | tasmAd.h yad.h bhAratenoktaM taddhi naivAsti kutrachit.h ||

The story of Sri Rama narrated here is culled out from the Mularamayana. Sri Madhvacharya has elaborated it in this Mahabharata Tatparyanirnaya bringing out the ethical and philosophical implications of various events of the Ramayana. It is further elaborated by Sri Narayana Panditacharya in the Sanraha Ramayana.

Thus, the Mahabharata is an epic that contains the glory of the two incarnations of the Supreme God viz., Sri Rama and Sri Krishna. Its greatness is enhanced by the further fact that it is composed by Sri Vedavyasa who himself is an incarnation of Lord Vishnu. kR^ishhNadvaipAyanaM vyAsaM viddhi nArAyaNaM prabhum.h | kohyanyaH puNDarIkAxAt.h mahAbhAratakR^idbhavet.h ||

4) Another important feature of the Mahabharata is that it is in three languages viz., darshana, guhya, and | bhAshhAstu trividhAstatra mayA vai sampradarshitAH | ukto yo mahimA vishhNoH sa tUkto hi samAdhinA || II-114 samAdhibhAshhayoktaM yattatsarvaM grAhyameva hi | II-115 aviruddhaM samAdhestu darshanoktaM chan gR^ihyate | AdyantayorviruddhaM yaddharshanaM tadudAhR^itam.h || II-116 darshanAntarasiddhaM cha guhyabhAshhAnyathA bhavet.h | tasmAd.h vishhNorhi mahimA bhAratokto yathArthataH || (II-128) a) The glory fo the Supreme God is conveyed by samadhi bhasha. This naturally has to be accepted as it is. b) Darshana bhasha is of two types: i) Whatever conflicts with what is stated before and after that is darshana bhasha. This naturally has to be interpreted in tune with what is stated before and after or else it has to be rejected. ii) Whatever is merely a restatement of some other darshana quoted for refutatino or to show the hollowness of it. c) Guhyabhasha is that which is different from samadhi and darshana bhasha. In the case of the Guhyabhasha, its deeper meaning has to be taken, rejecting the apparent meaning.

5) One more important feature of the Mahabharata is that it has three layers of meaning viz., manvAdi, AstikAdi, and uparicharAdi | manvAdi kechid.h bruvate hyAstikAdi tathApare | tathoparicharAdanye bhArataM parichaxate || (II-142) a. sakR^ishhNAn.h pANDavAn.h gR^ihya yo.ayamarthaH pravartate | prAtilomyAdi vaichitryAt.h tamAstIkaM prachaxate || b. dharmo bhaktyAdidashakaH shrutAdiH shIlavainayau | sabrahmakAstu te yatra manvAdiM te vidurbudhAH | c. nArAyaNasya nAmAni sarvANi vachanAni tu | tatsAmarthyAbhidhAyIni tamauparicharaM viduH || (II-142,145)

The story of the Mahabharata, centering around the personalities of Sri Krishna, the , etc., is the Astikadi layer of the meaning. This layer is designated as because the Pandavas whose story is narrated have been great Astiks, that is to say, they had great faith in Sri Krishna.

The Manvadi layer of the meaning is that meaning which conveys the virtues represented by Yuddhishtira, Bhima, etc. Yuddhishtira represents , Bhimasena represents bhakti, jnana, , medha, etc. The ten virtues are as follows: bhaktirj~nAnaM savairAgyaM praj~nA bhedhA dhR^itiH sthitiH | yogaH prANo balaM chaiva vR^ikodara iti smR^itaH || (II-146)

Arjuna represents , , and nididhyAsana. Nakula and sahadeva represent shIla and vinaya. Draupadi represents the Vedas. These virtues of these personalities are demonstrated in the events connected with them in the story of the Mahabharata. This layer of meaning is the manvAdi meaning.The expression manvAdi refers to dharma and other virtues listed here: mIyate pramIyate ebhiH paramAtmA iti manavo dharmaH bhaktyAdidashakaM shrutAdiH shIlavainayA vedAshcheti manupadavAchyaM paJNchakam.h |

The third layer of meaning viz., auparichara is the meaning that brings out Narayana as the meaning of each and every word of the Mahabharata. nArAyaNasya nAmAni sarvANi vachanAni tu | tatsAmarthyAbhidhAyIni tamauparicharaM viduH ||

The expression uparichara (II-145) itself refers to Narayana and brings out his sarvottamatva | upari - sarveshhAmupari charatIti uparicharaH sarvottamo nArAyaNaH | tasyaiva svaravarNapadavAkyAtmakasakalabhAratagranthena paramamukhyayA vR^ittyA pratipAdanamuchitam.h |

From the above explanation of the three layers of meaning and the terms referring to these three layers viz., AstikAdi, manvAdi, and uparichara, it is clear that these expressions do not refer to the three beginnings of the Mahabharata as contended by some modern Indologists. These do not refer to the episodes of Astika, Manu, and Uparichara as contended by them. This is made emphatically clear by Sri Vadiraja long before the Indologists thought of a reference to these episodes: manvAdi kechit.h bruvate iti shlokasya ApAtataH pratIyamAnA manavaH AstikAkhyo xashhiH uparicharAkhyo vasuH nArthaH | manUnAM prasaN^gasyaiva bhArate abhAvAt.h | Astikoparicharava svoshcha sarpayAgavighnakaraNAya satyavatyutpattaye cha AdiparvaNi AdibhAge ekaukAdhyAyamAtreNa prasaJNjanepi AdiparvaNi ante prasaJNjanAbhAvena sakalabhAratapratipAdyatvasya sutarAmayogAt.h |

The three layers of meaning as explained above are much richer than a mere reference to certain episodes. These bring out the very indepth meaning of the Mahabharata.

Chapter-III

The theme of the third chapter is to describe sarga and anusarga and also to give the background of the characters of the Ramayana as a preliminary to the narration of Sri Rama's story in the next six chapters. This chapter begins with three beautiful benedictory verses praising the three incarnations of the Supreme God viz., vedavyAsa, rAma, and kR^ishNa. Then, the benedictory verse of the Mahabharata viz., nArAyaNaM namaskR^tya naraM chaiva narottamam.h | devIM sarasvatIM vAchaM tato jayasudIrayet.h || is quoted, and its significance is explained. In this verse, Narayana refers to both Narayana and Vedavyasa, refers to Goddess Laxmi, Narottama refers to Vayu who is Jivottama, Nara refers to , and Sarasvati, of course, refers to the goddess of speech. Jaya is the name of this great epic. jayo nAmetihAso.ayaM kR^ishhNadvaipAyaneritaH | vAyurnarottamo nAma devIti shrIrudIritA || nArAyaNo iti vAchyavaktrasvarUpataH | ekaH sa bhagavAnuktaH sAdhakesho narottamaH || upasAdhako narashchokto devI bhAgyAtmikA nR^iNAm.h | sarasvatI vAkyarUpA tasmAnnamyA hi te.akhilAH || (III-5,7)

Then commences the explanation of sarga, i.e., creation.

Lord Narayana and Goddess Ramaa create Virincha assuming the forms of Vasudeva and Maya, create Vayu assuming the forms of Sankarshana and Jaya, and create (Sarasvati) and Shraddha (Bharati) assuming the forms of Pradyumna and Krti. Virincha and Vayu are also known as Purusha. Vayu and Bharati beget Shesha and Suparna, who serve as the bed and vehicle of the Supreme God. Shesha begets servants of the Supreme God called Kala, while Garuda begets Jaya, Vijaya, etc., also servants of the Supreme God. Vayu begets Vishvaxena. This is the first stage of the process of the creation of Virincha, Vayu, etc. Now these have to be provided with sthula sharira. This is initiated by Aniruddha and Shanti. They beget Virincha and Sarasvati with the body of Mahatatva. Virincha and Sarasvati beget Shiva and Parvati. These two beget the manas and the abhimani deities of the ten senses with Vaikarika Ahankara, the ten senses with Ahankara, Akasha, etc., and the five bhutas with Tamasa ahankara. Shiva also begets all other deities.

Vayu and Bharati beget Shesha, Shiva, and Indra. Indra begets all other deities and the deities connected with the sacrifice. It has to be noted here that these deities are stated to have been both by Virincha and Sarasvati and by Vayu and Bharati.

Lord Narayana also assumes the three forms of Vishnu, Brahma, and Shiva. He assumes these forms through His Vasudeva from and Goddess Laxmi's Maya form. Among these three forms, Vishnu's form is the direct form, while in Brahma and Shiva, He is present as Antaryamin.

The creation mentioned in the previous posting is termed a Tatvasrshti and takes place outside Brahmanda. The creation within the Brahmanda is known as Padmasrshti. The Tatvabhimani deities who were created outside the Brahmanda (Tatvasrshti) appeal to the Supreme God to create Brahmanda. The Supreme God conjoins with Goddess Laxmi. She delivers the golden Brahmanda. Lord Hari and all other deities enter into it. A lotus arises from the navel of Lord Hari. From this, Chaturmukhabrahma is born again. From him, all other deities will be born again. Then Chaturmukhabrahma creates the fourteen worlds and the abhimani deiites of senses, etc. Then, Sanaka, Sanandana, etc.; sages, Marichi, etc.; Vayu putras, , manushyas, cows, elephants, horses, serpents, etc., and other varied beings are born. All of these do not realize their true nature and go on rotating in transmigration. Then, Pralaya takes place. The Srshti and Pralaya are endless. The jivas, prakrti, and kala are eternal. Then what can be said of the Supreme God, who is the God of the gods? After describing Srshti and Pralaya, the various avataras assumed by Lord Narayana are described. The ten avataras of the God viz., Matsya, , etc., are well known. However, some special points stated in Tatparyanirnaya need our special attention. Here, two avataras are mentioned, the Adi Varaha and the Neela Varaha. The first one takes place before the ten avataras. Adi Hiranyaxa is killed by this avatara. The second is the third avatara among the ten avataras. Another Hiranyaxa is killed by this avatara. After describing the avataras upto Sri Rama, the birth of and is mentioned. These are stated to be the very persons who were and Hiranyaxa earlier. The birth of Dasharata is mentioned.

The early background of , , , , , Neela, and other is mentioned. These were Indra, , , , Shachi, and respectively. The avatara of Vayu as Hanuman is graphically described: sa devatAnAM prathamo guNAdhiko | babhUva nAmnA hanumAn.h prabhaJNchanaH ||

The fact that Sri Rama is Lord Vishnu Himself is well-known. We are further informed here that the Vasudeva form of the Supreme God assumed the incarnation of Sri Rama, while His Sankarshana, Pradyumna, and Aniruddha forms are present as an avesha in Laxmana, , and respectively.

In the context of explaining the various avataras of the God and the background of the others, the divine nature of the shanka, chakra, etc., is also explained. is the abhimani deity of the chakra, is that of the shanka, Vayu is that of the gada, Bhu is that of Padma, Sarasvati is that of Saranga, Vayu of five forms is of five arrows, and Durga is again of Khadga. durgAdhichakrAdhidevI syAt.h shrIshcha shaN^khaAdhidevatA | vAyurgadAdhidevaH syAd.h bhUmiH padmAbhimAninI || durgaiva khaN^gadevI syAt.h shArN6aJNchaiva sarasvatI | paJNcha bANAH paJNcha prANAH- (padyamAlA)

This chapter is closed by mentioning the fact that is Goddess Laxmi herself. svayaM ramA sIrata eva jAtA sIteti rAmArthamanUpamA yA | videharAjasya hi yaj~nabhUmau suteti tasyaiva tatastu sA bhUt.h ||

Chapter-IV

Chapters 4 through 9 give a brief account of Sri Rama's story. All the major events of Sri Rama's story are narrated. While narrating some of the crucial events like 's episode, 's episode, and Surpanakha's episode, the subtle issues of dharma and adharma are clarified. The relevance of these episodes is explained along with the main purpose of the theme. The background of the personalities concerned and the events are explained as well. Thus the objective of the narration of the different events of the story is not merely for the interest of the story but for the interest of the moral and spiritual aspects. Since hte main events of Sri RAma's story are well known, I will highlight only the moral and the spiritual aspects that are brought out in this portion of the Tatparyanirnaya.

The first important event in Sri Rama's story is 's invitation to Sri Rama to protect the sacrifice he had undertaken from the demons. This indicates the main purpose of Sri Rama's incarnation viz., protecting the sages and other innocent persons from the onslaught of the demons. Sri Rama kills and and throws Mareecha into the sea. This very Tataka will be born as in Krishnavatara. After the destruction of these and the completion of the sacrifice, Vishvamitra takes Sri Rama and Laxmana to the capital of the country of Videha. On the way, Ahalya is released from her curse by the touch of Sri Rama. Here are the instances of two women: one who was cruel and therefore destroyed and one who had suffered at the hands of Indra and Gautama and was released from her suffering. Gautama had indulged in excessive penance. This imbalance had to be cut down by provoking him. Therefore, Indra encroached upon Gautama's wife Ahalya. She was innocent but had become a victim of the circumstances.Hence, Sri RAma relieved her from her suffering. atiriktaM tayo hartuM gautamasyAshrame rahaH | surakAryaM surapatiH kurvan.h bhAryAM samaspR^ishat.h || (saN^.rA. I-6-18)

On arrival at , Sri Rama was informed of the condition for the marriage of Sita. He broke the bow of Shiva and married her. The marriage was celebrated in a befitting way. On his way to , confronts him. Both Parashurama and Sri Rama were the incarnations of Lord Vishnu. Therefore, there was no question of one defeating the other. However, a demon called Atula had found a place in Parashurama's navel. He was to be destroyed. His penance was also to be taken away. Therefore, Parashurama gave the Sharang Bow to Sri Rama and asked Him to kill Atula. Accordingly, Sri Rama killed him. Thus it was not a war between Parashurama and Sri Rama,but it was only to kill Atula that Sri Rama employed his bow. The fourt chapter narrates these episodes.

The Ayodhya Kanda events are described in the first 16 verses of the fifth chapter. Dasharata decides to coronate Sri Rama. But under the advice of Manthara, prevents it. Maanthara was not an ordinary woman. It is well-known that as a result of the samudramathana, Goddess Laxmi was born from the sea. Out of the same samudramathana, the Alaxmi called Jyestha was also born. She has been the wife of . It was this Alaxmi alias Jyestha who was born as Manthara. Instigated by this Manthara, Kaikeyi asked for her two boons, viz. (i) Sri Rama be banished to the forest for 14 years and (ii) Bharata be installed on the throne. Kaikeyi asked for such cruel boons because a demoness called Nikrti was present in her.

According to these boons, Sri Rama proceeds to the forest. He first meets the Nishada King Guha. Being honored by him, he proceeds to Chitrakuta. In the meanwhile, Dasharata dies.Bharata arrives, and completing Pitrkarya, he proceeds to Chitrakuta to persuade Sri Rama to return. Sri Rama does not oblige him. Bharata returns to Ayodhya with the of Sri Rama and lives outside the city of Ayodhya in Nandigrama.

After Sri Rama and Sita lived in Chitrakuta for some time, Indra's son appeared in the form of a crow and injures Sita in the breast. He indulges in this cruel act because a demon called Kuranga was present in him. Sri Rama throws a grass blade at the eye of this crow and destroys one eye of all crows. Since then, crows have only one eye. Then Sri Rama entered Dandaka forest.

In Dandaka forest, a sage called Sharabhanga offered himself to fire in the presence of Sri Rama. He was very old and was unable to perform even his minimum rituals. Dharmashastra permits self-immolation for such aged persons. anushhTAnAsamarthasya vAnaprasthasya jIryataH | jalAnashanabhR^igvagnimahAprasthAnamishhyate || (Varaha Purana)

A person in who is not able to perform his miniimum rituals to old age may take to self-immolation by drowning himself in water, observing a fast, falling from the peak of a mountain, or offering himself to fire. Accordingly, Sharabhanga performed self-immolation in the presence of Sri Rama. After this event, the demon confronts Sri Rama. He tries to kidnap Sita and carries Sri Rama and Laxmana on his shoulders. Sri Rama cuts his arms and throws him in a pit. His arms were cut because he had obtained a boon from Brahma that whoever is held by him in his arms cannot escape from it.

Chapter-IV to IX kAj~nAnamApaddapi mandakaTAxamAtrAt.h sargasthitipralayasamsR^itimoxahetoH | devyAH hareH kimu viDambanamAtrametad.h vikrIDatoH suranarAdivadeva tasmAt.h || (V-36)

On returning to His ashrama after killing Mareecha, Sri Rama found the ashrama empty. He moved on in the forest in search of Sita. First He saw , who was hurt by Ravana. He learned about Ravana kidnapping Sita. He moved on and killed on the way. Then He met in Matangavana and received her hospitality. Then he saw Hanuman and Sugreeva on Rishyamuka Hill. Hanuman approached Sri Rama and prostrated at His feet. With this, the fifth chapter of Tatparyanirnaya closes.

The events of Kanda are described in the sixth chapter. Hanuman, who prostrated at the feet of Sri Rama, was taken up by Sri Rama's arms with great affection. He took Sri Rama and Laxmana on his shoulders and brought them to Rishyamuka, where Sugreeva stayed. Sugreeva explained his pitiable condition on account of his brother's aggressive posture. Sri Rama promised him that his aggressive brother Vali will be killed, and the kingship will be restored to him. Sugreeeva also agreed to help Sri Rama find Sita. However, he wanted to know whether Sri Rama had a sufficient amount of strength to fight Vali. Therefore, he showed Rama the body of Dundubhi, who was killed by Vali. Sri Rama threw that dead body a hundred yojanas away with His toe. The carcass killed a number of demons living on Rasatala. Then, Sugreeva showed Rama seven demons present in the form of seven tala trees and said that if He could destroy these with one arrow, He could kill Vali. Sri Rama destroyed all of them with one arrow, which, after destroying the tala trees, pierced the seven underworlds viz., Atala, Vitala, etc., upto and also destroyed the demons knows as Kumiudi. Then, Sugreeva took Rama to the city of Kishkindha to kill Vali. Vali pounced on Sugreeva, but Sri Rama did not kill him, pretending that he could not distinguish between the two. The real reason was to give an opportunity for the brothers to reconcile and to avoid a confrontation. Even the long enmity between the brothers vanishes when they reach the point of crisis. saubhrAtrameva yadi vAJNchati vAlinaiva | nAhaM nirAgasamathAgrajaniM hanishhye || dIrdhaH sahodaragato na bhaveddhi kopo | dIrdho.api kAraNamR^ite vinivartate cha ||

When Sugreeva again appealed to Sri Rama to kill Vali, Sri Rama threw a strong arrow at Vali and killed him. It is well-known that Sri Rama killed Vali from behind a tree. The reason for this was neither fear nor treachery. Vali was also a great devotee and would have prostrated at the feet of Sri Rama if he had seen him. Then, it would have been a dilemma whether to stand by His promise to Sugreeva or to stand by Vali, who had prostrated at His feet. Therefore, Sri Rama preferred to be invisible. bhakto mamaushha yadi mAmabhipashyatIha | pAdau dhruvaM mama sameshhyati nirvichAraH || yogyo vadho nahi janasya padAnatasya | rAjyArthinA ravisutena vadho.arthitashhcha || tasmAdadR^ishyatanureva nihanmi shakraputram.h | tvitIha tamadR^ishyatayA jaghAna ||

Then, during the rainy season, there was a halt for four months. Sugreeva had not taken any initiative to find Sita. However, on the strong advice of Hanuman, the vanaras spread over different parts were gathered and started. Sri Rama gave his ring to Hanuman to show it to Sita to identify. After a good deal of wandering, they found that the time limit given by Sugreeva was over. Tara and Angada suggested that the efforts should be abandoned. But Hanuman opposed this. They moved on and ultimately reached the Mahendra mountain. At this place, they met , Jatayu's elder brother. He informed them that he had seen Ravana taking Sita away. She is kept in Ashokavana. The distance between Mahendra Mountain and was a hundred yojanas. Other vanaras were not able to jump this far. They all appealed to Hanuman to cross the sea and trace Sita. With this, the sixth chapter closes.

Hanuman offers salutations to Sri Rama in his mind before he takes a big jump over the sea. The sea became turbulent, and the living beings within the sea came out. The trees on the Mahendra mountain were uprooted and the Mainaka mountain came out of the sea to offer him a resting place. As he moved on, the mother of the serpents, viz. , confronts him. He enters her belly and comes out. Then, Simhika, a demoness who used to drag persons by attacking their shadows, drags him. He destroyed her also. Finally, he lands on the Trikuta hill that surrounded the city of Lanka. Throughout the process of crossing the sea, he had considerably expanded his body. Now, he contracts it to as small as a cat. He finds Sita in Ashokavana under a Simshupa tree. He hands the ring given by Sri Rama to Sita. In return, Sita gives her to Hanuman to give to Sri Rama.

In order to make Ravana aware of his strength and mission, Hanuman starts destroying Ravana's gardens. On hearing this, Ravana asks his army to punish him. Finding that they were not able to do the task, he deputes his son, Aksha. Hanuman kills Aksha. Then is deputed. Indrajit employs the against him. Out of respect for Brahma, he pretends to have been caught. The demons tie him with Nagapasha. Finding that they have used an inferior weapon, the Brahmastra returns. Then Hanuman is taken into Ravana's presence. Ravana orders his tail to be burned. With the fire applied to his tail, Hanuamn burns Lanka and returns to Sri Rama. He offers the Chudamani to Him and embraces Him with great affection, as it were, offering himself as a present to Him. svAtmapradAnamadhikaM pachanAtmajasya | kurvan.h samashlishhadamalaM paramAbhitushhTaH || (VI-50)

The eighth chapter begins with Sri Rama lying on a grass mat in order to persuade the sea to make the way for Him to go to Lanka. This was the mild way of persuading the sea before any harsh step was taken. At that time, came to join Sri Rama and fight against his own brother Ravana since his conduct was adharma. Sugreeva and all the others opposed accepting him as he belonged to the enemy's group. However, Hanuman stated that Vibhishana is genuinely supporting Sri Rama and that he be accepted. Sri Rama accepted him and coronated him on the kingdom of Lanka as he was sure of the defeat of Ravana.

Since the sea did not make way easily, Sri Rama took His arrow to aim at him. The samudraraja came out and suggested that a bridge be built over the sea. Sri Rama had build the bridge assisted by the vanaras. He crossed the sea and landed on Lanka. Ravana had made elaborate arrangements to protect the four gates of the city of Lanka. Sri Rama also made appropriate distribution of the army. A detailed description of the battle is given in this chapter.

After Ravana is killed, Shiva challenges Sri Rama to fight since He had killed his devotee Ravana. Then, Sri Rama gets His arrow ready to aim at Shiva. However, Shiva realizes his mistake. Then, a fire ordeal is pretended for Sita pratikrti. Sita returns from Kailasa. Sri Rama returns to Ayodhya by Pushpaka . Sri Rama is coronated. He favors all suitably. Hanuman asks for only uninterrupted devotion toward Him. prachardhatAM bhaktiralaM xaNe xaNe tvayIsha me hrAsavivarjitA sadA | (VIII-248)

With this happy note, the chapter closes.

The ninth chapter contains the events of the Uttarakanda story. After coronation, Sri Rama ruled the kingdom benevolently. There is a beautiful description of Rajarajya in this chapter.

prashAsatIshe pR^ithivI babhUva viriJNchilokasya samA guNonnatau |

jano.akhilo vishhNuparo babhUva na dharmahAnishcha babhUva kasyachit.h | (IX-4)

na kasyachidduHkhamabhUt.h kathaJNchit.h na chittahAnishcha babhUva kasyachit.h |

nAdharmashIlo na cha kashchanAprajona dushprajo naiva kubhArthakashcha ||

striyo na chAsan.h vidhavAH kathaJNchit.hna cheshhTahAnirnacha pUrvamR^ityuH |

yatheshhTamAlyAbharaNAnulepanAHyatheshhTapAnAshanavAsaso.akhilAH ||

babhUvurIshe jagati prashAsati prakR^ishhTadharmeNa janArdane nR^ipe ||(IX-9,11)

A much-debated episode in Uttarakanda is that of shambUkavadha. Many are under the impression that he was killed by Sri Rama because he was a sudra and had undertaken the penance for which he was not entitled. But the reason is more serious. He was a demon called Jangha. He was born as a sudra and had vowed to snatch away the very position of Shiva. Therefore, he was killed.

jaN^ghanAmA.asuraH pUrvaM girijAvaradAnataH |

babhUvashUdraH kalpAyuH sa lokaxayakAmyayA ||

tapashchachAra durbuddhirichchhan.h mAheshchvaraM padam.h |

ananyavadhyaM taM tasmAt.h jaghAna purushhottamaH || (IX-20,21)

Sri Rama banishing Sita also has an episode behind it rather than being merely a washerman scandalizing her stay in Ravana's place. There were demons called surANaka. They wanted to commit the highest sin. Brahma told them that separating Lord Vishnu and Goddess Lakshmi alone is the greatest sin. Therefore, they engineered the banishment of Sita by causing scandalous talk.

yAvadeva ramayA rameshvaraM no viyojayatha sadguNArNavam.h |

tAvaduchchamapi dushhkR^itaM bhavanmoxamArgaparipanthi no bhavet.h ||(IX-29)

Strictly speaking, there was no separation of Sri Rama and Sita at all.

pravishya bhUmau sA devI lokadR^ishhTyanusArataH |

reme rAmeNAviyuktA bhAskareNa prabhA yathA ||

When Sri Rama's avatarakarya was over, he left for .

While leaving for Vaikuntha, Sri Rama declared that whoever desires to come with Him may join Him. At this call, right from the ants to the good men who desired a higher world joined him. shrutvA tu tadya iha moxapadechchhavaste

sarve samAyayurathAtR^iNamApipIlam.h |

rAmAj~nayA gamanashaktirabhUttR^iNAdeH

ye tatra dIrghabhavino na tu te tadaichchcan.h || (IX-61)

While going to Vaikuntha, Sri Rama bestowed various favors on those who had assisted Him in his avatarakarya. He especially told Hanuman that he can see Him whenever he liked.

athAha vAyunandanaM sa rAghavaH samAshlishhan.h | tavAhamabhigocharaH sadA bhavAmi nAnyathA || (IX-63)

Thus closing the story of Sri Rama, Sri Madhvacharya once again informs us that he has given here the sketch of Sri Rama's avatarakarya, culling out the information from paJNcharAtra, bhArata, rAmAyaNa, etc. The entire itihAsapurANa literature reconciles the apparent differences and brings out the following indepth meaning:

ityasheshhapurANebhyaH paJNcharAtrebhya eva cha |

bhAratAchchaiva vedebhyaH mahArAmAyaNAdapi ||

parasparaviroghasya hAnAnnirNIya tattvataH |

yuktyA buddhibhalAchchaiva vishhNoreva prasAdataH || (IX-125,126)

It is hoped that this brief summary of the contents of the first nine chapters of Mahabharata Tatparyanirnaya will enable the readers to understand the text and its indepth meaning.