Stoicism in Descartes, Pascal, and Spinoza: Examining Neostoicism's
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of South Florida Scholar Commons Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate School 4-8-2016 Stoicism in Descartes, Pascal, and Spinoza: Examining Neostoicism’s Influence in the Seventeenth Century Daniel Collette University of South Florida, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd Part of the Philosophy Commons Scholar Commons Citation Collette, Daniel, "Stoicism in Descartes, Pascal, and Spinoza: Examining Neostoicism’s Influence in the Seventeenth Century" (2016). Graduate Theses and Dissertations. http://scholarcommons.usf.edu/etd/6210 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Stoicism in Descartes, Pascal, and Spinoza: Examining Neostoicism’s Influence in the Seventeenth Century by Daniel Collette A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Philosophy College of Arts and Sciences University of South Florida Major Professor: Roger Ariew, Ph.D. Daniel Garber, Ph.D. Colin Heydt, Ph.D. Douglas Jesseph, Ph.D. Thomas Williams, Ph.D. Date of Approval: March 25, 2016 Keywords: Early Modern Philosophy, History of Ethics, Stoicism, Neostoicism, Descartes, Pascal, Spinoza Copyright © 2016, Daniel Collette DEDICATION For Alistair and Wesley, my raison d'être. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Most chapters were presented in earlier form as colloquium; Mary Domski, Julia Jorati, Matt Kisner, and Julie Walsh offered especially helpful comments. My committee is composed of the finest people: Daniel Garber, Colin Heydt, Douglas Jesseph, and Thomas Williams. I am grateful to have learned with them; any errors in this manuscript are my own. I owe very special gratitude to my committee chair, Roger Ariew, for his unceasing generosity of time and a lasting mark of modeling excellence. He has shown what it means to be successful while still maintaining one’s integrity and ‘soul’. I am abundantly grateful for Doina-Cristina Rusu, the only non-committee member to read this work as it formed. She has provided many insightful comments making my arguments markedly better, and I have finished sooner because of her encouragement. I am a better philosopher, and a better person, because of her friendship. Additionally, many dear friends deserve credit for their encouragement and collaboration: Vlad Alexandrescu, Anthony Desantis, Anthony Fernandez, Benny Goldberg, Dahlia Guzman, Hugh LaFollette, Charles MacKenzie, Lucio Mare, Lucien Monson, Erika Oshiro, Nancy Stanlick, Jeff Steele, Christine Wieseler, Milton Wilcox, and Andrew Winters. Others I omit out of oversight, not ingratitude. To Joseph Anderson and Aaron Spink, many ideas and drafts (which sort of draft I will leave to the reader) have been exchanged at Coppertop and many places traveled: the bonds of friendship are the highest reward from candidacy. Finally, thank you to Jennifer Collette. More than anyone she has felt the weight of this process; I could not have done this as soon, or as well, without her. TABLE OF CONTENTS List of Abbreviations ..................................................................................................................... iii Abstract .......................................................................................................................................... iv Introduction ......................................................................................................................................1 Chapter One: Descartes’ First Morality: A Pyrrhonian Morale Par Provision .............................15 I. An Early Indifference Towards Morality .......................................................................18 I.a. Ethics in the Meditations on First Philosophy? ...............................................20 I.b. One Remaining Detail .....................................................................................28 II. An Alternative Reading of the Morale Par Provision ..................................................29 III. The Objection From a Letter to Elisabeth, 4 August 1645 ..........................................35 Chapter Two: Passions Embodied: Descartes’ Letters to Elisabeth Revisited ..............................38 I. The Passions of the Soul as Physiology .........................................................................40 I.a. The Passions of the Soul as Natural Philosophy ..............................................42 I.b. The Order of Philosophy and a Physics of Man ..............................................47 I.c. The Cartesian (Re)construction of the Passions of the Soul ............................50 II. Cartesian Morality .........................................................................................................53 II.a. Descartes and the Greek Ethicists ..................................................................54 II.b. Descartes’ (Late) Ethics .................................................................................58 II.c. A Historical Precedent for Descartes’ Approach ...........................................63 III. Conclusion ...................................................................................................................66 Chapter Three: Pascal On the Good Life: If Happiness Fails, Try Stoicism .................................68 I. Pascal’s Use of “Order” in the Pensées ..........................................................................69 II. Pascal’s Philosophical Anatomy ...................................................................................74 II.a. Pascal and Augustine ......................................................................................74 II.b. Pascal and Descartes ......................................................................................81 II.c. Pascal and Montaigne .....................................................................................94 II.d. Pascal and Epictetus .....................................................................................100 III. Pascal on Morality and the Good Life .......................................................................102 Chapter Four: Spinoza’s Anti-Stoicism, or, Spinoza Among the Neostoics ...............................115 I. Some Interpretations of Spinoza and the Stoic Morality ..............................................118 II. Spinoza’s Anti-Stoicism ..............................................................................................124 III. Spinoza Among the Neostoics ...................................................................................138 Conclusion ...................................................................................................................................143 i References ....................................................................................................................................149 Appendix: Medieval References to Stoicism ...............................................................................160 ii LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS AC Descartes, René. Meditations, Objections, and Replies. Edited and Translated by Roger Ariew and Donald Cress. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Co., 2006. AG Leibniz, G.W. Philosophical Essays. Edited and Translated by Roger Ariew and Daniel Garber. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Co., 1989. AT Descartes, René. Œuvres de Descartes. Edited by Charles Adam and Paul Tannery. Paris, 1910. EW Hobbes, Thomas. The English Works of Thomas Hobbes Vol. VI. London: Bohn, 1839-45. CD Augustine. City of God. Edited by Henry Bettenson. New York, NY: Penguin Classics, 2003. CSM Descartes, René. The Philosophical Writings of Descartes: Volumes I-II. Translated by John Cottingham, Robert Stoothoff, and Dugland Murdoch. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press, 2007-2009. CSMK Descartes, René. The Philosophical Writings of Descartes: Volume III, The Correspondence. Translated by John Cottingham, Robert Stoothoff, Dugland Murdoch, and Anthony Kenny. New York, NY: Cambridge University Press, 1999. ST Aquinas, Thomas. Summa Theologica. I-II. Translated by the English Dominican Province, 2008. http://www.newadvent.org/summa/2.htm. References to Pascal’s work are from Jean Mesnard’s Œuvres complétes, currently in four volumes (1964-1992). Since Volumes V-VIII are still forthcoming, I make the following exceptions. References for the Pensées are to the Sellier (S) edition (1999), though I also provide the older Lafuma (L) citations. References to the Entretien avec M. de Sacy are from Mesnard and Mengotti’s 1994 edition; this newer manuscript was discovered and published after already appearing in the Œuvres complétes. In some cases, a text is not available in any of the above collections. Under these conditions, I reference Le Guern’s Œuvres complétes (1965). All translations of the Pensées are from Roger Ariew’s edition (Blaise Pascal, Pensées, ed. and trans. Roger Ariew [Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Co., 2005]). All translations of Spinoza’s work are from Samuel Shirley’s Complete Works (Benedict Spinoza, Complete Works, ed. Samuel Shirley [Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Co., 2002]). iii ABSTRACT My dissertation focuses on the moral philosophy of Descartes, Pascal, and Spinoza in the context of the revival of Stoicism within the seventeenth century.