PBN TF/8 – IP/05 22/01/2013
EANPG PROGRAMME COORDINATING GROUP (COG) PERFORMANCE BASED NAVIGATION IMPLEMENTATION TASK FORCE (PBN TF)
EIGHTH MEETING
(Paris, France, 23-24 January 2013)
Agenda Item 1:
SUMMARY OF DISCUSSIONS OF THE SEVENTH MEETING OF THE ICAO EUR PERFORMANCE BASED NAVIGATION TASK FORCE MEETING
(Presented by the Secretariat)
SUMMARY This information paper presents the Meeting with the Summary of Discussions of the PBN TF/7 Meeting.
1. Action by the meeting
a) The PBN TF is invited to review and comment on the follow up actions stemming from the previous meeting.
(1 page + 1 appendix) PBNTF8 IP05_SoD PBN TF7 final.docx PBN TF/7 - SoD 06/07/2012
SUMMARY OF DISCUSSIONS
ICAO EUR PERFORMANCE BASED NAVIGATION TASK FORCE
(EUR PBN TF)
SEVENTH MEETING
(Paris, 2 –3 July 2012)
1. Introduction
1.1 The Seventh Meeting of the ICAO EUR PBN TF was convened on 2-3 July 2012 in the EUR/NAT Office of ICAO in Paris, France.
1.2 The Meeting was chaired by Mr Thomas Buchanan (Switzerland) and Mr Elkhan Nahmadov from the European and North Atlantic (EUR/NAT) Office of ICAO was the Secretary, assisted by Ms Catherine Daly from the same Office. Lists of participants and contacts are provided at Appendix A and Appendix B. A list of documentation submitted to the Meeting is provided at Appendix C. The meeting agenda is provided at Appendix D.
2. Review of the latest developments
ICAO update
2.1 The PBN TF was provided with an update on the latest amendments and proposals for amendment to ICAO provisions, particularly those related to PBN.
2.2 The PBN TF was provided with an overview of the new edition of the ICAO PBN manual which was expected to be published during the summer 2012. It was noted that the following activities were recommended following the publication of the new PBN manual:
a) Shortcomings with filing of PBN in the 2012 ATC FPL identified, which will need to be addressed pre-FF ICE;
b) Consequential changes [for routes with FRT] are required to ICAO documentation including Annex 11.
c) It is recommended that ICAO develop supporting guidance/information for the new navigation specifications, especially Advanced RNP.
d) The timeline for implementation will need to reflect development of supporting guidance material and implementation processes by States.
e) It is anticipated that future actions will be necessary post-PBNSG to support implementation.
2.3 The PBN TF was informed that the following material was in preparation in the area of ATM / Airspace Planning and Design Support
a) Continuous Climb Operations (CCO) Manual - Advance copy by July 2012;
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012 -2- PBN TF/7 - SoD
b) PBN Airspace Concepts Manual - Advance copy by July 2012;
c) ilearn information/workshop package on PBN airspace design - August 2012.
2.4 In the area of Flight Operations support, the following was expected:
a) PBN Operations Approval Manual - Under review by PBN Operations Approval Tiger Team Advance copy by September 2012
2.5 The PBN TF noted that the following on-line training packages were being prepared:
a) ilearn information/workshop package on PBN Operations Approval - September 2012;
b) ilearn information/workshop package on PBN overview - September 2012;
c) PBN Implementation toolkit addressing: executives, regulators, ANSPs, Aircraft operators, Manufacturers - September 2012.
2.6 The PBN TF noted a state letter addressing Instrument Flight Procedures was expected by the end of 2012 addressing:
a) Criteria to support new edition of PBN Manual;
b) Improved Baro-VNAV criteria;
c) Helicopter criteria;
d) Sample charts.
2.7 Work was ongoing on the development of a Collision Risk Model for PBN obstacle clearance and air-to-air separation, PBN Procedure Design Safety Assessment Manual and Advanced RNP support document.
ICAO PBN Symposium
2.8 The PBN TF was informed that the ICAO PBN Symposium will take place on 16-19 October 2012 in Montreal; the main objectives of which are:
a) The unveiling of future PBN provisions/directions;
b) Achievements and roadblocks;
c) Action to be taken;
d) PBN in the ASBU context, and
e) Commitment and resources.
2.9 In this respect, the PBN TF agreed that a contribution for the Symposium would be prepared on behalf of the EUR PBN TF. The presentation would report the status of implementation and discuss existing issues impeding implementation. Among them flight planning requirements in support of new PBN specifications, GNSS approvals, definition of IFR runway ends and 100% implementation requirement of the Assembly Resolution 37-11, ATC phraseology in support of PBN operations. It was agreed that the Chairman in coordination with the secretary and other members of the task force who volunteered to support, would develop a draft presentation aiming to make it ready for submission by the beginning of September 2012.
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012 -3- PBN TF/7- SoD
2.10 The PBN TF noted that the EUR SUPPs was amended to include specific provisions on flight planning for those current PRNAV approved aircraft that would not be considered equivalent to RNAV-1. The PBN TF noted that for these few remaining aircraft it would be required to indicate their equipage and capabilities by including Z in item 10 followed by NAV/EURPRNAV in item 18.
Regional workshops and Go Teams
2.11 The PBN TF noted that a PBN Airspace concept implementation workshop will be held on 9-12 in Georgia. In parallel, a regional Go- Team project will be done for States in the Southern Caucasus area. A global Go-Team project was scheduled on 4-7 September 2012 in the Russian Federation. The PBN TF noted that the outcome of these events will be reported at the next meeting. The PBN TF was informed that the final report of the GO Team project in Germany was completed and the German PBN implementation plan was updated taking the outcomes of the project into account.
Update by CANSO and IATA
2.12 The PBN TF was provided with information on the CANSO and IATA strategies to promote PBN implementation and noted the importance of continuous cooperation between international organisations to foster PBN from all angles, e.g. ANSPs, airspace users, airports, regulators etc. IATA provided an update on the IATA/airlines project with the Hellenic CAA on PBN implementation at Greek Island airports of which Heraklion and Corfu were selected as priority airports to gain experience with RNP APCH implementation. In the presentation IATA showed the outcome of the 2010 avionic survey encompassing about 2500 airframes of IATA member airlines. IATA also informed about a similar survey for 2012 which is expected to be published at the end of 2012. IATA reiterated that a business case for SBAS equipage is negative and airlines request priority from States and ANSPs to deploy RNP APCH APV BaroVNAV procedures. The PBN TF invited both organisations to continue providing updates at the next meetings.
EASA update
2.13 The PBN TF was provided with the status and foreseen evolution of the EASA regulatory and support material for PBN.
2.14 The following was noted:
a) EASA is still working, supported by EUROCONTROL, on the NPA for the certification specifications for airborne CNS –CS-ACNS); it will include transposition of former JAA TGL 10 on Precision RNAV); the NPA is however not yet published.
b) AMC 20-27 (APV/Baro-VNAV) is applicable and more stringent than corresponding FAA AC 20-129. AEA/IATA visited EASA on the subject on last 22 June:
c) IATA and AEA once more expressed concerns over the criteria for APV/Baro-VNAV approaches contained in AMC 20-27 and proposed Certification Memorandum CM-AS-002, which provides further guidance and clarifications on application of AMC 20-27 requirements;
d) The discussion with IATA and AEA initially focused on the airworthiness requirements in the AMC and the clarifications and guidance provided in the CM, although it soon became apparent that the main concerns voiced by IATA and AEA were in the domain of operational approvals, where EASA has no direct jurisdiction;
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
-4- PBN TF/7 - SoD
e) EASA provided a recommendation to the NAAs to limit APV/Baro-VNAV approaches to airfields at elevations not higher than 5000 ft. for operations with aircraft approved to the criteria of FAA AC 20-129. This recommendation was drafted in cooperation with the leading NAAs and is based on recognition of a discrepancy between the airworthiness criteria in the ICAO PBN manual (and FAA AC 20-129) and the procedure design criteria in ICAO PANS-OPS Vol. II. (i.e. not to airfields whose Final Approach Fix is at 5000 ft or above);
f) Although EASA appears to have been conservative in the assumption of the buffers applied for obstacle clearance in ICAO PANS-OPS Vol. II, the existing criteria of AMC 20-27 do not seem to be overly stringent; these represent the current state of technology, versus the PBN manual criteria which are believed to have been developed in the 1980’s. The FAA recently proposed even more stringent requirements in their new AC 20-138C;
g) With regards to the recommendation for operational approvals, EASA agreed that a more balanced recommendation may be justified. IATA, AEA and EASA agreed to form a Task Force to develop an improved recommendation to the NAAs. The Task Force should include airline operational experts, experts from the leading NAAs and EASA experts. IATA will draft the ToR for the Task Force and submit these to EASA for concurrence. The Task Force is anticipated to start soon after the summer holidays;
h) The CM to AMC 20-27 may be published by the end of 2012
i) There are currently no plans to update AMC 20-27.
j) AMC 20-28 (ref. NPA and CRD 2009-04 on LPV/SBAS) is in progress. Publication still planned in 2012. Presently Agency can already certify implementation of SBAS receivers on aircraft, based on a generic Certification Review Item (CRI), in fact based on said NPA and CRD.
k) 6 Rulemaking tasks related to PBN are contained in the draft EASA Rulemaking Programme (RMP) 2013-16:
l) The draft RMP is open to comments by EASA Member States (MS) and industry stakeholders (SSCC) until 05 July 2012; its adoption is expected in September 2012;
m) The ToR for RMT.0256 and RMT.257 (revision of operational criteria for current PBN operations, as listed in ‘Part SPA’) are finalized after consultation with MS and SSCC; publication is expected in July 2012; the tasks will be progressed through a Group for which nominations have been received; the Group will in particular include experts from general aviation and for pilot training; current thinking is in fact that the administrative process for SPA could in certain cases be avoided, when proper syllabi for pilot training would be in place. The NPA could be issued beginning of 2014.
n) RMT.0445 and RMT.0446 aim at developing rules for airspace design, including procedure design, respectively at the level of legally binding Implementing Rules (IR) and AMC/GM or CS; both are scheduled to be initiated in 2013;
o) RMT.0519 and RMT.0520 (again respectively for IRs and for AMC/GM and CS) have been newly introduced, to parallel the ‘mandate’ to EUROCONTROL. These tasks concern new PBN types and are based on the idea that EUROCONTROL would propose a SES IR rule specifying the ‘what’ (PBN types), ‘where’ (which airspace volumes), ‘when’ and by ‘who’ (e.g. States for airspace design and operators for aircraft equipment). In parallel EASA has to develop updates to the safety regulatory material (i.e. the ‘how’), like for instance
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012 -5- PBN TF/7- SoD
deciding whether or not some of these new PBN types require SPA or whether specific airworthiness criteria are necessary.
EC PBN IR
2.15 The PBN TF was presented with an update on the development of the PBN Implementing Rule by Eurocontrol as mandated by the EC. It was noted that a consultation was expected for circulation in the coming 2-3 weeks followed by a workshop in October 2012. The PBN TF members were invited to take active participation in the review of the package.
EGNOS status update
2.16 An update was provided by the EGNOS service provider on the EGNOS system and services status, EGNOS SoL Service issues, EGNOS Services Roadmap and EGNOS SoL Service introduction Status. The current status of LPV implementation in Europe was also provided. Further information could be found http://egnos-user-support.essp-sas.eu and www.essp-sas.eu.
3. Status of PBN implementation in the EUR region
Status of PBN in the EUR Region
3.1 The PBN TF was presented with statistics on the progress of PBN implementation in the EUR based on the data available to ICAO through updates of the CNS4b Table of the EUR Air Navigation Plan and the PBN implementation status. It was noted that although the tables indicated a very good progress, it was still far below the agreed 30% implementation by 2011 for all IFR RWY ends serving aircraft with MTOW 5700 kg (Assembly Resolution 37-11 refers). In this regard, the PBN TF discussed uncertainty about definitions of what is the IFR runway end and therefore what constitutes 100% implementation requirement.
3.2 The PBN TF was also provided with PBN implementation status by Eurocontrol based information available through the LSSIP process and the on-line implementation status map tool. The PBN TF requested Eurocontrol to investigate whether this map tool could be made available for all States in the ICAO EUR Region.
Presentations by States
3.3 The PBN TF was presented with the status of the national PBN planning and implementation in France, Italy, Ukraine and the United Kingdom. Another presentation was provided on the experiences from RNP APCH AR implementation in Sweden.
3.4 In particular the PBN TF noted information provided by France on the alignment of the ATC phraseology in support of PBN with the charting requirements. It was agreed that this subject could be one of the issues for contribution by the EUR PBN TF for the upcoming ICAO PBN Symposium.
3.5 The PBN TF noted information provided by Romania about the lack of EGNOS coverage over Romania. It was also noted that there was a regulatory requirement for certification of all ANS providers within the SES framework, potentially implying that the GPS provider should be subject to such certification as well. Taking into account the practicalities of implementing such approach in the GPS case, the PBN TF noted that a regulatory approach to grant exemptions in such cases should be developed by the appropriate bodies.
3.6 The PBN TF encouraged States to continue providing reports on the PBN status and plans at future meetings.
4. ICAO fuel saving estimate tool IFSET
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
-6- PBN TF/7 - SoD
4.1 The PBN TF recalled that EANPG (Conclusion 53/34 refers) supported the request on the estimation and reporting of fuel savings resulting from national or regional operational improvements and took note of the ICAO Fuel Savings Estimation Tool (IFSET) which was specifically designed for this purpose. It was noted that IFSET had been designed to assist States to estimate and report fuel savings consistently with the models approved by ICAO’s Committee on Aviation Environmental Protection (CAEP) and aligned with the Global Air Navigation Plan. It was noted that IFSET can help States measure the benefits from shortening/eliminating level segments on departure and arrival routes, shorter ATS-Routes (either in time or distance), cruising at different altitudes, and reducing taxi times.
4.2 The PBN TF members were encouraged to use the IFSET for estimating the benefits in terms of fuel savings/CO2 emission reduction should be part of any PBN related implementations.
4.3 In conjunction with this subject, a presentation was provided on the study of potential tradeoffs between fuel efficiency, CO2 emission and nose considerations when implementing CCOs.
5. ICAO EUR PBN approach guidance material
5.1 The PBN TF was provided with the final version of the EUR PBN approaches implementation guidance material and agreed to recommend to the EANPG COG to endorse this document as an ICAO EUR regional guidance in support of PBN approaches implementation 5.2 The PBN TF also agreed to recommend that the EANPG COG should task the EUR PBN TF with further maintenance of the document taking experiences accrued, new PBN specifications and emerging operational needs into account. 6. AOB
Follow-up actions list
6.1 The PBN TF reviewed the follow-up actions list from the previous meeting. It was agreed that all actions have been completed, reported and documented in this report. Consequently and taking the outcome of the discussions of the current meeting into account, the actions list was updated and provided at Appendix E.
Next meeting
6.2 The next meeting of the PBN TF will take place on 22-24 January 2013 in Paris with the main objective to discuss the outcomes of the ICAO PBN Symposium and AN-Conf/12 and their impact on the work of the task force.
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012 A-1 Appendix A to PBN TF/7-SoD APPENDIX A List of Participants
SPAIN AUSTRIA Francisco-Javier DE BLAS Florian BUCHMANN Juan David Nieto SEPULVEDA FRANCE SWITZERLAND Cedric TEDESCO Peter IMHOF Bertrand FOUCHER Thomas BUCHANAN François GREMY Laurent DELETRAZ GEORGIA Marc TROLLER Dr Vladimir JERENASHVILI UKRAINE GERMANY Pavlo KUD Roland KALUZA UNITED KINGDOM ITALY Geoffrey BURTENSHAW Stefano FELICI CANSO Carmelo LOPIS Akos VAN DER PLAAT Leonardo NICOLO Henrik EKSTRAND LATVIA EASA Andrejs DUDAREVS Bryan JOLLY Érika NEIMANE Filippo TOMASELLO MONTENEGRO EUROCONTROL Aleksandar DJORDJEVIC Rodolphe SOLOMON MOROCCO Richard FARNWORTH Abdellah SAKHI Sasho NESHEVSKI NORWAY Aline TROADEC Arne LINDBERG IAC Arne HEGGE Sergey KONOGIN
POLAND IATA Andrzej KROL Anthony VAN DER VELDT Karol KAZMIERCZAK JEPPESEN ROMANIA Thomas HESS Viorel SALISTEAN LUFTHANSA Valentin STOIAN Martin ZILLIG RUSSIAN FEDERATION Pieter-Bas OORTMAN Elmar ALEKSANDROV LUFTHANSA SYSTEMS FLIGHTNAV INC Vitaliy AMRAMTSOV Jordan MEEK Mikhail DANILIN Alexander LOSEV ICAO
Elkhan NAHMADOV Sven HALLE Catherine DALY
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-1 Appendix B to PBN TF/6-SoD APPENDIX B Contact List
ALGERIA Nesrine ZITOUNI E-mail: [email protected] Civil Aviation Engineer ALGERIA
Nadjib KHIALI +213 216 72130 Exploitation Service Chief E-mail: [email protected] Algiers ACC ALGERIA
ARMENIA Aram TUNYAN 0037410593144 Head of Safety Department Fax: 0037410289086 ARMATS E-mail: [email protected] CJSC I. GASPARYAN 33 Yerevan 0042 ARMENIA
Artur GASPARYAN +374 10 28 70 02 ATS Director Fax: +374 10 28 70 02 ARMATS CJSC, I. Gasparian 33 E-mail: [email protected] Yerevan 0042 ARMENIA
AUSTRALIA Ian MALLETT +61262171736 AUSTRALIA Fax: +61262171500 E-mail: [email protected]
AUSTRIA Florian BUCHMANN +43517032021 Department Air Traffic Management (ATM) Fax: +43517032006 Schnirchgasse 11 E-mail: 1030 Vienna [email protected] AUSTRIA
AZERBAIJAN Emil RAHIMOV +994124971673 ATS Expert Fax: +994124971604 Azeraeronavigation ATM Department E-mail: [email protected] AZ-1044 Baku Airport Heydar Aliyev AZERBAIJAN
Ramiz BASHIROV +994124971679 AZERAERONAVIGATION Fax: +994124972733 Heydar Aliev Intl Airport E-mail: [email protected] 370109 Baku AZERBAIJAN
Peyman MUKHTAROV +994124971679 Azeraeronavigation ATM Department Fax: +994124972733 370109 Baku Airport Heydar Aliyev E-mail: [email protected] AZERBAIJAN
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-2 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Rovshan SULTANOV +994 12 497 2782 p602 ATM Expert Fax: +994 12 497 1604 "Azeraeronavigation" Air Traffic Department E-mail: [email protected] Heydar Aliyev International Airport AZ 1044 Baku AZERBAIJAN
BELGIUM Pierre SOHIER +32 2 277 43 22 CNN-2nd floor Fax: +32 2 227 4282 Vooruitgang, 80 E-mail: [email protected] B-1030 Brussels BELGIUM
Roland MOINEAU +32(0)22774337 (direct) Adviser Fax: +32(0)22774282 Civil Aviation Authority E-mail: Airspace and Airports Directorate [email protected] CCN – 2nd floor rue du Progrès 80 bte 5 B-1030 BRUSSELS BELGIUM
DENMARK Tom ANDERSEN +4536186356 Luftfartsinspektor Trafikstyrelsen Fax: +4536186001 Danish Transport Authority E-mail: [email protected] Ellebjergvej 50 DK-2450 Kobenhavn SV Denmark DENMARK
FINLAND Mika SAALASTI +358 20 618 6108 Senior Inspector Fax: +358 20 618 6293 Transport Safety Agency, TraFi (Caa E-mail: [email protected] Finland) PL 320 00101 Helsinki FINLAND
FRANCE Cedric TEDESCO 01 58 09 35 14 DGAC/DTA/MCUR E-mail: cedric.tedesco@aviation- Bureau Réglementation de la Navigation civile.gouv.fr Aérienne et de l'espace aérien Division Procédures et Equipements FRANCE
Corinne BOUSQUET +33562145901 DGAC/DSNA/DTI Fax: +33562145401 FRANCE E-mail: corinne.bousquet@aviation- civile.gouv.fr
Bertrand FOUCHER +33562174701 Ecole Nationale de l'Aviation Civile (ENAC) E-mail: [email protected] Avenue Edouard Belin 31055 Toulouse cedex 4 FRANCE
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-3 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
François GREMY E-mail: francois.gremy@aviation- DSNA Operations civile.gouv.fr FRANCE
Antoine HERVE 0158093525 DGAC / DSAC / NO E-mail: antoine.herve@aviation- FRANCE civile.gouv.fr
Alexa HOURCLATS +33562245633 Société EGIS AVIA E-mail: [email protected] FRANCE
Philippe NOTRY +335 62 17 47 02 Département Circulation Aérienne E-mail: [email protected] Ecole Nationale de l'Aviation Civile (ENAC) Avenue Edouard Belin 31055 Toulouse cedex 4 FRANCE
Benoit ROTURIER +33562145851 DGAC/DSNA Fax: +33562145210 FRANCE E-mail: benoit.roturier@aviation- civile.gouv.fr
GEORGIA Oleg KENKISHVILI +995322744222 Flight Supervisor Fax: +995322744329 Sakaeronavigatsia Ltd E-mail: [email protected] Airport 00158 Tbilsi GEORGIA
Vladimir JERENASHVILI +995577114427 Sakaeronavigatsia Ltd Fax: +99532744227 Airport, E-mail: [email protected] 0158 Tbilisi GEORGIA
GERMANY Torsten JACOB + 49 6103 707 4143 DFS Deutsche Flugsicherung - German Air E-mail: [email protected] Navigation Services VE/I, International Affairs B-1040 GERMANY
Andre BIESTMANN E-mail: [email protected] GERMANY
Roland KALUZA +49061037071239 Am DFS Campus 10 63225 Langen Fax: +49061037071295 GERMANY E-mail: [email protected]
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-4 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Andreas MEYER +4961038043221 Bundesaufsichtsamt Für flugsicherung Fax: +4961038043250 Robert-Bosch-Strabe 28 E-mail: [email protected] 63225 Langen GERMANY
IRELAND Donal LAMONT +35316031483 Irish Aviation Authority E-mail: [email protected] The Times Building 11-12 D'Olier Street Dublin 2 IRELAND
Dermot MCMAHON +35316031531 Operations Directorate E-mail: [email protected] The Times Building 11-12 D'Olier Street Dublin 2 IRELAND
James O'SULLIVAN +353879183260 Irish Aviation Authority Fax: +353 61 474302 Control Tower E-mail: [email protected] Shannon Airport, Co Clare IRELAND
ISRAEL Joseph ZAYIT E-mail: [email protected] ISRAEL
Mor ESHEL +97239774666 ISRAEL Fax: +97239774599 E-mail: [email protected]
ITALY Stefano FELICI E-mail: [email protected] ITALY
Angelo CERASARI +390681662127 ENAV Spa Via Salaria, E-mail: [email protected] 716 – 00138 Rome ITALY
Alessandro GHILARI +39 06 81662143 ENAV S.p.A. – International Activities Fax: +39 06 81662389 Via Salaria 716 – 00138 Roma E-mail: [email protected] ITALY
Vasco LOCCI +39 06 44 596 771 Officer of Air Navigation Regulation E-mail: [email protected] Department ENAC - Italian Civil Aviation Authority ITALY
Carmelo LOPIS +39 06 44 59 68 04 Officer of Airspace Regulation Division Fax: +39 06 44 59 66 28 ENAC - Italian Civil Aviation Authority E-mail: [email protected] ITALY
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-5 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Paolo MEZZACAPO +390681662977 Via Salaria E-mail: [email protected] 716 - 00138 Roma ITALY
Leonardo NICOLO +390681662387 Enav SpA E-mail: [email protected] Via Salaria, 716 00138 Roma ITALY
Carmela TRIPALDI +393204781160 ENAC E-mail: [email protected] Head of Air Navigation Regulation Department ITALY
KAZAKHSTAN Pavel KOZLENKO +77172704219 Kazaeronavigatsia Fax: +77172773566 Astana E-mail: [email protected] KAZAKHSTAN
LATVIA Andrejs DUDAREVS +37167830954 CAA Senior Inspector Fax: +37167830967 Civil Aviation Agendy of Latvia E-mail: Airoprt Riga 1011 [email protected] LV-1003 Marupes Pagasts LATVIA
Érika NEIMANE +37167830953 Head of the ATM Section, ANS Division Fax: +37167830967 Latvian Civil Aviation Agency E-mail: [email protected] Airport "Riga" 10/1 LV-1003 Mārupes Pagasts LATVIA
Vadim TUMARKIN +371 67 300661 LGS AIS Fax: +371 67 300660 Int'l Airport Riga E-mail: [email protected] LV-1053 RIGA LATVIA
LESOTHO Senooe MOHAPI +26622312499 LESOTHO Fax: +26622310188 E-mail: [email protected]
LITHUANIA Margarita PAULAUSKIENE +37052739247 Head of Air Navigation Services Division Fax: +37052739248 Civil Aviation Administration E-mail: [email protected] Rodunios Kelias 2 LT-02188 Vilnius LITHUANIA
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-6 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Oleg SKIBICKIJ +37052 73 91 29 Head of ATM Division Fax: +370 8679 753 State Enterprise "Oro Navigacija" E-mail: [email protected] Rodunios Kelias 2 2023 Vilnius Airport LITHUANIA
MONTENEGRO Aleksandar DJORDJEVIC +382 77 272 323 Montenegro Civil Aviation Agency Fax: +382 20 625 517 Bul. Oslobodjenja 130 E-mail: [email protected] 81000 Podgorica MONTENEGRO
MOROCCO Abdellah SAKHI +212660100041 Head of Norms and Procedures Design E-mail: [email protected] Service Av Maa El Aynaine Agdal B.P. 1073 R.P. Rabat MOROCCO
NETHERLANDS Bart BANNING +31 20 406 2154 LVNL Fax: +31 20 406 2326 Air Traffic Control E-mail: [email protected] P.O Box 75200 NL-1117ZT Schiphol Airport NETHERLANDS
NORWAY Arne HEGGE +4791585545 Civil Aviation Authority Fax: +4775585005 P.O Box 243 E-mail: [email protected] NO-8001 BODǾ NORWAY
Arne LINDBERG +4798261801 NORWAY Fax: +4775585005 E-mail: [email protected]
POLAND Andrzej KROL +48 22 574 5764/5617 Head of IFP Design Unit E-mail: [email protected] Polish Air Navigation Services Agency POLAND
Karol KAZMIERCZAK +48 22 520 7225 Head of CNS Inspectorate Fax: +48 22 520 7226 Air Navigation Department E-mail: [email protected] Civil Aviation Office 02-0247 Warsaw POLAND
ROMANIA Viorel SALISTEAN +40212083339 CNS Expert E-mail: [email protected] ROMATSA Romanian Air Traffic Services Administration 10 Ion Ionescu de la Brad blvd. 1-Bucharest 013813 ROMANIA
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-7 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Mihai NECULA 4021 208 1528 Head of Navigation and AIS Dept. Fax: 4021 208 1564 Romanian CAA E-mail: [email protected] Sos. Bucuresti- Ploiesti No. 38-40 cod 013695 Bucuresti ROMANIA
Dan NICU +40212083226 Head of Terminal Operations Fax: +40212310789 Management Unit E-mail: [email protected] 10 Ion Ionescu de la Brad blvd. 013813 Bucharest ROMANIA
Valentin STOIAN +40 21 208 1515 Aeronautical Insptector Supervision E-mail: [email protected] Air Navigation Services Surveillance Department ANS Supervision Directorate Romanian Civil Aeronautical Authority ROMANIA
RUSSIAN Elmar ALEKSANDROV +78123051732 FEDERATION RUSSIAN FEDERATION E-mail: [email protected]
Vitaliy AMRAMTSOV +7 (863) 272.3986 Rostov-on-Don Fax: NA RUSSIAN FEDERATION E-mail: [email protected]
Mikhail DANILIN +74 95 601 0804 State ATM Corporation Fax: +74 95 601 0795 37/7 Leningradskiy prospekt E-mail: [email protected] 125993 Moscow RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Alexander LOSEV +89031707926 RUSSIAN FEDERATION E-mail: [email protected]
Vasily TOPCHIEV +7 4992316302 Senior Adviser, Fax: +7 4992315879 Department of International Relations, E-mail: [email protected] Federal Air Transport Agency (FATA), Ministry of Transport of the Russian Federation Leningradsky Prospekt, 37 125993 MOSCOW RUSSIAN FEDERATION
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-8 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Pavel ZUBKOV +78632723121 Deputy Director of ATM Branch "South Air Fax: +78632723102 Navigation" E-mail: [email protected] State ATM Corporation 344009 Rostov on Don, ave. Sholokhova 302 RUSSIAN FEDERATION
SAUDI ARABIA Abdalla A. AL-TURKOSTANI +02671 7717/1823 Air Traffic Management Fax: +671 9041 Planning & Operations E-mail: [email protected] P.O. Box 15441 Jeddah 21444 SAUDI ARABIA
Yahia ABDULHAMEED K +671 7717 SAUDI ARABIA Fax: +671 9041 E-mail: [email protected]
Muhammad AL JUHANI DA +671 7717 SAUDI ARABIA Fax: +671 9041 E-mail: [email protected]
Ghorman A AL SHEHRI +671 7717 SAUDI ARABIA Fax: +671 9041 E-mail: [email protected]
Ali AL-HAKAMI E-mail: [email protected] SAUDI ARABIA
Ibraheem AL-MAKRAN +671 7717 SAUDI ARABIA Fax: +671 9041 E-mail: [email protected]
Khalid AL-MATRAFI E-mail: [email protected] SAUDI ARABIA
Abdulaziz AL-MOHAMMED +96626717717 SAUDI ARABIA Fax: +96626717717 E-mail: [email protected]
SERBIA Zarko KATANCEVIC +38 111 292 7054 Civil Aviation Department of Republic of Fax: +38 111 292 7120 Serbia E-mail: [email protected] Bulevar Zorana Djindjica 144 Belgrade SERBIA
Gordana BORISAVLJEVIC +381 11 31 31 578 Civil Aviation Directorate of the republic of Fax: +381 11 311 7562 Serbia E-mail: [email protected] Omladinskih brigada 1 11070 New Belgrade SERBIA
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-9 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
SPAIN Miguez-Angel SANCHEZ E-mail: Miguel-Angel.sanchez@essp- ATC Center Madrid sas.eu Carretera de la Base Km 0.8 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz Madrid SPAIN
Aitor ALVAREZ RODRIGUEZ +34913210176 Head of the Area Satellite Navigation E-mail: [email protected] Division SPAIN
Javier Francisco CAMARA +34913214872 AENA E-mail: [email protected] Juan Ignacio Luca de Tena, 14 20827 Madrid SPAIN
Francisco-Javier DE BLAS +34916278893 ATC Center Madrid Fax: +34916278896 Carretera de la Base Km 0.8 E-mail: francisco-javier.deblas@essp- 28850 Torrejon de Ardoz sas.eu Madrid SPAIN
Daniel GARCIA-MONTEAVARO +34913215444 VIZCAINO Fax: +34913213212 Departamento de Radioayudas de E-mail: [email protected] Navegacion Aerea Division de Navegacion y Vigilancia Aeropuertos Espanoles y Navegacion Aerea C/ Josefa Valcarcel, 30 Despacho 5.07 E-28027 Madrid SPAIN
Javier MARTINEZ 34913213404 AENA Fax: 34913213119 Head of Concepts and Requirements Div E-mail: [email protected] ision Strategy and Plans Unit c/Juan Ignacio Luca de Tena, 14 28027 MADRID SPAIN
Juan David Nieto SEPULVEDA +34913968356 Directorate for Airports and Air Navigation E-mail: [email protected] Safety AESA (Spanish Air Safety Agency) Avenida General Peron 40 4e planta - 4B5A 28020 Madrid SPAIN
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-10 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
SWEDEN Ann-Christine SPORRONG +46 10 495 3713 Civil Aviation Authority E-mail: ann- SE-60173 Norrköping christine.sporrong@transportstyrelsen. SWEDEN se
SWITZERLAND Peter IMHOF +41313233513 Project Manager CNS Infrastructure Fax: +41313258060 Federal Office of Civil Aviation FOCA E-mail: [email protected] CH-3003 Berne SWITZERLAND
Thomas BUCHANAN +41 22 417 44 27 Head of International Affairs and Corporate Fax: +41 22 417 4582 Strategy E-mail: Skyguide [email protected] P.O Box 796 Route de Prébois 15-17 CH- 1215 Geneva 15 SWITZERLAND
Laurent DELETRAZ +4122 417 4423 SKYGUIDE Fax: +4122 417 4502 15-17 route de Pré-Bois E-mail: [email protected] CH-1215 Geneva 15 SWITZERLAND
Cécile DU MESGNIL +41224174429 Skyguide, Route de Prébois 15-17 1215 E-mail: [email protected] Genève 15 SWITZERLAND
Laure Noëlle FINK E-mail: Federal Office of Civil Aviation [email protected] 3003 Bern SWITZERLAND
Marc TROLLER Dr +41439316653 Skyguide E-mail: [email protected] Flugsicherungsstrasse 1-5 8602 Wangen b. Dübendorf SWITZERLAND
THE FORMER Sasho ANDONOV +389 2 313 9365 YUGOSLAV Civil Aviation Agency Fax: +389 23 115 708 REPUBLIC OF Dame Gruev 1 E-mail: [email protected] MACEDONIA 1000 SKOPJE THE FORMER YUGOSLAV REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA
TUNISIA Radhouan AISSAOUI +216 71 754 000 Ext 3.4813 Filght Procedure Designer - ANSP Fax: +216 70 729 201 Chef de Service des Etudes E-mail: [email protected] de la Circulation Aérienne TUNISIA
Omar ABDELKADER +21624240896 Flight Procedure Designer ANSP E-mail: [email protected] TUNISIA
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-11 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Noureddine BORJI +21671755000 Airspace Designer - ANSP Fax: +21670729201 TUNISIA E-mail: [email protected]
Nejib BOUCHRIHA E-mail: TUNISIA [email protected]
Helmi CHABCHOUB +216 71 942 322 Flight Engineer E-mail: Flight Operations [email protected] Tunisair TUNISIA
Nizar ELMRABTI +21624086205 Office de l'Aviation Civile et des Aéroports Fax: +21670729201 TUNISIA E-mail: [email protected]
Chahine SOMRANI +21671806522 Ingenieur Principal Fax: +21671806469 Direction Générale de l'Aviation Civile E-mail: [email protected] Ministère du Transport Aéroport International de Tunis-Carthage TUNISIA
TURKEY Murat CANPOLAT +90 312 204 2505 General Directorate of State Airports Fax: +90 312 222 0976 Authority E-mail: [email protected] DHMI (Air Traffic Control) Konya Yollu 06330 ETILER/ANKARA TURKEY
Sitki Kagan ERTAS +90 312 204 2592 Air Traffic Controller, General Directorate of Fax: +90 312 222 09 76 State Airports Authority(DHMI) E-mail: [email protected] Air Traffic Controller Konya Yolu 06330 ETILER/ANKARA TURKEY
Uğur ÖZDEMİR +90 312 2042542 ATCO Fax: +90 312 2220976 DHMI E-mail: [email protected] Genel Müdürlüğü Konya Yolu Üzeri 06330 Etiler Ankara TURKEY
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-12 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Cihan SAHIN +903122042501 Air Traffic Controller Fax: +903122220976 DHMI Genel Müdürlügü E-mail: [email protected] Konya Üzeri 06330 Etiler / Ankara TURKEY
UKRAINE Anastasiia SOBCHENKO +380 44 351 8091 Chief Expert of ATM/CNS Division E-mail: [email protected] State Aviation Administration of Ukraine UKRAINE
Dmytro BABEYCHUK +380443518044 Director Fax: +380443518372 Air Navigation and External Relations E-mail: [email protected] State Aviation Administration of Ukraine Peremogy Ave, 14 01135 Kyiv UKRAINE
Oleksandr GRECHKO +380443515445 State Aviation Administration Fax: +380442262494 Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure of E-mail: [email protected] Ukraine 14, Peremogy Avenue 01135 Kyiv UKRAINE
Pavel KOZHEVNIKOV +380 44 351 5725 Uksatse Fax: +380 44 246 2196 Airport E-mail: [email protected] Boryspil, Kyiv region 08307 UKRAINE
Pavlo KUD +380 44 351 5746 Ukrainian State Air Traffic Service Fax: +380 44 351 6394 Enterprise E-mail: [email protected] (UkSATSE) Airport Boryspil Kyiv Region 08307 UKRAINE
UNITED KINGDOM Geoffrey BURTENSHAW +44 207 453 6506 Directorate of Airspace Policy Fax: +44 207 453 6565 Civil Aviation Authority E-mail: [email protected] CAA House 45-49 Kingsway London WC2B 6TE UNITED KINGDOM
Alec MCLAREN +442087503794 NATS Services, Heathrow House, Bath E-mail: [email protected] Road, Cranford, Middlesex, TW5 9AT UNITED KINGDOM
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-13 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
UNITED STATES Kevin HAGGERTY +32 2 8115396 Federal Aviation Administration, Fax: +32 (2) 230 2597 Air Traffic Organization, Strategy and E-mail: [email protected] Performance International Office, Europe, Africa, Middle East Group FAA c/o American Embassy 27 Boulevard de Regent Brussels, BELGIUM UNITED STATES
Daniel VACA +1 202 385 8081 Air Traffic Organization, Strategy and Fax: + Performance E-mail: [email protected] Acting Manager, International Office Washington, D.C. UNITED STATES
AVIACONSULT Frank LUMNITZER +49 6085 988 3007 Director Fax: +49 6085 988 1656 Procedure design & aviation consulting E-mail: Ringstrasse 4 [email protected] 35647 Waldsolms GERMANY
CANSO Akos VAN DER PLAAT +31204063527 NETHERLANDS E-mail: [email protected]
Henrik EKSTRAND +4686738600 Ecology and Performance Manager E-mail: [email protected] Flight Operations Department Nova Airlines AB Kuoni Scandinavia Box 45439 SE-104 31 Stockholm SWEDEN
CEN Klaus-Dieter EHRHARDT +4961037074215 Aur Traffic Management E-mail: [email protected] DFS Deutsche Flugsicherung GmbH GERMANY
EASA Filippo TOMASELLO +49 221 89990 5040 EASA Fax: +49 221 89990 5540 Postfach 10 12 53 E-mail: DE-50452 KOLN or c/o EASA Ottoplatz 1 [email protected] 50676 Koln GERMANY
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-14 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Bryan JOLLY 49 221 89990 4134 EASA Fax: 49 221 89990 4634 Postfach 10 12 53 E-mail: [email protected] DE-50452 KOLN GERMANY
EUROCONTROL Rodolphe SALOMON E-mail: BELGIUM [email protected]
Richard FARNWORTH +33169887651 Eurocontrol E-mail: Centre du bois des Bordes [email protected] F-91222 Bretigny sur Orge FRANCE
Vojislav MILOSAVLJEVIC E-mail: Eurocontrol vojislav.milosavljevic.ext@eurocontrol Centre du bois des Bordes .int F-91222 Bretigny sur Orge BELGIUM
Sasho NESHEVSKI +3227293962 Directorate Single Sky Fax: +3227295190 Regulatory Support Division E-mail: Single European Sky (SES) Unit [email protected] 96 Rue de la Fusée 1130 Brussels BELGIUM
Lendina SMAJA +33 1 69 88 6923 Eurocontrol Fax: +33 1 6988 6923 Navigation and CNS Research E-mail: [email protected] Centre du Bois des Bordes BP 15 F-92222 Bretigny/Orge Cedex FRANCE
Aline TROADEC 33 1 69 88 72 74 Centre des Bois des Bordes BP 15 F-19222 Fax: 33 1 69 88 69 52 Bretigny/Orge Cédex E-mail: [email protected] FRANCE
IAC Sergey KONOGIN +84959537989 Head of Department Fax: +84959537989 Interstate Aviation Committee E-mail: [email protected] Commission for Flight Safety Programmes Harmonization and Coordination 22/2/1, Bolshaya Ordynka St., 119017 Moscow RUSSIAN FEDERATION
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-15 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
IATA Anthony VAN DER VELDT +3226261807 IATA Fax: +3226485135 Assistant Director Safety Operations and E-mail: [email protected] Infrastructure 350, Avenue Louise B-1050 Brussels BELGIUM
ICAO-HQ Erwin LASSOOIJ E-mail: [email protected] CANADA
JEPPESEN Thomas HESS +49 6102 508194 Jeppesen GmbH Fax: +49 6102 508 189 Frankfurter Strasse 233 E-mail: [email protected] 63263 Neu Isenburg GERMANY
Sorin-Dan ONITIU +496102508176 Jeppesen GmbH Fax: +496102507239 Frankfurter Strasse 233 E-mail: [email protected] 63263 Neu Isenburg GERMANY
Minerva VAZQUEZ-BARRIO +496102508128 Jeppesen GmbH Fax: +496102507239 Frankfurter Strasse 233 E-mail: Minerva.Vazquez- 63263 Neu Isenburg [email protected] GERMANY
LUFTHANSA Martin ZILLIG +41 44 828 5561 Head of NAV Data Standards Fax: +41 44 828 6599 SWITZERLAND E-mail: [email protected]
Josef ANSCHAU +496969695341 RNAV Operations & Navigation Fax: +49696967070 Deutsche Lufthansa AG E-mail: [email protected] FRA OZ/G-5 Lufthansa Basis D-60546 Frankfurt/Main GERMANY
Pieter-Bas OORTMAN +31612428814 Deutsche Lufthansa AG E-mail: [email protected] FRA OZ/G-5 Lufthansa Basis D-60546 Frankfurt/Main GERMANY
LUFTHANSA Stephen METTAUER E-mail: SYSTEMS Head of MINIMA [email protected] FLIGHTNAV INC SWITZERLAND
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
B-16 Appendix B to PBN TF/7-SoD
Juergen KUHNHENN +41448286546 Lido/Route Manual Standards E-mail: SWITZERLAND [email protected]
Jordan MEEK +41448281976 Lido/Rioute Manual Standards Fax: +41448286599 Lufthansa Systems Flight Nav Inc E-mail: [email protected] ZRH OD/R-D P.O. Box 202 SWITZERLAND
SESAR JOINT Andrea NEMEC +3225078005 UNDERTAKING SESAR Joint Undertaking E-mail: [email protected] AVenue de Cortenbergh 100 B-1000 Brussels BELGIUM
TRANSAERO Andrey SOROKIN E-mail: [email protected] AIRLINES RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Viacheslav CHISTOV +7 495 662 1560 Navigator of Transaero Airlines Fax: +7 495 661 0273 Flight Operations Department E-mail: [email protected] Bld, 47-1,Boldshaya Polyanka Street Moscow 119180 RUSSIAN FEDERATION
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
C-1 Appendix C PBN TF/7-SoD APPENDIX C Contact List
ICAO EUR PBN TF/7 (Paris, 2 to 3 July 2012)
European and North STATUS OF DOCUMENTATION Atlantic Office List of working papers
WP Presented Title by
1 Agenda Secretariat Guidance material for the implementation of RNP APCH 2 Eurocontrol Operations (Updated after PBN TF 06) 3 ESSIP report for 2011 Eurocontrol
List of information papers IP Presented Title by PFA Reg Supplementary Procedures EUR Region Doc 1 Secretariat 7030/5 EUR/NAT-S 11/06-EUR 2 ICAO Update Secretariat Invitation PBN Symposium, Montreal, Canada, 16-19 October 3 Secretariat 2012 Invitation 12th Air Navigation Conference, Montreal, Canada, 4 Secretariat 19-30 November 2012 5 SL on IFSET Secretariat 12th Air Navigation Conference, Montreal, Canada, 19-30 6 Secretariat November 2012 Guidance for the provision of NAV/COM/SUR information in 7 Eurocontrol the New ICAO 2012 Flight Plan 8 PBN Tasks in draft RMP 2013-2016 EASA 9 PBN Implementation Plan Italy PPT Presented Title by
01 ATC Key enablers for PBN implementation France 2 Status of PBN Implementation on EAU Secretariat 3 PBN Study Group – Final meeting PBN Manual Status United Kingdom 4 PBN ICAO HQ Activities Overview Secretariat UK Performance-based Navigation (PBN) Implementation 5 United Kingdom Status 6 CANSO Vision & Strategy on PBN Implementation CANSO 7 ICAO Fuel Estimation Savings Tool (IFSET) CANSO 8 Rev PBN Implementation plan inside Italian Airspace Italy
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012 C-2 Appendix C PBN TF/7-SoD
APPENDIX C Contact List
9 France PBN Implementation Status France
A CO2 versus noise trade-off study for the evaluation of ATM 10 speed constraints in the departure phase of flight - A case Canso study at Gothenburg Landvetter Airport 11 RNP AR Operation in Sweden Canso 12 PBN Planning and Implementation Ukraine 13 EGNOS Service Provision Status Spain 14 PBN Implementation project at Greek (Island) airports IATA
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012
D-1 Appendix D PBN TF/7-SoD
APPENDIX D Agenda
ICAO EUR PBN TF/7 (Paris, France, 2-3 July 2012) 02/07/2012 13:30 Registration 14:00 Introduction 14:15 Latest developments - ICAO – E.Nahmadov IP01 IP02, IP03, Ip04, IP05, IP06 ICAO global update ppt -Geoff - EC - Sasho –PBN IR - EASA – Filippo Aline IP07 IFSET CANSO/ICAO Akos/Sven 15:15 Coffee 15:45 Status of PBN implementation. ICAO/Eurocontrol ICAO ANP Tables and LSSIP updates Ppt02 - Elkhan WP03 Rick 16:15 National PBN Plan Italy Leonardo 16:30 EUR inputs for the ICAO PBN Symposium Aline/Rick 17:00 End of the day 03/07/2012 09:30 New revision of the PBN Manual - A-RNP Geoff - RNP2 - RNP0.3 10:30 Coffee 11:00 CANSO approach to PBN CANSO Akos 12:00 Lunch 13:00 A CO2 versus noise trade-off study for CANSO Henrik the evaluation of air traffic management speed constraints in the departure phase of flight" 13:30 RNP APCH guidance material WP02 Rick 14:00 EGNOS ESSP SAS -Spain 14:30 RNP AR APCH Henrik 15:00 IATA– project in Greece. A.Van der Veldt
15:15 Coffee 15:45 National PBN planning & implementation Ukraine Pavel Kud status France – Bernard ppt01 United Kingdom - Geoff etc AOB 17:00 Closure
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012 E-1 Appendix E PBN TF/7-SoD
APPENDIX E – FOLLOW UP ACTION LIST
ID # TASK ID WHO WHEN
7-1 Continue monitoring the status of PBN information from the responses to Table CNS4b Secretary PBN TF/8 and Eurocontrol LSSIP. Eurocontrol 7-2 Provide updates on equipage plans collected by IATA and Eurocontrol IATA/Eurocontrol PBN TF/8 7-3 Submit the EUR PBN approaches guidance material for the endorsement of the EANPG ICAO PBN TF/8 7-4 Provide comments on the EU PBN IR consultation package PBN TF PBN TF/8 7-5 Provide updates on the regulatory issues in the framework of EASA EASA PBN TF/8 7-6 Provide information on the outcomes of the ICAO PBN Go Team projects in the Russian ICAO PBN TF/8 Federation and the Southern Caucasus States 7-8 Provide reports using IFSET on fuel savings and CO2 reduction resulting from PBN PBN TF PBN TF/8 implementations 7-10 Coordinate an EUR PBN TF presentation for the ICAO PBN Symposium Chairman PBN TF/8
-END-
SoD PBN TF7 final.docx July 2012