Outcome Bias and Football 1 Running Head

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Outcome Bias and Football 1 Running Head Outcome bias and Football 1 Running head: OUTCOME BIAS AND FOOTBALL Outcome Bias in Subjective Ratings of Performance: Evidence from the (Football) Field Edgar E. Kausel School of Management Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile Av.Vicuña Mackenna 4860 Macul, Santiago, Chile. Phone: (56-2) 235-44018 [email protected] Santiago Ventura School of Management Pontificia Universidad Católica de Chile Av.Vicuña Mackenna 4860 Macul, Santiago, Chile. Phone: (56-2) 235-47303 [email protected] Arturo Rodríguez Faculty of Economics and Business University of Chile Diagonal Paraguay 257 Santiago, Chile 6510015 Phone: (56-2) 978-3770 Fax: (56-2) 222-0639 [email protected] Outcome bias and Football 2 Abstract The outcome bias occurs when people assess others’ decision making process or performance and put an unwarranted weight to their outcomes. This bias has important implications for the judgment and choice as well as the performance appraisal literatures. However, virtually every extant study has been conducted in the lab, likely due to endogeneity concerns in field. Penalty shoot-outs in association football (‘soccer’) offer an interesting way of studying outcome bias, as recent research suggests that their outcome is unrelated to in-game performance. We use Goal (goal.com) to study subjective performance ratings by reporters given to 1,157 players in 43 games from important football competitions. Using both multilevel mixed-effects and fixed-effects (within- players design) modeling, we found that winning on penalties was linked to higher performance ratings. This result persisted even after we removed players who took part in the penalty shoot-outs; thus, supporting the idea of outcome bias. We discuss implications for applied settings. Keywords: Judgment and Decision Making; Behavioral Economics; Heuristics and Biases; Outcome Bias; Football (Soccer); Performance Appraisal. Outcome bias and Football 3 Outcome Bias in Subjective Ratings of Performance: Evidence from the (Football) Field This is the lottery of penalty shootouts (Franz Beckenbauer during the 1990 World Cup; Vecsey, 1990) For me, the national team is over (Lionel Messi’s reaction after losing in penalty shootouts the Copa América final against Chile; Das, 2016) Some people use a similar argument to amplify a behavior after a win and to condemn the same behavior after a defeat. For example, if Neymar recovers a ball and then the team scores, journalists say: ‘Ah, the coach tamed Neymar and made him play collectively.’ But if the team loses, they say: ‘Useless coach, how can he make Neymar chase the wing-back instead of making him play close to the penalty box!’ The media specializes in corrupting human beings depending on a win or a loss. (Coach Marcelo “El Loco” Bielsa; El Dinamo, 2017) 1. Introduction From a normative perspective, we should distinguish the decision making process from its consequences (Skitka & Tetlock, 1993; Hastie & Dawes, 2009). Given that real decisions are made in an uncertain world, an appropriate decision process may lead to poor results—or a poor decision process may lead to positive outcomes (Baron, 1985; Bazerman & Moore, 2013; Brockner, 2015). For example, even if a well-intended physician follows a procedure flawlessly and exercises sound judgment, the operation may lead to patient death. More generally, we should be able to differentiate behavior from outcomes. This is consistent with Kahneman’s (2011) observation that “because luck plays a large role, the quality of leadership and management practices cannot be inferred reliably from observations of success” (p. 207). Indeed, the behavior vs. outcome issue is important in performance assessment within the industrial-organizational and educational psychology literatures. The aim in Outcome bias and Football 4 performance appraisal is to judge an individual's behavior, not factors beyond his or her control (Cascio & Aguinis, 2010). This is one of the reasons many managers and school principals often tend to put emphasis on subjective ratings to assess employees or teachers, as opposed (or in addition) to so-called ‘objective measures’ (Murphy & Cleveland, 1995). Although objective measures can tap job performance, they are more often indicators of outcomes—likely to be affected by external factors. For example, an objective measure of scholar performance is number of papers published. However, this outcome is affected by external factors such as the journal editors’ attitude toward the scholar’s specific field of study. Thus, researchers agree that subjective ratings are more likely to tap job performance1 than objective measures are (Landy & Conte, 2004). In particular, subjective ratings are said to cover psychologically relevant aspects of job performance given the context and task at hand (Campbell, 2012; Landy & Farr, 1983). Also, subjective ratings can capture different dimensions of job performance, such as task performance, contextual performance, and counterproductive behavior (Rotundo & Sackett, 2002). A relevant issue regarding subjective ratings is, however, the potential influence of outcome bias (Savani & King, 2015; Gino, Moore, & Bazerman, 2009). Outcome bias occurs when outcome knowledge affects the evaluation of how well an individual made a decision or performed a task (Baron & Hershey, 1988; Johnston & Marshall, 2016). For example, Baron and Hershey showed two groups of participants the same description of a medical decision making process but different outcomes. People who were told that the 1 We should underscore that performance is defined as behavior—something done by an individual (Campbell, Mcenry, & Wise 1990). Outcome bias and Football 5 outcome was positive perceived the decision making process as more favorable than those told that the outcome was negative. Yet, although there are several published studies showing evidence of outcome bias using subjective ratings in the laboratory, where outcome information can be randomized, there are virtually no studies in field settings (cf. Lefren, Platt, & Price, 20142). This is unfortunate because, as the authors of a seminal paper on outcome bias recognized, the “difficulty with the method we used is that it is restricted to somewhat artificial situations” (Hershey & Baron, 1992, p. 91). The reason for a lack of field studies on outcome bias is that, in the field, an individual’s performance is correlated with his or her outcomes (Bommer, Johnson, Rich, Podsakoff, & Mackenzie, 1995; Ilgen & Favero, 1985). As such, it is difficult to distinguish whether correspondence between subjective ratings and outcomes is the result of a biased assessment by the rater or actual performance by the ratee. In other words, there is a problem of endogeneity, whereby an individual’s performance may have an effect on both subjective ratings and outcomes. 2. Penalty shoot-outs and performance in the field Association football (‘soccer’) gives us an interesting setting to examine outcome bias in subjective performance ratings. In some competitions, after the game ends in a draw, the teams proceed to penalty shoot-outs to determine the winner. Many coaches and 2 Lefren et al. is a notable exception. Using American Football games, they found that coaches were more likely to change their team strategy after a close loss than after a close win. Although impressive in terms of the data used, this result could be explained by action bias rather than outcome bias (Bar-Eli, Azar, Ritov, Keidar-Levin, & Schein, 2007). After losing, coaches tend to take action because this ‘looks better’ and thus is more justifiable (Connolly & Zeelenberg, 2002). Relatedly, the study by Leftren et al. does not directly include subjective performance ratings, which is the focus of our study. Outcome bias and Football 6 journalists believe that chance plays a crucial role in the outcome of penalty shoot-outs, as reflected by Franz Beckenbauer’s quote at the outset of the present paper.3 This belief seems to be supported by data. Nate Silver—from the popular Five Thirty-Eight website—examined 37 official games from 2005 to 2013 played in the knockout stages of different continental championships among men’s national teams (Silver, 2014). For each game, he classified teams as favorites and underdogs by using the teams’ ELO ranking, a measure of team skill that has relatively strong predicting power in forecasting football outcomes (Lasek, Szlávik, and Bhulai, 2013). Silver found that favorites and underdogs had roughly equal chance to win the game on the penalty shoot- outs. We used Silver’s data and also found no significant differences in ELO rating between teams that won (M = 1,803; SD = 172) and teams that lost (M = 1,800; SD = 153) on penalty shoot-outs (t [36] = .12, p = .91). A different study with much more data at the individual level is consistent with this finding. The Economist’s Data Team (2017) analyzed 2,788 penalty kicks awarded in three European leagues between 2007 and 2016. They found no statistically significant relationship between a player’s past conversion rate and his future success (Data Team, 2017). In sum, the outcome of a penalty shoot-out (i.e. who wins and who loses) seems to be unrelated to in-game skill and performance at both the team- and player- levels of analysis. We provide more evidence regarding this issue in our results section. Note that we are not claiming that, in games defined by penalty shoot-outs, the teams’ in-game performances are equal. Indeed, we report below some evidence 3 We included two other quotes to reflect (a) how people in football are intuitively aware of the outcome bias and its problems (Marcelo Bielsa’s quote) and (b) how dramatic can an outcome of a penalty shootout be. Messi’s quote reflects this, as right after Argentina lost that game on penalties, Messi announced his retirement from the national team. Outcome bias and Football 7 suggesting that the there are some systematic differences in performance between teams in these games (i.e., favorites tend to have better performance than underdogs). What we are claiming is that, whichever the differences between two teams in this type of games are, these are unrelated to the penalty shoot-out outcome.
Recommended publications
  • ANNUAL REPORT 2015 Refer to Page 143 on How to Use This Interactive Image
    ANNUAL REPORT 2015 VISION The SABC inspires change through enriching, credible, relevant and compelling content that is accessible by all. MISSION To educate, inform and entertain all audiences accessing SABC services. VALUES Conversations and Partnerships Restoration of Human Dignity Building a Common Future This is the 78th Annual Report of the South African Broadcasting Corporation (SOC) Limited, referred to as ‘SABC’, ‘the Corporation’ or ‘the Company’ (Registration Number: 2003/023915/30). It is tabled in Parliament in terms of the Broadcasting Act, No 4 of 1999, as amended, and the Public Finance Man- agement Act, No 1 of 1999, as amend- ed. REGISTERED OFFICE ADDRESS: Radio Park, Henley Road, Auckland Park, Gauteng, 2006 CONTENTS | POSTAL ADDRESS: Private Bag X1, Auckland Park, Johannesburg, Gauteng, 2006 CONTACT TELEPHONE NUMBERS: South African Broadcasting Corporation [SOC] Ltd Tel: +27 11 714 9111 Fax: +27 11 714 3219 EMAIL-ADDRESS: [email protected] WEBSITE ADDRESS: Visit the SABC: www.sabc.co.za EXTERNAL AUDITORS INFORMATION: Auditor-General SA, Refer to page 143 on how to use this interactive image. Lefika House, 300 Middel Street, Brooklyn, Pretoria, 0001 BANKERS INFORMATION: ABSA Limited | SABC Annual Report 2014 | 2015 ABSA Towers East, 3rd Floor, 170 Main Street, Johannesburg COMPANY SECRETARY Ms Theresa Geldenhuys Group Company Secretary Tel: +27 (11) 714 3910, Fax: +27 (11) 714 3219, Mobile +27 83 679 9585 Private Bag X1, Auckland Park, 2006, Gauteng, South Africa E-mail: [email protected] ANNUAL REPORT CONTENTS
    [Show full text]
  • Africa Update
    ML Strategies Update David Leiter, [email protected] Georgette Spanjich, [email protected] Katherine Fox, [email protected] ML Strategies, LLC Sarah Mamula, [email protected] 701 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. Washington, DC 20004 USA 202 296 3622 202 434 7400 fax FOLLOW US ON TWITTER: @MLStrategies www.mlstrategies.com JANUARY 23, 2015 Africa Update Leading the News West Africa Ebola Outbreak On January 14th, the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) issued its 16th fact sheet on the Ebola outbreak in West Africa. The most recent fact sheet highlights that new Ebola cases continue to decrease in Liberia, and the number of confirmed cases has declined by 43 percent between December 22nd and January 5th in Sierra Leone, according to the United Nations (U.N.) World Health Organization (WHO). In addition, the fact sheet highlights how USAID partners have worked to open one Ebola treatment unit (ETU) and four community care centers (CCCs) in Sierra Leone. The latest fact sheet can be downloaded here. On January 15th, U.N. Special Envoy on Ebola Dr. David Nabarro said while the number of new Ebola cases in Liberia, Sierra Leone, and Guinea is declining, there are at least 50 micro-outbreaks in the three hardest hit countries. While Dr. Nabarro said it is good news that Liberia, Sierra Leone, and Guinea are now reporting the lowest weekly totals of new Ebola cases since this summer, he cautioned that the emergence of micro-outbreaks evidences there are still chains of transmission that need to be understood. He argued the key will be to continue efforts to get local communities to change their traditional healing rituals and funeral and burial practices.
    [Show full text]
  • P18 Layout 1
    WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 15, 2014 SPORTS Italy win over 10-man Malta Euro 2016 qualifiers TA’ QALI: Italy striker Graziano Pelle scored as Azerbaijan’s defence completely fell allowing a tame Nainggolan shot from 20 on his debut to earn a 1-0 away win over apart, he made it three with a fine header metres to trickle into the back of the net 10-man Malta with the visitors having hit from Danijel Pranjic’s cross. under his body. the woodwork four times in their Euro Two minutes into first half stoppage The Bosnians then gained the upper 2016 qualifier on Monday. time, Luka Modric’s brilliant pass set up hand and twice came close when Vincent The Southampton striker, one of four Marcelo Brozovic to make it four before Kompany cleared Pjanic’s shot off the line changes made by Antonio Conte after Modric himself converted a penalty after and Courtois kept out a Dzeko header with Friday’s laboured 2-1 home win over the break following a foul on Srna. an acrobatic save. Azerbaijan in Group H, struck from close An own goal by Rashad Sadygov com- range midway through the first half. pleted Azerbaijan’s misery just after the WALES 2 CYPRUS 1 Malta fought bravely, especially after hour mark, leaving Croatia to contemplate In Wales, Wales continued their unbeat- captain Michael Mifsud was dismissed in a much more meaningful encounter when en start to the Euro 2016 campaign as a the first half, while the Italians also finished they meet Italy, also unbeaten on nine nervy 2-1 triumph over Cyprus, after they with 10 men as Leonardo Bonucci was points, in Milan next month.
    [Show full text]
  • Rugby World Cup 2015 1 17 September 2015
    Rugby World Cup 2015 1 17 September 2015 A Date with Destiny Russell van Wyk breaks away for a try against Russia. Photo: Helge Schutz Compiled by: Helge Schütz & Johannes Aoxamub Photo: Yvonne Amukwaya Rugby World Cup A Publication of 2015 17 September 2015 2 Rugby World Cup 2015 Foreword by NRU President n behalf of the NRU board, I wish to skill, commitment, strength and endurance when congratulate all the players who have made they run out onto the field and take on our opponents it into our Rugby World Cup 2015 squad. during RWC 2015. OFor many of you it is indeed a dream come true and a I trust that you as players representing Namibia reward for all the effort and hard work that you have will be true ambassadors of our beautiful country and put in over the last couple of months. that you will show to the rest of the world that we as a Our road to qualification has certainly not been an nation are indeed a force to be reckoned with. easy one. During 2012 we found ourselves relegated Needless to mention that our participation in to the CAR 1 B division of the Africa Cup and we this prestigious tournament would not have been had to fight our way to the top again. But we did our possible was it not for the generosity of our sponsors country proud when we defeated Madagascar in 2015 Windhoek Draught, First National Bank of Namibia, in a match which many of us will remember for years Air Namibia, Auas Motors, Paratus Telecom and so to come.
    [Show full text]
  • 100 Most Influential Young Africans E-Brochure
    2016 100 MOST INFLUENTIAL YOUNG AFRICANS A Publication by AFRICA YOUTH AWARDS the Biggest AFrican Youth Awards Scheme which Recognises the Achievements of Young Africans, Young Change Makers on the Continent and Beyond www.africayouthawards.org About Us Africa Youth Awards is a prestigious award scheme with the prime aim of showing appreciation for the work of young Africans in Africa and the diaspora. Launched in 2014, the awards scheme was inspired by the lack of recognition for young Africans who have selflessly dedicated their lives to ensuring the future of Africa is optimistic. Youth movements are taking place all over the continent. Young people are becoming successful entrepreneurs, inventors, politicians, journalists, celebrities, educators, media personalities, advocates and role models. There is a precious need and business opportunity for Africa to reward these young achievers and leaders as they are the future of Africa. We must be able to award and appreciate these young people for their achievements, and as a result of this we believe that greater opportunities will be presented to them, which will enable them to continue what they have started and use their stories and experience to impact the lives of other young Africans across the world. We are confident that the Africa Youth Awards will continue to bring together these like minded young people who are passionate about the development and progress of Africa, and are making efforts wherever they are to see that Africa fulfils its promising potential. 100 Most Influential Young Africans When we opened nominations for Africa Youth Awards 2015, we immediately noticed stories submitted from across the world showed how Young Africans are rising to the occasion of leading and being part of the revolution sweeping across the continent.
    [Show full text]
  • Issued by the Britain-Tanzania Society No 109 Sept - Dec 2014
    Tanzanian Affairs Text 1 Issued by the Britain-Tanzania Society No 109 Sept - Dec 2014 World War I in East Africa “who cares about native carriers?” Mobile Money Constitutional Deadlock Ben Taylor: WORLD WAR I IN EAST AFRICA “WHO CARES ABOUT NATIVE CARRIERS?” Schutztruppe in German East Africa - German Federal Archive Bild 134-C0265 On 8 August 1914, the Royal Navy bombarded the German wireless relay station in Dar es Salaam. War had broken out in Europe just days earlier, and already it had come to East Africa. In the shadow of the horrors of western Europe, space in the popular memory for the East African theatre of the First World War is limited. Such room as there is tends to be dominated by Boys’ Own tales of derring-do, successes against the odds and heroic failures. The madcap British scheme to gain naval supremacy on Lake Tanganyika is Exhibit A. Two 40 foot motorboats, HMS Mimi and HMS Toutou, were shipped out to South Africa and transported 3,000 miles by land (including being dragged for 146 miles through the jungle of the Belgian Congo) to reach the lake. It should never have succeeded, and yet it did, capturing one German vessel and sinking another before forc- ing the Germans to scuttle their 220-foot flagship Graf von Götzen (now the MV Liemba). cover photo: Water Camp on Mikesse (near Morogoro) - Ruwu (near Kahe) road, December 1916. Imperial War Museum photo Q15412 World War I in East Africa 3 This inspired C.S. Forrester’s novel, The African Queen, a film of the same name starring Humphrey Bogart and Katherine Hepburn, and, more recently, Giles Foden’s book Mimi and Toutou Go Forth.
    [Show full text]
  • Germany Return to Top of FIFA's Rankings
    Sports FRIDAY, JULY 18 , 2014 Kenya eye CAN success after World Cup visit JOHANNESBURG: Watching World Cup matches in Brazil Angola and Gabon in a mini-league. the biennial tournament. Uganda were scheduled to play has convinced the football stars of Kenya they can qualify The six-match group phase kicks off in September, lasts Equatorial Guinea, but the central Africans were disquali- for the 2015 Africa Cup of Nations (CAN) in Morocco. A three months, and the top two finishers are guaranteed fied for fielding ineligible Cameroon-born Thierry Fidjeu. country famous for their athletes has not featured at the places at the tournament. Kenya hardly justified the opti- Mauritania, beaten 3-1 on aggregate by the continental football showpiece since making a first-round mism of Onyango this week when held 0-0 by Burundi in a Equatoguineans, were restored to the competition and vis- exit 10 years ago. Nairobi warm-up that turned nasty during the second half. it a Ugandan side battling to score. The ‘Cranes’ managed But ‘Harambee Stars’ goalkeeper Jeremy Onyango Harambee Stars midfielder Victor Wanyama from English just one against the Seychelles and played a goalless draw believes that is about to change as they prepare for a third- Premier League club Southampton was sent off for hack- with Malawi this week in a warm-up that concerned coach round eliminator in Lesotho this weekend. ing down an opponent. Lesotho had to substitute mid- Milutin Sredojevic. “An inability to score is a chronic prob- Onyango was among 16 players and four coaches who fielders Ralekoti Mokhahlane and Motlalepula Mofolo and lem in Uganda,” admitted the Serb.
    [Show full text]
  • 2014 ANNUAL PERFORMANCE REPORT Ii | Page
    2014 ANNUAL PERFORMANCE REPORT Contents FORWARD .................................................................................................................................. vi MESSAGE FROM THE HEAD OF CIVIL SERVICE ......................................................... viii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .......................................................................................................... x CHAPTER ONE ......................................................................................................................... 18 1.0 Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 18 1.2 The Civil Service Council ................................................................................................... 20 1.3 The Civil Service In 2014 ................................................................................................... 21 CHAPTER TWO ........................................................................................................................ 24 2.0 The 2014 Policy Framework ............................................................................................... 24 2.2 Highlights of The 2014 State Of The Nation Address By H.E. The President ................... 27 2.3 Highlights of The 2014 Budget Statement .......................................................................... 32 2.4 Global Economic Developments ........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Football for Health 20 Years of F-MARC Research and Education 1994 - 2014
    F-MARC - Football for Health 20 years of F-MARC Research and Education 1994 - 2014 Editors: )HŔ´#UNŔ¨J Astrid Junge TABLE OF CONTENTS | FOOTBALL MEDICINE PROJECTS Table of Contents Preface 1 Executive Summary 2 2 Epidemiology of Football Injury 4 2.1 Review of Literature 4 2.1.1 Football Injuries before 2000 4 2.1.2 Football Injuries in Children and Adolescent Players 6 2.2 Definitions of Injuries and Assessment Methods 8 2.2.1 Influence of Definition and Data Collection on Injury Incidence 8 2.2.2 Consensus on the Injury Definition and Data Collection Procedures 10 2.2.3 Injury Surveillance in Multi-Sport Events 12 2.3 Injuries during the Football Season 14 2.3.1 Injuries of Male Players of Different Age and Skill Level 14 2.3.2 Severe Injuries of Male Players 16 2.3.3 Injuries of Female Players of the German National League 18 2.3.4 Injuries in the Tunisian Professional Leagues 20 2.3.5 Injuries in the Congo National Football League 22 2.4 Injuries during Football Competitions 24 2.4.1 Injuries during FIFA Competitions 1998 - 2001 24 2.4.2 Injuries during the 2002 FIFA World Cup Korea/Japan™ 26 2.4.3 Injuries during the 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany™ 28 2.4.4 Injuries of Female Players in Top-Level International Competitions 30 2.4.5 Injuries during the FIFA Futsal World Cups 2004 and 2008 32 2.4.6 Injuries and Illnesses at the 2010 FIFA World Cup South Africa™ 34 2.4.7 Injury Surveillance in World Football Tournaments 1998-2012 36 2.5 Risk Factors and Injury Causation 38 2.5.1 Risk Factors of Injuries in Different Ages and Skill Level
    [Show full text]
  • Letter from Cairo 35 Issue
    Africa 2019 1 Board Chairman Diaa Rashwan Editor-in-Chief 06 stadiums Africa 2019 Abdelmoeti Abuzaid 6 with international standards 4 Governorates hosting Egypt has identified six venues for the tournament: Cairo Internation- 2019 AFCON al Stadium, Al Salam Stadium, 30 June Stadium, Alexandria Stadium, Ismailia Stadium and Suez Stadium. The 2019 Africa Cup of Nations Cairo is held in June 2019 with the participation of 24 teams divided into six groups for the first time in the history of the tournament. Cairo International Stadium Editor Cairo Stadium is one of the best 38.000 square meters, a tennis complex stadiums in the world. It hosts AFCON and a squash court that includes a main Nashwa Abdel-Hamid 2019’s quarter-finals, matches of playground and four training grounds. Egyptian national team, The Pharaohs, The Stadium’s secondary sports Cairo is the capital of the Arab Republic passing through the ancient city of Cairo. It alongside the opening, closing and official facilities include four football fields, a of Egypt. It is the largest city in the Arab is also the largest open Islamic museum in ceremonies of the AFCON tournament. swimming pool complex, hockey and world and Africa in terms of population the world. Besides, it is a creative artistic Cairo International Stadium, is an horseback riding stadiums, as well as an (about 10 million people). It is an ancient city center for festivals and artistic and cultural Olympic-standard, The architect of the international cycling stadium currently with a prominent position among the world activities. In addition, it is home to a large capitals.
    [Show full text]
  • Qatar Emir Issues Summit Invite Amid Gulf Dispute
    SUBSCRIPTION WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 2014 MUHARRAM 19, 1436 AH www.kuwaittimes.net Government, Kuwait to Ten Indian Qatar to World Assembly ramp up women die, Cup critics: discuss energy output after mass We’re no priority2 issues capacity21 sterilization28 vampires20 Qatar emir issues summit Min 07º Max 27º invite amid Gulf dispute High Tide 01:50 & 16:18 Low Tide 08:53 & 20:46 40 PAGES NO: 16340 150 FILS Sheikh Tamim warns airstrikes against IS not enough conspiracy theories DOHA: Qatar’s emir yesterday publicly invited fellow Gulf rulers to a Doha summit, apparently seeking to If you love Kuwait... forestall what diplomats say is an attempt by some peers to move it elsewhere in protest at what they see as an Islamist tilt in his foreign policy. Diplomats say preparations for the annual gathering of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) have become indicative of an unprecedented rift between Gulf Arab states over Doha’s backing of Islamists during Arab Spring revolts. By Badrya Darwish Continued on Page 13 Kuwaiti kidnapped [email protected] in Lebanon freed BAALBEK, Lebanon: A Kuwaiti man kidnapped in hy the sudden cry and panic to cut subsi- August in the eastern Lebanese Bekaa valley yester- dies on petrol? You already have cut them day was released and handed over to the authori- Wsilently on diesel and kerosene. By the way, ties, a security source said. There were no signs the how much diesel and kerosene does the nation con- kidnapping had been politically motivated, the sume? Was it really gigantic amounts that will save source said without elaborating.
    [Show full text]
  • Aggn Yearbook 2014-2015
    AGGN YEARBOOK 2014-2015 A man who uses force is afraid of reasoning 2014-2015 AFRICAN GOOD GOVERNANCE NETWORK Table of Contents PREFACE .................................................................................................................................................. 1 INTERNAL ISSUES INTERVIEW WITH REBECCA GACHAGO, CHAIRPERSON OF AGGN .......................................................... 4 FROM THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEES’ DESK ............................................................................................ 6 AGGN WORKSHOPS IN 2014 ................................................................................................................... 9 “Governance & Media” ........................................................................................................................... 9 “Authoritarian Rule” .............................................................................................................................. 10 “Population Growth – Chances and Challenges for Africa’s Societies” ................................................ 12 GOVERNANCE AND SECURITY BOKO-HARAM INSURGENCY AND ITS IMPLICATIONS ON REGIONAL SECURITY .............................. 14 EBOLA VIRUS DISEASE OUTBREAK IN WEST AFRICA ............................................................................. 17 FOREST RESOURCE GOVERNANCE IN CAMEROON ............................................................................... 20 MEDIA GOVERNANCE AND REPRESENTATION THE MEDIA AND GOOD GOVERNANCE IN AFRICA ...............................................................................
    [Show full text]