arXiv:1001.0065v1 [astro-ph.SR] 31 Dec 2009 ple opoetegoa antcfil ntecorona. the in EI field of magnetic modelings global and the probe observations to the applied review idea the we are paper, thus this l and the In phenomenon, in trapped wave waves global-scale the only to the Compared corona. the emiss in waves radio MHD s gyroresonance field, magnetograms, magnetic coronal photospheric the the probe t to measureed made above precisely being well are be attempts field not b can magnetic measured phenomena, coronal be eruptive the various can contrast, atmosphere In lower solar effects. the in field Magnetic eateto srnm,NnigUiest,Nnig2100 Nanjing University, Nanjing Astronomy, of Department diagnostics PengFei field CHEN magnetic coronal and waves EIT upre yte93poet(rn o 06B032,adt and 2006CB806302), No. (Grant project 10403003) 973 the by Supported 2009 † 15, August 10.1007/s11433-009-0240-9 accepted doi: 2009; 15, July Received inlnsaeotclyti,adtetraditional the and thin, optically are lines emis- di- sion optical field kinematics, plasma magnetic the directly. controls where obtained rectly corona, be the can for field However, magnetic so local layers, the atmospheric these in range height narrow antcfil esrmn,Hneeetcnbe can effect weak Hanle utilized For measurement, region. is field transition in magnetic and the used for , been testified and being long has solar effect the Zeeman mag- field, strong at- For netic solar important. the extremely in is Therefore, field mosphere magnetic of atmosphere. measurement the the in producing heating relatively plasma, quiescent the besides the activities, with eruptive abundant mag- interacts astro- atmosphere, field solar various netic the in In role vital processes. physical a plays field Magnetic diagnostics field, magnetic (CMEs), ejections mass coronal @2009 Science inChinaSeriesG:Physics,Mechanics&Astronomy Citation: orsodn uhr(mi:[email protected]) (email: author Corresponding [1] hn .F I ae n ooa antcfil diagnostics. field magnetic coronal and waves EIT F. P. Chen, 0240-9 pcrllnsaefre narelatively a in formed are lines Spectral . Springer SCIENCE INCHINAPRESS 3 China 93, anthdoyais(MHD) , eNtoa aua cec onaino hn GatNos. (Grant China of Foundation Science Natural National he int igoetemgei edi h corona, the in field magnetic informa- the effective diagnose or to provides speed tion period propagation oscillation the tem- the either and/or Thus, field magnetic de- perature. local are waves the by standing the termined the of or speeds waves phase The propagating by waves. caused MHD loops, trapped coronal the and prominences quiet structures, as the coronal such of in oscillations waves the MHD trigger or of form the in propagate emissions. radio gyroresonance mag- as coronal such field, the netic probe develop to to approaches imperative alternative is prob- it ill-posed Therefore, anyway. an lem is extrapolation mag- the photospheric netograms, on based field the magnetic extrapolate coronal to developed been have techniques ehiusd o oks well so work not do techniques c hn e ,20,5(1:18-79 o:10.1007/s114 doi: 1785-1789, 52(11): 2009, G, Ser China Sci bqiosprubtosi h ooawould corona the in perturbations Ubiquitous eslrsrae hc ietycontrols directly which surface, solar he os n ooa esooybsdon based seismology coronal and ions, c sfrefe xrplto ae on based extrapolation force-free as uch ae,adilsrt o hycnbe can they how illustrate and waves, T olfrtecrnlgoa seismology. global coronal the for tool l ihtetaiinltcnqe.Several techniques. traditional the with clzdcrnllos I ae are waves EIT loops, coronal ocalized h s fteZea n Hanle and Zeeman the of use the y www.springerlink.com [2] lhuhsome Although . www.scichina.com phys.scichina.com 0303and 10933003 33-009- which gives rise to a new discipline, i.e, coronal and Chen & Fang[12] pointed out that the temper- seismology[3]. ature variation also plays a role in determining the In the early 1960s, Moreton & Ramsey[4] discov- EUV intensity. The statistical study by Klassen ered a kind of arc-shaped chromospheric pertur- et al.[13], using SOHO/EIT observations, indicates bations propagating away from big flares to a dis- that the typical velocities of EIT waves range from tance > 5 × 105 km, later called Moreton waves. 170 to 350 km·s−1, with a mean value of 271 According to Uchida[5], Moreton waves were due km·s−1. Note that the EIT wave velocity can be to coronal fast-mode waves sweeping the chromo- as slow as 50 km·s−1 or even smaller[14]. According sphere, and they can be used to reconstruct the to recent research by Long et al.[15], who analyzed Alfv´en velocity, hence the magnetic field distribu- the high-cadence EUV observations by STEREO tions in the corona. In contrast to this large-scale satellite, the low cadence of the SOHO/EIT ob- waves, localized MHD waves were also found to be servations smoothed the EIT wave velocity evo- trapped in coronal loops and prominences (see ref. lution, i.e, the maximum velocity was underes- [6] for a review). timated and the low velocity was overestimated. /prominence oscillations provide Therefore, a renewed statistics of EIT wave veloc- the diagnosis of the local magnetic field, whereas ities, based on the high cadence observations of Moreton waves provide the magnetic field informa- STEREO/SECCHI, is strongly recommended. tion on a relatively larger scale. Both phenomena The discovery of EIT waves immediately re- cover only a small part of the solar surface. How- minded the researchers of the coronal counter- ever, EIT waves, which were discovered in the coro- parts of Hα Moreton waves, and so they were nal mass ejection (CME) event on 1997 May 12, explained in terms of fast-mode MHD waves in offer a perfect opportunity for the magnetic field the corona[9,16,17], though there were arguments diagnosis on a global scale. whether the fast-mode waves originate from the flare or the CME[18,19]. However, the fast-mode 1 EIT waves: Observations and model- wave model can not account for the following ob- ings servational features: (1) Even considering that the After the launch of the SOHO satellite in late 1995, high-cadence observations may upgrade the statis- [13] one of its payloads, the EUV Imaging Telescope tical results made by Klassen et al. , the EIT (EIT), detected an almost circular front propagat- wave velocities are still significantly smaller than ing outward from the source active region in the those of Moreton waves, which are truly fast-mode; CME/flare event on 1997 May 12[7]. More fre- (2) EIT waves may stop at the footpoints of the [20] quently, they are present as propagating patches, magnetic separatrix ; (3) EIT wave velocities are rather than circular fronts. Such a wave phe- anti-correlated with the speeds of the correspond- [13] nomenon is often referred to as “EIT wave”, but ing type II radio bursts ; (4) EIT waves acceler- ∼ · −1 occasionally called “coronal wave” by some authors ate from 20 km s near the source active region · −1 [15] (e.g., ref. [8]). EIT wave fronts, with an emission to more than 400 km s in the quiet region . enhancement ranging from a few to tens of per- In order to reconcile these discrepancies, Chen et cent, are always followed immediately by expand- al.[21,22] proposed a field-line stretching model, i.e, ing EUV dimmings in the base difference images[9]. as the strongly twisted flux rope erupts to form a Therefore, EIT waves and dimmings are consid- CME, a fast-mode piston-driven shock propagates ered symbiotic phenomena which require a com- outward, which corresponds to the coronal coun- mon physical process in any theoretical model[10]. terpart of Hα Moreton wave. At the same time, Since EIT waves and dimmings are found visible the erupting flux rope pushes the overlying mag- in several EUV bands, they are believed to result netic loop successively. The stretching of each mag- mainly from density enhancement and depletion, netic loop leads to an EIT wave front on the outer respectively, although Wills-Davey & Thompson[11] side and density depletion inside the magnetic loop.

1786 Chen, P. F. Sci China Ser G-Phys Mech Astron | Nov. 2009 | vol. 52 | no. 11 | 1785-1789 Therefore, the model explains the EIT waves and sion would be transferred along the field line to dimmings simultaneously. The field-line stretching its footpoints C and E, with the Alfv´enic veloc- model can account for all the four features men- ity vA. The expansion near the footpoints C and tioned above, and was supported by imaging and E compresses the plasma on the outer side, which spectroscopic observations[23]. produces the first EIT wave front. At the same time, the local expansion near point A would also 3 EIT waves as a tool for coronal seis- be transferred upward to the top part of the second mology magnetic field line, near point B, with the fast- 2 2 mode wave velocity (vf = pvA + vs , where vs is Since EIT waves propagate across almost the en- the sound speed) since it is perpendicular to the tire solar disk in many events, they are the ideal field lines, as illustrated by the right panel. Thus tool for the global magnetic field diagnosis. As for the top part of the second field line near point B other wave phenomena, how EIT waves are used expands. Again, the local expansion, as a kind of for coronal seismology depends on the identifica- perturbation, would be transferred along the sec- tion of the wave mode. If they are fast-mode MHD ond field line to its footpoints D and F, with the waves, the magnetic field reconstruction would be Alfv´enic velocity vA. Thereby, a second EIT wave the same as used for Moreton waves. Within such front is formed near points D and F. With such a a framework, several groups tried to reconstruct repeating circle, progressing EIT wave fronts are [24] the global magnetic field distribution . Consider- formed as outer field lines are pushed to expand ing the discrepancies between the fast-mode wave successively. Note that the successive expansion model and the observations, we have proposed a of the magnetic loops naturally leads to expanding magnetic field-line stretching model, as described dimming regions behind the EIT wave fronts. The in Sec. 2. In this section, we discuss how EIT apparent velocity of the EIT wave in the model waves can be used for coronal seismology in the is the distance between two successive EIT wave framework of our field-line stretching model. fronts, e.g., CD, divided by the time difference The sketch of our model is depicted in Figure 1, between the formation of the two successive EIT where the thick curved lines are the initial mag- wave fronts, ∆t. This is to say, the EIT wave the circles netic field lines. As the flux rope ( ) apparent velocity near points C and D is related moves upward, it pushes the top part of the first to the magnetic field by vEIT = CD/∆t, where field line near point A, and this local part expands B D C ∆t = R 1/vf ds + R 1/vAds − R 1/vAds. outward. As shown in Figure 1(a), the expan- A B A

H H

BB

A A

G FFEE CD I GCID Figure 1 The sketch of our field-line stretching model for EIT waves[21].

Chen, P. F. Sci China Ser G-Phys Mech Astron | Nov. 2009 | vol. 52 | no. 11 | 1785-1789 1787 Figure 2 (a) A magnetic configuration with an active region surrounded by potential field; (b) the corresponding distributions of the fast-mode wave and EIT wave velocities along the surface. The unit of the velocity is 900 km·s−1.

As demonstrated by Chen et al.[21], if the mag- EIT wave velocity distribution, similar to the tech- netic field lines are concentric semicircles, the re- niques used in , deserves substantial sulting vEIT is about 0.34vf . For any given mag- further studies. netic configuration, the EIT wave velocity distri- bution can be analogically derived by the above 4 Prospects formula. For example, Figure 2(a) depicts the magnetic configuration for an active region sur- As the largest-scale wave phenomenon in the rounded by a potential bipolar field. The cor- corona, EIT waves offer an ideal opportunity to responding EIT wave velocity and the fast-mode probe the coronal magnetic field. As proposed in wave velocity distributions are plotted in the Fig- our field-line stretching model, the formation of ure 2(b). The EIT waves are seen to accelerate near each EIT wave front conveys the magnetic infor- the boundary of the source active region. This fea- mation in 3D space, all the way from the erupting ture is consistent with the recent observation[15], flux rope to the top of each field line, and then but which cannot be interpreted by the fast-mode along the field line to its footpoints. Therefore, p wave model. similar to the -mode waves in the helioseismology, EIT waves can be used to probe the 3D distribu- We can adjust the coronal magnetic configura- tion of the coronal magnetic field, providing that tion so that the resulting EIT wave velocity distri- high-cadence EUV imaging observations are avail- bution can best match the observational one. In able. In this paper, we demonstrated the feasibility this way, the coronal magnetic field distribution of the forward modeling of the coronal seismology can be reconstructed. This procedure, which is based on EIT wave. However, the inverse model- forward modeling, is demonstrated here to be eli- ing, i.e., the direct inversion from EIT wave veloc- gible. The inverse modeling, i.e., to derive the 3D ity evolution to the coronal magnetic field, deserves coronal magnetic field directly from the observed further investigation.

1 Sahal-Br´echot S. The Hanle effect applied to magnetic field Astrophys J, 1984, 279: 857–865 diagnostics. Space Sci Rev, 1981, 29: 391–401 4 Moreton G E, Ramsey H E. Recent observations of dynamical 2 White S M. Solar and Radiophysics, Vol.314. phenomena associated with solar flares. Publ Astron Soc Pac, Gary D E, Keller C U, eds. Dordrecht: Academic Publisher, 1960, 72: 357 2004. 89–113 5 Uchida Y. Propagation of hydromagnetic disturbances in the 3 Roberts B, Edwin P M, Benz A O. On coronal oscillations. solar corona and Moreton’s wave phenomenon. Sol Phys, 1968,

1788 Chen, P. F. Sci China Ser G-Phys Mech Astron | Nov. 2009 | vol. 52 | no. 11 | 1785-1789 4: 30–44 ics of a globally propagating disturbance in the solar corona. 6 Roberts B. Waves and oscillations in the corona. Sol Phys, Astrophys J, 2008, 680: L81-L84 2000, 193: 139–152 16 Wu S T, Zheng H, Wang S et al. 3D numerical simulation 7 Thompson B J, Plunkett S P, Gurman J B et al. SOHO/EIT of MHD waves observed by EIT. J Geophys Res, 2001, 106: observations of an Earth-directed on 25089-25102 May 12, 1997. Geophys Res Lett, 1998, 25: 2465–2468 17 Wang Y M. EIT waves and fast-mode propagation in the solar 8 Vrˇsnak B, Warmuth A, Temmer M et al. Multi-wavelength corona. Astrophys J, 2000, 543: L89–L92 study of coronal waves associated with the CME-flare event of 18 Grechnev V V, Uralov A M, Slemzin V A et al. Absorption 3 November 2003. Astron Astrophys, 2006, 448: 739–752 phenomena and a probable blast wave in the 13 July 2004 9 Thompson B J, Gurman J B, Neupert W M et al. SOHO/EIT eruptive event. Sol Phys, 2008, 253: 263–290 observations of the 1997 April 7 coronal transient: Possible 19 Veronig A M, Temmer M, Vrˇsnak B. High-cadence observa- evidence of coronal moreton waves. Astrophys J, 1999, 517: tions of a global coronal Wave by STEREO EUVI. Astrophys 151–154 J, 2008, 681: L113–L116 10 Chen P F. Initiation and propagation of CMEs. J Astrophys 20 Delann´ee C, Aulanier G. CME Associated with transequatorial Astron, 2008, 29: 179–186 loops and a bald patch flare. Sol Phys, 1999, 190: 107–129 11 Wills-Davey M J, Thompson B J. Observations of a propagat- 21 Chen P F, Wu S T, Shibata K, et al. Evidence of EIT and ing disturbance in TRACE. Sol Phys, 1999, 190: 467–483 Moreton waves in numerical simulations. Astrophys J, 2002, 12 Chen P F, Fang C. EIT waves - A signature of global magnetic 572: L99–L102 restructuring in CMEs. IAU Symp, 2005, 226: 55–64 22 Chen P F, Fang C, Shibata K. A full view of EIT waves. As- 13 Klassen A, Aurass H, Mann G et al. Catalogue of the 1997 trophys J, 2005, 622: 1202–1210 SOHO-EIT coronal transient waves and associated type II ra- 23 Harra L K, Sterling A C. Imaging and spectroscopic investiga- dio burst spectra. Astron Astrophys, 2000, 141: 357–369 tions of a solar coronal wave. Astrophys J, 2003, 587: 429–438 14 Thompson B J, Myers D C. Catalog of Coronal “EIT Wave” 24 Warmuth A, Mann G. A model of the Alfv´en speed in the solar Transients. Astrophys J Suppl Ser, 2009, 183: 225–243 corona. Astron Astrophys, 2005, 435: 1123–1135 15 Long D M, Gallagher P T, McAteer R T J et al. The kinemat-

Chen, P. F. Sci China Ser G-Phys Mech Astron | Nov. 2009 | vol. 52 | no. 11 | 1785-1789 1789