DOCSLIB.ORG

Urban Forest Wood Re-Use Study

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Urban Forest Wood Re-Use Study San Francisco Urban Forest Wood Re-Use Study Presidio Graduate School Jonathan Dirrenberger Cheryl Dorsey Ryan Miller Sonja O’Claire Agenda • Presidio Team • Project Scope • Methodology • Case Studies • Current State of Re-Use • Stakeholders • EOL Wood Products • Recommendations • Barriers to Implementation Presidio Team • Presidio Graduate School Sustainable Management MBA candidates • Experiential learning project for Operations and Production course • Study produced for SF Planning Department Project Scope • Current wood waste processes • Street Trees (DPW) • Park Trees (RPD) • Case studies • Evaluate EOL processes • Make recommendations for a future wood re-use program Methodology • Stakeholder meetings • Facility tours • Phone interviews • Demand forecast • Value analysis Case Studies • Sacramento, CA • Olympia, WA • Cincinnati, OH Current State of Re-Use • DPW (Street Trees) • Hauls to Recology • RPD (Park Trees) • Chips, mulch and composts all tree waste on-site • Some logs used in parks • 100% re-use rate • Lumber is not a current end product • Estimated 10-20% of removed trees are of lumber quality Stakeholders Urban Tree EOL Wood Products • Logs • Lumber • Wood Chips • Mulch IncreasedProcessing • Compost • Hog Fuel • Biochar • Paper Products • Cellulosic Ethanol • Engineered Wood Immature Mature Debarking and Tree Growth Tree Removal Logs Storage Transport Tree Tree Chipping Storage Storage Pruned Adhesives and Tree Pruning Sawmilling Rough Cutting Wood Chips Tree Binders Tree and Wood Barriers, Engineered Transport Storage Lumber Wood Debris Firewood Pyrolysis Fermentation Pulping Debris Benches, etc. Wood Production Landfill Chipping or Non-Tree Bio-oil and Cellulosic Paper Engineered F/E Biochar Waste Grinding Wood Waste Syngas Ethanol Products Wood Mixed Contaminated Storage Transport Wood Chips Wood Chips† Wood Chip Overs Hog Fuel Screening Process Diagram for San Francisco Manure or Wood Chips Sand Fines Storage Other Applications Food Waste (Accepts) Urban Tree Wood Re-Use Storage Storage • Ovals indicate processes • Rectangles indicate materials Composting Mulching • Yellow indicates relevant EOL wood products • Abbreviations: GHG = greenhouse gas emissions Seed and P = pollution Other Applications Storage Compost Mulch Storage Other Applications Water F/E = fuel and/or energy Storage Storage • Dashed lines indicate processes and materials not recommended but shown for completeness Seed Planting & • Transport process indicates transport out of the Sapling Growth city (transport within the city is not shown) † Contaminated wood contains toxic chemicals (paint, waterproofing chemicals, chemicals to Sapling prevent rot, etc.) and is thus only suitable as hog fuel. This normally only occurs when non-tree wood waste is used. Tree Planting Defining Value of EOL Wood • Minimize GHG emissions and pollution • Minimize landfill • Keep local • Reduce costs • Raise awareness • Optional: obtain revenue Lee, C., Erickson, P., Lazarus, M., & Smith, G. (2010). Greenhouse Gas and Air Pollutant Emissions of Alternatives for Woody Biomass Residues, Final Draft Version 2.0. Stockholm Environment Institute Lee, C., Erickson, P., Lazarus, M., & Smith, G. (2010). Greenhouse Gas and Air Pollutant Emissions of Alternatives for Woody Biomass Residues, Final Draft Version 2.0. Stockholm Environment Institute Best Options • Priority • Lumber & Logs • ~10-20% of removed trees • Secondary • Wood chips, mulch, and compost • ~70-80% of removed trees • Last resort • Hog fuel • ~10% of removed trees • Future • Biochar • More research needed Demand & Financial Value - 2014 Demand & Financial Value - 2034 Key Recommendations 1) DPW process and store wood chips, mulch, and compost 2) The City develop program to harvest lumber • Short term: pilot for rough sawn program • Long term: rough and finished lumber 3) DPW & RPD share wood processing resources Secondary Recommendations A. Improve data collection B. Pre-empt possible public disapproval Barriers to Implementation • Funding • Legal & policy barriers • Public opinion Thank you! .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Fundamental Studies on Wood/Cellulose-Plastic Composites
    J Wood Sci (2007) 53:470–480 © The Japan Wood Research Society 2007 DOI 10.1007/s10086-007-0889-5 ORIGINAL ARTICLE Rashmi Kumari · Hirokazu Ito · Masahiro Takatani Miho Uchiyama · Tadashi Okamoto Fundamental studies on wood/cellulose–plastic composites: effects of composition and cellulose dimension on the properties of cellulose/PP composite Received: September 6, 2006 / Accepted: February 9, 2007 / Published online: May 29, 2007 Abstract Although wood/cellulose–plastic composites Introduction (WPC) of low wood/cellulose content have been more ac- cepted worldwide and are promoted as low-maintenance, high-durability building products, composites containing In recent years, interest in composites based on renewable high wood/cellulose content are not yet developed on an materials has grown tremendously because of social re- industrial scale. In this study, fl ow properties, mechanical quests for low environmental stress, low-maintenance and properties, and water absorption properties of the com- high-durability products, and ultraviolet (UV) durability.1–3 pounds of cellulose microfi ber/polypropylene (PP) and Construction, transportation, industrial, and consumer ap- maleic anhydride-grafted polypropylene (MAPP) were in- plications for wood/cellulose–plastic composites (WPC) are vestigated to understand effects of the high cellulose con- all on the rise. WPC have been primarily produced with a tent and the dimensions of the cellulose microfi ber. The low and medium percentage of wood/cellulose. Products molding processes studied included compression, injection, typically contain approximately 50% (by weight) wood/ and extrusion. It was found that fl uidity is not only depen- cellulose, although some composites contain very little dent on resin content but also on the dimension of the fi ller; wood/cellulose and others as much as 60%.1,4–7 Wood/ fl uidity of the compound declined with increased fi ber cellulose content may range from 70% to 90% and the length with the same resin content.
    [Show full text]
  • The Miracle Resource Eco-Link
    Since 1989 Eco-Link Linking Social, Economic, and Ecological Issues The Miracle Resource Volume 14, Number 1 In the children’s book “The Giving Tree” by Shel Silverstein the main character is shown to beneÞ t in several ways from the generosity of one tree. The tree is a source of recreation, commodities, and solace. In this parable of giving, one is impressed by the wealth that a simple tree has to offer people: shade, food, lumber, comfort. And if we look beyond the wealth of a single tree to the benefits that we derive from entire forests one cannot help but be impressed by the bounty unmatched by any other natural resource in the world. That’s why trees are called the miracle resource. The forest is a factory where trees manufacture wood using energy from the sun, water and nutrients from the soil, and carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. In healthy growing forests, trees produce pure oxygen for us to breathe. Forests also provide clean air and water, wildlife habitat, and recreation opportunities to renew our spirits. Forests, trees, and wood have always been essential to civilization. In ancient Mesopotamia (now Iraq), the value of wood was equal to that of precious gems, stones, and metals. In Mycenaean Greece, wood was used to feed the great bronze furnaces that forged Greek culture. Rome’s monetary system was based on silver which required huge quantities of wood to convert ore into metal. For thousands of years, wood has been used for weapons and ships of war. Nations rose and fell based on their use and misuse of the forest resource.
    [Show full text]
  • Non-Timber Forest Products
    Agrodok 39 Non-timber forest products the value of wild plants Tinde van Andel This publication is sponsored by: ICCO, SNV and Tropenbos International © Agromisa Foundation and CTA, Wageningen, 2006. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by print, photocopy, microfilm or any other means, without written permission from the publisher. First edition: 2006 Author: Tinde van Andel Illustrator: Bertha Valois V. Design: Eva Kok Translation: Ninette de Zylva (editing) Printed by: Digigrafi, Wageningen, the Netherlands ISBN Agromisa: 90-8573-027-9 ISBN CTA: 92-9081-327-X Foreword Non-timber forest products (NTFPs) are wild plant and animal pro- ducts harvested from forests, such as wild fruits, vegetables, nuts, edi- ble roots, honey, palm leaves, medicinal plants, poisons and bush meat. Millions of people – especially those living in rural areas in de- veloping countries – collect these products daily, and many regard selling them as a means of earning a living. This Agrodok presents an overview of the major commercial wild plant products from Africa, the Caribbean and the Pacific. It explains their significance in traditional health care, social and ritual values, and forest conservation. It is designed to serve as a useful source of basic information for local forest dependent communities, especially those who harvest, process and market these products. We also hope that this Agrodok will help arouse the awareness of the potential of NTFPs among development organisations, local NGOs, government officials at local and regional level, and extension workers assisting local communities. Case studies from Cameroon, Ethiopia, Central and South Africa, the Pacific, Colombia and Suriname have been used to help illustrate the various important aspects of commercial NTFP harvesting.
    [Show full text]
  • Old-Growth Forests
    Pacific Northwest Research Station NEW FINDINGS ABOUT OLD-GROWTH FORESTS I N S U M M A R Y ot all forests with old trees are scientifically defined for many centuries. Today’s old-growth forests developed as old growth. Among those that are, the variations along multiple pathways with many low-severity and some Nare so striking that multiple definitions of old-growth high-severity disturbances along the way. And, scientists forests are needed, even when the discussion is restricted to are learning, the journey matters—old-growth ecosystems Pacific coast old-growth forests from southwestern Oregon contribute to ecological diversity through every stage of to southwestern British Columbia. forest development. Heterogeneity in the pathways to old- growth forests accounts for many of the differences among Scientists understand the basic structural features of old- old-growth forests. growth forests and have learned much about habitat use of forests by spotted owls and other species. Less known, Complexity does not mean chaos or a lack of pattern. Sci- however, are the character and development of the live and entists from the Pacific Northwest (PNW) Research Station, dead trees and other plants. We are learning much about along with scientists and students from universities, see the structural complexity of these forests and how it leads to some common elements and themes in the many pathways. ecological complexity—which makes possible their famous The new findings suggest we may need to change our strat- biodiversity. For example, we are gaining new insights into egies for conserving and restoring old-growth ecosystems. canopy complexity in old-growth forests.
    [Show full text]
  • Engineered Wood Installation 3/8” Or 1/2” Tongue & Groove: Float, Nail/Staple & Full Spread Gluedown Read These Instructions Completely Before Beginning Installation
    ENGINEERED WOOD INSTALLATION 3/8” OR 1/2” TONGUE & GROOVE: FLOAT, NAIL/STAPLE & FULL SPREAD GLUEDOWN READ THESE INSTRUCTIONS COMPLETELY BEFORE BEGINNING INSTALLATION. GENERAL INFORMATION Smoking by individuals exposed to asbestos fibers greatly increases the risk of serious ATTENTION INSTALLERS bodily harm. Unless positively certain that the existing in-place product is a non- asbestos-containing material, you must presume it contains asbestos. Regulations WARNING: Installation of wood product may create wood dust, which is may require that the material be tested to determine asbestos content and may known to the state of California to cause cancer. Avoid inhaling wood dust or govern removal and disposal of material. See current edition of the Resilient Floor use a dust mask or other safeguards for personal protection. Covering Institute (RFCI) publication Recommended Work Practices for Removal Sawing, sanding and machining wood products can produce of Resilient Floor Coverings for instructions on removing all resilient floor covering wood dust. Airborne wood dust can cause respiratory, eye and structures. skin irritation. The International Agency for Research on Cancer If you have technical or installation questions please call 1-800-258-5758 (IARC) has classified wood dust as a nasal carcinogen in humans. IMPORTANT HEALTH NOTICE FOR RESIDENTS OF MINNESOTA ONLY: Precautionary Measures: If power tools are used, they should be equipped THESE BUILDING MATERIALS EMIT FORMALDEHYDE. EYE, NOSE, AND with a dust collector. If high dust levels are encountered, use an appropriate THROAT IRRITATION, HEADACHE, NAUSEA AND A VARIETY OF ASTHMA- NIOSH-designated dust mask. Avoid dust contact with eye and skin. LIKE SYMPTOMS, INCLUDING SHORTNESS OF BREATH, HAVE BEEN First Aid Measures in Case of Irritation: In case of irritation, flush eyes REPORTED AS A RESULT OF FORMALDEHYDE EXPOSURE.
    [Show full text]
  • WOOD | Natural Woodchips™
    WOOD | Natural WoodChips™ TORGINOL® Natural WoodChips™ are manufactured from a range of premium quality natural and engineered wood veneer species. 4617 South Taylor Drive Reclaim your environment with the holistic serenity of organic wood. Sheboygan, WI 53081 | USA TORGINOL® Natural WoodChips™ will enhance your environment (920) 694-4800 [email protected] | www.torginol.com with ecological simplicity. This innovative wood flooring solution combines the hygienic benefits of seamless flooring with nature’s TYPICAL WOOD SYSTEM elegant wood grains, sustaining a timeless appeal for the life of your floor. PERFORMANCE SPECIFICATIONS Color (Natural) Visual Evaluation (ASTM D4086) Pass * Dry Film Thickness Micrometer (ASTM D1005) 6 - 8 mils TMTM Shape Visual Evaluation (ASTM D4086) Random PROTECTIVE TOPCOAT Odor Olfactory (ASTM D1296) Odorless CLEAR GROUT COAT Moisture Content (< 5%) Moisture Meter (ASTM D4442) Pass NATURAL WOODCHIPS Size Distribution (~3/8”) Normal Sieve Analysis (ASTM C136) Pass PIGMENTED BASECOAT COVERAGE RATE GUIDELINES PRIMER/SEALER Type Size Full Coverage CONCRETE All ~ 3/8” 15 - 20 SF / LB *For best results, a sanding coat is recommended Coverage rates may vary depending on customer preferences and application techniques. prior to applying the final topcoat(s). WOOD SPECIES LIMITATIONS A Natural Product Wood is a natural material and may not be uniform in appearance. Natural variations in the characteristics of individual pieces W1010 / HONEY MAPLE W1000 / POWDERED ASPEN W2010 / WHITE ASH should not be considered defects. The color and grain variations contribute to the wood veneer’s unique character and beauty. Aging and Light Exposure W1015 / WINTER BIRCH W1040 / CLASSIC MAHOGANY W2015 / AGED HICKORY Wood ages naturally over time as it is exposed to light and other environmental elements.
    [Show full text]
  • A Future Vision for Optimally Using Wood and Biomass
    June 2008:Forest Products 6/5/08 9:09 PM Page 6 Integrated Biomass Technologies: AA Future Future Vision Vision for for Optimally Using Abstract Exciting new opportunities are emerging for sustainably meeting many global energy needs and simultaneously creating high­value bio­based consumer and construction products from wood, forest and agricultural residues, and other bio­based materials. In addition to traditional value­added bio­ based products, such as lumber, paper, paperboard, and composites, opportunities are now on the hori­ zon for biorefining to produce electricity, transportation fuels, chemical feedstocks, syngas, and nanocrystalline cellulose. In the near future, nanocrystalline cellulose, produced as a high­value by­prod­ uct from the biorefining process, could likely compete with carbon fiber for use in innovative high­ strength biocomposites. The holistic view of how to achieve both traditional and new high­value materi­ als with enhanced performance properties from renewable resources is called Integrated Biomass Technologies. This concept promotes the use of sustainable, bio­based, environmentally neutral (or even beneficial) technologies to meet global demands for building and materials end uses, chemicals, and energy. This concept provides a systematic approach for maximizing value, performance, resource sus­ tainability, and improving profitability in the agriculture and forest products industries. 6 JUNE 2008 June 2008:Forest Products 6/5/08 9:09 PM Page 7 By Jerrold E. Winandy, Alan W. Rudie, R. Sam Williams, and Theodore H. Wegner WoodWood andand BiomassBiomass The agricultural sector has made significant progress them are regarded as carbon neutral, releasing into in developing bio­based fuels and chemicals. Today, the the atmosphere only the amount of CO originally 2 dominant feedstock for ethanol transportation fuel is fer­ sequestered by the plant to produce the biomass.
    [Show full text]
  • The Number One Wood Floor for Concrete Installation the TOUGH QUESTIONS
    Questions? 800.595.9663 or wideplankflooring.com The Number One Wood Floor for Concrete Installation THE TOUGH QUESTIONS Don’t be afraid to ask us or any other Myths & Misconceptions flooring provider: • Can you install your floors direct to a Concrete slabs are one of the most common subfloor systems used today for residential and concrete slab? commercial construction. Unfortunately, it is a common misconception that you cannot install • Do I have to use a floating floor a wood floor on top of a concrete slab. This can be discouraging if you've had your heart set when installing to a concrete slab? on the look of wide plank floors. • Am I limited to a certain species The good news is Carlisle has been installing wide plank floors in conjunction with a concrete if I install your wood floors on a slab for over 45 years. Our floors exhibit the highest level of quality in the industry, which concrete slab? means they outperform other wood flooring available on the market. So you can get a floor • Do I have to use quartersawn wood that looks beautiful, and performs the best when installed with a concrete slab. when I install your wood floors on a Don't compromise the look of your floor because of industry myths and misconceptions. concrete slab? Learn more about what makes Carlisle wood floors more stable and get the look you have • Do I have to use an engineered been dreaming of for your project. floor if I install your wood floors on a concrete slab? Hundreds of Floors and Counting • Can I use a solid wood if I install your From Texas ranches, luxury retail stores, and boutique hotels, Carlisle floors have been wood floors on a concrete slab? installed direct to a concrete slab in hundreds of projects all over the worlds.
    [Show full text]
  • “Catastrophic” Wildfire a New Ecological Paradigm of Forest Health by Chad Hanson, Ph.D
    John Muir Project Technical Report 1 • Winter 2010 • www.johnmuirproject.org The Myth of “Catastrophic” Wildfire A New Ecological Paradigm of Forest Health by Chad Hanson, Ph.D. Contents The Myth of “Catastrophic” Wildfire: A New Ecological Paradigm of Forest Health 1 Preface 1 Executive Summary 4 Myths and Facts 6 Myth/Fact 1: Forest fire and home protection 6 Myth/Fact 2: Ecological effects of high-intensity fire 7 Myth/Fact 3: Forest fire intensity 12 Myth/Fact 4: Forest regeneration after high-intensity fire 13 Myth/Fact 5: Forest fire extent 14 Myth/Fact 6: Climate change and fire activity 17 Myth/Fact 7: Dead trees and forest health 19 Myth/Fact 8: Particulate emissions from high-intensity fire 20 Myth/Fact 9: Forest fire and carbon sequestration 20 Myth/Fact 10: “Thinning” and carbon sequestration 22 Myth/Fact 11: Biomass extraction from forests 23 Summary: For Ecologically “Healthy Forests”, We Need More Fire and Dead Trees, Not Less. 24 References 26 Photo Credits 30 Recommended Citation 30 Contact 30 About the Author 30 The Myth of “Catastrophic” Wildfire A New Ecological Paradigm of Forest Health ii The Myth of “Catastrophic” Wildfire: A New Ecological Paradigm of Forest Health By Chad Hanson, Ph.D. Preface In the summer of 2002, I came across two loggers felling fire-killed trees in the Star fire area of the Eldorado National Forest in the Sierra Nevada. They had to briefly pause their activities in order to let my friends and I pass by on the narrow dirt road, and in the interim we began a conversation.
    [Show full text]
  • Forest Ecosystem Services: Cultural Values
    Trees At Work: Economic Accounting for Forest Ecosystem Services in the U.S. South 11 Chapter 2 Forest Ecosystem Services: Cultural Values Melissa M. Kreye, Damian C. Adams, Ramesh Ghimire, Wayde Morse, Taylor Stein, J.M. Bowker WHAT ARE CULTURAL SERVICES? associated ecosystem and human components. However, our understanding of the many factors that give rise to cultural ow we define “culture” and societal well-being related ecosystem services is still a matter of ongoing investigation. to culture depends heavily on who is looking at it, but culture can be generally described as “the customs and H There is good reason for investigating the cultural ecosystem beliefs of a particular group of people that are used to express service values associated with forests: they are critical to our their collectively held values” (Soulbury Commission 2012). understanding of the value of forest land and the benefits of In the context of forests, culturally derived norms, beliefs, forest conservation. The U.S. South is expected to lose 30-43 and values help drive preferences for forested landscapes and million forest acres to urbanization between 1997 and 2060 forest-based benefits such as diversity and identity, justice, (Wear and Greis 2002), and structural changes in southeastern education, freedom, and spirituality (Farber and others 2002, ecosystems are expected to impact the provision of a wide Fisher and others 2009, Kellert 1996). Environmental policies range of cultural ecosystem service benefits (Bowker and others and responsible forest management can enhance how forests 2013). Concurrently, social trends also suggest that youth are help give rise to and support cultural ecosystem service values.
    [Show full text]
  • Current U.S. Forest Data and Maps
    CURRENT U.S. FOREST DATA AND MAPS Forest age FIA MapMaker CURRENT U.S. Forest ownership TPO Data FOREST DATA Timber harvest AND MAPS Urban influence Forest covertypes Top 10 species Return to FIA Home Return to FIA Home NEXT Productive unreserved forest area CURRENT U.S. FOREST DATA (timberland) in the U.S. by region and AND MAPS stand age class, 2002 Return 120 Forests in the 100 South, where timber production West is highest, have 80 s the lowest average age. 60 Northern forests, predominantly Million acreMillion South hardwoods, are 40 of slightly older in average age and 20 Western forests have the largest North concentration of 0 older stands. 1-19 20-39 40-59 60-79 80-99 100- 120- 140- 160- 200- 240- 280- 320- 400+ 119 139 159 199 240 279 319 399 Stand-age Class (years) Return to FIA Home Source: National Report on Forest Resources NEXT CURRENT U.S. FOREST DATA Forest ownership AND MAPS Return Eastern forests are predominantly private and western forests are predominantly public. Industrial forests are concentrated in Maine, the Lake States, the lower South and Pacific Northwest regions. Source: National Report on Forest Resources Return to FIA Home NEXT CURRENT U.S. Timber harvest by county FOREST DATA AND MAPS Return Timber harvests are concentrated in Maine, the Lake States, the lower South and Pacific Northwest regions. The South is the largest timber producing region in the country accounting for nearly 62% of all U.S. timber harvest. Source: National Report on Forest Resources Return to FIA Home NEXT CURRENT U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Engineered Wood Beams: Spanning the Distance
    Engineered Wood Beams: Spanning the Distance Structural Engineers Association of Ohio September 12, 2014 Bob Clark, APA APA-The Engineered Wood Association Non-profit Trade Association representing manufacturers of engineered wood products: Structural Panels: Plywood and Oriented Strand Board (OSB) Glulam I-joists Structural Composite Lumber (SCL): Laminated Veneer Lumber (LVL), Oriented Strand Lumber (OSL) What is an Engineered Wood Product? Any wood- based building material that has been improved physically by a man-process. Engineered Wood Products Machined into pieces… Sawing (Glulam) Peeling (Plywood/LVL) Slicing (OSB/OSL) Engineered Wood Products Processed for maximum strength by… Drying Sorting Grading Aligning Engineered Wood Products Manufactured by… Applying Adhesives Pressing Curing Finishing Designing panels for performance Strength, stiffness, durability, and dimensional stability Face Core Center Core Back Oriented Strand Board Layup Laminated Veneer Lumber (LVL) Veneers bonded together Beams, headers, rafters & scaffold planking Common thicknesses: ¾” to 3-1/2” All grain parallel to length Parallel Strand Lumber (PSL) Manufactured from veneers clipped into long strands in a parallel formation and bonded together Strand length-to-thickness ratio is around 300 Common uses: headers, beams, load-bearing columns Published on a proprietary basis by the manufacturer and recognized in evaluation reports. Other Structural Composite Lumber Laminated Strand Lumber (LSL): Flaked strand length-to-thickness ratio
    [Show full text]