RESUME' OF WORK DONE BY

FIFTEENTH LOK SABHA SIXTH SESSION, 2010

LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT, NEW DELHI January, 2011/Pausa, 1932 (Saka) RESUME' OF WORK DONE BY LOK SABHA

FIFTEENTH LOK SABHA—SIXTH SESSION (9 November, 2010 to 13 December, 2010)

LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI January, 2011/Pausa, 1932 (Saka) T.O. No. 3/15LS Vol. VI

© 2011 BY LOK SABHA SECRETARIAT Published under Rule 382 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha (Fourteenth Edition) and Printed by the General Manager, Government of Press, Minto Road, New Delhi. PREFACE

This Publication contains a brief resume of work done in the Fifteenth Lok Sabha during the Sixth Session i.e. from 9 November, 2010 to 13 December, 2010.

NEW DELHI; January, 2011 T.K. VISWANATHAN, Pausa, 1932 (Saka) Secretary-General. CONTENTS

PAGE(S)

1. DURATION OF SESSION ...... 1

2. BILLS (i) Government Bills ...... 2 (ii) Bills referred to Standing Committees ...... 4 (iii) Private Members’ Bills (Summary) ...... 8

3. CALLING A TTENTION ...... 9

4. COMMITTEES (i) Financial Committees...... 10 (ii) Standing Committees ...... 11 (iii) Committees other than Financial and Standing Committees ...... 13

5. DIVISIONS ...... 16

6. FINANCIAL BUSINESS (i) General Budget ...... 17 (ii) Railway Budget ...... 17

7. MEMBER ELECTED IN BYE-ELECTION ...... 18

8. MOTIONS Motions under Rules 191 and 342 (Summary) ...... 19

9. OATH/AFFIRMATION ...... 20

10. OBITUARY AND OTHER REFERENCES ...... 21

11. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE ...... 27

12. QUESTIONS (i) Starred ...... 28 (ii) Short Notice ...... 28 (iii) Unstarred ...... 28

13. RESIGNATION BY MEMBER ...... 29

(i) PAGE(S)

14. RESOLUTION Private Members’ Resolutions (Summary) ...... 30

15. SHORT DURATION DISCUSSIONS UNDER RULE 193 (SUMMARY) ...... 31

16. SPEAKER/DEPUTY SPEAKER/CHAIRMAN Announcements/Observations/References/Rulings ...... 32

17. SITTINGS OF LOK SABHA ...... 33

18. STATEMENTS (i) Statements made/laid by Ministers under Rule 372 during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha ...... 34 (ii) Statements made/laid by Ministers under Direction 73A of Directions by the Speaker during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha ...... 35 (iii) Statements made/laid by Ministers regarding Government Business during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha ...... 42 (iv) Matters under Rule 377—Position regarding receipt of replies from Ministries during Fifteenth Lok Sabha (as on 5.01.2011) ...... 43 (v) Statement showing time lost owing to interruptions and adjournment of the House during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha ...... 44 (vi) Statement indicating matters of Urgent Public Import- ance raised after (a) Question Hour and (b) Before the adjournment of the House for the day during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha...... 49

19. STATEMENT SHOWING TIME TAKEN ON VARIOUS KINDS OF BUSINESS ...... 50

20. VACATION OF SEATS ...... 51

(ii) 1. DURATION OF SESSION (6th Session of 15th Lok Sabha)

1. Date of Commencement : $9 November, 2010 2. Date of Adjournment sine die : *13 December, 2010 3. Date of Prorogation : 17 December, 2010 4. Total Number of days of Session : 35 5. Number of Actual days of Sittings : 23 6. Number of hours of sitting : 7 hours 35 minutes

$The first sitting commenced with the playing of National Anthem. *The sitting ended with the playing of National Song.

1 2 Bill House Passed Pending Pending amended Progress/ Passed, as leave of the withdrawn by 1 ments carried amend- remarks 1 —— No. of No. of tabled amendments } HM Time taken on in — 0 01 —— — 0 01 — — 1.2010 0 01 — — 1.2010 * the Bill) 9.11.2010 * 9.1 (Motion for and passing) and passing) withdrawal of (consideration (consideration 1 06 able discussi 2. BILLS — — — 15.1 passed by on the T on the (i) Government Bills Rajya Sabha) (in case of BillSabha Lok 3 4 56789 1.2010 — Date of Date of laying Date of 2.8.2010 15.3.2010 15.3.2010 15.1 15.11.2010 — introduction Amendment) Bill, 2010. (Amendment and Bill, 2010. Validation) Hundred and Thirteenth Co-operative Societies (Amendment) Bill, 2010. (Amendment and Validation) Second Bill, 2010. Name) Bill, 2010. 3. The Multi-State 5. The Enemy Property 4. The Enemy Property 2. The Constitution (One 1. The Orissa (Alteration of Sl.No. Title of the Bill 12 3 Passed Passed Passed Passed Pending Pending Pending Pending — 01 0 — — — 01 0 — — — 01 0 — — 1.12.2010 02 0 2.12.2010 — 02 0 2.12.2010 — — 01 0 — — — 1.12.2010 03 0 — — and passing) and passing) and passing) and passing) (consideration (consideration (consideration (consideration — — — — — — — 1.12.2010 1.12.2010 2.12.2010 2.12.2010 1.12.2010 7.12.2010 19.11.2010 — — 0 01 — — Appropriation (Railways) Appropriation (Railways) (Subsidiary Banks) Amendment Bill, 2010. at Workplace Bill, 2010. Bill, 2010. Bill, 2010. (No. 5) Bill, 2010. (No. 6) Bill, 2010 Accountability Bill, 2010. (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2010. against Sexual Harassment 6. Bank of India The State 7. and The Judicial Standards 9.Appropriation (No. 6) The 8.Appropriation (No. 5) The *Discussed together. 10. The 11. The 12. The Forward Contracts 6.12.2010 13. The Protection of Women 4 Pending in Pending in Pending in Pending in Pending in Lok Sabha Lok Sabha Lok Sabha Lok Sabha Rajya Sabha Rajya laying of 10.11.2010 15.11.2010 26.11.2010 09.12.2010 presentation/ Resource Resource Public Justice Law and reference reports Personnel, Committee/ (16.9.2010) (13.9.2010) (13.5.2010) (16.9.2010) (16.9.2010) Name of the Date of Remarks Grievances, Development Development Home Affairs 10.11.2010 Family Welfare Family Chairman Date of Chairman Chairman Health and Chairman Human Chairman Human Chairman Referred by 34567 (LS) (LS) (LS) (LS) (RS) Date of 5.8.2010 16.8.2010 15.4.2010 30.8.2010 25.8.2010 introduction Speaker/ Rajya Sabha in Lok Sabha/ (ii) Bills Referred to the Standing Committees and Presentation/Laying of Reports thereof Prisoners (Amendment) Bill, 2010 Post-Graduate Medical Education and Research Puducherry (Amendment) Bill, 2010 (Amendment) Technology (Amendment) Bill, 2010 Bill, 2010 and Fourteenth Amendment) and Fourteenth Bill, 2010 1. The Repatriation of Sl.No. Title of the Bill 12 2. The Jawaharlal Institute of 3. The National Institutes of 4.Technology The Institutes of 5. The Constitution (One Hundred 5 Pending Pending Pending with the with the with the Pending in Pending in Pending in Committee Committee Committee Lok Sabha Rajya Sabha Rajya Sabha — — — 23.11.2010 10.12.2010 13.12.2010 Resource Public echnology echnology, Personnel, Information Agriculture T (13.9.2010) (16.8.2010) (23.4.2010) T and Forests Environment Grievances, Science and (31.12.2010) Development (20.12.2010) (31.12.2010) Home Affairs Law and Justice Speaker Chairman Chairman Human Chairman Chairman (LS) (LS) (LS) (LS) (RS) (RS) 31.8.2010 Speaker 30.7.2010 19.4.2010 1.12.2010 15.11.2010 15.11.2010 Co- Property (Broadcasting Corporation of India) Amendment of India) Bill, 2010 Scientific and Innovative Research Bill, 2010 (Amendment) Bill, 2010 (Amendment) Bill, 2010 Second Validation) Bill, 2010 operative Societies (Amendment and and Accountability Bill, 2010 6. The Prasar Bharati 7. The Academy of 8. The Copyright 9. The Multi-State 10. The Enemy 11. The Judicial Standards 6 Pending Pending Pending Pending Pending with the with the with the with the with the Committee Committee Committee Committee Committee — — — Food, Family Finance Welfare Consumer Affairs and (8.12.2010) (1.12.2010) (16.12.2010) Development (31.12.2010) (10.12.2010) Development Public Distribution Chairman Human Resource — Chairman Human Resource — Chairman Health and 34567 1.2010 (LS) (LS) (RS) (RS) (RS) 6.12.2010 Speaker 7.12.2010 3.12.2010 Speaker 7.12.2010 16.1 of Justice (Regulation) Amendment Bill, 2010 Bangalore Bill, 2010 Women against Sexual Harassment at Workplace Bill, 2010 (Care and Protection Children) Amendment Bill, 2010 Authority of India Bill, 2010 of Mental Health and Neuro-Sciences, 12. The Forward Contracts 13. The Protection of 14. The Juvenile 15. The National Identification 16. The National Institute 12 SUMMARY

1. Bills pending at the end of the last Session 29 2. Bills introduced 10 3. Bills opposed at introduction stage Nil 4. Bills passed by Rajya Sabha and laid on the Table Nil 5. Bills passed by Rajya Sabha and returned by Lok Sabha Nil with amendments 6. Bills returned by Rajya Sabha with amendments and Nil laid on the Table of Lok Sabha 7. Bills passed 6 8. Bills negatived Nil 9. Bills withdrawn 1 10. Bills part discussed Nil 11. Motions for adjournment of debate on the Bills adopted Nil 12. Bills referred to Select Committee Nil 13. Bills referred to Joint Committee Nil 14. Bills reported by Select Committee Nil 15. Bills reported by Joint Committee Nil 16. Bills originated in and referred to Joint Committee Nil by Rajya Sabha in respect of which motion for concurrence were adopted by Lok Sabha 17. Bills referred to Standing Committees by 8 Chairman/Speaker 18. Bills reported by Standing Committees 8 19. Bills pending at the end of the Sixth Session of 32 Fifteenth Lok Sabha

7 (iii) Private Members’ Bills SUMMARY

1. Bills pending at the end of the last Session 127 2. Bills introduced Nil

3. Bills withdrawn Nil 4. Bills negatived Nil 5. Bills removed from the Register of Pending Bills Nil

6. Bills part discussed 1 7. Bills pending at the end of the Session vide para 127 No. 2329 of Bulletin-Part II, dated 5.1.2011

8 9 aken H. M. Time T Name of Minister and Date when taken up Name of Member of Name who called attention Shri Gurudas Dasgupta Acharia Shri Basudeb Shri Shailendra Kumar 3. CALLING ATTENTION 3. CALLING ` Subject working condition of the Private in the country and Teachers School steps taken by the Government in regard thereto. Listed in the Order Paper on 22.11.2010 16.11.2010, 10.11.2010, 29.11.2010, to 26.11.2010, 1.12.2010 to 3.12.2010, 30.11.2010, 6.12.2010 to 10.12.2010 and 13.12.2010. progress in the bank linkage programme of Self Help Groups and steps taken by the Government in this regard. Listed in the Order Paper on and 15.11.2010. 11.11.2010 of Sugarcane at 325 per quintal and steps taken by the Government in this regard. Listed in the Order Paper on and 15.11.2010. 11.11.2010 Sl. No. 1. *Situation arising out of the pitiable 2. *Situation arising out of lackluster 3. *Need to fix the Minimum Support Price Attention could not be taken up. * Due to interruptions in the House, above Calling 10 atement St aken Taken Action Action T Original — ————— 11 — 22 2 — — — — — tudy Reports Presented Remarks visits undertaken Averagepercentage Tours/Local S of attendance 87.5% — 4. COMMITTEES (i) Financial Committees 2 30 3 77.3% — 2 40 2 sittings M H of No. of Duration constitution 1.05.2010 27.05.2010 1 45 4 5.05.2010 55% 30 0 45% — — Date (2010-11) Public Accounts (i) Committee on i(i) i(i) Sub-Committee (ii) Estimates Undertakings i Sl.No. Name of the Committee 1. Committee on 2. Committee on Public 3. 11 — — — atement St aken Taken Action Action T Original — — 4 —— — — — 2 1 — 1— — —— 5 — 2 — 2 — 10 — tudy Reports Presented Remarks visits undertaken (Local List) Averagepercentage Tours/Local S of attendance 41.01%46.66% — — — 1 —45.16% — —35.19% — 6 — — — — 2 — 2 — — (ii) Standing Committees sittings M. H. of No. of Duration 3 4 5 6 7 891011 constitution 31.08.2010 731.08.2010 2 25 12 31.08.2010 40 1 —31.08.2010 1 —31.08.2010 1 00 1 31.08.2010 — *2 60% 20 1 31.08.200931.08.2010 4 45 2 — 35 6 —31.08.2009 13% 2 — 50 2 40% Date Agriculture Chemicals and Fertilizers and Steel Defence Energy External Affairs Food, Consumer Affairs and Public Distribution Information Technology 2. Meeting and interaction with Mongolian Parliamentary Delegation on 10.12.2010. 1. Committee on 12 2. Committee on 3. Committee on Coal 4. Committee on 6. Committee on 7. Committee on Finance 9. Committee on 5. Committee on 8. Committee on Sl.No. Name of the Committee *1. Meeting and interaction with Lithuanian Parliamentary Delegation on 15.11.2010. 12 2 —— — 2 — — — ———————— — 1———— — — — — 51.72% — 40.32% — 3 456 7 891011 31.08.2010 131.08.2010 — 45 1 31.08.2010 — 1 64%31.08.2010 0 — 2 20 — 31.08.2009 — 2 30 — — 31.08.200931.08.2010 1 2 00 1 45 1 41.3% 48% — — — — — — Petroleum and Natural Gas Railways Development Social Justice and Empowerment Urban Development Water Resources 12. Committee on 13. Committee on Rural 14. Committee on 15. Committee on 16. Committee on 12 10. Committee on Labour 11. Committee on 13 atement St aken Taken Action Action T ———————3 — — — Original 1 — ————————— — 1 2 — — tudy Reports Presented Remarks — — visits undertaken 53.33% — Averagepercentage Tours/Local S of attendance of Duration sittings H. M. 3 456 7 891011 9.06.2010 —23.09.2009 — — 1 — 7.10.2009 1 — 1023.09.2010 73.3% — 3 — — 1 — 23.09.2010 30 1 1 00 60% — Date ofConstitution No. 21.04.2010 1 0 307.10.2010 50% 1 — 1 25 65.8% — (iii) Committees other than Financial and Standing Absence of Members from the Sittings of the House MPLADS (2010-11) Privileges Ethics Private Members' Bills and Resolutions Subordinate Legislation 12 2. House Committee 4. Committee on 5. Committee on 6. Committee on 7. Committee on 3. Committee on 1. Committee on No. Committee Sl.the of Name 14 Memo- Committee considered the 3 randum No. regarding Construction of extension to Parliament House Annexe Building. 1 — ————— — ———————————— ———— — — — — — 57% —— — — The 3 456 7 891011 1.12.200923.09.2009 —19.10.2009 — — —4.08.2009 — — — — — — — 15.10.2009 — — —15.12.2009 1 — 0 40 23.09.2010 1 1 00 60% — Papers Laid on the Table Offices of Profit Committee Installation of Portraits/ of National Statues Leaders and Parliamentarians in Parliament House Complex Food Management in Parliament House Complex Maintenance of Parliament House Heritage Character and Development of Complex 9. Joint Committee on 8. Committee on 12 11. General Purposes 10. Rules Committee 12. Joint Committee on 13. Joint Committee on 14. Joint Committee on 15 The sitting on 15.11.2010 was held to elect the Chairman of the Joint Committee from amongst its Members. 1 — — — 1 — ———— — ————21 — — — — — — 1 — — — 55.56% — 46.6% — 23.09.2009 1 015.03.2010 50 1 33.3% 0 — 50 1.05.2010 1 1 00 50% — 23.09.2010 223.09.2010 2 45 1 36.6% 0 30 — 63.3% — (2010-11) 29.06.2009 115.11.2010 1 0 25 0 53% 45 — Government Assurances Empowerment of Women Salaries and Allowances of Members of Parliament Committee Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Committee 19. Committee on Petitions 21. Railway Convention 18. Committee on 20. Committee on 15. Committee on the 16. Business Advisory 17. Joint Committee on 16 adopted. Motion moved by adopted. Motion moved by adopted. Motion moved by Ayes: 296 Ayes: 298 Final Result Remarks Ayes: 294 Noes: 000Noes: Chidambaram, P. Shri Abst: 000 Abst: Affairs M/o Home Abst: 000 Abst: Affairs M/o Home Abst: 000 Abst: Affairs M/o Home Noes: 001Chidambaram, P. Shri 5. DIVISIONS thirteenth Amendment) Bill, 2010 Consideration thirteenth Amendment) Bill, 2010 thirteenth Amendment) Brief question on which Division was sought Motion for consideration Bill, 2010 Motion for passing of the Constitution of Clause 2 the Constitution Noes: 000Chidambaram, P. Shri the Constitution the thirteenth Amendment)thirteenth Bill, 2010 (One hundred and Constitution (One hundred and Amendment)thirteenth Bill, 2010 (One Constitution (One hundred and hundred and thirteenth Amendment)thirteenth Bill, 2010 (One hundred and Subject-matter Constitution (One hundred and 2. 9.11.2010 3. 9.11.2010 Sl.No. Date 1. 9.11.2010 17 me taken HM 0 01 0 01 0 01 0 01 Ti Supplementary Demands for Excess *Discussion and voting Grants (General) on Supplementary on Demands for Grants (General) *Discussion and voting on Demands for Excess Grants (General) *Discussion and voting on Demand for Grant (Railways) *Discussion and voting on on discussion (I) GENERAL BUDGET 01.12.2010 01.12.2010 BUDGET (II) RAILWAY 02.12.2010 02.12.2010 6. FINANCIAL BUSINESS 15.11.2010 15.11.2010 24.11.2010 24.11.2010 Date of Presentation Date(s) of Date of Presentation ry Demand for Subject Supplementary Demands 2008-09 without discussion. *Voted for Grants (General) for 2010-11 Demands for Excess Grants (General) for 2008-09 Supplementa Grant (Railways) for 2010-11 Demands for Excess Grants (Railways) for 18 26.11.2010 elected 24.11.2010 Date when declared Date of Oath/Affirmation Banka/ Constituency/State 7. MEMBER ELECTED IN BYE-ELECTION Name of Member Smt. Putul Kumari 8. MOTIONS Motions under Rules 191 and 342 SUMMARY No. of notices received : 668 No. of motions admitted : 100 No. of motions discussed : Nil No. of discussions completed : Nil No. of discussions remained : Nil part-discussed Total time taken : Nil

19 20 00 02 Date of26.11.2010 taken Time Language in which Oath/Affirmationmade Oath/AffirmationHindi H. M. Affirmation 9. OATH/AFFIRMATION ate Oath/Affirmation Constituency/St Name of Member Smt. Putul Kumari Banka/Bihar 21 00 05 00 02 H. M. Date of obituaryreferences Time taken 9.11.2010 22.11.2010 } } 3 4 5 1.2010 Death Date of Date 15.08.2010 1.08.2010 5.09.2010 10.10.2010 7.10.2010 15.11.2010 6.1 8.10.2010 10. (i) Obituary References ao M ane (Member, Fourth Lok Sabha) (Member, Lok Sabha) Fifth (Member, (Member, Fourth Lok Sabha) (Member, and Sixth Lok Sabhas) Fifth (Member, Second Lok Sabha) (Member, Lok Sabha) Tenth (Member, Eleventh and Twelfth Tenth, (Member, Lok Sabhas) (Member, Sixth Lok Sabha) (Member, 12 1. Shri N.K. Somani 5. Shri Onkar Lal 7. Pawar Vasant Dr. 8.Amar Pal Singh Shri 2. Shri Ganga Bhakt Singh 4. Shri Shankarr 6. Shri Siddhartha Shankar Ray 3. Shri Lalji Bhai Sl. Name of Member No. 22 00 03 00 02 00 02 10.12.2010 } 3 4 5 5.12.2010 28.11.2010 1.12.2010 1.08.2010 22.11.2010 3.12.2010 (Member, Fourth Lok Sabha) (Member, Seventh Lok Sabha) (Member, (Member, Seventh, Eighth, Ninth and Fourteenth (Member, Lok Sabhas) Lok Sabha) Fifth (Member, 12 9. Shri Mahabir Prasad 11.Meghrajji Shri 12. Shri M. Rajashekara Murthy 10. Shri Shrikishan Modi 23 0 01 0 03 H.M. Time taken 1.2010 9.1 reference } 3 4 5 — — 30.10.2010 15.11.2010 22.11.2010 incident 20.09.2010 Date of Date of Shivpuri district of (ii) References regarding tragic Incidents/Solemn Occasions Madhya Pradesh. people and large scale destruction of property due to cyclone 'Jal' that struct the coastal regions Nadu. Andhra Pradesh and Tamil of capsized in the Hooghly river near Kakdwip South 24 Parganas district of West Bengal drowning about 69 persons. Lalita Park of East Delhi's Laxmi Nagar in which about 70 people were killed and 82 injured. damage to property due to the Tsunami damage to property due the in the Mentawai Islands of Sumatra and eruption of Mount Merapi in Java, Indonesia. to over 160 people in collision of a goods train with Indore-Gwalior Intercity Express at in Badarwas Station 12 3. Reference to a tragic accident in which trawler 5. Reference to collapse of a multi-storey building in 4. Reference to the loss of lives about thirty 1.and Reference to the tragic loss of life 2. Reference to the death of 34 people and injury Sl. Incident No. 24 0 0 01 0 0 02 0 0 01 0 0 01 0 0 01 8.12.2010 — 10.12.2010 3 4 5 — 26.11.2008 26.11.2010 3.12.1984 3.12.2010 7.12.2010 13.12.2001 13.12.2010 anniversary of terrorist attack in Mumbai on 2008. 26th November, that occurred 26 years ago in 1984. and displacement of thousands others Nadu. of Tamil due to heavy rains in the State attack causing death of one infant and injuries to 39 people when a bomb exploded at Sheetla Ghat in Varanasi. Andhra Pradesh in the coastal regions of due to which 14 people were killed and thousands of others displaced. of the terrorist attack on Parliament 2001. House on 13th December, 12 6. Reference on the second 7. Reference to the Bhopal Gas Tragedy 8. Reference to the loss of 170 lives 9. Reference to a cowardly terrorist 11.Anniversary Reference to the Ninth 10. Reference to the unprecedented rains (iii) Congratulatory References/Felicitations

Sl. Incident Date of Date of Time taken No. occasion reference H. M.

1. Reference applauding all the Oct., 10 9.11.10 00 02 71 countries that participated in the Nineteenth Common- wealth Games, 2010 held in New Delhi from 3 to 14 Oct., 2010 and congratulating all the Indian sportsmen and sportswomen for winning 38 gold, 27 silver and 36 bronze medals thereby crowning the country with sporting glory by winning an unprecedented 101 medals. 2. Reference congratulating the Nov., 10 29.11.10 00 01 Indian contingent for its best ever performance of winning 14 gold, 17 silver and 33 bronze medals at the 16th Asian Games, 2010 held in Guangzhou, China in November, 2010. 3. Reference congratulating — 13.12.10 00 01 Saina Nehwal for winning her fourth major International title in the Hong Kong Super Series Badminton Tournament on 12 December, 2010.

25 (iv) References on Landmark Anniversaries and other Occasions

Sl. Incident Date of Date of Time taken No. occasion reference H. M.

1. Relinquishment of Office by 30.09.10 former Secretary-General (Shri P.D.T. Achary) and his appointment as Honorary 9.11.10 00 03 Officer of the House. 2. Appointment of Shri T. K. 1.10.10 } Viswanathan as the new Secretary-General, Lok Sabha. 3. Reference on the occasion of 1.12.10 1.12.10 00 01 World AIDS Day. 4. Reference on the 125th birth 3.12.10 3.12.10 00 01 anniversary of Bharat Ratna Dr. Rajendra Prasad, the first President of India. 5. Reference on the occasion of 3.12.10 3.12.10 00 02 International Day of Persons with Disabilities. 6. Reference on the occasion of 10.12.10 10.12.10 00 01 Human Rights Day.

26 11. PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE

(a) By Government ...... 1679 (b) By Private Members ...... Nil

27 12. QUESTIONS

(i) Starred Questions (a) Number of Questions put down in 480 Question Lists for oral answer (b) Number of Questions orally answered 5 (ii) Short Notice Questions (a) Number of Questions put down in Nil Short Notice Question List (b) Number of Short Notice Questions Nil orally answered (c) Number of Short Notice Questions Nil Laid on the Table of the House (iii) Unstarred Questions (a) Number of Questions put down in 5520 Question Lists for written answers (b) Number of Questions for which written 5995 answers were laid on the Table including those put down for oral answers but were not called for answers.

28 13. RESIGNATION BY MEMBER

Name of Member Constituency State Date on which Remarks accepted by Speaker

Shri Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy Kadapa Andhra Pradesh 29 November, 2010 Resigned on 29 November, 2010. Announcement was made in the House on 3.12.2010. 29 14. RESOLUTION Private Members’ Resolutions SUMMARY 1. No. of notices of Resolutions received : 5 2. No. of Resolutions discussed : Nil 3. No. of Resolutions adopted : Nil 4. No. of Resolutions withdrawn : Nil 5. No. of Resolutions negatived : Nil 6. No. of Resolutions on which debate was adjourned : Nil 7. No. of Resolutions part-discussed : 1

30 15. SHORT DURATION DISCUSSIONS UNDER RULE 193 SUMMARY No. of notices received : 309 No. of discussions admitted : Nil No. of discussions held : Nil No. of discussions completed : Nil No. of discussions remained part-discussed : Nil Total time taken : Nil

31 16. SPEAKER/DEPUTY SPEAKER/CHAIRMAN ANNOUNCEMENTS/ OBSERVATIONS/REFERENCES$/RULINGS Sl. Subject By whom Date No.

1. Announcement regarding cancellation The Deputy 11.11.2010 of sitting of Lok Sabha fixed for Friday, Speaker the 12th November, 2010. 2. Observation regarding appeal to all The Speaker 3.12.2010 sections of the House to allow the Private Members' Business to go on when the House re-assembled at 3.30 P.M. 3. Observation regarding appeal to all The Speaker 10.12.2010 sections of the House to allow the Private Members' Business to be taken up when the House re-assembled at 3.30 P.M. 4. Announcement regarding Internet The Speaker 13.12.2010 facility for the use of Members in the Inner Lobby of Lok Sabha and the same can be availed regularly from the Budget Session.

$ Pl. see Sl. No. 10 for reference.

32 17. SITTINGS OF LOK SABHA

Sl. Subject Date Remarks No.

1. Cancellation of sitting 10.11.2010 On the recommendation of Business fixed for 12th November, Advisory Committee at its sitting held 2010 on 10.11.2010, it was decided to cancel the sitting fixed for Friday, the 12th November, 2010 on account of Chhath festival. Announcement to that effect was made by the Chair on Thursday, the 11th November, 2010, Accordingly, the sitting fixed for Friday, the 12th November, 2010 was cancelled.

33 18. STATEMENTS (i) Statements made/laid by Ministers under Rule 372 during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha

Sl. Brief Subject Name of Minister Date Time Taken No. HM

*1. Regarding recently concluded Dr. M.S. Gill 16.11.2010 00 01 Commonwealth Games, 2010 at New Delhi. *2. Regarding the visit to India by the Shri S.M. Krishna 19.11.2010 00 01 President of the United States of America, Hon'ble Barack H. Obama. *3. Regarding the recent visits abroad Shri S.M. Krishna 19.11.2010 00 01 by Hon'ble Prime Minister. *4. Regarding export of non-basmati Shri Anand Sharma 19.11.2010 00 01 rice to some countries. *5. Correcting the reply given on Shri Pawan Kumar 24.11.2010 00 01 28.7.2010 to Starred Question Bansal No. 48 by Sarvashri Vishwa Mohan Kumar and Ashok Kumar Rawat, M.Ps regarding Flood control and Management and reasons for delay in correcting the reply. *6. Correcting the reply given on Shri Jairam Ramesh 24.11.2010 00 01 10.11.2010 to Starred Question No. 40 by Shri P. Kumar and Dr. Padmasinha Bajirao Patil, M.Ps regarding Environmental Clearance to various Projects. *7. Correcting the reply given on Shri Srikant Jena 25.11.2010 00 01 29.4.2010 to Unstarred Question No. 5628 by Shri Uday Singh, M.P. regarding Allocation of funds to NIPER and reasons for delay in correcting the reply. *8. Correcting the reply given on Shri Pawan Kumar 10.12.2010 00 01 29.11.2010 to Unstarred Question Bansal No. 3107 by Dr. Vivekanand, M.P. ‘ regarding inclusion of Jat community in OBC category.

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English Versions) of the statement.

34 (ii) Statements made/laid by Ministers under Direction 73A of Directions by the Speaker during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha

Sl. Brief Subject Name of Minister Date Time Taken No. HM

12 3 45

*1. Status of implementation of the Shri Sharad Pawar 9.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 3rd Report of the Standing Committee on Food, Consumer Affairs and Public Distribution on Demands for Grants, pertaining to the Department of Consumer Affairs, Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution. *2. Status of implementation of the Shri Mallikarjun 22.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Kharge the 10th Report of the Standing Committee on Labour on Demands for Grants (2010-11). pertaining to the Ministry of Labour and Employment. *3. Status of implementation of the Shri Mullapally 23.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Ramachandran the 144th Report of the Standing Committee on Home Affairs on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Home Affairs. *4. Status of implementation of the Shri Dinsha Patel 23.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 214th and 217th Reports of the Standing Committee on Industry on Demands for Grants (2008-09 and 2010-11, respectively), pertaining to the Ministry of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises. *5. Status of implementation of the Shri Praful Patel 25.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 98th Report of the Standing

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement. 35 36

12 3 45

Committee on Transport. Tourism and Culture on Action Taken by the Government on the recommendations/ observations contained in the 83rd Report on 'Functioning of Commission of Railway Safety', pertaining to the Ministry of Civil Aviation. *6 Status of implementation of the Shri Saugata Roy 26.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 38th Report of the Standing Committee on Urban Development on 'Soild Waste Management', pertaining to the Ministry of Urban Development. *7 Status of implementation of the Prof. K.V. Thomas 30.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 2nd and 4th Reports of the Standing Committee on Food, Consumer Affairs and Public Distribution on Demands for Grants (2009-10 and 2010-11, respectively), pertaining to the Department of Food and Public Distribution, Ministry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution. *8. Status of implementation of the Prof. K.V. Thomas 30.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 6th Report of the Standing Committee on Agriculture on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Department of Agriculture and Cooperation, Ministry of Agriculture. *9. Status of implementation of the Shri Bijoy Krishna 30.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Handique the 145th Report of the Standing Committee on Home Affairs on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Development of North Eastern Region.

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement. 37

12 3 45

*10 Status of implementation of the Shri Pawan Kumar 1.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Bansal the 1st Report on Demands for Grants (2004-05); 14th Report on Demands for Grants (2006- 07); 19th Report on Demands for Grants (2007-08); 31st Report on Demands for Grants (2008-09); and 38th Report on Demands for Grants (2010-11) of the Standing Committee on Personnel, Public Grievances, Law and Justice, pertaining to the Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions. *11. Status of implementation of the Shri Pawan Kumar 1.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Bansal the 206th Report of the Standing Committee on Science and Technology, Environment and Forests on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Department of Space, Ministry of Science and Technology. *12 Status of implementation of the Shri Virbhadra Singh 2.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 3rd Report of the Standing Committee on Coal and Steel on Demands for Grants (2009-10), pertaining to the Ministry of Steel. *13. Status of implementation of the Shri Jitin Prasada 2.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 2nd Report of the Standing Committee on Petroleum and Natural Gas on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas. *14. Status of implementation of the Shri Namo Narain 3.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Meena the 11th Report of the Standing

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement. 38

12 3 45

Committee on Finance on Demands for Grants (2009-10 and 2010-11, respectively), pertaining to the Department of Economic Affairs, Financial Services, Expenditure and Disinvestment, Ministry of Finance. *15. Status of implementation of the Shri Namo Narain 3.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Meena the 12th Report of the Standing Committee on Finance on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Department of Revenue, Ministry of Finance. *16. Status of implementation of the Shri Saugata Roy 3.11.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 6th Report of the Standing Committee on Urban Development on Demands for Grants (2009-10), pertaining to the Ministry of Urban Development. *17. Status of implementation of the Shri M.M. Pallamraju 6.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 1st Report of the Standing Committee on Defence on Demands for Grants (2009-10), pertaining to the Ministry of Defence. *18. Status of implementation of the Prof. K.V. Thomas 7.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 7th Report of the Standing Committee on Agriculture on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries, Ministry of Agriculture. } *19. Status of implementation of the Shri Bijoy Krishna 7.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Handique the 5th Report of the Standing Committee on Coal and Steel on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Mines.

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement. 39

12 3 45

*20. Status of implementation of the Shri Pawan Kumar 7.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Bansal the 6th Report of the Standing Committee on Information Technology on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting. *21. Status of implementation of the Shri Pawan Kumar 8.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Bansal the 2nd Report of the Standing Committee on Water Resources on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Water Resources. *22. Status of implementation of the Shri Pawan Kumar 8.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Bansal the 13th Report of the Standing Committee on Finance on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Planning. *23. Status of implementation of the Shri Virbhadra Singh 9.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 6th Report of the Standing Committee on Coal and Steel on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Steel. *24. Status of implementation of the Shri Pawan Kumar 9.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Bansal the 212th and 215th Reports of the Standing Committee on Industry pertaining to the Department of Heavy Industry, Ministry of Heavy Industries and Public Enterprises. *25. Status of implementation of the Dr. C.P. Joshi 9.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 9th Report of the Standing Committee on Rural Development on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to *Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement. 40

12 3 45

the Department of Rural Development, Ministry of Rural Development. *26. Status of implementation of the Shri Srikant Jena 9.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 2nd Report of the Standing Committee on Chemicals and Fertilizers, pertaining to the Department of Fertilizers, Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers. *27. Status of implementation of the Shri Srikant Jena 9.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 6th Report of the Standing Committee on Chemicals and Fertilizers, on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Department of Fertilizers, Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers. *28. Status of implementation of the Shri Kanti Lal Bhuria 10.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 2nd Report of the Standing Committee on Social Justice and Empowerment on Demands for Grants (2009-10), pertaining to the Ministry of Tribal Affairs. *29. Status of implementation of the Shri Salman 10.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Khursheed the 15th Report of the Standing Committee on Finance on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. *30. Status of implementation of the Shri Salman 10.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Khursheed the 20th Report of the Standing Committee on Finance on Demands for Grants (2009-10), pertaining to the Ministry of Corporate Affairs.

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement. 41

12 3 4 5

*31. Status of implementation of the Shri Srikant Jena 10.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 7th Report of the Standing Committee on Chemicals and Fertilizers on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Department of Pharmaceuticals, Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers. *32. Status of implementation of the Shri Srikant Jena 10.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 8th Report of the Standing Committee on Chemicals and Fertilizers on Demands for Grants (2010-11) pertaining to the Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals, Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers. *33. Status of implementation of the Shri Sultan Ahmed 10.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 140th Report of Standing Committee on Transport, Tourism and Culture on 'Promotion of Tourism in Jammu and Kashmir’ pertaining to the Ministry of Tourism. *34. Status of implementation of the Shri Jyotiraditya M. 13.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in Scindia the 94th Report of the Standing Committee on Commerce on Demands for Grants (2010-11), pertaining to the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Ministry of Commerce and Industry. *35. Status of implementation of the Shri P. Chidambaram 13.12.2010 00 01 recommendations contained in the 142nd Report of the Standing Committee on Home Affairs on implementation of Central Scheme of Modernization of Prison Administration, pertaining to the Ministry of Home Affairs.

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement. (iii) Statements made/laid by Ministers regarding Government business during Sixth Session of Fifteenth Lok Sabha

Sl. No. Brief Subject Name of Minister Date Time Taken H. M.

*1. Government business for the Shri Pawan Kumar 22.11.2010 00 01 week commencing the 22nd Bansal November, 2010. *2. Government business for the Shri Pawan Kumar 26.11.2010 00 01 week commencing the 29th Bansal November, 2010. *3. Government business for the Shri Pawan Kumar 3.12.2010 00 01 week commencing the 6th Bansal December, 2010.

*Laid a copy (Hindi and English versions) of the statement.

42 (iv) MATTERS UNDER RULE 377—Position regarding receipt of replies from Ministries during Fifteenth Lok Sabha (As on 05.01.2011)

Session Total No. of Pending Percentage of Number of replies replies sent to Matters received members by the raised Ministries

First Session (01.06.2009 to 09.06.2009) 37 23 14 62.16 Second Session (02.07.2009 to 07.08.2009) 322 231 91 71.73 Third Session (19.11.2009 to 18.12.2009) 185 130 55 70.27 Fourth Session (22.02.2010 to 07.05.2010) 312 225 87 72.11 Fifth Session (26.07.2010 to 31.08.2010) 276 127 149 46.01 Sixth Session (09.11.2010 to 13.12.2010) 259 32 227 12.35

1391 768 623 55.21

43 (v) Statment Showing the Time Lost Owing to Interrruptions and Adjournment of the House during the Sixth Session of the Fifteenth Lok Sabha Date Time Lost due to Time Lost due to Remarks Interruptions Adjournment of the House following Interruptions H. M. H. M.

12 3 4

10.11.2010 0 03 5 52 At 1101 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1104 hrs. At 1104 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1204 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 11.11.2010 0 04 5 56 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1103 hrs. At 1103 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1200 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1201 hrs. At 1201 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 15.11.2010 — 5 46 At 1107 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1207 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 16.11.2010 0 02 5 52 At 1100 hours., interruptions started and continued up to 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., due to interruptions. House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs.

44 45

12 3 4

At 1206 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 18.11.2010 0 02 5 55 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1203 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 19.11.2010 0 02 5 53 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1205 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 22.11.2010 — 5 53 At 1104 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1203 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 23.11.2010 0 02 5 54 At 1100 hrs., interruptions, started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs. House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1204 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 24.11.2010 0 02 5 55 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1203 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 25.11.2010 0 01 5 57 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1101 hrs. At 1101 hrs. due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1202 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 46

1 2 3 4

26.11.2010 0 01 5 52 At 1104 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1203 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1530 hrs. At 1530 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1531 hrs. At 1531 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 29.11.2010 0 01 5 54 At 1102 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1103 hrs. At 1103 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1203 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 30.11.2010 0 02 5 55 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1203 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 01.12.2010 — 5 43 At 1104 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1213 hrs., due to interruptions House was adjourned for the day. 02.12.2010 0 02 5 48 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1210 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 03.12.2010 0 02 5 47 At 1103 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1104 hrs. At 1104 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. 47

12 3 4

At 1208 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1530 hrs. At 1530 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1531 hrs. At 1531 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 06.12.2010 0 03 5 52 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1103 hrs. At 1103 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1205 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 07.12.2010 0 02 5 53 At 1100 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1205 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 08.12.2010 0 01 5 55 At 1101 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1102 hrs. At 1102 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1203 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 09.12.2010 0 02 5 53 At 1101 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1103 hrs. At 1103 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. At 1204 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 10.12.2010 0 01 5 42 At 1104 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1105 hrs. At 1105 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs. 48

12 3 4

At 1209 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1530 hrs. At 1534 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned for the day. 13.12.2010 0 05 0 53 At 1102 hrs., interruptions started and continued upto 1107 hrs. At 1107 hrs., due to interruptions, House was adjourned to meet again at 1200 hrs.

TOTAL 0 40 124 00 124 40

Time calculated on the basis of normal time of the House i.e. from 11 A.M. to 1 P.M. and from 2 P.M. to 6 P.M. (vi) Statement indicating matters of urgent public importance raised (i) after Question Hour and (ii) before the adjournment of the House for the day during the Sixth Session of the Fifteenth Lok Sabha Date No. of No. of Members Time Taken matters who spoke/ H. M. raised associated 09.11.2010 23 27 1 48 10.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 11.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 15.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 16.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 18.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 19.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 22.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 23.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 24.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 25.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 26.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 29.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 30.11.2010 Nil Nil Nil 01.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 02.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 03.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 06.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 07.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 08.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 09.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 10.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil 13.12.2010 Nil Nil Nil Total 23 27 1 48

49 19. STATEMENT SHOWING TIME TAKEN ON VARIOUS KINDS OF BUSINESS TRANSACTED DURING THE SIXTH SESSION OF FIFTEENTH LOK SABHA

Business Time Taken Percentage of the H. M. Total Time Taken

BILLS Government Bills 01 15 16.48 BUDGETS— (a) Railway Budget 00 02 00.44 (b) General Budget 00 02 00.44 MATTERS OF URGENT PUBLIC IMPORTANCE 01 48 23.74 MATTERS UNDER RULE 377 00 46 10.11 QUESTIONS 01 09 15.16 STATEMENTS— Rule 372 and Direction 73A 00 46 10.11 OTHER MATTERS such as Oath or 01 47 23.52 Affirmation, Papers Laid on the Table, Obituary References, Questions of Privilege, Points of Order, Personal Explanations etc.

Total 07 35 100

50 51 3.12.2010 Remarks Resigned on 29.11.2010 Announcement was made in the House on 29.11.2010 seat became vacant Date on which 20. VACATION OF SEATS 20. VACATION Pradesh Name of Member, Constituency Name of Member, Shri Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy, Shri Y.S. Kadapa, Andhra Kadapa, GIPMR—6110LS—21-2-2011 . and State