Arxiv:1603.00229V2 [Cs.SI] 2 Mar 2016 and Eating Disorders, Has Sustained the Development of Food- Tively

Fetishizing Food in Digital Age: #foodporn Around the World Yelena Mejova and Sofiane Abbar Hamed Haddadi Qatar Computing Research Institute, Qatar Queen Mary University of London, UK fymejova,[email protected] [email protected] Abstract sive, manufacturers have released cameras with specific food mode1, emphasizing the sharpness and saturation of colors. What food is so good as to be considered pornographic? Worldwide, the popular #foodporn hashtag has been used to Such daily food diaries provide an invaluable resource share appetizing pictures of peoples’ favorite culinary experi- for food culturalists and public health professionals. In par- ences. But social scientists ask whether #foodporn promotes ticular, the public sharing of food “pornography” contextu- an unhealthy relationship with food, as pornography would alizes the favorite foods of social media users around the contribute to an unrealistic view of sexuality (Rousseau world. As emotional state (Canetti, Bachar, and Berry 2002) 2014). In this study, we examine nearly 10 million Insta- and social interaction (Christakis and Fowler 2007) have gram posts by 1.7 million users worldwide. An overwhelm- been associated with the healthy weight maintenance, ob- ing (and uniform across the nations) obsession with chocolate taining daily reflections on dietary experience becomes im- and cake shows the domination of sugary dessert over local perative for a holistic view of an individual’s relationship cuisines. Yet, we find encouraging traits in the association of emotion and health-related topics with #foodporn, suggesting with food. The case of #foodporn is especially interesting, food can serve as motivation for a healthy lifestyle. Social ap- given the possibly negative connotations it introduces, per- proval also favors the healthy posts, with users posting with chance promoting an unhealthy relationship with food, as healthy hashtags having an average of 1,000 more followers pornography would contribute to an unrealistic view of sex- than those with unhealthy ones. Finally, we perform a demo- uality (Rousseau 2014). In the United States, for example, graphic analysis which shows nation-wide trends of behavior, the most liked Instagram posts are from donut and cupcake such as a strong relationship (r = 0:51) between the GDP per shops (Mejova et al. 2015). In this work, we seek to find capita and the attention to healthiness of their favorite food. whether such attitudes are common across the world. Our results expose a new facet of food “pornography”, re- vealing potential avenues for utilizing this precarious notion Instagram is a forum highly suitable for such food log for promoting healthy lifestyles. research. We find that a staggering 46% of the nearly 10 million Instagram posts mentioning #foodporn we collected were geo-located – a proportion vastly outnumbering sim- Introduction ilar collection of Twitter posts (which had only 5.8% with Gastro-porn was first coined by Alexander Cockburn in available geo-location data). The 72 countries we examine 1977 in a review of a cookbook: “True gastro-porn height- prove to have a wide range of integration with international ens the excitement and also the sense of the unattainable cuisine. Chocolate, cake, and other heavy foods dominate by proffering colored photographs of various completed the #foodporn conversation, with some nations sporting their recipes” (Cockburn 1977). Since then, the rise of diets and own unhealthy trends with #gordice (in Brazil) and #gour- fitness in the 80s, complemented by the rise in obesity rates mandise (in France), meaning “fat” and “gluttony”, respec- arXiv:1603.00229v2 [cs.SI] 2 Mar 2016 and eating disorders, has sustained the development of food- tively. However, we hesitate equating the #foodporn trend to related media (O’Neill 2003). With such a rich history, it is the effects of non-food pornography. Among the most pop- no surprise the hashtag #foodporn is one of the most popular foods is salad, followed by potentially healthy alterna- ular hashtags on social media, especially visual media such tives of sushi and chicken. Furthermore, the social approval as Instagram, often accompanied with a close-up of a tan- (in terms of likes and comments), as well as user following is talizing dish. In the age of social media, its users are now the highest for hashtags associated with the healthy lifestyle. defining what food “pornography” is to them. Thus, the impact of the study presented below is two-fold: #Foodporn hashtag is part of a vast lifestyle tracking an introduction of a fertile dataset for health research, and trend. “I Ate This” Flickr group, one of the largest and most a case study of a concept’s re-definition, as it is owned and active on the site, hosts over 640K photos that have been explored by the global social media community. contributed by over 40K members. The practice is so perva- Copyright c 2016, Association for the Advancement of Artificial 1http://www.cnet.com/news/what-are-all- Intelligence (www.aaai.org). All rights reserved. those-camera-modes-for-anyway/ Related Works Use of social media for monitoring public health has been Instagood Food Foodporn increasingly popular in the last few years (for a system- 25000 atic review, see (Capurro et al. 2014)). Popular Online So- cial Networks (OSNs) such as Twitter, Instagram, and Face- book, with over a billion users, have become a rich source 15000 for social scientists, psychologists, and health professionals. # of posts A range of behavioral health issues have been studied using OSNs, including depression and mental health (Park et 5000 al. 2015), obesity and diabetes (Abbar, Mejova, and Weber 0 2015), tobacco use (Prier et al. 2011), and insomnia (Paul and Dredze 2011). Complementary to physical activity data and Electronic Health Records (EHRs), social media data 2015−03−242015−03−242015−03−25 00 2015−03−25 12 2015−03−26 00 2015−03−26 12 2015−03−27 00 2015−03−27 12 2015−03−28 00 2015−03−28 12 2015−03−29 00 2015−03−29 12 2015−03−30 00 2015−03−30 12 2015−03−31 00 2015−03−31 12 2015−04−01 00 2015−04−01 12 2015−04−02 00 2015−04−02 12 2015−04−03 00 2015−04−03 12 00 12 provides a record of daily social engagement necessary for a holistic view on individuals’ health (Haddadi et al. 2015). Figure 1: Volume of Instagram posts mentioning #insta- Completing the information cycle, social media has also good, #food, and #foodporn hashtags. been illustrated to be a valuable tool for wellness and health promotion (Neiger et al. 2012a). Despite being in use for over 5 years, Instagram has re- opinions of these experts, in finding the attitudes every-day ceived little attention from the research community. With a social media users associate with this term. rich source of data around the picture posts, including social network of the users, a folksonomy of hashtags (Yamasaki, Data Sano, and Mei 2015), and an association with a hierarchy of locations, it provides a detailed view of individuals’ daily Our main source of data is Instagram, a social platform for lives and habitual activities. Hu et al. (Silva et al. 2013) sharing photo and video content via mobile devices (by de- present a first study of users’ posting behavior on Instagram, sign containing more geo-centric data compared to desktop- showing that food pictures are a major feature of Instagram oriented social sites). Using the Tags endpoint of Instagram posts. In recent work, we associate health-related activity API, we collected all posts containing the keyword #food- captured on Instagram to regional obesity, diabetes and other porn, resulting in a collection spanning 6 Nov 2014 – 6 Apr census statistics in the US (Mejova et al. 2015), finding dis- 2015 containing 9,378,193 posts from all over the world. tinctions between the behavior of users who are more, or To put it in context of other popular streams, we collected less, likely to be healthy. two additional datasets for a smaller overlapping time in- Dietary behavior research calls for a more global view, terval, one to compare to a general food-related conversa- since much of diet-related behavior is cultural (Counihan tion, with hashtag #food (consisting of 1,460,226 posts), and and Van Esterik 2013). As Fischler (Fischler 1988) puts it, similarly to general discussion on Instagram not necessarily by selecting and cooking food, one “transfers nutritional raw about food, with hashtag #instagood (3,368,416 posts). Fig- materials from the state of Nature to the state of Culture”. ure 1 shows the volume of the three streams, which decrease Culture-specific ingredient connections have been discov- with more topical specificity. ered by Ahn et al. (Ahn et al. 2011) who mine recipes to The posts both in large #foodporn dataset and smaller create a “flavor network”. Temporal nature of food con- ones were then geolocated using the World Borders shape sumption has been explored by West et al. (West, White, file2 by converting the (latitude, longitude) pair to the coun- and Horvitz 2013), who mine logs of recipe-related queries. try code from which the post is published. It is worth notice They illustrate the yearly and weekly periodicity in food that the geolocation module returns “None” when the post density of the accessed recipes, with different trends in does not contain geo-coordinates or when they fall close Southern and Northern hemispheres, suggesting a link be- to some disputed/unclear borders. The results of the geo- tween food selection and climate. In this research, we quan- location can be seen in Table 1. The proportion of success- tify the context around the favorite foods of nations around fully located posts increases from #instagood at 28.6%, to the world in terms of perceived healthiness or unhealthiness, #food at 31.6%, and to #foodporn at 42.8%.

Load more