DOCSLIB.ORG

A Narrative of Charitable Acknowledgment: Reframing Interpersonal Communication in Intimate Relationships Cory Williams

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Narrative of Charitable Acknowledgment: Reframing Interpersonal Communication in Intimate Relationships Cory Williams Duquesne University Duquesne Scholarship Collection Electronic Theses and Dissertations 2007 A Narrative of Charitable Acknowledgment: Reframing Interpersonal Communication in Intimate Relationships Cory Williams Follow this and additional works at: https://dsc.duq.edu/etd Recommended Citation Williams, C. (2007). A Narrative of Charitable Acknowledgment: Reframing Interpersonal Communication in Intimate Relationships (Doctoral dissertation, Duquesne University). Retrieved from https://dsc.duq.edu/etd/1365 This Immediate Access is brought to you for free and open access by Duquesne Scholarship Collection. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Duquesne Scholarship Collection. For more information, please contact [email protected]. A NARRATIVE OF CHARITABLE ACKNOWLEDGMENT: REFRAMING INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION IN INTIMATE ROMANTIC RELATIONSHIPS A Dissertation Submitted to the McAnulty School of Liberal Arts Duquesne University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Cory D. Williams December 2007 A NARRATIVE OF CHARITABLE ACKNOWLEDGMENT: REFRAMING INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION IN INTIMATE ROMANTIC RELATIONSHIPS By Cory D. Williams Approved November 30, 2007 __________________________________ __________________________________ Dr. Calvin Troup Dr. Janie Harden Fritz Associate Professor of Communication Associate Professor of Communication and Rhetorical Studies and Rhetorical Studies (Dissertation Director) (Committee Member) __________________________________ Dr. Richard Thames Associate Professor of Communication And Rhetorical Studies (Committee Member) ___________________________________ Dean Albert C. Labriola Dean, McAnulty School of Liberal Arts iii ABSTRACT A NARRATIVE OF CHARITABLE ACKNOWLEDGMENT: REFRAMING INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION IN INTIMATE ROMANTIC RELATIONSHIPS By Cory D. Williams December 2007 Dissertation Supervised by Dr. Calvin Troup No. of Pages in Text: 218 The field of interpersonal communication conducts many descriptive studies. However, guidance for healthy communication within intimate relationships is more difficult to come by—a condition stemming in part from an emotivist ethical paradigm. MacIntyre (1984) describes “emotivism” as the current state of society where individual preference serves as the ethical decision making compass. Emerging from Enlightenment scholarship (e.g., Hobbes, Rousseau, sociobiology), individual preferences have become main tenets in intimate interpersonal research. In the interpersonal theories of social exchange and goal-orientation, emotivism is encouraged in the emphasis placed on self- interest and technique. This exposes itself metaphorically through descriptions of communication as a tool, an economic bartering system, and a means of gaining emotional satisfaction. As a result, communication phenomena such as love and trust in intimate romantic relationships are difficult to express due to the difficulties self- interested language has in moving beyond the dichotomy of egoism and altruism. iv This interpretive study hopes to reinvigorate the philosophical ground for other- focused action in today’s historical moment in regard to the study of interpersonal intimate romantic relationships. To do this, communication must first be interpreted in an active paradigm. Communicative praxis (Schrag, 1986) provides the texture for this shift, describing the subject as decentered, and thus interpreted as multiple, temporal, and embodied. In the embodied connection of word to deed (the act of being to, for, and with the other), ethical conduct can be determined, thus providing ground to pose an interpretive framework for healthy romantic relationships—a narrative of charitable acknowledgment as defined in the work of Hyde, Schrag, and Augustine. The connection between charity and acknowledgment focuses on rhetorical competence, the emphasis on connecting word to deed, and the importance of will and habit. Acknowledgment serves as a hermeneutic to open up charity to a postmodern society on an axiological level, explored through transversal interpretations of faith, hope, and charity. Charitable acknowledgment, then, is the enactment (within a nexus of will, habit, and ethic) of unconditionality, sacrifice, and forgiveness. This approach to romantic relationships opens the door for new research and future discussion on the ethical implications of the narrative shift. v DEDICATION This dissertation is dedicated to my wife and son (to-be). May we continue as wonderfully as we have begun—in charity and love. vi ACKNOWLEDGMENT When a person comes to the end of a project, it is nice to have the opportunity to thank those who have made it possible—in a project with “acknowledgment” in the title it takes even greater meaning. First of all I would like to thank Dr. Calvin Troup for directing this dissertation. His advice helped provide quality and clarity to the project where it might not have otherwise been. Additionally, Dr. Janie Harden Fritz and Dr. Richard Thames provided erudite comments which aided its completion. To those at Concord University who have endured my struggles I am appreciative of their patience. My friends Bryan Kampbell, Erik Garrett, Kelley Crowley, Kristen Lucas, and Sharron Hope provided a boost when morale was low and intellectual vigor when there was a stumbling block. This project was aided by their conversations. My parents also provided that shot in the arm when things were going tough. Most of all however, I want to thank my wife Amy who perhaps more than anyone has empathized with the frustrations and triumphs of these last two and a half years. Her patience and love is what, for me, makes charitable acknowledgment worth discussing. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Abstract.............................................................................................................................. iv Dedication.......................................................................................................................... vi Acknowledgment .............................................................................................................. vii CHAPTER 1: Introduction to the Problem .........................................................................1 CHAPTER 2: A History of Understanding the Fractured Individual ...............................16 Premodern Approaches to the Fractured Individual .............................................18 Plato and Eros............................................................................................19 Aristotle and Reason .................................................................................22 Augustine and Caritas ...............................................................................24 Aquinas and Reasonable Caritas................................................................37 Modern Approaches to the Fractured Individual...................................................39 From Christianity to Humanism ................................................................39 Hobbes and the Enlightenment ..................................................................42 Scientific Maintenance of Self-Interest .....................................................46 Altruism “Discovered” and the Scientific Response .................................48 Postmodern Approaches to the Fractured Individual.............................................51 Derrida and différance ...............................................................................52 Foucault and the Death of Man..................................................................59 Summary................................................................................................................62 CHAPTER 3: Interpersonal Communication and the Egoism/Altruism Dichotomy ........64 MacIntyre and Emotivism......................................................................................65 viii Social Exchange Theory ........................................................................................71 Goal-Oriented Theories.........................................................................................82 Intimacy Skills .......................................................................................................89 Technification and the Disembodied, Dis-embedded IPC Skill ................91 IPC Skills and the Criteria of Satisfaction and Effectiveness....................96 Review of the Narrative of Individualism ...........................................................100 CHAPTER 4: Active Relationships.................................................................................103 A Review of the Lessons of Modernity and Postmodernity................................104 Communication as a Function of Action .............................................................109 Word and Deed........................................................................................111 The Decentered Self.................................................................................120 Summary of Active Relationships in Interpersonal Communication ..................128 CHAPTER 5: The Narrative of Charitable Acknowledgment ........................................134 Acknowledgment in Interpersonal Communication ............................................137 Acknowledgment as Active.....................................................................137 Acknowledgment as
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Rousseau and the Roots of Modernity
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Repozytorium Instytucjonalne Krakowskiej Akademii X: 2013 nr 1 Christopher Lazarski ROUSSEAU AND THE ROOTS OF MODERNITY The general will is always right, but the judgment that guides it is not always enlightened.1 Since Machiavelli, man and woman have become the center of political theory as the sole source and the ultimate sanction of political order. The theoretical order – contemplated by classical Greek philosophy and the Judeo-Christian tradition as the origin, the measure and the limit of political order – was rejected, at first as irre- levant and later on as non-existent. During the Enlightenment, theories of progress, the state of nature, and the social contract replaced the transcendent order. Man and woman were to lift themselves by their own bootstraps from misery and despotism, and usher humanity into a secularized paradise. One summer day in 1749, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, just starting out as a phi- losopher and contributor to the French Encyclopedia, experienced a sudden illumi- nation while walking to Vincennes to visit his incarcerated friend, Denis Diderot (1713–1784). In the Mercure de France, he had found an announcement about an essay contest organized by the Academy of Dijon. “Has the restoration of the sciences and the arts helped to purify morals?” ran the prize question. The powerful inspiration prompted by this question became the starting point for the political theory that Jean-Jacques perfected throughout his life. He challenged the idea of progress, so central to the Enlightenment, and succeeded in placing his concept of omnipotent general will among the canons of enlightened teaching.
    [Show full text]
  • A Comprehensive Framework to Reinforce Evidence Synthesis Features in Cloud-Based Systematic Review Tools
    applied sciences Article A Comprehensive Framework to Reinforce Evidence Synthesis Features in Cloud-Based Systematic Review Tools Tatiana Person 1,* , Iván Ruiz-Rube 1 , José Miguel Mota 1 , Manuel Jesús Cobo 1 , Alexey Tselykh 2 and Juan Manuel Dodero 1 1 Department of Informatics Engineering, University of Cadiz, 11519 Puerto Real, Spain; [email protected] (I.R.-R.); [email protected] (J.M.M.); [email protected] (M.J.C.); [email protected] (J.M.D.) 2 Department of Information and Analytical Security Systems, Institute of Computer Technologies and Information Security, Southern Federal University, 347922 Taganrog, Russia; [email protected] * Correspondence: [email protected] Abstract: Systematic reviews are powerful methods used to determine the state-of-the-art in a given field from existing studies and literature. They are critical but time-consuming in research and decision making for various disciplines. When conducting a review, a large volume of data is usually generated from relevant studies. Computer-based tools are often used to manage such data and to support the systematic review process. This paper describes a comprehensive analysis to gather the required features of a systematic review tool, in order to support the complete evidence synthesis process. We propose a framework, elaborated by consulting experts in different knowledge areas, to evaluate significant features and thus reinforce existing tool capabilities. The framework will be used to enhance the currently available functionality of CloudSERA, a cloud-based systematic review Citation: Person, T.; Ruiz-Rube, I.; Mota, J.M.; Cobo, M.J.; Tselykh, A.; tool focused on Computer Science, to implement evidence-based systematic review processes in Dodero, J.M.
    [Show full text]
  • Descriptive AI Ethics: Collecting and Understanding the Public Opinion
    Descriptive AI Ethics: Collecting and Understanding the Public Opinion GABRIEL LIMA, School of Computing, KAIST and Data Science Group, IBS, Republic of Korea MEEYOUNG CHA, Data Science Group, IBS and School of Computing, KAIST, Republic of Korea There is a growing need for data-driven research efforts on how the public perceives the ethical, moral, and legal issues of autonomous AI systems. The current debate on the responsibility gap posed by these systems is one such example. This work proposes a mixed AI ethics model that allows normative and descriptive research to complement each other, by aiding scholarly discussion with data gathered from the public. We discuss its implications on bridging the gap between optimistic and pessimistic views towards AI systems’ deployment. 1 INTRODUCTION In light of the significant changes artificial intelligence (AI) systems bring to society, many scholars discuss whether and how their influence can be positive and negative [21]. As we start to encounter AI systems in various morally and legally salient environments, some have begun to explore how the current responsibility ascription practices might be adapted to meet such new technologies [19, 33]. A critical viewpoint today is that autonomous and self-learning AI systems pose a so-called responsibility gap [27]. These systems’ autonomy challenges human control over them [13], while their adaptability leads to unpredictability. Hence, it might infeasible to trace back responsibility to a specific entity if these systems cause any harm. Considering responsibility practices as the adoption of certain attitudes towards an agent [40], scholarly work has also posed the question of whether AI systems are appropriate subjects of such practices [15, 29, 37] — e.g., they might “have a body to kick,” yet they “have no soul to damn” [4].
    [Show full text]
  • Moral Education and Authority: a Model for Education That Understands Moral Growth As a Consequence of the Teacher-Learner Relationship
    Moral Education and Authority: A Model for Education that Understands Moral Growth as a Consequence of the Teacher-Learner Relationship By Lisa MacDonald Supervisor: Dr. Andrea English Committee Members: Dr. Donovan Plumb, Dr. Mary Jane Harkins Thesis for Masters of Arts in Educational Foundations Copyright 2014 Lisa MacDonald To my mother and Mary, Table of Contents Abstract ........................................................................................................................................... i Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................... ii Introduction ....................................................................................................................................1 Part I: Forgotten Aspects of Moral Education -- A Theoretical Analysis Chapter 1: The Cultivation of the Good Will J.-J. Rousseau and J.F. Herbart on Education and Morality ..............................................................................................................9 1.1 Rousseau’s Emile and the Development of Amour de Soi-même and Amour-Propre ......10 1.2 Amour de Soi-même Complemented by Amour-Propre Founded on Self-Love, Pity, and Compassion ..............................................................................................................................19 1.3 Johann F. Herbart on Morality as the Whole Purpose of Education .................................24 1.3.1 The Inner Censor as a Key Concept in Moral Education
    [Show full text]
  • An Invitation to Qualitative Research
    CHAPTER 1 An Invitation to Qualitative Research n recent years, binge drinking has caused considerable concern among admin - istrators at colleges and universities, compelled by statistics that show marked Iincreases in such behavior. A qualitative researcher studying this topic would seek to go behind the statistics to understand the issue. Recently, we attended a fac - ulty meeting that addressed the problem of binge drinking and heard concerned faculty and administrators suggest some of the following solutions: • stricter campus policies with enforced consequences • more faculty-student socials with alcohol for those over 21 years old • more bus trips into the city to local sites such as major museums to get students interested in other pastimes Although well-intentioned, these folks were grasping at straws. This is because although they were armed with statistics indicating binge drinking was prevalent and thus could identify a problem, they had no information about why this trend was occurring. Without understanding this issue on a meaningful level, it is diffi - cult to remedy. At this point, we invite you to spend 5 to 10 minutes jotting down a list of questions you think are important to investigate as we try to better under - stand the phenomenon of binge drinking at college. What Is Qualitative Research? The qualitative approach to research is a unique grounding—the position from which to conduct research—that fosters particular ways of asking questions and particular ways of thinking through problems. As noted in the opening dis - cussion of binge drinking in college, the questions asked in this type of research usually begin with words like how, why, or what.
    [Show full text]
  • ROUSSEAU's ENGAGEMENT with AMOUR-PROPRE Peter Fuss
    Canadian Journal of Political and Social TheorylReuue canadienne de theorie politique et sociale. Volume X. Number 3 (Fall/Automne) 1986 . ROUSSEAU'S ENGAGEMENT WITH AMOUR-PROPRE Peter Fuss A number of years ago, while reflecting on the notion of self, I had occasion to wonder to what extent the French expression amour-propre had found its way into North American usage . Several standard American dictionaries had it, though flagged as being a foreign term . The translation given was self- esteem . I tried Larousse's small French-English, which offered two defini- tions : self-pride and self-respect . A considerably larger Cassell's gave four translations : self-love, self-respect, conceit, and vanity . Even this brief immer- sion in the ways of ordinary language was enough to bring out in me the frustrated philosopher, with his passion for making distinctions : Are self- esteem, self-love, and self-respect fundamentally the same things? And do any or all of these compounds amount or reduce to uncompounded conceit or vanity? Or is it that amour-propre is complicated, ambiguous, perhaps even in some sense "dialectical," so that self-respect and vanity mark out, respectively, its polar extremes? Lacking sufficient self-esteem (or is it conceit?) simply to retire to my study and think this through on my own, I cast about for inspiration . It took a while to find some . The passions and affections in general are not traditionally among the preferred subjects of the philosophical mainliners, who seem to have a distinctive passion of their own for quarreling about the so-called higher, more noetic human faculties .
    [Show full text]
  • CH 01 Study Guide
    Okami Study Guide: Chapter 1 1 Chapter in Review 1. Psychology is the scientific study of mental processes and events (mind) and any potentially observable or measureable activity of a living organism (behavior). Psychological science uses methods grounded in modern scientific knowledge to conduct research in order to advance psychological knowledge. Variable topics and points of view characterize psychology. 2. Although people have always been interested in questions of mental life and the connection between mind and behavior, psychology as a concept did not exist in the ancient world. Early attempts to treat psychological questions include the teachings of Buddha, Aristotle, Chinese philosophers such as Confucius and Lao- tze, and Renaissance philosophers such as René Decartes (dualism) and John Locke (British empiricism). 3. Scientific psychology was born during the late 19th century as a union between philosophy and biology. Some important early schools of scientific psychology include structuralism (Titchener), functionalism (James), psychoanalysis (Freud), behaviorism (Watson, Skinner), and humanism (Rogers, Maslow). 4. Psychology today is distinguished by employment setting (university, hospital, business, clinic) and focus (research or application of research to solving real- world problems); by the psychologist’s field of study (e.g., developmental psychology, clinical psychology, cognitive psychology, etc.); and by the psychologist’s perspective, or point of view. Contemporary perspectives include cognitive, biobehavioral, psychodynamic, evolutionary, sociocultural, and positive psychology. 5. Science is an empirical method of gaining knowledge of the natural world. It is not the only empirical method of gaining this knowledge, but it is the best one. This is because science is less prone to bias than other methods, has built-in methods to change errors in thinking, and constantly refines knowledge gained in the past.
    [Show full text]
  • Phenomenology: a Philosophy and Method of Inquiry
    Journal of Education and Educational Developement Discussion Phenomenology: A Philosophy and Method of Inquiry Sadruddin Bahadur Qutoshi Karakorum International University, Pakistan [email protected] Abstract Phenomenology as a philosophy and a method of inquiry is not limited to an approach to knowing, it is rather an intellectual engagement in interpretations and meaning making that is used to understand the lived world of human beings at a conscious level. Historically, Husserl’ (1913/1962) perspective of phenomenology is a science of understanding human beings at a deeper level by gazing at the phenomenon. However, Heideggerian view of interpretive-hermeneutic phenomenology gives wider meaning to the lived experiences under study. Using this approach, a researcher uses bracketing as a taken for granted assumption in describing the natural way of appearance of phenomena to gain insights into lived experiences and interpret for meaning making. The data collection and analysis takes place side by side to illumine the specific experience to identify the phenomena that is perceived by the actors in a particular situation. The outcomes of a phenomenological study broadens the mind, improves the ways of thinking to see a phenomenon, and it enables to see ahead and define researchers’ posture through intentional study of lived experiences. However, the subjectivity and personal knowledge in perceiving and interpreting it from the research participant’s point of view has been central in phenomenological studies. To achieve such an objective, phenomenology could be used extensively in social sciences. Keywords: descriptive nature, interpretative nature, method of inquiry, phenomenology, philosophy Introduction Phenomenology as a philosophy provides a theoretical guideline to researchers to understand phenomena at the level of subjective reality.
    [Show full text]
  • Knowledge Organization at the Interface
    Gustavo Saldanha – Ibict - Unirio, Brazil Giulia Crippa – Bologna University, Italy Concept Theory and Conceit Theory Ontology and Logology Between Conceptuality and Non- Conceptuality in Knowledge Organization Abstract: Knowledge Organization (KO) has a historically established construction based on a concept theory according to the Aristotelian model. It is from the Organon that the primary theoretical basis of documentary-language thinking is established. One can identify the construction of conceptual thinking in classical approaches such as Ranganathan's classification theory. More directly, Dahlberg's theory of concept proves the demarcating point of view of the Aristotelian foundation in KO. However, even in such approaches as Ranganathan's, one can also identify another theoretical tradition in classification theory concerned with constructing a non- conceptual approach. It is from Emanuele Tesauro that we can conceive a non-conceptual theory, establishing a given conceit theory. This research aims to point out the dichotomies and correlations between a concept theory and a non-conceptual one in KO. The research method is theoretical, structured from the perspective of a historical epistemology with a pragmatic background. At first, the historical-theoretical place of concept theory in the KO is determined. Later, the foundation of a non-conceptual theory (or conceit theory) is identified. Furthermore, the relationship between theories in historical and contemporary development in the classification theory is discussed. From the Aristotelian categories, one can understand a method for the relationship between signifier, meaning, and referent, and establish the associations of meaning between terms. The non-conceptuality theory can be historically identified in Emanuele Tesauro. From his Categorical Index, published in the Cannocchiale aristotelico, the condition of concept (and no-concept) is the apex of a variety of chain of rhetorical being, and it points to the creation and progressive unfolding of language figures (conceit elements).
    [Show full text]
  • Rousseau and the Ancients Rousseau Et Les Anciens
    , ". Rousseau and the Ancients Rousseau et les Anciens edited by SODS la direction de Ruth Grant & Philip Stewart Pen see Libre N° 8 CANADIAN CATALOGING DONNEESDECATALOGAGE IN PUBLICATION DATA AVANT LA PUBLICATION Main entry under title: Vedette principale au titre: Rousseau and the Ancients Rousseau et les Anciens (Pensee Libre: no. 8) (Pensee Libre: no. 8) Text in French and English Texte en fram;:ais et en anglais. Includes bibliographical references Comprend des references bibliographiques ISBN 0-9693132-7-6 ISBN 0-9693132-7-6 1. Rousseau, Jean-Jacques, 1712- 1. Rousseau, Jean-Jacques, 1712- 1778. 1. Grant, Ruth. II. Stewart, 1778. J. Grant, Ruth. II. Stewart, Philip. III. North American Asso­ Philip. III. Association nord­ ciation for the Study of Jean­ americaine des etudes Jean­ Jacques Rousseau IV. Title: Jacques Rousseau. IV. Titre: Rousseau and the Ancients. Rousseau et les Anciens. V. Series V. Collection The publication of this volume was made possible by cooperation of the North American Association for the Study of Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Duke University and Wabash College. Ouvrage publie grace au concours d l'Association nord-americaine des etudes Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Duke University et Wabash College. ISBN 0-9693132-7-6 © North American Association for the Study of Jean-Jacques Rousseau! Association nord-americaine des etudes Jean-Jacques Rousseau, 200 I. Collection Pensee Libre dirigee par Melissa Butler Pensee Libre series editor: Melissa Butler Imprime aux Btats Un is Printed in the United States Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Bernard Lamy: the Platonic education of amour-propre In the Confessions, Rousseau acknowledged his debt to the Oratorian father, Bernard Lamy.
    [Show full text]
  • Scientometrics and Key Performance Indications
    Scientometrics and key performance indicators What is scientometrics • “quantitative study of science, communication in science, and science policy” (Hess, 1997) • Is concerned with the quantitative features and characteristics of science and research • Is the field of study which concerns measuring and analysing scientific literature • Scientometrics is a sub-field of bibliometrics • Focused on the analysis of publications • The scientific and empirical study of science and its outcomes Research issues in scientometrics • measurement of the impact of research papers and academic journals, • the understanding of scientific citations, • the use of the measurements in policy and management contexts Allow • institutional productivity comparisons • institutional research rankings, • journal rankings • establish faculty productivity and position standards, • assess the influence of top scholarly articles, • profiles of top authors and institutions in terms of research performance Indexes (1): impact factor • The IF of an academic journal is a measure reflecting the yearly average number of citations to recent articles published in that journal. • Is frequently used as a proxy for the relative importance of a journal within its field: journals with higher impact factors are often deemed to be more important than those with lower ones. • was devised by the founder of the Institute for Scientific Information (ISI). Indexes (2): Science Citation Index • Introduced in 1979 by Garfield • The SCI is a citation index originally produced by the Institute
    [Show full text]
  • Taming Amour-‐‑Propre
    Taming Amour-Propre: A Study of Book IV of Rousseau's Emile by Antong Liu Department of Political Science Duke University Date: _________________ Approved: ___________________________ Ruth W. Grant, Supervisor ___________________________ Michael A. Gillespie ___________________________ Thomas A. Spragens, Jr. Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Department of Political Science in the Graduate School of Duke University 2014 ABSTRACT Taming Amour-Propre: A Study of Book IV of Rousseau's Emile by Antong Liu Department of Political Science Duke University Date: _________________ Approved: ___________________________ Ruth W. Grant, Supervisor ___________________________ Michael A. Gillespie ___________________________ Thomas A. Spragens, Jr. An abstract of a thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in the Department of Political Science in the Graduate School of Duke University 2014 Copyright by Antong Liu 2014 Abstract Amour-propre is a crucial concept of Rousseau's philosophy. Although recent studies have confirmed its moral ambiguity, they paid insufficient attention to Rousseau's account of amour-propre in his Emile and thus failed to appreciate the method Rousseau proposes therein to tame Emile's amour-propre. By close textual examinations of Emile, especially of the first part of its Book IV, this paper analyzes the moral ambiguity of amour-propre and Rousseau's remedy for its almost inevitable inflammation. Rather than eliminating amour-propre, the education of Emile aims at preventing his innocuous amour-propre from being inflamed. This at first requires that a cosmopolitan type of friendship be cultivated in Emile's heart so as to further cultivate his pity.
    [Show full text]