Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents

Monday, August 9, 2004 Volume 40—Number 32 Pages 1395–1500

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:51 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00001 Fmt 1249 Sfmt 1249 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUF4.006 P32AUF4 Contents

Addresses and Remarks Addresses and Remarks—Continued See also Bill Signings UNITY: Journalists of Color Convention and Intelligence reform—1423 a question-and-answer session—1477 Iowa, Davenport—1435 West Virginia, Cabela’s Retail Store in Michigan Triadelphia—1417 Grand Rapids, remarks—1395 Saginaw, remarks—1471 Bill Signings Minnesota Department of Defense Appropriations Act, Conservation Reserve Program in Le 2005 Sueur—1442 Remarks—1451 Mankato, remarks—1445 Statement—1453 New Hampshire, Stratham—1488 United States-Australia Free Trade Ohio Agreement Implementation Act, remarks— Cambridge, remarks—1410 1429 Canton, remarks—1403 Columbus, discussion—1454 Communications to Congress International Children’s Games and China, letter on export of certain items—1497 Cultural Festival in Cleveland—1401 Department of Defense Appropriations Act, Pennsylvania, Pittsburgh—1417 2005, letter on designation of emergency Radio address—1402 funds—1454 Texas, Knights of Columbus Convention in District of Columbia’s fiscal year 2005 budget Dallas—1430 request, letter transmitting—1471

(Continued on the inside of the back cover.)

Editor’s Note: The President was in Kennebunkport, ME, on August 6, the closing date of this issue. Releases and announcements issued by the Office of the Press Secretary but not received in time for inclusion in this issue will be printed next week.

WEEKLY COMPILATION OF Distribution is made only by the Superintendent of Docu- PRESIDENTIAL DOCUMENTS ments, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402. The Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents will be furnished by mail to domestic subscribers for $80.00 per year Published every Monday by the Office of the Federal Reg- ($137.00 for mailing first class) and to foreign subscribers for ister, National Archives and Records Administration, Washing- $93.75 per year, payable to the Superintendent of Documents, ton, DC 20408, the Weekly Compilation of Presidential Docu- Government Printing Office, Washington, DC 20402. The ments contains statements, messages, and other Presidential charge for a single copy is $3.00 ($3.75 for foreign mailing). materials released by the White House during the preceding The Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents is also week. available on the Internet on the GPO Access service at http:// The Weekly Compilation of Presidential Documents is pub- www.gpo.gov/nara/nara003.html. lished pursuant to the authority contained in the Federal Reg- ister Act (49 Stat. 500, as amended; 44 U.S.C. Ch. 15), under There are no restrictions on the republication of material regulations prescribed by the Administrative Committee of the appearing in the Weekly Compilation of Presidential Docu- Federal Register, approved by the President (37 FR 23607; ments. 1 CFR Part 10).

VerDate May 21 2004 12:06 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00002 Fmt 1249 Sfmt 1249 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUF4.006 P32AUF4 Contents—Continued

Communications to Congress—Continued Notices Export control regulations, letter transmitting Continuation of Emergency Regarding Export notice on continuation of emergency—1496 Control Regulations—1496 Communications to Federal Agencies Supplementary Materials Waiving Prohibition on United States Military Assistance With Respect to the Republic of Acts approved by the President—1499 the Congo, memorandum—1496 Checklist of White House press releases— 1499 Interviews With the News Media Digest of other White House Exchange with reporters in the Rose announcements—1497 Garden—1423 Nominations submitted to the Senate—1498

VerDate May 21 2004 13:13 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00003 Fmt 1249 Sfmt 1249 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUF4.006 P32AUF4 Week Ending Friday, August 6, 2004

Remarks in Grand Rapids, Michigan important reason of all is so that Laura will be First Lady for 4 more years. July 30, 2004 I want to thank Juan Olivarez for his lead- The President. Thank you all. I appreciate ership of this very important institution. I ap- you coming. Sit down if you’ve got a chair. preciate a fellow Tejano serving the commu- I’m proud you’re here. Thanks for inviting nity of Grand Rapids—that means a fellow me. You can’t come to Grand Rapids and Texan. [Laughter] I appreciate his warm words of introduction. Gracias, amigo. not think about a great President, Gerald Ford. What a decent man. What an honor- I appreciate Hoekstra—Peter Hoekstra for able citizen. And what a great example for his service in the United States Congress. I’m Presidents. proud to call him friend. And I appreciate my friend Vern Ehlers’ service to the people I appreciate you coming out for our Heart of Michigan in the United States Congress and Soul of America tour. This is going to as well. be a great campaign. I’m looking forward to I’m honored that Terri Lynn Land and it. And there’s going to be big differences. Mike Cox and Ken Sikkema are with us We’ll have differences over taxes, how to today. I’ve gotten to know these good souls keep the peace. And there seems to be a dif- during my trips here in Michigan. And they ference over the heart and soul of America. represent the State well. I appreciate Speak- My opponents think you can find it in Holly- er Rick Johnson joining us as well; State Sen- wood. I think you find it right here in Grand ator Bill Hardiman. I’m honored that these Rapids, Michigan. good citizens have decided to serve the peo- I’m excited about traveling the country. I ple of the communities in the great State of was in Springfield, Missouri, earlier. I’m Michigan. I thank them for the hard work going to Cleveland, Ohio; Canton, Ohio; on they have done and are going to do to make to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, tomorrow. I like sure we carry the State of Michigan this time. traveling. I like being with people. The I want to thank my friend Betsy DeVos crowds are big. The enthusiasm is high. And and Chuck Yob and Holly Hughes and the with your help, Dick Cheney and I will serve ambassador, Peter Secchia. I want to—does this Nation for 4 more years. it strike anybody funny, ‘‘Ambassador’’ Speaking about my friend Dick Cheney, Secchia? No? [Laughter] We love him in our I admit, he’s not the prettiest face in the race. family. [Laughter] But I picked him because he’s I want to thank all the grassroots activists steady and strong and reliable. He’s got good who are here. I appreciate your willingness judgment. Dick Cheney is a great Vice Presi- to work in the political process. I encourage dent. you to get people to register to vote. Make And speaking about really fine people, I sure people go to vote on election day. We am sorry that Laura is not here. have a duty in our society—in our democratic Audience members. Aw-w-w! system, we have a duty to participate. And The President. I know it. [Laughter] Most I want to thank you for getting people to par- people feel that way. They wish she were ticipate. And when you get them headed into speaking and I stayed at home. [Laughter] the polls, give them a little nudge our way. But I’m really proud of her. She is a great [Laughter] lady, a fantastic First Lady. I’m going to give Every incumbent who asks for the vote has you some reasons why I think you need to got to answer one central question, and that’s put me back in office, but perhaps the most why—why should the American people give 1395

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00001 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1396 July 30 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

me the privilege, the high privilege, of serv- didn’t pay for them. Leaders in both political ing as your President for 4 more years? In parties had promised prescription drug cov- the past few years, we’ve been through a lot erage for years. We got it done. Already, together, and we have accomplished a great more than 4 million seniors have signed up deal. But there’s only one reason to look for drug discount cards that provide real sav- backward at the record, and that is to deter- ings. And beginning in 2006, all seniors on mine who will lead the Nation forward, who Medicare will be able to choose a plan that can do the job for the American people. I’m suits their needs and gives them coverage for asking for your vote because so much is at prescription drugs. stake. We have much more to do to move We’ve expanded community health cen- this country forward. ters for low-income Americans. We’ve cre- I want to be your President for 4 more ated health savings accounts so families can years to make our country safer, to make our save tax-free for their own health care needs. economy stronger, to make the future better When it comes to giving Americans more and brighter for every single citizen who lives choices about their own health care and mak- in this country. From creating jobs to im- ing health care more affordable, we are turn- proving schools, from fighting terror to pro- ing the corner, and we’re not turning back. tecting our homeland, we’ve made much Most Americans get their health coverage progress, and I’m here to tell you, we have through their work. But today’s new jobs are got more to do. created by small businesses, which too often We have more to do to make America’s cannot afford to provide health coverage. To public schools the centers of excellence we help more American families get health in- know they can be so that no child is left be- surance, we must allow small employers to hind in this country. When we came to office join together to purchase insurance at the 31⁄2 years ago, too many children were being discounts available to big corporations. shuffled from grade to grade, year after year, To improve health care, we must limit the without learning the basics. So we’ve chal- frivolous lawsuits that raise health care costs lenged the soft bigotry of low expectations. and drive doctors out of medicine. We will We’re setting high standards. We’re focusing do more to harness technology to reduce on results. We’re insisting on accountability. costs and prevent health care mistakes. We We’re empowering parents. And we’re mak- will do more to expand research and seek ing sure local folks are in charge of their own new cures for terrible diseases. And in all public schools. And today, children across we do to improve health care in America, America are showing real progress in reading we will make sure that health decisions are and math. When it comes to improving made by doctors and patients, not by bureau- America’s public schools, we are turning the crats in Washington, DC. corner, and we are not turning back. We have more to do to make America’s We have more to do. This world of ours economy stronger. We’ve come through a lot is changing. Jobs of the future will require together. We’ve come through a recession greater knowledge and higher skill levels. We and terrorist attacks and corporate scandals. must reform our high schools to make sure We overcame these obstacles because the a high school diploma means something. We hard work of the American people, because will expand math and science education so the entrepreneurial spirit is strong, because young people can compete in a high-tech people like our farmers and ranchers refuse world. We will expand the use of the Internet to buckle. We overcame these obstacles as to bring high-level training into classrooms. well because of two well-timed tax cuts. We With 4 more years, we will help a rising gen- didn’t—when we provided tax relief, we eration gain the skills and confidence to didn’t try to pick winners or losers. We didn’t achieve the American Dream. play politics. We did it the fair way. We pro- We have more to do to make quality health vided tax relief to every American who pays care available and affordable. When we came taxes—for families with children, for married to office, too many older Americans could couples, for small businesses. And this time, not afford prescription drugs, and Medicare the check was really in the mail.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00002 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 30 1397

Because we acted, our economy since last Over the next 4 years, we’ll offer American summer has grown at a rate as fast as any workers a lifetime of learning and help them in nearly 20 years. Because we acted, Amer- get training for the jobs of the future at ica has added more than 1.5 million new jobs places like our community colleges. The edu- since last August. We still face serious chal- cation and training community colleges offer lenges, especially in places like western can be the bridge between people’s lives as Michigan, where the slowdown hit hard. I they are and people’s lives as they want them understand that. That’s why I’m going to to be. keep working to help all sectors of our econ- Today I met Sarah Soles. She used to work omy recover. We will not rest until every as a part-time receptionist at a doc’s office. American who wants to work can find a job. She went back to a community college pro- The cornerstone of our tax relief plan was gram. She’s now a nurse. She makes more help for small businesses. Most new jobs in money at steady employment because she America are created by entrepreneurs in found time to get more training and to get small businesses. Today I met Bob Roth a new degree. The community college system again. He runs a manufacturing company. He of America is vital in making sure America told me that business in this part of the coun- is a competitive place in the world. try is turning around, that people are begin- To make sure we continue to grow our ning to add jobs. As a matter of fact, his small economy and people can find work, we will business hired nine workers in the past year. insist on a level playing field when it comes He tells me the reason why is because he to trade. This country can compete with any- is confident about what tax relief means. He body, anytime, anywhere with free and fair says, ‘‘We’ll take fair advantage of any relief trade. And we will help American families that is possible. It helps us feel more con- keep more of something they never have fident about investing.’’ The small-business enough of, and that’s time—time to play with sector of the country is leading the growth the kids, time to go to the little league game, for new jobs in America. time to take care of their parents, or to go We can do more to make America more to class to improve themselves. I believe that job-friendly and America’s workplaces more Congress must enact comp-time and flex- family-friendly. To keep American jobs in time to help America’s families better juggle America, regulations must be minimal, rea- the demands of work and home. sonable, and fair. To keep American jobs After 4 more years, our Nation will have here, we must lessen our dependence on for- more small businesses. The entrepreneurial eign sources of energy. To keep American spirit will be strong. There will be greater jobs here, we must end the junk lawsuits that opportunity and better and higher wages for hurt small businesses. To keep American jobs the American workers. in America, we will not overspend your We have more to do to wage and win the money, and we will keep your taxes low. war against terror. America’s future depends I met Audra and Brian van Haren. They’re on our willingness to lead in the world. If here today. These good folks saved about America shows uncertainty and weakness in $2,500 on their taxes in 2003, and they’re this decade, the world will drift toward trag- going to save another 2,500 on their taxes edy. This will not happen on my watch. in 2004. That’s what the tax relief provided. Audience members. Four more years! It’s their own money to begin with, by the Four more years! Four more years! way. It’s not like—we’re not passing the Gov- The President. The world changed on a ernment’s out. These people worked hard for terrible September morning. And since that that money. They can spend it better than day, we have changed the world. Before Sep- the Government can spend their money. tember the 11th, Afghanistan served as the Some of the tax relief is set to expire, which home base of Al Qaida, which trained and means they’ll have to pay $1,100 more in deployed thousands of killers to set up ter- taxes next year. Now is not the time to be rorist cells in dozens of countries, including raising taxes on the working people of this our own. Today, Afghanistan is a rising de- country. mocracy, an ally in the war on terror, a place

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00003 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1398 July 30 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

where many young girls now go to school demanded a full accounting of Saddam Hus- for the first time, and America and the world sein’s weapons programs or he will face seri- are safer. ous consequences. After 12 years of defiance, Before September the 11th, Pakistan was he again refused to comply. When he contin- a safe transit point for terrorists. Today, Paki- ued to deceive the weapons inspectors, I had stani forces are aggressively helping to round a decision to make: forget the lessons of Sep- up the terrorists. They’re an ally in the war tember the 11th and trust a madman, or de- on terror, and America and the world are fend the United States of America. Given safer. that choice, I will defend our country every Before September the 11th, in Saudi Ara- time. Saddam Hussein sits in a prison cell; bia, terrorists were raising money and re- America and the world are safer. cruiting and operating with little opposition. When it comes to fighting the threats of Today, the Saudi Government has taken the our world and spreading peace, we’re turning fight to Al Qaida, and America and the world the corner, and we’re not turning back. We are safer. have more to do. We will continue to work Before September the 11th, Libya was with friends and allies around the world to spending millions to acquire weapons of mass aggressively pursue the terrorist enemy and destruction. Today, because America and our the foreign fighters in Iraq and Afghanistan allies have sent a strong and clear message, and elsewhere. See, you can’t talk sense to the leader of Libya has abandoned his pursuit them. You cannot negotiate with the terror- of weapons of mass destruction, and America ists. They’re coldblooded killers. We must and the world are safer for it. engage the enemy so we do not have to face Before September the 11th, the ruler of them here at home. Iraq was a sworn enemy of America. He was We will continue to lead the world with defying the world. He was firing weapons at confidence and moral clarity. We put to- American pilots who were enforcing the gether a strong coalition to help us defeat world’s sanctions. He had pursued and used terror. There are nearly 40 nations involved weapons of mass destruction against his own in Afghanistan, some 30 nations involved in people. He harbored terrorists. He invaded Iraq. I’ll continue to build alliances and work his neighbors. He subsidized the families of with our friends for the cause of security and suicide bombers. He murdered tens of thou- peace, but I will never turn America’s na- sands of his own citizens. He was a source tional security decisions over to leaders of of great instability in the world’s most volatile other nations. region. He was a threat. We will keep our commitments to help Af- After September the 11th, we had to look ghanistan and Iraq become peaceful, demo- at threats in a new light. The lesson of Sep- cratic societies. These two nations are now tember the 11th was, we must take threats governed by strong leaders, people com- seriously before they fully materialize. The mitted to freedom. People in Afghanistan September the 11th Commission concluded and Iraq are stepping up for their own secu- that our institutions of Government had rity. They’re willing to step up and to fight failed to imagine the horror of that day. After those who want to stop the advance of a free September the 11th, we could not fail to society. You know why? Because they want imagine that a brutal tyrant who hated Amer- their children to grow up in a peaceful world. ica, had ties to terror, had used weapons of Moms and dads in Iraq and Afghanistan have mass destruction, might use those weapons great hopes for their children. They want or share his deadly capabilities with the ter- them to be educated. They want them to re- rorists. We saw a threat. We looked at the alize their dreams. The people of those coun- intelligence and saw a threat. The United tries, the freedom-lovers in those two coun- States Congress—members of both political tries, can count on continued help from parties, including my opponent—looked at America and our coalition. the intelligence, and they saw a threat. You see, when we acted to protect our own The United Nations looked at the intel- security, we promised to help deliver them ligence, and it saw a threat and unanimously from tyranny, to restore their sovereignty,

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00004 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 30 1399

and to set them on the path of liberty. And to the world; freedom is the Almighty God’s when America gives its word, America keeps gift to each man and woman in this world. its word. We are turning the corner toward a more In these crucial times, America’s commit- peaceful world that we long for, and we’re ments are kept by the men and women of not turning back. our military. At bases across the country and We have more to do to protect our coun- the world, I’ve had the privilege of meeting try. Enemies who hate us are still plotting with those who defend our country and sac- to harm us; this is still a dangerous time. I rifice for our security. I’ve seen their great agree with the conclusion of the September decency and their unselfish courage. Ladies 11th Commission: Our homeland is safer, but and gentlemen, the cause of freedom is in we’re not yet safe. We’ve started the hard really good hands. process of reform. We’ve transformed our And we must make sure they have the full defenses. We’re creating a new Depart- support of the Federal Government. And ment—we have created a new Department that’s why last September, while our troops of Homeland Security. We passed the PA- were in combat in Afghanistan and Iraq, I TRIOT Act to give law enforcement tools proposed supplemental funding to support needed to track and bring terrorists to jus- our military in their missions. The legislation tice. The mission of the FBI is now focused provided funding for body armor and vital on preventing terrorism. We’ve integrated in- equipment, for hazard pay, for health bene- telligence and law enforcement better than fits, ammunition, fuel, and spare parts. In the we ever have before. When it comes to better Senate, only a very small, what I would call protecting America, we’re turning the cor- out-of-the-mainstream minority of 12 Sen- ner, and we’re not turning back. ators voted against the legislation. Two of There’s more to do to better secure our those twelve Senators are my opponent and ports and borders, to train first-responders, his runningmate. to dramatically improve our intelligence- Audience members. Boo-o-o! gathering capabilities. Reform won’t be easy; The President. Senator Kerry tried to ex- it never is in Washington. See, achieving it plain his vote by saying this: ‘‘I actually did requires taking on the entrenched interests vote for the $87 billion, before I voted against and challenging the status quo. It’s not it.’’ [Laughter] End quote. [Laughter] He’s enough to advocate reform; you have to be had different explanations since then. He able to get it done—— said that he was proud that he and his Audience member. Right! runningmate voted against the funding, then The President. ——because when it he further said, ‘‘The whole thing is a com- comes to reforming schools to provide an ex- plicated matter.’’ [Laughter] There’s nothing cellent education for all our children, results complicated about supporting our troops in matter. When it comes to health care reforms combat. to give families more access and more In the long run, our security is not guaran- choices, results matter. When it comes to im- teed by force alone. We will work to change proving our economy and creating quality the conditions that give rise to terror: poverty jobs, results matter. When it comes to better and hopelessness and resentment. A free and securing the homeland and fighting the peaceful Iraq, a free and peaceful Afghani- forces of terror, results matter. When it stan will be powerful examples in a neighbor- comes to choosing a President, results mat- hood that is desperate for freedom. Free ter. countries do not export terror. Free countries This week, members of the other political are peaceful countries. Free countries do not party gathered in Boston. There was a lot stifle the dreams of their citizens. of clever speeches and some big promises. By serving the ideal of liberty, we’re bring- Listen, my opponent has got good intentions, ing hope to others, and that makes America but intentions don’t always translate to re- more secure. By serving the ideal of liberty, sults. After 19 years in the U.S. Senate, my we’re living out the ideals of this country. opponent has thousands of votes but few sig- America knows that freedom is not our gift nature achievements. During 8 years on the

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00005 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1400 July 30 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Senate Intelligence Committee, he voted to based on this basic conviction: The role of cut the intelligence budget, yet he had no Government is not to control or dominate record of reforming America’s intelligence- the lives of our citizens; the role of Govern- gathering capability. He’s had no significant ment is to help our citizens gain the time record for reforming education or health and tools to make their own choices and im- care. In fact, he and his runningmate consist- prove their own lives. ently opposed reforms that limit the power And that’s why I’m working to usher in of Washington, reforms that would leave a new era of ownership and opportunity in more power in the hands of the people. America. We want more people owning their My opponent has spent 20 years in the own homes. We want more people owning Federal Government, and it appears he’s their own small business. We want more peo- concluded it’s not big enough. [Laughter] ple owning a piece of their retirement plans. He’s proposed more than $2 trillion of addi- We want people owning and managing their tional spending, and we’re just getting start- own health care accounts. When people own ed. The problem is, he hasn’t told us how something, they have a vital stake in the fu- he plans to pay for it. But you know how. ture of this great land. You and I can guess. It’s an educated guess. Our belief in liberty and opportunity and After all, he’s had a history of voting to raise the nonnegotiable demands of human dignity taxes. But we’re going to make it clear to are things that will never change in a rapidly him that raising taxes to fulfill all his big changing world. In this changing world, there promises will be the wrong medicine for are just some things that will not change: The America’s improving economy. values we try to live by, courage and compas- We have a difference of opinion. They sion and reverence and integrity; the institu- share the old Washington mindset: They will tions that give us direction and purpose, our give the orders, and you will pay the bills. families and our schools and our religious But we’re turning the corner, and we’re not turning back. congregations. These values and institutions This is a time of amazing change. It’s an are fundamental to our lives and to our fu- exciting period of time. In our parents’ gen- ture, and they deserve the respect of Govern- eration, moms usually stayed at home while ment. fathers worked for one company until retire- We stand for institutions like marriage and ment. The company provided health care and family, which are the foundations of our soci- training and a pension. Many of our Govern- ety. We stand for a culture of life in which ment programs and most basic systems, from every person matters and every person health care to Social Security to the Tax counts. We stand for judges who faithfully Code, were set up based on those old as- interpret the law instead of legislating from sumptions. the bench. Yet, our world today is different. Workers We stand for a culture of responsibility in change jobs and careers frequently. Often- America. Our culture is changing from one times both parents work. Many times there’s that has said, ‘‘If it feels good, do it,’’ and a single mom struggling to get ahead. Most ‘‘If you’ve got a problem, blame somebody new jobs are created by the small businesses else,’’ to a culture in which each of us under- that cannot afford to provide health care or stands we’re responsible for the decisions we pension or training. It is time to make the make in life. If you’re a mom or a dad, you’re Government work for America’s families. responsible for loving your child with all your America’s workers need their own health ac- heart and all your soul. If you’re worried counts that they can carry with them from about the quality of the education in the job to job. American workers need pensions community in which you live, you’re respon- and retirement plans that they own, that they sible for doing something about it. If you’re control, that they can pass from one genera- a CEO in corporate America, you’re respon- tion to the next. sible for telling the truth to your shareholders These reforms that make sure Americans and your employees. And in a responsibility stand on the side of families and workers are society, each of us is responsible for loving

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00006 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 30 1401

our neighbor just like we’d like to be loved our country forward by expanding oppor- ourselves. tunity to every corner of this great land. The strength of this country is not our During the next 4 years, we will spread Government. The strength of this country is ownership and opportunity so every single the heart and souls of the American people. citizen has a shot at realizing the great dream That’s the true strength of America. of this fantastic country. We will pass the en- Today I had the honor of saying hello to during values of our country to another gen- Dr. Peggy Curry. She’s the executive director eration. We will prevail. With your support of Grand Rapids Reach. The reason I bring and your prayers, I will be a leader America her up is one of the most important initiatives can count on in a time of great change. over the next 4 years will be to continue to Four years ago, as I traveled this great expand the faith-based program, to have country and came to places like Grand Rap- Government stand on the side of faith pro- ids, Michigan, asking for the vote, I made grams, not against faith programs. a pledge to my fellow Americans that if you Dr. Curry’s program distributes food to honored me with this great responsibility, I senior citizens. It mentors. There’s after- would uphold the dignity and the honor of school programs. There’s Christian outreach. the office to which I had been elected, so See, it’s a program that understands that help me, God. And with your help, I will when you help a person change their heart, do so for 4 more years. they can help change their lives. For those Thank you all. God bless. God bless you of you who are soldiers in the army of com- all. Thank you all. passion here in Grand Rapids and western Michigan, thank you for your service. Thank NOTE: The President spoke at 3:32 p.m. at Grand you for helping change America one heart, Rapids Community College. In his remarks, he referred to Juan R. Olivarez, president, Grand one soul at a time. Rapids Community College; Michigan Secretary For all Americans, these years in our his- of State Terri Lynn Land; Michigan State Attor- tory will stand apart. There are quiet times ney General Mike Cox; Majority Leader Ken in the life of a nation when little is expected Sikkema and Speaker Rick Johnson, Michigan of its leaders. These aren’t one of those times. State Legislature; Betsy DeVos, chairman, This is a period where we need resolve, firm Charles ‘‘Chuck’’ Yob, national committeeman, resolve and clear vision. None of us will ever and Holly Hughes, national committeewoman- forget that week when one era ended and elect, Michigan Republican Party; Peter F. another began. On September the 14th, Secchia, former U.S. Ambassador to Italy; Col. 2001, I stood in the ruins of the Twin Towers. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, leader of Libya; former President Saddam Hussein of Iraq; It’s a day that I will never forget. There were and the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks workers in hardhats yelling at me, ‘‘Whatever Upon the United States (9/11 Commission). This it takes.’’ I remember a guy grabbing my item was not received in time for publication in arm—a firefighter or policeman, I don’t the appropriate issue. know which one—he had tears in his eyes, and he looked at me and said, ‘‘Do not let me down.’’ Remarks at the International As we all did that day, these men and Children’s Games and Cultural women searching through the rubble took it Festival in Cleveland, Ohio personally. I took it personally. I have a re- July 30, 2004 sponsibility that goes on. I wake up every morning thinking about how to better protect The President. Thank you. Thanks for our country. I will never relent in bringing coming. Welcome to the United States. I am justice to our enemies, whatever it takes. honored to have been introduced by a great We have come through much together. Iranian-American, silver medalist Matt We’ve done a lot of hard work together. Ghaffari. Thank you, Matt, for being here, We’re turning the corner. We’re moving and thank you for your introduction. America forward by extending freedom and Listen, I don’t know if you know this— peace around the world, and we’re moving hold on—there are—the Governor of this

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00007 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1402 July 30 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

great State is with us today. Senators are with to get here to compete. Continue doing so. us today, very fine people in Senators I think it will help you—I know it will help Voinovich and DeWine. Members of the you in your life. Congress are here today. The reason why is I want to say one other word. I want to they want to join me in welcoming you who welcome the Afghan girls’ soccer team who do not live in the United States to our great is here. We’re glad every country is rep- country. We’re glad you’re here, and we hope resented. I think it’s especially interesting you have a wonderful experience in America. and an especially poignant and uplifting mo- You’re in a great United States city. Cleve- ment that young girls are here from the coun- land, Ohio, is a fantastic place to visit. And try of Afghanistan. Because your country is I want to thank—and I know you join me free, you’re here. Because your country is in thanking the mayor of Cleveland, Mayor free, you can now go to school for the first Jane Campbell, for her gracious hospitality. time—many of you can now go to school for I want to thank the sports authority figures the first time. who are here. I appreciate David Gilbert of Freedom is such a powerful part of the the Cleveland Sports Commission. I want to world in which we live, and we take great thank Alex Machaskee, who is the cochair pride in welcoming you all into a free society of the International Children’s Games, and from a free society. Dr. Fred Loop, who is the other chairman, May God bless you, and may God bless for working so hard to put this event on. all the athletes and their families and coaches I know you join me in thanking all the vol- who are here. Enjoy yourselves. Good luck. unteers from the city of Cleveland who have All my best. worked hard to make sure your stay here is a good stay. I suggest you go to the Rock NOTE: The President spoke at 6:35 p.m. at Cleve- ’n Roll Hall of Fame. Oh, yes, that’s where land Browns Stadium. In his remarks, he referred you need to spend some time. to Matt Ghaffari, 1996 Olympic silver medalist, I want to thank the former Olympians who Greco-Roman wrestling; and Gov. Bob Taft of are here. They wish you all the very best in Ohio. This item was not received in time for publi- the games and hope that you become Olym- cation in the appropriate issue. pians yourselves. And this is a good place to start, right here in the competition. A couple things I want to tell you. One, The President’s Radio Address I hope you enjoy yourself, and I hope you July 31, 2004 spend time not only competing hard but get- ting to know each other. Like, there’s all Good morning. This week, we received en- kinds of cultures here and different lan- couraging reports that show our economy is guages are spoken, but I think you’ll find you gaining strength. Consumer confidence hit a share a lot of things in common. Yes, you 2-year high in July. Existing home sales hit hope for a better life. You care deeply about an alltime new record in June. The home- people you love. You want the world to be ownership rate has hit a new alltime high. a better place. And so, not only compete And since last summer, our economy has hard, but spend time with each other and grown at a rate as fast as any in nearly 20 share cultures. I think you’ll find you’re all years. God’s children. There’s so much in common. These gains in our economy have come A couple other things I want to tell you at a time when Americans are benefiting is make sure that you continue to make the from the full effects of tax relief. I have trav- right choices in life. See, you’re at the age eled across America meeting small-business where you’re going to be challenged with owners who are investing tax savings into new some tough choices: drugs and alcohol, prej- equipment, and I have met families who are udice and hate. Reject that. Reject those using tax savings to pay for their children’s kinds of temptations and continue serving needs. All of this added economic activity is your bodies and your soul well by making creating opportunity. Since last August, right choices in life. You made right choices Americans have started work at more than

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00008 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1403

1.5 million new jobs, many of them in high- to pay the average home electricity bill for growth, high-paying industries. more than a year or fill up the gas tank of The impact of our growing economy is two cars for an entire year. To millions of being felt in Washington, where estimates of hard-working Americans, tax relief has been Government deficits are shrinking. My ad- the difference in helping make ends meet. ministration now forecasts that the combined This is a crucial time for our economy. We deficits in 2004 and 2005 will be about $100 have emerged from a period of great chal- billion less than previously expected, and be- lenge. Terrorist attacks, recession, and cor- cause of my policy of strengthening the econ- porate scandal hurt the wallets of millions omy while enforcing spending discipline in of Americans, but these shocks to our econ- Washington, we remain on pace to reduce omy did not damage our spirit. We’re a hard- the deficit by half in the next 5 years. working and resilient nation. Our economy These are hopeful signs, and we must is on a rising path, and together, we will bring make sure our economy continues to gain our prosperity to every corner of America. momentum. Families are working hard to Thank you for listening. make ends meet, and these families depend on good policies in Washington that promote NOTE: The address was recorded at 1:40 p.m. on growth, new jobs, and new opportunities. July 30 at the Amway Grand Plaza in Grand Rap- Thanks to the No Child Left Behind Act, ids, MI, for broadcast at 10:06 a.m. on July 31. we are improving our public schools so stu- The transcript was made available by the Office dents learn basic skills like reading, writing, of the Press Secretary on July 30 but was embar- goed for release until the broadcast. The Office math, and science. We have expanded Pell of the Press Secretary also released a Spanish lan- grant college scholarships so that more stu- guage transcript of this address. dents can attend college, and we are helping community colleges train workers for the new high-skill jobs being created in our Remarks in Canton, Ohio growing economy. July 31, 2004 We’re giving individuals more control over their health care dollars through newly cre- The President. Thanks for coming. I’m ated health savings accounts, and we must glad so many came out on a Saturday morn- also address the rising costs of health care ing. I appreciate the warm welcome. I par- by enacting commonsense reforms in our ticularly thank those who are sitting behind medical liability system. We must continue me; you’ve probably got the best view in the to open up foreign markets to American house. goods, because on a level playing field, Amer- We’re on the Heart and Soul of America ican workers and farmers and entrepreneurs tour. I’m out asking for the vote. I’m out ask- can compete with anybody, anytime, any- ing for your help. I want to serve this Nation where. for 4 more years. We must enact reforms to our legal system Audience members. Four more years! so hard-working entrepreneurs are not run Four more years! Four more years! out of business by frivolous lawsuits. We The President. Oh, there’s going to be must have a national energy policy so we be- big differences in this campaign. You’ll hear come less dependent on foreign sources of big differences on taxes, on how to win the energy. We must have sensible regulations war on terror. There seems to be a difference so that America’s job creators can focus on over the heart and soul of America. My oppo- satisfying their customers and not bureau- nents think you can find the heart and soul crats in Government. of America in Hollywood. And we must keep taxes low on American Audience members. Boo-o-o! families and small businesses by making the The President. The true heart and soul tax relief we have passed permanent. Thanks of America is found right here in Canton, to tax relief enacted since 2001, a family of Ohio. four earning $40,000 a year now pays nearly Last night I was in Cleveland; we’re head- $2,000 less in Federal taxes. That is enough ing to Cambridge; I’m heading to Pittsburgh

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00009 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1404 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

today. We’re taking this bus tour. I’m excited a duty in this country to vote. And those are about the campaign. The crowds are big. The the people, when they get people heading crowds are enthusiastic. With your help, to the polls, are going to nudge them our Dick Cheney and I will win 4 more years. way. Thanks for what you’re doing. I’m sorry Laura is not here. Also, I’m proud that Chris Spielman is Audience members. Aw-w-w! here. I’m glad that he is—taking one look The President. That’s generally the reac- at him reminded me how I’m glad we’re both tion. [Laughter] It’s kind of like, ‘‘Bring her on the same side. [Laughter] He’s a good on, and you stay at home.’’ [Laughter] But man. I want to thank the McKinley Bulldog she is a great First Lady. I am proud of her. marching band. Today I’m going to talk about what I intend Every incumbent who asks for your vote to do over the next 4 years, but perhaps the has to answer a central question, and that’s most important reason to put me back in is why. Why—why should the American people so that Laura will be First Lady for 4 more give me the great privilege of serving as your years. President for 4 more years? In the past few I mentioned my runningmate. I admit, years, we’ve been through a lot together. he’s not the prettiest on the ticket. [Laugh- Think about what we’ve been through. We’ve ter] That’s not why I picked him. I picked accomplished a great deal. We’ve done a lot him because he’s strong, he’s steady, and he together. But there’s only one reason to look gets the job done. backward at the record, and that’s to deter- I want to thank my friend Senator mine who best to lead the Nation forward. Voinovich. Put him back in there, will you, I’m asking for your vote because so much for the sake of Ohio and for the sake of is at stake. I’m asking for your vote because America. He is a fabulous human being and we have so much more to do together to a great United States Senator. Every time I move this country forward. If the people give talk to him, he says, ‘‘You be thinking about me 4 more years, this country will be safer. Ohio, Mr. President.’’ I said, ‘‘Don’t worry. Our economy will be stronger. Our future Ohio is an important State, George.’’ It’s im- will be brighter and better for every single portant for a lot of reasons. I carried it last citizen. From creating well-paying, good jobs time. I intend to work hard to carry it this to improving schools, from fighting terror to time. spreading peace and protecting the home- And if you want to know how you can help, land, we have made much progress. And we go to georgewbush.com. That’s where you will do more. get your marching orders. I want to thank We have more to do to make America’s Mike DeWine, the United States Senator public schools the centers of excellence we who serves with George Voinovich so well. all know they can be so that no child is left I appreciate your Governor, Bob Taft, joining behind in America. When we came to office us today. I’m proud he’s joining me on the 31⁄2 years ago, too many children were being bus tour. I want to thank Congressman Ralph shuffled from grade to grade, year after year, Regula, and Mary, for joining us. I was proud without learning the basics. So we challenged to say hello to your mayor, Mayor Creighton, the soft bigotry of low expectations. We today when I came in. I appreciate the fact raised the bar. We set high standards. We’re that Janet ran for office. She said, ‘‘When focusing on results. We’re empowering par- you get up there, make sure you assure them ents. We’re making sure the local folks are that I’m going to fill the potholes.’’ [Laugh- in charge of their own public schools. Today, ter] I said, ‘‘Okay.’’ I want to thank all the children across America are showing real other State and local officials. progress, substantial progress in reading and I’m proud that grassroots activists are here. math. When it comes to improving public Those are the people who put up the signs. schools, we are turning the corner, and we’re Those are the people who make the phone not turning back. calls. Those are the people who register the We have more to do. The world we live voters. Those are the people who tell Repub- in is changing. The jobs of the future will lican, Democrat, and independent you have require greater knowledge and higher-level

VerDate May 21 2004 12:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00010 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1405

skills. We will reform our high schools to Still back there? [Applause] They are. make sure a high school diploma means We have more to do to make America’s something. We will expand our math and economy stronger. We have come through science education so young people can com- a recession. We’ve come through terrorist at- pete in the high-tech world. We will expand tacks. We’ve come through a stock market the use of the Internet to bring high-level decline. We’ve come through corporate scan- training into classrooms. With 4 more years, dals. Yet, this Nation has overcome all these we will help a rising generation gain the skills obstacles. We’ve overcome the obstacles be- and the confidence to achieve the American cause we’ve got great workers in America, Dream. the most productive workers in the world, We have more to do to make quality health many of whom are right here in eastern Ohio. care available and affordable. When we came We’ve overcome these obstacles because to office, too many older Americans couldn’t we’ve got great farmers and ranchers in afford prescription drugs, and Medicare America. We’ve overcome these obstacles didn’t pay for them. Leaders in both political because the entrepreneurial spirit is strong parties had promised prescription drug cov- and the small-business sector is alive and well erage for years. We got it done. More than in America. 4 million seniors have signed up for the drug And we’ve overcome these obstacles be- discount cards that provide real savings. And cause of well-timed tax relief. We gave tax beginning in 2006, all seniors on Medicare relief to every American who pays Federal will be able to choose a plan that suits their taxes. We didn’t play winners or losers. We needs and gives them coverage for prescrip- did it the fair way. We gave tax relief for tion drugs. families with children. We gave tax relief for We’ve expanded community health cen- married couples. We provided tax relief for ters for low-income Americans. We’ve cre- every small business that was making pur- ated health savings accounts so families can save, tax-free, for their own health care chases. And this time, the check really was needs. When it comes to giving Americans in the mail. more choices about their health care and Because we acted, our economy since last making health care more affordable, we are summer has grown at a rate as fast as any turning the corner, and we’re not turning time in nearly 20 years. Because we acted, back. America has added 1.5 million new jobs since This world is changing. Most Americans last August. The economy is strong, and it’s get their health care coverage through their getting stronger. It lags in places like eastern work. Most of today’s new jobs are created Ohio; I know that. I’m aware of that. I just by small businesses, which too often cannot traveled on the bus with workers who told afford to provide health care. To help more me they are nervous about their future. American families get health insurance, we They’re concerned. I am too. And therefore, must allow small employers to join together we must have a President who understands to purchase insurance at the discounts avail- that in order to keep jobs at home, America able to big companies. must be the best place to do business. To improve health care, we must limit the I’m here to tell you we can do more to frivolous lawsuits that raise the cost of health make America job-friendly and America’s care and drive good doctors out of medicine. workplaces more family-friendly. To keep To make the health care industry more effi- American jobs in America, our regulations cient and cost effective, we must harness must be reasonable and fair. To keep Amer- technology to reduce costs and to prevent ican jobs in America, we must lessen our de- mistakes. We must expand research and seek pendence on foreign sources of energy. To new cures for terrible diseases. keep American jobs in America, we must end In all we do to improve health care in the junk lawsuits that hurt our business and America, we will make sure the health deci- employers. If you want to keep jobs in Amer- sions are made by doctors and patients, not ica, the Government must not overspend by bureaucrats in Washington, DC. your money, and the Government must keep

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00011 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1406 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

your taxes low. And that’s how you keep jobs ghanistan is now a place where many young at home. girls go to school for the first time. You also keep jobs at home by making sure Yesterday in Cleveland, Ohio, at the Inter- American workers have a lifetime of learning. national Children’s Games, I was able to hug And you help them get training for the jobs and say hello to a young girls’ soccer team of the future. And a great place to do that from Afghanistan. That wouldn’t have hap- is in our community college system. The edu- pened 3 years ago. Because we acted, Af- cation and training they offer can be the ghanistan is an ally in the war on terror. Be- bridge between people’s lives as they are and cause we acted, America and the world are people’s lives as they want them to be. safer. I know there’s great concern about trade Before September the 11th, Pakistan was in eastern Ohio. Let me tell you something a safe transit point for terrorists. Today, Paki- about trade. I believe that America and stan is an ally in the war on terror. Pakistani Americans can compete with anybody, any- forces are aggressively helping to round up place, anywhere so long as the rules are fair. terrorists, and America and the world are We understand what currency valuations safer. can do to manufacturing, particularly in east- Before September the 11th, in Saudi Ara- ern Ohio. We’ve been working with China bia, terrorists were raising money and re- to put fair policy in place. Just give us a cruiting and operating with little opposition. chance to compete, is all we’re asking. We’ve Today, the Saudi Government is taking the been enforcing our trade agreements. We’re fight to Al Qaida, and America and the world making sure that our workers and our manu- are safer. facturers are treated fairly. Before September the 11th, Libya was We’ll help American families keep more spending millions to acquire weapons of mass of something they never enough of, time— destruction. Today, because America and our time to play with their children, time to go allies have sent a strong and clear message, Little League games or Girl Scout meetings, the leader of Libya has abandoned his pursuit time to care for elderly parents, time to go of weapons of mass destruction; America and to class to improve their lives. I believe that the world are safer. Congress should enact comp-time and flex- time rules to allow American families to bet- Before September the 11th, the ruler of ter juggle the demands of work and home. Iraq was a sworn enemy of America. He was I think Government ought to be on the side defying the world. He was firing weapons at of the American family. After 4 more years, American pilots enforcing the world’s sanc- there will be better paying jobs in America. tions. He had pursued and he had used After 4 more years, there will be more small weapon of mass destruction. businesses. After 4 more years, the American Audience members. Boo-o-o! economy will continue to be the strongest The President. He harbored terrorists. in the world. He invaded his neighbors. He subsidized the We have more to do to wage and win the families of suicide bombers. He had mur- war on terror. America’s future depends on dered tens of thousands of his own citizens. our willingness to lead in the world. If Amer- He was the source of great instability. ica shows uncertainty and weakness in this After September the 11th, we looked at decade, the world will drift toward tragedy. all the threats of the world in a new light. This will not happen on my watch. The lesson of September the 11th is we must The world changed on a terrible Sep- take threats seriously before they fully mate- tember morning. And since that day, we have rialize. The September the 11th Commission changed the world. Before September the concluded our institutions of Government 11th, Afghanistan served as the home base had failed to imagine the horror of that day. of Al Qaida, which trained and deployed After September the 11th, we cannot fail to thousands of killers to set up terror cells in imagine that a brutal tyrant who hated Amer- dozens of countries, including our own. ica, who had ties to terror, had used weapons Today, Afghanistan is a rising democracy. Af- of mass destruction, might use those weapons

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00012 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1407

or share those capabilities with a deadly believe that there’s a democratic future for enemy. their countries. These are courageous people We saw a threat. I looked at the intel- who have stood up and led. And more and ligence and saw a threat. Members of the more of their citizens are joining them. More United States Congress from both parties, in- and more of the security needs in Iraq are cluding my opponent, looked at the intel- being handled by Iraqis. It’s their future. It’s ligence and came to the same conclusion; their responsibility. They understand that the they saw a threat. The United Nations Secu- men and women, the fathers and mothers rity Council looked at the intelligence, saw of Iraq, want their children to grow up in a threat, and unanimously demanded a full a peaceful world just like the moms and dads accounting of Saddam Hussein’s weapons of America want their children to grow up and weapons programs, or face serious con- in a peaceful world. sequences. After 12 years of defiance, he When we acted to protect their own secu- again refused to comply. He continued to de- rity, we promised to help deliver them from ceive the weapons inspectors. tyranny, to restore their sovereignty, and to And so I had a choice to make; this Nation help them on the path to liberty. And when had a choice to make: either forget the les- America gives it word, America will keep its sons of September the 11th and hope for the word. And in these times, America’s commit- best and trust a madman, or take action to ments are kept by the men and women of defend our country. Given that choice, I will our military. I’ve had the privilege of meeting defend America every time. with those who defend our country and sac- When it comes to fighting the threats of rifice for our security. I’ve seen their great our world, when it comes to making America decency and unselfish courage. The cause of safer, when it comes to spreading the peace, liberty, the cause of freedom, is in really good we’re turning a corner, and we’re not turning hands. back. We have more work to do, more hard work And we must make sure that the men and to do. We’ll continue to work with our friends women who wear our uniform have the very and allies around the world to aggressively best—the best training, the best equipment. pursue the terrorists and the foreign fighters And so last September, while our troops were wherever they hide—in Afghanistan and Iraq in combat in both Afghanistan and Iraq, I or elsewhere. See, you can’t talk sense to the proposed supplemental funding to support terrorists. You can’t negotiate with them. You them in their missions. This legislation pro- cannot hope for the best. You must bring vided funding for body armor and other vital them to justice. equipment, for hazard pay, for health bene- Audience members. Yes! fits, and ammunition and fuel and spare The President. We will engage these en- parts. In the Senate, only a handful, only a emies in Afghanistan and Iraq and elsewhere small, out-of-the-mainstream minority voted so that we do not have to face them here against the legislation. And two of those at home. We’ll continue to lead the world twelve Senators are on the ticket opposing with competence and moral clarity. We put us. together a strong coalition—a strong coali- Audience members. Boo-o-o! tion joined together to defeat the terrorists. The President. Senator Kerry tried to ex- There are nearly 40 nations involved in Af- plain his vote this way: ‘‘I actually did vote ghanistan, some 30 nations involved in Iraq. for the $87 billion, before I voted against it.’’ Over the next 4 years, we will continue to [Laughter] End quote. [Laughter] Now, he’s build alliances and work with our friends, but offering different explanations. At one time I will never turn America’s national security he said he was proud that he and his decisions over to leaders of other countries. runningmate voted against the funding for We must keep our commitments to help the troops, and then he said, ‘‘The whole Afghanistan and Iraq become peaceful, thing is a complicated matter.’’ [Laughter] democratic societies. You see, these two na- There’s nothing complicated about sup- tions are now governed by strong leaders who porting our troops in combat.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00013 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1408 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

In the long run, our security is not guaran- cess and more choices, results matter. When teed by force alone. We must work to change it comes improving our economy and cre- the conditions that give rise to terror: pov- ating jobs, results matter. When it comes to erty, hopelessness, and resentment. A free better securing the homeland, to fighting the and peaceful Iraq, a free and peaceful Af- forces of evil and spreading peace, results ghanistan will be powerful examples to their matter. When it comes to choosing a Presi- neighbors. Free countries do not export ter- dent, results matter. ror. Free countries do not stifle the dreams Audience members. Four more years! of their citizens. Free countries listen to the Four more years! Four more years! hopes and aspirations of the people that live The President. This week, the other party there. By serving the ideal of liberty, we’re gathered in Boston. bringing hope to others and making America Audience members. Boo-o-o! more secure. By serving the ideal of liberty, The President. We heard a lot of—there we serve the values we believe in. Freedom were some clever speeches and some big is not America’s gift to world; freedom is the promises. Their intentions, I think, are good. Almighty God’s gift to every man and woman My opponent’s intentions are good. But the in this world. problem is, intentions don’t always translate We have more to do to protect America. into results. An enemy still lurks, an enemy which hates After 19 years in the U.S. Senate, my op- what we stand for. And they’re still plotting. ponent has thousands of votes but few signa- The September the 11th Commission * had ture achievements. this interesting conclusion, which I agree with. It said our homeland is safer, but we Audience member. He’s a flip-flop. are not yet safe. They’re right. We’ve started The President. During 8 years in the Sen- the hard process of reform. We’ve trans- ate Intelligence Committee, he voted to cut formed our defenses—or we’re transforming the budget—intelligence budgets, yet he had our defenses, and we’ve created a new De- no record of reforming America’s intel- partment of Homeland Security. We passed ligence-gathering capability. He’s had no sig- the PATRIOT Act to give law enforcement nificant record in reforming education or the tools they need to track the terrorists. health care. As a matter of fact, he and his The mission of the FBI is now focused on runningmate consistently oppose reforms preventing terrorism. We’ve integrated intel- that limit the power of Washington and leave ligence and law enforcement better than we power in the hands of the people. ever have before. When it comes to better He spent 20 years in Government—nearly protecting America, we are turning the cor- 20 years; it appears he’s concluded that Gov- ner, and we’re not turning back. ernment just isn’t big enough. [Laughter] Listen, we’ve got more to do. Over the He’s proposed more than $2 trillion of addi- next 4 years, we’ll better secure our ports tional spending, and the campaign is just get- and borders and train first-responders and ting started. [Laughter] The times of the big dramatically improve our intelligence-gath- promise is coming down the stretch. [Laugh- ering capabilities. Reform is not going to be ter] The problem is he hasn’t told us how easy; I understand that. It never is. You see, he’s going to pay for it. there’s a lot of entrenched interests around, Audience members. Yes! particularly in Washington, a lot of people The President. If you look at his record, happy with the status quo. But it’s not I think we can figure it out. [Laughter] He enough to advocate reform; you have to be believes in higher taxes, at least that’s how able to get it done. he’s voted time in and time out—time in and When it comes to reforming schools to time out. If I had to guess how we’re going provide an excellent education for all our to pay for all these new promises, it’s going children, results matter. When it comes to to be: You get to pay. health care reforms to give families more ac- Audience members. Boo-o-o! The President. He said he’s only going * White House correction. to raise the tax on the so-called rich. But you

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00014 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1409

know how the rich is; they’ve got account- The role of Government should help our citi- ants. That means you pay. That means the zens, help our citizens gain the time and tools small business pays. It means the farmers and they need to make their own choices and to ranchers pay. That’s the wrong medicine for improve their own lives. this economy, and we’re not going to let him That’s why I’m working hard to usher in prescribe it. an era of ownership in America. See, we want There’s a big philosophical difference in more people owning something in our coun- this campaign. Our opponents share an old try. We want more people owning their own Washington mindset: They’ll give the orders, home, owning their own small business, own- and you pay the bills. But we’ve turned a ing their own health care accounts, owning corner, and we’re not turning back to that a piece of their retirement plan. When you way of thinking. own something, you have a vital stake in the Listen, we live in—we’re living in a time future of our country. of amazing change—amazing period of time, This is a world of change—a world of isn’t it? In our parents’ generation, moms change. But some things will never change: usually stayed at home and fathers worked our belief in liberty and opportunity for all for one company until retirement. A lot of and the nonnegotiable demands of human people are still doing that today, but it’s dignity. The individual values we try to live changing times, when you think about it. The by will not change, courage and compassion, company provided the health care and train- reverence and integrity. The institutions that ing and pension, and Government programs give us direction and purpose will not reflected that way of life. That’s just the way change, our families, our schools, our reli- the Government was structured in those gious congregations. These values are funda- days. mental to our lives. These institutions are Yet today, oftentimes workers change jobs necessary for a hopeful America; they de- and careers frequently, a lot of times both parents are working, a lot of times there’s serve the respect of our Government. only one mom at home working. It’s a dif- Some things will not change in this chang- ferent world we’re living in. Government has ing world. We stand for institutions like mar- got to reflect the different world. Govern- riage and family, which are the foundations ment has got to work with America’s working of society. We stand for a culture of life in families. That’s why workers need to own and which every person matters and every person manage their own health care accounts, so counts. We stand for judges who faithfully they can take them with them from job to interpret the law instead of legislating from job. the bench. That’s why our pensions and retirements And we stand for a culture of responsibility systems must insist that the owners be the in our country. You know, the culture of the workers. You see, Social Security needs to country is changing from one that has said, be strengthened by giving younger workers ‘‘If it feels good, do it,’’ and ‘‘If you’ve got the opportunity to manage some of their own a problem, blame somebody else,’’ to a cul- money in personal savings accounts. Social ture in which each of us understands we are Security will be strengthened by telling those responsible for the decisions you make in life. who have retired or are near retired, ‘‘Noth- If you’re fortunate enough to be a mother ing is going to change. The Government is or a father, you’re responsible for loving your going to pay your commitment.’’ But younger child with all your heart and all your soul. workers—and a country will be benefited If you’re worried about the quality of the when younger workers have an opportunity education in the community in which you to take some of their own money—their live, you’re responsible for doing something choice—and build up their nest egg so they about it. It’s your responsibility. If you’re a can pass it from one generation to the next. CEO in corporate America, you’re respon- You see, my reforms are based on the basic sible for telling the truth to your shareholders conviction, the role of Government is not to and your employees. And in a responsibility control or dominate the lives of our citizens. society, each of us is responsible for loving

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00015 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1410 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

our neighbor just like we’d like to be loved sein of Iraq; and the National Commission on Ter- ourselves. rorist Attacks Upon the United States (9/11 Com- For all Americans, these years in our his- mission). tory will always stand apart. There are quiet times in the life of a nation when little is Remarks in Cambridge, Ohio expected of its leaders. This isn’t one of those times. It’s a time where we need strong re- July 31, 2004 solve and clear vision. None of us will ever forget that week when The President. Thank you all very much. one era ended and another began. On Sep- Thanks for coming out today. Thanks for in- tember the 14th, 2001, I stood in the ruins viting me to Cambridge. It’s an honor to be of the Twin Towers. It’s a day I’ll never for- here. I always feel comfortable being in the get. There were workers in hardhats yelling middle of a ball diamond. I appreciate so at me, ‘‘Whatever it takes.’’ I remember many taking time out of your Saturday to walking along and a fellow grabbed me—po- come by and say hello and to welcome us liceman or fireman, I don’t know which on what we call the Heart and Soul of Amer- one—but he had tears in his eyes and said, ica tour. ‘‘Do not let me down.’’ You see, all of them There seems to be a difference of opinion working through the rubble there took the about the heart and soul—I’m running incident personally, just like you did and just against a fellow who thinks you can find the like I did. I have a responsibility that goes heart and soul in Hollywood. on. I wake up every single morning thinking Audience members. Boo-o-o! about how to better protect our country. I The President. No, I know where you find will never relent in bringing justice to the the heart and soul of America, right here in enemy and protecting our country, whatever places like Cambridge, Ohio. it takes. Thanks for coming out. I’m here to ask We’ve come through a lot together; there’s for the vote. I’m ready to lead for 4 more more to do. We’ve done a lot of hard work, years, and I want your help. and the world is getting better. During the Audience members. Four more years! next 4 years, we’ll spread opportunity and Four more years! Four more years! ownership through every corner of this coun- The President. I’m glad to be amongst try. During the next 4 years, we’ll continue my fellow Republicans, discerning Demo- to pass on enduring values to a younger gen- crats, and wise independents. I’d like to ask eration. And during the next 4 years, we will you to volunteer to register voters. See, we lead the cause of freedom and peace, and have a duty in this country to vote. We have we will prevail. a duty in a land of free to exercise our indi- Four years ago, I had traveled the great vidual choices in the ballot box. So please country and the great State of Ohio asking register your neighbors to vote. Make sure for the vote, pledging to our fellow citizens you tell them after they register to vote, and that if you honored me with the great respon- when you get them heading toward the polls, sibility of being President, I would uphold why don’t you nudge them our way? the dignity and the honor of the office to Thanks for coming. My regret is that Laura which I had been elected. And with your isn’t with me today. help, I will do so for 4 more years. Audience members. Aw-w-w! God bless. Thanks for coming. Thank you The President. I know. That’s usually the all very much. Thank you all. reaction. I’m really proud of her. She’s a great lady. Today I’m going to give you some NOTE: The President spoke at 11:04 a.m. at the reasons why I think you need to put me back Canton Memorial Civic Center. In his remarks, he referred to Mary Regula, wife of Representa- into office, but perhaps the most important tive Regula; Mayor Janet W. Creighton of Canton, reason of all is so that Laura can be First OH; former professional football player Chris Lady for 4 more years. Spielman; Col. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, I’m running with a really good man. I know leader of Libya; former President Saddam Hus- he’s not the prettiest face on the ticket.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00016 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1411

[Laughter] But I didn’t pick him for that rea- for every single citizen. I’m ready to lead the son. I picked him because he’s solid. I picked country for 4 more years. him because he’s got good advice and great Audience members. Four more years! experience. I picked him because he’s a good Four more years! Four more years! man. I’m proud to be running with Dick The President. Listen, we’ve got more to Cheney. do. We’ve got more work to do to make sure I’m proud to be traveling on this bus with our public schools are the center of excel- Governor Bob Taft. Thank you for coming, lence so no child is left behind in America. Governor. Senator Mike DeWine and his When we came to office 31⁄2 years ago, too wife, Fran. By the way, Voinovich was with many of the children were being just shuffled me a little earlier. You need to put him back through, grade to grade, year after year, with- into office; he’s a great United States Sen- out learning the basics. So we confronted the ator. He’s a good man—he’s a good man. status quo. We’re challenging what I call the I appreciate Congressman Bob Ney being soft bigotry of low expectations. We’re raising with us today. Congressman, I’m proud the bar. We expect better results. We’re in- you’re here. sisting on accountability. We’re empowering Mr. Mayor—I appreciate the mayor com- parents. And we’re making sure that local ing; Mayor Sam is with us today. I’m honored folks are in charge of the public schools. And you’re here, Mayor. Thank you, Mayor. I was today, children across America are showing walking by; he said, ‘‘You get a chance, put real progress when it comes to learning to in a good word for me.’’ He said he’s going read and math. When it comes to improving to fill the potholes. I said, ‘‘All right.’’ our schools, we’re turning the corner, and I want to thank all the other State and local we’re not turning back. officials. I appreciate the chairman of the There’s more to do; this world of ours is party, Bob Bennett. I want to thank all the changing. The jobs of the future will require grassroots activists who are here. Those are greater knowledge and a higher level of skill, the people who are putting up the signs and and so we must reform our high schools to manning the phones and getting your neigh- make sure a high school diploma means bors to show up to the polls on election day. something. We will expand math and edu- And I want to thank you for your hard work; cation so our youngsters can compete in a I really do. My job is to set the vision; your high-tech world. We will expand the use of job is to get the people to the polls. And the Internet to bring high-level training to together, we’re going to win Ohio and win classrooms all across America with 4 years— the Nation. with 4 more years. We will help raise a gen- Everybody running for office, every in- eration of young Americans to have con- cumbent who asks for the vote has got to fidence and the skills necessary to realize the answer the question, why—why are you run- American promise. ning again? Why should the American people We’ve got more to do to make quality give me the high privilege, the great privilege health care available and affordable. When of serving as your President for 4 more years? we came to office, too many of our older Let me tell you something. We’ve been Americans could not afford prescription through a lot together, and we have done drugs, and Medicare didn’t pay for them. You a lot. We’ve accomplished a great deal. But might remember the old debates of Medi- there’s only one reason to look backward at care: There was promise after promise, but the record, and that is to determine who best nothing was ever done. We got it done. More to lead the Nation forward. than 4 million seniors have signed up for I’m asking for your vote because there’s drug discount cards that provide real savings. a lot at stake, and there’s more to do to move And beginning in 2006, all seniors on Medi- our country forward. I want to be your Presi- care will be able to choose a plan that suits dent, and I’ll work hard to be your President their needs and gives them coverage for pre- and to keep your confidence to make this scription drugs. country safer, to make the economy stronger, Listen, we’ve expanded community health and to make our future brighter and better centers so low-income Americans can get

VerDate May 21 2004 12:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00017 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1412 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

health care. We’ve created health savings ac- The President. And so families with chil- counts so families can save, tax-free, for their dren got relief. People who are married got own health care needs. And when it comes relief. Small-business owners got relief. And to giving Americans more choices about their this time, the check really was in the mail. health care and making health care more af- [Laughter] fordable, we’re turning the corner, and we’re Because we acted, our economy since last not turning back. summer has grown at a rate as fast as any Most Americans get their health care cov- in nearly 20 years. Because we acted, Amer- erage through their work. I understand that. ica has added over 1.5 million new jobs since Most of today’s new jobs are created by small last August. Look, I understand there are businesses. Many small businesses cannot af- challenges here in eastern Ohio. This part ford to provide health coverage. We must of the country has lagged behind other parts deal with that. To help more American fami- of the country. But let me tell you something, lies get health insurance, small employers raising your taxes isn’t going to create jobs. must be allowed to join together to purchase Isolating America from the rest of the world insurance at discounts available for big com- isn’t going to create new jobs. Voting against panies. energy policy isn’t going to create new jobs. To make sure the health care system is We will not rest until every America who available and affordable, we must limit the wants to find a job, has one. That’s the policy frivolous lawsuits that raise health care costs, of the Bush administration. that not only raise your costs, but they drive There’s more work to do to make sure this the good doctors of Ohio out of business. Lis- country is job-friendly and our workplaces ten, we’ll harness technology to reduce costs are family-friendly. To keep American jobs and prevent costly errors. We will expand re- in America, regulations need to be fair and search to find new cures for terrible diseases. reasonable. To keep American jobs in Amer- In all we do to improve health care in Amer- ica, we must end the junk and frivolous law- ica, we’ll make sure the health decisions are suits that threaten employers all across the made by doctors and patients, not by bureau- country. To keep American jobs in America, crats in Washington, DC. we will not overspend your money and we Listen, we’ve got more to do to make this will keep your taxes low. country’s economy stronger. We’ve come through a lot together. Think about what To keep American jobs in America, we we’ve been through. We’ve been through a need a reasonable energy policy. As you recession. We’ve been through attacks. know in Cambridge, an important part of an We’ve been through a stock market decline. energy strategy is clean coal technology. My And we’ve been through corporate scandals. budget for next year provides $447 million But we’ve overcome all these obstacles. to encourage this vital technology. I’ll tell you We’ve overcome them together. I’ll tell you why: In order for us to be less dependent why: We’ve got the greatest workers in the on foreign sources of energy, we must use world in America; we’ve got the most produc- American coal. tive, greatest workers in this country. We have a difference of opinion on this. We’re overcoming these obstacles because My opponent said—he called coal a dirty en- we’ve got great farmers and ranchers. We’re ergy source. overcoming these obstacles because the en- Audience members. Boo-o-o! trepreneurial spirit of America is strong. The The President. He opposed my energy small-business sector of our economy is vi- plan, which promoted clean coal technology brant and alive. and alternative sources of fuel. The other And we’ve overcome these obstacles be- night in Boston, he said he wants America cause of well-timed tax cuts. Listen, we didn’t finally and forever independent of Mideast pick winners or losers when it came to tax oil. Listen, I share that goal, and I know how relief. We had a fair attitude, I think, that to achieve it. To make sure we’re inde- says if you pay taxes, you ought to get relief. pendent, to make sure we’re not dependent Audience member. Thank you! on foreign sources of energy, we must be

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00018 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1413

wise about how we use America’s energy the home base of Al Qaida, which trained sources, including coal. and deployed thousands of killers to set up We’ll offer America’s workers a lifetime of terror cells in dozens of countries, including learning and to help them get training for our own. Because we acted, Afghanistan is the jobs of the future at our community col- a rising democracy. Because we acted, many leges. Listen, to make sure American jobs young girls now go to school for the first stay here, we must be wise and educate peo- time. Let me tell you something, what hap- ple for the jobs of the 21st century. pened yesterday in Cleveland. I went to the When it comes to keeping jobs in America, International Children’s Games. I was able we must not isolate ourselves from the world. to see a young girls’ soccer team from Af- I know people around here are worried about ghanistan on American soil. Because we trade. Let me tell you my view of trade. I acted, the people are free. Because we acted, believe we can compete with anybody, any- we have an ally in the war on terror in Af- time, anywhere so long as the rules are fair. ghanistan. Because we acted, America is I believe—and my job is to make sure the safer, and so is the world. rules are fair, holding countries to account Before September the 11th, Pakistan was that mistreat American manufacturers, hold- a safe transit point for terrorists. Today, ing countries to account that do not let their they’re an ally in the war on terror. Their currency float, holding countries to account forces are aggressively helping to round up that close their markets. No, to keep jobs in the terrorists, and America and the world is America, you need a President who won’t iso- safer. late us in the world, a President who’s con- Before September the 11th, in Saudi Ara- fident in the American worker, the American bia, terrorists were raising money and re- entrepreneur, the American manufacturer, cruiting and operating with little opposition. and insists that foreign countries treat us just Today, the Saudi Government has taken the the way we treat them. fight to Al Qaida, and America and the world We’ll help American families keep some- are safer. thing they never have enough of, and that Before September the 11th, Libya was is time—time to be with your kids, time to spending millions to acquire weapons of mass go to Little League games or Girl Scout destruction. Today, because America and our meetings, time to take care of the elderly, allies have sent a strong and clear message, time to improve themselves by going back the leader of Libya abandoned his pursuit to class. Congress needs to join me in sup- of weapons of mass destruction, and America porting what we call comp-time and flex-time and the world are safer. to help American families better juggle the Before September the 11th, the tyrant of demands of work and home. Iraq was a sworn enemy of America. He was After 4 more years, there will be better defying the world. You might remember, he paying jobs in America. There will be more was firing weapons at American pilots who jobs in America. Our farmers will be better were enforcing the world’s sanctions. He had off, and the small-business sector will be alive pursued and used weapons of mass destruc- and well. tion against his own people. He harbored ter- Listen, we’ve got more to do to wage and rorists. He invaded his neighbors. He sub- win the war on terror. America’s future de- sidized the families of suicide bombers. He pends on our willingness to lead in the world. had murdered tens of thousands of his own If America shows uncertainty and weakness citizens. He was a source of great instability in this decade, the world will drift toward in a dangerous part of the world. tragedy. That’s not going to happen on my After September the 11th, we looked at watch. all the threats of the world in a new light. The world changed on that terrible morn- See, a lesson of that fateful day was that we ing in September. And since then, we have must take threats seriously before they fully changed the world. We’ve done the hard materialize. work, and we’re headed to peace. Before And so we looked at the intelligence and September the 11th, Afghanistan served as saw a threat; that’s what the intelligence said.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00019 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1414 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

The United States Congress—members of The people of these countries can count both political parties, including my oppo- on our continued help. See, when we acted nent—looked at the same intelligence and to protect our own security, when we took came to the same conclusion, that Saddam action to do our duty to protect our own peo- was a threat. The United Nations Security ple, we also promised to help deliver them Council looked at the intelligence and voted from tyranny, to restore their sovereignty, to unanimously to demand a full accounting of help them get on the path to liberty. And Saddam’s weapons, or he would face serious when America gives it word, America keeps consequences. That’s exactly what the world its word. said. After 12 years of defiance, the dictator In these crucial times, America’s commit- chose defiance again. He deceived the in- ments are kept by the men and women of spectors. So I had a choice to make: forget our military. At bases across our country and the lessons of September the 11th, hope for around the world, I have had the privilege the best, and trust a madman, or take deci- of meeting with those who defend our coun- sions to defend this country. And given that try and sacrifice for our security. These are choice, I will defend America every time. fine, fine people. Audience members. Four more years! The cause of freedom is in really good Four more years! Four more years! hands, and those who wear our uniform de- The President. The dictator of Iraq sits serve all the support from our Government. in a prison cell, and America and the world Last September, while our troops were in are safer. combat in both Afghanistan and Iraq, I pro- We have more to do. We’ve more to do. posed supplemental funding to support them We must continue to work with friends and in their missions. The legislation provided allies around the world to aggressively pursue funding for body armor and vital equipment, the terrorists and foreign fighters in Iraq and for hazard pay, health benefits, ammunition, Afghanistan and elsewhere. See, you can’t talk sense to these folks. You cannot nego- fuel, and spare parts. In the United States tiate with them. You cannot hope for the Senate, only a small, what I would call out- best. We must engage these enemies around of-the-mainstream minority of 12 senators the world so we do not have to face them voted against the legislation. Two of the here at home. twelve Senators are my opponent and his America will continue to lead the world runningmate. with confidence and moral clarity. We put Audience members. Boo-o-o! together a strong coalition to help us. There The President. When asked about his are nearly 40 nations involved in Afghanistan vote, Senator Kerry said, ‘‘I actually did vote and some 30 nations involved in Iraq. Over for the $87 billion, before I voted against it.’’ the next 4 years, we’ll continue to build on [Laughter] End quote. Now he’s got some our alliances and work with our friends for different explanations. He said, well, he’s the cause of security and peace. But I will proud of the vote, and further, he said the never turn over America’s national security whole thing is a complicated matter. There’s decisions to leaders of other countries. nothing complicated about supporting our We’ll keep our commitments to help Af- troops in combat. ghanistan and Iraq become peaceful and In the long run, our security is not guaran- democratic societies. These two nations are teed by force alone. We must work to change now governed by strong leaders. See, these the conditions that give rise to terror: poverty people are committed to free societies. They and hopelessness and resentment. You see, understand, the moms and dads of Iraq and a free and peaceful Iraq and a free and Afghanistan want the children there—want peaceful Afghanistan will be powerful exam- their children there to grow up in a peaceful ples for their neighbors. Free countries don’t world, just like moms and dads here in Amer- export terror. Free countries do not stifle the ica do, just like Laura and I do. We want dreams of their citizens. Free countries have people to grow up in a peaceful society. We governments which listen to the aspirations want them to be able to realize their dreams. of their people.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00020 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1415

By serving the ideal of liberty, we’re bring- ate. He’s had thousands of votes but few sig- ing hope to others, and that makes America nature achievements. During 8 years on the more secure. And by serving the ideal of lib- Senate Intelligence Committee, for example, erty, we’re serving the values which make us he voted to cut the intelligence budget, yet great. We don’t—America does not believe he had no record of reforming America’s in- that freedom is our gift to the world. America telligence-gathering capability. He’s had no believes freedom is the Almighty God’s gift significant record on education or health to every man and woman in this world. care. There are still enemies that want to do us See, he and his runningmate consistently harm. They still plot. Listen, I agree with the opposed reforms that limit the power of conclusion of the September the 11th Com- Washington, reforms that leave more power mission—says our homeland is safer, but in the hands of the people. We have a dif- we’re not yet safe. But we’ve started the hard ferent point of view. We have a different phi- process of reform. We’ve transformed— losophy. He spent nearly 20 years in Govern- we’re transforming our defenses and created ment, in the Federal Government, and now a new Department of Homeland Security. he’s concluded it’s not big enough. That’s We passed the PATRIOT Act to give law en- why he’s promised $2 trillion of new money. forcement the new tools to track and find That’s a lot of money, and the campaign is the terrorists. The mission of the FBI is now just getting started. [Laughter] He hasn’t told focused on preventing terror. We’ve inte- us how he’s going to pay for it, though. Yes, grated intelligence and law enforcement bet- I know, we can figure it out looking at his ter than we ever have before. When it comes record. In order to pay for all that new to protecting America, we’re turning the cor- spending, you’re going to have to pay for it. ner, and we’re not going back. But we’re not going to let him. There’s a lot more to do over the next 4 Audience members. No-o-o! years to better secure our ports and borders The President. It’s the wrong medicine and to train our great first-responders and for America. And the people understand, to dramatically improve our intelligence- you’re not raising taxes on the working peo- gathering capabilities. Listen, reform isn’t ple of this country. They share that same old easy. There’s a lot of entrenched interests in Washington mindset: They’ll give the orders, places like Washington, DC. [Laughter] and you pay the bills. [Laughter] Some people up there love the status quo. Audience member. No way! It’s not enough to advocate reform; you The President. We’re turning that corner, have to get it done, see, because when it and we’re not turning back. comes to reforming schools to provide an ex- This is a world of rapid change, amazing cellent education for all our children, results times we live in. In order to make sure the matter. When it comes to health care reforms American people are able to adjust to the to give families more access and more change, I think people need to own some- choices, results matter. When it comes to im- thing. I think you need to be owning your proving our economy and creating quality own health care account and managing it for jobs, results matter. When it comes to de- your purposes. I think people, younger work- fending America and spreading freedom and ers—I mean, young workers—need to have peace, results matter. When it comes to the opportunity to manage and own some of electing a President, results matter. their own retirement accounts. I think—I Audience members. Four more years! know we need to keep working for people Four more years! Four more years! to own their own home, own their own small The President. This week, the other party business. This administration understands gathered in Boston. And they had a conven- that when you own something, you have a tion and there was a lot of clever speeches vital stake in the future of our country. and some pretty big promises. Listen, I think No, this is a time of amazing change. But my opponent has good intentions, but good some things will never change: our belief in intentions don’t always translate into results. liberty, our desire for opportunity to spread He’s been there for 19 years in the U.S. Sen- throughout this country, the nonnegotiable

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00021 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1416 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

demands of human dignity. The individual those times. This is times that requires vision values we try to live by will not change: cour- and strength and determination, resolute age and compassion, reverence and integrity. will. The institutions that give us direction and None of us will ever forget that week when purpose, our families, our schools, our reli- one era ended and another began. On Sep- gious congregations. These values and insti- tember the 14th, 2001, I stood in the ruins tutions are fundamental to our lives. They of the Twin Towers. It’s a day I will never deserve the respect of Government. forget. I remember those guys in hardhats We stand for something. We stand for in- yelling at me, ‘‘Whatever it takes.’’ I remem- stitutions like marriage and family, which are ber the firefighter grabbing me by the arm the foundation of society. We stand for a cul- and looking me in the eye, bloodshot eyes ture of life in which every person counts and and sweat pouring, and he said, ‘‘Do not let every person matters. We stand for judges me down.’’ who faithfully interpret the law, not legislate This fellow—and they all took what hap- from the bench. pened on that day personally. I know you We stand for the Second Amendment, did, as did I. I have a duty that goes on. which gives every American the individual I wake up every morning thinking about how right to bear arms. I’ve got a good record to better protect America. I will never relent on that issue. It stands in stark contrast to in bringing justice to the enemy. I will never my opponent. As a sportsman, I understand relent in defending America, whatever it that gun ownership carries serious respon- takes. sibilities. I also know that when a person We’ve come through a lot. We’ve come commits a crime with a gun, they need to through a lot together. We’ve done a lot of be held to account. Over the past 3 years, hard work together to make this country Federal prosecutions of crimes committed hopeful and promising. During the next 4 with firearms have increased 68 percent. Our years, we’ll work to spread ownership and message is, law-abiding citizens should be al- opportunity to every corner of the country— lowed to bear and own a gun, and criminals I mean every corner. We’ll pass the enduring who commit crime with guns ought to go to values of our country on to another genera- jail. tion. We will lead the cause—lead the cause We stand for a culture of responsibility in of freedom and peace. And we will prevail. America. This culture of this country is With your support and your prayers, I will changing from one that has said, ‘‘If it feels be a leader America can count on in this good, just go ahead and do it,’’ and ‘‘If you’ve world of change. Listen, 4 years ago, when got a problem, blame somebody else,’’ to a I traveled to your great State and traveled culture in which each of us understands our wonderful Nation, I told our fellow citi- we’re responsible for the decisions we make zens, if you honored me with the great re- in life. If you’re fortunate enough to be a sponsibility of being the President, I would mother or a father, you’re responsible for lov- uphold the dignity and the honor of the office ing your child with all your heart and all your to which I was elected. If you give me 4 more soul. If you’re worried about the quality of years—with your help, with 4 more years, the education in which you live, you’re re- I will continue to honor that pledge. sponsible for doing something about it. If Thank you for coming. May God bless you you’re a CEO in corporate America, you’re all, and may God bless our great country. responsible for telling the truth to your Thank you all. shareholders and your employees. And in a responsibility society, each of us is respon- NOTE: The President spoke at 2:16 p.m. at Don sible for loving our neighbor just like we’d Coss Field in Cambridge City Park. In his re- marks, he referred to Gov. Bob Taft of Ohio; like to be loved ourselves. Mayor Samuel A. Salupo of Cambridge, OH; Rob- You know, for Americans, these years in ert T. Bennett, chairman, Ohio Republican Party; our history will always stand apart. There are Col. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, leader of quiet times in the life of a nation when little Libya; and former President Saddam Hussein of is expected of its leaders. This isn’t one of Iraq.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00022 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1417

Remarks at Cabela’s Retail Store in a great athlete, and a great adviser. He said, Triadelphia, West Virginia ‘‘When you ride your bike, don’t fall off.’’ July 31, 2004 [Laughter] I need to listen to him more. What a wonderful person Lynn Swann is, and General Manager Mike Boldrick. Mr. I’m proud to have him on my team. President, we’d like to welcome you to We’ve had a great day traveling in Ohio Triadelphia, West Virginia. It’s a suburb of and now in Pennsylvania, with a stop in West Wheeling. This is a new Cabela store. As you Virginia. The crowds are big, the enthusiasm can see, it’s 175,000 square feet. We’re going high. We’re on our way to 4 more years. to be bringing up to 1,200 new jobs to the I’m here to ask for your help. I’m out trav- area eventually. We currently have 450 peo- eling the country asking for people’s vote. I ple—— have more I want to do to see that this coun- The President. Four hundred fifty good try is safer, stronger, and better. people, I might add. Audience member. We love you! Mr. Boldrick. ——on staff. We’ll draw The President. Make sure you get your upwards of 5 or 6 million visitors a year to friends and neighbors to register to vote. And this location alone, making it the number one then, come election time, tell them we all tourist attraction in the State of West Vir- have a duty in this country to participate in ginia. the elections. And when you get them head- Marketing Manager John Castillo. And ed toward the polls, you might remind them the best news is, we’re building two more that George Bush and Dick Cheney are of these down in Texas next year. ready to lead this country with strength and The President. Oh, that’s great. vision and optimism. Mr. Boldrick. We’d like to present you I wish Laura were here. Man, did I luck with a Cabela’s hat and a rain slicker. out when she said yes. She’s a great wife and The President. Okay, thanks so much. wonderful, wonderful person and a wonder- Thanks for having me. Listen, thanks for hav- ful First Lady. Listen, I’m going to give you ing me. I’ve come by because, first, I love some reasons why you need to put me back to hunt and fish; secondly, because I heard in office, but perhaps the most important you’re expanding the job base here. Over reason is so that Laura will have 4 more years 1,200 new jobs is really good news for this as the First Lady. She sends her best. part of the country. I’m proud to be on the stage with Senator Mr. Boldrick. Absolutely. Arlen Specter. You need to put him back in The President. I want to thank you all to the United States Senate. I’m proud to for expanding your operations. You picked be on the stage with Rick Santorum, the a great place in the world to come. United States Senator. I thank Congress- Mr. Boldrick. We love it here. man—Congresswoman Melissa Hart and The President. Good, hard-working de- Congressman Tim Murphy for their service. cent folks who are going to make you proud. I want to thank everybody who is running So thanks for your hospitality. I love being for office. I particularly want to say thanks here with you all. to the grassroots activists who are here. You’re the people who are going to put up NOTE: The President spoke at approximately 4:34 the signs and make the phone calls. Find p.m. A tape was not available for verification of the content of these remarks. those discerning Democrats and wise inde- pendents and get them to join our cause to make this country a great place for every- Remarks in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania body. July 31, 2004 I understand a fellow Texan was here, Lee Ann Womack. I want to thank her for her The President. Thank you all very much. entertainment. Proud to call her friend. Thanks for coming. Boy, it’s great to be back Listen, I’m here to ask for the vote. And in Pittsburgh. Thank you all for being here. every incumbent who asks for your vote has I’m proud to be introduced by a great man, to answer a question, and that is, why. Why—

VerDate May 21 2004 12:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00023 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1418 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

why should the American people give me the not afford prescription drugs, and Medicare great privilege of serving for 4 more years? didn’t pay for them. Listen, leaders in both In the past years, we have done a lot to- political party, year after year after year, gether. We’ve come through a lot. And we’ve made promises to our American seniors. We accomplished a great deal. But there’s only got it done. More than 4 million seniors have reason to look backward at the record, and signed up for drug discount cards that pro- that is to determine who best to lead the Na- vide real savings. And beginning in 2006, all tion forward. seniors on Medicare will be able to choose I’m here to ask for the vote. I’m traveling a plan that suits their needs and gives them Ohio and West Virginia and Pennsylvania the coverage for prescription drugs. asking for the vote because we have so much We’ve expanded community health cen- more to do to move this country forward. ters for low-income Americans. We’ve cre- I want to be your President for 4 more years ated health savings accounts so families can to make the country safer, to make the econ- save, tax-free, for their own health care omy stronger. We have more to do to make needs. When it comes to giving Americans our economy stronger and more to do to more choices about their own health care and make our future brighter and better for every making health care more affordable, we’re single citizen. From creating jobs to improv- turning the corner, and we’re not turning ing schools, from fighting terror to spreading back. the peace, we have made progress. And we There’s more to do. There’s more to do. still have more to do. Most new jobs are created by small busi- We have more to do to make sure our pub- nesses, which have trouble affording private lic schools are the centers of excellence so health insurance. To help more American that no child is left behind in America. We families get health insurance at reasonable came to office 31⁄2 years ago, too many chil- costs, we must allow small employers to join dren were being shuffled from grade to together to purchase insurance at discounts grade, year after year, without learning the available to big companies. basics. We’re now challenging what I call the To improve health care we must stop the soft bigotry of low expectations. We’re raising frivolous lawsuits that raise the cost of health the bar. We’re insisting on higher standards. care. We believe in accountability. We believe in Audience members. Four more years! local control of schools. We believe in em- Four more years! Four more years! powering parents. Today, children across The President. My opponent takes a dif- America are showing real progress in reading ferent view. and math. When it comes to improving our Audience members. Boo-o-o! public schools, we’re turning the corner, and The President. He blocked medical liabil- we’re not turning back. ity reform 10 times, including twice in the We have more to do. We’ve got to recog- past 3 years. nize this world of ours is changing. The jobs Audience members. Boo-o-o! of the future will require greater knowledge The President. See, I don’t think you can and higher-level skills, so we’re going to re- be pro-doc, pro-patient, and pro-trial-lawyer form our high schools to make sure the high at the same time; I think you have to make school diploma means something. We will ex- a choice. I think you have to make a choice. pand math and science so our young people My opponent made his choice, and he put can compete in a high-tech world. We will him on the ticket. I made my choice. I’ll expand the use of the Internet to bring high- stand with the docs and the patients of Amer- level training in the classrooms. With 4 more ica and get medical liability reform. years, we’ll help a rising generation gain the We can do more to harness technology to skills and the confidence necessary to achieve reduce costs and prevent health care mis- the American Dream. takes. We can do more to expand research We have more to do to make quality health and seek new cures for diseases. In all we care available and affordable. When we came do to improve health care in America, we to office, too many older Americans could will make sure the health decisions are made

VerDate May 21 2004 12:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00024 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1419

by patients and doctors, not by bureaucrats In order to keep jobs here, in order to in Washington, DC. make sure this economy continues to grow, We have more to do to make our economy we will reject economic isolationism. We will stronger. Think about what we’ve been insist on a level playing field when it comes through. We’ve been through a recession and to trade. You see, I believe this: We can com- terror attacks and corporate scandals. We’ve pete with anybody, anytime, anywhere if the overcome these obstacles because the spirit rules are fair. of America is strong. We’ve overcome these We’ll help American families keep some- obstacles because we’ve got the best, most thing they don’t have nearly enough of, and productive workers in the world. We’ve over- that’s time—time to be with your kids, time come these obstacles because we’ve got great to take care of your elderly parents, time to farmers and ranchers. We’ve overcome these help yourself by education. Congress needs obstacles because the entrepreneurial spirit to enact what we call comp-time and flex- is strong in America and the small-business time to help American families better juggle sector of our economy is alive and well. work and home duties. And we’ve overcome these obstacles be- After 4 more years—with your work, after cause of two well-timed tax cuts. We didn’t 4 more years, there will be better and higher- pick winners or losers when it came to tax paying jobs in America, more small busi- relief. We had a fair view that said, ‘‘If you nesses in America, and America will remain pay taxes, you ought to get relief.’’ Families the greatest economic engine in the world. with children got relief. Married couples got Audience members. Four more years! relief. Small businesses that purchased Four more years! Four more years! equipment got relief. And this time, the The President. We have more to do to check was actually in the mail. wage and win the war against terrorism. Because we acted, our economy since last America’s future depends on our willingness summer has grown at a rate as fast as any to lead in the world. If America shows weak- in nearly 20 years. Because we acted, Amer- ness and uncertainty in this decade, the ica has added more than 1.5 million new jobs world will drift toward tragedy. This will not since last August. Because we acted, Pennsyl- happen on my watch. vania has added more than 68,000 jobs over The world changed on a terrible Sep- the past four months. When it comes to cre- tember morning. And since that day, we’ve ating jobs for America’s workers, we’re turn- changed the world. Before September the ing the corner, and we’re not turning back. 11th, Afghanistan served as the home base There’s more to do. There’s more to make of Al Qaida, which trained and deployed sure America is job-friendly and America’s thousands of killers to set up terror cells in workplaces are family-friendly. To keep dozens of countries, including our own. American jobs in America, regulations should Today, because we acted, Afghanistan is a be reasonable and fair. To keep American rising democracy. Because we acted, many jobs in America, we must lessen our depend- young girls now go to school for the first ence on foreign sources of energy. To keep time. Because we acted, last night in Cleve- American jobs in America, we must end the land, I had the opportunity to meet a young junk lawsuits that threaten our small-business girls’ soccer team from Afghanistan, here to owners. To keep American jobs in America, compete in the International Children’s we will not overspend your money and we Games. Because we acted, Afghanistan is an will keep your taxes low. ally in the war on terror, and America and We will offer American workers a lifetime the world are safer. of learning and help them get the training Before September the 11th, Pakistan was for the jobs of the future, at our community a safe transit place for terrorists. Today, Paki- colleges. You see, the education and training stan is an ally in the war against terror. Paki- they offer can be the bridge between peo- stan forces are aggressively helping to round ple’s lives as they are and people’s lives as up the terrorists, and America and the world they want them to be. are safer.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00025 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1420 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Before September the 11th, Saudi—in choice to make: either forget the lessons of Saudi Arabia, terrorists were raising money, September the 11th and trust a madman, or recruiting and operating with little opposi- defend our country. Given that choice, I will tion. Today, the Saudi Government is taking defend America every time. the fight to Al Qaida, and America and the Audience members. U.S.A.! U.S.A.! world are safer. U.S.A.! Before September the 11th, Libya was The President. We have more to do. We spending millions of dollars on weapons of have more to do. I’m seeking the office for mass destruction. Today, because America 4 more years, because we must—we must and our allies have sent a strong and clear continue to work with our friends and allies message, the leader of Libya has abandoned around the world to aggressively pursue the his pursuit of weapons of mass destruction, terrorists in places like Iraq and Afghanistan and America and the world are safer. and elsewhere. You see, you cannot talk Audience members. U.S.A.! U.S.A.! sense to these people. U.S.A.! Audience members. No-o-o! The President. Before September the The President. You cannot negotiate with 11th, the ruler of Iraq was a sworn enemy them. of America. He was defying the world. He Audience members. No-o-o! was firing weapons at American pilots enforc- The President. You cannot hope for the ing the world’s sanctions. He had pursued best and hope they change. and used weapons of mass destruction. He Audience members. No-o-o! harbored terrorists. He invaded his neigh- The President. We must engage these en- bors. He subsidized the families of suicide emies around the world so we do not have bombers. He had murdered tens of thou- to face them here at home. sands of his own citizens. He was a source America will continue to lead the world of great instability in a dangerous part of the with confidence and moral clarity. We put world. together a strong coalition of friends and al- After September the 11th, we looked at lies to help defeat this enemy. There are all the threats of the world in a new light. nearly 40 nations involved in Afghanistan, After September the 11th, this Nation needs some 30 nations in Iraq. Over the next 4 to take threats seriously before they fully ma- years, we’ll continue to build our alliances terialize. The September 11th Commission and work with our friends for the cause of concluded our institutions of Government security and peace. But I’ll never turn over had failed to imagine the horror of that day. America’s national security decisions to lead- Well, after September the 11th, we could not ers of other foreign countries. fail to imagine—could not fail to imagine that We’ll keep our commitments to help Af- a brutal tyrant who hated America and had ghanistan and Iraq become peaceful and ties to terror and had used weapons of mass democratic societies. These two nations are destruction might use those weapons or now governed by leaders who believe in the share his deadly capabilities with the terror- hopes and aspirations of their people. See, ists. they know what I know: Moms and dads of We looked at the intelligence, and we saw those countries want their children to grow a threat. Members of the United States Con- up in a peaceful world, just like the moms gress—from both political parties, including and dads here in America. They’ve got my opponent—looked at the same intel- dreams for their children, just like the moms ligence, and they saw a threat. The United and dads in America have dreams for our Nations looked at the intelligence and de- children. The people of these countries can manded a full accounting—— count on our continued help. You see, when Audience members. Boo-o-o! we acted to protect our own security, we also The President. ——of Saddam Hussein’s promised to help deliver them from tyranny, weapons programs. After 12 years of defi- to restore their sovereignty, to help them on ance, he again refused to comply. He de- the path to liberty. And when America gives ceived the weapons inspectors, so I had a its word, America will keep its word.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00026 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / July 31 1421

In these crucial times, our commitments By serving the ideal of liberty, we’re bring- have been kept by the men and women of ing hope to others. And that makes America our military. more secure in the long run, and it makes Audience members. U.S.A.! U.S.A.! the world more peaceful. By serving the ideal U.S.A.! of liberty, we’re serving the values of our The President. I want to thank all of the country. We know that freedom is not Amer- veterans who are here, who have set such ica’s gift to the world; freedom is the Al- a great example for those who wear the uni- mighty God’s gift to every man and woman form today. I’ve had the privilege of meeting in this world. with those who defend our country and sac- We have more to do to protect our coun- rifice for our security. I’ve seen their great try, more to do to protect America. There decency and unselfish courage. The cause of are enemies out there that still hate us, and freedom is in really good hands. They de- they’re still plotting. Listen, the September serve—those in the uniform deserve the full the 11th Commission said our homeland is support of our Government. safer, but we’re not yet safe. I agree with Last September, while our troops were in that assessment. We’ve started the hard proc- combat in both Afghanistan and Iraq, I pro- ess of reform. We’ve transformed our de- posed supplemental funding to support them fenses and are creating a new Department in their missions. That legislation provided of Homeland Security, ably run by former for body armor and for vital equipment, haz- Governor of Pennsylvania Tom Ridge. We ard pay, health benefits, ammunition, fuel, passed the PATRIOT Act to give law en- and spare parts. In the Senate, in the United forcement new tools to track and find terror- States Senate, only a small, what I would call ists. The mission of the FBI is now focused out-of-the-mainstream minority—— on preventing terrorism. We’re integrating Audience members. Boo-o-o! law and intelligence enforcement better than The President. ——of 12 Senators voted ever before. When it comes to better pro- against the legislation. tecting our country, we’re turning a corner, Audience members. Boo-o-o! and we’re not turning back. The President. Two of those Senators are There’s more to do—there’s more to do, my opponent and his runningmate. to do our duty to protect the American peo- Audience members. Boo-o-o! ple. We better—we’ve got to do a better job The President. Senator Kerry tried to ex- of securing our ports and borders. We’ve got plain his vote by saying, ‘‘I actually did vote to continue to train our first-responders. for the 87 billion, before I voted against it.’’ We’ve got to dramatically improve our intel- Audience members. Boo-o-o! ligence-gathering capability. It’s not going to The President. End quote. [Laughter] be easy. It never is. There’s a lot of en- Then he went on to say, well, he’s proud of trenched interests in Washington, DC. A lot the vote, and then he further said the whole of people got comfortable with the status thing is a complicated matter. There’s noth- quo. This administration isn’t. It’s not enough ing complicated about supporting our troops just to advocate reform; you have to be able in combat. to get it done. In the long run, our security is not guaran- When it comes to reforming schools to teed by military might and force alone. We provide an excellent education to all our chil- must work to change the conditions that give dren, results matter. When it comes to health rise to terror: poverty and hopelessness and care reforms to give families more access and resentment. A free and peaceful Iraq and a more choices, results matter. When it comes free and peaceful Afghanistan will be power- to improving our economy and creating jobs, ful examples in a neighborhood that’s des- results matter. When it comes to better se- perate for freedom. See, free countries do curing our homeland and spreading freedom not export terror. Free countries do not stifle and peace, results matter. And when it comes the dreams of their citizens. Free countries to picking a President, results matter. listen to the hopes and aspirations of their Audience members. Four more years! citizens. Four more years! Four more years!

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00027 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1422 July 31 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

The President. They recently had a meet- We have a time of change in this country, ing in Boston. a time of real, rapid change. It’s an exciting Audience members. Boo-o-o! time to be an American. But we’ve got to The President. We heard a lot of clever make sure the Government responds to these speeches and some pretty big promises. But times by standing on the side of workers and intentions—good intentions of my opponent families. We want people owning things in don’t always translate into results. Listen, America. We want workers to be able to own after 19 years in the Senate, he’s had thou- their own health care plans so they can take sands of votes but few signature achieve- them from job to job. We want younger ments. During 8 years on the Senate Intel- workers to be able to own a personal retire- ligence Committee, he voted to cut the intel- ment account when it comes to Social Secu- ligence budget. rity, an account they can call their own and Audience members. Boo-o-o! pass on from one generation to the next. We The President. Yet, he had no record of want more people owning their own home reforming America’s intelligence-gathering in America. We want more people owning capability. He’s had no significant record of their own small business. We understand that reforming education or health care. when a person owns something, he or she We have a difference of opinion: He and has a vital stake in the future of our country. his runningmate oppose reforms that limit No, in this changing world, there are some the power of Washington and leave more things that won’t change: our belief in liberty power in the hands of the people; I believe and opportunity and the nonnegotiable de- in limiting the power of Washington and giv- mands of human dignity. Values won’t ing more power to the people. No, I’m run- change, the values we try to live by: courage ning against an experienced Washington, and compassion, reverence and integrity. DC-type Senator. He’s spent nearly 20 years The institutions that give us direction and there, and it appears that he’s concluded the purpose must not change, our families, our Government just isn’t big enough. religious congregations. These institutions Audience members. Boo-o-o! are fundamental to our lives, and they de- The President. After all, he’s proposed serve the respect of the Government. more than $2 trillion of additional spending, In this changing times, our values and and we’re just getting started in the cam- strong beliefs will not change. We stand for paign. [Laughter] institutions like marriage and family, which Audience members. Boo-o-o! are the foundations of society. We stand for The President. But the problem is, he a culture of life in which every person counts hasn’t told us how he’s going to pay for it. and every person matters. We stand for Yet, all we’ve got to do is look at his record judges who faithfully interpret the law in- to determine how he’s going to pay for it. stead of legislating from the bench. He’s voted time and time and time again for We stand for a culture of responsibility in higher taxes. America. This culture of ours is changing Audience members. Boo-o-o! from one that has said, ‘‘If it feels good, just The President. You know how he’s going go ahead and do it,’’ and ‘‘If you got a prob- to pay for his new programs? You’re going lem, blame somebody else,’’ to a culture that to pay. But we’re not going to let him. says each of us is responsible for the deci- Audience members. No-o-o! sions we make in life. If you are fortunate The President. Listen, we have a dif- enough to be a mother or a father, you’re ference of opinion in the campaign, a clear responsible for loving your child with all your difference. My opponents share an old Wash- heart and all your soul. If you’re worried ington mindset: They will give the orders; about the quality of the education in the you’ll pay the bills. community in which you live, you’re respon- Audience members. Boo-o-o! sible for doing something about it. If you’re The President. We’re turning that corner, a CEO in corporate America, you are respon- and we’re not going back. sible for telling the truth to your shareholders

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00028 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 2 1423

and your employees. And in this responsi- world, a world where people can grow up bility society, each of us is responsible for and realize their hopes. loving our neighbor just like we’d like to be During the next 4 years, we’ll spread own- loved ourself. ership and opportunity to every corner—I Today I met Fay Morgan, the executive mean, every corner—of this country. We’ll director of the North Hills Community Out- pass the enduring values of America on to reach. It’s a faith-based program, all aimed the next generation. We’ll lead the cause of at feeding the hungry, providing clothes to freedom and peace, and we will prevail. those who need clothes in the winter, of Audience members. Four more years! helping people find a job. You know what Four more years! Four more years! it really is? It’s a program that’s heard a high- The President. Four years ago, I traveled er calling, that’s going to love their neighbor your great State and our wonderful Nation just like they’d like to be loved themselves. asking for the vote, and I made a pledge to The strength of this country—the strength my fellow Americans. I said if you honor me of this country is not found in our halls of with this great responsibility, I will uphold Government; the strength of this country is the dignity and the honor of the office to found in the hearts and souls of the American which I have been elected, so help me, God. citizens. And over the next 4 years, I will con- And with your help—and with your help, tinue to rally the armies of compassion to I will continue to do so over the next 4 years. help change America one heart, one soul, Thanks for coming. May God bless. Thank one conscience at a time. you all. For all Americans, these years in our his- tory will stand apart. There are quiet times NOTE: The President spoke at 6:08 p.m. at the in the life of a nation when little is expected David L. Lawrence Convention Center. In his re- of its leaders. This isn’t one of those times. marks, he referred to former professional football It’s a time where we need firm resolve, clear player Lynn C. Swann; country music entertainer vision, strong determination. Lee Ann Womack; Col. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, leader of Libya; former President Sad- None of us will ever forget that day when dam Hussein of Iraq; and the National Commis- one era ended and another began. On Sep- sion on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States tember the 14th, 2001, I stood in the ruins (9/11 Commission). of the Twin Towers. It’s a day that I will never forget. There were workers in hardhats yelling at me, ‘‘Whatever it takes.’’ I remem- Remarks on Intelligence Reform and ber working the line, thanking people for an Exchange with Reporters their sacrifice and service, thanking people August 2, 2004 for their care, for their loved ones who had rushed into harm’s way. A man grabbed me The President. Thanks for coming. I ap- by the arm, and he said, ‘‘Do not let me preciate the members of my administration down.’’ joining me. Thank you all for being here. He took it personally. The people going My most solemn duty is to protect our through the rubble took that day personally. country. It’s our most solemn duty as well. I know you took it personally, and so did I. In the 3 years since our country was attacked, I have a responsibility that goes on. I wake we’ve taken steps to overcome new threats. up every day thinking about how better to We will continue to do everything in our protect our country and our people. I will power to defeat the terrorist enemy and to never relent in defending America, whatever protect the American people. it takes. Recently, the Commission on the Terrorist We’ve come through a lot together—we’ve Attacks Upon the United States came to a come through a lot together. And we’ve done conclusion that I share, that our country is the hard work. And the country is getting safer than it was on September the 11th, better, and the world is becoming more 2001, yet we’re still not safe. The Commis- peaceful. That’s what we long for, a peaceful sion members have worked hard and served

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00029 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1424 Aug. 2 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

our country well. I speak for all Americans Many of these changes are specific rec- in thanking them for their fine work. ommendations of the 9/11 Commission. Oth- Their recommendations are thoughtful ers will go further than the proposal of the and valuable. My administration has already Commission’s report. All these reforms have taken numerous actions consistent with the a single goal: We will ensure that the people Commission’s recommendations. Today in Government responsible for defending we’re taking additional steps. America and countering terrorism have the Our Government’s actions against the ter- best possible information to make the best rorist threat accelerated dramatically after decisions. the attacks on the country. Across the world, Today I’m asking Congress to create the we’ve aggressively pursued Al Qaida terror- position of a National Intelligence Director. ists, destroyed their training camps, and That person—the person in that office will ended their sanctuaries. We’re working be appointed by the President, with the ad- closely with other countries to gather intel- vice and consent of the Senate, and will serve ligence and make arrests and to cut off the at the pleasure of the President. The Na- terrorist’s finances. tional Intelligence Director will serve as the We’ve created a new unified Department President’s principal intelligence adviser and of Homeland Security and gave it resources will oversee and coordinate the foreign and and the authority to defend America. We’re domestic activities of the intelligence com- employing the latest equipment and know- munity. Under this reorganization, the CIA how to secure our borders, our air and sea will be managed by a separate Director. The ports, and infrastructure. We’re bringing the National Intelligence Director will assume best technologies to bear against the threat the broader responsibility of leading the in- of chemical and biological warfare. Project telligence community across our Govern- BioShield will fund cutting-edge drugs and ment. other defenses against a biological, chemical, I want, and every President must have, the nuclear, or radiological attack. best, unbiased, unvarnished assessment of To track terrorists and disrupt their cells America’s intelligence professionals. Cre- and seize their assets, we’re using the tools ating the position of the National Intelligence of the PATRIOT Act. Congress needs to ex- Director will require a substantial revision of tend this important law. Congress needs to the 1947 National Security Act. I look for- make sure law enforcement have the tools ward to working with the Members of Con- necessary to defend the country. We’ve gress to move ahead on this important re- transformed the FBI to focus on the preven- form. tion of terrorist attacks. We’re continuing to The 9/11 Commission also made several expand and strengthen the capabilities of the recommendations about Congress, itself. I Central Intelligence Agency. We established strongly agree with the Commission’s rec- the Terrorist Threat Integration Center to ommendation that oversight and intel- merge and analyze, in a single place, foreign ligence—oversight of intelligence and of the and domestic intelligence on global terror. homeland security must be restructured and Yet, the work of securing this vast Nation made more effective. There are too many is not done. The elevation of the threat level committees with overlapping jurisdiction, in New York and New Jersey and Wash- which wastes time and makes it difficult for ington, DC, is a serious reminder, a solemn meaningful oversight and reform. reminder, of the threat we continue to face. Today I also announce that we will estab- All the institutions of our Government must lish a National Counterterrorism Center. be fully prepared for a struggle against terror This new center will build on the analytical that will last into the future. Our goal is an work—the really good analytical work—of integrated, unified national intelligence ef- the Terrorist Threat Integration Center and fort. Therefore, my administration will con- will become our Government’s knowledge tinue moving forward with additional bank for information about known and sus- changes to the structure and organization of pected terrorists. The new center will coordi- our intelligence agencies. nate and monitor counterterrorism plans and

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00030 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 2 1425

activities of all Government agencies and de- working hard to protect America. We don’t partments to ensure effective joint action and want these efforts to get in the way of their that our efforts are unified in priority and efforts to protect our fellow citizens. purpose. The center will also be responsible We are a nation in danger. We’re doing for preparing the daily terrorism threat re- everything we can in our power to confront port for the President and senior officials. the danger. We’re making good progress in The Director of the National protecting our people and bringing our en- Counterterrorism Center will report to the emies to account. But one thing is for certain: National Intelligence Director, once that po- We’ll keep our focus, and we’ll keep our re- sition is created. Until then, the center will solve. We will do our duty to best secure report to the Director of the CIA. our country. Given the growing threat of weapons and I’ll answer a couple of questions today. missile proliferation in our world, it may also Scott [Scott Lindlaw, Associated Press], have be necessary to create a similar center in our you got one? Government to bring together our intel- ligence analysis, planning, and operations to Congressional Action on Intelligence track and prevent the spread of weapons of Reform mass destruction. I asked the Commission headed by Judge Laurence Silberman and Q. First, I’d like to ask you what the level Senator Chuck Robb to determine the merits of urgency is here on those actions that re- of creating such a center. This Nation must quire congressional approval. They’re out on do everything we can to keep the world’s recess until Labor Day. Can you envision most destructive weapons out of the world’s calling them back into special session? And most dangerous hands. also, you’ve got a terror warning, as you said, Finally, we will act on other recommenda- in three cities. How do you react without tip- tions made by the Commission. In coming ping the bad guys off and without turning days, I’ll issue a series of directives to various the country into a fortress? departments to underscore and further out- The President. Yes. Well, the first ques- line essential steps for the U.S. Government tion is—listen, the Congress has been think- on the war on terror. All relevant agencies ing about some of these ideas. They can think must complete the task of adopting common about them over August and come back and databases and procedures so that intelligence act on them in September. We look forward and homeland security information can be to working with them—not only in the cre- shared and searched effectively, consistent ation of the National Intelligence Director, with privacy and civil liberties. how to do it the right way, but also the 9/ At the same time, the FBI Director will 11 Commission had some very constructive continue his restructuring of the Bureau to suggestions for congressional reform. I think create a specialized workforce for collecting, Tom told me one time he—how many dif- analyzing domestic intelligence on terrorism. ferent committees have you testified in front The Acting CIA Director will continue to in- of? crease efforts already underway to strength- Homeland Security Secretary Tom en human intelligence and analytical capa- Ridge. Well, 140 times our leadership was bilities. up there last year. The dedicated, hard-working men and The President. He testified 140 different women of our intelligence community are la- times. boring every day to keep our country safe. Secretary Ridge. Leadership. I’m proud of their work—and so should our The President. And—— American citizens. We’re in their debt. We’re Secretary Ridge. The leadership—Under grateful for them. And the changes we’re Secretaries—— making are designed to help the professionals The President. Yes. I mean, it’s a lot of— carry out their essential missions as best as he’s got a lot of jurisdictions up there, and they possibly can. I’ll work closely with the so he goes committee, subcommittee, this Congress to ensure that reform does not dis- committee, that committee. I mean, it seems rupt their daily work. We’ve got good people like it’s one thing to testify and, therefore,

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00031 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1426 Aug. 2 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

to be oversight; it’s another thing to make tions? And will you give the new Director sure that the people who are engaged in pro- sweeping budget authority? tecting America don’t spend all their time The President. Because I thought it was testifying. And so there’s going to be some the right thing to do, Adam. And the good important reforms. We look forward to work- thing about having an administration full of ing with Congress on the reforms. competent, capable intelligence people is The second part of your two-part ques- that I get all different kinds of opinions. The tion? best decisionmaking process is one where people have different opinions, and they Intelligence Information Sharing bring them to me in a forthright way, and Q. In a situation like this, where you have then I make the decision about what I think this new terror alert, how do you react with- is best. And I think that the new National out tipping off the terrorists and having them Intelligence Director ought to be able to co- move to different targets, and how do you ordinate budgets. I certainly hope Congress avoid turning the country into a fortress? reforms its budget process too, so that it’s The President. Well, I appreciate that. I a seamless process. think we have an obligation to inform the Secondly, the National Intelligence Direc- people involved with protecting New York tor will work with the respective agencies to City, in this case, or parts of Jersey or parts set priorities. But let me make it also very of DC about what we know. We have an obli- clear that when it comes to operations, the gation. When we find out something, we’ve chain of command will be intact. When the got to share it. What we’re talking about here Defense Department is conducting oper- is a very serious matter based upon sound ations to secure the homeland, there’ll be intelligence. And I would hope the people nothing in between the Secretary of Defense affected in New York realize that by sharing and me. I believe this system will serve our intelligence, we can better prepare in case country well as we head into the depths of something were to happen. the 21st century. As I said in my remarks In other words, if we were just silent on here—that this struggle against these thugs the subject, I think people would be a lot will go on for a while, and therefore we’ve more nervous. They would say, ‘‘What is just got to do everything we can to be better Government withholding? Why weren’t they prepared. sharing stuff with the people responsible, Gregory [David Gregory, NBC News]. Commissioner Kelly or Mayor Bloomberg?’’ So our attitude is, we try to be as transparent War on Terror as possible with the affected sites so that peo- Q. Mr. President, thank you. All of this, ple can then take responses necessary to bet- as you know, is coming in the context of the ter protect the people. Presidential election campaign. Your oppo- But it’s serious business. I mean, we nent has made a couple of charges that I wouldn’t be contacting authorities at the local would like your response to: One, essentially level unless something was real. And what saying that 3 years after the 9/11 attacks, to this points up to is that there’s an enemy go about the business of rehauling the intel- which hates what we stand for. And it’s a ligence community, is too long; second, different kind of war. And it’s one that we’re there’s been a suggestion from the Kerry just going to have to continue to work on— camp today that this administration is actu- and will—do the very best we can to protect ally responsible for fueling the recruitment the country. of Al Qaida through some of its policies, par- Adam [Adam Entous, Reuters]. ticularly—they didn’t say this directly—but the war in Iraq. Your response? Proposed National Intelligence Director The President. Yes, that’s a misunder- Q. Mr. President, some of your own advis- standing of the war on terror. Obviously, we ers oppose creation of a National Intelligence have a difference of opinion—a clear dif- Director. Why did you override their objec- ference of opinion—about the stakes that

VerDate May 21 2004 12:16 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00032 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 2 1427

face America. These people we face are cold- Intelligence Director be part of the Execu- blooded, committed killers. They’re inter- tive Office, part of the executive branch. Why ested in destroying our way of life. They were the change? Why make it part of—with con- interested in destroying our way of life before gressional oversight? I arrived in office. The only way to deal with The President. Well, I don’t think that these people is to bring them to justice. person ought to be a member of my Cabinet. See, evidently some must think that you I will hire the person, and I can fire the per- can negotiate with them, you can talk sense son, which is—any President would like. to them, you can hope that they change. That’s how you have accountability in Gov- That’s not what I know. I know in order to ernment. I don’t think that the office ought deal with these people, we must bring them to be in the White House, however. I think to justice before they hurt us again. And so it ought to be a stand-alone group to better we’re on the offense. We will stay—the best coordinate, particularly between foreign in- way to protect the American homeland is to telligence and domestic intelligence matters. stay on the offense. It is a ridiculous notion I think it’s going to be one of the most useful to assert that because the United States is aspects of the National Intelligence Director. on the offense, more people want to hurt us. Let’s see. John—or Mike [Mike Allen, We are on the offense because people do Washington Post], why don’t you, and then want to hurt us. John Cochran [ABC News]. The other part of your question was what, sir? Situation in Afghanistan/Iran Q. Thank you, Mr. President. You saw that Counterterrorism Efforts Doctors Without Borders pulled out of Af- Q. Why wait 3 years after the 9/11 attacks ghanistan because it was too dangerous. to call for this kind of reform? Senator Kerry You’ve seen reports about the re-formed has said that’s too long. Taliban. Why is the security situation there The President. Yes. We have imple- so poor? What do you see as the trajectory mented significant reforms since 9/11. The of it? And Mr. President, do you worry that FBI is reformed, and Director Mueller has you should have given more attention to Iran done a fabulous job. The communications earlier? between the FBI and the CIA have been en- The President. First, let me address Af- hanced by the creation of what’s called TTIC, ghanistan. I did see that the Doctors Without the Terrorist Threat Integration Center. We Borders left, and I’m sorry they did, because moved quickly to make sure that there is a they were providing a important function for seamless spread of information throughout the people who want to live in a free society. our Government. We called for and worked I also saw, at the same time, that there’s with Congress to create the Department of over—I think it’s 9 million Afghan citizens Homeland Security. Not everybody in Con- have registered to vote. That’s an unbeliev- gress agreed with how that Department able statement, isn’t it? Do you remember ought to be set up. But we got it set up, when we were here—I can’t remember, at and not only that, under Secretary Ridge, we one of my press conferences—we had a dis- have implemented the integration of mul- cussion about this, but there was some con- tiple agencies to better protect the home- cern that, well, maybe they’re not going to land. We’ve done a lot since September the get even the 3 million people registered to 11th. vote in Afghanistan. Or maybe it was—some Let’s see here. Jay Newton-Small minimal threshold. I think we’re over 9 mil- [Bloomberg News]. How are you? lion now? Q. Good, and you? Secretary Ridge. Yes, just about 9 mil- The President. I’m fine. lion. The President. Nine million people have Proposed National Intelligence Director said to the world, ‘‘We love freedom, and Q. Mr. President, the 9/11 Commission we’re going to vote.’’ Now, the Taliban still originally recommended that the National roams in parts of the country, and we’re

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00033 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1428 Aug. 2 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

working with the Afghan Government to essary to protect, as best as we possibly can. bring them to justice. These are similar to This is a big country. We’re a free country. the killers in Iraq; they’ll lurk in shadows and And as I’ve said many times, we’ve got to come out and kill indiscriminately. Do you be 100 percent correct; they’ve got to be cor- remember they pulled the women off the rect once. But the people need to know that bus? They got the bus; they stopped and said, we’re taking action on actionable intel- ‘‘Everybody—the women with voter registra- ligence. tion cards step up,’’ and they killed them. First part of the—the 9/11—listen, my job Nevertheless, the Afghan people refuse to be is to take a look at what I think is right and intimidated. They’re showing up in droves to to build on that which we’ve already done. vote. A free society is emerging in that part We’ve already done a lot. Take a good look of the world. at what has taken place since 9/11, and I In Iran, we are paying very close attention think you’ll be, as a citizen concerned about to Iran. We have ever since I’ve been in of- your own safety, I think you’ll be pleased. fice here. We are working with our friends And the question is, how do we do more? to keep the pressure on the mullahs to listen We’re more than happy to do more. to the demands of the free world. And we’re Last question. Deans [Bob Deans, Cox working with the—hold on a second, please. Newspapers]. Excuse me. We’re working with the IAEA to keep the pressure on Iran, and the Sec- Proposed National Intelligence Director/ retary is working very closely with the foreign Decisionmaking on Iraq ministers of France, Great Britain, and Ger- many, who are taking it upon themselves to Q. Yes, sir. Mr. President, can you say make it clear that the demands of Europe what you regard as the model for this Na- are also equal to—the same as the demands tional Intelligence Director? Is it the Fed? of the United States, that we expect for there Would it be the Joint Chiefs of Staff? to be full disclosure, full transparency of their The President. Yes. nuclear weapons programs. Q. And in what way would this new struc- Yes, Suzanne [Suzanne Malveaux, CNN]. ture prevent the kind of intelligence failings Suzanne. that preceded the war in Iraq with respect Q. Do you think the intelligence was—— to weapons, difficulty of the opposition faced, The President. Suzanne. and those sorts of things? The President. Not like the Fed. More Response to Terrorism Threats like the Joint Chiefs, because the Joint Chiefs Q. Mr. President, your opponent, John have got a—even though not a part of the Kerry, has called for a complete endorsement chain of command, they are affected by the of the 9/11 Commission’s recommendations. chain of command. How do your actions today differ from his And the second part of the—oh, why own in ensuring national security? And what would this—listen, let me talk about the in- can the American people see in the days to telligence in Iraq. First of all, we all thought come, either feel or see, to know that they we would find stockpiles of weapons. We are better protected? may still find weapons. We haven’t found The President. Well, when we put out a them yet. Every person standing up here threat alert like we did yesterday and then would say, gosh, we thought it was going to work with folks at the local jurisdictions to be different, as did the Congress, by the way, respond, the American people need to know members of both parties, and the United Na- that, one, our intelligence gathering is doing tions. But what we do know is that Saddam its job—the intelligence gatherers are doing Hussein had the capability of making weap- their job. And secondly, the response mecha- ons. nism is fast. And they need to know their And let me just say this to you: Knowing Government—there are thousands of people what I know today, we still would have gone working overtime to not only find data but on into Iraq. We still would have gone to analyze data and then take the steps nec- make our country more secure. He had the

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00034 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 3 1429

capability of making weapons. He had ter- agreement come true: Secretary of State rorist ties. The decision I made was the right Powell, Secretary of Agriculture Ann decision. The world is better off without Sad- Veneman, Secretary of Commerce Don dam Hussein in power. And I find it inter- Evans, and, of course, Ambassador Bob esting, in the political process, that some say, Zoellick, who is the U.S. Trade Representa- ‘‘Well, I voted for the intelligence,’’ and now tive. they won’t say whether or not it was the right Just as an aside, Zoellick has done heroic decision to take Saddam Hussein out. It’s the work, as has his staff, to see to it that the right decision, and the world is better off for world trades more freely and America is it. treated fairly when it comes to trade. Listen, thank you all. I appreciate Ambassador Michael Thawley, the Ambassador of Australia to the NOTE: The President spoke at 11:33 a.m. in the United States, for his tireless efforts in rep- Rose Garden at the White House. In his remarks, resenting his country’s best interests as we he referred to Acting CIA Director John E. McLaughlin; and Police Commissioner Raymond negotiate this trade agreement. Mr. Ambas- W. Kelly and Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg of sador, you are a credit to your country. New York City. The President also referred to I’m also proud that Senator Orrin Hatch the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks is with us. Senator, I appreciate you taking Upon the United States (9/11 Commission); and time to come and represent the United the Commission on the Intelligence Capabilities States Congress. This agreement received of the United States Regarding Weapons of Mass strong bipartisan support. It represents that Destruction (Silberman/Robb Commission). members of both parties understand the ben- efits of trade to our country. Welcome, Sen- Remarks on Signing the United ator, I appreciate you coming. States-Australia Free Trade We support free and fair trade. I support Agreement Implementation Act free and fair trade, because it has the power to create new wealth for whole nations and August 3, 2004 new opportunities for millions of people. The President. Welcome. Please be seat- Sound policy can help unleash the initiative ed. I’m honored to welcome you all to the and talent of free people. Open trade is White House this morning, as I sign the legis- sound policy. It has a record for creating jobs lation implementing the historic free trade and raising living standards and lowering agreement between Australia and the United consumer prices. States. My administration is working with the For nearly a century, our two nations have Congress to extend the benefits of free trade been allies in war and partners in peace. throughout the western hemisphere, in Afri- Prime Minister Howard’s superb leadership ca, and into the Middle East. We renewed has helped ensure that the friendship be- the African Growth and Opportunity Act, tween our two peoples remains strong, that which promotes economic reforms and re- our commitment to political and economic duces trade barriers on goods from the na- freedom remains firm. tions of sub-Sahara Africa. Working with The U.S.-Australia Free Trade Agreement Congress, we entered into a new free trade is a milestone in the history of our alliance. agreement with Morocco and Chile. We’re It expands our security and political alliance encouraging the free flow of trade across the by creating a true economic partnership. It Pacific. Last year I had the honor to sign will create jobs and opportunities in both our a free trade agreement with Singapore, nations. It will fuel economic growth America’s first with an Asian Pacific nation. throughout the Pacific Rim, and it will Today I’m honored to sign legislation enact- strengthen our common ties of family and ing the second. friendship. The total annual two-way trade in Amer- I appreciate so very much those in my ican and Australian goods and services stands Cabinet who have worked hard to make this at $28 billion. Australia is America’s 10th

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00035 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1430 Aug. 3 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

largest export market. Our trade with Aus- and the world. For the last several days, our tralia is important to every American. It is trade ministers in Geneva have worked tire- vital to our economy. The U.S.-Australia lessly to achieve an agreed framework for the Free Trade Agreement is a recognition of WTO’s Doha’s negotiation. This framework that importance and a commitment by both provides a roadmap for these ongoing talks. our nations to work in partnership for com- Among other things, it commits WTO mem- mon prosperity. This agreement will imme- bers to the elimination of export subsidies diately eliminate duties on 99 percent of all on agricultural products. And it commits U.S.-manufactured exports to Australia. That them to start new work on the overhaul, is the largest immediate reduction of tariffs streamlining, and transparency of customs on manufactured goods ever achieved in an rules. There is more work to be done, but American free trade agreement. Prime Minister Howard and I remain com- America’s manufacturers estimate that mitted to the success of the Doha negotia- eliminating these tariffs will increase the ex- tions. port of manufactured goods by nearly $2 bil- The United States and Australia have lion per year. That will mean new jobs for never been closer. We’re allies in the war American workers. This agreement will also on terror. We’re partners in the effort to help be good for America’s farmers. It will elimi- democracy take root in Afghanistan and Iraq nate all duties on American agricultural prod- and throughout the world. We understand ucts entering Australia. Today, American that free societies will be peaceful societies. farmers export almost $700 million worth of We long for peace. I appreciate Prime Min- goods to Australia. And because of this agree- ister Howard. He’s a strong partner in peace. ment, that total will rise. We understand that over the long term, the Free and fair trade means more than only way to create a safer world is to create eliminating tariffs on existing trade. We must a better world. We share a belief in the need also work to open up new sectors of our to help others. economies to competition and trade. This This trade agreement serves the interests agreement opens important sectors of Aus- of our countries. It serves the interests of tralia’s economy, such as telecommuni- the United States and Australia. It serves the cations, government procurement, express interests of citizens with ambition and initia- delivery, computers, tourism, energy, con- tive and entrepreneurial instincts in both our struction, financial services, and entertain- countries. It advances the principle of free ment. And the agreement strengthens pro- and fair trade. I am grateful to the Prime tections for intellectual property and pro- Minister, John Howard, for his good work motes electronic commerce. and his vision and his friendship. One of the great economic achievements And it’s now my honor to sign the U.S.- since the end of the cold war has been the Australia Free Trade Implementation Act. success of free and fair trade in raising up [At this point, the President signed the bill.] the world’s poor, bringing hope to the world’s hopeless, promoting freedom among the The President. Thank you all for coming. world’s oppressed, and creating jobs at home and abroad. The same advantages that this NOTE: The President spoke at 9:27 a.m. in the Rose Garden at the White House. In his remarks, agreement will bring to the United States he referred to Prime Minister John Howard of and Australia can and should be available to Australia. H.R. 4759, approved August 3, was as- the developing world. Our two nations are signed Public Law No. 108–286. committed to the reduction of trade barriers and other restrictions that are keeping too much of the world from the kind of pros- Remarks to the Knights of Columbus perity and opportunity that the developed Convention in Dallas, Texas world takes for granted. August 3, 2004 On Saturday, that commitment yielded an important result that will benefit manufac- Thanks for the warm welcome. Welcome turers and farmers from America, Australia, to Texas. And thanks for inviting me so I can

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00036 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 3 1431

come home. [Laughter] I really appreciate a devoted servant of God and a true hero the Knights of Columbus. This strong organi- of our time. zation believes in families and faith and com- Pope John Paul II has been a unique and passion for those in need. And I’m honored commanding voice for the cause of the poor, you’d invite me to the 122d Convocation of the weak, the hungry, and the outcast. He this great organization. has challenged our Nation and the entire I appreciate Carl Anderson and his leader- world to embrace the culture of life. He’s ship. I’ve gotten to know Carl because, you called upon us to uphold and affirm the dig- see, he’s more than just an introducer of nity of every person, rich and poor, able and Presidents. [Laughter] He’s a person who disabled, born and unborn. He’s called us to works with Presidents—at least this Presi- love and serve our neighbors in need. Few dent. And I’m proud to have his help. It’s organizations have worked harder and done good to see my family friend Virgil Dechant. more and met this challenge than the Virgil, it’s good to see you, sir. Thank you Knights of Columbus. I know you’re proud for such a warm greeting in the photo op of your organization, and you should be. line and reminding me of some great days The Knights were born in New Haven, gone past. Connecticut. Come to think of it, so was I. I’m proud to be here with Cardinal [Laughter] From your foundations in a small McCarrick. It’s good to see you, sir. He’s a church basement, you have raised up one of the great America organizations dedicated to neighbor in my temporary residence. charity and mutual assistance and the fight [Laughter] I appreciate Cardinal Egan. I ap- for civil liberties. preciate Cardinal Rigali of the great city of I’m proud to say that my family has con- Philadelphia, Cardinal Francis George of tributed to your ranks. A few years ago, Gov- Chicago, Cardinal Keeler of Baltimore, ernor Jeb became a Knight. [Applause] And Maryland. I’m honored you all are here. I he—yes—and he recently took his Third De- thank you for your presence. I’m honored gree. I’ll see him this weekend. His son is to be in the presence of Cardinal Macharski, getting married. I’ll pass on the word, aim the Archbishop of Krakow, who succeeded for the Fourth. [Laughter] Jeb knows, as I the Holy Father in that role. Welcome to do, that your works of mercy are making our the United States. Appreciate you coming, society more compassionate, changing the sir. I appreciate Bishop Wilton Gregory’s lives of millions of citizens. Compassionate leadership of the Conference of Catholic work changes our society one heart and one Bishops. soul at a time. I appreciate Your Eminences and Your Last year, the Knights raised and donated Excellencies, reverends, monsignors, fathers, a record $130 million to charity. That’s a phe- and deacons. Nuestros amigos de Mexico. I nomenal record. You also volunteered for an appreciate the officers and directors, State unprecedented 61 million hours of commu- deputies, board of directors, delegates, ladies nity service. You obviously have heard the and gentlemen, Knights, and my fellow call. Americans. Thanks for having me. I was pleased to hear this story about the Two months ago, I had the privilege of Knights in Corpus Christi, Texas, at the visiting His Holy Father Pope John Paul II Mother Teresa Day Shelter. They’re a daily at the Vatican. It was my third meeting with presence there. They’re mopping the floors, His Holy Father since I took office, and for collecting laundry soap, blankets, and food those of you who have ever met him, you for 130 homeless men and women. They’re know I’m telling you the truth when I tell not giving the orders; they’re serving the peo- you being in his presence is an awesome ex- ple. Patricia Henry, the shelter director, put perience. He is a true presence. On the occa- it this way: ‘‘If I need help, I just give the sion, I had the special honor of presenting Knights a call’’—such a powerful example. him with America’s highest civil award, the Americans across this great land know that Presidential Medal of Freedom. It was my they can do the same, that they can serve chance to express our Nation’s respect for our country by helping someone in need.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00037 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1432 Aug. 3 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

We’re grateful for your service to the men in—helping low-income parents in Wash- and women in uniform and to our Nation’s ington, DC, escape from schools—have their veterans. You’ve sent hundreds of thousands children escape from schools that will not of prayer books to those working to make teach and will not change. Because of the our country more secure and to bring free- work of the Knights of Columbus and other dom in parts of the world that are desperate concerned citizens in our Nation’s Capital, for freedom. You bring comfort and strength poor parents now have a choice. They will to our soldiers, sailors, airmen, and marines. have a $7,500 scholarship so they can afford I want to thank you for taking time to visit to send their school—their child to a private our wounded and disabled veterans, for pro- school or parochial school—their choice to viding comfort to their families, to give them make. a word of thanks. You know, one of the great statistics of this See, you’re—the Knights are soldiers in modern era is the fact that more people are the armies of compassion. You’re foot sol- owning their own home. It seems like to me diers. You’ve heard the call. You’re helping an optimistic society is one that encourages this Nation build a culture of life in which ownership, more people owning their own the sick are comforted, the aged are honored, business, people being able to own and man- the immigrant is welcomed, and the weak age their own health care account, people and vulnerable are never overlooked. You being—own a piece of their retirement pol- have a friend in this administration. You have icy that they can pass on from one generation somebody who wants to work with you to to the next, and people owning their own change America for the better. home. I love a society in which more and We have a responsibility in Government more people are able to say, ‘‘Welcome to to do things to help overcome recession and my home; come to my home.’’ This country corporate scandal. It’s easier to be a hopeful has added more than 1.6 million minority society when people are working. That’s why homeowners in the past 2 years. Today, the I put forth an economic stimulus plan to en- American homeownership rate is the highest courage small-business growth, a plan that ever—and the highest ever for minorities. will help get jobs moving so people can work When you own something, you have a vital and do their duty as a mom or a dad and stake in the future of your country. put food on the table. And we’re making I want to work with the Knights for reason- progress. able and compassionate immigration reform, When I came to Washington, I was con- to bring good, hard-working people out of cerned about a school system that simply the shadows of American life and to ensure shuffled children through grade after grade, that America is always a welcoming nation. year after year, and hoped for the best. Of- I recognize, like you recognize, that amidst tentimes, what we found out was kids with the great prosperity of America, amongst our great hearts were graduating from schools great wealth, there are pockets of despair in but couldn’t read. I challenged the soft big- this country, and we’ve got to do something otry of low expectations by raising the bar, about it. We must address despair so America insisting on high standards, by making sure is hopeful for every single person. See, we the money we spent—and we did spend got fellow citizens who are trapped in the more money—went to help those who need- misery of drugs and gang violence, collapse ed extra help early, before it was too late. of the family. I believe you’ve got to measure in order to Our society and our Government have a know. If you believe a child can read, you’ve responsibility. You have a responsibility. got to measure to determine whether or not Those of us honored to hold high office have that child is reading, and if not, get them a responsibility. We’re doing some practical help early, before it’s too late. things. We’ve got a community-wide effort Because we measure, we know that now to help educate kids to the dangers of using more minority children are learning to read drugs. We believe in collaborative efforts; at grade level, and that’s good for America. people all throughout society must work to I want to thank the Knights for their help reduce the demand for drugs. Listen, we’ll

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00038 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 3 1433

do all we can to bust the thugs, interdict the church. And the truth of the matter is, there’s drugs coming in from foreign—overseas. But a culture inside Government which resents we’ve got to work on demand. And teen use and fears religious charities and has discrimi- of drugs is down by 11 percent from 2001 nated against them. We’re changing that. I to 2003. That’s a hopeful sign. A hopeful want to thank the Knights for their help in America is where our children are learning— changing that attitude in Washington, DC. [applause]. Our goal is to end the unfair discrimination There’s a lot of work to be done on health against faith-based charities by the Federal care, but one place I know we can continue Government. And we’re making substantial to work together on is health care for the progress. In December 2002, I issued an Ex- poorest of the poor. We’ve expanded and ecutive order—I was hoping, frankly, that built over 600 community health centers in Congress would pass a law. I got tired of America. I want to double the number so waiting. [Laughter] I got tired of the process the 16 million poor Americans can get pri- debate. See, I’m focused on results. I want mary health care without putting a strain on there to be positive results. I want lives to the emergency rooms of our hospitals, be saved as best as possible. The process whether they be public or private. bogged down. For those of you who pay at- We’ve got to pay for—we’ve got to work tention to Washington, you know what I’m on additional welfare reforms to help people talking about when I say the process bogs find a job, help them have the skills necessary down. to work so they realize the dignity that comes So I signed an Executive order mandating from being independent from Government equal treatment for faith-based charities in and, at the same time, strengthen marriage the Federal grantmaking process. What that and the family as part of welfare reforms. means is, is that faith-based groups ought to But I believe one of the most effective be allowed to apply for Federal grants just ways our Government can help those in need like everybody else should be allowed to is to help the charities and community groups apply. Faith-based groups will not be allowed that are doing God’s work every day. That’s to discriminate against who they serve, and what I believe Government ought to do. I they won’t use the Federal money to pros- believe Government needs to stand on the elytize. But they’re allowed to use the money side of faith-based groups, not against faith- to change hearts and souls, to help save lives, based groups, when they come to saving to embetter the world we live in. lives. And so here’s the principle we’ve estab- Government can hand out money, and of lished: Religious charities that are effectively course there will be arguments whether helping the poor should have a fair and equal we’re handing out enough or not. But what chance to compete for Federal money. That’s Government can never do is put love in a the new—those are the new rules. And this— person’s heart or a sense of purpose in a per- in 2003, discretionary grants to faith-based son’s life. You see, in order to heal—help programs was over a billion dollars. We’re the lonely, it works every time when a loving making progress. We’re using Federal tax- soul puts their arm around and says, ‘‘What payers’ money for effective use in helping can I do to help you? How can I help you to save lives. We’re providing a social net- in your life? What can I do to make your work of loving—helping loving souls inter- life better?’’ Many are called by God to do face with people so they can realize a better so, and Government must stand on the side tomorrow. of those millions of acts of mercy and kind- Three years ago, I established the Com- ness that take place on a daily basis. passion Capital Fund. It’s an innovative idea. And so the Faith-Based Initiative that I’ve It was a—the fund gives money to inter- launched recognizes the need there be sepa- mediary organizations that provide faith- ration of church and state. The state should based and community organizations with never be the church, and the church certainly training, technical assistance—what it is, is should never be the state. But the state like a little incubator: ‘‘If you want to access should never fear the good works of the Federal money, here’s how you do it. If you

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00039 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1434 Aug. 3 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

want to start up a faith-based program, here’s the person who is seeking help. That person some of the lessons learned.’’ In other words, can use that voucher at any kind of program what we’re trying to say is not only are we he or she chooses, including faith-based pro- going to allow those faith-based programs grams, to help heal hearts and save lives. that already exist to access Federal money, In other words, some of these are the ways we want to help others spring up and under- that—what I’m telling you is, things are stand the pitfalls to succeed. The fund pro- changing in the Nation’s Capital when it vides grants to faith-based and community comes to invigorating the Faith-Based Initia- organizations as well to help them fund their tive, and the Knights have helped a lot. I programs for the poor and the hungry and appreciate your efforts to level the playing the homeless. We’ve awarded $56 million field when it comes to grantmaking. And be- under this program. Today I release another cause of your efforts, America is changing $43 million to the compassionate Federal for the better. grant program. I needed someone to lead this program, We’re moving forward on another initia- so guess who I turned to? The Knights. I tive, which is mentoring for the children of found Towey. Jim Towey is the Director of prisoners. I mean, if the job of Government the White House Office of Faith-Based and is to try to set priorities, a priority is to help Community Initiatives. He’s with me. You children of prisoners find love. Imagine what know what his job is? His job is to help the a tough life it is for a young boy or girl to faith community—by the way, all faiths—all go see his or her mom or dad behind prison faiths, Christian, Jew, or Muslim—all faiths bars. These are children who need help. understand what is possible now. His job is They’re vulnerable to gangs and crime and also to make sure the Federal Government despair. They’re desperate for responsible is a hospitable place for faith programs to adults in their life who can give them what work with. Let’s be frank about it. Many many of them long for, which is love and faith-based programs don’t want to interface tenderness. with Government. You know why? They’re The best way to do that is to encourage afraid of losing the ability to practice their all groups, including faith-based groups, to faith. How can you be a faith-based program provide mentors. And it’s happening in if you’re not allowed to practice your faith? America. For those of you who are mentoring Towey’s job—so Towey has got a big job. the children of prisoners, thank you for what It’s to change a culture, a suspicious culture, you’re doing to make America a more wel- and we’re making progress—a suspicious cul- coming place. We’ve awarded grants—today ture in Washington, a suspicious culture in we’ve unleashed another $45.5 million of the grassroots. grants to programs, all aimed at doing this. Here’s Towey’s story. He goes to meet I’ll tell you another program that’s impor- Mother Teresa for the first time. He shows tant is to help the addict, is to help the person up at one of her homes for the dying in India, so stuck on drugs that they can’t realize the and the sister who greeted him assumed he great human potential that God has given was there to work. [Laughter] That’s what them, and they need desperate help. I be- I assume every day that Towey shows up. lieve that some counseling programs work, [Laughter] So she gave Jim some cloth and no question about it. But I also know pro- said, ‘‘Go clean the sores of a dying man.’’ grams that change the heart works. When He says it changed his life, that experience. a person changes their heart, they change He went on to work full-time for the Mission- their habits. Government is not good at aries of Charity. Incredibly enough, Jim changing hearts. The Almighty God is good Towey, Director of the Office of Faith-Based at changing hearts, which happens to be the Initiatives in the White House, was Mother cornerstone of effective faith-based pro- Teresa’s lawyer. I ask you, what kind of soci- grams. And therefore, when it comes to ety is it where Mother Teresa needs a law- spending Federal money to help addicts, I’ve yer? [Laughter] It’s a society that needs tort asked the Congress, and the Congress has reform. [Laughter] I appreciate your good agreed to allow us to use vouchers to go to work, friend. Thanks for coming today.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00040 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1435

The Knights of Columbus are transferring Federal judicial system runs well. I have lives with works of compassion, and, just as nominated superb men and women for the importantly, you’re defending the values of Federal benches who will strictly and fully faith and family that bind us as a nation. I interpret the law, not legislate from the appreciate your fight to protect children from bench. obscenity. I appreciate your working to pro- In all these areas, caring for the poor and tect the Pledge of Allegiance, to keep us ‘‘one protecting the vulnerable, affirming life, and Nation under God.’’ I want to thank you— defending the family, we’re depending on the I want to thank you for the defense of the goodness and compassion of the American traditional family. That is a most fundamental people. And that’s good, because the Amer- institution for our society. I appreciate the ican people are good and compassionate. fact you’re promoting the culture of life. See, the strength of this country is not our We’re making progress here in America. military might. It’s not the size of our wallet. Last November, I signed a law to end the The strength of this country is the hearts and brutal practice of partial-birth abortion. This souls of the American people. And it is an law is constitutional. This law is compas- incredible honor to be the President of such sionate. This law is urgently needed, and my a nation, a President of a nation of compas- administration will vigorously defend it in the sion and decency and honor and such power- courts. I was pleased to sign the Born-Alive ful values that we’re able to bring people Infants Protection Act. I want to thank the from all walks of life under the rubric of Knights on that piece of legislation. I signed being an American. the Unborn Victims of Violence Act. Com- I appreciate the prayers of the people of mon sense and conscience tells us that when this country. People I’ll never get to say an expectant mother is killed, two lives are thanks to in person, lift Laura and me up ended, and the criminal should answer for in prayer. It’s a remarkable aspect of the both crimes. Presidency. More significantly, it’s a remark- I was pleased to sign legislation supporting able aspect of the life of the United States maternity group homes. We’ll continue to of America. I’m grateful for your prayers. I’m work to help crisis pregnancy centers. We’ll grateful for your great service and the exam- work together to strengthen incentives for ple you set for our country. adoption and parental notification laws. The Thanks for having me today. May God Knights have been helpful, and I appreciate bless your organization, and may God con- your help. My 2005 budget, I proposed to tinue to bless our great country. Thank you. more than triple Federal funds for absti- nence programs in schools and community- NOTE: The President spoke at 3:05 p.m. at the based programs above 2001 levels. Hyatt Regency Dallas. In his remarks, he referred I’ll continue to work with Congress to pass to Carl A. Anderson, Supreme Knight, and Virgil a comprehensive and effective ban on human Dechant, Past Supreme Knight, Knights of Co- cloning. Human life is a creation of God, not lumbus; Theodore Cardinal McCarrick, Arch- a commodity to be exploited by man. bishop of Washington, DC; Edward Cardinal I look forward to working with the Knights Egan, Archbishop of New York; Justin Cardinal to defend the sacred bond of marriage. A Rigali, Archbishop of Philadelphia, PA; Francis few activist judges have taken it upon them- Cardinal George, Archbishop of Chicago, IL; Wil- liam Cardinal Keeler, Archbishop of Baltimore, selves to redefine the institution of marriage MD; Franciszek Cardinal Macharski, Archbishop by court order. I support a constitutional of Krakow, Poland; and Gov. Jeb Bush of Florida. amendment to protect the sanctity of mar- riage by ensuring it is always recognized as the union of a man and woman as husband Remarks in Davenport, Iowa and wife. I appreciate the Knights’ stand on August 4, 2004 this issue. I also appreciate the Knights of Columbus’ The President. Thank you all so very stand on the Federal judiciary. I have a re- much for coming. Thanks for having me. It’s sponsibility as President to make sure the great to be back here in the Quad Cities area.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00041 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1436 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

It’s a great place to work and raise your fam- Gatlin. We were both raised in west Texas ily. It’s what I would call the heart and soul together. I was in Midland; he was in Odessa. of the country. We have a little difference I can’t sing; he can. [Laughter] of opinion about the heart and soul—some Listen, I want to thank all the grassroots of them think you can find it in Hollywood. activists who are here. I appreciate you com- Audience members. No-o-o! ing. I want to thank you for what you are The President. I think you find it right going to do, which is to register the voters. here in Davenport, Iowa. We have a duty in this country to vote. Make I’m looking forward to the race. I’m here sure you register people. Don’t worry about to ask for your vote and ask for your help. what party they’re in; we want everybody vot- Everywhere we’re going, the crowds are big, ing in America. However, now when you’re the enthusiasm is high, the signs are good. convincing them who to vote for, don’t over- With your help, Dick Cheney and I will have look discerning Democrats and wise inde- 4 more years. pendents. [Laughter] When you get them I regret that Laura is not here to see this headed toward the poll, nudge them our way. significant crowd. She is a fabulous First I’m counting on your help, and together Lady. She is a great mother and a wonderful we’re going to win not only Iowa, but it’s wife. Today I’m going to give you some rea- going to be a great victory in November na- sons for you to put me back in office, but tionwide. We were close in Iowa last time— perhaps the most important reason of all is not this time; we’re going to carry it. so that Laura will be the First Lady for 4 Every incumbent who’s asking for the vote more years. has to answer a question why—why should I’m proud to be running with Dick Che- the American people give me the great privi- ney. I admit he’s not the prettiest one on lege of serving as your President for 4 more the ticket. [Laughter] I didn’t pick him for years? In the past years we’ve been through his looks. [Laughter] I picked him for his a lot together. We’ve been through a whole judgment and his experience. Dick Cheney lot together, and we’ve accomplished a great is a great Vice President. deal. But there’s only one reason to look I want to thank my friend Jim Nussle. I backward at the record, and that is to deter- appreciate his leadership in the United States mine who best to lead our Nation forward. Congress. He’s the budget man. He’s looking out after your money. He and I understand I’m asking for your vote because so much when we spend money in Washington, it’s is at stake. We have more to do. We must not the Government’s money; it’s the peo- work to move America forward. I want to ple’s money. be your President for 4 more years to make I appreciate my friend Jim Leach joining our country safer. us today. What a fine, fine citizen of the State Audience members. Four more years! of Iowa. I want to thank my friend Tom Four more years! Four more years! Latham for joining us, the Congressman The President. I want to be your Presi- from the other part of the State. Thanks for dent for 4 more years to make our economy inviting him here to eastern Iowa. It’s good stronger. I want to be your President for 4 for your Congressmen to get a taste for the more years to make our future brighter and decency of the folks that live in this part of better for every one of our citizens. From the State. creating jobs to improving schools, from I want to thank Chuck Gipp, David Vaudt, fighting terror to spreading the peace, we all the State officials here. I appreciate the have made much progress, and there is still mayor coming. Mr. Mayor, we’re proud more to do. you’re here. Fill the potholes. [Laughter] We have more to do to make our public I want to thank Mayor Freemire of schools the centers of excellence we know Bettendorf as well. I’m proud you’re here. that they can be, so that no child is left be- I want to thank my friend David Roederer, hind in this country. When we came to office who is the campaign chairman for this great 31⁄2 years ago, too many children were being State of Iowa. I appreciate my friend Larry shuffled from grade to grade, year after year,

VerDate May 21 2004 12:16 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00042 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1437

without learning the basics. So we’ve chal- health savings accounts so families can save, lenged the soft bigotry of low expectations. tax-free, for their own health care needs. We’ve raised the bar. We believe in account- When it comes to giving Americans more ability. We believe in making sure local folks choices about their health care and making are in charge of public schools. We believe health care more affordable, we’re moving in empowering parents. And today, children America forward, and we’re not going to turn across America are showing real progress in back. reading and math. When it comes to improv- This world is changing. Most Americans ing America’s public schools, we’re turning get their health care coverage through their the corner, and we’re not turning back. work. Most of today’s new jobs are created Listen, we’ve got more to do. The world by small businesses, which too often cannot we’re in is changing. The jobs of the future afford to provide health coverage. To help will require greater knowledge and a higher- more American families get health insurance, level skills, so we’ve got to reform our high we must allow small employers to join to- schools to make sure a high school diploma gether to purchase insurance at the discounts means something. We’re going to expand available to big companies. math and science so young people can com- To improve health care, we must end the pete in our high-tech world. We will expand frivolous lawsuits that raise health care costs the use of the Internet to bring high-level and drive doctors out of medicine. You can- training into classrooms. With 4 more years, not be pro-patient and pro-doctor and pro- we will help a rising generation gain the skills trial-lawyer at the same time. You have to and confidence they need to realize the choose. My opponent made his choice, and American Dream. he put him on the ticket. [Laughter] I made We have more to do to make quality health my choice: I will continue to work with Con- care available and affordable. When we came gress to pass medical liability reform for the to office, too many older Americans could patients of America. not afford prescription drugs, and Medicare We can do more to harness technology to didn’t pay for them. Leaders in both political reduce costs and prevent health care mis- parties for years had promised prescription takes. We can do more to expand research drug coverage for our seniors; we got it done. and seek new cures for terrible diseases. And Already, more than 4 million seniors have in all we do to improve health care in Amer- signed up for drug discount cards that pro- ica, we’ll make sure the health decisions are vide real savings. Beginning in 2006, all sen- made by doctors and patients, not by bureau- iors on Medicare will be able to choose a crats in Washington, DC. plan that suits their needs and gives them We have more to do to make our economy coverage for prescription drugs. stronger. Listen, we’ve come through a re- I remember campaigning with Nussle and cession and terror attacks and corporate Leach and Latham and your fine United scandals and a stock market decline. We States Senator, Charles Grassley. I said, overcame these obstacles because of the hard ‘‘We’re going to strengthen Medicare to work of Iowa’s small-business people, be- make sure rural hospitals in Iowa get the help cause we’ve got the best workers in the they need,’’ so we provided more funds to world. We’ve overcome these obstacles be- hospitals healing—handling a low volume of cause we’ve got the best farmers in the world. patients. We’ve increased payments for am- And we’ve overcome these obstacles be- bulance providers and suppliers in rural cause of well-timed tax relief for the Amer- areas. We’re giving better bonuses to physi- ican people. Listen, we didn’t pick winners cians, so we can keep good doctors practicing and losers when it came to tax relief. We in rural America. In other words, we deliv- gave tax relief to every American who pays ered on our promise to the people of Iowa. Federal income taxes. We gave tax relief for The other folks talk a good game; we deliver. families with children. We gave tax relief for To help people get access to quality care, married couples. What kind of Tax Code is we’ve expanded community health centers it that penalizes marriage? It’s a Tax Code for low-income Americans. We’ve created that needs to be changed. We gave tax relief

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00043 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1438 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

for every small business that purchases And we’re going to make sure America’s equipment. And this time, the check really families keep more of something they never was in the mail. have enough of, and that is time—time to Because we acted, our economy since last be with your kids, time to take care of your summer has grown at a rate as fast as any parents, time to go to class to improve your- in nearly 20 years. Because we acted, Amer- selves. Congress needs to work with the ad- ica has added more than 1.5 million new jobs ministration to enact comp-time and flex- since last August. Because we acted, Iowa time to help America’s families better juggle has added more than 11,000 jobs over the their home needs and their work needs. past year. Because we acted, Iowa’s unem- What I’m telling you is, after 4 more years, ployment rate now is 4.3 percent. When it the economy will be better, more small-busi- comes to creating jobs for American workers, ness owners will be in America, better and we are turning the corner, and we’re not higher paying jobs will exist here, and our going back. farmers will be able to put something aside We worked to strengthen our farmers and for the future generations. ranchers. We passed a good farm bill; I was We have more to do to wage and win the proud to sign it. We phased out the death war against terror. America’s future depends tax so America’s family farmers can stay in on our willingness to lead in this world. If the family. We’ve opened up foreign markets America shows uncertainty and weakness in for Iowa’s and Illinois farmers. You see, if this decade, the world will drift toward trag- you’re good at something, you ought to have edy. This is not going to happen on my watch. the opportunity to sell that which you’re good Audience members. Four more years! at around the world. Four more years! Four more years! Listen, this country needs an energy strat- The President. The world changed on a egy. We must become less dependent on for- terrible September morning, and since that eign sources of energy if we want to keep day, we have changed the world. Before Sep- jobs here in America. And one way to be- tember the 11th, Afghanistan served as the come less dependent on foreign sources of home base for Al Qaida, which trained and energy is to promote alternative sources of deployed thousands of killers to set up terror fuel like biodiesel and ethanol. I told the peo- cells in dozens of countries, including our ple of this State when I was running in 2000, own. Today, Afghanistan is a rising democ- I support ethanol. I have kept my promise racy. Afghanistan is a place where many to Iowa’s farmers. In the last 3 years, Amer- young girls now go to school for the first ica’s farmers have posted record net-cash time. Afghanistan is an ally in the war against farm income—record—record exports, terror, and America and the world are safer. record farm equity and land values. I have Before September the 11th, Pakistan was made the success of America’s farmers and a safe transit point for terrorists. Today, Paki- ranchers a priority, and America is better off stan is an ally in the war on terror. Pakistani for it. forces are aggressively helping to round up To keep jobs in America, regulations need the terrorists. America and the world are to be reasonable and fair. To keep jobs in safer. America, we must end the junk lawsuits In Saudi Arabia, before September the which threaten our small businesses. To keep 11th, terrorists were raising money and re- jobs in America, we will not overspend your cruiting and operating with little opposition. money, and we will keep your taxes low. To Today, the Saudi Government is taking the keep jobs in America, we will offer our work- fight to Al Qaida. America and the world are ers a lifetime of learning and to make sure safer. they get training for the jobs of the future, Before September the 11th, Libya was at our community colleges. The education spending millions to acquire weapons of mass and training community colleges offer can be destruction. Today, because America and our the bridge between people’s lives as they are allies have sent a strong and clear message, and people’s lives as they want them to be. the leader of Libya has abandoned his pursuit

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00044 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1439

of weapons of mass destruction, and America When it comes to fighting the threats of and the world are safer. our world, when it comes to making America Before September the 11th, the ruler of safer, when it comes to spreading peace, Iraq was a sworn enemy of America. He was we’re moving forward, and we’re not turning defying the world. He was firing weapons at back. American pilots enforcing the world’s sanc- We’ve got more to do. I’m running for 4 tions. He had pursued and used weapons of more years because we’ve got more to do. mass destruction against his own people. He We must continue to work with our friends had harbored terrorists. He invaded his and allies around the world to aggressively neighbors. He subsidized families of suicide pursue the terrorists in Iraq and Afghanistan bombers. He had murdered tens of thou- and elsewhere. See, you can’t talk sense to sands of his own citizens. He was a source the terrorists. of great instability in a volatile part of the Audience members. No-o-o! world. After September the 11th, we looked at The President. You cannot negotiate with all the threats in a new light. One of the les- them. sons of September the 11th is, this country Audience members. No-o-o! must take threats seriously before they fully The President. You cannot hope for the materialize. The September the 11th Com- best. We must engage the enemies around mission concluded that our institutions of the world so we do not have to face them Government had failed to imagine the horror here at home. of that day. America will continue to lead the world After September the 11th, we could not with confidence and moral clarity. We put fail to imagine that a brutal tyrant who hated together a strong coalition to help us defeat America, had ties to terror, had used weap- terror, and that’s necessary. Over 60 nations ons of mass destruction might use those are involved with the Proliferation Security weapons or share his deadly capabilities with Initiative. Nearly 40 nations are involved in our enemies. We saw a threat. The United Afghanistan. Some 30 nations are involved States Congress—members of both political in Iraq. We will continue to build our alli- parties, including my opponent—looked at ances. We will continue to work with our the same intelligence and saw a threat to friends for the cause of security and peace. America. The United Nations looked at the But I will never turn over America’s national same intelligence, and it saw a threat and security decisions to leaders of other coun- unanimously demanded a full accounting of tries. Saddam Hussein’s weapons and weapons We will keep our commitments to help Af- programs or face serious consequences. ghanistan and Iraq become peaceful, demo- That’s what the free world demanded. cratic societies. These two nations are now After 12 years of defiance, the tyrant re- fused to comply. He continued to deceive governed by strong leaders, people who want the world. He deceived the weapons inspec- the boys and girls of their respective coun- tors that the world had sent into Iraq. Now, tries to grow up in peace. They know what I had a choice to make: Do I forget the les- we know in America: Moms and dads long sons of September the 11th and trust a mad- for a peaceful society; they long for their chil- man—— dren to be able to be educated and realize Audience members. No-o-o! their dreams. The people of these countries The President. ——or do I take action are stepping up, providing security for their to defend America? Given that choice, I will own people. After years of brutality, they see defend our country. a glimmer of hope, a chance to live in a free Audience members. Four more years! society. And these people can count on our Four more years! Four more years! help and the help of our coalition. The President. Because the dictator sits You see, when we acted to protect our own in a prison cell, the people of Iraq are better security, we also promised to help deliver off. America and the world are safer.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00045 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1440 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

them from tyranny, to restore their sov- world; freedom is the Almighty God’s gift to ereignty, to help set them on the path to lib- each man and woman in this world. erty. And when America gives its word, We have more to do to protect us. En- America will keep its word. emies who hate us are still plotting to harm In these crucial times, our commitments us. Those who claim that America’s war on are kept by the men and women of our mili- terror is to blame for terror threats against tary. At bases across our country and the the United States have a fundamental mis- world, I’ve had the privilege of meeting with understanding of the nature of the enemy. those who defend our country and sacrifice See, the 9/11 Commission said something for our security. I’ve seen their great decency wise: Our homeland is safer, but we are not and their unselfish courage. The cause of yet safe. freedom is in really good hands. Beginning immediately after September And our men and women in uniform de- the 11th, we’ve started the hard process of serve the full support of our Government. reform. We transformed our defenses. We’ve Last September, while our troops were in created a new Department of Homeland Se- combat in both Afghanistan and Iraq, I pro- curity. We passed the PATRIOT Act to give posed supplemental funding to support our law enforcement the tools they need to help military and its mission. This legislation pro- make America more secure. The mission of vided funding for body armor and vital the FBI is now focused on preventing terror. equipment, hazard pay, health benefits, am- We’re integrating intelligence and law en- munition, fuel, and spare parts for our mili- forcement better than we ever have before. tary. In the Senate, only a small, out-of-the- We’ve taken action on a large majority of the mainstream minority of 12 voted against the Commission’s recommendations. legislation. Two of those twelve Senators are We have more to do to better secure our my opponent and his runningmate. ports and borders, to train first-responders, Audience members. Boo-o-o! to dramatically improve our intelligence- The President. Here’s how my opponent gathering capability. That’s why this week I tried to explain his vote. He said, ‘‘I actually called on Congress to create a position of did vote for the $87 billion, before I voted National Intelligence Director, so that one against it.’’ [Laughter] End quote. [Laughter] person is in charge of coordinating all our Then he went on to say, he was proud that intelligence efforts overseas and here at he and his runningmate voted against it, and home. he further said the whole thing is a com- These reforms are not going to be easy. plicated matter. There is nothing com- I understand that. You see, reform is never plicated about supporting our troops in com- easy in Washington. [Laughter] There’s a lot bat. of entrenched interests there. People don’t In the long run, our security is not guaran- like to have the status quo challenged. It’s teed by force alone. We must work to change not enough, though, to advocate reform; you the conditions that give rise to terror—that’s have to be able to get it done. poverty and hopelessness and resentment. A And we’re getting it done on behalf of the free and peaceful Iraq and a free and peace- people of this country. When it comes to re- ful Afghanistan will be a powerful example forming schools to provide an excellent edu- to their neighbors in a part of the world that cation for all our children, results matter. is desperate for freedom. When it comes to health care reforms that Free countries do not export terror. Free give families more access and more choices, countries listen to the dreams and aspirations results matter. When it comes to improving of their citizens. By serving the ideal of lib- our economy and creating quality jobs, re- erty, we’re bringing hope to others, and that sults matter. When it comes to a strong farm makes America more secure. By serving the economy, results matter. When it comes to ideal of liberty, we’re making the world a better securing our homeland, fighting the more peaceful place. By serving the ideal of forces of terror, and promoting the peace, liberty, we serve the deepest ideals of our results matter. When it comes to electing a country. Freedom is not America’s gift to the President, results matter.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00046 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1441

Audience members. Four more years! from one that has said, ‘‘If it feels good, do Four more years! Four more years! it,’’ and ‘‘If you’ve got a problem, blame The President. No, there’s a lot of big somebody else,’’ to a culture in which each talkers in the Nation’s Capital. We just like of us understands we’re responsible for the to be known as the people who can get the decisions we make in life. If you’re fortunate job done. We’re living in a time of great enough to be a mother or a father, you are change. And it’s an exciting time—it really responsible for loving your child with all your is—to be an American. We got to make sure heart and all your soul. If you’re worried Government responds to these times by about the quality of the education in the standing side by side with people, side by community in which you live, you are respon- side with our workers, and side by side with sible for doing something about it. If you are our families. a CEO in corporate America, you’re respon- The best way to do so, in my judgment, sible for telling the truth to your shareholders is to encourage people to own something, to and your employees. And in a responsibility encourage people to own their own homes. society, each of us is responsible for loving Listen, the homeownership rate in America our neighbor just like we’d like to be loved is at an alltime high, and that’s good news ourself. for our country. We want our workers to be Listen, the strength of this country is not able to own their own health care accounts our military. The strength of this country is so they can take them from job to job. We not our wallets. The strength of this country want younger workers to be able to own a is the heart and soul of the American people. Social Security personal retirement account I want to be your President for 4 more that they can call their own and pass on from years so we can continue to rally the armies one generation to the next. We want people of compassion, so we can help change Amer- owning their own farm and their own small ica one heart, one soul, one conscience at business. See, we understand when you own a time. something, you have a vital stake in the fu- For all Americans, these years in our his- ture of this country. tory will always stand apart. There are quiet The world is—times have changed, but times in the life of a nation when little is some things are not going to change. Our expected of its leaders. This isn’t one of those belief in liberty will not change. Our belief times. It’s a time that requires strength and in the nonnegotiable demands of human dig- firm resolve. This is a time that requires nity will not change. Our desire to make sure courage and our willingness to lead. opportunity, the great American experience, Audience member. That’s why we love is spread throughout every corner of this you! country, will not change. The individual val- The President. None of us will ever forget ues we try to live by won’t change, courage that era—that week when one era ended and and compassion, reverence and integrity. another one began. On September the 14th, The institutions that give us direction and 2001, I stood in the ruins of the Twin Towers. purpose are important, our families, our It’s a day I will never forget. There were schools, our religious congregation. They are workers in hardhats yelling at me, ‘‘Whatever so important and so fundamental; they de- it takes.’’ A guy grabbed me by the arm. He serve the respect of Government. had tears in his eyes; he was exhausted from We stand for things. We stand for some- searching through the rubble to find his thing. We stand for institutions like marriage friend. He said, ‘‘Do not let me down.’’ and family, which are the foundations of our He took it personally. The people search- society. We stand for a culture of life in ing through the rubble took that day person- which every person matters and every person ally. You took it personally, and so did I. I counts. We stand for judges who faithfully wake up every morning thinking about how interpret the law instead of legislating from to better protect our people. I will never re- the bench. lent in defending America, whatever it takes. And we stand for a culture of responsibility Audience members. Four more years! in America. This culture of ours is changing Four more years! Four more years!

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00047 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1442 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

The President. No, we’ve come through how the Federal Government can help. See, much together. We’ve done hard work. Dur- I like to tell people every day is Earth Day ing the next 4 years, we will spread owner- if you make a living off the land, because ship and opportunity all throughout our land. people care more about the land if the person We’ll pass the enduring values of our country has to make a living off the land. to another generation. And during the next And so today I’m going to talk about some 4 years, we’ll continue to lead in the cause initiatives where the Federal Government of freedom so the world will be a more can help the best stewards of the land be peaceful place. better stewards of the land. I want to thank You know, 4 years ago I traveled your great you all for coming. I appreciate the Gov- State asking for the vote, and I made a pledge ernor. Thank you for being here, sir. Thank that if you honored me with this great re- you for your introduction. I particularly want sponsibility, I would uphold the dignity and to thank Mark and Shirley Katzenmeyer; the honor of the office to which I had been they’re the host family here. Little did they elected, so help me God. And with your help, realize—where is Mark? I will do so during the next 4 years. Mr. Katzenmeyer. Right over here, sir. May God bless you. Thanks for coming. The President. Oh, there you are. Good, Thank you all. you got a good seat. That’s good. [Laughter] And Karen as well, their sweet daughter. NOTE: The President spoke at 11:27 a.m. at Thanks for coming, Karen. LeClaire Park and Bandshell. In his remarks, he Guess what we talked about? Mountain referred to Iowa State Representative Chuck biking. [Laughter] Mark is a mountain biker, Gipp; Iowa State Auditor David A. Vaudt; Mayor and gosh, what a special place to mountain Charles W. Brooke of Davenport, IA; Mayor Mi- bike, isn’t it? I’m sorry I didn’t bring mine. chael J. Freemire of Bettendorf, IA; country music [Laughter] entertainer Larry Gatlin; Col. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, leader of Libya; former Presi- Mr. Katzenmeyer. You can borrow one. dent Saddam Hussein of Iraq; and the National The President. I could borrow one, yes. Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the Well, I’m not that sorry. Anyway—[Laugh- United States (9/11 Commission). ter]. But I really appreciate your hospitality. Senator Norm Coleman is with us, and the Governor. We were on the same helicopter. Remarks on the Conservation He said, ‘‘I wonder if the Katzenmeyers real- Reserve Program in Le Sueur, ly understood what was about to happen’’— Minnesota [laughter]—four choppers heading into their August 4, 2004 farm. But thanks for having us. I also want to thank your neighbors for putting up with The President. Thank you all. Please be us, and I appreciate you all coming. I want seated. Thanks for the warm welcome. It’s to thank Norm. He’s a good friend, a fine good to be on a farm. [Laughter] American United States Senator. farm and ranch families embody the best val- I appreciate Gil Gutknecht. And the Con- ues of our country, don’t they—love of fam- gressman for this area, John Kline, is with ily, love of the land, love of their country. us too. Thank you both for being here. I’m These are good, hard-working people. Farm- honored you guys are here. I also want to ing is what I like to call America’s first indus- thank—I want to thank Vicky, who is John’s try, and that industry feeds us, and it clothes wife. I appreciate you coming, Vicky. us. It’s now providing more energy for us. I thank the mayor of Le Sueur for being The success of America’s farmers and here. Mr. Mayor, appreciate you coming. ranchers is essential to the success of our Mayor Bob Oberle. You’re welcome. country. That’s why it’s fitting we’re here on The President. Yes, thank you. It’s an a farm to talk about the success of America. honor for us to be here. I want to thank the I’m going to talk about another role that other local officials who’ve come. I want to farmers play today, and that’s the essential thank the conservation groups. I see some role of being good stewards of our land, and of my friends from the conservation groups,

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00048 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1443

the people who want to make sure that the you’re going to get better quality at a better land is taken care of so wildlife can flourish. price. That’s just the way it is. That’s the way We’re going to talk about something today the market works. We want to be treated in that I think you’ll appreciate. As a matter of other countries the way we treat people here fact, you’ve been instrumental in helping to at home. That’s good trade policy. And so construct the policy. I want to thank—and we’re opening up markets. The more markets the farmers and ranchers who are here. It’s we open up, the better it is for farmers and really good to be here. ranchers because we can compete with any- Bryan—there’s Bryan. Yes, today when I body, anytime, anywhere just so long as the landed—by the way, I always like to greet playing field is level. somebody in the community who is serving And as a result—we also, by the way, cut the community by volunteering. And Bryan taxes on our farmers and ranchers as well Comstock is a volunteer firefighter for this as everybody else who paid taxes. That helps. part of the world. I want to thank you for I like to tell people I think the people in being here. I told him I was a supporter of southern Minnesota can spend their money the Crawford Volunteer Fire Department. I better than the Federal Government can. know something about it. It’s—these volun- Now, we’ll set priorities; don’t get me wrong. teer fire departments are really important for [Laughter] We got a war to win. We’ve got rural America, and I want to thank Bryan a homeland to protect. We got people to take and others who are volunteering time to help care of that can’t take of themselves. But by these farmers and ranchers who might get setting priorities, I believe that you can meet in trouble because of a sudden or instant fire. obligations and let people have more of their At any rate, we—this country better appre- own money. It helps this economy grow; I’m ciate our farmers and ranchers. I mean, it’s— telling you. When you got more money in really the cornerstone of good economic pol- your pocket, you demand an additional good icy is good farm policy, isn’t it? And I’m— or a service. And when you make that de- I appreciate the effects of the farm bill that mand, somebody is going to produce it. And we worked on and passed. It’s a good bill. when somebody produces it, somebody is And it’s making a difference. It has helped likely to find a job. farmers because it helped them plan and op- We also put the death tax on its way to erate on market realities, not based upon extinction. In order to have a vibrant agricul- Government dictates. It’s important any bill tural economy, it must be so that people can that deals with economics to understand the pass their farm from one generation to the markets, and that we view the markets as im- next without the Federal Government get- portant. And a market-oriented approach to ting in the way. We’re going to have to make farming is good, and it’s working. It’s making the death tax—the elimination of the death a difference for people right now. tax permanent. In order to get it out of the One reason it is, is because we recognize Congress, it’s—it was a decision to say, there’s a lot of consumers for American farm ‘‘Okay, we’re going to put it on its way to products outside the United States. Good extinction,’’ and then it comes back after 10 farm policy is good trade policy. Listen, if years. That’s the way we had to get it out, you’re good at something—and we’re really which means in the year 2011, there’s going good at growing things; we ought to be sell- to be some unusual decisions by people when ing what we grow, not only here at home the death tax comes into being. I’m pledged but elsewhere. I’m committed to making sure to eliminate it totally. I don’t think it makes that markets are open and we’re treated fair- any sense. I don’t think you ought to—[Ap- ly. I like to explain trade to our people this plause]. way, that we’ve opened up our markets here Anyway, we’ve taken action. And the pro- in the United States, and it’s good for con- ductivity of our farmers are—it really means sumers. We do. Think about it. When you we can compete anywhere. And therefore, get more products coming into the country, America’s farmers have posted record net- you can shop. You can make decisions. The cash farm income. I’m not talking about more opportunities you have to decide, good—I’m talking about record. Our exports

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00049 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1444 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

are way up. Farm equity and land values are To make sure these farmlands stay protected, strong. In other words, we got a good farm I directed the Secretary of Agriculture to economy, and I intend to keep it that way offer early reenrollments and extensions of as best as I possibly can. existing contracts. I’m going to talk about conserving the The farmers no longer need to worry about land. The best thing from the farm bill was whether or not this—they’ll be reenrolled in the conservation title. It encouraged people the program, as of this moment. You will be. to put aside lands for the right reasons: to We’re taking action now rather than waiting protect the soil, protect the water, provide so that there’s certainty when it comes to habitat for wildlife. The conservation title planning. I’m also directing the Secretary to was doubled from the previous farm bill to enroll farmers for an additional 800,000 acres this one. It’s up to about $40 billion over of land. a 10-year period of time. The Katzenmeyers Secondly, we’re going to expand the con- understand it. Here’s what Shirley said. She servation program to cover vital grasslands said, ‘‘You’re giving back to nature when it that often serve as borders of farmlands. I’m comes to putting money—land aside for the ordering the Secretary of Agriculture to help CRP. You’re giving back to nature. You’re protect 250,000 acres of grasslands, which giving back something to the soil so it doesn’t are the home of several species of birds, in- get depleted. All around, it’s a good prac- cluding the northern bobwhite quail. By ex- tice.’’ I agree, and so do farmers all across panding this program, our goal is to increase America. the quail population by about 750,000 birds So the main reason I’ve asked you all to a year. come, besides being in a beautiful part of Thirdly, we’re going to expand the con- the world, was to talk about three initiatives servation program to cover wetlands that are I think you’ll find interesting; three initiatives not in—the CRP now covers wetlands that important for our country; three initiatives are in a flood plain. But if you’re out of a which enable our farmers and sportsmen to flood plain—if your wetlands are out of a continue their roles as citizen-stewards of the flood plain, you’re not currently eligible for land. This initiative I think is good for the the program. These wetlands are what the environment. It’s good for the agricultural farmers around here call ‘‘prairie potholes,’’ sector. and offer a home for pheasants and ducks First, we’re going to expand and extend and other birds. These prairie potholes will the Conservation Reserve Program. The now be a part of the CRP, and that’s good Conservation Reserve Program is the largest for wildlife. I’m also making available re- public-private conservation partnership in sources needed to help farmers protect the Nation. Approximately 800,000 farmers 250,000 acres of such wetlands. This is part participate in this program. In return for an of an initiative that I outlined last Earth Day annual payment from this program, farmers which was to restore, improve, and protect retire some of their land, letting it turn back at least 3 million wetland acres over the next to its natural state. As I told you, it’s good 5 years. for the soil. It’s good for habitat. Interestingly Audience member. Thank you, Mr. Presi- enough, one of the things I like to ask is, dent. does it work? The question we need to ask The President. And that’s what I’m here more often in Washington, DC, is it actually to announce. I’m here to announce we can working? In this case, this program has do a good job of conserving nature by em- helped reduce soil erosion by more than 40 powering our farmers and ranchers. I want percent since 1986. That is a positive devel- to thank the wildlife people that are here. opment for America. I want to thank you for your practical way Right now we have 35 million acres of of approaching important issues for our farmland in the CRP, the Conservation Re- country. I particularly want to thank the serve Program. Contracts covering roughly farmers and ranchers who are here for doing two-thirds of the existing land in the program what you were raised to do, which is feed are scheduled to expire in 2007 and 2008. us and help clothe us and, in the meantime,

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00050 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1445

protect your land, which is good for the coun- I picked him for his judgment, his sound ad- try. vice. I’m honored to be here. Mr. Mayor, thanks I’m proud to be with Norm Coleman. He’s for coming. It’s great to be in a part of the doing a fine job as a United States Senator. world where people work with their hands And I’m proud of the job Governor Pawlenty and make a living off the land. is doing as well. He’s a good man. Plus, I God bless you all, and may God continue appreciate working with Congressman Gut- to bless our great country. Thank you very knecht and Congressman Kline, two really much. fine people, as well. I appreciate you guys being here. Thank you. NOTE: The President spoke at 2:55 p.m. at the I want to thank all the State people who Katzenmeyer family farm. In his remarks, he re- are here and the local people who have come ferred to Gov. Tim Pawlenty of Minnesota. out. Thanks for being here today. I particu- larly want to thank the grassroots activists Remarks in Mankato, Minnesota who are here. Those are the people who put August 4, 2004 up the signs and make the phone calls. These are the folks who go out and get people to The President. Thank you all. Thanks for register to vote. Let me tell you something, coming. Thanks for inviting me. It’s good to here’s what I believe: I believe all of us have be in Mankato. I understand I’m the first a duty in our country to vote. We have a President to have visited here since Harry duty to exercise our right as free citizens. I Truman. I don’t know what took the others want to thank you for registering people and so long to get here. [Laughter] Thanks for encouraging them to vote. Don’t overlook having me. discerning Democrats and wise independ- I’m here to ask for your vote. I’m also here ents. Get them to the polls, and when you to ask for your help. I appreciate you coming. get them headed our way, make sure they— I understand I’m not the biggest deal in give them a little nudge toward the Bush- town. After all, the Vikings practice here. Cheney ticket. [Laughter] But it is great to be in a place We came close in Minnesota last time. where people work hard and make a living This time, we’re going to win it. Every in- off the land, raise their families. It’s what I cumbent who asks for your vote has got to call the heart and soul of the country. The answer one central question, and that’s other folks believe the heart and soul can why—why should the American people give be found in Hollywood. I think it’s found me the high privilege of serving as your Presi- right here in southern Minnesota. dent for 4 more years. In the past few years, I’m excited about the race. I’m looking for- we’ve done a lot, and we’ve come through ward to the contest. Everywhere we go, the a lot together. But there’s only one reason crowds are big, the enthusiasm is high, the to look backward, and that is to determine signs are good. With your help, Dick Cheney who best to lead the Nation forward. and I will be reelected for 4 more years. I’m asking for your vote because so much I’m sorry Laura is not here. I know you is at stake in this election. We have much are too. You probably wish I had stayed at more to do to move America forward. I want home and she was the speaker. [Laughter] to be your President for 4 more years to make She is a great wife, a fantastic mother, and our country safer, to make our economy a wonderful First Lady for our country. stronger, and to make the future brighter and Today I’m going to give you some reasons better for every single citizen. to put me back in, but perhaps the most im- From creating jobs to improving schools, portant reason of all is so that Laura is First from fighting terror to spreading the peace, Lady for 4 more years. we have made much progress, and we have I’m proud to be running with Dick Che- more to do. We have more to do to make ney. Admittedly, he’s not the prettiest Vice America’s public schools the centers of excel- Presidential candidate in the race. [Laughter] lence we all know they can be, so that not I didn’t pick him for his looks. [Laughter] one single child is left behind in our country.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00051 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1446 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

When we came to office 31⁄2 years ago, too tax-free for their own health care needs. many children were being shuffled from When it comes to giving Americans more grade to grade, year after year, without learn- choices about their own health care and mak- ing the basics. So we’ve challenged the soft ing health care more affordable, we’re mov- bigotry of low expectations. We’ve raised the ing America forward, and we’re not turning bar. We believe in accountability. We trust back. the local folks to run the schools of America. Listen, most Americans get health care Today, children across America are showing coverage through their work. But most of to- real progress in reading and math. When it day’s new jobs are created by small busi- comes to improving America’s public schools, nesses, which too often cannot afford to pro- we are turning the corner, and we’re not vide health care. To help more American going back. families get health insurance, we must allow We have more to do. Listen, this world small employers to join together to purchase of ours is changing. The jobs of the future insurance at the discounts available for big will require greater knowledge and higher- companies. level skills. So that’s why we need to reform To improve health care, we must end the our high schools to make sure a high school frivolous lawsuits that raise health care costs diploma means something. We’re going to and drive good doctors out of medicine. You expand math and science education so our cannot be pro-patient and pro-doctor and young people can compete in a high-tech pro-trial-lawyer at the same time. You have world. We’ll expand the use of the Internet to choose. My opponent made his choice, to bring high-level training into classrooms. and he put him on the ticket. [Laughter] I With 4 more years, we will help a rising gen- made my choice, and on behalf of the pa- eration gain the skills and confidence they tients and doctors of America, I will continue need to achieve the American Dream. to urge Congress to pass medical liability re- We have more to do to make quality health form. care available and affordable. When we came We’ll do more to harness technology to re- to office, too many older Americans could duce costs and to prevent health care mis- not afford prescription drugs, and Medicare takes. We’ll do more to expand research and didn’t pay for them. Leaders in both political seek new cures for terrible diseases. And in parties had promised prescription drug cov- all we do to improve health care in America, erage for years. We got the job done. Al- we’ll make sure the health decisions are ready, more than 4 million seniors have made by doctors and patients, not by bureau- signed up for drug discount cards that pro- crats in Washington, DC. vide real and meaningful savings. Beginning We have more to do to make sure our in 2006, all seniors on Medicare will be able economy is stronger. Listen, we’ve come to choose a plan that suits their needs and through a lot. We’ve been through a reces- gives them coverage for prescription drugs. sion. We’ve been through corporate scandals. You see, when we reformed Medicare, we We’ve been through terror attacks. We’ve did so with rural hospitals in mind as well. been through a market decline. Listen—and We provided more funds to hospitals han- we’ve overcome the obstacles. We’ve got dling low volumes of patients. We increased great workers in America, is one reason we’ve payments for ambulance providers and sup- overcome them. We’ve got great entre- pliers in rural areas. We’re giving better bo- preneurs. We’ve got great farmers and great nuses to physicians so we can keep good doc- ranchers in this country. tors practicing in rural America. We made We’ve also overcome these obstacles be- a difference for the older citizens of this cause of well-timed tax cuts. Listen, when country, and we made a difference for those we cut the taxes, we didn’t pick winners or who seek health care in rural America. losers. We said if you pay Federal income To help people get access to quality care, taxes, you get tax relief. Families with chil- we’ve expanded community health centers dren got tax relief. Married couples got tax for low-income Americans. We’ve created relief. It’s an amazing Tax Code where we health savings accounts so families can save say we’re going to have a marriage penalty.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00052 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1447

Why do we want to penalize marriage? We Listen, we can do more to keep jobs here. need to encourage marriage in the country. You know, I’m sure the small-business own- A lot of the tax relief went to help small ers will tell you they’ve got to fill out a lot businesses, and the small-business sector of of paperwork. I can’t guarantee whether our economy is strong today. We promised Government has read it or not. [Laughter] all this. We delivered, and this time the check We need less regulation. In order to keep was actually in the mail. Because we acted, jobs here in America, we need tort reform. our economy since last summer has grown In order to keep jobs here in America, we’ve at a rate as fast as any in nearly 20 years. got to make sure American workers have a We’ve added more than 1.5 million new jobs lifetime of learning, and we’ve got to help since last August. Minnesota has added them training—help them have training for 32,000 jobs over the past year. Because we the jobs of the 21st century. And a good place acted, the unemployment rate in this State to start is at our community colleges. is now 4.4 percent. When it comes to creating And you know what else we need? We jobs for America’s workers, we’ve turned the need to make sure that American families corner, and we’re not turning back. have something they never have enough of, I also told the people when I was running and that is time—time to be with their kids, for President the last time, I said, ‘‘I under- time to go to the Little League game or work stand the need to have a healthy farm econ- in a Girl Scout troop, time to take care of omy.’’ A good farm economy is good for the an elderly parent, time to go to class to im- American economy. We passed a good farm prove themselves. And that’s why I think bill. We’re phasing out the death tax so farm- Congress ought to pass comp-time and flex- ers can pass their land from one generation time rules. to the next. In other words, what I’m telling you is In order to make sure jobs are here, we’ve Government needs to stand side by side with got to make sure our farm economy is strong. And one way to make sure the farm economy families. After 4 more years, this economy is strong is to open up markets for Minnesota is going to be strong, more people will be farm products. We want you selling your soy- working with better jobs. After 4 more years, beans all around the world. We want you sell- there will be more small-business owners. ing your corn all around the world. We want After 4 more years, our farmers are going to be selling that Minnesota beef and hogs to be doing better. You know why? Because all around the world. we’ve got a pro-growth, pro-entrepreneur, In order to make sure jobs stay here at pro-agricultural economic agenda. home, we’ve got to have an energy strategy. We’ve got to do more to wage and win See, we need to be better at conserving the war on terror. America’s future depends things, and we’ve got to be exploring for nat- on our willingness to lead in the world. If ural gas in environmentally friendly ways. we show uncertainty and weakness in this But for the sake of energy security, for the decade, the world will drift toward tragedy. sake of economic security, we need more That’s not going to happen on my watch. The ethanol and biodiesel. I envision a day where world changed on a terrible September sometime, somebody walks in and says, morning, and since that day, we’ve changed ‘‘Well, Mr. President, you’ll be happy to hear the world. the corn crop is up and we’re growing more Before September the 11th, Afghanistan soybeans in America, and we’re less depend- served as the home base of Al Qaida, which ent on foreign sources of oil as a result of trained and deployed thousands of killers it.’’ who set up terror cells around the world, in- And when you’re out gathering the vote, cluding our own country. Today, Afghanistan remind the folks that in the last 3 years is a rising democracy. Today, Afghanistan is American farmers have posted record net- a firm ally in the war against terror. And cash farm income, record exports, and record today, many young girls go to school for the farm equity and land values. Our farm pro- first time. Afghanistan is free, and America gram is working. and the world are safer.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00053 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1448 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Before September the 11th, Pakistan was stroy weapons or weapons programs, or face a safe transit point for terrorists. Today, Paki- serious consequences. The world spoke. stan is an ally in the war against Al Qaida. After 12 years of defiance, after 12 years Pakistani forces are helping to round up the of ignoring the demands of the free world, terrorists, and America and the world are he once again refused to comply. As a matter safer. of fact, he systematically deceived the weap- Before September the 11th, in Saudi Ara- ons inspectors. So I had a choice to make: bia, terrorists were raising money; they were forget the lessons of September the 11th and recruiting; they were operating with little op- trust a madman who is a sworn enemy of position. Today, the Saudi Government is this country, or take action necessary to de- taking the fight to Al Qaida, and America fend our people. Given that choice, I will and the world are safer. defend America every time. Before September the 11th, Libya was Audience members. Four more years! spending millions to acquire weapons of mass Four more years! Four more years! destruction. Today, because America and our The President. Because Saddam Hussein allies have sent a strong and clear message, sits in a prison cell, the Iraqi people are free, the leader of Libya has abandoned his pursuit and America and the world are safer. of weapons of mass destruction, and America We have more to do. I’m seeking the office and the world are safer. for 4 more years because I know we have Before September the 11th, the ruler of more to do. We must continue to work with Iraq was a sworn enemy of America. He was friends and allies around the world to aggres- defying the world. Remember, he was firing sively pursue the terrorists and foreign fight- weapons at American pilots which were en- ers in Iraq and Afghanistan and elsewhere. forcing the world’s sanctions. The tyrant had See, you can’t talk sense to these people. You pursued and used weapons of mass destruc- cannot negotiate with them. You cannot hope tion. He’d harbored terrorists. He invaded for the best. We must engage them so we his neighbors. And he subsidized the families do not have to face them here at home. of suicide bombers. He murdered tens of America will continue to lead the world thousands of his own citizens. He was a with confidence and moral clarity. We put source of great instability in a volatile part together a strong coalition to help defeat the of the world. enemies of freedom. There are nearly 40 na- After September the 11th, we looked at tions involved in Afghanistan, some 30 na- all the threats of the world in a new light. tions in Iraq, and over 60 nations involved The lesson of September the 11th is that with the Proliferation Security Initiative. America must take threats seriously, before Over the next 4 years, we’ll continue to build they fully materialize. alliances and work with our friends in the The September the 11th Commission con- cause of security and peace. But I will never cluded that our institutions of Government turn America’s national security decisions had failed to imagine the horror of that day. over to leaders of other nations. After September the 11th, we could not fail We’ll keep our commitments to help Af- to imagine that a brutal tyrant who hated ghanistan and Iraq become democratic, free, America, had ties to terror, had used weap- and, therefore, peaceful societies. These two ons of mass destruction might use those nations are now governed by strong people, weapons or share the capability of those people who are willing to listen to the hopes weapons with terrorist enemy. In other and aspirations of the people. You know what words, we saw a threat. I looked at the intel- the hopes and aspirations of mothers and ligence and saw a threat. Members of the dads are in Iraq and Afghanistan? They want United States Congress from both political their children to grow up in a peaceful world parties, including my opponent, looked at the just like in—American moms and dads do. intelligence and came to the same conclu- They want there to be hope for their kids. sion. The United Nations Security Council They want them to be able to realize their looked at the intelligence and unanimously dreams. These leaders understand that. demanded that Saddam Hussein disclose, de- More and more Iraqis are now stepping up

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00054 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 4 1449

to defend the peace, to defend their free- of their citizens. By serving the ideal of lib- dom. erty, we’re bringing hope to others, and that And my message to those people is that makes our country more secure. By serving they can count on continued help from the ideal of liberty, we’re spreading peace. America and our coalition. You see, when we And by serving the ideal of liberty, we’re acted to protect our own security, we prom- serving a basic understanding of our country, ised to help deliver them from tyranny, to a basic value of America. See, freedom is not restore their sovereignty, and to help set America’s gift to the world. Freedom is the them on the road to liberty. And when Amer- Almighty God’s gift to each man and woman ica gives its word, America will keep its word. in this world. In these crucial times, our commitments I’m running for 4 more years because I are kept by the men and women of our mili- understand we have more to do to protect tary. First, I want to thank all the veterans America. See, there are enemies who hate who are here. I appreciate the example us, and they’re still plotting to harm us. you’ve set for our troops today. I’ve had the Those who claim that America’s war on ter- privilege of meeting those who wear our Na- ror, our efforts to defend ourselves, is to tion’s uniform. I’ve seen their great decency, blame for terrorist threats against the United their unselfish courage. The cause of free- States have a fundamental misunderstanding dom is in really good hands. of the nature of the enemy we face. The We owe our troops best pay, best training, 9/11 Commission said America homeland is best possible equipment. That’s why last Sep- safe, but—safer, but we’re not yet safe. I tember, while our troops were in combat in agree. There’s more to do here at home. both Afghanistan and Iraq, I proposed sup- Immediately after September the 11th, we plemental funding to support them in their started the hard process of reform. We trans- mission. The legislation provided funding for formed our defenses and created the Depart- body armor and vital equipment, hazard pay, ment of Homeland Security. We passed the health benefits, ammunition, fuel, and spare PATRIOT Act, which was necessary to give parts. In the Senate, only a small, out-of-the- law enforcement the tools necessary to de- mainstream minority of 12 senators voted fend the American people. The mission of against that help. Two of those twelve are the FBI is now focused on preventing ter- my opponent and his runningmate. rorism. We’re integrating intelligence and Audience members. Boo-o-o! law enforcement better than we ever have The President. Here’s how my opponent before. We’re already taking action on a large tried to explain his vote. He said, ‘‘I actually majority of the 9/11 Commission’s rec- did vote for the $87 billion, before I voted ommendations. And they did good work, and against it.’’ [Laughter] That doesn’t sound I thank them for their work. the way they talk here in southern Min- We’ve got more to do to better secure our nesota. I suspect the people around here, ports and borders, to train first-responders, when they say something, they mean it. Now and to dramatically improve our intelligence- my opponent is offering a different expla- gathering capability. That’s why, this week, nation. He said he was proud he voted I called on Congress to create the position against it, and then he further said the whole of National Intelligence Director, so that one thing is a complicated matter. There’s noth- person is in charge of coordinating all intel- ing complicated about supporting our troops ligence overseas and here at home. These re- in combat. forms are not going to be easy, particularly In the long run, our security is not guaran- in Washington. [Laughter] Reform is never teed by force alone. We must work to change easy there. See, there’s a lot of entrenched the conditions that give rise to terror: poverty interests that love to defend the status quo. and hopelessness and resentment. See, a free It’s not enough to advocate reform. You have and peaceful Iraq and a free and peaceful to be able to get it done. Afghanistan will be powerful examples to And that’s what we have done. When it their neighbors. Free countries do not export comes to reforming schools to provide excel- terror. Free countries listen to the dreams lent education for all our children, we got

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00055 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1450 Aug. 4 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

the job done. Results matter. When it comes And we stand for a culture of responsibility to health care reforms to give families more in America. Listen, our culture is changing access and more choices, results matter. from one that said, ‘‘If it feels good, do it,’’ When it comes to improving our economy and ‘‘If you’ve got a problem, blame some- and creating jobs, results matter. When it body else,’’ to a culture in which each of us comes to having a strong farm economy, re- understands we’re responsible for the deci- sults matter. When it comes to better secur- sions we make in life. If you’re fortunate ing our homeland, fighting the forces of ter- enough to be a mother or a father, you’re ror, and spreading the peace, results matter. responsible for loving that child with all your When it comes to electing a President, re- heart and all your soul. If you’re worried sults matter. about the quality of the education here in We live in an exciting time. It’s a time of this community, do something about it. change. But we ought to make sure Govern- You’re responsible for taking action. If you’re ment responds to these times by standing a CEO in corporate America, you’re respon- side by side with people. You know how I sible for telling the truth to your shareholders think the best way to do that is to promote and your employees. ownership society. You see, if you’re a worker In a responsibility society, each of us is and you’re changing jobs, you’ve got to be responsible for loving our neighbor just like able to own your own health care plan so we’d like to be loved yourself. I understand you can take it from job to job. We want that the strength of this country is the hearts people to own their own home in America. and souls of the American people. I’m seek- We want people to be able to say, ‘‘Welcome ing 4 more years to continue to rally the ar- mies of compassion so we can help change to my house. This is my piece of property.’’ our country, one heart, one soul, one con- And more and more are, under this adminis- science at a time. tration. We want younger workers to be able For all Americans, these years in our his- to own a Social Security personal retirement tory will always stand apart. There are quiet account they call their own, so they can pass times in the life of a nation when little is it on to future generations. We want tax pol- expected of its leaders. This isn’t one of those icy such that younger Americans can own times. We need firm resolve, clear vision, a their own farm. We want people owning their willingness to lead. And none of us will ever own small business. We understand that forget that week when one era ended and when you own something, you have a vital another began. stake in the future of our country. On September the 14th, 2001, I stood in No, this world is changing, but there are the ruins of the Twin Towers. It’s a day I’ll some things that aren’t going to change: our never forget. I remember workers in hard- belief in liberty and opportunity and the non- hats yelling at me, ‘‘Whatever it takes.’’ I’ll negotiable demands of human dignity. The never forget the guy that grabbed me by the individual values we try to live by will not arm—I don’t remember if he was a fire- change, courage and compassion, reverence fighter or a policeman. I do know he had and integrity. The institutions that give us di- been in the rubble searching for a loved one. rection and purpose must not change, our His eyes were bloodshot. He said, ‘‘Do not families, and our schools, and our religious let me down.’’ congregation. These institutions are funda- See, he took it personally. Folks searching mental to our lives. They deserve the respect the rubble took it personally. You took it per- of our Government. sonally, and I took it personally. I have a re- We stand for institutions like marriage and sponsibility that goes on. I wake up every family, which are the foundations of our soci- morning thinking how to better protect our ety. We stand for a culture of life in which country. I will never relent in defending every person matters and every person America, whatever it takes. counts. We stand for judges who faithfully We’ve come through much together. interpret the law instead of legislating from We’ve done hard work. During the next 4 the bench. years, there’s more to do, more to spread

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00056 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1451

ownership and opportunity for every corner strong leadership of our Pentagon. Mr. Sec- of this country—I mean every corner. We’ll retary, thank you. pass the enduring values of our country to Secretary Rumsfeld. Thank you, sir. another generation. During the next 4 years, The President. I appreciate Deputy Sec- we’ll lead the world in the cause of freedom retary Wolfowitz for joining us today. I ap- and peace. preciate the other members of the Pentagon When I was campaigning in your great team who are here. I appreciate Jim Roche State in 2000, I said if you honored me with and Les Brownlee representing the Air Force the great responsibility, I would uphold the and the Army. General Myers, the Chairman honor and the dignity of the office to which of the Joint Chiefs, is with us. I appreciate I had been elected, so help me God. And the Chairman. I want to thank all the military with your help, I will do so for 4 more years. generals who are here, who run their respec- Thanks for coming. May God bless. Thank tive branches of the services. Thank you all you all. for coming. Thanks for your leadership. I appreciate Senator John Warner rep- resenting the United States Congress. Sen- NOTE: The President spoke at 5 p.m. at the South- ern Minnesota Construction Co. quarry. In his re- ator Warner is a strong leader when it comes marks, he referred to Gov. Tim Pawlenty of Min- to matters of defense. He’s the chairman of nesota; Col. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, the Senate Armed Services Committee. This leader of Libya; former President Saddam Hus- bill passed with overwhelming bipartisan sein of Iraq; and the National Commission on Ter- support. I want thank you for that, sir. rorist Attacks Upon the United States (9/11 Com- America’s military is fighting in many thea- mission). ters, yet always for the same cause. We seek to preserve freedom and peace for ourselves and for our friends. Remarks on Signing the Department In the last 3 years, our military men and of Defense Appropriations Act, 2005 women have struck a series of decisive blows August 5, 2004 against the enemy. They have relentlessly at- tacked the Al Qaida network. They’ve killed The President. Thank you all. Please be or captured many of its leaders. They’ve de- seated. stroyed its terror camps. We’re disrupting its America and our allies are fighting a new plans. We’re doing our duty. kind of war against a different kind of enemy. We’ve ended regimes in Kabul and Bagh- This conflict places great demands on the dad that supported and harbored terrorists men and women of our Armed Forces, in- and threatened America. They have helped cluding our Guard and Reserve. They have to launch the nations of Iraq and Afghanistan met every test. They’ve risen to every chal- on the path to lasting democracy and liberty. lenge. They have helped friendly nations build the The war also places demands on those of strength and institutions necessary to fight us in Government. We took an oath to pro- terror. At this hour, our troops are staying tect our country. We have a solemn responsi- on the offensive against Al Qaida. We’re tak- bility to support the service men and women ing the fight to the enemies, those who can’t who defend us in the field of battle. The De- stand the thought of a free Iraq and free Af- fense appropriations bill I will sign today ghanistan. Our troops are making America commits $391 billion toward meeting that re- safer, and we’re grateful for their sacrifices. sponsibility. With this legislation, America’s These great achievements have come at a military will know that their country stands cost of human life and grief. America is grate- behind them as they fight for our freedom ful for the families of those who mourn a and as they spread the peace. No enemy or loved one. We will honor their memory by friend can doubt that America has the re- completing the mission and making the sources to prevail, and we will. world a more peaceful place. We have made I want to thank the Secretary of Defense, a commitment to the men and women of our Donald Rumsfeld, for his steadfast and Armed Forces. We will support them. We

VerDate May 21 2004 12:16 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00057 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1452 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

will provide them fair pay and good treat- 4 years ago. America and our allies face a ment. We will continue to ensure they have deadly threat from ballistic missiles armed the tools they need to defeat the enemies with the world’s most dangerous weapons. of today. We will develop the weapons and And we will deploy the technologies nec- systems to meet the threats of tomorrow. essary to protect our people. The bill meets these commitments: first, Recent history has shown that threats to by providing more than $103 billion to the our shores can emerge from failing states half greatest source of American strength, our a world away. By acting early to end a crisis, servicepeople and their families. This appro- we can make our world safer. That’s why this priation is the fourth of my administration bill provides $95 million to help the people to include a pay raise for our troops. This of Darfur in western Sudan. Brutal militias year’s raise of 3.5 percent brings the total there are causing human suffering on an im- pay raise over the last 4 years to nearly 21 mense scale. The new funding will provide percent. This money is well earned, well de- famine relief, assistance for refugees, and served, and well spent. The bill also fulfills other humanitarian aid. Yet no amount of aid my pledge to eliminate the costs that too can substitute for true and lasting peace. The many servicepeople have had to pay for off- Government of Sudan must stop the violence base housing. It’s a real boost to the quality of Janjaweed militias, and all parties must re- of life for our military families. The excel- spect the cease-fire and allow the free move- lence and professionalism of an all-volunteer ment of humanitarian workers and supplies. force has never been higher. America must Third, this bill meets our commitment to do all we can to encourage these special America’s Armed Forces by preparing them Americans to stay in uniform. And that starts to meet the threats of tomorrow. Our en- with taking care of their families. emies are innovative and resourceful, and so Second, this bill meets our commitments are we. They never stop thinking about new by making sure that our Armed Forces have every tool they need to meet and defeat the ways to harm our country and our people, threats of our time. This bill provides $25 and neither do we. We must never stop billion in emergency appropriations to sup- thinking about how best to defend our coun- port current operations in Afghanistan and try when we all must always be forward- Iraq, the frontlines in the war on terror. This thinking. money will buy more armored Humvees, Over the past few years, new ideas and more ammunition, more fuel, more spare new technologies have increased the preci- parts. It will upgrade our helicopters with the sion of our weapons, reduced battlefield cas- latest equipment, allowing them to fly more ualties, and lessened the toll of war on inno- safely in the dangerous theaters. cent life. This bill continues that progress by This bill helps America maintain the peace funding the technologies that are changing around the world and keep our commitments the way we fight wars in order to keep the to our allies. It funds construction of three peace, technology such as the Army’s Future new state-of-the-art guided missile destroy- Combat System, which will give every soldier ers to patrol the seas, 42 new F/A–18 fighter precise tactical information in the heat of aircraft to guard the skies. It provides $4 bil- battle; the Littoral Combat Ship, which will lion for new C–17 strategic air lifters, which increase the reach of our Navy into hostile will increase our ability to move forces quick- shores and waterways; the versatile and cost- ly over long distances. And $200 million will effective Joint Strike Fighter; and wideband buy more Predator unmanned surveillance satellite laser communications that will im- aircraft to track and hunt our enemies. prove the ability of our forces to commu- This bill provides $10 billion for systems nicate over great distances. to defend against the threat from ballistic I appreciate the solid and bipartisan sup- missiles. Later this year, the first components port of this bill. I appreciate both people— of America’s missile defense system will be- people of both parties coming together to come operational. This will fulfill a pledge support our troops. We’re doing our duty to I made to the American people more than the people who are out doing their duty to

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00058 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1453

defend us and make the world a more peace- Section 8064 of the Act provides that, not- ful place. The message is clear: In a time withstanding any other provision of law, no of conflict and challenge, America stands be- funds available to the Department of De- hind our military. fense for FY 2005 may be used to transfer By taking care of our servicepeople in uni- defense articles or services, other than intel- form, by addressing the threats of today, by ligence services, to another nation or an preparing for the threats of a tomorrow, this international organization for international bill will help make America a safer place. peacekeeping, peace enforcement, or hu- And so I’m pleased to sign the Defense manitarian assistance operations, until 15 Appropriations Act for Fiscal Year 2005. days after the executive branch notifies 6 Thank you all for coming. committees of the Congress of the planned transfer. To the extent that protection of the NOTE: The President spoke at 9:56 a.m. in Room U.S. Armed Forces deployed for inter- 350 of the Dwight D. Eisenhower Executive Of- national peacekeeping, peace enforcement, fice Building. H.R. 4613, approved August 5, was or humanitarian assistance operations might assigned Public Law 108–287. require action of a kind covered by section 8064 sooner than 15 days after notification, the executive branch shall construe section Statement on Signing the 8064 in a manner consistent with the Presi- Department of Defense dent’s constitutional authority as Com- Appropriations Act, 2005 mander in Chief. August 5, 2004 A proviso in the Act’s appropriation for ‘‘Operation and Maintenance, Defense- Today I have signed into law H.R. 4613, Wide’’ purports to prohibit planning for con- the ‘‘Department of Defense Appropriations solidation of certain offices within the De- Act, 2005.’’ The bill provides funds to pursue partment of Defense. Also, sections 8010(b), the war on terror, advance other United 8036, 8041(b), 8110, and 8116 purport to States interests around the globe, and sup- specify the content of a portion of a future port our Armed Forces. budget request to the Congress for the De- Sections 8007, 8011, and 8106 of the Act partment. The executive branch shall con- prohibit the use of funds to initiate a special strue these provisions relating to planning access program, a new overseas installation, and making of budget recommendations in or a new start program, unless the congres- a manner consistent with the President’s con- sional defense committees receive advance stitutional authority to require the opinions notice. The Supreme Court of the United of the heads of departments and to rec- States has stated that the President’s author- ommend for congressional consideration ity to classify and control access to informa- such measures as the President shall judge tion bearing on the national security flows necessary and expedient. from the Constitution and does not depend Section 8005 of the Act relating to requests upon a legislative grant of authority. Al- to congressional committees for reprogram- though the advance notice contemplated by ming of funds shall be construed as calling sections 8007, 8011, and 8106 can be pro- solely for notification, as any other construc- vided in most situations as a matter of comity, tion would be inconsistent with the principles situations may arise, especially in wartime, enunciated by the Supreme Court of the in which the President must act promptly United States in INS v. Chadha. under his constitutional grants of executive A proviso within the appropriation for power and authority as Commander in Chief ‘‘Operation and Maintenance, Air Force’’ of the Armed Forces while protecting certain earmarks funds for a grant to a college for extraordinarily sensitive national security in- the purpose of funding minority aviation formation. The executive branch shall con- training, a proviso within the appropriation strue sections 8007, 8011, and 8106 in a man- for ‘‘Operation and Maintenance, Defense- ner consistent with the constitutional author- Wide’’ earmarks funds for a program for ity of the President. Asian American/Pacific Islander students,

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00059 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1454 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

and sections 8014 and 8021 of the Act grant part of the Department of Defense Appro- contracting-related exceptions or preferences priations, FY 2005 (H.R. 4613), as an emer- to Native Hawaiian organizations. The execu- gency requirement. tive branch shall implement the provisos and These funds are necessary to support Op- sections 8014 and 8021 in a manner con- eration Iraqi Freedom and Operation Endur- sistent with the requirement to afford equal ing Freedom, the Department of State’s Mis- protection of the laws under the Due Process sion in Iraq, State and local law enforcement Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the Con- assistance for security and related costs asso- stitution. ciated with the 2004 Presidential Candidate The executive branch shall construe sec- Nominating Conventions, the Judiciary, and tion 8101 of the Act, which purports to pro- to respond to the humanitarian crisis in the hibit alteration of command responsibility or Darfur region of Sudan. permanent assignment of forces until 270 Additional information on this action is set days after submission of a plan for such alter- forth in the attached letter from the Director ation to the congressional defense commit- of the Office of Management and Budget. tees, as advisory, as any other construction Sincerely, would be inconsistent with the constitutional grant to the President of the authority of George W. Bush Commander in Chief. Also, the executive NOTE: H.R. 4613, approved August 5, was as- branch shall construe section 8124, relating signed Public Law 108–287. to integration of foreign intelligence informa- tion, in a manner consistent with the Presi- dent’s constitutional authority as Com- Remarks in a Discussion in mander in Chief, including for the conduct Columbus, Ohio of intelligence operations, and to supervise August 5, 2004 the unitary executive branch. Finally, the Ex- ecutive Branch shall construe section 12001, The President. Thank you all. Please be which purports to assign the Secretary of De- seated. Thank you all. That’s what I’m here fense the duty to negotiate with a foreign asking for, for 4 more years. Yes, I’m trav- country, in a manner consistent with the eling our country—coming to Ohio a lot, by President’s constitutional authority to con- the way. I think you have to ask for the vote, duct the Nation’s foreign affairs, which in- and that’s what I’m here doing. I want your cludes the authority to determine who shall vote and want your help. negotiate for the United States under the I want to thank those of you who are in- President’s direction with a foreign country. volved with grassroots politics, the people George W. Bush who are helping to register the voters and the people who are going to be asking the The White House, voters to do their duty in democracy and go August 5, 2004. to the polls. I appreciate your work. And by NOTE: H.R. 4613, approved August 5, was as- the way, when you get them headed to the signed Public Law 108–287. polls, kind of nudge them our way. There’s more to do for this country. That’s what I want to talk about. We’ve got an un- Letter to the Speaker of the House of usual way of talking about the agenda for the Representatives on the Designation future today. I want to share some thoughts of Emergency Funds in the with you. We’ve got some citizens from the Department of Defense Columbus area who are going to talk about Appropriations Act, 2005 some of the ideas that we’re going to use August 5, 2004 to make America a compassionate place, a better place. And then I’ll be glad to answer Dear Mr. Speaker: some of your questions. I hereby concur with the Congress in the First, let me tell you I’m sorry Laura is designation of $25.856 billion provided as not here. She’s got a valid excuse. Governor

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00060 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1455

Bush’s oldest son—that would be my young- [Laughter] He got his ring, he said; he est brother—oldest son is getting married. doesn’t want another one. But I really appre- [Applause] Yes. And she’s there early. I’m ciate you coming. Thank you all for being going late, because I’m working. [Laughter] here. But she is a wonderful wife, a loving mother, Today I met a fellow named Jack Lehr. and a great First Lady. I’m really proud of He’s a soldier in the army of compassion. her. [Applause] Thank you all. That means he’s a person who is taking time I was hoping she would come with me be- out of his life to volunteer to help people. cause I wanted her to come to the site where Jack has been involved with tutoring people my grandfather was raised. I don’t know if in GED preparation programs. That means you know that or not—there you go—Grand- he’s a mentor, see. Jack has taken time out father Bush, raised right here in Columbus, of his life to help somebody who needs some Ohio. You know how we are in the political help. arena; we’re always trying to find a local One of the reasons I’m running—where peg—[laughter]. I’ve got one here. [Laugh- are you, Jack? Oh, there he is. Thanks for ter] And my family is better off having those coming out at the airport. I appreciate you. Ohio roots in our background. He’s also involved with Hospice. I know a I also picked a good man to run with. I lot of you are doing the same thing in your admit it, Dick Cheney is not the prettiest lives: You’re coaching Little League; or candidate in the race. [Laughter] I didn’t you’re involved with Boy Scouts or Girl pick him because of his looks. I picked him Scouts; or you’re feeding the hungry; or because he knows what he’s doing. He’s a you’re finding shelter for the homeless. All sound man with good judgment. of you are soldiers in the army of compassion. Before we get started here, I do want to And one of the reasons I’m seeking the office thank my friend your Governor, Bob Taft, for 4 more years is to continue to call upon for joining me today. Thanks for coming, our fellow citizens to love a neighbor just like Governor. Appreciate your service. I’ve you’d like to be loved yourself. See, that known him for quite a while. We were both means I understand the strength of our coun- Governors together, and we’re both mem- try is the heart and souls of our citizens. bers of the famous father club. That’s the true strength of America, and we I appreciate Congressman Pat Tiberi. He’s can change America one soul at a time by from this area; he’s doing a fine job. Who encouraging people to spread something you got there? Tiberi tells me coming in that Government cannot spread, which is love. this is his daughter’s first political speech. So One of the most important initiatives of when she starts dozing off, you know the rea- this administration is what is called the Faith- son why: I’ve been going on too long. But Based and Community Initiative, that allows I appreciate the congressman coming. Thank faith-based programs—people from all you. I also appreciate my friend Deborah faiths—to access Federal monies to help Pryce, Congresswoman Pryce, for being here them do their job of spreading love and com- too. passion. If you’re an addict, if you’re hooked Governor Jennette Bradley is with us. on drugs or alcohol, sometimes government She’s a good friend of mine. I appreciate her counseling can work. But sometimes it re- service to the State. Thank you, Jennette. quires a change of heart in order to change I want to thank Doug Preisse, who emceed habit. There are people who are empowered the event. He’s also head of the grassroots. to change hearts in our society—not by Gov- He’s what we call the party chairman. That’s ernment, by a higher calling. And therefore, the person in charge of making sure people Government ought to welcome these works who want to help have an opportunity to help of compassion and healing. to find the vote and turn people out to vote. I know we can change America for the bet- I want to thank my friend Bernie Kosar. ter by calling on those who are change I reminded him that the Dallas Cowboys are agents, those who are willing to put an arm going to be starting a 40-year-old quarter- around somebody who needs love and say, back this year. It’s not too late, Bernie. ‘‘I love you, brother. I love you, sister. What

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00061 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1456 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

can I do to help you have a better life here Al Qaida leadership has been brought to jus- in America?’’ tice, and we’re safer for it. I’m running—I’m asking for your vote Another lesson of September the 11th is, again, and I’m running because there’s more in order to be able to defend ourselves, we’ve to do to keep this country safer. You know, got to say to people who are willing to harbor it’s very important that we never forget the a terrorist or feed a terrorist, ‘‘You’re just as lessons of September the 11th, 2001. I know guilty as the terrorist.’’ And let me tell you I won’t; I know many of you will never forget something about leadership and about being it, either. the American President. If you say some- Audience member. We’ll never forget. thing, you’d better mean it. [Applause] The President. There you go. Let me Thank you all. And when I said to the share with you some of the lessons that I Taliban—those are the folks running Afghan- remember. One, we’re facing an enemy istan—‘‘Give up your evil ways or face the which has no heart, no compassion. And that consequences,’’ I meant it. They ignored us, puts them at an advantage, in a way, because and they paid the price. They’re no longer we’re a country of heart and compassion. in power, no longer can Al Qaida use Afghan- istan as a safe haven for training. Remember, See, these are ideological extremists who are thousands of people were trained in Afghani- willing to use terror to affect the conscience stan and then dispersed throughout the of the free world. They’re willing to try to world, some of whom came here to inflict have their way by wanton destruction of in- great harm on our people. The world is bet- nocent life. That stands the opposite of what ter off and America is safer because of the America stands for, isn’t it? We don’t believe actions we have taken in Afghanistan. in that, yet they do. They’re trying to shake Think about this: Afghanistan is going to our will and our confidence. One of the les- hold elections this fall. It’s amazing, isn’t it, sons of September the 11th is we face deadly when you think about it. What a change— foe who will kill on a moment’s notice to try what a change in a part of the world that to shake our confidence and our will. is desperate for freedom. Listen, it wasn’t but The second lesson of September the 11th 3 years ago or so that these people lived is, is that in order to protect ourselves—and under the clutches of one of the most brutal that’s my most solemn duty, is to protect the groups of people known to mankind, the American people—and by the way, it’s the Taliban. They wouldn’t let young girls go to solemn duty of first-responders all across our school in Afghanistan. They were so back- country; it’s the solemn duty of those who ward, their vision was so dim, that if you wear our uniform. There’s a lot of people dared express an opinion that they didn’t who understand the seriousness of the job agree with, you were in trouble. and the responsibilities we have. We’re lucky You know, I was in Cleveland the other to have a nation of so many responsible citi- day, and we went to the International Chil- zens who are willing to work hard to defend dren’s Games kickoff, and guess who was our homeland. there—a girls soccer team from Afghanistan, The second lesson is, though, that in order right here in America. What I’m saying is, to defend the homeland, we’ve got to be on Afghanistan is a better place. They’re an the offense. We must deal with those people emerging democracy. Over 8 million people overseas so we don’t have to face them here have registered to vote. They’re an ally in at home, and that’s what we’re doing. We’ve the war on terror. And the world is better got a lot of fine troops out there. We’ve got off because young girls and moms and dads other nations working with us to bring people have a chance to realize their ambitions for to justice. And we’re making progress, slowly their families, not the ambitions of backward, but surely making progress. This is a dif- barbaric people like the Taliban. ferent kind of war. Sometimes you’ll see ac- We’ve taken the lead in the world, and the tion; sometimes you won’t. We’re chasing world has changed for the better. Just think people down in caves, in the dark recesses about Afghanistan’s neighbor, Pakistan, for of the world. About two-thirds of the known a minute. Because of our leadership and

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00062 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1457

work with the Pakistan authorities, Al Qaida Now, the United States Congress looked is now on the run in Pakistan. We’ve got an at the same intelligence I looked at, the exact ally in the war on terror with President same intelligence, and came to the same con- Musharraf. No, this world is getting better clusion. Members of both political parties off. looked at the intelligence. My opponent A very important lesson of September the looked at the very same intelligence and 11th, one this Nation must never forget, is came to the same conclusion. The United that when we see threats, we must deal with Nations—remember I went to the U.N. and them before they fully materialize. That’s one said, ‘‘You have forever condemned him. of the vital lessons of that fateful day. See, You’ve told him to get rid of his weapons, with these people—remember, I described yet nothing has happened, so let’s try her one what they’re like—you cannot negotiate with more time.’’ And the United Nations looked them; you cannot hope for the best. I like at the intelligence, saw a threat, and passed to say therapy doesn’t work. [Laughter] They a resolution 15 to nothing. That was what made up their minds—they made up their the Security Council said. They said, ‘‘Dis- minds to inflict terrible harm on those who close, disarm, or face serious consequences.’’ disagree with them. And so the world spoke, and again he de- That’s why people who say that because fied us. And not only did he defy us, he sys- we’ve been on the offense to protect Amer- tematically deceived the inspectors. You re- ica, we’ve created more enemies than before, member the period of time; we said, ‘‘Well, just don’t understand the war on terror. They let’s give the inspectors the chance to work.’’ do not understand. These were people plot- We agreed, until we found out he was deceiv- ting prior to us taking action around the ing them. What he was trying to do was buy world. These are people who look for weak- time. Why? Because he wanted to reconsti- ness in the free world. These are people who tute a weapons program. He wanted to make are willing to exploit fear in the free world. sure he had the capacity to make weapons. And the United States of America will stand And if he had any, like we thought he did, strong and resolute in the face of this new he didn’t want anybody to find them, that’s challenge. why. I had a choice to make then: forget the Another lesson of September the 11th: I lessons of September the 11th, trust a mad- said if we see a threat, we must deal with man; or take action to defend our country. it before it fully materializes. We saw a threat Every time, I will defend America. in Iraq. And let me tell you why. Not only We are safer—we are safer and the world the intelligence say there was a threat there, is better off because Saddam is sitting in a but we remembered the history of the man. prison cell. I want to share something with He was a sworn enemy of America. Terrorists you. Committing troops into harm’s way is— were able to—and terrorist networks were in harm’s way is the most difficult decision able to operate in and out of his country. a President can make. That decision must al- Remember Abu Nidal? He was the guy that ways be last resort. That decision must be killed the man, an American citizen, because done when our vital interests are at stake, he was Jewish. His network was there inside but after we’ve tried everything else. There of Iraq. Zarqawi, who’s still is running around must be a compelling national need to put in Iraq—his network was in Iraq. He is a— our troops into harm’s way. I felt that. I felt Saddam was a fellow who paid the families we had a compelling national need. I know of suicide bombers. That’s one of the— we had tried diplomacy. I knew that diplo- suiciding to kill innocent people as an act macy at this point couldn’t possibly work be- of terror. He paid the families as an incentive cause he had no intention of listening to de- to do so. He had used weapons of mass de- mands of the free world. And when you put struction. Remember that? He had used your troops in harm’s way, they better have them on his own people. He had used them the best—the best equipment, the best sup- against countries in his neighborhood. He port, and the best possible pay. was a source of instability. He was a threat, That’s why I went to the Congress and and we saw him as a threat. said—last September—said we need more

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00063 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1458 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

money for our troops, $87 billion more ghanistan and Iraq. Now, it’s not easy to be money. Some of it was for reconstruction; a free society in a place like Iraq; it’s just most of it was for the troops, over $60 billion not. You can understand why. These people for the troops—Humvees, spare parts, body were brutalized. There were mass graves of armor, the things necessary that you would thousands of—of a thousand citizens. want. If you are a mom or dad—we probably I’ll tell you an interesting story, and it’s got a mom or dad here whose child is in one that touched my heart. Seven people Iraq—you want your son or daughter to have came to the Oval Office, seven Iraqi men. the best. [Applause] Thank you, appreciate Walking in that Oval Office, by the way, is you. a pretty interesting experience—the kind of There were two Senators—there were 12 place people stand outside and say, ‘‘When Senators who voted against more funding for I get in, I’m going to tell him what-for.’’ And the troops, two of whom are my opponent they walk in, they get overwhelmed by the and his runningmate. Oval Office, say, ‘‘Man, you’re looking good, Audience members. Boo-o-o! Mr. President.’’ [Laughter] The President. I don’t know if you heard the explanation. He said, ‘‘I actually did vote These people came in, and they said, ‘‘Lib- for the $87 billion, before I voted against it.’’ erator.’’ I said, ‘‘You don’t need to thank me; [Laughter] That’s not the way most folks you need to thank the American people. You speak in Ohio. As the Commander in Chief, need to thank the mothers and fathers of I’ll see to it our troops have the best—the those, and the husbands and wives of those, best possible pay, the best possible training, who served to free you.’’ They had something the best possible equipment to defend the in common besides being Iraqi men; all of United States of America. [Applause] Thank them had their right hands cut off by Saddam you all. By the way, I know we’ve got some Hussein. That’s the society that we’ve liber- veterans here. Thanks for setting such a good ated. You know why? Because his currency example for those who wear our uniform had devalued and he needed a scapegoat. So today. I appreciate your service. he found seven small-business men. For ex- The world is changing. This is an historic ample, one of them was a jeweler, and he times. Freedom equals peace. Listen, we’ve told me, he said, ‘‘I sold dinars to buy’’— done the hard work, and there’s more hard I think he said euros—‘‘to buy gold so I could work to do. But I want you to know that we’re make a watch.’’ And so what they were look- headed for a peaceful world. That’s my hope. ing for, the authority, Saddam and his thugs, My hope is that young children can grow up were looking for people who sold dinars that in a peaceful world. My hope is that we never caused the currency to be devalued at that have to live another day like we did on Sep- particular moment. They put them in prison, tember the 11th. and he cut off their right hands and burned And you achieve peace by spreading free- an X in their forehead. So in come seven dom. That’s what America believes. And guys who have got an X in their forehead. that’s hard work. Free nations are peaceful The good news is that they had been discov- nations. Free nations, nations that listen to ered by an American named Marvin Zindler the aspirations of their people, are nations from Houston, and he had a foundation to in which it’s hard to recruit people willing to kill themselves for a radical philosophy. help people from around the world. They That’s what Americans believe. We believe flew them into Houston. These seven guys that freedom is the Almighty God’s gift to had new hands, new prosthesis. every man and woman in this world. A guy took my Sharpie, wrapped his new And therefore, our strategy for peace is fingers, and wrote ‘‘God bless America’’ in to do everything we can to protect the home- Arabic. What a contrast—what a contrast in land by being on the offense against an societies: On the one hand, a society that was enemy. But it’s also to spread liberty. These so brutalized by a dictator that he could just are historic times. That’s why it’s vital we say, ‘‘I’m going to cut off their hands,’’ to stand with those who love freedom in Af- a society which says, ‘‘We want to heal you,

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00064 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1459

no matter who you are, no matter your reli- our word? Or are we going to go timid and gion, no matter where you’re from.’’ We be- weary and afraid of the barbaric behavior of lieve in human dignity and human rights in a few? I want to be your President for 4 more the United States of America. years because I believe that freedom can There’s good people now running those change the world and the world will be more countries, Karzai and Alawi. These are tough peaceful. guys. Alawi, I’m told, woke up one night in A couple of other—[applause]. Thank you London to a axe-wielding group of men that all. Let me talk about domestic policies. And had been sent by Saddam Hussein to kill him then we’re going to call on some of our— with an axe. He got away from the axe-wield- some of your citizens to help me make some ing thugs severely wounded. In other words, points. First of all, when I came to Wash- this guy has seen the worst of tyranny, and ington, I said we’re going to challenge the now he’s leading the country. He believes soft bigotry of low expectations. That means in a free Iraq. He believes in a self-governing the attitude that some kids can’t learn; there- Iraq. He believes in listening to the aspira- fore, let’s just shuffle them through the tions of the people. And he’s plenty tough school. You know what I’m talking about. to do the job. And people got shuffled from grade to grade, And so we’ve got to stand with these peo- and society woke up, said, ‘‘Oh, what hap- ple, see, because, you know what, a free pened?’’ Well, what happened was, was that world—a free Iraq in a part of the world we didn’t set high expectations and we never that’s desperate for freedom is an historic op- measured, really. We never—you see, if you portunity. Maybe I can put it to you best believe a child can read, then you want to this way: You know, my dad, I’m sure some know whether that child is reading. And you of your dads, fought in World War II against want to know early, before it’s too late. And Japan. And right after World War II, there when you can figure out whether a child is was a movement to rebuild Japan so it would not reading early, it gives you a chance to be a self-governing nation. Some doubted correct the problems so that no child is left whether that was possible. Some people in behind. That’s why we called it the No Child our country, they said, ‘‘Why are you wasting your time? Why worry about a self-governing Left Behind Act. Japan?’’ Fortunately, there were some opti- And we made good progress. There is mists, some people who believed in the more to do. That’s what I’m here to tell you. power of liberty to change societies and lives There’s more to do. We need intensive read- who stood the line and finally succeeded. We ing programs for junior high kids. We need succeeded in helping Japan self-govern. to make sure that they’ve got the basic edu- So I’m having Kobe beef one night with cation as they head to high school. We must Prime Minister Koizumi. He’s the Prime make sure that the Internet is in classrooms Minister of Japan and a good friend of mine. so that the free flow of information is vibrant We’re talking about how to keep the peace. and well. The broadbrand technology initia- We’re talking about how to deal with Mr. tive of mine is essential to making sure infor- Kim Chong-il of North Korea—people are mation flows into our schools. We want to starving, by the way, and who wants to try make sure the high school diploma means to blackmail the free world with a nuclear something. weapon. And here we are talking about There’s more work to do. We want to make peace. That’s what we’re talking about. See, sure the community colleges are vibrant. free societies are peaceful societies. Some- We’re about to talk to one of your citizens day, an American President will be talking who has gone back to school, after years, to to a duly-elected leader of Iraq, talking about upgrade her skill level. If we want them to the peace, and America will be better for it. keep jobs here in America, we’ve got to make And the people of Iraq are watching care- sure our kids are educated so they can com- fully right now. Are we going to be a country pete. And we’ve got to make sure people of our word? When we say we believe people have got the capacity to retrain for the jobs should be free, are we willing to stand by which exist. You’ve got jobs here.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00065 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1460 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Listen, I understand something about the you’re eligible, sign up for one. You’ll save job base in Ohio. I know people are nervous. money when it comes to purchasing prescrip- People are skittish. But there’s jobs being tion drugs. Next year, we’re going to actually created, and we’re going to talk to a job cre- start screening seniors. Doesn’t that make ator here as well. But one of the ways to sense, to have a health care system that says make sure jobs stay here is that we train peo- let’s screen you first so we can detect prob- ple for the jobs which actually exist. And lems early, before they’re too late. That was we’re going to talk to one of your citizens never a part of Medicare. Thanks to the re- here pretty quick—or two citizens, actually, forms we worked together on, it’s now an that are involved with work training. essential part and will save taxpayers money. Health care is an issue in this campaign— In 2006, prescription drugs will become how do we keep it affordable and available. available for the first time in Medicare, and We’ve made some good progress in health seniors will have more choices. Seniors will care. We’ve expanded what’s called commu- be able to design the health care plan that nity health centers. Those are for low-income meets their needs. That’s never been a part Americans to get help with primary care so of Medicare. And here’s how you save they’re not getting help in your emergency money. Medicare would pay for the $100,000 rooms. One way to hold down costs—which or so heart operation. Medicare would not I think is the crux of much of the problems; pay for the prescription drugs to prevent the health care costs too much—is to provide heart condition from happening in the first care for people who can’t afford health care place. See, you spend $2,000 of drugs to save in a cost-effective manner. And we’re doing the Government $100,000 of operating ex- that by expanding community health centers. penses. Inherent in my philosophy for health We’ve got to make sure that small-business care is we want the patient and the doctor owners have the capacity to pool risk. See, to be central to the decisionmaking process most people who are working uninsured in health care, not Washington, DC, bureau- work for small businesses. And small busi- crats. nesses must be allowed to pool risk across Finally, let me tell you one other thing jurisdictional boundaries—associated health about health care. One reason your health plans, they’re called—so they get the same care costs are going up, and one reason doc- purchasing power as big companies do in tors are nervous and many doctors are leav- order to make sure there is health insurance ing the practice of medicine is because of available for employees. junk and frivolous lawsuits. See, you can’t be We want to make sure there’s health sav- pro-patient, pro-doctor, and pro-trial-lawyer ings accounts available for people. We’re at the same time. You have to choose, see. going to talk to a new purchaser of a health I think those of us in public life have to savings account. You’ve probably heard of choose. My opponent made his choice, and them, aren’t sure what they mean. You’re he put him on the ticket. [Laughter] I made about to learn what they are. They are won- my choice. We need medical liability reform derful ways for people to save money, to in Washington, DC, to help our patients and make sure that the person or the family is doctors. in charge of their own health care decisions A couple of other points. We’ve been so that bureaucrats aren’t making the deci- through a lot. Ohio has been through a lot. sions for people. And there are ways to save Listen, when you go through a recession, cor- money. You’ll hear—[laughter]—you’ll like porate scandal, emergency, and war, you’ve it. [Laughter] been through a lot in a quick period of time, We strengthened Medicare. Think back, if you really think about it. Think about what now. You know, President after President, we have been through as an economy and candidate after candidate said, ‘‘Elect me; I’ll as a nation, and yet we’re strong. You know do something about Medicare.’’ I got the job why? We’ve got great workers. We’ve got the done, along with Congress. Medicare is bet- most productive workforce in the world. ter off. Four million seniors have signed up We’ve got great entrepreneurs. We’ve got for drug discount cards. If you haven’t, if wonderful farmers and ranchers. In other

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00066 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1461

words, we’ve got good people in this country goods. We’ll talk about a capital good pur- that are willing to work together to overcome chaser here in a minute. obstacles. But Government can help. And so the economy is strong. There’s I think one of the reasons why our econ- more work to do. But remember, we created omy is strong and getting stronger is because 1.5 million new jobs in the last year. Ohio’s of tax relief. Remember what the tax relief unemployment rate is 5.8 percent. It’s get- was like. If you’re a mother or a dad, you’ve ting better, is what I’m telling you—5.8 per- got a child, you got—your child credit went cent is good; we can do better. I’ll tell you up to 1,000. If you’re married, we did some- how you can do better: Don’t raise taxes on thing about the marriage penalty. I like to the American people, for starters. remind people, it’s a different kind of Tax Just remember, they’re out there prom- Code, isn’t it, that says we’ll penalize mar- ising every day. I think they’re over $2 tril- riage. [Laughter] That’s not what we believe. lion—‘‘they’’ being our opponents—have We ought to be strengthening marriage in promised more than $2 trillion in new spend- America, not penalizing marriage. ing. They just haven’t said how they’re going A lot of the relief—a lot of the tax relief— to pay for it. Well, they have—they have to also remember, when you’re out there gath- a certain extent. They said they’re going to ering the vote, what I’m trying to do is arm tax the rich. They’re going to raise the rates. you up to get ready to convince the Well, first of all, I don’t think anybody ought undecideds. [Laughter] Just remember this: to pay more than 35 percent to the Federal When we were for tax relief, we said if you Government. I think that’s a fair amount of pay taxes, you ought to get relief. In other money that somebody ought to pay. words, we didn’t try to play favorites. If Secondly, when they say they’re going to you’re going to have tax relief, the fairest way tax the rich, remember, when they’re raising to do it at Government is to say if you pay those income taxes, they’re also taxing small taxes, you get relief. And it’s working. businesses. Most small businesses pay indi- Part of the tax relief plan that’s really im- vidual income taxes. Thirdly, you know how portant is the small-business tax relief. Most the Tax Code works. When they say ‘‘tax the new jobs in America are created by small- rich,’’ those are the folks who have got the business owners. Therefore, it makes sense accountants to see to it they don’t pay tax, to cut taxes on small businesses, doesn’t it? so guess who gets stuck with the bill? You’re Actually, I’ll answer my own question: It only going to get stuck with the bill. The worst makes sense to cut taxes on small businesses thing for job creation is to be running up if you understand the role of Government the taxes on the working people of this coun- is not to create wealth but an environment try, and we’re not going to let him have a in which the entrepreneurial spirit can flour- chance to do so. ish. I’m winding down here. [Laughter] No- Let me make one other point on the small- body started to fall out yet. A couple other business tax relief, so everybody understands points I want to make. I’m running because it. Most small businesses are Subchapter S I understand there’s some things we need corporations or sole proprietorships. Now, to do to keep jobs here in America. We need what that means is they pay tax at the indi- tort reform to keep jobs here in America. vidual income tax level. And so when you We need good health policy to keep jobs here hear me talking about cutting individual in- in America. We need an energy plan to keep come taxes, you’ve got to be thinking about jobs here in America. We need to become the small businesses that are getting relief less dependent on foreign sources of energy. as well. See, one of the cornerstones of the Audience member. Get it done, George! economic recovery package, the economic The President. I am going to get it done. stimulus package, was letting small busi- I told you when I ran we would reform the nesses keep more money, which means it’s schools, and we did. I told you when I ran more likely they’re going to stay in business we would reform Medicare, and we did. I or more likely to hire somebody. It also en- told you when I ran we would cut the taxes couraged small businesses to buy capital on the working people, and we did. When

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00067 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1462 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

this administration says something, we mean The President. You like having your own it, and we get it done. home. First, the reason I asked him to come Audience members. Four more years! is, is that I told you I believe in ownership. Four more years! Four more years! There’s nothing better than a story when The President. Thank you all. Okay. I’ve somebody says, ‘‘We own our first home.’’ asked some citizens to come and help me They own their own home. That’s what we make my points. First of all, the cornerstone want. We want people from all walks of life of good policy, in my opinion, is to encourage to stand up in America and say, ‘‘Hey, I own people to own something. See, I believe a my own home. Welcome to my home’’—not, society in which there is widespread owner- ‘‘Welcome to the Government’s home,’’ but, ship is a hopeful and helpful society. If you ‘‘Welcome to my home.’’ own something, you really care about the fu- These good folks saved money in the tax ture of the country. That’s why I like owner- relief. That’s what I wanted to share with you ship. We want to have an environment so as well—2,200 in 2003. more people own their own business. We’re Mr. Jaminet. That’s right. going to talk to the CEO of a small business The President. Two thousand four—how here in a minute. There’s nothing more much? hopeful, is there, than saying, ‘‘Welcome to Mr. Jaminet. About the same. my home.’’ We want more people owning The President. Same, okay. This is their own home. And I’m proud to report $2,300. Now, that’s not a lot to people in the homeownership rates are at an alltime Washington, I guess, the numbers counters high in America today. We’re going to talk up there. It’s a lot to them. See, here’s what about owning your own health care account. I believe about tax relief. Government can I also believe that younger workers ought to set priority and it needs—and that’s hard in be allowed, at their option, to have personal Washington. Everybody has got their own savings accounts in Social Security so that the priorities. My job is to set priorities: It’s been Social Security system can survive. the defense of the homeland; it’s been win- For us old guys, retired or nearly retired, ning the war on terror; it’s been making sure nothing will change. But to make sure there’s education works well; making sure our sen- a Social Security system around for younger iors have a health care system that’s reason- workers—I’m talking about down there in able. But I believe once Government sets pri- the 30s—[laughter]—they ought to be al- orities, these folks can spend their money lowed to take some of their own money and better than the Federal Government can have a personal savings account that they can spend their money. pass on from one generation to the next. What did you do with all that money? First The Jaminets are with us, Emily and John. of all, it’s your money. Get nervous when you Thanks for coming. As you can see, Emily hear people in Washington say, ‘‘Well, we’re is about ready to have her fourth child. She spending the Government’s money.’’ [Laugh- doesn’t look old enough, does she, to have ter] It’s not the Government’s money. It’s four children. Thanks for coming. Tell us— John and Emily’s money that we’re spending. first of all, they have told me that they bought Now they’ve got more of their own to spend. a home. It’s an important distinction in the campaign. Mr. Jaminet. That’s right. People have got to listen carefully to the The President. First-time homebuyer. words. I think they’ll get a difference of phi- Mr. Jaminet. That’s right. losophy. The President. Why? Now, what did you do with all your own Mr. Jaminet. Why? For our family. money? [Laughter] The President. Good, well, most people Mrs. Jaminet. Well, I’m a stay-at-home buy a home for their families. That’s good. mom, so it’s allowed me to do that. [Laughter] And, so, like, tell—go ahead, tell The President. Good. me what you told me earlier. Refinanced it. Mrs. Jaminet. I’m just really—keep fo- cused on our family values and continue, like [Mr. Jaminet made brief remarks.] John said, to pay off debt, and him going

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00068 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1463

back to school is such a huge blessing to be passionate America is willing to retrain peo- able to work at Honda and have a career that ple for the jobs which exist. provides for all of us. [Ms. Wagner made further remarks.] The President. You work at Honda? Mr. Jaminet. Yes. The President. Right, and there’s Govern- The President. That’s good. It’s inter- ment money for that, trade adjustment assist- esting, isn’t it, a foreign company investing ance, displaced workers programs. I think it’s in the United States. That’s positive. I can a wise use of taxpayers’ money, frankly, to see why they did. We’ve got great people help people who have been displaced from here in America. They need to keep coming their work go back to school and gain the with their money. They’ll find great workers skills necessary to fill the jobs which exist. here. Thank you all for coming. Interestingly enough—I don’t know if, One think I want to remind you of is, parts Linda, you’re in a position to say this—but of the tax relief package expire. That’s what most people who go back to school for the happened when Congress passed the deal. new jobs end up making more money. It’s going to stay low for a while, and then Ms. Wagner. Absolutely. they go away. See, I’ve been calling on the The President. Yes, she was. That’s good. Congress to make the tax relief permanent. [Laughter] Now, if they don’t make it permanent, these Ms. Wagner. You’re talking somewhere good folks will pay $1,300 more in taxes. between 200 and 300 percent difference in They’ll have less of their own money. In salaries between an unlicensed person and other words, they’ll have $1,300 less to somebody who has got a license. spend. And I don’t think that’s good for the The President. Listen, if you’re out there economy, to be taking—I know it’s not good looking for work and you don’t think there’s for their family. They’re worried about their work available, go to your one-stops, ask and family. I’m worried about their family. I’m look for what’s available. Good Government worried about the economy too. And taking policy has made money available for people that money out of their pockets is not good. to be retrained in institutions which are flexi- Tax relief has got to be permanent in order ble and available and affordable. The com- to make sure this economy continues to munity colleges, for example, are willing to grow. [Applause] Thank you all. change curriculum to help meet the needs We’ve got an interesting story with Linda of the workplace. And this is a private institu- Wagner. Linda, thanks for coming. What’s tion that’s doing the same thing. You’re doing your job description? great work. Ms. Wagner. Well, we’re pretty proud of Ms. Wagner. Well, I happen to be a reg- our program. istered nurse, and I’m director of employee The President. You ought to be. education for Ohio Health Corporation. Ms. Wagner. We pay for the tuition, ex- The President. Great. And how does it penses, books, and we also fund three clinical work? instructors to also assist Columbus State in [Ms. Wagner made brief remarks.] getting our people educated. The President. Well, thank you, Linda. The President. Let me ask you some- Appreciate you. Good job. Pass that over to thing. Obviously somebody is looking for Jerry. See, the reason Linda came is because workers in those fields, I guess is why they’re I was convinced that she would be able to retraining people. explain it better than me, and she did. Ms. Wagner. Yes, that’s a desperate need. [Laughter] Health care—— Jerry Hurley. Absolutely. The President. Desperate need—there The President. But I appreciate that. You are jobs in this new society, jobs in a high- didn’t have to agree with her, Jerry. [Laugh- tech world that—where people need help in ter] All right, Jerry. order to gain the skills necessary to fill the Ms. Hurley. Hello, Mr. President. jobs. That’s what we’re talking about. A com- The President. How are you?

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00069 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1464 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Ms. Hurley. I am great today. Some people are nervous—of course The President. Okay. You don’t need to they’re nervous—but there are jobs out tell us your age, like you told me earlier. there, and the role of Government is to help Ms. Hurley. I am 53. people train for the jobs which exist, just like The President. And proud of it, I want Jerry. And I want to thank you for coming. you to know. We’ve got an interesting story that Russ Ms. Hurley. Yes, I am. and Kathy Griffith are going to share with The President. And you’re probably a you. They’re here with us. Russ is a self-em- grandmother. ployed consultant, engineering consultant. And he is—well, he’s going to talk to you Ms. Hurley. I am a proud grandmother. about health savings accounts, let me put it The President. There you go. Okay, tell to you that way. Tell everybody what a health us about—this is an interesting story. I hope savings account is. people out there are listening to Jerry’s story. Go ahead. I feel like a talk show host. [Mr. Griffith made brief remarks.] [Laughter] The President. Right, so let’s put it this [Ms. Hurley made brief remarks.] way. Say you’ve got a—you buy a insurance policy that says they’ll cover everything above The President. There you go. Listen, the the first $1,000 of expenses, which is not a reason I asked—isn’t that a great story? very high premium policy. And then, you put Thanks, Jerry. What a fabulous story. And, $1,000—in his case, he’s self-employed, so see, that’s going to be the story of the 21st he puts $1,000 of his own money, tax-free, century, when you think about it. This is a into a savings account which earns money changing world. The job picture changes tax-free, which he can withdraw tax-free to quite rapidly. Some jobs don’t change—like cover up the first $1,000 of expenses before firefighters, guys. We’ll need you forever. the insurance policy kicks in. So in his case, You don’t have to worry about these guys. the expense is the cost of the insurance policy Thanks for your service. plus the $1,000 tax-free money into the ac- But jobs change. When most of you were count, is that accurate? coming up, your dad worked, your mom Mr. Griffith. That’s true, yes. stayed at home, your dad had the job at the The President. All right—and this is a same company, and everything was fine. But new product, by the way, and it’s going to it’s a different world we live in today. And take a while for the American people to fig- the job picture changes, and it requires new ure it out, but it’s a product that says he’s skill sets. In order to make sure America is in control of his health care decisions. See, a competitive place, we’ve got to make sure he decides how the $1,000 is spent, not education not only gets it right for the young- somebody you never see before, you know, sters but that there’s continuing education somebody writing the insurance. It’s his call opportunity for people like Jerry. to make. After all, it’s his money. Probably Now, Government can’t say, ‘‘Go back to going to cause him to make better health care school.’’ Somebody has to make that choice choices, for starters, like exercise. [Laughter] herself or himself. But we darn sure can help. Now, let me ask you something, what were And the community college system is a great you spending prior to your health savings ac- place to get people retrained for the jobs count, and give people a sense of the savings. which exist. Not only is there great job satis- Mr. Griffith. We established our health faction achieved by somebody choosing to savings account and insurance policy in the take advantage of educational opportunities; middle of June, and before that, we were they’re making more money too. And that’s spending $1,111 a month for our insurance what’s important to realize. If you gain new policy. Since we established the HSA account skills and you become a more productive and the insurance policy, we’re now spending worker, productivity increases yield higher less than one-third of that on our monthly wages. And that’s what’s happening in Amer- premium. We expect that on an annual basis, ica. we will spend less than half—when you count

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00070 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1465

the insurance premium as well as our out- Listen, thanks for coming. I appreciate you of-pocket medical expenses—we’ll be spend- explaining this. Go ahead. Got anything else? ing less than half of what we spent with our Yes, hold on. previous medical insurance. Mr. Griffith. I’d like to say also that even The President. So he’s saving money. So though we made that change, we were able people say, ‘‘How can you—what can you put to keep the doctors that we had under our in place to help people save money in health previous policy. So we had no—have had no care?’’ Well, here’s the plan right here. And change at all in the health care we received, let me tell you the interesting thing about either in hospitals or doctors. the plan, is, see, Russ and Kathy are respon- The President. Yes, the docs will like this sible for the $1,000. It’s their money they because they like dealing directly with their put in tax-free, so therefore, they’re going patients. They’d rather be spending time healing than filling out paperwork, I can as- to be wise shoppers when it comes to health sure you. And at any rate, it’s an interesting care. They’re going to be a better decision- idea. Thank you all for coming. Very good maker. If the doctor says, ‘‘You’ve got to job. It’s working, in other words. A man just spend $800 on this,’’ they may say, ‘‘Well, stood up and said he saved half—from what I’m not so sure we want to spend 8, doc, he was spending, saved half of his previous you know.’’ [Laughter] expenses. That’s a good deal. People ought Mr. Griffith. Tell me I need that—— to look into it. The President. Go ahead. Seriously. Finally, Phil Derrow is with us, small-busi- Mr. Griffith. I was going to say, ‘‘Tell me, ness guy, CEO and president, Ohio Trans- doctor, that I need that.’’ mission Corporation, New Albany, Ohio. The President. Yes, see, rational decision- Welcome. making by patients where they’re in control Mr. Derrow. Thank you. of the decisionmaking process, is part of how The President. What’s your business do? you hold costs down. If you’ve got people [Mr. Derrow made brief remarks.] just spending your money and you just take it for granted that the decisionmaking proc- The President. Good, that’s—keep saying ess is wise, that’s inflationary. As you’re a part that, will you? [Laughter] Let me ask you, of the process of, kind of, discerning which are you adding any jobs this year? That’s what is what’s necessary and what’s not, it also is I’m interested in, and so are the people look- when it’s your money on the line and you ing for work. see it on your line—on the line, you’ll make Mr. Derrow. We are. better choices about your body. You’ll realize The President. How many? savings by living healthy lives, which isn’t the Mr. Derrow. We expect to add anywhere from 10 to 36 jobs this year depending on way the system is today. It’s an interesting the business that we—— system. The President. See, here’s what’s hap- And see, the way it works for small busi- pening in America today. Remember, I told nesses—let’s say Russ hires somebody and you most new jobs are created by small busi- is doing quite well in his business, he can nesses? That’s what he’s saying, 10 to 35 jobs set up an HSA for his employee, and he can here, 10 to 35 jobs there. The entrepre- kick in the $1,000. The employer can kick neurial sector of this country is strong. The in the $1,000 tax-free for the employee. small-business sector is vibrant and alive. That’s how you fund a better health care sys- We’ve been through tough times. He’s grow- tem. It’s going to take awhile for this product ing. A lot of it had to do with tax policy. Let to evolve, but in the heart of it, the heart me ask you something. Are you going to of the system, is that rather than bureaucrats make investment? making decisions for Russ, he and Kathy are Mr. Derrow. Absolutely. We make invest- making decisions for themselves and are re- ments each year. The reduction or the accel- warded on a tax-free return by making good erated depreciation allowance has allowed us and wise decisions in the health care. to make more investment than maybe we

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00071 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1466 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

otherwise would have. It’s also allowed our how to make the decisions of Phil easier, so customers to purchase capital equipment he can stay in business and expand. that they may not have. We’ve had a number Tell me—he’s got another interesting idea of customers tell us that they made capital that I think is very important for the country equipment purchases because of the acceler- to adopt: flex-time. ated depreciation schedule. Mr. Derrow. I’m glad you told me what The President. Yes, see, what that means my interesting idea was. [Laughter] is—that’s accountant talk. He’s not an ac- The President. I’m not a lawyer, but it countant, though. He hires accountants, looks like I’m leading the witness. [Laughter] right? Mr. Derrow. I always appreciate the help. Mr. Derrow. I do. I have one here. The President. You appreciate the fact The President. That’s good. [Laughter] I’m not a lawyer? That’s good. A lot of people Okay. What he’s telling you is that the tax just say—— relief we passed said that if you make an in- Mr. Derrow. I appreciate that quite a bit, vestment, you save money; you get a little actually. tax break for making an investment. What The President. Nothing wrong with law- will you invest in? Like, when you say ‘‘in- yers. We occasionally need a good one. But vestment,’’ what will you be buying? go ahead. Mr. Derrow. We purchase information technology equipment. We purchase capital [Mr. Derrow made further remarks.] equipment. We own and operate air com- The President. Yes, see, I think the Gov- pressor stations that deliver compressed air ernment ought to change that. What I’m tell- to our customers, and we have to make in- ing you is, I think the Government ought to vestments anywhere from several hundred allow employers to say to an employee, if you thousand dollars to a couple of million dollars want some time off and work different hours, to purchase the equipment to build that sta- you’re allowed to do so. If you want to accu- tion. And then we sell air to our customers. mulate time to spend with your family, spend The President. You and I are in the same with your parents, spend for being reedu- business. [Laughter] Is it hot air, by any cated, you’re allowed to do so. Government chance? ought to be standing side by side with people, Mr. Derrow. Oh, no. not against people. Government ought to be The President. When he makes an invest- helping families. Good job. Thanks, Phil. ment—listen, I want you to understand how Listen, I’ve got time for some questions. the economy works. See, the tax relief said Yes, ma’am. Why don’t you get up there and we’re going to encourage him to make invest- ask a question. Fire away. ment. He just said, ‘‘I’m going to purchase equipment.’’ Somebody has to make the equipment that he is going to purchase. And Opportunities for Non-High-School that’s how the economy—that’s how good tax Graduates/Association Health Care Plans policy works. It says to Phil, ‘‘We want tax Q. I’m a small-business owner. We employ policy to make it more likely you’ll make an roughly—and I could talk to you about—20 investment,’’ because when he makes an in- percent increase every year in the last 7 vestment, somebody has got to build the years. However, we happen to be a trade product. And when somebody builds the school. We train people for hairdressing, bar- product, somebody is more likely to keep a bering, manicuring, what have you. My peo- job or find work. That’s why good tax policy ple necessarily—are not necessarily college has been working. And the key is to make material, not necessarily community college sure that we don’t disincent Phil—in other material. There is a lack of ability for the words, we changed the taxes at a time when people who are not high school graduates to he’s still thinking about investing. Because take advantage of the kind of training that if he chooses not to buy the equipment, then we offer, and we would have the ability to the person who is making the equipment may put many, many more people per year in the lose the job. That’s how I think. I think about workforce if trade schools all over America

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00072 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1467

had the ability to have discretion about ac- people in Washington who argue process cepting non-high-school graduates or people rather than results. They say, ‘‘Well, we bet- who do not have GEDs. ter not do this; it might obscure a very impor- The President. Well, I appreciate that. tant line in our society, which is the separa- Thanks. I’ll look into that. Let me tell you tion of church and state.’’ something, though, what you need to do, you I happen to believe that the better ques- need to be able to pool risk. You’re talking tion is, does the program work; are we chang- about the health care—you need to be able ing somebody’s life for the better and, there- to pool risk with people who do the same fore, society is better off; and let’s figure out thing you do, whether they be in Texas, how to make the process work, which is what Michigan, California, or Ohio. You’re pre- we’ve done. This is a long answer I’m going vented from doing so now. In other words, to give you. I’m going to tell you how to do the more people that she can insure or seek it in a minute. I’m just telling you there’s insurance for in a larger pool, the more likely a cultural issue, because nobody wants the it is she’s got a better price. And that’s what church to become the state or the state to we need to be able to do. Your other issue, become a church. On the other hand, if a I need to look into it. Thanks. program is effective, we want that program Whoever made that grunt, please get up to be able to compete for funds. and yell a question. [Laughter] Sounded like Now, there are some rules that you’ve got Laughter a friendly grunt, doesn’t it? [ ] Yes, to understand. One, you can’t proselytize. In sir. Okay. Yes, sir, go ahead. Right here. You other words, you’ve got to take all comers. didn’t grunt, but go ahead. If you’re a faith-based program and a Chris- [At this point, a baby in the audience cried.] tian faith-based program, and a Jewish per- The President. Tell him to be steady; son walks in looking for help, you’ve got to we’re almost out of here. [Laughter] I don’t provide the help. In other words, it’s open, blame you. [Laughter] which—that’s not a problem for faith-based Yes, sir. programs. People are willing to help cure and solve lives. Faith-Based Initiative The other problem people have in the Q. I’m a pastor of a church in Lincoln faith-based field, they’re worried about inter- County, which is just east of here. And I’ve facing with Government because they’re agreed to be the chairman of a Christian coa- afraid Government is going to give them so lition for that county. Our church has grown, many rules and regulations they won’t be and we’re very interested in trying to acquire able to actually practice their faith. It’s hard two old buildings in the Newark City that to be a faith-based program if you can’t prac- are kind of dilapidated or falling down to put tice your faith. That’s our theory. a rehabilitation, reorientation kind of job vo- Now, so what I’ve had to do is set up of- cational training there for people to finish fices, and we’ve got an Office of Faith-Based their GEDs, for men and women to give Initiatives in the White House. So, step one, them some basic faith training and to help contact the White House Faith-Based Office. them rediscover what they can become. But Incredibly enough, you’re not going to be- it’s been difficult to know how to acquire or lieve this, this guy is a great guy running the plug into faith-based funds—— office. His name is Jim Towey. Guess what The President. Yes, I appreciate that. one of his jobs was. He was Mother Teresa’s Q. ——and I could use your support. lawyer. [Laughter] Imagine—what kind of The President. Sure. He’s got a great society is it where Mother Teresa needs a question. His question is, ‘‘How can I, some- lawyer? [Laughter] That’s what he was. body who is trying to set up a program to And the other thing is, sir, is that the help people, understand how the faith-based State—have you got one? Yes, the State gov- program works?’’ First of all, you’ve got to ernment has got an Office of Faith-Based understand this has been a struggle to change Initiatives. Their purpose is to expedite the the culture in Washington. There’s a lot of grant money that comes from the Federal

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00073 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1468 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Government. Some of the grant money is di- is demand, somebody will figure out how to rectly—goes directly to the programs, and supply. And so we’ve got to get into people’s you can apply for that through HHS, HUD, minds and heads early in life that drugs will for example—Health and Human Services— destroy your life. There’s community-based the Justice Department grants. There are effort that Washington helps fund, but it re- grants that people can apply to directly. quires grassroots organizations dedicated to There are grants that come through formula suppressing demand for drugs. to the State, and then it’s up to the State We actually have got a national advertising to see to it that the faith-based community campaign going on. The whole idea is to send has got appropriate access to the money. Bob a message to the kids that drugs will destroy has done a good job of setting up that office. your life. So that’s a useful role for the Fed- Thanks for that question. I appreciate it. eral Government, is to be advertising and Yes. then stimulating community-based pro- Support for the President grams. I happen to think the Faith-Based Initia- Q. [Inaudible] tive is a very important program to help teach The President. Thank you. Thank you, sir. kids that drugs can destroy. I’ll give you an I appreciate that a lot. example of a program I’m talking about. I Yes, sir. If you don’t have a mike, just yell think we ought to have—I know we need it out. to have a mentoring program for children Antidrug Efforts/Faith-Based Initiative whose moms or dads may be in prison, and surround that child with a loving adult that Q. Good afternoon, Mr. President. My helps that child understand that right choices name is Andre Porter. I’m a 24-year-old law in life—in America, if you make the right student here in Columbus and a proud mem- choices, you have a chance to realizing your ber of FBA. We sang a song for you today before you got here. dreams. Obviously, you guys made the right The President. Thank you very much. I choices. Somebody told you, somewhere in appreciate that. your life, about right choices. Now I don’t Q. Just wanted to let you know. know who it was—probably mom or dad. But The President. Thank you. if not mom or dad, somebody did. And they Q. We sang two songs. The second song told you about the right choices because they was about antiviolence and antidrugs. And had love in their hearts. And so, therefore, we grow up in an era right now where the one of the most—I think best ways to help culture is so centered on violence and drugs, kids get the right message is through vibrant and so our group—the song that we wrote, mentoring programs. And many of those these gentlemen here, FBA, we wanted to mentoring programs come out of the faith know what you have planned for our genera- community. tion to stop violence and increase the good- Thirdly, third aspect of a strategy on drugs ness of our culture? is to help the addict. There are—you know, The President. No, I appreciate you say- the truth of the matter is, a few consume ing that. That’s a great question. First, I think most of the drugs, relatively few. The addicts we have a duty to go on an education cam- are really the big drug users. I don’t know paign to explain to people that drugs will de- all the statistics off the top of my head. I’m stroy your life. In other words, the drug strat- going to guess, maybe 15 percent of the drug egy has been interdiction, which is impor- users consume by far the vast majority of the tant—in other words, stop them from coming drugs. They’re hooked. They can’t get off. in from Colombia or wherever they may be And so one of the things we’ve got to do coming in from. at the Federal level, it seems like to me, and There’s two other aspects, though, that we State and local level, is focus efforts on help- need to really stay focused on, and one is ing the addicts kick the habit. And you heard the reduction in demand. You know, the way me say earlier that addiction sometimes re- the market works, unfortunately, where there quires more than just a counseling session.

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00074 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1469

Addiction requires a change of heart, and Religious Freedom/President’s Faith that’s where the faith community can play Q. Hello. I just wanted to say that, being an integral role. And so I’ve asked Congress, a young Christian, it’s been very encouraging and Congress has passed money to give a to me to see you, as our country’s leader, voucher to an addict, where the addict gets being so open about your faith. to make the decision of the type of program The President. Thank you. Thanks a lot. he or she thinks will best help save their life, Q. And I was just wondering, do you feel faith-based or otherwise. And so there’s a— that your faith has been beneficial to your that’s our comprehensive strategy. decisionmaking process? And if so, how? I’ve got some positive news to report: The President. First, let me talk about Drug use for youngsters is down 11 percent faith in politics. It is essential that this coun- over the last couple of years. That’s good. try always guard the right for people to wor- It depends on where we started from. But ship as they see fit. It’s essential that people the point is, the trend line is good. And the understand, if you choose to worship or role of Government, in my judgment, is to choose not to worship, you’re equally an stand on the side of people in confirming the American. It’s very important for all our citi- fact that people can and should make healthy zens to understand that—that you can wor- choices with their life. ship or not worship, and you’re equally patri- otic. Counternarcotics Efforts in Colombia Now, secondly, if you choose to worship, Q. I’m from Colombia. you’re just as an American if you’re a Jew, The President. Colombia, que bueno. Christian, Muslim, or Hindu. That’s what Bienvenidos. We’ll have the whole—conduct freedom of religion means. I want the young- in Spanish. [Laughter] Actually, go ahead. sters out there to hear me on this. It’s an essential part of the value of our country. It Q. I’ve been here for 20 years. I just took is an essential tradition and truth that we my wife and my kids to Colombia. Colombia must pass from one generation to the next. is a country that has a lot of problems. At this point—[inaudible]. Now, having said that, I do have faith. And I want to thank—I’ll tell you, the most sus- The President. Gracias, senor. I tell you, taining aspect of the Presidency, one of the let me say something—[applause]. Thank most interesting parts of the Presidency, one you very much. We’re standing strong with of the most touching parts of the Presidency the Colombian Government. I want to thank is that people whom I have never known in you. You know why? I’ve got confidence in my life take time to pray for me and Laura Uribe. He’s the President, Uribe. He said, and our family. ‘‘Help us help ourselves.’’ He understands And what that means is that’s—it sustains that he has got to battle narcotraffickers in us. It strengthens us. It—the prayers comfort Colombia, for the sake of his own country. us, and so do my own prayers. And so that’s And so when he comes to the Oval Office, what religion means to me as the President. I take a look at him in the eye when he says, And I want to thank you for your question. ‘‘I want your help.’’ And I say, ‘‘Why?’’ And Yes, ma’am. he says, ‘‘Because I want our country to be free from these narcotraffickers.’’ It makes me feel comfortable that we’re doing the Constitutional Amendment on Marriage right thing with the taxpayers’ money to sup- Q. Mr. President, thank you for your port Colombia. It’s in our interest we do so. stance on the sanctity of marriage between It’s also in the interest of the Colombian peo- men and women. What can we do to keep ple that we help. judges who find in favor of relationships be- And he’s a freedom—this guy loves free- tween homosexuals? dom. I mean, he is a strong leader. Tell him The President. Let me—again, this is an thanks, if you talk—I’ll probably talk to him issue that people need to address with the before you do. [Laughter] utmost sensitivity and sincerity. It is an issue Yes, ma’am. that is a—an issue that we must not allow

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00075 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1470 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

to denigrate into emotional debate. It’s an Go ahead, yell it out. If you don’t like— issue that requires thoughtful discussion. if I don’t like the question, I’ll reinvent it. I believe society is better off by a clear [Laughter] Oops, he didn’t believe me. definition of traditional marriage. And the [Laughter] reason I do is because, one, traditional mar- riage between man and a woman has served Support for the President society and civilization well. Secondly, there is a firm commitment required in a marriage Q. Mr. President, I don’t have a question; between a man and a woman that must not I have three thank-yous. be undermined by redefinition. That com- The President. Thank you. mitment in itself provides stable, loving envi- Q. One, thank you for your availability to ronments for families. serve. I am deeply concerned about the fact, on this very sensitive issue is being redefined The President. Thank you, sir. by the courts, not by the people. I think that Q. Two, your candle is burning brightly. to the extent that—there needs to be a hon- The President. Thank you. est and open dialog about this issue amongst the people. Q. And three, thanks for accepting the call Now, Congress passed what’s called and answering the call to work for what’s DOMA, Defense of Marriage Act, signed by right in the country and in the world. my predecessor, which defined marriage as The President. Thank you, sir. God bless. between a man or a woman and prevented Thank you. Thanks a lot. I’ll tell you what, States from making a decision that would a guy just gave me the hook. I’m off to Sagi- cause another State to have to accept that naw, Michigan. I want to conclude by telling decision. Now, I think that law is a good law. you this: It is an honor to be the President I am worried about its constitutionality—in of such a great nation. other words, whether or not it will be over- Audience member. [Inaudible] turned by activist judges. As a matter of fact, a judge overturned the DOMA law of Wash- The President. Yes, sir. I appreciate you ington State yesterday. In other words, giving me a chance to come and share some judges are beginning to define the nature of thoughts with you. I have a desire, a deep marriage. desire to serve this country for 4 more years, So I said that if you believe like I believe, to make us a safer place, a stronger place, that traditional marriage is important, that and a better place. the best way to see to it that society—our May God bless you all. Thanks for coming. society will continue to define marriage as between a man or woman, is to—is the con- stitutional process, is to amend the Constitu- tion so that a judge cannot define. NOTE: The President spoke at 1 p.m. at the Aladdin Shrine Center. In his remarks, he re- Now, the other thing that that will do is ferred to Gov. Jeb Bush of Florida; Gov. Bob Taft it will enable the people to be involved and Lt. Gov. Jennette Bradley of Ohio; Doug through the State legislatures. In other Preisse, executive chairman, Franklin County Re- words, you’ve got to get it out of the Con- publican Party; former professional football player gress, the amendment, and then it has to be Bernie Kosar; President Pervez Musharraf of ratified by the States, which I think is a Pakistan; Palestinian terrorist Abu Nidal, who was healthy process. In other words, it’s the legis- found dead in Baghdad, Iraq, on August 19, 2002; lative branch that will be deciding the defini- senior Al Qaida associate Abu Musab al Zarqawi; tion of marriage on this very important issue, President Hamid Karzai of Afghanistan; Prime and not the judicial branch. And so that’s why Minister Ayad al-Alawi of the Iraqi Interim Gov- I advocated what I advocated, and it’s the ernment; Chairman Kim Chong-il of North Korea; right position for the country. and President Alvaro Uribe of Colombia.

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00076 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1471

Letter to Congressional Leaders gan folks were expecting to hear. [Laughter] Transmitting the District of Then he remembered where he was and he Columbia’s Fiscal Year 2005 called an audible. [Laughter] He said that Budget Request the University of Michigan was a powerhouse of a team. You see, my opponent is a Wash- August 5, 2004 ington politician who’s taken both sides of Dear Mr. Speaker: (Dear Mr. President:) just about every issue, including Big Ten Consistent with my constitutional author- football. ity and section 446 of the District of Colum- Listen, I want to thank you for welcoming bia Self-Governmental Reorganization Act, Vice President Cheney here a couple of as amended, I am transmitting the District months ago. I admit it, he’s not the prettiest of Columbia’s Fiscal Year 2005 Budget Re- face on the ticket. [Laughter] That’s not why quest Act. I picked him. I picked him because of his The proposed Fiscal Year 2005 Budget judgment, his experience, his ability to do Request Act reflects the major programmatic the job. Everywhere I go, the crowds are big, objectives of the Mayor and the Council of the enthusiasm is high, the signs are good. the District of Columbia. For Fiscal Year With your help, Dick Cheney and I will win 2005, the District estimates total revenues 4 more years. and expenditures of $6.26 billion. Audience members. Four more years! Sincerely, Four more years! Four more years! The President. I am—my only regret is George W. Bush that Laura is not traveling with me. She is a great wife, a wonderful mother, and a excel- NOTE: Identical letters were sent to J. Dennis Hastert, Speaker of the House of Representatives, lent First Lady for our country. I’m really and Richard B. Cheney, President of the Senate. proud of her. I’m really proud of her. I’m going to give you some reasons why to put me back into office, but perhaps the most Remarks in Saginaw, Michigan important one of all is so that Laura will be August 5, 2004 First Lady for 4 more years. I want to thank my friend Dave Camp, The President. Thank you all. Thanks for Congressman Camp. I appreciate you being coming. Thanks for coming. Thanks for hav- here. Congresswoman Candice Miller, my ing me here. I’m here to ask for the vote, good friend, is with us today. Thank you. and I’m here to ask for your help. It’s been Terri Lynn Land—I appreciate the secretary a great turnout. Thanks for coming. of state joining us. I wish Myrah Kirkwood It’s going to be an interesting campaign. all the best in her run for the United States We have big differences of opinion. For ex- Congress. ample, we have a difference of opinion over You invited the Gatlin Brothers. [Ap- the heart and soul of America. See, my oppo- plause] I know. They grew up in Odessa, nents believe you can find the heart and soul which is Ector County; I grew up in Midland of America in Hollywood. I think you can County, which is right around the corner find it right here in Saginaw, Michigan. from here—just a different State. [Laughter] Audience members. U.S.A.! U.S.A.! I appreciate my friends being here. They’re U.S.A.! good friends, and they’re good guys who care The President. That’s not the only thing a lot about our country. my opponent seems a little confused about. I want to thank all the grassroots activists The other day in Ohio, he said that there’s who are here. That means you’re the people nothing better than Buckeye football, period. who put up the signs, make the phone calls; Audience members. Boo-o-o! you’re the people who are going to help reg- The President. Then he came to Michi- ister our fellow citizens. See, everybody gan. First he told the crowd, ‘‘I go for the needs to participate in elections. I believe Buckeye football. That’s where I’m coming we have a duty; I know you believe we have from.’’ No, I know, that’s not what the Michi- a duty to vote on election day. And so when

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00077 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1472 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

you’re out registering voters, please don’t not afford prescription drugs. Medicare overlook discerning Democrats and wise didn’t pay for them, either. Leaders in both independents because, like you, they want a parties had promised prescription drug cov- safer and stronger and better America. erage for years. You remember all the prom- Every incumbent who asks for the vote has ises. We got it done. More than 4 million to answer a central question, why—why seniors have signed up for drug discount should the American people give me the cards that provide real savings for them. And great privilege of serving as your President beginning in 2006, all seniors on Medicare for 4 more years? In the past few years, will be able to choose a plan that suits their Americans have been through a lot together, needs and gives them coverage for prescrip- and we have accomplished a great deal. But tion drugs. there’s only one reason to look backward at To help more people get access to quality the record, and that is to determine who best care, we’ve expanded community health cen- to lead our Nation forward. ters for low-income Americans. We’ve cre- I’m here asking for the vote because ated health savings accounts so families can there’s so much at stake. We have much save tax-free for their own health care needs. more to do to move our country forward. I When it comes to giving Americans more want to be your President for 4 more years choices about their health care and making to create more jobs, improve our schools, to health care more affordable, we’re moving spread the peace. We have made much America forward, and we’re not turning back. progress; there is still more to do. Listen, this world we’re in is changing. We have more to do to make our public Most Americans get their health care cov- schools the centers of excellence we all know erage through their work, but most of today’s they can be so that no child in our country new jobs are created by small businesses, is left behind. When we came to office 31⁄2 which too often cannot afford to provide years ago, too many of our children were health coverage. And so, to help American being shuffled from grade to grade, year after families get health insurance, we must allow year, without learning the basics. So we chal- small employers to join together to purchase lenged what I call the soft bigotry of low ex- insurance at the discounts available to big pectations. We raised the bar. We believe in corporations. setting high standards. We believe in ac- To improve health care, to make sure countability. We believe in local control of health care is available and affordable for our schools. We believe in empowering the par- citizens, we must end the frivolous lawsuits ents of America. Today, children across that run up the cost of health care. You can- America are showing real progress in reading not be pro-patient and pro-doctor and pro- and math. When it comes to improving trial-lawyer at the same time. You have to America’s public schools, we’re turning the choose. My opponent made his choice, and corner and we’re not turning back. he put him on the ticket. We have more to do. The jobs of the future Audience members. Boo-o-o! will require greater knowledge and higher The President. I made my choice. I’m level skills. We’re going to reform our high going to continue to push Congress to pass schools to make sure a high school diploma real, meaningful medical liability reform in means something. We’ll expand math and Washington, DC. science education so our young people can We’ll do more to harness technology to re- compete in the high-tech world. We will ex- duce costs and prevent health care mistakes. pand the use of the Internet to bring high- We’ll do more to expand research and seek level training in the classrooms. With 4 more new cures for diseases. And in all we do to years, we’ll help a rising generation gain the improve health care in America, we will skills and competence they need to realize make sure that health decisions are made by the great promise of our country. doctors and patients, not by bureaucrats in We have more to do to make quality health Washington, DC. care available and affordable. When we came We have more to do to make this economy to office, too many older Americans could stronger. We’ve come through a recession.

VerDate May 21 2004 12:16 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00078 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1473

We’ve come through a terror attack. We’ve between people’s lives as they are and peo- come through corporate scandals. We’ve ple’s lives as they want to be. come through a lot. And we’ve overcome Let me tell you something else I believe. those obstacles because our workers are In order to keep jobs here, we’ve got to reject great, because the farmers are good at what economic isolationism. I believe that the they do, because the entrepreneurial spirit American worker, the American farmer, the of this country is strong. We’ve overcome American entrepreneur, the American man- these obstacles as well because of well-timed ufacturer can compete with anybody, any- tax cuts. time, anywhere, so long as the playing field Listen, when it came time to cutting taxes, is level. we didn’t pick winners or losers. We did it And you know what else? We’re going to the fair way. We gave tax relief to every help American families keep more of some- American who pays Federal taxes. The child thing they never have enough of, and that’s credit went up to help families with children. time—time to be with your kids, time to take We’re reducing the marriage penalty. Imag- care of your parents, time to go back to ine a Tax Code that penalizes marriage. school. Congress must enact comp-time and Audience members. Boo-o-o! flex-time rules to give American families more opportunities to choose their time. The President. We need to be encour- After 4 years, our farm economy will be aging marriage in America. strong. After 4 years, there will be more We helped our small businesses with tax small-business owners. After 4 years, there relief, and this time the check was really in will be better and—paying jobs under the the mail. Because we acted, our economy Bush administration. since last summer has grown at a rate as fast We have more to do to wage and win the as any in nearly 20 years. Because we acted, war against the terrorists. America’s future America has added 1.5 million new jobs since depends on our willingness to lead in the last August. world. If America shows uncertainty and Listen, I understand we face serious chal- weakness in this decade, the world will drift lenges in part of our country. The recovery toward tragedy. This will not happen on my here in Michigan has lagged behind other watch. parts, but we’ve got a plan in place. The Audience members. U.S.A.! U.S.A.! economy is improving; it’s getting better. U.S.A.! Factory orders are on the rise. Manufac- The President. The world changed on a turing jobs are coming back. Your unemploy- terrible September morning. And since that ment rate has fallen a full percent. And we’re day, we’ve changed the world. Before Sep- not going to rest until everybody who wants tember the 11th, Afghanistan served as the to work can find a job. home base of Al Qaida, which trained and To keep this economy strong, to keep jobs deployed thousands of killers to set up terror here at home, we need to end the endless cells in dozens of countries, including our regulations that strangle America’s employ- own. Today, because we acted, Afghanistan ers. To keep jobs here at home, we need is a rising democracy. Afghanistan is going tort reform in America. To keep jobs here to have Presidential elections this fall. Be- at home, we need a reasonable energy policy cause we acted, many young girls now go to that makes us less dependent on foreign school for the first time in their life. Because sources of energy. To keep jobs here at we acted, Afghanistan is an ally in the war home, we’ll be wise about how we spend your against terror. Because we acted, America money, and we will keep your taxes low. Lis- and the world are safer. ten, to make sure this economy is strong we Before September the 11th, Pakistan was will offer American workers a lifetime of a safe transit point for terrorists. Today, Paki- learning and help them get training for the stan is an ally in the war against terror. Paki- jobs of the future at places like our commu- stani troops are aggressively helping to round nity colleges. The education and training up the terrorists, and America and the world community colleges offer can be the bridge are safer.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00079 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1474 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Before September the 11th, in Saudi Ara- the actions of a madman, or take measures bia, terrorists were raising money and re- necessary to defend our country. Given that cruiting and operating with little opposition. choice, I will defend America every time. Today, the Saudi Government has taken the Audience members. U.S.A.! U.S.A.! fight to Al Qaida. America and the world are U.S.A.! safer. The President. Because we acted, the dic- Before September the 11th, Libya was tator sits in a prison cell, and America and spending millions to acquire weapons of mass the world are safer. destruction. Today, because America and our I’m seeking the vote; I’m running for 4 allies sent a strong and clear message, the more years because I understand we must leader of Libya has abandoned his pursuit continue to work with our friends and allies of weapons of mass destruction, and America around the world to aggressively pursue the and the world are safer. terrorists in places like Iraq and Afghanistan Before September the 11th, the ruler of and elsewhere. See, you can’t talk sense to Iraq was a sworn enemy of the United States the terrorists. You cannot negotiate with the of America. He was defying the world. He terrorists. We must engage the enemies was firing weapons at American pilots enforc- around the world so we do not have to face ing the world’s sanctions. He had pursued, them here at home. and he had used weapons of mass destruction America will continue to lead the world against his own people. He harbored the ter- with confidence and moral clarity. See, we rorists. He invaded his neighbors. He sub- put together a strong coalition to help defeat sidized the families of suicide bombers. He terror: over 60 nations involved with the Pro- had murdered tens of thousands of his own liferation Security Initiative; nearly 40 na- citizens. He was a source of great instability tions involved in Afghanistan; some 30 na- in the world’s most volatile region. He was tions involved in Iraq. Over the next 4 years, a threat. After September the 11th, we I will continue to build alliances and work looked at all the threats of the world in a with our friends in the cause of security and new light. You see, one of the lessons of that peace. But I will never turn over America’s fateful day was that we must take threats seri- national security decisions to leaders of other ously, before they fully materialize. countries. The September the 11th Commission con- Audience members. Four more years! cluded that our institutions of Government Four more years! Four more years! had failed to imagine the horror of that day. The President. We must keep our com- After September the 11th, we could not fail mitments to help Afghanistan and Iraq be- to imagine that a brutal tyrant who hated come peaceful and democratic societies. America, who had ties to terror, who had Those two nations are now governed by used weapons of mass destruction might use strong leaders. See, these leaders care deeply those weapons or share his capabilities with about the future of their nations. They care the terrorists. We saw a threat. deeply about the aspirations of their people. I went to the United States Congress, These are strong people, and many in their which looked at the same intelligence I did. country are now stepping up because they Members of both political parties looked at realize the great promise of a free society. the same intelligence, including my oppo- And the people of those countries, those who nent, and they reached the same conclusion. love freedom, can count on continued help And in the United Nations, they looked at from America and our allies. You see, when the same intelligence and unanimously de- we acted to protect our own security, we also manded a full accounting of Saddam’s weap- promised to help deliver them from tyranny, ons programs, or face serious consequences. to restore their sovereignty, to set them on After 12 years of defiance, he again refused the path of liberty. And when America gives to comply with the demands of the free its word, America keeps its word. world. He deceived the weapons inspectors. In these crucial times, America’s commit- And so I had a choice to make: Either forget ments are kept by the men and women of the lessons of September the 11th and trust our military. I want to thank the veterans who

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00080 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 5 1475

are here for setting such a fine example for improving their recruiting efforts. It’s a fun- those who wear our uniform. I’ve had the damental and dangerous misunderstanding privilege of meeting with those who defend of the enemy we face. As the 9/11 Report our country and sacrifice for our security. I’ve shows, terrorists had attracted recruits in the seen their unselfish courage. The cause of 1990s, long before America was at war with freedom is in really good hands. them. Now we’re on the offense. We’re strik- And those of us in Government have a ing the terrorists where they plot and plan duty to support those who wear the uniform. before they can come and get us here. By Last September, while our troops were in taking—by staying on the offense, we have combat in both Afghanistan and in Iraq, I captured information that has proved critical proposed supplemental funding to support to improving the security here at home. Lis- them in their missions. The legislation pro- ten, I agree with the conclusion of the vided funding for body armor and other vital 9/11. They said because of the actions we equipment, hazard pay, health benefits, am- have taken since September the 11th, our munition, fuel, spare parts. In the Senate, homeland is safer, yet we’re not totally safe. only a small, out-of-the-mainstream minority I understand that. The way to make America of 12 Senators voted against the legislation. more secure is to continue fighting this war Audience members. Boo-o-o! on the offense, continue bringing justice to The President. Two of them are my oppo- our enemies. nent and his runningmate. Right after September the 11th, we started Audience members. Boo-o-o! the hard process of reform. We’ve trans- The President. They asked him about his formed our defenses and created a new De- vote, and he said, ‘‘I actually did vote for the partment of Homeland Security. We passed $87 billion, before I voted against it.’’ the PATRIOT Act to give law enforcement [Laughter] Now he’s offering a different ex- the tools they need to fight and find the ter- planation. He said, you know, he was proud rorists. The mission of the FBI is now fo- that he and his runningmate voted against cused on preventing terrorism. We’re inte- the funding, and then he further went on grating intelligence and law enforcement to say the whole thing is a complicated mat- better than we ever have before. We’re tak- ter. [Laughter] There’s nothing complicated ing action on a large majority of the rec- about supporting our troops in combat. ommendations of that important Commis- In the long run, our security is not guaran- sion. teed by force alone. We must work to change We’ve more to do. We’ve got more to do the conditions that give rise to terror: poverty to secure our ports and borders, to train our and hopelessness and resentment. See, a free first-responders, to dramatically improve in- and peaceful Iraq and a free and peaceful telligence-gathering capability. That’s why I Afghanistan will be powerful examples for called on Congress this week to create the their neighbors. Free societies do not export position of National Intelligence Director so terror. Societies which listen to the hopes that one person is in charge of coordinating and aspirations of their people are peaceful all our intelligence efforts overseas and here societies. We long for peace. I want your chil- at home. dren growing up in a peaceful world. And Listen, these reforms are not going to be I understand that by serving the ideal of lib- easy, particularly in Washington. There’s erty, we will spread freedom and peace. By some entrenched interests up there, people serving the ideal of liberty, we’ll also rep- who defend the status quo. It’s not enough resent the values of this country. Freedom to advocate reform, you have to be able to is not America’s gift to the world; freedom get it done. is the Almighty God’s gift to every man and You see, when it comes to reforming woman in this world. schools and making sure we have an excellent Listen, we’ve got more to do to protect education for all our children, results matter. this country. Enemies who hate us are still When it comes to health care reforms to give plotting to harm us. My opponent says that our families more access and more choices, going to war with the terrorists is actually results matter. When it comes to improving

VerDate May 21 2004 12:16 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00081 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1476 Aug. 5 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

our economy and creating jobs, results mat- understands we’re responsible for the deci- ter. When it comes to seeing to it we have sions you make in life. a healthy agricultural economy, results mat- If you’re fortunate enough to be a mother ter. When it comes to better securing our or a father, you are responsible for loving homeland and fighting the forces of terror your child with all your heart and all your and spreading the peace, results matter. soul. If you don’t like the quality of the edu- When it comes to electing a President, re- cation in the community in which you live, sults matter. you’re responsible for doing something about Listen, we have—we’re in changing times, it. If you’re a CEO in corporate America, and they’re exciting times. The Government you are responsible for telling the truth to has got to stand on the side of people during your shareholders and your employees. In a changing times. That’s why I will continue responsibility society, each of us is respon- to promote what I call an ownership society. sible for loving our neighbor just like you’d See, if you change jobs, you want to be able like to be loved yourself. to own your health care plan so you can take I’m seeking the office for 4 more years be- it from job to job. If you’re a younger worker, cause I want to continue to rally the armies you’re probably concerned about whether or of compassion which exist all across our not you’ll see a dime from Social Security. country. The great strength of this Nation Therefore, younger workers ought to be is the hearts and souls of our citizens. By given the option of managing some of their rallying the love and the hearts and souls of own money in personal retirement accounts. our citizens, we can change America one heart, one soul, one conscience at a time. We want more people in this country own- Audience members. Four more years! ing their own business. And you know, we Four more years! Four more years! want more people owning their own home. The President. For all Americans, these I love it when somebody says, ‘‘Welcome to years in our history will always stand apart. my home. Thanks for visiting my home.’’ See, There are quiet times in the life of a nation we understand that when you own some- when little is expected of its leaders. This thing, you have a vital stake in the future isn’t one of those times. It’s a time that re- of the United States. quires clear vision, firm resolve. None of us In this world of change, there are some will ever forget that week when one era things that will not change: our belief in lib- ended and another began. erty, opportunity, and the nonnegotiable de- On September the 14th, 2001, I stood in mands of human dignity. The values we try the ruins of the Twin Towers. It’s a day that to live by will not change, courage and com- I will never forget. People in hardhats were passion, reverence and integrity. There are screaming at me, ‘‘Whatever it takes.’’ I was institutions in our society that give us direc- working a ropeline, and a guy grabbed me— tion and purpose, our families and our I don’t know if he was a firefighter or a po- schools and our religious congregations. liceman; I do know that he was looking These values are fundamental to our lives. through the rubble for one of his buddies— They deserve the respect of our Govern- and he said, ‘‘Do not let me down.’’ ment. He took it personally. The people in that We stand for institutions like family and site took it personally. You took it personally. marriage, which are the foundations of soci- I took it personally. I have a duty that goes ety. We stand for a culture of life in which on. I wake up every morning thinking about every person matters and every being counts. how best to protect our people. I will never We stand for judges who faithfully interpret relent in defending America, whatever it the law, instead of legislating from the bench. takes. And we stand for a culture of responsibility We have come through much together. in this country. The culture is changing from We have done hard work. We’re moving one that has said, ‘‘If it feels good, do it,’’ America forward by extending freedom and and ‘‘If you’ve got a problem, blame some- peace around the world and by expanding body else,’’ to a culture in which each of us opportunity here at home. During the next

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00082 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1477

4 years, we will spread ownership throughout You believe there ought to be diversity in our country. We want everybody realizing the newsroom. I understand that. You be- the American Dream. We will pass enduring lieve there ought to be diversity on the edi- values of our country to another generation. torial pages of America. I agree. You believe We will lead the cause of freedom and peace, there ought to be diversity behind the man- and we will prevail. With your support and aging editor’s desk. I agree with that too. I prayers, I will be a leader America can count also believe there ought to be diversity in on in a world of change. the political parties in America, and that’s Four years ago, as I traveled this great why I’m going to work hard to tell people country asking for the vote, I made a pledge my message, to tell people what I believe. to my fellow Americans. I said if you honor And I believe that Government should stand me with this great responsibility, I would up- side by side with people and help them gain hold the dignity and the honor of the office the tools necessary to realize the American to which I had been elected. And with your Dream, not just some people but everybody. help, I will do so for 4 more years. I believe those of us who have been given God bless. Thanks for coming. Thank you the high honor of representing the people all. must work to reform parts of Government that are stagnant and don’t stand side by side with people to give them the tools necessary NOTE: The President spoke at 6:05 p.m. at Wendler Arena. In his remarks, he referred to to perform. I believe it’s more important to Michigan Secretary of State Terri Lynn Land; be a doer than a talker. I believe it’s impor- Myrah Kirkwood, candidate for Congress in tant to say to people, ‘‘Judge me by my re- Michigan’s 5th congressional district; country sults.’’ And so today I want to talk about some music entertainers the Gatlin Brothers; Col. of the results of this administration, and then Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qadhafi, leader of I look forward to answering some of your Libya; former President Saddam Hussein of Iraq; questions. and the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks First, I want to thank the board of direc- Upon the United States (9/11 Commission). tors of this august organization. Thank you for having me. Thank you for greeting me Remarks to the UNITY: Journalists of behind stage. I want to thank the sponsor Color Convention and a Question- for providing the opportunity for people from all around the globe to come here—all and-Answer Session around the country—to come here to talk August 6, 2004 about important issues. I think one—you know, look, you can’t The President. Thank you, Ernest. Thank read a newspaper if you can’t read. And so you for having me. I appreciate the invita- one of the most important initiatives of this tion. It’s good that—Ernest tells me that administration was to challenge the soft big- there’s nearly 10,000 members of your orga- otry of low expectations. You know what I nization. I congratulate you for reaching out mean by that. If you lower the bar, guess and including a lot of people. You represent what happens? You get lousy results. And a very important profession. It’s one that I’m that’s the way it was in American public quite familiar with. [Laughter] schools 31⁄2 years ago. That’s why you had I appreciate the chance to—I deal with kids just shuffled from grade to grade, year my press corps on a regular basis. It’s a bene- to year, without learning the basics of edu- ficial—it’s a mutual beneficial society, see. cation. That’s the way it was, because there I need them to get the message out, and they was no accountability. See, we weren’t meas- need me to be a messenger. And we’re work- uring. ing hard to make sure that our relationship If you believe that every child can learn is cordial and professional. And that’s how to read and write and add and subtract, I feel about coming here too—to establish which I believe, then you must be willing a cordial and professional relationship with to measure to determine whether or not the people who help spread the news. children are learning to read and write and

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00083 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1478 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

add and subtract. No, here in this Capital No, we’re making a difference here in the there’s a lot of focus on funding but very little public schools of America. In a recent study focus on the result. We increased for funding of 61 urban school districts, 73 percent of for K through 12 by 49 percent since 2001. African American 4th graders narrowed the We increased funding for Title I by 52 per- achievement gap with white students in read- cent since 2001. But now, in return for in- ing. See, that’s how you—you know how you creased funding, we’re saying to local dis- know that? Because you measured, because tricts, show us whether or not a child can we say show us whether or not a child can read, early, before it’s too late. We’re meas- read, and, if not, let’s correct problems early, uring. before it’s too late. And when there are schools that aren’t We’re making progress in this country. teaching, there’s extra help to make sure the About 60 percent of Hispanic 4th graders children learn early, before it’s too late. narrowed the achievement gap. So long as We’ve raised the bar. We believe in local there’s an achievement gap, we’ve got more control of schools, and we’re insisting on ac- work to do. But we’re making substantial countability. And you know what? It’s begin- progress toward achieving what we want to ning to work. do, and that is every child reading at grade There is a reading gap in America. We can level by the 3rd grade and remaining at grade play like there’s not a reading gap in America, level throughout their entire public school but there is. Too many of our African Amer- career. ican kids cannot read at grade level by the There’s more to do. We’ve got to make 3rd and 4th grade, and that’s not right for sure our higher education is available for ev- America. Too many Latino youngsters can’t erybody. We’ve increased the number of stu- read. And one of the reasons why is because dents receiving Pell grants by a million since it’s so easy to quit on a classroom full of I’ve been President. We’ve got historic levels inner-city kids and kids whose parents maybe of funding for our black colleges. I told the can’t speak English as a first language. It’s Native Americans we will see that their easy to walk in and say, ‘‘These kids are too school systems were modernized. We spent hard to educate, let’s just move them $1.1 billion of Indian school construction re- through.’’ We’ve stopped the practice in pair since 2001, more than double spending America, and the schools are better off for in the previous 4 years. I told people we’d it. focus on schools, and we are. And we’re mak- I’ll tell you one other thing we’ve done, ing progress in America. which I think is important, is we’ve started You know, when I came into office we had the process of giving parents more choice in a problem with our economy. It was in a re- schools. If your public school fails after a pe- cession. In order to make sure this country riod of time, you ought to be allowed to move is hopeful and people have a better chance your child to another school. Why should a to realize their dreams, we need economic parent have their child trapped in a school growth. That’s why I cut the taxes on every- that won’t change? That doesn’t make any body. I didn’t cut them; the Congress cut sense to me. them. I asked them to cut them. It was to Here in the District of Columbia, we’ve stimulate the economy. It was to help people given $7,500 scholarships to the parents of have more money in their pocket so they low-income children so that they can move would demand additional goods or services. their kid from school to school—to another And the economic growth is strong and school if the public school is failing. I appre- it’s getting stronger, and that’s good for ev- ciate working with the Mayor of this city. See, erybody in America. I want you to remember my attitude is, if public—or school choice is the tax relief and how it worked. We didn’t good enough for the middle class and the play favorites in the Tax Code. We said if upper class, it ought to be good enough for you’re paying taxes, you ought to get relief. low-income Americans. And this is going to Seems to make—a fair way to me to make make a difference in Washington, DC. policy. If you’re paying taxes, you’re going

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00084 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1479

to have tax relief, and the Government ought which will allow small businesses to pool risk not to pay favorites. across jurisdictional boundaries so they can So everybody who paid taxes got relief. We get the same purchasing power that big busi- paid special attention to parents with chil- nesses have. I have got a plan that will help dren. We raised the child credit. We pro- all small businesses thrive in America. When vided relief for the marriage penalty. It’s an you own something, you have a vital stake unusual Tax Code that penalizes marriage. in the future of this country. Judge me on Seems like we ought to be trying to encour- homeownership in America. I believe it’s— age marriage in America, not penalize it. A I can’t tell you how exciting it is to know lot of our tax relief was aimed at small busi- more people in America can now say, ‘‘Wel- nesses. Most new jobs in America are created come to my home. I’m glad you’re here to by small businesses. Most small businesses visit me in my home.’’ To me, those are hope- pay tax at the individual income tax level. ful words for our country. That’s just a fact. By far, the majority of small I set a goal two summers ago to have 5.5 businesses in America are what they call sole million new homeowners by the end of the proprietorships or Subchapter S corpora- decade—minority homeowners by the end of tions. the decade. We’re meeting that goal—1.6 Since most new jobs in America are cre- million new minority homeowners in the last ated by small businesses, it makes sense to 2 years. You know, they talk a good game provide relief for small-business owners. And up here sometimes in Washington; we’re de- so when you cut the taxes on individuals, livering. More minority families own their you’re cutting taxes on by far the vast major- home today than ever before in the history ity of small businesses in America. And that’s of the United States of America. And that’s good for the economy. a positive development for this country. A It’s also good to encourage an ownership lot of it has to do with low interest rates. society. I came to Washington aiming to help A lot of it has to do with good tax policy. people own something. I want there to be A lot of it has to do with downpayment assist- more owners in America. The role of Gov- ance, counseling out of Housing and Urban ernment is not to create wealth but an envi- Development. Listen, if you’re a first-time ronment in which the entrepreneur can homeowner and you take a look at the con- flourish. At least, that’s my philosophy. And tract, that fine print looks a little small; peo- as a result of tax relief and a good economic ple get a little nervous. And so we’re pro- environment, there are more small minority viding counseling to help people understand owners—businessowners today than ever be- what it means to be a first-time homebuyer. fore. More and more people are realizing And it’s paying off. their dreams by owning their own business, Medicare—there’s been a lot of talk about and that’s healthy for this country. It’s impor- Medicare here in Washington, DC. You tant for this country. might remember that issue. At every single And there’s more work to do. You’ve heard political campaign, people said, ‘‘I want to me talk about tort reform. Tort reform is nec- help our seniors; I’ll help our seniors’’— essary to make sure the business environ- nothing got done. We got it done. We re- ment is such that people have the confidence formed a very important part of our health necessary to start their own business. Good care system by enabling seniors to have trade policy will help small businesses. We choices of their own and providing prescrip- regulate a lot here in Washington, DC. I tion drug coverage for seniors for the first can’t promise you whether or not any regu- time, in Medicare. They talk a lot up here. lator has ever read the reports that we ask I want the people of this country to remem- small-business owners to file in Washington. ber who actually has got the work done. I suspect they haven’t. But reasonable regu- Now, let me tell you about the Medicare latory policy will help small-business owners. bill, the reform bill. It started off first by the Small-business owners must be able to af- distribution of drug discount cards, which ford health care. That’s why I strongly urge provide real savings for our seniors. Over 4 the Congress to pass association health plans, million seniors have signed up so far. Low-

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00085 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1480 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

income seniors get a $600 credit as well as I believe strongly that the Justice adminis- the discount on their card. Next year, for the tration ought to enforce the civil rights laws, first time, there will be preventative and we are. I’m the first President to have screenings provided for in Medicare. Medi- banned racial profiling in Federal law en- care has never done that before. I mean, it forcement. I believe that the benches ought makes sense, doesn’t it, to say in Medicare, to reflect as best as possible the diversity of we want to diagnose problems early, before our country. And I believe my administration they become acute, in order to save taxpayers ought to, too, and I’ve fulfilled that commit- money and, more importantly, in order to ment. I’ve got people from all walks of life save lives. who advise me. In 2006, there will be a prescription drug My Cabinet is diverse. The people who coverage available in Medicare for seniors, walk into the Oval Office and say, ‘‘Mr. Presi- with low-income seniors getting substantial dent, you’re not looking so good today,’’ help in the payment of—help in their pre- they’re diverse. [Laughter] And I’m better scription drugs. In other words, the system off for it. I’m better off for listening from is better. Imagine a system where the Gov- people from different walks of life. And our ernment would pay a $100,000 hospital stay bench will be, too, if we can get people to for heart surgery but wouldn’t pay the medi- have a fair hearing on the floor of the United cines necessary to prevent the heart surgery States Senate. They need to stop playing poli- from happening in the first place. We’re tics with my nominees for the sake of good changing that, for the good of our seniors. justice, for the sake of diversity, and for the We’ve added community health centers all sake of unclogging some of these Federal across the country. These are primary care courts that have got loaded dockets because facilities for low-income Americans to get the Senate won’t approve some of my nomi- help. We want people to get help in primary nees. care facilities, not in emergency rooms. It’s Finally, I believe a compassionate America one way to help hold down costs. We pro- is one that taps into the strength of the coun- vided health savings accounts, which will be try. Those are the hearts and souls of our beneficial for people from all walks of life. people. I like to remind our citizens, Govern- These are tax-free health savings accounts ment can hand out money, but it cannot put that make sure the patient and the doctor hope in a person’s heart. That happens when are the center of the decisionmaking process a loving soul puts their arm around somebody in health care. in need and says, ‘‘What can I do to help I’m concerned about the fact that doctors you?’’ That’s the whole crux of the Faith and all across America are leaving the practice Community Initiative—Faith-Based and of medicine. And one reason they are is be- Community Initiative that I have worked cause of the frivolous lawsuits that plague the with Congress on and worked with my ad- medical profession. I think everybody ought ministration on to spread compassion in to have their day in court when they’ve got America. Oh, I know there’s a big debate a legitimate injury, but these frivolous law- here in Washington about separation of suits are running up the cost of medicine, church and state, and I accept that debate. and they’re making medicine harder for peo- And I think it’s important. The church should ple to access. We need tort reform in Wash- never be the state, and the state should never ington, DC, medical liability reform. And I be the church. No question about it. will continue to work so on behalf of the pa- But when we find effective programs that tients and doctors of America. are helping to save people’s lives, the Gov- Look, I understand Washington; you un- ernment ought to open up Federal money derstand Washington. There’s a powerful to those programs for competitive bidding. group up here in the trial lawyers. I don’t We ought not to fear faith-based programs. think you can be pro-doctor and pro-patient We ought not to fear those who are willing and pro-trial-lawyer at the same time. I think to love their neighbor just like they’d like to you’ve got to make your choice, and I’ve be loved themselves. made my choice. Audience member. [Inaudible]

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00086 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1481

The President. Excuse me—excuse me. devalued and he needed a scapegoat. In this I think it’s very important for the Faith- case, he needed seven scapegoats. I asked Based Initiative to continue on, because I one of the fellows who came in to see me, know we can save America one heart, one he said—I said, ‘‘Why you?’’ He said, well, soul, one conscience at a time. because he happened to have sold dinars to One of the most important initiatives is the buy euros, I think he said, to buy gold so drug rehabilitation initiative I’ve asked Con- he could manufacture the jewelry that he was gress to work with me on. Let me tell you making. He made this transaction on—evi- how it works. They appropriated $100 million dently on the wrong date, because the dic- to help those who are hooked on drugs. A tator picked him out and said, ‘‘You’re one lot of times the Government counseling pro- of seven, and I’m cutting off your hand and gram can work. But a lot of times it requires burning an X in your forehead.’’ And these a change of heart in order to change habits. were the fellows that came to see me. And so therefore, a person who is desperately They came to see me because their story seeking help will be able to take a voucher was documented and Marvin Zindler—I and have that voucher redeemed at a pro- don’t know if there’s any Houstonians here, gram of his or her choice, faith-based or not. but you know Marvin Zindler. He’s a—[ap- We need to give people who need help the plause]. Yes, you know Big Marv—— opportunity to interface with those fantastic Audience member. [Inaudible] healers and helpers that literally are saving The President. Yes, sir, born and raised our country, one heart and one soul at a time. in Houston; he knows—he was brought up I’ve got a duty as your President to work by Marvin Zindler, Big 2 News. He flew as hard as I can to secure our country. It’s them over to Houston, and they got new a duty that goes on. September the 11th hands. And they were coming to see me in changed the world. It changed how we must the Oval Office. And it was a very emotional look at our internal security. There is some moment for all of us. A guy took a Sharpie, thinking here in America that says, ‘‘If you folded it in his new hand, and wrote ‘‘God go on the offense against the terrorists, you’re bless America’’ in Arabic. You see, he said creating more terrorists.’’ That is a woeful ‘‘God bless America’’ because he had been misunderstanding of the nature of the ter- liberated from the clutches of a brutal tyrant rorist threat. who whimsically could cut off a hand. These were the people who were training The contrast was sharp to me, about the for years to bring harm to freedom-loving nature of freedom, a free society and a tyran- people. These were the people who took— nical society. Free societies are peaceful soci- who gained confidence because there was no eties. Free societies help people realize their response when they wantonly killed around dream. Free societies are compassionate so- the world. These are people who you cannot cieties. negotiate with, you cannot bargain with. And In the Oval, I told them, I said, ‘‘You know, these are people that you must not hope for I’m glad you’re here. It’s very important for the best, see. They’re coldblooded killers; you to know that a successful President is they will kill you just like that in order to one who realizes he’s not bigger than the of- create fear and intimidation. My most solemn fice, that the office of President is always big- duty is to protect our country. I will continue ger than the person, and that as we help you to do so by hunting these killers down around build a free Iraq, the institutions must be the world and bringing them to justice before bigger than the people so that never happens they hurt us here at home. And as we do to you again.’’ so, we will continue to spread freedom and While we pursue the terrorists to protect peace. ourselves, we must also be confident in the I want to tell you a story about an event ideals of liberty and how freedom can change that took place in the Oval Office. Seven men societies. You might remember—you cover came to see me from Iraq. They had had the news—you might remember a while back their right hands cut off by Saddam Hussein. where there was some doubt as to whether You know why? Because his currency had or not anybody would show up to register

VerDate May 21 2004 13:15 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00087 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1482 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

to vote in Afghanistan. Expectations were a new book out today that suggests perhaps quite low as to how many people would dare we should reconsider internment camps. take risk to exercise their God-given right. How do we balance the need to pursue and You might remember the incident when the detain some individuals from not-well-known Taliban pulled four women off a bus. They communities while at the same time keeping saw that they had voter IDs and killed them. innocent people from being painted by the Since that time, millions of people in Afghan- broad brush of suspicion? istan have registered to vote. I think the total The President. Yes, I appreciate that. now is over 8 million people are lining up First, we don’t need intern camps. I mean, to exercise their right as a citizen to partici- forget it. Right after 9/11, I knew this was pate in a free society. going to be an issue in our country. I knew The long-term solution to the world is to that there would be people that say, ‘‘There spread freedom and liberty, and America goes a Muslim-looking person; therefore, must continue to lead. We’re the home of that person might be viewed as a terrorist.’’ liberty. We believe in freedom. Deep in my I knew that was going to be a problem. That’s soul, I know that freedom is not America’s why I went to a mosque, to send the signal, gift to the world; freedom is the Almighty right after the attacks, that said let’s uphold God’s gift to every man and woman in this our values. People are innocent until judged world. And I believe the United States of guilty. Religious people, people that go to America must lead, must lead the world to- mosques, you know, need to be—Americans ward a more peaceful tomorrow by spreading need to be viewed as equally American as hope and liberty in places that are desperate their neighbor, be tolerant, let law enforce- for freedom. ment, to the best of their ability, determine I want to thank you all for giving me a guilt or innocence, but our fellow citizens chance to come today. It’s my honor to be need to treat people with respect. here. I look forward to answering some ques- tions. I’m off to shake a few hands in New By far, most Americans in this country did Hampshire. But what the heck, it’s the sea- that, not because I asked them to, just be- son, isn’t it? [Laughter] God bless you all. cause by far the vast majority of Americans Q. Thank you very much, Mr. President. are decent people. They care about their We appreciate you being here this morning. neighbors. I don’t care where you’re from The President. By the way, it’s Big 13 or what your walk of life is, by far the vast News, not Big 2. [Laughter] Thank you— majority of our citizens are willing to reach yes, 11 numbers. [Laughter] Excuse me. out to somebody who is different. And that needed to be done. As a matter of fact, the Civil Liberties/War on Terror anecdotal stories of neighbors helping neigh- Q. A little addition. [Laughter] Good bors across religious lines were heart- morning, Mr. President. I’m Joie Chen with warming. CBS News and the Asian American Jour- Now, in terms of the balance between run- nalist Association. [Applause] ning down intelligence and bringing people The President. You’ve got quite a fol- to justice obviously is—we need to be very lowing out there. sensitive on that. Lackawanna, for example, Q. It is, after all, the season, isn’t it? was a—there was a cell there. And it created [Laughter] a lot of nervousness in the community, be- I wanted to ask you about protecting all cause the FBI skillfully ferreted out intel- Americans as well. There are many Arab ligence that indicated that these people were Americans and Muslims in this country who in communication with terrorist networks. find themselves unfairly scrutinized by law And I thought they handled the case very enforcement and by society at large. Just yes- well, but at the time, there was a lot of nerv- terday we had arrests in Albany, New York. ousness. People said, ‘‘I may be next.’’ But Immediately afterwards, some neighbors in they weren’t next, because it was just a fo- the community said they feared that the law cused, targeted investigation. And by the would come for them unfairly next. We have way, some were then incarcerated and told

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00088 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1483

their stories, and it turned out that the intel- directions. What do you think tribal sov- ligence was accurate intelligence. ereignty means in the 21st century, and how I guess my answer to your question is, is do we resolve conflicts between tribes and that we’ve always got to make sure that peo- the Federal and the State governments? ple are judged innocent before guilty; that’s The President. Tribal sovereignty means the best insurance policy for law enforce- that: It’s sovereign. You’re a—you’ve been ment overstepping its bounds. I will also tell given sovereignty, and you’re viewed as a sov- you, however, that the threats we’re dealing ereign entity. And therefore, the relationship with are real, and therefore we must do ev- between the Federal Government and tribes erything we can to ferret out the truth and is one between sovereign entities. follow leads. Now, the Federal Government has got a We cannot—again—it’s interesting, these responsibility on matters like education and recent threats, you know, they’re becoming security to help, and health care. And it’s a more and more enriched, as you’re finding solemn duty. And from this perspective, we out. There was more than one thread line— must continue to uphold that duty. threat line. People are now seeing there was I think that one of the most promising other reasons why we took the action we areas of all is to help with economic develop- took. When we find out intelligence that is ment. And that means helping people under- real that threatens people, I believe we have stand what it means to start a business. That’s an obligation as Government to share that why the Small Business Administration has with people. And imagine what would hap- increased loans. It means, obviously, encour- pen if we didn’t share that information with aging capital flows. But none of that will hap- the people in those buildings and something pen unless the education systems flourish were to happen; then what would you write, and are strong, and that’s why I told you what would you say? we’ve spent $1.1 billion in the reconstruction And so we have a—in terms of law en- of Native American schools. forcement, we have a duty to uphold inno- cence and guilt. In terms of a Government, Diversity in College Admissions/Diversity we have the solemn duty to follow every lead in the Administration we find and share information we have with Q. Good morning, Mr. President. Thanks people that could be harmed. And that’s ex- for coming. I’m Ray Suarez, a member of actly what we’ve done, and I will continue the National Association of Hispanic Journal- to do as the President. ists and—[applause]—there’s a couple of This is a dangerous time. I wish it wasn’t others here too—and senior correspondent this way. I wish I wasn’t the war President. for The News Hour with Jim Lehrer on PBS. Who in the heck wants to be a war President? The President. Yes, I recognize you. I don’t. But this is what came our way. And [Laughter] this is our duty, to protect our people. It’s Q. In one of the most closely watched a solemn duty, and I’ll continue doing it to cases of the 2003 term, the Supreme Court the best of my ability. split the difference on affirmative action, al- lowing Bakke to stand but rejecting the nu- Native American Tribal Sovereignty/ merical formulas used by the University of Federal Aid to Tribes Michigan undergraduate schools. I’d like to Q. Good morning. My name is Mark hear your own view about when and if race Trahant. I’m the editorial page editor of the and ethnicity are admissible as factors for Seattle Post Intelligencer and a member of consideration both in college admissions and the Native American Journalists Association. in hiring in the workplace. Most school kids learn about the government The President. Yes. I think—I agreed in the context of city, county, State, and Fed- with the Court in saying that we ought to eral. And, of course, tribal governments are reject quotas. I think quotas are discrimina- not part of that at all. Mr. President, you’ve tory by nature. They discriminate—I think been a Governor and a President so you have they discriminate on the bottom, and I know a unique experience, looking at it from two they discriminate on the top. And so I agreed

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00089 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1484 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

with their assessment that a quota system was Q. Oh, I will—nationally syndicated col- an unfair system for all. umnist with Creators Syndicate and also the As you might remember, we also agreed editorial consultant for the Chicago De- with the finding that, in terms of admissions fender, the Nation’s only daily Black news- policy, race-neutral admissions policies ought paper. to be tried. If they don’t work to achieve an The President. Give them what—— objective, which is diversification, race ought Q. I will—and representing the National to be a factor. I agree with that assessment. Association of Black Journalists, the world’s I think it’s very important for all institutions largest minority media organization, and— to strive for diversity, and I believe there are the inside joke—a 1991 graduate of Texas ways to do so. A&M University. And Mr. President, before When I was the Governor of Texas, there I ask the question, I hope you’ll give our Gov- was concerns that our big institutions were ernor, Rick Perry, a call. I know you spend not—big educational institutions were not di- a lot of time in DC, Mr. President, but versified enough. So I went to the legislature they’re trying to cap the top 10 percent in and said, ‘‘Why don’t we work together and Texas, so that may have an impact on those say that there’s automatic admission to our students going to college. universities if you finish in the top 10 percent The President. Yes, but I appreciate your of your high school class, no matter what high recognizing that it’s working in the first place. school you go to.’’ And it worked. It worked Q. It is, but they actually—the percentage because the student bodies began to diversify of white students increased as well. at the University of Texas and at Texas A&M. The President. See, sometimes—— And—that’s an inside joke up here. [Laugh- Q. I understand. ter] You’re about to hear why. The President. ——they talk; sometimes You know, I have a responsibility to work they deliver. for diversity as well in the administration. I’ve Q. I understand. It’s okay. I’m working met the obligation. If you look at my adminis- with the A&M president on that. I also hope tration, it’s diverse. And I’m proud of that. that you would take a second round of ques- Condi Rice is there because she happens to tions from Texan to Texan, so we can ask be a very competent, smart, capable woman. a second question. If you would do me that She’s also African American. And she is my favor. closest foreign policy adviser. I see her every The President. All right, just ask your two day. When I see Condi, I think, brilliant per- questions. son. And I’m glad she’s there. Colin Powell— Fairness in the Voting Process/Voter he was here yesterday, evidently. Rod Participation Paige—Rod Paige was the superintendent of schools in Houston. I wanted somebody who Q. Mr. President, you remarked—in your knew what it meant to run a school district, remarks you said that 8 million people in Af- not a theorist; somebody who knows what ghanistan registered to vote and, as you said, it means to challenge the soft bigotry of low exercised their God-given right to vote. expectations. He had. He’s there. Alphonso The President. Right. Jackson, Elaine Chao, Norm Mineta—Mel Q. That may be a right from God, but it’s Martinez was in my Cabinet—we’ve got a not guaranteed in the U.S. Constitution. In diverse Cabinet. I’ve got a diverse adminis- 2000, an estimated 2 million people—half Af- tration. Hopefully, that sets an example for rican American—had their votes discounted, people when it comes to hiring, including from Florida to Cook County, Illinois, to news organizations. other cities. [Applause] Come on, that cuts into other questions. Are you going to order Attorney General John Ashcroft to send Fed- College Admissions in Texas eral election monitors to Florida and other Q. Mr. President, Roland Martin. southern States? And in this age of new con- The President. Tell them what it’s about, stitutional amendments, will you endorse a Martin. constitutional amendment guaranteeing

VerDate May 21 2004 13:43 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00090 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1485

every American the right to vote in Federal people do vote. And you have a duty on your elections? radio stations, on your TV stations to encour- The President. First of all, look, I can un- age people to register to vote. I have a duty derstand why African Americans, in par- to call them out to vote. Of course, I’m going ticular, are worried about being able to vote, to try to call them out to vote for me. [Laugh- since the vote had been denied for so long ter] in the South, in particular. I understand that. Second round. And this administration wants everybody to Q. All right, come back around, sir. vote. Now, I—the best thing we did was to pass Immigration Reform/Free Trade the Helping America Vote Act with over— Agreements I think it’s $3 billion of help to States and Q. Early in your administration, you talked local governments to make sure the voting a good deal about immigration reforms and process is fair. And it’s not just the South, possibilities there. I have not heard you talk by the way. The voting process needs help to that issue so much recently. I wonder what all over the country to make sure that you still think is possible, given the cir- everybody’s vote counts and everybody’s vote cumstances that we find ourselves in today. matter. I understand that. And that’s why I What is doable, particularly in the short was happy to work with the Congress to term? achieve this important piece of legislation. The President. Actually, I have talked Just don’t focus on Florida. Now, I’ll talk about it lately. I talked about it this winter, to the Governor down there to make sure because I think it’s necessary that we reform it works. [Laughter] But it’s the whole coun- our immigration laws. I believe where there’s try that needs—voter registration files need a willing worker and a willing employer, and to be updated; the machines need to work. they can’t find work here in America, the And that’s why there’s $3 billion in the budg- people ought to be allowed to be here legally et to help, Roland. And obviously, everybody to work; that’s what I believe. And I believe ought to have a vote. And what was your there ought to be a process that allows a per- other question? son to work here legally and go home and Q. Should we put it in—— come back without fear of being arrested. The President. The Constitution amend- I think there needs to be a—first of all, ment? this will help bring people out of the shadows Q. Should we guarantee it in the Constitu- of our society. This will help kind of legalize tion? a system that takes place everyday without The President. I’ll consider it—I’ll con- employers feeling like they have got to be sider it. And what’s your second question? subjected or employees feeling like they’re Q. Well, but you said it should be guaran- going to be arrested—subjected to fines or teed in Iraq; why not America? arrested. And so we need to reform our im- The President. Well, it’s not guaranteed migration laws. in Iraq. People have got to show up to vote Now, the issue there is whether or not in the first place. This is—the thing about people automatically get to step in the front democracy is people need to step up and de- of the line when it comes to citizenship. I cide to participate in the first place. There’s don’t think they should. I think those who no guarantees people are going to vote. They have been waiting in line to be a citizen ought should be allowed to vote. But the problem to be allowed to keep that priority in line. we have in our society is too many people I think people ought to—in this process choose not to vote. And we have a duty in ought to be allowed to apply for citizenship, the political process and you have a duty as but I don’t think they ought to be treated journalists to encourage people to register to specially in relation to those who have been vote, to do their duty. I’m not saying every— in line for quite a while. And in order to solve I’m saying people are choosing. It’s not guar- the logjam for citizenship, Congress has got anteed they’re going to. That’s part of the to raise the quotas on who can become a problem we have in America: Not enough citizen. And I support raising the quotas on

VerDate May 21 2004 13:59 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00091 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1486 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

certain population groups, like the Mexican his book, talking about his Iraqi experience. nationals, on who can become a citizen. And he conservatively estimated 2 to 4 more The long-run solution, particularly to years of a large-scale American presence in Mexican immigration, is going to be to help Iraq. This morning there is fresh fighting in Mexico develop a middle class. That’s why Najaf, Nasiriyah, Samara. What is the mission free trade is so important between our coun- at this point, for 140,000 American forces? tries. That’s why we better be careful about And how will we know when they’re done? rhetoric that begins to unwind a free trade The President. The mission is for there— agreement that is making an enormous dif- the mission is there to be a democratic Iraq ference in the lifestyles of people in Mexico. where they have elections to elect their gov- See, trade, to me, is the great hope for devel- ernment. That’s the mission, to help them oping nations. That’s why I was a strong sup- achieve that. And that’s important. And that’s porter of AGOA, the African Growth and necessary work. The tactics to achieve that Opportunity Act. It gives people a chance to are, one, we help provide security to the have a job that’s a meaningful job, because Alawi government as they move toward elec- of the trade between the world’s largest mar- tions. Obviously, there are people there that ket and their countries. NAFTA has made are still trying to disrupt the elections proc- a big difference in lifting lives of people. It ess. They can’t stand the thought of a free has improved the living standard in Mexico. society in the midst of a part of the world Listen, people are coming to the United that’s just desperate for freedom. These peo- States to work from Mexico because they ple don’t like freedom. You know why? Be- want to make a living for their families. And cause it clashes with their ideology. We actu- if they can’t make a living for their families ally misnamed the war on terror. It ought at home, they’ll come here to work. And to be the struggle against ideological extrem- therefore, we must work with Mexico to de- ists who do not believe in free societies who velop a middle class in the long run, so peo- happen to use terror as a weapon to try to ple can do their duty as a parent at home. shake the conscience of the free world. That’s what they want. And we need to [Laughter] change our immigration laws. Will it get No, that’s what they do. They use terror done? Probably not this year. This is an elec- to—and they use it effectively, because we’ve tion year; not much gets done, except for a lot of yelling and elbowing. But I would like got good hearts. We’re people of conscience. to see reasonable immigration reform come They aren’t. They will cut off a person’s head out of the Congress. like that, and not even care about it. That’s why I tell you, you can’t talk sense to them. Payroll Tax Maybe some think you can; I don’t. I don’t Q. A few minutes ago you mentioned think you can negotiate with them. Let the—every American received a tax cut that’s me—— working. The most onerous tax for many Q. That 2 to 4 year projections—— Americans, particularly on the low end of the The President. No, let me finish. Let me scale, is the payroll tax. What can be done finish, please, sir. Thank you, though. about payroll taxes? We will stay there until the job is com- The President. Well, obviously, I chose pleted and our commanders on the ground to provide tax relief by income tax cuts, not tell us. See, I think it’s very important for by payroll taxes, and the reason why is payroll those of us in the political arena to listen to taxes relief will affect the solvency of Social the commanders on the ground. Tommy was Security. So I chose not to deal with the pay- a great commander on the ground. I listened roll tax. to him. And now I’ll listen to General Casey as to—and Ambassador Negroponte as to U.S. Mission in Iraq when they think we’ve achieved our mission. Q. Mr. President, this week, General The second stage, by the way, Ray—he’s Tommy Franks, your former CENTCOM trying to get me to put a timetable out there. commander, has been on tour, talking about I’m not going to do it, see. And when the

VerDate May 21 2004 12:26 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00092 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1487

timetable is busted, they’ll say, ‘‘I told you.’’ The President. No, no, no, whoa, whoa, [Laughter] Anyway—— whoa—with regard to my opposition to quota Q. We’ve got to try. [Laughter] systems. The President. Yes, A for effort. Q. To quotas, okay. But I’ve never heard It’s still dangerous there, no question you speak against legacy. Now, the president about it. The dynamics have changed, how- of Texas A&M, Robert Gates, said that he ever, because Prime Minister Alawi, who’s would not use race in admissions, and then now in charge of the Interim Government— he later said he would not use legacy. If you he’s a tough, strong guy who believes that say it’s a matter of merit and not race, Iraq can be free and democratic. And that’s shouldn’t colleges also get rid of legacy? Be- an important step. It was—he’s willing to cause that’s not based upon merit; that’s step up and say clearly to the Iraqi people, based upon if my daddy or my granddaddy ‘‘Let’s reject this violence and terrorism that went to my college. is threatening a better way of life.’’ He’s the The President. Yes. I thought you were fellow who woke up in bed one night in Lon- referring to my legacy. [Laughter] don to confront an axe-wielding thug—thugs Q. That’s why I allowed you to go ahead from Saddam Hussein that tried to hatchet and bring it out. him to pieces, axe him to pieces. And so he’s The President. Well, in my case, I had seen firsthand what tyranny can do, and he’s to knock on a lot of doors to follow the old made a decision, obviously, to take risk on man’s footsteps. [Laughter] No, look, if what behalf of a free society. you’re saying is, is there going to be special The key to success, to answer your ques- treatment for people—in other words, we’re tion about when, is how quickly the Iraqis going to have a special exception for certain are trained and prepared to take action them- people in a system that’s supposed to be selves. The ultimate success of our venture fair—I agree. I don’t think there ought to in Iraq, which is a free and democratic coun- be. try, will depend upon how quickly we can Q. So the colleges should get rid of legacy. help the Iraqis defend themselves. The will The President. Well, I think so, yes. I is there, and now they must have the training think it ought to be based upon merit. And and equipment to provide them what is nec- I think it also ought to be based upon—and essary to do their duty in a free society. I think colleges need to work hard for diver- One of the biggest fears many Iraqi citi- sity. Don’t get me wrong—don’t get me zens have is that we’re not a country of our wrong. You said ‘‘against affirmative action,’’ word. People don’t want to take risks. They is what you said. You put words in my mouth. understand that at this point in time, if a vac- What I am for is—— uum were created, anarchy would reign and Q. I just read the speech, Mr. President. there would be mayhem and bloodshed. And The President. What speech? they’re fearful that the United States will Q. In terms of when you came out against once again say something and not mean it. the Michigan affirmative action policy, I say ‘‘once again’’ because you might re- and—— member at different times during Iraqi his- tory they were—they believed they heard The President. No, I said was I against something in terms of U.S. support, and it quotas. didn’t happen. And then there was a lot of Q. So you support affirmative action but death as a result of unfulfilled expectations. not quotas. We’ve got to stay with them until they The President. I support colleges affirma- achieve the objective. tively taking action to get more minorities Nice try. in their school. Q. That’s a long headline, Mr. President. Diversity and Legacy in College [Laughter] Admissions The President. I support diversity. I don’t Q. Mr. President, you say, quote, ‘‘Quotas support quotas. I think quotas are wrong. I are an unfair system for all,’’ with regards think quotas are wrong for people, and so to your opposition to affirmative action. do a lot of people.

VerDate May 21 2004 13:43 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00093 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1488 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Q. Just to be clear, you believe that col- lot of time here in New Hampshire, is getting leges should not use legacy. married tomorrow. The President. I think colleges ought to Audience member. Oh. use merit in order for people to get in, and The President. Yes, so we’re having a little I think they ought to use a merit system like family wedding. My brother Marvin is with the one I put out. me today. I can’t wait to say—see old number Q. Thank you very much. 41. You might remember him. He’s got a lot The President. Thank you all. Thanks for of friends in New Hampshire. And Mother, having me. of course, will be there. She can’t wait for me to arrive so she can tell me what to do. NOTE: The President spoke at 9:21 a.m. at the [Laughter] I’m still listening too. Washington Convention Center. In his remarks, he referred to Ernest Sotomayor, president, I want to thank Doug Scamman and Stella UNITY, and Long Island Editor, Newsday.com; Scamman for their beautiful hospitality. Mayor Anthony A. Williams of Washington, DC; Thanks for opening up your farm. What a former Secretary of Housing and Urban Develop- beautiful place. You know, the amazing thing ment Mel R. Martinez; Gov. Jeb Bush of Florida; about the Scammans is they’re both can- Gen. George W. Casey, Jr., commanding general, didates for the statehouse. They’re not run- Multi-National Force—Iraq; and U.S. Ambas- ning against each other; that’s the good news. sador to Iraq John D. Negroponte. Discussion Otherwise Stella would win. [Laughter] But participant Roland Martin referred to Gov. Rick I appreciate Doug, a onetime speaker of the Perry of Texas. house, going back into office. It’s such a good example for somebody willing to serve. And Remarks in Stratham, I appreciate Stella serving as well. I wish New Hampshire them all the best in their race. If they want August 6, 2004 my help, they can have it. If it helps me— not to be for them, I’ll try there too. I just The President. Thanks for coming. Lis- want them to win. ten, there’s no better way to spend a Friday But I do appreciate their hospitality. I love afternoon than at a picnic in New Hamp- families, and this is a great farm family. I shire. Thanks for coming. Gosh, what a fine say every day is Earth Day when you own gathering. Thanks for coming. I’m thrilled to a piece of the land. These people are taking be here. care of their property, and you can see it I’m here to ask for your vote. I’m back when you look around at what a beautiful in your important State one more time, say- spot. ing I’ve got something to do on behalf of I appreciate my friend Judd Gregg. You your country. I’d like your vote, and I’d like know, he is an amazing Senator. He gets the your help. We won New Hampshire last work done. He is a serious-minded guy who time; we’re going to win it this time. We’re I find a lot of fun to be around. He is a—— on our way to a great victory in November. Audience member. Six more years! I’m sorry Laura is not here. The President. That’s right, 6 more years; Audience members. Aw-w-w! you need to put him back up there. [Laugh- The President. That’s generally the reac- ter] You’re lucky to have had him rep- tion: Why didn’t you send her instead of resenting you; you really are. He’s a good, yourself? [Laughter] But what a great First sound man, as is Sununu, Jr. John Sununu Lady she is. She is a wonderful mother, a is doing a great job as well. I enjoy working wonderful wife. She’s doing a wonderful job with the two United States Senators from for the American people. I’m going to give New Hampshire. you some reasons to put me back in office, I appreciate your Governor, Craig Benson, but perhaps the most important one of all being here. I’m honored that he has agreed is so that Laura has 4 more years as the First to serve. He’s a good fellow, as is Congress- Lady. man Jeb Bradley, running for the United We’re working our way up the coast here. States Congress. We’ve got to make sure you Brother Jeb’s son, George P., who spent a put him back in. And I know his mother,

VerDate May 21 2004 13:43 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00094 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1489

Helen, is here. That’s good, Jeb, you listen And that’s what I’m here to tell you. We’ve to your mother too. [Laughter] got more to do for our country. I’m running And then my friend Charlie Bass is with for a reason. I want to make our country the us today. He’s a congressman—the other best country it can be by improving jobs and congressman from New Hampshire who’s improving our schools. I will continue to fight doing a great job for the people of this State. the war against terror. But you’ve got to know I’m proud they’re here. I’m going to continue to push for the peace. It’s good to see my friend Ruth Griffin and I’m going to continue to make this world a ‘‘Wiz’’ Wieczorek. These are people I’ve more peaceful place. known for—you might remember, I was We have done a lot. I’m here to ask for knocking on doors here a while ago—like, your help, because there’s more to do. I’m 4 years ago. [Laughter] And I met a lot of running with a good Vice President, a really good folks in New Hampshire, people that good Vice President. I admit, he’s not the I’ve never forgotten. The Scammans, for ex- prettiest face on the ticket. [Laughter] I’m ample, hosted a deal for Laura and me here. sure Lynne got a little upset with me when It’s kind of like old home week, and it’s very she hears me say that. I didn’t pick him for nostalgic for us to come back and—for me his looks. [Laughter] I picked him because to come back and look around and see many he’s a man of sound judgment and great ex- of the folks that worked so hard in 2000. I perience and a man who can do the job. Dick Cheney and I understand we have appreciate you staying with it. more to do for our country to achieve big We’ve got work to do. There’s a reason goals and big objectives. We’ve got more to I’m running for office. I want this country do to make our public schools the centers to be safer, stronger, and better for the of excellence we all know they can be, so American people. that no child is left behind in America. When I want to thank all the State folks who are we came to office 31⁄2 years ago—remember here, the elected officials. I want to thank back—too many kids were getting shuffled Cheryl McGuiness, the widow of American from grade to grade, year after year, without Flight 11 pilot. Cheryl is a woman of deep learning the basics. So we challenged what faith who has taken on, you know, an incred- I’ve called the soft bigotry of low expecta- ible burden on that day of September the tions. We’re raising the bar. We believe every 11th, and has dealt with it in such a strong child can learn to read and write and add fashion that she shines in her courage and and subtract, and we expect every child to strength. We love you, Cheryl. Thank you learn the basics. for being here. So we believe in accountability. We be- I want to thank Jayne Millerick and Nancy lieve in empowering parents. We believe in Merrill and my old buddy Tom Rath for local control of schools. And today, children being in charge of the grassroots organiza- across America are showing real progress in tion. These are the people who put up the reading and math. When it comes to improv- signs, people who do all the heavy lifting in ing our public schools, we’re turning the cor- a political campaign. I want to thank you for ner, and we’re not turning back. what you’re doing. I want to thank you for We’ve got more to do. See, the jobs of what you’re going to do. It’s really important the future will require greater knowledge we turn the vote out. And I’m counting on and higher level skills. And so we’ve got to you. I’m counting on your help. reform our high schools to make sure a high Every incumbent who comes to ask for the school diploma means something. We want vote has got to answer one sensible question to make sure math and science education are of why—why should the people put me back spread throughout our schools to give our in office for 4 more years? In the past few kids the skills necessary to compete. We’ll years, we’ve been through a lot together and use the Internet to bring high-level training we have accomplished a lot. But the only rea- into classrooms. What I’m telling you is, is son to look backward is to best tell who to that after 4 more years, a rising generation lead us forward. will have more skills and more confidence

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00095 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1490 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

so they can realize the great promise of our expand research to seek new cures for ter- country. rible disease. In all we do to improve health We’ve got more to do to make quality care in America, we will make sure the health health care available and affordable. Remem- decisions are made by doctors and patients, ber, when we came to office, too many older not by bureaucrats in Washington, DC. Americans had trouble with prescription There’s more work to do to make this drugs and Medicare didn’t pay for them. You economy stronger. Remember what we’ve might remember previous campaigns where been through. We’ve been through a lot. you heard, time in and time out, ‘‘Oh, don’t We’ve been through a recession. We’ve been worry, I’ll do something about Medicare,’’ through corporate scandals. We’ve been and nothing happened. We got the job done. through a terrorist attack. But we’ve over- More than 4 million seniors have signed come these obstacles because our workers up for drug discount cards that provide real are great, because our farmers are really savings. You need to sign up if you’re eligible. good at what they do. We’ve overcome these It will make a difference for you. Beginning obstacles because the entrepreneurial spirit in 2006, all seniors on Medicare will be able is strong. And we’ve overcome these obsta- to choose a plan that suits their needs and cles because of well-timed tax cuts. will give—and that gives them prescription Audience members. Four more years! drug coverage. To help people have access Four more years! Four more years! to quality care, we’ve expanded community The President. Listen, we didn’t pick win- health centers for low-income Americans. ners or losers when it came to tax relief. We We want those citizens getting health care felt that if you’re paying Federal income in these centers, not in emergency rooms. taxes, you ought to get relief. It’s the only We’ve created health savings accounts so fair way to do it. And so families with chil- families can save tax free for their own health dren got relief. We provided relief for mar- care needs. ried couples. You know, we’ve got a Tax Code Let me—hear this: When it comes to giv- that says there is a marriage penalty. ing Americans more choices about health Audience members. Boo-o-o! care and making health care more affordable, we’re moving forward, and we’re not going The President. No, that’s not—we ought backwards. to be encouraging marriage, not penalizing Most people get their health care coverage marriage. through their businesses. Most new jobs are We helped our small-business owners. created by small businesses today. And many That tax relief helped small-business owners. small businesses too often cannot afford to And this time, the check was really in the provide health coverage. So to help our fami- mail. [Laughter] lies get health coverage, we must allow small Our economy has been through a lot. To- employers to join together to be able to pur- day’s employment report shows our economy chase insurance at the discounts available to is continuing to move forward. And it re- big companies. minds us that we’re in a changing economy, Let me tell you what else we need to do and we’ve got more to do. I’m not going to to make sure you’ve got affordable health be satisfied until everybody who wants to care and available health care. We need to work can find a job. I’m running because I get rid of these frivolous and junk lawsuits. understand how to take a strong economy You can’t be pro-patient and pro-doctor and and make it stronger. I say we have a strong pro-trial-lawyer at the same time. You have economy, and it’s getting stronger. Our econ- to choose. My opponent made his choice, omy since last summer has grown at a rate and he put him on the ticket. [Laughter] I as fast as any in nearly 20 years. made my choice: I’m standing with the docs In the last year, we’ve added about 1.5 mil- and the patients. I strongly support medical lion new jobs. The unemployment rate is liability reform. down to 5.5 percent. Here in New Hamp- Listen, we’re going to harness technology shire, your unemployment rate is 3.9 percent. to reduce costs and prevent mistakes. We’ll Listen, when it comes to creating jobs for

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00096 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1491

American workers, in places like New Hamp- Audience members. No-o-o! shire you’ve proved that we’re moving Amer- The President. I’ll tell you what else we’ve icans forward, and we’re not turning back. got to do to make sure jobs stay here, is to Let me tell you what else we need to do. make sure our workers have the skills nec- We need to make sure our regulations are essary to fill the jobs of the 21st century. reasonable on our employers. I know some We’re going to offer American workers a life- of you file out—file a lot of paperwork. I time of learning. We’re going to make sure can’t promise anybody in Government has our community colleges are accessible and ever read it. [Laughter] We need tort reform affordable so people who need to can be re- if we want to keep our jobs in America. We trained for the jobs which will exist. Listen, need a fair and balanced legal system. If we education is crucial to making sure the jobs want to keep our jobs in America, we need stay here at home. an energy policy that is wise, that encourages I’ll tell you what else we’re going to do. conservation, that encourages renewable We’re going to make sure American families sources of energy, that encourages explo- keep more of something they do not have ration in environmentally friendly ways. To enough of, and that’s time—time to coach keep jobs here, we need to become less de- your kids. I want to thank the football coach- pendent on foreign sources of energy. es, the youth football coaches who are here To keep jobs here in America, we need today. I told the coaches, I said, ‘‘Thanks for reasonable trade policy. See, here’s what I passing on values to our children.’’ I want believe. I believe America’s workers, farmers, to thank those of you who work with the kids manufacturers, and entrepreneurs can com- in the community here. Thanks for being pete with anybody, anytime, anywhere, so good moms and dads. I want to thank the long as the playing field is level. We’re going 4–H Clubs that were here, doing good work to be opening up markets for the good peo- to help others. ple of New Hampshire. We want you selling See, I’m going to work with Senator New Hampshire goods not only in the Gregg. He’s proposed legislation to allow United States of America but all around the workers to have flex-time. That means they world. And my administration will give you can adjust their schedules to meet their a chance to compete in a fair way. needs so they can do their duty as a mom In order to make sure we keep jobs here, or a dad or as a community activist. Senator we’ve got to be wise about how we spend Gregg makes good sense in his legislation; your money. We’ve got to set priorities and I strongly embrace it. Government needs to not overspend it. You know how to start? The stand side by side with the families of Amer- best way to start with understanding fiscal ica. responsibility in Washington is to understand I’m running for 4 more years because I we’re not spending the Government’s want this economy to be stronger. I want our money. You listen closely to the rhetoric of farm economy stronger. I want the entrepre- these campaigns, you hear, ‘‘Well, we’re neurial spirit stronger. I want there to be going to spend the Government’s money.’’ higher and better paying jobs. I’m running That’s not what I think. I know whose money for 4 more years to continue to work for a we spend. We spend the people’s money. pro-growth, pro-entrepreneur, pro-small- In order to make sure jobs stay here, we’re business economic agenda that is good for going to keep your taxes low. This campaign America. is just getting started, and the other fellow We have more to do to wage and win the has already promised over $2 trillion of new war on terror. America’s future depends on programs. Imagine what’s going to be coming our willingness to lead in this world. If Amer- down the stretch. [Laughter] And the prob- ica shows uncertainty and weakness in this lem is, he hasn’t told us how he’s going to decade, the world will drift toward tragedy. pay for it. But given his record, I bet we This will not happen on my watch. can figure out how he’s going to pay for it. The world changed on a terrible Sep- He’s going to raise your taxes. But we’re not tember morning. And since that day, we have going to let him. changed the world. Before September the

VerDate May 21 2004 12:14 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00097 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1492 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

11th, Afghanistan served as the home base those weapons or share his capabilities with of Al Qaida, which trained and deployed enemies. thousands of killers to set up terror cells See, we saw a threat. We looked at the around the world, including our country. intelligence of the day and saw a threat. The Today, Afghanistan is a rising democracy. Af- United States Congress—members of both ghanistan is an ally in the war against these political parties, including my opponent— thugs. Many young girls now go to school looked at the same intelligence and came to in Afghanistan for the first time. Afghanistan the same conclusion. The United Nations is becoming free, and America and the world looked at the intelligence and recognized are safer for it. Saddam was a threat. They unanimously Before September the 11th, Pakistan was passed a resolution—unanimously passed a a safe transit point for terrorists. Today, Paki- resolution—which said, ‘‘Disclose, disarm, or stan is an ally in the war against terror. Paki- face serious consequences.’’ After defying the stani forces are aggressively to—helping free world for 12 years, he did so again. He round up Al Qaida and their friends and asso- deceived the weapons inspectors. And so I ciates, and America and the world are safer. had a choice to make: Do I forget the lessons In Saudi Arabia, before September the of September the 11th? 11th, terrorists were raising money and they Audience members. No-o-o! were recruiting and they were operating with The President. Do I trust a madman? Or little opposition. Today, the Saudi Govern- do I take action necessary to defend our ment is taking the fight to Al Qaida, and country? Given that choice, I will defend America and the world are safer. America every time. Before September the 11th, Libya was Audience members. Four more years! spending millions to acquire weapons of mass Four more years! Four more years! destruction. Today, because America and our allies have sent a strong and clear message, The President. And because Saddam the leader of Libya has abandoned his pursuit Hussein sits in a prison cell, America and of weapons of mass destruction, and America the world are safer. and the world are safer. Even though we did not find the stockpiles Before September the 11th, the ruler of that we thought we would find, we did the Iraq was a sworn enemy of America. He was right thing. He had the capability, and he defying the world. He was firing weapons at could have passed that capability on to our American pilots which were enforcing the enemies. world’s sanctions. He had pursued and he Now, there are some questions that a had used weapons of mass destruction. He Commander in Chief needs to answer with harbored terrorists. He invaded his neigh- a clear yes or no. My opponent hasn’t an- bors. He subsidized families of suicide bomb- swered the question of whether, knowing ers. He had murdered tens of thousands of what we know now, he would have supported his own citizens. He was a source of great going into Iraq. That’s an important question, instability in the world’s most volatile region. and the American people deserve a clear yes He was a threat. or no answer. I have given my answer. We After September the 11th, we looked at did the right thing, and the world is better all the threats of the world in a new light. off for it. I want you to remember, a lesson of Sep- Over the next 4 years, we’ll continue to tember the 11th was that we must take work with friends and allies around the world threats seriously, before they fully mate- to aggressively pursue the enemy in Iraq and rialize. The September the 11th Commission Afghanistan and elsewhere. See, you can’t concluded our institutions of Government talk sense to these people. You can’t nego- had failed to imagine the horror of that day. tiate with them. You can’t hope for the best After September the 11th, we could not fail with people who take airplanes and killed to imagine that a brutal tyrant who hated thousands of our citizens. We must engage America, who had ties to terror, who had these enemies around the world so we do used weapons of mass destruction might use not have to face them here at home.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00098 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1493

America will continue to lead the world and health benefits, for ammunition, fuel, with confidence and moral clarity. We put and spare parts. Only a handful of United together a strong coalition. We’re working to- States Senators voted against the help to our gether—there’s over 60 nations involved with military. the Proliferation Security Initiative, 40 na- Audience members. Boo-o-o! tions involved in Afghanistan, nearly 30 na- The President. Two of those twelve Sen- tions involved in Iraq. These are good people ators are my opponent and his runningmate. leading these countries. Our friends and al- Audience members. Boo-o-o! lies will continue to work together for the The President. Here’s how he tried to ex- cause of security and peace, but I will never plain his vote—[laughter]—‘‘I actually did turn America’s national security decisions vote for the 87 billion, before I voted against over to the leaders of other countries. it.’’ [Laughter] Listen, I’ve spent a lot of qual- We will keep our commitments to help Af- ity time in New Hampshire. That’s not how ghanistan and Iraq become peaceful and the people of New Hampshire talk. Now he’s democratic societies. This is important work; offering a different explanation. He said he’s it’s hard work, to go from being brutalized proud of his vote, and he said the whole thing by a tyrant to having confidence enough to is a complicated matter. [Laughter] There’s live in a free world. These two countries are nothing complicated about supporting our now governed by strong leaders. Prime Min- troops in harm’s way. ister Alawi in Iraq and President Karzai in Afghanistan are strong leaders who believe No, as Commander in Chief of these folks, in the hopes and aspirations of their people. I’m proud to stand with them. I’m proud of They want freedom, and so do the people the veterans who have served so well and of their countries. More and more of their set such a great example to those who serve. folks are stepping up and taking responsi- In the long run, our security is not guaran- bility. More people are becoming trained to teed by force alone. We must work to change defend their country against those who hate the conditions that give rise to terror: poverty freedom. And the people of those countries and hopelessness and resentment. See, a free can count on the United States and our coali- and peaceful Iraq and a free and peaceful tion. See, when we acted to protect our own Afghanistan will be powerful examples to security, we promised to help deliver them their neighbors. They live in a part of the from tyranny, to restore their sovereignty, world that is desperate for freedom. We be- and to set them on the path of liberty. And lieve in America—we know in America that when America gives its word, America keeps free societies are peaceful societies. Free so- its word. cieties do not export terror. See, by serving In these crucial times, our commitments the ideal of liberty, we’re serving our own are kept by the men and women of our mili- national interests. As freedom spreads, tary. I want to thank the 94th Military Police America becomes more secure, and the Army Reserve Unit of New Hampshire for world will be more peaceful. By serving the their service. I’ve had the privilege of meet- ideal of liberty, we’re serving the deepest be- ing with those who defend our country. I’ve liefs of our country. Freedom is not Amer- seen their unselfish courage and their great ica’s gift to the world; freedom is the Al- decency. The cause of freedom is in really mighty God’s gift to every man and woman good hands. in this world. And I have an obligation and our Govern- I’m running for 4 more years to make our ment has an obligation to make sure those country more secure and to help spread who defend us have the very best pay, train- peace throughout the world. And we’ve got ing, and equipment. Last September, while to do more to protect our country. You’ve our troops were in combat in Afghanistan read recently the threats. They’re real, be- and Iraq, I proposed supplemental funding cause there’s an enemy that still wants to to support them in their mission. This impor- harm us. My opponent said something the tant legislation provided funding for body other day I strongly disagree with. He said armor and vital equipment, for hazard pay that going to war with the terrorists is actually

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00099 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1494 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

improving their recruiting efforts. No, it’s up- it comes to electing a President, results mat- side-down logic. It shows a misunderstanding ter. This world we’re in is a—— of the enemy. During the nineties, these peo- Audience members. Four more years! ple were recruiting and training and pre- Four more years! Four more years! paring long before—long before—we went The President. This is an exciting time to war with them. They don’t need an excuse to be an American, in many ways. It’s a for their hatred, and it is wrong to blame changing world, and Government has got to America for the anger and the evil of the understand that. You know, you’ve got work- killers. We don’t create terrorists by fighting ers—when most of our dads were coming up, back. We defeat the terrorists by fighting they worked for the same company, didn’t back. change jobs, and so the pension plans or the I agree with the conclusion of the 9/11 health care plans were adjusted for that. Now Commission that said the homeland is safer it’s a different world. People are changing because of the actions we’ve taken, but not jobs; people are working out of their homes. yet safe. And so we’ve got work to do to make Oftentimes, moms and dads are both work- this country more secure. We’ll stay on the ing. And policy has got to reflect these chang- offense, but we’ve got work here at home. ing times, which means, it seems like to me, And we’ve started the process of reform. the best way to do so is to encourage an own- We’ve transformed our defenses. We’ve cre- ership society. For example, we want people ated a new Department of Homeland Secu- owning and managing their own health care rity. We passed the PATRIOT Act. It’s a very accounts that they can take with them job important piece of legislation to give law en- to job or go from job to home. forcement the tools necessary to disrupt and In terms of pensions, you know, older guys find terrorist cells. like me are set for Social Security, but young- The mission of the FBI is now focused er workers needed a different approach for on preventing terror. We’re integrating intel- Social Security. We ought to allow younger ligence and law enforcement better than ever workers to manage their own personal retire- before. We’re taking action on a lot of this ment accounts that they can pass from one important Commission’s recommendations. generation to the next. We’ve got more to do to better secure our When people tell me the number of small- ports and borders, to train first-responders. businesses owners in America are increasing, I want to thank the first-responders who are that’s really good news. I want people to own here, by the way—those are your police and something in our country. I’m going to con- firefighters and emergency teams. tinue to work for an ownership society. I called on Congress to create a position Homeownership is at an alltime high now in of National Intelligence Director to dramati- America. That’s fantastic news. Isn’t it won- cally improve our coordination and gathering derful to have somebody for the first time efforts. Listen, these reforms aren’t going to be able to say, ‘‘Welcome to my home. I’m be easy. It’s never easy in Washington. glad you’re here at my piece of property.’’ [Laughter] There’s a lot of entrenched inter- This administration understands that when ests, a lot of people defending the status quo. you own something, you have a vital stake It’s not enough to advocate reform; you’ve in the future of our country. Now, in times got to be able to get the job done. And that’s of change, some things will never change: our what we’ve done in this administration. belief in liberty, our belief in opportunity for When it comes to reforming schools to every citizen, our nonnegotiable demands of provide excellent education, we got the job human dignity. We believe in the individual done, and results matter. When it comes to values that we try to live by, courage and health care reforms to give families more ac- compassion, reverence and integrity. We be- cess and more choices, results matter. When lieve in the institutions that give us direction it comes to improving our economy and cre- and purpose, our families, our schools, and ating quality jobs, results matter. When it our religious congregations. These are funda- comes to better securing our homeland and mental to our lives, and they deserve the re- spreading the peace, results matter. When spect of Government.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00100 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 / Aug. 6 1495

We stand for institutions like marriage and said, I stood in the Twin Towers on Sep- family, which are the foundation of society. tember the 14th, 2001. It’s a day I’ll never We stand for a culture of life in which every forget. There were workers in hardhats person matters and every being counts. We yelling at me, ‘‘Whatever it takes.’’ I remem- stand for judges who faithfully interpret the ber a guy grabbing me by the arm—I don’t law instead of legislating from the bench. know if he was a firefighter or a policeman; And we stand for a culture of responsibility I do know that he had been searching in the in our country. The culture of this country rubble for a loved one. He looked at me with is changing from one that has said, ‘‘If it feels bloodshot eyes and said, ‘‘Do not let me good, just go ahead and do it,’’ and ‘‘If you’ve down.’’ got a problem, blame somebody else,’’ to a These are vivid impressions I will never culture in which each of us understands forget. Obviously, he took it personally. The we’re responsible for the decisions we make people searching through the rubble took in life. If you are fortunate enough to be a that day personally. You took it personally. mother or a father, you’re responsible for lov- I took it personally. I have a duty that goes ing your child with all your heart and all your on. It is a solemn duty to defend our country, soul. If you’re worried about the quality of which I will do, whatever it takes. the education in the community in which you live, you’re responsible for doing something We have come through much together. about it. If you’re a CEO in corporate Amer- We have done a lot of hard work. But there’s ica, you’re responsible for telling the truth more to do. There’s more to do to spread to your shareholders and your employees. opportunity and freedom and peace. During And in a responsibility era, each of us is re- the next 4 years, I will work to make sure sponsible for loving our neighbor just like the American Dream shines brightly for ev- we’d like to be loved ourselves. erybody and that we encourage an ownership I’m running for 4 more years to continue society. We will pass enduring values of our to rally the armies of compassion. See, I un- country to the next generation. We will lead derstand Government can hand out money. the cause of freedom and peace. And we will We do a pretty good job of it in Washington. prevail. [Laughter] But what Government cannot do Four years ago, I traveled your great State. is put hope in a person’s heart or a sense I said if you gave me the honor of serving, of purpose in a person’s life. That’s done I would uphold the dignity and the honor when a loving soul puts his arm around some- of the office to which I had been elected. body in need and says, ‘‘Brother,’’ or ‘‘Sister, And with your help—and with your help, I I love you. How can I help you?’’ will do so for 4 more years. Listen, we can rally the armies of compas- May God bless you all. Thanks for coming. sion. The great strength of America is the Thank you very much. Thank you all. heart and soul of our people, and we can change this blessed country one heart, one soul, one conscience at a time. NOTE: The President spoke at 1:07 p.m. at Bitter- For all Americans, these years in history sweet Farm. In his remarks, he referred to Jayne will always stand apart. There are quiet times Millerick, chairman, Nancy Merrill, national com- mitteewoman, and Tom Rath, national com- in the life of a nation when little is expected mitteeman, New Hampshire Republican State of its leaders. This isn’t one of those times. Committee; Col. Muammar Abu Minyar al-Qa- It’s a time that requires firm resolve, clear dhafi, leader of Libya; former President Saddam vision, dedication to freedom and peace. Hussein of Iraq; and the National Commission on None of us will ever forget that week when Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States (9/11 one era ended and another began. As Judd Commission).

VerDate May 21 2004 12:14 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00101 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1496 Aug. 6 / Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

Memorandum on Waiving been renewed by the Congress, the national Prohibition on United States Military emergency declared on August 17, 2001, and Assistance With Respect to the renewed on August 14, 2002, and on August Republic of the Congo 7, 2003, must continue in effect beyond Au- gust 17, 2004. Therefore, in accordance with August 6, 2004 section 202(d) of the National Emergencies Presidential Determination No. 2004–41 Act (50 U.S.C. 1622(d)), I am continuing for 1 year the national emergency declared in Memorandum for the Secretary of State Executive Order 13222. This notice shall be published in the Fed- Subject: Waiving Prohibition on United eral Register and transmitted to the Con- States Military Assistance with Respect to the gress. Republic of the Congo Consistent with the authority vested in me George W. Bush by section 2007 of the American The White House, Servicemembers’ Protection Act of 2002 (the August 6, 2004. ‘‘Act’’), title II of Public Law 107–206 (22 U.S.C. 7421 et seq.), I hereby: [Filed with the Office of the Federal Register, • Determine that the Republic of the 9:07 a.m., August 9, 2004] Congo has entered into an agreement with the United States pursuant to Arti- NOTE: This notice will be published in the Federal cle 98 of the Rome Statute preventing Register on August 10. the International Criminal Court from proceeding against U.S. personnel Letter to Congressional Leaders present in such countries; and Transmitting a Notice on • Waive the prohibition of section 2007(a) of the Act with respect to this country Continuation of Emergency for as long as such agreement remains Regarding Export Control in force. Regulations You are authorized and directed to report August 6, 2004 this determination to the Congress, and to arrange for its publication in the Federal Reg- Dear Mr. Speaker: (Dear Mr. President:) ister. Section 202(d) of the National Emer- gencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1622(d)), provides for George W. Bush the automatic termination of a national emer- gency unless, prior to the anniversary date Notice—Continuation of Emergency of its declaration, the President publishes in Regarding Export Control the Federal Register and transmits to the Regulations Congress a notice stating that the emergency is to continue in effect beyond the anniver- August 6, 2004 sary date. In accordance with this provision, On August 17, 2001, consistent with the I have sent the enclosed notice, stating that authority provided me under the Inter- the emergency caused by the lapse of the national Emergency Economic Powers Act Export Administration Act of 1979, as (50 U.S.C. 1701 et seq.), I issued Executive amended, is to continue in effect beyond Au- Order 13222. In that order, I declared a na- gust 17, 2004, to the Federal Register for tional emergency with respect to the unusual publication. and extraordinary threat to the national secu- Sincerely, rity, foreign policy, and economy of the George W. Bush United States in light of the expiration of the Export Administration Act of 1979, as NOTE: Identical letters were sent to J. Dennis amended (50 U.S.C. App. 2401 et seq.). Be- Hastert, Speaker of the House of Representatives, cause the Export Administration Act has not and Richard B. Cheney, President of the Senate.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00102 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 1497

Letter to Congressional Leaders on 7. One filament winding machine, for the Export of Certain Items to the Weifang Dongming Extinguisher People’s Republic of China Equipment, located in Weifang, August 6, 2004 Shandong, People’s Republic of China, to use in manufacturing 600,000 carbon Dear Mr. Speaker: (Dear Mr. President:) dioxide fire extinguisher bottles per In accordance with the provisions of sec- year. tion 1512 of the Strom Thurmond National Sincerely, Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 1999 (Public Law 105–261), I hereby certify George W. Bush that the export to the People’s Republic of China of the following items is not detri- NOTE: Identical letters were sent to J. Dennis Hastert, Speaker of the House of Representatives, mental to the United States space launch in- and Richard B. Cheney, President of the Senate. dustry and that the material and equipment, including any indirect technical benefit that could be derived from such exports, will not measurably improve the missile or space launch capabilities of the People’s Republic Digest of Other of China. White House Announcements 1. One linear accelerator for Huanggang Customs, for inspection of cargo enter- ing the Port of Shenzhen, People’s Re- The following list includes the President’s public public of China. schedule and other items of general interest an- 2. Fifty-thousand pounds of fine-grained nounced by the Office of the Press Secretary and graphite, for Shanghai Carbone Lor- not included elsewhere in this issue. raine Chemical, located in Shanghai, People’s Republic of China, to use in July 31 manufacturing temperature-resistant in- dustrial machinery components. In the morning, in Cleveland, OH, the 3. One linear accelerator for Harbin Boiler President had an intelligence briefing. Later, Company, Ltd., located in Harbin, Peo- he traveled to Canton, OH. ple’s Republic of China, to use in non- In the afternoon, the President traveled to destructive testing and inspection of Cambridge, OH. Later, he traveled to utility boilers and valves for conven- Triadelphia, WV. tional power and auxiliary equipment. Later in the afternoon, the President trav- 4. One hot isostatic press, for Guizhou Anji eled to Pittsburgh, PA. Foundry Company, located in Anshun In the evening, the President returned to City, Guizhou Province, People’s Re- Washington, DC. public of China, to use in consolidation of titanium and aluminum castings for August 2 chemical equipment parts. In the morning, in the Oval Office, the 5. Two environmental test chambers, for President had a telephone conversation with Flextronics Industrial Company, Ltd., Prime Minister Pedro Santana Lopes of Por- located in Jingan, Doumen Zhuhai, Peo- tugal to congratulate him on taking office and ple’s Republic of China, to test Xbox to discuss counterterrorism efforts. He then game consoles for the Microsoft Cor- had an intelligence briefing and met with the poration. Homeland Security Council. 6. One environmental test chamber, for Later in the morning, in the Cabinet Hon Hai Precision Industries Company, Room, the President had a Cabinet meeting. Ltd., located in Guangdong, People’s In the afternoon, in the Residence, the Republic of China, to test personal com- President and Mrs. Bush participated in an puters and peripheral equipment for interview with Redbook magazine. Later, he Apple, Compaq, and Dell. met with Secretary of State Colin L. Powell.

VerDate Aug 04 2004 01:53 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203250 PO 00000 Frm 00103 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1498 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

August 3 In the evening, the President returned to In the morning, the President had an intel- Washington, DC. ligence briefing. Later, he traveled to Dallas, TX, where, upon arrival, he met with USA August 6 Freedom Corps volunteer Larry Hawkins. In the morning, the President had an intel- In the afternoon, the President partici- ligence briefing. Later, he traveled to pated in a Victory 2004 luncheon at a private residence. Later, he traveled to the Bush Stratham, NH, arriving in the afternoon. Ranch in Crawford, TX. Later in the afternoon, the President trav- The President declared a major disaster in eled to Kennebunkport, ME. New York and ordered Federal aid to supple- The President declared a major disaster in ment State and local recovery efforts in the Kentucky and ordered Federal aid to supple- area struck by severe storms and flooding on ment Commonwealth and local recovery ef- May 13–June 17. forts in the area struck by severe storms and The President declared a major disaster in flooding on July 13–15. Kansas and ordered Federal aid to supple- The President declared a major disaster in ment State and local recovery efforts in the West Virginia and ordered Federal aid to area struck by severe storms, flooding, and supplement State and local recovery efforts tornadoes beginning on June 12 and con- in the area struck by severe storms, flooding, tinuing. and landslides beginning on July 22 and con- tinuing. August 4 The President declared a major disaster in In the morning, the President traveled to Pennsylvania and ordered Federal aid to sup- Moline, IL. While en route aboard Air Force plement Commonwealth and local recovery One, he had an intelligence briefing. Upon efforts in the area struck by severe storms arrival at the Quad City International Air- and flooding beginning on August 1 and con- port, he met with USA Freedom Corps vol- tinuing. unteer Peggy Schaefer. He then traveled to The President announced his intention to Davenport, IA. appoint the following individuals as members In the afternoon, the President traveled to of the John F. Kennedy Center for the Per- Minneapolis, MN, where, upon arrival at the forming Arts, Advisory Committee on the Minneapolis-St. Paul International Airport, Arts: Joy Bollinger; Sandra S. Brock; Jennifer he met with USA Freedom Corps volunteer Compton Corton; Peter Cummings; Judith Bryan Comstock. Waite Freeman; Janet Hendren; Christine Later in the afternoon, the President trav- Hughes; Mark B. Hutton; Mary Joann Jundt; eled to Le Sueur, MN, where he toured the Kathy Kelly; Deanna Kirchman; William Katzenmeyer family farm. Later, he traveled Lamb; Sandra K. Meyers; Gary Michael; to Mankato, MN. Mary Mohs; William D. Mounger; Oscar In the evening, the President returned to Persons; Kay Phillips; Jean Rolles; Fred Washington, DC. Sands; Masako H. Shinn; and Susan W. Si- mons. August 5 In the morning, the President had an intel- ligence briefing. Later, he traveled to Colum- bus, OH, where, upon arrival in the after- noon, he met with USA Freedom Corps vol- Nominations unteer Jack Lehr. Submitted to the Senate Later in the afternoon, the President trav- eled to Saginaw, MI, where, upon arrival, he met with USA Freedom Corps volunteer NOTE: No nominations were submitted to the Charlie Wargel. Senate during the period covered by this issue.

VerDate May 21 2004 12:14 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00104 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004 1499

Checklist Statement by the Press Secretary announcing of White House Press Releases that the President signed H.R. 1572, H.R. 1914, H.R. 2768, H.R. 3277, and H.R. 4380 Statement by the Press Secretary on disaster The following list contains releases of the Office assistance to Kentucky of the Press Secretary that are neither printed as items nor covered by entries in the Digest of Statement by the Press Secretary on disaster Other White House Announcements. assistance to West Virginia Statement by the Press Secretary on disaster Released August 2 assistance to Pennsylvania Transcript of a press briefing by Press Sec- retary Scott McClellan, Chief of Staff An- drew H. Card, Jr., and National Security Ad- viser Condoleezza Rice Acts Approved Statement by the Press Secretary on the fire by the President in an Asuncion supermarket in Paraguay Statement by the Press Secretary announcing Approved August 2 that the President signed H.R. 1303, H.R. H.R. 1303 / Public Law 108–281 4363, S. 741, S. 2264, and S.J. Res. 38 To amend the E-Government Act of 2002 Fact sheet: Making America Safer by with respect to rulemaking authority of the Strengthening Our Intelligence Capabilities Judicial Conference Released August 3 S. 741 / Public Law 108–282 To amend the Federal Food, Drug, and Cos- Transcript of a press gaggle by Press Sec- metic Act with regard to new animal drugs, retary Scott McClellan and for other purposes Statement by the Press Secretary announcing S. 2264 / Public Law 108–283 that the President signed H.R. 4759 Northern Uganda Crisis Response Act Statement by the Press Secretary on disaster S.J. Res. 38 / Public Law 108–284 assistance to New York Providing for the appointment of Eli Broad Statement by the Press Secretary on disaster as a citizen regent of the Board of Regents assistance to Kansas of the Smithsonian Institution Fact sheet: Compassion for Americans in H.R. 4363 / Public Law 108–285 Need Helping Hands for Homeownership Act of 2004 Released August 4 Approved August 3 Transcript of a press gaggle by Press Sec- retary Scott McClellan and a senior adminis- H.R. 4759 / Public Law 108–286 tration official on new conservation initiatives United States-Australia Free Trade Agree- Fact sheet: Supporting America’s Farmers ment Implementation Act and Conserving America’s Land Approved August 5 Released August 5 H.R. 4613 / Public Law 108–287 Transcript of a press gaggle by Press Sec- Department of Defense Appropriations Act, retary Scott McClellan 2005 Fact sheet: America’s Changing Workforce: Approved August 6 Ready for the 21st Century H.R. 1572 / Public Law 108–288 To designate the United States courthouse Released August 6 located at 100 North Palafox Street in Pensa- Transcript of a press gaggle by Press Sec- cola, Florida, as the ‘‘Winston E. Arnow retary Scott McClellan United States Courthouse’’

VerDate May 21 2004 12:14 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00105 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4 1500 Administration of George W. Bush, 2004

H.R. 1914 / Public Law 108–289 Jamestown 400th Anniversary Commemora- tive Coin Act of 2004 H.R. 2768 / Public Law 108–290 John Marshall Commemorative Coin Act H.R. 3277 / Public Law 108–291 Marine Corps 230th Anniversary Commemo- rative Coin Act H.R. 4380 / Public Law 108–292 To designate the facility of the United States Postal Service located at 4737 Mile Stretch Drive in Holiday, Florida, as the ‘‘Sergeant First Class Paul Ray Smith Post Office Build- ing’’

VerDate May 21 2004 12:30 Aug 10, 2004 Jkt 203001 PO 00000 Frm 00106 Fmt 1244 Sfmt 1244 E:\PRESDOCS\P32AUT4.006 P32AUT4