DOCSLIB.ORG

Introductory Note: the Who, the What and The

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Introductory Note: the Who, the What and The Power for the People: Sustainability and Stakeholder Engagement in the New Zealand Power Industry Jacqueline Nancy Louise Allen Faculty of Business and Law A thesis submitted to Auckland University of Technology in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Philosophy April 2013 Table of Contents List of Figures ..........................................................................................................v List of Tables ......................................................................................................... vi List of Appendices ................................................................................................ vii List of Acronyms ................................................................................................. viii Glossary of Maori Terms .........................................................................................x Attestation of Authorship ....................................................................................... xi Acknowledgements ............................................................................................... xii Abstract ................................................................................................................ xiv Introductory Note ................................................................................................. xvi Section 1 Introduction ..............................................................................................1 Chapter 1: Sustainability Introduction ..................................................................................................3 What is sustainability and why should we care? .........................................4 Sustainability and human society.................................................................4 Sustainable development .............................................................................9 Sustainability, economics and the business community ............................18 Mechanisms in pursuit of sustainability ....................................................24 Conclusion .................................................................................................26 Chapter 2: The Stakeholder Concept Introduction ................................................................................................27 The stakeholder concept ............................................................................28 From concept to theory ..............................................................................30 Who are stakeholders? ...............................................................................35 What is at stake? ........................................................................................41 Why do businesses respond to stakeholders? ............................................42 How do businesses respond to stakeholders? ............................................45 Why do stakeholders participate? ..............................................................49 How do stakeholders participate? ..............................................................50 When do stakeholders participate? ............................................................53 What are the limitations of stakeholder theory? ........................................54 Networks ....................................................................................................57 i Conclusion .................................................................................................59 Chapter 3: The Sustainability Stakeholder Nexus Introduction ................................................................................................60 Stakeholders and sustainability ..................................................................61 Enlightened self-interest perspectives ........................................................62 Moral/ethical perspectives .........................................................................67 Criticisms of the stakeholder engagement for sustainability concept ........72 Conclusion .................................................................................................78 Section 2 Introduction ............................................................................................79 Chapter 4: Methodology and Method Introduction ................................................................................................80 Locating the researcher ..............................................................................80 The methodological mix ............................................................................82 The research orientation .............................................................................87 The conceptual landscape ..........................................................................92 Grounded theory approach .........................................................................92 Literature review technique ...................................................................... 95 Sample selection ....................................................................................... 97 Commencing fieldwork ............................................................................ 99 Data collection .........................................................................................102 Data processing and presentation.............................................................106 Data analysis ............................................................................................108 Conclusion ...............................................................................................109 Chapter 5: Research Context Introduction ..............................................................................................110 Aotearoa New Zealand ............................................................................110 Energy ......................................................................................................113 Electricity generation ...............................................................................115 Economic reform .....................................................................................119 Electricity generation and the environment .............................................122 The New Zealand regulatory environment ..............................................126 The three companies ................................................................................129 Contact Energy Ltd ..................................................................................130 Mighty River Power .................................................................................131 ii TrustPower ...............................................................................................132 Conclusion ...............................................................................................133 Section 3 Introduction ..........................................................................................134 Chapter 6: Power Generator A and its Stakeholders Introduction ..............................................................................................137 The logistics of stakeholder relationships ................................................137 Views from inside the company ..............................................................139 Views from outside the company ............................................................148 Iwi stakeholders .................................................................................149 Environmental stakeholders ...............................................................158 Community stakeholders ...................................................................166 Regulatory stakeholders .....................................................................172 Conclusion ...............................................................................................183 Chapter 7: Power Generator B and its Stakeholders Introduction ..............................................................................................184 The logistics of stakeholder relationships ................................................184 Views from inside the company ..............................................................187 Views from outside the company ............................................................194 Iwi stakeholders .................................................................................194 Environmental stakeholders ...............................................................198 Community stakeholders ...................................................................205 Regulatory stakeholders .....................................................................211 Conclusion ...............................................................................................217 Chapter 8: Power Generator C and its Stakeholders Introduction ..............................................................................................218 The logistics of stakeholder relationships ................................................218 Views from inside the company ..............................................................221 Views from outside the company ............................................................229 Iwi stakeholders .................................................................................229 Environmental
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Determination of Critical Contingency Price in Respect of the Critical Contingency of 3Rd March 2012
    Determination of Critical Contingency Price in respect of the critical contingency of 3rd March 2012 Tim Denne ([email protected]) 20th April 2012 Introduction 1. This report sets out my determination of a Critical Contingency Price as required by the Gas Governance (Critical Contingency Management) Regulations 2008 (‘the Regulations’). The Critical Contingency Price is required in respect of the critical contingency of 3rd March 2012. 2. A critical contingency is defined under the Regulations. It is triggered when the operating pressure reaches a low threshold that defines the pressure required to “maintain the supply of gas across the relevant part or parts of the transmission system and to avoid disruption of distribution systems connected to the transmission system” (Regulation 25(1)(a)(iv)). 3. A draft report and recommended price was discussed at a workshop with interested parties on 16th April 2012. There were no objections to the proposed price. 4. My determination is that the critical contingency price for 3rd March 2012 is $11.10/GJ. The explanation is given below. The Event 5. A critical contingency was declared on the Maui pipeline on 3rd March 2012 following an unplanned outage of the Pohokura Production Station. The plant shutdown initially occurred as a result of a power outage at 3.40am, but production could not restart because of a fault in the plant heating system. The outage resulted in reduced supply and a low pressure being recorded at Rotowaro that fell below the threshold that triggered a critical contingency. The sequence of events is shown in Figure 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Connection Plus March/April 2001
    Your business newsletter from WEL Energy Group March/April 2001 24 hour faults 0800 800 WEL Threestrikes 0800 800 935 andand you’reyou’re notnot outout InternationalInternational WEL has improved its supply reliability during flavourflavour toto storms and lightning strikes thanks to a reconfigured WEL Energy lines network. contractors check BalloonsBalloons overover A two-year, $10 million programme is being completed to the network as part reduce the length of time Waikato customers suffer outages. of our reliability WaikatoWaikato Several new 33,000 and 11,000-volt cables and associated upgrade. indoor switchgear were installed in Hamilton North, and Contact Energy’s Te Rapa cogeneration plant was brought What’s that in the sky? It’s a bird? into the system. It’s a plane? No, it’s a new, huge, specially shaped Until recently the WEL’s system was operated as a radial balloon being brought to Balloons over network. Any fault on the 33,000-volt lines supplying its Waikato thanks to sponsorship from the substations resulted in a total loss of supply to that Hamilton City Council. substation. WEL is getting behind the WEL Energy WEL Contracts Manager Bill Doig says the old system looked Trust-sponsored annual hot air balloon like a tree and if any branch was affected by an outage, festival in April. Event Manager Linda Kelly everyone on that branch was cut off until repairs were says registrations have already been made. received from balloonists in Australia, The new system created a ring network so power is able America, Britain, Canada and a number of to be re-routed through another line.
    [Show full text]
  • Fonterra Submission on CCM Consultation 24 July 2020
    Statement of proposal for amending the Critical Contingency Management Regulations Summary Fonterra welcomes the opportunity to provide feedback on the Statement of Proposal for amending the Critical Contingency Management Regulations paper. Fonterra is a co-operative owned by around 10,000 New Zealand farmers, and as such we take a long-term view of both our industry and our country. We are New Zealand’s largest co-operative with 30 manufacturing sites spread across New Zealand with more than 10,000 staff working for the Co-operative in regional New Zealand. Natural gas is a critical energy source for 18 of our North Island manufacturing sites. Processing our farmers' milk within 12-hours of collection is vital to avoid the significant environmental damage from disposing milk on farm. The significant environmental and economic damage that results from an outage remains long after the gas has been restored. As our 18 sites are located from Whangārei in the north down to Pahiatua in the south, we are the only major gas user that is exposed to the greatest risk of a gas outage with each kilometre of pipeline to get to our sites. We have installed diesel fuel back-up at four of our sites to assist with mitigating some of the gas outage risk from various regional scenarios. This investment has been made based upon a range of factors, including how much could be utilised without jeopardising New Zealand’s diesel stocks. Fonterra considers that greater prioritisation of gas supply needs to be given to the dairy industry , especially during the peak milk months (September to December), to minimise both environmental and economic damage that would occur from a sustained gas outage.
    [Show full text]
  • Critical Contingency Management Plan
    Approved 30 September 2020 Critical Contingency Management Plan Prepared in accordance with the Gas Governance (Critical Contingency Management) Regulations 2008 First Gas Limited October 2020 Plan | Critical Contingency Management Plan Version Control This document is uncontrolled Control Details Owner Ryan Phipps, Transmission Operations Manager Version 12.0 Department Transmission Operations Effective date October 2020 Review date October 2020 Preparer John Blackstock, Senior Commercial Advisor History Version Date Summary of changes Preparer 7.0 18/12/2009 First issue for publication 8.0 09/05/2012 Revised to update the CCOs contact details 9.1 11/09/2012 Revised to reflect the recommendations made in the December 2011 and April 2012 Performance Reports, and amendment to Critical Contingency Imbalance Methodology 9.0 25/02/2014 Revised to update TSO and CCO contact details with effect from 1 March 2014 Revised to reflect amendment to the Gas Governance (Critical 10.0 14/05/2014 Contingency Management) Regulations 2008, and the appointment of a new CCO Minor corrections and amendments made to ensure 10.1 17/12/2014 consistency with the CCO’s amended Communications Plan Adapted to First Gas Limited business branding with minor 10.2 23/05/2016 Rebecca Pendrigh updates in formatting Revised to reflect the sale of the Maui Pipeline asset to First 10.3 16/06/2016 Gas Limited and consequently removal of references to MDL John Blackstock and other necessary contextual amendments Revised to become sole CCMP document for all of the 11.0 20/02/2017 Transmission System and to incorporate suggested John Blackstock amendments from previous critical contingency test exercises Changes drafted in 2018/2019 to accommodate the prospective commencement of the GTAC (including feedback from industry consultation).
    [Show full text]
  • 06 September 2010 Annual Report Created with Sketch
    20102010 Contents 1 Summary 2 Performance indicators 4 Chairman’s review 6 Managing Director’s review 9 Management discussion of fi nancial results 22 Company overview 26 Governance 39 Remuneration report 50 Security holder information Financial contents 54 Financial statements 60 Notes to the fi nancial statements 110 Audit report 111 Corporate directory The 2010 Annual Meeting of Contact Energy Limited shareholders will be held at the Christchurch Convention Centre, 95 Kilmore Street, Christchurch on Wednesday 27 October 2010, commencing at 10:30am [NZDST]. The Notice of Annual Meeting and shareholder voting/proxy form are provided separately to shareholders. Contact Energy Limited Annual Report 2010 1 Summary For the fi nancial year ended 30 June 2010 • Portfolio infl exibility in another wet year, together with rising retail costs, impacted on Contact Energy’s result for the fi nancial year ended 30 June 2010, with Underlying Earnings after Tax for the fi nancial year of $150 million down six per cent from $159 million for the 12 months to 30 June 2009 • Te Huka geothermal power station (23 MW) was handed over to Contact for commercial operation on 23 May 2010, under budget and ahead of schedule • Chosen as joint venture partner by the Taheke 8C and Adjoining Blocks Incorporation for the exploration and possible development of the Taheke geothermal fi eld • Lodged applications for resource consents with the Environmental Protection Authority for the proposed Tauhara 2 geothermal development project in Taupo • Continued to advance plans for
    [Show full text]
  • THE NEW ZEALAND GAS STORY the State and Performance of the New Zealand Gas Industry
    THE NEW ZEALAND GAS STORY The state and performance of the New Zealand gas industry SIXTH EDITION | DECEMBER 2017 Message from the Chief Executive Gas Industry Co is pleased to publish this sixth edition of the New Zealand Gas Story. It includes developments in the policy, regulatory and operational framework of the industry since the previous edition was published in July 2017. The New Zealand gas industry continues to make a significant contribution to New Zealand’s energy supply and is performing well against Government policy and consumer expectations. However, as Gas Industry Co has been signalling for some time, the role of gas in New Zealand has been changing. This has particularly been driven by three interrelated factors: development of new energy technologies and associated consumer preferences; low upstream investment in a low oil price environment over recent years, with resulting impacts on gas reserves; and developing responses to climate change. The key additional factor which will drive further change is the developing policies of the new Labour- led Coalition Government. Climate change policies included in the new Government’s list of priorities will undoubtedly be a significant influence on upstream and other investment. Coalition agreements provide for introducing a Zero Carbon Act and an independent Climate Commission, based on the recommendations of the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment, and for gradual inclusion of the agriculture sector in the Emissions Trading Scheme. The Labour/Greens Agreement includes requesting the Climate Commission to plan the transition to 100 percent renewable electricity by 2035 in a normal hydrological year. For the moment, gas contributes around 22 percent of New Zealand’s primary energy, and provides over 277,000 New Zealand homes and businesses with secure and affordable energy.
    [Show full text]
  • 04 September 2009 Annual Report Created with Sketch
    Contents 1 Summary 2 Performance indicators 4 Chairman’s review 6 Managing Director’s review 10 Management discussion of financial results 24 Company overview 27 Governance 40 Remuneration report 51 Security holder information Financial contents 56 Financial statements 61 Notes to the financial statements 110 Audit report 111 Corporate directory The 2009 Annual Meeting of Contact Energy Limited shareholders will be held at the Michael Fowler Centre, 111 Wakefield Street, Wellington on Thursday 22 October 2009, commencing at 10:30am NZDST. The Notice of Annual Meeting and shareholder voting/proxy form have been provided separately to shareholders. Contact Energy Limited Annual Report 2009 1 Summary For the financial year ended 30 June 2009 • Weather extremes, transmission constraints and reduced electricity demand combined to impact on earnings, with underlying earnings after tax of $161 million, down from $233 million for the 12 months to 30 June 2008 • Generators and turbines delivered for the 200 megawatt gas-fired peaking power station under construction at Stratford • Commenced injection of natural gas into the Ahuroa natural gas storage facility near Stratford • Continued construction of the 23 megawatt Tauhara phase one geothermal power station at Taupo • Secured final resource consents for the company’s 220 megawatt Te Mihi geothermal power station • Continued to develop wind, hydro and geothermal generation options • Completed the installation of more than 42,000 smart meters in Christchurch customers’ houses • Celebrated 50 years
    [Show full text]
  • Contact Energy Halfyear Report
    Contact Energy HalfYear Report For the six months to 31 December 2009 WorldReginfo - 958661ba-352a-4f48-9f15-51ef8c968ec0 Contents 1 National overview 3 Summary 4 Chairman and Managing Director’s review 8 Management discussion of fi nancial results Financial contents 21 Condensed interim group fi nancial statements 28 Notes to the condensed interim group fi nancial statements 40 Auditors’ review report 41 Corporate directory WorldReginfo - 958661ba-352a-4f48-9f15-51ef8c968ec0 Contact Energy Limited Half Year Report 2009 1 Otahuhu A National overview reactive power Contact is one of New Zealand’s largest publicly listed companies, with the ability to supply electricity and gas products across the country. We have Otahuhu B reticulated natural gas customers across much of the North Island, reticulated combined-cycle gas turbine 400 MW LPG customers in Christchurch, Queenstown and Wanaka, and we can supply bottled and automotive LPG nationwide. Auckland Sales Team Ohaaki geothermal 105 MW Existing assets and offi ces (currently operating at 65 MW) Existing power stations Offi ces Te Rapa cogeneration 44 MW Poihipi geothermal 55 MW Wairakei geothermal 157 MW and 15 MW binary plant Site of decommissioned New Plymouth power station Taranaki combined-cycle gas turbine 377 MW Levin Call Centre Lower Hutt/Petone Retail Services Centre LPG Distribution Wellington Contact Head Offi ce Queenstown/Wanaka LPG Sales and Distribution Reticulated LPG networks Christchurch LPG Sales and Distribution Reticulated LPG networks Clyde Clutha River hydro 432 MW Roxburgh Clutha River hydro 320 MW Dunedin Call Centre LPG Sales and Distribution Invercargill LPG Sales and Distribution WorldReginfo - 958661ba-352a-4f48-9f15-51ef8c968ec0 2 Contact Energy Limited Half Year Report 2009 Otahuhu C site combined-cycle gas turbine 400 MW (consented) Taheke 8C and Adjoining Blocks Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Gas Supply and Demand Scenarios 2012-2027
    Gas Supply and Demand Scenarios 2012 - 2027 March 2013 update including Maui pipeline analysis Concept Consulting Group Limited Level 6, Featherston House 119-123 Featherston St PO Box 10-045, Wellington, NZ www.concept.co.nz 179083179079.1 Concept Consulting Group Concept Consulting Group (Concept) is a New Zealand-based consultancy specialising in energy-related issues. Since establishment in 1999, Concept has advised clients in New Zealand, Australia, Ireland, Singapore and the United States. These clients have included energy businesses, governments, international agencies and regulators. Concept has undertaken a wide range of assignments, including market development, market analysis, technical evaluations, regulatory and policy analysis, and project management. The firm’s directors all have extensive backgrounds in executive management positions with energy companies in New Zealand, and the consulting team collectively offers practical hands-on experience across a wide range of disciplines. Preparation of this report This report was prepared by Simon Coates, David Hunt and David Weaver. Disclaimer Concept Consulting Group believes the information and opinions expressed in this report to be accurate and complete at the time of writing. However, Concept and its staff shall not, and do not, accept any liability for errors or omissions in this report or for any consequences of reliance on its content, conclusions or any material, correspondence of any form or discussions arising out of or associated with its preparation. GAS SUPPLY
    [Show full text]
  • Ecoefficiency for the Dairy Processing Industry, Melbourne: Dairy Australia
    Eco-efficiency for the Dairy Processing Industry, 2019 edition Eco-efficiency for the Dairy Processing Industry, 2019 Edition Prepared for: Mr Ian Olmstead Program Manager - Manufacturing Innovation & Sustainability - Trade & Industry Strategy Dairy Australia, Level 3, HWT Tower, 40 City Road, Southbank, Victoria, 3006 2019 Update Prepared By: The Ecoefficiency Group Pty Ltd Penny Prasad, Jane Gaffel, Nicole Price www.ecoefficiencygroup.com.au 2004 Edition Prepared By: The UNEP Working Group for Cleaner Production in the Food Industry Environmental Management Centre, The University of Queensland, St Lucia Penny Prasad, Robert Pagan, Michael Kauter and Nicole Price Sustainable Business Level 9, 121 Walker Street, North Sydney Patrick Crittenden Publication by: Dairy Australia 2019 Disclaimer: While every attempt has been made to ensure that the information in this publication is correct at the time of printing, errors can occur. The information is provided as general information only. Specific issues relevant to your workplace should be considered in light of this and on an individual basis. You should consult with professional advisers familiar with your particular factual situation for further advice. Page ii Eco-efficiency for the Dairy Processing Industry, 2019 edition Contents 1.0 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 1 2.0 Industry profile ................................................................................................. 3 3.0 Sustainability
    [Show full text]
  • 06 September 2011 Annual Report Created with Sketch
    20112011 Contents 1 Summary 2 Performance indicators 4 Chairman’s review 6 Chief Executive Offi cer’s review 9 Management discussion of fi nancial results 20 Company overview 24 Governance 37 Remuneration report 49 Security holder information Financial contents 51 Financial statements 58 Notes to the fi nancial statements 106 Independent auditor’s report 108 Corporate directory The 2011 Annual Meeting of Contact Energy Limited shareholders will be held at the Rotorua Convention Centre, 1170 Fenton Street, Rotorua on Wednesday 19 October 2011, commencing at 9.30am. The Notice of Annual Meeting and shareholder voting/proxy form are provided separately to shareholders. Contact Energy Limited Annual Report 2011 1 Summary For the fi nancial year ended 30 June 2011 • Underlying earnings after tax for the year of $150.9 million. An increase of 1 per cent from $149.8 million for the 12 months to 30 June 2010. • Commenced full commercial operation of the Ahuroa gas storage facility and the Stratford peakers – the anticipated fl exibility that these assets will restore to Contact’s generation portfolio has already been evidenced in second half-year earnings. • Commenced construction on the 166 megawatt (MW), $623 million Te Mihi geothermal project. • Consented three key energy developments: – Tauhara 2 – a 250 MW geothermal power station – consented for construction _ on the Tauhara geothermal area near Taupo. – Waitahora wind farm – a 156 MW wind farm – consented for construction in southern Hawke’s Bay. _ _ – Hauauru ma raki wind farm – a 504 MW wind farm – consented for construction along the western coast of the Waikato region to Te Akau South.
    [Show full text]
  • 2018 WEL Networks Asset Management Plan
    WEL Networks 2018 Asset Management Plan 0800 800 935 | wel.co.nz WEL Networks | 2018 Asset Management Plan 01 FOREWORD 29 March 2018 Dear Stakeholders, Thank you for taking the time to review the WEL Networks Limited Asset Management Plan (AMP) 2018. In essence the AMP is a snapshot of our intended capital expenditure on our network over the next ten years. It outlines the investment rationale and performance measurement of our assets and enables our community to thrive through the provision of a strong, safe, efficient and reliable supply for our customers. The AMP reflects our vision to create an innovative energy future. This vision is clearly demonstrated through projects focused on safety, continuous improvement and understanding new technologies and how they can benefit our network and our customers. Your feedback is essential for our business to progress and I’d invite you to comment on the initiatives outlined either by emailing me ([email protected]) or phoning 0800 800 935. Garth Dibley Chief Executive wel.co.nz WEL Networks | 2018 Asset Management Plan 033 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 4 WEL Networks | 2018 Asset Management Plan EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Asset Management Plan (AMP) describes the describing the relationship of the AMP with our nature and characteristics of our assets and investment strategic plans and its importance as a key requirements; it also provides an overview of our asset planning document. management planning, systems, procedures and practices. Where there is technical information in this AMP we aim to The Asset Management Plan provides a clear description explain it in a way that provides meaning and value to all of the objectives, measures, and targets we aim to our stakeholders.
    [Show full text]