DOCSLIB.ORG

A Case for Municipal Control and a Comprehensive Transportation Vision for the Five Boroughs

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
A Case for Municipal Control and a Comprehensive Transportation Vision for the Five Boroughs LET’S GO A Case for Municipal Control and a Comprehensive Transportation Vision for the Five Boroughs NEW YORK CITY COUNCIL SPEAKER COREY JOHNSON MARCH 5, 2019 TABLE OF CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................6 SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................................................................. 8 A Vision for Municipal Control ................................................................................................................................................ 8 GOVERNANCE: .................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 8 FINANCES: ............................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 8 Increasing Accessibility........................................................................................................................................................... 9 A Master Plan for City Streets ................................................................................................................................................ 9 TO IMPROVE BUS SERVICE: .............................................................................................................................................................................................. 9 TO CREATE LIVABLE STREETS: ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 10 TO ENCOURAGE SAFE, SUSTAINABLE TRANSPORTATION: ..................................................................................................................................... 10 TO REDUCE CONGESTION: ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 10 TO ADDRESS CLIMATE ADAPTATION: .......................................................................................................................................................................... 10 Rethinking the BQE ............................................................................................................................................................... 10 WHY TRANSPORTATION? ...................................................................................................................... 11 COMMON MODES OF TRANSPORTATION IN NEW YORK CITY..................................................................................... 13 BETTER TRANSIT MEANS A BETTER NEW YORK ........................................................................................................... 14 Better Transit is Better for the Economy .............................................................................................................................. 14 A More Fair City ..................................................................................................................................................................... 15 A Safer City ............................................................................................................................................................................ 15 A Greener New York .............................................................................................................................................................. 16 HOW WE GOT HERE ............................................................................................................................... 17 THE SUBWAY ....................................................................................................................................................................... 18 Early Mass Transit Policy ...................................................................................................................................................... 18 The Need for Great Expansion.............................................................................................................................................. 19 Completion of the Dual Systems and the Rise of the IND .................................................................................................. 21 Unification of the System ...................................................................................................................................................... 22 Post-World War II: Rise of the Automobile and the New York City Transit Authority ........................................................ 22 Fiscal Crisis ............................................................................................................................................................................ 24 A Lack of Focus and Investment .......................................................................................................................................... 25 Recent History: Another Slow Decline ................................................................................................................................. 25 SUBWAY ACTION PLAN .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 26 ACCURACY OF PERFORMANCE STATISTICS .............................................................................................................................................................. 28 A CRISIS OF CONFIDENCE – THE L TRAIN SHUTDOWN ............................................................................................................................................. 29 LOCAL TRANSPORTATION POLICY ................................................................................................................................... 30 A VISION FOR MUNICIPAL CONTROL ..................................................................................................32 GOVERNANCE ...................................................................................................................................................................... 33 Table of Contents 2 What’s Not Working ............................................................................................................................................................... 33 STRUCTURE OF THE MTA ................................................................................................................................................................................................ 33 MTA BOARD ....................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 34 Recommendation: Establish Big Apple Transit—the BAT ................................................................................................... 35 TRANSFER CONTROL OF THE SUBWAY AND BUSES TO THE CITY ......................................................................................................................... 35 BUILDING A BETTER BOARD .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 35 MOBILITY CZAR ................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 36 REGIONAL COOPERATION ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 36 OVERSIGHT ........................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 37 FISCAL TRANSPARENCY .................................................................................................................................................... 37 What’s Not Working ............................................................................................................................................................... 37 UNSUPPORTED DEBT AND CAPITAL ............................................................................................................................................................................. 37 DISTRACTED AND UNFOCUSED CAPITAL PLANNING PROCESS ............................................................................................................................ 38 Recommendation: Model BAT’s Structure on the City’s Water System ............................................................................ 39 ENSURE ADEQUATE FUNDING ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 40 OUTSIDE REVIEW
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Brooklyn Transit Primary Source Packet
    BROOKLYN TRANSIT PRIMARY SOURCE PACKET Student Name 1 2 INTRODUCTORY READING "New York City Transit - History and Chronology." Mta.info. Metropolitan Transit Authority. Web. 28 Dec. 2015. Adaptation In the early stages of the development of public transportation systems in New York City, all operations were run by private companies. Abraham Brower established New York City's first public transportation route in 1827, a 12-seat stagecoach that ran along Broadway in Manhattan from the Battery to Bleecker Street. By 1831, Brower had added the omnibus to his fleet. The next year, John Mason organized the New York and Harlem Railroad, a street railway that used horse-drawn cars with metal wheels and ran on a metal track. By 1855, 593 omnibuses traveled on 27 Manhattan routes and horse-drawn cars ran on street railways on Third, Fourth, Sixth, and Eighth Avenues. Toward the end of the 19th century, electricity allowed for the development of electric trolley cars, which soon replaced horses. Trolley bus lines, also called trackless trolley coaches, used overhead lines for power. Staten Island was the first borough outside Manhattan to receive these electric trolley cars in the 1920s, and then finally Brooklyn joined the fun in 1930. By 1960, however, motor buses completely replaced New York City public transit trolley cars and trolley buses. The city's first regular elevated railway (el) service began on February 14, 1870. The El ran along Greenwich Street and Ninth Avenue in Manhattan. Elevated train service dominated rapid transit for the next few decades. On September 24, 1883, a Brooklyn Bridge cable-powered railway opened between Park Row in Manhattan and Sands Street in Brooklyn, carrying passengers over the bridge and back.
    [Show full text]
  • Stuck at the Turnstile: Failed Swipes Slow Down Subway Riders
    STUCK AT THE TURNSTILE: FAILED SWIPES SLOW DOWN SUBWAY RIDERS A REPORT BY PUBLIC ADVOCATE BETSY GOTBAUM JUNE 2005 Visit us on the web at www.pubadvocate.nyc.gov or call us at 212-669-7200. Office of the New York City Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum Public Advocate for the City of New York PREPARED BY: Jill E. Sheppard Director of Policy and Research Yana Chernobilsky Jesse Mintz-Roth Policy Research Associates 2 Introduction Every seasoned New York City subway rider has swiped his or her MetroCard at the turnstile only to be greeted with error messages such as “Swipe Again,” “Too Fast,” “Swipe Again at this Turnstile,” or most annoying, “Just Used.” These messages stall the entrance line, slow riders down, and sometimes cause them to miss their train. When frustrated riders encounter problems at the turnstile, they often turn for assistance to the token booth attendant who can buzz them through the turnstile or the adjacent gate; however, this service will soon be a luxury of the past. One hundred and sixty-four booths will be closed over the next few months and their attendants will be instructed to roam around the whole station. A user of an unlimited MetroCard informed that her card was “Just Used” will have to decide between trying to enter again after waiting 18 minutes, the minimum time permitted by the MTA between card uses, or spending more money to buy another card. Currently when riders’ MetroCards fail, they seek out a station agent to buzz them on to the platform. Once booths close, these passengers will be forced to find the station’s attendant.
    [Show full text]
  • A Retrospective of Preservation Practice and the New York City Subway System
    Under the Big Apple: a Retrospective of Preservation Practice and the New York City Subway System by Emma Marie Waterloo This thesis/dissertation document has been electronically approved by the following individuals: Tomlan,Michael Andrew (Chairperson) Chusid,Jeffrey M. (Minor Member) UNDER THE BIG APPLE: A RETROSPECTIVE OF PRESERVATION PRACTICE AND THE NEW YORK CITY SUBWAY SYSTEM A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Cornell University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts by Emma Marie Waterloo August 2010 © 2010 Emma Marie Waterloo ABSTRACT The New York City Subway system is one of the most iconic, most extensive, and most influential train networks in America. In operation for over 100 years, this engineering marvel dictated development patterns in upper Manhattan, Brooklyn, and the Bronx. The interior station designs of the different lines chronicle the changing architectural fashion of the aboveground world from the turn of the century through the 1940s. Many prominent architects have designed the stations over the years, including the earliest stations by Heins and LaFarge. However, the conversation about preservation surrounding the historic resource has only begun in earnest in the past twenty years. It is the system’s very heritage that creates its preservation controversies. After World War II, the rapid transit system suffered from several decades of neglect and deferred maintenance as ridership fell and violent crime rose. At the height of the subway’s degradation in 1979, the decision to celebrate the seventy-fifth anniversary of the opening of the subway with a local landmark designation was unusual.
    [Show full text]
  • Reduced Fare Pass for Persons with Disabilities
    Application for NYC Ferry Reduced-Fare Ticketing Program for People with Disabilities Information Type or print in ink. Last Name First Name M.I. Street Address Apt./Unit No. City State Zip Code Daytime Telephone Birth Date Female Male Registered on Ferry App NYC Yes No Registered Email ALL INFORMATION WILL BE KEPT STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL. Mail Completed Application to: Mail : Ferry Hornblower Attn. Reduced Fare 110 Wall Street NewNYC York, NewOperated York 10005 by Drop off: 34th Street Ferry Terminal Ticket Booth: E. 35th Street & FDR Drive New York, New York 10016 Or Pier 11 Ticket Booth Pier 11, South Street New York, New York 10005 For supplementary information or additional copies of this Application please visit www. .nyc/ or contact Customer Service at Please allowferry three tReducedFareo five weeks for processing. 1-844-4NY-FERRY For assistance in filling out this application, please visit www.Ferry.nyc/ReducedFare or contact 1-844-4NY-FERRY Application for NYC Ferry Reduced-Fare Ticketing Program for People with Disabilities Information For All Applicants: The Ferry Reduced-Fare Ticketing Program provides the 30-Day Pass at a 50% discount rate. The Ferry by Hornblower Reduced-Fare Ticketing Program providesNYC reduced-fare Monthly Passes for persons with the following disabilities: • Receiving MedicareNYC benefitsOperated for any reason other than age • Serious mental illness (SMI) and receiving Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits • Blindness • H • Ambulatory disability • Lossard ofof bot Hearingh hands • Intellectual disability and/or other organic mental capacity impairment If you do not have one of these disabilities, you are not eligible for the Citywide Ferry Reduced- Fare Ticketing Program.
    [Show full text]
  • The Sanctuary of Prosecutorial Nullification 1/17/2020 3:02 Pm
    0239 AHMED, THE SANCTUARY OF PROSECUTORIAL NULLIFICATION 1/17/2020 3:02 PM THE SANCTUARY OF PROSECUTORIAL NULLIFICATION Zohra Ahmed* INTRODUCTION In the aftermath of the 2016 election, the shortcomings of existing sanctuary protections came sharply into focus.1 Historically, cities enacted sanctuary protections to extricate their law enforcement agencies from activities related to federal immigration enforcement. In sanctuary cities, local government agencies are typically restricted from sharing information with federal immigration authorities or from cooperating in apprehending individuals targeted for removal.2 After the White House issued an Executive Order (EO) in late January 2017, many immigrant rights advocates recognized that external facing policies that proscribed direct cooperation would not suffice.3 The EO announced that Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) would prioritize removing any undocumented person charged or convicted of a crime, no matter how serious.4 Recognizing the vital role state criminal courts play and would continue to play in fueling deportations, public defenders in New York City (“City”) identified a new actor with the power to enact stronger protections: the prosecutor.5 * Clinical Teaching Fellow, Cornell Center on the Death Penalty Worldwide, Cornell Law School, and member of 5 Boro Defenders. This Article is dedicated to the co-organizers of #nycdontprosecute campaign, in particular Rage Kidvai, Ying-Ying Ma and Madeline Porta, who hatched the plan for the campaign on the Sunday evening after the 2017 anti-inauguration protest in New York City, and to Naila Siddiqui, Alexandra Smith, Anna Ulrich and Alisha Williams who were each instrumental in sustaining the campaign. I am also grateful for Mary Ann Krisa, Jay Oddi, and the editors at the Albany Law Review for their editorial support.
    [Show full text]
  • LEGEND Location of Facilities on NOAA/NYSDOT Mapping
    (! Case 10-T-0139 Hearing Exhibit 2 Page 45 of 50 St. Paul's Episcopal Church and Rectory Downtown Ossining Historic District Highland Cottage (Squire House) Rockland Lake (!304 Old Croton Aqueduct Stevens, H.R., House inholding All Saints Episcopal Church Complex (Church) Jug Tavern All Saints Episcopal Church (Rectory/Old Parish Hall) (!305 Hook Mountain Rockland Lake Scarborough Historic District (!306 LEGEND Nyack Beach Underwater Route Rockefeller Park Preserve Rockefeller Park Preserve Rockefeller Park Preserve CP Railroad ROW Rockefeller Park Preserve Rockefeller Park Preserve CSX Railroad ROW Rockefeller Park Preserve (!307 Rockefeller Park Preserve Rockefeller Park Preserve NYS Canal System, Underground (! Rockefeller Park Preserve Milepost Rockefeller Park Preserve Rockefeller Park Preserve Rockefeller Park Preserve )" Sherman Creek Substation Rockefeller Park Preserve Rockefeller Park Preserve Methodist Episcopal Church at Nyack *# Yonkers Converter Station Rockefeller Park Preserve Upper Nyack Firehouse ^ Mine Rockefeller Park Preserve Van Houten's Landing Historic District (!308 Park Rockefeller Park Preserve Union Church of Pocantico Hills State Park Hopper, Edward, Birthplace and Boyhood Home Philipse Manor Railroad Station Untouched Wilderness Dutch Reformed Church Rockefeller, John D., Estate Historic Site Tappan Zee Playhouse Philipsburg Manor St. Paul's United Methodist Church US Post Office--Nyack Scenic Area Ross-Hand Mansion McCullers, Carson, House Tarrytown Lighthouse (!309 Harden, Edward, Mansion Patriot's Park Foster Memorial A.M.E. Zion Church Irving, Washington, High School Music Hall North Grove Street Historic District DATA SOURCES: NYS DOT, ESRI, NOAA, TDI, TRC, NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF Christ Episcopal Church Blauvelt Wayside Chapel (Former) First Baptist Church and Rectory ENVIRONMENTAL CONSERVATION (NYDEC), NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF PARKS RECREATION AND HISTORICAL PRESERVATION (OPRHP) Old Croton Aqueduct Old Croton Aqueduct NOTES: (!310 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Design a Subway Station Mosaic That Reflects Their Home Or School Neighborhood and Draw It
    MILES OF TILES MILES OF TILES BACKGROUND INFORMATION FOR TEACHERS “Design and aesthetics have been a part of the subway from the original stations of 1904 to the latest work in 2018. But nothing in New York stands still – certainly not the subway - and the approach to subway style has evolved, reflecting the major stages of the system’s construction during the early 1900s, the teens, and the late 20s and early 30s and the renovations and redesigns of later years. The earliest parts of the system still convey the flowery, genteel flavor of a smaller, older city. Later sections, by contrast, show a conscious turn toward the modern, including open admiration for the system’s raw structural power. The evolution of subway design follows the trajectory of the world of art and architecture as these came to terms with the Industrial revolution, and the tug-of-war between a traditional deference to European models and a modernist ideology demanding an honest expression of contemporary industrial technology.” —Subway style: 100 years of Architecture & Design in the New York City Subway New York City, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, was an industrial hub attracting many Americans from rural communities looking for work, and immigrants looking for better lives. It was, however, blighted by impoverished neighborhoods of broken down tenements and social injustice. The city lacked a plan for how it should look, where structures should be built, or how services should be distributed. It was described as a ‘ragged pincushion of towers’ with no government regulation over the urban landscape.
    [Show full text]
  • Bilingual Education for All!
    52 Free things to do in new York May 2019 established 1986 NewyorkFamily.com Hilaria Baldwinon marriage to Alec, w w w their four kids, . newyorkfamily and parenting authentically . c o m BilinguAl educAtion for All! THE PERFECT CAMP TO FIT YOUR SUMMER PLANS Preschool + Junior Camps • Sports Academy Gymnastics • Ninja Parkour • Golf • Basketball Elite Soccer • Ice Hockey • Ice Skating Urban Adventure for Teens JUNE 17 - AUGUST 30, 2019 Flexible Weeks Hot Lunch Provided Transportation & Aftercare Available Waterslide • Color Wars • Gymnastics Shows Kayaking • Golf Trips • Bowling • Skating Shows Hockey Games • Cruises & much more! EARLY BIRDS: Register by May 17 + Save! chelseapiers.com/camps May 2019 | newYorkfamily.com 3 contents MaY 2019 newyorkfamily.com pg. 12 pg. 32 pg. 64 pg. 52 pg. 38 62 | giving Back FEATURES columns Help Feed Kids in Need. Donate to this City Harvest fund-raiser that 38 | the Juggle is real For hilaria 6 | editor’s note helps feed New york’s children Baldwin May Flowers Hilaria Baldwin gets real with us 74 | Family day out about being a mom to four under five 8 | Mom hacks Harry Potter Café. Step into Steamy and her passion for healthy living Shopping experts The Buy Guide share Hallows in the East Village with this their mom must-haves for city living fun pop-up café full of wizardly 44| Bilingual education guide wonder New york City kids have many 12 | ask the expert - keeping girls options for a bilingual education, we in sports have the ultimate guide to finding the Dr. Karen Sutton talks about why hoMe &
    [Show full text]
  • Lawsuit Does Not Seek to Challenge His Conviction of Insider Trading
    Case 1:20-cv-08803-AKH Document 1 Filed 10/22/20 Page 1 of 52 CORNELIUS P. MCCARTHY (CM-3544) CHEHEBAR DEVENEY & PHILLIPS 485 Madison Avenue Suite 1301 New York, New York 10022 Tel.: 212-532-8204 Fax: 212-753-8101 E-mail: [email protected] PIERCE O’DONNELL (PO-5724) GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN & MACHTINGER LLP 2049 Century Park East, Suite 2600 Los Angeles, California 90067 Telephone: 310.553.3610 Fax: 310.553.0687 Email: [email protected] Attorneys for Plaintiff William T. Walters UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK -------------------------------------- X WILLIAM T. WALTERS, : Case No. 20-CV-8803 Plaintiff, : COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND -against- : DECLARATORY RELIEF PREETINDER BHARARA, DAVID : CHAVES, GEORGE VENIZELOS, RICHARD JURY TRIAL DEMANDED ZABEL, TELEMACHUS KASULIS, DANIEL : GOLDMAN, and DOES 1-50, INCLUSIVE, Defendants. -------------------------------------- X Plaintiff William T. Walters (“Walters” or “Plaintiff”), by and through his undersigned counsel of record, hereby alleges as follows: 92101-00002/3876779.18 Case 1:20-cv-08803-AKH Document 1 Filed 10/22/20 Page 2 of 52 INTRODUCTION 1. This case involves corrupt and illegal conduct by individual members of the U.S. Department of Justice in direct violation of Plaintiff William “Billy” Walters’ fundamental constitutional rights. It is no secret that, for years, federal law enforcement agents have used members of the media to promote their investigative agenda through illegal leaks of confidential information. This is the rare case in which the Department of Justice (“Department” or “DOJ”)—after first falsely denying the existence of any such leaks in court papers—was forced to admit on the eve of an evidentiary hearing that illegal leaks had occurred.
    [Show full text]
  • Amazon's Document
    REQUEST FOR INFORMATION Project Clancy TALENT A. Big Questions and Big Ideas 1. Population Changes and Key Drivers. a. Population level - Specify the changes in total population in your community and state over the last five years and the major reasons for these changes. Please also identify the majority source of inbound migration. Ne Yok Cit’s populatio ge fo . illio to . illio oe the last fie eas ad is projected to surpass 9 million by 2030.1 New York City continues to attract a dynamic and diverse population of professionals, students, and families of all backgrounds, mainly from Latin America (including the Caribbean, Central America, and South America), China, and Eastern Europe.2 Estiate of Ne York City’s Populatio Year Population 2011 8,244,910 2012 8,336,697 2013 8,405,837 2014 8,491,079 2015 8,550,405 2016 8,537,673 Source: American Community Survey 1-Year Estimates Cumulative Estimates of the Components of Population Change for New York City and Counties Time period: April 1, 2010 - July 1, 2016 Total Natural Net Net Net Geographic Area Population Increase Migration: Migration: Migration: Change (Births-Deaths) Total Domestic International New York City Total 362,540 401,943 -24,467 -524,013 499,546 Bronx 70,612 75,607 -3,358 -103,923 100,565 Brooklyn 124,450 160,580 -32,277 -169,064 136,787 Manhattan 57,861 54,522 7,189 -91,811 99,000 1 New York City Population Projections by Age/Sex & Borough, 2010-2040 2 Place of Birth for the Foreign-Born Population in 2012-2016, American Community Survey PROJECT CLANCY PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL 4840-0257-2381.3 1 Queens 102,332 99,703 7,203 -148,045 155,248 Staten Island 7,285 11,531 -3,224 -11,170 7,946 Source: Population Division, U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • COMPETITIVE PUBLIC CONTRACTS Eric M. Singer INTRODUCTION
    COPYRIGHT © 2016, VIRGINIA LAW REVIEW ASSOCIATION COMPETITIVE PUBLIC CONTRACTS Eric M. Singer* INTRODUCTION .................................................................................... 1298 I. THE GOVERNMENT’S CONTRACT-REMEDIES PROBLEM ................. 1305 A. Background ............................................................................ 1305 B. The Problem with Money Damages ....................................... 1310 C. The Problem with Vendor Screening and Oversight ............. 1314 D. The Problem with Relational Contracts. ............................... 1319 II. COMPETITIVE DUAL SOURCING AS CONTRACT ENFORCEMENT ..... 1322 A. Competitive Dual Sourcing Explained .................................. 1322 B. Variations .............................................................................. 1326 1. Geographic Division ....................................................... 1326 2. Operational Division: New York Subway ....................... 1328 3. Division by Competition: First Transcontinental Railroad ........................................................................... 1330 4. Temporal Division ........................................................... 1332 5. Substitution ...................................................................... 1335 6. Variations in Shifting Mechanisms.................................. 1336 C. Competitive Dual Sourcing versus Performance Bonds ....... 1338 III. IMPLEMENTING COMPETITIVE DUAL SOURCING ............................ 1342 A. Agent Incentives ....................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • The Backbone of the Metropolis How the Development of Rapid Transit Determined the Becoming of the New York City Metropolis
    The Backbone of the Metropolis How the development of rapid transit determined the becoming of the New York City Metropolis. History Thesis By: Pieter Schreurs Student number: 1090526 Email: [email protected] Telephone: 31(0)6-21256096 Tutor: Prof.Dr. Franziska Bollerey Date: July 2008 Cover image: “The Subway”, by George Tooker 1950, Egg tempera on composition board, Collection of Whitney Museum of American Art Source: “Subway City; Riding the trains, reading New York”; Brooks, 1997 The Backbone of the Metropolis How the development of rapid transit determined the becoming of the New York City Metropolis. History Thesis By: Pieter Schreurs Student number: 1090526 Email: [email protected] Telephone: 31(0)6-21256096 Tutor: Prof.Dr. Franziska Bollerey Date: July 2008 Image 1: The Network of Parkways. In the 1920s and 30s Robert Moses developed and intricate network of park ways around New York City. These were designed for the Joy of driving. Source: “The Power Broker”; Caro, 1975 4 Introduction Grade separated urban rapid transit and the metropolis: knowledge of what is in between this location and the previous one. users underground and re-emerge them to completely different parts of the city, without According to James Crawford, “…Transport technology has always affected both the growth and form of cities, and each new transport mode has left its stamp on urban form. When a New York, New York: new model is adopted, existing urban areas are forced into new uses and ever new forms and new development is arranged in accordance with the demands and capabilities of the In researching the development of rapid transit systems in relation to the development new mode...“ (Crawford, 2000, p.
    [Show full text]