42604486.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Soft Power in International Relations: Japan's State, Sub-state and Non-state Relations with China (Volume 1) Utpal Vyas A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of East Asian Studies, University of Sheffield September 2006 Abstract The term `soft power', coined by JosephNye in his 1990 Foreign Policy article of the same title, has been cited by academics, politicians and the mass media with varying degreesof confusion and hype. To some the term has meant the influence of Hollywood film culture around the world; to others, it refers to the economic power exerted by Western countries. In most cases, soft power has been associatedwith nation states and their national interests. However, for many people, the term is a vague conceptwith no real meaning. In order to develop a more precise view of soft power, this thesis begins with an examination of how power has been conceived of in international relations, by reviewing the main historical schools of thought in the field, i. e. the Realist, Liberalist, Critical and Constructivist schools. It then goes on to propose a theory of soft power basedupon Constructivist ideas. To test the application of this conceptualisation of soft power, this study addressesthe case of Japan's post-war relations with China, utilising analyses of three agentsof Japan's soft power. Firstly, at the state level, the activities of the Japan Foundation in China are investigated. Secondly, at the sub-statelevel, Kobe City's sister city relationship with Tianjin City, and its relations with other cities in China, are considered. Finally, at the non-governmental level, the activities of the Japan-ChinaFriendship Association are examined.Through an analysis of soft power at the state, sub-state and non-state levels, this thesis aims to provide a deeper understandingof soft power, and Japan's international relations as an example of its application. Contents List diagrams of .......................................................................... vii Acronyms and abbreviations...................................................... viii Acknowledgements .......................................................................x Note text on ................................................................................. xi Volume 1 Chapter 1 Introduction I ................................................................................ Introduction 1 ................................................................................................. The face in international 2 changing of power relations ................................. Soft in the 5 power as a new concept global system.................................... .. Japan its China 6 and relations with ............................................................... The in international 14 relevance of non-state actors relations ...................... Research hypotheses 14 questions and ........................................................ Three-level 16 agent comparison structure and methodology ....................... State in Japan 17 a) agents ................................................................... Methodology for Chapter 4 19 .................................................................. b) Sub-state in Japan 20 agents ............................................................ Methodology for Chapter 5 21 .................................................................. Non-state in Japan 22 c) agents ............................................................ Methodology for Chapter 6 25 .................................................................. Contributions this thesis 25 of ........................................................................ Structure the thesis 27 of ............................................................................... 1 Chapter 2 Power in international 30 relations ............................................... Introduction 30 ............................................................................................... General definitions of 31 power...................................................................... Theories interaction 34 of power and state .................................................... Realism Neo-realism 35 and .......................................................................... Sources in 36 a) of power realism ......................................................... b) Types 40 of power use....................................................................... Effects Realist theory 41 c) of power ..................................................... Liberalism Neo-liberalism 44 and ................................................................... a) Sources in Liberalism 45 of power ..................................................... b) Types in Liberalism 48 of power use ................................................. Effects Liberalist ideas 50 c) of of power ............................................... i) Individualism, Cooperation Institutionalisation 50 and ........................ ii) International Political Economy interdependence 53 and ................... Critical theories 59 ......................................................................................... Sources in theories 61 a) of power critical ............................................. b) Types 62 of power use....................................................................... Effects the international 63 c) of power on system ................................ Constructivism 67 ........................................................................................... Sources 68 a) of power.......................................................................... b) Types 69 of power use....................................................................... c) Effects 71 of power use ..................................................................... Conclusions 74 ............................................................................................... Chapter 3 Soft is it how does it function? 79 power: what and ................... What is 81 soft power?................................................................................... How is 88 soft power created and utilised? .................................................... Sources 89 a) of soft power ................................................................... i) Cultural 89 attractiveness................................................................... ii) The ideas ideology 91 attractiveness of and ...................................... iii) Economic 93 attractiveness ...............................:............................... b) Agents 93 of soft power ..................................................................... i) Central its 94 government and agencies............................................ 11 ii) Regional Local 97 and governments .................................................. iii) Non-state NGOs businesses 98 organisations: and .......................... Means instrumentalising 101 c) of soft power....................................:... i) Mass 101 media and communications............................................... ii) Movement 106 of people.................................................................... Effects 108 ..................................................................................................... The limits in foreign 114 of soft power policy.................................................. Illiberal 116 a) regimes .......................................................................... b) Poverty 117 and remoteness............................................................. Constructivism as a theoretical basis for the understanding 118 of soft power............................................................................................ Japan 124 as an example of soft power use .................................................. Conclusions 131 .......................................:..................................................... Chapter 4 The the Japan Foundation in China 133 activities of .................. Introduction: 133 state-level use of soft power ............................................... The Establishment the Japan Foundation 135 of ............................................ The Purpose the Japan Foundation 142 of .................................................... The Japan Foundation China 149 and ........................................................... Japanese Language Japan Studies 155 a) and ..................................... i) Preparatory School, Changchun 155 ................................................. ii) Beijing Centre for Japan Studies 158 ................................................. iii) Books translated, and original research at the Beijing Centre for Japanese Studies 161 ........................................................................ iv) Secondary Primary School Teachers 163 and ................................... Language Test Proficiency 164 v) -Japanese of ...................................... Japanese language textbooks 165 vi) and other materials ..................... b) Cultural Activities 167 ....................................................................... i) Television Film 167 and ...................................................................... ii) Live Performances Exhibitions 170 and ............................................. Seminars Conferences 174 iii) and ........................................................