IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE
DATED THIS THE 25 TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2014
PRESENT
THE HON’BLE MR.D.H.WAGHELA, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ASHOK B.HINCHIGERI
WRIT PETITION No.42743 OF 2012 (PIL-LB-BMP) AND WRIT PETITION Nos.29393-29531 OF 2013 AND WRIT PETITION Nos.46496-46718 OF 2014 C/W REVIEW PETITION No.265 OF 2013
W.P.Nos.42743/2012 AND 29393–29531/2013 AND W.P. Nos.46496-46718 OF 2014
BETWEEN
1. Smt. Shantha Mary, W/o David Raja Aged about 42 years No.24, 12th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
2. Smt. Ammu W/o Ravi Sharavana Aged about 36 years No.33, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
3. Sri Krishnan Nair, S/o Gopala Pillai Aged about 64 years, No.33, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
4. Sri Chinna Thai W/o Palani Aged about 42 years No. 22, 4 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
2
5. Smt. Jaya Mary W/o Louis Aged about 48 years No. 30, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047.
6. Smt. Hansar Begum W/o Kalam Aged about 36 years No. 17, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
7. Smt. Mary Marget W/o Sabastin Aged about 42 years No. 33, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
8. Smt. Prameela Pandy W/o Pandy V N Aged about 42 years No.21, 2 nd Block EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
9. Smt. Shakila W/o Yakoob Aged about 40 years No. 20, 24 th Block EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
10. Fakruddin S/o Shabuddin Aged about 35 years No. 33, 37th Block EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore-560047
11. Smt Vajravelu S/o K G Gurumurthy
3
Aged about 61 years No.20, 10 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
12. Sri Ramesh Peter S/o Babu Aged about 31 years No.67, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
13. Smt. Vani W/o Mahendra Aged about 43 years No.25, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
14. Smt.Ghouarjan W/o Sardar Aged about 52 years No.17, 3 rd Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
15. Sri Alla Bakhash S/o Abdul Munaf Aged about 53 years No.21, 1 st Block, 28 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
16. Smt. Lily W/o James Aged about 63 years No.16, 32 nd Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
17. Smt. Lalitha W/o Kaliyappan Aged about 41 years
4
No.09, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
18. Sri Jamal S/o Shaik Mohaddin Aged about 58 years No.20, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
19. Smt. Namita Devi W/o Amar Singh Aged about 32 years No.35, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
20. Smt. Rani W/o Durai Swamy Aged about 44 years No.6, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore-560047
21. Smt. Shantha W/o Vijaya Kumar Aged about 42 years No.3, 3 RD Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
22. Smt. Gulnaz Begum W/o Altaf Aged about 34 years No.31, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
23. Smt. Madhu W/o Jaya Prakash Aged about 28 years No.33, 8 th Block,
5
EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
24. Smt. Shanthi W/o Sunder Raj Aged about 45 years No.30,2 nd Floor, 23 rd Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
25. Smt. Reehana W/o Asgar Ali Aged about 38 years No.29, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters Koramangala Bangalore – 560 047
26. Smt.Rizwana W/o Mubarak Aged about 31 years No.19, 9 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
27. Smt.Regina W/o Anthony Simon Aged about 51 years, No.18, 21 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
28. Smt.Selvi W/o Elangovan, Aged about 46 years, No.36, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
29. Sri Sunder S/o Suthandam Aged about 45 years, No.25, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
6
30. Sri R.P.Pandey S/o Late K.S.Pandey Aged about 46 years, No.5, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
31. Sri Zaheer Ahamad S/o Ameer Jan Aged about 38 years, No.31, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
32. Smt.Pushpa W/o Jaishila, Aged about 55 years, No.15, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
33. Erudaya Raj S/o Jagri Yas Aged about 38 years, No.13, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
34. Smt.Naseema Banu W/o Khaium Pasha Aged about 27 years No.12, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
35. Sri Elumalai S/o Chenna Swamy, Aged about 31 years, No.31, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
7
36. Smt.Gajalakshmi W/o late Govaran Aged about 62 years, No.17, 1 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
37. Sri Rajamani W/o Vediyappan Aged about 50 years, No.14, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
38. Sri Farooq H/o Gulnaz Aged about 48 years No.12, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
39. Smt.Jayarani W/o Utari Das Aged about 37 years, No.21, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
40. Sri Bala Subramaniyan S/o Narayana Aged about 43 years, No.13, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
41. Smt.Arokiya Mary W/o George, Aged about 51 years, No.31, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
8
42. Smt.Asma W/o Maqsood Ali Aged about 38 years, No.29, 10 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
43. Sri Muthaiya S/o Krishnaswamy, Aged about 37 years, No.12, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
44. Smt.Manjula W/o A G Patil Aged about 35 years No.10, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
45. Smt.Yasmin Taj, W/o Naim Pasha, Aged about 35 years, No.33, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
46. Sri Seena Alias Srinivas S/o Muttu Aged about 34 years, No.5, 1 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
47. Smt.Savithramma W/o Krishnappa Aged about 63 years, No.11, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
9
48. Sri Michael S/o Madurai Aged about 52 years, No.34, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
49. Smt.Vasantha W/o Subramani Aged about 55 years, No.3, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
50. Smt.Parvathy W/o late Mohan Aged about 51 years, No.4, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
51. Smt.Jham Mery W/o Kanik Raj Aged about 37 years, No.23, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
52. Smt.Cristaina W/o Tamilselwam Aged about 31 years No.2. 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
53. Smt.Zareena Taj W/o Illyaz Aged about 37 years, No.22, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
10
54. Sri Ranjeeth S/o Chandeshwarsing Aged about 32 years No.15, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
55. Smt.Catharin Rajeswari W/o Late Barnad Aged about years No.12, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
56. Smt.Mary Basalica W/o John Joseph Aged about 32 years No.23, 165 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
57. Smt.Bhagamma W/o Perumal Aged about 38 years No.12, 39 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
58. Smt.Mehamunnisa W/o Khan F.K Aged about 42 years, No.22, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
59. Smt.Lakshmy W/o Frady, Aged about 52 years, No.8, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
11
60. Smt.Bhanupriya W/o Pradeep Kumar, Aged about 22 years, No.32, 22 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
61. Smt.Mary Lisa W/o Robert Aged about 37 years, No.2, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
62. Smt.Hasina Begum W/o Syed Zahiruddin Aged about 32 years, No.4, 23 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
63. Smt.Uma W/o Anthony, Aged about 32 years, No.18, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
64. Smt.Yasmin W/o Ibrahim Basha Aged about 45 years No.9, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
65. Smt.Maheswary W/o Arun Kumar Aged about 30 years, No.07, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
12
66. Smt.Saraswati W/o Mukesh Pandi Aged about 43 years, No.28, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
67. Smt.Hafija Begum W/o Remathulla Aged about 58 years, No.2, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
68. Smt.J.Rani W/o Raja Ram Aged about 42 years, No.16, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
69. Smt.Ayesha W/o Syed Babu Aged about 35 years, No.7, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
70. Smt.Savithri W/o Balakrishna Aged about 47 years, 15, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
71. Smt.Shabana W/o Z Ahmed Aged about 31 years, No.14, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
13
72. Sri Syed Farooq S/o Ameer Jan Aged about 43 years No.27, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
73. Smt.Jabeena Begum W/o Late Ismail Aged about 30 years, No.24, 23 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
74. Smt.Gulnaz Begum W/o Iliyaz Khan Aged about 36 years, No.1, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
75. Smt.Saraswathi W/o Nagaraj Aged about 34 years No.35, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
76. Smt.T.Violet Mary W/o Thomas Aged about 46 years No.31, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
77. Sri Ansar Khan S/o Ramahulla Khan Aged about 36 years No.2, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
14
78. Sri Jesentha W/o late Anthony Aged about 35 years, No.33, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
79. Smt.Prema W/o Babu Aged about 50 years, No.25, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
80. Sri Ramesh S/o Das Aged about 34 years No.4, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
81. Sri Aalam Pasha S/o Abdul Khadar Age of 54 years No.11, 4 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
82. Smt.Dilsad W/o Basheer Aged about 29 years, No.23, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
83. Smt.Kannamma W/o Selva Raj Aged about 42 years No.35, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
15
84. Smt.Saroja W/o Satish Aged about 42 years No.26, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
85. Smt.Rukmini W/o Rajamanikam Aged about 43 years, No.13, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
86. Smt.Rosy W/o ISAAC Aged about 55 years, No.16, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
87. Sri Sirajuddin S/o Syed Ibrahim Aged about 44 years, No.10, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
88. Smt.Vani Krishna Murthy S/o Sunderraj Aged about 38 years, No.25, 3 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
89. Smt.Pushpa W/o Peter Aged about 45 years, No.1, 4 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
16
90. Smt.Jesinthamary W/o Sagayaraj Aged about 25 years, No.12, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
91. Smt.Ragini W/o Dass Aged about 37 years, No.27, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
92. Smt.Gowri W/o Vijaykumar Aged about 47 years, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
93. Sri Murugan S/o Kanyappa Aged about 31 years, No.13, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
94. Smt.Udaya Kumari W/o Samuel Sunder Raj Alias Babu Aged about 53 years, No.20, 11 th Block EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
95. Smt.Theresa W/o Steefan Aged about 58 years, No.32, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
96. Smt.Nandarani Singh W/o Ramanuj Singh
17
Aged about 65 years, No.28, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
97. Smt.Mallika W/o Ashok Aged about 34 years No.11, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
98. Smt.Manjula W/o Kumar Aged about 36 years, No.04, 5 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
99. Smt.Shabeena Begum W/o Nazeer Ahmed Aged about 45 years, No.30, 10 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
100. Mary W/o George, Aged about 60 years, No.20, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
101. Smt.Kursheed W/o Sabjan Aged about 49 years, No.23, 6 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
102. Sri K.Mani S/o Kannan Aged about 30 years
18
No.33, 5 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
103. Sri Babu S/o Daniyal, Aged about 34 years, No.36, 5 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
104. Smt.Sagayamary, W/o Shan Mugam Aged about 46 years, No.17, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
105. Smt.Rathna, W/o Mariswamy, Aged about 43 years, No.31, 30 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
106. Sri M.S.Muthu S/o Michael, Aged about 49 years, No.13, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
107. Sri Srinivas, S/o Raja, Aged about 31 years, No.09, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
108. Sri K.Swamy Gowda, S/o Kale Gowda, Aged about 46 years, No.17, 14 th Block,
19
EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
109. Smt.Lakshmi W/o Suresh Aged about 47 years, No.14, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
110. Sri Sunder.S, S/o Ramamurthy, Aged about 43 years, No.30, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
111. Smt.Lakshmi, D/o Rabin, Aged about 40 years, No.26, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
112. Smt.Flora, W/o Denzel, Aged about 39 years, No.27, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
113. Smt.Sundara Velu, S/o Narayana Swamy, Aged about 55 years, No.18, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
114. Smt.Lilly, W/o Patrick, Aged about 75 years, No.21, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters,
20
Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
115. Smt.Sirin, W/o Mohammad Khaleem Aged about 35 years, No.31, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
116. Smt.Jayanthi, D/o Patrick, Aged about 18 years, No.27, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
117. Sri Mohammad Hussan, S/o Gulam Hasmad, Aged about 38 years, No.7, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore, South Range, Karnataka - 560 047,
118. Sri Lalitamma W/o Rudra Muniyappa Aged about 46 years, 22, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
119. Smt.Kannamma, W/o Palani Swamy, Aged about 54 years, No.18, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
120. Smt.Mary W/o Pushpa Raj, Aged about 55 years, No.22, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
21
121. Smt.Vijayalakshmi, W/o Govinda Raj, Aged about 78 years, No.1, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
122. Smt.M.Jagadammal, S/o Jagadisan, Aged about 61 years, No.1, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
123. Sri Mohammad Rafi, S/o Shek Aminuddin, Aged about 64 years, No.9, 23 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
124. Smt.Klara, W/o Arul Raj, Aged about 31 years, No.14, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
125. Smt.Manjula, W/o Sunder, Aged about 42 years, No.33, 1 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
126. Smt.Daras Kutty, W/o Kutty, Aged about 28 years, No.5, 22 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
22
127. Rani, D/o Vangi Raj, Aged about 40 years, No.28, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
128. Smt.Bhuvaneshwari, W/o Ruban Aged about 37 years, No.24, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
129. Smt.Kalyani, W/o Daniyal, Aged about 36 years, No.27, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
130. Smt.Lakshmi W/o Naveen Aged about 44 years, No.25, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
131. Smt.Parveen Taj, W/o Nisarath Khan, Aged about 41 years, No.35, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
132. Uttari Das, S/o Louis, Aged about 45 years, No.7, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
23
133. Smt.Lakshmi, W/o Vincent, Aged about 36 years, No.26, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
134. Sri Junid Ali, S/o Abdul Ali, Aged about 56 years, No.24, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
135. Sri Vijay R. S/o Ramaswamy, Aged about 37 years, No.8, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
136. Smt.Rani, W/o Lawrence, Aged about 37 years, No.26, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
137. Smt.A.Shanti, S/o D.S.Rajan, Aged about 46 years, No.23, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
138. Smt.M.Jayalakshmi, W/o Maltesh, Aged about 35 years, No.17, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
24
139. Smt.Amuda, W/o Sehdil Kumar, Aged about 28 years, No.21, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
140. Smt.Lakshmi, W/o Venkatesh, Aged about 33 years, No.4, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
141. Smt. Gowri W/O Anbu Aged about 35 years No. 3 Ground floor 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 1st Main, Slum board Quarters, L.R. Nagar, Bangalore-560047
142. Smt. Kamala W/O Gunashekar Aged about 55 years No. 26 First floor 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 1st Cross, Slum board Quarters, L.R. Nagar, Bangalore-560047
143. Smt. Papamma W/O C.Rok Aged about 86 years No. 12 Ground floor 6th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 18, Jayaraj Nagar, Austin Town, Bangalore-560047
25
144. Sri. Joseph Kumar S/O Ambrose Aged about 54 years No. 36, 3 rd Floor, 18 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047 Present Address 4th Cross, Rajendra Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
145. Smt.Farzana Khanam W/O Abdul Khadar Aged about 41 years No. 5, Ground floor, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
146. Smt. Hamsaveni W/O Gopi Chandar Aged about 45 years No. 1, Ground floor 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 8th Cross, 9 th Main, Ejipura, Bangalore-560047
147. Smt. Mary Ailina W/O Shiva Aged about 33 years No. 27, 2 nd floor 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 5th Cross, Anepalya, Neelasandara, Bangalore-560047
148. Smt. Anuradha. W/O Krishna Murthy.N Aged about 37 years No. 2, Ground floor, 1st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
149. Smt. Vanitha W/O Palaniswamy Aged about 32 years
26
No. 20, First floor 7th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 6th Cross, Rajendranagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 85, 4 th Cross, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore-560047
150. Smt. Surya W/O Balaram Aged about 41 years No. 16 First floor 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 1st Main, Rajendra Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
151. Sri. Michal S/O Siman Aged about 47 years No. 12, Ground floor, 18 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
152. Smt. Devika W/O Ashok Kumar Aged about 45 years No. 22, First floor 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
153. Manjula W/O T. Neharu Aged about 36 years No. 11, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
154. Smt. Azeez Unnisa W/O Farida Khan MK
27
Aged about 39 years No. 28, 2 nd floor 39 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
155. Sri. Manohar. N.R S/O Rajulu.NN Aged about 53 years No. 23,14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
156. Smt. Tabasum W/O Altahaf Pasha Aged about 29 years No. 20, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
157. Smt. Kala W/O Jansa Aged about 35 years No. 3, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 10 th Cross, Anepalya, Neela Sandra, Bangalore-560047
158. Smt. Bhagya W/O Mohan Aged about 45 years No. 8, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No.1, 5 th Cross, Ejipura, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore-560047
159. Sri. Srinivas S/O Raja Aged about 43 years No. 9, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, Near EWS Land, 80 ft Road, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
28
160. Smt. Manjula W/O Kumar Aged about 38 years No. 4, 5 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, Near EWS Land, 80ft Road, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
161. Smt. Violet W/O Jhon Aged about 40 years No. 5, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
162. Sri. Kamal S/O Purushotham Aged about 32 years No. 30, 2 nd Floor, 8 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
163. Sri. Edwin S/O Anthony Aged about 41 years No. 14, first Floor 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
164. Smt. Vasanthy W/O Raja Aged about 38 years No.18, First Floor, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
165. Smt. Nirmala W/O Ravi Aged about 41 years No.26, 2 nd floor, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
166. Smt. Shanthi W/O Annayappa Aged about 42 years No. 17, First Floor, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
29
Present Address Foot Path, Near EWS Land, 80ft Road, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
167. Smt. Irudaya Mary W/O Yesudass Aged about 36 years No. 16, First Floor, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, Near EWS Land, 80 ft Road, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
168. Smt. Eeshamma W/O Ramu Aged about 29 years No. 13, First Floor, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
169. Smt. Jayamma W/O Prakash Aged about 38 years No. 10, 39 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Garve Bhavi Palya, Hosur Main Road, Bangalore
170. Sri. Alexander.L S/O Lourd.G Aged about 41 years No. 30, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
171. Sri. Noel Banu. B S/O Bernad, Late Aged about 31 years No. 22, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
172. Smt.Rama Bai.T A W/O Ashok.T Aged about 49 years No. 12, 30 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
30
Present Address No.11, Samatha Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
173. Smt. Ayisha Bi W/O Mohamad Ali Aged about 50 years No. 31, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 18 th Cross, Laxmanrao Nagar Vivek Nagar Post, Bangalore-560047
174. Smt. Jayasheela W/O Chandra Shekar Aged about 60 years No. 22, 18 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
175. Smt. Rakalya W/O Jamal Ahamad Aged about 35 years No. 32, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
176. Smt. Elisabeth W/O Sada Aged about 40 years No. 13, 39 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
177. Smt.Christy S/O Wiliam Aged about 46 years No. 27, 1 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
178. Smt.Uma W/O Krishna Murthy Aged about 33 years No. 6, 21 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
31
Present Address 5th Cross, Anepalya, Neelasandra, Bangalore-560047
179. Smt. Jayamma W/O Subbarao Aged about 64 years No. 2, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
180. Sri. Rajendra S/O Adekappan Aged about 37 years No. 18, 9 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 663, 7 th Main, 9 th Cross, Rajendra Nagar, Bangalore-560047
181. Sri. Mohamad Yunisa S/O Fazil.N Aged about 40 years No. 22, 23 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Marenahally, EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
182. Smt. Manjula W/O Surya Babu Aged about 48 years No. 14, 32 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No.5, 1 st Main Road, Laxmanrao Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
183. Smt. Vathsala W/O Ranjith Kumar Aged about 26 years No. 18, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Garve Bhavi Palya Hosur Road, Bangalore.
32
184. Smt.Zahudunissa W/O Ameer Jan Aged about 55 years No. 1, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
185. Sri.Imthias S/O Syed Mohamad Aged about 48 years No. 3, 5 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 67, 1 st Cross, Laxmanrao Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
186. Smt. Biyathu W/O Shafi Aged about 35 years No. 34, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 7, 1 st Block, Chodasandra Sarjapur Road, Bangalore
187. Sri.Muralidharan. T D S/O Durai Raj Aged about 37 years No. 33, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
188. Smt. Nafeesa Begam W/O Mohamad Zaheer Aged about 40 years No. 7, 18 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendra Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
33
189. Sri. Venu S/O Penchalia Aged about 39 years No. 33, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Slum Board Buildings, Kaigondana halli Sarjapura, Bangalore
190. Smt. Ammu W/O Prashantha Aged about 28 years No. 2, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, in front of EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
191. Smt. Chinnamma W/O Muniramappa Aged about 70 years No. 5, 21 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, in front of EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
192. Smt. Stella Jones W/O Christoper Aged about 29 years No. 13, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
193. Smt.Mubeena W/O Ansar Pasha Aged about 38 years No. 22, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path Next to Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
194. Sri.Rabert Kennady S/O Das
34
Aged about 35 years No. 31, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 348,3 rd floor, 2 nd Cross, 2nd Main Road, Rajendra Nagar Bangalore-560047
195. Smt. Stella W/O Johnson Aged about 31 years No. 24, 8 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, in front of EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
196. Sri. Noor Pasha S/O Ibrahim Aged about 36 years No. 9, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendra Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
197. Smt. Anjali D/O Muniyappa Aged about 41 years No. 9, 6 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, Next to Samatha Nagar Slum, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
198. Smt. Shataj Begam W/O Ilias Pasha Aged about 50 years No. 6, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No.74, South East Estate, Fathiya Galli, Neelasanadra, Bangalore-560047
35
199. Smt. Arogya Mary W/O Lucas Aged about 36 years No. 29, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 7th Cross, Ejipura, Opp Musjit Vivek Nagar post, Bangalore-560047
200. Sri. Manoj. D S/O Dhanraj Aged about 44 years No.36 , 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Srinivagilu, Ejipura, Bangalore-560047
201. Sri. Kanika Swamy S/O Anthony Aged about 49 years No. 9, 4 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 5th Cross, Laxmanrao Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
202. Sri. Mohamad Hanif S/O Abdul Gani Aged about 63 years No. 4, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Papaina bagh, Neelasandar, Bangalore-560047
203. Smt. Reshma Bee W/O Shek Mohamad Ajiz Aged about 36 years No. 9, 6 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
204. Smt.Marina D/O Kanika Swamy
36
Aged about 27 years No. 10, 4 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendra Nagar, Vevek Nagar Post, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
205. Sri. Akash S/O Venkatraj Aged about 36 years No. 30, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Battery Pension Line, Vivek Nagar Post, Bangalore-560047
206. Smt.Zarina Taj W/O Mohamad Dastagir Aged about 40 years No. 4, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Guropana Palya, Bannaragatta Road, Bangalore
207. Sri. Rajendra S/O Vaianan Aged about 40 years No. 12, 8 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 3, Second Floor, Marena Halli, Next to EWS Land, Bangalore-560047
208. Smt. Mumtaj W/O Jabbar Khan Aged about 40 years No. 14, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
209. Sri. Lawrence. A D S/O Danial Aged about 58 years No. 33, 22 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
37
210. Smt. Mary Vani.K W/O Yesu Dass Aged about 40 years No. 31, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
211. Smt. Pushpa W/O Purushothama Aged about 50 years No. 13, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
212. Smt. Gaja Lakshmi W/O Gavaranna. Late Aged about 67 years No. 17, 9 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
213. Smt. Shanthi W/O Mohan Aged about 38 years No. 7,11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 10 th Cross, Laxmanrao Nagar, Bangalore-560047
214. Smt. Uma Rani W/O Annamalai Aged about 42 years No. 8, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendra Nagar, 80 ft Road, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
38
215. Smt. Parvathi W/O Subramani Aged about 50 years No. 5, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendra Nagar, 80 ft Road, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
216. Sri. Selva S/O Thomas Aged about 51 years No. 29, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
217. Sri. Balan S/O Sampangi Aged about 48 years No. 2, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
218. Smt. Mary.D D/O Dass Aged about 60 years No. 35, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
219. Smt. Neelamma W/O Raju Aged about 62 years No. 13, 42 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
39
220. Sri. Armugam S/O Dorai Raj Aged about 41 years No. 29, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
221. Smt. Thulasi W/O Kumar Aged about 65 years No. 32, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ejipura, Vevek Nagar, Bangalore-560047
222. Smt. Sheela .L W/O Prabhakar Aged about 43 years No. 9, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rose Garden, Neelasandra Bangalore-560047
223. Smt. Jyothi W/O Devaraj Aged about 60 years No. 11, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
224. Smt. Fathima W/O Alim Aged about 35 years No. 16, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road,
40
Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
225. Smt. Sandana Mary W/O Poul Raj Aged about 47 years No. 8, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
226. Smt. Devi Rajan. S W/O Selvaraj. A Aged about 35 years No. 41, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 12 th Main, Rajendra Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
227. Smt. Jesy W/O Guna Aged about 55 years No. 23, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
228. Smt. Shataj Begam W/O Syed Muthaf Aged about 40 years No. 12, 22 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
229. Sri. Anwar S/O Syed Hasse Aged about 50 years No. 10, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
230. Smt. Parveen Taj W/O Agaa Khan Aged about 41 years No. 32, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, Next to Ambedkar Nagar, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
41
231. Smt. Meena Martin W/O Jhon Manohar Aged about 56 years No. 22, 3 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
232. Smt. Hajira Banu W/O Syed Anwar Aged about 24 years No. 15, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
233. Smt. Sameena W/O Anwar Aged about 41 years No. 9, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
234. Smt. Malar W/O Babu Dead by her LR Ms. Vanitha, Aged about 18 years No. 11, 6 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
235. Sri. Anwer Pasha. Late S/O Abdul Wahab Dead by his Daughter Ms. Mahirunnisa, Aged about 33 years No. 32, 18 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
236. Smt. Varalakshmi. Late W/O Kubendran Dead by her LR Smt. Kanthamma, Aged about 42 years, No.12, 28 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047.
Present Address A Street, Bove line, Ashok Nagar, Bangalore-560047
42
237. Smt. Mustari W/O Sardar Aged about 41 years No. 35, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Foot Path, in front of EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
238. Smt. Shasi Kala W/O Selva.M Aged about 30 years No. 30, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address: No. 52, 5 th Cross, 5 th Cross, Viveknagar Ext, Bangalore-560047
239. Sri. Amir Khan S/O Mohamad Usman Aged about 14 years No. 2, 30 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047.
240. Smt. Martha W/O Jhon J Aged about 40 years No. 6, 2 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ejipura Main Road, Ejipura Viveknagar Post, Bangalore-560047
241. Smt. Baslica Mary W/O Bimal Krishna Mandal Aged about 29 years No. 25, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Behind Vasan Eye Care, 80 ft Road, Koramangala, Bangalore-560030
242. Smt. Anjali W/O Thangavelu Aged about 21 years
43
No. 4, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address On Footpath in front of EWS land Koramangala Bangalore-560047
243. Smt. Mallika Begum W/O Late Abdul Khalil Aged about 70 years No. 1, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Yelagondapallya Austin Town, Bangalore-560047
244. Smt. Jayanthy W/O Venkatesh Aged about 40 years No. 22, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 12 th Cross, Rajendra Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
245. Smt. Kasiyamma W/O Shanmugham Aged about 51 years No. 6, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
246. Sri. Late Anwar Pasha represented by his son Sri Chandpasha Aged about 35 years No. 35, 28 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Neelsandra, Bangalore-560047
247. Sri. Meghavan S/O Marakanaiah
44
Aged about 67 years No. 12, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Maranahalli, Koramangala, Next to EWS Land Bangalore-560047
248. Smt. Meghala W/O Selva Aged about 34 years No. 8, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047.
Present Address No. 5, Muniyappa Garden Neelsandra, Bangalore-47
249. Smt. Selvi W/O Narayana N Aged about 40 years No. 3, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 7, 7 th Cross, Rose Garden, Bangalore-560047
250. Smt. Late Rose Mary represented by her son Sri Anand Raj Aged about 37 years No. 2, 23 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address On Footpath in front of EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
251. Smt. Shamima Banu W/O Mohammed Farok Aged about 41 years No. 32, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Near Anganwadi, 1 st Cross, 2 nd Main, Farooqnagar, Bagranpura Mysore Road, Bangalore
45
252. Smt. Lakshmi W/O Jagdish Aged about 35 years No. 9, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047 Present Address No. 306, Outhouse, BDA Flat, Neelsandra Austin Town
253. Smt. Anthony Mary represented by her daughter Smt. Guna Prabha w/o Steven Pinto Aged about 34 years No. 35, 9 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047 Present Address Sarjapura
254. Smt. Shahin Taj W/O Galil Baig Aged about 38 years No. 2, 30 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Bomanahalli Garvebavipallya, Bomanahalli, Bangalore
255. Smt. Shobha E. W/O Edwin Aged about 35 years No. 24, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rose Garden, Neelsandra, Bangalore-47
256. Sri. Syed Saif S/O Syed Abdul Rehman Aged about 39 years No. 4, 42 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Neelsandra, Bangalore-47
46
257. Sri. Upendra G W/O Gajendra Aged about 23 years No. 16, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Corporation Quarters, Marenhalli, Bangalore-47
258. Smt. Nayeenmunnisa W/O Mohammed Shaukath Aged about 40 years No. 7, 6 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Neelsandra, Bangalore-47
259. Smt. Shanshad Begum W/O Chandpasha Aged about 40 years No. 15, 32 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxman Rao Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
260. Smt. Zareena W/O Syed Riyaaz Aged about 36 years No. 30, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxman Rao Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
261. Smt. Shakira W/O Syed Anwar Aged about 51 years No. 35, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendranagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
47
262. Smt. Manjula W/O Jayakumar Aged about 36 years No. 5, 31 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Samtha Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-47
263. Smt. Sunitha W/O Jayaram Aged about 34 years No. 3, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Near Ravi Depo, Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
264. Smt. Kuppamal W/O Mani Aged about 57 years No. 31, 22 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rose Garden, Neelsandra, Bangalore-47
265. Smt. Vennila W/O Velu Aged about 40 years No. 15, 6 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Vannerpet, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore-47
266. Smt. Aiesha W/O Ayub Khan Aged about 37 years No. 27, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
48
Present Address No. 241, 9 th Cross, 7 th Main, Shastri Nagar, Rajendranagar Bangalore-47
267. Smt. Ragina W/O M. Anthony Aged about 42 years No. 26, 1 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Narayanappa Cross, N Naganahalli Arabi College Post, Yelhanka Bangalore
268. Smt. Pushpa W/O Kumar Aged about 37 years No.26, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Near Mir Masjid, Neelsandra, Bangalore-47
269. Smt. Selvam M S/O Michael Aged about 37 years No.6, 6 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address On Footpath, Near EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-47
270. Smt. Kumari W/O Gurumurthy Aged about 40 years No. 3, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rose Garden, Neelsandra, Bangalore-47
49
271. Sri. Anand M S/O Late Muniswamy Aged about 46 years No. 14, 41 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ganesha Temple Cross, MS Nagar Old Bayapanhalli, Bangalore
272. Smt. Kalyani W/O Chandrashekhar Aged about 56 years No. 9, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 11 th Cross, Rajendranagar Bangalore-47
273. Smt. Poomani W/O Kannan Aged about 33 years No. 13, 3 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address New No. 62 (Old No. 101), Battery pension Line Maya Bazar, Viveknagar Post Bangalore-560047
274. Sri. George S/O James Aged about 31 years No. 1, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore - 560047
275. Sri. Parveez S/O Farooq Aged about 35 years No. 18, 18 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
50
Present Address Rajendranagar, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
276. Smt. Farida W/O Mohammed Noor Aged about 39 years No. 2, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Neelsandra Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
277. Smt. Jayalakshmi (A) Vijayalakshmi W/O Venkatesh Aged about 54 years No. 35, 21 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar Vivek Nagar Post, Bangalore-560047
278. Smt. Sujatha W/O Sundar V Aged about 30 years No. 6, 22 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar Vivek Nagar Post, Bangalore-560047
279. Smt. Shaheena W/O Noorulla M Aged about 47 years No. 19, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 14 th Cross, Anepalya Bangalore-560030
280. Sri. Shakeel Ahmad S/O Abdul Jameel Aged about 43 years No. 15, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
51
Present Address Mangammapalya, Bomanhalli Bangalore
281. Sri. Raju S/O Gowtham Aged about 51 years No. 12, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 3/4, Lady Curzon Road, Near Bowring Hospital Shivajinagar, Bangalore
282. Smt. Shahaz Begum W/O S Sharif Aged about 55 years No. 20, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Neelasandra, Bangalore-560047
283. Smt. Haryna W/O Devanasana Aged about 42 years No. 28, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Devarikara, Bangalore-95
284. Smt. Lilly W/O Kanikaraj Aged about 44 years No. 3, 3 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Corporation Quarters Bangalore
285. Smt. Geetha W/O Raghu Aged about 45 years No. 7, 40 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
52
Present Address No. 298, Opp BDA Complex Neelsandra Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
286. Smt. Munni W/O Naseer Mohammed Aged about 36 years No. 32, 3 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Fatian Galli, Near Gulshan Shalimar Neelsandra, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
287. Smt. Naseera W/O Mohammed Ferodin Aged about 26 years No. 35, 1 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 5th Cross, Rajendranagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
288. Smt. Manjula W/O Satish Aged about 40 years No. 15, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendranagar Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
289. Smt. Sayamma KM W/O Malayadri Aged about 43 years No. 19, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
290. Smt. Kavitha W/O Sudhakar Aged about 35 years No. 7, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
53
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
291. Sri. Jayaram S/O Perumal Aged about 33 years No. 32, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ejipura, Viveknagar Post Bangalore - 560047
292. Smt. Clara W/O Stanley Aged about 39 years No. 31, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address On Footpath, Near EWS Land Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
293. Sri. Janardhan GB S/O Jayamma V Aged about 35 years No. 30, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ejipura, Viveknagar Post Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
294. Sri. Suresh Babu S/O Krishna Aged about 51 years No. 34, 16 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ejipura, Viveknagar Post Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
295. Sri. Ravi A S/O Anjappa Aged about 40 years No. 7, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
54
Present Address Slum Board Buildings, Kaigondana halli Sarjapura, Bangalore
296. Sri. K Mayavan S/O Kuppuswamy Aged about 34 years No. 25, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 19 th Cross, Rajendranagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
297. Smt. Arul Swamy S/O Michael Aged about 43 years No. 32, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Shivajinagar, Bangalore
298. Smt. Gunalakshmi W/O Sharvana Kumar Aged about 42 years No. 28, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Samtha Nagar, 80 ft Road Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
299. Smt. Latha W/O Gunashekhar Aged about 32 years No. 5, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
300. Smt. Mariam Begum W/O Meer Kuthubuddin Aged about 33 years No. 34, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
55
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
301. Smt. Hamida Begum W/O Arif Pasha Aged about 31 years No. 31, 39 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
302. Smt. Lalitha W/O Babu Aged about 42 years No. 16, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Vannarpet, Viveknagar Post Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
303. Smt. Kasthuri W/O Albert Aged about 47 years No. 18, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address BPL Stop, Near Hope Farm Circle Whitefield, Bangalore
304. Smt. Prema Cicilia AJ W/O Shekhar K Aged about 41 years No. 15, 1 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Mahadevapura Bangalore
305. Smt. Hasina Begum W/O Riyazuddin Aged about 47 years No. 2, 9 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
56
Present Address Samtha Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
306. Smt. Jayatheresa W/O Arogyaswamy Aged about 88 years No. 32, 23 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ashok Nagar Bangalore
307. Smt. Maimanissa W/O Allah Baksh Aged about 44 years No. 19, 8 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No 140, 7 th Cross, Rajendranagar, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
308. Smt. Nancy R W/O Xavier Aged about 28 years No. 24, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rose Garden, Neelsandra Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
309. Smt. Jayamary W/O Hari J Aged about 62 years No. 3, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Near Neelasandra Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
310. Smt. Shahtaj W/O Riyaz Sharif Aged about 39 years No. 27, 42 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
57
Present Address A-3, 30, Slum Board Buildings, Kaigondana halli Sarjapura, Bangalore
311. Smt. Latha S W/O Srinivasan Aged about 28 years No. 7, 28 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Vannerpet, Viveknagar Post Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
312. Smt. Shameen Taj W/O Saleem Khan Aged about 44 years No. 16, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Slum Board Buildings, Kaigondana halli Sarjapura, Bangalore
313. Smt. Vijaylakshmi W/O Satyanandhan Aged about 32 years No. 1, 2 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address On Footpath, Near EWS Land Koramanagala, Bangalore-560047
314. Sri. Venkatesh M S/O Muniyappa Aged about 34 years No. 10, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address On Footpath, Near EWS Land Koramanagala, Bangalore-560047
315. Smt. Uma W/O Ashok Aged about 35 years No. 21, 24 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
58
Present Address HAL, Vimanapura Post, Bangalore
316. Smt. Lakshmi W/O Babu Aged about 41 years No. 31, 8 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Bayapanhali, Bangalore
317. Sri. Akber Shariff S/O Sattar Shariff Aged about 71 years No. 9, 41 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Laxmanrao Nagar, Opp. Government Hospital Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
318. Smt. Safia Begum W/O Salauddin Khan Aged about 55 years No. 30,7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendranagar, Bangalore-560047
319. Sri. Harihara Pande S/O Rajkumar Pande Aged about 73 years No. 22, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 2/2, 1 st Corss, Vannerpet, Viveknagar Post Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
320. Smt. Jayalakshmi W/O Kanakaraj Aged about 49 years No. 35, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
59
Present Address Slum Board Buildings, Kaigondana halli Sarjapura, Bangalore
321. Smt. Lakshmamma W/O Mani Aged about 56 years No. 13, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Near Viveknagar Bus Stop, Viveknagar Post Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
322. Sri. Androse S/O Pushparaj Aged about 43 years No. 11, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Anepalya, Neelsandra, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
323. Smt. Late Rajalaxmi represente by her son Sri Dileep Kumar Aged about 23 years No. 23, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Vannerpet, Viveknagar Post, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
324. Smt. Jasinta W/O Vijayan Aged about 27 years No. 12, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Srirampura, Bangalore
325. Smt. Susai Mary W/O Anand Aged about 54 years No. 33, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
60
Present Address Vannarpet, Viveknagar Post, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
326. Smt. Elizabeth Daisy W/O Prabhu M Aged about 28 years No. 6, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Vannarpet, Viveknagar Post, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
327. Smt. Bavani W/O Kumar Aged about 29 years No. 10, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar,Koramangala Bangalore-560047
328. Smt. Annai Pushpam W/O Clarence Pinto Aged about 36 years No. 35, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address HAL, Bangalore
329. Smt. Amalarakine W/O Elija Abraham Aged about 37 years No. 34, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Tannery Road, Bangalore
330. Smt. Rose W/O Ravi Aged about 45 years No. 4, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
61
Present Address Foot Path, 80 ft Road, Near EWS Land, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
331. Smt. Devamma W/O Basavaraju Aged about 38 years No. 27, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Koramagala Last Stop Bangalore-560047
332. Smt. Saraswathi W/O S R Jagadish Aged about 45 years No. 32, 4 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Marenahalli Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
333. Smt. Shashikala W/O Rajanna Aged about 45 years No. 10, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Near Shiva Theatre Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
334. Smt. Papamma W/O Lakshman Aged about 60 years No. 33, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
335. Sri. Kodhandan S/O Mani Aged about 52 years No. 28, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
62
Present Address, Austin Town, Bangalore
336. Sri. Pandit S/O Peruman Aged about 53 years No. 13, 26 nd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Austin Town, Bangalore
337. Smt. Venkatamma W/O Gajendra Aged about 45 years No. 22, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Corporation Quarters Bangalore
338. Smt. A Shanthi W/O Ashok Aged about 40 years No. 9, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Victoria Layout, Near Austin Town Bangalore
339. Smt. Lakshmi W/O Ramesha Aged about 28 years No. 34, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Mareppa Garden, Viveknagar Bangalore
340. Sri. Ranjeet Kumar S/O Chandreshwar Singh Aged about 32 years No. 15, 36 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Door No. 308, 11 th Cross, 13 th Main Rajendranagar, Bangalore - 560047
63
341. Smt. Devika W/O Sampath Aged about 36 years No. 34, 34 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendranagar, Koramangala, Bangalore - 560047
342. Smt. Jessi W/O Mani Aged about 42 years No. 23, 20 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 46, Bharathi, Vannerpet, Viveknagar Post Bangalore- 560047
343. Smt. Gulab John W/O Chotesahab Aged about 50 years No. 7, 9 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address On Footpath, Opposite EWS Land, Viveknagar Post Bangalore- 560047
344. Sri. C Vajrevelu (late) Represented by his son Sri Sunil Kumar Aged about 34 years No. 21, 39 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 6, Ambedkar Nagar, Viveknagar Post Bangalore - 560047
345. Smt. Selvi, Late W/O Ramu Represented by her son Sri Ravi Kumar Aged about 25 years No. 1, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
64
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar, Viveknagar Post Bangalore - 560047
346. Smt. Komala W/O Sarvanna Aged about 33 years No. 16, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Near Infant Jesus Church, Viveknagar Post Bangalore- 560047
347. Smt. Lakshmi W/O Shekar Aged about 30 years No. 1, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 8, Maya Bazaar, Vannerpet, Viveknagar Post Bangalore - 560047
348. Smt. Geetha W/O Raju Aged about 42 years No. 6, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 23, Maya Bazaar, Vannerpet, Viveknagar Post Bangalore - 560047
349. Sri. Pavadai Chettiyar S/O Vaithiyalingu Chettiyar Aged about 60 years No. 6, 18 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Mareppa Garden, Viveknagar Bangalore - 560047
350. Sri. Sanjeev Kumar Pandey S/O R P Pandey Aged about 30 years No. 6, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
65
Present Address A2-29, Slum Board Buildings, Kaigondana halli Sarjapura, Bangalore
351. Sri. Anthony Raj S/O Jhon Anthony Aged about 37 years No. 10, 26 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 13 th Cross, Laxman Rao Nagar, Koramangala, Bangalore- 560047
352. Smt. Gayathri W/O Ravi S Aged about 37 years No. 17, 7 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 7th Main, 4 th Cross, Rajendranagar, Koramangala, Bangalore- 560047
353. Smt. Shamshada W/O Kalik Basha Aged about 51 years No. 14, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address 7th Cross, Rajendranagar, Koramangala Bangalore- 560047
354. Smt. Gayathri W/O Karthikeyan Aged about 34 years No. 6, 14 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 339, 12 th Cross, Rajendranagar, Koramangala Bangalore- 560047
355. Smt. Salamma W/O E Srinivas
66
Aged about 55 years No. 17, 13 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore- 560047
356. Sri. R Vasudevan S/O M Raju Aged about 43 years No. 6, 27 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore- 560047
357. Smt. Saraswathi W/O Ganesh Aged about 39 years No. 36, 19 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore - 560047
358. Sri. V K Pande S/O Rama Nayak Aged about 37 years No. 30, 28 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 6, Opposite Ravi Depot, 4 th Main Garden Ambedkar Nagar, Koramangala Bangalore - 560047
359. Smt. Bhanumathi W/O Shanmugham Aged about 45 years No. 4, 29 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore-560047
Present Address No. 16, 1 st Cross, 2 nd Main, Ejipura, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore - 560047
67
360. Smt. A Kumari W/O Ananda Aged about 35 years No. 32, 35 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
Present Address Austin Town, Viveknagar Post Bangalore- 560047
361. Sri. Mahadeva S/O Muniyappa Aged about 53 years No. 30, 37 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendranagar, Koramangala Bangalore- 560047
362. Smt. Gangamma W/O Venkatesh Aged about 63 years No. 18, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
Present Address Rajendranagar, Koramangala Bangalore- 560047
363. Smt. Varalakshmi W/O Sagayiraj Aged about 40 years No. 11, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore-560047
Present Address Samtha Nagar, Adjacent to EWS land, Viveknagar Post Bangalore- 560047
(Petitioner Nos.141 to 363 impleaded vide Court order, dated 19.9.2014) … Petitioners
(By Sri S.Sunil Dutt Yadav, Advocate)
68
AND:
1. State of Karnataka, Represented by its Secretary, Housing & Urban Development Department, Bangalore – 560 001.
2. Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagara Palike, Represented by its Commissioner, N.R.Square, Bangalore – 560 002.
3. Maverick Holding & Investment(P) Ltd., A Company registered under the Companies Act-1956, having its Office at No.78/1, New K.R.Road, Basavanagudi, Bangalore – 560 002.
4. Economically Weaker Section’s Residential Welfare Association, (A registered Association), No.12, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by its General Secretary, Mr.P.S.Dass.
5. Sri Daniel Richard, S/o T.Daniel, Aged about 52 years, Opp. Sri Kumarans’ High School, Ramamurthynagar, Bangalore – 560 016.
6. Sri S.Govindraj, S/o Sundaram, Aged about 56 years, No.37/4, Bazar Street, Neelasandra, Bangalore – 560 047.
7. Smt.K.Kodhanatchi, W/o M.Vishnumurthy, Aged about 72 years, No.89, 19 th ‘A’ Cross, Buchappa Road, Ejipura, Bangalore – 560 047.
8. Smt.K.Ushadevi, W/o Arumainathan,
69
Aged about 52 years, No.89, 19 th ‘A’ Cross, Butchappa Road, Ejipura, Bangalore – 560 047.
9. Smt.K.Saravani, W/o Deva Sagayam, Aged about 45 years, No.D-340, 4 th Lane, East Ring Road, ITI Colony, Dooravani Nagar, Bangalore – 560 016.
10. Smt.Saraswathy, D/o Arjun Rao, Aged about 60 years, No.57-B, Rudrappa Garden, Vivekanagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
11. Sri Keshavelu, S/o Raghvalu, Aged about 64 years, No.57-B, Rudrappa Garden, Vivekanagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
12. Smt.Fathima, Aged about 73 years, House No.22, Block No.14, EWS Corporation Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
13. Sri D.Arul, S/o Late David, Aged about 63 years, 7th Main Road, 2 nd Cross, 2nd Stage, Rajendranagar, Vivekanagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
14. Sri G.Shanmugam, S/o M.Gopal, Aged about 58 years, House No.21, Block No.18, EWS Compound, Kormangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
70
15. Sri S.Marian Alfred, S/o late T.John, Aged about 54 years, Door No.151, Old Cement Lane, Austin Town, Bangalore – 560 047.
16. Sri K.Shivanna, S/o Kupanna, Aged about 61 years, No.65, 17 th Cross, 3 rd Stage, Ambedkarnagar, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
17. Sri S.John Dass, S/o C.Savarimuthu, Aged about 53 years, No.65, 17 th Cross, 3rd Stage, Ambedkarnagar, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
18. Smt.Queeni, W/o late K.James, Aged about 50 years, No.27, 2 nd Main, Ambedkarnagar, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
19. Smt.Savithramma, W/o Rajanna, Aged about 61 years, No.143, M.M.Garden, Neelasandra, Bangalore – 560 047.
20. Smt.Nabesabi, W/o Aneef, Age Major, Flat No.36, Block No.41, EWS Compound, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
21. Smt.K.Usha, D/o Chikkavenkittappa, Aged about 46 years, No.6, Ramaswamy Road, Sudama Nagar, Bangalore – 560 027.
71
Represented by her GPA Holder K.Sundaramurthy, S/o Karupaiah, Aged about 39 years, No.9, L.No. 7 th Street, Ashok Nagar, Bangalore – 560 025.
22. Smt.Devi.M, W/o Varadaraj, Aged about 53 years, No.22(3), 5 th Cross, Magadi Road, Bangalore – 560 023.
23. Sri P.M.Rajendran, S/o Pitchakkaran, Aged about 41 years, C/o Namakali Transport, 2nd Cross, 1 st Main, N.T.Pet, Bangalore – 560 002. Represented by Smt.D.Susaimary, W/o late Stanislas Raj, Aged about 58 years, No.1694, BDA C-23, Austin Town Layout, Bangalore – 560 047.
24. Sri C.Sigamani, S/o Narayana, Aged about 54 years, No.45/5, 4 th Cross, Ayyappa Block, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder, V.Krishnaswamy, S/o Veeranna Shetty, Aged about 57 years, House No.33, Block No.1, EWS Corposration Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
25. Smt.Menaka Gopala, W/o Gopalan, Aged about 70 years, No.A/136, 1 st Cross, Magadi Road, Bangalore – 560 023. Represented by her Power of Attorney holder,
72
Mrs.Josephine Felicita, C/o Mrs.Lilly Roslin, Aged about 48 years, No.1602, Block No.49, 3rd Stage, BDA Austin Town Layout, Bangalore – 560 047.
26. Sri R.Rameshkumar, Aged about 58 years, No.2, Corporation Quarters, Barlley St.Cross, Shantinagar, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Smt.Channammal, W/o M.Velu, Aged about 60 years, No.8, Block No.42, EWS Corporation Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
27. Sri P.Velu, S/o late Ponnuswamy, Aged about 58 years, No.59, Mackan Road, Bangalore – 560 001. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder G.Sampath Rajan, S/o Gunasekharan, Aged about 51 years, No.W Type House No.57, HMT Colony, Bangalore – 560 031.
28. Sri Janaki Ram.M, S/o late Muniswamy, Aged about 56 years, No.128, Seppings Road, Bangalore – 560 001. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Sri G.Sampath Rajan, S/o Gunasekharan, Aged about 51 years, No.W Type House No.57 HMT Colony, Bangalore – 560 031.
29. Smt.Khurshid Unnisa, D/o Sri Mohammed Ghouse,
73
Aged about years, No.23, ‘C’ Road, 11 th Cross, H.M.Road, Padarayanapura, Bangalore – 560 026. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Sri A.Devirajan, S/o Selva Rajan, Aged about 35 years, No.13, Appu Mutrition, Veerasandra, Industrial Estate, 19Km., Hosur Road, Bangalore – 560 058.
30. Sri.S.Ravi, S/o Sampangi, Aged about 47 years, No.13, Balaya Naidu Street, Vannarpet, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder, Smt.M.Pushpa, W/o Murugesh, No.17, Block No.30, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
31. Sri N.Vijayakumar, S/o Nitesh Kumar, Aged about 51 years, No.24, Dispensary Extension, Kalasipalyam, Bangalore – 560 002. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Smt.Jameela Begum, D/o Mohd. Ghouse, Aged about 40 years, No.14, 1 st Floor, Block No.23, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
32. Sri Imthiaz Basha, S/o Dastagir Sab, Aged about 47 years, Peer Boundary, Cotton Pet Main Road, Bangalore – 560 053.
74
Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Sri A.P.Robert, S/o F.Anthony, Aged about 66 years, No.22/7, Nadagatta, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
33. Sri K.Ramesh, Aged major, Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Smt.A.Shanthi, House No.6, Block No.39, EWS Quarters, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 043.
34. Sri P.V.Thiruimurugan, No.52, M.M.Road, Doddigunda, Cox Town, Bangalore – 560 005.
35. Smt.Pushpa Jayanthi, W/o Jagannath, Aged about 32 years, Ejipura Main Road, Bangalore.
36. Sri Udaya Subyan.K, No.33, London Street, Yellegunde Palyam, Bangalore.
37. Sri C.Moola Kondaiah, No.42/1, Ambedkar Nagar, 2nd Stage, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
38. Smt.Rosy Marry, D/o Zakiras, No.59, Masjid Street, Muniswamy Garden, Anepalya, Neelasandra, Bangalore – 560 047.
39. Sri Rajamani, S/o Venugopal, No.119, 4 th Cross, Viveknagar Extension, Bangalore – 560 047.
75
40. Sri A.M.Shivalingam, S/o Motaiah, No.40, Old Cement, Austin Town, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
41. Smt.Manjula, W/o Shivalingaiah, No.12, Block No.38, EWS Quarters, Bangalore.
42. Sri K.Sundara Murthy, Represented by GPA Mrs.Bharathi Venkata Rao, No.30, Corporation EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
43. Sri Aslam Khan, S/o Sri Ameer Jan, No.14, Old Kasi Road, Bangalore – 560 002.
44. Smt.Chandra, S/o Narayan Swamy, No.240, 5 th Cross, Austin Town, Bangalore – 560 047.
45. Sri Ravi, S/o Thangaraj, No.12, 7 th Cross, Sonnenahalli, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore.
46. Smt.Saraswathi Amma, W/o Sri Balakrishna, No.8, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
47. Smt.Geetha, W/o B.Shekhar, No.7, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
48. Smt.Devika Jagannath Pille, W/o Jagannath Pille, No.9, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
76
49. Smt.Rani, W/o Jagannath Pille, No.9, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
50. Sri Deivaraju.K, S/o Kolandai Swamy, No.83, 2 nd Cross, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
51. Smt.Suguna Das, W/o Das, Opp.Rama Temple, Dekappa Compound, Eejipura, Bangalore.
52. Smt.Shahajadi Begum, W/o Anwar Beg, No.22, East Street, Neelasandra, Bangalore.
53. Sri M.Velu, S/o Murugesh, No.84, 2 nd Cross, Sonnenahalli, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore.
54. Smt.Sharadamma, W/o Jeevarathnam, No.13, S.M.Road, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
55. Smt.Meena.S., LR of Sri Venkittaiah, Aged about 68 years, House No.35, Block No.41, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
56. Smt.E.Pramila, Aged about 43 years, W/o Bhaktachalam, House No.27, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
57. Smt.Irudhyamary, Aged about 55 years, W/o L.Arokiadass, House No.21, Old Block No.22,
77
EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
58. Sri S.Ravi, Aged about 47 years, S/o D.Swamy, House No.13, Old Block No.26, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
59. Sri S.Feroz, Aged about years, S/o Abdul Jaffar, House No.8, Old Block No.23, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
60. Smt.Ratnamma, Aged about 38 years, W/o late Kothanda, House No.16, Old Block No.38, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
61. Sri M.Keshavalu, Aged about 61 years, S/o Bothaiah, House No.25, Old Block No.10, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
62. Smt.Shivashanthi, Aged about 58 years, W/o late Shivakumar, House No.4, Old Block No.36, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
63. Smt.Meenakshi.R., Aged about 24 years, W/o late Pushpa, House No.14, Old Block No.36, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
64. Sri M.Venkitesh, Aged about 38 years, S/o Marappa, House No.13, Old Block No.15,
78
EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
65. Smt.Amuda Dass, Aged about years, House No.11, Old Block No.38 EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
66. Sri Ramachandran, Aged about years, House No.34, Old Block No.34, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
67. Smt.Bharathi, W/o late Dhanbhadur Aged about 60 years, House No.8, Old Block No.7, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
68. Bangalore Development Authority, Represented by Secretary, Chowdaiah Road, Kumara Park West, Bangalore.
(Amended Vide Court order dated 9.6.2014)
69. Mrs.B. Lalitha Aged 48 years, W/o. Vijayakumar 172, Jayaraj nagar A street Vivek Nagar Bangalore 560 047.
70. Mrs.Elizebeth Aged 73 years, W/o. Late. Devadass No34, K No3rd Street, Asok Nagar Bangalore 560 025.
71. Mrs.Rehana Begum Aged 55 years, W/o. Abdul Basheer S No 1061, 7 th A Main 3rd Block, Koramangala Bangalore 560 034.
79
72. Mrs.R.Vijayanthimala Aged 51 years, d/o. Raju No. 2, 14th Cross, Dolluglappa Block, Vivekanagar Post, Egipura Bangalore – 47.
73. Mrs.B. Latha Aged 38 years D/o. Boreth Ram No61, 1 st Main, John Bull Street Vivek Nagar, Bangalore 560 047.
74. Mr.Balraj Aged 67 years S/o. Mottiah, No. 4/1, 1 st Cross, Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
75. Mr.Yogedra N Aged 52 years S/o. Nagaraj, 1615, 18 th Main, 40 th Cross, 4th T Block Jayanagar, Bangalore 560 079.
76. Mrs.Sampath Rani, Aged 64 years, W/o. B.V. Govindaraj, No;330, 28 th Block, C.P.W Quarters, Koramangala Bangalore 560 034.
77. Mrs.Susan Caroline Raj Aged 56 years, W/o. Selvaraj. No1 7 th aCross A.R. Road Ejipura Bangalore -47.
78. Mr.K. Selvaraj. Aged 58 years, S/o. Muniswami Gulam Malli No253, lock HUDCO Police Quarters, Bangalore 560 034.
79. Mr. Syed Ijaz sha Legal Heir of Late. Sardar Sha. Aged 29 Years, No:78, Gundappa Street, 1st Cross, Neelasandra Bangalore 560 047.
80
80. Mrs.Mary Margaret. Aged 56 years W/o. S. Victor Ambrose 26-25/1 A Naryanapura Extn: Near M.E.G Lay Out, Indira Gandi Street Bangalore 560 016.
81. Mr.Gregory Robert. Aged 52 years, S/o. John Lawrence, No2, 6 th Cross, Bazar Street, Rose Garden, Neelsandra, Bangalore 560 047.
82. Mrs.Hellen Mari. Aged 75 years, W/o. Late. Sandya Vadase, No2, 6 th Cross,Bazar Street, Rose Garden Neelsandra Bangalore 560 047.
83. Mr.Syed Habib. Aged 53 years, S/o. S.Abdul Samad, No 56 M.S Garden South Street Cross, Neelsandra Bangalore 560 047.
84. Mr.Alexander. Aged 45 years, S/o. Late.C.S Paul. No3, 1 st Floor, Gundanahalli, Marathahalli Post, Bangalore 560 037.
85. Mr.Thirumala. Aged 54 years, S/o. Kalimuthu, No60, 3 rd Cross, Viveknagar Post Bangalore 560 047.
86. Mrs.Rajamani. Aged 60 years, W/o. Venkataraman, No:1, Muni Marappa Street, A.T. Halli, Shanthi Nagar, Bangalore 560 027.
81
87. Mr.Santosh Legal Heir of Late Tilaka, S/o. Kuppan, Aged 22 years, Door No 61, 1 st Main Road, John Bull Street, Vivek Nagar Bangalore 560 047.
88. Mrs.Vasantha. Aged 57 years, W/o. Subramani. No 1535, 4 th Cross, 3 rd Stage. B.D.A Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
89. Mr.J.P. Srinivasilu. Aged 57 years, S/o. Late. D Pappiah, No:521, Rachappa Garden. Shanthinagar, Bangalore 560 027.
90. Mr.J. Christopher. Aged 58 years, S/o. J. Joseph No 992, Block A27, Austin Town B.D.A Flats Neelsandra Bangalore-560 047.
91. Mr.D. Kannan. Aged 56 Years, S/o. Dhanapaul, No278, 1 st Floor. P.W.D Quarters Bangalore 560 027.
92. Mr.M. Kumaresh. Aged 49 Years, S/o.Murughesh. No New 574, No372. K.S Garden, 3rd Cross, Lalbagh Road Bangalore 560 027.
93. Mr.Rajamanikkam. Major. S/o. Radhakrishnan. Balwin Girls High School Richmond Road, Bangalore 560 025.
82
94. Mr.Raju. Aged Major. S/o. Kuppan. 52 5 th Cross Anappalaya, Adugodi, Bangalore
95. Mr. Ilyaz Khan. Aged 43 Years, S/o. Majid Khan, Old No 14, New No42, Mariamma Koil Street, Neelasandra, Bangalore 560 047.
96. Mr.Kalaidurai.P Aged about 63 Years S/O. Ponnuswami, 103, 6 th Main, 4 th Block, 2nd Phase, Girinagar, Bangalore 560 085.
97. Smt. Asmath. Aged 55 Years, W/o. Nazeer Ahmed, 17/1, Rahman Manzil, 3 rd Cross, Anappalaya, Bangalore b560 030.
98. Mrs. Lourde Mary. Aged 72 years, W/o. Thygaraj. No40, 20 th C Cross, Aradhana Lay Out. Ejipura Bangalore 560 047.
99. Mrs.N. Vanaja Aged 46 Years, W/o. B. Sriram. No 50, Rose Garden Ejipura, Bangalore 560 047.
100. Mr.Sri. Alagappan. Aged 56 Years, S/o. Ponnayya 9/5, Laksmi Road, 4 th Cross, Shanthinagar, Bangalore. 560 027.
101. Smt. Kodainayaki. Aged 48 years, W/o. D. Dhanarajan. No:22, 5 th Cross, Gauthamapura, Ulsoor, Bangalore 560 008.
102. Mr.C. Anto. Aged 52 Years, S/o. Chinnadurai. G.C No:10, Nissan House, Austin Town Bangalore.47.
83
103. Smt. Shamshad Begum. Aged 54 Years, w/o. Jabbar, 1673, B Type, B.D.A Complex, Austin Town, Bangalore. 560 047.
104. Smt. Sarawathi. Legal Heir of Late C Krishna. Aged 37 Years, W/o. Late. Saravanan. No47, Old Cement Lane Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
105. Mrs. Manjula. Aged 57 Years, W/o. Sivalingam, No4 Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
106. M. Subrmani. Aged 55 Years, S/o. Muthaiah, 6/1, 5 th Cross, Gupta Lay Out, Ulsoor, Bangalore 560 008.
107. Mrs. Razia Begum, Aged 49 years, D/o. Late. Azuma Bee. No:1, Masjid Street, Neelsandra Bangalore 560 047.
108. Mr. E.V. Jude. Aged Major. No70/29, 2 nd Main, Bharathi Lay Out. S.G. Palaya, Bangalore 560 029.
109. Mrs. Haseena Begum. Aged Major, W/o. Late. Haroon Shariff. No179, Central Street Main, Neelsandra Bangalore 560 047.
110. Mrs. Jayalaksmi. Aged Major. 8G, 4 th Cross, Munigowda Gardan, Neelsandra, Bangalore 560 047.
111. Mrs. Saraswathi. Aged 60 Years, Rudrappa Garden, Viveknagar, Banglaore 560 047.
112. Mrs. G. Sarala. Aged 48 Years, W/o. Govindraj,
84
No109, 2 nd Main, Rudrappa Garden Viveknagar, Bangalore -47.
113. Mrs. M. Ramadevi. Aged 47 Years, W/o. Gajendran, C27/7, D.R.D.O Township, C.V. Ramannagar Bangalore.
114. Mrs. Anthonyamma Major, W/o. Late. Natahn, No:7, Richmond Road, Bangalore.
115. Mrs. Laksmamma. Aged About 62 Years, W/o. D.N. Laksmaiah. No48, E Street, Shanthinagar, Bangalore. 560 027.
116. Mrs.K. Chandramma. Aged 57 Years, W/o. B. Sithambaram. 2/1, N Street, Shanthinagar, Bangalore 560 027.
117. Mr.K. Raju Aged 53 Years, S/o. Krishnan No. 362 /2, I cross, AnnasandraPalya, (behind Kittanna Hotel) H A L. Bangalore – 17.
118. Mrs.Krishnamma. Aged About 68 Years, C/o. T.M . Velu, 52, 5th Cross, Anappalaya, Adugodi, Bangalore 560 030.
119. MrsPrema T. Legal Heir of T. Eashwar Rao. No 318, Dorab Seth Road, Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
120. Mrs. K.M. Sowbagyvathi. Aged 45 Years, W/o. Shivanna. No:340, B.D.A Quarters, Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
85
121. Mrs. Mary Selina. Legal Heir of Late: Selvaraj. Aged about 63 Years. 24 th Cross, 1 st Floor, Ejipura, Bangalore 560 047.
122. Mr.Shanmugham. Aged about 49 Years, S/o. Gopal. No:120, 8 th Cross, Neelasandra, Bangalore 560 047.
123. Mr. M. Kumar. Aged 52 Years, S/o. M.G. Munian, No:8, 2 nd Cross, Vinayak Nagar, Bangalore 560 030.
124. Mr K. Muthu. Aged 52 Years, S/o. Kannan. No:60, 9 th Cross, Viveknagar, Bangalore 560 047.
125. Mrs. Saroja. Aged 50 Years, W/o. Ravichander, No45, 6 th Main Road, 3rd Cross, Venkatappa Lay Out Sanjaynagar, Bangalore. 560 094.
126. Mr. R. Ravichander. Aged 53 Years, S/o. Late Mr. Rajan. No:45, 6 th Main Road, 3rd Cross, Venkatappa Lay Out Sanjaynagar, Bangalore. 560 094.
127. Mr. S.Susairaj. Aged 53 Years, S/o. Saniago, No1, 2 nd Cross, 1 st Stage, Gowthamapura, Bangalore 560 008.
128. Mr. V. Ramanathan. Aged 6o Years, S/o. Varadarajan. No:77, 4 th Cross, Gowthamapura, Bangalore 560 008.
86
129. Mr. Ranga Rao. Aged 62 Years, S/o. Bhima Rao. No:8, 1 st Main, 2nd Stage, Gowthamapura, Bangalore 560 008.
130. Mrs. Luciya. Aged 49 Years, D/o. Joseph. No39, Maranahalli Single house, Samdha Nagar, E.W.S Quarters, Bangalore 560 047.
131. Mr. M. Subramani. Aged 56 Years, S/o. Muniswami. No: 1111. K.S. Garden, Lalbagh Road, Bangalore 560 027.
132. Mrs. Indirani, Aged 65 Years, W/o. D. Ramalingam. No:32, Vannarpet Bangalore 560 047.
133. Mr. M. Sampangi. Aged Years, S/o. Late. Muniswami, No281, K.S. Garden, Lalbagh Road, Bangalore 560 027.
134. Mrs. Maila. Aged 56 Years, W/o. Late. M. Rajenmdran No:8, Abhaya Garden, Vannarpet, Bangalore 560 047.
135. Mr. Krishnakumar. Aged 49 Years, S/o. Thruvegadam, No:31, Bazar Street, Vannarpet, Bangalore-560 047.
136. Mr. B. Ramu. Aged 43 Years, S/o. Late. Balakrishnan. Miller Tank Bund Road, Vasanth Nagar, Bangalore.
137. Mrs. Dilshad Begum. 4/5, Masjid Central Cross Street, Neelsandra Bangalore 560 047.
87
138. Mr.P Ananadan. Aged 51 Years, Legal Heir of Late. Sushhela. No33 Bazar Street, Vannarpet Bangalore 560 047.
139. Mrs.N. Pramila Devi. Aged 52 Years, W/o. Gynaprakash, No; &, Venkatappa Garden Viveknagar Bangalore -560 047.
140. Mr. Anthoney Dass. Aged 58 Years, S/o. Late Innasamuthu. No 136, 2 nd Battery Pension Lane Viveknagar, Bangalore-560 047.
141. Mr. Jaipal A. Aged 57 years, S/o. Arumugam No 10, Baliyanaidu Street, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
142. Mr. T. Mathew. Aged 28 years, Legal Heir of Late Benjamin K.V. Palampeak Lay Out, R.M. Nagar Bangalore 560 016.
143. Mr. Habeebulla T.R. Aged 64 Years, S/o. Abdul Rehman. No:4, 4 th Cross, H.M.T. Garden Neelsandra Bangalore 560 047.
144. Mrs. Gayathri Bai Aged 64 years, W/o. N. Venkatesh Rao 313, Kuvempu Nagar, Jalahalli East, Bangalore – 560 014.
145. Shanta Bai Aged 65 years, W/o. Bapu Rao Honnadevinilaya, Punya Devi Layout Padmabhushana Dr. Rajkumar Road Kalkere, Bangalore – 560 043.
146. Mrs. Arokiamary. Aged 80 Years, W/o. Late. John Sunderraj. No94, 2 nd Main Road, Ramasandra Lay out, Lingarajpuram Bangalore 560 084.
88
147. Mrs. Vasanthakumari, Aged 51 Years, W/o. Dass. New No:13 2 nd Main Road, Ramasandra Lay out, Lingarajpuram Bangalore 560 084.
148. Mr. Richard Paul, Aged 51 Years, S/o.Joseph Paul, No: 130, Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
149. Mr. Anthony Das. Y. Aged 55 years, S/o. A. Yessudass No4,A. No:1 Street, 58th Div: Chandni Chowck Road Cross Shivajinagar Bangalore. 560 041.
150. Mrs. S.R. Leelavathy Aged 48 Years, W/o. Ramakrishnan. No:35, 1 st Block J.P. Nagar 9 th Phase, Bangalore 560 062.
151. Mrs. Donni. Aged 75 Years, D/o. Pooswami. No:14, Langford Road, 1st cross, Shanthi Nagar Bangalore 560 027.
152. Mrs. Shesha Bai. Aged 80 Years, W/o. P.K. Panni. No:3, 4 th Cross, Kuvempu Road, Vijayanagar, Bangalore. 560 064.
153. Mr. Ramachandran. Aged 40 Years, S/o. Marappa, No:448, 12 th Cross, B Block, 6th Main, New Lingarajapuram Bangalore 560 084.
154. Mr. Prakash Rao. Aged 52 Years, S/o. Lourde Nathan, No:13, 4 th Cross, Nissan House Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
89
155. Mr. Venkatesh, Aged 40 Years, S/o. Marappa, No37, Samatha Nagar Main Road, Viveknagar, Bangalore 560 047.
156. Mrs. Sampathkumari. Aged Major,L/R. of Late Laksmi. No 85, 6 th Cross, Victoria Lay Out Bangalore 560 047.
157. Mr. Paul Johnson Aged 52 Years, S/o. Johnson, No 85, 6 th Cross, Victoria Lay Out Bangalore 560 047.
158. Mrs. Shanaz Begum. Aged 38 Years, W/o. Mustha Pasha No 29, 4 th Cross 22 nd main, Vinayaknagar Bangalore 560 078.
159. Mr. Bharath Kumar C. Aged 19 Years, S/o. Late. Chandrakanthi T. No11/7, Nandavanam, B Street, Jogpalaya Bangalore 560 008.
160. Mrs. Renu. Aged 34 Years, Legal Heir of Late Gunasekar. No 45/7, South Cross Street, Neelasandra Bangalore -47.
161. Mrs Noorjahan. Aged Major, D/o. Late:Abdul; Gaffar. No7, South Cross Street, Neelasandra Bangalore -47.
162. Mrs. Kamerunnissa. Aged 86 Years, W/o. Nawab Jan, No6, 6 th Cross, Mangammapalya Bommanahalli Bangalore. 560 068.
163. A Xavier. Aged 54 Years, S/o. Late. Arulnathan, No 162, 3 rd Main Road, Ambedkarnagar Bangalore 560 047.
90
164. Mr.Afsar. Aged 50 Years, S/o. Syed Abbas. No 1322, B 35, B.D.A Flats Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
165. Mr. Syed Jaffer. Aged 51 Years, S/o. syed Abbas No 65/3, 4 th Cross, Neelasandra Bangalore 560 047.
166. Mrs.Habbeba Banu Aged 48 Years, W/o. Mohd Akram. No4/1, 1 st main,5 th Cross S.K. Garden, Benson Town Bangalore 560 046.
167. Mr. Muniswami Aged 54 Years, S/o. Muniappa. No2, 7 th Cross, Munigowda Garden. Neelsandra, Bangalore 560 047.
168. Mr. M Shivsankar. Aged 58 Years, S/o. M. Muniya No:17/4, 2 nd Main Road, Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
169. D. Harri. Aged 52 Years, S/o. Dorairaj. No 1/3, Aiyyappa Block, Vannarpet. Bangalore 560 047.
170. Mr. S Srinivasan. Aged 50 Years, S/o. Subramani. No4, Valliaramman Temple Street Vannarpet Bangalore 560 047.
171. Mr. Mayil Velu. Aged 53 Years, S/o. Murugeshan, No:92, 3 rd Cross, Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
91
172. Mrs. Dhaneshwari Devi. Aged Major, L/R of Late: Gulzarilal. No 357, 7 Th main Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
173. Mr. Abbas Ali. Aged 42 years, S/o. Syed Gaffar, No12, 1 st cross, Siddiah Road Bangalore 560 027.
174. Mr. Samiulla. Legal Heir of Late Dilshad, City Plaza, Dharma Raja Koil Street Shivajinagar Bangalore 560 051.
175. P.S.Chinnathampi. Aged 62 62ears, S/o.Sadayan. No95, Samata Nagar Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
176. Mrs. Mangaladevi G Aged 43 Years, W/o. N. Sekaran. No D 331, East Lane I.T.I Colony Doorvani Nagar Bangalore 560 016.
177. Mr. Chinnappan S. Aged 63 Years, S/o. Late. Swami. No 38/54, Yellappa Bldg. Rose garden Neelsandra Bangalore 560 047.
178. Mrs. Amina Be. Aged 68 Years, W/o. Ummer. Door No 3, No1st Street, Shivaji Road, Shivajinagar, Bangalore 560 051.
179. Mrs. Fathima Sharif. Aged 45 Years, W/o. Abdulla Sheriff No 173, Rahmath manzil, South Cross Street, Neelasandra Bangalore 560 047.
92
180. S. Nalini Jayanthi. Aged 59 Years, W/o. Parthasarathi No 129, 1 st Square, Ausin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
181. Mrs. Mala Ravindranath. Aged Major, W/o. Ravindranath. No: 233, 5 th Square, Ausin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
182. Mrs. Vasanthi Selvaraj. Aged Major, W/o. Selvaraj. No179, K.B.A.R Road, Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
183. Mrs. Shamshunissa. Aged 53 Years, W/o. M.S. Syed, 6th Cross, Bommanahalli, Bangalore 560 068.
184. D. Jayakumar Aged 53 Years, S/o. Devaraj. Chikkabommasandra G.K.V.K Post Yelahanka, Bangalore 560 065.
185. Mr. William D ‘Çruz. Aged 47 years, S/o. A. D’Cruz. No22/1, Berli Street. Richmond Town Bangalore 560 025.
186. Mr. Selvaraj. Aged 54 Years, S/o. Krisnan, No2, Anjenya Temple Street, Vannarpet, Bangalore 560 047.
187. Mrs. Fathima. Aged 50 Years, W/o. Vinayagam. Miller Tank Bund Road, Vasanth Nagar Bangalore. 560 052.
188. Mr. R.Asok Kumar. Aged 47 Years, S/o. Late Ramu. No 136, Sector II, HMT Colony Jalahalli Bangalore 560 013.
93
189. Mr. T Kumar. Aged 53 Years, S/o. Thulukanam, No 13, Anjenya Temple Street, Vannarpet, Bangalore 560 047.
190. Mrs. Jyothi. Aged 56 Years W/o. David Raj, No 14, Baldwin Boys High School Hosur Road, Bangalore 560 025.
191. Mrs. M Devasagayam. Aged 51 Years, S/o. Late M. Lawzer, No 90, Baldwin Girls High School Richmond Road, Bangalore 560 025.
192. Mr. Mir Rahim Ali. Aged 57 Years, S/o. Syed Khadim Hussain. No 14, Allipura, Gowribidanur Talak, Chikballapur District.
193. Mr. Mir Mohmeed Rafi. Aged 53 Years S/o. Mir Mustafa Hussain. No 14, Allipura, Gowribidanur Talak, Chikballapur District.
194. Mr. L Mosses. Aged 64 Years, S/o. Lourdenathan, No 14, 6 th Cross, Anappalaya, Bangalore 560 030.
195. Mr. S Subramani. Aged 48 years, S/o. G. Sampangi. No54, Sanjeev Pura Vannarpet, Bangalore 560 047.
196. Mrs. Gangamma. Aged 51 Years, W/o. KAsimuthu. No142, 12 th Cross, R.K Hegde Nagar. Bangalore 560 077.
197. Mr. Rajkumar. R Aged Major, S/o. Ganganathan. No 12 Gangman Qtrs, Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
94
198. Mrs. Julina. Aged 49 Years, W/o. Andrews Anthoney, No2, L 6 th Street, Markam Road Bangalore 560 027.
199. Mrs. Lakshmi. Aged 56 Years, L/R of Late P.A Sundaram. No8/1, L 6 th Street, Markam Road Bangalore 560 027.
200. Mr. R Govindraj. Aged 50 Years, S/o. Reamaswami. No 133, 8 th Cross, Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
201. Mr. Subbiah Aged 55 Years, S/o.Nataraj Miller tank Bund road Vasanth Nagar Bangalore 560 052.
202. Mrs. Anasuya. Aged 52 Years, W/o. Chandran. No5, 17 th Cross, 3 rd Main Ramamurthy Nagar Bangalore 560 016.
203. K.Devaraj, Aged 48 Yyears, S/o. Late Kannan No. 328, Pension Lane, Vivekanagar, Bangalore – 47.
204. Mr. Puttaswami. Aged 65 Years, S/o.C Chennayya. No23, Sapthagirinilaya, Vidyranyapura Bangalore 560 097.
205. Mrs. Sulochana. Aged 70 Years, L/R of Late M.T Thulasiram. No9, Abhya Garden, 1st cross, Vannarpet Bangalore 560 047.
206. Mrs. Akther Begum. Aged 48 Years, W/o. Abdul Masjid, No 52, 7 th Cross, M.G Garden Neelasandra Bangalore 560 047.
95
207. Mr. Nasir Hussain Aged 53 Years, S/o. Kararrar Hussain. No1/11, South Street, Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
208. Mr. Vanathayan. Aged 52 Years S/o. Jagannatahn. No 1294. K.K. Halli. Ram Dev Garden Bangalore 560 084.
209. Mr. M Kalemulla Sherif Aged 52 Years, S/o. Alimulla Sherif. No 1600, B-49, Austin Town 3 rd Stage Bangalore 560 047.
210. Mr. A Chowree. Aged 71 Years, S/o. Arokiaswami. B-28/1053, Austin Town Bangalore 560 047 .
211. A Patrick. Aged 66 YearsS/o. A Arokiaswami, B-28/1053, Austin Town Bangalore 560 047 .
212. Mr. Mohan Singh. Aged 56 Years, S/o. Govardhan Singh No:3, 12 th cross, Ramaswami Palaya Bangalore 560 033.
213. K Devaraj. Aged 62 Years, S/o. Kozhanthaiswami. No83, 2 nd Cross, Sonnenahalli, Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
214. Mrs. Parvathy. Aged 70 Years, W/o.Late. Raman. No 178, Govindappa Bldg. C.V. Raman Nagar Bangalore 560 093.
215. Mr. Khajapeer. Aged 63 Years, S/o.Late Abdul Razzak No 7?2, 5 th Cross, Chaniah Compound, S.R.K Garden Bangalore 560 047.
216. Padmavathi. Aged 60 Years, W/o. Sankaran
96
No263, Ganga Bhavan Extn, Jayamahal, Bangalore 560 056.
217. Mr. Mir Kazim Raza Aged 50 years, S/o. Mir Miraj Hussain No 1141, I.K. Road, Alipur Chickballapur District.
218. Mrs. Nayeema Banu Age 60 Years, W/o. Syed Hafiz, 458, 2 nd Block, H.B.R Lay Out Bangalore 560 043.
219. Mr. K.D. Anthony Aged 60 Years, S/o. David. No59/4, 9 th Cross, Anappalaya Bangalore 560 030.
220. Mr. H.V.S Gopala Aged 67 Years, S/o. Venkitacahla Jungamma No822, D 7, BDA Qtrs Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
221. Mr. P Munian Aged 54 Years, S/o. Periyathampi, No92, 10 th Cross, Anappalaya Bangalore 560 030.
222. Mr. P.S. Dass Aged 58 Years, S/o. Periyanayagam. Baldwins Girls High School No90, Richmond Road, Bangalore 560 025.
223. Mrs. R Radha. Aged 45 years, W/o. Ravindrakumar No178, K.B.A.R Main Road Austin Town Bangalore 560 045.
224. Mrs.L Shakunthala. Aged 61 Years, W/o. J Velu. No12 Lakshmiah Road Ulsoor Bangalore 560 008.
225. Mrs. Jeevamani. Aged 52 Years,
97
W/o. Late Joseph Victor r No4, 8 th Cross, Rose Garden Bangalore 560 047.
226. M Ramaswami. Aged 53 Years. S/o. Munian No13, H.V. Lane 1st main Road Parvathipuram, Bangalore 560 002.
227. Mr. R Perumal. Aged 64 Years, S/o. Ramaswami. No44, Ramaswamipalaya. Bangalore 560 065.
228. Mrs. Gangamma Aged 65 Years, W/o. Lakshmana. New No 10, 2 nd Cross, Vinobhanagar Bangalore 560 002.
229. Mrs. Sarojini. Aged 68 Years, W/o. Late. Somasekhar. No4, 6 th Cross, Markam Road Bangalore 560 035.
230. Mrs. Suguna Dass. Aged 59 Years, W/o. Dass. No365, Mission Compound, Kaval Byrasandra Bangalore 560 032.
231. Mrs. Geetha. Aged 41 Years, L/R of Late Chandra. No 188, K.B.A.R Road Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
232. Mrs. Mubeen Taj. Aged 44 Years, W/o. Mohmmed Pasha No69/8, 9 th Main, Devraj Urs Nagar Bangalore 560 036.
233. Mrs. Rahmathunnissa Aged 55 Years, W/o. Abdul Rahim
98
No38/8, Bazar Street, Neelasandra, Bangalore 560 047.
234. T. Ravi. Aged 56 Years, S/o. Thangaraj. No12, 7 th Cross, Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
235. Mrs. Ranganayagi. Aged 60 Years, W/o. Mani. No 272, , Bazar Street, Neelasandra, Bangalore 560 047.
236. Mr. Bharani Dharan Aged 45 Years, S/o. M.S. Sadhasivam No 38/61, Muthappa Bldg Neelasandra, Bangalore 560 047.
237. Mrs. Vanitha Varalakshmi Aged 48 years, W/o. S Rahulan. No26, 2 nd Main 13 th Cross Ejipura Bangalore 560 047.
238. Mr. Nagaraj S Aged 60 Years, S/o. Late Ramiah, No 157, Kalaspalaya Bangalore 560 002.
239. Mrs. Meenaksi. Aged 53 Years, W/o. Late Mahadev, No12, 10 th A Cross, Ejipura Bangalore 560 047.
240. Mrs. Ratna. Aged 46 Years, W/o.Yellappan No465, Anandapuram, Mysore Road, Bangalore 560 018.
241. Mr. Kolapuri. Aged 70 Years, S/o. Late Kariappa. No168, Kalaspalaya Bangalore 560 002.
242. Mrs. Sharadha. Aged 59 Years, W/o. V Narayanswami. No1651, B Type, 3 rd Stage Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
99
243. Mrs. V Satya. Aged 45 Years, W/o. Venkatachalam. Payappa Garden, Shivajinagar Bangalore 560 051.
244. Mr. Anjanappa. Aged 77 Years, S/o. Late. Sanjarappa. No 16, Mothinagar, Kalaspalaya Bangalore 560 002.
245. A Murali. Aged Major. S/o. Late A Theresa. His Grace Cottage, 10/2, Ulsoor, Bangalore 560 008.
246. Mrs. Nirmala M. A Aged 48 Years W/o. Manuel Raj. No 7 Bobby Street Ulsoor, Bangalore 560 008.
247. Mrs. S Rajeswari Aged 58 Years, W/o. Sampangi. No11, 6 th Cross, Ejipura Bangalore 560 047.
248. Mrs. Kanchanadevi Aged 59 Years, W/o. Late Venkatesh No 13 M.G Garden Neelasandra Bangalore 560 047.
249. Mr. Vijayakumar. Aged 47 Years. S/o. Late govindraj No 132 C.P.W. D Quarters Domalur Bangalore 560 071.
250. Mr. Lokanathan. Aged 45 years, S/o. Late Govindraj No 132, C.P.W. D Quarters Domalur Bangalore 560 071.
251. Mrs. Susheela Aged 65 Years W/o. Late Irudayaraj, No 59, Rajgopal Road Austin Town, Bangalore 560 047.
100
252. Mr. Murali. M Aged 48 Years, S/o. Muniswami. No16/1, Kaliamma Koil Street Ulsoor, Bangalore 560 008.
253. Mrs. Shanthi S. Aged 38 years, W/o. Babu Jaralal. 1st main 4 th Cross, V.S.R.R Lay Out Bangalore 560 016.
254. Mr. Abdul Kuddus Aged 45 Years, S/o. Abdul Lathif No 26, Goripalaya, Bangalore 560 026.
255. Mrs. D Violet. Aged 60 Years, L/R of T.A Dass. No 16, 6 th Cross, Annappareddy Lay out Ramamurthy Nagar Bangalore 560 060.
256. Mrs. Ramantchi. M Aged 85 Years, W/o. Late Dasarathan Command hospital Quarters Cambridge Layout Bangalore 560 036.
257. Mrs. Sajida Saira Aged 35 Years, W/o. Wajid Khan. No 105, Neelasandar Bangalore 560 047.
258. Mr. B Loganatahn. Aged 50 Years S/o. PooBalam No 197, Ummer Saheb Road Banasankari 2 nd Stage Bangalore 560 076.
259. Mr. Shivanna Aged 46 Years, S/o. Basavgowda No 15, 1 st A Cross, Azad Nagar Bangalore 560 018.
260. Mr. A John Christy Aged 66 Years, S/o. T Arputhanathan No 7 B Street, Shanthi Nagar Bangalore 560 027.
101
261. Mr. P Murugan. Aged 48 Years, S/o. Parasuram No 248, 8 th Cross, Venkitapura Sarjapura Road Bangalore 560 033.
262. Mr.M Andrews. Aged Major, S/o. Maderanaikam No496, B-12, B.D.A Quarters Austin Town Bangalore 560 047.
263. Mr. S Dhanraj. Aged 52 Years, S/o. Late. Subbarayam No 15, 3rd Cross, Lalbagh Road Bangalore 560 027.
264. Mr. Rajamani. Aged 65 Years, S/o. Late Venugopal. No 58, rudrappa Garden Viveknagar Bangalore 560 047.
265. Mrs. Vinith Mary. Aged 41 Years, WE/o. Henry Felix No11, 5 th Street, Jogpalaya Ulsoor, Bangalore 560 008.
266. Mrs. N Vidhya. Aged 21 Years, D/o. Late. Nataraj No 106, Wilson Garden Bangalore 560 027.
267. Mrs.E. Pramila Aged 50 Years, D/o. Yethirajnaidu No 168/C, Yeshwanthpur Bangalore 560 022.
268. Mrs. Balakeshamma. Aged 49 years, W/o. Guru Brahma No21, R.H.A.F Lane Ulsoor, Bangalore 560 008.
(Respondent Nos.69 to 268 impleaded Vide Court order, dated 19.9.2014) .... Respondents
102
(By Sri R.Devdas, PGA a/w Ms.Shweta Krishnappa, HCGP for R1; Sri Adithya Sondhi, Senior Advocate for Sri Subramanya.R, Advocate for M/s Ashok Harnahalli Associates for R2; Sri S.S.Nagananda, Senior Advocate for Sri S.Sriranga, Advocate for M/s Just Law for R3; Sri Aniyan Joseph, Advocate for R4 and R69 to R268; Sri B.C.Thiruvengadam, Advocate for M/s Thiru & Thiru for R55, R59, R60 & R62-R64; Sri K.Krishna, Advocate for R68, R5 to R54, R56 to R58, R61, R65 to R67 – Notice held sufficient)
These writ petitions are filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India praying to declare that the order dated 24.8.2012 passed in WP 45915/11 vide Annexure – F passed by the High Court of Karnataka, Bangalore is not binding on the petitioners; and etc.
R.P.No.265/2013
BETWEEN :
1. Smt.Jacqueline, W/o Shri Xavier Aged about 34 years R/o No.25, 17 th Block, EWS Quarters, Bangalore – 560 047. Present residing on footpath adjoining EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
2. Smt.Shabeena, W/o Shri Jeeya, Aged about 25 years, R/o No.3, 15 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047. Presently residing on adjoining EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
3. Smt.Jhansi, D/o late Shri Babu, Aged about 22 years,
103
R/o No.3, 21 st Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047. Presently R/at No.55, 2nd Floor Gundapa Gowda Road, Ejipura, Bangalore – 560 047.
4. Shri Albert Vinod, S/o Sri Joseph, Aged about 84 years, R/o No.3, 38 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047. Presently R/at No.5, Samathanagar, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
5. Shri Daniel, S/o Shri Vedanayagam, Aged about 40 years, R/o No.18, 12 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047. Presently R/at No.3, 4 th Cross, Austin Town, Yellagondapaliyam, Bangalore – 560 047.
6. Smt.Selvi, W/o Murugeshan, Aged about 35 years, R/o No.28, 11 th Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047. Presently R/at No.7, Samathanagar, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
7. Smt.Chennamma, W/o Shri Mari, Aged about 44 years, R/o No.21, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Bangalore – 560 047. Presently R/at No.68, 6th Main Slum Board Quarters,
104
Ambedkar Nagar, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
8. Smt.Dhanavalli.D. W/o Shri Das, Aged about 35 years, R/o No.3, 33 rd Block, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047. Presently Residing on Footpath adjoining EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047. … Petitioners
(By Sri K.B.S.Manian, Advocate)
AND:
1. State of Karnataka, Through its Secretary, Housing & Urban Development Department, Bangalore – 560 001.
2. Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagara Palike, Represented by its Commissioner, N.R.Square, Bangalore – 560 002.
3. Maverick Holding & Investment(P) Ltd., A Company registered under the Companies Act-1956, having its Office at No.78/1, New K.R.Road, Basavanagudi, Bangalore – 560 002.
4. Economically Weaker Section’s Residential Welfare Association, (A registered Association), No.12, 25 th Block, EWS Quarters, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by its General Secretary Mr.P.S.Dass.
5. Sri Daniel Richard, S/o T.Daniel, Aged about 52 years, Opp. Sri Kumarans’ High School, Ramamurthynagar, Bangalore – 560 016.
105
6. Sri S.Govindraj, S/o Sundaram, Aged about 56 years, No.37/4, Bazar Street, Neelasandra, Bangalore – 560 047.
7. Smt.K.Kodhanatchi, W/o M.Vishnumurthy, Aged about 72 years, No.89, 19 th ‘A’ Cross, Buchappa Road, Ejipura, Bangalore – 560 047.
8. Smt.K.Ushadevi, W/o Arumainathan, Aged about 52 years, No.89, 19 th ‘A’ Cross, Butchappa Road, Ejipura, Bangalore – 560 047.
9. Smt.K.Saravani, W/o Deva Sagayam, Aged about 45 years, No.D-340, 4 th Lane, East Ring Road, ITI Colony, Dooravani Nagar, Bangalore – 560 016.
10. Smt.Saraswathy, D/o Arjun Rao, Aged about 60 years, No.57-B, Rudrappa Garden, Vivekanagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
11. Sri Keshavelu, S/o Raghvalu, Aged about 64 years, No.57-B, Rudrappa Garden, Vivekanagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
12. Smt.Fathima, Aged about 73 years, House No.22, Block No.14, EWS Corporation Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
106
13. Sri D.Arul, S/o Late David, Aged about 63 years, 7th Main Road, 2 nd Cross, 2nd Stage, Rajendranagar, Vivekanagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
14. Sri G.Shanmugam, S/o M.Gopal, Aged about 58 years, House No.21, Block No.18, EWS Compound, Kormangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
15. Sri S.Marian Alfred, S/o late T.John, Aged about 54 years, Door No.151, Old Cement Lane, Austin Town, Bangalore – 560 047.
16. Sri K.Shivanna, S/o Kupanna, Aged about 61 years, No.65, 17 th Cross, 3 rd Stage, Ambedkarnagar, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
17. Sri S.John Dass, S/o C.Savarimuthu, Aged about 53 years, No.65, 17 th Cross, 3rd Stage, Ambedkarnagar, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
18. Smt.Queeni, W/o late K.James, Aged about 50 years, No.27, 2 nd Main, Ambedkarnagar, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
19. Smt.Savithramma, W/o Rajanna, Aged about 61 years, No.143, M.M.Garden, Neelasandra, Bangalore – 560 047.
107
20. Smt.Nabesabi, W/o Aneef, Age Major, Flat No.36, Block No.41, EWS Compound, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
21. Smt.K.Usha, D/o Chikkavenkittappa, Aged about 46 years, No.6, Ramaswamy Road, Sudama Nagar, Bangalore – 560 027. Represented by her GPA Holder K.Sundaramurthy, S/o Karupaiah, Aged about 39 years, No.9, L.No. 7 th Street, Ashok Nagar, Bangalore – 560 025.
22. Smt.Devi.M, W/o Varadaraj, Aged about 53 years, No.22(3), 5 th Cross, Magadi Road, Bangalore – 560 023.
23. Sri P.M.Rajendran, S/o Pitchakkaran, Aged about 41 years, C/o Namakali Transport, 2nd Cross, 1 st Main, N.T.Pet, Bangalore – 560 002. Represented by Smt.D.Susaimary, W/o late Stanislas Raj, Aged about 58 years, No.1694, BDA C-23, Austin Town Layout, Bangalore – 560 047.
24. Sri C.Sigamani, S/o Narayana, Aged about 54 years, No.45/5, 4 th Cross, Ayyappa Block, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder, V.Krishnaswamy,
108
S/o Veeranna Shetty, Aged about 57 years, House No.33, Block No.1, EWS Corposration Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
25. Smt.Menaka Gopala, W/o Gopalan, Aged about 70 years, No.A/136, 1 st Cross, Magadi Road, Bangalore – 560 023. Represented by her Power of Attorney holder, Mrs.Josephine Felicita, C/o Mrs.Lilly Roslin, Aged about 48 years, No.1602, Block No.49, 3rd Stage, BDA Austin Town Layout, Bangalore – 560 047.
26. Sri R.Rameshkumar, Aged about 58 years, No.2, Corporation Quarters, Barlley St.Cross, Shantinagar, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Smt.Channammal, W/o M.Velu, Aged about 60 years, No.8, Block No.42, EWS Corporation Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
27. Sri P.Velu, S/o late Ponnuswamy, Aged about 58 years, No.59, Mackan Road, Bangalore – 560 001. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder G.Sampath Rajan, S/o Gunasekharan, Aged about 51 years, No.W Type House No.57, HMT Colony, Bangalore – 560 031.
109
28. Sri Janaki Ram.M, S/o late Muniswamy, Aged about 56 years, No.128, Seppings Road, Bangalore – 560 001. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Sri G.Sampath Rajan, S/o Gunasekharan, Aged about 51 years, No.W Type House No.57 HMT Colony, Bangalore – 560 031.
29. Smt.Khurshid Unnisa, D/o Sri Mohammed Ghouse, Aged about years, No.23, ‘C’ Road, 11 th Cross, H.M.Road, Padarayanapura, Bangalore – 560 026. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Sri A.Devirajan, S/o Selva Rajan, Aged about 35 years, No.13, Appu Mutrition, Veerasandra, Industrial Estate, 19Km., Hosur Road, Bangalore – 560 058.
30. Sri.S.Ravi, S/o Sampangi, Aged about 47 years, No.13, Balaya Naidu Street, Vannarpet, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder, Smt.M.Pushpa, W/o Murugesh, No.17, Block No.30, EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
31. Sri N.Vijayakumar, S/o Nitesh Kumar, Aged about 51 years, No.24, Dispensary Extension,
110
Kalasipalyam, Bangalore – 560 002. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Smt.Jameela Begum, D/o Mohd. Ghouse, Aged about 40 years, No.14, 1 st Floor, Block No.23, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
32. Sri Imthiaz Basha, S/o Dastagir Sab, Aged about 47 years, Peer Boundary, Cotton Pet Main Road, Bangalore – 560 053. Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Sri A.P.Robert, S/o F.Anthony, Aged about 66 years, No.22/7, Nadagatta, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
33. Sri K.Ramesh, Aged major, Represented by his Power of Attorney holder Smt.A.Shanthi, House No.6, Block No.39, EWS Quarters, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 043.
34. Sri P.V.Thiruimurugan, No.52, M.M.Road, Doddigunda, Cox Town, Bangalore – 560 005.
35. Smt.Pushpa Jayanthi, W/o Jagannath, Aged about 32 years, Ejipura Main Road, Bangalore.
36. Sri Udaya Subyan.K, No.33, London Street, Yellegunde Palyam,Bangalore.
37. Sri C.Moola Kondaiah, No.42/1, Ambedkar Nagar,
111
2nd Stage, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
38. Smt.Rosy Marry, D/o Zakiras, No.59, Masjid Street, Muniswamy Garden, Anepalya, Neelasandra, Bangalore – 560 047.
39. Sri Rajamani, S/o Venugopal, No.119, 4 th Cross, Viveknagar Extension, Bangalore – 560 047.
40. Sri A.M.Shivalingam, S/o Motaiah, No.40, Old Cement, Austin Town, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore – 560 047.
41. Smt.Manjula, W/o Shivalingaiah, No.12, Block No.38, EWS Quarters, Bangalore.
42. Sri K.Sundara Murthy, Represented by GPA Mrs.Bharathi Venkata Rao, No.30, Corporation EWS Quarters, Koramangala, Bangalore – 560 047.
43. Sri Aslam Khan, S/o Sri Ameer Jan, No.14, Old Kasi Road, Bangalore – 560 002.
44. Smt.Chandra, S/o Narayan Swamy, No.240, 5 th Cross, Austin Town, Bangalore – 560 047.
45. Sri Ravi, S/o Thangaraj, No.12, 7 th Cross, Sonnenahalli, Viveknagar Post, Bangalore.
112
46. Smt.Saraswathi Amma, W/o Sri Balakrishna, No.8, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
47. Smt.Geetha, W/o B.Shekhar, No.7, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
48. Smt.Devika Jagannath Pille, W/o Jagannath Pille, No.9, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
49. Smt.Rani, W/o Jagannath Pille, No.9, 2 nd Battery Pension Line, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
50. Sri Deivaraju.K, S/o Kolandai Swamy, No.83, 2 nd Cross, Viveknagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
51. Smt.Suguna Das, W/o Das, Opp.Rama Temple, Dekappa Compound, Eejipura, Bangalore.
52. Smt.Shahajadi Begum, W/o Anwar Beg, No.22, East Street, Neelasandra, Bangalore.
53. Sri M.Velu, S/o Murugesh, No.84, 2 nd Cross, Sonnenahalli, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore.
54. Smt.Sharadamma, W/o Jeevarathnam, No.13, S.M.Road, Vannar Pete, Bangalore – 560 047.
55. Smt.Meena.S., LR of Sri Venkittaiah,
113
Aged about 68 years, House No.35, Block No.41, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
56. Smt.E.Pramila, Aged about 43 years, W/o Bhaktachalam, House No.27, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
57. Smt.Irudhyamary, Aged about 55 years, W/o L.Arokiadass, House No.21, Old Block No.22, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
58. Sri S.Ravi, Aged about 47 years, S/o D.Swamy, House No.13, Old Block No.26, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
59. Sri S.Feroz, Aged about years, S/o Abdul Jaffar, House No.8, Old Block No.23, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
60. Smt.Ratnamma, Aged about 38 years, W/o late Kothanda, House No.16, Old Block No.38, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
61. Sri M.Keshavalu, Aged about 61 years, S/o Bothaiah, House No.25, Old Block No.10, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
62. Smt.Shivashanthi, Aged about 58 years, W/o late Shivakumar, House No.4, Old Block No.36,
114
EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
63. Smt.Meenakshi.R., Aged about 24 years, W/o late Pushpa, House No.14, Old Block No.36, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
64. Sri M.Venkitesh, Aged about 38 years, S/o Marappa, House No.13, Old Block No.15, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
65. Smt.Amuda Dass, Aged about years, House No.11, Old Block No.38 EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
66. Sri Ramachandran, Aged about years, House No.34, Old Block No.34, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047.
67. Smt.Bharathi, Aged about 60 years, W/o late Dhanbhadur, House No.8, Old Block No.7, EWS Tin Shed, Vivek Nagar, Bangalore – 560 047. ... Respondents
(By:Sri R.Devdas, P.G.A. a/w Ms.Shweta Krishnappa, HCGP for R1; Sri Adithya Sondhi, Senior Advocate for Sri Subramanya.R, Advocate for M/s Ashok Harnahalli Associates for R2; Sri S.S.Nagananda, Senior Advocate for Sri S.Sriranga, Advocate for M/s Just Law for R3; Sri Aniyan Joseph, Advocate for R4)
This Review Petition filed under Order 47 Rule 1 of CPC, praying to review the Order dated 24.08.2012 passed in WP No.45915/2011, on the file of the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka, Bangalore.
The judgment in these writ petitions and review petition having been reserved and being listed for pronouncement this day, Ashok B.Hinchigeri J ., pronounced the following:
115
C.A.V. JUDGMENT
W.P.Nos.42743/2012, 29393-29531/2013 and
46496-46718/2014 are filed by those persons, who are residing in the temporary make-shift tin sheds, erected by
Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (‘B.B.M.P.’ for short) at Vivekanagar, Bangalore. The petitioners’ case in brief is that the Bangalore City Corporation, the predecessor of
B.B.M.P., formulated a scheme for the construction of 1512 flats in 42 blocks of its land measuring 22 acres in
Koramangala, Bangalore for the purpose of providing shelter to the Economically Weaker Sections (EWS) of society in 1983-84. On the completion of their construction in 1993-94, the B.B.M.P. issued the letters of allotment and executed lease-cum-sale agreements in respect of individual flats to the respective allottees. Due to sub- standard construction, one after the other block started collapsing. Majority of the original allottees gave up their possession through the power of attorney, etc. Out of 1512 tenements, only a few numbering about 230 were occupied by the original allottees. Owing to poverty, the petitioners continued to live in the EWS quarters, even when they were unfit for human occupation. The B.B.M.P. demolished the remaining flats and shifted the petitioners and other actual
116 occupants to the tin sheds erected on the same land with the promise that they would be provided with the houses on the same land to be constructed either by B.B.M.P. itself or through a joint venture project.
2. The petitioners have produced the identity cards issued by B.B.M.P. in Annexure-A series, ration cards in
Annexure-B series and election identity cards in Annexure-
C series to evidence their possession of EWS quarters.
3. The B.B.M.P. initially passed the resolution on
31.5.2004 to the effect that the residential tenements would be reconstructed and given to the original allottees, who were displaced and rendered homeless on account of demolition of dilapidated EWS quarters. Subsequently, the actual occupants raised the protest, as they are the real displaced persons. Taking note of the grievance of the actual occupants, the B.B.M.P. modified its earlier resolution, dated 31.5.2004 by passing the resolution on
28.6.2005 providing for re-settlement of those, who were evicted from EWS quarters. It calls for identifying present residents therein, even if they are not the original allottees for the purpose of allotting the flats in the residential complex. On 29.7.2005 it passed another resolution for
117 evicting the residents from the dilapidated EWS quarters as a precautionary measure. It also provides for the allotment of flats to 1512 original allottees once the residential complex is constructed. Further, it provides for the construction of the residential complex on the remaining part of the land in question for allotting flats to the erstwhile residents (tenants).
4. Some of the original allottees filed
W.P.No.45915/2011, seeking inter alia, a direction to the
Government to allocate funds for expeditiously starting reconstruction of the demolished EWS quarters. The said proceedings culminated in the settlement amongst the petitioners in the said case, B.B.M.P. and M/s.Maverick
Holding & Investments Pvt. Ltd. The said settlement inter alia provides for building a residential complex for allotting the flats therein to the original allottees and for putting up a commercial complex for the benefit of said property developer. In the wake of the said arrangement, the
Division Bench held that there will be no justification for any person to remain on the present site beyond 8.10.2012.
5. The petitioners in the instant case have approached this Court contending that the original allottees
118 are not the only beneficiaries of the rehabilitation project.
As the parties in W.P.No.45915/2011 have willfully suppressed the facts relating to resolutions of B.B.M.P. to confer the benefits upon the actual residents of EWS quarters, the order passed in the said writ petition
(W.P.No.45915/2011) is not binding upon the petitioners in the present case. The prayers in this writ petition read as follows:-
“a) Wherefore it is prayed that this Honourable Court be pleased to grant appropriate order in the nature of a writ of declaration that the Order dated 24 th August, 2012 passed in WP No.45915/2011 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore is not binding on the petitioners; and
(ai) Isue writ of certiorari to quash the resolution of the BBMP vide No.13 (306) dated 30.10.2006 enclosed as Annexure-V, and consequently quash the Concession Agreement dated 12.1.2012 as per Annexure-AD.
(aii) Issue writ of certiorari to quash the Government Order No.NAAAEE 261 MNG 2006 Bangalore dated 26.9.2008 enclosed as Annexure-Z.
(aiii) Issue writ of mandamus to Respondent No.1 and 2 to construct shelters in the schedule property for the benefit of the Petitioners and persons similarly situated in terms of the resolution dated 29.7.2005 vide Subject No.1/05-06 produced as Annexure-J.
119
b) Without prejudice to what is stated above this Honourable Court be pleased to direct the Respondent no.2 to extend the benefits of re- allotment to the Petitioners and other persons who have been given certificates of residence by the B.B.M.P. enclosed as Annexure A series.
c) Without prejudice to what is stated above, this Hon’ble Court may be pleased to issue a writ of mandamus directing the Respondent nos.1 and 2 to make adequate provisions for shelter to the Petitioners, and till such measures are made, to ensure that they are adequately rehabilitated as per the provisions of the Resettlement & Rehabilitation Policy.
d) Pass such further order or orders as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present case and in the interest of justice.”
6. R.P.No.265/2013 is filed by eight persons, whose grievance is that though they were not made parties to
W.P.No.45915/2011, they have suffered adverse consequences, as a result of passing the final order, dated
24.8.2012 in the said petition. The review petitioners claim that they are the erstwhile residents of tin sheds erected by
B.B.M.P. It is their case that the original allottees did not make necessary payments and did not comply with the conditions of lease-cum-sale agreement.
120
7. Sri Sunil Dutt Yadav, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the second respondent-B.B.M.P. has passed the resolution on 28.06.2005 for accommodating both the original allottees and occupants like petitioners in the residential complex to be constructed. Subsequently, on 29.07.2005, the B.B.M.P. has passed the resolution modifying the earlier resolution, dated 28.06.2005, providing for accommodating the occupants like petitioners by putting up a residential complex in the remaining portion of the land in question.
The B.B.M.P. thereafter conducted a survey and identified the residents of the flats on 14.11.2003 and found that there were about 1101 tenants. Learned counsel submits that the B.B.M.P. has issued identity cards to the petitioners on 15.06.2007.
8. Learned counsel submits that the aforesaid resolutions are not rescinded. The petitioners have the legitimate expectation that the B.B.M.P. would honour its resolutions by accommodating the petitioners in the residential complex to be constructed. He relies on the
Apex Court’s judgment in the case of NAVJYOTHI COO-
GROUP HOUSING SOCIETY ETC . v. UNION OF INDIA
121
AND OTHERS , reported in AIR 1993 SC 155 . The relevant paragraph of the said decision is extracted hereinbelow:
“16. It may be indicated here that the doctrine of ‘legitimate expectation’ imposes in essence a duty on public authority to act fairly by taking into consideration all relevant factors relating to such ‘legitimate expectation’. Within the conspectus of fair dealing in case of ‘legitimate expectation’, the reasonable opportunities to make representation by the parties likely to be affected by any change of consistent past policy, come in. We have not been shown any compelling reasons taken into consideration by the Central Government to make a departure from the existing policy of allotment with reference to seniority in Registration by introducing a new guideline. On the contrary, Mr.Jaitley the learned Counsel has submitted that the DDA and/or Central Government do not intend to challenge the decision of the High Court and the impugned memorandum of January 20, 1990 has since been withdrawn. We therefore feel that in the facts of the case it was only desirable that before introducing or implementing any change in the guideline for allotment, an opportunity to make representations against the proposed change in the guideline should have been given to the registered Group Housing Societies, if necessary, by way of a public notice.”
9. Learned counsel submits that the respondent authorities are obliged to rehabilitate the petitioners in the letter and spirit of National Rehabilitation and
122
Resettlement Policy, 2007 issued by the Ministry of Rural
Development.
10. He submits that the petitioners were thrown out by using the police force. He would assert that the petitioners are dispossessed without following the due process of law and that, that is why they are entitled to allotment of flats in the residential complex to be constructed.
11. Sri K.B.S.Manian, learned counsel for the review petitioners in R.P.No.265/2013 submits that the B.B.M.P. has suppressed material facts in its statement of objections filed in W.P.No.45915/2011. He submits that the order in the said petition is passed on the basis of the settlement, which is void in the eyes of law. He submits that no census of the actual occupants is made available to this Court in the proceedings in W.P.No.45915/2011. The settlement arrived at and the order passed thereon in the said proceedings is bad for want of notice to the occupants. He would contend that the order, dated 24.08.2012 passed in
W.P.No.45915/2011 is liable to be reviewed and recalled, as fraud is played on the Court. He submits that the petitioners can always seek a review of the order invoking
123 the provisions contained in Order 23 Rule 3B of Civil
Procedure Code, 1908, as the review petitioners and the present writ petitioners were not put on notice before recording the compromise in W.P.No.45915/2011. He read out the provisions contained therein, which are extracted hereinbelow:
“3B. No agreement or compromise to be entered in a representative suit without leave of Court – (1) No agreement or compromise in a representative suit shall be entered into without the leave of the Court expressly recorded in the proceedings; and any such agreement or compromise entered into without the leave of the Court so recorded shall be void.
(2) Before granting such leave, the Court shall give notice in such manner as it may think fit to such persons as may appear to it to be interested in the suit.”
12. Learned counsel submits that the B.B.M.P. is unnecessarily entering into the public-private partnership, which is putting the petitioners to hardship and prejudice.
13. Sri Aditya Sondhi, learned Senior Counsel appearing for M/s.Ashok Haranahalli Associates for the second respondent B.B.M.P. submits that the doctrine of res judicata is squarely applicable to the case on hand in as much as the second public interest petition is not
124 maintainable on the very same cause of action. The
judgment rendered in previous public interest petition operates as judgment in rem. The order passed in the said
PIL is binding on all the parties; matter cannot be reopened at the instance of some persons, who were not parties to the said PIL. In support of his submissions, he brings to our notice the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s judgment in the case of STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ANOTHER vs. ALL
INDIA MANUFACTURERS ORGANIZATION AND OTHERS reported in AIR 2006 SC 1846. Paras 32, 33 and 34 of
the said decision, relied upon by him, are extracted
hereinbelow:
“32. Res judicata is a doctrine based on the larger public interest and is founded on two grounds: one being the maxim nemo debet bis vexari pro una et eadem causa ("No one ought to be twice vexed for one and the same cause" ) and second, public policy that there ought to be an end to the same litigation . It is well settled that Section 11 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (hereinafter "the CPC") is not the foundation of the principle of res judicata, but merely statutory recognition thereof and hence, the Section is not to be considered exhaustive of the general principle of law. The main purpose of the doctrine is that once a matter has been determined in a former proceeding, it should not be open to parties to re- agitate the matter again and again. Section 11 of the
125
CPC recognises this principle and forbids a Court from trying any suit or issue, which is res judicata, recognising both 'cause of action estoppel' and 'issue estoppel'. There are two issues that we need to consider, one, whether the doctrine of res judicata, as a matter of principle, can be applied to Public Interest Litigations and second, whether the issues and findings in Somashekar Reddy (supra) constitute res judicata for the present litigation.
Explanation VI to Section 11 states:
"Explanation VI. Where persons litigate bona fide in respect of a public right or of a private right claimed in common for themselves and others, all persons interested in such right shall, for the purposes of this section, be deemed to claim under the persons so litigating."
33. Explanation VI came up for consideration before this Court in Forward Construction Co. and Ors. v. Prabhat Mandal and Ors. (hereinafter "Forward Construction Co."). This Court held that in view of Explanation VI, it could not be disputed that Section 11 applies to Public Interest Litigation, as long as it is shown that the previous litigation was in public interest and not by way of private grievance. Further, the previous litigation has to be a bona fide litigation in respect of a right which is common and is agitated in common with others.
34. As a matter of fact, in a Public Interest Litigation, the petitioner is not agitating his individual rights but represents the public at large. As long as the litigation is bona fide, a judgment in a previous
126
Public Interest Litigation would be a judgment in rem. It binds the public at large and bars any member of the public from coming forward before the court and raising any connected issue or an issue, which had been raised/should have been raised on an earlier occasion by way of a Public Interest Litigation. It cannot be doubted that the petitioner in Somashekar Reddy (supra) was acting bona fide. Further, we may note that, as a retired Chief Engineer, Somashekar Reddy had the special technical expertise to impugn the Project on the grounds that he did and so, he cannot be dismissed as a busybody. Thus, we are satisfied in principle that Somashekar Reddy (supra), as a Public Interest Litigation, could bar the present litigation.”
14. Learned Senior Counsel submits that the unauthorised occupants of any public property have no vested right to demand that they be rehabilitated in a particular location.
15. He submits that the doctrine of legitimate expectation has no application for the case on hand. There can be no legitimate expectation dehors law. In this regard, he sought to draw support from the Apex Court’s judgment in the case of RAM PRAVESH SINGH AND OTHERS vs.
STATE OF BIHAR AND OTHERS reported in (2006) 3
127
BLJR 1931. Para 14 of the said decision read out by him is as follows:
“14. What is legitimate expectation? Obviously, it is not a legal right. It is an expectation of a benefit, relief or remedy, that may ordinarily flow from a promise or established practice. The term 'established practice' refers to a regular, consistent predictable and certain conduct, process or activity of the decision-making authority. The expectation should be legitimate, that is, reasonable, logical and valid. Any expectation which is based on sporadic or casual or random acts, or which is unreasonable, illogical or invalid cannot be a legitimate expectation. Not being a right, it is not enforceable as such. It is a concept fashioned by courts, for judicial review of administrative action. It is procedural in character based on the requirement of a higher degree of fairness in administrative action, as a consequence of the promise made, or practice established. In short, a person can be said to have a 'legitimate expectation' of a particular treatment, if any representation or promise is made by an authority, either expressly or impliedly, or if the regular and consistent past practice of the authority gives room for such expectation in the normal course. As a ground for relief, the efficacy of the doctrine is rather weak as its slot is just above 'fairness in action' but far below 'promissory estoppel'. It may only entitle an expectant : (a) to an opportunity to show cause before the expectation is dashed; or (b) to an explanation as to the cause for denial. In appropriate cases, courts may grant a direction requiring the Authority to follow the
128
promised procedure or established practice. A legitimate expectation, even when made out, does not always entitle the expectant to a relief. Public interest, change in policy, conduct of the expectant or any other valid or bonafide reason given by the decision-maker, may be sufficient to negative the 'legitimate expectation'.
The doctrine of legitimate expectation based on established practice (as contrasted from legitimate expectation based on a promise), can be invoked only by someone who has dealings or transactions or negotiations with an authority, on which such established practice has a bearing, or by someone who has a recognized legal relationship with the authority. A total stranger unconnected with the authority or a person who had no previous dealings with the authority and who has not entered into any transaction or negotiations with the authority, cannot invoke the doctrine of legitimate expectation, merely on the ground that the authority has a general obligation to act fairly.”
16. He submits that the petitioners cannot draw any support from the resolution, dated 28.06.2005, as there is no approval of the State Government for the transfer or sale of the property in question or undivided share therein vested in favour of the original petitioners in
W.P.No.45915/2011. To advance the submission that the previous sanction of the State Government is necessary, he
129 brings to our notice the provisions contained in Section
176(6) of the Karnataka Municipal Corporation Act, 1976,
which is extracted hereinbelow:
“176. Disposal of property and interest therein:- ……… ……….. ………… (6) Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, - (a) no movable property exceeding such sum in value as may be prescribed shall be sold otherwise than by public auction; (b) (i) no property whether movable or immovable of whatever value shall be transferred free of cost or for an upset price; (ii) no lease of any immovable property exceeding five years shall be granted; (iii) no immovable property shall be disposed of by sale or by other transfer, except with the previous sanction of the Government.”
17. He denies the allegation that the presence of the petitioners/unauthorised occupants in the area in question
was not brought to the notice of this Court in
W.P.No.45915/2011. He brings to our notice, Clause 5(a) of the joint memo filed in W.P.No.45915/2011, which reads as follows:
“5(a) Within 8 weeks from the decision of the this Hon’ble Court respondent No.2 agrees to hand over clear and vacant possession of 15.64 acres of
130
unencumbered land to respondent No.3 in its entirety to enable respondent No.3 to commence the project as per the concession agreement. Parties seek appropriate directions from this Hon’ble Court for effecting evacuation of occupants of the project area, many of whom are unauthorised occupants, and/or are not amongst the original 1512 allotees of the EWS apartments.”
18. He also brings to our notice paras 7 and 13 of the order, dated 24.08.2012 passed in W.P.No.45915/2011.
They are as follows:
“7. We have carefully perused the terms of Exhibit – C and are satisfied that it is to the advantage of the original allottees of the subject lands. This Writ Petition is in public interest and therefore Exhibit-C shall bind all original allottees or 1512 original allottees regardless of whether they have signed Exhibit-C or not. Several of the Petitioners are present in Court and affirm the submissions made by counsel for Petitioners and counsel for newly added Respondents. …………………..
13. In view of the above arrangement, we are satisfied that there will be no justification for any person to remain on the present site after six weeks from today. Accordingly, Respondent No.2 shall have the authority to evict/eject all occupants from the present site after 8 th October, 2012 and if necessary taking the aid/assistance of police force.”
131
19. He submits that the eviction process was taken up based on the direction issued by this Court in order to provide accommodation to the original allottees at the earliest. He contends that mere issuance of identity cards to the residents of an area does not mean that some right is created in their favour in respect of the area, where they reside. He submits that no allotment of flats was made to the writ petitioners, much less any lease was executed in their favour.
20. He submits that the B.B.M.P., with the assistance of the State Government, Slum Clearance Board and Rajiv
Awas Yojana Scheme, is rehabilitating the displaced families on the alternative land at Sulikunte. He further submits that the allotment of units is offered to the erstwhile unauthorised occupants, free of cost.
21. He submits that the B.B.M.P. has demonstrated its fairness in action. He submits that what the B.B.M.P. has done is absolutely in keeping with the Apex Court’s judgment in the case of OLGA TELLIS AND OTHERS vs.
BOMBAY MUNICIPAL CORPORATION AND OTHERS reported in (1985) 3 SCC 545. The first portion of para 57 of that decision, relied upon by him, is as follows:
132
“57. To summarise, we hold that no person has the right to encroach, by erecting a structure or otherwise, on footpaths, pavements or any other place reserved or ear-marked for a public purpose like, for example, a garden or a playground; that the provision contained in section 314 of the Bombay Municipal Corporation Act is not unreasonable in the circumstances of the case; and that, the Kamraj Nagar Basti is situated on an accessory road leading to the Western Express Highway. We have referred to the assurances given by the State Government in its pleadings here which, we repeat, must be made good. Stated briefly, pavement dwellers who were censused or who happened to be censused in 1976 should be given, though not as a condition precedent to their removal, alternate pitches at Malavani or, at such other convenient place as the Government considers reasonable but not farther away in terms of distance; slum dwellers who were given identity cards and whose dwellings were numbered in the 1976 census must be given alternate sites for their resettlement; slums which have been in existence for a long time, say for twenty years or more, and which have been improved and developed will not be removed unless the land on which they stand or the appurtenant land, is required for a public purposes, in which case, alternate sites or accommodation will be provided to them ………..”
22. The submissions of the learned counsel have received our thoughtful consideration. The first question that falls for our consideration is whether the second public
133 interest petition is maintainable on the same cause of action. The first public interest litigation–
W.P.No.45915/2011 was filed seeking a writ of mandamus to the respondents to allocate the funds and expeditiously start re-construction of EWS quarters and for constituting a committee comprising of the representatives of the State and the petitioners and other eminent members of the society to monitor the reconstruction of EWS quarters and for an assurance towards the re-allotment. Recording the joint memo, the said writ petition was disposed of with the imprimatur of the Court.
23. It is trite that the judgment in previous public interest litigation operates as judgment in rem and bars subsequent public interest litigation in respect of the same subject-matter. A judgment in rem is one pronounced upon the status of some particular person or thing and which binds all persons. Those matters which were substantially in issue in the proceedings will constitute res judicata in the subsequent proceedings. In taking this view, we are fortified by the Apex Court’s judgment in the case of All
India Manufacturers Organization And Ors. (supra).
134
24. However, assuming that the second public interest writ petition is maintainable, we propose to consider the various contentions raised by the petitioners.
The issuance of identity cards, ration cards, election identity cards and the favourable resolution of the B.B.M.P. do not confer any allotment rights on the unauthorized occupants. The said documents are only indicative of the possession of the unauthorized occupants. It cannot be said that the unauthorized occupants are the owners in the making of the EWS quarters. No allotment letter, much less any agreement is executed by B.B.M.P. or its predecessor,
Bangalore City Corporation in favour of the unauthorized occupants.
25. It is also not the case of the unauthorized occupants that they have paid any consideration towards the allotment. Their status is either that of tenants under the original allottees or the unauthorized occupants.
26. Yet another aspect of the matter, which cannot be overlooked is that the B.B.M.P. has not cancelled the lease-cum-sale agreement executed in favour of the original allottees. Without cancelling them and consequently without extinguishing the proprietary rights of the original
135 allottees in the EWS quarters, the B.B.M.P. cannot alienate the EWS quarters in favour of the unauthorized occupants or in favour of any other third party. The unauthorized occupants have not filed any suit in the civil court seeking the relief of specific performance of the agreement, if any entered into between themselves and the original allottees.
27. We are also not persuaded to accede to the request of the unauthorized occupants that they be accommodated only in the flats being constructed on the land in question on the basis of the doctrine of legitimate expectation. As held by the Apex Court in the case of Ram
Pravesh Singh and Ors., (supra), the expectation should be legitimate, that is, reasonable, logical and valid. The unauthorized occupants, who have no dealings, transactions or negotiations with the B.B.M.P., cannot invoke the doctrine of legitimate expectation merely on the ground that the authority has general obligations to act fairly.
28. As yet another reason, we hold that the resolution, dated 28.6.2005 passed by B.B.M.P. cannot be acted upon. As per Section 176 of the Karnataka Municipal
Corporations Act, 1976, no immovable property can be
136 disposed of by sale or by other transfer except with the previous sanction of the Government. In the instant case, admittedly, the B.B.M.P. has not obtained previous sanction of the Government for disposing of the flats in question in favour of the unauthorized occupants.
29. The perusal of the joint memo filed in
W.P.No.45715/2011 and the Division Bench’s order thereon shows that the presence of the unauthorized occupants on the land in question was indeed disclosed to the Division Bench.
30. Thus none of the submissions urged on behalf of the petitioners come to their rescue insofar as their prayer (a) to (aiii) are concerned. But it does not mean that the writ petitioners and the similarly placed tenants/unauthorised occupants are not entitled to any relief. The right to shelter is certainly within the sweep of
Article 21 of the Constitution of India. As held by the Apex
Court in the case of CHAMELI SINGH AND OTHERS ETC . v. STATE OF U.P. AND ANOTHER , reported in (1996) 2
SCC 549 , the protection of life guaranteed by Article 21 encompasses within its ambit the right to shelter to enjoy the meaningful right to life. The relocation of the petitioners
137 has to be a meaningful exercise consistent with the rights to life, livelihood and dignity. In a proactive spirit and on humanitarian ground, the State Government and B.B.M.P. have identified an area of five acres at Sy.No.122 of
Sulikunte Village, Varthur Hobli, K.R.Puram Taluk,
Bangalore for rehabilitating them.
31. The time-lag between the resolutions of B.B.M.P. and the filing of these petitions as also between the order of this Court accepting public-private partnership arrangement militate against the petitioners, as far as their prayers (a) to (aiii) are concerned. While the petitioners’ prayer (a) for declaration that the order, dated 24.8.2011 passed in W.P.No.45915/2011 is not binding on the petitioners and prayers (ai) to (aiii) brought in by way of amendment cannot be acceded to, the petitioners are entitled to substantial reliefs sought in prayers (b), (c) and
(d). The reliefs however are required to be moulded and granted.
32. As far as R.P.No.265/2013 is concerned, advertence has to be made to the Apex Court’s judgment in the case of SATYANARAYAN LAXMINARAYAN
BHAVANAPPA vs. MALLIKARJUN THIRUMALE reported in
138
AIR 1960 SC 137 wherein it is held that an error which has to be established by a long drawn process of reasoning on points where there may conceivably be two opinions can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face of the record.
33. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
HARINAGAR SUGAR MILLS LTD. AND ANOTHER Vs.
STATE OF BIHAR AND OTHERS reported in (2006) 1 SCC
509 has held that if two views are possible on a point, the same would not be a ground for reviewing an order, as it would not fall within the scope of the review jurisdiction.
34. The Apex Court has, in HARDAS vs. SMT.USHA
RANI BANIK AND OTHERS reported in AIR 2006 SC
1634, held that Section 114 and Order 47 Rule 1 of C.P.C. do not postulate rehearing of the disputes because a party had not highlighted all the aspects of the case or could perhaps have argued them more forcibly and/or cited binding precedents to the Court and thereby enjoyed a favourable verdict.
35. As held by the Apex Court in S.BAGIRATHI
AMMAL vs. PALANI ROMAN CATHOLIC MISSION reported in (2009) 10 SCC 464 an error contemplated under Rule 1
139
Order 47 of CPC for the permissibility of review must be such which is apparent on the face of the record and not an error which has to be fished out and searched. In other words, it must be an error of inadvertence. It should be something more than a mere error and it must be one which must be manifest on the face of the record. If the error is so apparent that without further investigation or enquiry, only one conclusion can be drawn in favour of the applicant, the review would lie. Under the guise of review, the parties are not entitled to rehearing of the same issue.
36. Thus the scope for reviewing an order is rather limited. The review petition is liable to be dismissed as there is no error, much less an error apparent on the face of the record.
37. In view of the facts and contentions as aforesaid, the petitions are disposed with the following order:
(i) R.P.No.265/2013 is dismissed.
(ii) Prayer Nos.(a) to (aiii) in W.P.Nos.42743/2012,
29393-531/2013 and 46496-46718/2014 are
declined.
(iii) The B.B.M.P.’s submission that the petitioners
and the similarly placed persons are being
140
rehabilitated in Sulikunte Village without
charging any amount from them is taken on
record.
(iv) The submission made on behalf of the
Government that, as the land in question in
Sulikunte Village itself is being given for the
purpose of rehabilitating the unauthorised
occupants evicted from the EWS quarters, the
permission of the Government under Section
176 of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations
Act, 1976 is not required for the allotment of the
flats in the residential complex to be
constructed in Sulikunte Village is taken on
record.
(v) The B.B.M.P. is directed to complete the
residential complex in Sulikunte Village and
hand over the flats therein to the eligible
oustees on ownership basis without charging
any amount from them.
(vi) It is possible that there may be some teething
problems in the rehabilitation project. It is
therefore open to the petitioners to represent to
141
the Government and the B.B.M.P. for the
redressal of their grievances.
(vii) The Government and the B.B.M.P. shall
consider setting up the Grievance Redressal
Cells in Sulikunte Village for attending to the
problems of the rehabilitated persons. The
problems of the rehabilitated persons
(petitioners and other similarly placed persons)
are required to be attended to sympathetically,
pro-actively and without any loss of time.
(viii) The Government shall consider opening the
schools, colleges and hospitals in Sulikunte
Village, if they are already not established. The
Government shall also consider increasing the
frequency of the city buses to and from
Sulikunte Village.
38. There is no order as to costs
Sd/- CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/- JUDGE
Cm/ VGR/MD