BRIEF ANALYSIS OF CSDS POST-POLL SURVEY IN MAHARASHTRA
The analysis here is based on a Post Poll survey conducted by Lokniti in Maharashtra between October 15 and 17, 2014 in 35 Assembly constituencies.
Sample size - 1542.
______
LEADERSHIP WAS NOT AN IMPORTANT ISSUE IN MAHARASHTRA
On being asked who they would like to see as the next chief minister of Maharashtra, 11 percent of the respondents took Uddhav Thackeray’s name and 10 percent said Devendra Fadnavis. What is more significant however is that 43 percent of the respondents did not take any name indicating that leadership was not an important issue in this Assembly election in Maharashtra. The post-poll survey further reveals that a large proportion of these voters who seemed to be uninterested in the issue of leadership ended up voting for the BJP (31 percent).
Chief Minister % Preference
(open ended question)
Uddhav Thackeray 11
Devendra Fadnavis 10
Prithviraj Chavan 8
Ajit Pawar 8
Pankaja Munde 4
Raj Thackeray 3
Nitin Gadkari 3
Sharad Pawar 3
Others 7
Can’t say/No answer 43 ______
LOCAL ISSUES WERE MORE IMPORTANT
When people were asked about what mattered to them more during the election – leadership or local issues, 21 percent opted for the former, while 35 percent for the latter.
While voting in the assembly election %
Local issues were important to me than Leadership 35
Leadership was more important to me than Local 21 issues.
Both Local issues and Leadership were important 14 to me
Neither Local issues nor Leadership important to 8 me
No opinion 22
______
HIGH DISSATISFACTION WITH CONG-NCP GOVT BUT LOWER THAN MARCH 2014
Although there was high dissatisfaction among voters with the Congress-NCP government in Maharashtra, when we compare it with previous surveys conducted by CSDS in the state there was a slight improvement. This perhaps explains the somewhat improved performance of both Congress and NCP in the Assembly election as compared to the drubbing they received in the Lok Sabha election.
Performance of Jan Mar Oct
Cong-NCP govt. 201 2014 2014 4
Fully satisfied 9 10 13
Fully dissatisfied 36 35 28
Source: CSDS Surveys in Maharashtra Sample Size - Jan 2014 – 1224; Mar 2014 – 1662; Oct 2014 – 1542. ______
A ‘CORRUPT’ GOVERNMENT
While nearly three-fourths of the respondents perceived the Congress-NCP government to be corrupt, the proportion of those saying that it is ‘Very Corrupt’ came down as compared to the surveys conducted right before the Lok Sabha election.
Cong-NCP govt. Jan Mar Oct was… 2014 2014 2014
Very corrupt 52 46 36
Somewhat 33 31 37
Not corrupt 3 7 7
Can’t say 12 17 20
Sample Size - Jan 2014 – 1224; Mar 2014 – 1662; Oct 2014 – 1542.
STRONG SUPPORT FOR SEPARATE VIDARBHA STATE IN VIDARBHA REGION
The post poll survey found strong support in the Vidarbha region for the idea of a separate Vidarbha state. Nearly two thirds of the respondents in the region supported the creation of a separate state. In the rest of Maharashtra, the sentiment against the creation of a Vidarbha state is nearly as strong with 53 percent opposing the idea of a separate Vidarbha state. ‘A separate Vidarbha state Vidarbha Rest of Among should be carved out of Maharashtr BJP+ voters region Maharashtra’ a in Vidarbha region
Agree fully with statement 51 10 65
Agree somewhat with 12 8 7 statement
Disagree somewhat with 10 15 2 statement
Disagree fully with statement 10 38 9
No opinion 18 29 17
Sample size for Vidarbha region is 366.
______
RULING PARTY ADVANTAGE FOR BJP
The BJP seems to have benefitted from the fact that it is the ruling party at the centre. Six out of ten respondents were of the opinion that for the all round development of the state the ruling party at the centre and the state should be the same.
‘For all round development of the % state the ruling party at the centre and the state should be the same’
Agree fully with statement 41
Agree somewhat with statement 18
Disagree somewhat with 9 statement
Disagree fully with statement 10
No opinion 22 ______
WHO’S TO BLAME FOR SENA-BJP BREAK-UP?
On the question of who is responsible for the break up of the Shiv Sena-BJP alliance, 29% of the respondents blamed the BJP and 20% blamed the Shiv Sena. While Sena voters clearly blamed the BJP and its leadership for the break up of the alliance, there was a mixed opinion among BJP voters.
All Among Among
BJP+ Shiv voters Sena voters
BJP/Amit Shah/Narendra Modi 29 14 51
Shiv Sena/Uddhav Thackeray 20 27 3
Both parties equally to blame 24 37 22
Neither to blame 2 1 2
No opinion 26 22 23
______
WHO’S TO BLAME FOR CONG-NCP BREAK-UP?
Much of the blame for the break up of the Congress-NCP alliance was put on the NCP. 26 percent of the respondents held the NCP responsible for the alliance coming apart whereas 18 percent blamed Congress. All Among Among Congres NCP s voters voters
NCP/Pawars to blame 26 38 14
Congress/Chavan to blame 18 14 33
Both parties equally to 30 17 30 blame
Neither to blame 1 1 2
No opinion 25 30 21
______
UPHOLDING SHIVAJI’S LEGACY WAS NOT A BIG ISSUE FOR VOTERS
Upholding the legacy of Shivaji does not seem to have been an election issue. While most respondents (37 percent) were of the opinion that Shiv Sena was best suited to protect Shivaji’s legacy, however when it came to voting only one-third of them ended up voting for the Shiv Sena. Also interesting is the finding that while BJP used Shivaji’s name in its election campaign, not many voters saw it as the party that will protect his legacy.
Shivaji’ All Voted for… s legacy will be best protect ed by…
BJP+ Sena
BJP 11 69 7
Shiv 37 24 35 Sena NCP MORE CORRUPT OR CONGRESS?
%
Cong more corrupt than 15 NCP
NCP more corrupt than Cong 20
Both parties equally corrupt 39
Neither party corrupt 6
Can’t say 21
______
SHIV SENA MORE COMMUNAL OR BJP?
When respondents were asked about which was a more communal party between the Shiv Sena and the BJP, the former was perceived to be a slightly more communal than the latter. However, interestingly the BJP was seen as being more communal than the Sena among Muslims.
All Among Muslims
BJP more communal than SS 15 25
SS more communal than BJP 18 18
Both parties equally 23 21 communal
Neither party communal 15 11
Can’t say 29 26 MOST BJP AND SENA VOTERS WANTED THE TWO PARTIES TO COME TOGETHER IN THE EVENT OF A HUNG ASSEMBLY
When respondents were asked to give their preference for a coalition government in case of a hung assembly, most (27 percent) said they would like to see a BJP-Shiv Sena government together. 40 percent of those who voted for the BJP and Shiv Sena supported such an alliance.
Coalition govt All Among Among Among in BJP+ NCP SS case of a hung voters voters voters Assembly…
BJP-SS 27 40 40 11
BJP-NCP 4 3 1 13
______