Guangxi Modern Technical and Vocational Education and Training Development Program

Social Monitoring Report

#1 Semiannual Report November 2020

PRC: Guangxi Modern Technical and Vocational Education and Training Development Program

Prepared by the Guangxi Education Department for the People's Republic of China and the Asian Development Bank.

CURRENCY EQUIVALENTS (as of 18 November 2020)

Currency unit – yuan (CNY) CNY1.00 = $0.1525 $1.00 = CNY6.5568

ABBREVIATIONS ADB – Asian Development Bank AP – affected person CAP – corrective action plan GPMO – Guangxi project management office GRM – grievance redress mechanism GZAR – Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region HD – house demolition IR – involuntary resettlement LA – land acquisition LAR – land acquisition and resettlement M&E – monitoring and evaluation PRC – People's Republic of China RBL – results-based lending RF – resettlement framework TVET – technical and vocational education and training

WEIGHTS AND MEASURES m – meter m2 – square meter mu – Chinese unit of measurement (1 mu = 666.667 square meters)

NOTE In this report, "$" refers to United States dollars.

This social monitoring report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature.

In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

Results-based Guangxi Modern Technical and Vocational

Education and Training Development Program

Resettlement Monitoring Report (No.1)

July 2019

CONTENTS 1 Background ...... 1 1.1 Project Overview ...... 2 1.2 Overview of Subprojects and Involuntary Resettlement Impacts ...... 3 1.3 Scope of External Resettlement Monitoring and Evaluation ...... 47 2 Land Acquisition and Resettlement Impacts ...... 49 3 Public Participation and Grievance Redress Mechanism ...... 58 4 Institutional Arrangements ...... 71 4.1 Responsibilities of the Institutions ...... 72 4.2 Personnel and Facility ...... 74 4.3 Office Facility ...... 74 4.4 Assessment on Organization Capacity ...... 74 4.5 Institution Capacity Building and Training ...... 75 5 Resettlement Monitoring ...... 79 5.1 Guilin Tourism College ...... 79 5.2 Guangxi Vocational College of Industrial ...... 80 5.3 Guangxi Vocational College of Construction ...... 81 5.4 Guangxi College for Preschool Education ...... 83 5.5 Wuzhou University ...... 84 5.6 Guangxi Eco-engineering Vocational and Technical College ...... 86 5.7 Guangxi Financial Vocational College ...... 87 5.8 Liuzhou City Luzhai Vocational Education Center ...... 89 5.9 Rong County Secondary Specialized School ...... 90 5.10 Hechi City Health School ...... 91

5.11 Guangxi Industrial Technician College (The original name is Guangxi petrochemical advanced technical school) ...... 92 5.12 The Second Light Industry Technical School of Guangxi ...... 93 5.13 QuanZhou Vocational & Technical Schools ...... 94 5.14 Liuzhou No.1 Vocational and Technical School ...... 95 5.15 Guangxi Nanning Senior Technical School ...... 96 6 Conclusions and Suggestions ...... 98

TABLE CONTENT

Table 1-1 Guangxi Modern Technical and Vocational Education and Training Development Program (college) Resettlement Impact and Category—Screening Table ...... 5

Table 1-2: Resettlement Monitoring and Evaluation Schedule ...... 48

Table 2-1: Resettlement Impact and Category of 15 Schools of Subproject under Construction —Screening Table (Draft) ...... Error! Bookmark not defined.

Table 3-1 Project Public Participation and Information Disclosure ...... 58

Table 3-2 Project Appeal Table ...... 63

Table 3-3 The Feedback Form of Grievance Redress Mechanism ...... 64

Table 3-4 The Data of Grievance Redress ...... 67

1 Background

This report presents the first semiannual monitoring report on implementation of resettlement provisions consistent with the Program Action Plan agreed for the results- based lending (RBL) Guangxi Modern Technical and Vocational Education and

Training (TVET) Development Program. The status of progress on each of the actions related to involuntary resettlement safeguards in the Program Action Plan for the monitoring period January 2019 to June 2019 is summarized in Table below:

No Action Status Reference Remarks 1 Carry out the necessary screening, Completed for 74 Table 1-1 In the event of any preparation of resettlement planning schools proposed Guangxi Modern changes to documents, and implementation and in the RBL TVET locations monitoring of resettlement activities in program Development identified, the accordance with the agreed Program (college) screening will be resettlement framework Resettlement revised and Impact and recategorized, in Category— line with the Screening Table potential impacts.

2 Assign a staff at the PMO to act as Completed Section 4.2 - resettlement coordinator on resettlement activities, prepare resettlement monitoring reports, and maintain a resettlement database 3 Engage an external resettlement Monitoring to be Table 1,2 It has been monitor, acceptable to ADB and the carried out during Resettlement agreed between PMO, to carry out resettlement the RBL M&E Schedule. ADB and the PMO monitoring on a semiannual basis; implementation Chapter 5 that the semiannual external monitoring period summarizes the semiannual reports prepared by the external findings of the monitoring report resettlement monitor to be submitted monitoring carried will be prepared simultaneously to ADB and the PMO out for 15 of the by the TRTA 74 schools being consultant with taken up under support from the RBL program. PMO. As a result, the external resettlement monitor has not been engaged.

No Action Status Reference Remarks 4 Establish clear roles and Completed Section 4.1 - responsibilities on resettlement as part details the of the program’s institutional responsibilities of arrangements the various institutions responsible for land acquisition and involuntary resettlement 5 Ensure timely submission of internal Completed - monitoring reports to ADB, and The resettlement disclose resettlement monitoring To be carried out - monitoring reports reports to the village committee and to be disclosed TVET institutions in local language upon finalization of reports. ADB = Asian Development Bank, M&E = monitoring and evaluation, PMO = program management office, RBL = results-based lending, TRTA = transaction technical assistance, TVET = technical and vocational education and training. 1.1 Project Overview

The Guangxi Modern TVET Development Program will strengthen the capacity of education departments of regional, municipal and county in the Guangxi Zhuang

Autonomous Region (GZAR) to provide guidance and supervision for vocational education institutions and manage projects.

The program will support various building, procurement of advanced practice and training equipment, and training of teaching staff of vocational education institutions

(schools) in Guangxi province. It will also support government capacity building efforts to achieve effective management of TVET system; improve the standards and quality of vocational and technical education, strengthen cooperation between schools and enterprises, and establish partnerships with ASEAN region institutions to promote regional cooperation. The project will have the following four outputs:

Output 1: Industry relevance of the technical and vocational education and training enhanced. Explore a new mode of school–enterprise cooperation in which enterprise participate in lesson, training materials and method developing, evaluation process, promote the upgrading of professional construction, and support the

construction demonstration characteristic specialty and training base by school–

enterprise cooperation.

Output 2: Quality of technical and vocational education and training

improved. Strengthen the internal quality assurance in vocational college, teaching

diagnosis and improving work system, improve vocational college, especially the

teaching environment in secondary vocational schools, and strive to meet the national

construction standards. Further improve the capacity of the faculty, establish a

“double-qualified” teacher certification and incentive system, increase the proportion

of “double-qualified” teacher with teacher certification and vocational qualification

certification.

Output 3: Inclusiveness of technical and vocational education and training

increased. Expand access for poor students to capacity building subsidy such as

counseling, career guidance and employment service, so that they can successfully

find jobs or start their own businesses after completing their studies，support the building of national cultural heritage and innovation bases and promote the inheritance and innovation of national culture.

Output 4: Role of technical and vocational education and training in regional economic development expanded. Strengthen the transfer of technology and knowledge between Guangxi and ASEAN countries, promote long-term cooperation

between vocational schools in Guangxi and ASEAN countries, increase the number of

two-way exchanges, and expand the number of ASEAN students who have obtained vocational education certificates in Guangxi.

1.2 Overview of Subprojects and Involuntary Resettlement

Impacts

According to the involuntary resettlement impact screening list and subproject content list provided by each subproject school, there are a total of 74 subproject schools, including 22 colleges and 52 secondary vocational schools. The 74 schools are mainly used to build and improve teaching buildings, training buildings and

administration buildings in the campus, and improve infrastructure equipment and

information construction as well as teachers.

According to preliminary investigation, the proposed 74 subproject schools are

screened and categorized as follows, 60 subproject schools are built on the reserved

land of the original campus without land acquisition (LA) and house demolition (HD)

impact, which are categorized as C;

 10 subproject schools have completed the land acquisition and house

demolition from 2010 to 2019, and the land acquisition of 3,265.88 mu has

been completed, which are categorized as B;

 4 subproject schools have not yet determined the construction content of

specific projects, and the category is not decided yet.

For the 10 subproject schools that have completed land acquisition and house demolition, only the project content and the amount of land expropriated are provided, without specific data of the affected persons (APs). The next report will conduct a site visit to the 10 subproject schools and the schools about to start construction, collect relevant information such as the compensation contract of land acquisition and house demolition, payment vouchers, and check whether the APs have any unresolved grievances, and whether there are legal disputes over the land or inheritance. The detailed resettlement situation of 74 subproject schools is shown in Table 1-1.

This monitoring found that there is no LA and HD impact among the 60 subproject schools that are built on the reserved land of the original campus. By the end of June

2019, 15 subproject schools are under construction which were specified in this report.

Table 1-1 Guangxi Modern TVET Development Program (college) Resettlement Impact and Category—Screening Table By June 2019 Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 1 Guilin Tourism Guilin City 1. The main content of the project is a teaching 133.88 million Category C The school Being implemented College facility construction project named "college yuan obtained the land students physical education teaching center", in certificated in 2004 addition to the construction installation project, and the equipment purchases and supporting municipal construction facilities. The main body adopts frame structure, contents are being and the building has two floors. The construction built in the original area is about 18,000 m2. campus, the 2. The main content of construction including a acquired land is teaching facility construction named "Bagui cuisine reserved for the culture experience center" and renovation of the school, and there is original training center (Hotel Training Center). no LA and HD 3. The content of the Talent Project Plan including impact. introduction of high-level talents, teacher training and promotion. 4. The contents of the International Cooperation Projects including consulting fee and certification fee, OLF training fee, teaching fee and construction of ASEAN tourism vocational service platform. 2 Guangxi Nanning The total building covering an area of 14,100 m2 114.79 million Category C According to the Vocational City and construction area is 51,025 m2 (including yuan (ADB and investigation, the College of 29,584 m2 construction area of the intelligent KFW Loan for land of original Industrial manufacturing training base of Guangxi Vocational 20 million campus was state- College of Industrial) yuan/supporting owned unused land

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） funds for 94.79 and transferred to million yuan) the government of Wuming county, GZAR on January 8, 2003. Since the government has not yet developed and utilized the land, the surrounding farmers have reclaimed and cultivated during this period. In 2012, the government of Wuming county has made green crop compensation to the farmers who cultivated the land. After completing the green crop compensation, the land has been allocated to Guangxi Vocational College

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） of Industrial. There are no remaining problems. 3 Guangxi Nanning Total construction is 34,780 m2 (including office 147.06 million Category C According to the Vocational City building for 10,837.1m2, basement for 3,667.9 m2, yuan investigation, the College of information center for 2,127.9 m2, library for construction is Construction 18,147.1 m2), covering an area of 5,218.8 m2. The carried out in the building is frame-shear wall structure. The original campus, construction content includes building, structure, the acquired land is water supply, electric, heating, air condition, fire reserved for the control and environment protection. school, and there is no LA and HD impact. The school obtained the land certificated in 2016. According to the investigation, there is no remaining problems. 4 Guangxi College Nanning The construction for Phase I covers an area of Total Category C According to the for Preschool Educational 477,102.39 m2 (about 715.65 mu). 427,028.8 m2 investment is investigation, the Education Zone (about 640.54 mu) for net area. 1,733.21 million land occupied by The construction content includes teaching and yuan (ADB loan the new campus of training building (public teaching room, teaching 144 million Guangxi College and training room and office room), library, indoor yuan/supporting for Preschool gym, office room, assembly hall and students funds for Education is state- activity room, student dormitory, dormitory for 1,589.21 million owned land, and single staff, canteen, office supporting room and yuan) the transfer

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） attachment room and so on. As well as the procedures of supporting infrastructure such as intelligent state-owned land system, playground, water supply, electric supply, have been front gate, wall, road, greening and viewing, water completed, the and square. land certificate is being applied now. There is no LA and HD impact. 5 Wuzhou Wuzhou 1. Civil of the comprehensive experimental building 105.5 million Category C The school University City (technical building). yuan obtained the land 2. Reeducation and training center certificate in 2003. 3. Comprehensive practical training platform for According to the economic and management vocational education. investigation, the 4. Intelligent control and manufacturing integrated construction training platform contents are 5. Comprehensive training room for teacher’s conducted in the educational ability original campus, 6. Intelligent renovation of library. the acquired land is 7. Construction of teaching staff reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 6 Guangxi Liuzhou city Construction of No.3 and No.4 student dormitory, Total Category C The school Eco-engineering a cooking practice building, and a library, a total of investment is obtained the land Vocational and 45,313.14 m2. 176.63 million certificate in 2003. Technical College yuan According to the investigation, the construction

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） contents are conducted in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 7 Guangxi Finance Nanning 28,116.91 m2 of the construction of Total estimated Category C The school Vocational and City library, including 24,500.72 m2 above ground and investment of obtained the land Technical School 3,616.2 m2 underground. the project is certificate in 2013, 97.61 million. there is no The loan is 60 remaining million yuan, problems. with supporting According to the facilities of investigation, the 37.61 million construction yuan. contents are built in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 8 Liuzhou city Luzhai The project covers an area of 2,133.40 m2, with a A total Category C The school Luzhai vocational county total construction area of 15,128.01 m2, including investment of obtained the land education center an above-ground construction area of 111,48.09 37.89 million certificate in 2010.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） m2. There are six floors above the ground, one floor yuan（20 million According to the underground. The basement is 4.5 m high and the yuan from investigation, the first floor is 4.2 m high, the height of the two to six ADB/supporting construction is layers is 3.9 m, and the total height is 23.85 m. The funds of 14.89 conducted in the basement is mainly equipped with motor vehicle million yuan） original campus, parking space, fire pool, water pump room, the acquired land is generator room and power distribution room; The reserved for the first to fifth floors are mainly equipped with training school, and there is rooms, preparation rooms, toilets, guard rooms, no LA and HD boiling water rooms, lecture halls and reading impact. rooms. There are offices, toilets, guard rooms and boiling water rooms on the sixth floor. 9 Rong county Rong student dormitory project of campus expansion ADB investment Category C According to the secondary county project covers an area of 1,221.26 m2; e- of 29.79 million investigation, the Vocational school commerce training building project of campus yuan subproject expansion project, covers an area of 1,275 m2 construction is implemented in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 10 Hechi City Health Hechi city The new construction for training building of Hechi Total Category C According to the School City Health School covers an area of 1,186 m2. the investment: investigation ， the demolished old auditorium in this school is used for 29.24 million new training construction, which does not involve land yuan /25 million building of Hechi acquisition. yuan (ADB) / City Health School

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 4.24 million will demolish the yuan （ Local school’s old government auditorium and supporting build it on the site. funds） There is no LA and HD impact. 11 Guangxi Nanning The student apartment for high-skilled talents is The total Category C The school Industrial city located in the east of the middle of the campus, investment of obtained the land Technician with a total construction area of 19,304.25 m2. The the project is certificate in 2014. College area of occupied land for building is 11,44.67 m2， 48.81 million According to the it is a high-rise building with 17 floors. The building yuan (Germany investigation, the is used for the student dormitory and supporting KFW bank is 20 construction is rooms. The main contents of construction include million yuan, carried out in the construction engineering, decoration engineering, and the school original campus, water supply and drainage engineering, electrical raised 28.81 the acquired land is engineering, heating engineering and general level million yuan by reserved for the related supporting engineering itself). school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 12 The Second Light Nanning A student dorm building with a six-layer frame A total Category C It had completed Industry city structure will be constructed in this project. The investment: the land acquisition Technical School height of building is 25.8 m, the total area of 28.11 million in 2014 and gotten of Guangxi building is 10,322.2 m2, the occupied land of yuan land certificate in building is 3,247.86 m2. There will be 227 standard 2015. 139.98 mu apartment dormitories (8 persons/room), 2 land has been accessible dormitories (2 persons/room), 5 public acquired which laundry rooms and 1 management room in this concludes new building. cultivated land of

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 19.89 mu, garden plot of 87.88 mu and forestland of 32.21 mu. In light of investigation, LA work had been completed, and its compensation had been completed in 2014. There are no remaining issues, 13 Quanzhou Quanzhou 1. A new student dormitory building, 5-floor frame 22 million yuan Category C The school Vocational & county structure building, covering an area of 881.29 m2, obtained the land Technical a total construction area of 4524.55 m2. certificate in 2008. Schools 2. Construct a one-floor steel frame structures According to the mechanics training workshop, the building covers investigation, the an area of 1,600 m2, with a total construction area construction is of 1,600 m2 implemented in the 3. Information teaching equipment original campus, 4. Upgrade and replace training equipment the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 14 Liuzhou No.1 Liuzhou city 1. Power electrical renovation 25 million yuan Category C The school Vocational and 2. School teaching, work area of smart water and obtained the land Technical School electricity meters and supporting facilities certificate in 2010. According to the

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 3. Energy-saving hot water supply system for investigation, the student dormitory construction is 4. Indoor and outdoor lighting lamps and lanterns carried out in the transformation original campus, 5. Construction for Integrated business information the acquired land is system reserved for the 6. Construction for financial management internal school, and there is control system no LA and HD 7. Introduction of western food courses and impact. vocational qualification certificates 8. Constructing new student dormitory buildings 15 Guangxi Nanning Nanning Integrated teaching building construction project of 55.32 million Category C The school Senior Technical city Guangxi Nanning senior technical school, main yuan (25 million obtained the land School construction contents: foundation pit support yuan from ADB/ certificate in 2014. engineering, civil engineering, installation 30.32 million According to the engineering, water supply and drainage yuan of local investigation, all engineering, electrical engineering, heating supporting subprojects are engineering, elevator engineering, firefighting funds) built in the original engineering, outdoor greening engineering, campus, the outdoor road engineering, sponge city, green acquired land is building, etc. reserved for the Construction scale: this project will build an school, and there is integrated teaching building, with a total land area no LA and HD of 92,27.51 m2 (13.84 mu in total) and a building impact. area of 19,054.06 m2, including an above-ground building area of 14,894.06 m2, including a building area of 14,591.70 m2 for practical training and a building area of 302.36 m2 for ancillary buildings.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） The underground building area is 4,160.00 m2. And supporting roads, greening, outdoor hydropower and other ancillary projects. 16 Guilin University Guilin City 1. Civil project is a construction content of the new 205 million yuan Category C The new campus unimplemented of Aerospace campus extension project. Including NO.1 to NO.4 (130 million has completed LA Technology Training Center, Center of Students Innovation yuan from ADB and HD in 2017. As and Entrepreneurship as well as the and 75 million Guilin University of Comprehensive Gymnasium. The total yuan supporting Aerospace construction area is 44,376.93 m2 and covers an funds) Technology area of 14,890 m2. participates the 2. Maintenance and renovation project. The Guangxi reginal estimated cost of the maintenance and renovation cooperation and project is 30 million yuan and 20 million yuan from integration ADB loan will be planned to put into use in 2019. promotion project 3. Balance Payment of the Construction. Balance (project no: 50050- payment of apartment buildings No.2, 5 and 6 in 004), and a DDR the south campus is expected to be paid with 15 has been prepared million yuan, and it is planned to use loans all from for the newly ADB. campus in 2017. According to the conclusion of DDR, land acquisition compensation and resettlement of house demolition have been completed, the land certificate has

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） been obtained in 2018, there is no remaining problems. The old campus obtained the land certificate in 2004. According to investigation, there are no remaining problems. 17 Yulin Normal Yulin city 1 Comprehensive teaching building No.7 and Investment Category C The school unimplemented University sports facilities construction project. The amount: 147.98 completed the land construction area of No.7 comprehensive teaching million yuan acquisition in 2009 building is 25,000 m2; a standard 400 m ground and the land track field with 3,000 m2 platform and audience compensation, and area; road, power, water supply, sewage and obtained the land greening will be also equipped as well as the certificate in 2014, pavement of Yulan Lake, Qingshui Platform and there is no Square of Yulan Lake. remaining 2. Basic laboratory renovation and upgrading problems. project (including experimental instruments, According to the equipment and software systems). investigation, the 3. Construction of Information Center (including construction cloud center, servers, switches and other basic contents will be equipment). implemented in the original campus, the acquired land is

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 4. Supporting facilities of dormitory No.7 and No.8 reserved for the (including bed, multifunction desk, chair and air school, and there is condition and so on). no LA and HD impact. 18 Guangxi Nanning The total construction area is 66,354.36 m2 and 227.54 million Category C The school unimplemented Transport city covering an area of 17,834.95 m2. including newly yuan (70.99 obtained the land Vocational and built cars and track training buildings for 27,215.36 million yuan certificate in 2003. Technical College m2, road and bridge training buildings for 39,139 /156.55 million According to the of m2. Equipped with parking lot, road and greening. yuan) investigation, the Communications construction contents will be carried out in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 19 Hechi University Yizhou City 1. Building a 15-floor vocational training building. 82.39 million Category C The school unimplemented Covering an area of 2,520 m2 and the construction yuan obtained the land is 30,000 m2. certificate in 2016. 2. Demolished the old dangerous building and there are no rebuilt a 7-floor student dormitory. The building remaining covers an area of 3,926.30 m2 and the construction problems. area is 10,409.75 m2. According to the 3. 15,000 m2 of the surface of the teaching building investigation, the 2 and 3,000 m2 environmental maintenance; 19,500 old dangerous m2 of artificial grassland and runway renovation training will be

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） project; 4,500 m2 of roof renovation on gym; 800 reconstructed in m2 for the well lid of the ditch in school as well 850 the original m2 of the road widening; 500 m2 single floor steel- campus. There is framed training room for art and design; 40 0m2 no impact of LA renovation of the art and design exhibition hall; and HD. circuit expansion 1250KVA box transformer and laying 10KV cable. 20 Guangxi Liuzhou city Two comprehensive buildings with the function of 25 million yuan Category C The school unimplemented Business School practical training and teaching and student obtained the land accommodation will be built, covering an area of certificate in 2005. 937.04 m2, with a total construction area of 6,680.2 According to the m2 (1,874.08 m2 for practical training and teaching investigation, the and 4,806.12 m2 for student accommodation). A construction will be dormitory building, covering an area of 383.81 m2, carried out in the building area of 2,363.06 m2, at the same time original campus, supporting automobile marketing training the acquired land is equipment and corresponding facilities of student reserved for the apartments. school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 21 Guangxi Yulin Yulin city 1. An investment of 18.2026 million yuan is A total Category C The school Have not started Agricultural invested in the construction of a seven-story high estimated obtained the land School building (including empty space), 2# teaching investment of certificate in 2011. building in the campus with an area of 1,223.62 m2 21.7026 million According to the and a total construction area of 9,000 m2. yuan， investigation, the 2. An investment of 3.5 million yuan was used to including： construction will be purchase teaching equipment and facilities, proposed KFW conducted in the including: loan of 20 original campus,

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds）（1）An investment of 1.674 million yuan was used million-yuan, the acquired land is to purchase 54 sets of multimedia equipment for self-raised reserved for the classroom of 2# teaching building. funds of 1.70 school, and there is （2）An investment of 0.48 million yuan was used million yuan. no LA and HD to purchase 2,000 sets of desks and chairs for 2# impact. teaching building classroom. （3）An investment of 1.346 million yuan was used to purchase a batch of new energy vehicle equipment, and build three training rooms, including the training room for basic technology of new energy vehicles, the training room for integration of electricians and electronics of new energy vehicles, and the training room for new energy vehicles. 22 Yulin No.1 Yulin city 1. Two (1#, 4#) student dormitory building A total Category C The school Have not started Secondary construction, the total construction area of investment of obtained the land Vocational 3,817.82 m2, including: 1# student dormitory, the 21.5 million certificate in 2015. School floor area of 316.34 m2, a total of five floors, the yuan（ADB According to the construction area of 1,637.98 m2; 4# student investment of investigation, the dormitory, the building covers an area of 326.62 20 million construction will be m2, the design of the empty space, a total of six yuan/self-raised carried out in the floors, the construction area of 2,179.84 m2; funds of 1.5 original campus, 2. Construction of intelligence campus million yuan） the acquired land is 3. Purchase of professional training equipment for reserved for the Chinese cuisine and western cuisine school, and there is 4. Logistics service and management professional no LA and HD training base construction impact. 5. Book purchase

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 23 Hechi Hechi city 1. the area of occupied land of vocational 20 million yuan Category C The school Have not started Yizhou Vocational education center fusion education complex （ADB: 20 obtained the land Education Center building in Hechi city is 810 m2, with a total million yuan/ certificate in 2014. construction area of 7,290 m2 Local According to the 2. the project of production-education integration supporting investigation, the information equipment procurement and funds） construction will be installation for Yizhou district vocational education conducted in the center in Hechi city, is mainly information original campus, equipment procurement and installation. the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 24 Guangxi yulin Yulin City The project will build a training comprehensive Total Category C According to Have not started technician college building with 8 floors and public auxiliary facilities, investment: investigation, the (Guangxi yulin the area of construction planning land is 3,991 m2, 29.03 million practical training senior technical the area of planning occupied land is 1,056.69 m2, yuan (KFW: 25 building will be built school) total area of building is 8,904.00 m2. million yuan, in the original the supporting campus of the funds: 4.03 school, and the million yuan) land was reserved for the school. There is no impact of LA and HD. 25 Liuzhou NO.2 Liuzhou city 1. Build a new integrated teaching building, and at Total Category C The school Have not started Vocational School the same time, build supporting power supply and investment: obtained the land distribution, water supply and drainage, and other 61.73 million certificate in 2010. ancillary facilities. yuan. The construction

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 2. The project will cover an area of 2,713 m2, the will be in the building covers an area of 13,738 m2. The main original campus, content of construction is to build a 4# training the acquired land is school and water supply and drainage and other reserved for the ancillary facilities. school, and there is no impact of LA and HD. 26 Guiping city NO.1 Guiping city A newly training comprehensive building will be The total Category C According to the Have not started Secondary built, covering an area of 800m2, the ground floor investment of investigation, the Vocational and will be 13 floors, a total construction area of 9,812 the project is 20 construction will be Technical School m2, supporting with related ancillary projects. The million yuan in the original main construction content is civil engineering, (KFW loans of campus, the water supply and drainage, fire control, electrical, 20 million acquired land is lightning protection and other projects. yuan.) reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 27 Guilin tourism Guilin city 1. Teaching comprehensive building: land area: 25.68 million Category C The school Have not started vocational 1,130 m2,the total area of building: 5,400m2，the yuan obtained the land secondary height: 18 meters (5 ground floors) certificate in 2005. professional 2. Counseling center building covers an area of According to the school 362 m2, including group activity area, sand table investigation, the game area, music relaxation area. training building will 3. Computer application professional training base: be rebuilt on the 3 training room, including: (a) 1 computer original site in the professional animation graphics processing room original campus (55 desk computers) covers an area of 102 m2; (b) and there is no LA 1 Network comprehensive wiring competition to and HD impact.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） upgrade the training room, located in training building 4# 4-1 room, covering an area of 102 m2； 3. PDS engineering technology certification training room (Network integrated wiring engineering certification training room), covering an area of 102 m2. In addition, Including training equipment procurement and training room decoration. 4. Stadium stage construction project: which covers an area of 200 m2. 5. The renovation project of the lecture theatre (multi-function hall): located in 2 floors of 7# in school，which covers an area of 404 m2, including sound amplification system, LED and other supporting facilities and equipment. 6. Renovation for track and field plastic ring runway: Refurbishment for a plastic ring track at the standard of 8 tracks,400 m, including a mixed plastic track: 8,148 m2; 30 mm reinforced non- filling artificial turf: 7,775.6 m2. 7. Rebuilding the dining room: covering an area of 1125 m2, the repast area is 1406 m2. Including the demolition and reconstruction of the old operation room, internal washing and elimination facilities and equipment in the operation room, water supply and drainage lines, the ground will be changed to anti-skid environmentally friendly glue ground, decorative partition, new add dining table cover,

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） healthy diet culture canteen management materials. 28 Guangxi Qinzhou Qinzhou 1. The project will construct a teaching building 25 million yuan Category C The school Have not started Agricultural city with 5 ground floors, and the building covers an obtained the land School area of 2,822.7 m2 certificate in 2002. 2. The project will construct a training student According to the dormitory building with 5 ground floors, and the investigation, the building covers an area of 3,500 m2. construction will be 3. Purchasing 10,000 books. conducted in the 4. Purchasing information campus system, original campus, professional teaching resources, library digital the acquired land is management system and another digital platform. reserved for the 5. Teacher training school, and there is 6. Purchasing 100 computers no LA and HD impact. 29 Guangxi Wuzhou Wuzhou Guangxi Wuzhou Business School proposes to The total Category C The school Have not started Business School city build one Training Building, with 7 floors above investment obtained the land ground and 1 underground floor (for underground amount of t certificate in 2011. civil anti-parking facilities). The building covers an 26.73 million According to area of 672.74 m2 and the total construction area yuan, the ADB investigation, the is 6,696.26 m2. The main construction contents loan will be 25 dilapidated old include civil engineering, decoration works, million yuan, administrative equipment and tools purchase, water supply and and the school office building in drainage engineering, electrical engineering, self-raised the original campus outdoor site hardening and greening, etc. funds is 1.73 will be demolished million yuan. and rebuilt, and there is no LA and HD impact.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 30 Guangxi Urban Guilin City 1. Sewage treatment center. 30 million yuan Category C The school Have not started Construction 2. Sports center obtained the land School 3. No. 17 Teaching Building; newly build 1 teaching certificate in 2012. building, with 6 floors, and total construction area According to the for 4,650 m2, including civil work and installation. investigation, the 4. National Craft Inheritance and Innovation construction will be Training Building, with total of 2 floors, with total carried out in the construction area for 3,000 m2, including civil work original campus, and installation. the acquired land is 5. UAV application technology production and reserved for the education integration training base: (1) The indoor school, and there is training room covers an area of about 300 m2, and no LA and HD the outdoor training field covers an area of about impact. 5,000 m2. Including two major modules, the UAV production and teaching integration of basic skills training module and UAV production and education integration surveying and mapping industry application training module; (2) Basic training and cultural construction of the training room; (3) Related equipment and facilities. 6. National Crafts Inheritance and Innovation Training Room: Baogui concrete training ground, Fine woodworking training room, Carved porcelain training room 7. Student Comprehensive Literacy Center: including Mind Oxygen Bar, Music House, Glamour Body Shape Dance Room, Dance Club, Tea Art Club, Originality Club.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 8. School–enterprise cooperation dual-sector construction (teacher training, corporate training), teaching ability improvement (information training, professional training, etc.), school executive training, school and enterprise teacher training (including foreign training), totaling of 70 person/times or more. 31 Guangxi Nanning 1. Intelligent manufacturing innovation center: it is A total Category C The school Have not started Vocational City planned to construct the first floor of the first investment of obtained the land College of practical training building to be put into use in the 47.56 million certificate in 1999. Mechanical and college, including the training room of the yuan (40 million The construction Electronical comprehensive practical training system of yuan of ADB) will be carried out in Technology intelligent processing unit, the training room of the the original comprehensive practical training system of campus, the industrial robot technology application and the acquired land is training room of Siemens advanced automation reserved for the technology. The total construction area is about school, and there is 1,000 m2. Self-owned capital construction. no LA and HD 2. Mass entrepreneurship space: it is planned to impact. build a student innovation and entrepreneurship base including seed incubation room, start-up incubation room, open Shared work platform, entrepreneurship training center, road show hall and other places on the second floor and part of the second teaching building on the second floor of the college, with a total construction area of about 3,000 m2.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 3. The college students' cultural quality education base: plan the second would be built in the college classroom teaching building on the fourth floor of the whole layer and the second and third floor construction includes parts of college students creative studio, youth culture media center, the second classroom transcripts experience show center, student community cultural exchange area, the second classroom performance database, dance studio, music studio, such as moral lecture hall, the amphitheater, a students' cultural quality education center, a total construction area of about 1,700 m2. 32 Guangxi Nanning A student apartment building with 6 floors above Total invest 40 Category C The school Have not started Vocational and city ground and 1 floor underground will be built, million yuan obtained the land Technical College covering an area of 2,258.07 m2, the total (including 34 certificate in 1998. construction area is 14,963.55 m2 (including million yuan The construction 13,098.75 m2 above ground and 1,864.80 m2 from ADB and 6 will be in the underground), the building height is 21.85 m. million yuan original campus, from school) the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 33 Guangxi Nanning Newly built 3 student dormitories and a canteen Total Category C The school Have not started Vocational City building, with a total area of 4,493 m2 and a total investment is 78 obtained the land College of construction area of 32,727.45 m2. The estimated million yuan. certificate in 2004. The construction

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） International total investment of the project is 102.76 million ADB loan for 65 will be in the Business yuan. million yuan original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 34 Guangxi Medical Nanning The total construction is 62,483.14 m2, building Total Category C The school Have not started College City area is 2,938.44 m2. Construction area for 15# investment is obtained the land student dormitory is 1,498.12 m2; construction area 170 million certificate in 2010. for student dormitory is 31,858.48 m2. 22 floors yuan. The construction above ground, 1 floor underground and the ADB loan for 57 will be in the building height 79.64 m. Construction area for 16# million original campus, student dormitory and canteen is 1,440.32 m2. The yuan/supporting the acquired land is functions are student dormitory, kitchen and funds for 113 reserved for the canteen, the building area is 3,0624.66 m2 million yuan. school, and there is (including underground area for 2,818.28 m2, no LA and HD capacity area for 2,156 m2 and 662.28 m2 out of impact. calculate). 20 floors above ground, 2 floors underground and the building height 74.25 m. 35 Nanning Chongzuo 1. Project of student dormitory: two 8-floor frame 61 million yuan Category C The construction Have not started Prefecture City structure buildings. The construction area is will be in the Education 20,000 m2 including furniture and other equipment. original campus, College 2. 100,000 books, library digital resources and the acquired land is equipment reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 36 Guangxi Science Laibin City 1. Construction of practical training platform for 80.78 million Category C The school Have not started and Technology general skills of teachers' specialty in yuan obtained the land Normal University demonstration teacher education base. certificate in 2012. 2. Library resources and equipment construction. The construction 3. Construction of intelligence campus. will be in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 37 Hezhou Hezhou 1. The industry-education integration training 105 million yuan Category C The school Have not started University City center covers an area of 6,650 m2, and the (75 million yuan obtained the land construction area is 20,000 m2. Total 6 floors, from ADB certificate in 2012. frame structure. loan/supporting The construction 2. The local ethnic studies center covers an area funds for 30 will be in the of 5,305 m2, and the construction area is 14,442.25 million yuan) original campus, m2. Total 4 floors, frame structure. the acquired land is 3. The modern vocational education experimental reserved for the training center planning purchase 4 laboratories' school, and there is modern vocational education training equipment no LA and HD impact. 38 Guangxi Ji Dian Nanning The proposed "Guangxi Ji Dian Gong Cheng Xue A total Category C The school Have not started Gong Cheng Xue city Xiao Shuangchuang building" is located in the west investment of obtained the land Xiao of Guangxi Ji Dian Gong Cheng Xue Xiao, on Anji 40 million yuan， certificate in 2012. avenue. A teaching building covers an area of including 25 According to 1,650 m2 and a construction area of 10,140 m2 million yuan of investigation, the (including the basement of the negative first floor ADB, 15 million construction will be

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） covering an area of 2,800 square meters). 2. Floor yuan of local in the original function design: the first floor: reception center and supporting campus, the car beauty and sales center; the second and third funds. acquired land is floors: school-enterprise cooperative hotel reserved for the management and training base; fourth and fifth school, and there is floors: entrepreneurship and innovation training, no LA and HD skills training, policy consulting and information impact. service room; sixth to ninth floors: "introducing enterprises to school" workshop room; and level 10: training and large conferences. 39 Guangxi Institute Nanning The project contents include civil engineering, A total Category C According to Have not started Science and city electrical engineering, water supply and drainage investment of investigation, the Technology engineering, firefighting engineering, solar energy 92 million yuan. construction will be School hot water engineering, elevator and split air The proposed in the original conditioning, etc. The total construction area of the KFW loan is 25 campus, the project is 36,167.39 m2, including the construction million yuan, acquired land is of an art training building of 12,557.23 m2, a and the reserved for the teaching and training building of 9,905.47 m2, a supporting school, and there is student dormitory building of 5,844.48 m2, a library funds is 67 no LA and HD of 8,244.96 m2. million yuan. impact. 40 Guangxi Textile Nanning Construct a teaching building with 15 layers on the A total Category C The school Have not started Industry School city ground, one underground layer, a total investment of obtained the land construction area of 15,872.37 m2, covers an area 46.5217 million certificate in 1996 of 996.40 m2. yuan. The ADB According to loans of 2.5 investigation, the million yuan, construction will be and the school in the original raised 21.52 campus, the

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） million yuan by acquired land is itself. reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 41 Guangxi Nanning 1. A new 12-story student apartment building with 37.5 million Category C The school Have not started Overseas city a floor area of 14,754.29 m2 is concave, 50.30 m yuan（ADB of 25 obtained the land Chinese School long, 39.20 m wide and 43.50 m high. There are 12 million yuan/ certificate in 2013. floors above ground, each of which is 3.60 m high. supporting According to Underground parking is provided in the building. funds of 12.5 investigation, the 2. To build an information management platform million yuan） construction will be based on big data and Internet of Things. The in the original construction contents include intelligent campus campus, the informatization unified management platform, acquired land is campus one-card system, teaching diagnosis and reserved for the improvement quality monitoring and analysis school, and there is platform, teacher professional development no LA and HD platform, professional development and evaluation impact. platform, teaching resources and network teaching platform, as well as hardware infrastructure equipment needed to support the operation of each platform and system. 42 Guangxi Nanning The project is a new practical building, the building 30 million yuan/ Category C The school Have not started nationality city area: 1,243 m2, building with 10 layers, building (KFW） obtained the land secondary height of 36.3 m, a total construction area of certificate in 1993. professional 9,614.95 m2. According to school investigation, the construction is in

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 43 Guangxi Youjiang Baise city A teaching administrative complex building is to be 9 million yuan Category C The school Have not started Commercial built covers an area of about 600 m2. obtained the land College for certificate in 1981. Nationalities According investigation, the school construction content is to demolish the small dangerous and old teaching administration complex building and reconstruction. The acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 44 Gvangjsih Liuzhou city This project is divided into three aspects: practical A total Category C The school Have not started Liujcouh Cuzmuz training condition construction, information estimated obtained the land Couyih Yozyau construction and teacher training. The construction investment of certificate in 2010.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） of practical training conditions includes the 25.28 million According to construction of a new VR wisdom practical training yuan（including investigation, the center; Improve the existing car beauty repair proposed KFW construction will be integration training room function; Improve loan of 25 in the original agricultural mechanization operation and million yuan ， campus, the maintenance training base of level 2 maintenance supporting acquired land is module, vehicle electrical vehicle maintenance funds of school reserved for the module, automotive engine troubleshooting of 282,600 school, and there is module, car parts detection module, car engine yuan） no LA and HD disassemble module, automobile chassis and impact. transmission disassembling modules, and on the base of new energy between the training room, car marketing training room 1;1 newly built 3D tour guide training room specializing in tourism service and management; 1 newly built financial affairs training room for financial affairs major;1 newly built practical training room for network construction and application of computer network technology; New social culture and art (preschool education direction) professional kindergarten simulation classroom, multi-functional vocal music training room each 1. Information construction mainly improves the information security of campus network and creates a smart campus environment by improving software and hardware configuration. Teacher training is to improve the overall quality of the teaching staff by means of

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） practical training in enterprises and training in developed areas. 45 Cangwu county Wuzhou The comprehensive building project including A total Category C The school Have not started secondary city three supplies and one leveling and the main investment of obtained the land specialized construction, covering an area of 1,074 m2, with a 20 million yuan， certificate in 2014. school total construction area of 7,678 m2. It has seven from KFW loan. According to floors, with a height of 4.5 m for each floor and 3.6 investigation, the m high from the second to seventh floors. The construction will be functions are set as office and training. in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 46 Beibuwan Qinzhou 1. The new construction of a new culture and A total Category C The school Have not started vocational city sports and skill training center, a total construction investment of obtained the land technical institute area of 9556 m2, 2 layer. The main contents of 28.95 million certificate in 2009. construction include civil engineering, decoration yuan According to engineering, equipment procurement, water investigation, the supply and drainage engineering, electrical construction will be engineering and outdoor water supply and in the original drainage and other infrastructure engineering campus, the within the scope, procurement of equipment, etc. acquired land is 2. culture and sports and skills training center reserved for the supporting equipment school, and there is no LA and HD impact.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 47 Lingshan county Lingshan 1.It is planned to build a teaching building, covering A total Category C The school Have not started vocational county an area of 701 m2, with a total construction area of investment of obtained the land technical institute 3,505.5 m2, with five floors on the ground, frame 26 million yuan certificate in 2003 structure. (The financial According to 2. It is planned to build a student dormitory loan amount is investigation, the building, covering an area of 576 m2 with a total 20 million yuan construction will be construction area of 2,880 m2, with five floors on and the self- in the original the ground, frame structure. raised campus, the 3. It is planned to build a publicity hall for supporting fund acquired land is enterprises recruitment, covering an area of 2,400 is 6 million reserved for the 2 2 m , with a total construction area of 2,400 m , a yuan) school, and there is floor height of 18 m, and a frame + steel structure. no LA and HD impact. 48 Guigang city Guigang Civil engineering projects of 8,000 m2，covers an A total Category C The school Have not started vocational city area of 1,140 m2 investment of obtained the land education center 22 million yuan certificate in 2009. According to investigation, the construction will be in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 49 Baise ethnic Baise city 1. Plan to build a virtual and real integrated training 25 million yuan Category C Equipment Have not started health school base for nursing major (equipment procurement); procurement, no

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 2. Smart campus construction (equipment civil engineering, procurement);3. Faculty quality improvement and there is no LA project (training) and HD impact. 50 LaiBin Vocational Laibin city Comprehensive building project construction, 27.5 million Category C The school Have not started Education Center frame structure, the occupied land area of yuan, including obtained the land School construction is about 1,200 m2, the building is 10 the self-raised certificate in 2013. floors, its area is 10,000 m2. funds is 2.5 According to million yuan. investigation, the construction will be in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 51 Guangxi Liuzhou city A total area of the planning land is 235,542.27 m2 The investment Category C The school Have not started Technician (Total: 353.313 mu), construction area of planning is 35 million obtained the land College of is 216,732.13 m2, according to the unified yuan (25 million certificate in 1993. Machinery & planning, and phased implementation, the yuan for KFW / According to Electricity construction area of project (phase I) is 153,965 10 million yuan investigation, the m2, the construction area of numerical control for the college) construction will be technology center building in the first phase of the in the original project is 13,838.29 m2. campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） education center ground area is 23,851.95 m2, the underground yuan/ local According to school area is 1,066.5 m2, the land area is 1,862.76 m2. supporting investigation, the The main content of construction includes civil funds: 85.7314 construction will be engineering and supporting construction electrical million yuan) in the original engineering, water supply and drainage campus, the engineering, fire production engineering, acquired land is ventilation engineering, weak current engineering, reserved for the communication engineering, etc. school, and there is 2. A newly training comprehensive building will be no LA and HD built, a total construction area of 29,214.02 m2， impact. and a training building covers an area of 19,250.02 m2；2 nursing buildings, and each nursing building covers an area of 9,964 m2. According to the actual situation, the original two nursing buildings were combined into one building, with a construction area of 10,401.85 m2, which covers total land area of 1,654.75 m2. 55 GuangxI Wuzi Nanning 1. Improving the basic ability of running a school 30 million yuan. Category C The school Have not started School city 2. Construction of campus culture obtained the land 3. Special promotion of educational research and certificate in 1979. reform According to 4. Research and construction of linkage between investigation, the middle and higher vocational education construction will be 5. Teaching resource construction in the original 6. Construction for professional training room campus, the 7. Campus intelligent informatization acquired land is 8. Educational propaganda reserved for the school, and there is

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） no LA and HD impact. 56 Guangxi Nanning The project will cover an area of 683.6 m2, the The investment Category C The school Have not started Mechanical and City original building (old hall) will be demolished with of this project is obtained the land Electrical Industry an area of 711.65 m2, and a new multipurpose estimated to be certificate in 2003. School building of 6,874.29 m2 will be built. The ground 32.71 million According to floor will be ten floors, the basement will be one yuan, including investigation, the floor, and the first ground floor is a multipurpose ADB loan for 30 construction will be hall, conference room, school history hall, and the million yuan, in the original second floor for the Youth League and community and 2.71million campus, the activities center, the third floor is the conference yuan will be acquired land is room and the teacher's office, the fourth floor is the raised by local reserved for the conference room and the administrative office; the construction school, and there is fifth floor is the classroom, and the sixth to tenth department. no LA and HD floors are the training room and the integrated impact. classroom. 57 Guangxi Aquatic Nanning 1. A newly teaching and training comprehensive The investment Category C After investigation, Have not started Animal City building will be built, covering an area of 1,500 m2, of this project is the construction Husbandry and a total construction area of 10,000 m2, estimated to be will be in the School supporting with outdoor greening, landscape, road 30 million yuan, original campus, hardening and hydropower facilities. from ADB loan. the acquired land is 2. Construction of campus informatization. reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 58 Guidong Health Hezhou city Which covers with total land area of 2,500 m2，of Special central Category C The school Have not started Secondary which the Building will cover an area of 1,500 m2. funds and self- obtained the land School Total construction area for 12,100 m2，with 6 floors. raised funds. certificate in 2001.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） According to investigation, the construction will be in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 59 Jingxi Vocational Baise city Jingxi city vocational and technical school, The total Category C The school Have not started and Technical comprehensive training building project building investment is obtained the land School area 6868 square meters, 7 floors above ground about 21.11 certificate in 1985. million yuan. According to investigation, the construction will be in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 60 Chongzuo City Chongzuo The total land area of the building is 3 mu, and the 20 million yuan Category C The school Have not started Vocational and city building area is 7,950 m2, which is 4-floor frame of KFW loan obtained the land Technical School structure above the land. certificate in 2010. According to investigation, the

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） construction will be in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. 61 Guangxi Nanning Proposed construction of a six-story 25 million yuan Undetermined The school Undetermined Industrial and city comprehensive training building, the total (ADB) obtained the land Commercial construction area of about 7,200 m2, covers an certificate in 2013 School area of about 600 m2; It has 60 multifunctional in Nanning classrooms integrating theory and reality. Wuming district to build a new campus, need to acquire land, land planning procedures are being handled. 62 Guangxi Quality Nanning The construction content has not been determined Undetermined For screening Undetermined Technology city and relevant materials have not been submitted Engineering School 63 Nanning Sports Nanning The construction content has not been determined Undetermined For screening Undetermined School city and relevant materials have not been submitted 64 Pingnan County Pingnan Pingnan County Secondary Vocational and 20 million yuan Undetermined For screening Undetermined Secondary County Technical school integrated building project, the main construction of teaching and training rooms

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） Vocational and 9,095 m2, construction content including civil Technical school engineering, decoration, water supply and drainage, electrical engineering. 65 Guangxi Nanning The planning construction net area for the new Total 1,535 Category B Land acquisition of Conduct site visits, Vocational city campus is 731,857 m2 (about 1,098 mu), campus million yuan 832 mu has been collect relevant College of net area is 554,813 m2 (about 832 mu). completed in 2019. data such as International Land area for the Construction of Phase I will be No specific data of compensation Business 406,008 m2 (about 609 mu), the construction net the affected contracts of LA and area is 358,895 m2 (about 538 mu); reserved population, as well HD, payment development land is 325,864 m2 (about 489 mu); as payment vouchers, etc., and total building area is 286,960 m2. The construction vouchers for land check whether the includes: public teaching building for 2,967 m2, acquisition, have affected persons teaching building for 14,454 m2, comprehensive been obtained. have any training building for 3,398 m2, library for 6,067 m2, The project will unresolved gym for 5,615 m2, students and staff activity center acquire farmland in grievances, and for 1,696 m2, assembly hall for 2,720 m2, student Zhentang Village of whether there are dormitory for 21,735 m2, canteen for 2,281 m2, Ningwu. More legal disputes over dormitory for single staff for 1,053 m2, screening is the land or comprehensive office support building for 3,054 needed. inheritance m2, teaching management building (administration acquired. building) for 1,909 m2, basement for 12,000 m2, green building incremental investment for 286,960 m2, seismic stabilizer bracket for 286,960 m2, electric transformer and distribution for 286,960 m2, 12 elevator, outdoor supporting facilities for 288,481 m2. 66 Guangxi Nanning Construction area for graphic design information Total Category B The acquisition of Vocational City center is 25,561.91 m2, covering an area of 3,028.5 investment is agricultural land

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） College of m2; construction area for accounting and finance 130.85 million has been Economy and department is 16,032.71 m2, covering an area of yuan. completed, Trade 2,973.12 m2; construction area for trading and ADB loan for 65 covering an area of management, tourism and foreign language is million 429.62 mu. The 14,392.97 m2, covering an area of 2,600.72 m2. yuan/supporting specific data of the Total 55,987.59 m2 of construction area. funds for 65.85 APs and the million yuan. payment voucher for LA have not been obtained yet. 67 Guangxi Radio Nanning 1. Building of 2# opening teaching and training 58.10 million Category B According to the and TV University City center covers an area of 1,006.51 m2, the yuan investigation, the construction area is 5,266.37 m2, cost 14.16 million school has yuan. completed the LA 2. Building of the information center and 2# in 2017, acquired distance education center covers an area of 2,775 178 mu of unused m2, the construction area is 1,1524.5 m2, cost land from the 33.43 million yuan. village collective, 3. Training for teachers (training for team and has completed management, professional teacher training, the compensation including outdoor training, indoors training and of LA and graduate trainee). resettlement, and 4. Construction of professional (talent training has obtained the program, curriculum system, curriculum land certificate in construction). 2017. No Construction of training room (purchase and remaining installation of equipment and decoration of the problems have training room). been found so far.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 68 Primary canteen Nanning Planned land area of the new campus is 39,1721 Total invest Category B From 2015 to 2016, in new campus City m2 (about 587.58 m2). Including the construction 118.34 million land acquisition and area for 18,800 m2 of primary canteen and covers yuan. was completed comprehensive an area of 4,320 m2. The comprehensive teaching with 587.58 mu, teaching building building covers an area of 2,293 m2, and the and compensation project of construction area is 2,0645 m2. has been Guangxi completed. Electrical Specific data on Polytechnic the APs and Institute payment vouchers for land compensation were not immediately available. 69 Heng county Heng A new training building, covering an area of 1,510 20 million yuan Category B The school vocational county m2, the total construction area of 7,640 m2, five (KFW 20 million completed the education center floors above ground, frame structure. yuan) acquisition of 64.15 mu of collective agricultural land in 2018. Compensation and resettlement had been completed. Specific data on the APs and payment vouchers for land

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） compensation were not immediately available. 70 Cenxi city Cenxi city 1 ． “KFW Building” project and “KFW” cultural A total Category B The school has secondary square construction project cover a total area of investment of completed LA of specialized 4,088.00 m2 20,395,800 188 mu, all belong school 2. The campus culture square covers an area of yuan to the mountain 1,500.00 m2 land; and has completed the compensation and the resettlement, and the land certificate was obtained in 2010. 71 Bobai county Bobai It covers an area of 229,770 m2 and a construction 398.67 million Category B The acquisition of secondary county area of 15,2915 m2. It mainly builds teaching yuan collective specialized education buildings, book reading rooms, training buildings, agricultural land school park student dormitories, canteens, office rooms, sports and state-owned fields, sport ground with roof, etc. agricultural land of 344.66 mu had been completed. completed the compensation and resettlement. Specific data on the APs and payment vouchers

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） for land compensation were not immediately available. The school obtained a land ownership certificate in 2019. 72 Zhaoping Hezhou city It is proposed to build a comprehensive teaching Bank loan Category B Land acquisition of vocational building with 6 floors above ground and 1 floor investment of 4.12 mu has been education center underground, with a planned land area of 4,442.42 20 million yuan completed. The m2, floor space of 1,540.85 m2, and a total compensation and construction area of 11,658.66 m2. the resettlement had been completed. Specific data on the APs and payment vouchers for land compensation were not immediately available. The school received the land ownership certificate in 2019.

Investment amount ten Resettlement thousand/CNY LA and HD Implementation No. Name of School Location Proposed Project Content Impact （ADB/local Situation Status Category supporting funds） 73 Guangxi Nanning Constructing 2 student dormitory buildings, which The project Category B Proposed to build a University of city covers an area of 3,664.14 m2. plans to invest new campus, it has Chinese Medicine 41.98 million completed the yuan, apply for acquisition of a co-financing agricultural land, loan of 30 land acquisition million yuan area of 616 mu, from KFW bank, and has completed and the land acquisition remaining 11.98 compensation. million yuan will be raised by the school through other ways. 74 Beihai secondary Beihai City The stadium covers an area of 6,350 m2 with a 90.57 million Category B The school vocational and building area of 12,960 m2. yuan obtained the land technical school certificate in 2014. 21.75 mu of land has been completed. The specific data of the APs and the payment voucher of land compensation have not been obtained yet. ADB = Asian Development Bank, DDR = due diligence report, GZAR = Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, HD = house demolition, LA = land acquisition, m = meter,

m2 = square meter, mu = Chinese unit of measurement (1 mu = 666.667 square meters) .

1.3 Scope of External Resettlement Monitoring and Evaluation

The objectives of monitoring and evaluation (M&E) are to assess whether the land acquisition and resettlement (LAR) is implemented on schedule and within budget and whether the goals and principles of the resettlement framework (RF) are achieved.

Specifically, M&E focus on the following aspects of the APs’ situation and the resettlement process.

• Social and economic situation prior to and after LA and/or resettlement

• Timely disbursement of funds and compensation payments to APs

• Measures taken to restore APs’ income/livelihoods

• Functioning of the grievance redress mechanism

• Social adaptability after resettlement, where required

• Restoration of APs’ incomes/livelihood, including vulnerable groups

• Special items related to the vulnerable groups

• Condition and quality of land temporarily acquired when it is returned to the

original land users; and,

• Living conditions and economic status of APs following resettlement in

comparison to the “without project” scenario.

M&E will include (i) the verification or establishment of a socioeconomic baseline

of the APs prior to actual LA, physical displacement/relocation, loss of assets or

disruption of businesses (as relevant); (ii) verification of internal monitoring data and

reports; (iii) the regular monitoring of their HD and displacement/relocation to new housing (as relevant) and adjustment during subproject implementation; and (iv) evaluation of their situation for a period of 2 years after LA or HD (as relevant). In addition, qualitative and quantitative evaluation will be made on the sustainability of living conditions of APs. Investigation will include consultations and observations with

APs, implementing agencies, local officials, village leaders, as well as a quantitative sample survey of at least 20% of affected households. Focus group discussions will be conducted with male and female APs, vulnerable groups and others.

If the findings of the M&E indicate significant compliance gaps, the external

monitor will work with the Guangxi program management office (GPMO) to prepare a corrective action plan (CAP) in cooperation with the relevant stakeholders, to address pending issues. The external monitor will also monitor and report on the implementation of the CAP.

Table 1-1: Resettlement Monitoring and Evaluation Schedule

No. Resettlement report Time of survey Submission date 1 Semiannual monitoring 1 May 2019 July 2019 2 Semiannual monitoring 2 December 2019 January 2020 3 Semiannual monitoring 3 June 2020 July 2020 4 Semiannual monitoring 4 December 2020 January 2021 5 Semiannual monitoring 5 June 2021 July 2021 6 Semiannual monitoring 6 December 2021 January 2022 7 Resettlement Completion report December 2022 January 2022

This report is the first monitoring report, according to the investigation, the 15 subproject schools under construction are classified as Category C, all of which are built on the reserved land of the original campus without LA and HD impact. See Part 5 for detailed information on the land availability and requirements for the individual subprojects.

This report only monitors the 15 subproject schools that have already started construction.

Other schools are preparing for the preliminary work, so they are not monitored and will be covered as part of the subsequent monitoring visits.

2 Land Acquisition and Resettlement Impacts

This monitoring found that, based on the results of monitoring, consultations, and land availability reviews of 15 subproject schools, these subprojects do not involve the impact of LA or HD and are category C involuntary resettlement. By the end of June 2019, construction of all 15 subproject schools have been started. The 15 subproject schools that have started the construction are all classified as category C in terms of resettlement. They are all being built in the original campus of the school, which is reserved for school, and there is no LA and HD impact. See Table 2-1 for detailed classification and impact.

Table 2-1: Resettlement Impact and Category of 15 Schools of Subproject under Construction—Screening Table (Draft) Investment amount Project Name of ten thousand/CNY Take Action No. Location Proposed Project Content Impact LA and HD Situation School （ADB/local and Measure Category supporting funds） 1. The main content of the project is a teaching facility construction project named "college students physical education teaching center", in addition to the construction installation project, equipment purchases and supporting municipal facilities. The main body adopts frame structure, and the building has two floors. The construction The school obtained the area is about 18,000 m2. land certificate in 2004 and 2. The main content of construction including a the construction contents teaching facility construction named "Bagui Guilin Tourism are being conducted in the 1 Guilin City cuisine culture experience center" and 133.88 million yuan Category C Not applicable College original campus, the renovation of the original training center (Hotel acquired land is reserved Training Center). for the school, and there is 3. The content of the Talent Project Plan no LA and HD impact. including introduction of high-level talents, teacher training and promotion. 4. The contents of the International Cooperation Projects including consulting fee and certification fee, OLF training fee, teaching fee and construction of ASEAN tourism vocational service platform. According to the The total building covering an area of 14,100 m2 114.79 million yuan investigation, the land of Guangxi and construction area is 51,025 m2 (including (ADB and KfW Loan original campus was state- Vocational Nanning 2 29,584 m2 construction area of the intelligent for 20 million Category C owned unused land and Not applicable College of City manufacturing training base of Guangxi yuan/supporting funds transferred to the Industrial Vocational College of Industrial) for 94.79 million yuan) government of Wuming county, GZAR on January

Investment amount Project Name of ten thousand/CNY Take Action No. Location Proposed Project Content Impact LA and HD Situation School （ADB/local and Measure Category supporting funds） 8, 2003. Since the government has not yet developed and utilized the land, the surrounding farmers have reclaimed and cultivated during this period. In 2012, the government of Wuming county has made green crop compensation to the farmers who cultivated the land. After completing the green crop compensation, the land has been allocated to Guangxi Vocational College of Industrial. There are no remaining issues. According to the investigation, the construction contents are Total construction is 34,780 m2 (including office being carried out in the building for 10,837.1 m2, basement for 3,667.9 original campus, the Guangxi m2, information center for 2,127.9 m2, library for acquired land is reserved Vocational Nanning 18,147 m2), covering an area of 5,218.8 m2. The 3 147 million yuan Category C for the school, and there is Not applicable College of City building is frame-shear wall structure. The no LA and HD impact. The Construction construction content includes building, structure, school obtained the land water supply, electric, heating, air condition, fire certificate in 2016. control and environment protection. According to the investigation, there is no remaining problems.

Investment amount Project Name of ten thousand/CNY Take Action No. Location Proposed Project Content Impact LA and HD Situation School （ADB/local and Measure Category supporting funds） The construction for Phase I covers an area of 477,102.39 m2 (about 715.65 mu). 427,028.8 m2 According to the (about 640.54 mu) for net area. investigation, the land The construction content includes teaching and occupied by the new training building (public teaching room, teaching Total investment is campus of Guangxi College Guangxi and training room and office room), library, 1,733.21 million yuan for Preschool Education is Nanning College for indoor gym, office room, assembly hall and (ADB loan 144 million state owned land, and the 4 Educationa Category C Not applicable Preschool students activity room, student dormitory, yuan/supporting funds transfer procedures of l Zone Education dormitory for single staff, canteen, office for 1,589.21 million state-owned land have supporting room and attachment room and so yuan) been completed, the land on. As well as the supporting infrastructure such certificate is being applied as intelligent system, playground, water supply, now. There is no impact of electric supply, front gate, wall, road, greening LA and HD. and viewing, water and square. 1. Civil of the comprehensive experimental building (technical building). The school obtained the 2. Reeducation and training center land certificate in 2003. 3. Comprehensive practical training platform for According to the economic and management vocational investigation, the Wuzhou Wuzhou education. construction is being 5 105.5 million yuan Category C Not applicable University City 4. Intelligent control and manufacturing carried out in the original integrated training platform campus, the acquired land 5. Comprehensive training room for teacher’s is reserved for the school, educational ability and there is no LA and HD 6. Intelligent renovation of library. impact. 7. Construction of teaching staff Guangxi The school obtained the Construction of No.3 and No.4 student Eco- Liuzhou Total investment is land certificate in 2003. 6 dormitory, a cooking practice building, and a Category C Not applicable engineering city 176.63 million yuan According to the library, a total of 45,313.54 m2. Vocational and investigation, the

Investment amount Project Name of ten thousand/CNY Take Action No. Location Proposed Project Content Impact LA and HD Situation School （ADB/local and Measure Category supporting funds） Technical construction is being College carried out in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. The school obtained the land certificate in 2003, Total estimated there is no remaining Guangxi investment of the problems. According to the Finance 28,116.91 m2 of the construction of project is 97.61 investigation, the Nanning 7 Vocational and library, including 24,500.72 m2 above ground million. The loan is 60 Category C construction is being Not applicable City Technical and 3,616.2 m2 underground. million yuan, with implemented in the original School supporting facilities of campus, the acquired land 37.61 million yuan. is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. The project covers an area of 2,133.40 m2, with a total construction area of 15,128.01 m2, The school obtained the including an above-ground construction area of land certificate in 2010. 11,148.09 m2. There are six floors above the According to the Liuzhou city A total investment of ground, one floor underground. The basement is investigation, the Luzhai 37.89 million yuan Luzhai 4.5 m high and the first floor is 4.2 m high. The construction is being 8 vocational (20 million yuan from Category C Not applicable county basement is mainly equipped with motor vehicle conducted in the original education ADB/supporting funds parking space, fire pool, water pump room, campus, the acquired land center of 14.89 million yuan) generator room and power distribution room; is reserved for the school, The first to fifth floors are mainly equipped with and there is no LA and HD training rooms, preparation rooms, toilets, guard impact. rooms, boiling water rooms, lecture halls and

Investment amount Project Name of ten thousand/CNY Take Action No. Location Proposed Project Content Impact LA and HD Situation School （ADB/local and Measure Category supporting funds） reading rooms. There are offices, toilets, guard rooms and boiling water rooms on the sixth floor. According to the investigation, the Rong county Student dormitory project of campus expansion subproject construction is secondary Rong project covers an area of 1,221.26 m2; e- ADB investment of being conducted in the 9 Category C Not applicable Vocational county commerce training building project of campus 29.79 million yuan original campus, the school expansion project, covers an area of 1,275 m2 acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. According to the Total investment: investigation, the new The new construction for training building of 29.24 million yuan /25 training building of Hechi Hechi City Health School covers an area of Hechi City million yuan (ADB) / City Health School will be 10 Hechi city 1,186 m2. the demolished old auditorium in this Category C Not applicable Health School 4.24 million yuan built on the site where the school is used for construction, which does not （ Local government school’s old auditorium is involve land acquisition. supporting funds） demolished. There is no LA and HD impact. The student apartment for high-skilled talents is located in the east of the middle of the campus, The school obtained the with a total construction area of 19,304.25 m2. The total investment land certificate in 2014. The area of occupied land for building is of the project is 48.81 According to the Guangxi 1,144.67 m2 ，it is high-rise buildings with 17 million yuan investigation, the Industrial Nanning floors. The building is used for the student (Germany KFW bank construction is being 11 Category C Not applicable Technician city dormitory and supporting rooms. The main is 20 million yuan, and conducted in the original College contents of construction include construction the school raised campus, the acquired land engineering, decoration engineering, water 28.81 million yuan by is reserved for the school, supply and drainage engineering, electrical itself). and there is no LA and HD engineering, heating engineering and general impact. level related supporting engineering

Investment amount Project Name of ten thousand/CNY Take Action No. Location Proposed Project Content Impact LA and HD Situation School （ADB/local and Measure Category supporting funds） It had completed the land acquisition in 2014 and obtained land certificate in A student dorm building with a six-layer frame 2015. 139.98 mu land has structure will be constructed in this project. The been acquired which The Second height of building is 25.8 m, the total area of concludes cultivated land of Light Industry building is 10,322.2 m2, the occupied land of Nanning A total investment: 19.89 mu, garden plot of 12 Technical building is 3,247.86 m2. There will be 227 Category C Not applicable city 28.11 million yuan 87.88 mu and forestland of School of standard apartment dormitories 32.21 mu. According to Guangxi (8 persons/room), 2 accessible dormitories investigation, LA work had (2 persons/room), 5 public laundry rooms and 1 been completed, and its management room in this new building. compensation had been completed in 2014. There are no remaining issues. The school obtained the 1. A new student dormitory building, 5-floor land certificate in 2008. frame structure building, covering an area of According to the 881.29 m2, a total construction area of 4,524.55 QuanZhou investigation, the m2 2. Construct a one-floor steel frame vocational & Quanzhou construction is being 13 structures mechanics training workshop, the 22 million yuan Category C Not applicable technical county carried out in the original building covers an area of 1600 m2, with a total schools campus, the acquired land construction area of 1600 m2 is reserved for the school, 3. Information teaching equipment and there is no LA and HD 4. Upgrade and replace training equipment impact. The school obtained the 1. Power electrical renovation Liuzhou No.1 land certificate in 2010. 2. School teaching, work area of smart water Vocational and According to the 14 liuzhou city and electricity meters and supporting facilities 25 million yuan Category C Not applicable Technical investigation, the 3. Energy-saving hot water supply system for School construction contents are student dormitory being carried out in the

Investment amount Project Name of ten thousand/CNY Take Action No. Location Proposed Project Content Impact LA and HD Situation School （ADB/local and Measure Category supporting funds） 4. Indoor and outdoor lighting lamps and original campus, the lanterns transformation acquired land is reserved 5. Construction for Integrated business for the school, and there is information system no LA and HD impact. 6. Construction for financial management internal control system 7. Introduction of western food courses and vocational qualification certificates 8. Constructing new student dormitory buildings Integrated teaching building construction project of Guangxi Nanning senior technical school, main construction contents: foundation pit support engineering, civil engineering, installation engineering, water supply and drainage engineering, electrical engineering, The school obtained the heating engineering, elevator engineering, land certificate in 2014. firefighting engineering, outdoor greening According to the engineering, outdoor road engineering, sponge 55.32 million yuan (25 Guangxi investigation, all city, green building, etc. million yuan from Nanning Senior Nanning subprojects are being built 15 Construction scale: this project will build an ADB/ 30.32 million Category C Not applicable Technical city in the original campus, the integrated teaching building, with a total land yuan of local School acquired land is reserved area of 9,227.51 m2 (13.84 mu in total) and a supporting funds) for the school, and there is building area of 19,054.06 m2, including an no LA and above-ground building area of 14894.06 m2, HD impact. including a building area of 14,591.70 m2 for practical training and a building area of 302.36 m2 for ancillary buildings. The underground building area is 4,160.00 m2. And supporting roads, greening, outdoor hydropower, and other ancillary projects.

ADB = Asian Development Bank, GZAR = Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region, HD = house demolition, LA = land acquisition, m = meter, m2 = square meter, mu = Chinese unit of measurement (1 mu = 666.667 square meters) .

3 Public Participation and Grievance Redress Mechanism

In order to engage with the community and enhance public understanding on the project and address the issues pertaining to resettlement, various types of APs and other stakeholders will be consulted with LRB/HDO. According to the RF, the views and attitudes of the stakeholders are collected during the negotiation, which will be recorded in writing and explain how the concerns of the APs are addressed and dealt with.

This monitoring found that there was no LA and HD impact on the 15 subproject schools that had been started construction, so no public participation and information disclosure was carried out in each subproject school.

In the follow-up monitoring, the sub-project schools with LA and HD impact will carry out public participation activities with the APs through forum and interview and track the resettlement and income recovery situation of the APs. External monitoring and evaluation personnel go deep into the affected households, conduct face-to-face interview with them,

M&E understand the situation of the implementation of the APs. Household interviews are mainly to learn the social and economic condition and resettlement policy implementation of the affected individuals and households, all kinds of compensation standard and the cash situation and resettlement situation of production and living, information release and transfer, public participation, vulnerable groups protection measures, grievance and appeal and its condition and opinions and suggestions of the APs on the implementation of resettlement. See table 3-1 for details.

Table 3-1 Project Public Participation and Information Disclosure Number of Public Participation No. Subproject Location Remarks during the Monitoring Period * Guilin University of 1 Guilin City Aerospace Technology 2 Guilin Tourism College Guilin City Not Applicable

3 Yulin Normal University Yulin city 58

Number of Public Participation No. Subproject Location Remarks during the Monitoring Period * Guangxi Vocational College 4 of Mechanical and Nanning City Electronical Technology Guangxi Vocational and 5 Nanning city Technical College Guangxi Transport Vocational 6 and Technical College of Nanning city Communications Guangxi Vocational College 7 Nanning City Not Applicable of Industrial Guangxi Vocational College 8 Nanning city of International Business Guangxi Vocational College 9 Nanning City of International Business Guangxi Vocational College 10 Nanning City Not Applicable of Construction Guangxi Vocational College 11 Nanning City of Economy and Trade

12 Guangxi Medical College Nanning City

Nanning Guangxi College for 13 Educational Not Applicable Preschool Education Zone Guangxi Radio and TV 14 Nanning City University Nanning Prefecture Education Chongzuo 15 College City Guangxi Science and 16 Laibin City Technology Normal University 17 Hechi University Yizhou City 18 Wuzhou University Wuzhou City Not Applicable 19 Hezhou University Hezhou City Guangxi Electrical 20 Nanning City Polytechnic Institute Guangxi 21 Eco-engineering Vocational Liuzhou city Not Applicable and Technical College Guangxi Finance Vocational 22 Nanning City Not Applicable and Technical School Guangxi Ji Dian Gong Cheng 23 Nanning city Xue Xiao Guangxi Institute Science and 24 Technology Nanning city School Guangxi Textile Industry 25 Nanning city School Guangxi Overseas Chinese 26 Nanning city School Guangxi nationality 27 secondary professional Nanning city school 59

Number of Public Participation No. Subproject Location Remarks during the Monitoring Period * 28 Guangxi Business School Liuzhou city Guangxiyoujiang Commercial 29 Baise city College for Nationalities Gvangjsih Liujcouh Cuzmuz 30 Liuzhou city Couyih Yozyau Guangxi Yulin Agricultural 31 Yulin city School Guangxi Industrial and 32 Nanning city Commercial School Heng county vocational 33 Heng county education center Liuzhou city Luzhai vocational Luzhai 34 Not Applicable education center county Cenxi city secondary 35 Cenxi city specialized school Cangwu county secondary 36 Wuzhou city specialized school Beibuwan vocational 37 Qinzhou city technical institute Lingshan county vocational Lingshan 38 technical institute county Guigang city vocational 39 Guigang city education center Yulin No.1 Secondary 40 Yulin city Vocational School Rong county secondary 41 Rong county Not Applicable Vocational school Bobai county Bobai county secondary 42 education specialized school park

43 Baise ethnic health school Baise city

Zhaoping vocational 44 Hezhou city education center 45 Hechi City Health School Hechi city Not Applicable Hechi Yizhou Vocational 46 Hechi city Education Center LaiBin Vocational Education 47 Laibin city Center School

Guangxi Industrial Technician 48 Nanning city Not Applicable College

Guangxi Technician College 49 Liuzhou city of Machinery & Electricity

Guangxi Traffic Technician 50 Nanning city College GuangXi Shangmao Senior 51 Nanning city Technical School

Number of Public Participation No. Subproject Location Remarks during the Monitoring Period * The Second Light Industry 52 Nanning city Not Applicable Technical School of Guangxi

Guangxi yulin technician 53 college（Guangxi yulin senior Yulin City technical school ） Liuzhou NO.2 Vocational 54 Liuzhou city School QuanZhou vocational & Quanzhou Not Applicable 55 technical schools county Guiping city NO.1 secondary 56 vocational and technical Guiping city school Hechi city vocational 57 Hechi city education center school

Guilin tourism vocational 58 secondary professional Guilin city school Liuzhou No.1 Vocational and Not Applicable 59 liuzhou city Technical School GuangxI Wuzi 60 Nanning city School

Guangxi University of 61 Nanning city Chinese Medicine

Guangxi QinZhou Agricultural 62 Qinzhou city School Guangxi Wuzhou Business 63 Wuzhou city School Guangxi Urban Construction 64 Guilin City School Guangxi Mechanical and 65 Nanning City Electrical Industry School Guangxi Aquatic Animal 66 Nanning City Husbandry School Guidong Health Secondary 67 Hezhou city School Beihai secondary vocational 68 Beihai City and technical school Jingxi Vocational and 69 Baise city Technical School Guangxi Nanning Senior 70 Nanning city Not Applicable Technical School Guangxi Quality Technology Nanning city 71 Engineering School Nanning city 72 Nanning Sports School Pingnan County Secondary Pingnan 73 Vocational and Technical County school Chongzuo City Vocational Chongzuo 74 and Technical School city

There is an existing grievance redress mechanism (GRM) as per government laws and regulations. However, it is not part of the 1B4P and CARP documents. To improve the documents, grievances will be properly documented during the process.

Existing Grievance Redress Mechanism. An existing GRM will receive, manage, and address any social issues which may arise due to the program. The purpose of this procedure is to provide a mutually satisfactory means for rapid response to any

AP’s complaint, to avoid any likelihood of a complicated legal procedure. The detailed procedures are as follows:

a. If any AP has grievance, he/she can voice his/her complaint to the village or

residential committee. The village or residential committee should keep records

and provide a reply to the AP within 10 working days.

b. If the AP is not satisfied with the reply, he/she can appeal to the township or

subdistrict government, which will take records, and provide a resolution to the

AP within 10 working days.

c. If the AP still does not accept the proposed resolution, then he/she can appeal

directly to the LRB/HDO, which should make a record of any appeal and

provide a resolution within 10 working days.

d. If the dispute still cannot be resolved, then the AP can appeal to the GPMO.

GPMO will facilitate and coordinate with local government. The GPMO is

responsible for keeping records of all appeals, and the resultant resolutions.

APs also have the right to use alternative channels at any time: (i) go through an administrative appeal according to the Administrative Procedure Law of the People's

Republic of China (PRC), or (ii) go directly to the People’s Court.

GRM Documentation. The GRM tracking system by the GPMO will include the following elements: (i) tracking forms and procedures for gathering information from project personnel and complainant(s); (ii) regular updating of the GRM database by the Resettlement Coordinator in the GPMO; and (iii) a simple but effective filing system, so that data can be retrieved for reporting purposes.

GRM Processing Form (Table 3-2) and GRM Reporting Form (Table 3-3) will be

provided to the TVET school which will then be distributed to the concerned villages,

LRB and HDO during preparation of the 1B4P/CARP. The forms will be filled in by the

village committees/HRB/LDO to document and track the

grievances/complaints/requests received and resolutions made by their respective

offices. The TVET school will regularly obtain the information and input them in the

GRM tracking system of the GPMO.

Table 3-2 Project Appeal Table

Name Department

Time Place

Content：

Grievance Suggestion：

Claimant’s opinion on the handling Agree Disagree

Signature of Signature of claimant responsible personnel

Time Time

Claimant’s telephone number: Responsible personnel’s telephone number:

Alternatively, the aggrieved person(s) may submit a complaint to the ADB project

team to try to resolve the problem. If good faith efforts are still unsuccessful, they may

submit their complaint to ADB's Accountability Mechanism.1 The first step requires good faith efforts to resolve the problem with the ADB project team.

The resettlement external monitor will record any grievances and concerns raised

by the affected households during monitoring. The concerns and issues raised,

external monitor’s assessment of each case, and recommendations proposed by the

external monitor will be reflected in the external monitoring report. See the feedback

of the GRM of this monitoring in Table 3-3.

1 Accountability Mechanism. https://www.adb.org/site/accountability-mechanism/main. 63

Table 3-3 The Feedback Form of Grievance Redress Mechanism

Problem of No. Subproject Location Remarks identification Guilin University of 1 Guilin City Aerospace Technology Not Applicable 2 Guilin Tourism College Guilin City

3 Yulin Normal University Yulin city Guangxi Vocational College 4 of Mechanical and Nanning City Electronical Technology Guangxi Vocational and 5 Nanning city Technical College Guangxi Transport Vocational 6 and Technical College of Nanning city Communications Guangxi Vocational College Not Applicable 7 Nanning City of Industrial Guangxi Vocational College 8 Nanning city of International Business Guangxi Vocational College 9 Nanning City of International Business Guangxi Vocational College 10 Nanning City Not Applicable of Construction Guangxi Vocational College 11 Nanning City of Economy and Trade

12 Guangxi Medical College Nanning City

Nanning Guangxi College for 13 Educational Not Applicable Preschool Education Zone Guangxi Radio and TV 14 Nanning City University Nanning Prefecture Education Chongzuo 15 College City Guangxi Science and 16 Laibin City Technology Normal University 17 Hechi University Yizhou City 18 Wuzhou University Wuzhou City Not Applicable 19 Hezhou University Hezhou City Guangxi Electrical 20 Nanning City Polytechnic Institute Guangxi Not Applicable 21 Eco-engineering Vocational Liuzhou city and Technical College Guangxi Finance Vocational Not Applicable 22 Nanning City and Technical School Guangxi Ji Dian Gong Cheng 23 Nanning city Xue Xiao Guangxi Institute Science and 24 Technology Nanning city School

Problem of No. Subproject Location Remarks identification Guangxi Textile Industry 25 Nanning city School Guangxi Overseas Chinese 26 Nanning city School Guangxi nationality 27 secondary professional Nanning city school 28 Guangxi Business School Liuzhou city Guangxiyoujiang Commercial 29 Baise city College for Nationalities Gvangjsih Liujcouh Cuzmuz 30 Liuzhou city Couyih Yozyau Guangxi Yulin Agricultural 31 Yulin city School Guangxi Industrial and 32 Nanning city Commercial School Heng county vocational 33 Heng county education center Liuzhou city Luzhai vocational Luzhai 34 Not Applicable education center county Cenxi city secondary 35 Cenxi city specialized school Cangwu county secondary 36 Wuzhou city specialized school Beibuwan vocational 37 Qinzhou city technical institute Lingshan county vocational Lingshan 38 technical institute county Guigang city vocational 39 Guigang city education center Yulin No.1 Secondary 40 Yulin city Vocational School Rong county secondary Not Applicable 41 Rong county Vocational school Bobai county Bobai county secondary 42 education specialized school park

43 Baise ethnic health school Baise city

Zhaoping vocational 44 Hezhou city education center Not Applicable 45 Hechi City Health School Hechi city Hechi Yizhou Vocational 46 Hechi city Education Center LaiBin Vocational Education 47 Laibin city Center School

Guangxi Industrial Technician 48 Nanning city Not Applicable College

Problem of No. Subproject Location Remarks identification

Guangxi Technician College 49 Liuzhou city of Machinery & Electricity

Guangxi Traffic Technician 50 Nanning city College Guangxi Shangmao Senior 51 Nanning city Technical School The Second Light Industry Not Applicable 52 Nanning city Technical School of Guangxi Guangxi yulin technician 53 college（Guangxi yulin senior Yulin City technical school） Liuzhou NO.2 Vocational 54 Liuzhou city School QuanZhou vocational & Quanzhou Not Applicable 55 technical schools county Guiping city NO.1 secondary 56 vocational and technical Guiping city school Hechi city vocational 57 Hechi city education center school Guilin tourism vocational 58 secondary professional Guilin city school Liuzhou No.1 Vocational and Not Applicable 59 liuzhou city Technical School Guangxi Wuzi 60 Nanning city School

Guangxi University of 61 Nanning city Chinese Medicine

Problem of No. Subproject Location Remarks identification Nanning city 72 Nanning Sports School Pingnan County Secondary Pingnan 73 Vocational and Technical County school Chongzuo City Vocational Chongzuo 74 and Technical School city

This monitoring found that 15 subproject schools that have started construction have set up a GRM in accordance with the above requirements. GPMO has also

established GRM tracking system and GRM database. Schools of each subproject

shall regularly collect information and share the information with the GPMO.

The GRM tracking system established by GPMO will include the following

elements : (i) tracking forms and procedures to collect information from project

personnel and complainants (see project complaint processing form and GRM

feedback form); (ii) the resettlement coordinator of the GPMO regularly updates the

complaint database; and (iii) a simple and efficient filing system for retrieving data for

reporting purposes.

Resettlement experts have set up a monitoring GRM database by EXCEL for

GPMO, and the GPMO staff were trained. The GRM database would be updated once

in 2 weeks and twice in 1 month. After the update, the updated summary results would

be timely provided to the consulting experts or external monitoring staff.

Table 3-4 The Data of Grievance Redress

Legacy Grievance Grievance Handing No. School Results Feedback Remarks Content Time Time Problems

Since 74 subproject schools involve in the project, each subproject school is required to establish a GRM for the APs in accordance with the above requirements.

The GPMO will supervise all subproject schools to establish a GRM as soon as possible and assign a full-time staff responsible for the resettlement. The GPMO has assigned a full-time staff member to handle resettlement. According to the survey, 15 subproject schools that have started construction have established GRM and designated full-time staff responsible for resettlement. See table 3-5 for the full-time resettlement staff designated by the subproject school that has started construction. Table 3-5 Contact Information of School Resettlement Staff of the Started Project Project Contact No. School Duty Work E-mail Leader Information

Deputy party secretary Lin Yejiang Dean of 0773- Zhang international 3690016 Xianchun Guilin Tourism college 0773- 1 Li [email protected] College Dean of 3690150 Yongqiang personnel 0773- Shi Director of 3690016 Jingsong logistics management

Director of logistics Fan Hongri Director of Jia Mingzu development 18178632088 Guangxi Vocational Deng planning 18178632688 2 [email protected] College of Industrial Kaihao Director of 18178633200 Huang New Campus 18178632211 Wensheng Construction Headquarters Office

Guangxi Eco- engineering 3 [email protected] Vocational and Technical College

Guangxi Vocational 0771- 4 College of Xie Dong Vice-president 3389889 [email protected] Construction 18677155661

Director of Guangxi College for Deng 5 logistics 18078145188 [email protected] Preschool Education Bochang management 68

Project Contact No. School Duty Work E-mail Leader Information Guangxi Finance 6 Vocational and Shen Lijun Dean [email protected] Technical School Guangxi Wuzhou Liang Assistant to 7 18934842568 [email protected] Business School Zhaohui the president

Liuzhou No.1

8 Vocational and Qin Haibo 18077216151 [email protected] President Technical School Liuzhou city Luzhai 9 vocational education [email protected] center

QuanZhou vocational Yan 10 Secretary 18078308276 [email protected] & technical schools Qiuming

Rong county Director of 11 secondary Vocational Liang Yuan 18977518598 [email protected] general affairs school Chief of Hechi City Health 0778-2297004 12 Jiang Bin General Affairs [email protected] School 18007786012 Section Guangxi Industrial Guan 13 Vice-president 13877168610 [email protected] Technician College Guoai

The Second Light Lan 14 Industry Technical Vice-president 13878111956 [email protected] Yangchong School of Guangxi

Guangxi Nanning Head of Huang 15 Senior Technical scientific 18178118050 [email protected] Xingyi School research

APs also have the right to use alternative channels at any time: (i) go through an administrative appeal according to the Administrative Procedure Law of the PRC, or (ii) go directly to the People’s Court.

If the APs remains dissatisfied and believes that he/she has been harmed by his/her non-compliance with ADB policies and has worked in good faith to resolve the problem by working with the ADB project team, they may lodge a complaint under the

ADB's Accountability Mechanism. Information about how to complain, can browse the web https://www.adb.org/site/accountability-mechanism/main.

According to the survey, there have been no complaints so far from the 15 subproject schools under construction. Resettlement external monitoring staff will

record any complaints and concerns raised by affected households during the

monitoring process. The concerns and questions raised, the assessment of events by external monitors and the recommendations made by external monitors will be reflected in the external monitoring report.

4 Institutional Arrangements

The GPMO is responsible for management of the overall investment program implementation including resettlement. The GPMO has assigned a full-time staff to handle any resettlement matters, including collecting and summarizing resettlement materials, maintaining resettlement databases and GRM, and assisting resettlement experts and external monitoring staff in conducting investigations. Since GPMO has limited experience on resettlement, especially ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (2009) policies and requirements, a resettlement consultant will be engaged to provide support and capacity building to the GPMO.2

Other key institutions involved in resettlement planning and implementation are the (i) TVET School for each subproject; (ii) Country/District LRB/HDO; and (iii)

Village/Community Committees. Figure 4-1 presents the institutional arrangements.

TVET school/design Site identification institute

Category C: No action. To TVET screening document in school/GPMO/LRB/HDO the monitoring report External Category A: Monitoring excluded. (External Category B Prepare Prior LAR: due TVET school/ LRB/HDO/village improved 1-book-4- Monitor) committee plan/Compensation and Relocation Plan

TVET school/ LRB/HDO/village Implementation Committee/other government Monitoring and agencies Reporting

Figure 4-1 Institutional Framework

2 There is a separate capacity development technical assistance for the program to provide support. This includes engagement of resettlement consultant to provide guidance and support during screening, planning, and implementation. The resettlement consultant will also be tasked to provide training to GPMO. 71

4.1 Responsibilities of the Institutions

GPMO. The roles and responsibilities include:

 organize related training on ADB’s involuntary resettlement (IR) policies, screen the IR impacts.

 conduct due diligence for prior to LAR and coordinate with the local government in developing a CAP.

 coordinate with the LRB/HDO at all levels to provide all the necessary LAR information.

 set-up resettlement database.

 set-up GRM tracking system.

 engage the external monitoring agency.

 prepare the semiannual internal M&E reports based on the information provided by local TVET school, LRB, HDO and other concerned organizations (civil affairs, labor and social security bureau, all women’s federation, village leaders, etc.).

TVET school for each subproject.

 Its main duties are to coordinate with the related agencies (LRB, HDO, etc.), and report regularly to the GPMO. A resettlement staff will be assigned.

 coordinate with the LRB/HDO to get the information and assist the GPMO to screen and the IR impacts and conduct the due diligence.

 Establish GRM, assist external monitoring units in their investigations and collect information.

 fill in the tables of appendix 2 of this RF and submit the improved 1-Book-4-Plan/

Compensation and Relocation Plan to GPMO.

 During LAR, closely monitor the implementation and coordinate with the

LRB/HDO to collect information for the internal monitoring report

 file all approval documents related to LAR.

County/District LRB and HDO are the key agencies for implementation of LAR.

 conduct detailed measurement survey, consultation, information disclosure.

 prepare the 1-Book-4-Plan/ Compensation and Relocation Plan before LAR and share with TVET school.

 documentation of the information disclosure, participation and GRM and share with TVET school.

 provide the information for the M&E reports to TVET school.

 Village/Community Committee play a key role in LA/HD since they are aware of the history and socioeconomic situation of the affected residents.

 participate in the detailed measurement survey.

 assist the LRB/HDO to conduct consultation, information disclosure, negotiation and GRM.

 reallocate housing sites and contracted land after land acquisition and house demolition.

 provide information on the affected vulnerable groups or those who may become vulnerable.

 organize village meetings to discuss the compensation rates, restoration, and relocation plan.

 documentation of the information disclosure, participation and GRM and share with TVET school.

Other Agencies. Apart from the key players above, other agencies will also be requested to support the program based on their specific roles and responsibilities: a) Civil Affairs responsible for identification Five-Guarantee and those eligible for the

Minimum Living Guarantee System. b) Women’s Federation for cash or in-kind assistance to the women headed households. c) Health Bureau responsible for urgent assistance if the households have serious illness. d) Construction and Housing Bureau responsible for affordable housing and low-rent

housing to vulnerable groups; approval of the house relocation plan. e) Labor and Social Security responsible for endowment insurance system for the landless farmers, provide relevant training and access to job opportunities in the area including project-related employment opportunities.

4.2 Personnel and Facility

In order to make the resettlement work smoothly, the resettlement agencies at all levels of the project are equipped with special staff, forming up and down smooth information transmission channels. Currently, there are five employees in GPMO, including one person in charge of resettlement. He is responsible for resettlement matters, including the collection and statistics of LA and HD, the collection and feedback of grievance and appeal, and other resettlement matters. According to the survey, 15 schools already under construction have assigned one full-time resettlement staff. The GPMO will urge schools that have not yet started construction to assign a full-time staff member in charge of resettlement work.

4.3 Office Facility

Each subproject school have made use of available resources and 15 schools already under construction have been equipped with basic office equipment, transportation equipment and communication equipment, including office tables and chairs, computers, printers, telephones, fax machines, vehicles and other equipment resources. The GPMO requires schools that have not yet started construction to be equipped with basic office facilities and equipment as soon as possible before starting work.

4.4 Assessment on Organization Capacity

This monitoring found that during the implementation of the project, the GPMO has assigned a full-time staff member to be responsible for the resettlement of the APs, including the summary and statistics of land acquisition and house demolition, the summary and feedback of grievance and appeals, as well as the coordination and monitoring assistance of the resettlement work. According to the survey, 15 schools

already under construction have assigned one full-time resettlement staff. The GPMO will urge schools that have not yet started construction to assign a full-time staff member in charge of resettlement work. In order to better implement the resettlement activities, the GPMO and each subproject schools should establish the organization, coordination, data and information feedback, and take the following measures:

(1) Each subproject school shall assign a full-time staff responsible for

resettlement matters, including the implementation of resettlement activities, the

collection and data statistics of land acquisition and house demolition materials,

the collection and feedback of grievances and appeals, as well as the coordination

and monitoring assistance of resettlement work.

(2) Resettlement consultants will be organize the training on resettlement,

monitoring and report preparation for each subproject school full-time staff in the

later stage, let the full-time staff of GPMO and subproject schools understand and

master the relevant requirements of the PRC's resettlement policy and ADB, and

improve their professional quality and policy processing capacity.

(3) The schools of each subproject should provide timely feedback on resettlement.

The schools of each subproject will provide feedback on any resettlement-related

information to the GPMO, and the GPMO will collect the feedback to the consulting

experts and ADB. Make its information from top to bottom and from bottom to top

smooth.

(4) Schools under construction have established GRM and designated a full-time

staff member responsible for resettlement work; but the subproject school that has

not started the construction has not yet established GRM and assigned a full-time

staff, The GPMO should urge the sub-project schools that have not yet established

the GRM to establish the GRM as soon as possible, and let each sub-project

school that has not yet started to assign a full-time staff responsible for

resettlement matters, so as to find problems and solve them in time, and establish

a timely information communication and feedback mechanism.

4.5 Institution Capacity Building and Training

In November 2018, independent experts on resettlement provided training to the staff of GPMO, and each subproject schools in charge of resettlement, mainly include:

Safeguard Policy Statement, RF, involuntary resettlement impact categorization checklist, the 1-Book-4 Plan and acquisition and compensation scheme table, information disclosure and public participation, training in the documentation of grievance mechanism and outline of internal monitoring, and answer the feedback of each subproject school to the training content. According to the implementation progress of the program, resettlement consulting experts in the later period will conduct detailed training on resettlement policy, the 1-Book-4 Plan, compensation plan form, information disclosure and public participation, and GRM for schools that have not started construction.

Figure 4-2 Training

Figure 4-3 Conference Attendance List

5 Resettlement Monitoring

According to the survey, 15 of the 74 subproject schools have started

construction. In mid-June 2019, independent resettlement consulting experts

visited the site and monitored the resettlement of the 15 subprojects already under

construction. According to the survey, the resettlement impact of the 15 subproject

schools under construction is classified as class C, all of which are constructed in

the reserved land of original campus, without LA and HD impact. The detailed

monitoring situation is as follows:

5.1 Guilin Tourism College

The civil engineering of Guilin tourism college is mainly to renovate and

decorate the original buildings, improve the teaching staff, and improve the basic

supporting facilities; According to the survey, the project is being built in the original

campus of the school, and the land is reserved for the school, there will be no LA

and HD impact. Land use certificate had been obtained in 2004, without any

remaining problems, Land Certificate is shown in Figure 5-1.

Figure 5-1 Land Use Certificate of Guilin Tourism College

5.2 Guangxi Vocational College of Industrial

Guangxi vocational college of Industrial will newly build manufacture training

base. According to investigation, the land of the original campus is unused state-

owned land which was transferred to Wuming county government of Guangxi on

8 January 2003. Because the land has been left undeveloped by government,

surrounding farmers reclaimed the land and conducted farming since then. The

government of Wuming county has completed young crop compensation with

farmers in 2012 and transferred it to Guangxi Vocational College of Industrial.

There’re no remaining problems. Compensation certificates and land use

certificates are shown in Figure 5-2 and Figure 5-3.

Figure 5-2 Land Use Certificate of Guangxi Vocational College of Industrial

Figure 5-3 Description of Young Crop of Guangxi Vocational College of Industrial 5.3 Guangxi Vocational College of Construction

Guangxi vocational college of construction mainly builds office buildings and libraries, including supporting infrastructure. After investigation, the new office building and library are built in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, there is no LA and HD impact, and before the commencement of civil construction, planning permit of construction engineering and building construction permit of planning department and construction department has been obtained according to domestic procedure, see figures 5-4–5-6.

Figure 5-4 Land Use Certificate of Guangxi Vocational College of Construction

Figure 5-5 Planning Permit of Construction Engineering of Guangxi Vocational College of Construction

Figure 5-6 Building Construction Permit of Guangxi Vocational College of Construction 5.4 Guangxi College for Preschool Education

Guangxi College for Preschool Education is mainly used for teaching and training

in the new campus (public teaching room, teaching and training room and office room),

library, indoor gym, school-level office room, halls and accommodation for college

students, student dormitory (apartment), single staff dormitory (apartment), canteen,

logistics and accessory occupancy, and intellectualized system, playground, water

supply and drainage, power supply and distribution, gates, walls, roads, greening and

landscape, water, square and other supporting infrastructure construction.

According to investigation, the occupied land by the new campus of Guangxi

College for Preschool Education is state-owned land, the transfer procedure of state- owned land has been completed, the land use certificate is being handled now, there is no impact of LA and HD. The supporting materials are shown in the Figure 5-7; before the commencement of civil construction, the construction project planning license of the planning department and construction department has been obtained, as shown in Figure 5-8.

Figure 5-7 the Certificate of State-owned Land Use for the New Campus of Guangxi College for Preschool Education

Figure 5-8 Construction Project Planning Permit for Construction land of Guangxi College for Preschool Education 5.5 Wuzhou University

Wuzhou university mainly builds the comprehensive experimental building and the improvement of the faculty, and so on.

According to investigation, comprehensive experimental building is in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact;

Wuzhou university obtained the land use certificate in 2003, see Figure 5-9; before project civil work, project planning and construction work permits, construction permits of planning department and construction department has been obtained according to domestic procedure. See figures 5-10 and 5-11.

Figure 5-9 Land Use Certificate of Wuzhou University

Figure 5-10 Planning Permit of Construction Engineering of Wuzhou University

Figure 5-11 Construction Work Permits of Wuzhou University 5.6 Guangxi Eco-engineering Vocational and Technical

College

Guangxi Eco-engineering Vocational and Technical College mainly builds the student apartment, training building, comprehensive library, After investigation, all subprojects are in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. Guangxi Vocational Ecological Technology College obtained the land use certificate in 2004, see Figure 5-12; before project civil work, project planning and construction work permits, construction permits of planning department and construction department has been obtained according to domestic procedure, see Figure 5-13.

Figure 5-12 Land Use Certificate of Guangxi Eco-engineering Vocational and Technical College

Figure 5-13 Planning Permit of Construction Engineering of Guangxi Eco- engineering Vocational and Technical College 5.7 Guangxi Financial Vocational College

Guangxi Financial Vocational College builds a library. According to investigation, all the subprojects are being built in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved

for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact; before project civil work, project

planning and construction work permits, construction permits of planning department

and construction department has been obtained according to domestic procedure. See

figures 5-14–5-16.

Figure 5-14 Land Use Certificate of Guangxi Financial Vocational College

Figure 5-15 Planning Permit of Construction Engineering of Guangxi Financial Vocational College

Figure 5-16 Building Construction Permit of Guangxi Financial Vocational College 5.8 Liuzhou City Luzhai Vocational Education Center

Liuzhou City Luzhai Vocational Education Center mainly builds training room, office and relevant supporting facilities. After investigation, all subprojects are in the original campus, the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact.

Liuzhou City Luzhai Vocational Education Center obtained the land use certificate in

2010. See Figure 5-17. Before project civil work, project planning and construction work permits, construction permits of planning department and construction department has been obtained according to domestic procedure. See figures 5-18–5-

19.

Figure 5-17 Land Use Certificate of Liuzhou Luzhai City Vocational Education Center

Figure 5-18 Planning Permit of Construction Engineering of Liuzhou City Luzhai Vocational Education Center Picture

Figure 5-19 Building Construction Permit of Liuzhou City Luzhai Vocational Education Center 5.9 Rong County Secondary Specialized School

Rong County Secondary Specialized School mainly builds student apartment and

training building, and improvement and purchase of facilities. After investigation, the

acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact; see Figure

5-20 for land use certificate.

Figure 5-20 Land Use Certificate of Rong County Secondary Specialized School 5.10 Hechi City Health School

Hechi city health school constructs training building with the land of demolished old auditorium, and improves supporting facilities and equipment.

After survey, the demolished old auditorium is reconstructed in the original site, without LA and HD impact. Construction units have obtained the construction project planning permit from the planning department and construction department before starting construction. See figures 5-21–5-22.

Figure 5-21 Land Use Certificate of Hechi City Health School

Figure 5-22 Construction Project Planning Permit of Hechi City Health School 5.11 Guangxi Industrial Technician College (The original name

is Guangxi petrochemical advanced technical school)

Guangxi industrial technician college mainly constructs student dormitory rooms

and supporting rooms, decoration engineering, water supply and drainage engineering,

electrical engineering, heating engineering and related supporting engineering.

According to the survey, all subprojects are built in the original campus, which are reserved land for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. Construction units

have obtained the construction project planning permit from the planning department

and construction department before starting construction. See figures 5-23 and 5-24.

Figure 5-23 Land Use Certificate 0f Guangxi Industrial Technician College

Figure 5-24 Construction Project Planning Permit of Guangxi Industrial Technician College 5.12 The Second Light Industry Technical School of Guangxi

The Second Light Industry Technical School of Guangxi builds student dorm

building and improves supporting facilities. The Second Light Industry Technical

School of Guangxi had acquired land in 2014, and the land certificate has been obtained in 2015. A total of 139.98 mu of land was acquired, including 19.89 mu of arable land, 87.88 mu of garden land and 32.21 mu of woodland. After investigation, the compensation and resettlement have been completed, there is no leftover problem.

The detailed documents are shown in figures 5-25–5-27.

Figure 5-25 Completion of LA Compensation Situation Notes of The Second Light Industry Technical School of Guangxi

Figure 5-26 Land Use Certificate of The Second Light Industry Technical School of Guangxi

Figure 5-27 Construction Land Use Permit of The Second Light Industry Technical School of Guangxi 5.13 QuanZhou Vocational & Technical Schools

QuanZhou vocational & technical schools mainly builds student dormitory building and automobile repair workshop, including supporting facilities.

After investigation, all the subprojects are in the original campus, where the land is

reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. QuanZhou vocational &

technical schools obtained land use certificate in 2008, see figures 5-28–5-29.

Figure 5-28 Land Use Certificate of QuanZhou Vocational & Technical Schools

Figure 5-29 Planning Permit of Construction Engineering of QuanZhou Vocational & Technical Schools 5.14 Liuzhou No.1 Vocational and Technical School

Liuzhou No.1 Vocational and Technical School builds new student apartment, renovation of power facilities and improvement of supporting facilities. After investigation, new student apartment building is in the original campus, where the land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact. Liuzhou No.1 Vocational and Technical School obtained land use certificate in 2010. See Figure 5-30.

Figure 5-30 Land Use Certificate of Guangxi Qinzhou Agriculture School

5.15 Guangxi Nanning Senior Technical School

Guangxi Nanning Senior Technical School mainly builds one integrated teaching

building, and complementary road, greening, outdoor water and electricity and other

ancillary work. After investigation, all the subprojects are built in the original campus,

which the acquired land is reserved for the school, and there is no LA and HD impact.

See figures 5-31–5-32 for land use certificate and project planning and construction permits.

Figure 5-31 Land Use Certificate of Guangxi Nanning Senior Technical School

Figure 5-32 Planning Permit of Construction Engineering of Guangxi Nanning Senior Technical School

6 Conclusions and Suggestions

Based on the findings of the monitoring visits, consultations and review of the land

availability of the 15 subprojects that have been initiated till date, there are no LA or

HD impacts and the subprojects were categorized C for involuntary resettlement.

The monitoring visits confirmed that the proposed subprojects have been

developed within the existing campuses of the 15 schools, the lands for which have

already been reserved for school development, and the land use certificates have been

obtained from the government, the impact of resettlement on the 15 subprojects

schools is classified as Category C; the subprojects are all sited in the original campus

where land is reserved, resulting in no LA and HD impact.

To make the resettlement work smoothly, GPMO and each of the subproject

schools already under construction have assigned a full-time staff member responsible for resettlement matters and established a GRM. With the help of consulting experts, a GRM processing table and tracking table were prepared, and the GRM database was recommended to be updated regularly. The GRM database would be updated once in 2 weeks and twice in one month. After the update, the updated summary

results would be timely provided to the consulting experts or external monitoring staff.

The subproject school that has not started the construction has not yet established

a GRM and assigned full-time staff, GPMO shall supervise the subprojects that has

not established GRM to established GRM as soon as possible. In addition, each

subproject school that has not yet started the construction should assign a full-time

staff responsible for resettlement issues three months before the project starts, so as

to find problems and solve them in time and establish a timely information communication and feedback mechanism. Because more subprojects school involved in the project, after each sub-project school determines the full-time staff of the resettlement, it is not recommended to change the staff easily. If it is necessary to change the staff, the GPMO will be informed in time, and the resettlement work and data transfer will be done well, and the training on the resettlement work procedures will be conducted for the new staff.

Resettlement consultants will organize the training on resettlement, monitoring

and report preparation for each subproject school full-time staff in the later stage, make

the full-time staff of GPMO and subproject schools understand and master the PRC’s

LA and HD policy and ADB policies, and improve their professional quality and policy processing capacity.

Schools of subprojects that have not yet started the construction should work closely with relevant departments in a timely manner to speed up the relevant land procedures and submit the 1-Book-4-Plan in a timely manner.

So far, there have been no complaints from the communities where the 15 subproject schools have started the construction, according to the survey.

Establish the internal data organization system, strengthen the internal monitoring responsibility system, speed up the collection and statistics of data, timely submit materials, do a good job of sorting out project files, and find problems to solve.

Each subproject school shall provide timely feedback on resettlement. Any information relatex`d to resettlement of each subproject school will be reported to the

GPMO, and then reported to the consulting experts and ADB.