Saturday, 9th June, 1951
PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES
(Part I—Questions and Answers)
OFFICIAL REPORT
VOLUME V m . 1051
(17th May to 9th Jnne, 1961)
Third Session (Second Part) of the
PARLIAMENT OF INDIA
1961 16 P.8.O. OOlJTENrPS
Folum V III^ F rm 27th Ma^ to M Jui^ IPSJ
Thursday, 17th May, 1051— 06Umn$.
Oral Answera to Questions • • • • • • • 48S<^—4M6 Written Answers to Questions • ♦ • • 4866—4874 ^iday, 18 th May, 1951— Oral Answers to Q u e stio n s...... • . # 4875—4407 i.; Written Answers to Questions .•••#••• 4507—4410 paturday, 19th May, 1961— Oral Answers to Questions ,.••••••• 44H—4440 Written Answers to Qiie«iioii* ,,•••••• 4441— 4444 Monday, 21st May, 1951— Oral Answers to Questions *#••••••• 4445—4476 Written Answers to Questions •••••••• 4476—4494 Tuesday. 22nd May, 1 951 - Oral Answers to Q u e s tio n s...... 4495—4588 Written Answers to Questions .,•••• • 4528—4586 Wednesday. 23rd May. 1951 - Oral Answers to Q u e s tio n s ...... 4587—4567 Written Answers to Q u e s t i o n s...... 4567—4576 Thursday, 24th May, 1951— ..•#••••• Oral Answers to Q u e s tio n s ...... • . 4577— 4606 Written Answers to Questions .••••••• 4607—4618 Friday, 25th May, 1951 - Oral Answers to Questions ...... ■ • • • • 4619—4652 Written Answers to Questions •••••••• 4652— 4666 Saturday, 26th May, 1951- Oral Answers to Q u e s tio n s ...... 4667—4698 Written Answers to Questions ,.•••••• 4698—4704 Monday, 28th May. 1951— j Oral Answers to Questions .•••••••• 4605— 4784 Written Answers to Questions •••••••• 4784—4748 Wednesday, 30th May, 1951- Oral Answers to Questions ••••«•••• 4749—4777 Written Answers to Questions .•••••#• 4777—4786 Thursday, 31st May. 1951— Oral Answers to Questions ••*•••••• 4787—4817 Written Answers to Questions •••••*•• 4817—4826 Friday, 1st June, 1951— Oral Answers to Questions ••••••«•• 4827—4859 Written Answers to Questions •••••••« 4859—4876
Monday, 4th June, 1951- Oral Answers to Questions #»••••••• 4877—4909 Written Answers to Questions «••••••• 4010—4928 236 P.S.D. («) Tuesday, 6th June, Oral AnswerB to Q u ofltion s...... • • • 4020—4965 Writton Answors to QueBtiond •••••••• 4900—6000 Wednesday, 6th June, 1961— Orol AiiMworfl to Questions ••••••••• 6001—6038 Written Angwora to Q u o H tio n s ...... 6033—6064 Thur8day, 7th Juno, 1961— Otal Aiswors to Que;^tion« . . . . . • • • 6065—6087 Wtitfcon Amwers to Quoationg . • ...... 6087—6106 Friday, 8th June, 1961— Oral Answers to Questions . • . • • • • • • « 6107—6137 Written Answers to Questions .••••••• 6137—6162 Saturday, 9th June, 1961— Oral Answers to Q u e s tio n s ...... 6163—6188 Written Answers to Q u o s t i o n s ...... 6188—6190 TEEE PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES fPart I—HJuestions and Answers) OFnCIAL REPORT
0163 AI64
PARLIAMENT OF INDIA that had lapsed, the ts ih respect of the other aerod: Ies were Saturday, 9th June, 1951 rlit proceeded with. The same com plainant made allegations reg(;rcting the nursery near Iluma3ain*s Tomb. These were investigated but no proof The House met at Half-paat Eight of of any oifence could be discovered and the Clock, the investigation was dropped.
[M r . S pe a k e r in the C h a ir ] Shri R. C. Upadhyaya: May I know ORAL ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS how many investigations are pending now? F r a u d s in C.P.W.D. Shri Rajagopalachari: I answai'cd *478$. Shri R. C. Upadhyftya: . (a) that question the other day. I have no Will the Minister of Home Affairs be figures at present with me—if the pleased to state whether aiiy com- reference is to other investigations. glaints were made to the Special Police Jistablishment against ofAcers and con- Shri R. C. Upadhyaya: May I k^ow iractors of the Central P. WJ). regard whether the investigation with regard ing frauds and excess payment in to item (ii), that is the construction respect of the following construction of a new nursery near llumaytin’s works by C.P.W.D.— Tomb, has been dropped? (i) construction of aerodromes at Palam, Gurgaon and Rohtak Shri Rajagoi^alaehari: Yes, Sir. I (Runways) by the Delhi Aviation said that it was the same complainant Division; and that wrote about the nursery near Humayun’s Tomb also. These . com (ii) construction of New Nursery plaints were investigated; the Special near Humayan Tomb? Police Establishment looked at them (b) Were these complaints register from the point of view of a prose* ed, if so, when and if not« do Govern cution in a court but no prrK)f of ment propose to register them now offence could be discovered. and start investigation as huge pub Pandit Munishwar Datt Upadhyay. lic money is alleged to be misappro May I know whether prosecution has priated and over paid? been sanctioned against the executive (c) Will Government take care that ♦engineer and some other oflkials of no document in respect of these cases the C.P.W.D. against whom charges is destroyed or tampered with? were proved prima facie? In answer to a question some time ago it was The Minister of Home .\ifalM (Shri stated that a prima fade case existed RaJagolialacliari): (a) Yes. Sir. . against some officers. Has prosecution (b) and (c). The complaints were been sanctioned? . made in 1948 in respect of the con Shri Rajagopalachari: Does the hon. struction of aerodromes in IiM2-43. Member refer to an answer gi\en by The complaint regarding the Rohtak m^? aerodrome was investigated and it was found that apart from irregularities Mr. Speaker: His point was that, in the preparation of estivnates. call some time back some' irregularities ing for tenders ctc., there was no were found acainst certiin CVPW.D. evidence to support a criminal charge. officials in rcsoert of con.atrucllon of In view of the result of the Inv
Shri Rajaipopalachari: I don’t remem Bengal Government to have a judicial ber having answered any question on enquiry by a high Judicial officer, that subject, Sir. Shri Krishnanand Rai: Is it a fact Pandit Munishwar Dait Cpadhyay: that the Commissioner has come to Jt was not answered by the Home the finding that the firing was...... Minister but by the Minister of Works, Power and Supply. Mr. Speaker: Order, order. It has already been covered by the pre’ ious Mr. Speaker: Then this question had answer. better be put to him. Shrl R. €. Upadhyaya: May 1 know D.D.T. whether any departmental action has '*'4782. Shri Thimmappa Gowda: Will been taken against the officers re the Minister of Health be pleased to ferred to in my question? refer to the answer to starred ques Shri Rajagopalaehari: As I said, tion No. 4182 asked on the 16th May these dftses reier to procedure in 1951 and state: 1942-43. inve.stigation being Initialed (a) the quantity of D.D.T. produc six years thereafter, in 1948. Some of ed in India every year and the places the ofWcers have been transferred to where it is produced; and Pakistan. No departmental actior is (b) the steps that have been taken r possible now. Moreover, as regards by the Government to produce the irregularities in the calling of tenders required quantity of D.D.T. in India? and the like. after so inany years there will be no meaninq in proceed The Minister of State for Rehabilita ing against them now. tion (Shri A. P. Jain): (a) At present only one firm in Baroda is producing C ooch-B ehar F ir in g I n cident D.D.T. and the total production is M781. Shri Krishnanand Rai: Will 24,000 lbs. per year. the Minister of Home Affairs be pleas (b) The Government of Bombay ed to state: . have formulated a scheme for setting up a factory for the manufacture of (a) whether the enquiry held by the D.D.T. with the assistance of the Divisional Commissioner, in Cooch- UNICEF. The scheme is still under , Behar firing incident is finished; and discussion with the UNICEF/WHO (b) if so, what steps the Govern authorities. ment of West Bengal have taken to implement the flndlngs of the Com Shri Thimmappa Gowda: IVIay I missioner’ know India’s requirements of D.D.T. every year? The Minister of Home Affairs (Shri RaJftffopalachari): (a) and (b). The Shri A. P. Jain: It is estimated that Divisional Commissioner’s enquiry into India requires 1,000 tons of D.D.T. per Cooch Bihar incident has been finished year The actual consumption in and he has made his confidential report 1950-51 was 576 tons. The 1,000 tons to the West Bengal Government. A I mentioned is exclusive of the D.DT. judicial enquiry by a High Court required for agricultural purposes. Judge is now proceeding. I am not in Shri Thimmappa Gowda: What la a position to disclose or discuss the the quantity used for agricultural pur , contents of the Divisional Com poses? ’ mlssioner’s report as it might pre judice the judicial enquiry. The Shri A. P. Jain: We have no estimate Deputy Commissioner of Cooch Bihar of it. and two other officers have been trans ferred from Cooch Bihar. This was Shri Thimmappa Gowda: May I done so as to give no room for the know what is the result achieved in belief that a full and detailed enquiry the spraying of D.D.T. to prevent was being hampered by the presence malaria in Malnad parts? of these officers in Cooch Bihar. Shri A. P. Jain: Well, the result has Shri Krishnanand Rai: After the been quite hopeful. Commissioner’s enquiry, may I know what was the necessity for and on U n iv e r s it y C o m m i s s io n whose demand-has the judicial enquiry •47S1 Shri a N. Das: Will the Minis been set up? i ter of Education be pleased to state: Shri Rajagopalachari: Even before (a) whether Government have con the Divisional Commissioner’s enquiry sidered the question of having a Cen began, or about the same time, when trally Organised Rosearch Organisation I was answering a question here I had, for a thorouA study of the Sclentlflc I think, promised a Judicial enquiry, methods of IMucational testing and but at any rate I asked the West appraisal; m i Oral Answers 9 J U N E 1951 Oral Answers
^ (b> if so» the steps being taken xo •Shri A. P. Jain: That is as well ^Ive effect to the recommendations of known to the Governmtnt as to others— the University Commission in this that is, the defects of quantum and regard; . quality that exist. ‘ (c) which of the Indian Univer sities have permanent full time Board Dr. Deshmnkh: Is it not a fact t^at of Examiners to perform functions as a high grade training college has bMn suggested by the Commission; and established by the Central Goven^ ment in Delhi? (d) whether Government have made ^ any provision for scholarships for the Shri A. P. Jain: I do not exactly training of experts in the Scientific follow to which high-grade college the methods of Educational testing? hon. Member is referring. The Minister of State for RehablUta- Dr. Deshmukh: For the training oj tion (Shrl A. P. Jain): (a) and (b). teachers. There is no proposal with the Govern Shrl A. P. Jain: This question does ment of India at present for setting not concern the training of teachers. up a Centrally organised Research Organisation. Tl>e recommendations Dr. Deshmukh: Is it aot proposed* of the University Education Commission Sir, that scientific research in educa in this regard, along with other tional testing is to be carried on recommendations are, however, still at a later stage in this college? That under consideration. * was the purpose of my question. (c) The Ministry of Education has Shri A. P. Jain: WelJ, Sir, the r^ no information on this point. commendations of the University Com (d) No provision has been made so mission are still under examination far for awarding scholarships for the and unless a final decision Is taken it study of the subject. is difficult to say where the institution will be set up. ♦ Shri S. N. Das: May I know whether there is any proposal to invite experts Slirl S. N. Das: May I know whether on this subject from foreign countries? any efl'orts have been made by the Government to estimate the total Shri A. P. Jain: The matter is under expenditure that would be incurred in ^ the consideration of the Government of connection with examination research India but no decision has been taken in Universities and different educa as yet. tional institutions? . Shri A. P. Jain: It is estimated that Shri S. N. Das: In view of the fact ultimately this scheme will involve that the University Commission has an expenditure of Rs. 10 rrores per given top priority to this reform, may year from the Central and SAttt I know whether there is any proposal Governments' revenues. The estimate to hold seminars in order to develop of the examination research Is fivm a group of experts? lakhs. Shri A. P. Jain: I have already stat- id that the matter is upder oonsidera- U n iv e r s it y E d u cation ion and that no decision has been M784. Shri S. N. Das: Will the taken as yet—Government is actively Minister of Education be pleased te considering the whole matter. state: Shri S. N. Das: Since the recom (a) the extent to which the recom« mendations of the University Com mendations of the University Gem- mission have been considered by the mission regarding University education Government, may I know what steps have been accepted by Government; have the Universities taken to bring about reforms in the system of (b) which of these accepted recon>- examinations prevailing in tlie country? mendations have been given effect to; and Shri A. P. Jain: We have no informa (c) how long it will take to appoint tion on that point except that the a Central Grants Commission as rt^ Universities have established psycho commended by the Comiplsslon? logical institutes for carr3^ng on experiments on objective tests. The Minister of SUte for Behablllta* tfon (Shri A. P. Jain): (a) and fb). Shrl S* N. Daa: May I know whether The hon. Member is referred to the the attention of Government has been reply to Starred Question No. 409S drawn to the fact that various kinds asked by Shri Kesava Rao on of corruption have entered into the May, 1991. Since then itatutory re* system of examinations prevailing In cognition has been given to VHsva* the Universities? Marti T University. 5ie« Oral Answers 9 JUNE 1951 Oral Answers 6 m (c) The attention of the hon. Mem i I aft ber iB invited to the reply given to part (a) of Starred Question No, 1961 f ^ a r m ^sked by Shri Barrow on the 7th March, 1951. Shri S. N. Das: May I know, Sir, [Shri A. p. Jain: It is not proposed since the recommendations of the Uni to do so now. However the cases of versity Commission have been con those Universities which are under the sidered by Government what efforts Centre, are under consideration ] have been made to ascertain the exjent to which the Universities have been Shri S. N. Das: May I know, Sir, able to give effect to the recommenda whether the recommendations of the tions of the Commission? University Commission regarding the Shri A. P. Jain: The Universities setting up of a Central Institute of are autonomous bodies and they are Physical Education has oeen consider giving effect to the recommendations ed by the Government? ' of the Commission. So far as the Central Government is 'concerned, we Shri A. p. Jain: In fact all U>e re have given effect to the recommenda commendations of the University tions with regard to the Aligarh and Commission which concerned the the Banares Universities. Two Bills Centre are under the active considera have been brought here which are tion of Government. Some of them ^ pending before the Legislature. The may be Implemented; others may not Visva Bharati Bill has. already been be implemented on account of financial passed. and other difficulties. Shri S. N. Das: To what extent the RADTO.S recommendations of the University ^4786. Shri Itaj Kanwar: Will the Commission regarding religious Minister of Information and Broad> instructions have been given effect to? ea»tln? be nleased to state the total Shri A, P. Jain: That will form the number of Radios installed and in subject matter of the Bill which will operation in each of the Part *A\ come up for discussion today. Part ‘B* and Part ‘C’ States on the latest date for which figures hie Dr. Deshmukh: Is the Government available? ^ tiware, Sir, that the revenues of various Universities differ very widely and if The Minister of State for Transport 80 whether any steps are intended to and RaUways (Shri Santhanam): A be taken so as to equalise l!i3 flnan-'lal statement is laid on the Table of the Income of the various’ universities by Hou.se on the presumption that the giving grants? hon. Member requires information re grading radio transmitters. [See Shri A. P. Jain: The revenues of Appendix XXVII, annexure No. 61]. the various Universities do differ and there is no doubt about it According Shri Raj Kanwar: Are any radios to the recommendations of the Uni or their parts manufactured in India versity Commission a grant committee and if not what steps, if any, are will be set up and it will of course Government taking to give a fillip to, equalise the grants which are being this industry? ’ made by the Centre to the different Shri Santhanam: 'fhe hon. Member universities. wants Information about radio receiv ing sets or transmitters? Shri Raj Kanwar: About receiving MvfeJTtWrPw t , ^TRT^, sets, Shri Santhanam: Full details about WT ^ P m ^ radiD receiving set parts Which are ^ 9 3rf%Rf ’(fwr manufactured and which are proposed to be manufactured were given in this V House only a few days ago. " Shri Raj Kanwar: What is the maxi fSHh Govlnd Das: Whether it is mum and minimum price of a radio proposed to give further consideration imported from abroad and whii^h in this respect In the cnse of newly country is the largest exporter of established Universities, as that of radios from abroad to India? Saugor?] * i Mr. Speaker: I think He tjoes Into too many details. Has the hon. mini Shri Saathanam: The hon. Member was for improved efficiency and it de will see that this question relates to pends on the education and the type Ixansmitters installed in various of people we get for the messenger States. service. We have been doing with Dr. Deshiiuikh: Has the Government chaprassis for so long a time, that it appreciated the importance of brcad- is difficult to change over to a new castinjj stations for educational pur system at once. But both efficiency poses arid is there any proposal to and economy will have to be consider establish any broadcasting station ed together, and so far the attempt purely for the educational purposes? has not proved very successful. But the experiment is still being carried on. ^ Shri Saathanam: I do not think it ’would be worthwhile to establish a Shri Raj Kanwar: How many particular station wholly for educa Ministries have replied with regard tional purposes. Each radio station is this proposal and what is the trend of used partly for educational purposes. thpir opinion? < . I think that is a better method. Dr. Deahmukh: Is it a fact that the Shri Rajagopalachari: Tne expert Poona University has established, or is ment is being carried on in the Cabinet going to establish, a broadcasting Secretariat and the Planning Com station for that purpose? mission and the results are being watched. Other Ministries have not been very enthusiastic about it, ^ Shri Santhanam: I have no informa- but ^ tion. as I said it is still being considered, Riv£r Projects Messenger Service System M787 . Shri Raj Kanwar: Will the *4788 . Shri B. K. Das: WiU the Minister of Home Affairs be pleased Minister of Natural Resources and to state: Scientific Research be pleased to ^tate (a) whether Government have come whether any of the River projects has to any decision with regard to the been compelled either to slow down introduction of Messenger Service or stop in consequence of want of System in the Central Secretariat and help from the Centre? the attached offices as recommended The Minister of Natural Resources ^ both by the Economy Committee and and Scientific Research (Shri Sri the Estimates Committee and if so, Prakasa): The attention of the hon. what that decision is; and Member is invited to the raply given \(b) if not, when a decision is likely by the hon. Shri N. V. Gadgil to Shri lo be reached in the matter? Kamath’s question No. 477 on the 29th, November 1950 wherein my hon. The Minister of Home Affairs (Shri colleague stated that none .'»f the river Rajagopalachari); (a) and (b). The valley development projects or plans Scheme is being tried in small com had been abandoned; but that some of pact organisations e.g.. Cabinet the investigations had been slowed Segretariat and Planning Commission down. The position remains the same, Introduction 141 larger Departments and Ministries will be considered in Shri B. K. Das: As regards the pro ^the light of the results this jects that have been undertaken by the of trial. States as well as by the Centre, are Shri Raj Kanwar: What is the pre there any works in regard to which the sent total expenditure incurred on jsranjts have been withheld? Class IV government servants who have been recommended by the Shri Sri Prakasa: No, Sir. •That is Economy Committee and the Ii^timates not so. It is only financial difficultlos Committee for replacement by the that have come In our way. proposed Messenger Service System Shri B. K. Das: What was the total and what is their total number? demand in respect of the three major Shri Rajagopalachari: If n^y hon. projects this year and what allorations ' friend wants to know the exact have been made for them? ngures, I would request him to give Shri Sri Prakasa: As the hon. Mem notice of a question. ber will recollect, the hon. the Financt Shri Raj Kanwar: What saving in Minister has budgeted for a sum of expenditure is expec<-ed If the Rs. 30 crores for the projects that art Messenger Service System is intro under the Centre and this will be duced? utilised for the various projects. Shri Ra.iagopnlachari: It is not Shri B. K. Das: I wanted to know merely saving in expenditure that was what sums out of that have been at the bottom of this proposal. It allocated for the three major projects? 1173 Oral Answers 9 JUNE 1951 Oral AnstOers ai74 Shri Sri Prakasa: If my recollection are human l^eings working together is correct, a lump sum grant has been there would be these differences. made in the budget and it will be distributed among the various projects. Mauivi Wajed Ali: May I know whether the question of new river Mr. Speaker: What he wants to en- valley projects in Assam is being dis QUlre about is whether there is any cussed by the Planning Commission? allocation at all to the three major • projects and, it* so, what? Shri\ Sri Prakasa: I do not know what proposals there are before the Shri Sri Prakasa: Separately? Nu, Planning Commission. But as the Sir. the grant is in a lump sum. hon. Member knows, wc have two pro Mr. Speaker: In respect of the three jects in Assam. One is along the major schemes is there anything to be Manas river and the other Is along the ipent over them? That is the point. Dehang river beyond Pasighat in the Abor Hills. We are proceedhig with The Minister of Finance (Shri C. D. these. beshiiiiikh): The figures are likely to be of the order of 16, 9 and 5, as far Saikh Mohiuddin: May I know the as I remember. 16 for Bhakrn, 9 for reason why the work of construction Damodar and 5 for Hirakud—that is of the bridge on the Ganges near Patna likely to be the distribution. is slowed down? Shri Shiva Rao: May I know whether Shri Sri Prakasa: I have no informa* there is any truth in the report that tlon. has appeared In the last year that a Board of Engineers has been Shri B. K. Das: Is It a fact that for appointed to look Into the Kosl Pro the Mayurakshl project undertaken by ject and that the first stage of the pro the West Bengal Government, the ject costing Rs. 10 crores U likely to grant has been withheld? be undertaken In the near future? Shri Sri Prakasa: No grant has been Shri Sri Prakasa: So far as the llrst withheld. part of the hon. Member’s question Is concerned the answer is in the nfTlr- Collective Farming mative. A Board of Engineers has been set up and they will look into the proposals regarding the first stage M789. Dr. Ram Suhhag Singh: Will Of the project. So far as the second the Minister of Defence be pleased to part Is concerned, it all depends state: whether the sum of Rs. 11 crores or (a) whet’ier the Defence autho so that is expected to bo spent on It, rities propose to launch experiments is forthcoming. in collective farming; and Shri A. C. Guha: May I know if any (b) if so, what kinds of farms are icheme the execution of which has proposed to be established? already been undertaken has been The Depnty Minister of Defence Slowed down or not? (Major-General Himatslnlijl): (a) and Shri Sri PraJuaa: Yes, Sir. Three (b). ‘‘Collective farms" as such are ichemes have been slowed down not proposed to be formed. Wherever They concern the Assam projects of compact blocks of 1,000 acres and the Dehang river In the Abor Hills. As above are available, they will be the hon. Member knows, the recent organised initially as State-managed earthquake has greatly disturbed the Ex-Servicemen’s Colonies. After these topography of the place and that is are worked as State-managed Colonies the chief'^ason why we have had to for about two years, the intention is make further investigations of this to transform them into Joint/Tenant. particular place. Then the Bargi pro Farming Co-operative Societies. ject on the Narbada and the Hasdeo project in Madhya Pradesh have also In cases where smaller blocks are been slowed down for want of money. available, they will be formed straight away into Joint/Tenant Farming Co Shri B. R. Bha^t: Is there any operative Societies grouping them into truth in the press report that the work a Federation. The biRgest Colony In of the Hirakud project has slowed the group will constitute the Federa down due to some d:(Terence of opinion tion Heoiquarters and will control and or lack of co-operation omorg> the supervise the a fill i a ted Societies. •nginoers? Dr. Ram Subbair Singh: May I know Shri Sri Prakasa: The work of the the total area of land on which such Hirakud project is going ahead. As farming has been allowed In the regards dlfTorencps. wherever there scheme? 55175 Oral Answers 9 JUNE 1951 Oral Answers 5l7e Major-General Himatsinhji: I think The Minister of Natural Resources this was answered last time. Tie Md SciepUflc Besearcb (Skri Sri total area under the new scheme will Ptakasa): (a) and (b). Investigation be 92,841 acres. In 1949 the .U.P. of the Geology and of the imneral Government have given 15,000 acres. deposits of various areas iji the Besides that, there are ten other Jalpaiguri and Darjeeling districts schemes in the various States, cover nave been undertaken during the last ing about 50.000 acres. 70 years. A list of the reports relating to these investigations is laid on the Table of the House. [5ee Appendix, Dr. Ram Subhai Sin#;h: May I Jcnow XXVIII, annexurt No. 62.] the average area of land which a soldier is entrusted to manage? . The reports indicate that the more Major-General Hlmatslnhjl: It will important minerals to be found in be an economical holding. The area these areas are coal, copper, goid. iron depends on the type o f land. white clay, graphite and dolomite. The coal Is of poor quality. The copper deposits are m all and cannot Shri Sondhi: Is it the policy of the be worked on a commercial scale or Government that the entire cereal support a smelting industry of any needed for the consumption of the size. The deposits of gold, iron ore and Army wiD be raised on their own dolomite are also considered to be lands, that is the lands attached to the uneconomic to be worked on a com Defence Ministry? mercial scale. Aiajor-General Himatsdnhji: It is not (c) Further investigations will be possible. Military personnel have to conducted if asked for by the State do their normal military training for Government. the defence of the country. They can not, therefore, be put on this job for Shri S. C. Samanta: May I know the whole-time. whether the building materials and the road metals that have been Shri Kamath: Is this scheme in investigated in those areas are suitable furtherance of Government’s Grow to be transported economically to More Food campaign or is the Defence other parts of India for. use? Minislrv organising this on Mts o^vn bat*' Shri Sri Prakasa: I have no specific information about this road material, Major-General Himatsinhji: The hon. but the general information that I have Member knows that a large number shows that they are uneconomic so far of soldiers have been demobbed and as working Is concerned. are likely to be demobbed gradually. Therefore their resettlement and r^ SbA S. C. Samanta: The hon. habilitation must be arranged. That Is Minister has said in the statement that the first and foremost reason for the investigations carried in 1950-51 this scheme. At the same time It alsc will soon reach the Ministry, May I happens to help in the Grow More expect that the results will be laid on Pood scheme. the Table of the House? Dr. Ram Subhag Singh: May I know • Shri Sri Pntkasa: Yes, Shr, if the the kind of ownership which is pro- hon. Member so desires. * ^ posed to be introduced on such land? Shri S. C. Samanta: In which parts Mr. Speaker: I think this was of the Jalpaiguri district has dolomite answered only a few days back. Was been found and to what extent? it not? Shri Sri Prakasa: I think that a care Major-General Himatsinhji: Yes, Sir. ful study of the reports placed on the Table of the House, will give the hon Member the needed information. Mineral Investigations Revenues ♦4790. Shri S. C. Samanta: Will the Minister of Natural Resourced and ^4791. Pandit Munlshwar Datt Scientific Research be pleased to state: Upadhyay: Will the Minister of (a) when and where mineral In Finance be oleased to state the total vestigations were conducted .in the revenue collections from direct and diitricts of Jalpaiguri and Darjeeling; indirect taxation separately in the years 1949-50 and 1950-51? (b) the reports of the findings of those investigations; and The Minister of State for JP'lnance (c) whether Government propose to fShri Tyagi): Collections during these conduct further investigatio»~ s in those two years from direct taxes will be districts In near future? about Rs 161.62 lakhs and Rs. 168,78 9 JUNE 1951 Oral Answers 6Z7« 5177 Oral Answers field projects in the W.H.O. budgets lakhs respectively, and from in^rect for 1950, 1951 and 1952 is placed on taxes about Rs. 195,65 lakhs and Rs the Table of the House. [See Appendix 219,18 lakhs. X X V U l annexure No. 63.] Pandit Munishwar Datt Upadh^ay: The final figures for 1932 as May I know how does the percentage sanctioned by the Fourth World b e t w e e n direct and indirect taxes com. Health Assembly which met in Geneva S re wUh the corresponding ngures in in May, 1951 are not yet known. the U.K. and U.S.A.? Pandit MuQishwar Datt Upaflhyay: Sbri in d ^ S May I know w^hy the provision for venereal disease control and also edu cation and training has been diacoo- direct taxes ^as 70 ^ ce tinued in the year 1952? Shri A. P. Jain: Probably there was no need for it and there is no pro vision in the Budget for 1952. Puidlt Muntohw" !>»« What Is the a m o u n t that we expect Pandit Munishwar Datt Upadhyay: the year 1951-52. May I know whether as a result of cholera and plague research has any specific medicine been found besides those that are known already? 2a9 crores and 95 laicns. Shri A. P. Jain: I would require notice of this question. s " ’" ■?2cSKj?’ Ji Pandit Munishwar Datt Upadhyay: May I know whether there were no taxes separately? Tuberculosis control clinics in Delhi, Shri Tyajl: For this, I shall require Patna and Trivandrum or in any other place in India and whether they have been newly started, as it appears from A f! Ruh'a: May 1 know 11 after item one of the statement? thf IlSiort o f the National Inconie Inquiry Committee, .ncf- Shri A. P. Jain: That appears to be so. Pandit Munishwar Datt Upadhyay: indirect taxation? Had we any Tuberculosis clinics in the Shri Tya^i; Naturally this Com- country anywhere? mUtee has been appointed just t6 ex amine the capacity to pay in the Shri A. P. Jain: So (ar as the Centre Incomes of people. This examination is concerned, these are the three is being taken up only for this pur clinics which have been set up. Three pose so that the incidence may be fair more are proposed to be .set up in Bombay, Lucknow and Calcutta. There to all sectors. may have been others which may have Mr. Speaker: I am going to the next' been set up by the State Governments. question. ' Pandit Munishwar Datt Upadhyay: Advisory Services and Field May I know whether the administra Projets tion of this Department is leh to Uie State or to the Central Government, ^4792. Pandit Manishwar Dali because I find that no provision has Upadhjay: Will the Minister of Health been made for administration as seen be pleased to state: from item 9 of the Statement for the year 1951-52? (a) the amount provided for India for her advisory services and field Shri A. P. Jain: Obviously a scheme projects in the 1952 Budget of W.H.O.; like that will partly be implemented (b) how it compares with the figures by the Centtal Government and partly for 1951 and 1950; and by the State Governments. (c) whether any rums are earmark Pandit Munishwar Datt Upadhyay: ed for any particular works or May I know where conferences are to •ervices? be held as stated in item 3 of the statement? Tiie Minister of State for Rehabilita tion (Shri A. P. Jain): (a) to (c). A Shri Av P. Jain: The conference may comparafive statement showing the take place either in Madras or lu details of the amount provided for Calcutta. 'India for her advisory services and Mr. Speaker: Next question. 5170 Oral Answers 9 JUNE 1951 Oral Answers sm I ncome-tax Shri C. D. Deshmukh: The principal object of the International Monetary >^4793. Pandit Munlshwar Datt Fund is to ensure that the currency fjpadbyay: Will the Minister of remains stable and to advise Member n '?nc€ be pleased to slate: Governments if there are any tempo (a) the amount , of income-tax le- rary difficulties in the balance of pay- ^eived from anonymous tax evaders mexits, to meet them. In the course up to May, 1951; and of carrying cut their duties, the Fund (b) whether such tax evaders have does advise the Member Governmentd disclosed their earnings and the in regard to fundamental economic ^ sources of earnings? conditions and if the conditions are such as to inhibit the formation of The Minister of State lor Finance capital, their advice would be useful (Shrl Tyagi): (a) The amount of in in taking remedial measures. come-tax received from anonymous tax evaders up to the month of May, Shri Amolakh Chand: May I know 1951 is Rs. 30,751. ^ if the ex-Finance Minister Dr. John (b) They have not disclosed their Matthai gave tax reliefs of various earnings and sources of earnings. kinds to the industrialists in the hope that they would help capital formation Mr. Speaker: We shall go to the and provide an incentive for increas next question. This was dealt with ed production and if so, what was the formerly. ' result*^ , . Shri C. D. Deshmukh: This has been C apital F orm ation discussed during tHe course of thi> Budget. *4794. Shri Amolakh Chand: Will the Minister of Finance be pleased tp Mr. Speaker; He wants to know ihe state whether there has been a pro results. gressive fall in the rate of capital formation in India during the last Shri C. D. Deshmukh: I cannot take three years and if so, what steps are the matter any further than I took It being taken to improve it? in the course of the Budget discussions. I mentioned there that the debenture The Minister of Finance (Shri C. D. flotation, that is 1950. had been more Deshmukh): Precise data are not successful than in the previous year. available* regarding the rate of capi Another slight indication is that the tal formation in India so that com amount floated in regard to Issue Capi parison or ascertainment of trends is tal was 72*68 crores in 1949 and it was not possible. However, Government 85 09 crores in 1950. This shows have been encouraging the formation perhaps p slight improvement. of capital in the private sector by various methods, the more importanf Shri T. T. Krishnamachari: Arisi|ig of which arc the liberalisation of de out of the ans^ipr of the hon. Minister preciation allowances on plant and in respect of concessions shown by the machinery for income-tax purposes, Government in the matter of de the exemption oi new industrial predation allowances, has it beea undertakings from income-tax for a noticed by Government that there is specified period, the granting of relief a tendency on the part of industrial in respect of customs duties on concerns in India to write up their imports of raw material and plant and capital similar to what is done in the machinery, and the promotion of smfill United Kingdom? savln^^f^ schemes. Shri C. D. Deshmukh: I am not aware of any official study ha\<1ng been made Shri Amolakh Chand: May I know in that regard. if India entered into an agreement with the International Monetary Fund Shri Amolakh Chand: The hon -with high hopes of capital * formation Minister said that no precise data are in India? available. May I know whether it is due to the fact that the industrialists Shri €. D. Deshmukh: There is no are not keeping proper accounts? connection between capital fomr.atioh. Shri C. D. Deshmukh: In relation to « in India and India's membership In the the last question or in relation to rapl- International Monetary Fund. tal formation? Mr. Speaker: The point seems to be: Mr. Speaker: Capital formation. whether any decisions have been taken SBirt C. D. Deshmukh: Gathering or anything done which will Indirectly information in regard to capital forma- help capital formation. That is how I lioti is not necessarily dependent on understand it: I do not know what the data being made available by Member means. ' industrialists. I would invite hon. fflll Oral Answers 9 J U N E 1951 Oral Answers 6182 Member’s attention to para 3 9 of the ing of new schools or new sections is First Report of the National Income also authorised. Committee where it ba: Shri A. P. Jain: In 1947, there were only? 117 schools; in 1951 the number of schools is 146; that is 20 schools more Shri C. D. Deshmukh: It is no use liave been opened. asking me what para 3.9 of the Fir.?t Report of the National Income Com Shri Deshbandhu Gupta: How many mittee says. I think a copy of fhe of these 29 schools have been opened report Is available in the library. f y the Government? S chools in D elhi (A dm issio n ) Shri A. P. Jain: They have either been opened by the Government or *4797. Shri Deshbandhu Gupto: Will InKen over by the Government. the Minister of Education be pleased to state: Shri Sohan Lai: May I know wnether (a) whether it is a fact that at the there is any reservation of seats in time of fresh admissions this year ^he Delhi Government schools for the large number of students were refus scheduled caste students? ed admission, if so, the number of Shri A. P. Jain: They are equally such students and steps taken by eligible for admission in all the Government to secure admission for schools. them: (b) whether it is a fact that there Shri Deshbandhu Gupta: Wiiii re Ls overcrowding in most of the ference to the reply to part (4? schools, if so, the average number of *nay I know the approximate number students which a teacher is required '^f students? Is it more than 2U,0lV» to take in the primary classes and in who have been refused admission this the Secondary classes respectively; year in the higher and secjndaiy and schools? Have you got any figures? (c) whether there are a large num Shri A. P. Jain: The approxinal** ber of private schools run by indiyl- r*umber of students who have been duals in small places on a commercial refused admission and who were re- basis, if so, what control do Govern- feistered with the Director oi Publv? ^ment exercise on such Institutions? Instruction was approximately 14U<' *Out of these, about 40 or so were n*»t The Minister of State for Rehabilita c.iialiflcd; two did not appear; the tion (Shri A, P. Jain): (a) Some cases remaining about 1358 have been fi>e.1 of refusal of admission have been re up, ported, but the exact number or such students is not yet available. The Shri Deshbandhu Gupta: Is the hon. Local Administration registers the Minister satisfied that these figures names of such students and all efforts represent the total picture, that is, that are made to secure seats for theai the number that ha.s- not been register Subject to availability of funds open ed is not many thousands? 5 m Oral Answers 9 JUNE 1951 Oral Anstvers 51841 Shri A. P. Jain: I am not sure about The hon. Member may have in mind the number of students who have not the system obtaining in certain Western been registered with the Director. I countries of calling up men com can only depend upon the figures pulsorily for service for one or two supplied by the Director and I do be years. The circumstances in which' lieve that the figures represent the this system was adopted vary from correct picture. country to country. This system has^ its obvious advantages inasmuch as it Shri DeshbandAiu Gupta: In view is the surest way of building up a very ^ of the fact that these private schools large reserve of nian-power to meet are really run on commercial lines, and emergencies. It, however, entails a there are so many abuses reported great strain on the Standing Army and against the schools, do Government is also a fairly expensive proposition; propose to take steps to Introduce It is said that in England, for example,, some control on these schools? the Standing Army has been denuded^ to such a large extent to provide Shri A. P. Jain: I do not know v/hat Instructors for national servicemen, the hon. Member means. This is a that the number of active formations free democratic country where any had to be reduced even below the body is at liberty to carry on any safety limit. For a country like ourt. institution or trade. It is for the the adoption of compulsory military parents to send their children to the service, which is more or less the same schools or not. thing as the adoption of the system of national service for a limited period» Mr. Speaker: We will go to the next is not at present a practicable pro question. position. We are finding it difficult to- spare Instructors and equipment even Shri Deshbandhu Gupta: A very for the ’^’errltorial Army and the good interpretation of democracy. National Cadet Corps and economy considerations require that the Army S hort S ervice S y st e m that we have got to-day should be *4798. Dr. M. M. Das: Will the Minis reduced further. Apart from this, the ter of Defence be pleased to state: building up of reserve of trained man power has no sipfnifloance unless we (a) whether Government contemplate ran build up at the same time resources ^ to introduce the “short service system” at the back to enable thip reserve in the Defence forces; and man-power to undertake defence in an (b) whether the ‘short service system’ emergency. Our first endeav(>ur hitf been given any trial before in the should, therefore, be to make India Indian Army? self-sufficient in regard to military equipment of various kinds rather than* The Deputy Minister of Defence to start a system of compulsory military (Major-General Hlmatsinhjl): (a) and service. (b). It is not quite clear what the hon. Member has in mind when he Mr. Speaker: I think further refers to the ‘Short Service System*. questions may be put off to some' In the Officer ranks the system of other occasion. We go to the next granting Short Service Commission for question. ^ limited periods has been in existence for a fairly long time. The Lower ranks B u r m a O il C o m p a n y are engaged ordinarily for a combined colour and reserve service of 15 years. *^799. Shri A. C. Guha: Will the In certain branches and under certain Minister of Natural Reaouroes a n ^ conditions, engagement for shorter Scieiitific Reaeareh be pleased to state: periods is also authorised. (a) If the Burma Oil Company has Dr. M. M. Das: In view of the fact any establishment at Manipur (Cachar- that this system of short term service Assam); has been adopted by many countries of the world, I beg to know what are (b) if the B.O.C. authorities have the advantages and disadvantages of transferred most of their useful ‘ the system and its implications, machinery to Patharla in East Pakis financial or otherwise, so far as our tan and have .stopped their mining country is concerned? operations; Major-General Himatslnhji: It is a (c) if so, what action have Govern question of national policy. I have ment taken in Tie matter; and anticipated this question and I have (d) the amount of royalties realised accordingly prepared a statement from the Manipur oil Helds during the which I would like to read with your financial years 1948-49. 1949-50 and permission 1950-.'^1? Oral Answers 9 JUNE 1951 Oral Answers filse The Minister of Natural Rrsourres SbrI Sri Prakasa: I hope that is so. and ScicntiAc Research (Shrl Sri Sir. Prakasa): (a) Manipur is a Part C State under a Chief ConnmlKsionor. It S ulphur has been ascertained from the Chief Commissioner, Manipur, that the M800. Shri A. C. Guha; Will the Burmah Oil Company has no establish Minister of Natural Resources and ment in Manipur. They have, how Scientific Research be pleased to state; ever, agents there for distribution of (a) if sulphur is available In ele petrol, kerosene oil and other by-pro- mental form in India; and ilurts. (b) if there are secondary sources (b) and (c). In 1949, Government of sulphur In India? permitted the Burmah Oil Company to export some of its machinery to The Minlfter of Natural Resource East Pakistan. The Geological Survey and Scientific Research (Shri SH of India and the Chief Commissioner, Prakasa): (a) Small quantities of ^anlpur, have no Information about bacterial deposits of sulphur have been the stopoage of mining operations in found in the Masulipatam Coast Assam by the Burmah Oil Company. Madras. We have so far no definite information of the existence of sulphur (d) Since no oil fields are being in the elemental form in the country. worked in Manipur, the question of realization of royalties does not arise. fb) There are deposits of iron pyrites, copper pyrites, gjrpsum and You will be pleased to note. Sir, baryte oc<"urring in different parts of that the hon Member in part (aV of India which may be looked upon as his question, has referred to Manipur secondary sources of sulphur in Cachar-Assam, and on that basis, the reply was drafted as I have read Shri A. C. Guha: May I know it out to the Hou.so. Later, it was dis whether the copper pyrites found In covered that the Burma Oil Comnany Dhalbhum is being utilised for the held n prospcctinL^ license for oil in extraction of sulphur? Masip\ir in Cachar-Assam. If the hon. Member was referring to Masl- Shri Sri Prakasa: I fear I could^ not pur. I may say that that license c atch the name of the place mentioned terminatod in 1947. As far as the by the hon. Member. If it is Bhajjal- Geolopirsl Survey of India is aware, pur, we have no information, the oil comoanv did not carry out any Shri A. C. Guha: It is not Bhagalpur work of imDnrtnnpp in this grea except but...... for some ceologicBl travcrpes. Mr. Speaker: It is bettor to go to the Shrl A, C, fiuha: Sir, It was a next question. mistake for Maslpur. Have Government taken any action Contract for Jeeps . for the extrpction of nil in ^ Pat.hiirla *4801. Shri Kamath: Will the Minis arep which bns tiow fallen in Indian ter of Defence be pleased to refer to territory according to the Bagge the answer to my starred question Award? No. 3504 aj?ked on. 25th April, 1951 and Shrl Sri Prakasa: This question of to state: Patharla is a constant headache (a) the full name, address and des because the dividing line between cription of the firm, and not merely its Pakistan and ourwnlvec: is not yet initials; Clear, either in the Radclifle or in the (b) whether it is a subsidiary firm, Bacge Award. But we are trying to if so, which is the principal; mal”e sure of the line and are taking ihe necessary steps in that behalf. (c) the capital assets and financial status of the firm; Shrl Cbaliha; Have the B.O.C. (d) its connection, if any, with authorities transferred their machinery Antlmistant Ltd. with whom the they had in Patharia over to Pakistan, earlier contract for jeeps had been as under the Bagge Award it fell into made; Pakistan? (e) whether any advance payment Shrl Sri Prakasa: I have no informa has been made to the Arm: and tion on the subiert. The fact is that (f) whether any jeeps have arrived that company have licenses for pro or are on their way? specting on either side: and so far as I am aware, thev are carrying out The Deputy Minister of Defence their work according to these licenses. (Major-Geneial Himatstnhji): (a) The Shrl ChaUha- Is it a fact that the name of the firm is S.C.K. (Agenc'cs) source of the petrol Is in Assam, i.€., Limited and its address is 3, St ^on the Indian side? James*s Place. London, S.W.L Hie 518 7 Ural Answers 9 JUNE 1951 V/ritten Answers 618» firm has recently informed our High Major-General Himatsinhji: Shr, that Commissioner in U.K. that the matter will be considered, I mean the Registrar of Companies has approved question of placing a copy of the con of the change of name now on request tract on the Table of the House. to *‘Sir James Marshal Cornwall and Shri Kamath: Does it contain a Partners Ltd.*' penalty clause and a clause for (b) We have no knowledge of the inspectl6n before shipment? firm being subsidiary to any other. Major-General Uimatsinhji: Yes, (c) The authorised capital of the Sir. Company is understood to be £25,000. Shri Kamath: Is there any variation The High Commissioner satisfied him in this contract from the standard self about the financial status and contracts of the Indian Stores Depart dependability of the firm. ment? (d) We are not aware of any jon- Major-General Hlmatsinhji: No, nection of this firm with Antimistant Sir. Ltd. Shri Kamath: The Finance Minister (e) No. blated some time back in answer to (f) No. Pandit Kunzru that the Auditor- General was dealing with this parti Shri Kamath: Has the Defence cular matter. Is his report on thg Ministry received a copy of the con subject going to be laid on the TaWi' tract which was signed on the 2nd of of the House? March with this firm and if so, may I know whether a copy of that contract The Minister of FUiance (gfcri G. D. will be placed on the Table of the Deshmukh): The question of Pandit House? Kunzru was about the audit report of the Auditor-General and I said that Major-General Hlmatsinhji: Sir, the audit report will be ready in due with the permission of the Defence course and will be placed before the Minister we may do so. House, and some reports have been Mr. Speaker: Does \he hon. Minister placed, according to article 151 of the agree? Constitution. The Minister of Defence (Sardar Shri Kamath: The Minister has not Baldev Singh): What is it? given the information as to what the initials stand for. I wanted ^ e full Mr. Speaker; About placing a copy name of the firm, Sir. What is ^he full of the contract of the 2nd March, IwSl name? on the Table of the House. Mr. Speaker: We need not go into Sardar Baldev Singh: 1 don't think those details now. so, Sir. If the hon. Member is The Question-hour is over. interested and wants to see the con tract. I am prepared to show it to him. WRITTEN ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Shri Kamath: In view of the fact that that contract provided for delivery to commence on the 2nd ol June, may : firr I know if any jeeps have arrived so far? f from any International Fund to pre wteT ft sent child mortality in India and what measures are being taken with ♦y c o ^ : ; WT the help of that fund; and (b) if so, the number of children who took benefit of these measures «PTf ’arvTT ^ Vf during the year 1950?] The Minister of State for RehabUita- 4ion (Shri A. P. Jain); (a) The Govern ment of India have not received any iI«T % aft ^ 5pqr monetary help from any International % STPT H t ?ntr Fund to prevent child mortality in India. But certain projects and 'jft ^ 5 % ifrrt advisory services such as free milk feeding schemes, anti-malaria, anti tuberculosis and anti-venereal diseases campaigns, maternity and child wel fare services, training centres and training of doctors and nurses abroad ftR i «rr ; have been started in this country with the aid and assistance of W.H.O. and the U.N.I.C.E.F. These programmes no doubt help in redvicmg mortality of children in India. (b) During the end of the year 1950 about one lakh of children in 18 ’T f f : different States of India were in receipt of a free drink of 8 oz. of re ( ^ ) i r f k ^ v f arrfssTift constituted skimmed milk every day. ^ ^ ^T«rr It is not possible to estimate the number of child beneficiaries under sff »Ft (ffTTpr »m ^ the other projects. T r a n s f e r of P h o to stat M ach in es ^ ^ 1^ i ; *4795. Shri Sldhva: Will the Minis (<1) JTftf ^ w r «T5 ter of Finance be pleased to state whether Government propose tc transfer the Photostat machines from the Administrative Intelligence Room ^ ; • to the Director of Archives as sug gested by the Estimates Committee (i) ^ !T | i ? and if not, why not? S h e ik h s and M o m in s of C h hota The Minister of Finance (Shri C. D. N a g p u r Deshmukh): Government ha\e decided to transfer the photostat machines to [*4m . Shri Oraon: WiU the Minister the Director of Archives. Action has of Home Affairs be pleased to state: already been Initiated wi^h a view to (a) whether Government are aware •elTecting the transfer. of the fact that those Muslims of Chhota Nagpur Division in Bihar who are known as Sheikhs and Momins and C ooch-B ehar F ir in g who are weavers by profession, are all Adibasis who had embraced Islam ♦4796. Shri Sldhva: Will the Minister during the Muslim rule; of Home Affairs be pleased to refer to his statemeftt that a Judicial enjuiry (b) if so, whether the Gk)vernment would be held regarding Cooch-Behar consider these Sheikhs and Momins of firing and state; Chhota Nagpur Division as Adibasis or (a) whether any tribunal has been not; . appointed for the purpose; and (c) if they are considered Adibasis. (b) if not, what are the reasons for whether these Sheikhs and Momins are given the same privileges by the Gov the delay? ernment as are being given to the The Minister of Home Affata (Shri other Adibasis; Bajagopalachari): (a) Mr. J^ftiw S. N. Guha Roy of the Calcutta High Court (d) if not, whether they are con has been appointed to hold a judicial templating to give them these privi ■ ^nQuiry into the Cooch-Behttr firing. leges or not; and (b) Does not arise. (e) if not, .why not?] ^191 Written Answers 9 J U N E 1951 Written Answers The Minister of Home Affairs (Shrl (d) A Minister travelling on duty Hajagopalachari): (a) Government is allowed to take any persons requir have no information. ed to accompany him for the purpose (b) to (e). I take it that what the of his visit. hon. Member has in mind is whether N a t io n a l A n t h e m these people should be treated as ♦4805. Shri P. Basi Reddl: Will tha Scheduled Tribes. They have been for Minister of Information and Broad long treated as just Muslims and not casting be pleased to state: as Scheduled Tribes. The question as to whether they should be given any (a) whether it is a fact that several special concession^ on the ground of representations have been made to being backward is quite • different Government urging the playing of thf matter and it is hopw the State National Anthem at the end of everj Government will duly consider it. day’s programme of the All India Radio; and 1 may add that if they desire to (b) if so, whether Government pro t:laim to be treated as trij?es, they may pose to introduce the National Anthem usefully address the Bihar Government into the daily programme of the All first who have to initiate any possible India Radio? change. The Minister of State for Transport F in a n c e C o m m is s io n and Railways (Shri Santhanam): (a) Some requests of this nature have *4803. Maulvi Wajed AU: Will the reached All India Radio. Minister.of Finance be pleased to state: (b) It is not proposed to introduce (a) when the proposed Finance the National Anthem into the daily Commission is going to be appointed programmes of All India Radio. It is and begin functioning; and intepded to be played only on special (b) the rules about the work of the occasions. Commission, if they are ready? L a w of C it iz e n s h ip The Minister of Finance (Shri C. D. M806. Shri G. S. Goha: Will the Deshmukh): (a) As soon as practicable. Minister of Home Affairs be pleased (b) The rules of procedure for its to state: working will be framed by the Com (a) whether a Bill on the law of mission after it has been constituted. citizenship is proposed to be brought before Parliament; and U se of C h a r te r e d P la n e s b y (b) if so, when? M in istib r s The Minister of Home Affairs (ShH *4S04. Shri Kamafth: Will the Minis Rajagopalachari): (a) Yes. ter of Finance be pleased to state: (b) The draft of the Bill is still (a) whether there are any rules under consideration. governing the use of special or chatter ed planes by Ministers, if so, what they are; (b) if not, what are the conditions or circumstances in which such use is • permitted; ymvT SWT ' (c) how many such planes were used ^ fi'TT ; by Ministers during 1948-49, 1949-90 and 1950-51, figures being given (I?) ^ W R f ^ W T separately for each Minister in each year; and XVf'S ^ ^ v( vtTOT (d) the persons, apart from officers and stafT, that a Minister is permitted to take with him on travel by such ^ fvrr planes? * The Minister of Finance (Shri C. D. (WT fif if Deshmnkh): (a) A copy of the current rules regulating the chartering of planfs by the hon. Ministers has been w nm w r ; placed on the Table of the House. l5ee Appendix XXVIII, annexure No. 64.] (b) Does not arise. vr «i»nf PpoT arrTiT (c) The Information is being collect ftPT ftPT wPrar % 7f# ed and will be placed on the Table of the House. 519 3 Written Answers 9 19 51 Written Answers 61 (?ft) (b) what is the total amount of such loans given so f^r? ^^T-T ^fsrar T«f These figures include import duty S c h ools nc D e lh i chargeable on gold bullion and gold 390. Shri Deshbandba GupU: Will sheets and plates which have under the Minister of Educatton be pleased gone no process of manufacture subse* to state: , . quent to rolling, assessable under item 61(3) and gold coin assessable under (a) the number of primary, lower item 62(2) of . the Indian Customs and higher secondary and high schools Tariff. recognued and unrecognised respec tively in the State of Delhi on 1st (b) The value of gold realised by May 1951; sale of confiscated gold is: (b) how many of them are run by 1948.- Rs. 0,34,435. local bodies, and how many by Gov 1949.—Rs. 10,09.134. ernment; • 1950.--Rs. 32,79^778. (c) the total amount of grant given 1951.-R s. 11,45,123. and expenses incurred on Government run schools during 1950-51; L and T e n u r e s y s t e m in Bah ad ara (d) the total number of students in the primary schools and Secondary 389. Pandit ‘ Munlshwar Dtttt and High Schools on 1st May 1951; Dpadhyay: (a) Will the Minister of and Home Affain be pleased to state what (e) how many of such schools are are the area, revenue and gross rental running two shifts? of the tract of land known as Sahadara Ilaqa which was added to Delhi State The MiniBter of State tm RehabiUU- Hon (Shri A. P. Jain): (a) (i) Recognis from U.P. in 1915? ' ed instituUons. (b) What is the law of land tenure (1) Primary Schools—550. applicable to Sahadara naqa aforesaid (2) Middle School*—76. at present? (3) H i| ^ Schools—30. (4) Higher Secondary Schools—36 (c) How does it differ from the law (ii) Unrecognised institutions are of land tenure in the rest of the State in many cases held in private houses. of Delhi? Government of India have no informa (d) Why not have a uniform law of tion regarding their number nor can land tenure in the whole of Delhi this number be ascertained without an State? ^ expenditure of time, moner and energy which would not be Justified by the The MinMer of Home Affairs (Shrl results. RaJagopaJachari): (a) The total area (b) By Ocv&mmerU By load Bodies of Shahdara Ilaqa is 30,38j) acres and its annual land revenue is Rs. 19,579. Primary 814 178 The gross rental of the tract is not Middle 27 14 available. However. the average High 14 annual cash rent is given below: Higher- Seoondary 2 Kind of land Annual rent per Bigha (r) (i) Grant given to aided schools— Kham. Rs. 23,97,200. (ii) Grant given to Local Bodies— Ohahi land (watered from wells) Bs. 1/4/- Rs. 8.93,270. Oanal irrigated land. R i. 5/-/- (iii) Grant given to" Specla! Sailab, land irrigated Schpols.—Rs. 72,100. by floods. Re. 7/ / (Iv) Other Grants.—Rs. 1,85,827. Barani land (dependant (v) Expenditure on Government on rain only). Re. I/-/* maintained Schools.—Rs. 28,25,573. (b) The Agra Tenancy Act, 1901 and (d) Number of students as on .Mlsf the U.P. Land Revenue Act, laOl. March. 1951. In Primary Schools—86,763. (c) The remaining area of the Delhi State is governed by the Punjab In Middle Schools—26,938. Tenancy Act. 1887, the Punjab I- 4ind In High and Higher Secondary— Revenue Act. 1887. and the Punjab 50,452. Tenants (Security of Tenure) Act, The enrolment figures for 1st May 19S0. IP51 are not readily available but can (d) The suggestion will be taken \ye collected and supplied to the up for consideration at the time of the Hon*ble Member, if he so desires. next settlement which is due slwrtly. (e) 88 Schools. 138 PSD Saturday, 9th June, 1951 ( PARLIAMENTARr DEBATES (Part n —Proceedings other than Questions and Answers) OFFICIAL REPORT VOLUME X. 1951 (31st March, 1951 to 20th April. 1951) Third Session of the PARLIAMENT OF INDIA 1960-51 (iv) Col.,.,.... WSDNESDAV. 6TH JUNE. 19IH-<:Ontd. Motion ra Conduct of Shri Mudgal. M.P. 10269-30J Mot ions re Delimitation of Constituencies Orders, 1951 10302-14, 10337 Indian Income-tax (Amendment) Bill- Introduced • 10314 Delhi and .-\jmer Rent Control Bill- Introduced. 10314 Ropresentation of tho Pt'lople (No.2) Bill- Di"cus:;ioll on motion to pass-Not coneludod 10314-37 TUUnfoDAY, 7TIl Jl:~E, 1951- L('I\\"(1 of .-\ ll~('n('e from tho HOUfO 10338 Bu:,illt'~" (.f the Heme. )(\338-42 rapt'"'' 1,\;<1 (Jil t be 1'abll"--- ~ot ilieHt i< II Ill:(!n ~r..t i( n ·fA (If Jlldic.H TnI'd)' Ad, 1!J:!4 1(342 ~I.)t i<,'11 rc lJ('limit tit i. n (.[ Cunlit it lIt'nein, Ordt'rl', 1USl l(I342-45. 10406-10. 10447-49 Plantali E~H'n t ii' I (; C( tis (1)((' lurnt i( n f.llI: H q: IIln tit 11 of 'fnx (11 t:l:lo 01' I'ul'd. n~ (1) BiJI --Intl'uit:ct'd •...... •.• IC34li-4tJ Hepr('fNltlltion of tho Peoplo (No.2) BiIl-l' al\fcd. us am(·ndell . 10346-48 R~jghl\t HHllladhi BiIl-Pai'H'd, nil nmended 10348--76 ~dJ(ldl1led ~\reas (AsI'irnilntiun of Lnwl<) llill-l'nHfctl 1037~80 Ht.'6oltlt ion re ('ont inuull('o for flll'tlwr OIlO yonr of pow(\rll of Po.rlinmont to nmke laws witla r('q'('d to (i) trndo and cumnJ(lrco within Stato; a.nd (ii) product ion, Hupply LInd dilitrihut ion of goods -Adopted •• 10380-406 Ht'~otllti<.n rc ruiHing of ('x port duty on doth-Adopted.. 1041C-39 Induetriul Di,put('H (Am('ndmellt nnd T<'mporary Provisions) BiIl-Di~cus. (!iUIl on motion to consider-Not concluded 10439-47 FRIDAY, 8TH Jl.·NE, 1951- Mot ion for Adjournment- Exclllllic·n of Hindi from the syllubus of LA.S •• 10460-62 Paper:; laid ~ n tho To.blo-- (i) Appropriation Accounts (Civil) 1948·49; (ii) Appropriation Accounts (Posts and Telegraphs) ]948.49 ...... lC463 Sto.t()ment showing progress mado re l'ccommclIda-ionll of Estimoto Commi- teo. • . • 10453 Eloction to Committoos- Committee on Estimates 10464-56 Standing Committee for the Ministry of Labour 10464-56 Standing Finance Committee • 1046'-55 Indian Council of Agricultural Research, • • 10456-56 Busineea of the House 1045~7 Motion ra Conduct ofShri Mudgal,lrL P. 1~7-85 Industrial Disputes (AmeIldmeot and Temporary Provieiema) BiJl.--P... ed, .. amended i;. • 10461-800 ~ion ... Delimitation of CoDItiiueociea Orden. 1961 1(\100--11 ( v ) Col ...... SATURDAY. 9TH JUNE. 1951- Papers laid on the Table - Commercial Appendix to the Appropriation Accounts (Civil) and Audit Report 10614 Statement in pursuance ofpromiae made on the 7th April 1951 1061' Agreement between India and Netherlands r4 Air Services. 10616 Eloction to CommitteE'S- EstimatE'S Committee; Standing Committees for the Ministries cf Labcur end Financo ; and Indian Council of Agricultural Resoarch •• 10614-16 Di~placcd I't\rsoll:l (Tt'mporary Relief from Indebtedness) BiIl-fntroduccd 10515 Motion 1"IS Dl,Jimitl\tion of C(lnRtituencies Orders. 1951 1051f-6U5 THE PARLIAMENTARY DEBATES (Part II-Proceedings other than Questions and Answers) OFFICIAL REPORT --..~----.------=------10515 Standing Finance Committee and in- dian Council of Agricultural Research, "{,tim/ny. 9th J'1I7C. 1951 cne nomination in the case of each of the first three Committees and two nominations in the case of the last '"err> :ec~i"ed. As the number of 1 h~ Iiottse n~eL Qt Half Past Eight Candidates is equal to the number at of the Clock. vacanr;,es in €:ach of these Comrwttees, I declare the following Members to be [iVIR. SPEAKER iit the C;wi;'] duly elected: QUESTIONS AND AL'fSWERS I. Committee on Zstin'ates- (See Part I) Shri R. Venkataraman. II. Standing Committee for the 0-30 A.M. jIinistr!J of Labcur- PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE Shri S. N. Das. CO:\·!:\iERCIAL ApPENDIX TO THE III. Standing Finance Committee- ApPRO?RIATION ACCOUNTS (CIVIL) AND AULlIT REPORT. Pandit Govind Malaviya. _ The Minister of FiD9.nce (Shri C. IV. Indian Councit of .4.gricuUural D. Deshmukh): I beg to lay on the Research- Table a copy of the Commercial Appen- 1. Shri G. A. Thimmappa Gowda. dix to the Appropriation Accounts (Civil) 1948·49 and the Audit Report 2. Thakur Bhanu Pratap Singh. 1950. [Placed in Library. See IV O. 1 (50)] STATEMENr IN PURSUANCE OF PROMISE DISPLACED PERSONS (TEMPORARY MADE ON THr;: 7TH APRIL. 1951 RELIEF FROM INDEBTEDNESS) The Deputy Minister of Food and BILL Agriculture (Shri Thirumala Rao): I 1'J..,! :\'IinistN' oi State for Rehabili- beg to lay on the table a statement ta dOil (Shri A. P . Jain): I beg to move containing replies to certain questionf fer leave [Q il1tl'oduce a Bill to l',ake in pursuance of an undertaking given ~ertain tCi1,porary provisioi~S for the by the hon. the Minister in course of re~:d of disp!2.ced persons from in- i1is n"')\"' tn t.h·~ deoate relating to the Demands for Grants under the d·~btedn2S5 ::·enclf:~J further leg:s!:1.tion Ministry of Food and Agriculture. rE:atL:~~ ~~~ .... r2to. lSee Appendix X)L,,{II.] That leave be granted to intro- ELECTION TO COMMITTEES duce a Bill to make certain tem- porary provisions for the relief (If ESTIMATES COMIVrITTEE; STANDING CoM- displaced persons from indebted- o I MITTEES FOR THE MINISTR:ES OF LABOliR ness pending further legislation re- AND FINANCE; AND INDIAN COUNCIL OF lating thereto. AGRICULTURAL RESEARCH. Mr. Speaker: I have to inform the The 1:10tion was adopted. House that upto the time fixed for re('civi!llt nominations for the Com- Shri A. P. Jain: Sir. I introduce mittee on Esti:u MOTIONS RE DELIMITATION OF Mr. Speaker: His amendment is CONSTITUENCIES ORDERS, going to be accepted in part. He. 1951-concld. may spea!c on the amendment moved Mi'. Speaker: We now take the De- by Dr. Ambedkar and he need not limitation Orders. move his amendment. So the only motions now before us Shri Shiv Charan Lal (uttar Pra- are the motions which the Law Minis- desh): Sir, if we go by the number ac- ter mentioned and I think they are cording to which the different States agreed and no argument will be are being put here, there are still a necessary excepting some explanation large number of States and the Mr. Jajware wants to give. I shall States whose turn will come at the dispose of that first. end will not have any time for dis- cussion and those orders will be Pilt Shl'i K. P. Sinha (Bihar): I wish to guillotine. Therefore I 3ugJest to withdraw my amendment No. 2 of that the time should be so distributed Supplementary List 1. that each State may get time accord- ing to their popUlation 'lnd strength. Dr. Ambedkar: I have no objection to that thOUgh I had accepted his MI'. Speaker: I think if table of amendment. precedence were to be prepared. then The amendment was, by leave, perhaps most of the time will be withdrawn. taken up in the pre[)araticn of the order itself. We will go as fast as :\11.'. Speaker: To save the time of we can and hon. Members will tear the House, I shall put through the in mind that there are people coming amendments which are accepted by after them, for whom time should be the Law :\,Iinister. As regards the reserved. Now: Vie will take up others, since they have been formal- nVltions in respect of Bihar. ly placed before the House I shall tell the House that the hon. Members BIHAR ORDER c,bnOerned de~ire to withdraw theIr '1'ne Minister of Law (Dr. Ambed- motions and seek the permission of ka,r): I am 'prepared to accept the the House to do so. following amendments: What about motion No. 3 on sup- ::>upplementary List 1 Amendment plementary List 1, in the name of Mr. No. 2 Parts 1 (ii) and (iii) and Part Bhagat? 5 of Shri I:us3:on of problems of. displaced persons, maps In bringing this motion before the accompany the order, it is a matter House the question that arose in my of regret that in the present case no min.j was: am I doing injustice to map is attached to do full justice to Bhagalpur, or am 1 doing injustice to the areas represented by the Order. Darbhanga, or to Purnea? Not at all. I have not got ::! 1l12P; had lone I 10520 Motions reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Constituencies OTdeTs, 1951 10321 [Shri P. G. Sen'] matters, quite a good sense of pro- would have shown how Purnea is portion about everything: how much being ill-treated by the formation of to go into the details, how much time the constituenc.Y Purnea-cum-Bhagal- to take in those details, etc. pur. I have already pointed out how the area of the ccnstituency Bhagal- So I now put this motion to the pur-CHnt-Purnea is contlg'UOllS as also House. tha.t ?f D~rbhanga-ctlnt-Bhagalpllr. Shri P. G. Sen: :\,Iay I submit to ThIs WIll be In the interest of the yeu, Sir, that this is the only House constituents of Bhagalpur as also of where onc can demand some justice Purnea and Darbhanga. As regards done? Darbhanga, people nny out forward various kinds of argUrl1ents. But Mr. Speaker: Ord2r, order. I may Jhanjharrw1', Lallk~ha and Phulparas tell the hon_ Member that the Hou~ 'are contiguous areas and can well be will certainly do justice, but to have connected with Bhagalpur without what one wants is not necessarily any difficulty. justice-though it may be so from Consequent upon this motion I one's own point of view, he has to have ta!;:en out from Purnea-cum leave it to the goud sense of other Santhal Pargana. Katihar (including peo[)le also who have no interest in Katihar municipality). ThIs has r:jr)ic;g i:ljustice to 8:1ycne. been taken out 2nd amaigam1ted with PUl'nea ;)o1't ion of Pur'nea-cum Dr. Ambedka .. : There is only one Bhagalpur constituency to :orm a p0int that I would like to mention in singular constituency. as Furnea West. connection with the motion made by If you throw a cursory glance ...... my friend, and it is this that the cons- tituency that he proposes will have Mr. S,\leaker: Order, order. I may a LOtal ,lUmber of electors of 4,43,524 just invite the attention of the hon. as against the maximum limit of Member to the fact that he need not .3,87,929_ That objection itself if go into all these details of local areas fatal to his proposal. and loeal geography. He will re- member that hon. Members of this Shri P. G. Sen: But it is a plural- House have been called upon to de- member constituency. cide upon these matters and practi- cally very few of them have any Dr. Ambedkar: So that is fatal to knowledge of local topography or his proposal. geography. He can therefore mention lUI'. Speaker: So I am going to put the m,lin points. If he gees into de- the motion of Shri P. G. Sen to vote. tails like that. the business will not (No. i in Supplementary List No. 2- come to an eni. In fact, the better B!har Order). The question is: position would ba'ie been. to my mind, that this I{ouse set up a con- [For text of the motion sp.e Amend- vention -that when any work of such ment No. 1 S. L. 2 printed in Appen- detailed character is left to an orga- dix XXXIII, annexure 1.] nised agency, though theoretically the House has the right to go into every Th~ motion was negatived. detail, for all oractical purposes we Mr. Sveakcr: Tl:en Mr. K. P. Sinha should interfere only where there is is 1I0t going to rr.ove his amendment. something very sei.-ious or gross. If I sup;::o~e lh~ aml'ndments that are we are to go into every detail, it going ~a b~ a.;cept€d z.re as follows:- means practico.lly all the time spent by the Election Commissioner and the Suppl. List No. l,-Amdt. Nv. 3, President's Order is wasted_ There moved by Shri B. R. Bhagat. has to be so:,~:'! reasonable limit up to which we could go. Therefore, the Suppl. List No. 2.-Amdt. No.3, part hon. Member need not ta!<:e the time :$ only as modifiec! by Amendmer.ts in of the House il1 discus~ing details. I Supp!ementary List No.6. said I would allow him four or five minutes-he has taken about 15 Suppl. List No. 5.-Amdts. No.1 & 2 minutes. of Sri Kshudiram Mahata. Shri P. G. Sen: I do not want to 10 A.M. speak. Cr, A.'1li:.edkar: Amendment No 3 Mr. Spea.ker: Very well, I do not part 3 in Supplementary List No. 2 think it is fair to allow any further is amended by Sri S. N. Das's time over this-he has had sufficient amendment in Supplementary List . time. Even then I would request the No.6, that is the amendment of Sri hon. Member to remember the agree- Jajware as modified by the amend- ment arrived at, and have, in these ment of Sri S. N. Das. 10622 Motions reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Constituencies Orden, 1951 101U Mr. Speaker: So, I am now putting XXXIII, annexure 1) for all the to the House the· three amendments. One of them, namely No.3 in S.L. No. entries in Cnlumns 2, 3 and 4 against 1 by Shri Bhagat has been further "A!amnagar" and "Naugachhia-cum- modified by th'~ Law Minister. The question is: Bihpm" .-;u8stitutc the following:- In amendment No. 3 in S.L. No. 1 by Shri Bhagat (printed in. Appendix· AhT.n!lgar Aillmnagar Police sta.tion of :lL .. :lhipura. sub-divi,;ion (of Bhagalpur District) and Challkidari union_q 3 and t of Bihpur polir:e ..,tation of Bha:,.;.ilpur Sadar sub-diviaion. Naugachl:lia-cum-13ihpur . ~augachhia police station anti Bihpur police :;tation (excluding chaukidari Unions 3 a.nd 4) of Bhl\g;ll- pllr Sadar :;ub-division_ The motion was adopted_ entries "Bihpur" and ":-lauga- Mr. Speaker: The question is: chhia" occurring in colu_mn 1, That the following modifications and all other entries occurring be made in the Delimitation of Parliamentary and Assembly Cons- against them in columns 2, 3 and stituencies (Bihar) Order, 1951, 4, the following be substituted, lail on the Table on the 16th namely:- May, 1951, namely:- L That at page 12, in Table B. -Assembly Constituencies, for the 1 2 3 4 Alamnagar _-\lamnagar Police station of :U~ipuril.. su?-division of Bhag,~lpur district . ,md C~aukldal"l umOl!.'; 3 and 4 of Bihpur police statIOn of Bh,~g;\ipur Sadar sub-division. Naugachhia-cum-Bihpur . ~aug The motion was adopted_ The question is: lUr. Speaker: Amendment No.l.in In Amendment No.1 in S.L. 5 by Shri S.L_ 5 by Shri Kshudiram Mahata ha~ Mahata for all the entries against been further modified by the han. the Tundi-cum-N:r3a in columns 2, 3, -l and Law Minister. 5. substitute the following:- 1 :! 3 4 5 Tundi-cum-Nirsa Tumti, Nirsa, Chirkunda polico station and Govind-:! 1 pur police station (excluding villages bearing thllna Nos. 1-71, 77-79. 31-89 a.nd 94) of Dhanbad sub-division. The motion was adopted. 1052·1 Motions reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 19:)1 Constituencies Orden, 1951 10121 Mr. Speaker: The question is: entries "Tundi" and "Nina" in That the following modifications column 1 and all the entries occur- be made in the Delimitation of ring against them in columns 2, 3 Parliamentary and Assembly Con- 4 and 5, substitute the follow- stituencies (Bihar) Order, 1951, ing:- laid on the Table on the 16th May, 1951, namely:- '1. At page 18, in Table B. - I\.ssembly Constituencies, for the 2 3(4 5 .-----_._----- Tmdi, )l'irH. Chirkundil Policeltation.i and Govin"lpur 2 .. Police Station (exeJuding villages bearing thana )l'os. 1-71, 77-79, SI-S9 and !H) of Dhanbad sub·division. The motion was adopted. ( General Seats) if q:r \Vf '1fT ~ U+rU~ ~\jrcn~: ~pn'1fu CJfT, m [m~~] (English t'ranslation of the abot'e speech) ~fl:rrr Cf1IT ~ [Shrl Ramraj Jajware"j have been reserved for a population area and o!l'~ se3t for the non-abori- of ten lac non-aborigines. whereas gines of Jarntara area. That is all ten seats have been reserved for a I have to say. population ,)f live lac aborigines. The Eledion Otficer woufd have accepted Mr. Speaker: The question is: this even new i [ rmly there was suffi- In motion No. 3 (3) in supplemen- cient and proper time to do so. But tary List No. 2 oriated in Appendix it is said thJ t they are heloless to do XXXIII, annexure 2- so clue to the nrder of t.be Principal (i) for the words the entry ';Deo- Executive. r have. therefore, no ghar-cum-~Tadhupur" intention to go into the details of that substi- matter. I only wish to say that jus- tute the word::; the entries tice hils not been done in this case "Deogilar-c,tlH-Madhupur" and and this matter should be considered ''Sarath''; again. and further that the seats (iii for the entry "Madhupur" should be allotted on the basis of in column and all the votel' population. At least ten seats entries occurring against it should be l'es.)rved for the non-abori- in columns 2. 3 and 4. the gines and eight for the aborigines. following be substituted. One seat should be allotted for Dumka namely:- :! Madhupur·cum-8amth Chaukidari beats 4, 5, 6, 8, and !) 'Jf ~ia"hupUl' '\l1l1 :! :\Iadhupur :\Itmicipality and Sarwan and :)arath police stations of Deoghar sub-division. ------.----.---- . -_.- - --- The motion was adopted. entries "Deoghar-cum-Madhupur" Mr. Speaker: The question is: '>.nd "Sc:rath' occurring in column I, and all other entries occurring That the following modifications against it in columns 2. 3 and 4. be made in the Delimitation of the folowing be substituted. Parliamentary and Assembly namely:- <;:onstituenc-ies (Bihar) Order, 1951 laid on the Table on the 16th May. 1.951, namely:- That at page 15, Table B.- "\::;s2n~bly Constituencies. for the :! :3 Deoghar Jasidih, Deoghar, (including Dec-ghar munieipality) and Mohanpur Poliee Station cf Dec;h .... ,nh- division. Madhupur-ctt1Il-Samth Chaukidal'i beats 4, 5, 6, 8 nnd 9 of )[adhupm' )Iunieipality ltnd Sarwan and Sarilth Policl) Station of Deoghar Sub-division . • The motion was adopted. "trictly consequential and not subs- tantial. Mr. Speaker: Now, I would like the House. at the end of the motions Dl'. Ambedkar: For that purpose I relating to each province, to pass a shall be moving a separate aIl11:!nd- sort of a motion to the effect that ment conferring upon you the power consequential amendments in respect to oermit the draftsman, in <:onsuIta- of be order relating to that particu- tion with you. to make c~rtain conse- lar state may be made :under ~e quential amendments. authority of the Speaker,· so that the draftsman and the Department will Mr. Speaker: So we shall do it by examine all these and set them one comprehensive motion at the end right. The amendments will be of the order!!. 10531) Motions reo Delimitrrtion of 9 JUNE 1951 Constituencies Order" 1951 1003)" As regards the other motions I take MI'. Speaker: The nam~ is there it that han. Members who haw and the motion has already been moved them '.'.'iIl have the leave of i11ade. Nothing further has to be thp. House to ',dthdraw them, (h);e in respect of it now except the ·"(Jti1!~. Let him not worry about The amendments were, by Ip.av,~. his name. We will see that it is pro- withdrawn. perl~' !lUt in. S!tri r{umbhar: There is another one excluding Kagal Taluk. • BOMBAY ORDER Or. Ambedkar: Sir. those are chang-· Dr. A.rnbcdkat·: Sir, I am prepared ~·'.'·:1:(;: could be done by the drafts- to a'>:'ept the follo\/illg amendments: 1,!c1fl C):: your authority. Supplementary Lis! No. 1 Amend, Mi.'. Speaker:'If they are C'cnse- ments No. 1 to B of ~;Iri Shankar Rao quential amendments, If we accept Deo and others. th~ substance th-::y will be made. .- They are pureiy con:sequential Shri Bhatt rose- a111e!ldmellts. Dr. ,I\mbedk:u: My friend, I know. List No.2: Amendment No.2 of Shri Sir. is particular about the men- Nijalingappa and Shri Munav:llli; sub- tioning of 'Santa Cruz' and so on. I ject to the modification that in the have teld him that those amendments entry against South Satara for "Item will be made on your authority by (15)" the words "Item (57)" be substi- ihe Jraftsman under the resolution I tuted. am proposing at the end .. Then I propose to accept: Mr. Speaker: As regards the d~., 1:, List No.3. amendment No.3. tails of r.'e!1t:cning Santa Cruz or lhlS pans (1) and (2) by Shri Deogirikar road C1' excluding Kagalor bringing and Shri Xumbhar. it in. IE: all the proposals by the hon. '{Ember.; be :nade to the draftsman Ir: i_L1 ~~'). 0. amendme:lls Nos. 1 ,:nd ;et them discuss with him. He and 2. suo;-?ct to the modif.cation • ·.vii! '::Jn2ider them and. if necessary. thd~ agains~' ,j;e t'n1 ry Kolhapur-cllm- I will pass orders. Sat,lra the word:> "The whole" at the beginning of t.he entry in column 2 Dr. Ambedkar: That ;s what I pro- are to be omitted. pose !') ask. In L;st No. 7. aJ~lendment No, 2. par! 2. by ~hri Hiny and Shri Deo-' girikar. ~T~: ~ a1~ ~~ T,';en in List No. 3 I propose to !lfT f-1i !fT rn+it if ~ ~ ~ 3fT'1 2 wilhdra'.': amendments Nos. 1. and ~ Q::tllf Q1 Mr. Speaker: This difficulty arises. native states which have been merg- because some of the Members are not ed with the distri<,:ts have not been present from time to time and there- given proper justice in this delimita- fore they miss U,e whole thing. Is tion. This should be rectified. there any other Member wishing to move any other amendment? Shl'i Kanayalal Desai: May I sa..... a Shri Hiray (Bombay): Yes, Sir. few v/ords in regard to the motion moved by Shri Shankarrao Deo? I do not rise to oppose the amendment Mr. Speaker; In addition to what moved by my friend Shri Shankarrao the Law Minister is accepting? Deo. but lowe it to myself and to Shri Hiray: Yes. the House to S Mr. Deputy-Speaker: I shall . note as are specified in List A) ot them down. M::>rsi Taluk oC Amravati district.,r 2. In amendment No. 4 of list No. 2 (Madhya Pradesh Order)- Dl·. Dc:;hmukh: I beg to move: (a) against the ent.ry "Darwha" for the existing entry In At page 3, Tabl~ A,-Parlia- column 2 substitute the mentary constituencies (Madhya following: Pradesh Order) agair.st the entry "B.<.tul". [or tll~ werds "Pusla "Dal'wha and Ladkhed RI.Cs. and .hrud R.LC:~. of Morsi Taluk and Ner R.I.C. (excluding of Amravati district" in column villages in List L)"; 2, substitute the following: (b) after the entry 'Darwha' in column 1 and all the entries occurring against it in columns "Pusla R.l.C. a..:,d Jarud R.LC. 2. a and 4. insert the (excluding such cf the village,; following entry;- ~ ______P ___ • ___P ___ '_"""!"" 0- _--, _ .... _ ._. __ • ____ -,p_. ______ Knb'11I, . Bi\IJlIlg,".lJl ·'.nd Kalamb R.T. C". rl:._' ·.'ilhg.. " ·)f ~.:r R.Ll·. ill Li~t Land th" "ill,\g.. ~ ·)f ',,·... ot'nal R.I.!.'. in Lid R. - Mr. Deputy-Speaker: Where is Dar· All these amendments ill 'vhleh I had wha in amendment No.4? given notice had been unanimously supporte~ by all the ;VIembers in this There is no Betul in the amend- House from Madhya Pradesh and ment. had been ~up,orted by a large volume of public opinion in Madhya Pradesh. Dr. Dcshmukh: It is in the main But as they happened to go contrary order: Page 3 of the President's to the principle underlying the Pre- Order. The first entry on that page is sidential Order, the hon. Dr. Ambed- Betu!. That has to be replaced by kar has founet himself unable to this entry. accept the:;e amendments. Accordinl; !\i~·. Deputy-E;~'cakel'; _-\n-.' .:;tbe,· to my interpretation, Sir. my amend- amer.dmcnt"? ments -s0u~d ha';e been in the best in::::12s::,; of the Scheduled Castes and Shl-i. Kishorimohan Tripathi: :VIy ScheJ'I:ei Tribes themselves. It was amendmen~s are. Nos. :3 and a in List in com:J~e,e agreement with the re· 1 an':! amendment. No. ;. in list 3. presenL1'i'i€S of the Sch",duled Castes a!;d ::> ;:~~i,:Ld Tribes themseh'es in Then. I h:!ve a cop-sequential this HcU!;~ from :\fadhya Pradesh that amer!c1ment. \'lith ref~rence to amend- I tablerl these motions. The principle men t No. : n list :3. as has been indi- that h.~; b:~:;'! accel)ted in the Presi- ca, :':1 by Dr. Ambedil:ar. I beg to dent hi Ord ?r. l1ainely that every mv,'e: singl~ d:stric: in a Sta~e should be im'ariably and ri;;:dly represe:1ted by With : <;(erefl.ce to amendment Oti·~· :'Oc:~cduled Caste ;VIember at least ~.;;). 2 v _ist 3, (:\IJ..Jlr·:l Fl'1(~esh has. undel' pecuEar ·:ircumstances, C""il'r) '1· nCl'Yo> 1 T'1b' e \- ri-=':rimentaliy reacted 01. sc,me of {he Pa~iiame;tary:>~ Co~stitu<:,!;cies, d~stricts in ":\.Iadhva Pradesh. namely. against ~he entry "Durg" for the Surguja. Bastar. Khand\.... a. a!1d Rai- words "Chhuikar.dan Tehsil" subs- gari1. I ha'j proposed to shirt these titut"! ~he words "K!1<'maria Scheduled Castes seats to areas ()i Te11sil ~xcludi:H! P. C. No. 8 of r.:g!;e,· c:;,;centration as it had been Kh:lmari:>. R.I.C.". r~('c.m.-!:e'1ded by the Parliamentary Advisory Committee. With respect T:'.is is p\lrely conseqnential. to mv 3l'.iendmer.ts to Parliamentary cor.;;tltuc!ides. I !:ad propo';cd that With r?fe~'ence to such other the ,.. ;~trict of Dur:,t and Rai9ur need amcndm<:nt'l of which I had given not b~ vivisect~d. notice and \\i:1ich have not been ac- cept.;d, I have iust to place on record !\Jlo. Dc!)u~y-Speaker: Is there any my complete disagreement with their purpc)se in this, except to ct'cate non-acceptance. discontent amoucg the people? 10538 Motions reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 COnltitumcie. Onteri.. Int1.... ' SII1'1 'Kt~ltorlmoban ·Tripathl: I wish ~ mIT 'fT ~ 'fit ~RRe (Cabinet) to place on record my protest. ;it 1Jlf 'IFf ~ lfAilfq ~f.:r ;l m Mr, Deputy-Speaker: It may create discontent among the people there. f~ ~ I "'{{f ~ ~ ~~ if; qitl""~" Shri Kishorimohan Tripathi: I am ~ "fiT w:r :;:;--: ;q; 3InT Mr. Deputy-Speaker: To this extent "Pusla R.Le. and Jarud 8.Le. the President's Order' stands modified. (excluding such of the villap'sas Dr. Deshmukh: I have to move are specified in List A) of Morai my amendments. Taluk of Amravati district". Mr. D~puty-Speaker: Yes. That is The motion was adopted. with reference to amendment No. 1 In amendment No.1 part 5 of ill Li"t No.2. list No. 2 (pl'inted in Appendix XXXIII, annexure No. 3)- 01'. .Ambedkar: There are amend- ments to his amendments Nos. 1 to;; of (a) against the entry "Darwba" List 2. for the existing entry in column 2 substitute the )\-11'. Deputy-Speaker: The question ,oHowing' is; "Darwha and Ladkher aI.es. At page 3, Table A.-Parlia- and Ner R.LC. (excluding mentary Constituenci~s, (Madhya villages in List L)"; Pradesh Oi'der) against the entry (0) after the entry "Darwha" In "Betul". for the words "Pusla t'olumn 1 and all the entries and Jarud R.LCs. of Morsi Taluk 'occurring against it in IIi Amravati district" in column columns 2, 3 and 4 the follow- 2. st!bstitu te the following: ing entry be inserted:------3 4, is ------Kalsmb. Bllbulgaon '\nd I{\amb R.I. Ca. the villao;rc.: of N",r -1 R.LC. Li,·:t Land the villages of Yeotmal R.Le. ia Li~t E. The motion was adopted. entries unckr the heading "Yeotmal District" in column 1, and all the 1\fr. Deputy-Speaker: The question is; entries against them in colurr.ns 2, 3 and 4 the fol!owing be substituted. 5. That at page 13, in Table B.- namely:- Assembly CQll"tituencies, for all the 1 3 Pu:>ad Pu~il.Cl talnk e'Xcludirg villl1gti' in Lii-t "J" . Dar",);... Darwha. and Lndkh€d R.I.G.·, a.nd Ner RI.C. (~X. dueling ,-ilIages in List L). Kalmnb. Babulgaon <~nd Kal<'.. mb R.I.C:;. the villc.,;c.> of Ner 1 RLL'. in List Laud the village:; of Y20tmal RJ.C. in LiH R. . Yeotmnl Yeotmal R.LC. excluding villages in List" R" and 1 il'clud:ng villages in L:sts " K" <'Jld .. ~I". \YacUlona \\'"dLOlH\ l~.I.C. of Kelapur taluq ; Wadgaon RJ.C. 1 (lxcluding villages in List" M" and RUD~ F .I.C. excluding " illages in List "~" of Kelapllr T<~· luq. Pandha!'!,ilvaua Pandha.rkavadd. and Ghatanji tOWlIod; Palldh.uk<\yada 1 R.LC. excluding villages in Li"t .. P" hat iuclun·- irg villl1ges in List" N" and Ghoti R.I.C. of Kela- plh' t&luq. Marega.on lI.\reg,\on and Sakra R.I.C~. of \'iani taluq aud village,; in List "P". Wani ard Velambai RI.Cs. of \Yaw taluq • ". 1 Wani. Dijiira;; • D,gras R.I.C. of Darwha taluq ; Arr.j R.r.C'. eltchi· 1 ding vill&g,\S ill Li:;t "K" and including \·illl\g".j in Li~t U J''. ------.--~----.-----.-- The motion was adopted. toOlS" Mottons reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Constituencies Orders, 1951 Jt)14-$ .Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question Mr. Deputy-Spe-aker: To this extent is: the President's Order stands modified. Leave may be granted to all the Mem- [For text of the motions see Amend- bers to withdraw their amendments. Jnent Nos. 1 to 3 in I:.ist No.2 printed All the other amendments moved by in Appendix XXXIII, annexure No.2:] other hon. Members were. by leave The motion was adopted. w)·:hdrawn. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question is: Mr. De1.)JJty-Sp~aker: The ::\faihya Prade2D Oi:der i:; r;"er. [For text pf the motions see Amend- ments Nos. Band 8 in List 1 printed 111.. Ambedf(ar: Th('~~ zre rJt!ier in Appendix XXXIII, annexure No. 3:1 ;~';blds wIn are l);0$sing me ~hat U:e:. matt':! .. may '::,k take_1 up fir~t. The motion was adopted. that :5 -Ne:st Bed;a: "ad :1:yderabai. !\fl'. D~ruty-Speaker: To the extent of these amendments the President's M,'. DP.;o'11;y-Srw:lkcl': I 31':1 takIng Order stands modified. The question 11,> Madras. is: At page 1. Table A.-Parlia- mentary Constituencies (lVfadhya .Pradesh Order) against the entry Dr. Ambedkar: With regilT6 T" the 'Durg' for the words "Chhuikadan :'Ia0.ras Order, I ar.1 pre;:lal":d to Tehsil" substitute the words :J(.' - ~~)~ th':? fCl!,~·.v!ng 3.rr~e:!d:r~E:~~3:- "({hamaria Tehsil excluding P.C. No. 8 of Khamaria R.C.!." Lig( 'io. 4. .-\J'nendrr.e'1t No. ,. 00rt ;~. seco::ct alternative. and The motion was adopted. ~3,·t 4. of Silri Kaia Venkatarao. MI'. Deputy-Speaker: The question .-\mcn.d mC!ll t 1';0. .:.. Darts 1 and is: 2. of :;hri i(bav3 Rao. At page 1, in Table A.-Parlia- mentary Constituencies, against Lis: No.6. Amendment :No. 1. the entry "B81aghat" for the word Parts 1 and 2. of Shri Sanjivaya. "Khamaria" in column 2. the .::ubl;'ct to ~he recast of 'part 2 as words "Chhinkhadan Tehsil and follows: p.e. No. 8 of Khamaria R.I.C. Khamaria Tehsil" be substituted. '~T'li a~ f.)r all tl~ ~ ~ntr:_~s a~ainst '2.' ,':;':'e" i!1 c01ullIP3 3. 3. 4 and 5 The motion was adopted. the following be substituted: ------._------.~----- EIGdc ErlJdn t.'::llk, BbllVcl.Jli t.1.1ak. D:l;";-"''':·.l."ll '>"l::k r ·s(:! ... ~\.!:u;.r ~uch of tho:" -·tiiLl2'."· rJ: i.~, ..'l-d :~,\;:'.. ·F·;~·i~:.~ ~~;~,r-:l Amendment No.2, part 1, ill List List NJ. 11. Amendment N->. 2, No.6. . parts 1 to 3, by Shri Kodanda· List No.7. Amendment No. 3 parts 1 and 2, of Shri Kala Venkata rama Reddy and others. Bao. lO:t46 Motions reo Delimitation oj 9 JUNE 1931 COllstitllencies Orderl. 19S1 14lltt List No.. 12. Amehdments No:;. 1Iinister of Law a:l fol1ow.:- to 13, subject to amendment That tor all the entries agaiolt No. 6 being modified by hon. "Tiruppur" in columns 2, 3. 4 and 5 the following be substituted:- .,., 'riJ'lIpP"r The Kollogdl, (~""i'~lll'&'ipalJl,yilom Bnd Tiruppur tal· uk.e and ::Ianl" ,\od AVl\llashi firus of .\\-al148hi taluk (excludil\~ the Kugahlr flrk" Bod ' I beg to move: 11 ..-\.M. Sir. I want to move all the amend- (i) At page .. in Table A.-ParHa- ments in List No. 10. They are on~ :nentary Constituencies, against the a ·.~orrigenda. .. ntry "Dharmapuri" for the words "and Edappadi firka of Tiruchengoda Sbri A. Josepb (:\Iadras) : I move taluk of Salem District" substitute my amendment No. 1 on List :.ro. 7. the words "and Edappadi firka and I also want to mo\"e amendment such of the Villages of Sankagiri tirka No. 2 on the same list. of Tiruchengode taluk of Salem Dis· trict as are specified in item 18A of ~r. Depu&Y-S~aker: They are taken the Appendix'. as moved. Shri'\. Joseph: I want to read (ii) At page 4, in Table A.-Parlia- some portions from the Report of mentary Constituencies. against the the ~farlras Delimitation Committee. entry "Tiruchengoda" for the words "We also had the benefit of hear- "(excluding Edappadi firk~ of Tiru- ing the debate in the State Legis- chengoda taluk)" substitute the words lature on the Go,-ernment's pro- .. (excluding Edappadi tirka and such posals. of the villages of Sankagiri flrka of Tiruchengode taluk as are specified in (1) Bvril before us and in the Item 18A of the Appendix)": c!ebate in the State Legislative Assembly it was UrJred that to (iii) At page 11 in Table B.-Assem- oro\'ide adequate repreRntation bly Constituencies, against the entry for all shades of political and "Tiruchengode". for th.e entry in other opinion. there must be a ·:olumn 2, substitute the followinl: good number of plural-member constituencies created in each district. and for each Legislature, "Tiruchengode taluk (excluding in addition to the plural-member Edappadi. firka and such of the constituencies carved out to proa villages of Sankagiri ftrka and of the \'ide for the reservation of seats Tiruchengode ftrka as are specified for the Scheduled Castes and in items (18A) and (16) respectively Scheduled Tribes. We discussed of the Appendix)". this proposal at length and came to the conclusion that, as even the reser"ation for Harijans and (Iv) At page 11 in Table B.-Assem- Scheduled Tribes is expected to bly Constituencies, against the entry disappear at the end of 10 years, "Edappadi", for the entry in column 50 that there may be no compart- :!. SUbstitute the followinl: mental reservation, It was inadvi- sable to bring in by the back-door, "'Edappadi' firka and such of the electorates which would realJ7 villages ofSllnkagu.i firka· ot Tiru- function on a communal or other chengode taluk as are specified in narrow basis. The onl,y reason uri- item (l8A) of the Appendix and ed for such reservation is to make the Mettur and Nangavalli flrkas provision for minorities, particu- of Amalut' taluk". . larly. religious miDoritie$." :257 PSD 10348 Motfon. reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Con.tituencie. Order" 1951 l~ rShri A. Josepb] Not only the minority communities. but prominent Hindu Legislators of Mr. Deputy-Speaker: Were similar Madras said in the State Legislature plural member constituencies created that Dlural-member constituencies in the U.P.? without reservation should be provid- ed for the minorities. It was not the Dr. ADlbedkar: No, Sir. Nowhere has· intention of those people to bring the an exception been made. religious minorities by the back- door put they want to bring weaker Prof. Raqa (Madras): I wish to re- section of the community. There is cord my dissent to the amendments a provision in the Constitution with that my hon. friend the Law Minister regard to affording facilities for the has just now moved to the order plac- minorities and weak~r section of the ed before us by the President, so far Community tor their uplift. Not only as they concern the Andhra districts. Christians and Muslims but even I do not wish to say anything more Hindus urged the Government to on this occasion, because it is useless provide plural-member constituencies so far as the purpose of getting the~e with distributive voting so that they altered is concerped. I do wish to say may come in the legislatures of States that at the earliest opportunity the and the Parliament. Tqere was a Election Commission. the President provision in the Constitution to bring and Parliament should try their members to the Upper Chamber of best to look into the matter and see States and to the Council of State whether some change could not be through the State Assemblies. Is it effected. not a backdoor election? Yes. If that is a backdoor election, it is clear I wish particularly to refer to two that the report (Delimitation Report of constituencies, one in Nellore and the Madras) itself ignores the Constitution. other in Anantapur. In the constitu- In the interest of the minorities and of encies that are now sought to be creat- the Constitution I appeal to the House ed it would be found, I ani assured. to realise the conditions of the mino- that the Harijans are not as numerous rities and show sympathy towards as they are in the other constituencies them. In Madras there are 25 lakhs which were provided for in the Presi- of Christians. I am not speaking dent's order. While I was co-operat· from a religious or communal point of ing with you, Sir. on the Delimitation view. As the hon. Law Minister arid Committee I understood that there Labour Minister know most of the were certain definite instructions Christians come from the dopn- given by the President, that the Hari- trodden masses of the people. They jan constituencies should be limited are in a helpless position. I appeal to those areas where their number is to the House to postpone the Madras the largest. order to the first we~k of the next session, so that they may provide I am rather afraid that this prin- plural-member constituencies. I know ciple has been departed from in order that many Harijan Members are laugh- to satisfy certain interest.i or certain ing at me. They will realise the considerations which are not germane \'onsequences it it befell to their lot. to the interests of the Harijans for We Christians have fought for the free- wh:>m these rlouble constituencies are dom of the country. We took part 10 being created. the 1942 struggle when all our leaders wele put in jail. I have guided my Shri A. Josepb: There is my atnend- people in their participation in the ment. Sir. non-co'operation movement. Because of that service I have been brought into. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: I bave noted this House. But it is not for my it down as having been moved. I education, nor for my social position have already given him an opportunity nor any other qualifications of mine. to speak-I am not giving another In the interest of the organisation to opportunity. I shall put both his which I belong and in the interest of amendments to vote. the Government I appeal to the House to provide plural member constituen- Sbrl Kala VeUatarao (Madras): I cies with distributive voting witqout·· am surprised that my hon. friend, Sri reservation. If the Law Minister is Ranga has thought it fit to say those not in a position to agree then ~ lew words on the amendments accept- oppose his motion and I would .aslt ed by the Law Minister. Perhaps my you tl' record· my disaf(reement with friend has forgotten that both the the proposal for single member ehaoges referred by bimself were the constituencies without giving any faci- original thinp to which Mr. ltanIa lities for the mlnoritlea. himself was a party .. in the Madras Dr. Ambedkar: I cannot accept the Delimitation Committee of which H amendment.. was a member. I wonder how he hn 1(16M Motf6n, reo Delimlta~lon of 9 JUNE 1951 CoRltUuencfe. 0nJen, 1"1 ._ brought in new arguments to oppose tance in what be has stated about tbe a thing ~hich he has himself support- amendments accepted by the hon. Law ed earlier. The changes made in the :\1inister. . President's order were based upon a new rule which the Election Commis- Mr. Deputy-Speaker: I will DOW sioner brought into vogue, namely tirst put the amendments accepted by that there should be a concentration :he hon. Law Minister and then' take of Harijans in any particular consti- up the others. tuency so as to merit the location ot a Harijan seat in that area. The question is: Prof. Raaga: Yes. lFor text of the motion He the ,-",cond alternative in part 3 of ;unend- Sbri Kala Venkatarao: Now Mr. :nent No.1 in List No.4 as printed in Ranga is subscribing to the new rule: Appendix XXXIII, annexure' 3:] I am very glad. We ourselves have subscribed to it in the case of about The motion was adopted. fifty constituencies in the State of Madras. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: To this extent The amendments now accepted by the President's Order stands modified. the hon. Minister have individual The question is: merits. Mr. Ranga has named two Constituencies. In the case of Anant- [For text of the motion see pur, Mr. Ranga perhaps does not reo ;;:arts 1 and 2 in amendment No. 2 of member that in the last elections in List No. 4 as printed in Appendix 1946 Mr. ·Rayappa belonging to the Scheduled Caste was elected from a XXXIII, annexure 3.] general seat from the Gutti constitu- ency. That shows the intluence of the The motion was adopted. Scheduled Castes in that constituency and removing that seat and placing Mr. Deputy-Speaker: To this ~ot it elsewhere shows that some injus- the President's Order stands moditled. tice is being done to the Scheduled Then I will put amendment No. :I in Castes there. Therefore the altera- List No.6, parts 1 and .2. as recast. tion was suggested. Even according I will put part 1 tlrst ~hlC~ has not to the alteration the difference of . been recast. The questIOn 18: concentrated Hariian population involved is only '2 per cent. and Mr. [For text of the motion s,ee Ranga cannot seriously object to it part 1 in amendment NQ. 1 of ~ under these circumstances. No.6 as printed in Appendix XXXIII,. annexure 3.] Regarding Nellore DistrJct, the hon. Law Minister was impressed because The motion was adopted. it was found that the two Harijan seats found in the Order, namely in Mr. Deputy-Speakel': To this ~tent Nellore and Gudur taluks, are adjacent the President's Order stands modified. to each other and ap area running Now I will put part 2 of amendment nearly 120 miles north of Nellore has No. 1 of List No. 6 as recast. The been left without any Harijan seat. question is: The present alteration was the one originally recommended by the Mad· In part ;! of ~ndm;ent No. 1 ras Delimitation Committee, including ?f Mr. Ranga, and the hon. Law Minister List No.6 (as printed IDb tiAtuPtepen~ has now accepted what he recommend- XXXIII, annexure 3) su s '-Ua ed earlier. Therefore, there is no subs- following: ------~- 1 ------1 .• Erode Erode taluk, Bhavaoi taluk. Dhllol':ruram !t.': [exoluding suoh of the villages Kunci: Firka ~Q e.re specified in item No. ,19) of ~~!!.. pendix] and KugaIur Firka and such of t.bot VI_- of GobiohettipaIayam Firka of Gobichetti~a:r: teJuk of Co~Wore district as are specl taluk item No. (18) of the APpendix;.andt~F'-'- of Kattalai. Kulithalai aDd PaIlJapavl _a KulithaJai taluk of Tiruohirapalli district·, The motion was adopt~, MOtlO~l' reo De/im/t(lUOIl of 9 JUNE 1!J5L COIl,t/r!umci~$ Oldus. 1951 I~ Mr. Deputy-Speaker: To this extem The question i3: the Presldent',;; Order stands modified.. (For text ot the motion lee The question is: . List No). 10. mu\'ec! by Dr. AmbEdkar as printed in Appendix XXXIII. anne- (Fol' text of the motion se~ xure 3.] amendment No. 2 of Ust No. d, stand·- ing in the name of Shri R. The moti.)O was ad.)pted. Subrarnaniam and others as printed in Appendix XXXiII. annexure 3:] llr. Deputy-Speaker: The Presi- dent's Order 3tand; modified to the • The motion was adopted. (xtent f)f thl,; amendment . The question i5: Mr. Depu&y-Speaker: The Presi- dent's Order stands modified to the rFol' text ot the motion lee e.'Ctellt of this amendment. oarts 1 to 3 of amendment :'i,). 2 .)l List No. 11 a; orinted in· Apgen·ih: The question is: . XXXIII. annexure 3.1 adop~ed. LFor text of the motioll s~", The motion was amendment No. a (parts 1 aed 2) of. llr. Deputy-Speaker: The Pre5id~nt's List No. 7 standing in the name Ot O"rler stands modirled to the extent of Shri Kala Venkatarao and others as this amendl1lt'nt. The que;;tion L,: printed in Appendix XXXIII, annexure :q [For amendment No. 6 in Li~t No. 12 as printed in Appendix. ~IU, The motion was adopted. anneXUJ:e 3] SUbstitute the follOWIng: Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The PTe,;i- That for ai: the :!ntries against dent's Order stand,;; modified tOJ titE "Tiruppur" In 'Columns 1, 2. 3, -\ extent of this amendment. and 5. the foi!.)wing be 5ub3tituteoi: -----.--.----__ ._. __ ._____ ._--t-_ ._------.. ------Ti l'llllpur The ('{Illegal, Gobi,'h"ttipaI8~-am "nd Tiruppur taluks and Sevur and .:\.Y8llashi firk,;s of ..\\-ana· ,;ohi tatnk [excluding ~he Kugalur 6rka and "II.lh of the villages of Gobichettipalayam lirka (of 'he Gobichettipalayam taluk as are specified in ite:u Xo. (IS) of the Appendix and the Varapatti firo of Tirllppur tatnk] of t-he Coimbatore District. The motion was adopted. of Tiruchengode taluk III Salem Dis- Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question is: trict as are snecifted in item 18A of the Appendlz.· (For text of the motions see amend- ments Nos. 1 to 5 and 7 to 13 of List (ii) At page 4 in TaQle A.-Parlia.- No. 12 as printed in Appendix XXXIII. mentary Constituencies, against the annexure 3.] entry "Tiruchengode taluk" for the words "(excluding Edappadi ftrka of The motions were adopted. Tiruchengode taluk)" substitute the words "(ex('luding Edappadi ftrka and Mr. Depub"-Speaker: The Presi- such of the villages of Sankaciri flrka dent's Order stands modifted to the of Tiruchengode taluk as are ~ed extent of these amendments. T~ in item 18A of the Appendix). question is: (i) At page 4 in Table A.-Parlia- (iii) At page 11 in Table a.- mentary Constituencies, against ,the Assembly Constituencies, against. the entry "Dharmapuri" for the words entrY "TfruchenlCode", for the ento' fa "and Edappadi ftrka· of TfruchenJrOde column 2, substitute the followinl: taluk of Salem District" substftute the words "and Edappadi ftrka and "Tirucbencoc:te taluk [excluding such of the villages of SQDkaglrl ftrka Edappadl ftrka and such of tile }053' Motions reo Delimitatiolt of 9 JUNE 1951 Coltltilllellciel Order., '1951 loai vjJJages' of Sankagiri !irka and ot Mr. Ik'puty-S~aker: Now I wW. the Tiruchengode firka as are :ake up amendment No. 1 (parts 1 specifielJ in items (l8A) and (16) and 2) and amendment No. 2 (parts respecth'ely ot the Appendix]". 1-8) in supplementary List ND. 1. (h') At page II in Table B,- .\8 Hon. Member: There is a modi- Assembly Constituentie", against the :ication to it. entry "Edappadi", for the entry in Mr. Deputy-Speaker: Then I will column 2. substitute the following: put the modification first, that is :,mendments 1 to 4 in supplementary "Edappadi tirka and such of the List NO.5. They relate to modifica- "illages of Sankagiri !irka of Tiru- ,ions to supplementary List No. 1. i'hcngode taluk as are specified in i1 em (18A i of the Appedix and Shri Himatsingka (West Bengal): In the :Uettur and Nangavalli firkas :,mendment No, -l in supplementary of Om,.lnr !dlnk". List No. 5 mo\'ed by Shri Jhunjhun- ·,'.'ala. in sub-c'lause (iii). in the third :ine the word 'Street' should be The motions were adopted. ,_·hanged into ·Road'. Jlr. Deputy-Speak..-r: In !hat case llr. iH-puty-Speakel': The President's it should reaa "in this Road" instead Orc1er stands modified to the extent Q~'of thi.~ Street", This will be of these amendments. The other hon. :·hanged. Members desire to withdraw their motion~. The question is: 1. That in motion No. 2(3) in sup- The amendments were. by leave. ;,lementary List No. 1 printed in withdrawn. .-\ppendix XXXIII, Annexure l. stand- :!.g in the names of Shri Prabhu ~I'. iH-puty-Speaker: Now the Presi- Dayal Himatsingka and' AI-Haj M.A. dent's Order stands modified to the :-.~'.que.- extent of the amendments carried. so far a" the l\Iadras Order is concerned. (i) tor the. words 'against the entry 'Jorasanko' " in column 1 for all the words occurrine in \VEST BE:\GM. ORDERS ('olumn 2. the words "against the entry 'Jorasanko' in Dr. .-\mbedkar: With regard to the column 1 (or all the words WcH Bengal Order. I am prepared to occurring in columns 1 and 2" accept the following amendments: be substituted; '1 That in motion No, 2(~) in sup- Consolidated List No.2-Parts 1 to ;-"ementary List No. 1 (West Bengal 6 of Shri Samanta and Shri B. K. Das, i.)rder) at page 2. standing in the ::ames of Shri Prabhu Dayal Himat- Supp1emenrc.ry List No. t: Amend- ,':lgka and AI-Raj :'v1.A. Haque,- f!~€nt No I-Parts 1 and 2 and Amend: ment No.2-Parts 1 to 8 of Shn (i) for the \\'')rds "in column 2", Himatsingka and :\lr. Ha9. as mod!- the words "in columns 1 and fied by Supplementary Llst No. ;). 2" be substituted: Amendments 1 to -l of Shri' Jhunjhun- 'Nala and Shri Sinha.) (ii) for the word 'Muktaram Babll Road" in line 7 of the I withdraw amendments Nos. -l and above motion. the words 12 to 15 from the Supplementary I..ist ":\fuktaram Babu Street" be No.3. The rest of them I move. substitu ted. Shri Chattopadhyay (West Bengal): :3. That in motion No. 2(6) in sup- I would like to mo\'e the amendment appearing in Supplementary List No. o:ementary List No. 1 (West Bengal 2. It covers 108 items. of which I do Order} at ;>age 3, standing in the' not want to press Item No. 30. !:ame') of Shri Prabhu Dayal Rimat- ~l!1gka and AI'Raj M.A. Haque. bet- 1'11'. Deputy-Speaker: The .question ween the "'Old') "cornwallis Street" j,' and the words "upto junction with". the words "trom jundion with the rFor . text of the motion see :Uachuabazar StrE'et" be inSlerted. amendment NO.2. (aU the' parts. i.e, 1-6) in Consolidated Lj~ as printed -I, That in motion No. 2(7) in snp- in Appendix XXXIII. annexure 1.] :llementary l.ist No. 1 (West Benpl The motion was adopted. Order) :It !>a,e- :i. slandilll In tho 10568 Motions reo Delimltation of 9 JUNE 1951 ConstiCuelleies Ord.ers. it'S1 {9M' ·(Mr. Deputy-Speaker] 'names of Shri Prabhu Dayal Himat- Vivekananda Road from junction singka and AI-Haj M.A. Haque,- with Circular Road, Upper upto junction with Circular Canal. and (i) in line 14, for the word "Easy" on the East by Circular Canal the word "East" be substitut- from junction with Vivekanada ed; Road up to junction with Ulta- (ii) between the word "Road up- danga Road." to" and the words "Ulta- 2. That at page 15. in Table B.- 'danga" the words "junction Assembly Constituencies, tor the entry with" be inserted: "Sobhabazar" in column 1 and the entry occurring against it in column 2, (iii) between the words "Road the following be substituted, nameIy:- Upper" and the words "from junction with", the wordJJ 2 "(the voters of this Road are not to be included in the area)" be inserted; and ~r\l.'hipi'fi\ "Ward Ko. 9 (Mnchipar&) of the Calcutta Municipality, (iv) the words "(the voters or excluding area bounded on this street are not to be in- the North by Keshab Sen. cluded in the area)" be Street from Junction with omitted. College Street up t!) junction with Amhrest Street, on The motions were adopted. the West by College Street Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question is: from junction with Keebab Sen Street up to junction That the following modifications be with lfirzapur Street. on the South by Mirzapl11' Street made in the Delimitation of Parlia- from junction with College mentary and Assembly Constituencies St,reet up to junction with (West Bengal) Order. 1951 laid on the Amherst St,reet snd on the Table on the 16th May, 1951, namely:- east by Amherst at,reet from 1. That at page 3. in Table A.- junction with Mirzapl11' Street Parliamentary Constituencies, against upto junction with Kesbab the entry "Calcutta North-East", in Sen Street and t'le area column 1 for the words "Collootola bolmded on t:,e North by Barabazar" in column 2 the word Gss Street from junction "Burtola" be substituted. with Circular Rosd Upper up to junction with Cireular 2. That at page 3. in Table A.- C.anal, on the West by Parliamentary €onstituencies. against Circular Road Upper from the entry "Calcutta North-West", in junction with GB8 Street column 1 for the word "Burtola" in upto jlmctioll with B-_·lia- column 2 the words "Collootola. Bara- ghats Road. on the South bazar" be SUbstituted.' by Beliaghata Road from junction with Circular Road The motion was adopted. Upper up to junction with Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question is: Circular Canal and 0 D the East by Circul$l' Canal from That the following modifications be jlmction with Beliaghata made in the Delimitation of Parlia- Road npto junction with mentary and Assembly Constituencies GB8 Stre~t. (The voters of (West Bengal) Order, 1951 laid on the Ciroular Road Upper are Table on the 16th May, 1951, namely:- 1101 to be included in th 1. That at page 15. in Table B.- excluded area)'" Assembly Constituencies, against the entry "Burtola", in column 1 for all the 3. That at pages 15 and 16, in Table entry occurring in column 2, the follow- B.-Assembly Constituencies, against Ing be substituted. namely:- the entry "Jorasanko", in column 1 for "Ward No.3 (Burtola) ot the all the words occurring in columns 1 Calcutta Municipality. excluding and 2, the following be substituted, the area bounded on the North by namely:- Ultadanga Road from junction "Ward No. 3 (Jorabagan) ot the with Circular Road Upper up to Calcutta Municipality, excludint junction with Circular Canal,· on the area bounded on the North by the West by Circular ROad Upper Kall ~a Tagore Street from from junction with Ultadanta the junction with Maharshi Road up to junction with Viveka- Debendra Road up to the junction nanda Road, on the South by with Chitpur Road Upper on ~ . •... 1').568 MotiOns reo DeUmitation of 9 JUNE 1931 CoMtituencie. Order,. It11 ....·· West by Maharshi Debendra Road the entry "Colootala", In colunua l. trom junction with Kali Krishna lor all the words occurrfD4r In tolunua Tagore Street upto junctioo with 2, the following be substituted, Dame- Cotton Street. on the South by ly:- Cotton Street from the junction with Maharshi Debendra Road "Ward No. 8 (Colootala) of the upto junction with Chitpur Road Calrotta Municipality and the area Upper and on the East by Chitpur Crom Ward No. 6 (Jorasanko) Road Upper from junction with bounded on the North by Mukta- Cotton Street upto junction with raPl Babu Street (voters of this Kali Krishna Tagore Street. (The Street are not to be included In yoters of Kali Krishna Tagore the area) from junction with Street are not included in the Chitpur Road Upper upto junction excluded area)." with Cornwallis Street, on the West by Chitpur Road Upper from 4. That at page 16. in Table B.- junction with Muktaram· Babu Assembly Constituencies. against the Street upto junction with Machua- entry "Jorabagan", in column 1 for all bazar Street, on the South by the words occurring in columns 1 and Machuabazar Street from junction 2, the following be substituted. name- with Chitpur Road Upper up to ly:- junction with Cornwallis Street and on the East by Cornwallis 'Ward No.6 (Jorasanko) of the Street from junction with Machua- Calcutta Municipality excluding bazar Street upto junction with the area bounded on the North by Muktaram Babu Street." Muktaram Babu Street from junction with Chitpur Road Upper upto junction with Cornwallis 7. That at page 18, in Table B.- Street, on the West by Chitpur Assembly Constituencies. against the Road Upper from junction with entry "Sealdah", in column 1 for all the Muktaram Babu Street up to word, .occurring in column 2. the junction with Machuabazar Street. following be substituted, namely:- on the South by Machuabazar "Ar~a from Ward No.3 (Burtola) Street from junction with Chitpur of th~ Calcutta ::\[unicipality. Road Upper upto junction with bounded on the North by lnta- Cornwallis Street and on the East danga Road from junction with by Cornwallis Street from junction Circular Road Upper up to junction with Machuabazar Street up to with Circular C&nal ... on the West junction with Muktaram Babu by CircullW Road."Upper from Street. (The voters of Muktaram junction with Ultadanga Road up Babu Street are not to be included to junction with Vivekananda in the excluded area)." Road. on the south by Viveka- nanda RQad from junction with 5. That at page 17. in Table B.- Circular Road Upper up to junction _"ssembly Constituencies, against the with Circular Canal and on the entry "Barabazar". in column 1 for all East by Circular Canal from the words occurring in column 2, the junction with Vh'ekananda Road following be substituted. namely:- lIpto junction With Ultadanga Road "Ward No.7 (Barabazar) of the and area from Ward 4 (Sukea's Calcutta Municipality and the area Street) of the Calcutta Municipality from Ward No. 5 (Jorabagan) of bounded on the North by Viveka- lhe Calcutta Municipality bounded nanda Ro;td from junction with on the North by Kali Krishna Circular Road UpDCr up to junction Tagore Str.eet (Yoters of this Street with Circular Canal. on the West are not to be included in the area) by Circular Road Upper from from the junction with Maharshi junction lVith Vivekananda Road Debendra Road up to the junction up to junction with Gas Street, on with Chitpur Road Upper, on the the South by Gas Street from West by Maharshl Debendra Road junction with Circular Road from jounction with KaU Krlslpla t:pper upto junction with Circular Tagore Street up to junction with Canal and on the East by Circular Cotton Street, on the South by Canal from junction with Gas Cotton Street from junction with Street upto junction with Viveka- Maharshi Debendra Road upto nanda Road and area from Ward junction with Chitpur Road Upper. No.9 (Muchipara) of Calcutta on the East by Chitpur Road Upper Municipality bounded on the North from junCtion with Cotton Street by Gas Street from junction with up to junction with Kali Krishna Circular Road Upper upto j1metion. Tagore Street."' . with Circular Canal, on the W_ by Circular Road Upper (the 6. That at pages 17 and 18, in Table voters of this Road are not to be B.-AssemblY Constituencies, against included in-the area) from juhctl :til'. Deputy-Speaker: They have Fo.urthly. I would like to give signed 011 oehalf of the others. allother instance occurring in page 5 of the Delimitation Order where Shri Chattopadhyay: I do 0 not want to imputE: any l11uth'e or to say any- Burwan and Khargram. two different thing with regard to this matter. :\Iy thulws ha\'e been grouped togeth~r point is this ...... and they have been appropriately named. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: I can only say that in :'.Iadras. I signed on behalf of Let me give you the fifth instance. the whole Committee. being the Chairman. Likewise. three members Mr. Depuiy-Speaker: It is all right might ha"e signed on behalf of the for the hon. Member to I{O on citing rest. instances and the precedents in U.P., Bihar and ether places. Does not the SIJri Chattopadhyay: In the caSe of hon. Member think that it is too late :\ladras. you have :;igned having been now? After all ".. ·hkhever candidate authorized by the Committee. In the :;tands they will know the constitu- case of Bengal no such authority has ency. been given by anybody and the Chair· man has not been authorized by the Shri Chattopadhyay: As we all Committee. I have gone t.hrough the know candidates choose certain kinds Madras report also. I beg to say of symbols and these symbols are that in the' case of the Delimitation very important factors in the matter Order tor the different States of of election. It is the symbol which IndIa a certain principle h. .been influences an election to a very Iarp- followed and where more than 2 dis- extent. In the matter of names ... OJ tricts have been groi.iped together both iti~ 0 almost as important all a qrri.. 000 11)6d4 Motiun, reo Delimita~ion oj 9 JUNE 1951 Con.tituencie. Orders, 1951 IOMI LShri Ch~opadhyay] AD HOD. MelDbel': That is the name bot Where three districts have been of that ward. grouped together, if you do not put in the name of the three districts, one or Shri Cbattopa4h)"a),,: No. That is two will find prominence because the now a constituency In the Town of name of that district alone will appear Calcutta. I shall read that out to in every printed paper as the name 7OU: ot the constituency and the other "Ward No. 4 (Sukeas' Street) districts will. sink into insignificance. cf Calcutta Municipality." In the same manner I should say in every pamphlet and in every bulletin Dr. M. M. Das (West Benga}): That of every candidate the name of a constituency deri\-es its name after particular place will be printed and Vidyasagar. the names ot the other two places will Shri ChaUopadb)"ay: That is exact- not be shown. This will give a decid- ly why I am raising the objection. ed advantage to particular members Exactly for that reason, I say that in particular constituencies. I should a member of the family of Vidyasagar think that the Members of the U.P., should not be allowed to take any Bihar, Rajl,tsthan, Madhya Pradesh advantage. A professor of the Vidya- and all other States have correctly sagar college living there should not named the constituencies so that no take any advantage. Any person candidate will have any advantage connected with the name of Vidyasagar at any place due to the name of his should not have any advantage. I village or his town being included in am not speaking on behalf of any the constituency to the exclusiQn of particular constituency. I have abso- others. (InteTTttption). I am extre- lutely no particular axe to grind. I mely doubtful about this matter. I am not doing it out of any particular can tell you that I wanted that this motive for myself. I am saying this matter should be dealt with propel"ly. on grounds of general principle. Ward I wrote a letter to the Prime Minis- No_ -I in Calcutta is a constituency by ter; I wrote to Dr. Ambedkar; I wrote itself. Why should it be named after to Shri Jagjivan Ram, to Shri Satya Vidyasagar? -Narayan Sinha and all other people and I am very much pained to tell Mr_ Deputy-Speaker: Does not a this House that in spite of the concur- ward consist of many streets? The rence of hon. Members from all the ward goes by the name of on~ of the States, like Bombay, U.P.,' Bihar etc. important streets. as the Brahmin I do not know what stands in street ward in my place. the way of accepting my suggestion. Is it false prestige that stands Sbri Cba&&opadbyay: Vidyasagar Is in the way of re-naming the an illustrious man: it is not a street constituencies? Nothing extra- or ward. ordinary has to be done now. I know Pandit MaUra (West Bengal): There if the territorial_ jurisdiction is touch- is a Vidyasagar Street. ed now that will create difficulties. I realize that. All I say is that when Shri Chattopadhya),,: We are very YOU are naming the constituencies, much concerned that in the elections you can do this correctly in five minut- nobody should secure any advantage es. You, Sir, can do it if you under- by utilising Vidyasagar's name: the take the responsibility. If it is left to !lame of Mahatma Gandhi or any the Election Commissioner, he will be other name. able to do it. It it is left to the office. they will be able to do it. I have Mr. Deputy-Speaker: What is the placed amendments before the House. name of the Ward? -I think the principle should be accepted of naming the constituencies correcly. Shri Chattopadhyay: It is Ward No_ so that no candidate may have any 4 Sukeas' Street. It has been named Vidyasagar. It has ne\-er been Vldya- "undue advantage. sagar. and it will ne\'er be Vidyasagar Then, Sir. I must say about one at any time In the future. This ma:r instance only in the Town of Calcutta. be due to omission. So many of the The constituency" has been named as Members of the Delimitation Advisor,r "Vidyasagar". I" do not like the ~e Committee have not put In their lie- -of Mahatma Gandhi or -ChlttaranJan nature: either the report was not or Subhas Chandra Bose or Vidyas8lar submittecJ to them or they dO not -should be. dragged in this matter. know bow tbe -- naming hu been aODe. My fear Is that any member of that r should say, in - tbl.t, matter ~. "family will secure some advanta~. out thing has been done by overslchl "n 'ot that. Is not too la~ now. It should be lit - 11)586 Motions reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Con8tituencie. Or"",. 19$1 I"" right· even now 10 'that no Injustice to ill health. That does not mean may be done. 1 say that in the case that the report has been approvecl of the West Bengal constituencies the only by three Members. A few mocti- • same procedure, and the same princi- fications have been proposed.and ac- ple as has been followed in the other cepted by the House. SOme are mere States and in other constituencies be corrections and clerical mista::.f mistakes on the face of ~e. - follow~d. Some are minor modifications. TheJ' Pandlt Maltra: My hon. friend who had to be done with the full concur- has just finished spoke with rence of the West Bengal Government. considerable vigour and enthusiasm the Election Commissioner, Delimita- worthy of a much better cause. I tion Commi Uee Members and those would like to tell you atonce, and the who moved them. Whatever might House will be informed when 1 say have happened with regard to other We agree with the proposal contained provinces. every province must have in the President's Order in respect of its own peculiar circumstances ;lnd West Bengal constituencies: all the peculiar characteristics and things like that. My hon. friend go~ four partie" or to be more accurate, frightened over the name of Vidya- three parties. namely. the Delimita- sagar. There is a big avenue called tion Committee. Government of West tlte Chittaranjan avenue; there is the Bengal the Election Commissioner and Rashbehari avenue: there is the Sen also the Members of Parliament ex- Gupta Road; there is the Mahatma cept my hon. friend who has iust Gandhi Road and there is the Lajpati spoken, are unanimous. Rai Road. These thJngs are th~e. Instead of two or three names they Shri Chattopadhyay: Sorry: I pro- have wed a simple name. ~e test. There are so many others. Vidyasagar street is there. It sur- Even the four Members who nave not prises me that an argument that a signed were not unanimous. grandson or brother-in-law of Vidya- sagar would get all the votes because the constituency is named after Vidya- Pandit Maltra: I am talking of Mem- :;agar. should in all seriousness, be bers of Parliament from West Bengal. advanced in this House. 1 may tell My friend's sole iontention is with re- you. from the point of view of sUn- <1ard to nomenclature. He has roamed plk·ity. with !t view to avoid all con- ~bout all the States of India to find fusion in the mind of intending can- out what names have been adopted in didates :)r others.;ill these names the different States. If my hon. were made: it is not a case of making friend thinks that he is so well posted a few departure::.. The West Bengal with regard to nomenclature and GO\·ernment had no objection; the things like that. that they have been Delimitation Committee had no objec- done in an immaculate waY in other tion: the Election Commissioner bad places except Bengal, my hon. friend n;) objecti(ln and we had no objection. is at perfect liberty to contest the Thererore. I submit tltat whatever elections from any other constituency. may be my hon. friend's grievances, With regard to the province of West the\-' are more fancied than real. I Bengal...... have considerable sympathy towards my hon. friend's peculiar ideas: but I Shri Chattopadhyay: I know that am afraid I cannot press them for the the constituency from which my hon. acceptance of this House. I would friell.d comes has been named after a therefore submit to you that the village though it comprises three amendments as have been proposed by districts ...... the Law Minister and accepted by the House may be accepted. After all. Pandit MaitFa: I am not giving you will find that with. regard to de- way. With regard to West Bengal. limitation of constituencies . in West from the beginning. there were consi- Bengal. there has been the least possi- derable discussions and we decided ble amount of disagt·eement. confusion to avoid cumbrous names and things Ot' trouble. like that. When the names of the constituencies were fixed. it had fhe Sbri Cbattopadhy.y: I am keen full approval of the Government of ah9ut my amendments, Sir. West Bengal, and the full approval of the Members of the Delimitation Com- Mr. Depuiy-8peaker: Does the bon. mittee. Three Members might have Member wish that 1 should put the signed. 1 have not .signed. but I am amendments one by one or in a lot? in full agreement with the report. I attended the meetings of the Com- SJui Cllattopadla7a),: One by one, U It would aive an ~rtunity to te.t mittee at the earlier stage. but at the t11. opinion ot the House and of Mem- later stages. _I could not attend owing bers from the different States. lo0668 Motiolls reo Delimitatfo;l of 9 JUNE 1951 Constituencies Orders. 1951 HI~,) Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The House will. 19 in Supplementary List No. 3 as then, have to sit for 10 days. printed in Appendix XXXIII, anne- Dr. Ambeodkar: If I may say a word. xure 1. J in view of the tact that there is such The motion was adopted. a keen difference of opinion, I am pre- pared to suggest that it may be left Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The other han. to the Speaker to treat this matter as Members desire to withdraw Uleir a sort of a nomenclature matter. with- amendments. out to.uching the sUbstance. This mat- ter may be kept open. Those Mem- All the other amendments were. by bers who care may approach the leave. withdrawn. Speaker and convince him that this 12 NOON is a matter of nomenclature and for· rn~lly they may be put in without in Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The President'~ any way disturbing the areliS th'lt are Order regarding West Bengal stand!; included in the particular cOllstituen- Il)()dified to the extent of the amenc- des. nients n'I)\'(~rl and ac-c-epted in fhe lTou"e. Pandit Maltra: I am afraid we can- not agree to this because if one single lvIember is keer. on having a change HYDERAIIAD ORDER in the nomenclature, another Member Dr. Ambedkar: I am prepared to may suggest another thing and ...... ;{('cept the f()llowing amendments: Shri Cha.ttopadhyay: Why are you ('onsolirial~d List. Ame1ldment No. airaid'? 1. '~ar~:i I llnd :l. by Shri Rarnach&r Dr. M. M. Das: That would be in- and ethers. <.:oIl\"t;nient. Amell(lmt!nt No.2. parts 1 to 6. Shri J. R. Kapoor (Uttar Pradesh): parIs 10 to 12 and parts 15 and 16 by The point raised by Mr. Chattopadhyay Shri Rama('har and others. is appealing to most of us.. We do not want that at this late stage there Amendment No.3, parts 1 and 2 by should be anl' substantial change. Shri Ramachar and others. The changes that he suggests could easily be made in. the manner sug- Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question ge;;ted by the Law Minister and an I~: overwhelming majority of the House fFor textpf the motion see Conso- will. I sh~uld say, support thi\t. lidated List. Amendment No. I, parts Shri S. M. Ghose (West Bengal): 1 and 5. Amendment No.2 parts 1. 2. How could this Order be finalised by :~. -to 5. 6. 10. 11, 12 and 15 and 16. the Speaker? My hon. friend has sug- a~d Amendment No.3 parIs 1 and 2 gested some nomenclature. Other printed in Appendix XXXIII. anne- Members may suggest some other xure 1.] names. There will be no end to that. The motion was adopted. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The han. MI'. Deputy-Speaker: The Presjdent's Speaker has to be here. He has to Order regarding Hyderabad stand;: invite other Members together and modified to the extent of t~e ascertain from them what their wishes ;1mendments moved and accepted.m are. What about the Order? Are we the H'Juse. The oth~r Me."llbers de~me 10 say that the Order has to be modi- to withdraw their amendments. fied to that extent or not? Nomen- clature is a part of the Order; it is All the other amendments were, by not something like the marginal notes. leave. withdrawn. I think there will be some difficulty in the matter. I leave it to the House. :\!ADHYA BHARAT ORDER Dr Anlb~dkar: I accept amendments Shri Chattopadhyay: With a peavy Nos.·1. 2. :J, 6, 7. 9 and 11 in List No. heart. Sir. I am forced to withdraw :J by Shri Radhelal Vyas. Also in them. List No. I, Appendix I. The amendments were. by leave.' Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question withdrawn. is: lIr. Deputy-SJ)eaker: Now I shall [For text of the moUons see Amend- put the amendmellts of Dr. Ambedkar ments Nos. 1. 2. 3, 8. 7, 9 and ttdlnl in. Supplementary List No.3. The List No. 3 printed in Appen x question II: XXXIII. annexure 2.]. [For text of the motions see amend- ments Nos. 1 to 3. 5 to 11 and 16 to The motions were adopted. 10570 Motinn.'l reo DelimitcLtion oj 9 JUNE 1951 COlUtituencies Order., 19'11~1 :\Ir. Deputy·Speaker: The question 1\lr. Deputy-Speaker: The question I" : is: rFor text of the motion :fee List 1. [For text of the motion lee Consoli- Appendix I (as n:odi~ed by the ~re" dated List. Amendment No. 1. parts a \"ious amendments In List No.3, prmt- and 3 pl"inted hi Appendix XXXIIt, ed in Appendix XXXIII. annexurtls 1 annexure I.J and 2.] The motion was adopted. The motion was adopted. Dr. Ambedkar: I accept, in 'Supple- l\IlYSORE ORDEH mentary List 2, amendment No. 1 of Sardar Ranjit Singh. as amended by Dr. Ambedkar: I accept amendmi!nt~ ::\os. 1 and 2 in List No. 1 by Shn amendment No.1. parts (i) and (U) in Rudrappa. SupplementarY List 3 by Sardar Man. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question So the amendment in Supplementary is: List 3 may be put first. ;Ur. Deputy-Speaker: The questioll LFor text of the motion see Amend- is: ments Nos. I and 2 in List No. t printed in Appendix XX~lII. anne- That in the motion in Supplementary xure 3.] List No. 2 printed in Ap~ndix The motion was adopted. XXXIII, annexure 1- Mr. Deputy-Speaker: All the other (i) against the entry ,"l\lalerkotla", amendments are desired to be with" in column 2, for the existing entry ..~rawn. the following be substituted, namely:- The amendments were, by leave. . Malerkotla police station exclud- withdrawn. ing patwari circle Saroud"; and Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The President'." (ii) against the entry "Ahmedgarb", Order regarding Mysore stands modl- in column 2, ior the existing entry the ned to the extent of these amendments following be substituted. namely:- now accepted. "Ahmedgarh and Amargarh police Then the Punjab Order? stations including pat,,,"ari Dr. Ambedkar: No, Sir. The Punjab circle Saroud:' Order will have to be kept back for ;ome time now. We may take up The motion was adopted. the. P.E.P.S.U. Order. )Il'. Deputy"Speaker: The que.stion P.E.P.S.U. ORDER is: Dr. Ambedkar: I accept amend- That the following modifications be ment 1, parts ~ and 3 of ~ardar made in the Delimitation of Parlia. Sachet Singh 111 the ConsolIdated mentary and Assembly Constituencies List and also amendment No. 1 . The motion was adopted. )0672 Molioltll reo DelimitaUon 0/ !) JUNE 1951 Conltituellcie. Orderl, 1951 IUJ7S Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The Presi- (Rajasthan) Order, 1951 laid' on the dent's Order regarding P.E.P.S.U. Table on the. 16th May, 19tH,. stands modified to the extent of the namely:- amendments now adopted. 1. That at page 1, in Table A.- RAJASTH:\N ORDER Parliamentary Constituencies, against the entry "Bikaner-Churu", in column Dr. Ambedkar: I accept amendment 2, for all the words beginning with No.1, parts 1 to 5 in the name of the words "Phalodi Tehsil" occurring Shri R. C. Upadhyaya in Consolidated in line 3, till the end, the following be List as modified by amendment ~o. 1 substituted, namely:- of Shri Ghule in S.L. No.4. "Nagaur tehsil (excluding Nagaur Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question Mundwa and Khatu Kalan is: police station and the Ladnu and Bardua police stations of [For text of the motion ~ee amend- the Beedwana Tehsil of the ment No. 1 by Shri Ghule in S.L. No. Nagaur District." 4.] 2. That at page 2, in Table A.- The motion was adopted. Parliamentary Constituencies, for the entry "Jodhpur-Barmer" occurring. In Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question column 1 and all other entnes is: occurring ~gainst them in columns 2. That the following modifications be :3 and 4, the following be substltuted~ made in the Delimitation of Parlia- namely:- mentary and Assembly Constituencies ------_.... _-_._------2 3 ------.--"~-- Jodhpur TIle Jodhpur d i"trict and the J aiaawer dietrict 1 __.... __ ----- _____" _____ • __-"----.------.I __ --- 3. That at page 2, in Table A.- occurring against it in columns 2. Parli.amentary Constituencies, for the 3 and 4, the following be substituted.. entry "Jalore-Barmer" occurring in namely:- column 1 and all other entries 1 3 ------Banner·Jalore The Banner distriot and the Jalore district (exolud. "iog the BhinmaJ, Jaswantpura and Hodran Polic~ stations of the J&<>wantpura Tebsil). ,------...--~--~------~ 4. That at page 2, in Table A.- I, and all other entries occurring Parliamentary Constituencies, for the against it in columns 2, 3 fJld 4, the entry "Pali-Sirohi" occuning in column following be substituted, namely:- ! :1 3 8irolli·PaIi The Sirohi distri~t. the Bhinma1, Jaswantpura &ad 1 Hodran Police stati0D8 of Jaswantpura tehsil of the J'alore diatnot and Pali. Bali and Desuri tehsila "and the Soja. tehail (ezoludiDg J3a8ri Kharaohi and Sojat police atatjoua). ------,------10674 Moti·on, reo Delfmitatfon of 9 JUNE 1951 COnltftuende. OrcIHt.l"lj•• :~, .. That at pale 2, in Table A.- and all other entries occur..... apfut Parliamentary Constituencies, for the it in columns 2, 3 and .. the lollowtD& entry "Nagaur" occurring in column 1 be substituted~ namely:- 3 ------_._------_.... ------~agaur.Pali The Pali dilttrict (excluding Pali, Bali, DetlUJ'i &nO I Soiat tebsi1s, but including &gr. Kharach. aDd SOJat police 8tatioP8 of the dojat Tehsil) and tbe Nagaur di~trict (ell:duding LadnUD and Bard"a police IItatioJVI of the Didwa.na Tehsil, the Peelw. police st.tiollllnd the vilJag.- of t·he ParbatEar aud Gacbbipura police 8tatioD8 ~peoified re6peot.~ely in item8 Noe. (E) &I,d (F) of the Appendix and the Nagaur tehsil, but including the Nagaur, Kunda"a and Khatu Kalan police etations of t·he N'agaur ._------tehsil. The motion was adopted. Chironji Khera, Kosra, Chareta, Chak Singor Khurd. Dang Bhaopur, Khidar- Dr. .-\mbedkar: 1 accept the. amend· pur, Bhaopur, Dang Bajoli, Gokalpur, ments in the name of Shrl R. C. Isarda, Jakhoda, Khidapura Jatan. Upadhyaya and others, Parts 1 to 19 on Kaneti, Kodana, Karoli Tarachand. pages :2 to 5 of C.L. Piplet, Kutalpur. Karoli Ghata, Karen Khurd, Karera Kalan, Kishangarb, Mr. Deput)'·S~aker: The question Kabirpura, Kachnari, Birpur, Naroz. is: Manrot, Madhpur, Rahlawad, SIngbor [For text of the motion see amend· Kalan, Singhor Khurd, SinganJruch. ment 3, parts 1 to 19, C.L. printed ill Sewti, Akhegarh, Badi-ka-Chhahra. Appendix XXXIII, annexure 1.1 Villages of the Todabhba -rebul The motion was adopted. (3) Dr. Ambedkar: Amendment No. 1 of S.L. No.2 and also No.2 of S.L. No. ?, Antarheda, Y.:aranpur. Patoli. Bhaj- as modified by amendment No. 2 m hera, Dantli, Anatpura, Medhipur. Supplementary List No.4, standing in Gheroli, Sankarwada Padla, Khalsa. my name may be accepted. Pandla Jagir, Kundawali, Shuda.- Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question Bharangpura, Sarsena Chak I, Sarseaa is: _ Chak 2, Bhensina. Shankarpur, Dorb. Muthepur, Nagal Nandal, Jbarlsar That the following modifications be Churpura, Madhopura, Shensa Patti made in the Delimitation of Parlia- Kalan, Bhensa Patti Khurd, Matasula, mentary and Assembly Constituencies Padli Khurd, Khidkhidf, Maderu (Rajasthan) Order, 1951 laid on the Bishanpura, Jodhpur, Todabhim. Table on the 16th May, 1951, Menhadwada, Asro, Bhimpur Kanetl. namely:- Makbara, Trisul, Nandipur, Chak 1 That for the Apf)endix at pages Mahendwada, Jhunki, Jaisni. Macbedl. 4-6 in Table A.-Parliamentary Dadanpur, Sahrakhar, Manoj, Sujan- Constituencies, the following be substi- pura, Aedalpur, Ladpur, Makb~ tuted, namely:- Kohra Kalan, Padampura Beroz, Nand. Gorda, Shankarpur, Kudhawal-Bala- APPENDIX was, Mohanpur, Badleta Buzurg. Villages of die Amber Tebsil. Badleta Khurd, Faujipura. Naaa1 Sultanpur Khedf, Gopalpura. Azizpur. (1) :Mirzapur, Chait Gazipur, Turekapur. Seropesa, Kherwadi, Dolatpura Mereda, Khanpur, Kariri Gazlpur. Kotsa. Garhl Badh, Fatehpur, Doravli, Jon! Villages of the KhaRdar Tebsll. Sherpur. (2) VIIIacH of the Lac... • ...... 'I'e...... Akoda, Barie, Balelr, Balora, (4) Bichpurl, Misran,· Bangarda Kalan, • Bangarda Khurd, Bichpuri Gujran, Imlall. Baroda Meo, Kborpud. BajoU, Bholanpura, Baironda Kalan, Bedha, . Sital, Mahlakpur, Rauapur, IOJ16 Motion,· reo Delimitation oj 9 JUNE 1951 Con,titrtettcie, Orderl. lIJ5( 'Mit LMr. Depllty-Speaker~ Ghat, Menapur, Buntoli, Gothari- Gadreta. Ladi-ka-Bas. Khundala. Jait- proh.it. Dwarakpl1r. Thumrela pura, Todo with Kalakota. Dariba, Gotheri, Guru. BerIa, Gujar Khohara: J~areda. :\Ioklawas. Bas.' Deepas. ~adhgujar Khohara. Rannlja Pha,': Klshanplira. Ramlawas. Luharwas. saJ~adka. Ambalpur. Kherlimahaiak. Dlidawas. phadika alias Jawaharpura. Butta.na, Harderhera. Kherli Viran, Sewa ahas Ramawas Faganwaa, Kherla, Chhangalki, Baorika, Chai- Dungar. manpura; Berka, Dusrahera. Dhandha. ~Iokahel'i, Bandka, Nibhera, Resti. Villages of the Police Statioa Bbojuar Gandul'a. Ratawali. Kherlirhalldrawnl. Melkheri. Dinar. Ahamdabas. Rughll- nathbas. (7) Nosar, Matora, Jakhan. Bapini Villages of tbe Kishangarb Sub- Poonasar, Karwan. Sanwan. llaipan' Tehsil of Tljara Tehsil. • .-;imbaro Talao. Bhadan. Baidu. Isru: Suwal. Kairla. Chadi Bhojasar. Au, (5) N~khra Charnan. Nokhra Bhatiyan, Jalslan. l\Ianaiora, Rinnalsar. Chan- Raoka. Chorbasai. Khora Pipli. pasar, Ajasar. Kolgaon, Sheikhpur, Khundinjagk Dohra. Mahrmpur. Khoha. Ghasoli. VUla!t'es of Police StatioD SOl Dkra. Khanpurmewan. Dongra, Niana. Bam- oora, Baghor. Pahar Shamlati. Ranoli . (8) .Bharuk. Ismanpur (including· Roondh Ismailpur). Tahatra Kherla. Tahatra. Channi. Choak. Khaitolai. Khura. Dadarhera. Nagla Dungar, Patan Luna Khurd. )Iahesa-ki-Dhani, l\Iewan, Nibhera, Siwana, Shiamaka, :\lodardi. N anariyai, Odanya, Sana- .•Ji1ota, Nagalijinnardar. Nagoli Khalil, wera. Sankara . Rata Khurd, Basai Balan. Rata Kalan. Basai-Jagta, Nangal Mojiya. Raipur- VilIa.&"es of Police Station Pokaran mewan. (9) Villages of the Neem-ka-Thana Tehsil. Jaimal. Girdi. That. Kailawa. (6) Guhala, ChaIa, Govindpura. Bhagot. Villages of Police Station Bardwa. Bhagega, Sirohi. Bhudoli with Khori (10) Agri, Ganeshar with Agri and Bhoj- pura, Barsinghpura, Gaonwari ~imod. Ridmalas. Raidhana. Urdrasar .Mahwa with Jiwanki Dhani and Kalu- Kusalpura. Godrakabas. Ringan, THoti: kidhani, Godawas, Neemkathana. Pipakuri. Dobron-ka-Bas. Rewara-ka- Ranasar. Mandholi. Chak Charanwas Bas. l\Iithari. Hussanipura. Farwasi, alias Puranawas, . Charanwas, Chak Lachhri. Dhia,va. :\Ianna-ki-Dhani . .:\Iandholi, Napawali. Maonda Khurd. .\yasji-ki-Dhani. Indarpura (Shree· Makdi, Maonda Kalan. Kanw81·a. Nathdwaral. Khirwaj. Pandorai, Kan- Natha-ki-Nagal. Lakha-ki':Nagal, Kan- Wai, Dayalpura. Lunoda. Lalaaarl. war-ki-Nagal. Jhalra. Dayal-ki-Nagal, Maws. Gaonwli, Biharipura. Dabla, Hinunat- pura, Semli. Behar. Jelo, Bagdawa. VlJIa,... s of Police Station Soja&. Imloha, Tigri. Salodra. Shampura. Dhani Ramsingh, Dunga-ki-NagaI. (11) Kishorepura, Khori, Nagal-Jat-Ki. Kharkadapanchu, Nagai Meena, Dal- Chitaraya. Cbandawal, Guria, patpura, Mothuka, Kangthli, Fateh- Khokra, Pachanda Kalan, Pachanda pura, Khurdfa, Rampura, Bega-ki- Khurd. Sandiaya. Dadiya. Dhundhala. NagaI, Jhamawas, Karja, Ballupura. .Melawas. :\Iushahya. Ramsinghpura (with Chak),. Haripura Dhani Ahironki, Bhopia, Jatuwas. Villaces of Parbatsar Police Stati... Hasampur. Chhaja-ki-Nagal. Rajpuru. (12) Mohanpura alias Kharkda. Patan, Kala Kota, Dokan, Kanakpura, Dhan- Sanchore. ~aigaon. Arath, Piplad, dheIa, Kacharda, Norana, Narda. Rohandi. Bhawansiya, Malaw'u, Bhagesar, Khadagbeejpur, Mokalwas. Gusaiyan. Hardani, Nimbrl, Bllu, Nanagwas, Raipur, Kola-ld-Nagal. Kinsariya, Khldarpura, Narwa, Parbat- Bhaduka alias· Himmatpura, Bhopat- sal', Shampura, Ranija, Mored, Adam. pura, Bakshipura, ReIa, Chak F8IaIl- Khokrar, Chamwas. Drokaliya, Gm&oU. was, I'aganwas, Ghasipura, Raion-ka- . Daioli Khurd, Gangawa, Btdlyad, Itota Bas, Partappura alias Kali Khera. Dunll'i. Khalar. ~taml'Otl, M~. 10117. Jlotionl ret De"mlCGt~ 01 9 JUNB 1151 ~ ~ _1~; VIIIqa 01 Gaehldpara PoUee StaUoa. Paplaj, Nandral, BadUaf, ~... (13) . Hajiwas, BUvas, KanJaoll, RNi'wh. AntroU Sanga, Marui, Blthawaliya. GahuU, Cbavand Khera. AtIhavarI, Kurada, LaIna Kalan, LaIna Khurd, Bedunda, Deo' Khera. Mena ka ~ Harnawapati, Kuchipula, Baman, Modia Khera, Bagadi. Khejdi, ~ Ratnas, Gusa Khairi, Khairi Sagatpuria, Taleda, CbohaU, Badkta. sUan, Akhepur, ltawa. Pannesbvarpunl. Madhyan, Palri Raj an, Altwa, Palrl· Jagpura, JavaI, Sabalpura, Bherukbera. Mahaichan, Bhutawa, Gachhipura, Berada ki Jupidia. Gandheri. Panderl, Intawa Dkhan, Gangahiya, Manaiwa, Belva. Sirsala. N ardoli Mertyan, Dhanoli, La [Mr. Deputy-Speakerj Nibhi, Ban Bihar, Chechipura, 1foroU. Khera Brahmin, Katb~ra Cbauth, Hinota GUjar, Bbanpur, DaadoU. Umara, Cbak, Umara, Samai, Puncbbri, Jayara, Surajpura, Bilpur, I'irozpur. Sbamdbak, Baroll Chautb, Bebaj, Basai Samanta, Randoll, Darrupura. Nagla Moti, Nagla Kbuman, Malipur Mahwri, Bhondia. Cbomenda, Iklebra, Deeg town, Abadi Deeg, Malpur, Bhilamka, Parmadra, VillaCes of the Police StatioD Rundb Parmadra, Badri, Pasta, JhUDjhuDu Naraina, Chauth, Nagla Harsukha, Rundb N araina. (13) VDIa&"es ot the Bayaaa Tehsil Budana Bagar, Desusar, Gopalpur~ (11) Hamiri Kalan, Hamiri Khurd, Hanut. pura, Islampur, Inderpura, Kasimpura, Biskbori, Imalia, Mabloni, Mertalab, Lalpur, Makhar, Merod, Soti, Sonasar. Kotha, Kilawa Aitmadpur, Gbazipur, Chinehroti. Kbareri, Bagren, Khamkbera, Kair, Mangren-Khurd, Katariapura, Nitbar, Kalsara, Jaspura-Moroli, Bhaja Moroli, Villages of Gudha Poliee Station Chikhru, Intkhera, Adda, Raroda, (14) Pipra, Kuntkbera, Madanpur, Nagla Honta, Meharwar, Aroda, Katkar, Pilu- Bas Bisbna, Bas Mana, Deep Pura. pura, Dhandhren, Jhamri, "Barkbera, Gura, Gadla Kalan, Gadla Khurd, Kherli, Sekbpur, Hingota, Mundia, Kishorepura, Kakrala, Ked with Gopal- Bamori, Nagala Nawaria, Nagala Baha- garh, Mainpur alias Miyanpura, Niwari. duria, Nagala Sewa Kurwaria, Phanso, Nangal Gujaran, Natas, Khatkar, Nag11 Cbak Pola, Chak Biehi, Cbak Viram- Deepsingh, Bhatlwar, Sheonathpura. pura, Pidawli, Kohara, Araji-Zalim, Harwana, Chanwara. Gurdha N adi, Baehena, Dabhana, Khatnavli. Aineholi, Navab, Chak Villages of the Sikar Tebsil Navali, Nagla Purohit, Nagla Cheeta- (15) riya, Dehgaon, Nagala Tirkha, Nagala Rupram, N agala Kishan Ballabh, Sikar (town), Debipura, Beri, Khod Nagala Sheo Lal, Nayagaon Kalan, Brahman, Kolida, Bhadwasi, Chand- Jarkho, Bhagori, Kanawar, Nagala pura, Dadia, Dadli-Hardayalpura, Chiman, Nagala Harlal, Har Nagar, Daulatpur, Dabpanora, Gungara- Araji N. Kishore, Bidyari, Murki, Deba Kushalpura, Jerthi, Jhigar (Chhoti), Sarai, Sarai Syed Ali, Bayana Town, Kudli, Katrathal. Raghunathgarh, Pip- Bagh Kanawar, Damdama, Lahchore rali, Sheosinghpura, Singhasan, Tar- Khurd, N ayagaon Khurd, Kaehera, pura, Dhani Tarpura, Bajor with Jhun- Brahmbad, Kooti Kheda, Purvai Kheda, jhara, Chainpura with Chak Chain- Seedpur, Nagla Jhainara, Nagla Nir- pura. Dhani Dassaki, Gokaipura, Mal- bhan, Salabad, N adigaon, Bajoli, Agha- khera, Smrathpura, Radhakisilanpura wali. Talampur, Jaswant Nagar, N~gl~ with Dhani Purohitji, Gothra Bhukran. Khusfaham, Nagla Med Singh, Alnoli, Birol, Butoli, Gudha Khurd, Gudha NagaI Khushali Ram, Nagla-Kharg Bara, Hathiyaj Rajpura, Jurathara, Singh, Birampura, Pipari,. Milakpur, Sikrai, Shamgarh. Sob, Palascra, Dhani Biretha, Sewala, Reeehroh, Lecehora Dulalki, Dhani Salimsingh, Todi. Kalan, Bansroli, Chokhanda, Sadpura, Nagla-Kurwaria. Villages of the Heem-lta-Thana Telasil Villages of the Dholpur Tehsil (16) (12) Buehara with Kola-ka-Bas, Chudla, Jugalpura, Debipura, Sanwalpura, Baretha Bothpura, Bugcboli, Dayeri, Mundli Ghata with Ganwar, Chiplata Siyapura, 'Duragpura, Sijroli, Bada- with Bhagwanpur Sikrai and Ladya, gaon Phoolpur, Tanda, Barabat, Rooppura, Khiroti Mandruppura, Dub~ti, Mugarwara, Biparpur, Sakat- Hathideh. Hardaskabas, A]meri pur, Nakpur, Bhojpur, Doobra, Mustaf- Kishorepura, Tatera, Raipura. Pithal- ..bad Tordaniyal, Sarkankbeda, Odi, pura Byore. Sanwalpura, Nor, Hari- Kajipura, Allahpura, Dariyapur, Pach- pura: Burhanpura, Jh~dli, Sherpura, gaon Aundela, Tal-Aundela, Masud- Surani, Athora With Mandsa, pur, , Narpura, Bhagiratbpura, ~hag Shipur, Jugrajpura, Mangarb, pura, Bhilagma, Chandpur, Mir]apur, Ajitgarh, Anantpura, Deorala, Asp~-a, Sahapur, Kheda, Sarani, Nagla-Bhagat," Garh Taknet, Tiloltpura, Gidakabas. Rajora Dhimri. Sandra, Bisnoda. Gar- Sihori, Kalyanpura. Shimarla, Gopal- wapur~, Nagla" Moroti, Rajal "Kalan, pura Nalot, Lorwada, Madhokabas. Rajai Khurd, Qasba Nagar, Basai Sukhsinghpura, Bhadwadl. Bithalpura, Dang, Barlpura, Blrpur, Patewari, Jugalpura, Thikaria, Dhair Kan~ 8ehron, Kotra, Kookpur, Khanpura, Kanwat, Harjanpura, Basdl lDlurd. 10686 Motions reo DeUmit4tion of 9 JUNE 19S1 CoMtit1&encie. Or"'" It11 1'" • 'Chhapar, Pithalpuri, Basdi Kalan, Villa.. es of tile Toda ...... Telldl KaUa Bas, Shilpur, Thoi, Karadka, Udalwas, Lisadia, Khurempura, Mun- (19) dru, NagaI Nathusar, Kolwa, Jalalsar, Arnia, Mahroli with Gudha and Bas Arnia, Utharna-Bas-Chain Sinehpura. Patwari, Bharni, Jalpali with Fadan- Amli (Devlia). Kundera (.JagiI') Dun! p~ra, Srimadhopur, Vijaypura, Bhopat- (Qasba), Kurasia, Kakoria, ka-Bas, Bassai, Dhalawas, Sheopura, Kant! Jairamoura, Kalyanpura, Pujarikabas, Chanderpura, Khera, Kala . Nad.). H~ Ganoli, Gola hera, Banedia Khurd. .. :)Uia, NagaI Bhim, Mau, Bagaria- Chandpura-Nadika Dhava, ChandU. was· Prithvipura, Kotri, Jaswantpura, Chopra, Chopri, Chhan-Mai-Bas-Suriya, Kacharda, Dha,li Zurawarsingh, Ukhda Chhatari. Jagtya, Jaithala, Bantbali, with Hamirpura Kalan, Chak Thikaria, Thatha, Sirohi, Dabar Kalan, Kacharda. Dabar Khurd, Dhibroo, Dhiklya, Thanwla, Devlya Ramsingh, Dalwasa. Villages of the Neem-ka-Thana Tebsil Devrawas, Nasrida, Panwar, Baneria (17) Chaman, Batoonda, Bagri, Dudawas, Bisalpura. Barwas, Dhandholi, Bas Guhala, ChaIa, Govindpura, Bhagot, Lachmana, Bas Chatra, Bhatera, Bhan- Bhagega, Sirohi, ~hudoli. with Kho~i . warthala, Malhera, Morda (Jagir), Agri, Ganeshar wIth Agri a!ld ~hoJ Moza Kasir, Moondia, Mugland. Moza pura Barsinghpura, Gaonwarl, Nimod. Titariya, Moza Barla, Moza Bibolao, Mah~a with Jiwanki Dhani and Madhosingbpura, Manpura, Jarkhia Kalukidhani, Godawas, Neem-ka- (alias Radha Ballabhpura) Rohota, Thana, Ranasar, Mandholi, Chak Rajmahal. Ramthala, Raghunathpura. Charanwas alias Puranawas. Charan- Rampura, Ralawta-bas-Beja, Ratao- was, CiJ.ak Mandholi, Napawali, pura, .Satwara, Sardara., Sadiawas. Maonda Khurd Makdi, Maonda Kalan, SandIa, Setiwas, Salgawas, Sankara- Kanwara, Natha-ki-Nagal, Lakha-ki- wara, Sujanpura. Sanwatgarh. Sarsarf, NagaI Kanwar-ki-Nagal, Jhalra, Dayal- HanUmanpl!ra. Shri Mansinghpura. ki-Nagal Gaonwli. Biharipura, DabIa, Gaonri (Thikana), Polyara, Mar Himmatpura. Semli. Behar, Jelo, Bag- Bhatiya. dawa, Imioha, Tigri,. Salodra, Sha~ pura, Dhani, Ramsmgh,. Dunga:ki- Bijwar, Am~·,a9ura, Gopipura, NagaI, Kishorepura, Khorl, NagaI-Jat- Narasinghpura. Bhimrwas, Bas Jodba ki, Kharkadapanchu, NagaI. Meena, ~ayangawan Gothra. Balapura, Naya Dalpatpura, Mothuka, Kangthli. Fate~ Gawa Dhigria, Kheriya. Jalari. Nand- pura, Khurdia, Rampura, Bega-KI- pura-Charanwas, Kherera, Mordiala. NagaI, Jhamawas, Karja, Ban~pura, !slampura. Lachamipura, Bas Bhag(- Ramsinghpura (with Cha,k), Haripura, rath, Bharua, Kakolwara Mahadevpura. Dhani Ahironki, Bhopla, Jat~was, Hasampur, Chhaja-ki-NagaI, RaJPura, Villages 01 the Jalpur Tehsil Mohanpura alias Kharkda, Patan,· Kala Kota, Dokan, Kanakpura, Dhandhela, (20) Kacharda, Norana, Narda, Bhagesar, Khadagbeejpur, Mokalwas, Nanagw~s, Jamdoli. Ballopura, Jaisinghpurkhor. . Raipur, Kola-ki-Nagal Bhaduka. ahas Samel, Malpura Dungar, Luniawas, Himmatpura, Bhopatpura, Bakshipura, Bindayakya, Dhula Bhaogarh, Mompur Rela, Chak Faganwas, Faganwas, Sadwa, Kerlangarh, Roopa-ki-Nagal, Ghasipura, Raion-Ka-Bas, Parta~pura Beed Mapura, Padli Meena, Kohah alias Kali Khera. Gadreta. Ladl-Ka- Nagoriyan. Kohah Laihiryan. Bas Deepas Kishanpura, Ramlawas, LUharwas Dudawas, Dhadika alias (21) Jawaharp~ra, Sewa alias Ra~awas, Faganwas, DUI.lgar, Kun~la, Jaltpura, Khatipura Charanandi, Jhotwada. Toda with Kalakota, Darlba. Jhareda, N angal J alsa Bora, Pempura, ~ah... Mokalwas, Bas. Deepas, Kishanpura, pura, alias Kooker. Khera SaUawas. Ramlawas. Luharwas. Dudaw~s, Sahajpura. Dhadika alias Jawaharpura, Dewa abas Ramawas, Faganwas, Dungar Villages of tile Phalen TeIISiI Villages 01 the Tonk Tehsil (22) (18) Toda, Tod, Minapur, KhandeJ. Norangpura, Suwava, Sambbar. . Aka,Ua. Balagarh Chandwar, Barothi, Barwata, Ranil, KhusbiDa. Dat,unda. Kalayanpura. Ranlr-bllas. Dodwada, Sartala. Chapri, Govindpufe. Ram Nagar. Laxmipura, Satwara. Jaoli, Sitaramppra, Nanpl. KalyaDa. Tokrawas. Hawaspura, Hachukada. Pan".. 108 Mottona reo DelimtiGticm of 9 JUNE I!!! Conatituende. Order.. 1961 1011. [Mr. Deputy-Speaker]· , ., • '~Shd Kalan, Asbtl Khurd, Sap Ka Mandka. Mandhal, Mored. Shreeram_ Bas, Madho ka Bas, Bhuteda, HU8tecIa. pur~, Slawata, SeengIa, Dabri, Baori, Mandba Bheda, Anooppura.. Shalkhoopura, Maurdj Kalan, Maurdi Shri Krishnpura, Bagha ka Bas. Khurd, Norda, Adarwa, Marwa, Aalesar Charanwas, Sitarampura. Panwa Kalan, SUrri, Khwazpura Govindgarh, Sawoo Kalan, Sawoo Peegoon, Mamana, Neemli, Sirohl Khurd, Itawa, Anandpura, Uda1pura~ Khurd, Kotda, Jhakolar, Panwaliya, Lorwara, Balekhan, Uganawas, Milak- Beegolao, Dantra, Bokdawas, Jadaota pur, Sundersar, Khannipur, Bad, Sall, Gharhar, GaUota, Sirohi Kalan' Abheykaranpura, Kumbawas, Shri- Lad~ra, Sakhwon, Dantri; ParasoU: kishanpur. Vimalpur, Daulatpura.. Goplpura, Shree Ramnagar, Bhojpura Thana ka Bas, Kaladera, Narsingb- Dudu, Baget, Khudiyala, Mangalwada' pura, Gwardi, Radhakishanpura, Tan Chapparwada, Cheepiya, Chapra: Prayagpura, Babupura, Noppura Kbai- sar, Harsoli, Ghatga, Kairiya Bujarg, tika Bas, Saharanpura, Bessakhurd. Mahatgaon, Relana, Gagardoo, Dhan- Kana Ankhol, Bali, Bamal, Bandaio. Basan· ViJlages of the Parbatsar Police Statioa. Deora, Bhadurda, Bhutail,· Chora, (37) Dadhura, Deoda, Dugawa, Gundau, Intada, JaiIatra, Jhab, Jhairal, Jodhoa. Sanchore, Maigaon, Arath, Piplad was, Khara, Kura, Lachhiwar, Laya. Rohandi, Bhanwansiya, MalawaS dara, Mirpura, Muli. Palri Deoran, Gusaiyan, Hardani, Nimbri, Bilu, Kin. Rampura, Panchala, Sankar, Saranau, sariya, Khidarpura, Narwa, Parbatsal", Surawa, Taitrol Deoran, Tantra. Titop, Shampura, Rusija, Mored, Bidujad Nimbau, Maru-Khaira, Paman. Binjrol. Adani, Khokar, Charnawas, Dhokaliya' Gingoli, DaisH Khurd, Gangawa, Bidi:" Villages of the Jodhpur Tehsil yad, Kola Dungri. Khalar, Mamroli.. Mandan. (31) Villages of the Gaehbipura Police- Ganwan, Bagan, Chainpura, Bhad· Station wasiya, Mahamandir (Proper), Man· (38) dore, Sunthala, Basni. Villages of the Police Station Antroli Sanga, Mairasi, Bithawaliyap Mathaniya Kurapya, Lalna Kalan, LaIna Khurd. Harnawapati, Kuchipula, Bamail.. (32) Ratnas, Gura Khairi, Khairi SHan, Madhyan, Parli Rasan, Altwa, Parll Godawasiya, Dawatra, Burkiya, Nan· Mahacchan, Bhutawa, Gachhi puna.. diya Prabhawati, Saivaki Khurd. Intawa Lakhan, Gingaliya, Manaiwa~ Villages of the Police Station Bhojasar Sirsala, Nandoli, Mertyan, Dhandoli, Lodoli, Sirsun, Bagoll, Baru, Dollarlya. (33) Gular, Inlawa Khichiyan, Bhaduroa. Nosar, Matora, Jakhan, Bapini, Villages of the Police Station Banhra Poonasar, Karwan, Santwan, Maipan, Nimbaro Talao, Bhadan, Baidu, Isru. (39) Suwaf, Kairla, Chadi, Bhojasar, Au, Ridmalas, Raidhana, Undrasar. Nokhra Charnan, Nokhra, Nokhra KusaJoura, Godrakabas, Ringan, Tiloti, Bhatiyan, Jaislan, Manaiora, Rirmal- Pipakuri. Dobron-ka-Bas, Rewara-ka- sar, Chanpasar, Ajasar. Bas, Mitha. ai, Husainupra, I'arwasf. Lachhri, Dhiawa, Manna-ki-Dhanl. Villages 01 the Police Station Sankra Ayasji-ki-Dhani, Indarpura (Shree Nathwara), Khinwaj, Pandorai, KanraI. (34) Dayalpura, Lenda, Lalasari, Mawa. Channi, Choak, Khaitolai, Khura, Luna Khurd, Mllhesa-ki-Dhani, Villages 01 Garbi 'hbsll Modardi, N anaaiya, Od,amya, Sanaara, Sankara. (40) Vlllages of the Police Station Pokaran Bhagatpura, Panchavada, Bhesau, Piplara, Bildi, Padradi, Itawa Saran- (35) pur, Bhamu-ka-parda, Davela. Kotda, Singuda-ka-parda, Gusani-ka-parda, Jaimal, Kirdi, That, Kailawa. Todi Moti, Kesarpura. Todi Chhoti, Villages of the Dcgana Police Station Lokiya. Oda, Nadariya. Kadwal, Odwa. Kalali-khurda, Badi Kher, Lalpura. (36) Govindpura, Ihali Talai. Odwara. Dungar, Navagarha, Arthuna, Porda. Jaitpura, Dagra, Dagri, Khairwa, Navgaon. Vakhatpura, Dhani, Dolat- Dugor Dasan, Dugor·Achlan, Khl,lri pura, Vadia, Adai, Koi-vav, Hadmatia. Khurd, Pandwali, Khuri Kalan, Mo~s, Fala-Bara. Malana, Patia, Bhardajal. Bhadli, Churiyawas, Jodhawas Khl,lrd, Vakhatpura, Raiyana, Bhatal, Nahall. Klindawas, .Alawas, Nimbola Khurd, Tamatiya Rathor, Jolana, Tamrua. Undiyas, Ranas, Deola Madha, Deola Vardia, Kuna, Amja, Nakarchi Varela.. Manda. Khatolai, Jalsu Khurd, Jalsu Ruhal. Kuwadla. Panas! Chhotl, Nanag,. Antroli Kalan, Antroli Khurd, Punasi Badi, Guwedia. Ador, Gopinath- Sarsanda, Banwarla, Chilmas, Dugor ka-Gada. Garndi-Narayanjl, It~ IO_59~ Motions reo Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Ccnutituencie. 0nIer" 1151 10itI [Mr. Deputy-Speaker] Anjana. Garnawat, Kunwaria, Vasi Jalpacca, Nala, Bhagibao, Ruc:lra. Moti, Kushalkot, Udela, Senala. Kanta Ghati, ThaprawaU, Suved, Ramabavri, Bhuvav, Mal, Sami Tad, Gangrar TehsU Hantia, Paderi, Makad jap, Khunta Neri, Ghanta, Thobawada, Kalawat, (41) Dodawat, Somawat, Kikar, Thana. N alia ka Kheda, Gulabpura, Bindolia, KaUiakada, Kanuwada, Bilkhal. r.imbahera, Dhoda, Kishanpura, Rana- Pareda, Khunadari, Jawas. waton-ka-Kheda, Kurantia, Sudri, Villages of the Girwa TehsU Amarpura, Mokamsingh-ka-Kheda Bakhatpura, Gangrar, Indora, Khar~ (44) khanda, Singola, Amara-ka-Kheda Hathi Dah, Ratanpura, Phila, Laxmipura, t.axmansingh-ka-Kheda' Jammu, Bambora, Soma Kheda, Patu Deth, Genia, Bhatkheda, Gurajania; Kheda, Khovad, Awara, Leg, Bori, Kacharia, Banina, Bhatwada Kalan Kaladia, Ant, Sulawas, Kot, Gudli. Bhatwada Khurd, Kanti, Nathi k~ Budel, Lalpura, BernIa, Bajni Dodi. Kheda. Borda, Taleri, Bhawanipura Kurawad, Achhata, Rlwatpura, Kara- Jatan, Medikheda, Chanderia, Choga- dia, Nadiwala. Buthal, Balar, Dhori vadi, Bhilia Kheda, Nagri, Bilia, Suwa- Kheda. Sagtadi, Kara Kala, Suron ka nia, Shivpura, Awalheda, Gosundi, Gudh. Bhulia, Nad. Charinar. Sangrampura, Gowlia, Murlia, Lalas, Soniyana, Negdia Kalan, Nagpura, ViUages of the Uathala TehsiJ Saron, Puthoil, Eklingpura, Karediya, (45) Sankra ka Kheda, Sokdiya, Bolo ita Rajpura, Kheta Kheda, Sarwania, Savanta, Aran, Ajolia ka Kheda, Jodh- Mal Khejdi, Amia, Lunda, Malnawas, singh ka Kheda, Sadapura, Dadia, Dhakdon ka kheda, Lilaji ka kheda, Dhunwalia, Laxanpura, Raipuria, Gulabpura, Amar pura. Solankhiyon Solankiyon-ki-Khedi, Mungacr:-ka- ka kheda, Bhau pura, Haria Kheda, Kheda, Semliya, Khuntiya, Sonigaron Naharpura, Chanpuria, Jhal ka kheda, ka Kheda, Balderkha, Datta ka Kheda, Sangrampura, Paria, Udaipuria. Prathi Ladupura, Salera including Hamlet Singh ka lrheda, Gathpura, Nankia Ganeshpura, Jojron-ka-Kheda, Lambia. kheda, Mota kheda, Phatapura, Seed, Sarpura, Ranavaton ka kheda, Magri ViUages of the Kotri Tehsil ka Phala, Jasvantpura, Saranpura, Pithalpura. Umraon ka vala, Gop Jd (42) Bhagal, Kanode, Gangpura, Kundia, Savpura. Chamlavdi. Samel, Surkhan, ! :Mandola, Pataria, Chak Jalalda, VOJaces 01 the Daaprprll ~ Akaira Jagir, Nahareda (Jagir), (51) Laxmipura, Susawan, Basorikhera, Raptawan, Fatehpur, Niyana, Gopal- Momasar, Surjansar, Adsar, Dbeer- pura Mathri, Mathna, Khedli Kesha, desar Chotiyan, Lalasar, Sattasal'. Manpur Jagir, Tatawa Jagir, Bhatsue, Likhmadesar, Rewada, Koontasar. Lisadia, Shambhaspur, Ranieda, Khedli Keetasar Beedawatan, Keetasar, Bhati- llhaidoliya, Banda, Koyalla, Miyada, yan, Bigga, SaUera, Jalabsar, Beetam- Bambuliya, Kheri, Cha~npura, Raroti, sar Lakhansar, Udasar Cham.. Lyharia. Ud~asar Bas (West and East), Bholly., Thukariasar, Toliasar, Jaitasar, Lakba- sar Jodaasar, Janjeu, Seruna, Samand- (47) sar' Poonarasar, Manakrasar, Beejasar. Deiwan Bas Lodera. Gusainsar, Raj- Ulti jagir, Kotrisunda, Rithod, Shah- pura. Dheerdesar, Prohitan, Lad~ya, ,garh, Tajgarh, Majravta, Kalyanpura, Baibisar, Gajpura, Gopalsar, Deralsarz Ghata, Sambalpur, Chandpura, Chirari, Narsisar Chak Heerawtan, BaSl Bhatt Khed!, Jaloida, Gugalhedi, Heerawt~n, Chak Basi Mamotan, Basi Hanutia, Khedahedi, Hikar, Naredi Marnotan. (Jagir). Villages 01. the Nohar Tehsil Villages 01 the Talera TehsiJ (52) (48) GOJameri Ramgarh, Parika, Bar- wali,o Dee'plana, Nohar. Janaiy.. Gamach, Kann, Tirath, Bhawani- Padampura, Rajpuriya, Gudiyat. Ram- pura, Sinta, Marana, Deheet, Sedari, sara, Phephana. Dhani-:Ariyan, Jasana, Chandan Hedi, Sunwansa. Khulanda, Charanwasi, Malvanl, Ratanpura. 'Ladpura, Bhumkhera, Bad',:nda, Bajad, Pichkrai, Dhani Bhanipura. Gaglavada, Bakaspura, Delunda, Vina- yaka, Sanwar, Bhopatpura, Notara, Villages of the Ganganagar Tebsil Titarbasa, Chhapavada, Jalodi, Nenda, .Jamidpura, Khedia, Lamba-Pipal, (53) Raghunathpura, Talera, Jaloda, Aktasa, Kikarwali, 13 L.N.P., 14 L.N.P., 15 Sidari, Mandadi. L.N.P. I, 15 L.N.P. HA, 15 L.N.P. lIB. 16 L.N.P., 17 L.N.P.• 18 L.N.P., 19 Villages 01 the Asnawar Sub-Tehsil L.N.P., 20 I..N.P .. 21 L.N.P., 22 L.N.P.. 23 L.N.P.. 24 L.N.P., 25 L.N.P.. H (49) L.N.P., 27 L.N.P., 28 L.N.P. I. 28 L.N.P. 11, Potikhiyan, 19' M.L., 20 M.L. I. Asnawar, Talwadia, Khedla, Man- 20 M L. II, 21 M.L., 22 M.L., 23 M.L.. purq, Gaonri, Arnia, Badidia, Dhanoda, 24 M.L.. 25 M.L.. 10 M.L., 9 M.L. : Nesar, Jatambari, Ananda (Anda), 8 M.L., 7 M.L., 6 M.L., 18 M.L., 1 HB.. Bhimli, Gadgaeh, Drabli, Kanskhedli, 2 H.H. I, 2 H.H. II. 3 H.H., 4 H.B., Lawasal, Badia Gordhanpura, Roop- 5 H.H., 6 H.H., 7 H.H.. 8 H.H.• 9 HA, pura Badlia. Piplia-Gujran. Todi Son- 10 H.H., 11 H.H., 12 H.H., 13 H.B., pura, Gaup\ua, Ganeshpura, Sal-ki- 1 B.B., 17 G.G., 18 G.G., 19 G.G.. Dungri, Guda, Baredi, Mankund, Nala, 20 G.G.. 1 L.L., 3 L.L.• 4 L.L., 5 L.L.. Rangpatan, Gadiamet, Khajuri Kalan, 6 L.L., 7 L.L.. 8 L.L., 9 LL.. 10 L.L.. Kanwarpura, Mohamedpura and Naya- 11 L.L., 12 L.L., 21 G.G., 22 G.G.• :gaon, Ghhotiyakhedi, Dungargoan, 23 G.G., 31 G.G., 32 G.G., 24 G.G... Tokdi and Baldevpur, Semli Gokul, 25 G.G., 26 G.G., 27 G.G., 28 G.G.. Malatonta, Naya Gaon, Khar Khesa. 29 G.G., 30 G.G., Chunawadh, 30 G.G.. Udaipur Khushhal. 34 G.G .• 36 G.G. I, Villages 01 the BikaDer TehsU :l6 G.G. II. 16 g, 15 g. (50) The motions were adopted. Ghadhwala, Kesardesar, Bobran, Dr. Ambedkar: I accept amendment .Barsinghsar, Saroopdesar, Lalamdsar, No. 1 in Supplementary List 3 bJ' 'Basi, Kalyansar Bada, Ambisar Shri M. L. Verma and others. 'Chohannan, Baehhasar, Geegasar, Sur- -dhana-Cbohanan, Surdhana Bas Pari- Mr. J)eputy-Speaker: The QuestioD haran, Sujasar. KUehu Bas Deoran, is: Kilehu Bas Selotan, Bhojusar, Kesar- [For text of the motion see Amend- desa.r Gangaguran, Deshnoke, Saroop- ment No. 1 in S.L. No .. 3 printed Ja -desar, Palana, Jorhbeer, Nenoka Bas, Appendix xxxm. annexure 2.} .Bhojanshala, Kesardasarjatan, Kalyan- ur-A;Juna. Kalyansar, Utrada. '!be motion was adOPted. 106M Mottcms reo DelfmftaUcm of e JtJNI: It51 Coutttucndei Onfn', 1851 lOUT N Dr. Aahdbr: I acc~Pt ~~enclmen~ I):' amended to the extent of th~ ameado b OSS' hI toJ ot Supplementary Ust No. 5 ments. y ri n. C. Upadhyaya. ' , Mr. DePuty-Speaker' is: . The questiOQ S>WRASHTRA ORDER ~. Th~t in motions Nos. 1 and 3 Dr. ADahedkar: I accept amendments: POndnte? In CO~so1idated Ust (Rajasthan Nos. 1 and 2 ot List No. 1 by Mr. C. C. r er) standmg in my f Shah and Shri Hathi. Words "item B" "it name, or the "'t " ' ems E and F" and 1 em G wherever they OCCur the ~.ords and figures "or item (31)" Shri C. C. Shah (Saurashtra): A. Ite~ (37) ~nd (38)" and "or item regards amendment No. 2 in List 1 it (36) respectIvely be substituted. says that the plural constituency of' 'Limbdi-Lakhtar-Dasadl}' be split up .into two general constituencies. That . 2. That. in mOti.on No. 3(10) printed has been done in List 2. I ask fOI In Co~soh~ated LIst (Rajasthan Order) leave that amendment No.2 in List 1 standm'f. In my name, against the be substituted by the amendment jo, entry Jodhpur Tehsil North", in List 2. ~olumn 2, the words "villages of" in hne 7 and the words "specified in item No. A of the Appendix" be omitted. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The question: is: . 3. That. in ml)li.on No. 3(11) printed In C0!lsoh~ated LIst (Rajasthan Order) standIng m my name. against the That the following modifications be' entry "Pha·lodi", in column 2 the made in the Delimitation of Parlia-· words "villages of" and the ~ords mentary and Assembly Constituencies.. "specified in item No. A of the Appen- (Saurashtra) Order, 1951 laid 00 the' dix" be omitted. Table on 16th May, 1951, namely:- The motion was adoDted. 1. That at page 2, Table B.- Assembly Constituencies, for the' The other amendments were; by leave entries "Limbdi" and "Wadhwan" of the House, withdrawn. occurring in column I, and all other' entries occurring against them III Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The President's columns 2, 3 and 4, the follOwing be' Order relating to Rajasthan stands substituted, namely:- 2 8 , , . Limbdi Wadhwan The village groUJolII of Kantharia, Bhoika, Choki~ 2 1 Bhadakva, VeJaIka, Chhatr'ala, Chuda, Chokdl and Vastedi of Limbdi Taluka and Wadhwan Taluka excluding Khodu and Nagra village groups. 2. That at page 2. Table B.-As- column I, and all other entries O<'Cur- sembly Constituencies for the entry ring against it in columns 2, 3 and ., the· "Limbdi-Lakhtar-Dasada" occurring in following be substituted. namely:- '---~------.-..---.------2 3 , Limbdi·Lakhtar The village g.:J:r: of Shiani, Anke\-alia. Limbdi. I Pan'lir.a, H , Balot, RaloJ, Jambu, Mul~avJa and Re.r.agadh of, Limbdi Taluka and Village group!! of Lakhtar. Lilapur, Bapodara and Nann Ankevalia of Lakhtar Taluka. Da.sada-J.. akhtar Dasada Taluka and village 'groups of De",alia. Talsa- 1 ~,Vithalgadh, Chharad and Malin of Lakhtar Taluka. The motion was '--+------,-,--adopted. ------10598 Motton. reo DelfmlttJtton of 9 JUNE 1151 Cout,tuende. Orden. INt I ...... ,~; Mr. Depuiy-Speaker: To the extent Mr. J)epDty-Speaker: Only two mote· of these amendments the Saurashtra orders relating to U.P. and the Punjab Order of the President stands modified. are outstanding. If there is unaniIrilt,.· in the House we can meet as late as There is no other amendment. possible, for I do not want to give the- impression that I have muzzled them. Dr. Ambedka.r: As regards the jf anybody wants to speak. Travancore and Cochin Order there is no .amendment. A corrigenda has Sbri AmoJakb ChaDd: Can we not: adjourn for half an hour and then been issued. continue for the simple reason that at. Shri R. Velayudhan (Travancore- 4-30 P.M. Members may not come? Cochi~: There were some discrep- ancies in printing. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: The Minister must have sufficient time to consider' Shri Lakshmanan (Travancore-Co- the amendments. chin): They have all been covered Sbri T. T. Krishnamachari (Madras):- by th~ corrigenda. Is there no other business? PART C STATES ORDER: DELHI . Mr. Deputy-Speaker: NQ other busi-- ness except passing these two orders. Dr. Ambedkar: I accept amendment No. 2 in Consolidated List (in the The House then adjourned till Half name of Shri Kesava Rao and others). Past Four of the Clock. Mr. Deputy-Speaker: Tl!e question is: The House re-assembled at Half Past- [For text of the motion see amend- Four of the Clock. ment No. 2 standing in the name of Shri Kesava Rao and Dr. Gangadhar [MR. SPEAKER in the Chair] Siva in the Consolidated List relating to the Part C States Order printed in PuNJAB ORDER Appendix XXXIII. annexure 1.] Mr. Spe-.&ker: We will now proceed with the Punjab Order. May I know- The motion was adopted. the Nos. of the agreed amendments?- I think we will follow the same proce-- Mr. Deputy-Speaker: There are no dure as in the morning. other amendments, I suppose. The President's Order relating to Part C Dr. AmbNkar: The agreed- amend-- States stands modified to the extent ments are as follows: of the amendment just now carried. Other amendments by Dr. Ambedkar List 7.-Amendment No.2, part 5,. and others, if any, are to be withdrawn sub-part (i) and sub-part (il), of Sbri by the leave of the House. B. L. Sondhi, Chaudhuri Ranbir Singh- and others. The other amendments were, by leave withdrawn. ' List 9.-Amendment No.6, parts 2· and 3, of Prof. Yashwant Rai. .Dr. Ambe~r: Only two other pro- VInces remam, namely U.P. and List lO.-~nly the ftrst amendment Punjab. Several amendments have in the list I move. come just now and I have not had time to apply mind to them. If the r do not move the second and the- parties concerned are prepared to go third amendments as these are super- by the original arrangement then I am seded by amendments Nos. 5 (i) of- prepared to proceed further. But I List 7 and 3(6) of List 12. find that some changes have been List 12.-Amendment No.1, parts 1 introduced and r must have a clear and 2, of Shri B. L. Sondhi, Ch. Ranbir· understanding of what is sought to be done. I personally think that half an Singh and others. hour in the afternoon would be more Amendment No. 2 of Sardar- than enough. for both the Provinces. Bhopinder Singh Man and others. .. ' modifted by amendment in List No. 13. Shrl Shiv Chuan LaI: There mIcht of Ch. Ranbir Singh and others. be dUIlculty then with regard to the· quorum, because Members of other Amendmen~ No.3. parts f. 5 and ,. States may be absent from the House. (second part) of Shri Sondhi. eta.. uoeoo Motion, reo DelimitatIon of 9 JUNE 1951 Constituencie. Orde... , 1951 10101 [Dr. Ambedkar] .Ranbir Singh and others with minor 2 J ._--_.. _------... ------_._-----,._------Jagraon. Jagraon Tehsil ! 1 Ludhiana Sadar N ul'pllr B"t" Baddowal,' Dh!1.nura Lalton Kalan GIll and Dha.ndari Kalan zai1s of Ludhiana &ada~ thana, am' Shankar and Ha.n Zails of Delhon tnana I.' nel Dakha Zail of Dakha thana of Ludhiana Tehsil. ~elhon . Pa.khowal and Andlu Zai1s of R&i Kot thana tmd Delhon thana (excluding Shankar and Hans ZaiIB) of Llldniana Tehsi1. '------~------~.------ Amendment No.4, parts 1 and 2 of Pandit Thakur Das Bhargava and List lO.---Qnly the first amendment Chaudhuri Ranbir Singh. in the list. List 12.-Amendment No. I, parts 1 These are the amendments I am and 2, of Shri B. L. Sondhi, Ch. Ranbir prepared to accept, Sir. Singh and others. Mr. Speaker: I take it no other han. Amendment No. 2 of Sardar Member wishes me to put any of his Bhopinder Singh Man and others, as motion to the House. modified by amendment in List No. 13. of Ch. Ranbir Singh and others. Well, then I shall dispose of these amendments first. Amendment No.3, parts 4, 5 and G (second part) of Shri Sondhi and The question is: others, with minor consequential changes in part 6 (second part) as [For text of the motions see follows: List 7.-Amendment No.2, part 5, 6. At pa,~e 6. in Table B.- sub-part (i) and sub-part (ii), of Shri Assembly Constituencies, for the 'B. L. Sondhi, Chaudhuri Ranbir Singh entries 'Ludhiana Sadar', 'Jagraon" and others. and 'Raikot' in column 1 and all the entries occurring against them in List 9.-Amendment No.6, parts 2 columns 2. 3 and 4. substitute the 'and 3, of Prof. Yashwant Rai. foUowing:- 1 2 3 , . Jagraon. Jagraon Tehall . I Ludhiana Sader Yurpur Bet, Baddowal, Dhandra. Lalton Kalan, Gill and Dhandari Kalan zaila or Ludhiana Sadar thana, and Shankar and HaD Zails or Delhon thana and Dakha Zail or Dakha thana of Ludbiana Tebail. ~l)elhon .' Pakhowal and AndIu Zails or Rai Kot. tbana and 1 Delbon thaaa (exoluding Shankar and Hans ~la) of Ludhiana Tehail. printed in Appendix XXXIII, anne- subject to the insertion of i'I.AJ. xures 3, 4.] . Domestic Camp" after "Chakeri Aer0- drome" in the entry in coL 2 aaaJatt- The motions were adopted. Kanpur (East). Mr. Speaker: To this e2(tent the List 8.-Amendment No.4, parts 1· President's Order is modified. and 2, of Shri K. C. Sharma. Now leave is asked for to withdraw Amendment No. 5 of Shri Beni amendments Nos. 2 and 3 in List No. 10 Singh and others. and all the other motions that have been moved. Amendment No.7, parts 1 to 4, ot The amendments were, by leave, Shri Amolakh Chand. withdrawn. Amendments Nos. 8. and 10 of Shrt Ch. Ranbir Singh: There is a clerical Beni Singh and others. error here, Sir. Amendment No. 12, parts 1 and 2~ Mr. Speaker: As I have pointed out, of Shri K. C. Shar-ma. all technical errors and apparent Amendment No. 1-1 of Shri T. N. mistakes may be brought to the Singh. attention of the hon. Minister of Law and they will be put through as conse- List 9.-Amendments Nos. 1, 4, 5 quential amendments. and 6. Now let us go to the U.P. Order. Amendments Nos. 2, 7 and 8 subject to the following modifications proposed UTTAR PRADESH ORDER by me: Dr. Ambedkar: Sir, the agreed That in the motions in List No. 9 amendments are as follows: (Uttar Pradesh Order) standing in my List I.-Amendment No. 1 of Pandit ,name tne following amendments be - Shiv Charan Lal. made:- List 7.-Amendment No.2, parts 1, 1. That in motion No.2, at page 3 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6, of Shri C. D. Pande. of the List, against the entry "Allah- abad District (East) cum J aunpur Dis- Amendment No.5 of Shri Sohan Lal trict (West)" for the words "(excluding and others subject to substitution vf the Munciipality and Cantonment of "Basti District (Central East) cum Allahabad" ill column III. the words Gorakhpur District East" for "Basti "Chail tehsil (excluding the Munici- District (Central East) cum Hasanpur pality and Cantonment of Allahabad" Pargana", in col. 1. be substituted. Amendment No.6, part 2, of Shri Satish Chandra. 2. That in motion No.2, at page 3 of the List. after the entry "Allahabad Amendment No. 9 of Babu Gopinath District (West)" the following entry be Singh and Pandit Balkrishna Sharma, inserted:- I II ill Gorakhpur Di;;trict. (CU1- such 01 H.e Patwari circles of i;.uch of the Patwari circle and tral). Ha"cli pargana of Pbarcnco) fore.. t aree.s of na,·p.li par. tehsil of Gorakhpur Dir trict gana of Pharpnda tc.bsil of as are ,'pecified in item (94) of Gorakhpur Di&trict as are the Appendix. speCified in item \94) of tha AppfmHx." 3. That in motion No.8, at page 12 Baghpur, Sobhan, Baghwat, Nehuta, of the List, for items Nos. (3S) and (39) Rastpur, Kakar Dahl, Bairisawai, of the proposed Appendix, the follow- Marag, Rampur Sheoli, Kandri, ing items be substituted: - . Bhewan, Nunari Bahadurpur, Bara- gaon, Baranpur Kahinjari, Kasbipur "Patwari circles of Akbarpur Tebsll Deepchand, Kashipur Hiraman, Kashi- (38) pur Jagamman Shah, Kashipur Shur- shah, Hatika, Manda, Kekarmau. Singhpur SahoU; Nqvada Deorani, Naubasta, Bhaupur, Pitrapur, Ant. Jaitpur SheoU, Hiraman Sheoli, Raipalpur, Baluwapur, Lalpur and- Dhakan SheoU, Saraiyan, Baridaryao, Aliapur. JOeo. MottoM reo De'im'tc&tfcm 01 ·9 JUNE 1951 C~ o.-r..1tI1.- I . . [l)r.Ambedkar] Dr. A ...... : ThOle .am., ...... Patwarl circles of DeraD1U' TwU on wbicb there was Ieneral .... ment were accepted. In reeard to the (39) particular amendment ~erred to .",. the hon. Member it is No. 14 in JUt Nandpur, Sargaon Khurd, Mungisa- No.8. pur, Derapur !plas, Salirnpur, Sabdal- :pur, ~urhawal, Maujpur, Agwasi, Paadi' Kuazra: My hon. triead Ursan, Padnai, Korawa, Amauli Kur- Dr. Ambedkar says tbat those ameJJd. ;mian, 'Hathuma, Mukbilpur, Daryapur ments have been accepted about which Netarah, Garhiya Sikandra, Moham- there was general agreement. I do madpur Sultanpur, Jagannathpur, not know what be means by "general Sandalpur, Haswan, Jamaura, Revan, agreement". If be meant amDIl8 Hawaspur, Ankna, Pendarathu, Sahni.- the members of the majority party. 'pur, Chamrawa, Kasolar, Achhraull, obviously there could have been agree- · Dharampur, Indrukh, Sargaon Buzurg, ment on many other points. If that Jignis, Galuwapur and Baragaon was the only basis on whicb the Bhikhi." modifications were to be made, there was no need for the appointment of 4. That in motion N? 2, at page 1 a Delimitation Advisory Committee. ·of the List, the entries relatmg to But I should like to know whether ·"Almora District (West) cum Garhwal apart from the fact that there was District (East)" be deleted. agreement on those points, there was any other reason for their acceptance. 5. That in motion No.2, at page ~, the following be deleted:- Dr. Ambedkar: Well, I think the hon. House knows that we have been (i) The entries relating to "Kanp~r proceeding upon the basis of the 'District (North) cum Farruk~abad DIS- decision of Members of the various trict (South-East) cum TehsIl Etawah committees which were appointed by District (East)" in the two places the Speaker to delimit the constituen- 'where they occur. cies and whenever the Members have (ii) agreed to make a change, I have The entries relating to "Etawah thought it fit to accept that cbange. District (West) ". No. 14 which I am accepting is one (iii) The entri25 relating to "Kanpur such amendment. District (South)". Pandit K1lDZl'1l: Does he mean 6 That in motion No.7, at page 6 Members of the majority party or of . the List the entries relating to does he mean the Members of the '''Kanpur City (South)", "Kanpur committee appointed by tbe Speaker? (Central)", "Ghatampur <:Yest) ~m Dr. Ambedkar: With regard to that, Bhognipur (East)" and BhognlPU~ I should like to point out that so far · (South-East>' cum Akbarpur (South) as delimitation is concerned. no dis- be deleted. tinction bas been observed between Members of the majority party and 7 That in motion No.8, in the Members of any other party. All Appendix, item No. 17-A relating to Members have been invited to place Patwari circles of Meerut Pargana be their views before this Cabinet Sub- . omitted. Committee which was appolnted to examine this matter. Any member, I withdraw amendment No. 3 in List irrespective of the party to which he No.9. belonged, had the freedom to come Amendment No. 3 in List No. 9 was, and plead his cause. Some Members by leave, withdrawn. did come. Mr. Speaker: So I am taking all of Shrl T. N. Siqh (Uttar Pradesh): them together. Do the hon. Members Sir as my name has been broUCht in I wish to take anyone of them inde- wo~ld ask your permision to say a few '-pendentlY? If that is so I have no words. It is only thls that the amend- ment to which my hon. friend referred objection. is only a consequential amendment Pandlt Kunzru (uttar Pr8:desh):. which sbould have been made and I wan~ to know ·what is the pnnciple which by error was not made in the ·on which all these amendtnents have report of the Committee. I can been accepted. I find that one of the explain the details persoually to him, · amendments bas been tabled . by a as it Is 'I:\C)t ~ble to explain It Ilere. member of the Committee, Shri T. N. ·M~ . sPeaker:- Does any other Mem- · Slngh. I would, in partlcular like to ber Wish to take' up bfs motion Inde- .. .mow what that amendment Is. . pendently? 't .' Slart J. .. Kapoor. I have one or instead of the percenta,e ot Sebed111ed ·two amendments to the Order. Cute electors being 32, as it thea w. Mr. Speaker: Is it in the agreed it might now be 34·5. I should have .list or beyond the agreed list? thoUCht. Sir, that this very reuoaabJe' amendment which was ooce made b7 Shr!· J. R. Kapoor: The agreed list the Delimitation Committee itself aod bas already been given by the hon. which· has now been repeated by me Minister. should have been readily agreed to and accepted. I do not know, Sir. Mr. Speaker: So he wants to move what valid reasons there are for not .something else. May I know what they a~reeing to them. It appears to me• .are? SIr, that a great injustice is being Shri J. R. Kapoor: Sir, the amend- perpetrated on the Scheduled Caste ments which I wish to press are: electors of Agra City. If I had known the reasons for the non-acceptance of Amendment in List No.7, Page my amendments I would have been ~No. 5. satisfied. But I am compelled to move Amendnment No.7, List No. 10, these amendments and even at tb1s Page No.4. . late stage I hope and trust. good List No. 11, Page I, No. 1 and No.2. sense, logic and a sense of justice and fairplay would impel the hon. Minister Sir, all these amendments are alter- to accept one of them. .native amendments and the acceptance of anyone of them would satisfy me Dr. Ambedkar: Sir, I hope this and serve the purpose I have in view. matter was discussed in the committee ·The only purpose of these amendments and I told Mr. Kapoor that his amend- is to secure representation, even ment was incomplete and therefore though it may be of a limited extent, could not be accepted without caUSing to the Scheduled Caste electors of Agra disturbance to other constituencIes.. City. Hitherto, Sir, Agra City used He was not able to give a complete 10 send two representatives to t.he scheme where the thing would be State Assembly. Out of these one was fitted in with the rest. That is the a Scheduled Caste representative. reason why this amendment was not Now while Agra district will be send- considered. ing ten members, and Agra City 3 re- presentatives, the Agra City Scheduled Shri J. R. Kapoor: rose- Caste representatives will not be able Mr. Speaker: The hon. Member has to send even one. This is obviously no right of reply. Does he wish me to unfair hnd unjust to the Scheduled put these to the House now? Caste electors of Agra City. I have, therefore, tabled these amendments to Shri J. R. Kapoor: Of course. though secure some partial representation to it may be rejected. the Scheduled Caste electors of Agra City. Mr. Speaker: Then I shall plaCf them before the House. One significant fact to which I would like to draw the attention of ShrJ J. R. Kapoor: No, Sir, I would the hon. the Law Minister and the like to wtihdraw them. House is that in the constituencies that I have suggested there is the The amendmel~ts of Shri J. R. KapooJ largest concentratjon of Scheduled were. by leave, withdrawn. Caste electors, particularly in the constituency which I have suggested Mr. Speaker: I will now put .n tho in my amendment No. 11 the percen- agreed amendments which the La... tage of scheduled castes is 34·5. If Minister has placed. The question is: the hon. the Law Minister had care- fu.U.y considered my suggestion, he [For text of the motions see would not have ignored the rights of those Scheduled Caste electors. There List I.-Amendment No. 1 of Pandi is nothing novel in the amendment. Shiv Charan Lal. As a matter of fact it is very much based on the scheme presented before List 7.-Amendment No.2, parts J the House. by the Delimitation Com- 2, 3, 4. 5 and 6, of Shri C. D. Pande. mittee itself. On page 10 of their reOort. they have suggested that the Amendment No. 5 of Shri Sohan La teh$ils of Karoli and Agra should he and. others subject to subsUtutioa 0 combined into one constituency. I "Basti District (Central East)· 1 c:u, bave· ~r;l.cticallv suggeste4. the. same Qnrakb"'ur District East" f!''' "Bast thing, only with some sUght addition District (Central East) c:um· Rasanp ot two wards of Alra Ctiy, 80 that . P8J'Iana", in col. 1. 10608 Motion. re. DenmltCItlcm of 9 JUNE 1901 Cotutltunde. Or.,." 1"1 [Mr. Speaker] I_ Amendment No.6, part 2, of Shrt an~i19.-Amendments No.. I, f, • Satish Chandra. Amendment No.9 of Babu Gopinath Amendments Nos. 2, 7 and 8 subject Singh and Pandit Balkrlshna Sharma to the following modifications: subject to the insertion of "I.A.F: Domestic Camp" after "Chakeri Aero- In the motions in List.. No. 9 (Uttar drome" in the entry in col. 2 against Pradesh Order) standing in the name Kanpur (East). of Dr. Ambedkar substitute the follow- ing: List 8.-Amendment No.4, parts 1 and 2, of Shri K. C. Sharma. 1. In motion No.2, at page 3 ot the Amendment No. 5 of Shri Beni List, against the entry "Allahabad Singh and others. District (East) cum Jaunpur District (West)" for the words "(excluding the Amendment No.7, parts 1 to 4, of Municipality and Cantonment of Allah- Shri Amolakh Chand. abad'.' in column III, substitute the- words "Chail tehsil (excluding the- Amendments Nos. 8 and 10 of Shri Municipality and Cantonment of Beni Singh and others. Allahabad". Amendment No. 12, parts 1 and 2, of Shri K. C. Sharma. 2. In motion No.2, at page 3 of the· List, after the entry "Allahabad Dis- Amendment No. 14 of Shri T. N. trict (West)" insert the following Singh. entry: I III Gorakhpur District (Cen- such of the Patwari circles of such of the Patwa.ri circle and' tral). Ha...,.c1i pargana of Pharenda forest areas of Haveli par- tehilil of Gora.k1:-pur District yana of Pha.renda tehail ~ u.s are specifi~d in item (94) Gora.khpur District as are of the Appendix. specified in item (94) of tho Appendix... 3. In motion No.8, at page 12 of Sandalpur, Haswan, Jamaura, Revan. the List, for items Nos. (38) and (39) Hawaspur, Ankna, Pendarathu, Sahni- of the proposed !-.ppendix, substitute pur, Chamrawa, Kasolar, Achhrauli, the following items:- Dharampur, Indrukh, Sargaon Buzurg. "Patwari circles of Akbarpur Tehsil Jignis. Galuwapur and Baragaol1 Bhikhi." (38) Singhpur Saholi, Nevada Deorani, 4. In motion No.2, at page 1 of the Jaitpur Sheoli, Hiraman Sheoli, List., omit the entries relating to Dhakan Sheoli, Saraiyan, Baridaryao, "Almora District (West) cum Garhwal Baghpur, Sobhan, Baghwat, Nehuta, District (East)". Rastpur, Kakar Dahl, Bairisawai, Marag, Rampur Sheoli, Kandri, 5. In motion No.2, at page 2, omit Bhewan, Nunari Bahadurpur, Bara- the following: gaon, Baranpur Kahinjari, Kashipur "(i) The entries relating to Deepchand, Kashipur Hiraman, Kashl- "Kanpur District (North) cum pur Jagamman Shah, Kashipur Bhur- P'arrukhabad District (South-East) shah, Hatika, Manda, Kekarmau. cum Tehsil Etawah District (East)'· Naubasta, Bhaupur, Pitrapur, Ant, in the two places where they occur. Raipalpur, Baluwapur, Lalpur and Aliapur. (if) The entries relating to Patwari circles of Derapur TehsU "Etawah District (West)". (39) (iii) The entries relating to "Kanpur District (SOuth)... • Nandpur, Sargaon Khurd, Mungisa- pur, Derapur Khas,· Salimpur, Sabdal- 6. In motion No.7, at page 8 of the pur, Kurhawal, . Maujpur, Agwasi, Ust, omit the entries relatlnar to Ursan, Padnai, Korawa, Amauli Kur- "Kanpur City (South)". "Kanpur mian, Hathuma, Mukbllpur, Daryapur . (Central)", "Ghatampur (West) cum Netarah, Garhiya Sikandra, Moham- BhOtmh)Ur (East)" and "BholDfpur madpur SWtanpur, Jacannathpur. (South-East) cum Akbarpur (South)- lOUIO Motions re Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Comtituencie. Order., 1951 10111 7. In motion No.8, in the Appendix, Mr. Speaker: It has not been placed omit item No. 17-A relating to Patwari before the House. So there is DO aeed circles of Meerut Pargana. to withdraw it. . printed in Appendix XXXIII, anne- Sbr! ChaUopadbyay: I have an xure 3.] amendment to this amendment. I bee to move: . The motions were adopted. In the Consequential Amendment Sbri Hyder Husein (Uttar Pra- standing in the name of Dr. Ambedkar. desh): I had moved an amendment after the words "formal chanps'". (List No.3). I propose to withdraw insert the words "including nomencla- it. But with your permission I would ture of Constituencies". like to make a short statement before doing 50. Mr. Speaker: Does the hon. Minister accept it? I had tabled this amendment to give etIect to the recommendations of my Dr. Ambedkar: I cannol accept it State. The U.P. Government had in this formal and binding character. suggested the creation of 57 two- The Prime Minister (Sbrl lawa.hu- member constituencies over and above 1&1 Nebru): I take it, Sir, that if a those reserved for the Scheduled name is wrongly spelt it will be Castes. There is no reservation for correctly spelt. That does not need a other minorities under the Constitution formal amendment. U there are mtnor and so my State desired to have these errors I take it that they can al1rQs 57 multi-member constituencies in be corrected. order to give a better chance to them. This number was fixed on a popula- Shri Chattopadbyay: There was tiO.1 oasis as their number is 85 lakhs goo:i deal of discussion this mominl in my State. This recommendation over this and there was some differ- was not accepted by the Government ence of opinion too in this matter and . of India and was not even considered Dr. Ambedkar said "Let this matter by the Delimitation Committee. I of nomenclature be left to the accordingly moved my amendment Speaker". and it had a good reception among the Dr. Ambedkar: I admit. But I said Members of my State. But it had its if the Speaker thought that the change repercussions in other States and the in nomenclature of a place is a formal hon. the Prime Minister advised us to change; then it will be covered by my drop the matter. In view of that advice I crave the leave of the House amendment. to withdraw my' amendment. Shri ChattopadbyaJ': It is for this reason that I have tabled this amend- llr. Speaker: Has the hon. Member, ment. as also the other' hon. Members who have moved amendments, the leave of Mr. Speaker: What does he want the House to withdraw their amend- me to do now? ments? Shri CbaHopadhyaJ': I would like that after the words "formal changes" The amendments were, by leave, the words "including nomenclature of withdrawn. Constituencies" should be inserted. It Mr. Speaker: That disposes of all is not formal. It is in my opinion the motions. Now I shall take up con- very substantial, beeause in some seque!ltial amendments. cases ...... Dr. Ambedkar: I beg to move: Mr. Speaker: I understand his point If he urges that it is a substantial "That with reference to the thing, no amendment can DOW be amendments to the Delimitation of made. If it is a formal or c0nse- Parliamentary and Assembly quential amendment which will Constituencies Orders moved and include also sometimes, as Dr. Ambed- accepted by the House necessary kar said, even a change in nomencla- consequential, drafting and other ture, then matters will stand cIlffer. formal c~anges be carried out; in ently. Therefore it is no use haviDa the said Orders under the autho- this amendment. rity of the Honourable the Speaker." . Slid J. B. Kapoer. Do we take it that the cJaanae of the name of • Dr. Deshmukh: I have given notice constltuenc1, if it does not materiall:l' of a siQIar amendment. I be, to or even aliahtb' ehaDh the exteat·, of withdraw it. the COdStfW-C7. is covend b7 157 PSO. Dr. Ambedkar's motloo? 10612 Motion, re DeZimitation of 9 JUNE 1951 Con.tituencie. ,"fierI, 1951 1_ Dr. Ambedkar: It is in the discretion the West Bengal Govern.ment. the of the Speaker. Delimitation Committee appointed b7 you, the Election Conuniuioo.. aad . Mr. Speaker: The House has Members of Parliament from West accepted certain modifications. The Bengal excluding my friend Mr. Mlhlr· House is gOing to give powers to the Lal Chattopadhyay were all abs0- Speaker to make amendments of a lutely unanimous. It is not a quesUon consequential or formal character of three, four or five villages. The because, as was said, I believe, in the whole question was gone into. As a morning, there may be a mjs-descrip- matter of fact tbe question of shorten- tion of a boundary. Instead of "east" ing the names of constituencies was it might have been stated as "west". gone into at considerable length in the Only such amendments will be put Delimitation Committee, and it had through. There can be no further the full concurrence of the West amendments now. Even by the Bengal Government and the Election unanimous decision of the House the Commission. Having been defeated Chair cannot go beyond the decisions on that...... of the House. The Chair will do only what is absolutely necessary to give effect to the decisions already arrived Mr. Speaker: Now the hon. Member at by the House. That is the spirit in will see that there is no use ,oin& which the consequential amendments into the merits of that. As I have will take place. said, all consequential and formal amendments will take place. And as Shri Chattopadhyay: i\Iay I submit the hon. the Leader of the House has one thing for your discretion? In the pointed out, if there is a mis-descrip- case of some constituencies in West tion which is necessary to be correct- Bengal it is found that constituencies ed, certainly it will be a consequential covering three districts have got the change, and I shall consider it. But name of the constituency in the name that does not mean a wholesale change of only one. village of one district. will be made. It requires no further The name is neither the name of any clarification now. I shall therefore put of the three districts nor the name of this motion. any of the three sub-divisions nor the name of any division of the district Paadit KDllZrn: The procedure that but only the name of a village from you have suggested will no doubt be which possibly one Member of Parlia- convenient and may also be desirable. ment comes. But may I know under what law or Pandit Maitra: I take objection to rules this procedure can be followed? it, Sir. Under the Representation of the People Act it is the House that has to Shri Jawaharlal Nehru: Sir, the decide what changes should be made mCltter has been left to your discre- in the Order issued by the President. tion. I think it should remain there. The House may make certain mis- The actual thing is the delimitation. takes. But could the Speaker or could I would submit to you, Sir, that where anybody have the power to rectify you in your discretion think that the those mistakes? If for instance in an actual description requires a change, Act some mistakes have been made you can certainly do so. and something is there which obviously should have been deleted because Several HoD. Members: Yes, yes. of some amendment made in some other section, neither the Law Ministry Pandit Maitra: Sir, the point is nor the Government have any power sought to be revived by my friend to alter it except by means of a Bill Mr. Mihir Lal Chattopadhyay. This brought before the House and adopted question was discussed at consider- by it. I should, therefore, like to know, able length before the House broke for however convenient the procedure lunch. My friend at the eleventh suggested by you may be, wbat i$ the hour has brought 108 amendments authority under which it can be changing the nomenclature of consti- followed? tuencies delimited in West Ben_at It is not a question of one or two names. 5 P.M. It was discussed and at the last moment my friend declared with a Mr. Speaker: In the flrst place, the heavy heart 'I withdraw my amend- hon. Member, I think. is labourinC ments'. That Is what happened. under a misconception in statin.c the proposition so wtdel7 as be has done. With regard to the nomenclature of Even in cases of Bills which are ~ the constituencies in West Bencal let by this Housel I believe, it is not 0Dl7 me point out to you that In this matter the practice out it Is the InhereDt I; 10614 Motions re Delimitation of 9 JUNE 1951. Papers l4id on the Tab!.. IGlb constituencies OrdeTs. 1951. power of the Speaker, as representing Parliamentary and Assembb' the House, to correct all patent, Constituencies' Orders moved and clerical, spelling and such other conse- accepted by the House, neceasar;y quential mistakes. That is also pro- consequential, drafting and other vided in the Rules of Procedure. formal changes be carried out in Supposing a new section is added and the said Orders under the au~ tw6 sections are numbered as section rity of the hon. Speaker." 14 and section 14, is it seriously con- tended that it is not in the competence The motion was adopted. of the Speaker or anybody to correct the sequence of numbers and that the corrections can be made by coming to the House by a separate independent PAPERS LAID ON THE TABLE Bill? It is too much to say so. AGREEMENT BETWEEN INDIA AND NETBEIl- -rhis power is well known and it is LANDS Te AIR SERVICES technically described as 'patent errors' and 'errors on the face of the record'. Tbe Deputy MiDister of Collllllerce This is similar to the power of a judge and Industry (Sbrl Karmarkar): I lay to correct mistakes in the judgment on the business and it brings to a close which is delivered; it does not go between the Government of India and beyond that and in this particular the Government of Netherlands relat- case there is a specific motion now ing to air services in pursuance· of a coming before the House that for promise given in reply to Starred· carrying out all amendments which question No. 3440, dated 24th AprU are consequential, drafting and other 1951. [See Appendix XXVIII, Anne- formal changes, the House vests the xure 68]. Speaker with authority and in any . case. whatever doubt is felt, it is set Mr. Speaker: This is the last item at rest by the authority given by the on the Table a copy of the agreement House. It is not merely a matter of the very long and strenuous session convenience, but even of strict adher- that we had and I think. I must con. .ence to legal and constitutional forms. gratulate the Members for the good spirit all round shown, particularly in The question is: the end. for the last two days. "That with reference to the amendments to the Delimitation of The House then adjourned sine die.