Journal of Mormon History Vol. 33, No. 1, 2007
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of Mormon History Volume 33 Issue 1 Article 1 2007 Journal of Mormon History Vol. 33, No. 1, 2007 Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/mormonhistory Part of the Religion Commons Recommended Citation (2007) "Journal of Mormon History Vol. 33, No. 1, 2007," Journal of Mormon History: Vol. 33 : Iss. 1 , Article 1. Available at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/mormonhistory/vol33/iss1/1 This Full Issue is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Mormon History by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Journal of Mormon History Vol. 33, No. 1, 2007 Table of Contents CONTENTS LETTERS • --Is This Academic Discourse? Dan Vogel, v • --“Tunnel Vision” D. Michael Quinn, xi PRESIDENTIAL ADDRESS • -Toward a Mormon Sense of Time Philip L. Barlow, 1 TANNER LECTURE • --Historical Reflections on Mormon uturF es Stephen J. Stein, 39 ARTICLES • --The 1876 Journal of Frank Hammond: “Travailing” to the Little Colorado John J Hammond, 65 • --“Lonely Bones”: Leadership and Utah War Violence William P. MacKinnon, 121 • --Tensions in David O. McKay’s First Presidencies Gary James Bergera, 179 REVIEWS --Claudia L. Bushman, Contemporary Mormonism: Latter-day Saints in Modern America Glen M. Leonard, 247 --H. Michael Marquardt, The Rise of Mormonism, 1816–1844 Jed Woodworth, 252 --Leonard J. Arrington, Great Basin Kingdom: An Economic History of the Latter-day Saints, 1830-1900 Thomas G. Alexander, 257 --Fred E. Woods, Gathering to Nauvoo David E. Johnson, 260 --David L. Bigler, Fort Limhi: The Mormon Adventure in Oregon Territory, 1855–1858 Samuel J. Passey, 262 --Jana Riess and Christopher Kimball Bigelow. Mormonism for Dummies. J. Nelson-Seawright and Taryn Nelson-Seawright, 265 This full issue is available in Journal of Mormon History: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/mormonhistory/vol33/iss1/ 1 JOURNAL OF MORMON HISTORY SPRING 2007 Mission Statement of the Mormon History Association The Mormon History Association is an independent organization dedi- cated to the study and understanding of all aspects of Mormon history. We welcome all who are interested in the Mormon past, irrespective of reli- gious affiliation, academic training, or world location. We promote our goals through scholarly research, conferences, awards, and publications. COVER: Abstraction of the window tracery, Salt Lake City Tenth Ward. De- sign by Warren Archer. Articles appearing in this journal are abstracted and indexed in His- torical Abstracts and America: History and Life, published by ABC-CLIO, and in Religion Index One: Periodicals, published by the American Theological Library Association. ©2007 Mormon History Association ISSN 0194-7342 Copies of articles in this journal may be made for teaching and re- search purposes free of charge and without securing permission, as permitted by Sections 107 and 108 of the U.S. Copyright Law. For all other purposes, permission must be obtained from the author. The Mormon History Association assumes no responsibility for contri- butors’ statements of fact or opinion. ii Staff of the Journal of Mormon History Editor: Lavina Fielding Anderson Executive Committee: Lavina Fielding Anderson, Sherilyn Cox Bennion, Breck England, G. Kevin Jones, Jennifer L. Lund, Carol Cornwall Madsen, Kahlile B. Mehr, Patricia Lyn Scott Editorial Staff: Elizabeth Ann Anderson, Robert Briggs, Barry C. Cleveland, Linda Wilcox DeSimone, John S. Dinger, John Hatch, Scarlett M. Lindsay, Linda Lindstrom, Craig Livingston, H. Michael Marquardt, Murphy S. Mathews, Stephen R. Moss, Jerilyn Wakefield Editorial Manager: Patricia Lyn Scott Book Review Editor: Tom Kimball Assistant Review Editor: Linda Wilcox DeSimone Indexer: Marjorie Newton Business Manager: G. Kevin Jones Compositor: Brent Corcoran Designer: Warren Archer Board of Editors Polly Aird, Seattle, Washington Douglas D. Alder, St. George, Utah Todd Compton, Mountain View, California Kenneth W. Driggs, Decatur, Georgia Paul M. Edwards, Independence, Missouri B. Carmon Hardy, Orange, California Janet Burton Seegmiller, Southern Utah University, Cedar City, Utah John C. Thomas, BYU—Idaho, Rexburg, Idaho The Journal of Mormon History is published three times a year by the Mormon History Asso- ciation, 581 S. 630 East, Orem, UT 84097, 1-888-642-3678, {[email protected]}. It is dis- tributed to members upon payment of annual dues: regular membership: $45; joint/spouse membership: $55; student membership: $20; institutional membership: $55; sustaining membership: $125; patron membership: $250; donor membership: $500. For subscriptions outside the United States, please add $10 for postage in U.S. currency, VISA, or MasterCArd. Single copies $15. Contact Larry and Alene King, executive direc- tors, at the address above. A fully digitized copy of all back issues up through 2003 is avail- able on DVD for $40. Contact the Kings or order online at www.mhahome.org. The Journal of Mormon History exists to foster scholarly research and publication in the field of Mormon history. Manuscripts dealing with all aspects of Mormon history are welcome, including twentieth-century history, regional and local history, folklore, histori- ography, women’s history, and ethnic/minorities history. First consideration will be given to those that make a strong contribution to knowledge through new interpretations and/or new information. The Board of Editors will also consider the paper’s general in- terest, accuracy, level of interpretation, and literary quality. The Journal does not consider reprints or simultaneous submissions. Papers for consideration must be submitted in triplicate, with the text typed and dou- ble-spaced, including all quotations. Authors should follow the Chicago Manual of Style, 15th edition (the Journal’s style guide is available on the Mormon History Association’s website {www.mhahome.org}) and be prepared to submit accepted manuscripts on com- puter diskette, IBM-DOS format preferred. Send manuscripts to the Journal of Mormon History, P.O. Box 581068, Salt Lake City, UT 84158-1068. iii JOURNAL OF MORMON HISTORY Volume 33, No. 1 Spring 2007 CONTENTS LETTERS Is This Academic Discourse? Dan Vogel v “Tunnel Vision” D. Michael Quinn xi PRESIDENTIAL ADDRESS Toward a Mormon Sense of Time Philip L. Barlow 1 TANNER LECTURE Historical Reflections on Mormon Futures Stephen J. Stein 39 ARTICLES The 1876 Journal of Frank Hammond: “Travailing” to the Little Colorado John J Hammond 65 “Lonely Bones”: Leadership and Utah War Violence William P. MacKinnon 121 Tensions in David O. McKay’s First Presidencies Gary James Bergera 179 REVIEWS Claudia L. Bushman, Contemporary Mormonism: Latter-day Saints in Modern America Glen M. Leonard 247 H. Michael Marquardt, The Rise of Mormonism, 1816–1844 Jed Woodworth 252 Leonard J. Arrington, Great Basin Kingdom: An Economic History of the Latter-day Saints, 1830-1900 Thomas G. Alexander 257 Fred E. Woods, Gathering to Nauvoo David E. Johnson 260 David L. Bigler, Fort Limhi: The Mormon Adventure in Oregon Territory, 1855–1858 Samuel J. Passey 262 Jana Riess and Christopher Kimball Bigelow. Mormonism for Dummies. J. Nelson-Seawright and Taryn Nelson-Seawright 265 iv LETTERS Is This Academic Discourse? ists, like apologists, can succumb to “tunnel-vision” (233) and “dogma- Editor’s note: This response is condensed tism” (239) because of an “unwill- from a full version, available on www. ingness to accept ambiguity and signaturebooks.com/excerpts/making3. gray areas, the denial of unresolved html. inconsistencies, the concealment of D. Michael Quinn’s critique of re- uncomfortable evidence, the impo- cent biographies of Joseph Smith sition of approved dogma, and the (“Biographers and the Mormon ridicule of dissent” (239). He not ‘Prophet Puzzle’: 1974 to 2004,” 32, only suggests that naturalists inten- no. 2 [Summer 2006]: 232–39) dem- tionally suppress and conceal infor- onstrated hostility toward historians mation, but also asserts that anyone who view the Mormon founder natu- who lacks belief in the paranormal ralistically. In apologizing for “so makes “omissions (and logically, many criticisms” of my book, Joseph possible distortions)” (233). How- Smith: The Making of a Prophet (Salt ever, Quinn fails to consider “possi- Lake City: Signature Books, 2004), ble distortions” arising from his fail- Quinn reported that I “encouraged” ure to consider the possibility of de- him “to express publicly my critique lusion or deception. in the interest of academic dis- Naturalistic perspectives are dis- course” (232 note 8). While this is torted only if one begs the question true, it was not a concession to any- by assuming a contrary position thing Quinn wrote. from the outset. Obviously, Quinn I appreciated his statement that wanted to appeal to the perceived my biography “deservedly won the biases of his audience. Despite Mormon History Association’s best- Quinn’s attempt to privilege the in- book award” (238), but not what I terpretations of believers, his argu- consider to be a superficial reading ment is fallacious because it rests and an ad hominem approach. He on the mere possibility of distor- acknowledged that some of my inter- tion. pretations were “nuanced” (234) but Quinn believes that the “greatest critiqued them as if they were not. weakness” of Joseph Smith biogra- His analysis seemed to be more pre- phies produced by naturalistic in- occupied with defending his previ- terpreters is “their