201

INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES

ACTING SPEAKER (Mr Andrews) Private Members’ Business - Notice of Motion No 4 - Removal from Notice Paper - Statement 5282 Select Committee into Child Abuse in Western Australia - Establishment - Amendment to Motion - Statement 2301 Unparliamentary Use of the Word “Corrupt” - Statement 11774

ACTING SPEAKER (Mr Dean) Swan River - Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion - Ruling 8805; Dissent from Ruling 8806

ACTING SPEAKER (Mr McRae) Community Development and Justice Standing Committee - Inquiries into the Arts and Rehabilitation in Prisons - Statement 3691 Members of the Legislative Assembly - Code of Conduct - Amendment to Motion, as Amended - Ruling 10660; Dissent from Ruling 10660 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Response to Recommendations and Report of the Standing Committee on Community Development and Justice - Statement 4591

ACTING SPEAKER (Mr O’Gorman) Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Amendment to Motion - Ruling 10552 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Division of Bill - Statement 10956 Private Members’ Business - Notice of Motion No 11 - Removal from Notice Paper - Statement 10200 Public Accounts Committee - Report - Statement 7392

AINSWORTH, MR ROSS ANDREW (Roe) (NPA) Address-in-Reply - Amendment to Motion - Health Services 114 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3223-3240 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board and Department - Select Committee - Motion 7246 Sheep and Goats Imported - Ovine Johne’s Disease 14148 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6737 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1087 Community Development, Department of - Esperance Office - Staff 6042 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Prosecution of Landholders 13923, 13924 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3110 Crime Child Offenders - Esperance - Petition 5329 Crime Prevention Structures Review Report 8728; Funding Allocation 8599 Links Between Drug Use and Crime - Grievance 8936 Prevention and Emerging Trends 10871 Safer WA - Funding Allocation 8599 Criminal Code Amendment Bill (No. 3) 2003 - Second Reading 14087 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12353 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13183 Defence Forces Army Museum of WA - Amendment on the Amendment 10999 Fremantle Artillery Barracks - Amendment on the Amendment 10999 Drugs - Links Between Drug Use and Crime - Grievance 8936 Esperance Port - Port of the Year - Statement 12855 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1703, 1704, 1719 Health Lady Brand Lodge - Closure 12860 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” - Motion 1219 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11713 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 629 Consideration in Detail 642, 646, 652, 1104, 1114 Justice, Department of - Parolees High-risk - Motion 11412 Land Acquisition - Valuations of CBD Buildings 8871 202 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

AINSWORTH, MR ROSS ANDREW (continued) Local Government - Safer WA - Funding 14986 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion, as Amended 10576 Member for Stirling - Leave of Absence 8288 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12786 Misuse of Drugs Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10193 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 8954, 8955 Police Officers - Number - Matter of Public Interest 7891 Reid Highway-Altone Road Beechboro - Fatal Accident - Failure of Traffic Lights 5830 Speeding Offenders - Confiscation of Vehicles 10591 Stations - Closure or Downgrading 4560 Police Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3923 Portman Iron Ore Ltd - Koolyanobbing Mine - Petition 5330 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8810 Prisons - Video Games - Review - Motion 11412 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7072 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8706 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 5859, 5860 Consideration in Detail 5883, 5884 Third Reading 6476 Questions on Notice - Answers - Motion 12786 Railways Freight Trains - Safety Issues - Petition 5330 Perth Urban Ra il Development - Supplementary Master Plan - Cost of Works Packages 10636 Rail Safety - Expenditure 10717 Roads Bridge and Road Construction - Expenditure 9310 Regional Roads Program - Cutbacks in Funding 10678, 10679 Road Safety Confiscation of Vehicles 10591 Council - Regional Representation 8005 Expenditure 10717 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7246 Sentencing Legislation - Child Offenders - Esperance - Petition 5329 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2684 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9692 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9692 Water Resources - Chemicals - Data 13986 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12350 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8879 Western Power Inquiry into Infrastructure and Customer Service - Motion 12503 Regional Power Connections - Grievance 10386

ANDREWS, MR PAUL WILLIAM, BA, DipEd, DipRSA, DipLS (Southern River) (ALP) Aborigines - Antisocial and Criminal Behaviour - Premier’s Comments 10282 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Reaction 3498 Address-in-Reply - Motion - Health 307 Air Pollution - Toxic Pollutants - Levels of Exposure 10960 Amanda Young Foundation - Statement 7355 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3574, 3712, 3848-3851, 3987, 4170-4172, 4679 Consumer and Employment Protection - Consumer Credit Grants 8177 Crime - Gosnells Area - Police and Local Government Initiatives 5368 Curtin University of Technology - Podiatry Course - Grievance 10388 Disability Services Crook, Mr Ian - Petition 6129 Farina, Ms Judith - Petition 5328 Sullivan, Mr Rick - Petition 4589 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 203

ANDREWS, MR PAUL WILLIAM (continued) Education - Teachers Pay Rise 14883; Motion 11431 Predicted Shortage 11537 Education and Health Standing Committee Annual Report 2001-02 - Tabling 492 Annual Report 2002-03 - Report No 4 10651 Gorgon Project - Commonwealth’s Position 12684 Gosnells, City of - Crime Initiatives 5368 Health Attention Deficit Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder - Referral to Education and Health Standing Committee - Motion 6848 Insurance Funds - Premiums - Increase 916 Nurses - Recruitment Campaign 1312 Organ Donation 6491 Radiotherapy Treatment - Waiting List 13700 Reform Committee - Progress 13921 Hospitals - Emergency Departments - Campaign to Ease Pressure 8602 Housing - Gosnells - Tenders for Six Town Houses 1787 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11655 Consideration in Detail 12733-12736, 12749-12757, 12868, 12874 Industrial Relations Commission - Role in Resolving Teachers Industrial Dispute 14883 Lions Clubs International Children of Courage Awards - Statement 8306 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Petition 12327 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10857 Matilda Street, Huntingdale - Grievance 486 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4578 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3504 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 910, 930 Schools - Canning Vale High - Implementation Committee - Statement 507 Schools - Information Technology Plan - Improvements 13606 Waste Disposal Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility 4558, 5831 Toxic Waste Dumping - Reporting Requirements 5087 Water Resources - Dam Storage Levels 397 Western Power - Privatisation 2922 Workplace Relations Amendment (Termination of Employment) Bill 2002 - Rejection by Senate - State Government’s Reaction 10593

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES, MEc, Leader of the Opposition (Cottesloe) (Lib) Aborigines - National Parks and Nature Reserves - Transfer to Aboriginal Groups 11257 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 Second Reading 6501 Council’s Amendment 13980 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 9137 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2525 Consideration in Detail 2561-2567, 2839, 2945-2948, 2953 Third Reading 2975 Address-in-Reply - Motion Health 78 Legislative Program 74 Metropolitan Railway 80 Ministers’ Travel 73 State Development 75 Transport 81 Water Resources 79 204 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES (continued) Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3096-3098, 3223, 3394 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading 4097 Commissioner of Workplace Agreements - Retirement 4097 Health - Expenditure 4098 Office of State Revenue - Expenditure on Audit of Land Tax Database 4097 Police Service - Expenditure 4098 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Agriculture, Fisheries and Mining 7541 Budget Presentation 7527 Capital Works 7534 Commonwealth Grants 7535 Education - Expenditure 7537 Health Budget 7537 Industrial Development 7542 Police Officers - Appointment 7538 Roads Funding 7539 Southern Rail Link 7539 Stamp Duty 7529 State Debt 7533 Taxes and Charges - Increases 7527 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7527 Auditor General, Office of Funding Allocation 11107 Matter of Public Interest 12328 Australian Flag - Legislation to Outlaw Desecration 2518 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1748 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Second Reading 1921 Consideration in Detail 12050-12059, 12070-12074, 12184-12193 Third Reading 12218 Bateman, Mr Thomas Henry MLA -Condolence Motion 11892 Bills, Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper 72; Council’s Message - Motion 381 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1496 Burrup Peninsula - Native Title Agreement 10026, 10027 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6381 Consideration in Detail 6391, 6392 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 10200 Consideration in Detail 10405-10413, 10429, 10430 Council’s Amendments 13830 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6381 Consideration in Detail 6393, 6394 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 10200 Cabinet Anwyl, Ms Megan - Briefing 6677 Directive Banning Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 6644, 6645 Meetings - Government’s Election Promise - Motion 6027 Reshuffle 8438 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6618 Consideration in Detail 6750, 6751, 6758-6763, 6773, 6774, 6799, 6871, 6880, 6881, 6892, 6893, 6903 Dissent from Deputy Speaker’s Ruling 6895 Third Reading 6920 Council’s Amendments 11661-11665 Protection of Children who Experiment with Cannabis 6485 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 9861 Consideration in Detail 9870, 9880, 9881, 9885-9890 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 205

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES (continued) Child Abuse - Government Inaction - Matter of Public Interest 9101 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Third Reading 9135 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1084 Cole Royal Commission - Findings about Rule of Law Matter of Public Interest 5845 Rule of Law 5826 Committees, Task Forces, Reviews and Advisory Groups - Number Established - Cost 8307 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Prosecution of Landholders 14071 Consultants Government’s Failure to Achieve Promised Cut in Expenditure 3087 Report - Tabling 2820 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Motion 14905 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8185 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1188 Crane, Mr Albert Victor - Condolence Motion 10155 Crime Curfew for Juveniles in Northbridge 6808, 8440, 8439, 12683 Scarborough Situation 12684 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Standing Orders Suspension 6153; Amendment to Motion 6154 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13177 Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline - Amendment to Motion 6838 Drugs Cannabis Decriminalisation 5715, 7671, 7880; Matter of Public Interest 6347; Petition 10171 Export to Finance Purchase of Harder Drugs 6336 Fawcett, Mrs Julie - Invitation to Appear to Bar of the House - Standing Orders Suspension 7682 Interstate and International Travel by Government Employees 10876 Life Education Preventive Health Program - Funding Cut 12757 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 Second Reading 5122 Consideration in Detail 5225-5235, 5246-5254, 5350-5357, 5377-5389 Third Reading 5392 Council’s Amendments 13825-13828 Education Teachers Number and Resignations 8125, 8126 Pay Rise - Matter of Public Interest 10975 VacSwim Program - Cost and Number Enrolled 8127 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision 1865, 1866 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13216 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13626 Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee 13704, 13705 Consideration in Detail 13730-13733 Third Reading 13734 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13216 Second Reading 13219 Consideration in Detail 13531-13541, 13685, 13686 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13216 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13626 Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9706 Environmental Protection, Department of - Payne, Mr Roger 4556, 4742, 4743 Fire Management in the Western Australian Environment - Motion 2710 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2374-2379 First Home Owner Grant Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendment 6189 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6825 Freedom of Information - Government’s Accountability Policy 12197 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3511 206 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES (continued) Gambling - Burswood International Resort Casino 1584, 1706, 1707 Geraldton Port Authority 394, 396, 508, 509 Government Radio Advertisements - Budget 7357 Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value Awarded 9230 Government Departments and Agencies Auditor General’s Report - Breaches of Privacy by Agencies 3926 Credit Cards - Answers to Questions 14070 Funding Cuts - State Budget Surplus 11619 Privacy Protection - Legislation 3927 Privatisation - Government’s Position 12467, 12468 Government Media Office 8173 Government Openness and Accountability - Accountability Watchdogs - Underfunding - Matter of Public Interest 12328 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1496 Grayden, Mr David - Condolence Motion 8785 Hancock, Mr Lang - Development of Iron Ore Industry - Statement 4111 Health Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA Former Minister for Health’s Failure to Take Action 9660, 9665; Matter of Public Interest 9672 Select Committee - Motion, as Amended 10615 Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11910 Crisis in System - Matter of Public Interest 5094 Department - Ms Jean Thornton - Allegations 9665, 9871 Escalating Crisis - Matter of Public Interest 3797 Funding 5235, 5236; Matter of Public Interest 14886 Life Education Preventive Health Program - Funding Cut 12757 Management of Health System Standing Orders Suspension 11629 Matter of Public Interest 11629 Mental Health System - Funding - Petition 11910 Nurses Number and Resignations 7942, 7943 Nurse West - Savings 9515 Heritage - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 528 Higher Education Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8848 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper 275; Council’s Message - Motion 381 Council’s Message - Motion 1492 Hospitals Capital Works Funding - Upgrades 11538 Derby Regional - Signage at Meeting - Comments by Minister for Health 2164 Elective Surgery - Waiting Times - Matter of Public Interest 14886 Emergency Departments - Upgrades 11538 Geraldton Regional - Redevelopment Contract 9416, 9417 Moora District Brick - Presentation to Premier 13193, 13194 Matter of Public Interest 13203 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Indemnity for Doctors 14249 Trust Accounts - Indemnity for Doctors 14249 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11640 Industrial Relations Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5845 Government Action on Disputes 13613, 13693 Government Leadership - Matter of Public Interest 10975 Legislation - Tourism Industry - Motion 1615 Information Commissioner Matter of Public Interest 12328 Wookey, Ms Darryl - Appointment in Acting Position 12197 Inquiries, Task Forces, Committees, Summits, Symposiums and Reviews - Number 8225 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 207

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES (continued) Insurance - Public Liability - Legislation 275 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 1112, 1116 Referral to Public Accounts Committee 1122 Iraq War - Support for Australian Defence Personnel - Motion 5442; Amendment to Motion 5443 Justice, Department of - Parole System - Reforms 10493 Legal Practice Bill 2002 Second Reading 4598 Third Reading 9135, 9137 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2029 Lobbyists Anwyl, Ms Megan - Briefing to Cabinet 6677 Burke, Mr Brian Cabinet Directive 6644, 6645, 6678 Meetings with Ministers of Crown and Ministerial Staff 7270, 7408, 7597, 7779, 7946, 8145, 8146, 8343, 8518, 8638, 9140, 9306, 9742 Meetings with Premier and Ministerial Staff 6789 Payroll Tax Amnesty 5445, 5446, 5723, 5724, 6338, 6339, 6642, 6643 Premier’s Instruction 5992, 6182 Privileged Access to Labor Government 5364 Racing and Wagering Western Australia - Board Composition 5363 Grill, Mr Julian Cabinet Directive 6645, 6678 Meetings with Ministers of Crown and Ministerial Staff 7270, 7408, 7597, 7779, 7946, 8145, 8146, 8343, 8518, 8638, 9140, 9306, 9742 Meetings with Premier and Ministerial Staff 6789 Payroll Tax Amnesty 5445, 5446, 5723, 5724, 6338, 6339, 6642, 6643 Premier’s Instruction 5992, 6182 Local Government - Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 528 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13964 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1188 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion, as Amended 10689 Leader of the Opposition Censure Motion 4876 Stirling House Hostel - Alcohol - Personal Explanation 3476 Member for Bunbury - Electorate Office Activities 5576, 5577 Methanex Corporation - Failure of Project to Proceed 11908 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General Breach of Criminal Code 765, 766 Documents Given to Minister for Health 602, 913 Director of Public Prosecutions - Letter to Raymond Mickelberg 913 Formal Request for Further Documents 22 Minister for Health - Distribution of Copies 88, 89 Minister for Tourism - Standing Aside 13919, 13920 Ministers of the Crown Accountability - Standing Orders Suspension 11114 Attorney General - Decisions on Matters Involving Allegations of Criminal Behaviour by Cabinet Members - Motion 812 Credit Cards 14069, 14070 Lobbying - Premier’s Instruction 5992 Minister for Health Ms Jean Thornton - Allegations against Former Minister for Health 9665, 9871 Statement - Standing Orders Suspension 14258 Minister for Housing and Works Allegations of Ministerial Impropriety - Standing Orders Suspension 9210 Breach of Code of Conduct 599 Public Tender Process 9230, 9416, 9417 Minister for Police and Emergency Services -Expenditure on Restaurant Meals 9744 208 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES (continued) Ministers of the Crown (continued) Minister for Racing and Gaming - Breach of Code of Conduct 599 Minister for the Environment and Heritage No-confidence Motion 4565 Standing Orders Suspension 4565 Ministerial Code of Conduct - Breaches 599 Premier Accountability - Standing Orders Suspension 11114 Chief of Staff - Meeting with Mr Brian Burke 5723, 5724 Comments on Privatisation 12316 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 6789 Move into Federal Politics 12060 Ms Barbara Wiese 13811 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Naming of Cabinet Ministers 4750, 5083, 5084 Treasurer - Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 6338, 6339, 6642, 6643 National Competition Council -Threat to Payments - Standing Orders Suspension 12471; Motion 12479 National Parks and Nature Reserves - Transfer to Aboriginal Groups 11257 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13821 Offshore Minerals Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 6204 Owen, Mr Raymond Cecil MLA - Condolence Motion 4550 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations - Matter of Public Interest 12328 Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6147 Planning Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 434; Amendment to Motion 13623 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Future 1196 Police Claremont Station - Closure 14349 Great Northern Highway between Muchea and Wubin - Patrols 12375 Moora Visit - Brick Presentations to Premier 13193, 13194 Multanovas Country Roads 8001 Revenue - Road Safety Initiatives 8000 Officers - Number - Matter of Public Interest 7888 Pay Dispute Matter of Public Interest 10975 Premier’s Comments 10960 Terrorist Threat - Lack of Resources 3345, 3346 Warnbro Shooting Incident - Parole Conditions 10280 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - Hospitality Accounts 8271 Prisons Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Motion 5601 Policy to Reduce Prison Population - Risk to Community - Matter of Public Interest 10500 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8717 Racing and Wagering Western Australia - Board Composition 5363 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 777 Railways Loch and Grant Streets Stations -Partial Closure 776; Grievance 883 Southern Rail Link Budget Blow-out 14878, 14879 Budget Details 12320 Cost Blow-out 12320, 13922; Matter of Public Interest 13932 Cost Estimates 7223, 7224 Funding by Debt 3225 Matter of Public Interest 2941 Project Cost 20 South Perth Station 2924 Tabling of Cost Estimates 19 Under Treasurer’s Warnings 3226 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 209

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES (continued) Regional Development - Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13203 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3835 Consideration in Detail 3838, 3839 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 7897 Council’s Amendments 8023-8030, 8038-8060 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours Matter of Public Interest 8450 Premier’s Announcement 9083 Standing Orders Suspension 8456 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme - Motion 434; Amendment to Motion 13623 Multanova Use 8000, 8001 Road Safety - Resources - Matter of Public Interest 8013 Rottnest Island - Accommodation Costs 4102 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers Cabinet Ministers - Naming 4750, 5083, 5084 Interim Report - Allegations Against Ministers of the Crown 5086 Schools Bus Service - Minister’s Refusal to Grant Rolling Leases to Operators 13382, 13383 High Schools - Bank Account Balances 8127 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Motion, as Amended 10615 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 Second Reading 2987 Consideration in Detail 3660 Shark Patrol - Grievance 12822 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 Recommittal 1692 Council’s Amendment 4727 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 Second Reading 8479 Consideration in Detail 8496-8498 State Budget Radio Advertisements 7357 Surplus - Cuts to Public Services 11619 State Finance Capital Spending 3225 Commonwealth Grants Commission - Payments 6685 Government Financial Results Report 2001-02 - Capital Works Deferred, Delayed or Cut 1586 State Debt 7022, 7516 Taxes and Charges Increases - Matter of Public Interest 7034 Pre-election Promise 7221 State Government Insurance Office 12467, 12468 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 Consideration in Detail 14284-14286 Second Reading 14279 Stirling House Hostel - Alcohol - Leader of the Opposition - Personal Explanation 3476 Sustainability Strategy 11248, 11249, 11395 Swan River 8787 Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion 8807 Swan Village of Care - Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Motion 5601 Taxation - Payroll Tax Assessments of Employee-like Contractors 3499, 3500 Relief - Mr Burke and Mr Grill 5445, 5446, 5723, 5724, 6642, 6643 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 4734-4742, 4753-4758, 4838-4843 210 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BARNETT, HON COLIN JAMES (continued) Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3524 Consideration in Detail 3554, 3555 Tourism Lack of Government Support - Motion 1615 Portfolio - Elevation of Status - Matter of Public Interest 2822 Workplace Relations Legislation - Motion 1615 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 9105 Second Reading 9105 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7514 Unclaimed Money (Superannuation and RSA Providers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4843 Universities - Guild Fees - Allocation 2520 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper 275; Council’s Message - Motion 381 Council’s Message - Motion 1492 Water Resources - Community Water Forums - Advertisement for Hon Adele Farina 1461, 1462 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13964 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11303 Western Power Disaggregation - Electricity Prices 12760 Managing Director Conditions of Employment 11954 Limousine Service Account 10423 Trips to Melbourne 10158, 10159, 10421, 12816 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 940, 956-959 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion 381 Council’s Message - Motion 1492

BARRON-SULLIVAN, MR DANIEL FRANK, Deputy Leader of the Opposition (Mitchell) (Lib) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 8988 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2534 Address-in-Reply - Motion Labor Party 191-196 Public Liability Premiums 191 Small Business 191-193 Union Movement 191-196 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Government Expenditure 7662-7665 Small Business 7660 Taxation 7660-7661 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7660 Bills, Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper - Amendment to Motion 390 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility - Waste Taken without Approvals and Closure 4562, 4563 Building Industry - Home Indemnity Insurance 1464, 1465, 14251, 14252 Bunbury Regional Hospital Coxall, Maddison 10165, 10284 General Surgeons Roster 1308 Intensive Care Unit 12063, 12064 Specialist Surgeon Shortage 10675 Theatre Facilities Upgrade 10166 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11510 Consideration in Detail 11522-11526 Third Reading 11527 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 - Third Reading 6482, 6493 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6731 Consideration in Detail 6854 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 211

BARRON-SULLIVAN, MR DANIEL FRANK (continued) Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 7235, 7339 Consideration in Detail 7352, 7353, 7383-7386, 8739, 8740, 8746-8752, 8994-9002 Council’s Amendments 12590-12598 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Second Reading 1069 Consideration in Detail 1984-1987, 1990-1995, 2033, 2035, 2172, 2173, 2177-2184 Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee 1093 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3111 Consumer and Employment Protection Department - Media Statement - Photocopying of Legal Tender 9148 Ferguson, Mr Peter - 5 Columba Street, Bunbury 9803, 10326, 14985 Soft Furnishings Businesses - Backyard Operators 9802 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 4609 Consideration in Detail 4845-4853, 5488, 5489, 5506, 5507 Referral to Select Committee 5500, 5501 Third Reading 5591 Council’s Amendments 9294 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1172, 1178; Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1194 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5349 Education Conferences and Seminars by School Executive Organisations 7936 Department Mills, Ms Sally - Grievance 1281 Officers at Level 9 and Above 5625 Hearing Impaired Children - Funding 8134 Mott Inquiry - Report 5627 Standards and Outcomes - Improvement 5905 Teachers - Pay Rise - Matter of Public Interest 10969 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision 2921, 2922 One Vote, One Value - Statement 14249 Overriding of State Laws 7023 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2197 Employment and Training - Department - Officers at Level 9 and Above 5625 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 2197 Referral to Community Development and Justice Standing Committee 2262 Consideration in Detail 2362-2372, 2378; Adjournment of Debate 2363 Third Reading 2412 Fire and Emergency Services Levy - Matter of Public Interest 10172 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Introduction and First Reading 6792 Fuel Prices - Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection’s Lack of Action - Matter of Public Interest 919 Gluyas, Ms Bridgid - Payment to Judgment Creditor 11436 Government Advertising - Expenditure 5905, 6217, 6218, 6398, 6534, 6778, 7094, 7765, 7766, 8096 Government Contracts - Statistics 6221-6223, 6398, 6535, 6536, 6779, 6936, 7094, 7095, 7263, 7767, 7768 Government Departments and Agencies Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6233, 6234, 6400, 6539, 6782, 7098, 7772, 7940, 8106 Credit Cards 6219, 6220, 6535, 6778, 7094, 7262, 7403, 7766, 8100 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6236, 6237, 6412, 6789, 6936, 7104, 7105, 7265, 8506, 8507 Leschenault Estuary - Management 5911, 5912, 6039-6041, 6238, 6672, 8135, 8136, 8270, 8341, 8511, 8512 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 6229-6231, 6399, 6538, 6781, 7097, 7593, 7770, 7771, 8104 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 6228, 6229, 6399, 6537, 6538, 6780, 7097, 7593, 7770, 8102 Motorcycles - Statistics 6224, 6225, 6398, 6536, 6780, 7095, 7096, 7263, 7768 Privately Plated 6226, 6227, 6399, 6537, 6780, 7096, 7769, 7936 212 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BARRON-SULLIVAN, MR DANIEL FRANK (continued) Health Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11920 Crisis in System - Matter of Public Interest 5103 Warburton Medical Clinic - Dialysis Services 10876 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 390 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1490 Council’s Amendments 3076-3081 Housing and Works, Department of - Tenants - Antisocial Behaviour Amendment to Motion 8634 Amendment on the Amendment 8636 Industrial Relations Government Leadership - Matter of Public Interest 10969 Legislation - Tourism Industry - Motion 1616 Reforms - Level of Disputation 10817 Insurance Home Indemnity Insurance 1464, 1465, 14251, 14252 Small Business - Costs 10024, 10025 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 609 Consideration in Detail 638-640, 646, 647, 653-663, 1098, 1101-1112, 1117 Third Reading 1390 Legislative Assembly - Speaker - Deliberative Vote 2814 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote 2001-2003, 2813; Matter of Public Interest 2011 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Amendment to Motion 12702 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Bunbury Port Authority Access to Waterways 10695 Leschenault Homestead 10697-10700 Lobbyists - Burke, Mr Brian and Grill, Mr Julian - Labor Party Preselections 6186 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion, as Amended 10584, 10595 Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10596 Ministers of the Crown Attorney General - Coffee-making Machine in Ministerial Office 5756 Credit Cards 6219, 6220 Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection - Lack of Action on Fuel Prices - Matter of Public Interest 919 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12794 Minister for State Development - Failure to Attend In Unison Conference 11906 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4574 Staff Vehicles - Privately Plated 6231, 6232, 6539, 6781, 6782, 7097, 7098, 7265, 7771, 7939 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5465 Consideration in Detail 5475-5487, 8957-8959 Council’s Amendment 14137 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5465 Consideration in Detail 5475-5487, 8942-8956 National Competition Council Deregulation of Hours - Threat to Cut Competition Payments 12689 Threat to Payments - Motion 12475 Police Australind Station - Petition 3785 Bunbury Rapid Response Squad 12609, 12610 DNA Testing - Home Burglary and Sexual Assault 4859 Multanovas - Burrows, Mr Ian 664 Pay Dispute 10961, 10962; Matter of Public Interest 10969 Warburton 12810 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - Officers Classified at Level 9 or Higher 7261 Prisons - Regional - Closures 4858, 4859 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 213

BARRON-SULLIVAN, MR DANIEL FRANK (continued) Procedure and Privileges Committee Changes to Prorogation and Extended Sessions - Report 12587 Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Report 4880 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8611, 8703 Prostitution Legislation - Petitions 9381, 13614 Public Accounts Committee - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1172, 1178; Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1194 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 5857, 5858 Third Reading 6480 Questions on Notice Answers - Motion 12794 Government Expenditure - Failure to Answer 12758 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 895 Third Reading 1380 Real Estate and Business Agents Supervisory Board - Hoad, Mr Michael 3491, 3492 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13739 Consideration in Detail 13794-13804, 13831-13837 Third Reading 13837 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours Competition Policy Guidelines 5366, 5368 Federal Government Funding 9231, 9232 National Competition Council Threat 12689 Small Business Development Corporation Submission 8309, 8310, 8441 Standing Orders Suspension 8451 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2680 Small Business Business Insurance Premiums 10024 Insurance Costs 10025 November Sensis Business Index - Small and Medium Enterprises 13609 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8486 State Finance State Debt - Cost of Servicing 7672, 7673 Taxes and Charges Business Insurance Premiums 10024, 10025 Increases - Matter of Public Interest 7043 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 4752 Tourism - Lack of Government Support - Motion 1616 Universities - Guild Fees - Allocation 2521 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 390 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1490 Council’s Amendments 2841 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5119 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 390 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1490 Youth Development Holiday Program - Unsuccessful Applications 8133

BIRNEY, MR MATTHEW JOHN (Kalgoorlie) (Lib) Aborigines Mining Lease No 36/7 - Heritage Site 689 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Police Guard or Patrol 14486 Address-in-Reply - Motion Country Road Speed Limits 299 DNA Procedure 294-297 Police 297-298 Adoption - Gay and Lesbian Couples 10566 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1893 214 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BIRNEY, MR MATTHEW JOHN (continued) Anti-Corruption Commission - Premier’s Meeting with Mr T.E. O’Connor 1759 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Third Reading Glock Pistols 8470, 8471 Police Budget 8469 Police Numbers 8469, 8470 Business of the House - Notice of Motion - Amendment 12691 Cabinet - Directive Banning Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 6678, 6679 Cannabis Crime Stoppers Advertisement on Drug Dealer Phone-in Day 4558, 4559 Decriminalisation Cultivation of up to Two Cannabis Plants 5829 Matter of Public Interest 6349 Minister for Health’s Position 5718 Link to Criminal Offending 5995 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6691 Consideration in Detail 6792-6797, 6849, 6855, 6902; Question to be Put 6906 Abuse by Drug Dealers 6486 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 9859 Consideration in Detail 9881-9885 Third Reading 10000 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3116 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8166 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1192 Courts Bench Warrants - Number Outstanding 9798 Court Security and Custodial Services Contract - Renewal of Contract 12855 Kalgoorlie Court of Petty Sessions 675, 678 Crime Cannabis - Link to Criminal Offending 5995 Clearance Rates 13611 Crime Stoppers - Advertisement on Drug Dealer Phone-in Day 4558, 4559 Curfew, Statewide 8888, 8889 Fremantle - Statistics 12685 Home Burglaries - Convictions 11814 Northbridge Curfew for Juveniles 8888, 8965 Security 8598 Statistics 14917 Safer WA - Axing 12682 Statistics 1513 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13640 Third Reading 13737 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13640 Government Contracts - Buy Local Policy - Australian and New Zealand Government Procurement Agreement 13269 Government Departments and Agencies Government Employees’ Home Ownership Scheme - Applications 10326 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employees 7772-7777, 7941, 7942, 8124 Government Employees’ Home Ownership Scheme - Applications 10326 Halden, Hon John - Meetings with Minister for Housing and Works and Ministerial Staff 6043 Health DNA Analysis - Staff Numbers 11677 Improved Services - Government’s Commitment 1317 Kalgoorlie and Eyre - Funding Cuts 14143 Mammography Service - Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Petitions 7033, 8009, 8158, 8796, 8873, 9226 McCallum, Dr Barney - Government Payments 10877 Housing and Works, Department of - Public Housing Tenants - Antisocial Behaviour - Notice of Motion 8459; Motion 8616 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 215

BIRNEY, MR MATTHEW JOHN (continued) Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Browning, Mr Paul - Appointment 3782, 3783 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 618 Consideration in Detail 641, 643 Justice, Department of Employees Drink-driving in Government Car 7121 Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Actions 7115 Theft of Plants 7121 Enoch, Mr Jeff - Expenditure on Taxis 7269 Home Detention Orders - Number and Breaches 12374, 12812 People in Custody - Escapes, Deaths and Suicides 9491 Reid, Ms Rhonda 7121 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3679 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2015 Lobbyists - Burke, Mr Brian and Grill, Mr Julian - Cabinet Directive 6678, 6679 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1192 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion 10546 Amendment to Motion 10551, 10554 Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10603; Dissent from Acting Speaker’s Ruling 10661 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4870 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit Minister for Health Evidence on Involvement 1866 Ministerial Appointments Diary 2165 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Advice and Discussions 1515 Mining Eastern Goldfields Transport Board - Mine Site Charter Transport 10875 Lease No 36/7 - Aboriginal Heritage Site 689 Lease No 37/30 and Miscellaneous Licence No 27/83 - Seepage Management Plan 984 Portman Iron Ore Ltd - Koolyanobbing Mine - Grievance 4819; Petitions 4813, 5559 Ministers of the Crown Minister for Health - Cannabis Decriminalisation 5718 Minister for Housing and Works - Meetings with Hon John Halden 6043 Minister for Police and Emergency Services Government Credit Card - Meals, Drinks and Expenses 9742, 13426 Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12775, 12803 Restaurant Expenditure 5997 Staff - Use of Government-owned Credit Cards 14955 Minister for Racing and Gaming Air Travel to Albany Cup 7270 Charter Flight Cost 8871 Staff - Corporate Credit Cards 14531 Misuse of Drugs Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 10190 Consideration in Detail 10196-10199 Police 48 Positions Available for Redeployment 4644 Accidental Shooting of Maintenance Worker 13268 Act - Review 982 Belmont Station - Number of Officers 1629 Budget - Breakdown of Items 14527 CADCOM Project - Abandonment of Part of System 4637 Civilian Police Service Employees - Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 3093 Clairvoyants - Use 3987 Clarkson Station - Closure 11783 Community Operations - Motion 4758 Coolgardie Station - APLO Numbers 11434, 14485 216 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BIRNEY, MR MATTHEW JOHN (continued) Police (continued) Crime Stoppers - Advertisement on Drug Dealer Phone-in Day 4558, 4559 Custody - Escapes, Deaths and Suicides 6235, 10701 DMR Consulting Pty Ltd - Cost 13267 DNA Testing 26, 11677, 13261, 14919 Dog Squads - Number and Cost 13423 Firearms - Number 9713 Flying Squads - Establishment 666 Fremantle - Staff 12685 Fremantle Regional District - Officer Numbers 11561 Full-time Equivalents - Shortfall 13425 Functional Review Taskforce - Cancellation of AIMS Contract 4744 Glock Pistols 6337, 8313, 8315, 9750, 11001, 13259 Goldfields-Esperance - Budget 1513, 13259 Government’s Pre-election Promises - Motion 14089 Joondalup - Officer Numbers 14521 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Station 1513, 2994, 3711, 11434, 13259, 14485 Menzies Station - Petitions 5835, 5977, 6131, 6791, 7032 Midland Station 10031, 12881, 13269, 13426 Numbers - Increase 12808 Officers Charges of Assaulting 686 Legal Representation 1712 Nu mber 4660, 13424; Matter of Public Interest 7888 Number in each WA Electorate 3712 Overtime Payments 8500 Pay Claim 10588 Private Firearm Ownership 7595 Rates of Pay 10498 Recruitment 7361 Stress Leave 3984 Overtime - Cost 10680 Records of Occupations of People Arrested 7596 Recruits - Number and Duties 13262 Redundancies for Civilian Administration Positions 3091 Response Times for Priority Offences 12377 Royal Commission Legal Representation for Police Officers 1712 Mr Lewandowski’s Evidence 1866 Sworn Officers Stood Down 8929 School Truants - Powers 3711 Squads and Units - Names and Purposes 14958 Stations Officer Numbers 11625, 11627 Percentage Operating Below Authorised Strength 11696, 11697, 11782, 11783 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Guard or Patrol 14486 Tactical Response Group - Transport by Aircraft 3980 Telephone Calls to Police Stations 8968 Vehicle Pursuits - Guidelines 14522 Vehicles Prohibition on Officers Taking Vehicles Home 3708 Purchase from States and Territories 3989 Violence Restraining Orders - Enforcement - Seizure of Firearms 10719 Police Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3916 Consideration in Detail 3941-3945, 4080-4086 Third Reading 4086 Prisons Court Security and Custodial Services Contract - Renewal of Contract 12855 Officers - Number, Workers Compensation and Overtime 6239 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 217

BIRNEY, MR MATTHEW JOHN (continued) Prisons (continued) Policy to Reduce Prison Population - Risk to Community - Matter of Public Interest 10507 Prisoners - Escapes from Custody 9139 Riverbank Remand Centre - Missing Electronic Equipment and Whitegoods 7121 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 7054 Consideration in Detail 9245, 9263-9267, 9271, 9279-9291, 9405-9408, 9431-9433, 9436, 9439, 9440 Third Reading 9447 Public Accounts Committee - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1192 Questions on Notice - Answers - Motion 12775, 12803 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6356 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6356 Consideration in Detail 7075-7090, 7211-7220 Council’s Amendments 8905-8907 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6356 Consideration in Detail 7231-7233 Third Reading 7234 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6356 Red Cross, Australian - Kalgoorlie-Boulder Soup Patrol 3572; Grievance 9384 Regional Development - Buy Local Policy - Australian and New Zealand Government Procurement Agreement 13269 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 8033-8036, 8046-8053, 8056-8060 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers Historical Terms of Reference 688; Date 2214 Police Officers Named - Standing Down 5088 Sworn Officers Stood Down 8929 Schools Computers - Policy on Leasing or Buying 2998 Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Truancy Officers 2583 Truants - Police Powers 3711 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3637, 3638, 3641-3647, 3651 Sentencing Legislation - Criminal Offences - Maximum Jail Term of Six Months or Less 1760 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3695-3697 Speed Limits - Increase - Remote Areas 403, 517 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3543 Total Waste Management Kalgoorlie-Boulder Motion 5255 Petition 8010 Toxic Waste Transportation - Petitions 5837, 5978, 6130, 6345, 6469, 6686, 7031, 7207, 7330, 8159, 8795, 8873, 9225 Transport Eastern Goldfields Transport Board - Mine Site Charter Transport 10875 Heavy Haulage Transport Units - Kalgoorlie-Coolgardie 2993 Transperth - Unrestricted Travel Passes for Disabled Voluntary Community Workers - Petition 9226 Water Resources - Goldfields - Report on Alternative Water Source 607 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11299

BOARD, HON MICHAEL FRANCIS, JP (Murdoch) (Lib) Aborigines - Health Statistics - Derby Regional Hospital 83 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2552 Third Reading 2975 Address-in-Reply Motion - Fremantle Eastern Bypass and Roe Highway 3843-3845 Amendments to Motion Health Services 106 Water Shortage 224 218 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BOARD, HON MICHAEL FRANCIS (continued) Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 1875 Consideration in Detail 3093-3096 Agriculture - Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7692 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate - Youth Funding 7563, 7567 Grants 7565 Portfolio 7563 Programs 7564-7567 Third Reading - Health Budget 8587, 8588 Elective Surgery Waiting List 8587 Regional Health Care 8588 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7563 Army Museum of WA and Fremantle Artillery Barracks Motion 10989 Amendment on the Amendment 10998 Aubrey, Mr Russell - Personal Explanation 4828 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1753 Buses - Southern Coast Transit 2168 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 - Third Reading 6482 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 6393, 6394 Cannabis Decriminalisation - Limit on Number of Cautions Issued 5716 Education Classes and Health Campaigns 1197 Personal Explanation 6675 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6627 Children and Young People’s Policy, Office of - Funding Cut 7523 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1191 Dangerous Goods Safety Bill 2002 - Second Reading 8813 Education and Health Standing Committee Annual Report 2001-02 491 Annual Report 2002-03 10649 Trip to Canada and the United Kingdom - Statement 8702 Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9703 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8927 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3515 Gosnells, City of - Inquiry - Petition 2930 Health Attention Deficit Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder - Referral to Education and Health Standing Committee - Motion 6844; Appointment of Co-opted Member 6848 Child Development Services - Funding Cuts 13699 Chiropractors Advice to Minister 2039 Competition Review of Health Provider Legislation 14144 Operation in Public Health Service 2040 Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement 7678, 7679, 10673, 10674 Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11911 Country Health Services Review - Moora Hospital Project 13195 Crisis in System 10824; 11400; Matter of Public Interest 5097 Dental Bunbury Clinic 5830, 5831 Dental Board of Western Australia 1589, 1590 Regional Services - Waiting Lists 11702 Seniors - Subsidy Scheme 278 Department Annual Reporting Procedures - Investigation 8595 Auditor General’s Report 8725 Eastern States Consultants - Hiring 10593 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 219

BOARD, HON MICHAEL FRANCIS (continued) Health (continued) Escalating Crisis - Matter of Public Interest 3786 Funding Cuts 11621, 11622, 13700 Matter of Public Interest 14888 Superannuation and Capital User Charges 8723, 8724 Hearing - Universal Newborn Hearing Screening Program 11778 Improved Services - Government’s Commitment 1314, 1323 Management of Health System - Matter of Public Interest 11631 Medical Indemnity Tort Law Reform 6184 Mental Health System Amendment to Motion 11270 Clinical Outcomes 11903 Funding - Community Organisations 12612, 12613 Funding Cuts 11533, 12205 Report on Review of Mental Health Act 11901 Metropolitan Health Service - Report 2001-02 5993, 5994 Mundaring Medical Centre - X-ray Licence - Petition 6687 Nurses Agency - Excessive Use 204, 205; Reduction in Use 12462 Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 3776 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” 1044, 1045; Motion 1206 Nurse-Link Initiative 8725 Prisons - Pay Commitment 3344, 3496 Recruitment Campaign 2167 Obstetric Services Review - Implementation of Recommendations 6649 Osteopathic Profession - Competition Review of Health Provider Legislation 14144 Priority Issues - Matter of Public Interest 6815 Royal Flying Doctor Service - Government Assistance to Replace Aircraft 8965 Selby Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service - Petition 8446 Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Motion, as Amended 10616 Heritage - William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12093 Hospitals Agency Nurses - Excessive Use 204, 205; Reduction in Use 12462 Ambulances Bypass and Ramping 397, 4158, 5371, 10823, 10825, 10963, 11399, 11400 Improvement of Services in Metropolitan Area - Motion 12485 Armadale-Kelmscott Memorial - High Dependency Care Unit 5448 Budget Overrun 3493 Capital Works Funding 7359, 11532, 11533 Derby Regional - Specialist Staff - Relocation to Broome District Hospital 83 Elective Surgery - Waiting Times 14879; Matter of Public Interest 14888 Emergency Departments 4158, 11532, 11533 Government’s Promise 5089 Halls Creek - New Initiative 1307 Kalamunda District Community - Redevelopment - Motion 13401 Kalgoorlie Regional - Nurse Shortage 2675 King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women - Roberman, Dr Brian - Petitions 8011, 9670 Moora District Matter of Public Interest 13208 Review’s Findings on Regional Resource Centre 13195 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Poisons Licence 3980 Quality and Safety Accreditation 8963 Regional Areas - Downgrading for Redevelopments 13519 Rockingham-Kwinana District - Upgrade 6681 Royal Perth - Ambulance Ramping 11399 Sir Charles Gairdner - Radiation Therapy 5238 St John Ambulance - Response Times 4748, 4749 Staff - Violent Attacks 12062, 12063 Waiting Lists - Purchase of Surgery fro m Non-public Hospitals 2817 220 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BOARD, HON MICHAEL FRANCIS (continued) Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11641 Consideration in Detail 12725-12728, 12731, 12753-12757, 12870 Third Reading 12875 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 620 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1191 Medical Act 1894 - Review 5240 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Amendment to Motion - Standing Orders Suspension 10553 Motion, as Amended 10572 Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10654 Member for Murdoch - Personal Explanations Aubrey, Mr Russell 4828 Cannabis Smoking Implements 6675 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass Matter of Public Interest 13617 Motion 413 Motion for Disallowance 14116 Minister for Health Private Health Insurance 917 Support for Southern Rail Link 917 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 12338 Consideration in Detail 12346, 12602, 12617, 12621-12623 Referral to Select Committee 12457; Amendment to Motion 12458 Third Reading 12629 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3484 Consideration in Detail 3803-3823 Third Reading 3824 Council’s Amendments 5890, 5891 Prisons - Nurses - Pay Commitment 3344, 3496 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8609 Public Accounts Committee Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts Standing Orders Suspension 14221 Tabling of Papers 14220 Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1191 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 5868 Consideration in Detail 5876-5888, 6395 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6375 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6375 Consideration in Detail 7211 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6375 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6375 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 902 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1287 Consideration in Detail 1337, 1345, 1357, 1365 Third Reading 1383 Council’s Amendments 3507, 3508 Railways - Southern Rail Link Matter of Public Interest 2934 Minister for Health’s Support 917 William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12093 Regional Development - Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13208 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 221

BOARD, HON MICHAEL FRANCIS (continued) Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13753 Road Traffic Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12721 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme Matter of Public Interest 13617 Motion 413 Motion for Disallowance 14116 Minister’s Position 4106 Petitions 3785, 5093, 6471 Submission Form 4105 Leach Highway and South Street - Reclassification - Petitions 2170, 2653, 3195, 4590, 6471, 7525 Southern Suburbs - Mixing Passenger Traffic and Heavy Freight Vehicles 8176 Schools Cadet Programs - Funding 3089, 3090, 3228 Non-government - Funding - Petition 4590 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7692 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Motion, as Amended 10616 Seniors - Dental Subsidy Scheme 278 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8491 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9701 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9701 Consideration in Detail 10278, 10280, 10290-10294 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11387 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 959 Youth - Funding of Programs and National Youth Week 6490

BOWLER, MR JOHN JAMES MANSELL (Eyre) (ALP) Address-in-Reply - Motion Adeline 328 Education 330 Gay and Lesbian Reform 327 Kalgoorlie Golf Course 329 Kalgoorlie - Recreational Facilities Funding 326 Prospector 329 Anti-Corruption Commission - Appointment of Chairman and Members 205 Cabinet - Regional Subcommittee Meetings 12065 Commercial Tenancy Rights 775 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Question to be Put 1187 Crime Statistics - Goldfields-Esperance Region 14074 Dairy Industry - Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9253 Economics and Industry Standing Committee Inquiry into the WA Strata Management Industry - Final Report 9399 Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA - Eighth Report 14235 Environment Lake Bryde Conservation Reserve 6813 Natural Heritage Trust Funding 9086 Fly In, Fly Out Employees - Grievance 9997 Fire and Emergency Services - Regional Airports - Removal of Front-line Emergency Response Crews 5241 Fuel and Energy FuelWatch - Quantifiable Benefits for Consumers 13926 Goldfields Gas Pipeline - Cost of Gas Transmission 11958 Gallop Labor Government - Performance in 2002 3925 Geraldton Port Authority - Port Upgrade 4104 Health Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement - Funding Cuts 3778 Escalating Crisis - Matter of Public Interest 3795 222 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BOWLER, MR JOHN JAMES MANSELL (continued) Housing - New Living Program - Golden Grove 6042 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2026 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - Motion - Question to be Put 1187 Mining Exploration Expenditure Figures 2214 Goldfields Mining Expo - Statement 12604 Greenfields Mineral Exploration Inquiry - Exploration Expenditure Figures 2214 Newcrest Mining Ltd - Expansion of Telfer Goldmine 5827 Windimurra Vanadium Mine - Royalties 10881 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12803 National Basketball League Game, Kalgoorlie 12614 Neil, Mr Jack - Statement 11777 Parks and Reserves - Drummond Nature Reserve - Freshwater Claypan Wetlands 13201 Parliament House - Centenary Celebrations 7516 Police Community Operations - Motion 4772 DNA Testing - Back-capture Program 918 Laverton and Warburton Stations 12378 Newman Station - Replacement 9875 Public Accounts Committee - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Question to be Put 1187 Public Liability Insurance - Relief Package - Public Benefits 5717 Questions on Notice - Answers - Motion 12803 Racing Kalgoorlie - Statement 912 Racing Radio, Kambalda - Establishment 2215 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6370 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6370 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6370 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6370 Retail Trading Hours - Deregulation - Review 10967 Safer WA Community Security Program - Leonora - Funding 1787 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9253 Swan River Colony - One Hundred and Seventy-fifth Anniversary Celebrations 7516 Taxes and Charges - Increases 8440 Telstra - Privatisation 9425 Total Waste Management Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion 5264 Transport Air - Regional Airports - Removal of Front-line Emergency Response Crews 5241 Eastern Goldfields - Grievance 10643 Geraldton - Southern Transport Corridor Project 4104 Water Resources Goldfields - Water Strategy 2038 Inquiry - Statement 8963 Regional Western Australia - Sustainable Water Supply - Motion 3957 Water Treatment Plants, Laverton and Leonora 10881

BRADSHAW, MR JOHN LESLIE, MPS, JP (Murray-Wellington) (Lib) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2539 Consideration in Detail 2794-2811, 2942, 2945, 2968-2972 Third Reading 2977 Address-in-Reply Motion Government’s Economic Record 3977 Harvey Water 3978 Metropolitan Health Services Board 3977 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 223

BRADSHAW, MR JOHN LESLIE (continued) Address-in-Reply (continued) Motion (continued) Pinjarra Courthouse 3975 Murray District Hospital 3976 Parents and Citizens Association 3976 Primary School 3975 Premier’s Workload 3978 Water Corporation 3975 Amendment to Motion - Health Services 126 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3394 Agriculture Dairy Industry - Select Committee Appointment of Members 9258 Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9256 Department Closure of Offices or Facilities 3404 Horticulture-Viticulture Specialist at Waroona 1124 Geographe Wine District - Statement 3669 Gnowangerup Agricultural School - Independent Review 14524 Hay Bales Safety Guidelines for Transport 13674 Transportation Regulations 7928 Waroona, Harvey and Brunswick Agricultural Societies - Statement 12603 Alcoa World Alumina Australia Noise Regulation 27 Application 3003 Wagerup Alumina Refinery Emissions 3676 Noise Levels 822 Operation within EPA Environmental Conditions 9804 Statement 8723 Use of Oil on Red Mud Lakes 8870 Animal Welfare - RSPCA Officer, South West - Petition 11497 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9129 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Alcoa Liquor Burning Plant 7733 Wagerup Refinery 7732 Australind 7731 Brunswick Junction Primary School 7730 Burekup Train Station 7732 Dampier-to-Bunbury Gas Pipeline 7734 Drug Addiction Treatments 7735 Parents and Friends’ Federation of Western Australia - Private School Funding 7734 Pinjarra Primary School 7732 State Budget 7730 Wellington Dam - Salinity 7733 Western Australian Agricultural College, Harvey 7734 Third Reading - Alcoa - Wagerup Refinery - Effects on Local Community 8588 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Alcoa Liquor Burning Plant 7733 Wagerup Refinery 7732 Australind 7731 Brunswick Junction Primary School 7730 Burekup Train Station 7732 Dampier-to-Bunbury Gas Pipeline 7734 Drug Addiction Treatments 7735 Parents and Friends’ Federation of Western Australia - Private School Funding 7734 224 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BRADSHAW, MR JOHN LESLIE (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 (continued) Second Reading - Cognate Debate (continued) Pinjarra Primary School 7732 State Budget 7730 Wellington Dam - Salinity 7733 Western Australian Agricultural College, Harvey 7734 Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 12052, 12054, 12055 Bateman, Mr Thomas Henry, MLA - Condolence Motion 11894 Brunswick Tunnel - Statement 8307 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11519 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6699 Consideration in Detail 6910, 6914 Third Reading 6931 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Third Reading 14912 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8184 Crane, Mr Albert Victor, MLA - Condolence Motion 10156 Crime Statistics 8077 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10830 Drugs - Next Step Drug Addiction Program - Number of Clients 5176 East Perth Football Club - Grand Final - Statement 912 Economics and Industry Standing Committee - Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA - Eighth Report 14238 Education Harvey Agricultural College 683, 5510 Read Write Now - Termination of Contracts 3419, 3420 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13218 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13659 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13218 Second Reading 13256 Consideration in Detail 13532 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13218 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13659 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2203 Employment and Training - Read Write Now - Termination of Contracts 3419, 3420 Energy Operators and Water Agencies (Powers) Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading - 5225 Second Reading 5254, 6508 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1472 Estimates Committees - Standing Orders Suspension 7391 Fairbridge - Statement 4854 Finance Brokers Scandal - Charges and Convictions 8155 Fire and Emergency Services Levy - Rebates 12378 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 2203 Consideration in Detail 2365 Forests - Tuart - Conservation and Protection 7111 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) (Reviews) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9132 Harvey Italian Shrine Committee - Statement 1706 Hay Bales - Transport 7928, 13674 Health Asbestosis - Vitamin A Program 11140 Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder - Subsidised Medication 9491 Department - Holden Statesman Sedans - Number and Cost 6240 Dichlorvos - Approval for Use 2038 Murray Districts Multipurpose Health Service 11436 Pain Management Centre Bunbury - Funding 13309 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 225

BRADSHAW, MR JOHN LESLIE (continued) Health (continued) Peel District Health Advisory Council - Membership 7925 Regional Areas - Members of Committee 4165 Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Select Committee - Amendment to Motion 10612 Homeswest - Yarloop - Property Sales 3853 Hospitals Directors of Nursing-Health Service Managers - Meetings in South West District 7110 Harvey - Budget for Future Planning 11676 Moora District - Matter of Public Interest 13210 Murray District - Future 3263 Peel Health Campus - Patient Transfers - Cost 3263 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Parking 9471 Yarloop Budget for Future Planning 11676 Closure of Beds 10424 Petition 12445 Recommendations for Future 4165 Upgrading 10424 Leece, Mr Keith - Statement 10022 Liquor Sales in Restaurants - Petition 14215 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Alcoa Holman, Professor D’Arcy 12850 Liquor Burning Plant 12850 Tripartite Process 12849 Wagerup Refinery 12849 Land Tax 12851 Obesity 12848 School Maintenance Brunswick Junction Primary School 12848 Harvey Primary School 12848 Pinjarra Primary School 12848 Western Australian School Canteen Association 12848 Local Government Fire and Emergency Services Levy - Rebate 12378 Murray, Shire of - Town Planning Scheme No 4, Amendment No 157 8074 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13956 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Amendment to Motion 10525 Motion 10529 Member for Moore - Leave of Absence 7659, 9857 Mining - South West - Government Revenue 6941 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5471 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5471 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3511 Peel Regional Park - Management 2993 Peel Waterways - Economic and Development and Recreation Management Plan 9793 Pinjarra Courthouse - Closure 3234 Planning Murray, Shire of - Town Planning Scheme No 4, Amendment No 157 8074 Peel Region Scheme Changes 4644 Disallowance 4087, 4146 Police Bikie Gangs - Failure to Wear Helmets 3781 Crowd Control Licences 4665, 13270 Pollution - Uduc Road, Harvey 1401 Power Stations - Minimum Buffer 986 226 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BRADSHAW, MR JOHN LESLIE (continued) Prescribed Burning Program - Completion 14883 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8713 Public Accounts Committee Auditor General’s Annual Report 2001-02 - Review 7859 Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14224 Port Coogee Development - Sixth Report 14231 Visiting Medical Practitioners - Tabling of Papers 4075 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6368 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6368 Consideration in Detail 7211 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6368 Consideration in Detail 7232, 7233 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6368 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 973 Council’s Amendments 3506, 3507 Railways Australind 2994, 4665, 9306 Service to Yarloop - Petition 8009 Integrated Rail Transport Planning Report - Market Research Survey 2994 South West Passenger Rail Committee - Recommendations 12378 Regional Development - Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13210 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 8050, 8051 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13789 Schools Canteens - Guidelines for the Sale of Foodstuffs 11953 Gnowangerup Agricultural School - Independent Review 14524 Goods and Services Purchasing Policy 14541 Great Mates Program - Statement 10415 Harvey Primary - Repairs and Refurbishment 14488 Non-government - Funding - Petition 5092 River Valley Primary - Bus Service for Students from Roelands 1777 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia Appointment of Members 9258 Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9256 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Amendment to Motion 10612 Serpentine River - Guide Poles 7924 Sewerage Commercial Properties - Connection to Reticulated Systems 8155 Murray and Serpentine Rivers - Leakage from Septic Tanks 8155, 9006 South Western Highway Harvey - Petition 6346 Weir Road-Uduc Road Intersection - Study 9306 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 Second Reading 8490 Consideration in Detail 8496, 8498 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11390 Transport Bus and Omnibus Licences - Grievance 1975 Centenary of Flight 2003 Air Show - Statement 13808 Hay Bales 7928, 13674 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading Bus Services 9123 Grill, Hon Julian 9124 Member for Dawesville 9121 Peel Deviation 9123 Pinjarra Courthouse, Visit by Ministers 9121 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 227

BRADSHAW, MR JOHN LESLIE (continued) Wagerup Alumina Refinery Emissions 3676 Noise Levels 822 Operation within EPA Environmental Conditions 9804 Statement 8723 Use of Oil on Red Mud Lakes 8870 Water Resources Catchment Areas - Controlled Burns and Clearing 692 Dandalup-Karnet Water Mound - Gazettal 984 Farm Dams - Management Charges - Motion 7702 Management - Charges - Motion 7702 Murray and Serpentine Rivers - Degradation - Petition 2931 Peel Waterways - Economic Development and Recreation Management Plan 9793, 12226 Preston Beach Grievance 7849 Petition 8159 Upgrading 685 Underground Water - Use 692 Wokalup and Samson Brook Dams - Connection to the Stirling Dam-to-Perth Pipe 5510 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13956 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11292 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 951, 956 Youth on Health Fest, Mandurah - Statement 13515

BROWN, HON CLIVE MORRIS, Minister for State Development; Tourism (to 27 June); Small Business (to 27 June) (Bassendean) (ALP) Aborigines - Employment Initiatives 10496 Alcoa World Alumina Australia - Galton-Fenzi, Dr Brian - Conflict of Interest 987 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 11272 Second Reading 11272, 11941 Consideration in Detail 12050-12060, 12070-12076, 12179-12195, 12207-12217 Standing Orders Suspension 12217 Third Reading 12217, 12224 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14321 Burke, Mr Brian - Meetings with Ministers of the Crown and Ministerial Staff 9140 Burswood International Resort Casino - Burswood Dome - Retention 2008 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3987 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee - Question to be Put 1097 Committees and Boards - Members - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7754 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14395 Dangerous Goods Safety Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3915 Second Reading 3915, 8816 Consideration in Detail 8819-8822 Third Reading 8877 Drought Assistance - Nungarin Business Community 3090 Economy, Western Australian 10421 Employment and Training - Aborigines - New Initiatives 10496 Environment - State Agreements - Exemptions from Act 11315 Forests and Forestry Old-growth Forest - Commonwealth Government Commitment 4860 Pinetec Pty Ltd 6397, 13924 Plantation Timber Industries in South West - Commonwealth Government Funding 398 Free Trade Agreement - Australia-United States - Discussions 10587, 14075 Fuel and Energy Goldfields Gas Pipeline - Removal of Tariffs 9425 Power Stations - Minimum Buffer 986 Fuel Tanker Trucks - Rollover Accidents 8148 Gallop Labor Government - Approval Rating among Businesses 3671 Government Advertising - Expenditure 7094 228 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BROWN, HON CLIVE MORRIS (continued) Government Contracts - Statistics 7094, 7095 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off - 14449 Call Centres - Programs in North West 5178 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3987 Cleaning Services 6408, 13767 Club-Association Memberships 8851, 10703 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 14515, 14562 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 7098 Credit Cards 7094, 14504 Creditors 7092, 9760 Employment Contracts 7093 Government Intellectual Property Policy 8731 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12896 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5165 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6412 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14568 Leave Liability 5157 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14376 Leschenault Estuary - Management 6672 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6403 North West - Staff and Programs 3568 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10709 Privatisation - Government’s Position 12468 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7775 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14416 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14475 Staff Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14536 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7119 Unfilled and Acting Positions 1756 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 8860 Web Sites - Online Payments 11318 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14548 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 988 Government Vehicles 7095-7097 Grill, Mr Julian - Meetings with Ministers of the Crown and Ministerial Staff 9140 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14395 Immigration - Business Migration 6684 Industrial Development Agreement Acts - Variations Approved, Rejected, Amended or Withdrawn 14528 BHP Billiton - Purchase of Tugboats 13611 “Building Future Prosperity: Creating Jobs and Wealth through Industry Development” - Statement 10491 Burrup Peninsula 23, 7884, 8597 Gorgon Project 8892, 11959, 12684 HIsmelt Corporation Pty Ltd 3670, 5906, 9304, 9305 Kwinana - Buffer Zone - Grievance 2785 Methanex Corporation - Failure of Project to Proceed 11908 North West - Downstream Processing Projects 10164 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract 2004 Raytheon Australia Pty Ltd 13812 Seed Capital for New Products and Services 1713 State Agreements - Exemptions from Environmental Protection Act 1986 11315 Whicher Range Gas Resource - Drilling Program 13198 Industrial Relations Legislation Advertisements - Small Business Development Corporation 4699 Tourism Industry 1590; Motion 1620 Unions - Government Grants 8860 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 229

BROWN, HON CLIVE MORRIS (continued) Iraq War - Impact on Tourism 6343 Iron Ore (Yandicoogina) Agreement Act 1996 - Amendment - Statement 2160 Mining Exploration Expenditure Figures - Greenfield Mineral Exploration Inquiry 2214 Iron Ore (Hamersley Range) Agreement - Secondary Processing Obligations 9304 Lease No 37/30 and Miscellaneous Licence No 27/83 - Seepage Management Plan 984 Mineral Titles - Auditor General’s Report - Statement 1972 Rio Tinto Exploration Pty Ltd - Iron Ore Processing 5908, 5909 Western Metals Export Facility Derby - Closure of Lennard Shelf Zinc Operations 11904 Windimurra Vanadium Mine - Royalties 10881 Ministers of the Crown Minister for State Development Business Mission to Germany, The Netherlands and the UK - Statement 8692 Failure to Attend In Unison Conference - Personal Explanation 11909 Ministerial Mission to Hyogo-Kansai, Japan - Statement 14216 Overseas Trips 2056 Singapore and China Visit - Statement 1460 Visit to Indonesia - Statement 12449 Minister for Tourism - Attendance at Tourism Functions 3928, 3929 Mobile Phones - Use 4806 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10715 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14435 Corporate Credit Cards 8255, 11314, 14361 Memberships of Clubs-Associations-Unions - Payment of Fees 10704 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4811 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7119 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5147, 7098 Nungarin Business Community - Letter to Minister for State Development 3090 Questions on Notice - Answers 8007 Rally Australia 4561, 4861, 4862, 6187, 7267 Regional Development North West 5909, 6400, 6401 Regional Telecommunications Inquiry - Terms of Reference 278 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours 8179, 8180, 8312 Rottnest Island Accommodation Costs 4102 Budget Details 2053 New Year’s Eve 7362 School Leavers Week 3091 SARS - Impact on Tourism 6343, 7027 Service Stations - Use of Mobile Phones While Refuelling Motor Vehicles 11314 Small Business Commercial Tenancy Rights 775 First Steps Online Program 1197, 1198 Goods and Services Tax - Impact 5998 Government’s Approval Rating 3671 Government Consultation 8180 Home-based Business Forum 6648 Small Business Development Corporation 4699, 8179, 8180 Small Business Development Corporation Act - Review 5892; Statement on 597 Sport and Recreation Australian Surf Life Saving Association - Annual Championship 2007-09 8004 Burswood Dome - Future 2008 Hopman Cup - Venue 3980 Superannuation - Changes - Increased Compliance Costs for Business 1588 Taxation Goods and Services Tax - Small Business 5998 Increase - Impact on Average Worker 6239 230 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

BROWN, HON CLIVE MORRIS (continued) Telecommunications Infrastructure in Regional Areas 11622 Mobile Telephones - Use While Refuelling Motor Vehicles 11314 Networking the Nation Program - North West 3572 Regional Telecommunications Inquiry 278, 1466, 2386 Statewide Telecommunications Enhancement Program - North West 3571 Telstra - Privatisation 9425, 11622 Tourism 10-year Plan 6412 Budget Allocations 9496 Commission - Offshore Marketing Budget - Cuts 3927 Conventions and Exhibitions 9236 Crisis Marketing Funds 9310 Economic and Employment Value - Education of the Community 9087 Election Commitment 5993, 7517 International Visitors - Emirates Services 6412 Iraq War - Impact 6343 Lack of Government Support - Motion 1620 Lack of Professionalism in Industry 7405 Nature-based - Revenue 986 North West - Funding of Programs 6406, 6540 Portfolio - Elevation of Status - Matter of Public Interest 2830 Slowdown - International Visitors 7267 Tourism Planning Task Force Report - Media Release - Security Measures 3352 US Navy Sea-swap Operations 2926 Workplace Relations Legislation 1590; Motion 1620 $5 million Crisis Funding - Statement 5822 US Navy Sea-swap Operations 2926 University of Western Australia - Pathfinder Fund 1713 Vinnicombe, Dr Patricia - Statement 5825 Water Strategy - Goldfields 2038 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8880 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 285 Second Reading 285, 952 Consideration in Detail 956-959 Third Reading 959

CADBY, HON ALAN ALFRED, BA, BEd, GradDipAppSc (North Metropolitan) (Lib) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Legislation Committee 4227 Second Reading 4233, 4271, 4272 Committee 4503-4523 Draft Statutes 3733 Address-in-Reply - Motion Education College of Teaching 2133-2136 TAFE - Visit to China 2127 North Metropolitan Region Economic Development 2129 Medical Services 2131 Police 2132 Public Housing 2128 Westpac Call Centre 2130 Arts Events - Value Adding 4964 Building and Construction Industry Training Fund 12008, 12145, 12291 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 12530, 12559 Committee 12642-12644 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 231

CADBY, HON ALAN ALFRED (continued) Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 12530, 12559 Cannabis - Student Information 7449 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9592 Colleges of TAFE Eastern Pilbara - Accounting Controls 10367 Joondalup Regional Performing Arts Centre and Hospitality Training Centre 9358 Places in 2004 13862 Staff - Teaching of Schoolchildren 10365 Teaching Loads and Class Sizes 1259 West Coast College 7822, 12270 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 9041 Crime Statistics - North West Metropolitan Police District 11174 Donnybrook-Balingup, Shire of - Local Law - Eating Areas in Streets and Other Places - Disallowance - Order Discharged 2591 Drivers Licences Funding for Young People to Learn to Drive 8411 Graduated Driver Training and Licensing System - Failure Rate 7175, 9055 Waiting Time for Practical Test 8685, 13080 Education Curriculum Council - Amalgamation with Department of Education and Training 5411 Education, Department of Amalgamation with Department of Training 4906, 5026, 5053, 5313 $19 million Gain 12667 Joondalup Hospitality Training Institute - Cost Blow-out 12927 Joondalup Regional Performing Arts Centre and Hospitality Training Centre 9358 Local Learning and Employment Partnership Program - Joondalup Pilot Project 6458 New Upper School Courses - Funding and Professional Development 3178, 3615 Pilot Course Program - Changes 8678 Post-compulsory Courses of Study - Support Materials 7474 Public Education Endowment Trust - Grant Applications 14044 Teachers Criminal Records Checks - Statement 14204 Long Service Leave 12669 Primary - Professional Development in Mathematics and Science 5775 Professional Development for New Upper School Courses 3178 Specialist Teachers for Students with Special Needs 2346 Strike Action 11483 Unqualified 10923 Tertiary Entrance Examination - Statistics 14838 VacSwim Program - Cost and Number Enrolled 12925, 14620 Vocational Education and Training - Review 12556 Year 11 and 12 Courses 10112 Employment and Training Amalgamation of Department of Training with Department of Education 4906, 5026, 5053, 5313 Department of Training - $19 Million Gain 12667 Industry Training Advisory Bodies - Funding 1661 Joondalup Hospitality Training Institute - Cost Blow-out 12927 Vocational Education and Training Courses and Support Materials 7474 Disallowance - Order Discharged 2591 Review 12556 Vocational Education and Training Amendment Regulations 2002 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 5008 Committee 11217, 11218 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers Education and Employment 8643-8645 Health 8640 Government Election Promises 8639 North Metropolitan Region 8645, 8646 Stamp Duty 8640-8643 232 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CADBY, HON ALAN ALFRED (continued) Gaming Machines - Rate of Return for Punters 2125 Government Departments and Agencies - Salary Increases 11838 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Goldfields Office - Regional Manager 4024 Industrial Relations - Regulations 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 2591 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2890 Land Tax Exemptions - Residential Building Delays 11366 Local Learning and Employment Partnership Program - Joondalup Pilot Program 6458 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment No 992/33 - Clarkson-Butler - Disallowance 14823 Minister for Education and Training - Answers to Questions - Motion 6062; Statement 13012 Molecular Inventory Systems Pty Ltd - Dealings with Department 6081 Motor Bike Licensing - Restriction of Times 8411 People’s Republic of China - Visit - Statement 13108 Police Mounted and Canine Sections - Funding 13117 North West Metropolitan District 1804, 11174 Officers - Attrition Rate 13070 Teachers - Criminal Records Checks - Statement 14204 Ports and Harbours Hillarys Boat Harbour 13144, 13351, 13474, 13595, 14212 Pen Fees - Income 13144 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 12236 Committee 13991-13994 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 6977 Committee 7278, 7282-7284 Railways Discontinuance Legislation - Delay in Introduction 3440 Loch and Grant Streets Stations - Partial Closure Consideration of Statement - Motion 12252, 12254 Review 10749 Security Personnel - Number 13021 Stations 11042, 11209 Schools Bus Service - Composite Rate Model 4029 Cadet Programs - Funding 9021 Craigie Senior High - Sale 7822 Drug Information Program - Modification 7449 Enrolments - Statistics 14771 Funding - Average per Student Funding 14606 Government Funding - Petition 3855 Non-government - Funding - Petition 4181, 7599 Staff - Inappropriate Behaviour or Relationships with Children 14642, 14711, 14802 Statement 14720 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9324 State Superannuation Amendment Regulations (No 2) 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 2591 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 12408, 13431 Committee 13441, 13444, 13445, 13555-13477 Recommittal 13855 Taxis - Restructuring of Industry 3291 Teller and Associates - Dealings with Department 6081 Tourism - Long-range Aircraft - Perth Stopovers 2484 Transport Heavy Haulage Transport Units - Escort Pilots 12029, 13078, 13079 Licensing Centres - Motor Bike Licensing - Restriction of Times 8411 Long-range Aircraft - Perth Stopovers 2484 Mitchell Corporation - Road Trains - Compliance with Regulations 12028, 12029 Permits 12028 School Bus Service - Composite Rate Model 4029 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 233

CADBY, HON ALAN ALFRED (continued) Wanneroo-Carabooda Area - Thrips Infestation - Vegetable Growers 4342, 4400 Water Resources Doust Water Brake - Evaluation 4203 Kalgoorlie - Water from Mundaring and No 8 Pumping Station 7450 Water-saving Devices - Evaluations 4203 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13996

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN, BA, Minister for Education (to 14 January); Education and Training (from 14 January); Sport and Recreation (to 27 June); Indigenous Affairs (to 27 June) (Willagee) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Education and Training Council - Chairperson - Credit Card 14308 Aboriginal Lands Trust - Review 2521, 4169 Brookton Aboriginal Reserve - Statement 7658 City of Albany Aboriginal Accord - Statement 5978 Cultural Awareness Training in Education System 12818 Djidi Djidi Aboriginal School, Bunbury 9420 Heritage and Culture Grant Scheme - Statement 746 Kiwirrkurra Community - Statement 1176 Mining Lease No 36/7 - Heritage Site 689 Ministerial Council on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs - Statement 1973 Ngaanyatjarra Lands - Statement 4817 Penny, Ms Neila - Statement 5080 Pia Wadjarri Remote Community School - Statement 8581 Reconciliation Grants Scheme - Statement 4554 Sport and Recreation Facilities - Improvement 5085 Swan Valley Nyungah Community 8174, 8726 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 180 Second Reading 180, 2554 Consideration in Detail 2562-2567, 2794-2811, 2833-2839, 2943, 2944, 2951-2956, 2959-2965, 2968, 2970, 2973 Third Reading 2974, 2977 Reaction 3498 Bali Bombings - Busselton Senior High School 2007 Benson, Ms Melissa - Statement 4555 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14324 Bromell, Mr Ross - Geographe Primary School - Grievance 1278 Building and Construction Industry Training Fund 9803, 9856 Building and Construction Industry Training Fund and Levy Collection Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 11379 Second Reading 11379 Consideration in Detail 12626-12629 Third Reading 12766, 12767 Construction Skills Training Centre - Funding 7887 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 4171 China - Educational and Training Services Development 12687 Colleges of TAFE Class Sizes and Workload of Lecturers 5628 Full-time Positions 4749 Governing Council of Central TAFE - Chairperson - Mobile Telephone 14307 Help in Pregnancy Program - Statement 11897 Lecturers’ Certified Agreement 14486 Pilbara - Amalgamation 12812-12815, 12859 TAFEWA Training Program - Skill up for the Burrup - Statement 10816 West Coast College of TAFE - Carine Campus 4702, 5516 Committees and Boards - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7929 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14395 Dawson, Mr Peter - WAIS Athlete of the Year - Statement 2919 Education Aboriginal Education and Training Council - Chairperson - Credit Card 14308 Amity House, Albany 5756, 8130 234 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN (continued) Education (continued) Australian Education Union - Pay Demand 11253 Budget - Increase 7025 College of Teaching - Interim Board - Statement 68 Compulsory Schooling for Years 11 and 12 9784 Conferences and Seminars by School Executive Organisations 7936 Cultural Awareness Training 12818 Curriculum Council - Amalgamation with Department of Education and Training 5242 Curriculum Guides 11742 Department Amalgamation with Department of Training 5242, 11948; Statement 4553 Appointment of Directors - Statement 4816 Budget 11780, 11781, 13918 Capital Works Budget 8894, 8895 District Offices - Staff 9478 Evaluation of Students at Educational Risk Program 14957 Funding Cuts 13813 Internet 9712, 11947 Mills, Ms Sally - Grievance 1282 Officers at Level 9 and Above 5625 Staff - Compulsory Criminal Records Checks - Statement 14053 Development of Educational Services with China 12687 Director General - Meetings with Members of Parliament 2846, 2847 “Do you Hear what I Hear?” Resource Kit - Statement 274 Duty of Care for Students Policy 14485 Education and Training Initiatives - Training System Plans 6342 Education Innovation Awards - Statement 3342 Ethnic Job Study Grant 14500 Functional Review Taskforce - Recommendations 12463, 12465 Geraldton Region - Statement 13192 Government Policies - Impact on Start of School Year 4564 Harvey Agricultural College 683, 5510 Hearing Impaired Children - Funding 8134 Help in Pregnancy Program - Statement 11897 Language Development Centres 4169, 14530 Languages other than English Program - Grievance 7332 Literacy and Numeracy Programs Expenditure in North West 3004 Reading School of the Year Award 7229 Summer Reading Challenge 7229 Midvale Multi-agency Service Centre - Statement 12315 Ministerial Council on Education, Employment, Training and Youth Affairs - Statement 174 Mott Inquiry - Report 5627 Phoenix - Proposed Workshop 8792 Port Hedland Education Partnership - Statement 11377 Review of Education and Training - Statement 4068 Rockingham - New Initiatives 10027 Secondary Graduation Certificates - Number 5518 Standards and Outcomes - Improvement 5905 State Budget Initiatives 9783 Students at Educational Risk Program - Evaluation 4176 Teachers 400 New Teachers for 2003 1784 Complaints of Physical and Sexual Abuse of Students 1774, 5625 Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 9664, 9878 High Schools - Number and Male Teachers 1786 Language other than English 6339 Laptop Computers 691, 2584 Level 3 - Appointment 8130 LOTE Technology and Enterprise Science and Mathematics 14966 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 235

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN (continued) Education (continued) Teachers (continued) Number and Resignations 8125, 8126 Number and Stress Leave 5624 Numbers 9468 Pay Rise 7026, 10821, 11253, 11706, 12863, 14883 Matter of Public Interest 10973 Motion 11426 Permanency 11396; Grievance 3197 Placement Process 4176 Potential Teachers Available to Rejoin Profession 1783 Predicted Shortage 11537 Primary - Number and Male/Female Ratio 1785, 1786, 8131 Projected Number of Retirements 1784 Recruitment Drive 1048 Recruitment Numbers for 2003 1783 Relief Teachers in Country Schools 11703 Retirements and Resignations 1784-1786 Scholarships and Recruitment - Statement 5332 Secondary - Male-Female Ratio 8131 Strike Action 11250, 13197, 13198 Student Scholarships - North West 3004 Teacher of the Year Award 7029 Temby, Mrs Therese - Statement 9659 VacSwim Program - Cost and Number Enrolled 8127 Vocational Education and Training Expansion of Programs 11743 Statement 11681 Wanneroo - New Initiatives 2387 Education and Training, Department of Budget 13813, 13918 Central Office - Positions Abolished 14355 Complaints Management Unit 14353 Staff - Compulsory Criminal Records Checks - Statement 14053 Employment and Training Burrup Resource Development Projects - Karratha School Students 5994 Employment Directions Initiative - 4697 Hospitality Training Centre, Joondalup - Establishment 4702 Review of Education and Training - Statement 4068 Training Budget 7025 Burrup Skills Task Force - Statement 5563 Construction Skills Training Centre - Funding 7887 Department Amalgamation with Department of Education 5242, 11948; Statement 4553 Budget 11780, 11781, 13918 Capital Works Budget 8894, 8895 Compulsory Criminal Records Checks - Statement 14053 District Offices - Staff 9478 Funding Cuts 13813 Officers at Level 9 and Above 5625 Development of Training Services with China 12687 Evaluation of Students at Educational Risk Program 14957 Excellence Awards - Statement 10944 Rockingham 10027 Skill up for the Burrup 12606; Statement 10816 Training System Plans 6342 Vocational Education and Training Expansion of Programs 11743 Statement 11681 Western Australian Group Training Scheme - Grievance 7854 236 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN (continued) Government Advertising - Expenditure 6217 Government Contracts Ethnic Community Council 14500 Statistics 6221, 6223 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14449 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 4171 Cleaning Services 6408, 13767 Club/Association Memberships 7932, 9776 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 14516, 14562 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6233 Credit Cards 6219, 14957 Creditors 6207, 9762 Employment Contracts 6672 Grants - Nu mber, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12900 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5166 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6236 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14569 Leave Liability 5157 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14377 Leschenault Estuary - Management 6039 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6404 North West - Staff and Programs 2579 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10709 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 8124 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14417 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14954 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7761 Staff “Attached List” 2310 Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14537 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 9470 Unfilled and Acting Positions 1232 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 9718 Web Sites - Online Payments 10725 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointment to Boards and Committees 14548 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 1400 Government Vehicles 6224, 6226, 6228, 6230 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14395 Health Hearing - “Do you Hear what I Hear?” Resource Kit - Statement 274 Medical Students - Increase in Number of University Places - Grievance 6137 Phoenix - Proposed Workshop 8792 Heirisson Rotary Club - Principal of the Year Award 2002 - Statement 5823 Higher Education Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7044 Second Reading 7044, 8849 Indigenous Affairs, Department of Browning, Mr Paul - Appointment 3782, 3783 Mandurah Office - Closure 1233 Regional Offices - Closure 8005 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Role 8174 Industrial Relations Australian Education Union - Pay Demand 11253 Government Leadership - Matter of Public Interest 10973 Industrial Relations Commission - Role in Resolving Teachers Industrial Dispute 14883 State Wage Case Decision - Impact on Minimum Wages for Adult Apprentices 9233 Iraq War - Support to School Students 5996 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2022 Lobbyists - Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 8145 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 237

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN (continued) Melville, City of - Sale of Primary School Land 9423 Members of Parliament Leader of the Opposition - Stirling House Hostel - Alcohol 3347 Meetings with Director General of Education 2846, 2847 Menegola, Mr Joe - Statement 7657 Mining Lease No 36/7 - Aboriginal Heritage Site 689 Ministers of the Crown Credit Cards 6219 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 8145 Mobile Phones - Use 4807 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10716 South Africa, Mozambique and Mauritius Trip - Statement 4818 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14436 Corporate Credit Cards 8257, 9922, 14365 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9781 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4811 Vehicles - Privately Plated 6231 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5148 Northbridge - Curfew for Juveniles 6809 Olympic Games - Government Assistance to Athletes 681 Planning - Swanbourne Senior High School Site - Consultation 3229 Police Pay Dispute - Matter of Public Interest 10973 Questions on Notice - Answers 8007, 11259 Schools Administrators - Briefing Sessions - Acceptance of Hospitality 14530 Albany - Allegations of Sexual Abuse 9235 Allocation of Funds 1781 Annual Reports 11744 Behaviour Management and Discipline Strategy 601, 828, 10964, 11744 Broadband Rollout - Benefits 8966 Bunbury High - Principal 825 Bus Service - River Valley Primary 1777 Busselton Senior High - Bali Bombings 2007 - Grievance 12827 Cadet Programs - Activities Outside School Premises 1053 Canteens - Guidelines for the Sale of Foodstuffs 11953 Chaplaincy Program 7940, 14530 Christmas Carol Singing 2314 City Beach High - Special Education Unit - Grievance 11501 Class Sizes 9470, 9477, 6039 Cleaning Contracts - Audit 283, 9423, 9424 Complaints of Physical and Sexual Abuse of Students 1774, 1775 Computers - Policy on Leasing or Buying 2998 Country High School Hostels 3675, 4702 Cross-boundary Enrolments 9478 Dalyellup Primary - Design 9751 Dawesville Bridge South - New Middle School 1779 District High - Review 5582 District Offices - Cost 14354 Djidi Djidi Aboriginal School, Bunbury 9420 Duncraig Senior High - Special Education Unit 4168 Education Assistance Fund - Schools Assisted 672, 2572, 4703 Enrolments - Years 8 to 12 5632 Fees 770, 772, 3673, 4108, 5365, 14354 Formula for Determining Average Cost per Student - Review 1127 Full-service Schools - Midvale Multi-agency Service Centre 12323 Funding - Methodology for Differential Resourcing 11744 Geographe Primary - Grievance 1278 Girrawheen Senior High - Behaviour Management and Discipline Strategy 601 Gnowangerup Agricultural School 14056, 14524 Goods and Services Purchasing Policy 14541 238 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN (continued) Schools (continued) Governor Stirling Senior High - Music Program 14541 H Index - Vasse Electorate 14519 Halls Head Community College - New Year 8 Students 1778 Harvey Primary - Repairs and Refurbishment 14488 High Schools Bank Account Balances 8127 Painting and Floor Covering Replacement Program 8130 Improvement Program - North West 2584 Inclusivity Program 4177 Information Technology Plan 2586, 13606 Internet 11947, 12202 Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Truancy Officers 2583 Karratha - Training and Employment Opportunities from Burrup Resource Development 5994 Kindergartens - School Enrolment Criteria - Statement 11680 Koorabye - Remote Community School 2817 Kwinana Senior High - Major Capital Works Project - Statement 13917 Level 3 - Staffing Formula Changes 773 Level 6 Principals - Appointment 14353 Maintenance 5622, 8130, 14348; Grievance 7334 Margaret River Primary - Education Resources and Support - Grievance 8694 Melville Primary - Sale of Land 9423, 9665 Midvale Primary 12323; Statement 12315 Mt Magnet District High - Second Deputy Principal 5722 Newton Moore High 825, 985, 14487 Non-government Criteria for Re-registration 11948 Funding 5578, 11786 Registration Criteria 11949 Review 11949 Student Numbers 9467 North West Administration Area Upgrades 9747 Automatic Irrigation Programs 9474 Capital Works Program 5629 Construction Projects 9746 Covered Assembly Program 5628 Expenditure 5511 Facilities for Students with Intellectual Disabilities 5628 Information and Communications Technology Programs 5630 Libraries - Expenditure 5630 Maintenance Programs 9475 New Facilities 5517 Operation Refresh Program 9474 Performing Arts Programs 5512 Refurbishment Programs 5517 Upgrading Programs 5517 Pastoral Care and Extracurricular Activities 11743 PEAC Classes 3259 Pia Wadjarri Re mote Community School - Statement 8581 Police Background Checks of Employees 1773 Preprimary Class Sizes 682 School Enrolment Criteria - Statement 11680 Students Receiving Literacy and Numeracy Assistance 1775 Primary Administration Upgrades 5630 Library Upgrades 5518 Number and Staffing 1779 Students Receiving Literacy and Numeracy Assistance 1775 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 239

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN (continued) Schools (continued) Primary (continued) Toilet Upgrades 5633 Principals - Male and Female 5625 Program Maintenance Works Funds - Cuts 4106 Refurbishment - Funding 14348 Regional Areas Closure 5369 Relief Teachers 11703 Retention Rates 2672 River Valley Primary - Bus Service for Students from Roelands 1777 School Grant for Rural Schools - Co mponent for Travel to Extracurricular Activities 14485 Staff New Formula 14354 Trial of Merit Selection 14349 Student Numbers 9467 Student Population 3259 Support to Students on War in Iraq 5996 Teacher Numbers 9468 Technology Upgrades 3781 Upper Swan Primary - Completion of Renovations 14486 Vandalism 2928 Vasse Primary - Security System 5755 Vocational Education and Training - Expansion of Programs 11743 Wanneroo Primary and Junior Primary 5237 Wilful Damage - Cost 1771 Year 10 Students 8132 Year 11 Students - Students Studying a Language Other Than English 14355 Year Levels Repeated and Skipped 1776 Years 11 and 12 - Compulsory School Years 4559 Smith, Mr Graeme - Principal of the Year Award 2002 - Statement 5823 Sport and Recreation Australian Football League - Funds for Football Development in WA 6814 Avon Descent - Funding 2848 Community Sport and Recreation Facilities Fund Program - Grants 2588 Country Sport Enrichment Scheme 5512 Events in the North West - Funding 2848 Grants for Elite Sportspeople 9493 Hall of Champions - Statement 2919 Hopman Cup - Venue 1200 Indigenous Population - Improvement of Facilities 5085 Noalimba Recreation Camp 827, 2818, 3000 North West Country Sport Enrichment Scheme 5512 Funding 2847, 9474 Safety Standards in Outdoor Recreational Industry 9476 Sporting Redevelopment Programs 5629 State Sporting Associations Grants - North West 3005 Perth Oval 2819, 3003 Soccer Sports Stadium at Perth Oval 8794 State Government Assistance 8006 Sporting Facilities - Priority List 1519 “Strategic Directions for Western Australian Sport and Recreation 2003-2005” - Statement 5561 Tennis Stadium - Location 4159 Trailswest 828, 2587 WA Little Athletics - Arena Joondalup - Grievance 1284 Walking Trails - Improvement 828 Western Australian Institute of Sport Athlete of the Year - Statement 2919 State Budget - Education Initiatives 9783 Stirling House Hostel - Alcohol - Leader of the Opposition 3347 240 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CARPENTER, HON ALAN JOHN (continued) Swimming Pool - Dampier - Grievance 9392 Universities Curtin University of Technology Grievance 10389 Statements 1974, 12448 Fees - Increase 7673 Funding - Impact of Federal Government’s Approach 10288 Graduates Maths, Science, LOTE and Information Technology 2574 Teaching Qualifications 2574 Guild Fees - Allocation 2520, 2521 Services and Amenities Fee 206, 207, 5447 University of Western Australia Centre of Excellence in Applied Organic Geochemistry - Statement 12448 National Union of Students - Contribution 2521 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9858 Second Reading 9858, 11308 Consideration in Detail 11528, 11529, 11541-11559 Third Reading 11771, 11774 CASH, HON SAMUEL GEORGE ERNEST, LLB (Hons) London, FCIS (North Metropolitan) (Lib) Aborigines Aboriginal Justice Council - Membership and Meetings 10150 Affirmative Action on Public Employment - Legislation 3612 Conservation Reserves - Transferring of Ownership 13349 Council of Aboriginal Elders - Abolition 9633 Pastoral Leases - Number Held 14214 Rock Art - Burrup Peninsula 7847, 8688 Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 Second Reading 14580 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14788-14851 Address-in-Reply Motion China - Natural Gas 51 Electricity Reform 51-59 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 3163 Albany Cemetery - Funeral Services 11057 Anti-Corruption Commission - Staff - Job Offers with the CCC and Redundancies 10789 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 Second Reading Government Accountability 6248 Recurrent Expenditure 6246 Committee 6950-6952 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 4) 2002 Second Reading Burt Commission on Accountability - Findings and Recommendations 6260 Capital Expenditure 6258-6260 Financial Administration and Audit Act - Functions of the Office of Auditor General 6261 Committee 6963 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading Budget 2002-03 Perth to Mandurah Railway 9529 Reviews 9529 State Debt 9527 Taxes and Charges - Increases 9521-9526 Trading Hours - Deregulation 9526 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading Capital Works Budget 9536 Former Minister for Housing and Works - Government Contracts 9539-9544 Attorney General’s Remarks - Urgency Motion 4385 Australian Competition and Consumer Commission - Samuel, Mr Graeme - Meeting with Premier 4396 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 241

CASH, HON SAMUEL GEORGE ERNEST (continued) Barrow Island Bill 2003 Second Reading 12985, 13030 Committee 13089-13103 Building Industry BGC Construction - Government Contracts 7645 Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded 9193; Urgency Motion 7294 Home Building Contracts Act 1991 - Section 21 - Remedies 8365 Business of the House - Minister for Housing and Works - Western Power and Mr David Eiszele - Discharge from Notice Paper 12409 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6963 Committee 9016-9018 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6963 Committee 9018 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9596 Chemistry Centre (WA) - Resignations 14636 Companies (Co-operative) Act 1943 - Amendments 7011 Corruption and Crime Commission - Anti-Corruption Commission Staff - Job Offers 10789 Criminal Property Confiscation Act - Contravention of the Bill of Rights 1689 12966 Debits Tax Assessment Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 3760 Debits Tax Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 3760 Drugs Alcohol and Drug Authority McCotter, Dr Denzil 13004, 13121, 13143 Termination of Contract 13352, 13864 Cannabis - Funding for Education 8686 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Taxi and Bus Drivers 7178 East Hamersley Primary School - Staffing Levels 861 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 Order Discharged - Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 6546 Second Reading 9806 Committee 11964-11979, 12278-12285, 12293-12312, 12511-12516 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision - Urgency Motion 1798 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14649 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14649 Committee 14832-14835 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14649 Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11442 Committee 11450 Environment Burns Beach Property Trust - Appeal 1567 Greenhouse Gas Emissions - Kyoto Protocol - Impact on Western Power 1261 Estimates Committees - Appointment Motion 7144 Amendment to Motion 7146 Motion, as Amended 7150 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3458 First Home Owner Grant Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 5404 Committee 5920 Forests and Forestry - Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736 - Motion for Disallowance 14026 Fuel and Energy Electricity Council of Australian Governments Agreement 3029 Electricity Reform Implementation Committee - Consultants’ Report - Tabling Motion 12413 Amendment to Motion 13336, 13338 242 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CASH, HON SAMUEL GEORGE ERNEST (continued) Fuel and Energy (continued) Electricity (continued) Reform Adjournment Debate 4985 Implementation 5019 Report on Options for Development in Western Australia 1662, 2482, 2511 Tariff Reduction 10092 Kwinana Power Station 13065, 13119 Renewable Energy Projects Adjournment Debate 579 Minister’s Commitments 712 West Kimb erley Power Project 14608, 14777 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) (Reviews) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7790 Government Construction Contracts Court Complex, Hay Street, Perth - Tender Process 11480 Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded 9193; Urgency Motion 7294 Government Departments and Agencies Aborigines - Affirmative Action on Employment - Legislation 3612 Budget Revenue 4527 Budget Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9984-9986, 10153, 10260, 10380 Court Action or Litigation - Involvement 7184-7202, 7325, 7459, 7460, 12289 Functional Review Taskforce Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9984, 10151, 10152, 10259, 10260 Management Initiated Redundancies 6124 Procurement Reform Process - Appointment of Consultants 12922 Register of Intellectual Property 5412, 6101-6119, 6325-6327, 6987, 6988, 7458, 7459 Schedule of Levies and Revenue 7010, 7327 Health BreastScreen WA - Services for Women 9568 Clinic Plane Based at Kununurra - Use by Medical Practitioners 10787 Medical Personnel - Negligence Claims - Limitation Period 10262 Medical Practitioners who Deliver Infants - Negligence Claims Limitation 9568 Occupational Therapists - Advertising 2123 Tetrahydrocannabinol 6958, 7178, 7453 Heritage Legislation - Introduction 14840 Home Building Contracts Act 1991 - Section 21 Remedies 8365 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Reinstatement - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1247 Homeswest - 6 Farr Avenue, North Perth - Renovation 2227 Hospitals Geraldton Regional Broad Construction Services Pty Ltd - Expression of Interest Documentation 14197, 14615 Tenders 12433 Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technology - Additional Funding 5410 Wyndham District - Visiting Medical Specialists 12555 Housing and Works, Department of Kununurra - Inspections of Rental Accommodation 10785 Non-residential Building Budget - BGC Construction Contracts 7645 Register of Intellectual Property Assets 4907 Indigenous Affairs, Department of Browning, Mr Paul - Appointment 4453 Kalgoorlie Office - Regional Manager 4341 Industrial Development Burrup Fertilisers - Commencement of Operations 10935 Burrup Peninsula - Native Title Agreement 9585, 9846 Burrup Rock Art 7847, 8688 Karratha - PKK Environment and Infrastructure Pty Ltd - Report 10935 Mungari Industrial Estate 4931 North West Shelf Project China - LNG Contract - Motion 831 Royalties Agreement 12144 Industrial Relations - Kwinana Power Station - Picket Line 13591 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 243

CASH, HON SAMUEL GEORGE ERNEST (continued) Insurance - Royal Life Saving Society of WA - Public Liability Cover 1005 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2893 Iraq Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 2730, 2853 Opposition to Proposed War - Urgency Motion 5039 Kimberley - Chemical Use Review - Status 11364 Land Certificate of Title Volume 1138 Folio 74 - Temopolous Family 1839 Clearing - Derby-West Kimberley, Shire of 10789 Crossing Falls - Land Development for Lifestyle Lots 1452 Lots 246 and 257 Lights Road, Denmark - Status 39 Land Administration, Department of Government Trading Enterprise 2604, 8412 Revenue Sharing Arrangements 11053 Land Tax Assessment Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4268 Land Tax Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4268 LandCorp - Allegation of Bias in Dealings with Licensed Real Estate Agents 9058 Local Government Derby-West Kimberley, Shire of Pastoral Lease Exclusions 11053 Permits to Clear or Maintain Road Verges 10789 Revaluations of Properties - Payments to Valuer General 10381 Unauthorised Demolition of Buildings - Upgrading of Powers 9633 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of - Town Reserves 740 Mozambique Rule 6300, 6459, 13352 Mungari Industrial Estate - Waste-to-energy Plant 4931, 7996 Native Title Burrup Peninsula - Agreement Details 9585, 9846 Derby-West Kimberley, Shire of 10788 Kununurra - Claims 10785 Nuclear Activities (Prohibition) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7809 Occupational Safety and Health Act 1984 - Parliament House 11208 Palaeontologic Objects and Other Fossils - Protection from Removal from Western Australia 5773, 6582 Parks and Reserves Conservation Reserves - Transferring Ownership to Indigenous Persons 13349 Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736 - Motion for Disallowance 14026 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of - Town Reserves 740 Pastoral Leases Aboriginal Interests - Number Held 14214 Aboriginal Living Areas - Establishment 6600 Adjournment Debate 4484 Amendments to Exclusion Document 13024 Bulka - Excision of Land 6600 Derby-West Kimberley, Shire of Letter on Pastoral Exclusions 11053 Pastoral Lease Exclusions 11053 Excisions Agreement and Negotiation 6600 Appeal Process 6601 El Questro Station 10934 Negotiating Teams 6997 Tabling of Information 6601 Exclusions - Freehold Land 10934 International Agreements and Covenants - Impact 13164 Meetings of Pastoral Working Groups - Pastoralists and Graziers Association Representative 6601 Reorganisation 3437 Windimurra - Mining Leases and Exploration and Miscellaneous Licences 1806 Working Groups - Members and Meetings 6602 Youanmi Downs Sandstone - Status 11602 Pay-roll Tax Assessment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 3760 Pay-roll Tax Bill 2001 - Second Reading 3760 244 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CASH, HON SAMUEL GEORGE ERNEST (continued) PCCOPS System 878 Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6968 Planning Burns Beach Lot 2 - Appeal 1567, 8412 Bushplan-Bush Forever - Tamala Park - Compensation 6327 Certificate of Title Volume 1138 Folio 74 - Temopolous Family 1839 Denmark - Pedestrian Access Way 552 Fitzroy Crossing Release of Residential Land 10788 Strategic Plan 11054 Hope Valley-Wattleup Redevelopment Compensation 5958 Voluntary Agreements 7313 Karratha - PKK Environment and Infrastructure Pty Ltd - Report 10935 Kununurra 1452, 10784, 10933 Land in Certificate of Title Volume 1138 Folio 74 - Purchase by WA Planning Commission 348 Lendich, Mr Vladimir - Bullsbrook Land 11054 Lennard Brook Easement, Gingin 9972 Lot 1409 Huntingdale Road, Huntingdale - Rezoning 1453 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment No 992/33 Clarkson-Butler - Disallowance 14823 Lot 2 Burns Beach 1533 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Zoning 466 Town Planning Scheme Amendments - Kununurra and Environs 10783 Ports and Harbours Hillarys Boat Harbour - Department of Fisheries Building 9025 Wyndham Jetty Piles Maintenance Work 162 Ord River District Co-op Plant and Buildings 10933 Plant and Equipment 1452 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Consultation 4027 Southern Rail Link Horseshoe Bridge 10150 Wentworth Hotel - Closure 4255 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6320 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7968 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours 4396 Roads Certificate of Title Volume 1138 Folio 74 - Purchase by WA Planning Commission 348 Hodges Drive-Karrinyup Road - Traffic Congestion 7461 Hospital Road - Upgrading 6606 Lennard Road Easement, Gingin - Paving 8673 Tom Price-Karratha - Funding of Upgrade 10788 Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody - Recommendations - Implementation 9633 Royal Life Saving Society of WA - Public Liability Cover 1005 Safer WA Community Security Program - Funding 3871 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 3758, 4267 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9328 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges Parts I and II - Adjournment of Debate at Conclusion of Second Reading Speech - Fourth Report 1542, 1929 Standing Orders No 61A - Consideration of Committee Reports - Sixth Report 3034, 3582 No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 1666, 2732, 3999 No 230(b) - Motion 2316 Standing Order No 73 - Amendment to Question 140 339 State Administrative Tribunal - Veterinary Surgeons - Complaints 10789 State Budget Cash Deficits 9361 Recurrent Expenditure and Capital Works Programs - Deferment or Cancellation 6988-6997, 7184 Revenue Estimates 12268 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 245

CASH, HON SAMUEL GEORGE ERNEST (continued) State Finance Government Financial Results Report 2001-02 - Capital Works Deferred, Delayed or Cut 2911 Stamp Duty 6280, 12004 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 - Restoration to Notice Paper - Motion 344 Strategic Management Council - Membership - Meetings and Role 5821 Succession Law - Reform 11835 Swimming Pool - Leonora - Government Funding 2764 Tabled Papers - Leader of the House Motion - Standing Orders Suspension 13338 Amendment to Motion 13336, 13338 Taxation - Payroll Tax Changes 4957 Reform - Tax-free Threshold 5316, 5662 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 3745 Committee 3880-3882, 4013-4022, 4030-4035, 4206-4222 Recommittal 3884-3896 Third Reading 4266 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 3745 Committee 3883 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) (Taxing) Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 3745 Taxis - Tetrahydrocannabinol - Maximum Amount for Drivers 7178 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Motion, as Amended 3862 The West Australian - Kununurra Delivery 1452 Transfer of Land Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 5406, 5414 Committee 5418-5421 Transperth - Cannabis Policy for Bus Drivers 7178, 7481 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading Commercial-in-confidence 9545 Confidential Information 9546 Government Accountability 9545 Treasury and Finance, Department of - Tender No 221/2003 - Political and Public Administration Services 4903 Unclaimed Money (Superannuation and RSA Providers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6418 University of Western Australia - Hackett, Mr Winthrop - Bequest 1738 Veterinary Surgeons Board - Complaints 10789 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1247 Committee 2632 Wanneroo Basketball Association - Relocation 5194 Water Corporation Lake Navarino Forest Resort - Water Supply 14030 Recurrent and Capital Works Programs 4205, 4936 Water Resources Bores - Water Users’ Charge 6083, 7477 Kununurra - Water Source Protection Plan 10786, 10787 Water Services Coordination Act - Review - Tabling by Leader of the House Motion 12413 Amendment to Motion 13336, 13338 Wild Dogs - Review 5533 Wentworth Hotel - Closure for Construction of Southern Rail Link 4255 Western Power Eiszele, Mr David - Employment Contracts 4201, 4448, 4533, 5050; Tabling of Papers 5397; Motion Discharged from Notice Paper 12409 246 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CASH, HON SAMUEL GEORGE ERNEST (continued) Western Power (continued) Electricity Tariff Reduction 10092 Forest Hill Vineyard Electricity Supply 8579 Kwinana Power Station 13591, 14616 Kyoto Protocol - Impact 1261 Wyndham Prawn Farm 10787 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1247 Second Reading 7417

CHAIRMAN OF COMMITTEES (Hon George Cash) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 - Committee - Ruling 13155 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee - Ruling 3726 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 2) 2001 - Committee - Ruling 5762 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Rulings 11329, 11330 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Committee - Statement 3317

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE, Minister for Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries; the Midwest, Wheatbelt and Great Southern; Leader of the Government in the Legislative Council (Agricultural) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Health, Office of - Mr Edward Shane Houston 9356 Alcohol on Community Lands - Prohibition 2867 Child Protection Workers - Placement 11481 Family Violence Prevention Support Service - North West 11481 Gordon Inquiry 2910, 4532, 6953, 12163; Statement 130 Government Programs 7844, 7846, 8407 Inalienable Freehold Title to parts of Conservation Estate 11830, 11831 Roebourne - Neglected Children 4448 Sites of Significance - Dunsborough Centrepoint Shopping Centre 13005 State Forests - Transfer of Ownership to Aboriginal Groups 11172 Swan Valley Nyungah Commu nity 4253, 4393, 7643, 7825, 13079 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Committee 12653, 12935-12951 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5658, 5786 Committee 5930-5933, 6044-6050 Third Reading 6052 Assembly’s Message 12393, 12394 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 First Reading 4291 Second Reading 4291 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14788-14791 Address-in-Reply - Motion, as Amended Agricultural Areas 4499 Bali Bombings 4499 Crime Rates 4497 Electricity Reform 4498, 4499 Nursing Services 4498 South West Region 4499 State Forests 4498 Adjournments of the House Complimentary Remarks 4538, 14846 Special 472, 1668, 3190, 4538, 7966 Agricultural Practices (Disputes) Act 1995 - Report 4378 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board Animal Pest Management - Feral Pigs and Emus 2872 Kimberley - Chemical Use Compensation 2122, 2604 Herbicide Drums Buried 8 Interim Report of Expert Medical Panel - Statement 5285 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 247

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Agriculture (continued) Agriculture Protection Board (continued) Kimberley - Chemical Use (continued) Reports 12287, 13118, 13592 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Inquiry - Amendment to Motion 10907 Statements 1630, 9544 Status 11364 Weed Control Chemicals and Equipment 14045 Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement - ALP’s Stance 10363 Bananas - Imports 12666 Cattle and Sheep Saleyards - Location 4902 Chemicals - Aerial Spraying - Legislation 12967 Chicken Meat Industry Act - Proposed Changes 10111 Climate Risk Management - Statement 13554 Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd 6, 11044 Dairy Industry Crisis - Ministerial Inquiry 9552 Deregulation 7644 European Dairy Farmers in Western Australia 2121 Overseas Farmers and Investors 2126 Re-regulation 10918 Damara Sheep - Environmental Impact 10781 Department Economic Analysis Capability 11599 Eucla Ravensthorpe and Esperance Offices 5193 Full-time Equivalents 1742 Functional Review Committee Review 5412 Institutional Biosafety Committee 593 Land Conservation Officers 3872 Merredin - Staffing and Funding 5534 Staff Appointments of Level 5 and Above 1739 Dogs, Wild 5314, 5533, 5664, 10248 Drought Assistance Breakdown of Expenditure 1951 Exceptional Circumstances Aid 2764, 3029, 3442, 4258, 4394, 5397, 11176 Government Package 2602 Northern and Eastern Wheatbelt 1532 Statements 2467, 5397, 5759, 13114, 13585 Supplementary Information 2120 Economic Impact 3729 Dwellingup - Chemicals Dump 8 Egg Industry - Deregulation 14837, 13117 Egg Marketing Board 9847, 6281, 10251 Employment of Underage Children on Farms 12270 FarmBis Western Australia - Funding 9584 Flatulence Tax on Livestock in Western Australia 9196 Flower Levy 11041 Food Irradiation - Quarantine Phytosanitary Measures 11602 Foxes 2123; Adjournment Debate 583 Gascoyne-Murchison Region - Shearing Numbers 6122 Genetically Modified Canola 6457, 11478, 12140, 12960 Genetically Modified Crops Gene Technology Agreement 466 Gene Technology Interdepartmental Committee 1661 Introduction 2603 Marketing Strategy 10481 Office of the Gene Technology Regulator 161, 245 Trials 161, 11833, 12927 248 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Agriculture (continued) Genetically Modified Organisms 6279, 7824 Grain Licensing Authority 5957, 14713; Statement 11565 Grain Marketing Legislation - Reform 862 Grain Pool of Western Australia - Merger with Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd 6 Harper Report - Herbicide Spraying 861 Hemp Industrial - Legalisation 7177 Horticultural Industry - Use of Chicken Litter 12670 Hydroponic Industry 9556, 11604 Indonesia and Singapore - Trade Potential - Statement 830 Institutional Biosafety Committee - Membership 40 Lamb - Definitions of Lamb Meat 7450 Land Water and Wool Sustainable Grazing on Saline Lands Subprogram 12558 Landcare Facilitators and Coordinators 161, 241, 352 Livestock Transport - Cost Impact of New Regulations 11599 Meat Processing Industry - Statement 229; Motion 10078 Mediterranean Fruit Fly - Quarantine Checkpoint 10091 Merredin - Evaporation Ponds 4341 Mesquite Control Policy 594 Midland Saleyards 160, 2873, 3732, 4204, 8366 Milk Prices 9971, 10480 Muchea Saleyards 10117, 13143 Multi Peril Crop Insurance Taskforce Report - Statement 4948 Northern Emu Barrier Fence 551 Noxious Weeds - Kalgoorlie-WA Border Railway Track - Control 11365 Onion Weed - Declaration as Noxious Weed 12141 Operation Minotaur - Adjournment Debate 583 Ovine Johne’s Disease 551, 14029 Parkeston Stockyards 11207, 11479 Persons under 18 Years - Harvesting and Carting Machinery on Private Property 12556 Pest Management - Inspections and Bounty 2872 Potato Marketing in Western Australia 5021, 9971; Statement 10882 Rabbit Control 14195 Saleyard Facilities 10481 Scott Coastal Plain - Water Allocation 14777 Skeleton Weed Eradication Program 538, 711, 1533, 3177, 12656, 14839 Strainer Posts and Fencing Posts - Cutting by Farmers for Own Use 14839 Three-horned Bedstraw - Eradication Funding 12141 Wanneroo-Carabooda Area 4342, 4345, 4400 Wheat Exports to Iraq 7 Impact on Crops of Snow in the Stirling Ranges 11043 Marketing - Single-desk Arrangement - Statement 6462 Outstanding Payments - Statement 6094 Variety WAWHT2248 - Release by Department 3872 Wheat Streak Mosaic Virus 8365 Wild Dogs - Increase in Pastoral Regions 2123 Albany Regional Prison - Staffing Levels 2483; Inspector of Custodial Services - Annual Report 3172 Alcoa World Alumina Australia - Wagerup Alumina Refinery - Future Tripartite Group 13006 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Committee 2889 Order of Business - Motion 2590, 2723; Amendment to Motion 2723 Anti-Corruption Commission 9063; Statement 14725 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Committee 9534l Arts and Culture Arts Events - Value Adding 4964 Perth Entertainment Centre 39, 4934 Australia Post - Bulbs and other Plant Species 12266 Australian Competition and Consumer Commission - Mr Graeme Samuel 3289, 4396 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 249

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Australian Labor Party Brochures Outlining the Outlook for Western Australia - Cost 2225 Northbridge Retailers - Donations 10365 Nuclear-powered Warships - Policy 4957 Western Australian State Conference - Environment and Sustainability 11883 Australian Wildlife Conservancy Ningaloo Development 4251, 4338, 4525, 5811, 5812, 5813 Wilson, Dr Barry 349, 1454, 3026, 5019, 5048, 5190, 6952 Bali Bombings 3866; Condolence Motion 1731 Baxter, Hon Norman Eric - Condolence Motion 13313 Buegge, Mr Bob - Adjournment Debate 5669 Building Industry - Builders Registration Board and Building Disputes Tribunal 14716, 14776 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 1668 Second Reading 1668, 1825 Cognate Debate 1816 Third Reading 1963 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 11580 Second Reading 11580 Business of the House Members’ Statements 6088 Order of Business 1639, 1640, 2860, 3270, 4500, 5285, 5636, 6305, 6414, 7828, 9029, 11442, 12104, 12227, 12411, 14626, 14804, 14820 Adjournment Debates 1035, 1166, 1266, 1553 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Motion 2590, 2723; Amendment to Motion 2723 Standing Orders Suspension 3584 Statements 3584, 7416, 11320 Personal Explanation 14804 Sessional Orders Suspension 7965, 10238, 14804 Standing Orders Suspension 10233 Statements 9926, 10327, 10379, 14204, 14726 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Restoration to Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message 13316 Third Reading 13555 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Restoration to Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message 13316 Cabinet Meetings - Confidentiality of Discussions 10380 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 7828 Hydroponic Equipment Policy 9556 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5658, 5786 Committee 5929, 5930 Third Reading 6051 Cockburn Sound - Dolphin Population - Studies 3024 Commerce and Trade Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement 10363, 12015, 12288 General Agreement on Trade in Services 5052 Live Sheep Export Ban on Export of Ewes 10090 Cormo Express 11175, 11821, 11838, 12292, 12553, 12664 Market Cultural and Religious Factors 12666 Replacement with New Processed Meat Markets 11890 Sabotage of Feed 13473, 13593 Committees and Boards - Appointments - Women 2512 Committees of the House - Reports - Consideration - Standing Orders Suspension 2735 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3737-3744 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Prescribed Burning Program 4341 Conservation Council of Western Australia 9843, 9969 Constitution Acts Amendment Act - Premier’s View on Referendum for Change 3022 250 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Consultants Change in Policy 11599 Six-monthly Returns 8674, 10091 Consumer and Employment Protection - Mr Pat Walker 3289 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Second Reading 11441 Coral Bay - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd 4392, 4446, 4525, 10110, 10111 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Committee 14754-14769, 14779-14782, 14826-14832 Further Recommittal 14826 Third Reading 14832 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment Bill 2003 Referral to Committee of the Whole House - Motion 14666 Committee 14751-14753 Report 14751 Recommittal 14751 Crime Community Safety and Crime Prevention Council - Funding Allocation 12289 Curfew for Juveniles in Northbridge 7175, 9974, 10365 North West Metropolitan Police District - Statistics 11174 Safer WA 12289, 13594 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 11582 Second Reading 11582 Defence Forces Lancelin Defence Training Area Delegation to the United States Military 1847 Environmental and Socioeconomic Impact 12162, 13081, 14841 Extension 865 Fire 5778, 7450, 9057 Permissive Occupancy Arrangement 1803, 14715 Proclamation 11039 Public Environmental Review 554, 11207 Training Activities 13070 Military Flights - Perth International Airport 12160 Nuclear-powered Warships - Labor Party Policy 4957 United States Navy Australian Marine Complex 12160, 12161 Discussions with Local Officials and Politicians 12158 Discussions with Washington Consultants 12275 HMAS Stirling Ammunition Facility - Nuclear Weapons 12569 Infrastructure Changes to Site 12161 Investigations into Ability of Australian Marine Complex to Meet Needs 12158 Sea-swap Operations Community Consultation 4528 Coordination 12275 Correspondence with US Government 6282 Evaluation of Trial 5024 Impact on Ecologically Sustainable Development 9986 Nature and Volume of Freight Transports 11884 Tabling of Correspondence 5537, 8397, 9556 Dogs, Wild 5314, 5533, 5664; Statement 6094, 7182 Domestic Violence - Joondalup - Reduction in Numbers at Domestic Violence Unit 3175 Drugs - Cannabis - Minor Offences - Legislation 4451 Dunsborough Centrepoint Shopping Centre - Cessation of Work 13005 Economy, Western Australian - Sustainability - Motion 11468 Education, Department of - Amalgamation with Department of Training 5313 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision - Urgency Motion 1808 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - First Reading 2507 Employment Advocate, Office of the - Wage Decisions - Government Action 5818 Employment and Training 1450, 5313, 5773 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 251

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 9927 Second Reading 9927, 11448 Committee 11450, 11451 Report 11451 Third Reading 11451 Environment Barrow Island 10482, 10483 Bio-Gene Bioprospecting Ltd - Plant Samples 13118 Coastal Region between Abrolhos Islands and Fremantle - Declaration 13590 Controls on the Rural Sector - Motion 12545 Damara Sheep - Environmental Impact 10781 East Kimberley Nature Reserves - Stock Incursions 10362 Firewood 9976, 10094 Greenhouse Gas Emissions 1261; Urgency Motion 996 Lancelin Defence Training Area - Environmental Impact 12162 Mallee Seed 13864, 14607 Narembeen Deep Drainage Project - Soil Conservation Notice 3336 Natural Heritage Trust 161, 241, 352 Regional Coastal and Marine Facilitator - South Coast Region - Funding 10089 Regional Herbarium Project - Volunteer Program 3023 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 2637 Second Reading 2637 Committee 10346-10360, 11143-11159 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 6414 Clearing Regulations 14615 Environmental Protection Authority - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd - Advice 10111 Environmental Protection, Department of - Hine, Mr Phillip - Alleged Breach of Code of Ethics 595 Estimates Committees Appointment - Motion 7143; Amendment to Motion 7146 Correction to Answer; Statement 8756 Finance Brokers Control Act - Repeal 7476, 8426 Fines, Penalties and Infringement Notices Enforcement Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 4037 Second Reading 4037 Fire and Emergency Services Body Bags Purchase 11208 Lancelin Defence Training Area - Fire 5778 Military Emergency or Retaliatory Attack - Essential Services 5022 Fisheries Coastal Region between Abrolhos Islands and Fremantle - Declaration 13590 Commercial - Licences to Trap Herring on South Coast 6955 Cottesloe Reef Fish Habitat Protection Area 10812, 12666 Crayfish Operators and Licences 2124 Dampier Archipelago - Coral and Live Rock Collection Licences 11600, 12957 Department - Mr Nic Dunlop 9843 Dolphins - James Point Cockburn Sound 3024 Dusky Whaler Sharks - Conservation Status 1843, 3439 Finfish and Mackerel Reviews 12959 Fish Habitat Protection Area - Volunteer Program - Funding 10812 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2002 Clause 5 Disallowance Motion 1641, 1644 Statement 1640 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Disallowance Motion 14586 Gascoyne and West Coast - Recreational Fis hing Regulations 5958 Houtman Abrolhos - Green Paper 3286 Indonesia and Singapore - Trade Potential - Statement 830 Lobster Pots 9586, 10808 Management Report - Statement 4240 Marron and Yabbies - Penalties for Stealing 5411, 8566 252 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Fisheries (continued) Palmer, Jeff and Gail 1841, 3028; Statement 12567 Pearl Farm Lease - Paspaley Pearling Company Pty Ltd, Encounter Cove Kimberley 8421 Recreational - GST Contribution 12960 Recreational Fishing Survey - Estimates of Catch 12959 Shark Bay - Prawn Trawling Fleet 10781 Shark Fishing 8675, 13120 Turtle Exclusion Devices on Vessels 11041 West Coast Rock Lobster Fishery Management Plan Amendment 2003 - Disallowance 12109 Western Rock Lobster Fishery 1006, 1140, 7314, 7647, 11600; Statement 12277 Wyndham Prawn Farm 10787 Forests and Forestry Alco, Yornup and Thornton Forest Blocks - Post-logging Audit 13008 Australian Forestry Standard - Certification 2761 Craft Wood Licensing System 1954 Draft Forest Management Plan Bole Logs Allocation 1008 First and Second Grade Log Allocation 351 Minister’s Submission 1658 Release - Statement 169, 10474; Sessional Orders Suspension 10472 Statements 11168, 11587, 11588 Farm Forestry Training - Departmental Responsibility and Fees 1450 Forest Products Commission 703, 4958, 5776, 5956, 9647, 9203, 9648, 9654, 10261 Gnangara Pine Plantation 713, 14800; Statement 1407, 13105 Greenbushes Timber Mill - Conditions on Allocation of Resources 1840 Hacketts Gully - Logging 13858 Infinitree Plantation Program 9360, 14714 Jarrah and Karri Allocation of Sawlogs - Companies Short-listed 14799 Logging Statistics 2902, 8413, 10483; Personal Explanation 6960 Request for Proposals - Stage B 2225, 2481 Sawlog Volumes 11182 Volume Sold from Bauxite Mines 12960 Logging Area and Volume 1560, 9619 Log Prices Review 1533 Meetings with Former Burke Government Ministers 6958, 7175 Recording in Forest Product Commission’s Accounts 5025 Timber Residue - Access for Craftwood Industry 7323 Ludlow Tuart Forest - Mining 12668 Manjimup 2874, 9357 Marri Clear-felling and Gap Creation 2228 Woodchips 7323, 9358 Nannup Timber Mill - Conditions on Allocation of Resources 1840 Native Forest and Plantation Stumpages - 11206 Old-growth Forest - Government’s Policy 7166; Urgency Motion 544 Pentarch Forest Products Pty Ltd - Stumpage Rates and Log Specifications 5662 Pinetec Pty Ltd 710, 1262, 13018, 1743, 11173 Pinjar Pine Plantations - Statement 1407, 13105 Richardson, Mr Trevor - Native Forest Log Sales Contracts 8676, 9628 Sawlogs from Mine Sites - Sale 6286 South West Sawmills - Resource Security Commitment 14776 State Forests Nos 15, 39 and 64 - Partial Revocation of Dedication 14592 Nos 7, 14, 16, 28, 32, 33 and 58 - Partial Revocation of Dedication 14591 Transfer of Ownership to Aboriginal Groups 11172 Timber Contracts - Financial Security beyond the Forest Management Plan 13860, 14198 Timber Allocations - Final Recommendations 8565 Warren Forest Region - Logging Roads 8413 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 253

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Forests and Forestry (continued) Wesbeam Pty Ltd - Timber Resource 1262; Statement 1407 Wespine Industries Pty Ltd - Pine Sawlogs 6282 Wood Cutters Sellers and Collectors - Goldfields - Licences 9646 Wood Sellers - Unlicensed 9647 Yanchep Pine Plantations - Statement 1407, 13105 Freedom of Information Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11025 Committee 11029 Fuel and Energy Electricity Council of Australian Governments Agreement 3029 Electricity Reform Implementation Committee - Consultants’ Report - Tabling Motion 12423 Amendment to Motion 13336, 13338 Reform - Frontier Economics Report Amendment to Motion 13336, 13338 Tabling 13339 Tariff Reduction 10092 Energy Reduction Targets 10366 International Hydrogen Conference, Broome - Funding 6328 Kwinana Power Station - Industrial Dispute 13119 West Kimberley Power Project - 14608 Gas and Electricity Safety Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 12912 Second Reading 12912 Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 49 Second Reading 10059 Personal Explanation 50 Gene Technology Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 49 Second Reading 10056 Personal Explanation 50 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 First Reading 9050 Second Reading 9050, 14200, 14605 Committee 14626-14633, 14643-14649 As to Third Reading 14726 Third Reading 14727, 14729 Government Advertising Budget - Government's Self-promotion Campaign 8433 Cost of Campaigns 11366 Expenditure 9065 Government Contracts In Excess of $50 000 9059 Panel Contracts - Number and Cost 13025, 13027, 13028, 13361, 13362 Government Departments and Agencies Aborigines - Programs 7844, 7846, 8407 Budget Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9984, 10380 Chief Executive Officers 8434, 9629, 10258, 11495 Consultants - Six-monthly Returns 8674 Court Action or Litigation - Involvement 7184, 7188, 7189, 7190, 7325 Directors General - Salary Packages 873 Energy Reduction Targets 10366 Functional Review Taskforce Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9984, 10259 Grants Loans and Financial Assistance 9067 Leave Liability 12431 Management Initiated Redundancies 6124 Media Advisers 12158 Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 11178, 11862, 11864, 11865 254 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Register of Intellectual Property 6101, 6102, 6107, 6325, 6326, 6327 Schedule of Levies and Revenue 7010, 7327 Wilson, Dr Barry 349 Government Jet - Use in October 2002 3609, 3727 Government Media Office - Recipients of Media Summaries and Transcripts 11878 Government Vehicles - Executive Vehicle Scheme 11192 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 First Reading 1666 Second Reading 1666, 1825 Cognate Debate 1816 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1825 Committee 1831, 1945-1948, 1957-1961 Recommittal 1962, 1963 Third Reading 1963 Health BreastScreen WA - Tabling of Document 9557 Department - Thornton, Ms Jean - Letter to the Premier 9848 Dumbleyung District Memorial Hospital - Statement 13598 Food Irradiation - Regulatory Controls 9555 Mental Health System - Funding Cuts 11601 Mustac, Dr - Medical Assessment Panel 14711 Smoking - NOHSC Guidance Note - Environmental Tobacco Smoke in the Workplace 12269 Heritage - Ellensbrook Precinct 3174 HMAS Orion - Dive Site - Location 3288 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1158-1161, 1252 Assembly’s Message 1446 Housing - Supported Housing Assistance Program - Criteria 6279 Immigration Detention Centres - Release of Children 9656 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Browning, Mr Paul - Appointment 4453 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula 3171, 3613 Gorgon Project 3024, 10483, 10918, 11038, 11884, 13024 Jervoise Bay Development - Dolphin Population 3024 Karratha and Barrow Island - Motion 4490 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 438, 1237 Pilbara - Protection from Terrorist Attack 5533 Industrial Hemp Bill 2003 First Reading 14154 Second Reading 14155 Industrial Relations Community and Public Sector Union - Wages and Conditions Bargaining 14770 Wage Decisions - Government Action 5818 Information Technology Contracting and Purchasing - Compliance Reviews - Statement by Minister for Housing and Works - Motion 12262 Insurance Claim of Blackmail by the Premier - Threshold on Claims 2480 Claims - 30 per cent Threshold 2761 Manipulation of Profits by Companies - Mr Brendan McCarthy’s Evidence 2602 Multi Peril Crop Insurance Taskforce Report - Statement 4948 Public Liability - Threshold on Claims 2480 Iraq Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 2597, 2730 Opposition to Proposed War - Urgency Motion 5040 Jeffery, Major General Michael, AC, MC - Governor General of Australia - Motion 9318 Joondalup Blue Light Drags - Funding 4451 Justice, Department of - Ministerial Councils for Corrective Services 12265 Kelly, Hon Garry Kenneth - Condolence Motion 28 Kings Park - Inalienable Freehold Title to Aboriginal Groups 11831 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 255

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Land - Clearing Gingin - Native Vegetation Clearing 10749 Guidelines - Statement 13554 Liveringa Station Camballin 11210 Swan Location 6845 3873, 4255 Legislative Assembly Recurrent Funding 14774 Second Reading Speeches - Interjections - Adjournment Debate 3061 Sittings 4198, 4203, 4400 Speaker - Deliberative Vote 1949 Legislative Council Attorney General’s Remarks - Question 4392; Urgency Motion 4381 Members’ Electorate Offices 9587 Pairing Arrangements - Adjournment Debate 2149 President - Deliberative Vote 1948, 2119, 2600, 3022 Recurrent Funding 14774 Sitting Hours - Statement 13014 Liquor Licensing - National Competition Policy 13070, 13117, 13147, 13346 Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week Trading - Petition 14724 Lobbyists Former Burke Government Ministers - Meetings on Logging 6958, 7175 Hawker, Mr Bruce - Meetings with Premier 6957 Local Government City of Joondalup - Chief Executive - Mr Denis Ian Smith 4344 City of Stirling - Waste Diverted to Atlas Calingiri Farm 13120 Mallee Fowl - Interpretive and Visitor Centre Ongerup 11601 Manjimup Premier’s Visit 4399 Relocation of Families 3618 Marine Parks and Reserves Authority - Dr Barry Wilson 1454, 3026, 5019, 5048, 5190, 6952, 7184, 7448 Marketing of Potatoes Act 1946 - Statement 10882 Members of Parliament Electorate Offices 8424 Giffard, Hon Graham - Leave of Absence 11437, 11960, 12278, 12912 Moore, Hon Norman - Personal Explanation - Coral Coast Marina Development 12103 Scott, Hon Barbara - Overseas Travel 4202, 4528 Mickelberg Case Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General Documents Given to Minister for Health 549, 1005, 1528 Late-night Telephone Discussion with Premier 160, 166 Receipt of Documents from Solicitor General 464, 860 Transcript of Assistant Commissioner Kucera’s Transcript of Evidence and Affidavit-in- chief 36 Government Media Personnel 241 Number of Copies and Source of Leaked Copy 345 Mining Inalienable Freehold Title to Aboriginal Groups 11830, 11831 Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining - Removal of Pinus pinaster 12668 Portman Iron Ore - Windarling and Jackson Ore Deposits - Archaeological Survey 13009 Sawlogs from Mine Sites - Forest Products Commission Role 4958 Ministers of the Crown Air Charter Flights 7013, 7165 Attorney General - Meetings with Solicitor General 464 Excessive Workload 2868 Government Vehicles - Accidents 11192 Minister for Education and Training - Answers to Questions - Statement 13013 Minister for Housing and Works - Deferral of Cabinet Reshuffle Decision 9191 Minister for Planning and Infrastructure 6277, 11478 Office Location and Refurbishment and Staff 2902, 2903, 3063, 3334, 3335 256 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Ministers of the Crown (continued) Parliamentary Secretaries - Visit to Croatia - Statement 11595 Personal Explanation - Karri and Jarrah Logging Statistics 6960 Portfolio Changes - Statement 9544 Premier Visit to China 1800 Visit to Japan - Meeting with Marubeni Corporation 3868 Visit to Manjimup, Pemberton and Bridgetown 4399, 4529 Visit to South Korea 2650 Workload 2868 Questions without Notice - Attendance in Chamber 3171 Statutory Obligations - Power of Minister to Direct 11478 Mobile Telephones - Coverage in Western Australia 244 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No.2) 2002 First Reading 9520 Second Reading 9520 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 First Reading 9519 Second Reading 9519 National Competition Council Council of Australian Govrnments Communique 11175 Judge, Ms Petrice 14635 Liquor Licensing Guidelines - Government’s Submission 13346 Potato Marketing in Western Australia - Funding Implications 5021 Native Title Burrup Peninsula Approvals 3171 Management Plan for Non-industrial Land 8671 Native Title Claimants 6282 Office of - Pilbara - Alcohol Consumption 4448 Pilbara - Termination of Proceedings in National Native Title Tribunal 8671 Ningaloo Reef Ningaloo Station - Briefing on Tourist Accommodation 5811-5813 Save Ningaloo Reef Campaign 4392, 4446 Tourism Development Proposals for Coast 10088 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 12637 Second Reading 12637 Parliament - Prorogation - Statement by Leader of the House 9149 Pastoral Leases Feral Goats - 4944 Kimberley - Sheep 710 Liveringa Station, Camballin - Land Clearing 11210 Management 11612 Windimurra - Zadow, Mr Dale 7013, 11613 Perth International Airport - Military Flights - Statistics 12160 Planning Mauds Landing Development Advertising Campaign 9581, 10117 Advice to Government 5529, 7184 Appeals Process 11598 Australian Wildlife Conservancy - Correspondence with Premier 4251, 4338 Commercial Conflicts of Interest 4392, 4446 Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd Advice Prior to Crown Solicitor’s Advice 12265, 12429 Appeals Committee Composition 11045 Crown Solicitor’s Advice 12002; Statement 12103 Economic and Social Benefits of Proposal 10745, 12161 Environmental Protection Authority’s Advice 12551, 13166, 13913, 13914 Environmental Risks and Management Needs 11038, 12569 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 257

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Planning (continued) Mauds Landing Development (continued) Legality of Decision 12285, 12286, 12430 Letter from EPA 10246, 10360 Meetings 4392, 4525 Ningaloo Advertising Campaign 9843 Premier’s Decision on Appeals 12140, 12430 Request for Reports on Appeals 12921 Premier’s Open Letter 9581, 10263 Premier’s Trip to Coral Bay 9968 Rejection Decision 9842; Motion 9959 Urgency Motion 4184 Wilson, Dr Barry 349, 1454, 3026, 5019, 5048, 5190, 6952, 7448 Written Decision 9969 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments No 1019/33 - Townsites in Stoneville and Parkerville - Postponement of Consideration 5761 No 1055/33 - Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Statement 13331 Pyrton Site - Management 9624 WA Planning Commission - Power of Minister to Direct 11478 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 456 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - First Reading 1835 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 12147 Second Reading 12147, 12640 Police North West Metropolitan Police District - Statistics 11174 Numbers - Western Australia 6283 Pay Dispute - Newspaper Advertisement 11038, 11173 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Raid 4253 Pollution - Omex Site - Remediation Costs 3176 Port Kennedy Golf Course - Ground Water Use 3172 Ports and Harbours Geraldton Port Authority - Dredging Operations 10089 Hillarys Boat Harbour - Department of Fisheries Building 9025 Mangles Bay Marina - Feasibility and Impact Statement 13473 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the Duty Media Adviser - Weekend of 7 and 8 June 2002 1745 International Hydrogen Conference Broome - Funding 6328 Office of Premier - New Position for Former Media Adviser 11478 Policy Office - Staff 11042 Public Sector Standards, Commissioner for 595, 9063 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Committee 7285 Questions on Notice Answers 1807, 2875, 6086, 6304, 10252, 11178, 11179, 11484, 12271, 12438, 14778 Minister for Education and Training - Statement 13013 Unanswered - Premier’s Pledge 11891 Questions without Notice 1965; Ministers in the Legislative Assembly - Refusal to Answer 11176 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Adjournment of Debate 2143 Standing Orders Suspension - 3271 Railways Doodlakine Station - Closure 9361 Noxious Weeds - Kalgoorlie-WA Border Railway Track - Control 11365 Perth Urban Rail Development - Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Motion 5936 Pine Sawlogs - Amount of Unused Resource 9627 Southern Rail Link - Patronage Forecasts - Statement 4888 Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Statement by President 5935 Regional Development - Rural Towns Project - Merredin 4341 258 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 4236 Second Reading 4236 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Standing and Sessional Orders Suspension 7949, 7966 Standing Orders Suspension - Second and Third Reading Stages - Time Management 7966 Amendments to be Put Before Sessional Order Invoked 7978 Committee 7978-7983 Assembly’s Message 8359, 8387, 8393 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation - Amendment to Motion 9178 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours 4396 Roads Albany Highway Bypass - Mt Barker - Statement 6094 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Statement 13331 Rural Areas - Expenditure 11177 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Interim Report - Statement 4888 Safer WA Community Security Program - Funding 3871 Salinity Beacon River Valley - Deep Drainage Project Funding 4450 Budget Allocation 7827 Drainage Systems - Review 5536 Engineering Evaluation Initiative Projects - Funding 11480 Funding - Catchment Demonstration Initiative 12009 Infinitree Plantation Program - Salinity Management Benefits 14714 Land Water and Wool Sustainable Grazing on Saline Lands Subprogram - Funding 12558 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality - Bilateral Agreement - 5662; 7451 Ord Irrigation Area 11882 Packsaddle Plain 9079 Research - Funding 11365 Wallatin Creek Catchment Project Doodlakine 13142 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children - Membership 13844 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5286-5299, 5636-5639 Select Committee on the Reserves (Reserve 43131) Act 2003 - Appointment of Members 9518 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 First Reading 4036 Second Reading 4036 Sessional Orders Continuation and Amendment - Motion 14842 Suspension 9549, 14592 Sewerage - Lancelin - Infrastructure 8417 Sittings of the House Adjournment Debate 4046 Days and Hours 1809; Motion 2468 Extended Times 471, 2751, 3270, 8391 Sessional Orders Suspension 7960, 9367 Sitting Dates for 2003 - Statement 3269 Southern Brush-tailed Phascogales - Mortalities 2124 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading Administrative Reform Measures 3603 Amendments Consequential to Taxation Administration Bill 2001 3603 Business Tax Review 3603 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 Motion 1663, 4497 Proposal to Travel - Motion 4493, 4496; Report 4492 Petition Presented by Mr Barry Granville Waller Motion 10087 Seventh Report - Amendment to Motion 14158;Motion, as Amended 14159 Special Report 4035 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 259

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Standing Committee on Legislation - Criminal Investigation (Exceptional Powers) and Fortification Removal Bill 2001 - Government’s Response to Report 4524 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges Standing Order No 61A - Consideration of Co mmittee Reports - Sixth Report 3583 Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 2736, 7443 President’s Ruling 2735 Progress 2735 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges Motion 9548 Amendment to Motion 9549 Motion, as Amended 9549 Standing Orders No 72 - Standing Orders Suspension 1792 No 73 - Amendment - Motion 130 Nos 208 and 209 - Amendment - Motion 5666 Suspension 9536, 14842 State Budget Government’s Self-promotion Campaign 8433 Recurrent Expenditure and Capital Works Programs - Deferment or Cancellation 6988-6992 Revenue Estimates 12268 State Finance Drought - Economic Impact 3729 Revised Government Financial Strategy Statement - Statement 2468 Stamp Duty - De Facto Relationships 6280 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 Restoration to Notice Paper - Motion 344 Order Discharged and Bill Referred to the Standing Committee on Legislation 5320 Second Reading 12395 Committee 12397-12405 Third Reading 12638 Strategic Management Council - Membership - Meetings and Role 5821 Tabled Papers Amendment to Motion 13336, 13338 Frontier Economics Report 13339 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2001 - Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) (Taxing) Bill 2001 - Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Telecommunications Mobile Telephones - Coverage in Western Australia 244 Security Arrangements for Infrastructure 13164 Terrorism - Pilbara - Protection from Attack 5533 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes Motion 3855 Amendment to Motion 3858 Motion, as Amended 3862 Standing Orders Suspension 3863, 4304 Trans-Tasman Mutual Recognition (Western Australia) Bill 2002 Leave to Introduce 10 Introduction and First Reading 10 Second Reading 3602 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 Cognate Debate 5658 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5786 Third Reading 6051 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7463 Trustees of Western Australia Limited (Transfer of Business) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6324 United States of America Australia’s Support for Military Action in Iraq - Motion 2597, 2730 260 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) United States of America (continued) Nuclear-powered Warships - Labor Party Policy 4957 Opposition to Proposed War on Iraq - Urgency Motion 5040 Support for Military - Urgency Motion 1411 United States Navy Australian Marine Complex 12160, 12161 Discussions with Local Officials and Politicians 12158 Discussions with Washington Consultants 12275 HMAS Stirling Ammunition Facility - Nuclear Weapons 12569 Infrastructure Changes to Site 12161 Investigations into Ability of Australian Marine Complex to Meet Needs 12158 Sea-swap Operations Community Consultation 4528 Coordination 12275 Correspondence with US Government 6282 Evaluation of Trial 5024 Impact on Ecologically Sustainable Development 9986 Infrastructure 12159 Nature and Volume of Freight Transports 11884 Tabling of Correspondence 5537, 8397, 9556 Task Force 12159 Veterinary Preparations and Animal Feeding Stuffs Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7122 Second Reading 7122 Voluntary Euthanasia Bill 2002 - Second Reading 11031 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement to Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1158-1161, 1251 Assembly’s Message 1446 Wambengers - Mortalities 2124 Waste Disposal Atlas Waste 13120, 8676, 11182 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility - Fugitive Emissions 6279 Water Corporation Market Equity Pty Ltd 5664, 5954 Ministerial Responsibility 5407 Water Resources Avon River - Tamarix Parviflora 10778 Champion Lakes Recreational Facility 6276 Farm Dams - Management Charges - Consultation 10477 Gascoyne River - Tamarix Aphylla 10778 Merredin - Evaporation Ponds 4341 Narembeen-Avon Drainage Works - Soil Conservation Notice 1950 Narembeen Deep Drainage Project - Soil Conservation Notice 3336 Port Kennedy Golf Course - Ground Water Use 3172 Scott Coastal Plain - Water Allocation 14777 Secret Harbour Golf Course - Ground Water Use 3172 State Water Strategy - Responsibility 5407 Wallatin Creek Catchment Project Doodlakine 13142 Water Restrictions 1839 Water Services Coordination Act - Review 12667, 13006 Tabling - Motion 12423; Amendment to Motion 13336, 13338 Yarragadee Aquifer 6276, 14711 Yenyening Lakes System 9974 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 715 Second Reading 715, 4537 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 12405 Second Reading 12405 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 261

CHANCE, HON KIMBERLEY MAURICE (continued) Western Power Access Requirements Regulations for Entry to Grid 3874 Electricity Tariff Reduction 10092 Kwinana Power Station - Industrial Dispute 14616 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7471 Workers Compensation Degree of Disability 12033 McCarthy, Mr Brendan - Evidence to Committee 2602 WorkCover WA - Deadline to Lodge Common Law Claim 3178 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1158-1161, 1252 Assembly’s Message 1446 Second Reading 4269

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (Mining and Pastoral) (GWA) Aborigines Aboriginal Cultural Materials Committee 4945, 5659, 6603-6605, 9649 Aboriginal Heritage Act 4945, 7179, 7450, 6085, 6457 Cheeditha Community 9022 Dampier Public Wharf - Engravings 10262 Electricity Supply Cost - Remote Communities 8422 Mt Henry Bridge - Aboriginal Site Clearance 9651 Ngaanyatjarra Council (Aboriginal Corporation) College - Funding 5974 Ngaanyatjarra Lands School 5973 Ngalia People - Yakabindie Nickel Project 6604 Ninga Mia Village - Relocation 4052, 4053, 4363 Reserve No 24574 Drilling Activity 4300, 6331, 6999, 8430, 9377, 10381 Dumping of Waste Rocks up to Boundaries 4301, 6122 Relocation Costs 4064, 7838 Rock Art Burrup Peninsula Assessment of Impact of Emissions 4298, 4527, 7014 Disturbance and Loss 6303, 6460, 6584, 7512 Evaluation 10931 Minimisation of Emissions 7203 Monitoring Committee - Funding 8576 Murujuga Rock Art Estate 2766, 6584 Petition 6289 Karijini National Park - Vandalism 9080 Sites of Significance Assessment and Deletion from Register 11832 Excavation Applications 7450 Heritage of WA Act 12146, 12965 Protection 6085, 6457, 7019, 12006 Swan Valley Nyungah Community 4253, 4393, 4945, 4946, 7643, 13079 Tjalka Boorda Aboriginal Community - Sewage Treatment Ponds 5960 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5781 Address-in-Reply - Motion Energy Renewal 837 Greenhouse Gas Emissions 843 Adjournment of the House - Special 6589 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Kimberley - Chemical Use - Review 900, 9517, 10900, 12663, 13118, 14045 Chemicals - Aerial Spraying - Legislation 12967 Cotton Industry, West Kimberley 9195, 9970; Petition 8756 Damara Sheep - Environmental Impact 10781 Dwellingup - Chemicals Dump 8 Elevated Work Platforms - Legislation 7824 262 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Agriculture (continued) Gascoyne-Murchison Region - Shearing Numbers 6122 Harper Report - Herbicide Spraying 861 2,4,5-T - Kimberley - Statement 7321 Drums in Dwellingup Area 2346 Ord River Stage 2 - Interim Joint Proponents 2869 Western Agricultural Industries - Memorandum of Understanding 11039 Air Transport Eastern Goldfields - Transport Board - Act - Machinery of Government Report 10930 Perth-Broome Air Freight Service - Petition 9149 Shark Bay Airport - Power Supplies 11862 Alcohol - Derby - Alcohol-related Medical Treatment 12435 Anti-Corruption Commission - Monitoring of Compliance with Code of Ethics 9063 Australian Labor Party Energy Platform 12026-12027 Environment and Sustainability 11883 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes 12982 Second Reading 13038 Committee 13089-13103 BHP Billiton Ltd - Port and South Hedland - Asbestos Sheeting 1003 Bills, Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message 1160 Boab Inn, Derby - Extension of Trading Hours 11613 Boxing Control Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6319 Burrup Peninsula (Crown Land) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 4502 Second Reading 4502 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13319 Committee 13324 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7798 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5781 Committee 5929 Carnarvon - Surge Wall Project 163 Character First - Adjournment Debate 3468 Colleges of TAFE Hedland Campus - Down-sizing 14870, 14871 Kimberley - Budgeted Student Contact Hours 14045 Pundulmurra Campus - Selection Process for Manager 3773, 11478 Community Development Department - Derby - Staff 12955 Employment Project - Complaint about Forging of Signatures 11478 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3741-3744 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Kimberley 9373 Consumer and Employment Protection - Complaint about Forging of Signatures 9022 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Second Reading 11438 Committee 11584-11586, 12386-12392 Coral Bay - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd 1675, 4025 Drivers Licences - Remote Communities 1736 Eastern Goldfields Transport Board Act 1984 - Machinery of Government Report 10930 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14669 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14669 Committee 14832-14835 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14669 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3463 Employment Advocate, Office of the - Wage Decisions - Government Action 5818 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 263

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11447 Committee 11450 Environment Approval Process - Transparency 9207 Barrow Island Building Demolition - Asbestos Disposal 10482 ChevronTexaco - Breach of DEP Licence Conditions 14042 Demolition Work - Waste Disposal 12016 Fauna Road Kills 9626 Naturally Occurring Radioactive Material 10367; Statement 10378 BHPB Briquette Shiploader 443 Brickworks Emissions - Consultant’s Report 9630 Burrup Peninsula 5779, 7996 Conservation Estate - Grazing Impacts 9845 Damara Sheep - Environmental Impact 10781 Dampier Public Wharf Expansion - Impact 463 Dwellingup - Drums Containing Herbicides 2346 East Kimberley Nature Reserves - Stock Incursions 10362 Environmental Approval Process - Transparency 10774, 10776 Environmental Enforcement Unit - Establishment 7006 Goats, Feral - Damage to Conservation Estate 12016 Greenhouse Gas Emissions 995, 4294-4295, 4450, 4942 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Community and Industry Reference Committee 10258, 11373 Kalgoorlie Cement Works Acoustic Consultant and Stormwater Run-off 7837 Adjournment Debate 1836 Breaches of Occupational Safety and Health Legislation 9378 Compliance with Departmental Instruction 7507 Department of Environmental Protection Orders 5678 Document Improvement Notice 5807, 5808 Dust Complaints 5970, 9652 E-mail about Dangerous and Unsafe Work Practices 9375, 9643 Improvement Notices 5076, 5077 Letter from Acting Minister for the Environment and Heritage 9646 Licensing under the Environmental Protection Act 9632 Noise Levels 469, 5676, 7003, 9649 Occupational Safety and Health Legislation Breaches 8433 Petition 1403 Soil Contamination and Toxic Dust 13015 Trailers - Roadworthiness 9616 Unlicensed Forklift on Wilson Street 9616 Unsafe Work Practices 9376, 9377 Verbal Directions on Safety Issues 8430 Vexatious Complaints 7653 Video of Worker Spraying a Diesel-engine Oil Aerosol Solution 4903 Website - Investigations 5677 WorkSafe Improvement Notices 6466 Kimb erley Prawn Farm 1531, 1806 Mt Gibson Station - Field Report on Endangered Flora 11879 Plant and Animal Extinctions in Australia - Statement 13596 Plastic Bags - Levy 1804, 3335 Spoil Bank, Port Hedland - Vehicle Access 3470 Whitlock Creek - Dredge Spoil 12038 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 6417 Environmental Protection Authority Formal Assessment Process 8420 LeProvost, Mr Ian - Conflict of Interest 1271 264 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Environmental Protection, Department of Code of Conduct and Public Sector Code of Ethics 7992 Hine, Mr Phillip - Alleged Breach of Code of Ethics 595 Kalgoorlie Regional Office 8782, 9653 Mistakes 7003 Water and Catchment Protection - Records of Decisions and Actions 9062 Euthanasia - Voluntary - Petitions 1521, 5636 Fire and Emergency Services Authority Charter Flights in the Kimberley 9621 Fires on Derby Highway 9623 Prescribed Burns - Incendiary Devices 9623 Kimberley - Permits to Burn 10149, 10154 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 1441 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3457 Fisheries Dampier Archipelago 11600, 12957 Kimberley Prawn Farm 1531, 1806 Pearl Farm Lease 8421 Shark Bay - Prawn Trawling Fleet 10781 Forests and Forestry Forest Products Commission - Request for Tender No 2655 703, 9647, 9648, 10261 Wood Cutters, Sellers and Collectors - Goldfields - Licences 9646 Wood Sellers - Unlicensed 9647 Fuel and Energy Barrow Island - Oil Production Facilities 9566 Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline - Management and Maintenance 9373 Electricity Aboriginal Communities 8422 Cost of Generation 13861 Reform - Frontier Economics Pty Ltd Study Motion 12427 Amendment to Motion 13337, 13338 Tabling 8567 Field Use and Unaccounted for Gas - Emissions 12952 International Hydrogen Conference Broome - Funding 6123, 6328 Mumbida Wind Farm Proposal - Request to Proceed 11372 Renewable Energy Access Regime - Introduction 9374, 13349 Renewable Energy Sector - Statement 13596 Government Departments and Agencies Chief Executive Officers - Inaccurate or Misleading Information to the Minister 8434, 9629, 10258, 11495 Media Advisers 12158 Public Sector Management Administrative Instruction 728; Tabling 12023 Greens (WA) - Resources - Statement 9201 Health Asbestos - BHP Billiton Ltd Housing in Port and South Hedland 1003 Brookdale Community Health Centre - Community Nurse 9561 Cancer-related Illnesses - Statistical Data on Patients 14621 Derby - Alcohol-related Medical Treatment 12435 Laverton - Agency Nurses - Expenditure 7007 Heritage of Western Australia Act 1990 - Aboriginal Sites of Significance 12146, 12965 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1160 Second Reading 2148 Homeswest 28 and 30 Phoenix Place, Kalgoorlie - Completion 7476 Kalgoorlie - Antisocial Behaviour 5054, 7476 Hospitals Broome District - Staff-patient Ratios and Bedding 38 Derby Regional 1419, 3194, 4205, 11614 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 265

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Hospitals (continued) Paraburdoo - Future Plans 4063 Radioisotopes Usage 10794 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Offices - Closure Relocations 14639 Industrial Development BHP Billiton - Port Hedland - Iron Ore Dust Contamination 14198 Burrup Peninsula Adjournment Debate 4988 Archaeological and Ethnographic Surveys 7996 Correspondence with His Royal Highness Prince Charles 3613 Development 10930 Infrastructure Funding - Breakdown 4366 Murujuga Region - Tabling of Federal Minister’s Letter 6584 Native Title Affidavits 2480 Preservation - Petition 4 Service Corridors 10773 Use of Intercourse Islands or Maitland for Industrial Purposes 4299 West Intercourse Island 5779, 6584 Woodside Petroleum Ltd - LNG Plant - Emissions 8420 Cockburn Cement Ltd - Breach of Licence Conditions 11882 Funding - Budget Breakdown 12017 Gorgon Project Carbon Sequestration Program - Monitoring 13019 ChevronTexaco - Breach of DEP Licence Conditions 14042 Conservation Projects Contribution 10919 Date of Development Advice 13020 Development 9975 Environmental Evaluation 13020 GTL Resources PLC - Methanol Proposal - Environmental Assessment 1271 Karratha and Barrow Island - Motion 4246, 4305, 4435 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 1141 Resource Projects - Funding - Breakdown 12020 Industrial Relations Legislation - Adjournment Debate 59 Wage Decisions - Government Action 5818 Industry and Resources, Department of Advice to Magistrates - Statement 7182, 8683 Political Recommendations by Officers 12023 Records of Decisions and Actions 10143 Iraq War Adjournment Debates 1672, 5557 Urgency Motion 5043 Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 2002 Second Reading 578, 843 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to the Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Motion 851 Jerrold, Mr Kenny - Statement 13011 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Community and Industry Reference Group - Chairperson 10804 Land Clearing - Liveringa Station, Camballin 11044, 11210 Land Administration, Department of - Deposited Plans 194089, 194090 and 194091 - Tabling 1838 Legislative Assembly - Sittings 4203, 4400 Legislative Council - Attorney General’s Remarks - Urgency Motion 4384 Local Government Act - Review 13470 Contract Superintendents 1740 East Pilbara, Shire of - Relocation of Land to the Town of Port Hedland 14801 Rating System and Distribution of Funds - Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment to Motion 11987; Amendment on the Amendment 11999 Roebourne, Shire of - Correspondence from Mrs Weightman 11362 Westonia, Shire of 14028 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of 13028, 13895 266 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Members of Parliament Greens (WA) - Salary Increases - Adjournment Debate 1672 Sharp, Hon Christine - Leave of Absence 4241 Watson, Hon Giz - Leave of Absence 2111 Mineral and Petroleum Resources, Department of Breaches of Mining Act 4370, 7652, 9207, 10142, 10774, 13911 Cooke Review - Incorrect Information 4933 Director General - Letter to Editor 10146, 10147 Inspections and Prosecutions 12954 Records of Decisions and Actions 8430, 10144 Mining 12-hour Shifts - Review 4936 Aboriginal Sacred Sites - Protection 12006 Answers to Questions on Notice - 6998, 7000, 7013 Australian Prospectors and Miners Hall of Fame - Access Road 6998, 9206, 10775, 10936 Big Bell Mine - Tailings Storage Facility 1674 Bowler Report into Mineral Exploration - Government’s Response 11240 Bulong Nickel Mine 4361, 4053 Coalition Government’s Policy Paper - Treatment of Prospectors’ Ore 4368 Croesus Shaft Site Visit 8399, 8400, 10143 Dallhold Resources Management Pty Ltd - Tailings Dam 4369 Exploration and Mining Tenement Holders - Expenditure Exemptions 9562 Fimiston Site Contamination of Water 9077 Depth Width and Length of Super Pit 6332 EPA Service Unit Investigation 10809, 10810 Increase in Capacity 13017 Licence Conditions 1269, 1270, 1556, 5021, 5819, 8780 Monitoring 1272 Pollution Leakage and Seepage 10777 Unconditional Performance Bond 4369, 6122 Works Approval 652 12955 Gidgi Site 1269, 1270, 1272, 1556 Goldfields Ltd - Kundana Gold Mine 13898-02 Greenfields Mineral Exploration Guidelines 8435, 10144 Inquiry 4374-4376, 6607 Hazards of Old Workings 7328 Jubilee Gold Mine - Licence Conditions 1269, 6466, 9651 Jundee Gold Mine - Licence Conditions 1556 Kalgoorlie - Town Site Boundaries 1559 Kalgoorlie-Boulder 1565 Kalgoorlie Consolidated Gold Mines Pty Ltd Acoustic Noise Consultant 9647 Asbestos in Open Pit 4056, 7001 Blast Hole Drill Rigs 1557 Breach of Licence Conditions 1273, 1454, 4054, 4055, 10794, 10808, 13015 Breaches of Mining Act 1564, 3905 Closure Plan for Mt Charlotte Mine 1558 Cooke Review - Submissions 4364 Environmental Bond 8429, 10142 Fimiston Tailings Dams 13906-13910 Hounslow, Mr B. 1557 Licence Conditions 7508, 7993 Ninga Mia Village 4052, 4053, 4363 Prospecting Licence 26/2665 4362 Realignment of Eastern Bypass Road - Funding 4301, 4360, 4373, 4546; Petition 4052 Rehabilitation of Tenements 4361, 7203 Relocation of Railway Line 3904 Removal of “Cyanide” from Licence Conditions 8780 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 267

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Mining (continued) Kalgoorlie Consolidated Gold Mines Pty Ltd (continued) Super Pit Mining Operations 1273, 1564, 1566, 4051, 4368, 5806, 7000 Waste Dump Proposal - Environmental Bond 4368 Kundana Gold Mine - Breach of Licence Conditions 7839 Lake Yellowdine - Discharges 13902 Leases No 26/261 4064, 4300, 4301, 6122, 6331, 6999, 7838, 8430, 9377, 10381 No 26/353 12022, 13905 No 26/383 10936, 10938 No 36/7 7328, 7838, 9062, 9206, 10773 Nos 24/352, 24/390, 24/39, 24/40 and 24/41 10772, 12953 Nos 25/32, 25/19 and Prospecting Licence 25/525 10774, 12953 Nos M25/19 and M25/32 - Clearing of Vegetation 1558 Standard No Mining Condition - Validity 4367 Loongana Lime Breaches of Licence Conditions 11881 Burning of Waste Oil 7995 Complaints 7005, 13016 Kiln Temperature Readings 9631 Licence Conditions 7005, 8431, 8777, 8779 Mineral and Gold Deposits - Determination of Economic Viability 3905 Minerals Environment Liaison Committee - Membership 7329 Mt Charlotte Site 4371, 4372, 10148, 10149, 12024 Mt Gibson Integrated Iron Ore Deposit 10932 Mt Percy Open Pits 4363 Mt Pleasant Gold Mine - Licence Conditions 1270, 7000 Open Pit - Calculation of Bonds 3905 Optimum Resources 6959, 9208 Oroya Tailings Dam 5801-5805, 7652, 8780, 8781 Parks and Reserves - Prohibition on Mineral and Petroleum Exploration and Mining 11883, 12025 Portman Iron Ore Ltd Cockatoo Island - Breach of Licence Conditions 8678, 9620 Koolyanobbing Mine - Expansion 5317, 5659, 6604, 8423 Windarling and Jackson Ore Deposits 13009 Prospecting Licence P25/525 - Clearing of Vegetation 1558 Regulation - Answers to Questions 8429 Rio Tinto Exploration Pty Ltd - Lease 45/695 4992 Tailings Dams 2511, 6999 Tenements P26/1848 and P26/1858 - Dangerous and Unsafe Working Conditions 11241, 12952 Uranium - Yeelirrie 242, 3729 Western Metals Export Facility, Derby 1137 White Foil Project 11236-11239 Williamstown 1675, 4932, 7203 Windarling Range - Portman Mining Ltd - Conditions 13009 Windimurra Vanadium Mine 7651, 9554, 11880, 12021 Yakabindie Nickel Project 4530, 6603, 6604 Minister for State Development - Letter from Mr K. Bartle, Kalgoorlie 3907 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 13995 Committee 13995 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading 13343 Native Title - Burrup Peninsula 2480, 4298, 4299, 5779 Ngaanyatjarra Council (Aboriginal Corporation) College - Funding 5974 Ngaanyatjarra Lands School 5973 Ningaloo Reef - Permanent Dive Site Moorings 11879 Nuclear Activities (Prohibition) Bill 2002 Second Reading 7812 Impact on Mining and Exploration Leases 4367 268 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Offshore Minerals Bill 2001 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5923 Committee 5924-5927 Offshore Minerals (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5923 Offshore Minerals (Registration Fees) Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5923 Parks and Reserves East Kimberley Nature Reserves - Stray Livestock 11494 Gascoyne-Murchison Region - Goats - Damage 12016 Karijini National Park 4366, 9080 Point Spring Nature Reserve - Fencing of Boundaries 12922, 13912 Prohibition on Mineral and Petroleum Exploration and Mining 11883, 12025 Pastoral Leases Feral Goats - Management 11612 Liveringa Station, Camballin - Land Clearing 11044, 11210 Livestock Straying onto East Kimberley Nature Reserves 11494 Mt Gibson Station 11879 Rangeland Reports 12015 Windimurra Correspondence with Pastoral Lands Board 11372 Purchase by CALM 11880 Zadow, Mr Dale 5192, 5532, 7013, 8398, 11613 Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 6972 Statement 7321 Planning Hampton Location 135, Kalgoorlie 4299 Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Freehold Lots 2154 Mauds Landing Development Rejection Decision - Motion 9964 Urgency Motion 4185 Viability 4024 Peel Region Scheme - Disallowance 5548 Port Hedland - Coastal Management Plan 2911 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of - Reserve No 41812 13028, 13895 Planning and Infrastructure, Department for - International Hydrogen Conference Broome - Funding 6328 Police Corporate Assistance 10771 Derby 12552, 13018 Officers - Retiring - Annual and Long Service Leave 9056, 10771 Pilbara District Police Office 9622 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Raid 4253 Pollution Contaminated Sites - BHP Billiton, Newman 8367 National Pollutant Inventory - Pollution Emission Figures 7019, 8410 Port Hedland - Iron Ore Dust Contamination 14198 Ports and Harbours Broome 6586, 8400, 8684, 8688 Dampier Public Wharf Expansion 463, 10262 Port Hedland Port Authority - Spoil Bank - Vehicle Access 3470 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 12237 Committee 13991-13994 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - International Hydrogen Conference Broome - Funding 6328 Public Sector Standards, Commissioner for Anti-Corruption Commission 9063 Hine, Mr Phillip -Alleged Breach of Code of Ethics 595 Questions on Notice - Answers Breach of Standing Orders 6998, 7000, 7013 Premier’s Pledge 11891, 13911 Relevance - Provision of Answers 4301 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 269

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Questions on Notice - Answers (continued) Tabling with Production of Documents - Motion 12409; Withdrawal of Motion 12986 Racing - Golden Mile Trotting Club 743 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Committee 8655-8670 Railways Kalgoorlie - Relocation of Line for Mining Purposes 3904 Loopline Tourist Railway Boulder-Kalgoorlie 1274, 4360 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 Second Reading 6427 Committee 6551-6553 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Second Reading 7974 Assembly’s Message 8373-8391 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation - Amendment to Motion 9182 Roads Australian Prospectors and Miners Hall of Fame - Access Road 6998, 9206, 10775, 10936 Cape Leveque Road East of Broome to One Arm Point Community 11055 Kalgoorlie Eastern Bypass Road 4301, 4360, 4546, 4373, 7328; Petition 4052 Lake Raeside Crossing Upgrade - Funding 7651 Mt Henry Bridge - Aboriginal Site Clearance 9651 Yampire Gorge Road - Closure 4366 Salinity Ord Irrigation Area 11882 Packsaddle Plain 9079 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children (Appointment of a Commissioner for Children) - Motion 7638; Amendment to Motion 7639 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5286-5299 Sewerage Port Hedland Sewage Treatment Ponds - Tjalka Boorda Aboriginal Community 5960 Shark Bay 10780 Shark Bay World Heritage Interpretive Centre - Delays 11052 Standing Order No 230 - Amendment - Motion 14694 Tabled Papers - Leader of the House Motion - Standing Orders Suspension 13338 Amendment to Motion 13337, 13338 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5781 Vinnicombe, Dr Patricia - Statement 5962 Voluntary Euthanasia Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 1128 Referral to Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes 1128 Second Reading 1128 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1160 Waste Disposal Brookdale Community Reference Group 9645, 9983, 11880 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility 7003, 9561 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Yarri Road Waste Disposal Ponds and Tip Facility 4053 Kalgoorlie Liquid Waste Disposal Companies 5678 No 5 Greenfield Street, South Hedland Rural Estate 9643 No 972 Leehey Street, Wedgefield, Port Hedland 9622 Nufarm Ltd - Licence for Disposal of Chemicals 13896 Total Waste Management, Kalgoorlie-Boulder Depth to Ground Water 9650 Enforcement of Licence Conditions 7002 Licence Agreement 4959 Licence Conditions 11071, 12953 Monitoring Bores 7001 Odours 7840 Solid Waste Treatment 9060 Toxic Waste from Brookdale Waste Facility 7002 Waste Control Pty Ltd, Bellevue 13903, 13904 270 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CHAPPLE, HON ROBIN HOWARD (continued) Water and Rivers Commission - Penalties for Breaches of Licence Conditions 9644 Water Resources Community Water Forums - Kununurra 4433 Laverton - Water Quality 5817 Newman - Ground Water Contamination 8367, 11174 Shark Bay Cemetery - Pipeline Charges 10780 Tamarix Aphylla 10778, 10779 Water Services Coordination Act - Review - Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12427; Amendment to Motion 12427, 13337, 13338 Whitlock Creek - Dredge Spoil 12038 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13884 Western Power Access Requirements Regulations for Entry to Grid 3874, 5772 Average Unit Cost - Publication 4303 Disaggregation 10809, 12025 Shark Bay Airport - Power Supplies 11862 Wittenoom 3471, 6278 WorkSafe Western Australia Elevated Work Platforms - Legislation 7824 Imp rovement Notices Issued to Anti-Corruption Commission 8431 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1160

CONSTABLE, DR ELIZABETH, PhD (Churchlands) (Ind Lib) 990 6RPH Information Radio - Funding 2572 Aborigines Abused and Neglected Children 4673 Children in Foster Care 4673 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2540 Consideration in Detail 2563, 2564, 2567, 2837, 2838, 2942, 2953, 2958-2962 Adoption Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander Children - Foster Care and Abuse 4673 Budget Allocation 9494 Carer and Relative Inter-country Inquiries 4674, 5175 Health Assessment of Applicants 5174 Inquiries for Carer Adoption 4674 Laws - Petition 1970 Overwe ight Applicants 7107 Procedures for Birth Parents to Make Inquiries 4673 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 1859 Consideration in Detail 3082-3086, 3098-3103, 3206-3211, 3214-3223, 3237, 3238, 3242, 3365-3369, 3384- 3387, 3390, 3396-3400 Council’s Amendments 5727-5732 Animal Welfare Act - Appointment of Scientific Inspectors 8871 Banksia Hill Detention Centre 5757 Bold Park - Capital Funding Allocations and Operational Budget 1758 Cannabis Convictions 7108 Offences - Statistics 8514 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6720 Consideration in Detail 6774 Community Development Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander Children - Foster Care and Abuse 4673 Child Abuse - Government Inaction - Matter of Public Interest 9095 Child Death Review Committee 5175, 6240 Children in Care - Allegations of Abuse While in Care 8180 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 -Referral to Select Committee 5499 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 271

CONSTABLE, DR ELIZABETH (continued) Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5570, 5589, 5590, 5701-5708, 5979-5982 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 Second Reading 8068 Consideration in Detail 8295-8299, 8303, 8319, 8326, 8332, 8333 Recommittal 8336 Crime Motor Vehicle Break Ins 8076, 12374 Statistics 8076 Disability Services Autism - Early Intervention Programs 14554 Commission Cleaning Services 5721 Health Services 13278 Diermajer, Mr Aaron - Petition 4588 Turpin, Mr Boris - Petition 10168 Drivers Licences - Waiting Time for Practical Test 8075, 10878 Education Department - Internet Bandwidth Cost and Policy on Internet Use for Students 11947 Secondary Graduation Certificates - Number 5518 Teachers 400 New Teachers for 2003 1784 Complaints of Physical and Sexual Abuse of Students 1774, 5625 High Schools - Male Teachers 1786 LOTE, Technology and Enterprise, Science and Mathematics 14966 Numbers 1785, 1786, 5624, 9468 Potential Teachers Available to Rejoin Profession 1783 Primary - Male Teachers 1785, 1786 Projected Number of Retirements 1784 Recruitment Numbers for 2003 1783 Retirements and Resignations 1784-1786 Stress Leave 5624 Environment Environmental Enforcement Unit - Tasks and Powers 5910 Legislation - Complaints of Non-compliance 7100 Sand Pile, Lot 2000 Pearson St, Churchlands 7751 Fire and Emergency Services Levy - Revenue 14487 Freedom of Information Amendment Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 11313 Second Reading 12482 Gaming Machines - Western Australian Clubs 1127 Gorgon Project - Employment Opportunities 11959 Government Advertising - Open Letter to the Prime Minister from the Premier - Cost 10637 Government Departments and Agencies - Consultants 3705 Government Media Office - Budget and Staff 2996, 6036 Guardianship and Administration Board - Location 5754 Health Aged Care - Respite Accommodation 8518, 8519 Audiology Services - Statistics 14138 Autism 13312, 14144, 14554 Child and Adolescent Mental Health Clinic - Patient Numbers, Staff and Funding 6209 Clinical Psychologists - University Places and Number Trained and Employed 6777 Crisis and Emergency Services - Funding 14140 Independent Living Program - Expansion - Request for Quotation 14986 Mental Health System Accommodation Services - Funding 13280 Adult Inpatient Facilities - Funding 13286 Amendment to Motion 11269 Carer Respite Programs - Funding 13279 Community Services - Funding 13290 Older Adult Psychiatry Services - Funding 13283 272 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CONSTABLE, DR ELIZABETH (continued) Health (continued) Nurses Assaults by Patients 11951 Number and Stress Leave 7924 Nurse-Link Initiative 7923 Retirements and Resignations 4159 Police Background Checks on those Looking after Children 2048 Psychiatrists - Number Trained 6216 Heritage Empire Games Village Precinct 9855, 9876 Family Homes and Precincts Nominated and Listed for Heritage Assessment 12385 Games Village Precinct - Petition 10264 Hillarys Boat Harbour - Financial Independence 2997 Hospitals Ambulances Drivers - Number and Stress Leave 7091 Free Service for Pensioners 11397 Complaints of Physical or Sexual Abuse by Staff 2048 Drug and Property Theft 2042 Emergency Departments - Number Treated 2047 Graylands 2051, 6240 Osborne Park - Upgrade 11907 Shenton Park Rehabilitation 14558, 14559 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11686 Insurance Commission of Western Australia - Land between 125 and 137 St Georges Tce, Perth 1779, 5510 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 627 Juries Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6001 Kwinana Freeway - Railway Reserve 3708 Lobbying Disclosure and Accountability Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 8583 Second Reading 8612 Local Government - Rates Gross Rental Value and Unimproved Land Value Methods 5395 Pensioner Cardholders’ and Seniors’ Concessions 13551, 13552 Main Roads Western Australia - Expenditure 13295, 13429 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion, as Amended 10667 Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10669 Member for Pilbara - Leave of Absence 746 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit - Minister for Health - Allegations 1310, 1311 Mindarie Marina - Financial Independence 2997 Mitchell Freeway - Railway Reserve 3708 Motor Vehicles - Break Ins 8076, 12374 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 Second Reading 13817 Third Reading 13823 Planning Bushplan-Bush Forever 4666 Exmouth Marina Village - Impact of Government Investment on Ningaloo Reef Resort 2997 Mauds Landing Development - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd - Government Announcement 12225 Police Community Operations - Motion 4770 Informants - Number 4156 Officers - Number 1515, 3711; Matter of Public Interest 7895 Staff Resignations, Retirements and Dismissals 14969 Stations - Number, Interview Rooms and Holding Cells 1514, 3710 Prisons Acacia - Colour Television Sets for Prisoners 2576 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 273

CONSTABLE, DR ELIZABETH (continued) Prisons (continued) Drugs 9494, 9495 HIV and Hepatitis C Programs 9495 Prisoners Colour Television Sets and other Recreational Equipment 1517 Complaints of Physical and Sexual Abuse 1518, 2051 Wilful Damage - Cost 1516 Prostitution - Number of Prostitutes and Offences 8092 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Referral to Joint Select Committee 1297 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 7908-7910 Schools Behaviour Management and Discipline Strategy 828 Cadet Programs - Funding 4690 Complaints of Physical and Sexual Abuse 1774, 1775 Enrolments - Years 8 to 12 5632 Internet Filtering Mechanisms 11947, 12202 Non-government Funding - Petition 3784 Student Numbers 9467 PEAC Classes 3259 Police Background Checks of Employees 1773 Preprimaries - Students Receiving Literacy and Numeracy Assistance 1775 Primary Administration Upgrades 5630 Library Upgrades 5518 Number and Staffing 1779 Students Receiving Literacy and Numeracy Assistance 1775 Toilet Upgrades 5633 Principals - Male and Female 5625 Student Numbers 3259, 9467 Teacher Numbers 9468 Wilful Damage - Cost 1771 Year Levels Repeated and Skipped 1776 Years 11 and 12 - Compulsory School Years 4559 Seniors - Local Government and Water Rates Concessions 13551, 13552 State Administrative Tribunal 5753, 6205, 6776 State Revenue, Office of Companies Audited 13304 Employment Agency Classification - Payroll Tax 13305 Reclassification of Contractors as Employees 13304 Taxation Land Tax 13310 Payroll Tax 13303, 13305, 13551 Transport Bus Drivers - Number and Stress Leave 8075 Licensing Centres - Metropolitan - Staff Funding and Practical Tests for New Drivers Licences 8075 University Graduates - Maths, Science, LOTE and Information Technology 2574 Water Conservation and Management Bill 2003 - Introduction and First Reading 10268 Water Resources Rates - Pensioner Cardholders’ and Seniors’ Concessions 13551, 13552 South West Drainage Division - Pipehead Storage and Drinking Water Supply Sites 985 Water Efficiency Incentives - Consumption Levels 8094 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 Second Reading 11285 Consideration in Detail 11541, 11542, 11546-11552, 11555-11559 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 947 Workers Compensation Assessment of Injured Workers - Use of American Guide 4178 WorkCover WA - Conciliation and Review Directorate - Determination of Degree of Disability 9144 274 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CRIDDLE, HON MURRAY JOHN (Agricultural) (NPA) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Committee 12652, 12653, 12920, 12921, 12932-12951 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13135 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5782 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 4421 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Legislation Committee 4229 Address-in-Reply Motion Drought 1810, 1811 One Vote, One Value 1810 Road Funding 1814, 1815 Skeleton Weed Program 1811, 1812 Transport 1812-1816 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 2738 Adjournments of the House - Complimentary Remarks 4542 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 5302 Agriculture Cattle and Sheep Saleyards - Location 4902 Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd Impact of Changes to Transport Legislation 2870 Merger with Grain Pool of Western Australia 6 Narrakine Storage Facility - Road Safety 11206 Department Eucla, Ravensthorpe and Esperance Offices 5193 Full-time Equivalents 1742 Functional Review Committee Review 5412 Merredin - Staffing and Funding 5534 Dogs, Wild Culling 5314 Review 10248 Drought Assistance 1532, 2602, 4394 Economic Impact 3729 Egg Industry - Deregulation - Asset Value of Golden Egg Farms 14837 FarmBis Western Australia - Funding 9584 Kimberley Chemical Use Review - Release of Report - Statement by Minister for Agriculture 12664 Grain Carting - Shortage of Drivers 12004 Grain Marketing Legislation - Reform 862 Grain Pool of Western Australia - Merger with Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd 6 Landcare Facilitators and Coordinators - Funding 161 Meat Processing Industry - Statement by Minister for Agriculture - Motion 10077 Midland Saleyards - Relocation 8366 Milk Prices - Peters and Brownes Group 9971 Muchea Saleyards 10117, 13143 Northern Emu Barrier Fence 551 Ovine Johne’s Disease 14029 Skeleton Weed Eradication Program 711; Statement by Minister for Agriculture 12654 Three-horned Bedstraw - Eradication Funding 12141 Wheat - Variety WAWHT2248 - Release by Department of Agriculture 3872 Animal Welfare - Inspectors - Appointment 6299 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Committee 2876, 2880, 2881 Order of Business - Amendment to Motion 2724 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13340 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1733 Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13054 Baxter, Hon Norman Eric - Condolence Motion 13314 Building Industry - Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Consultation 6956 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1820 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 275

CRIDDLE, HON MURRAY JOHN (Agricultural) (NPA) (continued) Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13316 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 12641 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 12641 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 7792 Third Reading 11334 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5782 Committee 5928-5930 Commonwealth Government - Policies and Legislative Approach - Motion 6577 Consultants - Six-monthly Returns 8674, 10091 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 9041 Dogs - Wild - Control 5314 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 Committee 11963, 11974, 11978, 12278-12285, 12293-12312 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 6547 Electoral - One Vote, One Value - Mid West 1807 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14661 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14661 Committee 14832-14835 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14661 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 4966 Committee 10132-10141, 10213-10225, 10331-10360, 11144-11159, 11196-11204, 11212-11218, 11222, 11223, 11227, 11230, 11231, 11321-11326, 11329 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4909 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 6416 Fire and Emergency Services - Northam Fire Station - Staffing 7177 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 1434 Fisheries Finfish and Mackerel Reviews 12959 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2002 - Clause 5 - Disallowance Motion 1642 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Disallowance Motion 14581, 14590 Gascoyne and West Coast - Recreational Fishing Regulations 5958 Master Class 5 Ticket - Changes 11834 Palmer, Jeff and Gail - High Court Appeal Case 3028 Recreational - GST Contribution 12960 Recreational Fishing Survey - Estimates of Catch 12959 West Coast Rock Lobster Fishery Management Plan Amendment 2003 - Disallowance 12105, 12124 Western Rock Lobster Fishery - Crisis 7647 Fuel and Energy Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline - Acquisition of State Corridor Rights 4448 Electricity - South West Interconnected System 13347 Narrogin Integrated Wood Processing Plant 14712 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14169, 14596 Committee 14626-14633, 14643-14649 Geraldton Port Authority - Dredging Operations 9195 Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Consultation 6956 Government Departments and Agencies Consultants - Six-monthly Returns 8674 Procurement Reform Process - Centralisation of Procurement to Metropolitan Area 12923, 13065 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Second Reading 1820 Committee 1946-1948, 1957-1960 Health Green Head - Palliative Care Services 9023 Men’s Health - Funding in Rural Areas 13592 Parkinson’s Disease Nurse Specialists - Funding 14607 276 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CRIDDLE, HON MURRAY JOHN (Agricultural) (NPA) (continued) Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 2242 Committee 2750 Hospitals Cost-care Centres - South West and Country Health Services 6582 Country - Budgets for Hospitals 8684 Geraldton Regional 13859, 14193 Northampton District - Services 10747 South West - Budgets for Hospitals 8684 Housing and Works, Department of - Better Risk Management and Best Practice Contracting - Policy Framework 6956 Infinitree Plantation Program 9360 Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 2002 - Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to the Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Motion 853 Jurien Bay Marine Park Order 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 14666 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13135 Live Sheep Export - Cormo Express - Australia’s Quarantine Regulations 12553 Local Government Busselton, Shire of - Legal Costs - Disputed Planning and Development Matters 9657 One Vote, One Value - Mid West 1807 Regional Road Group Funding Grants - Funding 5660 Main Roads Western Australia - Employees - Complaints by Member for Armadale 4201 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading 13343 Natural Heritage Trust - Funding 161 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5646 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10104 Planning Canal Rocks Pty Ltd versus Shire of Busselton - Consultation 10488 Mauds Landing Development - Rejection Decision - Motion 9968 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment No 1039/33 - Victoria Quay, Port of Fremantle - Statement by Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Motion 10076 Peel Region Scheme Disallowance 5547 Statement by Minister for Racing and Gaming 13577 William Street Bridge - Demolition 9846, 9975 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 265, 361, 362, 366, 370, 460 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2246 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12639 Police Geraldton - Hours Worked by Officers 4933 Non-metropolitan Districts - Staffing Levels 12432 Officers - Hours Worked 4933 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 13991-13994 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 - Assembly’s Message 5918 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 6980, 7127 Committee 7277-7286 Recommittal 7287 Questions without Notice - Answers - Ministers in the Legislative Assembly - Refusal to Answer 11176 Racing Country Race Clubs and Country Racing - Toodyay Picnic Race Day 2229 Radio Stations - Reception Upgrade 5773 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8648 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8648 Committee 8650-8670 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8648 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8648 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3295 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 277

CRIDDLE, HON MURRAY JOHN (Agricultural) (NPA) (continued) Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 (continued) Committee 3318, 3319, 3323, 3324, 3327-3332 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 3050 Railways Narrows Rail Link - Infrastructure Costs 4959 Perth Urban Rail Development - Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment to Motion 5950 South West Metropolitan Railway Master Plan - Statement by Parliamentary Secretary - Motion 7439 Urban Rail Development - Cost 1416 Regional Development Fund - Applications and Distribution of Fund 243 Regional Headworks Scheme - Review 3287 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5320 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Second Reading 7973 Committee 7986 Assembly’s Message 8372-8391 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation - Amendment to Motion 9178 Roads Brookton Highway 4254, 14771 Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd Narrakine Storage Facility - Road Safety Concerns 11206 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Select Committee - Amendment to Motion 2220 Urgency Motion 4896 Funding - Condemnation of Government - Motion 9339 Geraldton Primary North-south Road Alignment Study - Petition 4435 High-wide-load Corridors 1803, 1840, 4025 Indian Ocean Drive - Completion 7825 Lime Sands Route 2 - Cost of Consultation Process 1740 Northampton-Port Gregory-Kalbarri 12288 Regional Road Groups - Funding 5050, 5660; Urgency Motion 5398, 5403 Roe Highway Stage 8 - Infrastructure Costs 4959 Salinity - National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality - Budget Allocation 7451 School Bus Service - Contract - Review 13469 Select Committee into the Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Amendment to Motion 2220 Select Committee on Rules Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5294-5299, 5638 Sittings of the House - Days and Hours - Amendment to Motion 2473 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9333 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel - Report 4491; Motion 4493 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3152 State Finance - Drought - Economic Impact 3729 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 - Restoration to Notice Paper - Motion 344 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Recommittal 3890 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13432 Committee 13444, 13448, 13449, 13558-13561, 13568, 13569 Taxis Country Taxi Plates - Annual Renewable Licence 3173 Fares - CPI Increase 3173 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes Amendment to Motion 3857 Personal Explanation 3860 Standing Orders Suspension 3864 Transport Buses - Contract - Review 13469 Cycleways - East Perth-Maylands 165, 346, 1740 278 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

CRIDDLE, HON MURRAY JOHN (Agricultural) (NPA) (continued) Transport (continued) Heavy Haulage Transport Units 2482, 12004 Oversize Permits 2762 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5782 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2621 Committee 2630 Water Corporation - Tender No MN-02-10963 - Welding Repairs to Greater Southern Towns Water Supply Pipelines 1662 Water Resources Port Gregory 6084 Yuna Chapman Valley - Water Pipeline 4531 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14001 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4537 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13883 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7495 Wonthella House, Geraldton - Extension 1953 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1553, 1650

DAY, HON JOHN HOWARD DADLEY, BSc, BDSc (Darling Range) (Lib) Aborigines -Cultural Awareness Training in Education System12818 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2530 Consideration in Detail 2561-2565, 2795-2806, 2810, 2835, 2838, 2840, 2942, 2944, 2950-2957, 2961-2973 Third Reading 2974 Address-in-Reply Motion 1909 Bali Bombings 1909 Education 1911 Health Services 1911 Kalamunda District Community Hospital 1909 Amendment to Motion - Health Services 108 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading Centre for Excellence in Teaching 4120, 4121 Kalamunda District Community Hospital 4122, 4123 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Education and Training, Department of 7567, 7569 Health System 7568 Kalamunda District Community Hospital 7570-7573 Mental Health 7569, 7570 Police Service 7570 Taxation 7568 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7567 Building and Construction Industry Training Fund and Levy Collection Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 12624 Consideration in Detail 12625-12629 Third Reading 12766 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6727 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2173 Disability Services - Petitions Netherway, Ms Donna 9226 Shurmer, Ms Sarah 8011 Stathy, Ms Raelene 5834 Economics and Industry Standing Committee Annual Report 2001-02 - Tabling 494 Inquiry into the WA Strata Management Industry - Final Report 9399 Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA - Eighth Report 14238 Education Amity House Albany - Allocation 8130 Budget - Increase 7025 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 279

DAY, HON JOHN HOWARD DADLEY (continued) Education (continued) Compulsory Schooling for Years 11 and 12 - Budget Savings 13815 Cultural Awareness Training 12818 Curriculum Council - Amalgamation with Department of Education and Training 5242 Curriculum Guides 11742 Department Amalgamation with Department of Employment and Training 5242, 11948 Budget 11780, 11781 Capital Works Budget 8894, 8895 Central Office - Positions Abolished 14355 Complaints Management Unit 14353 District Offices - Staff 9478 Evaluation of Students at Educational Risk Program 14957 Funding Cuts 13813 Internet Web Site 9712 Functional Review Taskforce - Recommendations 12463, 12465 Language Development Centres Closure 4169 Waiting Lists 14530 Students at Educational Risk Program - Evaluation 4176 Teachers Laptop Computers 691 Level 3 - Appointment 8130 Pay Rise 7026, 11707, 12863; Motion 11415 Placement Process 4176 Primary - Male/Female Ratio 8131 Secondary - Male/Female Ratio 8131 Strike Action 11250, 13197, 13198 Vocational Education and Training - Expansion of Programs 11743 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13635 Consideration in Detail 13728-13730 Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee 13702, 13704, 13727 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Second Reading 13233 Consideration in Detail 13504-13511, 13528-13541, 13683, 13684, 13687-13690 Third Reading 13702 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13635 Employment and Training Budget 7025 Department Amalgamation with Department of Education 5242, 11948 Budget 11780, 11781 Capital Works Budget 8894, 8895 District Offices - Staff 9478 Funding Cuts 13813 Evaluation of Students at Educational Risk Program 14957 Vocational Education and Training - Expansion of Programs 11743 Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 9703 Council’s Amendments 11775, 11788 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 2374-2376 Fuel and Energy Coal-fired Electricity Generation - Coal 21 Initiative 14882, 14883 Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Motion 6827 Amendment to Motion 6842 Electricity Deregulated Market 1199 280 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

DAY, HON JOHN HOWARD DADLEY (continued) Fuel and Energy (continued) Electricity (continued) Lower Prices 1868 Prices - Guarantee 13517, 13518, 13701 Reform - Implementation 10497 Reform - Legal Work 10590, 10679 Energy in WA Conference - Address by Minister for Energy 8155 Epic Energy - Tariff Regulation 7518 Goldfields Gas Pipeline - Removal of Tariffs 9425 Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator - Tariff Regulation 7518 Kemerton Peak-load Ga s Turbines 12765 Mumbida Wind Farm Proposal - Delay in Approval 8793, 9236, 9237 Gas and Electricity Safety Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12706 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) (Reviews) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9130 Health Funding - Matter of Public Interest 14894 Kalamunda Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service - Closure 3985 Nurses - "National Review of Nursing Education 2002" - Motion 1219 Priority Issues - Matter of Public Interest 6817 Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation Former Minister for Health’s Failure to Take Action - Matter of Public Interest 9674 Select Committee - Amendment to Motion 10611; Motion, as Amended 10618 Higher Education Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8846 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 3078, 3079 Hospitals Elective Surgery - Waiting Times - Matter of Public Interest 14894 Kalamunda District Community - Redevelopment 919, 13927; Motion 13399, 13405 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11694, 11708 Consideration in Detail 12731, 12732, 12756, 12867, 12872 Liquor - Sales in Restaurants - Petition 13614 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10687 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3501 Owen, Mr Raymond Cecil MLA - Condolence Motion 4550 Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 6144 Consideration in Detail 6179, 6188 Police - School Crossings and Traffic Wardens - Review 4107, 4108 Police Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3920 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8704 Public Accounts Committee - Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14226 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 5861 Questions without Notice - Standing Orders Suspension 13390 Railways - Perth Urban Rail Development - Electricity Generation Capacity - Upgrading 6941 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 8036, 8043, 8044, 8048, 8055, 8056 Schools Administrators - Briefing Sessions - Acceptance of Hospitality 14530 Allocation of Funds 1781 Annual Reports 11744 Behaviour Management and Discipline Strategy - Review 11744 Children’s Crossings and Traffic Wardens - Review 4107, 4108 Class Sizes 6039, 9470, 9477 Cleaning Contracts - Audit 283, 9423, 9424 Cross-boundary Enrolments 9478 District Offices - Cost 14354 Education Assistance Fund - Schools Assisted 672, 2572, 4703 Fees - Level of Collection 770, 772, 3673, 14354 Formula for Determining Average Cost per Student - Review 1127 Funding - Methodology for Differential Resourcing 11744 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 281

DAY, HON JOHN HOWARD DADLEY (continued) Schools (continued) High Schools - Painting and Floor Covering Replacement Program 8130 Inclusivity Program 4177 Level 6 Principals - Appointment 14353 Maintenance and Refurbishment 8130, 14348 Non-government Criteria for Registration and Re-registration 11948, 11949 Funding - Reduction 5578; Review 11949 Pastoral Care and Extracurricular Activities 11743 School Grant for Rural Schools - Component for Travel to Extracurricular Activities 14485 Staff 14349, 14354 Vocational Education and Training - Expansion of Programs 11743 Year 10 Students 8132 Year 11 Students - Students Studying a Language Other Than English 14355 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation Amendment to Motion 10611 Motion, as Amended 10618 Small Business Electricity Prices - Reduction 13518 Tax on Hire Items 6941 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9700 Consideration in Detail 10018, 10019 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9700 Transport - Buses - Kalamunda - Reduction in Number of Drivers 4636 Universities Guild Fees - Compulsory - Petition 2782 Services and Amenities Fee 206, 207, 5447 Water Corporation - Subdivision of Residential Lots - New Water Main to Complete the Loop - Grievance 11504 Water Resources - Pipeline - Kimberley-Perth 2716 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 Second Reading 11278 Consideration in Detail 11406, 11407, 11528, 11529, 11541-11559 Third Reading 11771 Western Power Disaggregation Electricity Prices 2390 Fall in Value 1868, 1869 Kemerton Peak-load Gas Turbines 12765 Electricity Outage - Darlington-Mundaring Area 6411 Electricity Prices - Reduction 13200, 13201, 13518 Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5458 Managing Director - Conditions of Employment 10029, 10965, 11109, 11258, 11393

DEAN, MR ANTHONY JAMES, BSc, DipEd (Bunbury) (ALP) Aborigines - Djidi Djidi Aboriginal School Bunbury 9420 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Bunbury Marine Environment 7917 Deregulation of Trading Hours 7917, 7918 Schools, Bunbury 7916, 7917 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7916 Burrup Resource Development Projects - Karratha School Students 5994 Busselton Jetty - Interpretive Centre and Underwater Observatory 14254 Community Development - Bunbury Parenting Information Centre - Petition 11261 Consumer and Employment Protection - Kaye Group - National Investment Institute 13815 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1182 Dairy Industry - Select Committee - Appointment of Members 9258 Drugs Use Analysis 8789 Economy - Western Australian - Government’s Management 2164 282 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

DEAN, MR ANTHONY JAMES (continued) Education Children’s Book Week - Statement 11530 Government Policies - Impact on Start of School Year 4564 Teachers Pay Rise 10821; Motion 11420 Fire and Emergency Services Emergency Helicopter Service - Elvis Helicopters 1707 Levy - Introduction 8313 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2364 Freycinet Collection - Exhibiting Items Purchased 2675 Fuel and Energy Electricity - Simcoa Operations Pty Ltd 13517 Fuel Prices - Government’s Policy - ACCC Letter 772 FuelWatch - Expansion 10681 Health Mental Health System - Funding - Petition 12444 Midwives - Report on the Midwifery Work Force in Australia 8179 Seniors - General Practitioner Access 6185 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula - Training and Employment Opportunities for Karratha School Students 5994 Whicher Range Gas Resource - Drilling Program 13198 Industrial Relations - Hours of Work for Employees 11399 Insurance - Public Liability - Western Australia’s Response 3227 Justice, Department of - Murder Trial - Hancock, Mr Don and Lewis, Mr Lou 12763 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2027 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Petition 12326 Sales in Restaurants - Petition 13928 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Bunbury Deregulation of Shopping Hours 10694, 10695 Education 10693 Liberal Party Visit 10695 Population Growth 10694 Port of Bunbury 10694 Yarragadee Aquifer 10694 Ludlow Tuart Forest 11620, 13276 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - Motion 1182 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10598 Personal Explanation 11077 Mining - Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining 11620, 13276 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12804 Motor Vehicles - Caravans Mobile - Licence Classifications 9797 Museums - Regional Social History Museum, Bunbury - Grievance 8938 Pemberton District Hospital - Statistics 14553 Planning Mauds Landing Development - Petition 5091 Woodcrest Rise College Grove Bunbury - Petition 11260 Police - National Automated Fingerprint Identification System 12608 Ports and Harbours - Small Boat Harbours - Boat Pen Space - Cost 12376 Prostitution - Legislation - Petition 8691 Public Accounts Committee Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14224 Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1182 Visiting Medical Practitioners - Tabling of Papers 4074 Questions on Notice - Answers - Motion 12804 Racing - Bunbury Trotting and Race Clubs - Turnover and Dividends 2588 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 7080-7082 Railway - Perth-Bunbury - Freight Rail Track 6339 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 283

DEAN, MR ANTHONY JAMES (continued) Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - Opposition’s Assertion 7523 Road Safety - Leader of the National Party - Claims 515 Schools Djidi Djidi Aboriginal School Bunbury 9420 Karratha - Burrup Resource Development Projects 5994 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Appointment of Members 9258 Seniors - General Practitioners - Home or Hostel Visits 6185 Sewerage - Infill Sewerage Program - Petition 744 Sport and Recreation - Carey Park Football Club - Statement 12854 Stallard Family - Statement 7879 Tourism Busselton Interpretive Centre Jetty and Underwater Observatory 14254 New Concept for State Tourism Strategy - Grievance 13488 Transport Buses - Bunbury - Grievance 10390 Licensing Centres - EFTPOS Facilities 9772 Mobile Caravan Licences - Classifications 9797 Walkley Awards for Excellence in Journalism - Spagnolo, Mr Joe - Statement 2383 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5118 Water Resources South West District from the Shire of Waroona including Capel 12906 Wellington Dam - Salt Content 2420 Woodcrest Rise, College Grove, Bunbury - Petition 11260

DEPUTY CHAIRMAN OF COMMITTEES (Hon Kate Doust) Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Committee - Ruling 14833

DEPUTY CHAIRMAN OF COMMITTEES (Hon Jon Ford) Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee - Rulings 254, 458

DEPUTY CHAIRMAN OF COMMITTEES (Hon Simon O’Brien) Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 - Committee - Ruling 5201 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 - Committee - Statement 9169

DEPUTY PRESIDENT (Hon George Cash) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Ruling 12645 Address-in-Reply - Motion - Ruling 1937, 1938 Adjournment Debate - Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Ruling 4042 Constitution Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Ruling 2337 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading - Ruling 3447 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Adjournment Debate - Ruling 4042 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Ruling 2143 Sittings of the House - Extended after 6.00 pm - Ruling 2752

DEPUTY PRESIDENT (Hon Kate Doust) Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Ruling 5026

DEPUTY PRESIDENT (Hon Adele Farina) Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders - Motion - Ruling 10233 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Ruling 2244 Questions on Notice - Answers - Tabling with Production of Documents - Motion - Ruling 12410 Water Resources - Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion - Ruling 8544

DEPUTY PRESIDENT (Hon Jon Ford) Salinity - Methods to Reduce Escalating Problems - Motion - Statement 13464 284 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

DEPUTY PRESIDENT (Hon Simon O’Brien) Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Referral to Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Ruling 11598

DEPUTY SPEAKER (Mrs D.J. Guise) Business of the House - Notices of Motion - Removal from Notice Paper - Statements 8797, 13614 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail - Ruling 6894; Dissent from Ruling 6895 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Statement 11127 Dissent from Ruling - Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 6895 Economics and Industry Standing Committee - Declaration of Pecuniary Interests - Strata Management Inquiry Statement 1628 Public Accounts Committee - Auditor General’s Annual Report 2001-02 - Statement 5838 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail - Ruling 3841 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Statement 10394

DERMER, HON EDMUND RUPERT JOSEPH, BSc (Hons), DipEd (North Metropolitan) (ALP) Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Division Number - Correction Adjournment Debate 3629 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 696 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches Fifth Report 3998 Voluntary Euthanasia Bill 2002 - Second Reading 11034

DONALDSON, HON BRUCE KIRWAN (Agricultural) (Lib) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Committee - 12939-12951 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - 4425, 4468 Address-in-Reply Motion Aquaculture 2493 Drought and Farming 2487-2491 Health System 2493 New Coast Road 2491, 2492 Payroll Tax 2492 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 2493 Agriculture Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd - Ability to Handle Record Grain Crop 11044 Dogs, Wild - Culling 5664 Drought Assistance Breakdown of Expenditure 1951 Statement by Minister for Agriculture 13112 Flatulence Tax on Livestock in Western Australia 9196 Grain Licensing Authority - Third Party Exporters 14713 Kimberley Chemical Use Review - Release of Report Statement by Minister for Agriculture 12662, 13105 Midland Saleyards - Relocation 3732 Saleyard Facilities - Development 10481 Skeleton Weed Eradication Program Outbreak 14839 Review - Statement by Minister for Agriculture 11598, 12654 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Second Reading - 2771 Committee - 2774, 2883-2889 Brown, Senator - Statement 12670 Building Industry - Government Construction Contracts - Premier’s Directive 7822 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1816 Business of the House - Afternoon Tea Suspension - Adjournment Debate 372 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9942 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 11847-11859 Commerce and Trade - Live Sheep Export - Sabotage of Feed 13473 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 285

DONALDSON, HON BRUCE KIRWAN (continued) Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3619-3627, 3739-3744 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Committee 11584-11586 Dandaragan Primary School - Class Sizes and Classrooms 13007 Dogs, Wild - Control 5664 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14683 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14683 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14683 Environment - Controls on the Rural Sector - Motion 12543 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 4981 Committee 10134-10141, 10334-10360, 11151-11159 Third Reading 11575 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3460 Committee 3599, 3601, 3602 Third Reading 3602 Report 3602 Fisheries Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2002 Clause 5 - Disallowance Motion 1641 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Disallowance Motion 14584 Lobster Pots - Number 9586, 10808 Marron and Yabbies - Penalties for Stealing 5411, 8566 Tuna Article in Magazine - Statement 7453 West Coast Rock Lobster Fishery Management Plan Amendment 2003 - Disallowance 12118 Western Rock Lobster Fishery Licences 1006, 1140 Price Fluctuations 7314 Fremantle Cemetery - Transfer of Management to the Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Inquiry - Amendment to Motion 11339 Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 50 Gene Technology Bill 2001 - Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 50 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14159 Committee 14626-14633, 14643-14649 Third Reading 14728 Geraldton Regional Hospital - Tenders 14033 Government Construction Contracts - Premier’s Directive 7822 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Second Reading 1816 Committee 1831, 1946, 1947, 1956 Greens (WA) - Protest in Federal Parliament - Statement 12670 Housing and Works, Department of - Construction Contracts Policy - Premier’s Directive 7822 Legislative Council - Temporary Chamber - Statement 9982 Local Government Amalgamations - Financial Assistance Grants 12437 Amendment Bill - Introduction 11602 Elections - Ward Representation 6585 Valuations - Removal of Subsidy 10251 Member of Parliament - Cash, Hon George - Leave of Absence 10883 Nettles, Senator - Statement 12670 Ningaloo Reef - Rally - Adjournment Debate 3770 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5648 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10120 Parliamentary Secretaries - Visit to Croatia - Statement 11588 Parks and Reserves Jurien Bay Marine Park Order 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 14666 Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736; Motion for Disallowance 14690 286 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

DONALDSON, HON BRUCE KIRWAN (continued) Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2245 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12638 Railways Perth Urban Rail Development - Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment to Motion 5947 Southern Rail Link - Risk Assessment Reports - Tabled Papers - Motion 11604 Regional Road Groups - Funding - Urgency Motion 5399 Salinity - Drainage Systems - Review 5536 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5638 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Petition Opposing the Gnarabup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Third Report 4003 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 7435 United States of America - Bush, President - Senators Brown and Nettles - Behaviour - Statement 12670 Water Corporation Dividend - Increase - Statement by Minister for Government Enterprises 8348 Mount Eliza House - Renovation for Corporate Entertainment 2230 Water Resources Farm Water Grants Scheme - Approval Prior to Allocation of Funds 6458 Mundaring Weir and Canning Dam - Catchment Areas 14615 Water Flows into Dams 12669 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4537 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13574, 13878

D’ORAZIO, MR JOHN BIASE, BSc, MPS (Ballajura) (ALP) Aborigines - Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Closure 13608 Auditor General, Office of - Budget - Motion 11739 Bali Bombings - Official Day of Mourning 2002 Ballajura Police Station - Petitions 3909, 6791 Banks - Community - Stamp Duty Concessions for Patrons 2573 Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 12216 Canning River - Great Gardens Initiative 11398 Commerce and Trade Free Trade Agreement - Discussions Between Governments of Australia and USA 10587 Western Australia’s Export Performance 9660 Consumer and Employment Protection, Department for - Property Investment Seminar 12765 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1180 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13182 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5376, 5377 Fire and Emergency Services Levy - Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion 10181 Health Attention Deficit Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder - Referral to Education and Health Standing Committee - Motion 6848 Auditor General’s Report - Stroke Management 10168 Medical Students - Increase in Number of University Places - Grievance 6136 Nurse-Link Initiative 604 Hospitals Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technology - Progress 2165 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner 9088 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11691 Consideration in Detail 12730, 12752-12757, 12846, 12847, 12868, 12871 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment (Prohibition of Human Cloning) Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 12877, 12878 Kings Park - Parking Fees 10283 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2017 Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week Trading - Petition 12572 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Ballajura and Morley- Land and Redevelopment Issues 10845, 10846 Medical Services - Availability on Sundays 10848 Rail Link - Armadale to Joondalup 10848, 10849 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 287

D’ORAZIO, MR JOHN BIASE (continued) National Competition Council - Threat to Payments 12204 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Expansion 5577 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3510 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 9437, 9438 Third Reading 9449 Public Accounts Committee Annual Report 2001-02 488 Annual Report 2002-03 9999 Auditor General’s Annual Report 2001-02 - Review 7857 Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14218, 14221 International Conference Paper - Statement 7585 Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1180 Port Coogee Development - Sixth Report 14228 Visiting Medical Practitioners - Tabling of Papers 4071 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6367 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6367 Consideration in Detail 7079 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6367 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6367 Road Aware Program 1463 Safer WA Community Security Program - Bayswater and Swan, Cities of - Funding 1783 Schools - Non-government - Funding - Petition 5454 State Budget - Comments by Leader of the Opposition - State Debt and Surplus 6811 State Finance Government Spending in 2002-03 11697 Stamp Duty - Community Banks - Concessions 2573 Swan River - Great Gardens Initiative 11398 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11385 Tourism Planning Task Force Report - Media Release - Security Measures 3352 Transport - Ballajura - Improvements 4644 Waterwise Rebate Program 4855 Wesfarmers CSBP Ltd - Ashfield Site - Ground Water Monitoring Data 6183 WorkSafe Western Australia - Inspectors - Number 7224

DOUST, HON CATHERINE ESTHER (South Metropolitan) (ALP) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4422 Address-in-Reply - Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 2861 Brownlie Towers Statement 14784 Resolution of Issues 1422 Burrup Fertilisers Pty Ltd - Ammonia-urea Plant 4532 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9940 Commonwealth Government - Policies and Legislative Approach - Motion 6562 Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders - Amendment to Motion 10230 Drought Assistance - Exceptional Circumstances Aid 4258 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Urgency Motion 4897 Legislative Council Members - Electorate Offices 9587 Occupational Safety and Health Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4536 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10119 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - Adjournment Debate 4487 Salinity - Budget Allocation 7827 Select Committee on Rules Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5639 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel - Report 4490 Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 1930 Sewage Pumping Station, Busselton - Establishment - Fourth Report - Petition 4378; Addendum 4490 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 4378, 7438 Try, Mr John Eric - Statement 14036 288 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN, BA, BJuris, LLM (Kingsley) (Lib) Aboriginal Education and Training Council - Chairperson - Credit Card 14308 Aboriginal Health, Office of - Houston, Mr Shane Edward 6236, 14138 Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council - Chairperson 11563, 11679 Aboriginal Lands Trust - Review 4169 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6501 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4604 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3965, 3966 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2554 Consideration in Detail 2566, 2567, 2798, 2803-2809, 2833, 2836, 2839 Address-in-Reply Motion Government Taxes and Charges 203, 211 Police Service 212, 213 Unions 212, 213 Water Charges 203 Amendments to Motion Health Services 121 Water Shortages 214 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 1895 Consideration in Detail 3361-3365, 3395, 3398 Agriculture Chicken Meat and Egg Industry - Protection from Infectious Bursal Disease Virus 11436 Virulent Infectious Bursal Disease - Inspections 14984 Anti-Corruption Commission - Staff 7112, 12739 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading Community Care Services 4129 Labour Relations Reforms 4127-4129, 4131 Unions 4129-4131 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Beenyuup Wastewater Treatment Plant 7561 Black Spot Funding 7560 Cadet Programs 7560 Centenary Medal Recipients 7561, 7562 Kingsley Amateur Football Club 7561 Kingsley Sporting Clubs 7562, 7563 Police Service 7560 Public Transport 7558-7560 Third Reading 8471 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7558 Auditor General, Office of Budget - Motion 11723 Matter of Public Interest 12329 Australian Labor Party - Western Australian Labour Advisory Council - Establishment 7948 Bali Bombings Anniversary Personal Explanation 11894 Speaker’s Ruling 11894 Statement 11895 Condolence Motion 1751 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14308-14315, 14321, 14324, 14327, 14336-14346, 14921, 14924, 14936 Building Industry Building and Construction Industry Training Fund - Board Composition 9803 Building and Construction Site Inspections and Reports 5177 Building Code of Conduct - Code Monitoring Committee 1761 Building Industry and Special Projects Directorate 400, 7945, 11819 Building Trades - Licensing 13985 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 289

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Building Industry (continued) Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5838 Report - Criminal Matters 11537 Complaints Against Unions 3847 Construction Skills Training Centre -Funding 7887 Crane Accidents 5173, 11562, 11956 Crane Industry Review - Industries Covered 11562 Crane Safety Standards Working Group - Causes of Incidents Leading to Establishment 4698 Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Discussions 9418 Interim National Building Industry Task Force - Establishment 400 Safety Rules - New 011676 Special Projects Inspectorate - Draft Memorandum of Understanding with Police Service 1761 Standard Working Week - Reduction 4155 Workplace Health and Safety in the Building and Construction Industry Discussion Paper - Submissions 1767 Workplace Safety 10818 Cabinet Meetings Attendance of Cabinet Secretary 5516 Government’s Election Promise - Motion 6022 Informal Discussions 6541 Cannabis - Decriminalisation - Petition 9225 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6723 Consideration in Detail 6751-6763, 6772, 6792-6807, 6859-6862, 6869-6889 Standing Orders Suspension 6885 Censorship Access to Child Pornography on the Internet - Access on the Internet 10964 Film Classifications - Grievance 11077 Child Support (Adoption of Laws) Amendment Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 3694 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 7347 Consideration in Detail 7353, 7354, 7377-7383, 8735-8745, 8752-8754 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1078 Cockburn Shopping Centre - Hamilton Hill - Ownership 9309 Cole Royal Commission Findings about Rule of Law - Matter of Public Interest 5838 Government Support 1233 Colleges of TAFE Governing Council of Central TAFE - Chairperson - Mobile Telephone 14307 West Coast College of TAFE - Carine Campus 1728, 1768, 1776, 4638, 4687 Committees and Boards Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7751-7756, 7929-7931, 8078 Review - Appeals Tribunal - Establishment 683 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14391-14398 Community Development Child Death Review Committee - Membership 5174 Child Pornography - Access on the Internet 10964 Department - Neagu, Ms - Vehicle Use 4686 Consumer and Employment Protection Extended Working Hours Review Panel - Membership and Terms of Reference 11950 Reference No 0211682 - Number of Complaints 1769 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 4617 Referral to Select Committee 5495 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Second Reading 14910 Motion 14908 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 Second Reading 8061 Consideration in Detail 8288-8335 Third Reading 8337 290 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 (continued) Recommittal 8337 Council’s Amendments 9455 Crime Neighbourhood Watch Committees - Committees and Projects 9796 Railway Stations - Motor Vehicles Stolen Damaged or Burgled 11698, 11700 Safer WA 8071, 9796 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 10827 Division of Bill Motion 10955 Statement by Acting Speaker (Mr A.P. O’Gorman) 10956 Consideration in Detail 10957, 11128, 11131-11134 Standing Orders Suspension 6155 Criminal Code Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Division of Bill 10955 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 12368 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13187 Disability Services Commission Budget 6411 Cleaning Services 5520, 6411 Martin, Ms Ruth - Petition 4814 Education Aboriginal Education and Training Council - Chairperson - Credit Card 14308 Ethnic Job Study Grant 14500 Teachers - Pay Rise - Matter of Public Interest 10968 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13377 Employment and Training Apprentices - Transfield Services 2671 Employment Directions Initiative 4697 Training Bunbury Automotive Training Facility - Minister’s Visit - Morning Tea 1728 Construction Skills Training Centre - Funding 7887 Crane Operators - Accredited Trainers 11562 Internet Skills Training - Advertising Campaign 1709 Western Australian Group Training Scheme 4174; Grievance 7853 Unemployment - Increase in Rate 1770 Environment Gnangara Concept Plan - Delay 2843 Tremaine, Mr Gary - Sale of Property - Grievance 6135, 10645 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 505, 529 Estimates Committees - Standing Orders Suspension 7392 Firearms - Antique and Curio - Legislation 2997 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8205 Forests and Forestry Forest Products Commission - Board Members - Credit Cards 11141 Gnangara Pine Plantation - Harvesting 5623 Fuel and Energy - Poultry Litter-fired Electricity Plant, Muchea 5283, 7114 Gallop Labor Government - Approval Rating among Businesses 3671 Government Contracts Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded 9418 Ethnic Community Council 14500 Occupational Safety and Health Policies 9773 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14441-14453 Call Centres - Delays 9732 Chief Executive Officers - Names and Contracts 11955 City Centre Fitness Club Program 9514; Payment 11677 Cleaning Services 6406-6410, 7101, 7102, 8270, 8503; Cost 13764-13770 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 291

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Club-Association Memberships Payment 7393, 7394, 7397-7400, 7587-7590, 7932, 8086, 8087, 8851 Written Policy on Payment of Fees 9773-9779, 10206, 10702, 10703 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 12385, 13296-13301, 13549, 13673, 14141, 14510-14517, 14560-14564, 14970, 14971 Credit Cards 11677, 12385, 12631, 12740, 14501-14509, 14956, 14957 Creditors 6207-6209, 6397, 6533, 7092, 7758, 7931, 8079, 9752-9756, 9760-9766, 9770, 10052, Employment Contracts 6534, 6672, 6776, 7093, 7261, 7587, 7758, 8083 Fixed-term Contracts - Management 3986 Grants - Number Value and Acquittals of Funding 12881-12892, 12896, 12900-12908, 13263, 13264 Indigenous People - Number Classification and Redundancies 5160-5170 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14564, 14566, 14568-14570, 14973-14978 Leave Liability 5152-5160 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14365-14388, 14943, 14945 Management Initiated Redundancies 5179; Bar on Criticism of Government 6402-6406, 7595, 8122 Paid Parental Leave 1918; Cost 4704 Pay Dispute - Government’s Policy 13808 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10704-10713, 10871 Printed Information 5177 Public Service Functional Review - Report 4155 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14398, 14399-14411, 14416-14426 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 - 7758-7764, 7932, 8083, 8245, 8246 SARS Virus - Action Plan 7779 Staff “Attached List” 336, 669, 670, 821, 982, 1395, 2310, 3258, 3847 Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14531-14540, 14964, 14965 Seconded from Unions WA or Individual Unions 7118-7120, 7778, 8139, 9139, 9470 Senior and Executive Service Positions 5913 Sick Leave 12811 Unfilled and Acting Positions 335, 666, 1232, 1755, 1756, 3132, 3257, 3561 Unions WA or Individual Unions - Grants 8857-8865, 9138, 9469, 9716-9718 Wage Policy 14307 Web Sites - Online Payments 10723 Government Employees Superannuation Board - Members - Credit Cards 11677 Government Media Office - Corporate Credit Cards 5904 Government Openness and Accountability - Underfunding - Matter of Public Interest 12329 Hairdressers Registration Board - Annual Report 2002, 7779 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14391-14398 Health Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA Former Minister for Health’s Failure to Take Action - Matter of Public Interest 9676 Motion, as Amended 10619 Select Committee 10418; Motion 10301; Amendment to Motion 10324, 10609 Asbestos - Buildings on Corner of William and Murray Streets, Perth 1767, 4705 Craigie Dental Therapy Centre 12857 Department Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Allocation of Funds 4704 Thornton, Ms Jean - Allegations 9661-9663, 9873; Letter to the Premier 10022, 10023, 10287, 10587 Health Administrative Review Committee - Mr Mike Daube 7091 Nurses - Agency Expenditure and Numbers 11670, 12817 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces 2040 SARS Virus - Government Employees 7779 Smoking - Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Workplace 9146, 9793 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Acceptable Level of Impairment in the Workplace 9792 Visiting Medical Practitioners - Failure of Reviews 6206 Young People in Aged Care Accommodation - Statement 9415 Heritage Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 518 William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12088 292 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Hospitals Ambulance Bypass Statistics 7925 Ambulances - Northern Suburbs 14143 Joondalup Health Campus - Ambulance Bypasses and Call Offs 7925 Housing - State Housing Commission - Chairperson Credit Card 11563 Government Vehicle 11679 Housing and Works, Department of Broome - Purchase of Hostel 5395 Construction Contracts Policy - Discussions 9418 Director Ge neral - Joyce, Mr Greg - Discussions with Premier 9418 Right to Buy Scheme - Number of Properties Sold 13296 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11651 Division of Bill - Motion 11768 Consideration in Detail 12727, 12728, 12735, 12736, 12749-12757, 12769, 12774, 12843-12845, 12867-12872 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula - Industrial Action 2523, 2670, 3988 James Point Development - Environmental Protection Authority Assessment 4699 Monro’s Plantation Tea Rooms - Closure 3670 Industrial Relations Cole Royal Commission into the Building Industry - Report - Criminal Matters 11537 Compulsory Bargaining Services Fees - Government Support 5996 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union 36-hour Working Week Campaign 401, 4155 Action on Burrup Peninsula 2523, 2670, 3988 BGC Construction Correspondence 4700 Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5838 Deal Struck with Building and Construction Companies 3351, 3352 Intimidatory Tactics 3853 Log of Claims 4170 Membership - Pressure Tactics 9730 Pattern Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 5827, 9743 Right-of-entry Privileges - Abuse 3853 Safety Complaints 1467 Targeting of Safety Issues on Building Sites 10594 Workplace Safety 8638, 10818 Drug and Alcohol Testing of Employees - Union’s Position 5913 Employer-employee Agreements - Registration and Registrar’s Determinations 5910, 5911, 7944, 8127, 8755, 14523 Enterprise Bargaining Agreements - Publication 6790, 7597 Freedom of Association Rules - Federal Court Case 1770 Government Action on Disputes 13808 Government Employees - Pay Dispute 13808 Government Leadership - Matter of Public Interest 10968 Legislation Advertising - Cost 4699, 3854 Schapper, Mr Derek - Drafting 1766 Small Business 8126 Tourism Industry - Motion 1613 Transition Period 1770 Minimum Conditions of Employment Act - Accrued Sick Leave Payments 5827 Pilbara Mine Workers Union - Registration 9715, 11818 Prosecutions for Breaches of Workplace Laws 1762 Right-of-entry List of Authorised Union Representatives - Commission Web Site 1201 Shops and Warehouse (Wholesale and Retail Shops) State Award 1977 - Impact of Introduction 1763 State Wage Case Decision - Impact on Minimum Wages for Adult Apprentices 9233 Tracey, Mr Will - Union Entry Permit 3848 Unfair Dismissal Laws - Impact on Small and Medium Businesses 4678 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 293

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Industrial Relations (continued) Unions Building Industry 400 Complaints by Construction Firms 3847 Compulsory Charges 1768 Deregistration of State-based Unions 87, 88 Exemption under Act from Access to Medical Information 1768, 1769, 2042 Government Grants 8857-8865, 9138 Provision under which to take Action for Disclosure of Employee’s Private Details 1769 Right-of-entry to Work Sites 4701 Western Australian Labour Advisory Council - Establishment 7948 Workplace Agreements Back Paying of Employees 11392 Date for Cessation 1763 Workplace Health and Safety in the Building and Construction Industry 1767 Information Commissioner Amalgamation with Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations 12318, 12319 Matter of Public Interest 12329 Insurance - No-fault Compensation - Report 12225 Insurance Commission of Western Australia - Chairperson of Board of Commissioners - Mobile Telephone and Credit Card 11678 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 625 Consideration in Detail 639, 645, 650-652, 659-663, 1101, 1102, 1109-1112 Third Reading 1393 Joint Standing Committee on the Anti-Corruption Commission - Fourth Report 6934 Land Clearing - 304 Badgerup Road, Gnangara 8345, 8521, 11140, 13295, 13429 LandCorp Hope Valley - Property Purchases 4682 Stakehill Wetlands Precinct and Baldivis 10566 Wattleup - Property Purchases 4681 Legal Practice Bill 2002 Second Reading 4597 Consideration in Detail 5733-5751, 8897-8904, 8970-8977 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Bush Forever 11102 Development Application, Town of Vincent 11103 Environmental Protection (Western Swamp Tortoise Habitat) Policy Approval Order 11102 Industrial Relations 11103 Public Liability 11104, 11105 Town of Kwinana Planning Scheme Amendment No 6 11101 Local Government Broome, Shire of - Renal Dialysis Outpatient Hostel in Residential Area 8074 Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 518 Joondalup, City of - Petition 4066 Rates 13548, 14524 Roads Funding - City of Joondalup - Statement 13806 Wanneroo, City of City Watch Patrol - Underpayment of Officers 14984 Employment and Management Practices 13277 Local Government and Regional Development, Department of - Corporate Membership of City Centre Fitness Club - Payment 11677 Lotterywest - Chairperson - Government Car 11563 Luisini Winery - Petition 14885 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 1764-1766, 8072 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion, as Amended 10558 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4875 Personal Explanation - Unparliamentary Language 2821 294 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Ministers of the Crown Attorney General - Decisions on Matters Involving Allegations of Criminal Behaviour by Cabinet Members Motion 799 Credit Cards - 9467, 13427 Minister for Health - Ms Jean Thornton - Allegations Against Former Minister for Health 9661-9663, 10022, 10023 Minister for Housing and Works - Allegations of Ministerial Impropriety - Standing Orders Suspension 9222 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12800 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4585 Mobile Phones - Use 4180, 4803-4809 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10714-10717 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 4179, 5141-5152, 5173, 14428-14441 Corporate Credit Cards 7934, 8246-8265, 9919-9925, 11314, 12102, 12382, 12506, 12510, 12631, 13272, 13985, 14360, 14361, 14365, 14940 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9780-9782, 10206, 10704 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4180, 4809-4812 Seconded from Unions WA or Individual Unions 7118-7120, 7778 Motor Vehicles - Noisy and Smoky Vehicles 5755, 8077, 9796 Museum, WA - Statement 8306 Occupational Safety and Health Alcohol and Other Drugs in the Workplace - Guidance Note 14984 Building Industry - New Safety Rules 11676 Crane Industry Review - Industries Covered 11562 Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Workplace 9146, 9793 Government Contracts 9773 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Acceptable Level of Impairment in the Workplace 9792 “Safetyline” Magazine 9143 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations Amalgamation with Office of the Information Commissioner 12318, 12319 Matter of Public Interest 12329 Planning Appeals Meetings - Number Time Limit and Cancellation 4683 Baldivis - Property Purchases 13549 Broome, Shire of - Renal Dialysis Outpatient Hostel in Residential Area 8074 Burns Beach Lot 2 - Report of Review 6541 Coastal Planning - Community Involvement 4687 Coastal Zone Council - Independent Chairperson 4688 East Perth Redevelopment Authority - Conditions of Expansion 12379 Kwinana Town Planning Scheme Amendment No 76 - Delays 12377 Leighton Beach Development - Expansion - Community Consultation 12810 Major and Minor Amendments - Criteria for Determination 4691 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 4630-4635, 1764-1766 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendments Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 429 No 1060/33A 915, 916 Southern Rail Link 605, 606 Planning Appeals and Scheme Amendments - Number to be Determined 2385, 2386 Stakehill Wetlands Precinct - Property Purchases 13549 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Public Housing 11140 Town Planning Scheme Amendments - Backlog 10677 Planning and Infrastructure, Department for - Enforcement of Lease Conditions 8074 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 757-759 Police Audit of Training Procedures and Equipment 12811 Building Industry Special Projects Inspectorate - Draft Memorandum of Understanding 1761 Community Operations - Motion 4771 Joondalup 3986, 14500, 14501 Lost Man-hours Due to Changes in Court Times and Cancellation of Cases 8073, 12379 Occupational Safety and Health Audit 12376 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 295

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Police (continued) Pay Dispute - Resolution 10820, 10821; Matter of Public Interest 10968 Police Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3936 Pollution Acid Sulfate Soil - Problems 10442 Air Noisy and Smoky Motor Vehicles 5755 Report on Perth’s Air Quality - Implementation 6532 Toodyay - Phenol Contamination of Properties 823 Port Kennedy Port Kennedy Development Project 4639-4642. 4697 Port Kennedy Resorts Pty Ltd - Bond/Guarantee 1780 WA Beach and Golf Resort Pty Ltd - Conditions 10877 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the Policy Office - Corporate Credit Cards 5898 Staff Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 13271 Prostitution - Control Board - Costs 7227 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7069 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 7045 Consideration in Detail 9245, 9262-9290, 9406-9413, 9427, 9429-9435, 9439-9442 Third Reading 9444 Public Interest Disclosure Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 10946 Second Reading 10979 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 5574-5576, 5585 Questions on Notice Answers 8007, 8008, 11258, 11259, 14885; Motion 12800 Generic Answers 10720 Unanswered 3353 Racing - Bookmakers - Telephone and Internet Betting Limits 6541, 7269 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 975 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1292 Consideration in Detail 1338, 1342, 1352, 1353-1366; Standing Orders Suspension 1367 Third Reading 1375 Railways Greenwood Station - Completion 8505 Southern Rail Link City Rail Development Project - Demolition of Buildings 4677 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Impact of Activities on Costs 3351, 3352 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 605, 606, 8072 Sinking Under the Perth CBD 4635 William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12088 Stations - Car Stealing and Burglary 11698, 11700 Warwick Station - Parking Bays 8137 Whitfords and Warwick Stations - Vehicle Theft from Car Parks 8071 Real Estate and Business Agents Supervisory Board - Chairperson - Credit Card 11319 Regional Development Goldfields-Esperance Development Commission - Chairperson - Credit Card 11819 South West Development Commission - Chief Executive Officer - Mobile Telephone and Government Vehicle 11563 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 7904-7912 Council’s Amendments 8024, 8027-8029, 8037-8039 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13782 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - Forum 11392 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces Deputy Premier 2999 Minister for Health - Refusal to Provide Information 2040 296 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces (continued) Number, Membership and Cost - 11671 Road Traffic Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12720 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme - Motion 429 Rezoning of Land 12818 Local Government - Funding - City of Joondalup - Statement 13806 Ocean Reef Road-Trappers Drive - Traffic Lights - Petition 13773 Rottnest Island - Budget Details 2053 Schools Cadet Programs - Activities outside School Premises 1053 Cleaning Contracts - Redeployment and Redundancy Packages 1762 Fees - Statement 508 Non-government - Funding - Petition 7524 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation Motion 10301 Amendment to Motion 10324, 10609 Motion, as Amended 10619 Seniors Local Government and Water Rates Concessions - Seniors Concessions 13548 Safety Inspections of Homes 3852 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 3657, 3664 Council’s Amendments 9464 Sewerage - Sewage Spills Contamination 12380 Maintenance Logs 14983 Small Business Government’s Approval Rating 3671 Penalty Rates - Impact - Government Assistance 11818 Review of Government Services 11561 Unfair Dismissal Laws - Impact 4678 Small Business Development Corporation - Industrial Relations Legislation - Advertisements 4699 Small Business Development Corporation Act - Review 5892 St Andrews IDEA Project - Previous Government’s Involvement 2572 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9683 Consideration in Detail 10008-10020, 10032-10036, 10039-10048 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9683 Consideration in Detail 10269-10275, 10295, 10399, 10404 Third Reading 10427 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3530 Consideration in Detail 3549, 3552, 3556 Tourism Commission - Chairperson - Credit Card 12506 Downturn - Impact on Casual Employees 9512 International Travel Downturn - Government Assistance 8273 Lack of Government Support - Motion 1613 Workplace Relations Legislation - Motion 1613 Transport - Fuel Tanker Trucks - Rollover Accidents 8148 Two Rocks - Marina Fuel Contamination 8137, 8139 Odour Problems 7113 Victims of Crime Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 11089, 11097 Waste Management Board - Chairperson - Credit Card 12380 Water and Rivers Commission - PPK Environment and Infrastructure 13771 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 297

EDWARDES, HON CHERYL LYNN (continued) Water Resources Gnangara Water Mound - Pine Plantation Harvesting 5623 Jandakot Structure Plan - Water Resource Management Strategy 13772 Rates - Pensioner and Seniors’ Rebates 13548, 14524 Toodyay - Phenol Contamination 823 Welker Environmental Consultancy - Contract Details 13547 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12349 Western Power - Chairman - Credit Card 13270 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation (Acts of Terrorism) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1511 Workers Compensation Legislation - Time Limit for and Access to Common Law Claims 1763 Outstanding Claims - Cost 3932 Referral for Treatment - Four-week Time Limit 8891, 8892 Reform Government Position Paper 3931 Injury Management Savings 4700 WorkSafe Western Australia Building and Construction Site Inspections and Reports 5177 Buildings on the Corner of William and Murray Streets, Perth - Asbestos 1767 Crane Accidents 5173, 11956 Crane Safety Standards Working Group - Causes of Incidents Leading to Establishment 4698 Grants for Training 5177 Safety Complaints - Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union 1467 “Safetyline” Magazine 9143 Warning Notices to Builder - CFMEU Involvement 10594 Yellagonga Regional Park - Final Management Plan 824 Youth Skate Parks - Funding 11677, 13295 Young People in Aged Care Accommodation - Statement 9415

EDWARDS, MR JEREMY PHILIP DALHOUSIE (Greenough) (Lib) Aborigines - Mullewa - Antisocial Behaviour 12460 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2543 Address-in-Reply Motion Greenough Electorate - Issues 186, 187 Heritage 187, 188 Members’ Behaviour 185 Water 188 Amendment to Motion - Water Shortages 214 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1873 Agriculture Agricultural Shows - Statement 12197 Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7250 Department - Select Committee - Motion 7250 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Budget Allocations to Geraldton 7735 Heritage Issues 7739 Power Supply to Northern Wheatbelt Area 7738 Road Funding 7736 Transport 7738 Taxes and Charges - Increases 7735 Third Reading Agriculture 8469 Emu and Kangaroo Control 8469 Industrial and Residential Land Development 8468 Local Government and Road Funding 8468 Marine Research Facility Centre, Geraldton 8468 Power Supplies 8468 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7735 298 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDS, MR JEREMY PHILIP DALHOUSIE (continued) Army Museum of WA - Motion 10983; Amendment on the Amendment 10997 Australian Young Rural Ambassador - Suckling, Mr Karl - Statement 2812 Bus Service - Perth-Mandurah - Petition 8691 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6716 Consideration in Detail 6902, 6903 Third Reading 6924 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3118 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8164 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10831 East Perth Power Station Site 5245, 7679, 8896, 9312 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13661 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13368 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13661 Environment Geraldton Junior and Senior Motocross Club - Grievance 2782 Keep Australia Beautiful Council - Funding 4863 Wilderness in Western Australia - Liberal Party Position 12858 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 534, 1469 Fire and Emergency Services - Levy - Matter of Public Interest 10176 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Referral to Community Development and Justice Standing Committee 2268 Fishing Industry Council Awards - Statement 2812 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8220 Fremantle Artillery Barracks 8311, 11785; Motion 10983; Amendment on the Amendment 10997 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board 8730 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme - Motion 419 Fuel Prices - Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection’s Lack of Action - Matter of Public Interest 921 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3948 Geraldton Junior and Senior Motocross Club - Grievance 2782 Government Departments and Agencies - Significant and Major Incidents Reported - Tabling of List 1788 Heritage Assessments - Number 10869 Empire Games Village Precinct - Assessment 13275 Former Claremont Teachers College - Heritage Lis ting 13276 Greenough Hamlet Interpretive and Visitor Centre - Statement 10672 Heritage Council of WA Assessment Program - Backlog 11951 Resignation of Ms Wallace 9237 Staff 6940 Hillview Hospital Site - Future Use 2311 Municipal Inventories - Standard Policy 3562 Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 520 WA Register of Heritage Places - Number of Places Listed 7107 William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Motion 12077; Amendment to Motion 12094 William Street Precinct - Recommendation to Minister 11319 Heritage Bill 2002 - Status of Draft 2311 Hospitals Geraldton Regional - Cost Blow-out 13523 Morawa - Multipurpose Service Hospital - Grievance 13490 Northampton District - Grievance 11750 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11690 Industrial Development Cockburn Cement Ltd - Dongara Lime Plant - Grievance 5689 Industrial Sites Review - Geraldton 14257 Land Clearing - Binnu - Grievance 888 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3684 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2017 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Aboriginal Children - Criminal Actions 10840, 10841 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 299

EDWARDS, MR JEREMY PHILIP DALHOUSIE (continued) Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading (continued) Farming Communities 10837, 10838 Heritage 10840 Livestock Transport 10839, 10840 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading (continued) Local Government 10839 Road Funding 10839 Local Government Belmont, City of - Inquiry 11113 Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 520 Safer WA - Transfer of Responsibility 4855 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14272 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13949 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion 10537; Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10686 Ministers of the Crown Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection - Lack of Action on Fuel Prices - Matter of Public Interest 921 Minister for Water Resources - Appointment 3573 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 Second Reading 13816 Third Reading 13823 Planning Heathcote Site 7103, 13839 Hillview Hospital Site - Future Use 2311 Industrial Sites Review - Geraldton 14257 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 419 Raffles Hotel Site - Impact on Social Value 7103 Wireless Hill Park Excision from Class A Reserve No 29813 - Motion for Disallowance 14086, 14106 Land Excision - Petition 10826 Police - Community Operations - Motion 4769 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 7064 Consideration in Detail 9428, 9432, 9435 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 5860 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6361 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6361 Consideration in Detail 7212 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6361 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6361 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 959 Railways - Southern Rail Link Architectural Heritage Survey 6187, 8855 William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Motion 12077; Amendment to Motion 12094 William Street Buildings - Heritage Impact Study 9802 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2663 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13758 Safer WA - Transfer of Responsibility to Local Government 4855 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7250 Starling, Ms Erica - Statement 6181 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 10276 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11384 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3538 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading Govern ment’s Sale of Heritage Properties 9116 Road Funding Cuts Under the Labor Government 9115 Ward, Mr Tom - Community Service Record - Statement 3225 300 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDS, MR JEREMY PHILIP DALHOUSIE (continued) Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5117 Water Corporation Computer Sciences Corporation - Information Technology Contract 2269 Significant and Major Incidents Reported - Tabling of List 1788 Water Resources Harvey Dam - Use for Perth Water Supplies 2005 Management - Matter of Public Interest 2391 Minister for Water Resources - Appointment 3573 Water Forums 3417, 3418 Water Symposium 3417 Yarragadee Aquifer - Studies on Abstraction of Water 3008 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13949 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11307 Western Power Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5459 Kalbarri - Maintenance 12614; Statement 11530 Mid West Facilities 12614; Grievance 5689

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY, MB BS, Minister for the Environment and Heritage (to 27 June); the Environment (from 27 June) (Maylands) (ALP) Aborigines - CALM Mentored Aboriginal Training and Employment Scheme - Statement 13773 Agriculture Drought Assistance Dalwallinu 25 Farm Water Grants - Statement 4816 LandCare Facilitators and Coordinators - Funding 208, 209 Oil Mallee Company of Australia Ltd - Funding 775 Poison 1080 - Alternative Poisons 9309 State Weed Plan - Funding 14981 Alcoa World Alumina Australia Noise Regulation 27 - Application 3003 Wagerup Alumina Refinery 822, 3676, 8870, 9804 AlintaGas - Sale - Allocation of Funds to Salinity 8276 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14343, 14924 Burke, Mr Brian - Meetings with Ministers of the Crown and Ministerial Staff 9306 Canning River Great Gardens Initiative 11398 Regulation of Drainage Water and Pollutants 14542 Sewage Discharge from Boats - Monitoring 10879 Urban Drainage - Impact - Statement 14055 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 4170 Cockatoos - Baudin’s White-tailed and the Forest Red-tailed Black - Research into Conservation 1396 Cockburn Sound - Environmental Protection Policy - Revised Draft - Statement 3774 Colleges of TAFE - Carine Campus - Closure 1776 Commerce and Trade - China - Environmental Benefits and Opportunities 12688 Committees and Boards - Members - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7753 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14393, 14397 Conservation and Land Management, Department of Budget Papers - Reduction of 400 000 Hectares in Forest Area Managed 2843 Bunbury Office - Wildlife Officer 2844 Busselton District Office - Positions Vacant 9794 Coral Bay - Turtle Conservation 1629, 14982 Denny Road - Maintenance 13307 Management Costs for all Major Land Categories 3001 Mentored Aboriginal Training and Employment Scheme - Statement 13773 Mowen Road - Maintenance 13307 Prescribed Burning Program Completion 14883 Health Impact 5509 Progress 3089 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 301

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Conservation and Land Management, Department of (continued) Prescribed Burning Program (continued) South West 13813 Update 8965 WA Forest Alliance Claim 9007 Prosecution of Landholders 13923, 13924, 14071 Consultants - Expertise 1397 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3479 Second Reading 3479, 5113 Consideration in Detail 5564-5590, 5701-5713, 5725, 5726, 5979-5992, 6192-6203 Third Reading 6670 Council’s Amendments 12768 Coral Bay Bills Bay - Protection of Environment 818 CALM Rangers 816 Commercial Marine Nature-based Tourism Licences 815 Land Vested in CALM 816 Leach Drains and Sewerage Ponds - Impact 1395 Marine Parks and Reserves Authority Responsibility 818 Moorings 817 Ningaloo Marine Park - Damage from Mooring and Anchoring Activities 819 Public Meeting and Fish and Coral Deaths 820 Rehabilitation 820 Rubbish Dump Sewerage Outlets and Community Fishing Tables 820 Turtle Conservation 1629, 5583 Visit by the Minister for the Environment and Heritage 819 Deer, Feral - Gidgegannup, Greenough, Chapman Valley and Northampton 5896 Environment Acid Sulfate Soils - Management Strategy 13519 Appeals to the Minister - Number and Processing 7268 Biodiversity Conservation Act - Consultation Paper 8138 Bioprospect Ltd - Licence to Assess and Commercially Exploit Chemicals in WA’s Plants and Animals 14983 Catchment Management - Responsible Agency and Funding 14543 Container Deposit Legis lation 8794, 1280 Development Proposals - Geoheritage Issues 13312 Elwood, Mr Tony - Quarry at Red Hill 8315, 12069; Grievance 6611 Environmental Enforcement Unit 4857, 5910, 6936 Environmental Protection Policies - Cockburn Sound - Statement 3774 Flooded Gums - Defoliation by Insects 2843 Florida, Bouvard and Melros - Sand Dune Degradation - Grievance 6140 Friends of the Porongurup Range Inc - Assistance to Purchase Farming Property 2845 Geographe Bay - Removal of Seagrass Wrack from Beach 7117 Gn angara Concept Plan - Delay 2843 Greenhouse Gas Emissions - “Draft Western Australian Greenhouse Strategy” - Statement 14875 Indigenous Plant Species - Statistics on Diversity 3404 International Sustainability Events - University of Notre Dame Australia - Statement 10568 Kalgan Queen Scenic Cruises and Wildlife Interpretation - Grievance 11749 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Golf Course - Site Pollution 1401 Keep Australia Beautiful Council - Funding 4863 Lake Bryde Conservation Reserve 6813 Legislation - Compla ints of Non-compliance 7100 Litter Regulations 10590 Manganese Levels 9785 Native Wildlife - Smuggling 12319 Natural Heritage Trust 208, 209, 8869, 9086 Peel Waterways - Economic and Development and Recreation Management Plan 9793 Peel-Harvey Estuarine System - Nutrients 13675 Plastic Bags 8445, 10495 Prescribed Burning 11110 Quokka - Muddy Lake Wetland System Bunbury 6532 302 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Environment (continued) Regional Herbarium Project 3002, 6397, 7596 Sand Pile, Lot 2000 Pearson St, Churchlands 7751 Shopping Trolleys - Abandoned - Grievance 1681 Snake Creek Diversion - Grievance 12169 State Budget Initiatives 9785, 9786, 9788 State Reference Network Gauging Stations - Closure 981 State Weed Plan - Funding 14981 Tremaine, Mr Gary - Sale of Property - Grievances 6136, 10646 Underwood Avenue Bushland - Protection from Development 7116 Urban Nature Program - Budget and Staff 9800 Western Australian Environmental Awards 2003, 9800 Western Swamp Tortoise 7115, 8275 Wetlands - Stirling Estate 1757 Wilderness Discovery Centre - Costs 14551 Wilderness in Western Australia - Liberal Party Position 12859 World Summit on Sustainable Development - Statement 2517 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 1481 Third Reading 2567, 2570 Council’s Amendments 11794-11805 Grievance 12576 Report of Legislation Committee 2414, 2417 Environmental Protection Authority Advisory Council - Membership 13311 Board Membership Changes 4746 Qualifications of Potential Members 823 Environmental Protection, Department of Chief Executive Officer - Appointment 13809 Payne, Mr Roger - Retirement 4556 Pollution Response Squad - Training 12612 Review 6648 Staff 8856, 13810 Fire and Emergency Services Bushfire Risk 2384, 2385, 13813 Fire Management in the Western Australian Environment - Statement 7330 Firefighting Aircraft - South Coast 7117 Fires in the USA and Canada 10678 Prescribed Burning 11110 Forests and Forestry Buckingham near Collie - Impact of Logging 7780 Community Forest Inspection Program 5451 Draft Forest Management Plan Effectiveness 6533 Release - Statement 172 Water Catchments 1048, 1049 Flooded Gums - Defoliation by Insects 2843 Forest Management Plans Assessment by EPA 4690 Implementation 24 Sustained Yield - Ferguson Report Recommendations 14529 Forests Round Table - Membership 13429 Gnangara Pine Plantation - Harvesting 5623 Greater Preston National Park - Illegal Tree Felling 8344 Jarrah - First and Second-grade - Implications of Opposition’s Policy for Annual Yield 9663 Karri - Forest Explorer Self-guided Drive, Pemberton 8344 Ludlow Tuart Forest 5897, 11620, 13275 Mature and Intact Forest - Increase in Percentage Retained 1396 Old-growth Forest Leader of the Opposition’s Comment 5240 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 303

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Forests and Forestry (continued) Old-growth Forest (continued) Timber Industry Restructure Package 1587 Sky Jetty Project - Viability 5584 Social and Economic Impact of WA Forests Report - Alterations 5622 South West Area and Logging 9744 Nesting Hollows in Trees - Scientific Papers 1399 State Forests - Partial Revocation of Dedication No 56 Motion 12174, 12589 Request for Council’s Concurrence 12615 Tabling of Paper 11930 Nos 15, 39 and 64 Motion 13774, 14086 Request for Council’s Concurrence 14086 Nos 7, 14, 16, 28, 32, 33 and 58 Motion 13681, 14084 Request for Council’s Concurrence 14084 Sustainable Forest Management Output 2843 Tuart Ecosystems - Swan Coastal Plain 1200 Tuart Forests - Conservation and Protection 7111 Warrup, Corbal, Mersea, Dudijup and Kingston Blocks 13770 Wellington Discovery Forest 7406, 8146 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Motion 8907 Fuel and Energy Manganese Levels in Liquid Fuels 9785 Poultry Litter-fired Electricity Plant, Muchea 5283, 7114 Waste-to-energy Projects - Funding 1866 Government Advertising - Expenditure 6534 Government Contracts - Statistics 6535, 6536 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14445, 14452 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 4170 Cleaning Services 6408, 13765, 13769 Club/Association Memberships Payment 7589; Personal Explanation 13526 Written Policy on Payment of Fees 9776 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 12385, 14512 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6539 Consultants - Expertise 1397 Credit Cards 6535, 12385, 14502 Creditors 6533, 9756 Employment Contracts 6776 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12908, 13263 Indigenous People - Number, Classifications and Redundancies 5164 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 7105 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14568 Leave Liability 5155 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14372, 14386 Leschenault Estuary - Management 8341 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6403 North West - Staff and Programs 3409 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10706 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7941 Qantas Club or other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Fees 14407, 14424 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14461, 14481 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7761 Staff “Attached List” 821 304 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Staff (continued) Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14534, 14539 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7118 Unfilled and Acting Positions 1755 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 8859 Web Sites - Online Payments 10724 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14545, 14550 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 1759 Government Vehicles 6536-6538 Grill, Mr Julian - Meetings with Ministers of the Crown and Ministerial Staff 9306 Hamelin Bay - Access Road and Boat Ramp 3420 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14393, 14397 Health CALM - Health Impacts of Prescribed Burning Program 5509 Ultrafine Airborne Particles - Impact on Health 4173 Heritage Assessments 10869, 10967 Clune Family - Newmarracarra Homestead, Greenough - Funding Assistance 13309 Empire Games Village Precinct 9876, 13275 Family Homes and Precincts Nominated and Listed for Heritage Assessment 12385 Former Claremont Teachers College - Heritage Listing 13276 Great Fingal Mine Office, Cue - Roof Replacement 13309 Heritage Council of WA Assessment Program - Backlog 11951 Resignation of Ms Wallace 9237 Staff 6940 Municipal Inventories - Standard Policy 3562 North West - History Projects - Funding 9477 Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 522 WA Register of Heritage Places - Number of Places Listed 7107 William Street Precinct - Recommendation to Minister 11319 Heritage Bill 2002 - Status of Draft 2311 Industrial Development HIsmelt Corporation Pty Ltd - Kwinana Plant - Air Pollution 402, 1051 James Point Development - Environmental Protection Authority Assessment 4699 Kwinana - Noise Monitoring 3419 Rockingham Area - Noise Monitoring 3419 Kings Park Parking Fees 10283 Western Power Parkland - Funding 8343 Land Clearing 304 Badgerup Road, Gnangara 8345, 13295, 13429 South West - Remnant Native Vegetation on Private Land 9772 Crown Land Surrounding Sussex Location 4443, Scott River - Management 14552 Local Government Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 522 Mindarie Regional Council - Waste Disposal Plant - Grievance 5684 Municipal Inventories - Statement 67 Stirling, City of - Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme 11741 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12747 Second Reading 12747 Cognate Debate 13943 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13964 Consideration in Detail 13969-13973 Third Reading 13973 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 1764-1766 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 305

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Mining BGC (Australia) Ltd - Open-cut Mining at the Lakes 12860 Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining 11620, 13275 Portman Iron Ore Ltd Grievance 4820 Koolyanobbing Mine 6183 Ministers of the Crown Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 9306 Minister for the Environment and Heritage No-confidence Motion 4572 Personal Explanations Auditor General’s Draft Report on Water Resource Management 11313 Government Departments and Agencies - Club-Association Memberships - Payment 13526 Question on Notice 732 - Correction 14259 Total Waste Management Pty Ltd Licence 9464 Mobile Phones - Use 4805 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10715 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14432, 14440 Corporate Credit Cards 8249, 9921, 12382 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9781 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4810 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7118 Vehicles Privately Plated 6539 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5144 Motor Vehicles - Noisy and Smoky Vehicles 5755, 9796 Mt Sandiman Station - Incorporation of Section into National Park 14571 Parks and Reserves Beeliar Regional Park - Management Plan 14980 Bold Park - Capital Funding Allocations and Operational Budget 1758 Cape Range National Park - Turtle Conservation Licence 14982 Crown Land Surrounding Sussex Location 4443, Scott River - Management 14552 Drummond Nature Reserve - Freshwater Claypan Wetlands 13201 Freshwater and Marine Fish and Crustaceans - Definition as Wildlife 14542 Greater Preston National Park - Illegal Tree Felling 8344 Ludlow National Park - Arum Lily Control 5897 Management Plans - Agency Responsible 14555 Mt Sandiman Station - Incorporation of Section into National Park 14571 National Parks and Nature Reserves - Commitment to Spend $25 million 5896 Ningaloo Marine Park CALM’s Responsibility 815 Damage from Mooring and Anchoring Activities 819 Turtle Conservation Licence 5583, 14982 Regional Parks - Small Grants Program 3231 Wellington National Park - Inclusion of Wellington Discovery Forest 7406 Yalgorup National Park - Controlled Burning 10637 Yellagonga Regional Park - Final Management Plan 824 Planning Burns Beach, Lot 2 - Report of Review 6541 Heathcote Site - Reassessment of Heritage Value 7103 Mauds Landing Development - Minister’s Position 4103 Raffles Hotel Site 4563, 7103 Grievance 7336 Petition 4815 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Future 1196 Pollution Acid Sulfate Soil - Problems 10442 Air HIsmelt Corporation Pty Ltd 402, 1051 Meeting of Environment Protection and Heritage Council 8311 Noisy and Smoky Motor Vehicles 5755 306 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Pollution (continued) Air (continued) Perth Air Quality 824, 4173, 6532 Smoke Haze 2816 Toxic Pollutants - Levels of Exposure 10960 Airborne Mercury 9792 Chemicals - Quantities, Storage, Transportation and Disposal 12808 Heavy Industry - Obligations 9877 Pollution Response Squad - Training 12612 Toodyay - Phenol Contamination of Properties 823 Uduc Road, Harvey 1401 Wesfarmers CSBP Ltd - Ashfield Site - Ground Water Monitoring Data 6183 Questions on Notice - Answers 8007, 11259 Railways - Southern Rail Link Air Quality Benefits 402 Architectural Heritage Survey 6187 Buildings on William and Wellington Streets - Heritage Value 9008 Perth Heritage Buildings - Impact 7407 William Street Buildings - Heritage Impact Study 9802 Rainbow Lorikeets - Threat to Native Species 5897 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 5893; Personal Explanation 14259 Roads Denny Road - Maintenance 13307 Mowen Road - Maintenance 13307 Old Coast Road, Mandurah - South of Dawesville - Removal of Trees 14556 Robins, Mr David Noel - Statement 8160 Salinity Buckingham near Collie - Impact of Logging 7780 Engineering Projects - Funding 8599 Funding 4661, 12063 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality Budget Allocation 7885 Motion 6522 Rural Communities - Funding 1867 Signing 9876 North West - Funding for Programs 7099 Oil Mallee Company of Australia Ltd - Funding 775 Steering Committee to Evaluate Engineering Projects - Establishment 517 Sewerage Murray and Serpentine Rivers - Leakage from Septic Tanks 9006 Ravenswood Hotel - Deep Sewerage Connection 14542 Sewage Spills 12380, 14983 Walpole Waste Water Treatment Plant - Effluent Overflow 5754 State Budget - Environment Initiatives 9785, 9786, 9788 Sustainability Strategy - Agencies 11253 Swan River Fish Deaths 8181, 8182 Great Gardens Initiative 11398 Matter of Public Interest 8800 Regulation of Drainage Water and Pollutants 14542 Riverplan 8788, 8890, 8968 Sewage Discharge from Boats - Monitoring 10879 Trust - Scientific Patrol Boat 14077 Urban Drainage - Impact - Statement 14055 Walls Adjacent to Sir James Mitchell Park - Damage 9799 Tourism Licences - Coral Bay 815 Two Rocks Marina - Fuel Contamination 8137, 8139 Unions - Government Grants 8859 University of Notre Dame Australia - Statement 10568 University of Western Australia - Underwood Avenue Bushland 7116 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 307

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Waste Disposal Atlas Waste - Licence Conditions for Mirrabooka Landfill and Recycling Site 13273 Batteries, Motor Oils and Tyres 13273 Bellevue Community Consultative Committee - Membership, Meetings and Remuneration 826 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility Closure 14253 Community Reference Group 8790, 8791 Government and Opposition Approach 4558 Medical Records of Residents 4557 Statement 4551 Toxic Drums 5831 Waste Taken without Approvals and Closure 4562, 4563 Hazardous Waste - Management and Regulation - Statement 13604 Hazardous Waste Solutions Site, Bellevue - Policy Failure - Statement 1850 Mindarie Regional Council Waste Disposal Plant - Grievance 5684 Perth Metropolitan Area - Total Tonnage 12819 Recycling Legislation - Manufacturers’ Waste Product Packaging 14525 Pot Recyclers, Midvale 13699 Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme - City of Stirling 11741 Total Waste Management, Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion 5266; Personal Explanation 9464 Toxic Waste Dumping - Reporting Requirements 5087 Trucks - Wash-out Facilities 7406 Waste Management and Recycling Fund - North West 3007 Waste Management Board - Chairperson - Credit Card 12380 Waste-to-energy Projects - Funding 1866 Water and Rivers Commission Funding Increase 11704 PPK Environment and Infrastructure 13771 Review 6648 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3204 Second Reading 3204, 5122 Water Resources Busselton Water Board - Renewal of Appointments 983 Catchment Areas - Forest Management Plan 1048, 1049 Catchment Management - Responsible Agency and Funding 14543 Dandalup-Karnet Water Mound - Gazettal 984 Farm Dams - Management Charges - Motion 7697 Farm Water Grants Scheme 2849; Statement 4816 Gnangara Water Mound - Pine Plantation Harvesting 5623 Great Gardens Initiative 11398 Ground Water Exploration and Monitoring 13267 Swan Coastal Plain - Monitoring Program 1787 Harris River Dam - Removal of Additional Water 5753 Jandakot Structure Plan - Water Resource Management Strategy 13772 Management Auditor General’s Report 11252; Personal Explanation 11313 Charges - Motion 7697 Matter of Public Interest 2396 Peel Waterways 9793, 12226 Peel-Harvey Estuarine System - Nutrients 13675 Preston Beach - Grievance 7850 Regional Western Australia - Sustainable Water Supply - Motion 3958 South West District from the Shire of Waroona including Capel - Total Annual Water Allocation 12906 South West Drainage Division - Pipehead Storage and Drinking Water Supply Sites 985 Southern-Wongong River - Water Flow 981 State Reference Network Gauging Stations - Closure 981 Toodyay - Phenol Contamination 823 308 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EDWARDS, HON DR JUDITH MARY (continued) Water Resources (continued) Water Tanks - Incentives to Install 3417 Wokalup and Samson Brook Dams - Connection to the Stirling Dam to Perth Pipe 5510 Yarragadee Aquifer 3008, 7092 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12748 Second Reading 12748 Cognate Debate 13943 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13964 Consideration in Detail 13975-13979 Third Reading 13979 Western Power - Kings Park Parkland - Funding 8343 ELLERY, HON SUZANNE MARY, Parliamentary Secretary, Attorney General (from 27 June); Health (from 27 June); Electoral Affairs (from 27 June) (South Metropolitan) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Commu nity Controlled Health Organisation, WA - Inquiry into Funding - Establishment of Select Committee Amendments to Motion 14018 Motion, as Amended 14018 Aboriginal Health, Office of - Xanthis, Mr Colin - Legal Fees 9583 Derbarl Yerrigan Health Service - Closure 12008 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4405 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14795 Address-in-Reply - Motion Legislative Reform 10, 11 Past Members - Condolences 10 Agriculture - Kimberley - Chemical Use Review - Report 13146 Building Industry Building and Construction Industry Training Fund - Ministerial Review of Levy 12145 Government Construction Contracts - Statement 7319 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 10059 Committee 10066, 10067, 10070, 10072-10075, 10740-10745, 10752-10770, 10883-10900, 11008-11025 As to Report 11025 Third Reading 11331, 11335 Colleges of TAFE Pilbara - Pundulmurra Campus - Selection Process for Manager 11478 West Coast College of TAFE - Hospitality Training Centre 12270 Community Development Child Protection Unit - Funding 12557 Employment Project - Complaint about Forging of Signatures 11478 Drugs Alcohol and Drug Authority Funding 14047 McCotter, Dr Denzil 13004, 13072, 13121, 13143, 13352, 13864 Buprenorphine 12958, 13082, 14609 Drug and Alcohol, Office of - Annual Report Correction - Tabling 14623 School Education Program - Funding 12928, 14642 Sobering-up Centres - Funding 9653 WA Drug Abuse Strategy Office - Funding 14047 Education Depart ment - Amalgamation with Department of Training 12143 Joondalup Hospitality Training Institute - Cost Blow-out 12927 Teachers - Strike Action 11483 Vacswim Program - Cost and Number Enrolled 12925 Environment Barrow Island - Naturally Occurring Radioactive Material 10367 Domestic Fires - Burning of Painted Wood 10801 Environmental Health Foundation - Establishment 11177, 11205 Environmental Health Standards 10782 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 309

ELLERY, HON SUZANNE MARY (continued) Fire and Emergency Services - Chemical Fires - Emergency Response Plan 11040 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Select Committee - Motion 1921 Government Contracts Construction Contracts - Statement 7319 Panel Contracts - Number and Cost 13086 Government Departments and Agencies - Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 11191 Health Aborigines - Services Purchased by Department - Payments 10790 Autism - Statistical Occurrences 10801 Benlate Systemic Fungicide 11479 Bunbury Pain Management Centre - Funding 12552 Bunbury Pathways Program - Funding 11476 Cancer-related Illnesses - Statistical Data on Patients 14621 Carer Support Programs - Funding 11476 Clinic Plane Based at Kununurra - Use by Medical Practitioners 10787 Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement 11477, 12270 Domestic Fires - Burning of Painted Wood 10801 Environmental Health Foundation - Establishment 11177, 11205 Environmental Health Standards 10782 Family Early Intervention Program - Closure 11482 Iatrogenic Illnesses and Deaths 14640 Joondalup Child Development Centre - Waiting List for Therapy 14608, 14637 Men’s Advisory Network - Funding 13072 Mental Health System Funding 11836, 12434, 12438, 13086, 14040 Government Commitment 10093 Mental Health, Office of - South West and Lower Great Southern Carer Program 11362 Non-government Health Organisations - Review 13350 North Metropolitan Health Service Survey 13860, 14032 Not-for-profit Organisations - Funding Cuts 12142, 13143 Organ Donation - Pre-transplant Testing 14049 Parkinson’s Disease Nurse Specialists - Funding 14607 Patient Assisted Travel Scheme - Interstate 13008 Q Fever - Number of Cases 10250 Sexual Health - Funding 11603 Smoking Enclosed Public Spaces - Pubs and Clubs 10747, 11837 Regulations Cabarets, Nightclubs, Hotels and Bars 14211 Market Place Inequity 10815 Smoking in Proximity to Entrances and Exits of Enclosed Public Places 11075 Smoke-free Enclosed Public Places - Review 12965 Thimerosol - Use as a Preservative in Vaccines 10801 Hospitals Breast Reconstructive Surgery - Waiting Time 11073 Broome District - Medical and Financial Positions, and Patient Transfers 10813 Bunbury Regional - Bed Numbers 14028 Busselton District - Bed Numbers 14028 Colonoscopies - Waiting Time 10812 Derby Regional 10813, 11614 Elective Surgery - Waiting Times 11073; Cutbacks 10811 Emergency Departments - Number Treated 11615 Geraldton Regional - Cost Blow-out 13859 Graylands - Murchison Ward 13072, 14046 Gynaecological Surgeons 10750 Margaret River - Upgrade 12266 Northampton District - Services 10747 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children Child Protection Unit - Additional Funding 11039 Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner 13082 310 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

ELLERY, HON SUZANNE MARY (continued) Hospitals (continued) Radioisotopes Usage 10794 Wyndham District Downgrading or Closure 12004 Visiting Medical Specialists 12555 Housing Homelessness - Task Force Strategy - Extra Units for Mentally Ill 14048 People Who Care - Government Support 1138 Housing and Works, Department of - Construction Contracts Policy - Statement 7319 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 12915 Second Reading 12915 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment (Prohibition of Human Cloning) Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 12917 Second Reading 12917 Joint Standing Committee on the Anti-Corruption Commission - Integrity within the Public Sector - Review of the Anti- Corruption Commission - Second Report 7444 Rottnest Island - Boating Community - Grey and Black Water Disposal 13069 Schools - Drug Education and Information Program 12928, 14642 Select Committee into the Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 1921 Training Department - Amalgamation with Department of Education 12143 Joondalup Hospitality Training Institute - Cost Blow-out 12927 Transport - Southern Suburbs - Adjournment Debate 4928 Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Bill 2002 - Second Reading 573 Volunteers - Not-for-profit Health Organisations - Funding Cuts 12142, 13143 Western Power - Underground Power - Petition 696

EMBRY, HON PATRICK (South West) (Independent from 15 May) Abalone Farm, Bremer Bay - Statement 9371 Aborigines Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA - Inquiry into Funding - Establishment of Select Committee Motion, as Amended 14019 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Statement 9198 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Committee 12921, 12939-12951 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Committee 5932 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 - Third Reading 6315 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Legislation Committee 4231 Address-in-Reply Motion Australian Wheat Trade with Iraq 353 Compensation to People Affected by Government Decisions 354, 355 Foreign Aid 353, 354 Government Consultation, Lack of 359 Heritage Listing of Properties - Impact on Owners 356-359 Mobile Telephone Network Coverage - Deficiencies 359 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 3584 Adjournments of the House - Complimentary Remarks 14849 Agriculture Drought Assistance Exceptional Circumstances Aid 3442 Statement by Minister for Agriculture 13114 Egg Marketing Board 6281, 9847, 10251 Harvest Yields - Exceptional Circumstances Funding 3029 Midland Saleyards - Delay in Decision-making Process 4204 Single Desk System - Statement 11489 Strainer Posts and Fencing Posts - Cutting by Farmers for Own Use 14839 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 311

EMBRY, HON PATRICK (continued) Agriculture (continued) Western Australian Export Grain Transportation and Handling Agreement 10154 Wheat - Impact on Crops of Snow in the Stirling Ranges 11043 Alcoa World Alumina Australia - Wagerup Alumina Refinery -Monitoring of Health of Wagerup Community 9566 Amity House, Albany 5536, 7477; Adjournment Debate 5672 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Second Reading 2770 Committee 2775, 2876, 2877, 2880, 2881, 2889 Australian Competition and Consumer Commission - Samuel, Mr Graeme 3289 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1735 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Second Reading 13054 Committee 13089-13103 Boxing Control Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6319 Boxwood Hill Sporting Complex 14031; Statement 14038 Brown, Mr Ray - Adjournment Debate 869 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1822 Bunbury Port - Fees Paid 866 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13320 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 9591 Committee 10075, 10885-10900 Third Reading 11334 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 - Committee 5929 Censorship Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6556 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 11830 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Committee 3040 Commerce and Trade Live Sheep Export - Cormo Express - Australia’s Quarantine Regulations 12292 United States Free Trade Agreement - Statement 11489 Community Development Child Protection - Children’s Advocate 6299, 6581 Paedophiles - Protection of Children 9624 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3607, 3622-3627, 3740-3744 Consumer and Employment Protection Co mplaint PE36898 - Application for Leave to Appeal 1139 Walker, Mr Pat 3289 Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders Motion 9840, 10225 Amendment to Motion 10227 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 3) 2001 - Second Reading 5768 Crane, Mr Albert Victor - Statement 10255 Dogs - Wild - Control - Statement 5962 Drivers Licences - Fatal Accident - Statement 7456 Dumbleyung District Memorial Hospital - Statement 13596 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Committee 11971 Electoral - Reform - Adjournment Debate 1835 Electricity Electricity Reform Implementation Committee - Consultants’ Report Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12414 Windy Harbour - Petition 1919 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14808 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14808 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14808 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 4921 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 6417 Committee 10141, 10212-10225, 11199-11204 Third Reading 11569 Fines, Penalties and Infringement Notices Enforcement Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6258 312 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

EMBRY, HON PATRICK (continued) Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 1435 Forests and Forestry Manjimup - Timber Mill Quotas 2874 Old-growth Forest - Social and Economic Impact of Policy - Urgency Motion 546 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14602 Committee 14630-144633 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Second Reading 1822 Committee 1946, 1947, 1957-1959 Health Bunbury Health System - Statement 13353 Mental Health System - Funding Cuts 11601 Nurses - Security in Remote Areas 8365, 9565 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1252 Second Reading 2148 Insurance - Manipulation of Profits by Companies 2231, 2347 Iraq - Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3582, 3713 Kokoda Trail - Adjournment Debate 170 Land Clearing - Statement 12442 Local Government Rating System and Distribution of Funds - Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment on the Amendment 11999 Mallee Fowl - Interpretive and Visitor Centre, Ongerup 11601 Mobile Telephones - Coverage in Western Australia - Statement 6093 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading 13345 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5647 Occupational Safety and Health Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10110, 10118 Parliamentary Secretaries - Visit to Croatia - Statement 11594 Peel Region Scheme - Disallowance 5549 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2246 Police Officers -Active Duty - Number 13471; Statement 13477 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 13991-13994 Prisons Albany Regional - Adjournment Debate 2644 Child Rapist - Adjournment Debate 3190 Prisons Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 6296 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7128 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3304 Railways Perth-Albany Line - Reintroduction 13071 Safety at Night 9626 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Committee 7988 Assembly’s Message 8386-8391 Roads Albany Highway - Mt Barker Bypass 11835, 12007; Statement 6092 Fatal Accident - Statement 7456 Funding - Condemnation of Government - Motion 9348; Statement 9557 Rottnest Island - Kingstown Barracks - Asbestos Roofing 1008; Adjournment Debate 1163, 1555; Statement 6462 Schools Bus Service - Adjournment Debate 1671 Non-government - Funding - Petition 4304 Select Committee into Water Services - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7159 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children (Appointment of a Commissioner for Children) - Establishment - Motion 7635 Serong, Brigadier Francis Philip - Death - Adjournment Debate 2150 Sessional Orders - Continuation and Amendment - Motion 14845 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9332 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 313

EMBRY, HON PATRICK (continued) Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 2329 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 6271 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 230(b) - Motion 2317 Swimming Pools - Subsidies to Local Government 5053 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Committee 4206-4222 Telstra - Statement 9371 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 4336 Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Amendment to Motion 3860 Torr, Ms Joan - Adjournment Debate 4930 Transport Air - National Airspace System - Federal Government Changes - Statement 13477 Buses - School Bus Service - Adjournment Debate 1671 Department - Winzer, Mr Neil - Termination Package 1954 Safety at Night 9626 Western Australian Export Grain Transportation and Handling Agreement 10154 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7463 United States of America - Australia’s Support for Military Action in Iraq - Motion 3582, 3713 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1252 Water Resources- Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7159 Water Services Coordination Act - Review - Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12414 Western Power - Statement 9371 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7496 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1550 Workers Compensation Legislation 2231, 2347 Validity of Claims 2606 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1252 FARINA, HON ADELE (South West) (ALP) Backpacker Hostels - Fire Safety 1260 Bromell, Mr Ross - Personal Explanation - Grievance 1263 Cycleways 468 Forests and Forestry - Ludlow Tuart Forest - Mining - Petition 11960 Housing and Works, Department of - Warren-Blackwood Call Centre - 3617 Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining - Petition 11960 Premier - Visit to Manjimup, Pemberton and Bridgetown 4529 Roads Mandurah Bypass Road, Coodanup - Pedestrian Crossing - Petition 10882 Rural Areas - Expenditure 11177 Salinity Funding - Catchment Demonstration Initiative 12009 Schools Bus Service - Contractors’ Back Pay Arrangements 13357 Geographe Primary - Personal Explanation 1263 Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 Extension of Reporting Time 6943 Report 8348 Censorship Amendment Bill 2002 Extension of Reporting Time 337 Third Report 1919 Commonwealth Powers (De Facto Relationships) Bill 2003 Extension of Reporting Time 14623 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Ninth Report 6943 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 Extension of Reporting Time 11821, 12911 Twelfth Report 13843 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) (Reviews) Amendment Bill 2003 Eighth Report 6543 314 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

FARINA, HON ADELE (continued) Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes (continued) Higher Education Bill 2003 Eleventh Report 11195 Extension of Reporting Time 9569 Special Report - Addendum to the Eleventh Report 11437 Human Reproductive Technology Bills - Thirteenth Report 14710 National Crime Authority (State Provisions) Amendment Bill 2002 Extension of Time 338 Report 3618 Trans-Tasman Mutual Recognition (Western Australia) Bill 2002 Extension of Reporting Time 338 Fourth Report 1919 Unclaimed Money (Superannuation and RSA Providers) Bill 2002 - Seventh Report 5915 Work of the Committee in the First Session of the Thirty-sixth Parliament - Report 338, 446 Tourism Planning Task Force Report - Statement 9850 Warren-Blackwood Area Call Centre - Housing and Works, Department of 3617 Water Resources - Community Water Forums - Advertisement for Hon Adele Farina - Adjournment Debate 1446 FISCHER, HON JOHN (Mining and Pastoral) (ON) Aborigines Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission Act - Rate Exemptions 13065 Aboriginal Cultural Materials Committee - Chairperson - Conflict of Interest 13165 Aboriginal Heritage Sites Register - Broome - Registration of Names 5957 Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council 3868 Broome - Heritage Consultants 8423 Mungullah Community Aboriginal Corporation - Chairperson 6281 Roebourne - Neglected Children 4448 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 - Third Reading 6314 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4287 Address-in-Reply Motion Land Rights 561 Public Liability Insurance 562 Workers Compensation Legislation 555 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 4319 Adjournments of the House - Complimentary Remarks 4543, 14849 Agriculture Banana Imports 12666 Food Irradiation - Quarantine Phytosanitary Measures 11602 Foxes - Increase in Pastoral Regions 2123 Live Sheep Export - Statement 6595 Mediterranean Fruit Fly - Quarantine Checkpoint 10091 Noxious Weeds - Kalgoorlie-WA Border Railway Track - Control 11365 Onion Weed - Declaration as Noxious Weed 12141 Ovine Johne’s Disease 551 Parkeston Stockyards 11207, 11479 Rabbit Control - 14195 Wheat Exports to Iraq 7 Wheat Streak Mosaic Virus 8365 Wild Dogs - Increase in Pastoral Regions 2123 Air Travel - Cost - Statement 11488 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Second Reading 2768 Committee 2775-2889 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13340 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1733 Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13052 Brown, Mrs Hazel - Adjournment Debate 4237 Building Industry - Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded Urgency Motion 7318 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 315

FISCHER, HON JOHN (continued) Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13320 Committee 13323, 13324 Bungle Bungle National Park - Mindi Mindi Aboriginal Corporation 1004 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 7795 Third Reading 11334 Capital Punishment - Offenders Convicted of Heinous Crimes - Motion 12996 Carnarvon Gascoyne Flood Mitigation Plan - Statement 9370 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Second Reading 2899 Committee 3039, 3042 Community Development - Roebourne - Initiatives to Assist Young People 4395 Consultants - Adjournment Debate 5435 Consumer and Employment Protection, Department of - Adjournment Debate 1165 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Committee 12391 Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders - Motion 9835 Crime - Murchison Region - Adjournment Debate 2508 Criminal Law (Procedure) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1025 Dogs, Wild - Control - Statement 7182 Drugs Drug and Alcohol Strategy - Urgency Motion 236 Sobering-up Centres - Funding 9362, 9653 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Committee 12285 Education Central Reserve Area - Costs 13142 Teachers Remedial 13859 Training in Aboriginal Culture 9026 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14805 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14805 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14805 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4911 Second Reading 5017 Committee 10132-10141 Third Reading 11577 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers 9011 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 566 Fire and Emergency Services Communications Systems 12433 Regional Airports - Removal of Front-line Emergency Response Crews - Statement 6090 Fisheries - Palmer, Jeff and Gail - Statement 12565 Fuel and Energy Fuel Prices - Regional Fuel Retailers - Adjournment Debate 373 Petrol - Legislative Requirements in WA 12035 Wyndham - Power Failures 3286 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14604 Committee 14643-14649 Third Reading 14728 Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Urgency Motion 7318 Health Agencies - Statutory Reporting Deadlines 9194 Australia New Zealand Food Standards System 13470; Statement 13076 Broometime Lodge, Broome Cost 5660 Incident of Antisocial Behaviour 14029 Statement 9980 Cue Nursing Post 1136 316 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

FISCHER, HON JOHN (continued) Health (continued) Kimberley - Dialysis Centre 5192 Nurses - Crisis in Public Hospitals - Adjournment Debate 1267 Heritage - Rawlinna Precinct - Funding 12288 Hoochery, The - Kununurra - Statement 11368 Hospitals Broome District - Medical and Financia l Positions and Patient Transfers 10813 Derby Regional 465, 10813 Wyndham District - Downgrading or Closure 12004 Housing Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council 3868 Kimberley Dialysis Centre - Location 5192 Housing and Works, Department of Broometime Lodge, Broome - Antisocial Behaviour 5660, 13007, 14029; Statement 9980 Construction Contracts Policy - Urgency Motion 7318 Indigenous Affairs, Department of, Broome - Heritage Consultants 6459, 7312 Industrial Development Bauxite Deposit - Mitchell Plateau, Kimberley 14837 Drilling Platforms - Radioactive Material 37, 162 Karratha and Barrow Island - Motion 4440 Methanex Corporation - Development on Burrup Peninsula 1531 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 699 Pilbara - Protection from Terrorist Attack 5533 Inspector of Custodial Services Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14579 Insurance Claim of Blackmail by the Premier - Threshold on Claims 2480 Claims - 30 per cent Threshold 2761 Manipulation of Profits by Companies - Mr Brendan McCarthy’s Evidence to Committee 2602 Public Liability - Threshold on Claims 2480 Iraq Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3426, 3575 War - Student Rally - Adjournment Debate 5034 Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 2002 - Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to the Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Motion 855 Second Reading 858, 866 Justice, Department of - Kanpa Bail Facility 5314 Live Sheep Export - Statement 6595 Lobbyists Adjournment Debate 5435 Hawker, Mr Bruce - Meetings with Premier 6957 Local Government Act - Definition of Emergency 7177 New Nullarbor Shire - Establishment 11834 Rates - Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission Act 13065 Rating System and Distribution of Funds - Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment on the Amendment 11998 Roads Funding 10942 Mauds Landing Development - Adjournment Debate 4237 Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Fall at Funeral - Compensation Payment 12923 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit - Revocation of Mr Lewandowski’s Indemnity 1802, 1950 Mining Bauxite Deposit - Mitchell Plateau, Kimberley 14837 Delays in Projects - Statement 12273, 12672 Drilling Platforms - Radioactive Material 37, 162 Portman Iron Ore Ltd Koolyanobbing Mine - Expansion 9585 Statement 14202 Windimurra Vanadium Mine - Adjournment Debate 2643 Mobile Telephones - Coverage in Western Australia 244 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 317

FISCHER, HON JOHN (continued) Native Title Mindi Mindi Aboriginal Corporation - Bungle Bungle National Park Decision 1004 Office- Pilbara - Alcohol Consumption 4448 Pilbara - Up-front Payment 8395 Portman Iron Ore Ltd - Statement 14202 Yaburarra and Mardudhunera Claim 9847 Noxious Weeds - Kalgoorlie-WA Border Railway Track - Control 11365 Nullarbor Plain - Road-rail Service 346 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5645 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10107 Occupational Safety and Health Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4535 Onslow Airfield - Statement 5963 Ord River Muster - Statement 8572 Parker, Mr Ron - Australian Interaction Consultants - Ethnographic Survey 14636, 14712 Pastoral Leases Aboriginal Pastoral Properties in Kimberley Region - Statement 6460 Kimberley - Sheep 710 Mt Barnett Station 4024 Police CADCOM Project - Adverse Report by Auditor General 12555 Cue, Mount Magnet and Meekatharra - Staffing Levels 6082 Great Northern Highway Roadblock between Broome and Wilare Bridge 9972, 10377 Royal Commission - Adjournment Debate 1039, 2149 Scott, Detective Frank - Corruption Allegations 4957, 5050 Stock Stealing Squad Chatley, Bob and Colleen 3024 Criteria for Investigation of Allegations 1417, 3024 Port Hedland Detention Centre - Visit by Girls from Mandurah Catholic College 14771 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5046 Qantas Air Services - Freight Capacity into the North of Western Australia 4340 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8542, 8647 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8542, 8647 Committee 8653-8670, 8680, 8679 Recommittal 8681 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8542, 8647 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8542, 8647 Regional Development Buy Local Policy - Statement 14785 Financial Assistance Schemes - Double-dipping by State Government Agencies 10113 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Assembly’s Message 8392 Roads Funding Condemnation of Government - Motion 9354 Local Government 10942 Mining and Pastoral Region 10248 Goldfields Highway - Wiluna-Meekatharra 8568 Meekatharra Bypass Road 5409 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Lack of Evidence 2227 Salinity - Methods to Reduce Escalating Problems - Motion 13464 Schools Bus Service - Marble Bar 4531 Carnarvon - New Private School 3173 Catholic - Government Funding - Adjournment Debate 60 Country Areas - Remedial Teachers 13859 Islamic - Funding and Curriculum 3730 Kununurra Primary - Deterioration of Buildings 6582 Mandurah Catholic College - Visit by Girls to Port Hedland Detention Centre 14771 Roebourne Primary - Statement 9200 318 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

FISCHER, HON JOHN (continued) Schools (continued) South Hedland Primary - Roof and Ceiling Repairs 7476 St Cecilia’s Catholic School, Port Hedland - Closure 2870 Select Committee into Water Services - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7156 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children (Appointment of a Commissioner for Children) - Establishment Motion, as Amended 8554 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5295-5299, 5638 Sittings of the House - Extended after 6.00 pm - Amendment to Motion 2755 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel Motion 4493 Report 4491 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches Fifth Report 3154 Standing Orders - No 73 - Amendment to Question 343 Telecommunications Mobile Telephones - Coverage in Western Australia 244 Needs Assessment 12267 Terrorism - Pilbara - Protection from Attack 5533 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Amendment to Motion 3861 Standing Orders Suspension 3864 Tourism - Lake Kununurra and Ord River - Landing Rights 12031 Universities - Student Places - Adjournment Debate 3060 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2622 Water Corporation - Desalination of Water - Hydraulic Head Pressure 862 Water Resources Adjournment Debate 3770 Gascoyne Sustainable Capacity of Scheme Water 1261 Water Cooperative - Statement 9558 Harris River Dam - Redfin Perch 3436 Kununurra Bore Field 10364 Lake Kununurra and Ord River - Control Maintenance and Management 12031 Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7156 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4537 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12233 Western Power - Wyndham - Electricity Meter Readings 4902, 5438 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation (Acts of Terrorism) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3047 Workers Compensation Degree of Disability 12033 McCarthy, Mr Brendan - Evidence to Committee 2602 WorkCover WA - Review of Legislation - Motion 12125 Youth - Roebourne - Initiatives to Assist Young People 4395 FORD, HON JONATHAN ROBERT (Mining and Pastoral) (ALP) Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13056 B Squadron No 34th Cavalry Unit - Adjournment Debate 582 Burrup Peninsula Rock Art Assessment of Impact of Emissions 4527, 7512 Disturbance and Loss 6584, 7512 West Intercourse Island 5779, 6584 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Committee 14765-14769 Ford, Ms Erinna - Statement 13014 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 836, 1131 Onslow Seawall - Reconstruction 3292 Standing Committee on Legislation Corruption and Crime Commission Act 2003 and Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment Bill 2003 Twenty-first Report - Tabling 14623 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 319

FORD, HON JONATHAN ROBERT (continued) Standing Committee on Legislation (continued) Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Report - Extension of Time 7464 Overview of the Committee’s Operations for the First Session of the Thirty-sixth Parliament Seventeenth Report 2111, 4318 Sentencing Bills - Report - Extension of Time 7464 State Administrative Tribunal Bills - Extension of Time 11821, 13843 Taxation Bills - Sixteenth Report 1792

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO, QC (East Metropolitan) (Lib) Aborigines Aboriginal Housing Development Authority 4937, 5026 Aboriginal Justice Council - Cancellation of Support 4937 Aboriginal Visitors Scheme in Prisons - Funding 4937 Gordon Inquiry - Recommendations - Cost 12163 Government Programs 7014, 7015, 7017, 7509, 7511, 7654, 7841, 7842, 7844, 7846, 8402, 8407 Heritage Issues - Aboriginal Heritage Sites 9552 North West - Programs 8401 Sites of Significance - Perth Urban Rail Development 9192, 9356 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 Second Reading 12526 Instruction to Committee of the Whole 12650 Committee 12968-12981 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13129 Committee 13154-13163 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Committee 6044-6050 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 Second Reading 6242 Committee 6308-11 Third Reading 6315 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 4415 Committee 4513-4523 Address-in-Reply Motion Commission on Government 1935 Mickelberg Case - Attorney General’s handling of Affidavit 1940 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers 1936 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 4191 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Order of Business - Amendment to Motion 2724 Committee - 2885-2889 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Committee 9530, 9533, 9535 Articled Clerks - Employment 13591 Asymptote Consulting - Tabled Paper No 785 5312 Baudin, Commander Nicolas - Bicentenary of Expedition to Australia - Statement 11369 Beck, Mr Tinsley Manning - Petition for Relief - Motion 4954 Building Industry - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded 6953; Urgency Motion 7304 Cabinet Meetings - Confidentiality of Discussions 10380 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 814 Committee 10066-75, 11011-11025 Censorship Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 6554 Committee 6557 Child Support (Adoption of Laws) Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 3463 Committee 3591 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 10238, 10449 320 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO (continued) Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 (continued) Motion 11825 Committee 11825-11830, 11839-11859 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Second Reading 2895 Committee 3038-3041 Community Development Families in Need of Support - Assessment 9617 SafeCare 4392, 4452, 4901 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3624-3627 Consultants - Change in Policy 11599 Coroners Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6061, 6086 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 2) 2001 Second Reading 5428 Committee 5764 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 3) 2001 Second Reading 5765, 5768 Committee 5768-69 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Committee 14754-14769, 14779-14782, 14826-14832 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 14739-14752 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 Instruction to Committee of the Whole 9367 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 9369 Crime Burglary - Charges Laid 10941 Car Theft - Three-strikes Law 7475 Ho micides - Number of Charges 2510 House Break-ins 14852-14867 Northbridge - Curfew for Juveniles - Children Apprehended 10939 Perth Station - Children Apprehended 10940 Railway Stations - Motor Vehicles Stolen, Damaged or Burgled 9618 Safer WA 14027 Theft from Vehicles - Preventive Measures 5049 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14729 Criminal Injuries Compensation Act - Amendments 13348 Maximum Amount 9969, 10089 Statement 10095 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13325 Criminal Investigation (Exceptional Powers) and Fortification Removal Act 2002 - Appointment of Special Commissioners 5412 Criminal Law (Procedure) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 1014, 1154-56 Committee 1154-56 Cycleways - East Perth-Maylands 2151, 13359 Detention Centres - Security Concerns 4940 Director of Public Prosecutions, Office of - Establishment 5808 Drugs Cannabis Charges and Cautions 7309 Convictions 7309 Drug and Alcohol Strategy - Urgency Motion 234 Law Enforcement 7448 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision High Court Challenge 11361 Urgency Motion 1793 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4911 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 321

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO (continued) Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 (continued) Second Reading 4970 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 6416 Committee 10135-10141, 10329-10360, 11146-11159, 11223-26 Environmental Protection, Department of - Industrial Pollution Monitoring - Budget 10805 Estimates Committees - Appointment - Amendment to Motion 7146 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 155, 167, 563 Committee 723-729 Third Reading 729 Fines, Penalties and Infringement Notices Enforcement Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6253 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 1436-39, 3043 Fisheries Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2002 Clause 5 - Disallowance Motion 1643 Palmer, Jeff and Gail - Prosecution 1841 Forests and Forestry Draft Forest Management Plan Minister’s Submission 1658 Statement by Leader of the House - Motion 10080 Hacketts Gully - Logging 13858 Jarrah and Karri Sawlogs - Request for Proposals - Stage B 2481 Old-growth Forest Mills Seeking Business Exit Assistance 705 Social and Economic Impact of Policy - Urgency Motion 540 Timber Industry Restructure Plan 6277 Timber Mills - Business Exit Assistance 43 Timber Allocations - Final Recommendations 8565 Freedom of Information Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11027 Committee 11029, 11030 Fuel and Energy - Mains Power Cable - Cost to Reconnect when Broken by a Storm 4939 Government Advertising Budget 8433, 9065 Government Construction Contracts Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded Letter to Director General of Department of Housing and Works 6953 Urgency Motion 7304 In Excess of $50 000 9059 Government Departments and Agencies Aborigines - Programs 7014-15, 7017, 7509, 7511, 7654, 7841-42, 7844, 7846, 8401,8402, 8407 Grants Loans and Financial Assistance 9067 Leave Liability 12431, 12552 Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 11057-11070, 11183-11191, 11862-11868, 11874- 11877, 12014, 13481 Staff - Recruitment Procedures 4058 Government Media Office - Recipients of Media Summaries and Transcripts 11878 Government Vehicles - Executive Vehicle Scheme 11192 Greenhouse Gas Emissions - State Government Stand - Urgency Motion 994 Groves, Ms Vicki - Prisoner F - Parole Board’s Decision 3434, 4026 Heritage - Fund and Register 11877 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1250 Homicide Victims Support Group 3728, 3730, 3866; Adjournment Debate 4043 Hospitals Breast Reconstructive Surgery - Waiting Time 11073 Colonoscopies - Waiting Time 10812 Elective Surgery - Waiting Time 11073 Elective Surgery Cutbacks 10811 Housing and Works, Department of Better Risk Management and Best Practice Contracting - Policy Framework - Letter to Director General 6953 Construction Contracts Policy - Urgency Motion 7304 322 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO (continued) Industrial Disputes - Prisons 4028 Inspector of Custodial Services Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14575 Iraq Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3576 War - Justification - Adjournment Debate 5325 Joondalup, City of - Report of Governance 14193 Juries Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 6945 Committee 6949 Justice, Department of Child Sex Offenders - Names 12570 Community Orders - Completion - Statement 10253 Early Release Orders - Administrative Instructions on Breaches 5048 George, Ms Kate 4938 Juvenile Justice Teams 8432, 8671 Leech, Mr Tony - Overseas Tour 3609 Ministerial Councils for Corrective Services 11831 Parole Conditions 10361, 10362 Parole System - Number of Offenders, Classification and Breaches 13167 Pre-release Parole and Home Leave Programs 5530 Royal Association of Justices - Assistance to Produce Magazine 1744 SafeCare - Referral of Sex Offenders 4901 Tie Line Between Attorney General’s Office 9633 Warrants of Commitment - Number and Classification of Offenders 13482 Justices of the Peace 7651, 9375 Kelly, Hon Garry Kenneth - Condolence Motion 29 Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Tortfeasors’ Contribution) Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6316 Legal Practice Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13129 Committee 13138, 13148-13154 Legal Practitioners Act - Section 13(3) Directions - Statement 13600 Legislative Council Attorney General’s Remarks - Urgency Motion 4382 Frontbench Desks in Chamber - Statement 9853 Sitting Hours - Statement 7834 Temporary Chamber - Statement 5963, 7834, 9980 Lotterywest - Safer WA - Grants 14027 Maritime Museum Adjournment Debate 3630 Opening 3441 Members of Parliament Electorate Offices 8424 Personal Explanations Comments by Attorney General 3421 Perth Urban Rail Development - Comment by Parliamentary Secretary 3057 Staff - Attorney General’s Attack - Adjournment Debate 3629 Mickelberg Case Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General Documents Given to Minister for Health 549, 1005, 1422, 1528 Late-night Telephone Discussion with Premier 160, 166 Meetings with Solicitor General 344 Receipt of Documents from Solicitor General 462, 464, 550, 860 Solicitor General’s Advice 1529 Tape of Channel 7 Interview 9021, 12286 Transcript of Assistant Commissioner Kucera’s Transcript of Evidence and Affidavit-in-chief 36 Copy to The West Australian 1003 Government Media Personnel 241 Minister for Health - Allegations 1136 Number of Copies and Source of Leaked Copy 345 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 323

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO (continued) Mickelberg Case (continued) Lewandowski Affidavit (continued) Tape of Interview by Alison Fan with Tony Lewandowski 8564, 8671, 13141 Petition - Handing Over on Front Steps of Parliament 344 Ministers of the Crown Attorney General Facsimile Application of Signature 4956, 5020 Inverview with Bob Maumill 1258 Legal Practitioner Qualifications 13468, 13591 Meetings with Solicitor General 344, 464 Policy for Announcing Early Release of Prisoners 4200 Posing with the Director of Public Prosecutions on Harley Davidson Motorbike 344 Receipt of Documents from Solicitor General 462 Resignation from the Position of Leader of the Opposition 14634 Tie Line Between Office of Attorney General and Department of Justice 9633 Visit by Journalists to Ministerial Office 1135 Government Vehicles - Accidents 11192 Minister for Culture and the Arts - Art Purchases 7479 Minister for Disability Services - Employment of People with Disabilities 14801 Minister for Health - Recipient of Fax Sent to the WA Christian Community 1949 Minister for Housing and Works - Cost of Faxing 1801 Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Absence 6277 Minister for the Kimberley, Pilbara and Gascoyne - Office Budget 865 Parliamentary Secretaries - Visit to Croatia - Statement 11594, 11595 Staff - Temporary 3906 Staff Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers, Credit Cards, Fax Machines, Business Cards and Home Internet Access 4060 Motor Vehicle Theft Railway Stations 9618 Three-strikes Law 7475 National Maternity Action Plan - Adjournment Debate 1448 Nurses - Prisons - Adjournment Debate 3767 Order of Business - Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Amendment to Motion 2724 Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6974 Planning Mauds Landing Development - Urgency Motion 4188 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment No 1028/33 - South East Districts Omnibus (No 5) Disallowance 4466 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 256, 262-267, 361, 456-461, 469 Police Cannabis - Charges and Cautions 7309 Drugs - Law Enforcement 7448 Pay Dispute - Newspaper Advertisement 11038, 11173 Theft from Vehicles - Preventive Measures 5049 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - Duty Media Adviser - Weekend of 7 and 8 June 2002 1745 Prisons Aboriginal Visitors Scheme - Funding 4937 Arts Programs 5809 Excell, Mr - Pre-release Program 3285 Finn Prisoner - Announcement of Early Release 4200 Fires Lit by Prisoners in Cells 4938 Hakea - Sick Leave 3616 Industrial Disputes 4028 Inspector of Custodial Services - Annual Report 3172 Juvenile Sex Offender and Murderer B - Pre-release Program 3285 Keating, Mr Paul Stephen - Urinalysis 7013 Nurses - Adjournment Debate 3767 Pre-release Parole and Home Leave Programs 5530 Prisoner F 3434, 4026, 4200 Prisoners - Release Programs 3024 324 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO (continued) Prisons (continued) Security Concerns 4940 Thursday Prison Census - Tabling 5955 Wimbridge Prisoner - Sex Offender Treatment Program 4199 Prisons Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 6054 Committee 6293-96 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8771 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 Second Reading 1027 Committee 5065-5073, 5201-5205 Third Reading 5205 Assembly’s Message 5916-5918, 7125, 7126 Progress 5919 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Recommittal 7287 Question without Notice No 1514 - Changes to Prepared Answer 5 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Committee 8664-8670 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 2497 Notice of Motion 2852 Second Reading 3280, 3293 Statement 3167 Railways Derailed Locomotives - Adjournment Debate 3191 Fremantle - Reduction of Service 4939 Perth Station - Children Apprehended 10940 Perth Urban Rail Development Tabled Paper Nos 468 and 841 Author 5318, 5771 Lawrence, Dr Peter 6298, 6455 Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Motion 5197, 5521, 6433 Motion, as Amended 6434 Statement by President 5935 Southern Rail Link Aboriginal Heritage Sites 9192, 9356, 9552 Clifton Coney Stevens (WA) Pty Ltd - Final Report 7821 Interpeak Lay-off 9373 Journey Times 5955 Kwinana Freeway Route - Impact of Construction 6095 Modelling of Patronage Forecasts 6580; Tabling of Document 5779 Passenger Numbers and Greenhouse Gas Emissions 11610 Tabled Paper No 785 - Asymptote Consulting 5312 Traffic Delays on Roads Caused by Construction 5413 William Street Tunnel - Risk Analysis 4446, 6096, 7651 South West Metropolitan Railway Master Plan - Statement by Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Motion 6271, 7441 Stations - Car Stealing and Burglary 11193 Urban Rail Development Personal Explanation 3057 Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Motion 4994, 5183, 5184 Vehicles Stolen, Damaged or Burgled at Stations 9618 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 - Committee 6551, 6552 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Second Reading 7970 Amendments to be Put Before Sessional Order Invoked 7978 Committee 7978-7990 Third Reading 7990 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 325

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO (continued) Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 (continued) Assembly’s Message 8368-8391 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 9175; Amendment to Motion 9177 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme 8686-87, 8689-90 Kwinana Freeway - Ra ilway Construction 6095 Old Perth Road, Bassendean - Reopening 13125 Rottnest Island - Funding - Motion 14183 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers Lovell, Mr Avon - Prosecution for Failure to Cooperate 4938 Musarri, Mr - Failure to Cooperate 4938 Schools Fees Sanctions on Students for Non-payment 4939 Lockridge Senior High - Access to School Ball 7643, 9078 Non-government - Funding - Petition 4435 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5286-5299 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 Second Reading Discharged and Referral to Legislation Committee 4502 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9160 Committee 9338, 9339, 9363, 9367 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 4500 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9160 Committee 9169, 9336-9338 Sittings of the House - Days and Hours - Amendment to Motion 2472 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 1932 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 6268-6271 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3152, 3155 State Budget - Government’s Self-promotion Campaign 8433 State Finance Interest Rates 9064 Revenue Increases 5218 Unbudgeted Capital Loan Repayments 9064 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 Second Reading 3754 Committee 4011-4022, 4032-4035, 4206-4222 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2001 - Second Reading 3754 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) (Taxing) Bill 2001 - Second Reading 3754 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 13441-44, 13446-50, 13475-77, 13557-13572 Taxis Additional Plates - Increases in Categories 9843 Deregulation of Industry Communication with Commonwealth 10260 Northern Territory 6080 Statement 13478 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Amendment to Motion 3857 Trading Hours - Deregulation Adjournment Debate 4488 Statement 13478 Transfer of Land Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 5419 Trustees of Western Australia Limited (Transfer of Business) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6322 Unclaimed Money (Superannuation and RSA Providers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6422 United States of America - Australia’s Support for Military Action in Iraq - Motion 3576 Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Bill 2002 - Second Reading 571 326 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

FOSS, HON PETER GILBERT Da CONCEICAO (continued) Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1250 Second Reading 2622 Committee 2632 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7486 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1250 Second Reading 7434, 7464 Young Offenders Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14170 Second Reading 14170

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN, BEc, MPhil, MA, DPhil, Premier; Minister for Public Sector Management; Federal Affairs; Science; Citizenship and Multicultural Interests (Victoria Park) (ALP) Aborigines Antisocial and Criminal Behaviour - Premier’s Co mments 10282 Gordon Inquiry 2270, 3777, 3778, 10053, 11815; Statement 171, 3774, 9081 Mullewa - Antisocial Behaviour 12460 National Parks and Nature Reserves - Transfer to Aboriginal Groups 11257 North West - Child Abuse and Family Violence Programs 9747 Swan Valley Nyungah Community 10636; Statement 7655 Adams, Ms Brenda - Condolences to the Leader of the National Party 8436 Address-in-Reply - Amendment to Motion - Water Shortages 225 Agent General of Western Australia - Fisher, Mr Robert - Statement 11378 Agriculture Department - Locust Control Campaign Award 914 Drought 2270, 2927, 3779, 3930, 3931, 5513 Air Transport - North West 4657 Anti-Corruption Commission Appointment of Chairman and Members 205 Premier’s Meeting with Mr T.E. O'Connor 1759 Staff Job Offers with the CCC and Redundancies 7112 Permanency and Entitlements 12739 Anzac Day Review Committee - Statement 11680 Auditor General, Office of the - Funding Allocation 11107 Australian Flag - Legislation to Outlaw Desecration 2518 Australian Labor Party Deregulation of Trading Hours - Policy 8503 Lawrence, Dr Carmen - Election to Federal Presidency 13202 Western Australian Labour Advisory Council - Establishment 7948 Bali Bombings 1865, 2002; Condolence Motion 1747 Bateman, Mr Thomas Henry - Condolence Motion 11892 Blue Light Events - North West 2720 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14921 Building Industry Cole Royal Commission Findings - Rule of Law 1233, 5826 Government Construction Contracts 9230, 9418 Cabinet Anwyl, Ms Megan - Briefing 6677 Directive - Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 6644, 6645, 6678, 6679 Meetings 5516 6541; Motion 6018 Regional Subcommittee - Meetings 4656, 4657, 12065 Reshuffle 8438 Secretary - Cabinet Minutes 5373 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Debate - Absence of Premier 6812 Refusal of Minister for Police and Minister for Community Development to Speak 6812 Centres of Excellence - Government Support 1307 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3848 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 327

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Child Pornography - Internet Access 10964 Citizenscape Web Site - Statement 376 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Ramifications for Claimants 2007 Commerce and Trade China - Trade Developments 12682 Western Australia's Export Performance 9660 Committees and Boards Appointments 11531, 11787 Members - Mobile Telephones Pagers Vehicles and Credit Cards 7751 Committees, Task Forces, Reviews and Advisory Groups - Number Established - Cost 8307 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14391 Community Development Child Pornography - Internet Access 10964 Mullewa - Resourcing 12460 Computer Literacy - North West - Funding 3983 Consultants Government’s Failure to Achieve Promised Cut in Expenditure 3087 Report - Tabling 2820 Welker Environmental Consultancy - Contract Details 13547 Crane, Mr Albert Victor - Condolence Motion 10155 Crime Crime Prevention Structures Review Report 8599, 8728 Curfew for Juveniles in Northbridge 6678, 6808, 8439, 9872, 12198, 12321, 12683, 12684 Curfew Statewide 8888, 8889 Halls Creek and South Hedland 6680, 6681 Neighbourhood Watch - Committees and Projects 9796 North West 3006, 3416, 8272 Safer WA 4855, 8071, 8599, 9796, 12682 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13176 Defence Forces Armidale-class Patrol Boats - Tender 9417 Fremantle-class Patrol Boats - Contract 766 Fremantle Artillery Barracks 8311, 11785; Statement 11376 Premier’s Message of Support for Personnel in Gulf Region 5716 Disability Services Commission 6341 Drugs Cannabis 3005, 5715, 5716, 6336, 7671, 7880, 12757 Programs in North West - Funding 3005 Economy Forecasts and Reports 11252 New Projects 85 Western Australian Indicators and Forecasts 21, 4556 Strength 5085, 10818, 13194 Edith Cowan University - Microchip Test Facility 510 Education North West - Land Packages for Educational Institutions 3411 Teachers - Pay Rise 11707 Westfield Premier's Education Scholarship - Statement by Premier 3196 Electoral Legislation Legislation - Supreme Court Decision 1865, 2921, 2922, 2927 Overriding of State Laws 7023 Employment Regional Areas - Employment Initiatives 9232 Unemployment Rate 4743, 8788 Statistics 2814, 5364, 6644, 8724 Environment - Law Reform Program - Bennett, Mr Michael 688 Environmental Protection, Department of - Payne, Mr Roger - Termination of Employment 4742, 4743 Family Court - Petition 13485 328 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Fire and Emergency Services Bushfire Risk - Preparedness by State Government 2519 Firefighting Aircraft - Media Statement by Federal Minister 1046 North West - Expenditure on Firefighting Equipment 5180 State Security - Up-to-Date Plans 1864 Fisheries North West - Strategic Research Fund for the Marine Environment 4166 Swan River - Ban on Recreational Fishing 8787 Forests and Forestry Draft Forest Management Plan - Jarrah Volumes 209 Infinitree Plantation Program 8438 Jarrah - Allocation of 130 000 Cubic Metres 9420 Manjimup - Furniture Industry 8600, 9420 Old-growth Forest 104242, 11256, 11257 Sky Jetty Project - Government’s Failure to Deliver 9879 Timber Allocations - Announcement 8600 Tree Farming - Timber Volumes 3848 Woodchip Mill, Donnybrook 2522 Freedom of Information - Government’s Accountability Policy 12197 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board 8730 Fuel and Energy Electricity - Drought Areas - Reduction of Charges 3931 Epic Energy 7520, 7521 Fuel - Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection - Matter of Public Interest 923 United States Energy Market - Potential for WA Economy 13809 Gallop Labor Government - Performance in 2002 3925 Government Advertising Expenditure 5905, 6217 Open Letter to the Prime Minister from the Premier - Cost 10637 Radio Advertisements - Budget 7357 Government Contracts “Buy Local” Policy - Australian and New Zealand Government Agreement 13269 Construction Contracts 9230, 9418 Statistics 6221, 6222 Government Departments and Agencies Auditor General’s Report - Breaches of Privacy by Agencies 3926 Bad Debts Written Off 14441 Bunbury Tower - Lease Agreement 8274 Call Centres - Delays 9732 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3848 Chief Executive Officers - Names and Contracts 11955 Cleaning Services 6406, 13764 Club/Association Memberships 7393, 9426, 9773 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6233 Credit Cards 6219, 12631, 14501 Creditors 6207, 9752 Employment Contracts 6534 Fixed-term Contracts 3986; Statement 2160 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12881 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5160 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6236 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14973 Leave Liability 5152 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14365 Leschenault Estuary - Management 8270 Machinery of Government Taskforce - Reform Recommendations - Statement 3775 Management-initiated Redundancies 5179 North West - Staff and Programs 4658 Paid Parental Leave 1918, 4704 Pay Dispute - Government’s Policy 13808 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 329

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10871 Privacy Protection Legislation 3927 Privatisation - Government’s Position 12461, 12467, 12469 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employees 7772 Public Service Functional Review - Report 4155, 7749 Qantas Club or other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14398 Reform - Statement 4552 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14455 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7758 SARS Virus - Action Plan 7779 Staff Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14531 Redundancy Packages 694 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7118 Senior Executive Service Positions 5913 Sick Leave 12811 Unfilled and Acting Positions 3257 UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7118, 8857 Web Sites - Online Payments 10720 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 987 Government Media Office Budget and Staff 2996, 6036 Corporate Credit Cards 5904 Preparation of Material for Labor Backbenchers 8173 Strategic Communications and Community Liaison Units 8173 Government Vehicles Audible Security Alarms 13308 Home Garaging 6229 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 6228 Motorcycles - Statistics 6224 Privately Plated 6226 Graffiti Removal Programs - North West 9006 Grayden, Mr David - Condolence Motion 8785 Harmony Week, WA - Statement 5330 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14391 Health Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA Former Minister for Health’s 9660, 9665; Matter of Public Interest 9676 Select Committee 10418; Motion 10310 Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement 10417 Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11914 Council of Australian Governments Meeting - Agenda 10160, 10589 Crisis in System 10824; Matter of Public Interest 5095 Department Human Resource Standards Inquiry - Statement 10491 Thornton, Ms Jean Allegations 9661-9663, 9871, 9873 Letter to the Premier 10022, 10023, 10287, 10587 Response to Matters Raised in a Letter - Statement 9658 Health Administrative Review Committee - Daube, Mr Mike 7091 Life Education Preventive Health Program - Funding Cut 12757 North West 3982, 4667, 7099 Physical Activity Taskforce - Recommendations 4156 SARS Virus - Government Employees 7779 Smoke-free Enclosed Public Places - Review 7886, 7887 Heritage Duncraig House 512, 513 Raffles Hotel 6186 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Reinstatement to Notice Paper 275 330 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Hospitals Ambulances 5371, 10823 Capital Works Funding 11538 Country - Closure or Downgrading 4862, 4863 Derby Regional - Signs at Meeting - Comments by Minister for Health 2164 Eme rgency Departments - Upgrades 11538 Geraldton Regional - Redevelopment Contract 9416, 9417 Government’s Promise 5089 Moora District 13193; Matter of Public Interest 13205 Housing and Works, Department of Construction Contracts Policy 9230, 9418 Director General - Joyce, Mr Greg - Discussions with Premier 9418 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11755 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula - Industrial Action 3988 Delta Electricity and Access Economics Investment Monitor 7222 New Projects 85 North West Shelf Project - LNG Contract with China 5577; Statement 13, 1175, 1850 Projects in Western Australia - Strength 13194 Industrial Relations Adult Minimum Wage - Statement 8874 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Action on Burrup Peninsula 3988 Government Action on Disputes 13613, 13693, 13808 Government Employees - Pay Dispute 13808 Reforms - Level of Disputation 10817 Unions Deregistration of State-based Unions 87, 88 Government Grants 8857 Western Australian Labour Advisory Council - Establishment 7948 Information Commissioner - Wookey, Ms Darryl - Appointment in Acting Position 12197 Inquiries, Task Forces, Committees, Summits, Symposiums and Reviews 8225 Insurance Ministerial Summit 6182 No-fault Compensation - Report 12225 Public Liability 275, 1049, 3227, 5717; Statement 3195, 8436 Insurance Commission of WA - Land between 125 and 137 St Georges Tce, Perth 1779, 5510 Iraq Prime Minister’s Statement 3932 War - Support for Australian Defence Force Personnel Motion 5440 Premier’s Message 5716 Joint Standing Committee on the Anti-Corruption Commission - Government’s Response to Report No 2 - Tabling 5560 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3686 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Matter of Public Interest 12697 Lobbyists Anwyl, Ms Megan - Briefing to Cabinet 6677 Burke, Mr Brian Cabinet Directive 6644, 6645, 6678, 6679 Labor Party Preselections 6186 Meetings with Premier and Ministerial Staff 6789 Premier’s Instruction 5992, 6182 Privileged Access to Labor Government 5364 Racing and Wagering Western Australia - Board Composition 5363 Taxi Industry Decision 10162 Grill, Mr Julian Cabinet Directive 6645, 6678, 6679 Labor Party Preselections 6186 Meetings with Premier and Ministerial Staff 6789; Personal Explanation 6807 Premier’s Instruction 5992, 6182 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 331

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion 10511 Disclosure Standards 1046, 1047 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4866 Member for Bunbury - Electorate Office 5576, 5577 Member for Kingsley - Personal Explanation - Unparliamentary Language 2822 Member for Roleystone 12206 Travelling Entitlements - Review 4160 Vehicles - Audible Security Alarms 13308 Members of Parliament (Financial Interests) Act 1992 - Review 2575 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General - Documents Given to Minister for Health 602 Government Discussions 516 Minister for Health 1312, 1866 Reassessment by Special Interagency Unit 7029 Mining Bores - Water Users’ Charge 7883 Newcrest Mining Ltd - Expansion of Telfer Goldmine 5827 Ministers of the Crown Attorney General - Allegations of Criminal Behaviour by Cabinet Members - Motion 795 Credit Cards 6219 Former Minister for Health - Portfolio Change 10167 Lobbying - Premier’s Instruction 5992 Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection - Fuel - Matter of Public Interest 923 Minister for Health - Thornton, Ms Jean 9661-9663, 9871, 10022, 10023 Minister for Housing and Works Breach of Code of Conduct 599 Public Tender Process 9230, 9416, 9417 Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Parliamentary Refreshments 5831 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Parlia mentary Refreshments 5831 Minister for Racing and Gaming 599, 766, 8871 Breach of Code of Conduct 599, 766 Charter Flight Cost 8871 Minister for State Development - Failure to Attend In-Unison Conference 11906 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4570 Minister for Water Resources - Appointment 3573 Ministerial Code of Conduct 599, 5831 Mobile Phones, Use 4803 Parliamentary Secretaries Appointment - Statement by Premier 9855 Ministerial Code of Conduct - Expenditure 5833 Portfolio Changes - Statement 9855 Premier Comments on Privatisation 12316 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 6789 Move into Federal Politics 12060 Personal Explanations Correction to Answer to Question on Notice 9426 Meetings with Mr Julian Grill 6807 Employees, Level 9 or Higher -Department of the Premier and Cabinet 8159 Travel China - Statement 1850 China and Korea - Statement 10492 Japan and Korea - Statement 273 Malaysia - Statement 8931 United Arab Emirates 2162; Statement 2917 United States of America 12317 United States of America and Mexico - Statement 14873 Wiese, Ms Barbara 13811 332 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Ministers of the Crown (continued) Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Naming of Cabinet Ministers 4750, 5083, 5084 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14428 Corporate Credit Cards 7934, 9919, 12631 Memb erships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9780 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7118 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4809 Vehicles - Privately Plated 6231 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5141 Vehicles - Audible Security Alarms 13308 Mullewa - Aboriginal Children’s Behaviour - Resourcing 12460 National Competition Council Deregulation of Hours 8503, 12689 Proposed Penalty - Statement 12679 Threat to Payments 12061; Motion 12472 National Parks and Nature Reserves - Transfer to Aboriginal Groups 11257 Ningaloo Reef - “Future Directions” - Statement 11499 Nyandi Prison Redevelopment 5580; Motion 5604 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9857 Second Reading 9857, 12346 Consideration in Detail 12346-12349 Occupational Safety and Health - Smoke-free Enclosed Public Places - Review 7886, 7887 Owen, Mr Raymond Cecil - Condolence Motion - 4549 Parliament House - Centenary Celebrations 7516 Planning Commission - Raffles Hotel Site - Unlawful Actions 6186 Heathcote Site 512, 513 Mauds Landing Development Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd Government Announcement - Travel Costs of Ministerial Staff 12225 Legality of Decision 11700, 11779, 11902, 12202 Future Directions - Statement 11499 Ningaloo Advertising Campaign 9877 Rejection Decision - Motion 9905 Raffles Hotel Site - Heritage Council and WA Planning Commission 6186 Rockingham Planning and Development Task Force - Staff and Costs 7948 Scarborough Senior High School Site - Swimming Pool 8728 Police Community Operations - Motion 4768 IVIS Technology - Use 8517 Moora Visit - Brick Presentation to Premier 13193 Pay Dispute 10960; Statement 11497 Prosecutions - Reassessment by Special Interagency Unit 7029 Royal Commission - Mr Lewandowski’s Evidence 1866 Telephone Calls to Police Stations 8968 Terrorist Threat - Lack of Resources 3345, 3346 Warnbro Shooting Incident - Parole Conditions 10280 Ports and Harbours Broome - Upgrading 3495, 3496 Geraldton Port Authority - Mt Gibson Pty Ltd Project 508 North West - Boat Harbour Projects 9919 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the Hospitality Accounts 8271 Officers Classified at Level 9 or Higher 7261; Personal Explanation 8159 Policy Office - Corporate Credit Cards 5898 Staff, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 13271 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 333

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Presiding Officers - Deliberative Vote Legislative Assembly 2814 Legislative Council 2001, 2002, 2813; Matter of Public Interest 2014 Questions on Notice 10720, 12758; Statement 10816 Racing Bookmakers - Telephone and Internet Betting Limits 7269 Racing and Wagering Western Australia - Board Composition 5363 Railways - Southern Rail Link Budget Details 7358 Cost Es timates 7223 Premier’s Support 14877 Project Cost 20 South Perth Station 2815, 2924 Tabling of Cost Estimates 19 Regional Development “Buy Local” Policy - Australian and New Zealand Government Agreement 13269 Commissions Act - Review 3001 Government’s Policy 512, 4648-4655 Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13205 Regional Investment Fund - Statement 5822 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 Leave to Introduce 16 Introduction and First Reading 16 Research and Development Microchip Test Facility - Edith Cowan University 510 North West 4667 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7896 Second Reading 7896 Declaration as Urgent 7897, 7902 Consideration in Detail 7904-7912 Third Reading 7912 Council’s Amendments 8023, 8025, 8033-8046, 8048, 8050, 8051-8060 Retail Trading Hours - Deregulation Competition Policy Guidelines 5366, 5368 Federal Government Funding 9231, 9232 Government’s Position 5244 National Competition Council Threat 8503, 12689 National Competition Policy 8503 Premier’s Announcement 9083 Public Interest Test 8504 Small Business Development Corporation Submission 8309, 8310 Standing Orders Suspension 8453 Ripley, Mr Julian Further Information on Conviction 25, 86, 282 Letter from Mr Rupert Gerritsen 2926 Reassessment of Prosecution by Special Interagency Unit 7029 Roads Funding Cuts 7224 Road Safety Priority Planners 2003 - Number Printed and Distributed 5508 Roebuck Artefacts - Return to Western Australia 664 Royal Australian Navy - Patrol Boat Tender 766, 9417 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers Cabinet Ministers - Naming 4750, 5083, 5084 Government’s Pre-election Commitment 3494 Interim Report 5086; Statement 4551 Royal Commissions and Inquiries - Records 10638 Royal Flying Doctor Service - Fundraising Drive 13383 Safer WA - Transfer of Responsibility 4855 334 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Salinity Bilateral Agreement with the Commonwealth Government 7228, 7229 Collie Catchment Area - Water Quality 6485 Funding 6342, 6336 Infinitree Plantation Program 8438 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality Bilateral Agreement - Signing 2928 Funding 3231, 3232, 6184, 6808, 11536 Motion 6525 Statement 3342 SBS Radio - Grievance 6133 Schools Cleaning Contracts - Redeployment and Redundancy Packages 1762 Connection through Telstra - North West 3412 Science and Technology New Science Programs 276 Premier’s Science Awards - Statement 2516 Research in Western Australia - Statement 13603 Science Initiatives 10023 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Motion 10310 Small Business Development Corporation - Deregulation of Retail Trading Hours 8309, 8310 Sport and Recreation Junior Football 7779 North West Funding 3411 Multicultural Leisure and Sporting Programs 9006 Multi-sports Stadiums 3006 Programs 7947 Sporting Hall of Fame 3005 Walking Trails - Expenditure 5182 Rugby World Cup - Benefits 13524 St Andrews IDEA Project - Previous Government’s Involvement 2572 State Budget - Radio Advertisements 7357 State Finance Commonwealth Grants - Reduction 7022 Delta Electricity and Access Economics Investment Monitor 7222 Moody’s Investors Service Credit Rating 11533 State Accounts Figures 599 Taxes and Charges - Pre-election Promise 7221 State Government Insurance Office - Government’s Position 12467, 12469 Sustainability Strategy 11248, 11249, 11395, 11536, 11909; Statement 11375 Swan River 8787, 8004, 11398 Swan River Colony - One Hundred and Seventy-fifth Anniversary Celebrations 7516 Swan Village of Care - Nyandi Prison Redevelopment 5580; Motion 5604 Taxis - Burke, Mr Brian - Lobbying Activity 10162 Telecommunications - Network WA National Communications Fund Project - Statement 12680 Telstra - Electronic Dividend Payments 8869 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3355 Second Reading 3356 Tourism Downturn 8273, 9512 Portfolio - Elevation of Status - Matter of Public Interest 2827 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7514 Two Rocks Marina - Odour Problems 7113 United Arab Emirates - Trade Mission - Statement 4710 United States of America 3932, 13809 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper 275 Waste Water Treatment Plants - North West - Expenditure 5181 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 335

GALLOP, HON DR GEOFFREY IAN (continued) Water Corporation Advertising Campaign 8272 Computer Sciences Corporation - Information Technology Contract 2269 Water Resources Bores - Water Users’ Charge 7675, 7676, 7883 Collie Catchment Area - Water Quality 6485 Farm Dams - Management Charges 7883 Farms and Mines - Management Fee 7675, 7676 Goldfields - Report on Alternative Water Source 607 Ground Water - Regional Areas 3349, 3350 Harvey Dam - Use for Perth Water Supplies 2005 Minister for Water Resources - Appointment 3573 North West - Funding for Programs 5518 Pipeline - Kimberley-Perth 2716 Water Efficiency Incentives - Consumption Levels 8094 Water Forums 3417, 3418 Water Shortage - Dam Storage Levels 397 Water Symposium 3417; Statement 2653 Waterwise Rebate Program 4855 Wellington Dam - Cost-benefit Analysis of Sending Water to Metropolitan Area 6812 Yarragadee Aquifer - South West Water Extraction 8444, 8445 Western Power Disaggregation - Electricity Prices 12760 Managing Director - Conditions of Employment 10965, 11109 Privatisation 12759 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Petition 7207 Youth Curfew for Juveniles in Northbridge - Youth Affairs Council Legal Challenge 9872 Halls Creek and South Hedland 6680, 6681 North West - Youth-related Crime and Antisocial Behaviour Programs 8272

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS, Parliamentary Secretary, Planning and Infrastructure (to 27 June); Education (to 14 January); Education and Training (from 14 January); Sport and Recreation (to 27 June); Indigenous Affairs (to 27 June) (North Metropolitan) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Cultural Materials Committee 4945, 5659, 6603, 6604 Aboriginal Heritage Act 4945, 5438, 6085, 6457, 7179, 7450 Aboriginal Heritage Sites Register - Broome - Registration of Names 5957 Aboriginal Housing Development Authority - Funds Allocated 4937 Affirmative Action on Public Employment - Legislation 3612 “Bringing them Home” Report - Implementation of Recommendations 9193, 9648 Broome - Heritage Consultants 8423 Bungalbin, Windarling, Boondine Hill and Mt Jackson - Sites of Cultural Significance 5317 Child Sexual Abuse - Statistics on Communities 8566, 8679 Council of Aboriginal Elders - Abolition 9633 Government Programs 7841, 7842 Newton Moore Senior High - Absentee Rates 10362 Ngaanyatjarra Council (Aboriginal Corporation) College - Funding 5974 Ngaanyatjarra Lands School 5973 Ngalia People - Yakabindie Nickel Project 6604 Ninga Mia Village - Relocation 4052, 4053, 4363 Reserve 24574 4064, 6331, 7838, 8430, 9377 Rock Art 7847, 9080 Sites of Significance Cities of Perth and South Perth 7478 Excavation Applications 7450 Perth Urban Rail Development 7647, 8362, 9192 Protection 6085, 6457, 7019 Swan Valley Nyungah Community 4945, 4946 336 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 First Reading 3057 Second Reading 3057 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Legislation Committee 4230 Second Reading 4480 Committee 4504-4523 Third Reading 4524 Draft Statutes 3733 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14796 Agriculture Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd - Impact of Changes to Transport Legislation 2870 Livestock Transport - Fatigue Management Regulations 6459, 7477 Overwidth Loads of Hay and Straw - Restrictions on Travel 5051 Pastoral Industry Working Groups 2481 Arts and Culture Western Australian Academy of Performing Arts 2914, 2915 Western Australian Conservatorium of Music - Reorganisation 2914 Western Australian Institute of Music - Reorganisation 2914 Asymptote Consulting - Tabled Paper 5312 Australian Wildlife Conservancy - Ningaloo Development Briefing 5815, 5816, 6286 Beck, Mr Tinsley Manning - Petition for Relief - Motion 4952 Boat Moorings - South of Bunbury - Registration Regulations 3867 Boxing Control Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6319 Carnarvon - Surge Wall Project 163 Colleges of TAFE Eastern Pilbara - Accounting Controls 10367 Kimberley - Budgeted Student Contact Hours 14045 Pilbara - Hedland Campus - Down-sizing 14870, 14871 Staff - Teaching of Schoolchildren 10365 Training and Assessment - Competency Based System 14714 West Coast College of TAFE - Carine Campus - Sale 7822 Community Development Child Abuse - Aboriginal Communities 8566, 8679 Early Childhood - National Consultation Document - WA Submission 13145, 13148 Coral Bay - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd - Agreement with Government 1675 Crime - Northbridge Curfew for Juveniles - Crisis Care Unit 10923 Drivers Licences Funding for Young People to Learn to Drive 8411 Graduated Driver Training and Licensing System 1736, 7175, 9055 Waiting Time for Practical Test 8685 Drugs Cannabis - Student Information 7449 School Education Program - Funding 13912 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Taxi and Bus Drivers 7178 East Perth Power Station Site 1167-1169 Education Amity House, Albany - Redevelopment 5536, 7477 Central Reserve Area - Costs 13142 Children with Special Needs - Educational Aides 3439 Curriculum Council - Amalgamation with Department of Education and Training 5411 Department Amalgamation with Department of Training 5053 Buy Local Policy 1258 Central Office Structure - Reform 594 Early Childhood Education - Training and Experience of Personnel 246 Early Development Survey - Joondalup, West Coast and Swan 14195, 14802 Local Learning and Employment Partnership Program - Joondalup Pilot Project 6458 New Upper School Courses - Funding and Professional Development 3178, 3615 Ngaanyatjarra Council (Aboriginal Corporation) College - Funding 5974 Pilot Course Program - Changes 8678 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 337

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Education (continued) Public Education Endowment Trust - Grant Applications 14044 Robson Report - Recommendations 164, 594 Teachers 2346, 3178, 5775, 9026, 10923, 14717, 14798 Tertiary Entrance Examination - Statistics 14838 Vacswim Program - Cost and Number Enrolled 14620 Year 11 and 12 Courses 10112 Employment and Training Local Learning and Employment Partnership Program - Joondalup Pilot Program 6458 Training - Department - Amalgamation with Department of Education 5053 Environment Gnangara Land Use and Water Management Strategy - Implementation 1844 Kwinana - Air Quality Buffer - Review 1738 Spoil Bank, Port Hedland - Vehicle Access 3470 Forests and Forestry Timber Industry Worker Assistance Package - Funding 3611 Woodchip Mill - Donnybrook 41, 1269 Fuel and Energy Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline - Acquisition of State Corridor Rights 4448 International Hydrogen Conference - Broome - Funding 6328 Geraldton Regional Hospital - Medical Services Agreement 14193 Government Contracts 1258, 13482 Government Departments and Agencies Aborigines Affirmative Action on Employment - Legislation 3612 Programs 7841, 7842 Budget Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 10153 Court Action or Litigation 7196, 7197, 7460 Functional Review Taskforce Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 10151 Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 13481 Register of Intellectual Property 5412, 6115, 6116, 7458, 7459 Health Asbestos - Kingstown Barracks, Rottnest Island 1008 Australia New Zealand Food Standards System - Introduction 13470 Community Child Health Team - Full-time Equivalents 13593 Early Development Survey - Joondalup, West Coast and Swan 14195 Iatrogenic Illnesses and Deaths 14775 Medical Practitioners - Spinal Manipulation - Qualifications 14198 Men’s Health - Funding in Rural Areas 13592 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Taxi and Bus Drivers 7178 Higher Education Bill 2003 First Reading 9045 Second Reading 9045 Housing - Aboriginal Housing Development Authority - Funds Allocated 4937 Immigration - Port Hedland Detention Centre - Visit by Girls from Mandurah Catholic College 14771 Indigenous Affairs, Department of Broome - Heritage Consultants 6459, 7312 Bunbury Office - Closure 7310 Goldfields Office - Regional Manager 4024 Kalgoorlie Office - Regional Manager 4341 Regional Offices - Closure 6580 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula - Rock Art - Legislative Protection 7847 Kwinana - Air Quality Buffer - Review 1738 Mungari Industrial Estate 4931 Joint Standing Committee on the Anti-Corruption Commission - Annual Report 2001-02 4318 Land Certificate of Title Volume 1138, Folio 74 - Temopolous Family 1839 Clearing - Statistics 8679, 8688 Crossing Falls - Land Development for Lifestyle Lots 1452 Lots 246 and 257 Lights Road, Denmark - Status 39 338 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Land Administration, Department of 1838, 2604, 8412; Statement 3010 LandCorp - Licensed Real Estate Agents 9058 Local Government Aboriginal Sites 7478 Rockingham City Council 4200 Main Roads Western Australia Contract Superintendents 1740 Employees - Complaints by Member for Armadale 4201 Roadside Tree Removal Policy 8408 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Boundary Fence 5314 Mining Kalgoorlie Consolidated Gold Mines Pty Ltd Ninga Mia Village 4052, 4053, 4363 Realignment of Eastern Bypass Road 4301, 4546 Rehabilitation of Tenements 4361 Lease No 26/261 4064, 6331, 7838, 8430, 9377 Lease No 36/7 - Aboriginal Heritage Site 7838, 9062 Mt Percy Open Pits - Relocation of Railway Line 4363 Portman Iron Ore Ltd - Koolyanobbing Mine - Expansion 5317, 5659 Williamstown - Rezoning of Land 1675 Yakabindie Nickel Project 4530, 6603, 6604 Ministers of the Crown Minister for Education and Training - Motion 6071 Office Location and Refurbishment - Staff 2907, 3633 Parliamentary Secretary - Visit to China - Statement 2108 Motor Bike Licensing - Restriction of Times 8411 Ningaloo Reef - Ningaloo Station - Briefing on Tourist Accommodation 5815, 5816, 6286 Parks and Reserves Karijini National Park 4366, 9080 Neerabup National Park 6299, 8398, 8414, 8578, 8579 Pastoral Leases Aboriginal Living Areas - Establishment 6600 Bulka - Excision of Land 6600 Excisions 6600, 6601, 6997 Land Management Conditions 4944 Meeting Pastoral Working Groups - Pastoralists and Graziers Association 6601 Mt Barnett Station 4024 Pastoral Industry Working Groups 2481 Reorganisation 3437; Statement 3270 Windimurra - Zadow, Mr Dale 5532, 8398 Working Groups - Members and Meetings 6602 Personal Explanations Commonwealth Road Funding 6436 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment No 1055/33 - Fremantle Eastern Bypass 2861 Planning Beaches - South Metropolitan Area - Impact of Population Growth 3470 Burns Beach Lot 2 8412, 8414, 6082, 7837 Bushplan-Bush Forever 1839, 6327 Certificate of Title Volume 1138, Folio 74 - Temopolous Family 1839 Commission - Membership 7453, 7461 Egerton Estate, Ellenbrook - Boundary Extension 1966 Fremantle-Rockingham Controlled Access Highway - Beeliar Regional Park, Cockburn 42 Hampton Location 135, Kalgoorlie - Granting of Freehold Title 4299 Heathcote Site 2152, 4202, 4257, 4343, 6325 Hope Valley-Wattleup Redevelopment 5958, 7313 Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Freehold Lots 2154 Kununurra - Industrial Land and Residential Lots 1452 Land in Certificate of Title Volume 1138 - Purchase by WA Planning Commission 348 Leeuwin-Naturaliste Statement of Planning Policy - Smiths Beach 2601 Lot 1409 Huntingdale Road, Huntingdale - Rezoning 1453 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 339

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Planning (continued) Lot 502 Sudlow and Phoenix Roads, Bibra Lake - Subdivision 2910 Lots 293 to 296 Eedle Terrace, Bridgetown 3438 Margaret River - WA Planning Commission’s Inquiry by Design 36 Mauds Landing Development - Meetings 4398 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 1138 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments No 5 - South East District Omnibus - Statement 1405 No 1016/33 - Western Suburbs Omnibus Amendment No 3 - Statement 2109 No 1019/33 - Townsites in Stoneville and Parkerv ille - Disallowance 5799; Statement 2590 No 1028/33 - South East Districts Omnibus (No 5) - Disallowance 4461 No 1037/33 - North West Districts Omnibus Amendment No 5 - Statement 2110 No 1038/33 - Thomsons Lake Regional Centre - Statement 1406 No 1039/33 - Victoria Quay, Port of Fremantle - Statement 33 No 1040/33 - Tapper Road, Banjup - Statement 32 No 1041/33 - South West Districts Omnibus (No 5) - Statement 32 No 1054/33 - Western Power Depot, Belmont - Statement 5761 No 1055/33 - Fremantle Eastern Bypass 5055; Personal Explanation 2861; Statement 2851 No 992/33 - Lot 2 Burns Beach 1533 Opposition 6325 Southern Rail Link 1415, 1805 Mindarie Marina - Zoning 2249 Nicholson Road and Thornlie Road Railway Station Precincts - Study of Land Use and Transport Integration 464 Peel Region Scheme - Disallowance 5549 Port Catherine Project 2153, 8396, 9560 Port Hedland - Coastal Management Plan 2911 Public Open Space - New Residential Developments 1169 Pyrton Site - Development Proposals 8363 Railway Reserves - Reclassification 5969 Separation Point Marine Precinct 8577, 9634 South Beach Urban Development, Cockburn-Fremantle 8413; Landfill 8576 South West Metropolitan Corridor - Recreational Needs 7458 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Zoning 466 Sussex Locations and Lots 14 and 15 Margaret River - Rezoning 3177 Woodman Point-South Fremantle Coastline - Zoning 3633 Planning and Infrastructure, Department for - International Hydrogen Conference, Broome 6328 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 Committee 253-268, 361-372, 457-460, 470 Third Reading 470 Pollution Amcor Contaminated Site, Bibra Lake 1951 Port Coogee - Remediation of Contamination 9080 Port Kennedy Development Project Agreement Act - Tabling of Variations 1968 Deed of Covenant 4341 Facilities, Consultation and Residential Housing 6329 Funding and Public Consultation 2151 Ownership of Freehold Lots 1968 Priority Public Works 9560 Ports and Harbours Broome 6586, 8400, 8684, 8688 Geraldton 1005, 2156, 9195 Port Hedland - Spoil Bank - Vehicle Access 3470 Wyndham 162, 1452 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 7274 Committee 7277-7286 Recommittal 7828 Third Reading 7828 Correction to Second Reading Speech - Statement 6944 340 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Questions on Notice - Answers 1956, 2875, 3030, 4345, 5961, 6086, 6305, 6587, 7180, 7315, 7453 Questions without Notice - Answers 4026 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 First Reading 1442 Second Reading 1442 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 3053 Second Reading 3310 Committee 3318-3332 Third Reading 3333 Railways Discontinuance Legislation - Delay in Introduction 3440 Freight Network Review - Fremantle Eastern Bypass 36 Fremantle - Reduction of Service 4939 Loopline Tourist Railway, Boulder-Kalgoorlie - Concept Plan - Tabling 4360 Narrows Rail Link - Infrastructure Costs 4959 Nicholson Road and Thornlie Road Railway Station Precincts - Study of Land Use and Transport Integration 464 Northern Suburbs Rail Service - Clarkson Extension 4239, 4359 Perth Urban Rail Development Aboriginal Sites 7647, 8362 Cost 1416 Tabled Paper Nos 468 and 841 Author 5318, 5771 Lawrence, Dr Peter 6298, 6455 Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Motion 5528, 5936, 6433 Reserves - Reclassification under MRS 5969 Southern Rail Link Aboriginal Heritage Sites 8673, 9192 Annual Cost of Operation 7645 Capital Costs and Items of Expenditure 2226, 3734, 4358 Clifton Coney Stevens (WA) Pty Ltd 7821, 8569 Cost 1659, 2348, 4297 Interpeak Lay-off 9373 Journey Times 5955 Kwinana Freeway Route - Impact of Construction 6095 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1415, 1805 Modelling of Patronage Forecasts 6580; Tabling of Document 5779 Murdoch to CBD Bus Service 4297 Patronage Forecasts 1416; Tabling of Paper 3179 Rockingham High-tech Local Transit System 1952 Soil Testing 5410 Statement 31 Tabled Paper No 785 - Asymptote Consulting 5312 Traffic Delays on Roads Caused by Construction 5413 Travel Time Saving 1416 Wentworth Hotel - Closure 4255 William Street Tunnel - Risk Analysis 4446, 6096, 7651 WA Government Railways Commission - Manjimup and Donnybrook Subdivisions 3634 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 First Reading 3899 Second Reading 3899, 6431, 6547 Committee 6550-6554 Third Reading 6554 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 First Reading 7949 Second Reading 7967, 7978 Amendments to be Put Before Sessional Order Invoked 7978 Committee 7979, 7986, 7988, 7990 Third Reading 7990 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 341

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Roads Brookton Highway - Corrigin-Hyden Section 4254 Bussell Highway, Cowaramup - Cattle Crossing 3617 Busselton Bypass and Strelly Street Intersection - Traffic Lights 3727 Causeway - Vehicle Numbers 2913 Certificate of Title Volume 1138, Folio 74 - Purchase by WA Planning Commission 348 Fremantle-Rockingham Controlled Access Highway - Beeliar Regional Park, Cockburn 42 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Community Newspaper Advertisements 3290, 3614, 4533 Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme 8686, 8687, 8689, 8690 High Street, Fremantle - Widening 4027, 4343 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment No 1055/33 5055 Private Properties or Residences Acquired 4449 Select Committee - Amendment to Motion 2221, 2232, 2317, 2474 Submission Period - Extension 4029 Funding - Commonwealth - Personal Explanation 6436 Gibbs Street, Boyup Brook - Road Alignment 7475 Goldfields Highway - Wiluna-Meekatharra 8568 Hepburn Avenue - Extension 1007 High Street, Fremantle2229, 3176, 4027, 4343 High, Wide-load Corridors 1803, 1840, 4025 Hodges Drive-Karrinyup Road - Traffic Congestion 7461 Hospital Road - Upgrading 6606 Indian Ocean Drive 7825, 8568 Kalgoorlie Eastern Bypass Road - Realignment 4301, 4546 Kwinana Freeway - Railway Construction 6095 Lake Raeside Crossing Upgrade - Funding 7651 Lennard Road Easement, Gingin - Paving 8673 Lime Sands Route 2 - Cost of Consultation Process 1740 Meekatharra - Bypass Road 5409 Narrogin-Wagin Link Road - Completion 5534 Native Vegetation Cleared for Road Works 8412 Northbridge Tunnel - Vehicle Numbers 2913 Orrong Road - Traffic Volume 3875, 4358 Peel Deviation - N1.5 and N3 Routes 4252, 4339 Regional Road Groups - Funding 5050; Urgency Motion 5400 Riverside Drive - Vehicle Numbers 2913 Roe Highway Stage 7 - Local Impact Committee 4365 Roe Highway Stage 8 4449, 4959 Roe Highway Stages 4 to 8 - Cost 4027 Shepperton Road - Causeway - Victoria Park - Vehicles 8413 South Western Highway - Shelving of Upgrade 1259 Stephenson Highway Road Reserves 3612, 3871, 4935 Tonkin Highway Extension - Tenders 7820 Wellington Street - Vehicles 2913 Yampire Gorge Road - Closure 4366 Rottnest Island - Kingstown Barracks - Asbestos Roofing 1008 Schools Armadale Primary - Structural Faults 3290 Breakfast Clubs 9557 Bus Services 4029, 4447, 4531, 7643, 7821, 8673, Carine Senior High - Bullying 4397 Carnarvon - New Private School 3173 Class Sizes 1660 Coolbellup - Closure of Primary Schools 10797 Craigie Senior High - Sale 7822 Dandaragan Primary 2871, 3178, 3731, 4340, 12038 Drug Education Program - Funding 13912 Drug Information Program - Modification 7449 Duncraig Primary - Sale of Land 14049 342 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Schools (continued) Enrolments - Statistics 14771 Esperance Senior High - Funding 6083 Expenditure 592 Fees - Sanctions on Students for Non-payment 4939 Flinders Park Primary, Albany - Septic Tank Overflow 6081 Fremantle Primary - Covered Assembly Area 5409 Funding - Average Per Student Funding 14606 Hand Washing that Includes the Use of Soap - WorkSafe Guidance Notes 14838 Islamic 3730, 5810 Kindergartens 3025, 14723 Kingstown Barracks, Rottnest Island - Asbestos Roofing 1008 Kununurra Primary - Deterioration of Buildings 6582 Lockridge Senior High - Fees - Access to School Ball 7643, 9078 Mandurah Catholic College - Visit by Girls to Port Hedland Detention Centre 14771 Margaret River Senior High 4063, 8673, 9567 Melville Senior High - Sale 4259 Melville Primary - Sale 4259 Newton Moore Senior High - Aboriginal Children 3610, 10362, 14635 Ngaanyatjarra Lands School 5973 Preprimaries - Class Sizes 2229, 2763 Primary Class Sizes 2229, 2763 Four-year-olds 2871, 3178, 3731, 4340 Pupil-free Days - Death of 12-year-old in High Speed Vehicle Collision 10365 Secret Harbour Middle - Construction 7479 South Fremantle Senior High - Music Centre Funding 351, 7179 South Hedland Primary - Roof and Ceiling Repairs 7476 St Cecilia’s Catholic School, Port Hedland - Closure 2870 Staff - Inappropriate Behaviour or Relationships with Children 14642, 14802 Wattleup Primary - Student Numbers 10798 Select Committee into the Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Amendment to Motion 2221, 2232, 2317, 2474 Sewerage - Flinders Park Primary School, Albany 6081 Sport and Recreation “De-dorking” Sport and Recreation Organisations 2225 Noalimba Recreation Camp - Sale 38 Speedway Commission, Western Australian - Statutory Authority 5410 Water Polo - State Under 20s Team 4453 State Budget - Recurrent Expenditure and Capital Works Programs 6994, 6995 Taxis Country Taxi Plates - Annual Renewable Licence 3173 Fares - CPI Increase 3173 Northern Territory - Deregulation 6080 Restructuring of Industry 3291 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Maximum Amount for Drivers 7178 The West Australian - Kununurra Delivery 1452 Tonkin, Premier John - Infrastructure and Landmarks - Naming 4546 Transfer of Land Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 5417 Committee 5418-5421 Third Reading 5421 Transport Air Intrastate Air Services - Review 3874 Qantas Air Services - Freight Capacity into the North of Western Australia 4340 Skywest Airlines Pty Ltd Fokker F100 Jet 4446, 4525 Laverton Air Service 5414 Bicycles - Medical Exemptions for the Wearing of Helmets 2153 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 343

GIFFARD, HON GRAHAM THOMAS (continued) Transport (continued) Buses Drivers Cannabis Use 7481 Tetrahydrocannabinol 7178 Gas Fuelled and Fuel Cell Trials 6464 Kwinana Freeway Bus Service - Passenger Numbers 1838 Murdoch to CBD Bus Service 4297 School Bus Services Augusta Students - Fare Concessions 8673, 9567 Busselton-Yallingup Steiner School Bus Route - Replacement Bus 4447 Composite Rate Model 4029 Fare Concessions for Country Students 7821 Garaging Allowance 7643 Marble Bar 4531 Cycleways Country Areas 468 East Perth-Maylands 165, 346, 1740, 2151 Perth City - Bicycle Network 468, 8414 Cyclists - Number and Accidents 2250 Department 1995 Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 1170 Winzer Mr Neil - Termination Package 1954 Heavy Haulage Transport Units - Audits 2482 Livestock - Fatigue Management Regulations 6459, 7477 Motor Bike Licensing - Restriction of Times 8411 Narrogin - Road Train Traffic 5534 Nullarbor Plain - Road-rail Service 346 Oversize Permits 2762 Overwidth Loads of Hay and Straw - Restrictions on Travel 5051 Rockingham Central City Transit Service - Steering Committee 3175 South Metropolitan Region - Local Impacts Committee 4399 Transperth - Cannabis Policy for Bus Drivers 7481 TravelSmart 2249, 5970, 9563 University of Western Australia - Hackett, Mr Winthrop - Bequest 1738 Waste Disposal - Mungari Industrial Estate - Waste-to-energy Plant 4931 Water Resources Gnangara Land Use and Water Management Strategy 1844, 6304 Yarragadee Aquifer - Testing 5659, 7324 Wentworth Hotel - Closure for Construction of Southern Rail Link 4255 Western Australian Land Authority Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 9048 Second Reading 9048 WorkSafe Western Australia - Hand Washing 14838

GRAHAM, MR LARRY (Pilbara) (Ind) Aborigines - North West Child Abuse and Family Violence Programs 9747 Family Counselling 4166 Family Violence Prevention Support Service 3570 Housing 2717 Address-in-Reply Motion Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 318-321 Kyoto Protocol 320, 321 Local Government 318 Resource Development and Royalties 318, 319 Amendment to Motion - Water Shortages 216 Agriculture - North West 3410, 3570, 5513 Alberta, Canada 1586, 1587 344 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRAHAM, MR LARRY (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading Asbestos and Asbestos-related diseases 4116-4120 Wittenoom Tragedy 4116, 4119, 4120 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Agreement Acts 7727-7730 Budget - Pilbara 7724, 7725 Disability Housing 7725 Infrastructure 7727, 7729 Royalties 7726, 7728, 7729 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7724 Arts and Culture North West - Building Programs 5515 Western Australian Symphony Orchestra - Year of the Outback Regional Tour 7782 Australian Labor Party - Deregulation of Trading Hours - Policy 8503 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Second Reading 11932 Consideration in Detail 12050, 12051, 12055-12060, 12070, 12074-12077, 12178-12189, 12193-12195, 12207-12217 Standing Orders Suspension 12217 Third Reading 12217, 12221 Bills, Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper 72 Blue Light Events - North West 2720 Cabinet - Regional Subcommittee Meetings 4656, 4657 Centenary of Federation - Funding - North West 2719 College of TAFE, Pilbara - Amalgamation 12812-12815 Community Development Children in Need of Care and Protection 8141, 8143 CREATE Foundation Funding - North West 4167 Department Halls Creek 7597, 8144 South Hedland 7597, 8140 Grandparents as Primary Carers - Assistance in North West 5514 North West Aboriginal Family Counselling 4166 Caring for the Carers Program 9476 Child and Family Sexual Abuse Counselling 8114 Family Strength Programs 4670, 4672, 8521 Homelessness and Social Exclusion Programs 5514 Men’s Emergency Accommodation Service 5395 Social Exclusion Programs 8867 Community Development and Justice Standing Committee - 2001-02 Annual Report 1690 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3107 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1194 Crime Halls Creek and South Hedland 6680, 6681 North West 3006, 3416, 8272 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Standing Orders Suspension 6155 Disability Services North West 3414, 6783, 6784, 7598, 8151 Post-school Options Program - Funding in North West 2848 Read, Ms Annette - Petition 10171 Stewart, Ms Amanda - Petition 4813 Domestic Violence - North West 3570, 4167 Drugs - Programs in the North West 3005, 3268, 6785, 6787, 8520 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5388-5391 Education Director General 2846, 2847 Land Packages for Educational Institutions 3411 Literacy and Numeracy Programs - Expenditure in North West 3004 Teachers - North West 2584, 3004 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 345

GRAHAM, MR LARRY (continued) Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee 13708, 13709 Amendment to Motion 13710 Employment and Training - North West 3413, 3414 Environment - Programs in the North West 4670, 5182 Fire and Emergency Services Levy - Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion 10179 North West - Funding 2587, 5180, 5756 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Referral to Community Development and Justice Standing Committee 2261 Consideration in Detail 2369, 2375, 2379, 2380 Fisheries - North West - Funding and Programs 3411, 3415, 4166 Fuel and Energy - Fuel Prices - Maximum Wholesale Price System 3000 Government Departments and Agencies Call Centres - Programs in North West 5178 North West - Staff and Programs 2577, 2579, 2713, 2714, 2844, 3002, 3405, 3409, 3568, 3981, 4160, 4163, 4658 Travel Expenditure 2575, 2576 Graffiti Removal Programs - North West 9006 Health Crisis in System - Matter of Public Interest 5099 Dental - North West 3265, 3266 East Pilbara Health Service - Budget Allocation 3264 North West Capital Works Programs 6786, 7099 Child Health Nurses - Enhanced Home Visiting Program 9476 Dialysis Units 6783 Funding 3267, 4667, 7099 Medical Equipment Funding 3982 Medical Professionals - Packages 3263 Mental Health Services for Children 6235 Nullagine Health Clinic - Construction of Replacement 4179 Patient Assisted Travel Scheme 3264, 3265 Pilbara 3262; 4178 Regional Areas - Medical Professionals - Packages 3263 Telehealth Initiatives - Budget 4176 Telemedicine Programs - Nature, Location and Cost 4175 Heritage - North West - History Projects - Funding 9477 Hospitals Halls Creek - Replacement 4178 Moora District - Matter of Public Interest 13207 North West Day Surgery Units 6786 Equipment Programs 6787 Expenditure on Improvements 6785 Expenditure on Maternity Facilities 6783 Improvement Works Programs 6785, 6786 Positron Emission Tomography Scanners 7947 Specialist Medical Services 4692, 4693 Upgrading 6782 Housing Homelessness - North West Programs 5514, 8867 Landstart Development Division - Joint Venture Developments in North West 5515 New Living Program - North West 2718, 5284 North West Aborigines 2717 Aborigines and Torres Strait Islander People 8152 Country Housing Authority Programs 8151 Funding 8123, 8273 Seniors 6036, 6037 Smoke Alarms Program 2718 346 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRAHAM, MR LARRY (continued) Housing (continued) North West (continued) Supported Housing Assistance Program 5396 Urban Renewal Programs 2720 Woodrise Estate, Albany - Joint Venture Developments in North West 5515 Industrial Development Agreement Acts - Variations Approved, Rejected, Amended or Withdrawn 14528 HIsmelt Corporation Pty Ltd - Government Assistance 5906, 9304, 9305 North West - Land Acquisition for Industry 4668 Information Technology - Computer Literacy - North West - Funding 3983 Kings Park - Western Power Parkland - Funding 8343 Land - North West - Purchases 4669 LandCorp - North West 4668, 4669 Libraries - Programs in North West 3416 Local Government - North West 2717, 2719, 2721, 7781 Magistrates Court, Port Hedland - Transfer to Kalgoorlie 4860 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1194 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion 10525; Amendment to Motion 10523 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4872; Standing Orders Suspension - Amendment to Motion 4866 Meetings with Director General of Education 2846, 2847 Travelling Entitlements - Review 4160 Members of Parliament (Financial Interests) Act 1992 - Review 2575 Mid West Region - Projects - Funding 9140 Mining Iron Ore (Hamersley Range) Agreement - Secondary Processing Obligations 9304 Rio Tinto Exploration Pty Ltd - Iron Ore Processing 5908, 5909 Minister for Community Development - North West Visits 9470 Museums - North West - Funding 5514, 5515 National Competition Council - Deregulation of Hours 8503 Planning - North West Groyne Construction Programs 8123 Marina Programs 8113 Navigational Aids and Nautical Charts - Funding 8123 River Foreshore Development Programs 7265, 8114 Police Stations - Officer Numbers 3709 Ports and Harbours - North West 4668, 4670, 9919, 10419 Public Accounts Committee - Matter of Privilege - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1194 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Standing Orders Suspension 1332 Railways North West 4668, 9748 Southern Rail Link - Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 1601, 1602 Regional Development Commissions Act 1789, 2054, 2055, 2312, 3001, 3563 Gascoyne Region 4655, 4685, 4686 Goldfields-Esperance - Government Policy 4652 Government’s Policy 3573, 4648 Government Services 3988, 3989 Great Southern 4651, 4684, 4685 Kimberley 4649, 4650, 4685, 4686 Mid West Region 4652, 4653, 4684, 4685 North West 5909, 6400, 6401, 8150, 8151, 8268, 9749 Peel Region 4654, 4684, 4685 Pilbara 4649, 4685, 4686 Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13207 Regional Collocation Scheme - North West 2719, 2721 South West 4650, 4651, 4684, 4685 Wheatbelt Region 4653, 4654, 4684, 4685 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4139 Research and Development - North West 4667 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 347

GRAHAM, MR LARRY (continued) Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours 8503, 8504 Roads - North West Bridge Refurbishment 8866 Funding 4671 Passenger Transport Programs 4668 Programs 8111, 8113 Sealing Programs 8868 Upgrading Programs 8866, 9748 Salinity - North West - Funding for Programs 7099 Schools - North West Administration Area Upgrades 9747 Automatic Irrigation Programs 9474 Capital Works Program 5629 Chaplaincy Program 7940 Connection through Telstra 3412 Construction Projects 9746 Covered Assembly Program 5628 Expenditure 5511 Facilities for Students with Intellectual Disabilities 5628 Improvement Program 2584 Information and Communications Technology Programs 5630 Information Technology Plan 2586 Libraries - Expenditure 5630 Maintenance Programs 9475 New Facilities 5517 Operation Refresh Program 9474 Performing Arts Programs 5512 Refurbishment Programs 5517 Upgrading Programs 5517 Science and Technology - Innovation Fund Projects - North West 3413 Seniors - North West 3265, 3414, 5514, 6036, 6037 Sewerage - North West Infill Sewerage Program 5178 Waste Water Treatment Plants - Expenditure 5181 Sport and Recreation Avon Descent - Funding 2848 Country Sport Enrichment Scheme 5512 Events in the North West - Funding 2848 North West Country Sport Enrichment Scheme 5512 Funding 2847, 3411, 9474 Multicultural Leisure and Sporting Programs 9006 Multi-sports Stadiums 3006 Programs 7947 Safety Standards in Outdoor Recreational Industry 9476 Sporting Hall of Fame 3005 Sporting Redevelopment Programs 5629 State Sporting Associations Grants 3005 Trailswest 2587 Walking Trails - Expenditure 5182 State Finance - Oil and Gas Royalties - State-operated Investment Fund 1586 Telecommunications- North West 3571, 3572 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3545 Tourism - North West - Funding of Programs 6406, 6540 Transport - North West 4657, 4668, 4671, 5179, 8112, 8269, 8339 University, Murdoch - Pilbara - Study Funding 8142 Volunteering WA - Student Community Involvement Program - North West 4168 Waste Disposal - Waste Management and Recycling Fund - North West 3007 Water Resources- North West 2419, 2420, 2849, 5518, 7781 Western Power - Kings Park Parkland - Funding 8343 Women’s Interests - Women’s Refuge Group Funding - North West 4167 348 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRAHAM, MR LARRY (continued) Year of the Outback - Cost 4706 Youth - North West Assistance Programs for Young People Leaving Home 5513 Crime and Antisocial Behaviour Programs 8272 Detoxification Programs 3268, 6787 Grants Western Australia - Expenditure in North West 2848 Halls Creek and South Hedland 6680, 6681 Holiday Programs 8867

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID, LLB, Minister for Racing and Gaming; Government Enterprises; Goldfields-Esperance (to 27 June); Housing and Works (from 27 June); Land Information (from 27 June) (East Metropolitan) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Health, Office of - Mr Edward Shane Houston 9356 Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council - Construction Program 12005 Aboriginal Justice Council.4937, 10150 Aboriginal Visitors Scheme in Prisons 712, 4937 Cheeditha Community 9022 Government Programs 7014, 7015, 7017, 7509, 7842 Homelessness 1263, 2157 Housing - Construction Program 12005 Road Safety Directions for Aboriginal Road Users Document 6302 Rock Art - Murujuga Rock Art Estate - Tabling of Federal Minister’s Letter 6584 Tjalka Boorda Aboriginal Community - Sewage Treatment Ponds 5960 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 First Reading 6596 Second Reading 6596, 12645 Instruction to Committee 12651 Committee 12653, 12920, 12921, 12928-12951, 12968-12981 Third Reading 13088 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 First Reading 9159 Second Reading 9159 Cognate Debate 13104 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13138 Committee 13154 Instruction to the Committee 13155 Committee 13155-13163 Report 13163 Third Reading 13163 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 First Reading 2341 Second Reading 2341 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 Second Reading 6308 Committee 6309-6313 Third Reading 6314, 6316 Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 - First Reading 10327 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14789, 14793-14795 Adjournments of the House - Special 2350, 6589 Agriculture Drought Assistance - Payroll Tax Reductions and Stamp Duty Exemptions 2868 Elevated Work Platforms - Legislation 7824 Herbicides - Drums in Dwellingup Area 2346 Anti-Corruption Commission Staff - Job Offers with the CCC and Redundancies 10789 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 9321 Second Reading 9321, 13340 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 First Reading 4235 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 349

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 (continued) Second Reading 4235, 6950 Committee 6961 Third Reading 6961 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 4) 2002 First Reading 4235 Second Reading 4235 Committee 6961 Third Reading 6963 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 First Reading 8682 Second Reading 8682 Committee 9531-9535 Report 9535 Third Reading 9535 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 First Reading 8683 Second Reading 8683, 9544 Australian Crime Commission (Western Australia) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14149 Second Reading 14149 Australian Wildlife Conservancy - Ningaloo Development 5811-5815, 5972, 6080 Brazier, Mr Michael - Forfeited Surety 8677 Building and Construction Industry Training Fund and Levy Collection Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 12981 Second Reading 12981 Building Industry Government Construction Contracts 9552, 9555, 10751 Home Building Contracts Act 1991 - Section 21 Remedies 8365 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13321 Committee 13322-13325 Business of the House - Legislative Assembly Messages - Sessional Orders Suspension 6587 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 First Reading 6587 Second Reading 6587 Cognate Debate 6963 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8774 Committee 9016-9018 Report 9020 Third Reading 9020 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 First Reading 10738 Second Reading 10738 Cognate Debate 12530 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 12642 Committee 12642-12644 Order Discharged 12919 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 First Reading 6590 Second Reading 6590 Cognate Debate 6963 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8774 Report 9020 Third Reading 9020 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 First Reading 10739 Second Reading 10740 Cognate Debate 12530 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 12642 Order Discharged 12919 350 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Analysis of Seized Cannabis by a Qualified Chemist - Cost 10094 Capital Punishment - Offenders Convicted of Heinous Crimes - Motion 12995 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 First Reading 2338 Second Reading 2338 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 9946 Second Reading 9946, 10464 Censorship Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 6557 Committee 6557, 6558 Third Reading 6558 Central Park Plaza - Sale of Half Ownership 12665 Child Support (Adoption of Laws) Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 3464 As to Committee Stage 3591 Committee 3591 Third Reading 3591 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 9321 Second Reading 9321, 11451, 11484 Committee 11825-11830, 11839-11859 Third Reading 12104 Application of Standing Order No 230A - Statement 10055 Motion 11485, 11824 Statement 12277 Civil Liability Bill 2002 First Reading 2342 Second Reading 2342, 2349 Committee 3038-3042 Third Reading 3037, 3042 Colleges of TAFE Performance Delivery Agreements - Tabling 592 Pilbara - Pundulmurra Campus - Selection Process for Manager 3773 Student-Teacher Ratios 592 Teaching Loads and Class Sizes 259 Colliefields Hotel - Suspension of Licence 4526 Commonwealth Powers (De Facto Relationships) Bill 2003 First Reading 14154 Second Reading 14154 Community Development Child Protection - Children’s Advocate 6299, 6581 SafeCare - Referral of Sex Offenders 4901 Companies (Co-operative) Act 1943 - Amendments 7011 Constitution Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2335 Second Reading 2335 Consumer and Employment Protection Bey Apartments East Perth - Strata Management 12963 Community Development Employment Project Roebourne - Complaint about Forging of Signatures 9022 Complaint PE36898 - Application for Leave to Appeal 1139 Department 553, 1005 Ford, Ms Jan - Complaints about Sale of Properties in Port Hedland 14868 Home Building Contracts Act 1991 - Section 21 Remedies 8365 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 6052 Second Reading 6052, 9041 Committee 9044, 9045 Third Reading 9045 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 351

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 First Reading 6597 Second Reading 6597 Coral Bay - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd - Mr Derek Carew-Hopkins 3866 Coroners Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 6088 Committee 6305 Third Reading 6306 Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders - Amendment to Motion 10227 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 2) 2001 Second Reading 5432 Committee 5762-5765 Third Reading 5765 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 3) 2001 Second Reading 5768 Committee 5768, 5769 Third Reading 5770 Corruption and Crime Commission - Anti-Corruption Commission Staff 10789 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 First Reading 8356 Second Reading 8356 Instruction to Committee 9367 Committee 9368 Third Reading 9370 Crime Burglary - Charges Laid 10941 Car Theft - Three-strikes Law 7475 Curfew for Juveniles in Northbridge 9849, 10939 Homicides - Number of Charges 2510 House Break-ins 14852-14867 Kalgoorlie - Burglary Charges 4302 Perth Station - Children Apprehended 10940 Railway Stations - Motor Vehicles Stolen Damaged or Burgled 9618 Safer WA - Incorporated Association - Lotterywest Grants 14027 Theft from Vehicles - Preventive Measures 5049 Criminal Code Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2003 First Reading 14625 Second Reading 14625 Criminal Injuries Compensation Act - Amendments 13348 Maximum Amount 9969, 10089 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 First Reading 12634 Second Reading 12634, 13870 Committee 13870-13872 Report 13873 Third Reading 13873 Criminal Investigation (Exceptional Powers) and Fortification Removal Act 2002 5412 Criminal Law (Procedure) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 1154, 1155 Committee 1154-1157 Third Reading 1157 Criminal Property Confiscation Act - Contravention of the Bill of Rights 12966 Debits Tax Assessment Bill 2001 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4268 Third Reading 4268 Debits Tax Bill 2001 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4268 Third Reading 4268 Defence Forces - Army Vehicles - Accidents with Civilian Vehicles 14030 Detention Centres - Security Concerns 4940 352 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Director of Public Prosecutions, Office of - Establishment 5808 Domestic Violence - Joondalup - Reduction in Numbers at Domestic Violence Unit 2873 Drugs Cannabis CANNA Range of Fertilisers 13121 Changes to Legislation 1167 Charges and Cautions 7309 Convictions 7309 Custodial Sentences for Convictions 9976, 10942 Decriminalisation - Plant Material Demonstration 7826 Law Enforcement - Law Enforcement 7448 Mirrabooka - Report of Drug Dealing 7180 Economic Regulation Authority Community Consultation 5316, 6330 Establishment 5534 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 First Reading 5432 Second Reading 5432 Order Discharged and Referred to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 6545 Second Reading 11859, 11961 Committee 11963, 11968-11978, 12148, 12278-12285, 12293-12312, 12511-12516 Third Reading 12918 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision 11361; Urgency Motion 1796 Electronic Transactions Bill 2001 - Second Reading 5200 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 Second Reading 3047, 3463 Third Reading 3463 Employment and Training - Industry Training Advisory Bodies - Funding 1661, 2127 Environment Dwellingup - Drums Containing Herbicides 2346 Environmental Recovery Services Ltd - Conditions of Licence 2347 Kalgoorlie Cement Works Breaches of Occupational Safety and Health Legislation 9378 Document Improvement Notice 5807, 5808 E-mail about Dangerous and Unsafe Work Practices 9643 E-mail with Photographic Evidence 9375 Improvement Notices 5076, 5077 Occupational Safety and Health Legislation Breaches 8433 Trailers - Roadworthiness 9616 Unlicensed Forklift on Wilson Street 9616 Unsafe Work Practices 9376, 9377 Verbal Directions on Safety Issues 8430 WorkSafe Improvement Notices 6466 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Clearing Regulations 6583 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure Standing Orders Suspension 7287 Tabling of Budget Papers 7287 Consideration of Tabled Papers 7288 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 721 Committee 725-729 Third Reading 729 Fire and Emergency Services Authority 10114, 9621, 9623 Kimberley - Permits to Burn 10149, 10154 Levy 590, 591, 2916, 13166, 14867 Northam Fire Station - Staffing 7177 Nuclear Accidents 4397, 4526 Risk Management Training 8415 Shire of Gingin - Firebreak Order - Swan Location 7807, East Lancelin 3291, 4432 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 353

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 1026, 1431 Committee 1434-3043 Third Reading 3044 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3044, 3592 Committee 3596-3602 Third Reading 3602 Firearms Act - Amendments 10364 Licences - Proof of Identity for Renewal 1137 Rifle Clubs - Rents - Adjournment Debate 2605 First Home Owner Grant Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 5406 Committee 5920 Third Reading 5921 Forests and Forestry Sawmills - Registration - Number and Type 3772 Sky Jetty Project - Public-private Partnership 6585 Fuel and Energy Electricity Reform - Blake Dawson Waldron - Advice 12143 Fuel Prices - Impact of International Oil Price 10921 International Hydrogen Conference Broome - Funding 6123 Petrol - Ethanol 4527 Gambling Burswood Property Trust - Corporatisation - Statement1404 Burswood International Resort Casino 1419, 1529, 1659 Casino Tax - Shortfall 10808 Gaming Machines - Rate of Return for Punters 2125 SuperStar Leo and SuperStar Virgo 7166 Government Contracts Cemetery Records System - Tender Details 13122 Construction Contracts 9552, 9555 Court Complex, Hay Street, Perth - Tender Process 11480 Panel Contracts - Number and Cost 12966, 13083-13085, 13126, 13169-13172, 13892 Tender No 12603 - Stationery Contracts for Government Agencies 14607 Tender No 26526 - Results on Government’s Web Site 11210 Tendering Process 10251, 10477, 11210 Union Agreements 10751 Government Departments and Agencies Aborigines - Programs 7014-7017, 7509, 7842 Budget Revenue 4527 Budget Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9985, 10153 “Buy Local” Policy - Exemptions 13146 Court Action or Litigation - Involvement 7186, 7188, 7194, 7195, 7453, 7459 Functional Review Taskforce Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9984, 10151, 10152 Leave Liability 12552 Procurement Reform Process 12922, 12923, 13065 Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 11067-11070, 11184-11190, 11868 Register of Intellectual Property 6104-6107, 6111-6114 Salaries - Increase 11838 Government Vehicles - Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered - Conversion Policy 12162 Groves, Ms Vicki - Prisoner F - Parole Board’s Decision 3434, 4026 Health Broometime Lodge, Broome - Incident of Antisocial Behaviour 14029 Chiropractors - Workers Compensation 12966 Medical Personnel - Negligence Claims - Limitation Period 10262 Nurses - Prisons - Industrial Action 3610 Prisoners - Transfer of Responsibility 4398, 4447 Smoking Regulations 8679, 9567, 10381, 11242 Smoke-free Workplaces 10790 354 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Heritage - Duncraig House - Sale 11483 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 1446 Second Reading 1834, 2243 Committee 2747-2751 Third Reading 2751 Homeswest - Discrimination Complaints 3772 Homicide Victims Support Group 3728, 3730, 3866 Homosexuality Discrimination - Community Education 14608, 14610 Lesbian and Gay Law Reform 14608, 14610 Hospitals Geraldton Regional 14615, 13010, 13121, 13865, 14033; Statement 14624 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner 2916 Housing Broometime Lodge, Broome - Complaints of Antisocial Behaviour of Residents 13007 Commonwealth-State Housing Agreement 10117 Hilton - Redevelopment 13144 Homelessness Indigenous Prisoners 1263, 2157 Task Force Strategy - Extra Units for Mentally Ill 14048 Housing and Works, Department of Aborigines - Rental Homes 9849 Broometime Lodge, Broome - Incident of Antisocial Behaviour 14029 Construction Contracts Policy - Limit on Number and Value - Cabinet Discussion 9552 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 9555 Director General - Mr Greg Joyce - Statement - Tabling 10116 Ecoscape (Australia) Pty Ltd - Albion Town Development 9844, 12143 Fremantle Eastern Bypass and Roe Highway Stage 8 - Land Reservations 10367 Kununurra - Inspections of Rental Accommodation 10785 Lot 587 Herbert Street, Broome - Lodgment of Expression of Interest 13064 New Living Program 12668 Industrial Development - Burrup Peninsula Murujuga Region - Tabling of Federal Minister's Letter 6584 Water Supply 8361 Industrial Relations Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Enterprise Bargaining Agreements 10751 Legislation - Advertising Costs 4 Prisons - Industrial Disputes 4028 Inspector of Custodial Services Bill 2003 First Reading 12914 Second Reading 12914, 14580 Insurance Common Law Rights of Workers 2231 Manipulation of Profits by Companies 2347 Royal Life Saving Society of WA - Public Liability Cover 1005 Supplementation Fund Levy - Reduction 240 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 1444 Second Reading 1444, 3034 Third Reading 3037 Juries Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 6544 Second Reading 6544, 6948 Committee 6949 Third Reading 6950 Justice, Department of Beamish, Mr Darryl - Cost of Appeal 4531 Button, Mr John - Cost of Appeal 4531 Child Sex Offenders - Names 12570 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 355

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Justice, Department of (continued) Convicted Criminals - Right to Compensation 9194 Early Release Orders - Administrative Instructions on Breaches 5048 George, Ms Kate 4938 Juvenile Justice Teams 8432, 8671 Kanpa Bail Facility 5314 Leech, Mr Tony - Overseas Tour 3609 Ministerial Councils for Corrective Services 11831 Parole Breaches 10361 Number of Offenders Classification and Breaches 13167 Pre-release Parole and Home Leave Programs 5530 Warrants of Commitment 10362 Royal Association of Justices - Assistance to Produce Magazine 1744 SafeCare - Referral of Sex Offenders 4901 Tie Line between Attorney General’s Office 9633 Warrants of Commitment - Number and Classification of Offenders 13482 Justices of the Peace - Retirement 7651,9375 Land Clearing Regulations 6583 Remnant Native Vegetation 2345 Lots 5 and 49 Great Eastern Highway, Belmont 7176, 8409 Land Tax Assessment Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 4268 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4269 Third Reading 4269 Land Tax Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 4268 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4269 Third Reading 4269 Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Tortfeasors’ Contribution) Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6318 Legal Practice Bill 2002 First Reading 9157 Second Reading 9157 Cognate Debate 13104 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13138 Committee 13148-13154 Report 13163 Third Reading 13163 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote 2344 Liquor Boab Inn, Derby - Extension of Trading Hours 11613 Deregulation of Industry 11477; National Competition Policy Payments 11832 Licensing Authority - Review 5820 Bulletin - Purpose, Cost, Staff and Distribution 2513 Changes to Laws 12140, 12293, 12922 Consultation on Policy Changes to Laws 12003 National Competition Policy 4956, 5408 Liquor Stores - Sunday Trading 8565, 10745 Rugby World Cup - Extended Hours for Liquor Outlets 10246, 10252, 10807 Summary of Transactions Annual Return 11204 Loan Bill 2003 First Reading 14590 Second Reading 14590 Lobbyists - Payroll Tax Amnesty Mr Brian Burke 4524; Personal Explanation 6086 Mr Julian Grill 4524 Local Government City of Belmont -Lots 5 and 49, Great Eastern Highway, Belmont 7176 356 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Local Government (continued) City of Joondalup - Chief Executive - Qualifications 6583 Elections - Ward Representation 6585 Revaluations of Properties - Payments to Valuer General 10381 Shire of Gingin - Firebreak Order - Swan Location 7807, East Lancelin 4432 Swimming Pools - Subsidies 5053 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 14574 Second Reading 14574 Lotterywest Community Service Outlet Cost 13863 Increase in Price of Lotto Tickets 549 Name Change of Lotteries Commission to Lotterywest 6954 Ruah Community Services - Grant 2780 Safer WA - Grants 14027 Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Funeral Fall - Compensation Payment 12923 Mickelberg Case Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General Documents Given to Minister for Health 1422, 1528 Meetings with Solicitor General 344 Receipt of Documents from Solicitor General 462, 550 Solicitor General’s Advice 1529 Tape of Channel 7 Interview 9021, 12286 Copy to The West Australian 1003 Minister for Health - Allegations 1136, 12966 Revocation of Mr Lewandowski’s Indemnity 1802, 1950 Tape of Interview by Alison Fan with Tony Lewandowski 8564, 8671, 13141 Petition - Handing Over on Front Steps of Parliament 344 Ministers of the Crown Attorney General Alleged Offences 14033 Facsimile Application of Signature 4956 Interview with Bob Maumill 1258 Policy for Announcing Early Release of Prisoners 4200 Posing with the Director of Public Prosecutions on Harley Davidson Motorbike 344 Resignation from the Position of Leader of the Opposition 14634 Solicitor General - Meetings with and Receipt of Documents from 344, 462 Tie Line between his Office and the Department of Justice 9633 Visit by Journalists to Ministerial Office 1135 Minister for Government Enterprises - Restaurant Expenses 12677 Minister for Racing and Gaming - Personal Explanation - Mr Brian Burke 6086 Office Location and Refurbishment, and Staff 2904-2906, 3063, 3064, 3193 Portfolio Changes - Statement 9518 Misuse of Drugs Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 10327 Second Reading 10327 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No.2) 2002 Second Reading 13995 Committee 13995, 13996 Third Reading 13996 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading 13875 Motor Vehicles Industry - Not Guilty Appeals 1005 LPG Conversion Policy 12162 Theft Railway Stations 9618 Three-strikes Law 7475 Mozambique Rule Abolition 6300, 6459 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 357

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Mozambique Rule (continued) Effectiveness in WA 13352 Mullewa - Break and Enters and Vandalism Incidents - Crime Statistics 12291 National Competition Council Directive - Non-compliance 4200 Legislative Reviews 12014 Liquor Licensing Guidelines 4956, 5408 Role and Implementation of Policy 4395 Native Title, Office of - Budget 241 Ningaloo Reef Ningaloo Station - Briefing on Tourist Accommodation 5811-5815, 5972, 6121 Save Ningaloo Reef Campaign - Meetings 6080 Nuclear Accidents - Response Measures 4526, 4397 Occupational Safety and Health Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10122 Smoke-free Workplaces - Government’s Policy 9628 Occupational Safety and Health Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 4536 Third Reading 4537 Parliament House - Occupational Safety and Health Act - 11208 Parliamentary Counsel’s Office - Legislative Drafting Professionals 14637 Pay-roll Tax Assessment Bill 2001 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4268 Third Reading 4268 Pay-roll Tax Bill 2001 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 4268 Third Reading 4268 Planning Kununurra - Shortage of Residential Land 10784 Mauds Landing Development 6080, 12551 Peel Region Scheme - Statement 2315 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Telephone Survey 10246 Wireless Hill Park 9584, 9973 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 2243, 2246 Third Reading 2246 Police Aircraft - Authority to Carry Dangerous Goods 1418 Anti-terrorist Measures - Additional Staff 4254 Augusta Station - Staffing 12286 CADCOM Project - Adverse Report by Auditor General 12555 Cannabis 7309, 10942 Corporate Assistance 10771 Cue, Mt Magnet and Meekatharra - Staffing Levels 6082 Cyclists Riding on Roads Adjacent to Shared Cycleways 10380 Derby 12552, 13018 DNA Testing - Budget Allocation 877 Drugs - Law Enforcement 7448 East Perth Station - Infringement Notice Booklets 3434 Firearms 10249 Forrestfield Station 13010, 13119 Geraldton - Hours Worked by Officers 4933 Great Northern Highway Roadblock between Broome and Wilare Bridge 9972 Greer, Mr Arthur 2227, 3436, 6083, 7202 Kalamunda Station 13010, 13119 Mason, Ms Sharon - Murder 2227, 3436, 3731, 6083 Metropolitan Area 872, 4365 Mirrabooka - Report of Drug Dealing 7180 Mounted and Canine Sections - Funding 13117 Mullewa Station - Crime Statistics 12291 Multanovas 3435, 3873, 4935 358 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Police (continued) North West Metropolitan District - Staff Levels 1804 Officers Annual and Long Service Leave 3066 Attrition Rate 13070 Hours Worked 4933 Number 4023 Recruitment 10938 Recruits - Number 6958 Retiring 9056, 10771 South West 245 PC Cop System 878 Pilbara District Police Office - Cheeditha Community Aboriginal Group 9622 Plant Material Demonstration in Legislative Assembly - Inquiry 7826 Red-light Cameras - Revenue - Road Safety Initiatives 3435 Resources - Number 4023 Royal Commission - Submissions 14638 Scott, Detective Frank - Corruption Allegations 4957, 5050 Stations - Unmanned 13010 Stock Stealing Squad 1417, 3024 Theft from Vehicles - Preventive Measures 5049 Traffic Accidents - Infringement Notices 7452 United States Warships - Protection - Cost 5969 Police Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 4038 Second Reading 4038, 5428 Committee 5553 Third Reading 5553 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - Vehicle Speeding Fines 9973 Prisons Aboriginal Visitors Scheme 712, 4937 Arts Programs 5809 Bandyup - Restraints on Prisoners Attending Medical Appointments 7311 Banksia Hill - Staff and Detainee Numbers 7008 Biometric Identification System - Trial 7011 Cost per Prisoner - Saving from Reduced Prisoner Numbers 2514 Death in Custody 7451 Excell, Mr - Pre-release Program 3285 Finn, Prisoner - Announcement of Early Release 4200 Fires Lit by Prisoners in Cells 4938 Hakea - Sick Leave 3616 Indigenous Prisoners - Homelessness 1263 Industrial Disputes 4028 Inspector of Custodial Services - Reports 5313 Juvenile Sex Offender and Murderer B - Pre-release Program 3285 Keating, Mr Paul Stephen - Urinalysis 7013 Nurses - Industrial Action 3610 Nyandi - Aboriginal Women 10940 Nyandi-Longmore Site - Redevelopment 10116 Pre-release Parole and Home Leave Programs 5530 Prisoner F 3434, 4026, 4200 Prisoners Health - Transfer of Responsibility 4398, 4447 Payment of Funeral Expenses 10778 Release Programs 3024 Sentenced to Two Years or Less 1456 Rangeview Remand Centre 7008, 10935 Roebourne Regional - Inspector of Custodial Services Report 5313 Security Concerns 4940 Thursday Prison Census Tabling 5955 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 359

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Prisons (continued) Wimbridge Prisoner - Sex Offender Treatment Program 4199 Prisons Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 6290 Committee 6294, 6295, 6296 Third Reading 6297 Prostitution - Soliciting in Public Places - Fremantle 7648 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 8773 Third Reading 8774 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 First Reading 9569 Second Reading 9569 Consultation 4027 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 Second Reading 5062 Committee 5065-5073, 5203-5205 Third Reading 5205 Assembly’s Message 5915-5918, 7124, 7125 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 First Reading 6560 Second Reading 6560, 6587 Questions on Notice - Answers 2875, 6305 Questions without Notice 1514 - Changes to Prepared Answer 5 Racing Betting Exchanges on Australian Racing 9582 Betting Transactions - Minimum Levels 4900 Bookmakers - Telephone Betting Limits 2760 British Gambling Exchanges - Impact 6580 Country Race Clubs and Country Racing 1257, 2229; Statement2107 Cox Plate 2348 Cross-border Betting - Report 4025 Lark Hill Racing Complex 2348, 2349 Racing and Wagering Western Australia 2512, 2513, 5191, 5312 Racing Radio - Programming Format Change 10807 Radio Stations - Reception Upgrade 5773 Western Australian Trotting Association - Consultation 2345 Western Australian Turf Club - Mr Ted Van Heemst 1003 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 First Reading 7409 Second Reading 7409 Cognate Debate 7955 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8649 Third Reading 8681 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 First Reading 7412 Second Reading 7413 Cognate Debate 7955 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8649 Committee 8650-8670, 8680 Recommittal 8680, 8681 Third Reading 8681 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 First Reading 7412 Second Reading 7412 Cognate Debate 7955 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8649 Third Reading 8681 Racing, Gaming and Liquor, Department of 5820, 7996 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 First Reading 7411 360 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Racing Restriction Bill 2003 (continued) Second Reading 7412 Cognate Debate 7955 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8649 Third Reading 8681 Railways Arrests Number 872 Perth Station - Children Apprehended 10940 Southern Rail Link - South Perth Station 3026 Stations - Car Stealing and Burglary 11193, 11209 Vehicles Stolen, Damaged or Burgled at Stations 9618 Residential Tenancies Act 1987 - Review 3027 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 13849 Second Reading 13849 Retail Trading Australia Day - Extended Trading Permits 5049, 5819 Current Hours Regime - Legality 9020 Liquor Stores - Sunday Trading 8565 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Land Reservations 10367 Road Safety - Aboriginal Road Users 6302 Roe Highway Stage 8 - Land Reservations 10367 Speed Limits 246, 350 Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody - Implementation 9633 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers Lack of Evidence 2227 Mr Avon Lovell - Prosecution for Failure to Cooperate 4938 Submissions by Police Personnel - Restrictions 14638 Royal Life Saving Society of WA - Public Liability Cover 1005 Rugby World Cup - Extended Hours for Liquor Outlets 10246, 10252, 10807 Schools - Non-profit Private Country School - Water Efficiency Rebate 6298 Select Committee into Water Services - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7160, 7622 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 Second Reading Discharged and Referral to Legislation Committee 4502 Cognate Debate 9159 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9168 Committee 9338, 9339, 9363-9367 Third Reading 9367 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 4501 Cognate Debate 9159 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9168 Committee 9169, 9335-9338 Report 9367 Third Reading 9367 Sewerage Beenyup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Noise Complaints 11204 Busselton Waste Water Treatment Plant - Industrial Liquid Waste 5319 Infill Sewerage Program 2875, 11614 Kwinana Waste Water Recycling Plant - Cost 1263, 1420 Lancelin - Infrastructure 6955 Port Hedland Sewage Treatment Ponds - Tjalka Boorda Aboriginal Community 5960 Shark Bay 10780 Subiaco Waste Water Treatment Plant - Sewage Outfall at Swanbourne Beach 1456 Waste Water 2121, 6607 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 First Reading 1835 Second Reading 4267 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 361

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 (continued) Committee 4267 Third Reading 4267 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 First Reading 8681 Second Reading 8681, 9333 Committee 9334 Report 9334 Third Reading 9334 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Proposal to Travel 4318 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 4318 Standing Order No 230(b) - Motion 2316 State Administrative Tribunal Task Force Report 3874 Veterinary Surgeons - Complaints 10789 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 First Reading 10736 Second Reading 10736 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 11195 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 First Reading 10735 Second Reading 10735 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 11195 State Budget 2004-05 Estimates 589 Cash Deficits 9361 Recurrent Expenditure and Capital Works Programs 6990, 6993, 6994, 7184 State Finance Burswood International Resort Casino - Impact of Tax Changes 1419 Consolidated Fund - Balance 1008 Government Financial Results 2001-02 Report 2911; Statement 1521 Interest Rates 9064 Revenue - Increases 5218 Stamp Duty 2868, 12004, 12043 Unbudgeted Capital Loan Repayments 9064 Succession Law - Reform 11835 Swimming Pools - Subsidies to Local Government 5053 Taxation Casino Tax - Shortfall 10808 Land Tax Exemptions - Residential Building Delays 11366 Payroll Tax Amnesty - Mr Brian Burke 4524; Personal Explanation 6086 Changes 589, 4906, 4957 Reductions for Drought-affected Farmers 2868 Reform - Tax-free Threshold 5316 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 Second Reading 3878 Committee 3880-3882, 4011-4022, 4032-4035, 4206, 4222 Recommittal 3884-3896 Third Reading 4267 Government Response to Report of the Standing Committee on Legislation 2349 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2001 Second Reading 3878 Third Reading 4267 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) (Taxing) Bill 2001 Second Reading 3878 Third Reading 4267 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 First Reading 3627 Second Reading 3627, 4336 362 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 (continued) Third Reading 4345 Standing Orders Suspension 4313 Totalisator Agency Board Bonus Payment 5531 Turnover Tax 5772 Tourism - Ningaloo Station - Briefing 5811-5815, 5972, 6121 Transport Cyclists Riding on Roads Adjacent to Shared Cycleways 10380 Driver Fatigue - Review of Regulations and Codes 12556 Eastern Goldfields Transport Board - Document Tabling - Statement 13129 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 First Reading 9320 Second Reading 9320, 9548 Treasury and Finance, Department of - Political and Public Administration Services 4903 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 First Reading 2340 Second Reading 2340 Unclaimed Money (Superannuation and RSA Providers) Bill 2002 First Reading 4899 Second Reading 4899, 6425 United States of America - Warships - Cost of Police Protection 5969 Veterinary Surgeons Board - Complaints 10789 Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Bill 2002 Second Reading 574 Third Reading 574 Victims of Crime Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 11485 Second Reading 11485 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Receipt and First Reading 1446 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 6560 Third Reading 6560- Water Corporation Answers to Questions 14610 Burrup Water Supply 8361 Computer Sciences Corporation - Information Technology Contract 859, 1003 Desalination of Water - Hydraulic Head Pressure 862 Dividend - Increase 7308; Statement 8348 Lake Navarino Forest Resort - Water Supply 14030 Market Equity Pty Ltd - Survey 4900, 4955, 4956, 5048, 5197, 5770, 5954 Market Surveys - Details 5801 Mount Eliza House - Renovation for Corporate Entertainment 2230 Newdegate Rifle Range - Lease Charges 2605 Recurrent and Capital Works Programs 4205, 4936 Revenue Estimates 6579, 7448 Tender No MN-02-10963 - Repairs to Greater Southern Towns Pipelines 1662 Water Meters - Accuracy 13118 Water Shortage - Mis leading Information 10088 Water Resources 155 Kilolitres per Annum Consumption Target 5191 Advertising Campaign - Costs 5311 Aquifers - Extraction Rate 4344 Bores 13122, 4339, 6083 Charges 2760, 2872 Class 1 Regional Towns - Increased Prices 7480 Consumption Figures 5311 Desalinated Seawater - Piping from Esperance to Kalgoorlie-Boulder 13066 Doust Water Brake - Evaluation 4203 Front-load Washing Machines - Water Consumption 4904 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 363

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Water Resources (continued) Gascoyne - Sustainable Capacity of Scheme Water 1261 Goldfields - Report on Alternative Water Source 1657 Ground Water Applications to Increase Extraction 5676, 5801, 14027, 14605, 14606, 14610 Bore Fields Developed 1455 Development Options 6085 Extraction 4199, 6586 Perth Region 13003, 13346 Supply Bores Turned Off 13346, 13352 Hamilton Hill Area - Water Quality 12926 Harris River Dam 734, 3436 Harvey Dam 10245, 10476 Harvey Water - Offer of Extra Three Gigalitres for Perth Market 10361, 13010 Integrated Water Supply Scheme - Increase in Water Supply 5407 Kalgoorlie 7450, 12665, 14049 Kununurra Bore Field 10364 Laverton - Water Quality 5817 Metropolitan Area - Supplementation of Supplies 11837 Mundaring Weir and Canning Dam - Catchment Areas 14615 Non-profit Private Country School - Water Efficiency Rebate 6298 Perth’s Dams - Water Volume 4252 Perth Households - Annual Water Consumption 1746 Perth Integrated Water Supply Scheme 13116, 13140 Port Gregory 6084 Price Increases - Protection of Large Families 5191 Rebate - Number and Value of Cash Rebates 8564 Samson Brook Dam - Expansion 13915 Scott River Basin - Ground Water 6 Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7160, 7622 Shark Bay Cemetery - Pipeline Charges 10780 State Water Strategy - Class 1 Domestic Customers 5530 Statement 14617 Strategic Management Unit - Mr David Hatt 872 Strategy Developments 1134 Waste Water Use 2121 Water-saving Devices - Evaluations 4203 Water Flows into Dams 12669 Water Restrictions 9551, 11837, 13003, 13064, 14634 Water Royalty 4204, 4205 Water Shortage - Tabling of Documents 6454 Wellington Dam - Salt Content 12144 Yarragadee Aquifer Development 6080, 6085 Drilling of Additional Bores 2121 Extraction Rate 14615 Metropolitan Southern Bores 8563 South West Water Extraction 9192 Three New Bores 5327 Yuna Chapman Valley - Water Pipeline 4531 Western Australian Rifle Association - Newdegate Rifle Range - Lease Charges 2605 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation (Acts of Terrorism) Bill 2002 First Reading 1446 Second Reading 2768, 3048 Third Reading 3048 Workers Compensation Amendments to Legislation - Common Law Rights of Workers 2231 Chiropractic Profession 12966 Legislation - Support for Changes 2347 Validity of Claims 2606 364 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRIFFITHS, HON NICHOLAS DAVID (continued) Workers Compensation (continued) WorkCover WA Deadline to Lodge Common Law Claim 2228, 3027 Review of Legislation - Motion 12131 WorkSafe Western Australia Driver Fatigue Regulations and Codes - Review 12556 Elevated Work Platforms - Legislation 7824 Improvement Notices Issued to Anti-Corruption Commission 8431 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 First Reading 1446

GRYLLS, MR BRENDON JOHN (Merredin) (NPA) Address-in-Reply Motion Electoral Issues 1913 Medicine and Education 1916 Public Liability 1915 Salinity and Water 1914 Amendment to Motion - Water Shortages 221 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7251 Agricultural Shows - Statement 2000 Dairy Industry - Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9249 Department - Select Committee - Motion 7251 Drought Assistance Dalwallinu 25 Nungarin Business Community 3090 Landcare Facilitators and Coordinators - Funding 208, 209 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Agriculture 7916 Education 7915 Health 7914 Water and Business 7876-7878, 7912, 7913 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7914 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1506 Business Enterprise Centres - Closure 10420 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11517 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6387 Consideration in Detail 6392 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6387 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 6855, 6856, 6876, 6879, 6893 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 7343 Consideration in Detail 7352-7354, 7378, 7380, 7386, 8736-8745, 8748, 8752, 8754, 8993-8997, 9001 Adjournment of Debate 8751 Council’s Amendments 12592 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Second Reading 1076 Consideration in Detail 1988, 1989, 1993, 1999 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3105 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4617 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5704, 5706, 5709-5713, 5725, 5980-5984, 6195-6197 Criminal Code Amendment Bill (No. 3) 2003 - Introduction and First Reading 14065 Cunderdin Aviation Expo Committee - Statement 7879 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5234, 5235, 5248-5253, 5348- 5351, 5354-5359, 5377, 5390 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13371 Employer-employee Agreements - Registration 6682 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 365

GRYLLS, MR BRENDON JOHN (continued) Environment Ms Bobbie Reilly - Environmental Achievement Award - Statement 12855 Natural Heritage Trust - Funding 208, 209 State Budget Initiatives 9785, 9786 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Grievance 12574 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 13414 Golden Pipeline Heritage Trail - Statement 5362 Government Contracts - Centralisation of Procurement Process in Perth 14254 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1506 Consideration in Detail 1581, 1693-1698, 1702, 1703, 1714-1721 Third Reading 1724 Health Corrigin Medical Trauma Training Weekend - Statement 5714 District Health Advisory Councils - Appointment of Representatives 1309 Downgrading and Closing Facilities 5242 Improved Services - Government’s Commitment 1316 Mental Health System - Funding - Matter of Public Interest 11263; Funding - Petition 13928 Regional Areas 2273 SARS - Impact on Tourism 7027 Hospitals Merredin District Anaesthetist 2273 Doctor Crisis 2389, 2673 Doctor on Duty 2166 Medical Staff and Resources - Grievance 2357 Northam District - Anaesthetist 2273 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11758 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 616 Consideration in Detail 640, 641, 645, 1103, 1107-1110, 1113, 1117, 1118 Third Reading 1392 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4598 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2021 Liquor Deregulation of Industry - National Competition Policy Payments 11784 Licensing Changes to Laws - Matter of Public Interest 12692 National Competition Policy 13524 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Agriculture 10863 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Control 10861 Organ Donation 10860 Small Business 10862, 10864 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13958 National Competition Council Liquor Licensing Act Review - National Competition Policy 13524 Threat to Payments - Motion 12478 Native Title - Technical Task Force - Cost 9311 Nungarin Business Community - Letter to Minister for State Development 3090 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1904 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 965 Consideration in Detail 1354 Regional Development - Centralisation of Procurement Process in Perth 14254 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13749 Consideration in Detail 13797-13800, 13805, 13806, 13831-13833 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours Anti-competitive Behaviour 8312 Competition Policy Guidelines 5720, 5721 366 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GRYLLS, MR BRENDON JOHN (continued) Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours (continued) Impact of Inflexible Industrial Relations Laws 5997 Matter of Public Interest 8447 Salinity - National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality Budget Allocation 7885 Funding 3231, 3232, 6184, 11536 Motion 6514 Rural Communities - Funding 1867 Signing 9876 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7251 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9249 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8484 State Budget Environment Initiatives 9785, 9786 Water Resources - Payout Ratio 8871 Sustainability Strategy Funding 11536 Salinity and Algal Bloom Crises 11536 Swan River - Matter of Public Interest 8799 Tourism Budget Allocations 9496 Golden Heartland Tourism Awards - Statement 10414 Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome - Impact 7027 Water Corporation - Dividend - Payout Ratio 8871 Water Resources Farm Dams - Management Charges - Motion 7699 Ground Water - Regional Areas 3349, 3350 Harris River Dam - Removal of Additional Water 5753 Management Charges - Motion 7699 Matter of Public Interest 2393 Regional Western Australia - Sustainable Water Supply - Motion 3950 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13958 Western Power Bremer Bay - Power Supplies 12321, 12323, 12466 Broadband Telecommunications Network Trial - Victoria Park 9234 Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5457 Inquiry into Infrastructure and Customer Service - Motion 12498 Wheatbelt - Power Supplies 12321, 12323, 12466 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation (Acts of Terrorism) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1512 Wyalkatchem Australian Tidy Towns Competition Winner - Statement 6641

GUISE, MRS DIANNE JOY (Wanneroo) (ALP) Address-in-Reply - Motion Agriculture in Wanneroo 201 Land and Water Use 202 New Legislation 200 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1876 Agriculture - Wanneroo Agricultural Show - Statement 13807 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Goods and Services Tax 7722 Wanneroo electorate 7723 Water 7724 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8459, 8464 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7722 Bali Bombings Assistance to Western Australians 1865 Busselton Senior High School 2007 Barbagallo Raceway, Wanneroo - Grievance 12824 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 367

GUISE, MRS DIANNE JOY (continued) Burma Star Association - Statement 10414 Child Abuse - Petitions 11909, 12572 City Entertainers Community Concert Group - Statement 11776 Crayfish - Restrictions on Pots 2214 Defence Forces - Joblink - Petition 477 Disability Services - Recreational Arts Activities - Access 7228 Economy - Western Australian 21, 5085 Education Teachers - Pay Ris e 11706; Motion 11430 Wanneroo - New Initiatives 2387 Electoral - One Vote, One Value - Petition 5559 Elsegood, Mr John - Response to a Statement by the Attorney General 9396 Employment Advocate, Office of the - Workplace Agreements - Interpretation of No-disadvantage Test 3932 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Report of Legislation Committee 2414 Estimates Committees - Standing Orders Suspension 7392 Fire and Emergency Services Levy City of Wanneroo 10161 Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion 10180 Freycinet Collection - Auction 1711 Fuel and Energy Bottled Gas - Rebate for Seniors and Pensioners - Petition 5559, 6128 Electricity Reform - Prices 13196 Goods and Services Tax - Moore Report 10674 Government Departments and Agencies - Privatisation - Government’s Position 12461 Health General Practitioner Services - Wanneroo - Grievance 11752 Nurse Practitioners - Progress 6645 Radiotherapy Treatment - Grievance 9386 Homelessness - Strategy to Prevent 2275 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11760 Industrial Relations - Workplace Agreements Abolition 11113 No-disadvantage Test - Interpretation by Office of the Employment Advocate 3932 Insurance - Public Liability - Affordable Cover 1049 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2016 Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week Trading - Petition 12572 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Planning in Wanneroo 10864-10866 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10684 Mindarie Regional Council - Waste Disposal Plant - Grievance 5683 Multanovas and Red-light Cameras - Revenue - Road Safety Initiatives 7361 Parks and Reserves - Small Grants Program 3231 Planning Burns Beach Lot 2 - Rezoning and Development - Petition 2524 Mindarie Marina - Easement - Grievance 12172 Procedure and Privileges Committee Changes to Prorogation and Extended Sessions - Report 12584 Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Report 4879 Review of Government’s Response to Report on Estimates Committees 2001 and Review of Estimates Committees 2002 5691 Use of Videoconferencing by Legislative Assembly Committees - Second Report 8939 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8714 Railways - Northern Suburbs Rail Service Clarkson Extension 3090 Statement 3668 Retail Trading - Review of Hours - Opposition Submission 5447 Road Safety - Multanovas and Red Light Cameras - Revenue 7361 Schools Busselton Senior High - Bali Bombings 2007 Koorabye - Remote Community School 2817 368 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

GUISE, MRS DIANNE JOY (continued) Schools (continued) Wanneroo Primary and Junior Primary - 5237 Seniors - Bottled Gas Rebate - Petition 5559, 6128 Tourism Economic and Employment Value - Education of the Community 9087 State Tourism Strategy - 9666 Training Services - Joblink - Petition 477 Two Rocks - Seagrass Management - Statement 5714 Unemployment - Statistics 8724 Waste Disposal - Mindarie Regional Council Waste Disposal Plant - Grievance 5683 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11304 Western Power Managing Director - Conditions of Employment 11249 Privatisation 12759 Yanchep - Locality Name - Petition 3354

HALLIGAN, HON RAYMOND JAMES, MNIA (North Metropolitan) (Lib) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 4281 Committee 4513-4523 Address-in-Reply Motion Governor’s Speech and Globalisation 238-240 Health System Difficulties 248-250 Sentencing 251-253 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 3720 Agriculture - Use of Chicken Litter 4345, 12670 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Order of Business - Amendment to Motion 2727 Second Reading - 2756 Committee 2774, 2876-2879, 2881, 2883 Third Reading 2890 Associations Incorporation Amendment Regulations (No. 2) 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 12104 Bali Bombings - Memorial Service - Statement 12153 Builders’ Registration Amendment Regulations 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 13431 Bulk Handling Act Amendment Regulations 2003 - Order Discharged 13431 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 9576, 9588 Committee 11013-11025 Chattel Securities Amendment Regulations 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 12104 Courts - Local Court Amendment Rules (No. 2) 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 7271 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Committee 12278-12285, 12293-12312 Electricity Reform - Blake Dawson Waldron - Advice 12143 Electronic Transactions Bill 2001 - Second Reading 5198 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers Accountability 7599 Contractors and Tendering 7601-7606 State Supply Commission 7600 Fisheries Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 6) 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 11007 Kimberley Prawn Fishery Management Plan Amendment 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 1631 Fremantle, City of - Prevention and Abatement of Sand Drift Local Law - Order Discharged 4949 Geraldton Regional Hospital Construction Contract 13010, 13474 Project Cost 13121 Tenders 13865 Government Advertising - Cost of Campaigns 11366 Government Contracts AOT Consulting Pty Ltd 12165 Cemetery Records System Tender Details 13071, 13122 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 369

HALLIGAN, HON RAYMOND JAMES (continued) Government Contracts (continued) Construction Contracts Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Exemptions 7825 Requirement for CFMEU Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 9555, 10751 Panel Contracts Number and Cost 12966, 13025-13028, 13083-13086, 13126, 13167-13174, 13361-13365, 13482, 13483, 13891, 13892 Tendering Process - Government’s Web Site 10251, 11210 Tender No 26526 - Results on Government’s Web Site 11210 Union Agreements 10751 Government Departments and Agencies - Buy Local Policy - Exemptions 13146 Government Employees Housing Authority - Failure to Provide Housing in Regional Areas 554 Health Mental Health System - Funding 12438 Palliative Care Specialist Support - Partnership with Non-government Sector 1955 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1251 Committee 2746 Homeswest Plants - Type and Quantity 7475 Rental Stock and New Construction - Expenditure 5974 Seniors - Fire Alarms Security Screens and External Lighting 5975 Solar Hot-water Heaters - Installation 6303 Transfer of Properties to Community Housing Providers 5975 Housing Commonwealth-State Housing Agreement 10117 Maniana - Aircraft Noise Restrictions 863 Regional Areas - Government’s Failure to Provide 554 Supported Housing Assistance Program - Criteria 6279 Housing and Works, Department of Construction Contracts Policy - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Exemptions 7825 Construction Forestry Mining and Energy Union - Requirement for Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 9555 Director General - Mr Greg Joyce - Statement - Tabling 10116 Hamilton Hill Town House Construction - Eligibility to Tender 8368 New Living Program 12668 Pre-qualified Contractors 9195 Industrial Relations Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Builders Tendering for DHW Contracts 10751 Industrial Relations Commission Amendment Regulations (No.2) 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 3423 Information Technology - Government Contracting and Purchasing - Compliance Reviews - Motion 12260 Iraq - Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3716 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation City of Melville Local Law Relating to Signs, Hoardings and Billposting - Report 4011 City of Perth Code of Conduct Local Law - Fourth Report 1639, 4000 Powers of Entry and Powers to Make Local Laws that Affect Private Land under the Local Government Act 1995 Sessional Report - 28 June 2001 to 9 August 2002 - Sixth Report 5636, 7444, 10077 Seventh Report 11159, 7783 Joondalup Blue Light Drag - Funding 4451 Local Government Appeals - Delays 6606 Boddington, Shire of - Health Local Laws 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 13431 Bunbury, City of - Local Law Relating to Advertising Devices - Disallowance - Order Discharged 9319 Dumbleyung, Shire of - Health Local Laws 2001 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 13431 East Fremantle, Town of - Urban Environment and Nuisance Local Law - Disallowance - Order Discharged 4949 Fremantle, City of - Prevention and Abatement of Sand Drift Local Law - Disallowance - Order Discharged 4949 Joondalup, City of Mayoral Chain 13594 370 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HALLIGAN, HON RAYMOND JAMES (continued) Local Government (continued) Joondalup, City of (continued) Suspension 14718 Kwinana, Town of - Urban Environment and Nuisance Local Law - Disallowance - Order Discharged 13555 Melville, City of - Local Law Relating to Signs, Hoardings and Billposting - Disallowance - Order Discharged 3423 Mundaring, Shire of Clause 2.4.13(2) Standing Orders Local Law - Disallowance - Order Discharged 11007 Health Local Laws 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 11008 Perth, City of - Amendments to Perth Parking Local Law 1999 - Disallowance - Notice Discharged 8525 Pingelly, Shire of - Health Local Laws 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 13029 Roebourne, Shire of - Local Laws Relating to Fencing - Disallowance - Order Discharged 13029 Vincent Town Council - Inquiry 1806 Wanneroo, City of - Mayoral Chain 13594 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Boundary Fence 5314 Mining Mines Safety and Inspection Amendment Regulations 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 3423 Mining Amendment Regulations 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 12104 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10101, 10125 Occupational Safety and Health Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4534 Parliamentary Secretary - Visit to Croatia - Statement 11594 Perth Airport - Aircraft Noise Restrictions - Maniana 863 Planning Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 1138 Perth Airport - Aircraft Noise Forecasts - Maniana 863 Scarborough Senior High School Site - Future Use 14775 Town Planning and Development (Appeal) Regulations 2003 - Schedule 1 of the Fees - Disallowance - Order Discharged 11007 Port Authorities Amendment Regulations 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 7271 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the Office of Premier - New Position for Former Media Adviser 11478 Policy Office - Staff 11042 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 Second Reading 5060 Committee 5066 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Committee 7279-7283 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 3054 Second Reading 3307 Railways - Northern Suburbs - Clarkson Extension Earthworks Contract 4239 Cost Breakdown 4359 Roads Hepburn Avenue - Extension 1007 Road Traffic (Vehicle Standards) Regulations 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 2217 Schools Girra wheen Senior High Adjournment Debate 475 Statement 10371 Mindarie High School - Doric Constructions Pty Ltd Contract 1423 Sittings of the House - Extended after 6.00 pm - Amendment to Motion 2754 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 1933 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 6267-6271, 7437 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3159, 3998 Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Work of the Committee - Report 448 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 371

HALLIGAN, HON RAYMOND JAMES (continued) Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Committee 4208-4222 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 13475, 13555 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Amendment to Motion 3861 Transport Perth (Passenger) Transport Regulations 2002 Regulation 29 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 1631 Public Transport Authority Regulations 2003 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 12104 United States of America - Australia’s Support for Military Action in Iraq - Motion 3716 University of Western Australia - Amending Statute No. 3 of 2002 - Disallowance - Order Discharged 7271 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1251 Committee 2630, 2631 Water Polo - State Under 20s Team 4453 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1654 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation (Acts of Terrorism) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3047 WorkCover WA - Review of Legislation - Motion 12134 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1251

HILL, MR SHANE ROBIN (Geraldton) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Lands Trust - Review 2521 Murchison Region Aboriginal Corporation - Funding 11140 Sport and Recreation Facilities - Improvement 5085 AlintaGas - Geraldton and Greenough - Availability of Natural Gas 6788 Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement - Discussions 14075 Building Industry - Working Days Lost Through Industrial Disputes 3674 Cancer Foundation of WA - Relay for Life Geraldton - Statement 6180 Collie Power Station - Privatisation 12758 Domestic Violence - Mrs Sue Evans - Statement 10414 Edith Cowan University Microchip Test Facility 510 Education and Health Standing Committee Annual Report 2001-02 - Tabling 493 Annual Report 2002-03 - Report No 4 10650 Environment Plastic Bags - Ban on Use 8445 Regional Herbarium Project - Funding 3002 Validation and Vouchering Services 7596 Fire and Emergency Services Fire Hydrant Installation 14348 Levy - Insurance Companies - Charges on Notices 11435 Foodbank WA, Geraldton - Statement 11106 Geraldton Regional Hospital - Redevelopment Contract - Status 12857 Government Departments and Agencies Funding Cuts 7223 Privatisation Government’s Position 12465 Health - Renal Dialysis Services - Geraldton 1462 Heritage Clune Family Newmarracarra Homestead, Greenough - Funding Assistance 13309 Great Fingal Mine Office, Cue - Roof Replacement 13309 Immigration - Business Migration 6684 Industrial Relations - Construction Industry - Working Days Lost through Industrial Disputes 3674 Insurance - Fire Service Levy Charge on Notices 11435 Legislative Assembly - Sittings in 2004 10676 Local Government - Fire Hydrant Installation 14348 Microchip Test Facility - Edith Cowan University 510 Neighbourhood Watch - Geraldton - Statement 1305 Pastoral Leases Improvements 10880 Pastoral Lands Board - Membership 10880 372 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HILL, MR SHANE ROBIN (continued) Planning Mauds Landing Development - Legality of Decision 11700 Mid West Region - Town Planning Schemes 10878 Police Mullewa Station - 44-hour Week 3847 Officers - Regional and Remote Locations 12066 Ports and Harbours Geraldton Port Authority - Dredging Operations 12205 Port Authority Governance 5582 Railways - Westrail Freight Network - Privatisation 12465 Road Safety - Speed Campaign 10280 Royal Flying Doctor Service - Fundraising - Statement 8307 Salinity - Engineering Projects - Funding 8599 Schools Allendale Primary - Waterwise School Accreditation - Statement 14248 Governor Stirling Senior High - Music Program 14541 Seniors - Active Ageing Task Force - Geraldton Forum 1196 Sport and Recreation - Indigenous Population - Improvement of Facilities 5085 State Budget - Funding Cuts 7223 Teachers - Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 9664 Transport Regional Airports - New Services 10823 Geraldton and the Mid West Infrastructure 86 Westview Hostel, Geraldton 11957 Youth Development Officer - Geraldton 10567

HODSON-THOMAS, MS KATINA, JP (Carine) (Lib) Address-in-Reply - Motion Bali Bombing 2188 Intersections - Safety Concerns 2190, 2191 West Coast College of TAFE - Carine Campus - Closure 2188-2191 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1880, 1891 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Infill Sewerage Program 7748 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Deletion of Roe Highway Stage 8 and Fremantle Eastern Bypass 7747 Perth-Mandurah Railway 7742, 7745, 7746 Roads - Funding Cuts and Safety Issues 7742-7745 School Buses 7746, 7747 Taxes and Charges - Increases 7742 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate - 7742 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6635 Consideration in Detail 6792, 6907 Deputy Speaker’s Ruling 6895 Standing Orders Suspension 6864 Colleges of TAFE Class Numbers 3709 West Coast College of TAFE - Carine Campus Closure 5516; Petition 1970 Hospitality Training Centre 4702 Committees, Task Forces, Reviews and Advisory Groups - Number Established 4786 Consumer and Employment Protection - Motor Vehicle Industry - Corrosion Detectors - Petition 65 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10834 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13183 Dangerous Goods Safety Bill 2002 - Second Reading 8814 Disability Services - Parliamentary Adoption Scheme - Statement 3224 Electricity -Southern Rail Link Usage 10879 Employment and Training - Hospitality Training Centre, Joondalup - Establishment 4702 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Motion 8917 Fremantle, City of - Curfew on Freight Routes 14256 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 373

HODSON-THOMAS, MS KATINA (continued) Hancock, Mr Lang - Inquiry into Death 9801 Health - Neurotrauma Research Program - Petitions 6468 Heritage - William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12091 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11714, 11754 Consideration in Detail 12728, 12729, 12749, 12869-12872 Industrial Relations - Reforms - Impact on Southern Rail Link 4648 Insurance - Public Liability - Taxis 4663 Justices of the Peace - Females - Number 689 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Electoral Boundaries - Redistribution 10855 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Deletion of Roe Highway Stage 8 and Fremantle Eastern Bypass 10856 Perth-Mandurah Railway 10855, 10856 Roads - Funding and Safety Issues 10856, 10857 West Coast College of TAFE - Carine Campus - Closure 10855 Lobbyists - Burke, Mr Brian - Taxi Industry Decision 10162 Motor Vehicles - Industry - Corrosion Detectors - Petition 65 Parliament - Members and Staff - Driver Fatigue Due to Sitting Hours 6813 Planning Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass 13525 - Hearings Committee Report 13606; Matter of Public Interest 13615; Motion 420; Motion for Disallowance 14108, 14135 Amendment - Southern Rail Link 511 Amendment No 1060/33A - Railway Works within a Road Reservation 9305 Scarborough Senior High School Site - Future Use 2275; Swimming Pool 8728 Planning and Infrastructure, Department for Road Transport Section Investigations - Fuel Tanker Truck Rollover Accidents 9308 Web Site - Updating 10873 Police Attendance at “The Gathering of the Eagles” 14522 Metropolitan Railway System 11434 Multanovas Locations - Fatal Motor Vehicle Accidents 9720; Warning Oncoming Traffic 4623 Revenue - Road Safety Initiatives 7028; Tabling of List of Expenditure 7028 Review of Placement Criteria - Motion 13421 Owner-onus Legislation - Proclamation 8117 Red-light Cameras Revenue - Road Safety Initiatives 7028; Tabling of List of Expenditure 7028 School Crossing Attendants - Travel Allowance 10051 Traffic Management and Road Safety Budget - Underspending 8003, 8183 Ports and Harbours Esperance Port Authority - Cranes, Haulage - Front End Loader Services Contract 3561 Fremantle - Shipping Container Movements 4856, 4857 Kimberley Port - Location 12381 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8809 Procedure and Privileges Committee Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Report 4883 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8594, 8604 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 5847 Consideration in Detail 5875-5889, 6394, 6395 Third Reading 6475 Council’s Amendment 7921 Questions on Notice - Unanswered 3353 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 1054 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1291 Consideration in Detail 1336, 1337, 1340-1344, 1347, 1357-1367 Third Reading 1374 Council’s Amendments 3506-3509 374 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HODSON-THOMAS, MS KATINA (continued) Railways Armadale CBD - Sunday Service 9797 Crossings - Rumble Strips - Installation 8121 Currambine Line - Lengthening of Platforms 8117; Railcars 8122 Female Passengers - Statistics on Safety at Night 4664 Joondalup - Special Events Train Services 9727 Loch and Grant Streets Stations - Partial Closure 4626 New MetroRail - “On Track” Newsletter 12860, 12861 Operational Subsidies 4628 Perth Urban Rail Development - Change of Name to New MetroRail 8118 Police Officers Rostered for Duty 11434 Quinns Road-Hester Avenue - Boom Gates Installation 4629; Level Crossing 8116, 8517 Security Barriers - Installation 4628 Security Guards 9728 South West Metropolitan Railway - Road Reserve 14920 Southern Rail Link Brochures - Number, Cost and Distribution 8121 Budget Details 7358, 14876, 14877 Bus Services - Kwinana Freeway 2999 Cost Blow-out 12067, 12068, 12201, 12324, 12325; Matter of Public Interest 13930 Debt Servicing Cost 2387 Dedicated Busway 4646 Electricity Usage 10879, 11957 Industrial Relations Laws - Impact on Costs 4648 Kwinana Freeway Route - Cost 4622 Matter of Public Interest 2931 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 511 Metropolitan Regional Improvement Fund - Allocation of Funds 4624 Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 1595 Passenger Numbers and Travel Times 3677 Perth Heritage Buildings - Impact 7407 Petition 1971 Railcars - Maximum Number of Passengers 8120 Ramps and Noise Bunds - Cost 4647 Rockingham-Perth Travel Times 4624 Rockingham Transit System 13925, 13926 Sinking Under the Perth CBD 10499 Soil Testing 5450 South Perth Station 2815 Survey of Support for Changed Route 8116 Toilet Facilities on Trains - Cost 4626 Transit Guards 8120 Tunnel under Fremantle Road, Mandurah 8340 William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12091 Transit Guards - Number and Skills 2995, 11315 Urban Rail Development Enhanced Travel Demand Modelling 2523, 2672 Supplementary Master Plan 2522 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13756 Road Traffic Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12718 Roads Albany Highway - Overtaking Lanes 9307 Brand Highway - Overtaking Lanes 9307 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme 13525; Matter of Public Interest 13615; Motion 420; Motion for Disallowance 14108, 14135 Expenditure on Advertising, Publications and Consultation 9728 Hearings Committee Report 13606 Fremantle Port 4856, 4857, 14256 Funding - Cuts 7224, 7522 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 375

HODSON-THOMAS, MS KATINA (continued) Roads (continued) Great Northern Highway - Overtaking Lanes 9307 Greening Freeways - Statement 8962 Hepburn Avenue-Glengarry Drive Roundabout - Statement 13516 Kwinana Freeway 3708, 4623, 8118 Marmion Avenue-Reid Highway-North Beach Road Intersection - Grievance 2354 Regional Road Groups - Wheatbelt North Group Funding Allocation 9303 Road Safety Australasian Spinal Research Trust - Funding 3348 Driver Fatigue - Parliamentary Sitting Hours 6813 Duncraig 8115 Implementation of Strategy 8002 Resources - Matter of Public Interest 8014 Underspending of Budget 8003, 8183 Roads of National Importance - Federal Funding 3088, 3089 South Western Highway - Overtaking Lanes 9307 Tonkin Highway Extension - “Building the Highway” Publication 7940 Toodyay Bypass - Environmental Survey 8114 Schools Bus Service - Contract - Finalisation 8444 Crossing Attendants - Travel Allowance 10051 Duncraig Senior High - Special Education Unit 4168 North Beach Primary - Pedestrian Overpass - Statement 2811 State Finance - Taxes and Charges - Increases - Matter of Public Interest 7037 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11381 Consideration in Detail 11403-11406 Third Reading 11520 Council’s Amendments 14243 Taxis Burke, Mr Brian - Lobbying Activity 10162 Demerit Point Penalty System 4672 Industry Reform - Motion 10622 Multipurpose - Seatbelts 8120 “Multipurpose Taxi Customer Service Charter” 8115 Plate Buyback Program - Lease Arrangements 10566; Macquarie Bank Ltd 5365 Public Liability Insurance - Review 4663, 4672 Survey on Deregulation of Industry 8597 Transport Buses Armadale CBD 9797 Canning Bridge-Perth Central Business District 4646 Kwinana Freeway Bus Service - Cancellation 3925 Rockingham-Fremantle Bus Transit System 4625 School Bus Service - Contract Finalisation 8444 Special Licence Operators - Safety Regulations 8865 Transperth - Transit Guards 9307 Charter Vehicles - Access to Freeway Busways 4676; Temporary Permits 4676 Concessional Fares - Changes 9730 Department - Telephone Service - Waiting Times 9714 Fuel Tanker Trucks - Rollover Accidents 9308 Heavy Vehicle Advisory Group - Membership 4629 Recreational Boating Facilities Scheme - Reallocation of Funds 2995 Regional Areas - Audits 9731 Rockingham Central City Transit Service - Steering Committee 4622 Subsidies - Cost 8119 Water Corporation Advertising Campaign 8272 Karrinyup - Sale of Land 9508 376 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HOUGH, HON FRANCIS CARSON, JP (Agricultural) (ON) Aborigines - Road Safety Directions for Aboriginal Road Users Document 6302 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13138 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 - Third Reading 6314 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4424 Address-in-Reply Motion Country Roads 1151, 1152 Environmental Issues - Misleading Information 1146-1148 Salinity 1149-1153 Water Crisis 1146-1149 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 4249, 4259 Adjournments of the House - Complimentary Remarks 4543 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board Animal Pest Management - Feral Pigs and Emus 2872 Chemical Use - Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Inquiry - Amendment to Motion 10909 Drought Assistance - Exceptional Circumstances Aid 2764; Adjournment Debate 3900 Exceptional Circumstances Claims 11176 Flower Levy 11041 Fox Control Program - Adjournment Debate 580 Genetically Modified Crops - Adjournment Debate 1036 Grain Licensing Authority - Grain Producer Members 5957 Hemp, Industrial - Legalisation 7177 Land, Water and Wool Sustainable Grazing on Saline Lands Subprogram - Funding 12558 Livestock Transport - Fatigue Management Regulations 6459, 7477 Merredin - Evaporation Ponds 4341 Milk Prices - Single Desk for Dairy Industry 10480 Overwidth Loads of Hay and Straw - Restrictions on Travel 5051 Pest Management - Inspections and Bounty 2872 Single Desk System - Statement 11487 Skeleton Weed Eradication Program 1533, 3177 Wheat - Marketing Outstanding Payments - Statement 6091 Single-desk Arrangement - Statement 6461 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Second Reading 2767 Committee 2882-2889 Australian Labor Party - Western Australian Aboriginal Native Title Working Group 43, 164 Bali Bombings - Statement 11179 Belmont, City of - Inquiry - Report 13474 Brazier, Mr Michael - Forfeited Surety 8677 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1825 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7804, 7829, 7960 Capital Punishment - Offenders Convicted of Heinous Crimes - Motion 12986, 13333 Commerce and Trade - United States Free Trade Agreement - Statement 11487 Consumer and Employment Protection - Department Motor Vehicle Industry - Not Guilty Appeals 1005 Staff 553 Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders - Motion 8558, 9183, 9825; Statement 10485 Defence Forces - Lancelin Defence Training Area Environmental and Socioeconomic Impact 13081 Environmental Impact 12162 Public Environmental Review 11207 Statement 9851, 10096 Training Activities 13070 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14685, 14804 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14685, 14804 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14685, 14804 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 377

HOUGH, HON FRANCIS CARSON (continued) Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3463 Employment and Training - Apprentices - Financial Incentive for Ongoing Training 5773 Environment Blair Fox Generation WA Pty Ltd - Poultry Litter-fired Electricity Plant, Muchea 4398 Bringo Motocross Track - Relocation 1262 Greenhouse Gas Emissions - State Government Stand - Urgency Motion 997 Lancelin Defence Training Area - Environmental Impact 12162 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers 7783 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 - Third Reading 730 Fire and Emergency Services - Authority - Advertising 10114 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3456 Firearms Act - Amendments 10364 Licences - Proof of Identity for Renewal 1137 Rifle Clubs - Rents - Adjournment Debate 2605, 2777 Fisheries Crayfish - Operators and Licences 2124 West Coast Rock Lobster Fishery Management Plan Amendment 2003; Disallowance 12123 Folsom Prison - Statement 7649 Forests and Forestry - Infinitree Plantation Program - Salinity Management Benefits 14714 Fuel and Energy Electricity Country Power Supplies 4960; Adjournment Debate 5074 Gnowangerup, Jerramungup and Ravensthorpe Area 12923 Fuel Prices - Impact of International Oil Price 10921; Statement 10926 Petrol - Ethanol 4527 Poultry Litter-fired Electricity Plant, Muchea 4398 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14162 Committee 14631-14633 14643-14649 Third Reading 14728 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1825 Greens (WA) - Salary Increases - Adjournment Debate 580 Health Iatrogenic Illnesses and Deaths 14640, 14775; Statement 14782 Medical Practitioners - Spinal Manipulation - Qualifications 14198; Statement 14782 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2148, 2240 Homeswest - Bogle Way, Geraldton - Fence Height 5195 Houghton, Mr Colin - Adjournment Debate 3467 Iraq Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3016, 3134 Opposition to Proposed War - Urgency Motion 5041 War - Justification - Adjournment Debate 5554; March in Esperance - Statement 5964 Justice, Department of - Convicted Criminals - Right to Compensation 9194 Land Clearing 2345 Law and Order - Adjournment Debate 731, 870 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13138 Lotterywest - Community Service Outlet - Cost 13863 Mauds Landing Development - Advertising Campaign 10117 Members of Parliament Fischer, Hon John - Leave of Absence 10883 Greens (WA) - Salary Increases - Adjournment Debate 580 Stephens, Hon Tom - Betrayal - Adjournment Debate 4986 Ministers of the Crown - Attorney General - Alleged Offences 14033 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 13995 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading 13345, 13873 Motor Vehicles Industry - Not Guilty Appeals 1005 Motor Vehicle Dealers Licence - Adjournment Debate 2507 378 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HOUGH, HON FRANCIS CARSON (continued) Mullewa Break and Enters and Vandalism Incidents - Crime Statistics 12291 Statement 12152 Native Title - Western Australian Aboriginal Native Title Working Group Attendance at ALP State Conference 43, 164 Newdegate and Dowerin Field Days - Adjournment Debate 731, 870, 1036 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10124 Police Anti-terrorist Measures - Additional Staff 4254 Mullewa Station - Crime Statistics 12291 Multanovas Adjournment Debate 3060 Speeding Fine Revenue and Road Deaths 3435, 3873, 4935 Officers - Recruitment 10938 Radar Detectors - Adjournment Debate 3060 Red-light Cameras - Revenue - Road Safety Initiatives 3435 Traffic Accidents - Infringement Notices 7452 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8769 Racing - Cox Plate 2348 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3309 Railways Doodlakine Station - Closure 9361, 10093, 10811 Southern Rail Link - Annual Cost of Operation 7645 Wubin Rail Line 9848 Regional Development - Rural Towns Project - Merredin 4341 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Assembly’s Message 8381-8391 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - Statement 8572 Roads Indian Ocean Drive - Funding 8568 Narrogin-Wagin Link Road - Completion 5534 Road Safety - Aboriginal Road Users 6302 Speed Limits - Reduction to 50 Kilometres and Hour 350 Salinity Beacon River Valley - Deep Drainage Project Funding 4450 Engineering Evaluation Initiative Projects - Funding 11480, 12435 Infinitree Plantation Program - Salinity Management Benefits 14714 Land, Water and Wool Sustainable Grazing on Saline Lands Subprogram - Funding 12558 Methods to Reduce Escalating Problems - Motion 13450 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality - Bilateral Agreement - Signing 5662 Research - Funding 11365 WA Channel Management Group - Funding 10795 Wallatin Creek Catchment Project, Doodlakine 13142 Schools Esperance Senior High - Funding 6083 Funding - Petition 3855 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5639 Seniors - Geraldton - Airconditioning Rebate 864 Sentencing Legislation - Inequities - Adjournment Debate 3467 Sittings of the House - Extended after 6.00 pm - Amendment to Motion 2756 Sport and Recreation Ledge Point Golf Club - Government Funding - Adjournment Debate 1554 Speedway Commission Western Australian - Statutory Authority 5023, 5410 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Petition Objecting to the Proposal to Establish a Sewage Pumping Station in Heseltine Park, Glenlea Road, Busselton - Fourth Report 5002 Swimming Pool Fencing - Adjournment Debate 4986; Sixth Report 5005, 7436 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3157 State Finance - Land Tax - New Assessments 2483 Swimming Pools - Isolation Fencing - Adjournment Debate 4986 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 379

HOUGH, HON FRANCIS CARSON (continued) Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Committee 4013-4022 Transport Driver Fatigue - 30 Minute Rest Breaks 9588 Livestock - Fatigue Management Regulations 6459, 7477 Narrogin - Road Train Traffic 5534 Overwidth Loads of Hay and Straw - Restrictions on Travel 5051 United States of America Australia’s Support for Military Action in Iraq - Motion 3016, 3134 Opposition to Proposed War on Iraq - Urgency Motion 5041 Support for Military - Urgency Motion 1413 Water Corporation Lease Charges 2605 Newdegate Rifle Range - Adjournment Debate 2777 Water Meters - Accuracy 13118 Water Resources Deep Drainage - Assessment of Downstream Impact 1418 Merredin - Evaporation Ponds 4341 Planning for Future Water Supplies for WA - Motion 12136 Rainwater Tanks - Installation 40 Wallatin Creek Catchment Project, Doodlakine 13142 Water and Energy-efficient Homes - Environmental Building Code 40 Water Restrictions - Metropolitan Area - Supplementation of Supplies 11837 Wellington Dam - Salt Content 12144 Yarragadee Aquifer - City Supply 7312 Yenyening Lakes System 9974 Watkins, Christie - Death - Adjournment Debate 272 Western Australian Rifle Association - Newdegate Rifle Range Adjournment Debate 2777 Lease Charges 2605 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1551 Workers Compensation - WorkCover WA - Deadline to Lodge Common Law Claim 2228, 3027 HOUSE, HON BARRY JOHN, BEcon, JP (South West) (Lib) Aborigines Newton Moore Senior High - Absentee Rates 10362 Sites of Significance - Dunsborough Centrepoint Shopping Centre 13005 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Committee 12928-12951 Address-in-Reply Motion Beenup Mine - Environmental Concerns 1430, 1431 Industrial Relations Legislation - Impact 1425 Performance of Gallop Government 1424-1426 Road Funding and Construction 1427-1429 Social and Environmental Law Reform 1425, 1426 Water Supply 1429, 1430 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 3431, 3442 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Chemical Use - Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Inquiry - Amendment to Motion 10909 Dairy Industry 2121, 9552, 10918 Egg Industry - Deregulation - National Competition Council Submission 13117 Landcare Facilitators and Coordinators - Abolition of Positions 241 Midland Saleyards - Sale 160 Potato Marketing in Western Australia - National Competition Policy 5021 Scott Coastal Plain - Water Allocation 14777 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1734 Baudin, Commander Nicolas - Bicentenary of Expedition to Australia - Statement 11367 Boat Moorings - South of Bunbury - Registration Regulations 3867 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13316 Committee 13322-13325 380 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HOUSE, HON BARRY JOHN (continued) Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 9608 Committee 10764-10770 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10459 Colliefields Hotel - Suspension of Licence 4526 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3623-3627 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 7139 Committee 9041, 9045 Courts - Preliminary Hearings - Abolition - Adjournment Debate 730 Cullen, Ms Di - Adjournment Debate 4930 Disability Services - Whale Watching, Augusta and Dunsborough - Facilities for the Disabled 4062 Dogs - Docking of Tails 2479 Drugs - Buprenorphine 12958, 13082 Dunsborough Centrepoint Shopping Centre - Cessation of Work 13005 Education - Department - Buy Local Policy 1258 Environment Firewood - Supplies and Collection 10806 Natural Heritage Trust - Abolition of Landcare Officer Positions 241 Nelson Locations 12889 and 12890 - Forest Conservation Area 9844 Regional Coastal and Marine Facilitator - South Coast Region - Funding 10089 Regional Herbarium Project 3023, 4431 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4907 Second Reading 4976 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers 9150 Forests and Forestry Draft Forest Management Plan - Release - Statement by Leader of the House 10471 Jarrah and Karri Sawlogs - Request for Proposals - Stage B 2225 Manjimup - Furniture Industry 9357 Nelson Locations 12889 and 12890 - Forest Conservation Area 9844 Old-growth Forest - Social and Economic Impact of Policy - Urgency Motion 547 Pinetec Pty Ltd - Competitive Process for Allocation of Pine Resources 13018 Timber Resource 11173 State Forests - Land Swap - Petition 13122 Freycinet Collection - Auction - Adjournment Debate 1037 Fuel and Energy Petroleum Resource Rent Tax 10745 Waterloo-Busselton Transmis sion Line - Route 1009 Gambling Burswood International Resort Casino Additional 200 Gaming Machines 1529 Mr Graham Richardson’s Meeting with Minister 1659 Tax Changes 1419 Burswood Property Trust - Corporatisation - Statement by Minister for Racing and Gaming - Motion 13104 Casino Tax - Shortfall 10808 SuperStar Leo and SuperStar Virgo 7166 Government Contracts - Buy Local Policy 1258 Health Bunbury Pain Management Centre - Funding 12552 Nurses - Prisons - Industrial Action 3610 Office of Mental Health - South West and Lower Great Southern Carer Program 11362 Repatriation Private Patient Scheme 7449 Statement 7648 War Widows - Treatment as Private Patients 7449 Heritage - Ellensbrook Precinct 3174 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 2144 Committee 2747-2750 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 381

HOUSE, HON BARRY JOHN (continued) Hospitals Bunbury Regional 8777, 14028 Busselton District - Bed Numbers 14028 Country Hospital Medical Advisory Committees - Remuneration of Chairmen 5956 Margaret River Statement 12439 Upgrade 12266 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Bunbury Office - Closure 7310 Industrial Development - Gorgon Project 10918 Industrial Hemp Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14081 Justice, Department of - Preliminary Hearings - Abolition - Adjournment Debate 730 Land Clearing - Bush Rural Land 1801, 1949 Margaret River - Land Swap 1135; Petition - Adjournment Debate 1670 Liquor Deregulation of Industry 11477 Licensing Authority - Review 5820 Changes to Laws - Submissions to National Competition Council 12140, 12922, 13117 Consultation on Policy 12003 National Competition Policy 4956, 5408, 13346 Licensing Bulletin - Purpose, Cost, Staff and Distribution 2513 Liquor Stores - Sunday Trading 8565, 10745 National Competition Policy Payments 11832 Rugby World Cup - Extended Hours for Liquor Outlets 10246, 10252, 10807 Summary of Transactions, Annual Return 11204 Lotterywest Increase in Price of Lotto Tickets 549 Name Change of Lotteries Commission to Lotterywest 6954 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 13994 Committee 13996 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading 13340 Motor Vehicles - Stamp Duty - Petition 696 National Competition Council Liquor Licensing Guidelines 5408 Government’s Submission 13346 National Competition Policy 4956 Potato Marketing in Western Australia - Funding Implications 5021 Parks and Reserves - Scott River National Park - Inclusion of Reserves 13858 Planning Leeuwin-Naturaliste Statement of Planning Policy - Smiths Beach 2601 Mauds Landing Development - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd 10745 Peel Region Scheme - Disallowance 5543 Statement by Minister for Racing and Gaming 13109, 13578 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 365-372, 456 Police Augusta Station - Staffing 12286, 12430 East Perth Station - Infringement Notice Booklets 3434 Prisons Bunbury Regional - Adjournment Debate 5032 Nurses - Industrial Action 3610 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7138 Racing Betting Exchanges on Australian Racing 9582 Betting Transactions - Minimum Levels 4900 Bookmakers - Telephone Betting Limits 2760 British Gambling Exchanges - Impact 6580 Cross-border Betting - Report 4025 382 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HOUSE, HON BARRY JOHN (continued) Racing (continued) Lark Hill Racing Complex 2348, 2349 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Board Composition 5191, 5312 Costs 2512 Distribution of Net Profits 2513 Racing Radio - Programming Format Change 10807 Racing Restriction Act - Relocation of Race Meetings - Statement by Minister for Racing and Gaming 13106 Rules of Harness Racing 1999; Amendment - Adjournment Debate 1836 Western Australian Trotting Association - Consultation 2345 Western Australian Turf Club - Van Heemst, Mr Ted 1003 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7955 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7955 Committee 8650-8670, 8680 Recommittal 8681 Racing, Gaming and Liquor, Department of Appeals to Supreme Court 7996 Staff with Legal Qualifications 5820 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7955 Railways - WA Government Railways Commission - Manjimup and Donnybrook Subdivisions 3634 Regional Development - Buy Local Policy - Nature of Local Business 2650 Retail Trading Australia Day - Extended Trading Permits 5049, 5819 Liquor Stores - Sunday Trading 8565 Roads Bussell Highway 704, 3617 Busselton Bypass and Strelly Street Intersection - Traffic Lights 3727 Funding - Condemnation of Government - Motion 9343 Peel Deviation - N1.5 and N3 Routes 4252, 4339 Regional Road Groups - Funding - Urgency Motion 5401 Schools Bus Service Augusta Students - Fare Concessions 8673; 9567 Busselton-Yallingup Steiner School Bus Route - Replacement Bus 4447 Country Students - Fare Concessions 7821; Petition 10055 Garaging Allowance 7643 Student Concessions - South West - Adjournment Debate 5322 Subsidy - Petition 10055 Busselton Senior High - Fast Track Program 5196 Margaret River Senior High Bus Fare Concessions for Augusta Students 8673, 9567 Funding 4063 Newton Moore Senior High - Aboriginal Children - Absentee Rate 10362, 14635 Non-government - Funding - Petition 7122 Non-profit Private Country School - Water Efficiency Rebate 6298 Scott, Mr Allie - Southern Senior of the Year - Adjournment Debate 1447 Select Committee into Water Services - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7151 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5295-5299 Sessional Orders - Continuation and Amendment - Motion 14845 Sewerage Busselton Waste Water Treatment Plant - Industrial Liquid Waste 5319 Heseltine Park Pumping Station, Busselton - Petition 337 Waste Water Treatment Plants - Industrial Liquid Waste 6607 Small Business - Improvement Program - Closure 6278 Sport and Recreation Noalimba Recreation Camp - Sale 38 Pemberton Sports Club - Government Property Purchase 11194 Rugby World Cup - Extended Hours for Liquor Outlets 10246, 10252, 10807 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 383

HOUSE, HON BARRY JOHN (continued) Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Petition Opposing the Gnarabup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Third Report 4313 Petition Opposing the Establishment of the Sewage Pumping Station in Heseltine Park, Glenlea Road, Busselton - Fourth Report 5002 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3156 Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance A Sessional Overview of the Committee’s Operation - Second Report 4001 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Report - Extension of Time 7464 Inquiry into the Transfer of Management of Fremantle Cemetery to the Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Extension of Reporting Time 12911 Local Government Act 1995 - Sixth Report 14825 Petition on Western Power’s Underground Power Policy - Fifth Report 14779 Second Report - 1663 Transfer of Management of the Fremantle Cemetery to the Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Fourth Report 14669 State Administrative Tribunal - Statement 10924 State Finance Burswood International Resort Casino - Impact of Tax Changes 1419 Stamp Duty - Motor Vehicles - Petition 696 Taxation Casino Tax - Shortfall 10808 Petroleum Resource Rent Tax 10745 Totalisator Agency Board 5531, 5772 Tourism Bunbury Regional Events Unit 9970 Northcliffe - Unsealed Roads 13469 Whale Watching Augusta and Dunsborough - Facilities for the Disabled 4062 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2620 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6559 Water Resources Farm Dams - Management Charges - Community Consultation Groups 10112, 10477; Statement 10483 Farm Water Grants Scheme - Applications 6456 Manjimup and Nannup Shires - Statement 9199 Non-profit Private Country School - Water Efficiency Rebate 6298 Quinninup 13125 Scott Coastal Plain - Test Hole for Water Bore Licence 14769; Water Allocation 14777 Scott River Basin - Ground Water 6 Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 7151 Yarragadee Aquifer - South West Water Extraction 9192 Western Power - Waterloo-Busselton Electricity Transmission Line - Petition 337 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7429

HOUSE, HON MONTAGUE GRANT, JP (Stirling) (NPA) Albany Port Authority - Advertising of Positions on Board 4680 Amity House, Albany - Redevelopment 5756 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Agricultural Colleges 7666 Environment 7669 Fishing Industry 7667 Government Debt 7668 Health 7667 Rural and Regional Western Australia 7666 Rural Power Supplies 7667 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7665 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1503 Cardiac Recovery and Intervention Programs - Funding 14146 Colleges of TAFE - Class Sizes and Workload of Lecturers 5628 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1182 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13181 384 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HOUSE, HON MONTAGUE GRANT (continued) Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13217 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13643 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13217 Second Reading 13223 Consideration in Detail 13511-13513 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13217 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13643 Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9704 Environment Biodiversity Conservation Act Consultation Paper 8138 Friends of the Porongurup Range Inc - Assistance to Purchase Farming Property 2845 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 13406, 13419 Fuel and Energy Electricity Reform - Rural and Regional Areas 4675 South West Interconnected System 4680 Fuel Prices - Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection’s Lack of Action - Matter of Public Interest 922 Solar Hot Water Systems - Rebates 9506 Government Departments and Agencies - Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14455-14458, 14461, 14470, 14472, 14475-14478, 14481-14483, 14954 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1503 Consideration in Detail 1580-1582 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11710 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - Motion 1182 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion, as Amended 10663 Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection - Lack of Action on Fuel Prices - Matter of Public Interest 922 Parliament - Regional - Albany Sitting - Motion 14061 Planning - Signature of Minister’s Delegate on Assignment of Lease Documents - Delay 14557 Public Accounts Committee Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14223 Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1182 Port Coogee Development - Sixth Report 14229 Visiting Medical Practitioners - Tabling of Papers 4077 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 7082 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1343 Regional Development Great Southern Development Commission - Wages and Achievements 13276 Peel Development Commission - Wages and Achievements 14488 South West Development Commission - Wages and Achievements 14488 Wheatbelt Development Commission - Wages and Achievements 13276 Roads - Great Southern Region - Expenditure 4676 Sewerage Timewell Road Treatment Plant, Albany 13985 Walpole Waste Water Treatment Plant - Effluent Overflow 5754 State Forests Nos 15, 39 and 64 - Partial Revocation of Dedication - Motion 14085 Western Power Budget Allocations 9506 Power Poles - Rural and Regional Areas 5509

HYDE, MR JOHN NORMAN, BA, DipEd (Perth) (ALP) Army Museum of WA - Fremantle Artillery Barracks - Amendment to Motion 10995 Attorney General - Decisions on Matters Involving Allegations of Criminal Behaviour by Cabinet Members - Motion 803 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1753 Building Industry - Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5846 Cannabis - Decriminalisation - Petition 9855 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6738 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 385

HYDE, MR JOHN NORMAN (continued) Community Development and Justice Standing Committee - Annual Report 2001-02 1688 Consumer and Employment Protection Bromley, Mr Stuart - Breach of Travel Agents Act 3492 Community Education Program 1791 Illegal Retail Trading from a Residential Home in East Perth - Grievance 9993 Itinerant Salesmen - Sale of Stereo Speakers from the Back of Vans 10825 Prestige Coatings and Restorations - Grievance 5335 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5846 Container Deposit Legislation - Grievance 1279 Convention and Exhibition Centre - Budget and Timing 1781 Conventions and Exhibitions 9236 Corruption and Crime Commission - Legislation 7519 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 Second Reading 8172, 8183 Consideration in Detail 8329, 8332, 8334 Delay 11781 Crime - Government Initiatives 8442 Curfew for Juveniles in Northbridge Government’s Commitment 12198, 12321 Legal Challenge by Youth Affairs Council 9872 Plans for introduction 6678 Defamation and Libel Laws - Grievance 3198 Disability Services Nylander, Mr Owen - Petition 5452 Sexton, Mr Peter - Petition 6468 East Perth Power Station Site - Future Use 13610 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill - Consideration in Detail 2377 Fire and Emergency Services Levy- Matter of Public Interest 10178; Amendment to Motion 10179 Heritage Court Hotel - Petition 10169 Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 526 William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12085; Amendment on the Amendment 12098 Housing - Affordable - Grievance 2355 Infill Sewerage Program - Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 2697 Joint Standing Committee on the Anti-Corruption Commission Annual Report 2001-02 1982 Annual Report 2002-03 11085 Hearing with the Anti-Corruption Commis sion on 25 August 2003 - Sixth Report 12582 Integrity within the Public Sector - Third Report 6141 Report on Hearing with the Anti-Corruption Commission - Fourth Report 6932 Seventh Report - National Conference of Parliamentary Oversight Committees of Anti- Corruption/Crime Bodies 2003 14239 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3689 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2028 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Petition 12327 Sales in Restaurants - Petition 13773, 14215 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Overseas Aid 10866 Parliamentary Conduct 10867 Local Government - Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 526 Mauds Landing Development - Rejection Decision - Motion 9915 Native Title Mining Tenements - Validity 401 Representative Bodies - Pressure to Deliver Results 2271 Nuclear Waste Importation into Western Australia - Petition 879 Storage Facility - Petition 1053 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 Second Reading 13819 386 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

HYDE, MR JOHN NORMAN (continued) Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 (continued) Third Reading 13823 Personal Explanation - Withdrawal of Comment 9434 Police Community Operations - Motion 4765 Government’s Pre-election Promises - Motion 14104 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7060 Questions on Notice - Answers - Government’s Failure to Provide 11394 Rally Australia - Agreement to Stay in Western Australia 6187 Retail Trading - Illegal - East Perth Residential Home - Grievance 9993 Roads Lane Width Reductions - Narrows Bridge 3233 Parking Offenders - Statement 5713 Safer WA Community Security Program - City of Perth 2573 Schools Broadband Rollout - Benefits 8966 Retention Rates 2672 Select Committee on the Infill Sewerage Scheme - Establishment - Motion 2697 Southern Rail Link City Section 7883 Foreshore Opportunities 6489 Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 1600 Sinking Under the Perth CBD 8893 Urban Enhancements and Streetscape Improvements 5833 William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12085; Amendment on the Amendment 12098 Stamp Duty - Rental Businesses - Grievance 890 Standing Committee on Community Development and Justice - Emergency Services Legislation in Western Australia - Second Report 2792 State Debt - Blow-out 770 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3534 Total Waste Management, Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion 5270 TravelSmart - Grievance 7855 Unified Buddhist Church of Vietnam - Petition 12327 Victims of Crime Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 11088 Volunteering WA - Student Community Involvement Program - Progress 5445 Water Resources - Management - Matter of Public Interest 2400 Wellington Dam - Hydro-electric Power Generator 2577 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 11407

JOHNSON, HON ROBERT FRANK, JP (Hillarys) (Lib) Aborigines Child Protection Workers - Placement 11628 Gordon Inquiry Documents 3778 Evidence 3777 Funding Allocations 2270 Implementation of Recommendations - Funding 9086 New Allegations or Evidence 1462 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 2944, 2953-2959, 2965, 2966, 2969 Third Reading 2976 Address-in-Reply Motion - Gordon Inquiry 3968 Amendments to Motion Health Services 122 Water Shortages 227, 289 Adjournments of the House - Complimentary Remarks 4149, 9465, 14302 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 1853 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 387

JOHNSON, HON ROBERT FRANK (continued) Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 (continued) Consideration in Detail 3081-3087, 3094-3097, 3100, 3103, 3205, 3209, 3210, 3213-3222, 3237, 3242, 3243, 3357-3402 Third Reading 3557 Council’s Amendments 5728-5732 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading - Neurotrauma Research - Funding 4135 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 4) 2002 - Second Reading 4139 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Cannabis Law Reform 7552 Hillarys Boat Harbour 7548 Prostitution 7553 Rottnest Island 7550 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8461 Third Reading 8583 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7548 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8461 Auditor General, Office of - Budget - Motion 11727 Bali Bombings - Anniversary - Standing Orders Suspension 11894 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 12191 Standing Orders Suspension 12217 Beach Tavern, Mullaloo - Petition 5091, 6470 Bills, Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion, as Amended 407 Business of the House Closing Days - Standing Orders Suspension - Motion 13679 Management 1468 Motion 3071 Private Members’ Business - Standing Orders Suspension 14078 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Council’s Message 13215 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Council’s Message 13215 Cabinet Meetings - Government’s Election Promise - Motion 6009 Secretary - Cabinet Minutes 5373 Cannabis Decriminalisation - Dependence and Mental Illness 7882 Fawcett, Mrs Julie - Invitation to Appear to Bar of the House - Standing Orders Suspension 7680, 7686 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6695 Consideration in Detail 6752, 6753, 6763, 6857, 6858, 6876, 6881 Standing Orders Suspension 6881 Third Reading 6930 Debate - Absence of Premier 6812 Refusal of Minister for Police and Minister for Community Development to Speak 6812 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 - Third Reading 10000 Committees and Boards - Appointments Details 11531 Tabling of Boards and Committees Register 11787 Community Development Care and Protection Orders Funding Cuts 12739 Number of Applications 13840 Child Abuse Government Inaction - Matter of Public Interest 9096 Investigation of Allegations 3230 Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 1880, 2298; Amendment to Motion 2287 Child Death Review Committee - Hon Kay Hallahan - Terms of Employment 6037 Child Protection Appointment of Officers in Aboriginal Communities 11628, 14955 Underresourcing 9090 388 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

JOHNSON, HON ROBERT FRANK (continued) Community Development (continued) Children Placed in Out-of-home and Alternative Care - Number 13840 Commissioner for Children - Appointment 9090 Department Child Protection Workers 14955 Staff Morale 13668 Grandparents as Primary Carers - Grievance 9995 Wards of the State - Powers of Department 11742 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Standing Orders Suspension 14897 Motion 14903 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1183, 1184 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 Standing Orders Suspension 6151 Second Reading 10835, 10946 Disability Services Drury, Mr Matthew - Petition 5453 Paterson, Mr Fraser - Petition 10264 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 Second Reading 5136 Consideration in Detail 5359 Education and Health Standing Committee - Leave to Sit When House is Sitting 1691 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Declaration as Urgent 13216 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 13216 Second Reading 13251 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Declaration as Urgent 13216 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2205 Energy Operators and Water Agencies (Powers) Amendment Bill 2003 - Declaration as Urgent 6031 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Referral to Legislation Committee 1487 Appointment of Members 1488 Esperance Port Authority - Anwyl, Ms Megan 8269 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2205 Freedom from Fear Campaign - Cancellation 280 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8216 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3524 Gaming Machines - “Australia’s Gambling Industry” Recommendations 1708 Government Departments and Agencies Pay Dispute - Industrial Action 14076 Privatisation - Government’s Position 12469 Guardianship and Administration Board - Applications - Number 4705 Health Department - Thornton, Ms Jean - Allegations 9667, 9875 Family Early Intervention Program - Funding Cuts 12739 Management of Health System - Matter of Public Interest 11632 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petitions 6469 Seniors - Physiotherapy and Mobility Classes - Funding Cuts 11623 Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Select Committee - Motion 10322; Amendment to Motion 10324 Hillarys Boat Harbour - Beachfront Parking Fees 11112 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Council’s Message 1387 Motion 1489 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion, as Amended 407 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11765 Standing Orders 12875 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment (Prohibition of Human Cloning) Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 12876 Industrial Relations - Government Action on Disputes - Minister’s Meeting with Public Sector Unions 14076 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 389

JOHNSON, HON ROBERT FRANK (continued) Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 647, 656, 1113-1116 Referral to Public Accounts 1122 Iraq War - Standing Orders Suspension - Motion 5440 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 4717, 8973 Legislative Assembly - Committees - Use of Videoconferencing - Motion 9400 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Government Intranet - Use of For Promoting Members 11120 Hillarys Boat Harbour - Parking 11124 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - Motion 1183, 1184 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion 10514 Amendments to Motion 10523, 10551, 10555 Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10684 Acting Speaker’s Ruling 10660 Dissent from Acting Speaker’s Ruling 10660, 10662 Disclosure Standards 1046, 1047 Leader of the Opposition Censure Motion 4869 Standing Orders Suspension 4864 Amendment to Motion 4865 Member for Swan Hills - Leave of Absence 746 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General - Media Statement 13918 Minister for Health - Discussions with and Copies to Staff 1306 Ministers of the Crown Absence from Parliamentary Sittings 1713 Former Minister for Health - Portfolio Change 10167 Minister for Health - Thornton, Ms Jean - Allegations Against Former Minister for Health 9667, 9875 Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Expenditure on Parliamentary Refreshments 5831 Minister for Police and Emergency - Expenditure on Parliamentary Refreshments 5831 Ministerial Code of Conduct - Expenditure by Ministers 5831 Parliamentary Secretaries - Ministerial Code of Conduct - Expenditure 5833 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No.2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 8957 National Competition Council - Threat to Payments Motion 12477 Standing Orders Suspension 12470 Parliament Regional - Albany Sitting - Motion 14059 Sitting Hours 1468 Personal Explanation - Fraudulent Behaviour by Members of Parliament 9393 Police - Government’s Pre-election Promises - Motion 14105 Prisons Child Rapist - Parole Denial 3232 Paroled Prisoner Release into Custody of Uniting Church Minister 3232 Explanations of Decisions to Release 3233 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 8199, 8590 Standing Orders Suspension 9243 Consideration in Detail 9276-9278, 9285, 9290, 9291, 9406 Public Accounts Committee - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1183, 1184 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 5862 Consideration in Detail 5876, 5877 Third Reading 6478 Questions without Notice - Standing Orders Suspension 13388 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 390 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

JOHNSON, HON ROBERT FRANK (continued) Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6379 Radio Lollipop - Statement 11107 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Urgent Bill 514, 515 Second Reading 760 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1298 Standing Orders Suspension 1325 Third Reading 1384 Rally Australia - New Contract 4861, 4862 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13776 Consideration in Detail 13798 Retail Trading Hours Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 8875 Second Reading 8907 Rottnest Island Accommodation Upgrade and Repair 13608; Motion 13712 Auditor General’s Report 13695 Management Plan - Implementation of Recommendations 13696, 13697 Task Force - Role 13607 Schools - Non-government - Funding - Petition 3908 Select Committee into Child Abuse in Western Australia - Establishment - Motion 1880; Amendment to Motion 2297, 2298 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Motion 10322; Amendment to Motion 10324 Seniors - Physiotherapy and Mobility Classes - Funding Cuts 11623 Small Business - Energy Reforms - Reduction in Electricity Prices 12764 Southern Rail Link - William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Amendment on the Amendment 12100 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 - Consideration in Detail 1692 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8492 Standing Orders Suspension - Completion of Matter of Public Interest 1602 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Standing Orders Suspension 10425 State Government Insurance Office - Privatisation - Government’s Position 12469 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 Second Reading 14280 Consideration in Detail 14285-14289 Swan River - Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion Dis sent from Acting Speaker’s Ruling 8806 Speaker’s Ruling 8807 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3534 Standing Orders Suspension 3355 Tourism - Election Commitment - Funding 7517 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading Department of the Premier and Cabinet - Public Relations Officers 9116 Hillarys Boat Harbour - Fire 9117 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1489 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion, as Amended 407 Waste Disposal - Total Waste Management, Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion - Question to be Put 5270 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11296 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8877 Western Power Disaggregation - Electricity Prices 12764 Managing Director - Directorships and Board Memberships 10161 William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Amendment on the Amendment 12100 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1489 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion, as Amended 407 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 391

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES, BSc, DipEd, JP, Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection; Training (to 14 January); Indigenous Affairs (from 27 June); Minister Assisting the Minister for Public Sector Management (from 27 June); Leader of the House in the Legislative Assembly (Nollamara) (ALP) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3482 Second Reading 3482 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Third Reading 2361 Adjournments of the House Complimentary Remarks 4147, 9465, 14301 Special 1726, 2418, 4147, 4885, 5752, 6935, 7922, 9465, 12880, 14301, 14916 Agriculture Dairy Industry - Select Committee - Appointment of Members 9258 Elevated Work Platforms - Safety Regulations 10166 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes Presentation and Adoption 8463 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8463 Third Reading 8590 Bali Bombings - Anniversary Standing Orders Suspension 11895 Statement by Member for Kingsley 11895 Bills, Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper 70 - Motion 379; Amendment to Motion 404; Motion, as Amended 411 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14313, 14340 Building Industry Building and Construction Site Inspections and Reports 5177 Building Code of Conduct - Code Monitoring Committee 1761 Building Industry and Special Projects Directorate Complaints by Union Officials 11819; Personal Explanation 11894 Criticism 400 Effectiveness 7945 Building Trades - Licensing 13985 Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5842 Commonwealth Legislation - Statement 12573 Concrete Construction Methods - Statement 3068 Crane Accidents Corner of Milligan and Hay Streets - Investigation 11956 Operator Training 5173, 11562 Crane Industry Review - Industries Covered 11562 Crane Safety Standards Working Group Causes of Incidents Leading to Establishment 4698 New Regulations - Statement 11746 Home Indemnity Insurance Albany - Grievance 887 Mutual Fund 14251, 14252 Protests by Builders, Subcontractors and Building Suppliers 1464, 1465 Interim National Building Industry Task Force - Establishment 400 Special Projects Inspectorate - Draft Memorandum of Understanding with Police Service 1761 Standard Working Week - Reduction 4155 Working Days Lost through Industrial Disputes 3674 Workplace Health and Safety in the Building and Construction Industry Discussion Paper - Submissions 1767 Workplace Safety 10818, 10967 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 10266 Second Reading 10266 Consideration in Detail 11522-11526 Third Reading 11527 Business of the House Closing Days of Session - Standing Orders Suspension - Motion 13678 Management 1468 Motion 3071, 8614 Order of Business 91, 1176 392 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Business of the House (continued) Private Members’ Business Precedence 1853 Standing Orders Suspension 6791, 7659, 14078 Standing Orders Suspension 9238 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Council’s Message 13214 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Council’s Message 13214 Cabinet Meetings - Government’s Election Promise - Motion 6025 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 6774, 6852-6854, 6867, 6881 Dissent from Deputy Speaker’s Ruling 6898 Question to be Put 6755, 6771, 6851, 6863, 6868, 6877, 6900, 6906, 6908, 6916 Referral to Joint Select Committee - Question to be Put 6770 Standing Orders Suspension 6881; As to Question to be Put 6866; Question to be Put 6867 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3712 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 8747-8754 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee 1096 Cole Royal Commission - Findings about Rule of Law - Matter of Public Interest 5842 Colleges of TAFE Class Numbers 3709 Corporate Services - Centralisation 3780 West Coast College of TAFE Carine Campus Closure 1768 Sale 1728 Hospitality Training Centre - Statement 2352 Committees and Boards Appointments 11560 Members - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7753 Committees of the House - Appointment 70 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14392, 14397 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Declaration as Urgent 3104 Consumer and Employment Protection Bromley, Mr Stuart - Breach of Travel Agents Act 3492 Community Education Program 1791 Consumer Credit Grants 8177 Consumer Justice Strategy - Statement 4068 Consumer Protection Boards and Committees - Statement 9382 Department Media Statement - Photocopying of Legal Tender 9148 Property Investment Seminar 12765 Extended Working Hours Review Panel - Membership and Terms of Reference 11950 Fair Trading Legislation 11908 Ferguson, Mr Peter - 5 Columba Street, Bunbury 9803, 10326, 14985 Financial Counsellors Association of WA - Statement 11247 FuelWatch - Quantifiable Benefits for Consumers 13926 Illegal Retail Trading from a Residential Home in East Perth - Grievance 9994 Itinerant Salesmen - Sale of Stereo Speakers from the Back of Vans 10825 Kaye Group - National Investment Institute 13815 Mezzanine Financing 283, 5372, 7656 Prestige Coatings and Restorations - Grievance 5336 Reference No 0211682 - Number of Complaints 1769 Soft Furnishings Businesses - Backyard Operators 9802 Solar Eclipse Sunglasses 3780 Statement 3069 Strata Management Industry Report - Statement 11896 Wealth Creation Seminars - Property Investment Adviser Regulations 11627 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3913 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 393

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 (continued) Second Reading 3913, 4620 Consideration in Detail 4845-4853, 5488, 5489, 5506, 5507 Referral to Select Committee 5498 Third Reading 5591, 5698 Council’s Amendments 9293 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Third Reading 6504 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Receipt 14896 Standing Orders Suspension 14896 Motion 14898 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 9456 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1182; Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1193 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Standing Orders Suspension Amendment to Motion - Question to be Put 6154 Question to be Put 6157 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 - Third Reading 12599 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13178 Disability Services - Pryce, Ms Jacinta - Petition 11261 Education Read Write Now - Termination of Contracts 3419, 3420 Teachers - Pay Rise - Matter of Public Interest 10971 Education and Health Standing Committee - Leave to Sit When House is Sitting 1691 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003; Electricity Industry Bill 2003; Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Declaration as Urgent 13218 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 1572 Second Reading 1573 Employment Advocate, Office of the - Workplace Agreements - Interpretation of No-disadvantage Test 3932 Employment and Training Apprentices - Transfield Services 2671 Business Grow - North West 3413 Enterprise Options Program - North West 3413 Read Write Now - Termination of Contracts 3419, 3420 Technology and Training Centres - North West 3414 Training Bunbury Automotive Training Facility - Minister’s Visit - Morning Tea 1728 Burrup Skills Task Force - Statement 477 Crane Operators - Accredited Trainers 11562 Internet Skills Training - Advertising Campaign 1709 Qatar Training Program - Statement 273 Western Australian Group Training Scheme 4174 Unemployment - Increase in Rate 1770 Energy Operators and Water Agencies (Powers) Amendment Bill 2003 - Declaration as Urgent 6031 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Referral to Legislation Committee 1487 Appointment of Members 1489 Estimates Committees Procedure and Privileges Committee’s Report - Statement 2917 Report of Management Committee 7706 Standing Orders Suspension 7390 Statement 6608 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 - Leave to Consider 930 Fawcett, Mrs Julie - Invitation to Appear to Bar of the House - Standing Orders Suspension 7685 Finance Brokers Control Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14062 Second Reading 14062 Finance Broking Industry - Part Repeal of Act - Statement 1971 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 1570 Second Reading 1570 394 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Fuel Prices Differential between City and Country 1052 Government’s Policy - ACCC Letter 772 Maximum Wholesale Price System 3000 Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection’s Lack of Action - Matter of Public Interest 927 Terminal Gate Price - Statement 1974 FuelWatch Expansion 10681 Financial Benefits 7885 Quantifiable Benefits for Consumers 13926 Government Advertising - Expenditure 6778 Government Contracts - Statistics 6779 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14444, 14452 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3712 Cleaning Services 6407, 13765, 13769 Club/Association Memberships 7397, 9775 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 14141, 14510, 14970 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 7940 Credit Cards 7403, 12740, 14508 Creditors 6207, 9754 Employment Contracts 7093 Grants - Number Value and Acquittals of Funding 12888, 12904 Indigenous People - Number Classification and Redundancies 5163 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 7104 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14974 Leave Liability 5154 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14369, 14385 Leschenault Estuary - Management 5911 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Govern ment 6402 North West - Staff and Programs 3405 Paid Parental Leave - Statement 6334 Pay Dispute - Industrial Action 13810, 14076 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10706, 10712 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7775 Public Sector Management Act 1994 - Review - Statement 11376 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14405, 14423 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14458, 14481 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7760 Staff “Attached List” 1395 Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14533, 14539 Seconded from Unions WA or Individual Unions 7778 Unfilled and Acting Positions 666 Unions WA or Individual Unions - Grants 9716 Web Sites - Online Payments 10723, 10730 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14550 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 692 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 7593 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 7593 Motorcycles - Statistics 6780 Privately Plated 6780 Hairdressers Registration Board - Annual Report 2002 7779 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14392, 14397 Health Asbestos - Buildings on Corner of William and Murray Streets, Perth 1767, 4705, 4879 Department - Thornton, Ms Jean - Allegations 9665 Management of Health System - Standing Orders Suspension 11629 Smoking - Environmental Tobacco Smoke in Workplace 9146, 9793 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 395

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Health (continued) Tetrahydrocannabinol - Acceptable Level of Impairment in the Workplace 9792 Heritage - William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Amendment on the Amendment 12095 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion 379; Amendment to Motion 404; Motion, as Amended 411 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1489, 1495 Council’s Amendments 3076-3081 Housing and Works, Department of - Tenants - Antisocial Behaviour - Amendment to Motion 8627 Industrial Relations Reforms - Economic Impact of 5451 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula Burrup Skills Task Force - Statement 477 Comments by Leader of the Opposition 5579 Industrial Action 2523, 2670 Monro’s Plantation Tea Rooms - Closure 3670 Industrial Hemp Bill 2003 - Declaration as Urgent 14080 Industrial Relations Beachside Café, Albany - Investigation 2169 Compulsory Bargaining Services Fees - Government Support 5996 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union 36-hour Working Week Campaign 401, 4155 Action on Burrup Peninsula 2523, 2670 BGC Construction Correspondence 4700 Claims by Hon Tony Abbott in the Sunday Times 8729 Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5842 Intimidatory Tactics 3853 Log of Claims 4170 Membership - Pressure Tactics 9730 Pattern Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 5827, 9743 Right-of-entry Privileges - Abuse 3853 Safety Complaints 1467 Targeting of Safety Issues on Building Sites 10594 Workplace Safety 8638, 10818, 10967 Construction Industry - Working Days Lost through Industrial Disputes 3674 Crane Safety Standards Report - Statement 14 Drug and Alcohol Testing of Employees - Union’s Position 5913 Employer-employee Agreements Number Registered 8127, 14523 Registrar’s Determinations 8755 Registration 5910, 5911, 6682, 7944 Enterprise Bargaining Agreements - Publication 6790, 7597 Freedom of Association Rules - Federal Court Case 1770 Government Action on Disputes - Minister’s Meeting with Public Sector Unions 14076 Government Leadership - Matter of Public Interest 10971 Hours of Work for Employees 11399 Industrial Disputes - Number 12325 Legislation Advertising Costs 687, 3854 Schapper, Mr Derek - Drafting 1766 Small Business 126 Tourism Industry - Motion 1625 Transition Period 1770 Longer Working Hours - Review - Statement 8278 Minimum Conditions of Employment Act - Accrued Sick Leave Payments 5827 National Wage Case - Importance to Basic Living Standards 6683; Statement 7021, 8580 Paid Parental Leave - Statement 6334 Pilbara Mine Workers Union - Registration 9715, 11818 Prosecutions for Breaches of Workplace Laws 1762 Reforms Impact on Western Australian Economy 5451 396 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Industrial Relations (continued) Reforms (continued) Statement 376 Right of Entry List of Authorised Union Representatives - WA Industrial Relations Commission Web Site 1201 Shops and Warehouse (Wholesale and Retail Shops) State Award 1977 - Impact of Introduction 1763 Tracey, Mr Will - Union Entry Permit 3848 Unfair Dismissal Laws - Impact on Small and Medium Businesses 4678 Unions Building Industry 400 Compulsory Charges 1768 Exemption under Act from Access to Medical Information 1768, 1769 Provision under which to take Action for Disclosure of Employee’s Private Details 1769 Right of Entry to Work Sites - BGC Construction Correspondence 4701 Workers’ Minimum Standards - Statement 1851 Workplace Agreements Abolition 11113 Back Paying of Employees 11392 Date for Cessation 1763 Grievance 2360 Minimum Legal Standards for AWAs 5995 No-disadvantage Test - Interpretation by Office of the Employment Advocate 3932 Workplace Bullying - Statement 5682 Workplace Health and Safety - ILO Convention 155 - Statement 6472 Workplace Health and Safety in the Building and Construction Industry Discussion Paper - Submissions 1767 Insurance Employers Indemnity Supplementation Fund Surcharge - Statement 5681 HIH Insurance Collapse - Costs to the State 5171 Home Indemnity Insurance Albany Building Industry - Grievance 887 Mutual Fund 14251, 14252 Protests by Builders, Subcontractors and Building Suppliers 1464, 1465 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1113 Iraq War - Standing Orders Suspension - Motion 5440 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation - Membership Change 9857 Joint Standing Committee on the Anti-Corruption Commission - Membership Change 13679 Labour Relations Reform Bill 2002 Proclamation - Statement 882 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Third Reading 9135 Legislative Assembly Committees - Use of Videoconferencing - Motion 9399 Sittings in 2004 10676; Statement 10383 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2010 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10430 Local Government Belmont, City of - Inquiry 11113 South West Land Division - Private Ownership of Land 10564 Wanneroo, City of City Watch Patrol - Underpayment of Officers 14984 Employment and Management Practices 13277 Machinery of Government (Miscellaneous Amendments) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14260 Second Reading 14260 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee Information Divulged - Motion 1182; Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1193 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 1765 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Notice of Motion 9242 Amendment to Motion 10555; Standing Orders Suspension 10554 Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10606, 10682; Dissent from Acting Speaker’s Ruling 10662 Motion, as Amended 10664 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 397

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Members of Parliament (continued) Leader of the Opposition Censure Motion 4878; Standing Orders Suspension 4864, 4865 Comments on Burrup Development 5579 Travel Allowance 13694 Member for Ballajura - Leave of Absence 8875 Member for Swan Hills - Leave of Absence 746 Opposition Members - Statements - Standing Orders Suspension 4110 Ministers of the Crown Accountability - Standing Orders Suspension - Question to be Put 11118 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 7408 Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection Lack of Action on Fuel Prices - Matter of Public Interest 927 Building Industry and Special Projects Directorate - Personal Explanation 11894 Minister for Health Statement - Standing Orders Suspension 14258 Thornton, Ms Jean - Allegations Against Former Minister for Health 9665 Minister for Housing and Works - Allegations of Ministerial Impropriety - Standing Orders Suspension 9220 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4587; Standing Orders Suspension 4565 Minister for Training - Delegation to China - Statement 4070 Mobile Phones - Use 4804 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10714, 10716 Premier - Accountability - Standing Orders Suspension - Question to be Put 11118 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 5143, 14431, 14439 Corporate Credit Cards 8248, 9920, 12102, 12510, 13985 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9780 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4810 Seconded from Unions WA or Individual Unions 7778 Vehicles - Privately Plated 7097 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No.2) 2002 Introduction and First Reading 4079 Second Reading 4080 Cognate Debate 5465 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5473 Consideration in Detail 5475-5487, 8957-8959 Third Reading 9135 Council’s Amendment 14137 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 4078 Second Reading 4078 Cognate Debate 5465 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5473 Consideration in Detail 5475-5487, 8942-8956 Third Reading 9135 Motor Vehicles Car Rental Industry - Review 5583 Unlicensed Dealers 10497 National Competition Council - Threat to Payments Standing Orders Suspension 12470 Motion 12480 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Amendment Bill 2003 - Referral to Select Committee - Amendment to Motion - Question to be Put 12481 Occupational Safety and Health Alcohol and Other Drugs in the Workplace - Guidance Note 14984 Brookton - Record Fine 11535 Crane Industry Review - Industries Covered 11562 Elevated Work Platforms - Safety Regulations 10166 Longer Working Hours - Review - Statement 8278 “Safetyline” Magazine 9143 398 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Occupational Safety and Health (continued) Tetrahydrocannabinol - Acceptable Level of Impairment in the Workplace 9792 Tobacco Smoke in Workplace 9146, 9793 Work-related Deaths 8522 Work-related Injuries - Statement 6675 Workplace Bullying - Statement 5682 Occupational Safety and Health Act 1984 - Review - Statement 3477 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12743 Second Reading 12743 Offshore Minerals Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 6204 Okely, Mrs Rona - Statement 3635 Parliament Prorogation - Statement 9227 Regional - Albany Sitting - Motion 14057 Sitting Hours 1468 Planning Commission - Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 1765 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendments Nos 1043/33, 1044/33 and 1049/33 - Statements 12822 Police Building Industry Special Projects Inspectorate - Draft Memorandum of Understanding 1761 Pay Dispute Matter of Public Interest 10971 Opposition’s Pay Offer 11108 Procedure and Privileges Committee - Membership 11921 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Standing Orders Suspension 9242 Consideration in Detail - Question to be Put 9268 Public Accounts Committee Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14220 Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion 1182; Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1193 Membership 12832 Public Sector Management Act 1994 - Review - Statement 11376 Questions on Notice Answer Advice 8007, 11258, 11259 Government’s Failure to Provide Answers 11394 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Cognate Debate 6356 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6380 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Cognate Debate 6356 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6380 Consideration in Detail 7075-7088, 7213-7220 Third Reading 7390 Council’s Amendments 8905, 8906, 9003 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 Cognate Debate 6356 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6380 Consideration in Detail 7232 Third Reading 7234 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 Cognate Debate 6356 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6380 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Urgent Bill 514, 515 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1294 Standing Orders Suspension 1325 Consideration in Detail - Question to be Put 1365, 1368 Third Reading 1369 Railways - Southern Rail Link- William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct- Amendment on the Amendment 12095 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 399

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Real Estate and Business Agents Supervisory Board Chairperson - Credit Card 11319 Hoad, Mr Michael 3491, 3492 Regional Development Goldfields-Esperance Development Commission - Chairperson - Credit Card 11819 Vasse - Expenditure 10564 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4141 Residential Tenancies Act 1987 - Review - Statement 881 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12047 Second Reading 12047, 13790 Consideration in Detail 13794-13806, 13831-13837 Third Reading 13837 Retail Trading Current Hours Regime - Legality 8889 Deregulation of Hours Change in Government’s Decision 9662 Competition Policy Guidelines 5720, 5721 Forum 11392 Grievance 6617 Impact of Inflexible Industrial Relations Laws 5997 Legislation 11908 National Competition Council Threat 9471 Opposition’s Assertion 7523 Penalty Rates 7358 Review 6487, 10967 Small Business Development Corporation Submission 8441 Standing Orders Suspension 8458; Question to be Put 8458 Harvey Norman - Sunday Trading 8968 Illegal - East Perth Residential Home - Grievance 9994 Review of Hours - Opposition Submission 5447 Retirees WA Inc - Administration Concerns 9008 Road Traffic Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 11639 Second Reading 11639 Science and Technology - Innovation Fund Projects - North West 3413 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Appointment of Members 9258 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 - As to Cognate Debate 2664 Sittings of the House - Sitting Dates for 2003 - Statement 1677 Small Business Beachside Cafe, Albany - Investigation 2169 Penalty Rates - Impact - Government Assistance 11818 “Small Business Matters” Article 914 Unfair Dismissal Laws - Impact 4678 Small Business Development Corporation - Submission on Deregulation of Retail Trading Hours - 8441 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 Recommittal 1691 Third Reading 1904 Standing Orders Amendments - Statement 597 No 90 - Suspension - Motion 893, 1984 Procedure and Privileges Committee Report on Minor Amendments - Motion 893 Report on Minor Adjustments - Motion 1984 Suspension - Completion of Matter of Public Interest 1602 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Cognate Debate 9683 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Cognate Debate 9683 Standing Orders Suspension 10424 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 Consideration in Detail 14287-14289 Third Reading 14289 400 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KOBELKE, HON JOHN CHARLES (continued) Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Closure 13608 Taxation - Tobacco Tax Windfall 1708 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Third Reading 11520 Tobacco Franchise Fees - High Court Decision 512 Tourism Lack of Government Support - Motion 1625 Workplace Relations Legislation - Motion 1625 Trade Practices Act Commonwealth - Criminal Sanctions 2523 Review - Statement 172 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion 379; Amendment to Motion 404; Motion, as Amended 411 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1489, 1495 Water Services Coordination Act - Review - Statement 12445 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 11541 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 6142 Second Reading 6142 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation (Acts of Terrorism) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 378 Second Reading 378, 1512 Workers Compensation Assessment of Injured Workers - Use of American Guide 4178 Employers Indemnity Supplementation Fund Surcharge - Statement 5681 Legislation - Time Limit for and Access to Common Law Claims 1763 Outstanding Claims - Cost 3932 Referral for Treatment - Four-week Time Limit 8891, 8892 Reform Government Position Paper 3931 Injury Management Savings 4700 WorkCover WA - Conciliation and Review Directorate - Determination of Degree of Disability 9144 Workplace Relations Amendment (Termination of Employment) Bill 2002 - Rejection by Senate - State Government’s Reaction 10593 WorkSafe Western Australia Building and Construction Site Inspections and Reports 5177 Buildings on the Corner of William and Murray Streets, Perth - Asbestos 1767, 4879 Crane Accidents Corner of Milligan and Hay Streets - Investigation 11956 Operator Training 5173 Crane Safety Standards Working Group Causes of Incidents Leading to Establishment 4698 New Regulations - Statement 11746 Grants for Training 5177 Inspectors - Number 7224 Safety Complaints - Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union 1467 “Safetyline” Magazine 9143 Warning Notices to Builder - CFMEU Involvement 10594 Workplace Death, Brookton - Record Fine 11535 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Council’s Message 1387; Motion 1489, 1495 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion 379; Amendment to Motion 404; Motion, as Amended 411 KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES, APM, Minister for Health (to 27 June); Tourism (from 27 June); Small Business (from 27 June); Sport and Recreation (from 27 June); Peel and the South West (from 27 June) (Yokine) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Health, Office of - Houston, Mr Edward Shane 6236 Health Statistics - Derby Regional Hospital 83 Address-in-Reply - Amendment to Motion - Health Services 116 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 401

KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES (continued) Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1749 Bateman, Mr Thomas Henry, MLA - Condolence Motion 11893 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14336 Busselton Jetty - Interpretive Centre and Underwater Observatory 14254 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5694 Second Reading 5694, 6743 Consideration in Detail 6753, 6757-6763, 6772- 6775, 6792-6807, 6849, 6850, 6854-6862, 6870-6880, 6889, 6891, 6893, 6902-6907, 6910-6915 Third Reading 6917 Abuse by Drug Dealers 6486 Protection of Children who Experiment with Cannabis 6485 Statement 7208 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 4172 China - Benefit to State of Economic Ties 12686 Committees and Boards - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7930 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14396 Crime - Links Between Drug Use and Crime - Grievance 8937 Drugs Cannabis Decriminalisation Cultivation of up to Two Cannabis Plants 5829, 6646 Matter of Public Interest 6352 Minister for Health’s Position 5718 Education Classes and Health Campaigns 1197 Links Between Drug Use and Crime - Grievance 8937 Next Step Drug Addiction Program - Number of Clients 5176 North West - Detoxification and Sobering-up Centres and Programs 3268, 6785, 6787, 8520 Regional Areas - Drug Teams 8893 Use Analysis 8789 Western Australian Drug and Alcohol Strategy 2002-05 - Statement 175 Wheatbelt Community Drug Service Team 6647, 6648 Economy, Western Australian - Benefit to State of Economic Ties with China 12686 Federal Budget - Impact on State’s Health Portfolio 7674 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8221 Government Advertising - Expenditure 6778 Government Contracts - Statistics 6779 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14450 Cleaning Services 6409, 13768 Club/Association Memberships Payment 8087 Written Policy on Payment of Fees 9777 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 14517 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6782 Credit Cards Access 6778 Statements - Checking 14506 Creditors Amount and Number 9766 Payment of Invoices 6208 Employment Contracts 6776 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12902 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5168 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6789 Leave Liability 5159 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14380 Leschenault Estuary - Management 8136 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6404 North West - Staff and Programs 4163 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10711 402 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Printed Information 5177 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7776 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Fees 14420 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14478 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7762 Staff - Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14537 UnionsWA or Individual Unions Grants 9469 Seconded Staff 7119 Web Sites - Online Payments 10727 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14549 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 1126 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 6781 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 6780 Motorcycle Statistics 7096 Privately Plated 7096 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14396 Health Aborigines - Kimberley 8310 Aged Care Kununurra 5722 Respite Accommodation 8518, 8519 State Aged Care Plan for WA, 2003 to 2008 - Statement 9382 Attention Deficit Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Referral to Education and Health Standing Committee - Appointment of Co-opted Member 6848 Subsidised Medication 9491 Barmah Forest Virus - South West 9472 Budget - Spending Levels 5172 Bulk-billing by General Practitioners 3495, 5829; Grievance 6612 Candlewicks Containing Lead - Ban on Importation, Production and Sale 7946 Centre for Mental Health Services Research - Funding 8523 Child and Adolescent Mental Health Clinic - Patient Numbers, Staff and Funding 6209 Chiropractors 2039, 2040 Chlorination of Drinking Water - Changes to Ovarian Function 8520 Clinical Psychologists - University Places and Number Trained and Employed 6777 Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement 3778, 7026, 7678 Country Health Services Review - Budget Allocation 9501 Crisis in System - Matter of Public Interest 5101 Dental Aged-care Oral Health Program 3265, 7360 Andrews, Mr Ron 1311, 1312, 3261 Bunbury Clinic 5830, 5831 Dental Board of Western Australia 1589, 1590 Funding for Dental Health Programs - Grievance 1981 North West - Funding 3266 Seniors - Subsidy Scheme 278 Department of Annual Reporting Procedures - Investigation 7360, 8595 Auditor General’s Report 8725 Holden Statesman Sedans - Number and Cost 6240 Key Performance Indicators and Annual Reports 5086 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Allocation of Funds 4704 Thornton, Ms Jean - Allegations 9667, 9875 Derby Health Summit - Statement 275 Dichlorvos - Approval for Use 2038 District Health Advisory Councils Appointment of Representatives 1309 Consultation Program 6490 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 403

KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES (continued) District Health Advisory Councils (continued) Statement 9383 East Pilbara Health Service - Budget Allocation 3264 Escalating Crisis - Matter of Public Interest 3790 Esperance Doctor to Provide Services to Norseman - Budget Allocation 9503 Funding Impact of Federal Budget 7674 Superannuation and Capital User Charges 8723, 8724 Health Practitioner Legislation - Statement 7999 Health Reform Committee Budget Allocation 9501 Membership, Terms of Reference and Report 9510 Health Review, Office of - Statement 2919 Improved Services - Government’s Commitment 1318 Insurance Funds - Increased Premiums 916 IVF Programs 4174, 9493 Kalamunda Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service - Closure 3985 Kimberley Capital Works Moneys 1201 Health Status of Residents 6812 Lead Concentrations in Human Blood - Guidelines 7946 Medical Indemnity Tort Law Reform 6184 Medical Services Agreement - Signing 7923 Mental Health Web Site 8967 Metropolitan Health Service - 2001-02 Report 5993, 5994 Midwives Enhanced Role 4106 Report on the Midwifery Work Force in Australia 8179 North West Capital Works Programs 6786, 7099 Child Health Nurses - Enhanced Home Visiting Program 9476 Dialysis Units 6783 Funding for Multipurpose Health Centre 3267 Medical Professionals - Packages 3263 Mental Health Services for Children 6235 Nullagine Health Clinic - Construction of Replacement 4179 Nurse Practitioners - Progress 6645 Nurses Additional Positions 7676 Agency Excessive Use 204, 205 Reduction in Use 5581 Wage Parity 2821 Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 3776 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” 1044, 1045; Motion 1221 Number and Resignations 7942, 7943 Number and Stress Leave 7924 Nurse-Link Initiative 604, 7923, 8725 Nurse West - Savings 9515 Recruitment Campaign 1312, 2167, 2672; Grievance 2789 Retirements and Resignations 4159 Statement 69, 1459 Use of Personal Care Assistants 1313 Wage Parity 2821 Obesity in Children - Grievance 10647 Obstetric Services Review - Implementation of Recommendations 6649 Opposition’s Report Card 4747 Organ Donation 6491 Patient Assisted Travel Scheme 3264, 3265 Peel District Health Advisory Council - Membership 7925 Peel Region - Specialist Services for Women 211 404 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES (continued) District Health Advisory Councils (continued) Phoenix - Audit Report - Statement 8279 Pilbara - Plan 3262, 4178 Pit Stop Program - Albany 3262 Pneumococcal Disease - Immunisation Program - Grievance 8697 Police Background Checks on Those Looking after Children 2048 Psychiatrists - Number Trained 6216 Radiotherapy Treatment - Grievance 9387 Regional Areas Downgrading and Closing Facilities 5242 Funding 8791, 8792 Medical Professionals - Packages 3263 Members of Committee 4165 Prevention and Promotion Programs - Budget Allocation 9503 Satisfaction with Service 2273 Renal Dialysis Services Geraldton 1462 Kimberley 2389 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces 2040 Ross River Virus Peel Region 2054 South West 9472 Royal Flying Doctor Service - Government Assistance to Replace Aircraft 8965 Rural and Regional Services - Budget Allocation 9497, 9503, 9504 Selby Child and Adolescent Mental Health Service - Relocation Review Group Report - Statement 173 Seniors - General Practitioner Access 6185 Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome - State Response 6340 Smoking Playgrounds and Schools 7027, 7028 Public Places - Statement 4069 Regulations - Review Response - Statement 9228 Tabling 8896 South West District Health Advisory Committee 3979 South West Health Service Budget 1125 Stroke Strategy Plan 1466, 3979 Telehealth Initiatives - Budget 4176 Telemedicine Programs - Nature, Location and Cost 4175 Ultrafine Airborne Particles - Impact on Health 4173 Vasse Leeuwin Health Service - Budget 1125 Visiting Medical Practitioners 5081, 6206 Vitamin A Program - Funding 3985 Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Former Minister for Health’s Failure to Take Action - Matter of Public Interest 9678 Western Australian Drug and Alcohol Strategy 2002-05 - Statement 175 Hospitals Admissions - Percentage from Regional Areas 9511 Agency Nurses - Excessive Use 204, 205 Albany Regional - Surgeons 3262, 3985 Ambulances Bypass Statistics 397, 4158, 7925 Drivers - Number and Stress Leave 7091 Armadale-Kelmscott Memorial - High Dependency Care Unit 5448 Bed Crisis 9422 Budget Overrun 3493 Bunbury Regional - General Surgeons Roster 1308 Capital Works Funding 7359 Complaints of Physical or Sexual Abuse by Staff 2048 Country - Improved Facilities 9087 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 405

KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES (continued) Hospitals (continued) Derby Regional - Relocation of Specialist Staff to Broome District Hospital 83 Directors of Nursing/Health Service Managers - Meetings in South West District 7110 Drug and Property Theft 2042 Emergency Departments Ambulance Bypasses 4158 Ca mpaign to Ease Pressure 8602 Number Treated 2047 Fremantle Additional Beds 209 Medical Services Centre - Statement 4818 Stroke Patients 775, 3261 Graylands Complaints of Physical or Sexual Abuse by Staff 2051 Patient Numbers 6240 Halls Creek New Initiative 1307 Replacement 4178, 5722 Joondalup Health Campus Ambulance Bypasses and Call Offs 7925 Grievance 2787 Kalamunda District Community - Redevelopment 919 Kalgoorlie Regional - Nurse Shortage 2675 King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women Inquiry Implementation Group - Statement 6472, 8874 Report - Statement 3910 Statement 1677 Kununurra - Aged Care Facility 5722 Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technology - Progress 2165 Merredin District Anaesthetist 2273 Doctor Crisis 2389, 2673 Doctor on Duty 2166 Medical Staff and Resources - Grievance 2358 Moora District - Grievance 6615 Murray District - Future 3263 North West 4692, 4693, 6782-6787, 7947 Northam District - Anaesthetist 2273 Peel Health Campus Accessibility 2009 Day Care Extensions and Dialysis Machines 3979 Medical Indemnity Insurance Premiums of Visiting Medical Practitioners 205, 206 Patient Transfers - Cost 3263 Personal Care Assistants 1313 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner 9088 Parking 9471 Poisons Licence 3980 Quality and Safety Accreditation 8963 Rockingham-Kwinana District - Upgrade 6681 Sir Charles Gairdner - Radiation Therapy 5238 St John Ambulance - Response Times 4748, 4749 Teaching - Limit on Number of New Patients 8442 Waiting Lists - Purchase of Surgery from Non-public Hospitals 2817 Warren District - Downgrading of After-hours Medical Services 2271, 2272 Yarloop - Recommendations for Future 4165 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9404 Second Reading 9404 Consideration in Detail 12868 Liquor Stores - Seven-day-a-week Trading - Petition 12691 406 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES (continued) Medical Act 1894 Reforms 4177; Statement 8786 Review 5240 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit - Minister for Health - Ministerial Appointments Diary 2165 Ministers of the Crown Credit Cards 13427 Meetings between Mr Brian Burke, Mr Julian Grill and Ministers of the Crown and Ministerial Staff 7270 Minister for Health Cannabis Decriminalisation 5718 Personal Explanation - Newspaper Comment 5081 Support for Southern Rail Link 917 Thornton, Ms Jean - Allegations Against Former Minister for Health 9667, 9875 Minister for Peel and the South West - Vis it to South West 11539 Mobile Phones - Use 4808 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10716 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14438 Corporate Credit Cards 8260, 9923 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9782 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7119 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4812 Vehicles - Privately Plated 6782 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5150 Mosquitoes - Mandurah 2053, 3260, 9514 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2655 Second Reading 2655, 3798 Consideration in Detail 3804-3824 Third Reading 3824, 3826 Council’s Amendments 5890, 5891 Perth Air Quality Management Plan - Impact on Health of Ultrafine Particles 4173 Police Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3919 Questions on Notice - Answers 8007, 11259 Rail Link, Southern - Minister for Health’s Support 917 Regional Development Peel Development Commission - Grievance 11747 South West Development Commission - Chief Executive Officer - Mobile Telephone and Government Vehicle 11563 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Minister for Health - Refusal to Provide Information 2040 Rottnest Island Accommodation Upgrade and Repair 13608; Motion 13719 Auditor General’s Report 13695 Longreach Units - Maintenance 14554 Management Plan - Implementation of Recommendations 13696, 13697 Quokkas - Statement 13190 Storm Damage - Repair Work 11536 Task Force - Role 13607 Seniors Aged-care Oral Health Program - North West 3265 Dental Subsidy Scheme 278 General Practitioners - Home or Hostel Visits 6185 Small Business Business Enterprise Centres - Closure 10420 Business Migration Program - Statement 10640 Energy Reforms 12760, 12764 Insurance Costs 10024, 10025 November Sensis Business Index - Small and Medium Enterprises 13609; Statement 13605 Review of Government Services 11561 Sport and Recreation Barbagallo Raceway, Wanneroo - Grievance 12825 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 407

KUCERA, HON ROBERT CHARLES (continued) Sport and Recreation (continued) Indian National Sports Plan - Statement 13367 National Basketball League Game, Kalgoorlie 12614 Rugby World Cup - Benefits 10499 Soccer - Restructuring of Administration in WA - Grievance 11506 Travel Costs for Sportspeople - Statement 11379 Taxes and Charges - Business Insurance Premiums 10024, 10025 Tourism Busselton Interpretive Centre, Jetty and Underwater Observatory 14254 Commission - Chairperson - Credit Card 12506 Event Tourism - Future Economic Benefits 13520 Federal Government’s White Paper 13612 New Concept for State Tourism Strategy - Grievance 13489 “Pathways Forward: Strategic Plan 2003-2008” - Statement 10944 State Tourism Strategy 9666 Transport - Regional Airports - New Services 10823 Unions - Exemption under Act from Access to Medical Information 2042 Water Resources - Chlorination - Changes to Ovarian Function 8520 Western Power - Disaggregation Benefits to Small Business 12760 Electricity Prices 12764 Youth - North West - Detoxification Programs and Respite Centres 3268, 6787

LOGAN, MR FRANCIS MICHAEL, BA (Hons), Parliamentary Secretary, Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries; the Midwest, Wheatbelt and Great Southern; Environment and Heritage (to 27 June); the Environment (from 27 June) (Cockburn) (ALP) Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2276, 2281 Consideration in Detail 2308, 2309 Third Reading 2361 Council’s Amendments 9136 Agriculture Agricultural Protection Funding - North West 3410 Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7255 Atrazine - Use in Western Australia 4172 Chicken Meat and Egg Industry - Protection from Infectious Bursal Disease Virus 11436 Compacted Soil and/or Subsoil Zones 1124 Dairy Industry Milk Prices - Grievance 8281 Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 9246; Amendment to Motion 9247 Department Bushland Covenanting Scheme 14968 Closure of Offices or Facilities 3404 Horticulture/Viticulture Specialist at Waroona 1124 Nannup and Busselton - Staff and Buildings 4696 Select Committee - Motion 7255 South Perth - Valuation 4701 Drought Assistance 3570, 9788; Grievance 1682; Statement 2654 Flower Industry - Postal Poll - Accuracy of Eligible Producers List 13841 Midland Saleyards - Relocation 14884 Ovine Johne’s Disease 14148 Poison 1080 691 Soil Phosphorus Levels and Fertiliser Application Rates 9311 State Budget Initiatives 9787 Virulent Infectious Bursal Disease - Inspections 14984 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14339 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 759 Second Reading 759 Declaration as Urgent 1496 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1496, 1576, 1578 408 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

LOGAN, MR FRANCIS MICHAEL (continued) Burke, Mr Brian Meetings with Ministers and Ministerial Staff 7946 Taxi Industry Decision 10285 Busselton Jetty - Jarrah Logs for Use as Piles 8522 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 Cognate Debate 2276 Consideration in Detail 2283 Third Reading 2361 Centres of Excellence - Government Support 1307 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3851 China - Environmental Benefits and Opportunities 12688 Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia - Statement 1305 Committees and Boards - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7931 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14397 Consumer and Employment Protection - Solar Eclipse Sunglasses 3780 Crown Land Surrounding Sussex Location 4443, Scott River 14552 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph, MLA - Condolence Motion 13186 Disability Services - People with Intellectual Disabilities - Petitions 9381 Economy, Western Australian - Impact of Industrial Relations Reforms 5451 Electricity Reform - Support 26 Environmental Protection Authority - Board Membership Changes 4746 Fire and Emergency Services - Prescribed Burning 11110 Fisheries Aquaculture - North West 3415 Cherax Rotundus - Introduction 690 Commercial - Management Plans 671 Cottesloe Reef - Recreational Fishing - Petition 5977 Crayfish - Restrictions on Pots 2214 Dive Wrecks - Number and Fishing Exclusion Zone 12819 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 13415 Geographe Bay - Restrictions on Commercial Fishing 682 Mandurah and Peel Region - Fisheries Inspectors - Grievance 1679 Pink Snapper - Effects of Trawl Fishery - Statistical Confidence Levels of Analyses 14147 Research and Community Education Programs - North West 3411 Sustainable Annual Catch - South West Fisheries - 12506-12509 WA Fishing Industry Council - Seafood Cocktail Forum - Statement 3344 Forests and Forestry Forest Management Plans - Sustained Yield - Ferguson Report Recommendations 13553 Forest Products Commission Board Members - Credit Cards 11141 Personal Explanation 7230 Plantation Forestry - Strategic Afforestation in Agricultural Zone 9788 Sawn Timber Recovery Data 4688 Jarrah Imbalance in Numbers of Marri 6205 Total Quota Request 5892 Third Grade - Sawn Timber Recovery Rate 3000 Karri and Marri - Total Quota Request 5892 Ludlow Tuart Forest - Harvest Statistics 13276, 14145 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme Motion 436 Amendment to Motion 13624 Motion for Disallowance 14133 Inclusion in Metropolitan Region Scheme 402 Opposition’s Campaign 3493 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7208 Second Reading 7208, 8838 Consideration in Detail 8841-8846 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 409

LOGAN, MR FRANCIS MICHAEL (continued) Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 (continued) Third Reading 9003, 9004 Council’s Amendments 14914, 14915 Government Advertising - Expenditure 6218 Government Contracts - Statistics 6221, 6223 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14451 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3851 Cleaning Services 6409, 13768 Club/Association Memberships 7398, 9777 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 13549, 14564 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6233 Credit Cards 6220, 14507 Creditors 6208, 9768 Employment Contracts 7093 Government Intellectual Property Policy 8731 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12904 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5169 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6237 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14570 Leave Liability 5159 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14384 Leschenault Estuary - Management 6238 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6405 North West - Staff and Programs 3002 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10712 Privatisation - Government’s Position 12468 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7776 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14423 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14478 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7763 Staff “Attached List” 669 Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14538 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7120 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 8862 Web Sites - Online Payments 10729 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14550 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 693 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 6230 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 6228 Motorcycles - Statistics 6225 Privately Plated 6226 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 751 Second Reading 751 Declaration as Urgent 1496 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1496, 1576, 1578 Consideration in Detail 1580-1583, 1693-1704, 1714-1721 Third Reading 1722 Council’s Amendments 2192 Grill, Mr Julian - Meetings with Ministers and Ministerial Staff 7946 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14397 Industrial Development BHP Billiton - Purchase of Tugboats 13611 Raytheon Australia Pty Ltd 13812 Industrial Hemp Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 13680 Second Reading 13680, 14083 410 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

LOGAN, MR FRANCIS MICHAEL (continued) Industrial Relations Reforms - Impact on Western Australian Economy 5451 Unions - Government Grants 8862 Land Clearing 304 Badgerup Road, Gnangara 8521, 11140 Binnu - Grievance 889 Crown Land Surrounding Sussex Location 4443, Scott River - Management 14552 Live Sheep Export - Cormo Express - Statement 11898 Mid West Region - Projects - Funding 9140 Mining - Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining - Timber Harvest Statistics 13276, 14145 Ministers of the Crown Credit Cards 6220 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 7946 Mobile Phones Use 4808 Personal Explanation - Forest Products Commission Information 7230 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10716 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14438 Corporate Credit Cards 8262, 9924, 12506 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9782 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7120 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4812 Vehicles - Privately Plated 6232 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5151 Pig, Potato and Poultry Industries (Compensation Legislation) Repeal Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 13497 Second Reading 13498 Planning Mauds Landing Development - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd - Legality of Decision 11779, 11902, 12202 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass Amendment to Motion 13624 Inclusion 402 Motion 436 Motion for Disallowance 14133 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 894 Second Reading 895, 1905 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 11380 Second Reading 11380, 12178 Plastic Bags - Environment Protection and Heritage Council Meeting 10495 Pollution Air - Meeting of Environment Protection and Heritage Council 8311 Heavy Industry - Obligations 9877 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 971 Regional Development Commissions Act - Division 2, Section 23(1)(e) Breaches 3563 Government Services 4684, 4685 Wages and Achievements - Development Commissions 13276, 14488 Rottnest Island New Year’s Eve 7362 School Leavers Week 3091 Rugby World Cup - Benefits 10499 Salinity - Funding Delays by Commonwealth 6336 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality 6808 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7255 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 411

LOGAN, MR FRANCIS MICHAEL (continued) Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Establishment - Motion 9246; Amendment to Motion 9247 Shark Patrol - Extension to Mandurah - Grievance 1979 State Budget - Agriculture, Forestry and Salinity 9313, 9787 Swan River - Matter of Public Interest 8803 Taxis - Burke, Mr Brian - Lobbying Activity 10285 Tourism - Event Tourism - Future Economic Benefits 13520 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2276, 2281 Consideration in Detail 2284 Third Reading 2361 Unemployment Rate 8788 Waste Disposal Recycling - Pot Recyclers, Midvale 13699 Total Waste Management, Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion 5261 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 First Reading 4716 Second Reading 4716, 5394

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE, BA, LLB, BJuris, JP, Minister for Planning and Infrastructure (Armadale) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council - Chairperson 11563, 11679 Housing - North West 2717 Murchison Region Aboriginal Corporation - Funding 11140 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Statement 1972 Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 8875 Second Reading 8875, 10188 Third Reading 10190 Adjournments of the House - Special 10700 Agriculture Gascoyne Muster, Carnarvon - Statement 11898 Hay Bales 7928, 13674 Midland Saleyards - Position Paper 3707 Pastoral Industry Working Groups - Development Reports - Statement 11682 Animal Welfare Act - Appointment of Scientific Inspectors 8871 Dogs - Docking of Tails - Statement 2920 Architects Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 13679 Second Reading 13679 BGC (Australia) Ltd - Preferential Treatment by Court Government 5446 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14315, 14343 Broome Nursing Home - Agreement with the Ribibi 8182 Building Industry - New Safety Rules 11676 Centenary of Federation - Funding - North West 2719 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3574, 4679 Cockburn Shopping Centre, Hamilton Hill - Ownership 9309 Collie Hospital - Tender for Roof Repairs 1783 Committees and Boards - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7755, 8078 Committees, Task Forces, Reviews and Advisory Groups - Number Established 4786 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14393, 14398 Convention and Exhibition Centre - Budget and Timing 1781 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph, MLA - Condolence Motion 13186 Disability Services - Petitions Caldwell, Mr David 9380 Richards, Mr Robert 14052 Drivers Licences Performance of Licensing Call Centre - Statement 9082 Replacement Licences - Fee 10565 Waiting Time for Practical Test 8075, 10878 412 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) East Perth Power Station Site Future Use 5245, 13610 Ministerial Council Meetings 7679, 9312 Sale of Surrounding Land 8896 Environment Coastal Erosion - Grievance 5338 Coastwest Grants Program - Statement 9990 Erosion Programs - North West 4670 Port Geographe - Groyne Field - Grievance 5338 WA Coastlines Document - Cost, Distribution, Purpose and Funding 11318 Federal Budget - Road Funding 7677 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board 8929; Motion 8910 Government Advertising - Expenditure 6218, 7766 Government Architect - Appointment 12226 Government Contracts Occupational Safety and Health Policies 9773 Preference to Quality Assured Tenderers 1125 Statistics 6222, 6223, 7767, 7768 Tendering Process - Impropriety under Previous Government 9234 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14447, 14453 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3574, 4679 City Centre Fitness Club Program 9514, 11677 Cleaning Services 6410, 8270; Cost 13766, 13770 Club/Association Memberships 7399, 8087, 9778, 10206 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 13300, 14970 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6234, 7772 Consultants 3705 Credit Cards 6220, 7766, 14508 Creditors 6208, 7931, 9760, 9769 Employment Contracts 6776, 8083 Government Employees’ Home Ownership Scheme - Applications 10326 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12892, 12908 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5165, 5170 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6789, 8506 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14977 Leave Liability 5156, 5159 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14386, 14945 Leschenault Estuary - Management 6041, 8512 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6405, 8122 North West - Staff and Programs 2714, 4658 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10708 Privatisation - Government’s Position 12465 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7777, 8124 Qantas Club or other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14411, 14425 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14472, 14482 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 8083, 8246 Staff “Attached List” 670, 3847 Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14535, 14539 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7120 Unfilled and Acting Positions 3561 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 8863, 8865, 9717 Web Sites - Online Payments 11316 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14551 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 989, 3562 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 6230, 7771 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 6229, 7770 Motorcycles - Statistics 6225, 7768 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 413

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Government Vehicles (continued) Privately Plated 6227, 7769 Halden, Hon John - Meetings with Minister for Housing and Works and Ministerial Staff 6043 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14393, 14398 Heritage Hillview Hospital Site - Future Use 2311 Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 524 William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Motion 12080; Statement 12047 Homeswest Collie - Maintenance Budget 7778 Yarloop - Property Sales 3853 Housing Affordable - Grievance 2356 BHP Billiton Ltd - Port Hedland and Newman 10963 Gosnells - Tenders for Six Town Houses 1787 Government Employees’ Home Ownership Scheme - Applications 10326 Landstart Development Division - Joint Venture Developments in North West 5515 New Living Program 2718, 5284, 6042 North West Aborigines 2717 Aborigines and Torres Strait Islander People 8152 Country Housing Authority Programs 8151 Funding 8123, 8273 Seniors 6036, 6037 Smoke Alarms Program 2718 Supported Housing Assistance Program - 5396 Sustainable Housing Design Competition - House Design Restrictions for Broome Region 826 Urban Renewal Programs North West 2720 State Housing Commission - Chairperson 11563, 11679 Woodrise Estate, Albany - Joint Venture Developments in North West 5515 Housing and Works, Department of Albany - Security Doors 8146 Broome - Purchase of Hostel 5395 Right to Buy Scheme - Number of Properties Sold 13296 Tenants - Antisocial Behaviour - Motion 8621; Amendment to Motion 8623, 8635 Industrial Development Australian Marine Complex - Fabrication Precinct - Statement 13485 Industrial Sites Review - Geraldton 14257 North West - Land Acquisition for Industry 4668 Industrial Relations Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Deal Struck with Building and Construction Companies 3351, 3352 Reforms - Impact on Southern Rail Link 4648 Unions - Government Grants 8863, 8865 Insurance - Public Liability - Taxis 4663 Kierath, Mr Graham - BGC (Australia) Ltd - Preferential Treatment 5446 Land Acquisition - Valuations of CBD Buildings 8871 Land Administration, Department of Document Lodgments - Statement 9230 Restructure - Statement 3070 LandCorp Hope Valley - Property Purchases 4682 North West Land Acquisition for Industry 4668 Residential and Light Industrial Land Releases 4669 Stakehill Wetlands Precinct and Baldivis 10566 Wattleup - Property Purchases 4681 Lobbyists Burke, Mr Brian Meetings with Ministers and Ministerial Staff 8343, 9742 Taxi Industry Decision 10285 414 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Lobbyists (continued) Grill, Mr Julian - Ministers and Ministerial Staff 8343 Local Government Broome, Shire of - Renal Dialysis Outpatient Hostel in Residential Area 8074 Coastal Planning and Land Use Strategies 13308 Fremantle, City of - Curfew on Freight Routes 14256 Gosnells, City of - Safer WA Community Security Program 3009 Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 524 Main Street Program - North West 2717, 7781 Mandurah Cinema Complex - Non-compliance with Building Code 1778 Murray, Shire of - Town Planning Scheme No 4 Amendment No 157 8074 Rates - Gross Rental Value and Unimproved Land Value Methods 5395 Regional Collocation Scheme - North West 2719, 2721 Roads Funding 10874 Swan, City of - Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment - Statement 14056 Local Government and Regional Development, Department of - Corporate Membership of City Centre Fitness Club - Payment 11677 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12839 Second Reading 12839, 14274 Main Roads Western Australia 10-year Plan for Road Construction Projects 4695 Expenditure 13295, 13429 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 8072 Mining - Eastern Goldfields Transport Board - Mine Site Charter Transport 10875 Ministers of the Crown Credit Cards 6220 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 8343, 9742 Minister for Housing and Works - Meetings with Hon John Halden 6043 Minister for Planning and Infrastructure Personal Explanations Expenditure on Parliamentary Refreshments 5833 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 535 Question on Notice - Government Contracts 10827 Statements Planning Ministers’ Conference, Adelaide 6334 Singapore and Malaysia Visit 10946 Visit to Europe and United Arab Emirates 9383 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4577 Mobile Phone Use 4806, 4809 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10715 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14433, 14440 Corporate Credit Cards 8253, 8265, 9922, 9924, 14360 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9781, 9782 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7120 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4811, 4812 Vehicles - Privately Plated 6232, 7771 Staff Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5146, 5152 Motor Vehicles Mobile Caravans - Licence Classifications 9797 Noisy and Smoky Vehicles 8077 Murdoch University - Pilbara - Study Funding 8142 National Party - New MetroRail - Cost Claims 8005 Nego, Kim - State Coroner’s Finding - Statement 11378 Ningaloo Reef - Pastoral Release Exclusions 3677 Occupational Safety and Health Building Industry - New Safety Rules 11676 Government Contracts 9773; Personal Explanation 10827 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 415

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Parks and Reserves Alfred Cove - Reserves Sold or Leased 228 Beeliar Regional - Roe Highway Construction 4561 Peel Regional - Management 2993 Pastoral Leases Gascoyne Muster, Carnarvon - Statement 11898 Improvements 10880 Pastoral Lands Board Membership 10880 Robson, Professor Alan - Chairman - Statement 8580 Reorganisation - Statement 3343 Planning Appeals Meetings - Number, Time Limit and Cancellation 4683 Baldivis - Property Purchases 13549 Broome, Shire of - Renal Dialysis Outpatient Hostel in Residential Area 8074 Bunbury, City of - Town Planning Scheme - Delay in Approval 4645 Bushplan-Bush Forever Compensation for Land Classified 4666 Negotiated Outcomes for Land Cost and Area 4666 Purchase of Additional Sites 4655 Busselton - Old Court House Complex 8077 Canning Highway - Reservation Between Causeway and Canning Bridge 9715 Coastal Erosion - Grievance 5338 Coastal Planning - Community Involvement 4687 Coastal Planning and Land Use Strategies 13308 Coastal Zone Council - Independent Chairperson 4688 Coastwest Grants Program - Funding 13308 Dawesville Channel - Sand Bypass System 8502 Dialogue with the City 11111, 11255; Statement 8436 Donaldson and Warn - Report on Study into Creation of Civic Square 10565 East Perth Redevelopment Authority 12379; Statement 13192 Exmouth Marina Village - Impact of Government Investment on Ningaloo Reef Resort 2997 Greater Bunbury Region Scheme - Grievance 12171 Heathcote Site - Sale or Transfer of Land 13839 Hillarys Boat Harbour 10819, 11112 Hillview Hospital Site - Future Use 2311 Industrial Sites Review - Geraldton 14257 Karel Avenue Bushland - Grievance 11084 Kwinana Town Planning Scheme Amendment No 76 - Delays 12377 Leighton Beach Development - Expansion - Community Consultation 12810 Location 413, Smiths Beach - Tourism and Residential Development 4642 Mabel Talbot Park and Henderson Park Reserves - Grievance 3201 Major and Minor Amendments - Criteria for Determination 4691 Mauds Landing Development 2997; Motion 9913 Maylands Boatyard Pty Ltd - Lease 4630-4635 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments Clarkson-Butler - Statement 11617 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Hearings Committee Report 13606 Land Resumptions 13697 Matter of Public Interest 13618 Motion 424 Motion for Disallowance 14123 Reasons for Inclusion in MRS 402 Statements 2918, 13367 Traffic Management 13525 Gnangara Water Mound - Statement 13605 No 5 - South East District Omnibus - Statement 1459 No 1016/33 - Western Suburbs Omnibus Amendment No 3 - Statement 2163 No 1019/33 - Townsites in Stoneville and Parkerville - Statement 2654 No 1037/33 - North West Districts Omnibus Amendment No 5 - Statement 2161 416 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Planning (continued) Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments (continued) No 1038/33 - Thomsons Lake Regional Centre - Statement 1460 No 1039/33 - Victoria Quay, Port of Fremantle - Statement 15 No 1040/33 - Tapper Road, Banjup - Statement 67 No 1041/33 - South West Districts Omnibus (No 5) - Statement 68 No 1054/33 - Western Power Depot, Belmont - Statement 5823 No 1060/33A - Railway Works within a Road Reservation 915, 916, 9305 Southern Rail Link 511, 605, 606, 8072; Personal Explanation 535 Swan, City of - Statement 14056 Mid West Region - Town Planning Schemes 10878 Mindarie Marina 2997; Grievance 12173 Mundijong Town Site - Town Planning Scheme Amendment 4560; Grievance 5340 Murray, Shire of - Town Planning Scheme No 4, Amendment No 157 8074 Newman - Community Dialogue Planning Initiative 10963 North East Corridor Extension Strategy - Statement 10640 North West 8113, 8123 Peel Region Scheme 4644; Disallowance 4143; Statement 2352 Planning Appeals and Scheme Amendments - Number to be Determined 2385, 2386 Planning Ministers’ Conference, Adelaide - Statement 6334 Port Geographe Groyne Field 9712; Grievance 5338 Port Hedland - Community Dialogue Planning Initiative 10963 Public Access Ways - Grievance 7852 Raffles Hotel Site Artist’s Impression 3353, 3500, 4110; Statement 3679 Construction of 17-storey Building 1051, 3092 Meeting 5090 Multiplex’s Drawings - Accuracy 4691 Residential Codes 5584, 5585 Scarborough Senior High School Site - Future Use 2275 Siesta Park - Coastal Erosion - Grievance 8933 Signature of Minister’s Delegate on Assignment of Lease Documents - Delay 14557 Stakehill Wetlands Precinct - Property Purchases 13549 Subiaco Redevelopment Authority - Statement 13192 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Public Housing 11140 Tourism Planning Task Force Report - Statement 9856 Town Planning Appeal Tribunal - Statements 5221, 7656, 12314 Town Planning Scheme Amendments - Backlog 10677 WA Coastlines Document - Cost, Distribution, Purpose and Funding 11318 Wireless Hill Park Excision from Class A Reserve 29813 - Motion for Disallowance 14296 Grievance 11082 Planning and Infrastructure, Department for Auditor General’s Report - Statement 12681 Enforcement of Lease Conditions 8074 Recognition by the Planning Institute of Australia - Statement 6676 Road Transport Section Investigations - Fuel Tanker Truck Rollover Accidents 9308 Web Site - Updating 10873 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 756-759 Port Kennedy Development Project Assignment of Crown Land 4641 Guarantees Against Pac Asia Holdings Pty Ltd 4642 Meeting Details 4639 Secured and Unsecured Creditors 4640, 4641 Statements 479, 9228 WA Beach and Golf Resort Pty Ltd - Conditions 10877 Ports and Harbours Albany Port Authority - Advertising of Positions on Board 4680 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 417

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Ports and Harbours (continued) Broome Commonwealth Government Contribution 10423 Jetty Extension Project - Statement 5826 Opposition’s Policy 12863 Dampier Port Authority - Port Control Closure - Statement 11378 Esperance Port Authority Anwyl, Ms Megan 8269 Cranes Haulage - Front End Loader Services Contract 3561 Statement 12447 Fremantle Shipping Container Movements 4856, 4857 Statement 5562 Geraldton Port Authority Dredging Operations 12205 Port Upgrade 4104 Resignation of Chairman and Board Member 394; Statement 377 Tabling of Documents 396 Hillarys Boat Harbour - Financial Independence 2997 Kimberley Port - Location 12381 North West - Improvement Programs 4668, 4670 Port Authority Boards - Diversification of Membership 5090 Governance 5582 Port Hedland Port Authority - Chairman 10419 Regional Port Authorities - Appointments 10494 Small Boat Harbours - Boat Pen Space - Cost 12376 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 4830 Second Reading 4830, 8811 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 4751 Second Reading 4751, 5870 Consideration in Detail 5876-5889, 6394-6396 Third Reading 6475, 6480 Council’s Amendment 7921 Questions on Notice 3353, 8007, 14885 Questions without Notice - Member for Alfred Cove - Statement 3679 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 92 Second Reading 92, 1064 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1289 Consideration in Detail 1338-1365 Third Reading 1385 Council’s Amendments 3506-3509 Railways Albany - Grain and Woodchip Transport - Grievance 13495 Argyle Street Crossing, Herne Hill - Risk Assessment 9751 Armadale-CBD - Sunday Service 9797 Australind Market Research Survey 2994 Passenger Numbers and Operating Costs 9306 South West Passenger Rail Committee 4665 Crossings - Rumble Strips - Installation 8121 Currambine Line 3090, 8117, 8122 Female Passengers - Statistics on Safety at Night 4664 Freight - Increase 9084 Goongoongup Bridge - Statement 4817 Greenwood Station - Completion 8505 Integrated Rail Transport Planning Report - Market Research Survey 2994 Joondalup - Special Events Train Services 9727 418 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Railways (continued) Loch and Grant Streets Stations - Partial Closure 776, 4626; Grievance 884; Statement 598 New MetroRail Cost Claims by National Party 8005 “On Track” Newsletter 12860, 12861 Statement 7999, 8437 North West - Programs 4668, 9748 Operational Subsidies 4628 Perth-Bunbury - Freight Rail Track 6339 Perth Urban Rail Development Change of Name to New MetroRail 8118 Supplementary Master Plan - Cost of Works Packages 10636 Quinns Road-Hester Avenue 4629, 8116, 8517 Security Barriers - Installation 4628 Security Guards 9728 South West Metropolitan Railway - Road Reserve 14920 South West Passenger Rail Committee - Recommendations 12378 Southern Rail Link Architectural Heritage Survey 8855, 9426 Brochures - Number, Cost and Distribution 8121 Budget Details 9874, 12320, 14876, 14877 Bus Services - Kwinana Freeway 2999 City Rail Development Project - Demolition of Buildings 4677 City Section 7883 Commencement and Completion 9746 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Impact of Activities on Costs 3351, 3352 Cost and Annual Value of Community Service Obligation 399, 400 Cost Blow-out 12067, 12068, 12201, 12207, 12320, 12324, 12325; Matter of Public Interest 13934 Cost Comparisons 10163 Cost Estimates 2168 Cost Savings 10025 Debt Servicing Cost 2387 Dedicated Busway 4646 Electricity Usage 4645 Feeder Bus Routes 8504 Foreshore Opportunities 6489 Industrial Relations Laws - Impact on Costs 4648 Kwinana Freeway Route - Cost 4622 Land Resumptions - Cost 280 Leader of the Opposition’s Policy 14072 Leasing Contracts 11625 Matter of Public Interest 2935 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 511, 605, 606, 8072; Personal Explanation 535 Metropolitan Regional Improvement Fund - Allocation of Funds 4624 Ongoing Recurrent Cost Estimate of $47 million 2391 Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 1597 Opposition Attitude 2519, 2670 Policy 11900 Transport Spokesperson’s Report 2924 Passengers 3677, 13920 Patronage Forecasts - Tabling of Paper 4565 Railcars - Maximum Number of Passengers 8120 Ramps and Noise Bunds - Cost 4647 Rockingham-Perth Travel Times 4624 Rockingham Residents - Consultation 11702 Rockingham Transit System 13925, 13926 Rolling Stock 279, 280 Sinking Under the Perth CBD 4635, 8893, 10499; Statement 12679 Soil Testing 5450 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 419

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Railways (continued) Southern Rail Link (continued) Statement 14, 14874 Survey of Support for Changed Route 8116 Timetable for Completion 14879 Toilet Facilities on Trains - Cost 4626 Transit Guards 8120 Tunnel under Fremantle Road, Mandurah 8340 Urban Enhancements and Streetscape Improvements 5833 Wellington and Murray Streets, Perth - Acquisition of Land - Statement 5560 William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Motion 12080; Statement 12047 William Street Buildings 1050, 1051 William Street Traffic Bridge - Removal 10680 Transit Guards 2995, 11315 Upgrade - Federal Funding 606 Urban Rail Development Acquisition of Property 604, 605, 1465, 1588 Enhanced Travel Demand Modelling 2523, 2672 Statement 10384 Supplementary Master Plan 2522 WA Government Railways Commission - Coach Contracts - Statement 597 Warwick Station - Parking Bays 8137 Westrail Freight Network - Privatisation 12465 Whitfords and Warwick Stations - Vehic le Theft from Car Parks 8071 Regional Development Commissions Act - Division 2 Section 23(1)(e) Breaches 2312 Government Services 4685, 4686 Government’s Policy 3573 North West 8151, 8268, 9749 Regional Collocation Scheme - North West 2719, 2721 Regional Policy Statement for Western Australia - Statement 3341 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 1573 Second Reading 1573, 3836 Consideration in Detail 3838-3841 Third Reading 3842 Road Traffic Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12721 Roads Albany Highway - Overtaking Lanes 9307 Albany Road System - Impact of Grain and Woodchip Trucks - Grievance 13495 Brand Highway - Overtaking Lanes 9307 Bridge and Road Construction - Expenditure 9310 Collie-Darkan and Corrigin-Hyden - Safety Concerns - Grievance 12168 Construction Projects - South West 4643 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme 402, 13525 Matter of Public Interest 13618 Motion 424 Motion for Disallowance 14123 Statement 13367 Expenditure on Advertising Publications and Consultation 9728 Hearings Committee Report 13606 Liberal Land Resumptions 13697 Member for Murdoch’s Pledge 2272 Minister’s Position 4106 Opposition’s Campaign 3493 Rezoning of Land 12818 Statements 2918, 5220 Submission Form 4105 Fremantle Port Curfew on Freight Routes 14256 420 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Roads (continued) Fremantle Port (continued) Shipping Container Movement 4856, 4857 Funding 7522, 3350, 7677 Great Northern Highway - Overtaking Lanes 9307 Great Southern Region - Expenditure 4676 Kwinana Freeway Bus Lanes 3708, 4623 Emergency Services 8118 Extension - Commencement and Completion 9746 Interchange Resurfacing - Statement 5682 Railway Reserve 3708 Lane Width Reductions - Narrows Bridge 3233 Local Government - Funding 10874 Mandurah - Funding to Seal Road - Grievance 485 Marmion Avenue-Reid Highway-North Beach Road Intersection - Grievance 2355 Matilda Street, Huntingdale - Grievance 487 Melville Parade - Concrete Barrier/Fence 8271 Mitchell Freeway - Railway Reserve 3708 North West Bridge Refurbishment 8866 Funding 4671 Programs 4668, 8111, 8113 8866, 8868, 9748 Northbridge Tunnel - Settlement of Claims - Statement 4555 Old Coast Road, Mandurah 14556; Grievance 10385 Peel Deviation Commencement and Completion 9746 Commonwealth Government’s View 6679 Federal Funds 2169 Funding - Grievance 8699 Grievance 13493 Land Acquisition 9471, 9473 Progress 12069 Preprimaries - 40-Kilometre an Hour School Zones - Statement 11498 Regional Road Groups - Wheatbelt North Group Funding Allocation 9303 Regional Roads Program - Cutbacks in Funding 10678, 10679 Reid Highway-Altone Road - Traffic Accident - Statement 6335 Road Projects - Commencement and Completion Dates 3562 Road Safety - Resources - Matter of Public Interest 8020 Roads of National Importance - Federal Funding 3088, 3089 Roe Highway Stage 4 - Progress 3672 Stage 6 3929; Statement 1569 Stage 7 3929; Statements 5079, 10266, 12449 Stage 8 Beeliar Regional Park 4561 Member for Murdoch’s Pledge 2272 South Western Highway 9303, 9306, 9307 Southern Suburbs - Mixing Passenger Traffic and Heavy Freight Vehicles 8176 Tonkin Highway Extension - “Building the Highway” Publication 7940 Toodyay Bypass - Environmental Survey 8114 Traffic Accidents - Criterion for Reporting to Police 8854 Safer WA Community Security Program - Funding 1782, 1783, 1787, 1782, 2573, 3009 Schools Bullsbrook District High - Upgrade of Toilets 2716 Bus Service 8444, 133882; Grievance 12578 Preprimaries - 40 Kilometre an Hour School Zones - Statement 11498 Seniors - North West - Retirement Units 6036, 6037 Serpentine River - Guide Poles 7924 Shipping Industry - Coastal Shipping - Federal Government Actions 4863 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 421

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) State Boating Council - Appointment of Chairman - Statement 11246 State Budget - Road Funding Cut 7522 Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 - Review 8854 Tabled Papers - No 1450 - Error - Statement 11499 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 10184 Second Reading 10184, 11391, 11401 Consideration in Detail 11403-11406 Third Reading 11521 Council’s Amendments 14243 Taxis Burke, Mr Brian - Lobbying Activity 10285 Country Taxi Industry Review - Statement 13677 Demerit Point Penalty System 4672 Industry Reform - Motion 10626 Multipurpose Seatbelts 8120 Taxi Customer Service Charter 8115 Plate Allocation - Busselton and Dunsborough 8868 Plate Buyback Program 5365, 10566 Plate Leases - Level of Interest 14257 Public Liability Insurance - Review 4663, 4672 Restructuring of Industry - Statement 9659 Survey on Deregulation of Industry 8597 Taxi Industry Forum - Statement 4553 Tourism Lake Argyle Tourist Village - Redevelopment - Statement 8000 Tourism Planning Task Force Report - Statement 9856 Traffic Accidents - Criterion for Reporting to Police 8854 Transport Air Ansett Australia Ltd - Levy 6646 Broome Airport - Statement by Mr Dick Smith 10591 Fly In, Fly Out Charter Services - Statement 7515 National Airspace System - Federal Government Changes 8443; Statement 11681, 12742 Regional Airports - Statement 10158 Safety - Statement 10491 Skippers Aviation Pty Ltd - Perth-Laverton Route - Statement 8160 Western Australian Services - Statement 5332 AusLink Proposal 1590 Australian Transport Council - Statement 882 Ballajura - Improvements 4644 Boat Driver Training - Compulsory Course 13200 Buses Armadale-CBD 9797 Bunbury - Grievance 10391 Bus and Omnibus Licences - Grievance 1976 Canning Bridge-Perth Central Business District 4646 Drivers - Number and Stress Leave 8075 Kalamunda - Reduction in Number of Drivers 4636 Kwinana Freeway Bus Service - Cancellation 3925 Mandurah-Dawesville - New Buses and Terminal 4639 Rockingham-Fremantle Bus Transit System 4625 Route Changes and City Bus Stop Relocations - Advertising 8341 School Bus Service 8444; Grievance 12578 Southern Coast Transit 2168 Special Licence Operators - Safety Regulations 8865 Transit Guards 9307 Charter Vehicles 4676 422 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MacTIERNAN, HON ALANNAH JOAN GERALDINE (continued) Transport (continued) Concessional Fares - Changes 9730 Country - Funding 4802 Country Pathways Scheme - North West 8112 Cycleways 5450; Statement 8786 Cycling Infrastructure - North West 8112 Department - Telephone Service - Waiting Times 9714 Eastern Goldfields Grievance 10644 Transport Board - Mine Site Charter Transport 10875 Freight Coastal Shipping and Rail Freight 9084 Network Reform - Grievance 12581 Planning - South Metropolitan Corridor 1467 Fuel Tanker Trucks - Rollover Accidents 9308 Geraldton - Southern Transport Corridor Project 4104 Geraldton and the Mid West - Infrastructure 86 Hay Bales 7928, 13674 Heavy Haulage Transport Units - Kalgoorlie-Coolgardie 2993 Heavy Vehicle Advisory Group - Membership 4629 Licensing Call Centre - Performance - Statement 9082 Licensing Centres 8075, 9772, 12381; Grievance 10642 Metropolitan - Funding 4802 Mobile Caravan Licences - Classifications 9797 North West Expenditure 5179 Improvements in Accessibility for People with Disabilities 8269 Infrastructure Programs 8339 Passenger Transport 4671 Services Upgrade 4668 Recreational Boating Facilities Scheme 2995; Statement 9990 Regional Areas - Audits 9731 Road Coaches - Purchase - Statement 597 Rockingham Central City Transit Service - Steering Committee 4622 Shared-use Paths - Statement 8786 South Metropolitan Region Freight Network Reform - Grievance 4827 Improvement 5369 Subsidies - Cost 8119 Transperth 9307, 11392 TravelSmart - Grievance 7856; Statement 11077 Water Resources Gnangara Water Mound - Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment - Statement 13605 Peel Waterways - Power Boats - Number 14553 West Coast College of TAFE Carine Campus 4638, 4687 Joondalup Campus 1782 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 11406 Western Australian Land Authority Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 6473 Second Reading 6473, 8884 Third Reading 8984, 8986 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 10569 Second Reading 10569, 12350 Western Australian Symphony Orchestra - Year of the Outback Regional Tour 7782 Western Power - Traffic Accident - Reid Highway-Altone Road - Statement 6335 Woodchip Mill - Assessment of Sites Environmental Impacts 3561 Year of the Outback - Cost 4706 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 423

MARGETTS, HON DIANE ELIZABETH (Agricultural) (GWA) Aboriginal Cultural Materials Committee - Section 18 Applications 5665 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 Second Reading 12519 Ruling by Deputy President (Hon George Cash) 12645 Instruction to Committee of the Whole 12650 Committee 12651-12653, 12919-12921, 12928-12951, 12968-12981 Third Reading 13088 Address-in-Reply - Motion - Water Resources 2331 Adjournments of the House - Standing Orders Suspension 5666 Agriculture Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement 10363 Dairy Industry - Deregulation 7644 Department of - Institutional Biosafety Committee 593 Genetically Modified Crops Canola 6457, 11478 Gene Technology Interdepartmental Committee 1661 Introduction 2603 Office of the Gene Technology Regulator 161, 245 Trials 161, 11833, 12927 Genetically Modified Organisms 6279, 7824 Institutional Biosafety Committee - Membership 40 Pastoral Industry Working Groups 2481 Potato Marketing in Western Australia 9971 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading Kingstream Proposal at Oakajee 6252 Office of Energy Green Power Scheme 6252 One Per Cent Budget Incentive Scheme 6252 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 4) 2002 - Second Reading - Oakajee Proposal 6262 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Committee 9533, 9534 Australia Post - Bulbs and other Plant Species 12266 Australian Labor Party - Nuclear-powered Warships Policy 4957 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1734 Banks - Manual Slide Credit Card Facilities 12435 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes 12984 Second Reading 13063 Building Industry - Government Construction Contracts 7316 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1823 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 and Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6966 Impact on Small and Medium-Sized Businesses 6967 Tax Threshold Increase 6967 Taxation and Land Developers 6967 Committee 9016-9020 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 and Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 12641 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 10455 Committee 11825-11828, 11839-11859 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Second Reading 2898 Committee 3039, 3040 Commerce and Trade Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement 10363, 12015, 12288, 14721 General Agreement on Trade in Services 5052 Committees of the House - Reports - Consideration - Standing Orders Suspension - Amendment to Motion 2736 Commonwealth Government - Policies and Legislative Approach - Motion 6571 Community and Public Sector Union 14770 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3619-3627 424 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MARGETTS, HON DIANE ELIZABETH (continued) Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 7141 Committee 9042, 9043 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 2) 2001 Second Reading 5432 Committee 5764 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 3) 2001 - Second Reading 5768 Defence Forces Army Vehicles - Accidents with Civilian Vehicles 14030; Statement 14038 Lancelin Defence Training Area Adjournment Debate 473 Delegation to the United States Military 1847 Extension 865 Fire 5778, 7450, 9057 Permissive Occupancy Arrangement 1803, 14715 Proclamation 11039 Public Environmental Review 554 Military Flights - Perth International Airport 12160 Military Strategies of Federal Government - Statement 14721 Nuclear-powered Warships - Labor Party Policy 4957 United States Navy Australian Marine Complex 12160, 12161 Discussions with Local Officials and Politicians 12158, 12275 HMAS Stirling Ammunition Facility - Nuclear Weapons 12569 Infrastructure Changes to Site 12161 Investigations into Ability of Australian Marine Complex to Meet Needs 12158 Sea-swap Operations 4528, 9193, 9986, 11884, 12275; Petition 4377, 8347, 9149, 14669 Detention Centres - Release of Children 9656 Economic Regulation Authority 5316, 5534, 6330 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 Order Discharged and Referred to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 6545 Second Reading 9947, 9977, 10444 Committee 11963-1978, 12148, 12278-12285, 12293-12312, 12511-12516 Third Reading 12918 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14680 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14680 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14680 Electronic Transactions Bill 2001 - Second Reading 5200 Environment Bio-Gene Bioprospecting Ltd 13118, 14211 Chittering - Application for Planning Consent for Water Supply System 9635 Gnangara Water Mound - Threatened Species and Ecological Communities 6302 Greenhouse Gas Emissions Adjournment Debate 1669 State Government Stand - Urgency Motion 998 Kwinana - Cumulative Risk Study 711 Mid West and Murchison Rangelands - Management 4943 Moore River Estuary Development - Petition 8347 Narembeen Deep Drainage Project 551, 1741, 3336 Regional Herbarium Project - Funding 6084 Wetlands - Protection - Funding 9637 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4911 Second Reading 4969 Committee 11149-11159, 11196-11204, 11213, 11214, 11219, 11224 Clearing Regulations - Statement 7320 Estimates Committees - Appointment -Amendment to Motion 7148 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers7949 Finance Brokers Control Act - Repeal 7476, 8426 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 425

MARGETTS, HON DIANE ELIZABETH (continued) Fire and Emergency Services Coronial Inquiry into Fire at Lancelin - Statement 7455 Gingin Shire of - Firebreak Order - Swan Location 7807 East Lancelin 3291, 4432 Lancelin Defence Training Area - Fire 5778 Military Emergency or Retaliatory Attack - Essential Services 5022 Risk Management Training - 8415 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 1256 Fisheries West Coast Rock Lobster Fishery Management Plan Amendment 2003 - Disallowance 12113 Western Rock Lobster Fishery - Exemptions for Input Restrictions 11600 Forests and Forestry Gnangara Pine Plantation - Logging 4448, 4991 Kojonup Location 9212 - A mendment of Class A Reserve 1736 - Motion for Disallowance 14020 Pine Plantations - Resource Plans - Statement by Minister for Forestry and Fisheries 13105 Fuel and Energy East-west Infrastructure Corridor - Mt Margaret-Geraldton - Land Acquisitions 2158 Electricity Reform Implementation Committee - Consultants’ Report - Tabling by Leader of the House Motion 12411 Gene Technology Bills Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 50 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 - Second Reading - 14597 Geraldton Port Authority Data from Seagrass Monitoring Sites 11889, 13145 Dredging Operations 8567, 9845, 10089, 10116, 11363 Photosynthetic Active Radiation 9022, 9986 Port Upgrade 1005, 2156, 9588; Statement 9852 Government Contracts Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Urgency Motion 7316 Tender No 12603 - Stationery Contracts for Government Agencies 14607, 14197 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Second Reading 1823 Committee 1831, 1945, 1946, 1957, 1959-1961 Recommittal 1962, 1963 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1248 Housing and Works, Department of - Construction Contracts Policy - Urgency Motion 7316 Industrial Development East-west Infrastructure Corridor - Mt Margaret-Geraldton - Land Acquisitions 2158 Jervoise Bay Development - Breakdown of Expenditure on Infrastructure 12027 Kwinana - Cumulative Risk Study 711 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 1235 Shark Lake Industrial Site Esperance - 11209 Worsley Alumina Pty Ltd - Harris River Dam Water Allocation 4905 Iraq War Australia’s Support for United States Military Action Adjournment Debate 5215 Motion 2591, 3994, 4190, 4242 Justification - Adjournment Debate 5555 Opposition - Adjournment Debates 5031, 5434; Urgency Motion 5037 United Nations Processes - Adjournment Debate 1164, 1266 Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 853 Second Reading 857 Land Clearing Block CG 3819 North of Old Plain Road 8417 Gingin - Native Vegetation Clearing 10749 Regulations - Statement 7320 Swan Location 6845 3873, 4255 Local Government Gingin, Shire of 4432 426 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MARGETTS, HON DIANE ELIZABETH (continued) Local Government (continued) Rating System and Distribution of Funds Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Amendment to Motion 11991 Amendment on the Amendment 11992 Main Roads Western Australia - Roadside Tree Removal Policy 8408 Mining BGC (Australia) Ltd - Open-cut Mining at the Lakes - Impact on Water Resources 584 East-west Infrastructure Corridor - Mt Margaret-Geraldton - Land Acquisitions 2158 Gnangara - Status of Applications 3023, 3906 Portman Iron Ore Ltd 5665 Uranium - Petitions 6289 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - Standard of Answers to Questions - Statement 8574 Moora District Hospital - Brick - Request for Tabling 13129 National Airspace System - Federal Government Changes 8443 National Competition Council Council of Australian Governments Communique - 11175 Directive - Non-compliance 4200 Judge, Ms Petrice 14635 Legislative Reviews 12014 Policy Agreements - Statement 11608 Role and Implementation of Policy 4395 Statement 10926 Nuclear Activities (Prohibition) Bill - Enactment; Petition 6289 Nuclear Power Stations - Statement 7835 Parks and Reserves - Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736 Motion for Disallowance 14020, 14690 Parliament House - Smoking Locations - Statement 12272 Pastoral Leases 2481, 4944 Perth International Airport - Military Flights - Statistics 12160 Planning Developer Contributions to Infrastructure Costs Associated with Land Development 12553 Gingin Coast Structure Plan 12926 Mauds Landing Development - Urgency Motion 4187 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment No 1019/33 - Townsites in Stoneville and Parkerville Disallowance 5795 Moore River Estuary Development - Land Subdivision 12006; Petition 8347 Separation Point Marine Precinct 8577, 9634 Shark Lake Industrial Site, Esperance 11209 Town Planning Appeal Tribunal - BGC (Australia) Pty Ltd - Hearing Process 13081 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 365, 366 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2246 Pollution - Wesfarmers CSBP Ltd - Kwinana 7179 Port Kennedy Golf Course - Ground Water Use 3172, 4062 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12239 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7271 Questions - Standard of Answers from Minister for the Environment and Heritage - Statement 8574 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Committee 3319, 3320 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 Second Reading 6429 Committee 6550-6553 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Assembly’s Message 8389 Salinity 9637, 9638 Schools Dandaragan Primary 2871, 3731, 4340, 12038, 13861 Primary - Four-year-olds 2871, 3731, 4340 Select Committee into Water Services - Establishment - Motion 6449; Amendment to Motion 6452 Sewerage Gnarabup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Petition 337 Lancelin - Infrastructure 6955, 8417 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 427

MARGETTS, HON DIANE ELIZABETH (continued) Sittings of the House - Days and Hours - Amendment to Motion 2471 Small Business - Manual Slide Credit Card Facilities - 12435 Smoking Regulations - Review 8679 Southern Brush-tailed Phascogales 1260, 2124 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 3759 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9325 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel - Report 4491 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3151, 3152 Standing Order No 230(b) - Motion 2316 Standing Orders No 73 - Amendment - Amendment to Question 342 No 230 - Amendment - Motion 14691, 14703 Suspension - Adjournment of the House 5666 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 - Order Discharged and Bill Referred to the Standing Committee on Legislation 5320 Swan River Trust 9553, 9634, 10247 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Second Reading 3751 Committee 3880, 3881, 4014-4022, 4031-4035, 4206-4222 Recommittal 3884-3896 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Second Reading 3751 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) (Taxing) Bill 2001 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 49 Second Reading 3751 Telecommunications - Security Arrangements for Infrastructure 13164 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Amendment to Motion 3860 Trustees of Western Australia Limited (Transfer of Business) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6324 Unclaimed Money (Superannuation and RSA Providers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6425 United States of America Bush, President - Visit to Australia - Statement 12563 Nuclear-powered Warships - Labor Party Policy 4957 Servicepersons’ Worth to Economy of WA 10921 Support for Military - Urgency Motion 1407 United States Navy Australian Marine Complex - Security Plan 12161 Australian Marine Complex - Terms of Rules of Engagement 12160 Discussions with Local Officials and Politicians 12158 Discussions with Washington Consultants 12275 HMAS Stirling Ammunition Facility - Nuclear Weapons 12569 Infrastructure Changes to Site 12161 Investigations into Ability of Australian Marine Complex to Meet Needs 12158 Sea-swap Operations Community Consultation 4528 Coordination 12275 Impact on Ecologically Sustainable Development 9986 Infrastructure 12159 Minister’s Visit to US 9193 Nature and Volume of Freight Transports 11884 Petitions 4377, 8347, 9149, 14669 Task Force 12159 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1248 Second Reading 2618 Committee 2628-2631 Wambengers - Mortalities 1260, 2124 428 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MARGETTS, HON DIANE ELIZABETH (continued) Waste Disposal Atlas Waste - Calingiri - Ground Water 3613, 4547 Waste Management and Recycling Fund - Review 2226 Water and Rivers Commission Budget 2002-03 - Unspent Moneys 9642 Discretionary Powers 5194 Ground Water Management Areas - Target for Excess Use 9640 Improving Rivers and Estuaries - Partnerships 9638 Major Initiatives for 2003-04 9636 National Action Plan/Natural Heritage Trust - Budget 9640 Policy for Public Drinking Water Source Areas 9642 Rural Water Supply Assistance - Budget 9638 Water Allocation Policies Unspent Money 9643 Water Resources Catchment Areas - Protection 2765 Chittering - Application for Planning Consent for Water Supply System 9635 Desalinated Seawater - Piping from Esperance to Kalgoorlie-Boulder 13066, 13593 Gnangara Park Management Plan - Mining Applications 3023, 3906 Gnangara Water Mound 4448, 4991, 6302, 8416 Harris River Dam 3436, 4903 Hough Brook 345, 1139, 1745 Legislation - Review 465 Mathews, J.B. 1421 Narembeen-Avon Drainage Works 1950 Narembeen Deep Drainage Project 1741, 3336 Nilgin Service Co Ltd 4940 Office of Water Regulation 9639-9641 Port Kennedy Golf Course 3172, 4062 Secret Harbour Golf Course 3172, 4062 Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 6449; Amendment to Motion 6452 Water Services Coordination Act Review 8368, 12667, 13006; Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12411 Wellington Dam 9637 Yarragadee Aquifer - South West Water Extraction 12961, 12962 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4537 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1651 WorkSafe Western Australia - Inquiry into Fire at Lancelin - Statement 7455 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1248 Yandle, Mr Alan 12146

MARLBOROUGH, MR NORMAN RICHARD, Parliamentary Secretary, Consumer and Employment Protection; Indigenous Affairs (from 27 June); Minister Assisting, Public Sector Management (from 27 June) (Peel) (ALP) Aborigines - Gordon Inquiry -Comments by Member for Hillarys 2167 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2280 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2948, 2949 Adjournments of the House - Complimentary Remarks 14305 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3242 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading 4133 Ban on Use of Asbestos 4134 Lang Hancock 4135 Live Sheep Trade 4133 Safety of the Nation 4135 Army Museum of WA - Amendment on the Amendment 10998 Australia and its People - Statement 913 Cannabis - Decriminalisation - Matter of Public Interest 6355 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2280 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1991, 1997, 1998 Colleges of TAFE 4749, 12859 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 12364-12369 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 429

MARLBOROUGH, MR NORMAN RICHARD (continued) Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13187 Education Department - Budget 13918 Rockingham - New Initiatives 10027 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee 13726, 13727 Federal Budget - State Government’s Expectations 7518 Fremantle Artillery Barracks - Amendment on the Amendment 10998 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Motion 8913 Health - Bulk-billing by General Practitioners 3495; Peel Region 211 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula 5579, 7884 Kwinana - Buffer Zone - Grievance 2784 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract 2004 Industrial Disputes - Number 12325 Leader of the Opposition - Comments on Burrup Development 5579 Mining - WA Limestone - Petition 10170 Mitchell, Mr Russell James 10416 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 Second Reading 13821 Third Reading 13823 Police - DNA Testing - Success of Program 7679 Procedure and Privileges Committee - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Report 4882 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Third Reading 7235 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 966 Consideration in Detail 1346 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 13833, 13834 Road Safety - Black Spots Funding 9089 Schools - Behaviour Management and Discipline Strategy 601 Science and Technology - New Science Programs 276 Small Business - Home-based Business Forum 6648 Southern Rail Link - Opposition Transport Spokesperson’s Report 2924 Taxis - Industry Reform - Motion 10631 Tobacco Tax Windfall 1708 Training Department - Budget 13918 Rockingham 10027 Western Australian Group Training Scheme - Personal Explanation 7857 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2280 Western Australian Group Training Scheme - Personal Explanation 7857

MARSHALL, MR ARTHUR DIX (Dawesville) (Lib) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2542 Address-in-Reply Motion - Dawesville Electorate 102 Amendment to Motion - Health Services 106 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading - Peel Deviation 4112 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Third Reading - Dawesville 8466 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1754 Burswood International Resort Casino - Burswood Dome - Retention 2008 Bus Services Mandurah-Dawesville - New Buses and Terminal 4639 Perth-Mandurah - Petitions 7031, 8580, 9380; Statement 6641 Cannabis - Decriminalisation - Petitions 6470, 7033 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6631 Third Reading 6922 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10832 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13182 Dawesville Electorate - Falcon - Statement 11777 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13369 430 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MARSHALL, MR ARTHUR DIX (continued) Energy Operators and Water Agencies (Powers) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6505 Environment - Florida, Bouvard and Melros - Sand Dune - Grievance 6139; Petitions 5977, 7033, 9090 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2367, 2368 Fisheries GG Fish - Statement 8722 Mandurah and Peel Region - Fisheries Inspectors - Grievance 1678 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8213 Flower Industry - Accuracy of Eligible Producers List 13841 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Motion 8917 Government Vehicles - Audible Security Alarms 13308 Harrison, Ms Nicole - Statement 4853 Health ADD and ADHD - Referral to Education and Health Standing Committee - Motion 6847 Dental - Mr Ron Andrews 1311, 1312, 3261 Mosquito Control - Peel Region - Funding 14552 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petitions 6344 Physical Activity Taskforce - Recommendations 4156 Ross River Virus - Peel Region 2054 Vitamin A Program - Funding 3985 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11650 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Mandurah Office Closure 1233 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2028 Liquor - Sales in Restaurants - Petition 14053 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Mandurah infrastructure 10433 Peel Deviation 10431 Mandurah Cinema Complex - Non-compliance with Building Code 1778 Mandurah Forum Family and Children’s Facility - Closure 1519 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion, as Amended 10574; Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10600, 10686 Vehicles -Audible Security Alarms 13308 Ministers of the Crown - Vehicles - Audible Security Alarms 13308 Mosquitoes - Mandurah 2053, 3260, 9514 Peel Health Campus Day Care Extensions and Dialysis Machines 3979 Maternity Wing - Petition 284 Medical Indemnity Insurance Premiums of Visiting Medical Practitioners 205, 206 Peel Waterways - Power Boats - Number 14553 Planning Dawesville Channel - Sand Bypass System 8502 Peel Region Scheme - Disallowance 4093 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7058 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Third Reading 6476 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6359 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6359 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6359 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6359 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 782 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1295 Standing Orders Suspension 1335 Consideration in Detail 1348 Third Reading 1385 Railways -Southern Rail Link 9746; Petition 1568 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13747 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - Petition 6687 Roads Kwinana Freeway Extension - Commencement and Completion 9746 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 431

MARSHALL, MR ARTHUR DIX (continued) Roads (continued) Mandurah - Funding to Seal Road - Grievance 484 Old Coast Road Mandurah - Grievance 10384; Petitions 1970, 2171, 2652, 3784, 4813, 5837, 7031, 8691, 9380, 12444 Peel Deviation Commencement and Completion 9746 Federal Funds 2169, 2170 Funding - Grievance 8698 Grievance 13492 Land Acquisition 9471, 9473 Statement 9415 Sticks Boulevard-Old Coast Road, Mandurah - Petition 8008, 8157 Traffic Noise - Dawesville Petition - Statement 1704 Sandover Medal - Mr Allistair Pickett - Statement 911 Schools Dawesville Bridge South - New Middle School 1779 Halls Head Community College - New Year 8 Students 1778 Sewerage Falcon - Petition 4709 Infill Sewerage Program Grievance 4823 Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 2697 Statement 5361 Shark Patrol - Extension to Mandurah - Grievance 1978 Sport and Recreation Burswood Dome - Future 2008 Community Sport and Recreation Facilities Fund Program 2588 Hopman Cup - Venue 1200, 3980 Peel Region Athletic Scholarship Awards - Statement 7355 Peel Thunder Football Club - Statement 4099, 10021, 14248 Perth Oval 2819, 3003, 8794 Sporting Facilities - Priority List 1519 Tennis Stadium - Location 4159 Trailswest - Future 828 Walking Trails - Improvement 828 Taxi Industry Reform - Motion 10629 Totalisator Agency Board - Sports Betting Account and Fixed-odds Betting 8149 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Government Cost Cutting 9118 Yalgorup National Park - Controlled Burning 10637

MARTIN, MRS CAROL ANNE, BA (Kimberley) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Customary Law Project - Grievance 1683 Martu People - Rudall River National Park 10030 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 1871 Consideration in Detail 3389 Dolby, Mr Aide - Statement 8722 Economy - New Projects 85 Education and Health Standing Committee Annual Report 2001-02 - Tabling 489 Annual Report 2002-03 - Tabling 10649 Fifth Report - Tabling 11754 Fuel and Energy Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Sale 8002 Electricity - East Kimberley 9232 Gubinge Road, Broome - Sealing - Petition 66 Health Aborigines - Kimberley 8310 Aged Care - Kununurra 5722 Broome Nursing Home - Agreement with the Ribibi 8182 432 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MARTIN, MRS CAROL ANNE (continued) Health (continued) Kimberley 1201, 2389, 6812 Hospitals Derby Regional - Specialist Staff - Relocation to Broome District Hospital - Petition 65 Halls Creek - Replacement 5722 Kununurra - Aged Care Facility 5722 Industrial Development New Projects 85 North West - Downstream Processing Projects 10164 Law Reform Commission of Western Australia - Aboriginal Customary Law Project - Grievance 1683 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2024 Lennard Shelf Zinc and Lead Mines - Closure 11904 Members of Parliament Leader of the Opposition - Stirling House Hostel - Alcohol 3347 Standards of Behaviour - Statement 3669 Native Title Agreements and Litigation 4102 Martu Determination - Rudall River National Park 10030 Police Pay Dispute - Petition 11259 Regional and Remote Areas 11905 Ports and Harbours Broome 10423, 12863 Port Authority Boards - Diversification of Membership 5090 Regional Telecommunications Inquiry - Terms of Reference 278 Royal Flying Doctor Service - Fundraising Drive 13383 Shipping Industry - Federal Government 4863 Snake Creek Diversion - Grievance 12169 Stirling House Hostel - Alcohol - Leader of the Opposition 3347 Swimming Pool - Dampier - Grievance 9391 Telecommunications - Regional Inquiry 278, 1466 Tourism Commission - Offshore Marketing Budget - Cuts 3927 Transport - Air Broome Airport - Statement by Mr Dick Smith 10591 Kimberley Airfreight Service - Petition 10639 TS Broome - Petition 14215 Unemployment Rate 4743 Youth - Kimberley - Facilities and Activities 13696

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT, BSc, DipGem (Vasse) (Lib) Aborigines - Nyoongah Youth Centre Busselton - Statement 7878 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2276 Consideration in Detail 2308, 2309 Council’s Amendments 9136, 9137 Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 Second Reading 10185 Third Reading 10190 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2537 Consideration in Detail 2566, 2793, 2794, 2802-2807, 2833-2835, 2951 Address-in-Reply Motion Zimbabwean Farmers 321 Environment - Government’s Record 324 Amendment to Motion - Water Shortages 218 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7253 Atrazine - Use in Western Australia 4172 Compacted Soil and/or Subsoil Zones 1124 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 433

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT (continued) Agriculture (continued) Dairy Industry - Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9253 Department 4696, 7253, 14968 Oil Mallee Company of Australia Ltd - Funding 775 Poison 1080 691, 9309 Soil Phosphorus Levels and Fertiliser Application Rates 9311 State Weed Plan - Funding 14981 Alcoa World Alumina Australia - Dr Brian Galton-Fenzi - Conflict of Interest 987 AlintaGas - South Busselton - Reticulated Gas - Statement 5362 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Budget Papers 7543 Department of Indigenous Affairs, Bunbury 7545 Vasse Electorate 7546 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7543 Auditor General, Office of - Budget - Motion 11733 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1753 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Second Reading 11937 Consideration in Detail 12052-12054 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Mr Welker - Appointment 14967 Bromell, Mr Ross - Geographe Primary School - Grievance 1277 Busselton Jetty 8522; Statement 3668 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6639, 6650 Consideration in Detail 6792, 6803-6807, 6860, 6890, 6911, 6912 Third Reading 6927 Canning River 14542, 10879 Capel - Statement 5713 Caravan Parks - Ludlow Proposal - Grievance 9991 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2276 Consideration in Detail 2283 Conservation and Land Management, Department of Budget Papers - Reduction of 400 000 Hectares in Forest Area Managed 2843 Bunbury Office - Wildlife Officer 2844 Busselton District Office - Positions Vacant 9794 Coral Bay - Turtle Conservation 1629, 14982 Denny Road - Maintenance 13307 Management Costs for all Major Land Categories 3001 Mowen Road - Maintenance 13307 Prescribed Burning Program - WA Forest Alliance Claim 9007 Consultants Expertise 1397 Welker Environmental Consultancy - Appointments 14967 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Second Reading 5104 Consideration in Detail 5564-5573, 5587-5590, 5701-5712, 5725, 5726, 5979-5992, 6192-6203 Third Reading 6504, 6667 Council’s Amendments 12768, 12769 Coral Bay - Turtle Conservation - Department of Conservation and Land Management 1629, 5583 Crematoriums - Legislation, Number and Location 14145 Deer, Feral - Gidgegannup, Greenough, Chapman Valley and Northampton 5896 Driver Training and Education Centre - Perth International Airport 9138 Economics and Industry Standing Committee Inquiry into the WA Strata Management Industry - Final Report 9398 Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA - Eighth Report 14233 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Economics and Industry Standing Committee 13705, 13706 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13253 Energy Operators and Water Agencies (Powers) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6032 Environment Appeals to the Minister - Number and Processing 7268 434 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT (continued) Environment (continued) Bioprospect Ltd - Licence 14983 Catchment Management - Responsible Agency and Funding 14543 Coastal Erosion - Grievance 5337 Development Proposals - Geoheritage Issues 13312 Elwood, Mr Tony - Quarry at Red Hill 8315, 12069; Grievance 6609 Environmental Enforcement Unit - Day-to-day Operations 6936 Flooded Gums - Defoliation by Insects 2843 Geographe Bay - Removal of Seagrass Wrack from Beach 7117 Greenhouse Gas Emissions - Reduction by Government Departments and Agencies 685 Indigenous Plant Species - Statistics on Diversity 3404 Kalgan Queen Scenic Cruises and Wildlife Interpretation - Grievance 11748 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Golf Course - Site Pollution 1401 Law Reform Program - Mr Michael Bennett 688 Manganese Levels - 9785 Peel/Harvey Estuarine System - Nutrients 13675 Port Geographe - Groyne Field - Grievance 5337 Quokka - Muddy Lake Wetland System, Bunbury 6532 Regional Herbarium Project - Funding 6397 State Agreements - Exemptions from Act 11315 State Budget Initiatives 9788 State Reference Network Gauging Stations - Closure 981 State Weed Plan - Funding 14981 Underwood Avenue Bushland - Protection from Development 7116 Urban Nature Program - Budget and Staff 9800 WA Coastlines Document - Cost Distribution Purpose and Funding 11318 Western Australian Environmental Awards 2003 - Cost 9800 Western Swamp Tortoise 7115, 8275 Wetlands - Stirling Estate 1757 Wilderness Discovery Centre - Costs 14551 Wilderness in Western Australia - Liberal Party Position 12858, 12859 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 499 Referral to Legislation Committee 1488 Report of Legislation Committee 2417 Third Reading 2568 Council’s Amendments 11794-11805 Environmental Protection Authority Advisory Council - Membership 13311 Qualifications of Potential Members 823 Environmental Protection, Department of Chief Executive Officer - Appointment 13809 Review 6648 Staff - Bullying 13810 Staff Departures 8856 Fire and Emergency Services Fire Management in the Western Australian Environment - Motion 2706 House Fires - Smoke Alarms and Causes of Fires 9729 Fisheries Cherax Rotundus - Introduction 690 Commercial - Management Plans 671 Dive Wrecks - Number and Fishing Exclusion Zone 12819 Geographe Bay - Restrictions on Commercial Fishing 682 Pink Snapper - Effects of Trawl Fishery - Statistical Confidence Levels of Analyses 14147 South West - Sustainable Annual Catch 12507-12509 Forests and Forestry Buckingham near Collie - Impact of Logging 7780 Community Forest Inspection Program 5451 Draft Forest Management Plan - Effectiveness 6533 Flooded Gums - Defoliation by Insects 2843 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 435

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT (continued) Forests and Forestry (continued) Forest Management - Sustained Yield - Ferguson Report Recommendations 13553, 14529 Forest Products Commission - Sawn Timber Recovery Data 4688 Forests Round Table - Membership 13429 Greater Preston National Park - Illegal Tree Felling 8344 Jarrah - Imbalance in Numbers of Marri 6205 Jarrah Third Grade - Sawn Timber Recovery Rate 3000 Karri- Forest Explorer Self-guided Drive, Pemberton 8344 Logging Roads - Traffic Rules 8501 Ludlow Tuart Forest 5897, 13275, 14145; Petition 3354; Personal Explanation 3354 Mature and Intact Forest - Increase in Percentage Retained 1396 Pinetec Pty Ltd - Relocation and Timber Resource 6397 South West 1399, 9744 State Forests Nos 15, 39 and 64 - Partial Revocation of Dedication - Motion 14084 Nos 7, 14, 16, 28, 32, 33 and 58 - Partial Revocation of Dedication - Motion 14083 Sustainable Forest Management Output - 400 000 Hectare Reduction in Area Managed 2843 Tree Farming 3848 Warrup, Corbal, Mersea, Dudijup and Kingston Blocks - 13770 Wellington Discovery Forest - Inclusion in National Park 7406 Woodchip Mill - Assessment Environmental Impacts 3561 Fuel and Energy Bottled Gas - Rebate for Seniors and Pensioners - Petition 8447 Energy Smart Government Program - Report 14077 Manganese Levels in Liquid Fuels 9785 Narrogin Electricity Generation Station - Oil Mallee Waste 8138 Solar Hot Water Systems - Statement 7356 Wind Power - Peppermint Grove Beach 685 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3947 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8833 Government Architect - Appointment 12226 Government Contracts - Preference to Quality Assured Tenderers 1125 Government Departments and Agencies Bunbury Tower - Lease Agreement 8274 Consultants - Expertise 1397 Greenhouse Gas Emissions - Reduction 685 Internet Payments 11004 Web Sites - Online Payments 10720-10731, 11316, 11318 Welker, Mr Charlie 5511, 14544-14551 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 692-694, 987- 989, 1125, 1126, 1400, 1515, 1759, 3132, 3562 Health Barmah Forest Virus - South West 9472 Bulk-billing by General Practitioners - Petition 8008 Bunbury Health Task Force - Report 14571 Candle Wicks Containing Lead - Ban on Importation Production and Sale 7946 Chlorination of Drinking Water - Changes to Ovarian Function 8147, 8520 Full-time Equivalent Employees - Number 14572 Improved Services - Government’s Commitment 1315 Lead Concentrations in Human Blood - Guidelines 7946 Medicare - Bulk-billing - Petition 4589, 5837 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” - Motion 1215 Priority Issues - Matter of Public Interest 6825 Restaurants - Unwrapped Complimentary Mints 13305 Ross River Virus - South West 9472 South West District Health Advisory Committee - 3979 South West Health Service - Budget 1125 South West Mental Health Service - Staffing Levels and Expenditure 14146 Ultrafine Airborne Particles - Impact on Health 4173 Vasse Leeuwin Health Service - Budget 1125 Heritage - Western Australia’s Icons - Statement 12853 436 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT (continued) Housing Homelessness - Youth - Funding 9791 Sustainable Housing Design Competition - Restriction to House Designs for Broome Region 826 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11656 Consideration in Detail 12865-12873 Industrial Development HIsmelt Corporation Pty Ltd - Kwinana Plant 402, 1051; Petitions 1175, 1276 State Agreements - Exemptions from Environmental Protection Act 11315 Industrial Relations Legislation - Advertising Costs 687 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 630 Consideration in Detail 641, 645 Land Clearing - South West - Remnant Native Vegetation on Private Land 9772 Crown Land Surrounding Sussex Location 4443, Scott River - Management 14552 LandCorp - Atwell South - Statement 506 Lifeline WA - Annual Appeal - Statement 8306 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Bunbury District Hospital 10854 Bunbury Senior High School 10854 Carnarvon Senior High School 10854 South West Department for Community Development 10852 Department for Health - Mental Health Services 10853 Economic Growth 10851 Provision of Services 10852 Regional College of TAFE 10855 Western Power Infrastructure Requirements 10853 Local Government Coastal Planning and Land Use Strategies 13308 Mundijong Town Site - Town Planning Scheme Amendment - Personal Explanation 5091 South West Land Division - Private Ownership of Land 10564 Lotterywest Federation Walkway - Cost of Advertisement 13306 Heritage-listed Buildings or Properties - Grants 2845 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13943 Consideration in Detail 13972 Main Roads Western Australia - 10-year Plan for Road Construction Projects 4695 Members of Parliament Member for Roleystone - Behaviour 12206 Personal Explanations Ludlow Mining 3354 Mundijong Town Site - Town Planning Scheme Amendment 5091 Mining Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining 13275, 14145; Petition 3354; Personal Explanation 3354 Portman Iron Ore Ltd - Koolyanobbing Mine - Expansion 6183 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4568 Motor Vehicles Company Cars - Accidents 9138 Loud Music - Police Powers to Control 9743 Museum, Western Australian 6038, 8147 Noalimba Recreation Camp - Closure 827 Occupational Safety and Health - Work-related Deaths 8522 Parks and Reserves Beeliar Regional Park 4561, 14980 Cape Range National Park - Turtle Conservation Licence 14982 Crown Land Surrounding Sussex Location 4443, Scott River - Management 14552 Freshwater and Marine Fish and Crustaceans - Definition as Wildlife 14542 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 437

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT (continued) Parks and Reserves (continued) Greater Preston National Park - Illegal Tree Felling 8344 Ludlow National Park - Arum Lily Control 5897 Management Plans - Agency Responsible 14555 Mt Sandiman Station - Incorporation of Section into National Park 14571 National Parks and Nature Reserves - Commitment to Spend $25 Million 5896 Ningaloo Marine Park - Turtle Conservation Licence 5583, 14982 Wellington National Park - Inclusion of Wellington Discovery Forest 7406 Pastoral Leases - Mt Sandiman Station - Incorporation of Section into National Park 14571 Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6143 Planning Bunbury, City of - Town Planning Scheme - Delay in Approval 4645 Bushplan-Bush Forever - Purchase of Additional Sites 4655 Busselton - Old Court House Complex 8077 Coastal Erosion - Grievance 5337 Coastal Planning and Land Use Strategies 13308 Coastwest Grants Program - Funding 13308 Greater Bunbury Region Scheme - Grievance 12170 Location 413, Smiths Beach - Tourism and Residential Development 4642 Mauds Landing Development 4103, 9877; Motion 9895 Port Geographe - Groyne Field 9712; Grievance 5337 Rockingham Planning and Development Task Force - Staff and Costs 7948 Siesta Park - Coastal Erosion - Grievance 8932 WA Coastlines Document - Cost, Distribution, Purpose and Funding 11318 Police - Loud Music from Motor Vehicles - Noise Abatement Powers 9743 Pollution - Air HIsmelt Corporation Pty Ltd 402, 1051; Petitions 1175, 1276 Perth Air Quality Management Plan 824, 4173 Mercury - 9792 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 5852 Questions on Notice - Unanswered 3353 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 932 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1300 Consideration in Detail 1337 Railways Pemberton-Northcliffe Tramway - Traffic Rules 8501 Southern Rail Link 402, 4645; Matter of Public Interest 13933 Rainbow Lorikeet - Threat to Native Species 5897 Regional Development - Vasse - Expenditure 10564 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3834 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - National Competition Council Threat 9471 Roads Construction Projects - South West 4643 Denny Road - Maintenance 13307 Logging Roads - Traffic Rules 8501 Mowen Road - Maintenance 13307 Old Coast Road Mandurah - South of Dawesville - Removal of Trees 14556 Pemberton Tramway Company - Collision on Privately-owned Logging Road 7778 Road Projects - Commencement and Completion Dates 3562 Road Safety 5508, 9138 Roe Highway Stage 8 - Beeliar Regional Park 4561 Salinity Buckingham near Collie - Impact of Logging 7780 Funding - Projects and Activities 4661 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality - Motion 6518 Oil Mallee Company of Australia Ltd - Funding 775 Schools Bunbury High - Principal 825 Bus Service - Subsidy - Statement 2382 Busselton Senior High - Grievance 12826; Petitions 12690, 13202 438 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT (continued) Schools (continued) Dalyellup Primary - Design 9751 Geographe Primary - Grievance 1277 H Index - Vasse Electorate 14519 Lutheran College, Dalyellup - Statement 912 Newton Moore High 825, 985, 14487 Non-government - Funding - Petition 6685 Preprimaries - Class Sizes 682 Vasse Primary - Security System 5755 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7253 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9253 Select Committee on the Infill Sewerage Scheme - Establishment - Motion 2688 Seniors - Bottled Gas Rebate - Petition 8447 Service Stations - Use of Mobile Phones While Refuelling Motor Vehicles 1314 Sewerage Capel - Treatment Plant and Infill Program 1781 Conlon Street Waterford 8153, 8154 Infill Sewerage Program Busselton 2215 Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 2688 Ravenswood Hotel - Deep Sewerage Connection 14542 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9690 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9690 State Budget Agriculture, Forestry and Salinity 9313 Environment Initiatives 9788 Swan River Environmental Health - Motion 9259 Fish Deaths 8181, 8182; Budget Cut 8004 Matter of Public Interest 8797 Regulation of Drainage Water and Pollutants 14542 Riverplan Management Plan 8968; Release for Public Comment 8788, 8789 Sewage Discharge from Boats - Monitoring 10879 Sustainability Strategy 11398 Trust - Budget Cut 8004 Taxis - Plate Allocation - Busselton and Dunsborough 8868 Telecommunications Mobile Telephones - Use While Refuelling Motor Vehicles 11314 Rural Areas - Statement 13516 Tourism Crisis Marketing Funds 9310 Nature-based - Revenue 986 Transport Busselton Town Bus Service - Petition 4590 Licensing Centres - South West 12381 School Bus Service - Subsidy - Statement 2382 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9124 South West Department for Community Development - Crisis Accommodation 9125 Infrastructure Requirements 9125 Schools - H Factor 9125 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2276 Consideration in Detail 2284 University of Western Australia - Underwood Avenue Bushland 7116 Waste Disposal Atlas Waste - Licence Conditions for Mirrabooka Landfill and Recycling Site 13273 Batteries, Motor Oils and Tyres 13273 Bellevue Community Consultative Committee 826 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 439

MASTERS, MR BERNARD KENT (continued) Waste Disposal (continued) Brookdale Community Reference Group - Reconvening 8790, 8791 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility 4557, 14253 Perth Metropolitan Area - Total Tonnage 12819 Water and Rivers Commission Funding Increase 11704 Review 6648 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5120 Water Resources Busselton Water Board - Renewal of Appointments 983 Catchment Management - Responsible Agency and Funding 14543 Chlorination - Changes to Ovarian Function 8147, 8520 Dunsborough - Fluoride Levels of Bores 8149 Ground Water 1787, 13267 Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Conservation Initiatives 12384 Management - Matter of Public Interest 2395 Peel-Harvey Estuarine System - Nutrients 13675 Southern-Wongong River - Water Flow 981 State Reference Network Gauging Stations - Closure 981 Yarragadee Aquifer 7092; Petition 8446 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13943 Consideration in Detail 13975, 13977, 13978 Western Australian Land Authority Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 8823 Third Reading 8984 Western Power Complaints - Grievance 8284 Electricity Generation - Transmission and Distribution Efficiencies 14520 Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5459 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 948 Youth- Homelessness - Funding 9791

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW, BA, BJuris (Hons), LLB, JP, Attorney General; Minister for Justice and Legal Affairs (to 27 June); Electoral Affairs; Peel and the South West (to 27 June); Health (from 27 June) (Fremantle) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Customary Law Project - Grievance 1684 Aboriginal Health, Office of - Houston, Mr Edward Shane 14138 Mental Health Services - Funding Cuts 11905 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2256 Second Reading 2256, 4606 Consideration in Detail 4725, 8988-8990 Third Reading 8992 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 746 Second Reading 746, 3962 Consideration in Detail 3963-3967 Third Reading 3967 Council’s Amendments 7389, 7390 Auditor General, Office of - Matter of Public Interest 12332 Banksia Hill Detention Centre 5757 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14311 Building Industry - Cole Royal Commission - Report - Criminal Matters 11537 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 11660-11669 Caravan Parks - Ludlow Proposal - Grievance 9992 Censorship Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendment 7390 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3849 Child Abuse - Procurement of Children for Sexual Acts by Electronic Means - Grievance 11080 Child Support (Adoption of Laws) Amendment Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 3694 440 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Civil Judgments Enforcement Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14278 Second Reading 14278 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 8997 Clontarf Aboriginal College - Location 1309 Committees and Boards Members - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7752 Review - Appeals Tribunal - Establishment 683 Commonwealth Powers (De Facto Relationships) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12450 Second Reading 12450, 14069, 14079 Third Reading 14079 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14392 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3122 Convention and Exhibition Centre - Liquor Licence Application - Statement 12446 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 2) 2001 - Council’s Amendments 6499 Corporations (Consequential Amendments) Bill (No. 3) 2001 - Council’s Amendments 6500 Corruption and Crime Commission - Legislation 7519; Referral to Committee 8964 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 First Reading 14908 Second Reading 14908, 14911 Third Reading 14912 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7861 Second Reading 7861, Declaration as Urgent 8061 Second Reading 8187; Adjournment of Debate 8070; Pro Forma Amendments 8191 Standing Orders Suspension 8288 Consideration in Detail 8288-8305, 8316-8335 Recommittal 8336, 8337 Third Reading 8337 Council’s Amendments 9454-9456 Council’s Amendments, As Corrected 9456, 9458 Delay 11781 Courts Bench Warrants - Number Outstanding 9798 Court Security and Custodial Services Contract - Statement 478 Courts of Petty Sessions 678 Family Court - Duvall, Mr David and Debbie 4703 Kalgoorlie Court of Petty Sessions 675, 678 Pinjarra Courthouse - Closure 3234 Courts Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14292 Second Reading 14293 Crematoriums - Legislation, Number and Location 14145 Crime - Forfeiture of Cash and Property - Statement 3478 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 6151 Standing Orders Suspension 6151 Second Reading 6158, 10955 Consideration in Detail 10956-10960, 11127-11139; Statement by Deputy Speaker 11127 Third Reading 11560 Criminal Code Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2003 Division of Bill 10955 Consideration in Detail 14263-14271 Third Reading 14272 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 11682 Second Reading 11682 Consideration in Detail 12354-12373 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 441

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 (continued) Third Reading 12600 Council’s Amendments 14263 Criminal Law (Procedure) Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 1388, 1389 Criminal Property Confiscation Act - Ruling by Court of Criminal Appeal - Statement 10156 Crown Solicitor - Appointment - Statement 11246 Defamation and Libel Laws - Grievance 3199; Statement 13486 Double Jeopardy Law - Statement 13487 Drugs Cannabis - Convictions 7108 Interstate and International Travel by Government Employees 10876 Life Education Preventive Health Program - Funding Cut 12761 Perth Drug Court - Evaluation - Statement 13486 Electoral Political Parties - Funding 12862 Reform - Solicitor General’s Advice 2005; Statement 6676 Electoral and Constitution Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 13495 Second Reading 13496 Electoral Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12744 Second Reading 12744 Order Discharged 13397 Electoral Reform Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2257 Second Reading 2257 Electricity - Reform - Legal Work 10590, 10679 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 979 Female Genital Mutilation - Legislation - Grievance 3203 Finance Brokers Scandal - Charges and Convictions 8155 Fines, Penalties and Infringement Notices Enforcement Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2253 Second Reading 2253, 3959 Finn, Mr Shane - Limited Work Release and Home Leave Order - Statement 3477 Fisheries - Palmer, Jeff and Gail - High Court Appeal Case 2929 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8206 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme - Motion 427 Gluyas, Ms Bridgid - Payment to Judgment Creditor 11436 Government Advertising - Expenditure 8096 Government Contracts - Statistics 6936, 7263 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14443 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3849 Cleaning Services 7101, 13764 Club/Association Memberships - Payment 7587, 9775 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 13296, 14561 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 8106 Credit Cards 8100; Statement 14501 Creditors 8079, 9754 Employment Contracts 7093 Grants 12885 Indigenous People 5162 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6936 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14566 Leave Liability 5153 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14367 Leschenault Estuary - Management 6238 Management Initiated Redundancies 7595 North West - Staff and Programs 2713 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10705 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections 7774 442 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs 14402 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14457 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7759 Staff 982, 8139, 14532 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 8859 Web Sites - Online Payments 10722 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14545 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 1515 Government Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 12332 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 8104 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 8102 Motorcycles - Statistics 7263 Privately Plated 7936 Guardianship and Administration Board 4705, 5754 Hancock, Mr Lang - Inquiry into Death 9801 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14392 Health Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA Former Minister for Health - Matter of Public Interest 9680 Select Committee - Motion 10317 Statement 9658 Asbestosis - Vitamin A Program 11140 Association of Relatives and Friends of the Mentally Ill - Funding 11254 Audiology Services - Statistics 14138 Autism - Early Intervention Programs 13312, 14144; Number of Children Diagnosed 14144 Bunbury Health Task Force - Report 14571 Cardiac Recovery and Intervention Programs - Funding 14146 Child Development Services - Funding Cuts 13699 Chiropractors - Competition Review of Health Provider Legislation 14144 Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement - Signing 10673, 10674 Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11916 Continence Aids - Government Funding 13309 Country Health Services Review - Moora Hospital Project 13195 Crisis and Emergency Services - Funding 14140 Crisis in System - Bypass and Ramping 11400 Dental Craigie Dental Therapy Centre 12857 Regional Services - Waiting Lists 11702 Department Annual Reports and Auditor General’s Qualified Audit Opinion 13274 Staff and Salaries Increases 14256 DNA Analysis - Staff Numbers 11677 Duncraig House - Proceeds from Sale 11909 Eastern States Consultants - Hiring 10593 Full-time Equivalent Employees 14572 Funding Cuts 11621, 11622, 11959, 12611, 13700 11959 Matter of Public Interest 14890 Statement 11244 General Practitioner Services - Wanneroo - Grievance 11753 Health Review, Office of - Statement 14258 Hearing - Universal Newborn Hearing Screening Program 11778 Independent Living Program - Expansion - Request for Quotation 14986 Kalgoorlie and Eyre - Funding Cuts 14143 Lady Brand Lodge - Closure 12860 Life Education Preventive Health Program - Funding Cut 12761 Management of Health System - Matter of Public Interest 11633 McCallum, Dr Barney - Government Payments 10877 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 443

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Health (continued) Mental Health System Aboriginal Services - Funding Cuts 11905 Accommodation Services - Funding 13280 Adult Inpatient Facilities - Funding 13286 Bed Closures 13274 Carer Respite Programs - Funding 13279 Clinical Outcomes 11903 Community Organisations - Funding 12612, 12613 Community Services - Funding 13290 Funding Cuts 11533, 12205 Matter of Public Interest 11265; Amendment to Motion 11269 Programs 10822, 10823 Health Consumers’ Council of WA - Funding Cuts 12203 Older Adult Psychiatry Services - Funding 13283 Report on Review of Mental Health Act 11901 Mosquito Control - Peel Region - Funding 14552 Murray Districts Multipurpose Health Service 11436 North Metropolitan Population Health Division - Funding Cut 12688 Nurses Agency 12462, 12817 Assaults by Patients 11951 Number 12817 NurseWest - Details 11670 Prisons - Pay Commitment 3344, 3496 Osteopathic Profession - Competition Review of Health Provider Legislation 14144 Pain Management Centre, Bunbury - Funding 13309 Parkinson’s Disease Nurse Specialists - Grievance 12579 Priority Issues - Matter of Public Interest 6824 Reform Committee 10495, 13921 Restaurants - Unwrapped Complimentary Mints 13305 Seniors - Physiotherapy and Mobility Classes - Funding Cuts 11623 Sexually Transmitted Infections - Statement 10265 South West Health Service - Staff 11111 South West Mental Health Service - Staffing Levels and Expenditure 14146 Victoria Park Pharmacy - Statement 9989 Warburton Medical Clinic - Dialysis Services 10876 Wheatbelt District Health Advisory Council - Meetings - Reimbursement of Costs 12065 Heritage - Duncraig House - Proceeds from Sale 11909 Hospitals Amb ulances Bypass and Ramping 10825, 10963, 11399, 11400 Free Service for Pensioners 11397 Improvement of Services in Metropolitan Area - Motion 12489 Northern Suburbs 14143 Bunbury Regional Coxall, Maddison 10165, 10284 Intensive Care Unit 12063, 12064 Specialist Surgeon Shortage 10675 Theatre Facilities Upgrade 10166 Capital Works Funding 11532; Personal Explanation 11560 Dumbleyung District Memorial 13521, 13698 Elective Surgery - Waiting Times 14879; Matter of Public Interest 14890 Emergency Departments 11532; Statement 10265 Fremantle - Stroke Patients 11704 Geraldton Regional 12857, 13199, 13200, 13610, 13523 Harvey - Budget for Future Planning 11676 Joondalup Private Hospital 12469 Kalamunda District Community - Redevelopment 13927; Motion 13402 Moora District 13195; Matter of Public Interest 13210 444 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Hospitals (continued) Morawa - Multipurpose Service Hospital - Grievance 13491 Northampton District 10963, 11624; Grievance 11751 Osborne Park - Upgrade 11907 Pemberton - Statistics 14553 Port Hedland 14881 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Indemnity for Doctors 14249 Regional Areas - Downgrading for Redevelopments 13519 Royal Perth Ambulance Ramping 11399 Norrish, Mrs Sanchia - Death - Motion 13725 Shenton Park Rehabilitation 14558, 14559 Staff - Violent Attacks 12062, 12063 Teaching - Funding 11540 Trust Accounts - Indemnity for Doctors 14249 Warren District - Closure of Beds 11110 Wheatbelt - Fundraising Proceeds 14075 Yarloop 10424, 11676; Statement 9990 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11767 Pro Forma Amendments - Motion 11770 Consideration in Detail 12728-12737, 12755-12757, 12770-12773, 12842-12846, 12866, 12869-12874 Standing Orders Suspension 12874, 12875 Third Reading 12875 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment (Prohibition of Human Cloning) Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 12876, 12877 Third Reading 12878 Industrial Relations Cole Royal Commission into the Building Industry - Report - Criminal Matters 11537 Unions - Government Grants 8859 Information Commissioner Amalgamation with Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations 12199, 12318, 12319 Matter of Public Interest 12332 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1109 Juries Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 4713 Second Reading 4713, 6002 Consideration in Detail 6008, 6009, 6189-6191 Third Reading 6496 Justice, Department of Charges Against Australian Citizens by People from Overseas 5757 Court Security and Custodial Services Contract - Statement 478 Criminal Law - Joinder of Offences - Grievance 483 Employees 7115, 7121 Enoch, Mr Jeff 7269, 7885, 7886 Fines Enforcement Registry - Outstanding Fines 9505 Hancock, Mr Don and Mr Lou Lewis - Murder Trial - Jury Decision 12763 Imprisonment Rates - Statement 4710 North Fremantle Bail Hostel - Use 1309 Parole Board Matters - Portfolio Responsibility 14073, 14074 People in Custody - Escapes, Deaths and Suicides 9491 Reid, Ms Rhonda 7121 Justices of the Peace Age of Termination of Commissions 7945 Elsegood, Mr John - Grievance 481 Females 689 Motherway, Mr Liam - Statement 10568 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3682 Law Reform Commission Western Australian - Grievance 483, 1684 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4873; Standing Orders Suspension - Amendment to Motion 4865 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 445

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Legal Aid Albany 1519 Guidelines - Statement 3909 Legal Practice Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2254 Second Reading 2254, 4599 Consideration in Detail 4717, 5733-5751, 8887, 8888, 8897-8904, 8960, 8961, 8970-8982 Council’s Amendments 13543-13545 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote 2003; Matter of Public Interest 2030 Liquor Licensing - Convention and Exhibition Centre - Statement 12446 Magistrates Court Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14275 Second Reading 14275 Magistrates Court (Civil Proceedings) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14277 Second Reading 14277 Mantraps - Serpentine-Jarrahdale Hills 1587 McIlveen, Mr Watson - Grievance 8283 Mickelberg Case Appeal - Minister for Health - Evidence 2009, 2010, 2276 Legal Expenses - Statement 10157 Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General - Documents Given to Minister for Health 600, 913 Distribution of Copies - Minister for Health 88, 89 Formal Request for Further Documents 22 Letter from the Director of Public Prosecutions to Raymond Mickelberg 913, 914 Minister for Health - Allegations 1310, 1311 Minister for Health - Investigation by Police Royal Commission 4109 Police Royal Commission - Reopening Investigation 767, 769 Ministers of the Crown Attorney General Allegations of Criminal Behaviour by Cabinet Members - Motion 805 Coffee-making Machine in Ministerial Office 5756 Visits to the United Kingdom and Europe - Statement 494 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 7597 Minister for Health Investigation by Police Royal Commission 4109 Personal Explanation - Hospitals - Capital Works 11560 Mobile Phones - Use 4804 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10714 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14430 Corporate Credit Cards 8246, 9920, 12382 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9780 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4810 Vehicles - Privately Plated 6781 Staff, Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5142 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 8948, 8949 Oaths, Affidavits and Statutory Declarations Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14290 Second Reading 14290 Oaths, Affidavits and Statutory Declarations (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14291 Second Reading 14291 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations 8602, 12199, 12318, 12319; Matter of Public Interest 12332 Parker, Hon Justice Kevin - Statement 13487 Planning Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 427 North West - River Foreshore Development Programs 7265, 8114 446 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Police Bikie Gangs - Failure to Wear Helmets 3781 Custody - Number of Escapees 6235 DNA Testing - Home Burglary and Sexual Assault 4859; Staff Numbers 11677 Officers Charges of Assaulting 686 Legal Representation 1712 Royal Commission - Legal Representation for Police Officers 1712 Prisons Acacia 2576, 6487, 6489; Statement 9384 Albany Regional - Night Shift Security Procedures 3008 Bandyup 5913, 6487, 6489; Grievance 7338 Child Rapist - Parole Denial 3232 Court Security and Custodial Services Contract - Statement 478 Drugs 9494, 9495 Hakea 6487, 6489, 6683, 7885, 7886 Harding, Mr Richard - Report 2576 HIV and Hepatitis C Programs 9495 Imprisonment Rates - Statement 4710 Nurses - Pay Commitment 3344, 3496 Nyandi-Longmore Site 9509, 9510; Motion 5607 Officers 6239 Paroled Prisoners 3232, 3233 Policy to Reduce Prison Population - Risk to Community - Matter of Public Interest 10503 Prisoners Colour Television Sets and other Recreational Equipment 1517 Complaints of Physical and Sexual Abuse 1518, 2051, 2052 Regional - Closures 4858, 4859 Riverbank Remand Centre - Missing Electronic Equipment and Whitegoods 7121 Wilful Damage - Cost 1516 Prisons Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendment 6500 Public Accounts Committee - Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Report - Statement 14873 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 5574-5576 Questions on Notice - Answers 8008, 11259 Regional Development Commissions Act - Division 2, Section 23(1)(e) Breaches 2054, 2055 North West - Programs 8150 Peel Region - Government Services 4684, 4685 Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13210 South West - Government Services 4684, 4685 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 498 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Number, Membership and Cost 11671 Royal Commission into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers 688, 2214, 4109 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Motion 10317 Seniors - Physiotherapy and Mobility Classes - Funding Cuts 11623 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 175 Second Reading 175, 2988 Consideration in Detail 2988, 3245-3256, 3637-3659, 3663-3668, 3692 Third Reading 3694 Council’s Amendments 9463, 9464 Sentencing Legislation Criminal Offences - Maximum Jail Term of Six Months or Less 1760 Six-year Sentences - Parole 2674 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 177 Second Reading 177, 2685 Consideration in Detail 2979, 3696-3702 Third Reading 3703 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 447

McGINTY, HON JAMES ANDREW (continued) Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 (continued) Council’s Amendments 9460 State Administrative Tribunal - Establishment 5753, 6205, 6776 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9102 Second Reading 9102 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9703, 10002 Consideration in Detail 10010-10020, 10032-10049 Third Reading 10428 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9104 Second Reading 9104 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9703, 10002 Consideration in Detail 10268-10280, 10289-10299, 10395-10404 Third Reading 10425 Swan Village of Care - Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Motion 5607 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3548 Consideration in Detail 3550-3556 Third Reading 3556 Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Bill 2002 - Charges Against Australian Citizens 5757 Victims of Crime Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 4714 Second Reading 4715

McGOWAN, MR MARK, BA, LLB, DipLP, Parliamentary Secretary, Premier; Public Sector Management; Federal Affairs; Science; Citizenship and Multicultural Interests (Rockingham) (ALP) Address-in-Reply - Motion Asylum Seekers - Australia’s Policy and Effect on Navy Personnel 129, 183 Western Australian Governor 128 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Rockingham - Funding 7918 Treasurer’s Role 7918 Volatile Substance Abuse 7918 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8465 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7918 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8465 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1752 Bills Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 393, 404 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6706 Standing Orders Suspension - Question to be Put 6887 Carnac Island Sea Lion Colony - Statement 5363 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5691 Second Reading 5691, 7349 Consideration in Detail 7352-7354, 7377-7387, 8735-8746, 8993-9002 Third Reading 9135 Council’s Amendments 12590-12598 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 94 Second Reading 94, 1089 Consideration in Detail 1984-1999, 2033-2036, 2172-2184 Third Reading 2361 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3129 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph, MLA - Condolence Motion 13185 Defence Forces Armidale-class Patrol Boats - Tender 9417 Army Museum of WA - Motion 10990; Amendment to Motion 10994 448 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McGOWAN, MR MARK (continued) Defence Forces (continued) Fremantle Artillery Barracks - Motion 10990; Amendment to Motion 10994 Fremantle-class Patrol Boats - Contract 766, 3224 Military Heritage - School Students 14255 Premier’s Message of Support for Personnel in Gulf Region 5716 US Navy Sea-swap Operations 2926 Drought Assistance - Government Package 2270 Economy, Western Australian 4556, 10818, 13194 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee Amendment to Motion 13710 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Second Reading 13242 Consideration in Detail 13538, 13539, 13691 Federal Budget - State Government’s Response 7672 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8925 Fuel and Energy Electricity Reform - WA Power Conference Support 11783 United States Energy Market - Potential for WA Economy 13809 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3522 Graffiti - Statement 4855 Health Council of Australian Governments Meeting - Agenda 10589 Incontinence Pads - Petition 5835, 6469 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petition 6469 Rockingham Recreational Social Centre for People with Mental Illness - Petition 6686 HMAS Anzac - Statement 6181 HMAS Darwin - Statement 6181 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message Amendment to Motion 393, 404 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula - Development 23 HIsmelt Corporation Pty Ltd - Leader of the Opposition’s Comments 3670 Noise Monitoring - Kwinana and Rockingham 3419 Projects in Western Australia - Strength 13194 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 98 Second Reading 98, 633 Consideration in Detail 638-645, 648-663, 1098-1114, 1118-1120 Third Reading 1390, 1394 Iraq War - Premier’s Message of Support for Australian Defence Force Personnel 5716 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Local Government Revenue 11124 McIlveen, Mr Watson - Grievance 8282 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Amendment to Motion 10524 Motion 10533 Member for Rockingham - United States of America Visit - Statement 507 Ministers of the Crown Minister for Racing and Gaming - Breach of Code of Conduct 766 Premier - Visit to United States of America 12317 Motor Vehicles - DVD-Television Players - Statement 11777 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Amendment Bill 2003 Referral to Select Committee - Amendment to Motion 12458 Consideration in Detail 12601, 12602, 12616-12623 Third Reading 12629 Occupational Safety and Health - Seating in Workplaces - Statement 4101 Police - Government’s Pre-election Promises - Motion 14098 Procedure and Privileges Committee - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Report 4884 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 970 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 449

McGOWAN, MR MARK (continued) Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 (continued) Referral to Joint Select Committee - Question to be Put 1324 Rail Link, Southern Matter of Public Interest 2940 Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 1601 Rockingham Residents - Consultation 11702 Rally Australia - New Contract 7267 Retail Trading - Current Hours Regime - Legality 8889 Rockingham - Government Achievements - Statement 11106 Rockingham-Kwinana District Hospital - Statement 2001 Royal Australian Navy - Patrol Boat Tender 766, 9417; Statement 3224 Safer WA Community Security Program, Rockingham - Funding 1782 Schools - Military Heritage - Preservation 14255 Seniors Card - Extension of Benefits to People with Disabilities - Statement 6642 Shark Patrol - Grievance 12823 Sport and Recreation Rockingham - Recreational Social Centre for People with Mental Illness - Petition 6686 Rugby World Cup - Benefits 13524 Springfield Retirement Village - Local Government Rates Rebates 5508 State Budget - Leader of the Opposition’s Comment 1585 State Finance Commonwealth Grants - Reduction 7022 Moody’s Investors Service Credit Rating 11533 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 First Reading 12806 Second Reading 12806, 14283 Consideration in Detail 14284-14286 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Claims of Oppression, Abuse and Intimidation 8001 Taxation - Increase - Impact on Average Worker 6239 Total Waste Management Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion 5273 Tourism 10-year Plan 6412 International Visitors Emirates Services 6412 Slowdown 7267 Lack of Professionalism in Industry 7405 Portfolio - Elevation of Status - Matter of Public Interest 2832 US Navy Sea-swap Operations 2926 Unemployment Statistics 2814, 6644 United States of America Energy Market - Potential for Western Australian Economy 13809 US Navy Sea-swap Operations 2926 Visit by Member for Rockingham - Statement 507 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message Amendment to Motion 393, 404 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11295 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message Amendment to Motion 393, 404

McHALE, HON SHEILA MARGARET, BA, DipSSc, JP, Minister for Community Development, Women’s Interests, Seniors and Youth; Disability Services; Culture and the Arts (Thornlie) (ALP) 990 6RPH Information Radio - Funding 2572 Aborigines Abused and Neglected Children 4673 Child Protection Workers - Placement 11628 Children in Foster Care 4673 Disability Services Initiatives - Statement 377 Gordon Inquiry Comments by Member for Hillarys 2167 Implementation of Recommendations - Funding 9086 New Allegations or Evidence 1462 450 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McHALE, HON SHEILA MARGARET (continued) Aborigines (continued) Gordon Inquiry (continued) Report - Statement 274 Indigenous Women’s Congress - Statement 11897 North West Family Counselling 4166 Family Violence Prevention Support Service 3570 Onslow - Protection of Children and Women 8178 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Claims of Oppression, Abuse and Intimidation 8001 Adoption Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander Children - Foster Care and Abuse 4673 Adoptions Regulations 1995 - Statement 8692 Budget Allocation 9494 Carer and Relative Intercountry Adoption and Inquiries 4674, 5175 Gay and Lesbian Couples 10566 Health Assessment of Applicants 5174 Inquiries for Carer Adoption 4674 Overweight Applicants 7107 Procedures for Birth Parents to Make Inquiries 4673 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Introduction and First Reading 99 Second Reading 99, 1899 Consideration in Detail 3081-3085, 3093-3104, 3205-3218, 3222, 3223, 3236-3244, 3357-3387, 3390-3392, 3395, 3397-3402 Third Reading 3557, 3559 Council’s Amendments 5727-5733 Arts and Culture Australia Business Arts Foundation Awards - Statement 9989 Business Sponsorship - Statement 478 Contemporary Music Initiatives for Young People - Statement 10945 Task Force 4070 Cultural Ministers Council Meeting - Statement 6132 Entertainment-Culture Centres - Bunbury, Mandurah, Kalgoorlie and Geraldton 3008 “Essentially Ellington” Event - Statement 479 North West - Building Programs 5515 State Arts Sponsorship Scheme Awards - Statement 13193 Visual Arts - Achievements and Developments - Statement 1853 Bali Bombings Assistance and Support - Statement 2251 Condolence Motion 1753 Bateman, Mr Thomas Henry, MLA - Condolence Motion 11893 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14327 Cannabis Decriminalisation - Dependence and Mental Illness 7882 Youth Suicide 6815 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3850 Children and Community Development Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14244 Second Reading 14244, 14259 Children and Young People’s Policy, Office of - Funding Cut 7523 Committees and Boards - Members - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7755 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14395 Community Development Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander Children - Foster Care and Abuse 4673 Advisory Council on the Prevention of Deaths of Children and Young People 8600 Best Beginnings Program, Midland - Statement 6132 Campaign to Warn of the Dangers of Parents Shaking their Babies - Statement 7657 Care and Protection Orders 12739, 13840 Carers’ Counselling Line - Statement 10569 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 451

McHALE, HON SHEILA MARGARET (continued) Community Development (continued) Child Abuse Government Inaction - Matter of Public Interest 9097 Investigation of Allegations 3230 Mandatory Reporting - Statement 171 Select Committee - Establishment Amendment to Motion 1890, 2285 Motion 2289 Child Card - Funding 9085 Child Death Review Committee Budget and Meetings 6240 Hon Kay Hallahan - Terms of Employment 6037 Membership and Cost 5174, 5175 Statement 11247 Child Protection Appointment of Officers in Aboriginal Communities 11628, 12610, 14955 Underresourcing 9090 Children in Care - Allegations of Abuse While in Care 8180 Children in Need of Care and Protection Halls Creek 8143 South Hedland 8141 Children Placed in Out-of-home and Alternative Care - Number 13840 Commissioner for Children - Appointment 8603, 9090 Community Services Industry Awards - Statement 3341, 13604 CREATE Foundation Funding - North West 4167 Department Child Abuse Allegations 8182 Child Protection Workers 14955 Esperance Office - Staff 6042 Funerals 9512 Halls Creek 7597, 8144 Neagu, Ms - Vehicle Use 4686 South Hedland 7597, 8140 Staff Morale 13668 Donovan Village Hostel Playgroup - Statement 6609 Early Years Strategy - Statement 12314 Family Violence - Police Reports 9089 Foster Carers Statement 6335 Subsidy Increase 7028 Grandcare - Statement 12742 Grandparents as Primary Carers Assistance in North West 5514 Grievance 9996 Statements 5221, 12447, 12742, 13677 Mandurah Forum Family and Children’s Facility - Closure 1519 Men’s Emergency Accommodation Service North West 5395 Statement 173 National Carers Week - Statement 2162 National Child Protection Week - Statement 10816 North West Aboriginal Family Counselling 4166 Caring for the Carers Program 9476 Child and Family Sexual Abuse Counselling 8114 Family Strength Programs 4670, 4672, 8521 Homelessness and Social Exclusion Programs 5514 Social Exclusion Programs 8867 Office for Children and Young People’s Policy - Establishment - Statement 2251 Out of School Care - Regulations - Statement 1276, 10639 Parkerville Children’s Home - Centenary - Statement 5681 452 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McHALE, HON SHEILA MARGARET (continued) Community Development (continued) Red Cross, Kalgoorlie-Boulder Soup Patrol Funding 3572 Grievance 9385 Wanslea Family Services - Statement 11617 Wards of the State - Powers of Department 11742 Westview Hostel, Sunset, Geraldton 11957 Disability Services Access for People with Disabilities to Government Information Services and Facilities - Statement 8693 Access to Public and Private Sector Organisations - Grievance 11503 Accommodation Support - Statement 4554 Autism - Early Intervention Programs 14554 Bennett Brook Arts and Training Pilot Project - Statement 12681 Commission Budget 6411 Cleaning Services 5520, 5721, 6411 Health Resource and Consultancy Team - Statement 5824 Health Services 13278 Commonwealth Assistance 7521 Commonwealth-State-Territory Disability Agreement - Statement 2353, 8161 Disability Services Act 1993 - Tenth Anniversary - Statement 14875 Domestic Violence - Women with Disabilities - Statement 14056 Indigenous People - Statement 377 International Day of People with a DisAbility - Statement 3775, 14054 Local Area Coordination Program - Statement 9082 Making a Difference Awards - Statement 598 North West Carer Training Program 6783 Emergency Support Programs 7598 Funding 6784, 8151 Post-school Options Program - Funding 2848 Respite Initiatives 3414 Recreational Arts Activities - Access 7228 Residential Accommodation Services - Drop-in Places 4745, 4746 Therapy and Professional Services Funding - Statement 2655 Women on Wellness Conference, Perth - Statement 3070 Domestic Violence Domestic Violence Advocacy Support Central 11703 Freedom from Fear Campaign - Cancellation 280 Grievance 9390 Indigenous Family Violence Prevention Support Service - North West 3570 International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women - Statement 13603 Involvement of Children - Police Reports 9089 Regional Domestic Violence Committees - Grants Program - Statement 1044 Statements 274, 3196, 4711 Warren-Blackwood Area 3350 Women’s Refuge Group Funding - North West 4167 Women with Disabilities - Statement 14056 Drought Assistance - Northern and Eastern Wheatbelt 1198, 1199 Enright, Mr Nick Death 7597 Statement 6132 Freycinet Collection 1711, 2675 Gaming Machines - “Australia’s Gambling Industry” Recommendations 1708 Government Advertising - Expenditure 6534 Government Contracts - Statistics 6535, 7263 Government Departments and Agencies Access for People with Disabilities to Information, Services and Facilities - Statement 8693 Bad Debts Written Off 14450 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3850 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 453

McHALE, HON SHEILA MARGARET (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Cleaning Services 6410, 7102, 13768 Club/Association Memberships 7590, 10703 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 13298, 14563 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6539 Credit Cards Access 7262 Statements - Checking 14504 Creditors 7092, 9764 Employment Contracts 7587 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12901 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5168 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 8507 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14975 Leave Liability 5158 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14377 Leschenault Estuary - Management 6040 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6404 North West - Staff and Programs 4160 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10710 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7942 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14418 Record Keeping - Statement 13485 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14477 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7762 Staff “Attached List” 336 Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14965 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7119 Unfilled and Acting Positions 335 UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7119, 8861 Web Sites - Online Payments 10725 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14548 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 693 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 6538 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 6538 Motorcycles - Statistics 6536 Privately Plated 6537 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14395 Health Early Intervention Programs 12739, 14554 Mental Health System - Amendment to Motion 11270 Homelessness Mandurah 1867 North West Programs 5514, 8867 Strategy to Prevent 2275 Youth - Funding 9791 Libraries - Programs in North West 3416 Lobbyists - Meetings with Ministers of the Crown and Ministerial Staff - Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 7779 Local Government - Record Keeping - Statement 13485 Ministers of the Crown Cultural Ministers Council Meeting - Statement 6132 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 7779 Minister for Community Development - Visit to Halls Creek and South Hedland 9470 Mobile Phones - Use 4807 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10716 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14437 Corporate Credit Cards 8258, 9923, 13272 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9781 454 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McHALE, HON SHEILA MARGARET (continued) Ministers of the Crown (continued) Staff (continued) Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4811 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7119 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5149 Vehicles - Privately Plated 7771 Museums North West - Funding 5514, 5515 Regional Social History Museum. Bunbury - Grievance 8939 WA Museum 6038, 8147 Police Family Violence - Reports to Department for Community Development 9089 Volunteers - Checks at Reduced Rates 10962 Questions on Notice - Answers 8007 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 8030, 8031, 8047 Schools Cadet Programs - Funding 3089, 3090, 3228, 4690 Out of School Care Junior High School Students - Grievance 8935 Regulations - Statement 1276, 10639 Select Committee into Child Abuse in Western Australia - Establishment Amendment to Motion 1890, 2285 Motion 2289 Seniors Active Ageing Task Force Geraldton Forum 1196 Statement 8280 Elder Abuse - Statement 3068 International Federation on Ageing Sixth Global Conference - Statement 1569, 2517 North West Assistance to Grandparents as Primary Carers 5514 Lifetime Links Grants 3414 Safety Inspections of Homes 3852 Seniors Awards - Statement 12680 Seniors Cardholders - Access to Fare Concessions Interstate 6038 State Records Office - Assessment of Official Records - WA Inc 9798 Unions - Government Grants 8861 Volunteers Consultation on Government Policy Decisions 11900 National Volunteer Week - Statement 7658 Police Checks - Reduced Rates 10962 Statement 14216 Thank a Volunteer Day - Statement 4067 Volunteer Resource Centres - Grants - Statement 881 Volunteering Compact - Rural and Remote Western Australia 206 Volunteering WA - Student Community Involvement Program 4168, 5445 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 2840, 2841 Women’s Interests International Women’s Day - Statement 5080 Women’s Refuge Group Funding - North West 4167 Women on Wellness Conference, Perth - Statement 3070 Youth Children’s Week - Statement 2161 Contemporary Music Initiatives for Young People - Statement 10945 Debt - Govern ment Assistance 10420 Development Officer, Geraldton 10567 Funding of Programs 6490 Homelessness - Funding 9791 Kimberley - Facilities and Activities 13696 Mandurah 1867 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 455

McHALE, HON SHEILA MARGARET (continued) Youth (continued) National Youth Week 6490 North West Assistance Programs for Young People Leaving Home 5513 Holiday Programs 8867 Office for Children and Young People’s Policy - Establishment - Statement 2251 Skate Parks - Funding 11677, 13295 Suicide - Cannabis Use 6815 WA Youth Awards Showcase - Statement 6677 Youth Development Holiday Program - Unsuccessful Applications 8133 Youth Grants Western Australia - Expenditure in North West 2848 Youthspaces and Facilities Fund - Statement 7021

McNEE, MR WILLIAM JOHN (Moore) (Lib) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2544 Consideration in Detail 2796-2799, 2801, 2804, 2810 Address-in-Reply - Amendment to Motion - Health Services 111 Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7259 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6663 Christmas Carol Singing 2314 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3120 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13378 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2208 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1478 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2208 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1717 Leeman Boat Ramp - Petition 7330 Legislative Council President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2031 Moora District Hospital Grievance 6614 Matter of Public Interest 13207 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality - Bilateral Agreement Signing 2928 Motion 6528 Pneumococcal Disease - Immunisation Program - Petition 13929 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 968 Regional Development - Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13207 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7259

McRAE, MR ANTHONY DAVID, BA (Riverton) (ALP) Aborigines New Employment Initiatives 10496 Unemployment - Statistics 5364 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 Council’s Amendments 9136 Address-in-Reply - Motion Conservation Management 332, 333 Education Migrant Access to Mainstream Schools 332 Reduction of Class Sizes 331 School Fencing 332 Student Retention Rates 330, 331 Native Title 333, 334 People with Disabilities - Employment 333 Visit to China and Singapore 334 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3389 BGC (Australia) Ltd - Preferential Treatment by Court Government 5446 Child Protection - Appointment of Officers in Aboriginal Communities 12610 Commonwealth Trade Practices Act - Criminal Sanctions 2523 Dairy Industry - Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9248 456 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McRAE, MR ANTHONY DAVID (continued) Disability Services - Commonwealth Assistance 7521 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5360, 5375, 5376 Economics and Industry Standing Committee Annual Report 2001-02 - Tabling 493 Annual Report 2002-03 - Tabling 12830 Inquiry into the WA Strata Management Industry Final Report 9397 Fourth Report 4829 Inquiry into the Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA Sixth Report 10648 Eighth Report 14231 Electricity - Developments in the Industry - Grievance 1976 Federal Budget - Road Funding - Impact of Federal Budget 7677 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 2364 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8223, 8922 Freight Coastal Shipping and Rail Freight 9084 Freight Planning - South Metropolitan Corridor 1467 Network Reform - Grievance 12580 South Metropolitan Region - Freight Network Reform - Grievance 4825 Government Departments and Agencies - Pay Dispute - Industrial Action 13810 Health Chinese Herbal Medicine Practitioners and Acupuncturists - Petition 3783, 5454 Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement - Negotiations 7026 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petitions 6344; Personal Explanation 6472 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11759 Immigration - Baxter Detention Centre - Letter from Inmates - Statement 10673 Insurance - Ministerial Summit 6182 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 644 Kierath, Mr Graham - BGC (Australia) Ltd - Preferential Treatment 5446 Legislative Council President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2028 Occupational Safety and Health - Work-related Deaths - Brookton - Record Fine 11535 Personal Explanation - Neurotrauma Research Program - Petition 6472 Planning Karel Avenue Bushland - Grievance 11083 Mauds Landing Development - Rejection Decision - Motion 9917 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass Amendment to Motion 13621 Fremantle Land Resumptions 13697 Matter of Public Interest 13621 Motion 431 Motion for Disallowance 14128 Police Crime Fighting Success 8891 Officers’ Unprofessional Conduct - Penalties 5723 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 900 Consideration in Detail 1352 Railways Freight - Increase 9084 Southern Rail Link Budget Blow-out 14880 Matter of Public Interest 2939 Upgrade - Federal Funding 606 Retail Trading - Harvey Norman - Sunday Trading 8968 Roads Freight Networks - Statement 3669 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme - Motion 431; Amendment to Motion13621 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 457

McRAE, MR ANTHONY DAVID (continued) Roads (continued) Fremantle Eastern Bypass (continued) Matter of Public Interest 13621; Motion for Disallowance 14128 Liberal Land Resumptions 13697 Member for Murdoch’s Pledge 2272 Funding 3350, 7677 Road Safety - Double Demerit Point System 11624 Roe Highway Stage 6 - Progress 3929 Stage 7 - Progress 3929; Statement 3669 Stage 8 - Member for Murdoch’s Pledge 2272 Schools Maintenance - Grievance 7333 Willetton Senior High - Statement 1706 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9248 Select Committee on the Infill Sewerage Scheme - Establishment - Motion 2691 Seniors - Riverton Seniors Awards - Statement 12854 Small Business - First Steps Online Program 1197, 1198 Swan River - Matter of Public Interest 8804; Amendment to Motion 8805 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3537 Unified Buddhist Church of Vietnam - Petition 12326 Water Resources - Farm Dams - Management Charges - Motion 7703 Western Power - Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5463 WorkSafe Western Australia - Workplace Death - Brookton - Record Fine 11535

McSWEENEY, HON ROBYN MARY, BA, JP (South West) (Lib) Aborigines Child Protection Workers - Placement 9357 Child Sexual Abuse - Statistics on Communities 8367, 8566, 8678, 9566, 9567 Gordon Inquiry 4257, 4532, 14838 Roebourne - Neglected Children 4452 Support Workers - Placement, Experience and Training 9357 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Bropho, Mr Robert 554 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Committee 12928 Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5658, 5770, 5780 Committee 5931-5933 Assembly’s Message 12393 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4280 Address-in-Reply Motion Aged Care Crisis 452 Australian Defence Force 449 Compulsory Student Services and Amenities Fees 452 Gordon Inquiry Recommendations 453-456 Health Crisis 450, 451 Old-growth Logging - Restructuring of the Timber Industry 452 Year of the Outback 449,450 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 3019, 3030 Agriculture Environmental Protection Act Draft Regulations - Consultation 11838 Farmers - Compensation - Petition 8639 Bropho, Mr Robert - Removal from Front of Parliament House Building 9022 Building Industry - Registered Builders - Qualifications 13861 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 9605 Committee 10768-10770, 10883-10900 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5658, 5770, 5780 Colleges of TAFE - Training and Assessment - Competency-based System 14714 Community Development Child Abuse - Aboriginal Communities 8367, 8566, 8678, 9566, 9567 458 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

McSWEENEY, HON ROBYN MARY (continued) Community Development (continued) Foster Carers - Shortage 166 Social Workers and Graduate Welfare Officers - Cannington, Mirrabooka and Armadale Offices 7822 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3464 Committee 3606, 3607, 3619-3627, 3734-3744 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Prescribed Burning Program Target 14641 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Second Reading 11046 Committee 11584-11586, 12386-12392 Diamond Tree Sky Lift - Funding 13008 Environment Controls on the Rural Sector - Motion 12531 Craft Wood - Exemption for Use of Trees from Private Properties 12008, 12291; Statement 12150 Environmental Protection Act 11838, 13145 Firewood 9976, 10094, 10382, 10923, 11211 Timber Fellers - Wildlife Conservation Act Section 23D Exemptions 12925 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referra l to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4909 Second Reading 4916 Committee 10129-10141, 10211-10225, 10332-10360, 11143-11159, 11196-11204, 11212-11233, 11321, 11322, 11330 Third Reading 11566 Environmental Protection Authority - Regulations - Draft Exemptions 14195 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers Agriculture 8350, 8351 Albany 8348, 8349 Dairy Industry 8350 Denmark - Allocation of Moneys 8349 Diamond Tree Sky Lift 8352 Increased Taxes and Charges 8352 Road Funding - 8351 Women’s Interests 8353, 8354, 8356 Fire and Emergency Services Emergency Call System for Medical Emergencies - Changes 2347 Prescribed Burning - Target 14641 Flinders Park Primary School, Albany - Sewerage 6081 Forests and Forestry Diamond Tree Sky Lift - Statement 14037 Old-growth Forest - Social and Economic Impact of Policy - Urgency Motion 543 Sky Jetty Project - Public-private Partnership 6585 Timber Fellers - Wildlife Conservation Act Section 23D Exemptions 12925 Woodchip Mill - Donnybrook 41, 1269 Woodchips - Transport - Manjimup-Bunbury Railway Line 13351 Fuel and Energy - Waste-to-energy Projects - Maddington 2765 Health Department - Thornton, Ms Jean - Letter to the Premier 9848 Family Early Intervention Program - Closure 11482 Patient Assisted Travel Scheme - Albany Resident 2126 South West Mental Health Service - Advice Line 5025 Warren-Blackwood Health Service - Podiatrist 5776 Homeswest - Manjimup - Low-income Families 2874 Hospitals Albany Regional 864, 5055 Gynaecological Surgeons 10750 South West - Centralised Purchasing Facility - Buy Local Policy 5313 Liquor Licensing - National Competition Policy 13070 Local Government - Kojonup, Shire of - Regional Investment Fund Applications 468 Manjimup - Premier’s Visit to Manjimup and Pemberton 4399 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5647 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 459

McSWEENEY, HON ROBYN MARY (continued) Native Title, Office of - Pilbara - Alcohol Consumption 4452 Parks and Reserves - Jurien Bay Marine Park Order 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 14665 Parliament House - Bropho, Mr Robert - Removal from Front of Building 9022 Planning Augusta-Walpole Coastal Strategy - Consultancy Tender 12147 Lots 293 to 296 Eedle Tce, Bridgetown 3438 Police Numbers - South West 245 Prisons - Albany Regional Prison - Staffing Levels 2483 Railways - Manjimup-Bunbury Line - Woodchips Transport 13351 Regional Development Fund - Kojonup, Shire of 468 Roads - South Western Highway - Shelving of Upgrade 1259 Schools Flinders Park Primary, Albany - Septic Tank Overflow 6081 School Bus Service - Replacement of Old Buses 4905 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children (Appointment of a Commissioner for Children) - Establishment Amendment to Motion 8548 Stamp Duty - Property Purchases 12043 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions Second Report 2327 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5658, 5770, 5780 Waste-to-energy Projects - Maddington 2765 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7483 Youth - Great Southern Community Youth Committee - 3615

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK, BA, DipEd, Leader of the Opposition in the Legislative Council (Mining and Pastoral) (Lib) Aborigines Aboriginal Health, Office of - Houston, Mr Edward Shane 9356 Alcohol on Community Lands - Prohibition 2867 Belang Aboriginal Corporation - Living Area Excision in Shire of Murchison 14710 Gordon Inquiry 2910, 6953 Inalienable Freehold Title to Parts of Conservation Estate 11830, 11831 State Forests - Transfer of Ownership to Aboriginal Groups 11172 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 Second Reading 12516 Committee 12654, 12921, 12934-12951, 12968-12981 Third Reading 13088 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Legislation Committee 4222 Second Reading 4469 Committee 4505-4523 Third Reading 4524 Address-in-Reply Motion Opening Ceremony 140, 141 Woodside Energy and China - North West Shelf Gas Deal 141 Compulsory Student Services and Amenities Fees 142 Native Title 143-149 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 2494, 2598, 2607 Adjournments of the House 4540, 5667, 6589, 14847 Agriculture Chicken Meat Industry Act - Proposed Changes 10111 Mosquito Control Policy 594 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Order of Business - Amendment to Motion 2727; Motion 2590, 2722 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13339 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Committee 9532 Australian Labor Party - Brochures Outlining the Outlook for Western Australia - Cost 2225 Australian Wildlife Conservancy Ningaloo Development Adjournment Debate 4354 Briefing 5811-5817, 5971-5973, 6276, 6286 460 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Australian Wildlife Conservancy (continued) Ningaloo Development (continued) Correspondence with the Premier 4251, 4525 Decision 4338 Meetings 6080 Statement 6591 Wilson, Dr Barry Conflict of Interest 1002, 1257, 1454, 1657, 3026, 3433, 3434, 4198, 5019, 5048, 5190, 6952 Directorship 349, 350, 462 Bali Bombings Condolence Motion 1732 Offer by Private Organisation to Evacuate Australians 3866 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes 12983 Second Reading 13042 Committee 13089-13103 Baxter, Hon Norman Eric - Condolence Motion 13313 Boxing Control Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6318 Building Industry Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded Advice 7642 Cabinet Discussion 9552 Consultation 7165 Urgency Motion 7307, 7316 Industry Construction Panel Nominations Selection and Remuneration 2651 Business of the House Order of Business Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Amendment to Motion 2727; Motion 2590, 2722 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 14804, 14820 Statement 6284 Capital Punishment - Offenders Convicted of Heinous Crimes - Motion 13002; Statement 13352 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10464 Central Park Plaza - Sale of Half Ownership 12665 Commerce and Trade - South Korea - WA Trade Office Closure 1415 Committees of the House - Consideration of Reports - Standing Orders Suspension 2735; Amendment to Motion 2736 Commonwealth Government - Policies and Legislative Approach - Motion 6569 Community Development, Department of Marble Bar 592 Physical Threats Against Officers 8361, 9190, 9654 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3607, 3619-3627, 3742-3744 Conservation Council of Western Australia Dunlop, Mr Nic 9843 Funding 9969 Constitution Acts Amendment Act - Premier’s View on Referendum for Change 3022 Consumer and Employment Protection Bey Apartments, East Perth - Strata Management 12963 Ford, Ms Jan - Complaints about Sale of Properties in Port Hedland 14868 Convention and Exhibition Centre - Completion Date 6298 Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd Appeals Committee 10110 Carew-Hopkins, Mr Derek 3726, 3866, 4023, 4198 EPA Advice - Tabling 10111 Meetings 4392, 4446, 4525 Minister’s Appeal 3284 Personal Explanation 12103 Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders - Amendment to Motion 10228; Motion - Deputy President’s Ruling 10233 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Referral to Committee of the Whole House - Motion 14667 Crime - Kalgoorlie - Burglary Charges 4302 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 461

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Current Retail Trading Hours Regime - Legality 9020 Economy - Western Australian - Sustainability - Motion 11454 Education, Department of - Amalgamation with Department of Training - Statement 6284 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision - Urgency Motion 1795 Electricity Reform Implementation Committee - Consultants’ Report - Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12424 Employment and Training, Department of - Amalgamation with Department of Education - Statement 6284 Environment Barrow Island - Gorgon Gas Development 10483 Coastal Region between Abrolhos Islands and Fremantle - Declaration 13590 Draft Wilderness Policy 11476 Greenhouse Gas Emissions Kyoto Protocol - Ratification by Australia 1134 State Government Stand - Urgency Motion 991 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Motion 4912 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 6414 Committee 11230 Environmental Protection Authority Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd Advice - Tabling 10111 Reports - Use of Appeal Committees 13913 Environmental Protection, Department of - Keating, Ms Fiona - Employment Details 14192 Fire and Emergency Services Emergency Helicopter Service - Funding 1042 Levy Number of Households Making Payments 590 Publicity Campaign 13166 Revenue 590, 591, 2916, 14867 Fisheries Coastal Region between Abrolhos Islands and Fremantle 13590 Department - Dunlop, Mr Nic 9843 Forests and Forestry Gnangara Pine Plantation 713, 14800 Pinetec Pty Ltd - Relocation and Timber Resource 9191 State Forests - Transfer of Ownership to Aboriginal Groups 11172 Freedom of Information Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11025 Government Contracts Limit on Number and Value of Construction Contracts Awarded Cabinet Consideration 9552 Consultation 7165 Urgency Motion 7307, 7316 Tendering Process - Procurement Policy Review 10477 Government Departments and Agencies Bunbury Tower Expenditure 7308 Government’s Financial Obligation 7473 Chief Executive Officers - Resignations and Termination Packages 4962, 5019 Directors General - Salary Packages 873 Voluntary Severance Schemes 7308 Wilson, Dr Barry - Positions Held 349 Government Jet - Use 3609, 3727 Health Bunbury Pathways Program - Funding 11476 Carer Support Programs - Funding 11476 Medical Emergency Helicopter 8671 Heritage - Midland Inn 11172 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1159-1162, 1246 Hospitals Derby Regional - Specialist Staff - Relocation to Broome District Hospital 35, 42 Emergency Departments - Ambulance Bypasses 2779, 4057 462 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Hospitals (continued) Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner 2780, 2916, 4058, 13082 Wyndham District - Downgrading or Closure 159 Housing Doric Constructions Pty Ltd - Contract for Mindarie High School 159 Public Housing in the Western Suburbs of Perth - Tabling of List 1662 Housing and Works, Department of Construction Contracts Policy 7642, Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Cabinet Discussion 9552 Urgency Motion 7307, 7316 Lot 587 Herbert Street, Broome - Lodgment of Expression of Interest 13064 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula Native Title Agreement 5771, 13124, 13141 Native Title Approvals 549, 3171, 9020 Projects and Map of Locations 3609 Water Supply 8361 Draft Wilderness Policy - 11476 Gorgon Project Development 10483 Dupuy Aquifer 12921 Environmental Approval 13024 Environmental Safeguards 11038 Environmental Social and Economic Review 11884 Industry Construction Panel - Nominations, Selection and Remuneration 2651 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 696 Resource Exploration - Native Title Act - Impediment to Land Access 2760 Industrial Relations Doric Constructions Pty Ltd - Reynolds, Mr Kevin 159 Legislation - Advertising Costs 4 Infrastructure and Landmarks Named After Premier John Tonkin 4546 Insurance - Supplementation Fund Levy - Reduction 240 Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 2002 Second Reading 574 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to the Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Motion 852 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation - Sessional Report - 28 June 2001 to 9 August 2002 7447 Jeffery, Major General Michael AC MC - Governor General of Australia - Motion 9318 Justice, Department of - Ministerial Councils for Corrective Services 12265 Kelly, Hon Garry Kenneth - Condolence Motion 29 Kings Park - Inalienable Freehold Title to Aboriginal Groups 11831 Legislative Assembly Sittings 4198 Speaker - Deliberative Vote 1949 Legislative Council Attorney General’s Remarks 4392; Urgency Motion 4379 Pairing Arrangements - Adjournment Debate 2149 President - Deliberative Vote 1948, 2344, 2600, 3022 Lobbyists - Payroll Tax Amnesty - Burke, Mr Brian and Grill, Mr Julian 4524 Local Government Dampier - Swimming Pool - Statement 7831 East Pilbara, Shire of - Boundary Change 13467 Leonora Swimming Pool - Statement 7831 Port Hedland, Town of - Boundary Change 13467 Rating System and Distribution of Funds - Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Motion 10234, 11344; Amendment to Motion 11987; Amendment on the Amendment 11992; Motion, as Amended 12000 Lotterywest - Ruah Community Services Grant 2780 Manjimup - Relocation of Families 3618 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit - Minister for Health - Implications 12966 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 463

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Mining Bowler Report into Mineral Exploration - Government’s Response 3284 Exploration and Mining Title Applications 873, 7474, 8426 Exploration Prospecting and Mining Licences - Number Surrendered 14801 Inalienable Freehold Title to Aboriginal Groups to Parts of Conservation Estate 11830, 11831 Iron Ore (Yandicoogina) Agreement Act 1996 - Tabled Variation Agreement - Statement by Parliamentary Secretary - Motion 13107 Lennard Shelf Zinc and Lead Mines - Closure 12265 Resource Exploration - Native Title Act - Impediment to Land Access 2760 Western Metals Export Facility Derby - Closure of Lennard Shelf Zinc Operations 12265 Ministers of the Crown Air Charter Flights 7013, 7165 Excessive Workload 2868 Minister for Government Enterprises - Restaurant Expenses 12677 Minister for Health - Recipient of Fax Sent to the WA Christian Community 1955 Minister for Housing and Works Administrative Staff 5659 Deferral of Cabinet Reshuffle Decision 9191 Reprimand by the Premier 702 Minister for Local Government and Regional Development - Air Charter 1800 Minister for State Development - Overseas Trips 1969 Minister for the Kimberley, Pilbara and Gascoyne - Christmas Wish List 14778 Office Location and Refurbishment, and Staff 2902-2909, 3063-3065, 3192, 3193, 3334, 3335, 3633 Premier Visit to China 1800 Visit to South Korea 2650 Workload 2868 Questions without Notice - Attendance in Chamber 3171 Native Title Act Impediment to Land Access 2760 Review 2478, 2915 Burrup Peninsula Agreement Details 13124, 13141 Approvals 549, 3171 Management Plan for Non-industrial Land 8671, 9020 Native Title Claimants 6282 Tabling of Agreement 5771 Claims - Statistics 1736 Exploration and Mining Title Applications - Heritage Surveys and Agreements 873 Legislation - Amendments 548 Litigation Details 2510 Question on Notice 1043 Office of Budget 241, 348 Budget - Adjournment Debate 269 Funding 462, 860 Pilbara - Termination of Proceedings in National Native Title Tribunal 8671, 9020 Ningaloo Reef Adjournment Debate 4354 Ningaloo Station 5811-5817, 5971-5973, 6120, 6121, 6276, 6286 Save Ningaloo Reef Campaign 4392, 4446, 6591, 6080 Tourism Development Proposals for Coast 10088 Nuclear Activities (Prohibition) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7815 Offshore Minerals Bill 2001 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5921 Committee 5925-5927 Offshore Minerals (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5921 Offshore Minerals (Registration Fees) Bill 2001 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5921 464 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Parks and Reserves Marine Parks and Reserves Authority Advice to Government 7184 Wilson, Dr Barry 350,462, 702, 1002,1257, 1454,1657, 3026,3434, 4198, 5019,5048,5190, 6952, 7448 Minutes of Meeting 3433 Payroll Tax Amnesty - Mr Brian Burke 4524 Changes 589 Planning Lot 587 Herbert Street, Broome 13004 Mauds Landing Development Advertising Campaign 9581 Advice to Government 5529, 7184 Appeals Process 11598 Australian Wildlife Conservancy - Adjournment Debate 4354 Correspondence with Premier 4251, 4338 Commercial Conflicts of Interest 4392, 4446 Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd Advice Prior to Crown Solicitor’s Advice 12265, 12429 Appeals Committee Composition 10110, 11045 Carew-Hopkins, Mr Derek 3726, 3866, 4023, 4198 Crown Solicitor’s Advice 12002, 12551; Personal Explanation 12103 Economic and Social Benefits of Proposal 11204, 12161, 12569, 14769 Environmental Protection Authority’s Advice 10111, 12551, 13166, 13913, 13914 Environmental Risks and Management Needs 11038, 12569 Legality of Decision 12285, 12286, 12430 Letter from EPA 10246, 10360 Meetings 4392, 4398, 4446, 4525, 6080 Minister’s Appeal 3284 Premier’s Decision on Appeals 12140, 12430 Request for Reports on Appeals 12921 Statement 12149, 12271 Gascoyne Development Commission 2601 Minister’s Biased View 3433, 3608, 4434 Minister’s Support 2479 Ningaloo Advertising Campaign 9843 Premier’s Open Letter 9581, 10263 Premier’s Trip to Coral Bay 9968 Rejection Decision 9842; Motion 9949; Statement 10094 Statements 6591, 11604, 12010 Urgency Motion 4182, 4189 Wilson, Dr Barry 349, 350, 462, 702, 1002, 1257, 1454, 1657, 3026, 3433, 3434, 4198, 5019, 5048, 5190, 6952, 7448 Written Decision 9969 Smiths Beach Development - Number of Units and Sites Approved 13357 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Adjournment Debate 268 Police Metropolitan Area 872 Number Rostered On 4365 Ports and Harbours - Black Rocks, King Sound - Port Development 11372 Prisons Cost per Prisoner - Saving from Reduced Prisoner Numbers 2514 Prisoners Sentenced to Two Years or Less 1456 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 - Assembly’s Message 5917, 5918 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 7131 Committee 7286 Questions on Notice - Answers - Statement 7180 Questions without Notice -Answers Adjournment Debate 1964 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 465

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Questions without Notice -Answers (continued) Inadequacy - Adjournment Debate 5029 Racing - Country Race Clubs and Country Racing 1257 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8532 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8532 Committee 8657-8670 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8532 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8532 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 2247, 2494 Second Reading 3168 Railways Number of Arrests 872 Perth Urban Rail Development -Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment to Motion 5953 Safety Mechanisms on Locomotives and Rail Crossings - Petition 2217 Southern Rail Link 4297 WA Government Railways Commission - Coach Contracts - Statement - Motion 12255 Regional Development Gascoyne Development Co mmission - Mauds Landing Development 2601 Implementation of Government’s Policy 13589 Regional Development Fund - Applications and Distribution 584 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5309, 5319 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Standing and Sessional Orders Suspension 7966 Assembly’s Message 8359, 8360, 8368-8391 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 9173 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass Select Committee - Motion 1923; Amendment to Motion 1925 Urgency Motion 4892 Funding - Condemnation of Government - Motion 9347 Speed Limits - Increase - Remote Areas 246 Tonkin Highway Extension - Tenders 7820 Rottnest Island Authority Boat Torque Cruises - Outstanding Landing Charges 3727 Funding 4023, 7820 Funding - Motion 14171 Rottnest Hotel Leasing Arrangements 4023 Swimming Pool - Statement 7831 Salinity - Methods to Reduce Escalating Problems - Motion 13457 Schools Duncraig Primary - Sale of Land 14049 Mindarie High School - Doric Constructions Pty Ltd Contract 159 Non-government - Funding - Petition 4490 Select Committee into the Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 1923; Amendment to Motion 1925 Select Committee into Water Services - Establishment - Motion 6436; Amendment to Motion 8544; Substituted Motion 8544; Substituted Motion, as Amended 8545 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House Adoption of Proposed Orders - Final Report 5285 Appointment of Members 3991 Establishment 3990 Final Report 5200, 5286-5299, 5636-5639 Interim Report 4976 Leave to Move Motion 3990 Special Report - Extension of Time 4948 466 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Sessional Orders Continuation and Amendment - Motion 14844 Suspension 9550 Sewerage Beenyup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Noise Comp laints 11204 Waste Water Use 2121 Sittings of the House Adjournment Debate - 4041 Days and Hours - Motion 2469; Amendment to Motion 2471 Extended Times 471, 2751, 8391 Sport and Recreation “De-dorking” Sport and Recreation Organisations 2225 Hopman Cup Funding 14836 Noalimba Recreation Camp - Sale 11361 Subiaco Oval - Statement 9197 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel Fifth Report 4491; Motion 4493 Petition Presented by Waller, Mr Barry Granville Motion 10087, 10368 Special Report 3991 Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 1934, 2327 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges Parts I and II - Adjournment of Debate at Conclusion of Second Reading Speech - Fourth Report 1930 Standing Order No 61A - Consideration of Committee Reports - Sixth Report 3583 Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 2737, 3143, 3998 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges Amendment to Motion 9549; Motion, as Amended 9549 Standing Order No 230(b) - Motion 2316 Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Inquiry into Appointment of Electoral Commissioner - Motion 33, 43 Local Government Rating System and Distribution of Funds - Motion 10234 Standing Orders No 72 - Standing Orders Suspension 1792 No 73 - Amendment 132, 140 No 230 - Amendment 14696 Suspension - Adjournment of the House 5667 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 11195 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 11195 State Budget Estimates for 2004-05 589 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 Order Discharged and Bill Referred to the Standing Committee on Legislation 5320 Second Reading 12243 Committee 12396-12401 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12408 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Motion 3855; Amendment to Motion 3856, 3861 Standing Orders Suspension 3863, 4304, 4313 Second Reading 4335 Totalisator Agency Board - Funds - Distribution - Adjournment Debate 5554 Tourism Ningaloo Station - Briefing 5811-5817, 5971-5973, 6120, 6121 Regional Investment Fund - Infrastructure Funded 13022 Trans-Tasman Mutual Recognition (Western Australia) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 12406 Transport Intrastate Air Services - Review 3874 Kwinana Freeway Bus Service - Passenger Numbers 1838 Murdoch to CBD Bus Service 4297 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 467

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Transport (continued) Skywest Airlines 4446, 4525, 4530, 5414 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7463 Voluntary Euthanasia Bill 2002 - Referral to Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes 1128 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Reinstatement on Notice Paper Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1159-1162, 1246 Water and Rivers Commission Report of Mr Carew-Hopkins - Tabling 11360 Yarragadee Aquifer - Advice 6297 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 6558 Third Reading 6560 Water Corporation Answers to Questions 14610 Burrup Water Supply 8361 Computer Sciences Corporation - Information Technology Contract 859, 1003, 1140 Dividend Increase 7308 Market Equity Pty Ltd Public Figures Test 5664 Survey 4900, 4955, 4956, 5048, 5770, 5954; Statement 5961 Market Surveys - Details 5801 Ministerial Responsibility 5407 Revenue Estimates 6579, 7448 Water Shortage - Misleading Information 10088 Water Resources 155 Kilolitres per Annum Consumption Target 5191 Advertising Campaign - Costs 5311 Aquifers - Extraction Rate 4251, 4344 Bores 4339, 7642, 13122 Champion Lakes Recreational Facility 6276 Charges - Increases 2760 Class 1 Regional Towns - Increased Prices 7480 Consumption Figures 5311 Farms and Mines - Management Fee 7642 Front-load Washing Machines - Water Consumption 4904 Gnangara Water Mound - Ground Water Protection Policy 14026 Goldfields - Report on Alternative Water Source 1657 Ground Water Applications to Increase Extraction 5676, 5801, 14027, 14605, 14606, 14610 Bore Fields Developed 1455 Development Options 6085 Extraction - Environmental Problems 6586 Extraction and Replenishment Rate 4199 Perth Region 13003, 13346, 14192 Supply Bores 13346, 13352; Statement 13352 Sustainable Yield - Perth Region 13071 Hamilton Hill Area - Water Quality 12926 Harvey Dam 10245, 10476 Harvey Water - Offer of Extra Three Gigalitres for Perth Market 103361, 13010 Integrated Water Supply Scheme - Increase in Water Supply 5407 Kalgoorlie 12665, 14049 Kununurra - Water Source Protection Plan 14633 Perth’s Dams - Water Volume 4252 Perth Households - Annual Water Consumption 1746 Perth Integrated Water Supply Scheme 13116, 13140, 13467 Price Increases - Protection of Large Families 5191 Rebate - Number and Value of Cash Rebates 8564 State Water Strategy 5407, 5530, 13857 Statement 14616 Strategic Management Unit - Mr David Hatt 872 Strategy Developments 1134 468 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

MOORE, HON NORMAN FREDERICK (continued) Water Resources (continued) Waste Water - Use 2121 Water Restrictions 1839, 9551, 13003,13064, 14634 Water Royalty 4204, 4205 Water Services Coordination Act - Review - Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12424 Water Shortage - Tabling of Documents 6454 Yarragadee Aquifer Champion Lakes Water-based Recreation Facility 6276 Development 6080, 6085 Drilling of Additional Bores 2121 Extraction Rate 14615 Metropolitan Southern Bores 8563 South West 14711, 14769 Testing 5659, 7324 Three New Bores 5327 Water and Rivers Commission Advice 6297 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12227 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 Second Reading 1543 Third Reading 1665 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Assembly’s Message - Cognate Debate 1159-1162, 1246 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 7471 Second Reading 7468

MURRAY, MR MICHAEL PHILIP (Collie) (ALP) Boat Driver Training - Compulsory Course 13200 Burrup Peninsula - Protection of Investments - Emergency Response 8791 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail - Dissent from Deputy Speaker’s Ruling - Question to be Put 6899 Collie Catchment Area - Water Quality 6485 Collie Hospital Funding for Laser Machine - Statement 1306 Tender for Roof Repairs 1783 Commerce and Trade - China - Educational and Training Services Development 12687 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Prescribed Burning Program 3089; South West 13813 Dairy Industry - Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9247 Disability Services - Access to Public and Private Sector Organisations - Grievance 11502 Dogs - Control - Shire of Collie - Petition 6608 Drake-Brockman, Mr Fred - Statement 7880 Economics and Industry Standing Committee Annual Report 2002-03 - Tabling 12832 Inquiry into the WA Strata Management Industry Final Report 9399 Report No 4 4829 Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA - Eighth Report 14234 Economy Forecasts and Reports 11252 Western Australian 10421 Education - Development of Educational Services with China 12687 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13647 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13647 Employment and Training Development of Training Services with China 12687 Regional Areas - Employment Initiatives 9232 Environment - Acid Sulfate Soils - Management Strategy 13519 Fire and Emergency Services Bushfire Risk - South West 13813 Firefighting Aircraft - Media Statement by Federal Minister 1046 Forests and Forestry Infinitree Plantation Program 8438 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 469

MURRAY, MR MICHAEL PHILIP (continued) Forests and Forestry (continued) Old-growth Forest - Commonwealth Government Commitment 4860 Pinetec Pty Ltd - Financial Assistance 13924 Plantation Timber Industries in South West - Commonwealth Government Funding 398 Wellington Discovery Forest - Logging and Studies 8146 Fuel and Energy Bottled Gas - Petition 12821 Collie Coal-fired Power Station - Statement 9415 Collie Power Station - Privatisation 12463 Electricity Reform - Privatisation of Government-owned Power Stations 3348 FuelWatch - Financial Benefits 7885 Hamelin Bay - Access Road and Boat Ramp 3420 Health Midwives - Enhanced Role 4106 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petition 6469 Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome - State Response 6340 Homeswest - Collie - Maintenance Budget 7778 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11711 Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week Trading - Petition 12821 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Bottled Gas 11808 Economy of Collie 11806, 11807 Fire and Emergency Services 11808 Mining 11805, 11807 Real Estate 11805, 11806 Schools 11805 Telecommunications 11808 Minister for Peel and the South West - Visit to South West 11539 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No.2) 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5472 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5472 Motor Vehicles - Unlicensed Dealers 10497 Police - Clearance Fees - Waiving in Cases of Hardship 9715 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Racing Radio, Collie - Establishment 2215 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Rights in Water and Irrigation Act 1914 - Petition 12691 Roads Bednall Road Bridge - Petition 7849 South Western Highway - Donnybrook-Greenbushes 9303 Roo Gully Wildlife Sanctuary - Statement 10672 Salinity Collie Catchment Area - Water Quality 6485 Infinitree Plantation Program 8438 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 9247 State Finance - Commonwealth Grants Commission - Funding Cut 4744 Superannuation - Changes - Increased Compliance Costs for Business 1588 Telecommunications Infrastructure in Regional Areas 11622 Regional Telecommunications Inquiry 2386 Telstra - Privatisation 11622 Workplace Agreements - Grievance 2359

O’BRIEN, HON SIMON McDONNELL (South Metropolitan) (Lib) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 12523 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 4412 Committee 4506-4523 470 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

O’BRIEN, HON SIMON McDONNELL (continued) Address-in-Reply Motion Community Consultation 1011, 1012 Economic Development 1001, 1002 Government’s Legislative Program 1000-1002, 1009, 1010, 1013 Governor’s Speech 999, 1001 Perth to Jandakot Railway 1011, 1012 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 4443, 4454 Agriculture - Hydroponic Industry 9556; Code of Conduct 11604 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Order of Business - Amendment to Motion 2726 Building Industry - Builders Registration Board and Building Disputes Tribunal Conflict of Interest Guidelines 14716 Messrs Knowles and O’Connor 14776 Business of the House - Order of Business - Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Amendment to Motion 2726 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6967 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6967 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 7606, 7790, 9034, 9052, 9574 Committee 10065-10072, 10740-10745, 10752-10770, 10883-10900, 11008-11025 Third Reading 11331 Analysis of Seized Cannabis by a Qualified Chemist - Cost 10094 Hydroponic Equipment Policy 9023, 9556 Chemistry Centre (WA) - Future 7825, 8675 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 9042, 9043 Defence Forces - Adjournment Debates Support for Service Men and Women 5673 Thirtyniners’ Association of Australia 582 Disability Services Accommodation Support - Applications 11044 Alternatives to Employment Funding 6280 Commission Budget Increase 165 Cleaning Services 5663 Residential Accommodation 5023, 5318, 5959 Committees, Working Parties and Reviews 6096 Funding - Budget Measures 6960 Industrial Relations Reform Legislation - Impact on People with Disabilities 6585, 12266 Miller, Ms Coral - Statement 10252 Paterson, Fraser - Statement 10370 Read, Ms Annette - Statement 10252 Turpin, Mr Boris - Statement 11050 Drugs Alcohol and Drug Authority - Funding 14047 Buprenorphine - Prescription Procedures 14609 Cannabis CANNA Range of Fertilisers 13121 Custodial Sentences for Convictions 9976, 10942 Decriminalisation - Plant Material Demonstration 7826 Minor Offences - Legislation 4451 Drug and Alcohol Strategy Funding 244 Urgency Motion 231, 237 Mirrabooka - Report of Drug Dealing 7180 School Education Program - Funding 12928, 13912, 14642 WA Drug Abuse Strategy Office - Funding 14047 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 5015 Third Reading 11575 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers Budget Deficits 8757 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 471

O’BRIEN, HON SIMON McDONNELL (continued) Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers (continued) Disability Services 8758, 8759 Government Expenditure 8757 Health 8757, 8760, 8762 Stamp Duty 8760, 8761 Fremantle Cemetery Board - Transfer of Management to the Metropolitan Cemeteries Board Savings 8366 Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Inquiry Motion 10910; Motion, as Amended 11339 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Personal Explanation 1639 Health Allied Health Taskforce - Work Force Issues Report 5412, 5536, 5778, 10482 Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement 11477, 12270 Men’s Advisory Network - Funding 13072 Mental Health System - Funding Petitions 11960, 12103 Statistics 11836, 13086 Heritage Duncraig House 467, 11483 Legislation - Introduction 14840 Hospitals Emergency Departments - Number Treated 11615 Metropolitan Teaching - Recurrent Allocations 4256 Waiting Lists 1137 Housing and Works, Department of - Fremantle Eastern Bypass and Roe Highway Stage 8 - Land Reservations 10366, 10367 Industrial Relations - Reforms - Impact on People with Disabilities 6585, 12266 Iraq - Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3992 Legislative Council - Attorney General’s Remarks - Urgency Motion 4386 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Meetings Between Minister and City of Fremantle 12293 Local Government Kojonup, Shire of - Valuation of Land 713 Melville, City of - Lot Sizes 12558 South Perth, City of - Council Elections 3733 Local Government Amendment Bill 2003 - Drafting 2605 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 5639 Committee 5652-5657 Planning Absolon Street, Palmyra - Closure at Both Ends 13147 Heathcote Site 467 Melville, City of - Lot Sizes 12558 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments No 1055/33 - Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion 865 Submissions 5055, 5196 Tabling of Documents 13350, 14194, 14195 Roe Highway Stage 8 865 Southern Rail Link 1415, 1805 Planning Control Area No 75 - Lot 7 Absolon Street and Stock Road, Palmyra - Upgrading 12926 Rockingham Marina - Government’s Support 14609 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Telephone Survey 10246 WA Planning Commission - Membership 13862 Wireless Hill Park Land Excision 9973, 10748, 10922, 12669 Redevelopment 9584 Statement 12013 Police Aircraft - Authority to Carry Dangerous Goods 1418 Cannabis - Custodial Sentences for Convictions 10942 Mirrabooka - Report of Drug Dealing 7180 472 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

O’BRIEN, HON SIMON McDONNELL (continued) Police (continued) Officers - Number 4023 Plant Material Demonstration in Legislative Assembly - Inquiry 7826 Resources - Number 4023 Prisons Location of Proposed Women’s Prison - Petition 10101 Nyandi-Longmore Site - Redevelopment 10116 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 2136 Second Reading 3168, 3179, 3271 Committee 3318-3326, 3329-3332 Third Reading 3333 Railways Freight Network Review - Fremantle Eastern Bypass 36 Perth Urban Rail Development - Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Motion 5943; Amendment to Motion 5946 Southern Rail Link Capital Costs and Items of Expenditure 2226, 4358 Cost Details 13358 Cost Increase 1659 Expenditure 2348 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment 1415, 1805 Murray and Wellington Streets Land Resumptions 11210 Patronage Forecasts 1416 Petitions 537, 1919 Soil Testing 5410 South Perth Station 3026 Travel Time Saving 1416 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass Adjournment Debates 4042, 5320 Community Newspaper Advertisements 3290, 3614, 4533 Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme 865; Tabling of Documents 14194, 14195 Documents Tabling 13350 Land Reservations 10366, 10367 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment No 1055/33 5055 Personal Explanation 1639 Select Committee - Motion 1522, 2485; Amendment to Motion 1925, 2111 Submission Period - Extension 4029, 5196 Urgency Motion 4890 High Street, Fremantle - Widening 3176 Leach Highway-Stock Road Intersection Absolon Street, Palmyra 13147 Upgrading 12926, 13024 Roe Highway Stage 7 - Route 11176 Stage 8 Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme 865, 12009 Land Reservations 10366, 10367 Remarks by Member for Riverton - Statement 14205 Rockingham Marina - Government’s Support 14609 Safer WA - Melville 13594; Statement 11491 Schools Drug Education Program - Funding 13912, 14642 Drug Information Program - Funding 12928 Non-government - Funding - Petition 4240 Select Committee into the Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 1522, 2485; Amendment to Motion 1925, 2111; Sport and Recreation - Noalimba Recreation Camp - Future Use 554 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 6264-6271, 7438 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 473

O’BRIEN, HON SIMON McDONNELL (continued) Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes National Crime Authority (State Provisions) Amendment Bill 2002 - Extension of Time 3134 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Sixth Report 4304 Work of the Committee in the First Session of the Thirty-sixth Parliament - Report 447 State Finance - Consolidated Fund - Balance 1008 Taxation - Payroll Tax - Changes 4906 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes Amendment to Motion 3859, 3860 Second Reading 4324 Transport South Metropolitan Region - Local Impacts Committee 4399 Transperth - Unrestricted Travel Passes for Disabled Voluntary Community Workers - Petition 9011 United States of America Australia’s Support for Military Action in Iraq - Motion 3992 Support for Military - Urgency Motion 1412 Water Resources - Kimberley Pipeline Project - Petition 4887

O’GORMAN, MR ANTHONY PATRICK (Joondalup) (ALP) Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1873 Beach Tavern, Mullaloo Grievance 4821 Petitions 4709, 5454, 6128 Colleges of TAFE Hospitality Youth Showcase - Statement 9416 West Coast College of TAFE - Joondalup Campus - Tender for Works 1782 Community Development and Justice Standing Committee - Annual Report 2001-02 1687 Community Development - Foster Carers - Subsidy Increase 7028 Consumer and Employment Protection - Fair Trading Legislation 11908 Economy, Western Australian 3087 Electricity Reform - Election Platform 3776 Employment and Training Hospitality Youth Showcase - Statement 9416 Lake Joondalup Baptist College Skill Centre - Statement 10022 Environment Container Deposit Legislation 8794 Litter Regulations 10590 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8219 Health Alzheimer’s Disease - McCusker Foundation - Statement 4100 Bulk-billing by General Practitioners - Proposed Changes 5829 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petition 6344 Opposition’s Report Card 4747 Hillarys Boat Harbour - Access Issues 10819 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11688 Industrial Development - Seed Capital for New Products and Services 1713 Industrial Relations National Wage Case - Importance to Basic Living Standards 6683 Workplace Agreements - Minimum Legal Standards for AWAs 5995 Joondalup, City of Government’s Position 14250 Petition 4066 Joondalup Health Campus - Grievance 2786 Lake Joondalup Baptist College Skill Centre - Statement 10022 Liquor Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week Trading - Petition 12821 Sales in Restaurants - Petition 13676 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Government’s Budget Commitments to Joondalup 10849, 10850 Joondalup City Councillors 10849 Member for Nedlands - Comments 10851 474 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

O’GORMAN, MR ANTHONY PATRICK (continued) Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading (continued) Volunteer and Sporting Groups in Joondalup 10850 McGowan, Mr Ted - Statement 13517 Native Title - Abolition - Implications 281 Police - North Metropolitan District - RADAR Model 4160 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13775 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours Government’s Position 5244 Grievance 6616 Legislation 11908 Petition 6608 Road Safety - School Areas 1868 Schools Beaumaris Primary - Petition 2351 Belridge Senior High - Rock Eisteddford - Statement 12604 Mullaloo Heights Primary - Petition 6129 Non-government - Funding - Reorganisation 11786 Ocean Reef Primary - Statement 2812 Road Safety 1868 Science and Technology - Science Initiatives 10023 Small Business Energy Reforms - Benefits 12760 “Small Business Matters” Article 914 Sport and Recreation Edith Cowan University - Joondalup Soccer Club - Statement 1704 Soccer - State Government Assistance 8006 WA Little Athletics - Arena Joondalup - Grievance 1283 West Perth Football Club - Premiership - Statement 12196 Standing Committee on Community Development and Justice - Emergency Services Legislation in Western Australia - Second Report 2792 Telecommunications - Mullaloo Mobile Telephone Facility - Petition 285 Universities Edith Cowan University - Joondalup Soccer Club - Statement 1704 Funding - Impact of Federal Government’s Approach 10288 University of Western Australia - Pathfinder Fund 1713 Western Power - Disaggregation - Benefits to Small Business 12760

OMODEI, HON PAUL DOMENIC (Warren-Blackwood) (Lib) Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2278 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2553 Consideration in Detail 2797, 2798 Address-in-Reply Motion Fire and Emergency Services 303 Forest Management Plan 303-305 Petrol and LPG Prices 303 Roads 305, 306 Sky Jetty 307 Amendments to Motion Health Services 119 Water Shortages 291 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7238, 7692 Dairy Industry Milk Prices - Grievance 8280 Select Committee - Establishment Motion 8614 Amendment to Motion 9250 Motion, as Amended 9257 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 475

OMODEI, HON PAUL DOMENIC (continued) Agriculture (continued) Department - Select Committee - Motion 7238, 7692 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading Department of Conservation and Land Management 4132 Health Services 4132, 4133 Regional Forest Agreement 4132 Safer WA Program 4131 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Agriculture 7868 Disability Services 7867 Education 7867 Goods and Services Tax 7865 Manjimup Apple Export Syndicate 7869 National Competition Policy 7867 Regional Forest Agreement 7866 South West Roads 7870 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8462 Third Reading Disability Services 8479 Goods and Services Tax 8477 Government Projects 8479 Housing and Works 8478 Roads 8478 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7865 Estimates Committees A and B Reports and Minutes - Presentation and Adoption 8462 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6652 Consideration in Detail 6752, 6757, 6759, 6855, 6870, 6901, 6904, 6905, 6909-6914 Adjournment of Debate 6756, 6760, 6856 Deputy Speaker’s Ruling 6895 Third Reading 6929 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2278 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 8999 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1087 Conte, Mr Vic - Statement 4101 Disability Services Commission Cleaning Services 6341 Funding 6341 Edgar, Mr Kenneth - Petition 14051 Evans, Mr Shaun - Petition 4708 Miller, Ms Coral - Petition 10169 Murphy, Mr Garth - Petition 9668 Residential Accommodation Services - Drop in Places 4745, 4746 Robinson, Ms Sally Anne - Petition 7030 Domestic Violence - Warren-Blackwood Area 3350 Economics and Industry Standing Committee - Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA - Eighth Report 14236 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13644 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13375 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13644 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2193 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 1473 Third Reading 2569 Fire and Emergency Services Bushfire Risk 2384 Fire Management in the Western Australian Environment - Motion 2702 Levy - Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion 10181; Amendment on the Amendment 10182 Manjimup - Petition 3908 476 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

OMODEI, HON PAUL DOMENIC (continued) Fire and Emergency Services (continued) Pemberton Firefighters 2385 State Security - Up-to-date Plans 1864 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 2193 Referral to Community Development and Justice Standing Committee 2259, 2268 Consideration in Detail 2361, 2362, 2367, 2370, 2376, 2380-2382, 2401-2411 Third Reading 2411 Council’s Amendments 3829-3833 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No. 8) 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 13410 Forests and Forestry Draft Forest Management Plan Jarrah Volumes 209, 210 Water Catchments 1048, 1049 Jarrah - Allocation of 130 000 metres 9420 Manjimup - Furniture Industry 8600, 9420 Old-growth Forest Logging in South West 8601 Timber Industry Restructure Package 1587 Sky Jetty Project 5584, 9879; Petition 745 State Forests - No 56 - Partial Revocation - Motion 12588 Timber Allocations - Announcement 8600 Fremantle Cemetery Board - Amalgamation with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Motion 8915 Fuel and Energy Bottled Gas - Rebate for Seniors and Pensioners - Petitions 8012, 8278 Electricity - Windy Harbour - Petitions 284, 879, 1053 Windy Harbour - Statement 11106 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3520 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 8828 Consideration in Detail 8841-8846 Third Reading 9003 Health Manjimup - Petition 3908 Warren Blackwood Health Service - Petition 2171 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Bunbury Office - Closure - Petition 8277 Industrial Hemp Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14080 Iraq - Prime Minister’s Statement 3932 Land Clearing - Personal Explanation 892 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2025 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Timber Industry 10841, 10842 Water Resources 10843, 10844 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14273 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13950 Consideration in Detail 13969-13973 Third Reading 13973 Manjimup Cherry Harmony Festival - Statement 3669 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion 10538 Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10656 Member for Warren-Blackwood Personal Explanations Land Clearing 892 Remarks to Minister for Planning and Infrastructure 8280 Suspension from the House 210, 6341 Mickelberg Case - Minister for Health - Investigation by Police Royal Commission 4109 Mining - Bores - Water Users’ Charge 7883 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 477

OMODEI, HON PAUL DOMENIC (continued) Ministers of the Crown Minister for Health - Investigation by Police Royal Commission 4109 Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Personal Explanation 8280 Premier’s Visit to Warren-Blackwood Area - Petitions 2652, 2930, 3785 National Competition Council - Threat to Payments - Motion 12479 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13819 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12175 Police Stations - Warren-Blackwood - Petitions 7207, 7525, 8008, 8277 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 8605 Third Reading 9448 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 5865 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 937 Standing Orders Suspension 1334 Consideration in Detail 1338 Third Reading 1378 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2658 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Minister for Health - Investigation 4109 Schools Margaret River Primary - Education Resources and Support - Grievance 8694 Non-government - Funding - Petitions 7206, 7655, 8158 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7238, 7692 Select Committee into the Dairy Industry in Western Australia - Establishment Motion 8614 Amendment to Motion 9250 Motion, as Amended 9257 Select Committee on the Infill Sewerage Scheme - Establishment - Motion 2301, 2700 Seniors - Bottled Gas Rebate - Petitions 7031, 8012, 8278 Sport and Recreation - Warren Area - Petition 4066 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9697 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9697 Consideration in Detail 10270-10273 State Law Publisher - Internet Site - Statement 1305 Suspension of Member for Warren-Blackwood 210, 6341 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3542 Tourism Pemberton Visitors Centre - Tourist Bureau - Petition 4067 Portfolio - Elevation of Status - Matter of Public Interest 2832 Sky Jetty Project - Petition 745 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading Local Government 9110 Peel Deviation 9111 Railway Line 9111 State Finances 9109, 9110 South Western Highway 9110, 9111 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2278 United States of America - Support for Military - Prime Minister’s Statement 3932 Warren-Blackwood Area - Impact of Government Policies - Petitions 2652, 2930, 3785 Warren District Hospital Closure of Beds 11110 Downgrading of After-hours Medical Services 2271, 2272 Petition 3784 Water Resources Bores - Water Users’ Charge 7675, 7676, 7883 Catchment Areas - Forest Management Plan 1048, 1049 Farm Dams - Management Charges Motion 7693, 7706, 8200 Petitions 10170, 10383 478 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

OMODEI, HON PAUL DOMENIC (continued) Water Resources (continued) Farm Dams - Management Charges (continued) Water Tax 7883 Farm Water Supplies - Petition 9671 Farms and Mines - Management Fee 7675, 7676 Lefroy Brook - Petitions 8012, 8157 Management Charges - Motion 7693, 7706, 8200 Matter of Public Interest 2394 Manjimup and Nannup Shires - Petitions 9091, 9224 Regional Western Australia - Sustainable Water Supply - Motion 3955 Water Restrictions - Manjimup - Statement 2000 Yarragadee Aquifer City Supply - Petition 7524 South West Water Extraction 8444, 8445; Petitions 7032, 8010, 8277, 9670 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13950 Consideration in Detail 13975-13978 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5393 Western Power Carlotta - Power Outages - Statement 11529 Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5464 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 946

PENDAL, HON PHILLIP GEORGE (South Perth) (Ind Lib) Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2969 Address-in-Reply - Motion - Southern Rail Link 3842 AlintaGas Sale - Allocation of Funds to Salinity 8276 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Third Reading Home Burglaries 8585 Auditor General - Matter of Public Interest 12332 Bills, Lapsed - Restoration to Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 404 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6688 Child Abuse - Select Committee Establishment; Motion 1888; Amendment to Motion 1890 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 12595 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Second Reading 1082 Consideration in Detail 2034, 2172-2175, 2180 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Referral to Select Committee 5490, 5503 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Motion 14901 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 Second Reading 8170 Consideration in Detail 8328, 8329, 8333 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1189 Defence Forces Army Museum of WA - Motion 10987 Fremantle Artillery Barracks - Motion 10987 Enright, Mr Nick - Death 7597 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1479 Family Court - Duvall, Mr David and Ms Debbie 4703 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 -Consideration in Detail 2373 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8222 Fremantle Cemetery - Board Amalgamation 8929 Government Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 12332 Health IVF Programs 4174, 9493 Management of Health System - Matter of Public Interest 11637 Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Select Committee Motion 10315; Amendment to Motion 10612 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 479

PENDAL, HON PHILLIP GEORGE (continued) Heritage Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 527 William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Motion 12082; Amendment to Motion 12083; Amendment on the Amendment 12099 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Reinstatement to Notice Paper Council’s Message Amendment to Motion 404 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11647 Division of Bill - Motion 11769 Consideration in Detail 12724-12731, 12735, 12737, 12753-12757, 12771, 12772, 12775, 12840-12847, 12864-12874 Standing Orders Suspension 12875 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment (Prohibition of Human Cloning) Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 12878 Information Commissioner - Matter of Public Interest 12332 Inspector of Custodial Services Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12711 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 614 Iraq War - Support for Australian Defence Personnel - Amendment to Motion 5444 Justice, Department of - Fines Enforcement Registry - Outstanding Fines 9505 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3685 Legislative Council President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2023 Local Government Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 527 Roads Funding 10874 Stirling, City of - Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme 11741 Medical Act Reforms 4177 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct - Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10670, 10682; Motion, as Amended 10688 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 12342 Consideration in Detail 12346-12349, 12601, 12602, 12615-12622 Referral to Select Committee 12451, 12600; Amendment to Motion - Question to be Put 12481 Nyandi-Longmore Prison Site 2351, 9509, 9510 Parliament - Premises Rented or Leased 6041 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations - Matter of Public Interest 12332 Planning Canning Highway - Causeway and Canning Bridge 9715 Donaldson and Warn - Report on Study into Creation of Civic Square 10565 Police Driving Offences - Confiscation of Motor Vehicles 9746 IVIS Technology - Use 8517 Kensington Police Complex - Flags Displayed 1514 Traffic Accidents - Criterion for Reporting to Police 8854 Public Accounts Committee - Matter of Privilege Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1189 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6362 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6362 Consideration in Detail 7076-7079, 7086-7090, 7210 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6362 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6362 Rail Link, Southern Buildings on William and Wellington Streets - Heritage Value 9008 Feeder Bus Routes 8504 Matter of Public Interest 2933 Petition 6128 William-Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct Motion 12082; Amendment to Motion 12083; Amendment on the Amendment 12099 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 906 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1068, 1177, 1202, 1285 Standing Orders Suspension 1329 480 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

PENDAL, HON PHILLIP GEORGE (continued) Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 (continued) Consideration in Detail 1338-1340, 1348-1351, 1355, 1356 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 7901 Council’s Amendments 8027, 8034 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - Petition 5835, 6128; Matter of Public Interest 8449 Roads Local Government - Funding 10874 Melville Parade - Concrete Barrier/Fence 8271 Traffic Accidents - Criterion for Reporting to Police 8854 Roebuck Artefacts - Return to Western Australia 664 Rottnest Island - Longreach Units - Maintenance 14554 Royal Commissions and Inquiries - Keeping of Records 10638 Safer WA - Review 9745 Schools - Non-government - Funding - Petition 6130 Select Committee into Child Abuse in WA - Establishment Motion 1888; Amendment to Motion 1890 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation Motion 10315; Amendment to Motion 10612 Seniors - Fare Concessions Interstate 6038 Sewerage Infill Sewerage Program Cannington 9A and 9C 10442 Criteria for Determining Priority 9147 Waterford 9147 Sport and Recreation - Grants for Elite Sportspeople 9493 Stamp Duty - Lot 131 The Cutting, Mosman Park 14541 State Records Office - Assessment of Official Records - WA Inc 9798 Succession Law - Reform 11954 Swan River - Walls Adjacent to Sir James Mitchell Park - Damage 9799 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Status of Land 10636 Swan Village of Care - Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Petition 2351 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11388 Telstra - Electronic Dividend Payments 8869 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3532 Consideration in Detail 3549-3551, 3553, 3556 Transport Buses - Route Changes and City Bus Stop Relocations - Advertising 8341 Seniors Cardholders - Access to Fare Concessions Interstate 6038 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading Perth Electric Tramway Society 9108 Public Liability Insurance 9108 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Reinstatement to Notice Paper Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 404 Waste Disposal Recycling - Legislation - Manufacturers’ Waste Product Packaging 14525 Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme - City of Stirling 11741 Water Conservation and Management Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10299 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Reinstatement to Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 404

PRATT, HON LOUISE CLARE (East Metropolitan) (ALP) Aborigines - Rock Art - Burrup Peninsula - Disturbance and Loss 6303 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 Second Reading 6306 Committee 6313 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4408 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1735 Burrup Peninsula - Rock Art - Disturbance and Loss 6303 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9932 Commonwealth Government - Policies and Legislative Approach - Motion 6574 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 481

PRATT, HON LOUISE CLARE (continued) Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 9039 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 569 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Select Committee - Amendment to Motion 2118 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14200, 14594 Government Departments and Agencies - Partnerships 9555 International Women’s Day - Adjournment Debate 5034 Iraq War - Adjournment Debate 5322, 5435; Urgency Motion 5044 National Maternity Action Plan - Adjournment Debate 1449 Planning - Dialogue with the City - Statement 11371 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3304 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Motion 4496 Petition Opposing the Gnarabup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Third Report 4314 Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 1932 Sewage Pumping Station, Busselton - Establishment - Petition - Fourth Report 5002 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 6268 Woodbridge Primary School - Temporary Relocation 5774 YMCA Youth Parliament - Adjournment Debate 1964

PRESIDENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (Hon John Alexander Cowdell, BA (Hons), DipEd, JP) Address-in-Reply Acknowledgment 4887 Presentation to Governor 4500 Adjournment of the House - Complimentary Remarks 4544, 14849 Allnut, Mr Ian - Public Service Medal - Statement 8368 Bali Bombings - Statement 1731 Baxter, Hon Norman Eric - Condolence Motion 13316 Business of the House Messages - Revision of Procedures - Statement 446 Order of Business - Ruling 2861 Committees of the House - Reports - Consideration - Ruling 2735, 3143 Foss, Hon Peter - Personal Explanation - Comments by Attorney General - Ruling 3422 Governor’s Speech Delivery 1 Distribution of Copies 10 Heritage - City of Subiaco - Petition 2590 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Assembly’s Message - Ruling 1445 Jeffery, Major General Michael, AC MC - Governor-General - Statement 11046 Kelly, Hon Garry Kenneth - Condolence Motion 30 Legislative Council Clerks Assistant and Usher of the Black Rod - Appointments - Statement 1919 Inaccuracy of Hourglass - Statement 12912 President - Deliberative Vote - Statement 2478; Ruling 2600 Record-keeping Plan - Statement 4182 Refurbished Chamber - Statement 11607 Ringing of the Bells - Statement 11823 Sitting Arrangements - Statement 14726 Sub Judice Rule - Statement 12568 Temporary Chamber - Statements 4887, 5761, 9926, 10735, 11007 Temporary Change of Seating for Hon Peter Foss and Hon Barry House - Statement 12278 Local Government Amendment Bill 2003 - Inquiry - Second Reading Speech - Ruling 14199 Opening of Parliament - Visitors Welcomed 1 Parliament House Northern Elevation and Extension Plans - Statement 2315 Smoking Locations - Statement 12386 Parliamentary Services Department - Record-keeping Plan - Statement 4182 Perth Urban Rail Development - Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Statement 5933 Petitions - Ruling 337 Questions without Notice - Deliberative Vote of President - Statement 2478 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Notice of Motion - Statement 3019 482 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

PRESIDENT OF THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL (continued) Rulings Committees of the House - Reports - Consideration 2732, 3143 Order of Business 2861 Personal Explanation by Hon Peter Foss 3422 Petitions 337 President of the Legislative Council - Deliberative Vote 2600 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Proposal to Travel - Motion 4495 Standing Order No 328 - Reference to Committee Inquiry in Second Reading Speech 14199 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 2735, 3143 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill, Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill and Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 1445 September 11, 2001 - Commemoration - Statement 696 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Proposal to Travel - Motion - Ruling 4495 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Time Limits on Speeches - Rulings 2735, 3143 Standing Order No 328 - Reference to Committee Inquiry in Second Reading Speech - Ruling 14199 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7463 Voluntary Euthanasia Bill 2002 - Statement 1441 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Assembly’s Message - Ruling 1445 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Assembly’s Message - Ruling 1445

QUIGLEY, MR JOHN ROBERT, LLB (Innaloo) (ALP) Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1863, 1870 Ansett Australia Ltd - Levy 6646 Attorney General - Allegations of Criminal Behaviour by Cabinet Members - Motion 801 AusLink Proposal 1590 Bandyup Women’s Prison - Grievance 7337 Burglary - Strategies 11785 Child Abuse - Government Action 11109 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3115 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 Referral to Select Committee 5497 Consideration in Detail 5507 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8169 Domestic Violence - Government Action 11109 Economy, Western Australian 12686, 14071 Federal Budget - Impact on State’s Health Portfolio 7674 Health Commonwealth-State Health Care Agreement 10417 Nurses - Recruitment Campaign 2672 Legal Practice Board - Personal Explanation 7068 Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal - Matter of Privilege 12690 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10659, 10663 Mezzanine Financing - City Apartments Development 5372 Police Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3922 Railways - Southern Rail Link - William Street Traffic Bridge - Removal 10680 Roads Stephenson Highway Road Reserves - Retention - Statement 2382 West Coast Highway, Scarborough - Statement 2000 Rottnest Island - Storm Damage - Repair Work 11536 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Personal Explanation 10031 Scarborough Beach Car Park - Antisocial Behaviour - Statement 12602; Grievance 12829 Development Limits - Petition 13929 School Fees - Impact of Policy 4108 Select Committee on the Infill Sewerage Scheme - Establishment - Motion 2699 Small Business - Government Consultation 8180 Sport and Recreation Australian Surf Life Saving Association 2007-09 Annual Championship 8004 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 483

QUIGLEY, MR JOHN ROBERT (continued) Soccer - Restructuring of Administration in WA - Grievance 11505 Surf-lifesaving Clubs - Statement 6642 World Peace Soccer Game - Statement 13516 Swanbourne Senior High School Site - Consultation 3229 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Appointment of Administrator 8726 Tourism - Election Commitment 5993 Treasurers Conference - Outcome 5828 Tuart Forest Ecosystems - Swan Coastal Plain 1200 Volunteering Compact - Rural and Remote Western Australia 206

QUIRK, MS MARGARET MARY, LLB (Hons), Parliamentary Secretary, Police and Emergency Services (from 27 June); Justice (from 27 June); Community Safety (from 27 June) (Girrawheen) (ALP) Abandoned Shopping Trolleys - Grievance 1680 Address-in-Reply - Motion Balga and Girrawheen Senior High Schools 190 Community Welfare 191 Crime Statistics - West Metropolitan Police District 188 Government Service Delivery 190 New Living Housing Program 189 Racism 191 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate - Commonwealth-State Housing Agreement 7739 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7739 Child Abuse Child Sex Offenders Register 2820 Procurement of Children for Sexual Acts by Electronic Means - Grievance 11079 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5983, 5984 Corruption and Crime Commission - Legislation - Referral to Committee 8964 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 8301 Crime Australian Crime Commission - Creation 209 Burglary Rates 8308 Statistics 9422 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13188 Disability Services - Doust, Mr Bradley - Petition 5092 Drugs Illegal Drug Laboratories - Introduction of Legislation 8596 Record Drug Bust 5088 Education Clontarf Aboriginal College - Location 1309 Education and Training Initiatives - Training System Plans 6342 Tertiary - Statement 5362 Female Genital Mutilation - Legislation - Grievance 3202 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2364 Firearms - Unlicensed Hand Guns - Use in Criminal Activities - Grievance 5687 Health Daffodil Day - Statement 506 Funding for Dental Health Programs - Grievance 1980 Skin Cancer Awareness Week - Statement 3223 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11693 Consideration in Detail 12773, 12774, 12873, 12874 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation City of Melville - Signs, Hoardings and Billposting - Report - Tabling 4115 City of Perth Code of Conduct Local Law - Fourth Report 1725 Powers of Entry - Private Land - Seventh Report 7859 Sessional Report - 28 June 2001 to 9 August 2002 - Sixth Report 5691 Joondalup Private Hospital - Sale 12469 484 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

QUIRK, MS MARGARET MARY (continued) Justice, Department of Criminal Law - Joinder of Offences - Grievance 482 North Fremantle Bail Hostel - Use 1309 Offender Management - Improvements 14253 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3688 Law Reform Commission, WA - Recommendations on Joinder of Criminal Offences - Grievance 482 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Role of Charitable and Non-profit Bodies 12852, 12878 Mia-Mia Flats, Modena Place, Balga - Petition 2652 Minister for Housing and Works - Allegations of Ministerial Impropriety - Standing Orders Suspension - Question to be Put 9223 Mirrabooka Mosque - Interfaith Service - Statement 8721 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3819, 3820 Police CityNEX Camera Surveillance System 11396 DNA Testing - National Approach 2820 Drug Bust 5088 Section 8 Dismissals - Reform 88 Prisons Golf Lessons for Prisoners 10029 Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Motion 5616 Public Access Ways - Grievance 7851 Questions without Notice - Standing Orders Suspension - Question to be Put 13390 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours 6487; Petition 7849 SBS Radio - Grievance 6132 Schools Chaplaincy Program - Funding 14530 Vandalism 2928 Sentencing Legislation - Changes - Improvements 14253 St Vincent de Paul Society - Meahan, Mr John - National President - Statement 8962 Stamp Duty - Family Businesses - Grievance 8286 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9696 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9696 State Budget - Underlying Position of State’s Finances 7024 Swan Village of Care - Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Motion 5616 Taxes and Charges - Claim by Federal Minister 2385 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3529 Training System Plans 6342 Unified Buddhist Church of Vietnam - Petition 12327 Victims of Crime Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11085 Consideration in Detail 11087-11100 Third Reading 11407, 11509 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 948 Youth - Debt - Government Assistance 10420

RADISICH, MS JAYE AMBER, BA, LLB (Swan Hills) (ALP) Address-in-Reply - Motion Access to Justice 18 Education and Training 18 Electoral and Social Law Reform 18 Health Funding 17 North West Shelf Joint Venture - Contract with China 17 Policing 18 Social Fairness 16 Water Resources 18 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Budget - Impact on Electorate 7920 Ellenbrook Community Support Group 7920 Great Eastern Highway - Speed Limit 7919 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 485

RADISICH, MS JAYE AMBER (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate (continued) Hospital and Health System - Community Support 7920 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Budget - Impact on Electorate 7920 Ellenbrook Community Support Group 7920 Great Eastern Highway - Speed Limit 7919 Hospital and Health System - Community Support 7920 Burrup Peninsula - Media Comments on Major Projects 8597 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13185 Disability Services Franceschini-Piil, Daniel - Petition 14215 Holton, Ms Leah - Petition 7525 Domestic Violence Advocacy Support Central 11703 Education Phoenix - Proposed Workshop 8792 Teachers - Teacher of the Year Award 7029 Fire and Emergency Services - Fire Hazard Alarms - Petition 66 Forests and Forestry Jarrah - First and Second-grade - Implications of Opposition’s Policy for Annual Yield 9663 Logging - Perth Hills - Statement 10020 Goods and Services Tax - Impacts on Small Business 5998 Health Agency Nurses - Reduction in Use 5581 Bulk-billing by General Practitioners - Grievance 6611 Council of Australian Governments Meeting 10160 Phoenix - Proposed Workshop 8792 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11760 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5740, 5741 Local Government - Outer Metropolitan Councils - Resourcing Levels - Statement 14249 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion 10545 Thanks for Support During Health Treatment - Statement 5361 Mezzanine Financing - Risks 283 Midland Saleyards - Relocation 14884 Mining - BGC (Australia) Ltd - Open-cut Mining at The Lakes 12860 National Competition Council - Threat to Payments 12061 Planning Dialogue with the City 11111, 11255 Mauds Landing Development - Rejection Decision - Motion 9916 Police Drug-impaired Drivers 13523 Kiara Station - Services and Opening Times 7596 Prisons Acacia - Annual Report - Financial Penalty 12856 Bandyup - Security 5913 Public Accounts Committee - Port Coogee Development - Sixth Report 14230 Railways - Argyle Street Crossing, Herne Hill - Risk Assessment 9751 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours - Implications for Competition 9419 Road Safety - Speed Limits on Local Government Roads - Grievance 8700 Schools Behaviour Management and Discipline Strategy - Funding 10964 Bullsbrook District High - Upgrade of Toilets 2716 Eastern Hills Senior High - Music Program - Petition 14885 Fees - Impact of Policy 5365 Full-service Schools - Midvale Multi-agency Service Centre 12323 Junior High School Students - Out of School Care - Grievance 8934 Midvale Primary - Midvale Multi-agency Service Centre 12323 Non-government - Funding - Petition 6345 Upper Swan Primary - Completion of Renovations 14486 Sport and Recreation Hills Football Association - Junior Football 7779 486 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

RADISICH, MS JAYE AMBER (continued) Sport and Recreation (continued) Swan IC Soccer Club - Statement 11529 Swan Valley Planning Act - Review 8854 Taxis - Plate Leases - Interest 14257 Universities - Fees - Increase 7673

RAVLICH, HON LJILJANNA MARIA, BA, DipEd, EdAdmin, Parliamentary Secretary, Community Development, Women’s Interests, Seniors and Youth; Disability Services; Culture and the Arts; Health (to 27 June); Tourism (from 27 June); Small Business (from 27 June); Sport and Recreation (from 27 June); Peel and the South West (from 27 June) (East Metropolitan) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Health, Office of 1659, 2484, 2647, 2779, 4345 Child Protection Workers - Placement 9357, 9362, 12924 Child Sexual Abuse - Statistics on Communities 8367, 8678, 9566, 9567 Gordon Inquiry 8, 3875, 13470, 14838 Government Programs 7017, 7511 Support Workers - Placement, Experience and Training 9357, 9362 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Bropho, Mr Robert 554 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14796, 14797 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 First Reading 3761 Second Reading 3761, 5302 Committee 5305-5309 Third Reading 5309 Agriculture Genetically Modified Foods - Dispensing of Medicines and Vaccines 1006 Kimberley - Chemical Use Review - Terms of Reference of Medical Panel 3435 Alcoa World Alumina Australia - Wagerup Alumina Refinery - Monitoring Community Health 9566 Arts and Culture Fremantle Arts Centre - Review 10115, 10479 Palaeontologic Objects and Other Fossils 6582 WA Ballet and WA Opera - Merger 10478 Year 12 Perspectives Program - Regional Tour 10092 Associations Incorporation Act - Membership Provisions - Statement 3010 Australian Wildlife Conservancy - Ningaloo Development - Briefing 5816, 5817 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1735 Banks - Manual Slide Credit Card Facilities 12435 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility - Graffiti at Community Health Centre 9561 Building Industry Building and Construction Industry Training Fund - Surplus 12008 Registered Builders - Qualifications 13861 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 First Reading 7135 Second Reading 7135 Child Welfare Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 471 Third Reading 471, 472 Children and Young People’s Policy, Office of - Staff 4454 Colleges of TAFE - 2004 Places 13862 Community Development ABC Learning Centres Ltd - Child-care Centre, Hilton 1006 Child-care Centres - Supervision and Breaches of Regulations 12268 Child Care Services Board 6959, 10249 Child Abuse Aboriginal Communities 8367, 8678, 9566, 9567 Child Abuse and Maltreatment Notifications 11042, 12007 Child Death Review Committee - Reporting Process 11042 Child Protection 12924 Children in Care - Placement Breakdowns 6300 Commissioner for Children - Appointment 2483 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 487

RAVLICH, HON LJILJANNA MARIA (continued) Community Development (continued) Custody of Children - Legal Representation for both Parents 12292 Department Derby - Staff 12955 Marble Bar 592 Officers - Physical Threats 8361, 9028, 9190, 9654 Families in Need of Support - Assessment 9617 Foster Carers - Shortage 166 Kids Cove Child Care Centre, Mandurah 6581 Kids Help Line 9027, 9847, 9974 Out of School Care - Regulations 1137 Paedophiles - Protection of Children 9624 Roebourne - Initiatives to Assist Young People 4395 SafeCare 4392, 4452 Social Workers and Graduate Welfare Officers 7822 Wards of the State - Government Responsibility 5024 Disability Services Accommodation Support - Applications 11044 Commission Budget Increase 165 Cleaning Services 5663 Residential Accommodation 5318, 5959 Committees, Working Parties and Reviews 6096 Funding - Budget Measures 6960 Industrial Relations Reform - Impact on People with Disabilities 467, 6585, 12266 Residential Accommodation Services 5023 Whale Watching - Augusta and Dunsborough - Facilities for the Disabled 4062 Domestic Violence - Appointment of Eight Specialist Police Officers 12924 Drugs Cannabis - Funding for Education 8686 Derby - Alcohol-related Medical Treatment 12435 Drug and Alcohol Strategy 244; Urgency Motion 235 Hydroponic Equipment Policy 9023 Education Department Amalgamation with Department of Training 11837 $19 Million Gain 12667 Teachers Long Service Leave 12669 Remedial 13859 Vocational Education and Training - Review 12556 Environment Draft Wilderness Policy 11476 Kwinana - Cumulative Risk Study 711 Fire and Emergency Services Emergency Call System for Medical Emergencies - Changes 2347 Emergency Helicopter Service - Funding 1042 Forests and Forestry - Old-growth Forest - Mills Seeking Business Exit Assistance 705 Government Departments and Agencies Aborigines - Programs 7017, 7511 Budget Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9985, 9986 Court Action or Litigation - Involvement 7199-7202 Functional Review Taskforce Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9984, 10152 Panel Contracts 13173, 13174, 13364, 13365 Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 11059-11065 Register of Intellectual Property 6117, 6119 Staff - Recruitment Procedures 4058 Health Aborigines - Building Solid Families Program - Funding 163 Agencies - Statutory Reporting Deadlines 9194 Allied Health Taskforce - Work Force Issues Report 5412, 5536, 10482 488 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

RAVLICH, HON LJILJANNA MARIA (continued) Health (continued) Asbestos - BHP Billiton Ltd Housing in Port and South Hedland 1003 Biala Psychiatric Hostel - Licensing 9 BreastScreen WA 9568 Brookdale Community Health Centre - Community Nurse 9561 Bunbury Health Task Force - Report 4904 Community Midwifery Program 4048 Cue Nursing Post 1136 Derby - Alcohol-related Medical Treatment 12435 Green Head - Palliative Care Services 9023 Health Act - Amending Legislation 9562 HIV Strategy 8415 Laverton - Agency Nurses - Expenditure 7007 Medical Emergency Helicopter 8671 Medical Practitioners who Deliver Infants - Negligence Claims Limitation 9568 Medicines and Vaccines - Dispensing Via Genetically Modified Foods 1006 Mental Health Nurses 4202, 4990 Mental Health System 9564 Not-for-profit Organisations - Funding Cuts 12290 Nurses - Security in Remote Areas 8365, 9565 Occupational Therapists 2123, 3194 Palliative Care Specialist Support - Partnership with Non-government Sector 1955 Patient Assisted Travel Scheme - Albany Resident 2126 Phoenix - Audit Report 8363 Psychiatrists 4202, 4990 Smoking Cost to Health System of Smoking-related Diseases 9565 Enclosed Public Spaces - Removal of Exemptions 9359 Regulations - Review 9565, 10481 South West Mental Health Service Advice Line 4959, 5025 Clinical Director 4343 Lord, Dr David 4397 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Safe Levels 6958 Hospitals Albany Regional 864, 5055 Broome District - Staff-Patient Ratios and Bedding 38 Bunbury Regional 2780, 8777 Cost-care Centres - South West and Country Health Services 6582 Country - Budgets for Hospitals 8684 Country Hospital Medical Advisory Committees - Remuneration of Chairmen 5956 Derby Regional 465, 1419, 3194, 4205 Emergency Departments - Ambulance Bypasses 2779, 4057 Fremantle - Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner 2780 King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women 1041, 4058 Magnetic Resonance Imaging Technology 5410 Medical and Surgical Registrars - Impaired Performance Risk 5051 Metropolitan Teaching - Recurrent Allocations 4256 Multipurpose Health Service, Country Hospitals 4344, 4399 Paraburdoo - Future Plans 4063 South West Budgets for Hospitals 8684 Centralised Purchasing Facility - Buy Local Policy 5313 Teaching - Overspending 4345 Waiting Lists 1137 Wyndham District - Downgrading or Closure 159 Housing - BHP Billiton Ltd - Port and South Hedland - Asbestos Sheeting 1003 Industrial Development Draft Wilderness Policy 11476 Jervoise Bay Development - Heavy Fabrication Facility 4964 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 489

RAVLICH, HON LJILJANNA MARIA (continued) Industrial Development (continued) Kwinana - Cumulative Risk Study 711 Industrial Relations Cole Royal Commission into the Building Industry - Statement 11605 Reforms 467, 6585, 12266 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation - City of Melville - Fifth Report 4318 Joppek, Mr Phil - “My Explanation” - Adjournment Debate 4929 Kojonup, Shire of - Valuation of Land 713 Labour Relations Reform Bill 2002 - Impact on Agencies 467 Ministers of the Crown Minister for Culture and the Arts - Art Purchases 7479 Minister for Disability Services - Employment of People with Disabilities 14801 Office Location and Refurbishment and Staff 2908, 2909 Staff - Temporary 3906 Staff, Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers, Credit Cards, Fax Machines, Business Cards and Home Internet Access 4060 Museum, Western Australian 5052, 8362, 8674 Ningaloo Reef - Ningaloo Station - Briefing on Tourist Accommodation 5816, 5817 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Act - Loopholes in Legislation 42 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 3896 Second Reading 3897, 5649 Committee 5652-5657 Third Reading 5658 Parliamentary Secretary - Visit to Croatia - Statement 437, 11589 Pastoral Leases - Windimurra - Zadow, Mr Dale 5192 Planning Denmark - Pedestrian Access Way 552 Metropolitan Region Scheme A mendments No 1020/33 - Egerton Estate, Ellenbrook 553 No 1055/33 - Fremantle Eastern Bypass 865, 5196 Rockingham Foreshore - Height Restrictions on Buildings 863 Police - Child Protection and Family Violence Officers - Appointment 12924 Pollution - Domestic Smoke - Amending Legislation 9562 Questions on Notice - Answers 6305, 11178 Railways Loch and Grant Streets Stations - Partial Closure - Statement 539 WA Government Railway Commission - Coach Contracts - Statement 539 Refugees - Unaccompanied Minors - Memorandum of Understanding 9026 Road Coaches - Purchase - Statement 539 Roads Bussell Highway - Upgrade 704 Fremantle Eastern Bypass 865, 5196 Rottnest Island - Funding - Motion 14189 Schools Busselton Senior High - Fast Track Program 5196 Cadet Programs - Funding 9021 Country Areas - Remedial Teachers 13859 Dandaragan Primary 13007, 13861 East Hamersley Primary - Staffing Levels 861 Fremantle Primary - Funding 5194 Kindergartens 12668, 13009, 13067 Out-of-school Care - Regulations 1137 Staff - Inappropriate Behaviour or Relationships with Children 14711 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 8549; Motion, as Amended 8551 Small Business - Manual Slide Credit Card Facilities 12435 Sport and Recreation Hopman Cup - Funding 14836 Noalimba Recreation Camp - Future Use 554 Tom Hoad Cup - Statement 14786 Wanneroo Basketball Association - Relocation 5194 490 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

RAVLICH, HON LJILJANNA MARIA (continued) State Budget - Recurrent Expenditure and Capital Works Programs 6996, 6997 Tourism Bunbury Regional Events Unit 9970 Ningaloo Station - Briefing 5816, 5817 Whale Watching, Augusta and Dunsborough - Facilities for the Disabled 4062 Training Department 11837, 12667 Vocational Education and Training - Review 12556 Volunteers - Not-for-profit Health Organisations - Funding Cuts 12290 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Second Reading 1831, 2626 Committee 2629-2632 Third Reading 2632 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12234 Youth Great Southern Community Youth Committee 3615 Office for Children and Young People’s Policy - Establishment 2483 Roebourne - Initiatives to Assist Young People 4395

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN, BA, DipEd, Deputy Premier; Treasurer; Minister for Energy (Belmont) (ALP) Aborigines - Martu People - Rudall River National Park 10030 Accountability Watchdogs - Underfunding - Matter of Public Interest 12337 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Competition Policy) Bill 2002 Second Reading 6503 Council’s Amendment 13829, 13980 Adjournments of the House - Special 535, 3256, 11813 Alberta, Canada Oil and Gas Royalties - State-operated Investment Fund 1586 Tax Rates 1587 AlintaGas Albany - Fee to Find Gas Line 14969 Full Retail Contestability in the Gas Market - Statement 745 Geraldton and Greenough - Availability of Natural Gas 6788 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 8162 Second Reading 8162, 9130 Declaration as Urgent 9129 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2252 Second Reading 2252, 4137 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 4) 2002 Introduction and First Reading 2252 Second Reading 2252 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7362 Second Reading Budget context 7363 Building WA 7365 Commonwealth-State Financial Relations 7373 Community Development 7370 Community Safety and Security 7369 Education and Training 7368 Economy 7364 Environment 7371 Health 7366 Regions 7372 Revenue Base 7374 Cognate Debate 7527 Declaration as Urgent 7527 Third Reading 8466 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 491

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7376 Second Reading 7376 Cognate Debate 7527 Declaration as Urgent 7527 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 5) 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14294 Second Reading 14294 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 6) 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14294 Second Reading 14294 Auditor General, Office of Budget - Motion 11734 Matter of Public Interest 12337 Australian Labor Party - Election Policy - Regional WA 10028 Banks - Community - Stamp Duty Concessions for Patrons 2573 Beach Tavern, Mullaloo - Grievance 4822 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces Establishment 14308, 14346 Welker, Mr - Appointment 14967 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5222 Second Reading 5222 Cognate Debate 6381, 6388 Consideration in Detail 6391, 6392 Third Reading 6482, 6495 Business Tax Review (Assessment) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9238 Second Reading 9238 Cognate Debate 10200, 10203 Consideration in Detail 10405-10413, 10429, 10430 Third Reading 10563 Council’s Amendments 13829, 13830 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5224 Second Reading 5224 Cognate Debate 6381, 6388 Consideration in Detail 6393, 6394 Third Reading 6496 Business Tax Review (Taxing) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9240 Second Reading 9240 Cognate Debate 10200, 10203 Third Reading 10563 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9241 Second Reading 9241, 9866 Consideration in Detail 9870, 9880-9889, 9999 Third Reading 9999, 10002 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3851, 4679 Committees and Boards - Members - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7752, 7756 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14391, 14398 Consultants Michael, Dr Ken - Ministerial Advice 7225 Welker Environmental Consultancy - Appointments 14967 Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd - Merger with Grain Pool of Western Australia - Statement 596 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Information Divulged - Motion - Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1194 Courts - Port Hedland Magistrate - Transfer to Kalgoorlie 4860 Disability Services - Robinson, Ms Sally Anne - Petition 6346 East Perth Power Station Site - Funding 13812 492 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3911 Second Reading 3911, 5138 Consideration in Detail 5225-5235, 5246-5254, 5348-5360, 5378-5391 Third Reading 5392 Council’s Amendments 13825-13828 Economy - Western Australian Government’s Management 2164 Growth 3087 Strength 14071 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12836 Second Reading 12836 Declaration as Urgent 13215 Cognate Debate 13626, 13661 Referral to Economics and Industry Standing Committee 13706-13708 Consideration in Detail 13730, 13733 Third Reading 13734, 13737 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12833 Second Reading 12833, 13394, 13397, 13499 Declaration as Urgent 13215 Consideration in Detail 13504-13515, 13528-13537, 13540-13541, 13683-13692 Third Reading 13702 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 12838 Second Reading 12838 Declaration as Urgent 13215 Cognate Debate 13626, 13661 Third Reading 13738 Energy Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9401 Second Reading 9401, 9708 As to Third Reading 9711 Third Reading 9859 Council’s Amendments 11775-11788 Energy Operators and Water Agencies (Powers) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6506 Environment Greenhouse Gas Emissions - Reduction by Government Departments and Agencies 685 North West - Environmental Improvement Initiative Programs 5182 Federal Budget - State Government Expectations 7518 Response 7672 Fire and Emergency Services - Emergency Helicopter Service - Elvis Helicopters 1707 First Home Owner Grant Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendment 6189 Forest Products Commission - Treasury Performance Indicators 5622 Fuel and Energy Albany Wind Farm 6788, 10880, 10881 Coal-fired Electricity Generation - Coal 21 Initiative 14882, 14883 Cockburn Gas-fired Power Station 9663, 9664; Statement 13191 Collie Power Station - Privatisation 12463, 12758 Da mpier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Maintenance - Power Blackout Warnings 10286, 10287 Motion 6834; Amendment to Motion 6837 Sale 8002 Director of Energy Safety - Report on Electricity Network - Statement 8161 Electricity Adeline Area, Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Statement 66 Country Power Supplies 5449 Deregulated Market 1199 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 493

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Fuel and Energy (continued) Electricity (continued) Developments in the Industry - Grievance 1977 East Kimberley 9232 Lower Prices 1868 Prices - Guarantee 13517-13518, 13701 Reform Election Platform 3776 Implementation 10497 Prices 13196 Privatisation of Government-owned Power Stations 3348 Rural and Regional Areas 4675 Support 26 WA Power Conference Support 11783 Simcoa Operations Pty Ltd 13517 South West Interconnected System 4680 Southern Rail Link Usage 10879 Energy in WA Conference - Address 8155 Energy Smart Government Program 14077; Statement 13917 Epic Energy Regulator’s Draft Ruling 6492 Tariff Regulation 7518 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) Act - Review - Statement 12821 Goldfields Gas Pipeline - Cost of Gas Transmission 11958 Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator Cost Recovery 10163 Ministerial Briefing 7225 Ruling 6492, 7226, 7230 Tariff Regulation 7518 Kemerton Peak-load Gas Turbines 12765 Ministerial Council on Energy, Brisbane - Statement 3910 Mumbida Wind Farm Proposal - Delay in Approval 8793, 9236, 9237 Narrogin Electricity Generation Station - Oil Mallee Waste 8138 Solar Hot Water Systems - Rebates 9506 Wellington Dam - Hydro-electric Power Generator 2577 Wind Power Great Southern 11958 Peppermint Grove Beach 685 Gambling Burswood International Resort Casino Additional 200 Gaming Machines 1584 Burswood Dome - Retention 1706 Share Price 1707 Gaming Machines - Western Australian Clubs 1127 Gas and Electricity Safety Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 10392 Second Reading 10392, 12707 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) Act - Review - Statement 12821 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) (Reviews) Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 8163 Second Reading 8163, 9133 Declaration as Urgent 9130 Briefing by Office of Energy - Tabling 9383 Government Advertising - Expenditure 6218, 6398 Government Contracts Centralisation of Procurement Process in Perth 14254 Statistics 6222, 6223, 6398, 7095 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14442, 14453 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 3851, 4679 Cleaning Services 6407, 6410, 13764, 13770 494 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Club/Association Memberships 7394, 7400, 9774, 9779 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 13301, 13673, 14560, 14971 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 6234, 6400 Credit Cards 6220, 8100, 1167, 14070, 14509, 14956 Creditors 6209, 6397, 9753, 9770 Employment Contracts 6672, 7261 Funding Cuts 7223, 11619 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 12883, 12905 Greenhouse Gas Emissions - Reduction 685 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5161, 5170 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 6237, 7265 Key and Card Entry - Number and Procedures 14564, 14978 Leave Liability 5153, 5160 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14388, 14943 Leschenault Estuary - Management 5912, 8135 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6402, 6406 North West - Staff and Programs 2577, 2844 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10704, 10713 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7773, 7777 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Membership Fees 14399, 14426 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14456, 14483 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7759, 7764, 8245 Significant and Major Incidents Reported - Tabling of List 1788 Staff Investigations Conducted by Barbara Abbott 14532, 14540 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7118, 7120 Travel Expenditure 2575, 2576 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 8858, 8864 Wage Policy 14307 Web Sites - Online Payments 10721, 10731 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointment to Boards and Committees 5511, 14544 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 694, 1125 Government Employees Superannuation Board - Members - Credit Cards 11677 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 6231, 6399 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 6229, 6399 Motorcycles - Statistics 6225, 6398 Privately Plated 6227, 6399 Grain Pool of Western Australia - Merger with Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd - Statement 596 Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14391, 14398 Health Chlorination of Drinking Water - Changes to Ovarian Function 8147 Crisis in System - Matter of Public Interest 5103 Funding - Increase 5235,5236, 5373 Nurses - Workloads - Exceptional Matters Order 2002 1711 Priority Issues - Matter of Public Interest 6820 Hospitals King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women - Medical Legal Actions - Cost 5172 Princess Margaret Hospital for Child ren - Medical Legal Actions - Cost 5172 Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula 917, 918, 10026, 10027 Cockburn Cement Ltd - Dongara Lime Plant - Grievance 5690 Projects at Risk Due to Southern Rail Link Budget Blow-out 917, 918 Industrial Relations Fly in, Fly Out Employees - Grievance 9998 Unions - Government Grants 8858, 8864 Information Commissioner - Matter of Public Interest 12337 Insurance - Regulation of Industry 1308 Insurance Commission of Western Australia - Chairperson - Mobile Telephone and Credit Card 11678 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 495

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Liquor Deregulation of Industry - National Competition Policy Payments 11784 Licensing Changes to Laws - Amendment to Motion 12698 National Competition Policy 13524 Loan Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 8162 Second Reading 8162 Lobbyists - Burke, Mr Brian and Grill, Mr Julian Meetings with Ministers of Crown and Ministerial Staff 8146, 8638 Payroll Tax Amnesty 5445, 5446, 5723, 5724, 6338, 6339, 6642, 6643 Local Government Joondalup, City of - Government’s Position 14250 Rates - Pensioner and Senior Rebates 13548-13552, 14524; Grievance 5334 Springfield Retirement Village - Rate Rebates 5508 Lotterywest Chairperson - Government Car 11563 Federation Walkway - Cost of Advertisement 13306 Heritage-listed Buildings or Properties - Grants 2845 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee- Information Divulged - Motion- Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1194 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit - Minister for Tourism - Standing Aside 13919, 13920 Military Heritage - School Students 14255 Mining - South West - Government Revenue 6941 Ministers of the Crown Absence from Parliamentary Sittings 1713 Credit Cards 6220, 9467, 14069, 14070, 14078 Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 5723, 5724, 6338, 6339, 6642, 6643, 8146, 8638 Minister for Racing and Gaming - Air Travel to Albany Cup 7270 Mobile Phones - Use 4180, 4803 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10714, 10717 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14429, 14441 Corporate Credit Cards 8265, 9925, 12102 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 9780, 9782 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4180, 4809 Seconded from UnionsWA or Individual Unions 7118, 7120 Vehicles - Privately Plated 6232, 7265 Staff, Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 4179, 5142, 5173 Treasurer - Overseas Travel - Statement 880 National Competition Council Liquor Licensing Act Review - National Competition Policy 13524 Tabling of Documents 12615 Threat to Payments 12204 Motion 12473 Standing Orders Suspension - Question to be Put 12472 Native Title Abolition - Implications 281 Agreements and Litigation 4102 Applications - South West Region - Statement 5331 Burrup Peninsula - Agreement Details 10026, 10027 Combined Metropolitan Working Group’s Application - Suspension of Mediation - Statement 9083 Martu Determination 10030; Statement 1458 Metropolitan Area and South West - Statement 4815 Mining Tenements - Validity 401 Miriuwung-Gajerrong People - Statement 5824 Representative Bodies Funding - Statement 5561 Pressure to Deliver Results 2271 Technical Task Force - Cost 9311 Wongatha Native Title Application - Statement 9229 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations - Matter of Public Interest 12337 496 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 4712 Second Reading 4712, 6149 Consideration in Detail 6179, 6188 Third Reading 6188 Port Kennedy Port Kennedy Resorts Pty Ltd - Bond/Guarantee 1780 Water Corporation Works Agreement 4697 Questions on Notice - Answers 8007 Questions without Notice - Standing Orders Suspension 13389 Racing Bookmakers - Telephone and Internet Betting Limits 6541 Bunbury Trotting and Race Clubs - Turnover and Dividends 2588 Great Southern - Government Assistance 2314 Racing Radio, Collie and Kambalda - Establishment 2215 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5345 Second Reading 5345 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5341 Second Reading 5341 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5348 Second Reading 5348 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5347 Second Reading 5347 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1355 Railways Perth Urban Rail Development - Electricity Generation Capacity - Upgrading 6941 Southern Rail Link Budget Blow-out 14878-14880 Cost Blow-out 13922; Amendment to Motion 13937 Electricity Usage 10879, 11957 Funding by Debt 3225 State Debt Structure 917, 918 Under Treasurer’s Warnings 3226 Regional Development Centralisation of Procurement Process in Perth 14254 Commissions - Division 2 Section 23(1)(e) Breaches 1789 Government Services 3988, 3989 Retail Trading Hours - Deregulation - Implications for Competition 9419 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Deputy Premier 2999 Schools Military Heritage - Preservation 14255 Non-government - Funding - Petition 8012 Select Committee on the Infill Sewerage Scheme - Establishment - Motion 2306, 2688 Seniors Council Rate Rebates - Grievance 5334 Local Government and Water Rates Concessions 13548, 13551,13552 Sewerage Capel - Treatment Plant and Infill Program 1781 Commercial Properties - Connection to Reticulated Systems 8155 Conlon Street, Waterford 8153, 8154 Infill Sewerage Program Busselton 2215 Cannington 9A and 9C 10442 Criteria for Determining Priority 9147 Grievance 4824 North West 5178 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 497

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Sewerage (continued) Infill Sewerage Program (continued) Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 2306, 2688 Murray and Serpentine Rivers - Leakage from Septic Tanks 8155 Timewell Road Treatment Plant, Albany 13985 Waterford 9147 Small Business Electricity Prices - Reduction 13518 Stamp Duty - Rental Businesses - Grievance 891 Tax on Hire Items 6941 Springfield Retirement Village - Rates Rebates 5508 Stamp Amendment Bill 2001 Consideration in Detail 1692, 1693 Council’s Amendment 4727 Stamp Amendment (Budget) Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7526 Second Reading 7526, 8493 Consideration in Detail 8496-8498 Third Reading 8498 State Budget Comments by Leader of the Opposition 1585, 6811 Funding Cuts 7223 Surplus 1710, 11619 Underlying Position of State’s Finances 7024 Water Resources - Payout Ratio 8871 State Finance Capital Spending - 3225 Commonwealth Grants Commission 4744, 4747, 6685 Federal Budget Weaknesses - Implications for Western Australia 5719 Government Financial Results Report 2001-02 Capital Works Deferred, Delayed or Cut 1586 Statement 1568 Government Financial Results Report 2002-03 - Statement 11618 Government Spending in 2002-03 11697 Oil and Gas Royalties - State-operated Investment Fund 1586 Revised Government Financial Strategy Statement - Statement 2516 Stamp Duty Community Banks - Concessions 2573 Family Businesses - Grievance 8287 Lot 131 The Cutting, Mosman Park 14541 Rental Businesses - Grievance 891 State Debt 770, 7022, 7516, 7524, 7672, 7673 Taxes and Charges Claim by Federal Minister 2385 Increases 8440; Matter of Public Interest 7038 Treasurers Conference - Outcome 5828 State Revenue, Office of Companies Audited 13304 Employment Agency Classification - Payroll Tax 13305 Reclassification of Contractors as Employees 13304 Taxation Goods and Services Tax - Moore Report 10674 Land Tax 13310 Payroll Tax Applications for Information about Assessments - Refusals 13551 Assessments of Employee-like Contractors 3499, 3500 Back Taxes, Fines and Penalties and Revenue 13305 Employment Agency Classification 13305 Relief - Mr Burke and Mr Grill 5445, 5446, 5723, 5724, 6642, 6643 Revenue 13303 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 4734-4742, 4752-4758, 4838-4843 498 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Standing Orders Suspension 3355 Totalisator Agency Board - Sports Betting Account and Fixed Odds Betting 8149 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 8162 Second Reading 8162, 9125 Declaration as Urgent 9105 Unclaimed Money (Superannuation and RSA Providers) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3912 Second Reading 3912, 4844 Third Reading 4845 Water Corporation Dividend - Payout Ratio 8871 Forecast Dividend 87 Karrinyup - Sale of Land 9508 Significant and Major Incidents Reported - Tabling of List 1788 Subdivision of Residential Lots - New Water Main to Complete the Loop - Grievance 11504 Water Resources Albany and Great Southern - Expenditure on Infrastructure 10880 Catchment Areas - Controlled Burns and Clearing 692 Chemicals - Data 13986 Chlorination - Changes to Ovarian Function 8147 Community Water Forums - Advertisement for Hon Adele Farina 1461, 1462, 1469 Dunsborough - Fluoride Levels of Bores 8149 Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Conservation Initiatives 12384 Management - Matter of Public Interest 2398 North West - Funding for Programs 2419, 2420, 7781 Preston Beach - Upgrading 685 Rates - Pensioner and Senior Rebates 13548, 13551, 13552, 14524 Springfield Retirement Village - Rates Rebates 5508 Underground Water - Use 692 Water Treatment Plant - Laverton and Leonora 10881 Wellington Dam - Salt Content 2420 Western Power Albany Buy Local Policy for Cars 4691 Reconnections 10875 Bowey Property, Kulin - Cost of Power Connection 10028 Bremer Bay - Power Supplies 12200, 12321, 12323, 12466 Broadband Telecommunications Network Trial, Victoria Park 9234 Budget Allocations 9506 Chairman Credit Card 13270 Letter to Minister for Energy - Tabling 10441 Complaints - Grievance 8285 Denmark - Reconnections 10875 Disaggregation Electricity Prices 2390 Fall in Value 1868, 1869 Kemerton Peak-load Gas Turbines 12765 Electricity Generation - Transmission and Distribution Efficiencies 14520 Electricity Maintenance Program - Statement 10157 Electricity Outage - Darlington-Mundaring Area 6411 Electricity Prices - Reduction for Small Businesses 13200, 13201, 13518 Electricity Supplies - Contingency Arrangements 12686, 12687 Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5459 Kalbarri - Maintenance 12614 Katanning Reconnections 10875 Managing Director Conditions of Employment 10029, 11249, 11258, 11393, 11954 Directorships and Board Memberships 10161 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 499

RIPPER, HON ERIC STEPHEN (continued) Western Power (continued) Managing Director (continued) Limousine Service Account 10423 Statement 10050, 10492, 11248 Trips to Melbourne 10158, 10159, 10421, 12816 Mid West Facilities 12614; Grievance 5690 Mt Barker - Reconnections 10875 Pensioner Rebates 1760 Power Poles - Rural and Regional Areas 5509 Privatisation 2922 Regional Power Connections Grievance 10387 Wheatbelt - Power Supplies 12200, 12321, 12323, 12466

ROBERTS, HON MICHELLE HOPKINS, BA, DipEd, Minister for Police and Emergency Services; Justice (from 27 June); Community Safety (from 27 June) (Midland) (ALP) Aborigines - Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Police Guard or Patrol 14486 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion 1750 Bateman, Mr Thomas Henry -Condolence Motion 11893 Boards, Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 14936 Building Industry - Complaints Against Unions 3847 Censorship - Film Classifications - Grievance 11078 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 4171 Committees and Boards - Mobile Telephones, Pagers, Vehicles and Credit Cards 7929 Communications and Public Relations - Cost of Consultancy 14393 Child Abuse 2820, 11109; Matter of Public Interest 9100 Courts Albany - New Complex 7881 Security and Custodial Services Contract - Renewal 12855 Crime Australian Crime Commission - Creation 209 Burglary 8303, 11785, 11814 Cannabis - Link to Criminal Offending 5995 CityNEX Camera Surveillance System - 11396 Clearance Rates 13611 “Crime and Justice Statistics for Western Australia: 2002” - Statement 14874 Crime Stoppers - Advertisement on Drug Dealer Phone-in Day 4558, 4559 Fremantle - Statistics 12685 Goldfields-Esperance Region - Statistics 14074 Gosnells Area - Police and Local Government Initiatives 5368 Government Initiatives 8442 Motor Vehicle Break Ins 8076, 12374 Northbridge 8965, 14917 Police Success in Combating 8891 Prevention and Emerging Trends 10871 Railway Stations - Motor Vehicles Stolen, Damaged or Burgled 11698 Reported Offence and Clearance Statistics - Statement 11244 Safer WA - Review 9745 Statistics 1513, 8076, 8077, 9422; Statement 3069, 5079 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13179 Disability Services - Mr Winston Davis - Petition 6686 Domestic Violence - Government Action 11109 Driver Training and Education Centre - Perth International Airport 9138 Drugs Cannabis 4558, 4559, 5995, 8514 Illegal Drug Laboratories - Introduction of Legislation 8596 Record Drug Bust 5088 Education - Teachers Pay Rise - Matter of Public Interest 10974 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 Cognate Debate 2192 Second Reading 2209 500 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

ROBERTS, HON MICHELLE HOPKINS (continued) Fire and Emergency Services Authority Defence Force National Employer Support Award - Statement 1852 Combined Ladder Platform Appliance - North West 2587 Community Development and Justice Standing Committee Report - Statement 5220 Fire Hydrant Installation - 14348 House Fires - Smoke Alarms and Causes of Fires 9729 Levy 8313, 10161, 11435, 12378, 14487; Matter of Public Interest 10176 New South Wales Bushfires - Statement 2782 North West - Funding 5756 Regional Airports - Removal of Front-line Emergency Response Crews 5241 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 - Council’s Amendments 3236 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Cognate Debate - Motion 2192 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2209 Referral to Community Development and Justice Standing Committee 2267 Consideration in Detail 2365-2381, 2401-2411 Third Reading 2411, 2414 Council’s Amendments 3829-3833 Firearms Antique and Curio - Legislation 2997 Unlicensed Hand Guns - Use in Criminal Activities - Grievance 5688 Firearms Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 13385 Second Reading 13385 Forests and Forestry - Logging Roads Traffic Rules 8501 Government Advertising - Expenditure 7765 Government Contracts - Statistics 7767 Government Departments and Agencies Bad Debts Written Off 14446 Chamber of Commerce and Industry of WA - Funding 4171 Cleaning Services 8503, 13766 Club/Association Memberships - Payment 8086, 10702 Computers and Mobile Phones - Lost or Stolen 14513 Conferences and Seminars - Cost 7772 Credit Cards 7766, 14503 Creditors 10052, 7758 Employment Contracts 7758 Grants - Number, Value and Acquittals of Funding 13264 Indigenous People - Number, Classification and Redundancies 5165 Internet Payments 11004 Interpreting Services for Hearing Impaired People 8506 Leave Liability 5156 Legal Advice - Expenditure 14374 Leschenault Estuary - Management 8511 Management Initiated Redundancies - Bar on Criticism of Government 6403 North West - Staff and Programs 3981 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10707 Public Affairs, Public Relations and Media Liaison Sections - Employee Numbers 7775 Qantas Club or Other Airline Membership Programs - Payment of Membership Fees 14409 Right of Entry to Private Property - Statutes 14470 Sale of Assets Valued at over $500 000 7932 Staff 9139, 3132, 3258, 14964 UnionsWA or Individual Unions - Grants 9138 Welker, Mr Charlie - Appointments to Boards and Committees 14547 Government Employees Housing Authority - Busselton 3132 Government Vehicles Home Garaging 7770 Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered 7770 Motorcycles Statistics 7768 Privately Plated 7769 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 501

ROBERTS, HON MICHELLE HOPKINS (continued) Hawker Britton - Cost of Consultancy 14393 Industrial Development - Burrup Peninsula - Protection of Investments - Emergency Response 8791 Industrial Relations Government Leadership - Matter of Public Interest 10974 Unions Complaints by Construction Firms 3847 Government Grants 9138 Inspector of Custodial Services Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 11685 Second Reading 11685, 12712 Consideration in Detail 12716, 12717, 12718 Third Reading 12718 Insurance - Fire Service Levy Charge on Notices 11435 Justice, Department of High-risk Offenders - Management Practices 12605, 12607, 12608; Statements 11899, 12574 Home Detention Orders - Number and Breaches 12374, 12812 Offender Management - Improvements 14253 Parole Breaches 10282, 10283, 10415, 12608 Correction to Previous Answer 10493 High-risk Parolees - Motion 11413 Mitchell, Mr Russell James 10416, 10494, 10495 Reforms to System 10493 Reduced Imprisonment Strategy 12606 Serious Offenders 10415, 10416, 10417 Lobbyists - Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill - Ministers 8518 Local Government Fire and Emergency Services Levy - Rebate 12378 Fire Hydrant Installation 14348 Gosnells, City of - Crime Initiatives 5368 Safer WA Funding 14986 Members of Parliament - Driver Fatigue Due to Sitting Hours 6813 Mickelberg Case - Lewandowski Affidavit 765, 766, 1515 Ministers of the Crown Meetings with Mr Brian Burke and Mr Julian Grill 8518 Minister for Police and Emergency Services Meals, Drinks and Expenses 5997, 9742, 9744, 13426 Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12787 Staff - Use of Government Credit Cards 14955 Mobile Phone Use 4805 Plants and Flowers - Cost of Hiring or Purchasing 10715 Staff Contracts, Vehicles, Mobile Telephones and Credit Cards 14433 Corporate Credit Cards 8251, 9921, 14531, 14940 Memberships of Clubs/Associations/Unions - Payment of Fees 10206 Presents and Social Functions - Funding 4810 Vehicles - Privately Plated 7939 Vehicles, Mobile Phones, Pagers and Credit Cards 5145 Misuse of Drugs Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 8582 Second Reading 8582, 10194 Consideration in Detail 10196-10199 Third Reading 10200 Motor Vehicles Break Ins 8076, 9138, 12374 Company Cars - Accidents 9138 Loud Music - Police Powers to Control 9743 Parliament - Staff - Driver Fatigue Due to Sitting Hours 6813 Police Accidental Shooting of Maintenance Worker 13268 Act - Review 982 502 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

ROBERTS, HON MICHELLE HOPKINS (continued) Police (continued) Albany - New Complex 7881 Attendance at “The Gathering of the Eagles” 14522 Audit of Training Procedures and Equipment 12811 Belmont Station - Number of Officers 1629 Bikie Gangs - DNA Profiling - Statement 879 Budget - Breakdown of Items 14527 Bunbury Rapid Response Squad 12609, 12610 CADCOM Project - Abandonment of Part of System 4637 Child Sex Offenders Register - National Approach 2820 CityNEX Camera Surveillance System 11396 Civilian Police Service Employees - Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 3093 Clairvoyants - Use 3987 Claremont Station - Closure 14349 Clarkson Station - Closure 11783 Clearance Fees - Waiving in Cases of Hardship 9715 Community Operations - Motion 4778 Coolgardie Station - APLO Numbers 11434, 14485 Crime Fighting Success 8891 Crime Stoppers - Advertisement on Drug Dealer Phone-in Day 4558, 4559 Crowd Control Licences 4665, 13270 Custody - Escapes, Deaths and Suicides 10701 DMR Consulting Pty Ltd - Cost 13267 DNA Testing 26, 918, 2820, 7679, 13261, 14919; Statement 879 Dog Squads - Number and Cost 13423 Drink-driving - Christmas Anti-drink-driving Campaign - Statement 2918 Driving Offences - Confiscation of Motor Vehicles 9746 Drug-impaired Drivers 13523 Drug Bust 5088 Firearms, Number 9713 Flying Squads - Establishment 666 Fremantle - Staff 12685 Fremantle Regional District - Officer Numbers 9794, 11561 Full-time Equivalents - Shortfall 13425 Functional Review Taskforce - Cancellation of AIMS Contract 4744 Gang Violence - Statement 7514 Glock Pistols 6337, 8313, 8315, 9750, 11001, 13259 Goldfields-Esperance - Budget 1513, 13259 Great Northern Highway between Muchea and Wubin - Patrols 12375 Informants - Number 4156 Joondalup 3986, 14500, 14501, 14521 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Station 1513, 2994, 3711, 11434, 13259, 14485 Kensington Police Complex - Flags Displayed 1514 Kiara Station - Services and Opening Times 7596 Laverton and Warburton Stations 12378 Lost Man-hours Due to Changes in Court Times and Cancellation of Cases 8073, 12379 Loud Music from Motor Vehicles - Noise Abatement Powers 9743 Major Sporting Events - Allocation of Resources 9743 Metropolitan Railway System 11434 Midland Station 10031, 12881, 13269, 13426 Motorists - Testing for Drugs 12326 Mullewa Station - 44-hour Week 3847 Multanovas Burrows, Mr Ian 664 Country Roads 8001 Locations 4623, 9720 Revenue - Road Safety Initiatives 7028, 7361, 8000 Tabling of List of Expenditure of Revenue 7028 National Automated Fingerprint Identification System 12608 Newman Station - Replacement 9875 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 503

ROBERTS, HON MICHELLE HOPKINS (continued) Police (continued) North Metropolitan District - RADAR Model 4160 Northam Station - Grievance 5686 Numbers - Increase 12808 Occupational Safety and Health Audit 12376 Offence and Clearance Statistics - Statement 14054 Officers Number 1515, 3711, 3712, 4660, 13424; Matter of Public Interest 7892 Overtime Payments 8500 Pay Claim 10588 Private Firearm Ownership 7595 Rates of Pay 10498 Recruitment 7361 Regional and Remote Locations 12066 Stress Leave 3984 Unprofessional Conduct - Penalties 5723 Overtime 10680 Owner-onus Legislation - Proclamation 8117 Pay Dispute 10820, 10821, 10961, 10962; Matter of Public Interest 10974 Porter, Mr Kingsley - Deputy Commissioner - Retirement - Statement 1458 Records of Occupations of People Arrested 7596 Recruits - Number and Duties 13262 Redeployment 4644 Red-light Cameras 7028, 7361, 11005 Redundancies for Civilian Administration Positions 3091 Regional and Remote Areas 11905 Reid Highway-Altone Road, Beechboro - Fatal Accident - Failure of Traffic Lights 5830 Response Times for Priority Offences 12377 Royal Commission - Sworn Officers Stood Down 8929 Scarborough Beach Car Park - Antisocial Behaviour - Grievance 12829 School Crossing Attendants - Travel Allowance 10051 School Crossings and Traffic Wardens - Review 4107, 4108 School Truants - Powers 3711 Section 8 Dismissals - Reform 88 Speeding Offenders - Confiscation of Vehicles 10591 Squads and Units - Names and Purposes 14958 Staff Resignations Retirements and Dismissals 14969 Stations Closure or Downgrading 4560 Interview Rooms and Holding Cells 1514 Number and Holding Cells 710 Officer Numbers 3709, 11625, 11627 Percentage Operating Below Authorised Strength 11696, 11697, 11782, 11783 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Guard or Patrol 14486 Tactical Response Group - Transport by Aircraft 3980 Traffic Management and Road Safety Budget - Underspending 8003, 8183 Vehicle Pursuits - Guidelines 14522 Vehicle Searches - Legislative Authority 9751 Vehicles Prohibition on Officers Taking Vehicles Home 3708 Purchase from States and Territories 3989 Violence Restraining Orders - Enforcement - Seizure of Firearms 10719 Warburton 12810 Warnbro Shooting Incident 10281, 10282; Statement 10158 Western Australia-Northern Territory Agreement - Statement 12446 Yalgoo, Shire of - Aboriginal Police Liaison Officer 2391 Police Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3072 Second Reading 3072, 3939 Consideration in Detail 3941-3946, 4081-4086 Third Reading 4086 504 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

ROBERTS, HON MICHELLE HOPKINS (continued) Prisons Acacia - Annual Report - Financial Penalty 12856 Broome Regional 13815 Court Security and Custodial Services Contract - Renewal 12855 Golf Lessons for Prisoners 10029 Policy to Reduce Prison Population - Risk to Community - Matter of Public Interest 10509 Prisoners - Escapes from Custody 9139 Video Games - Review - Motion 11413 Prostitution Control Board - Costs 7227 Number of Prostitutes and Offences 8092 Soliciting in Public Places 7362 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 6007 Second Reading 6007, 7072 Consideration in Detail 7074 Third Reading 7074 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 6003 Second Reading 6003, 8720, 8731 Consideration in Detail 9246, 9262-9292, 9406-9414, 9427-9442 Third Reading 9444, 9452 Public Consultation - Statement 3478 Questions on Notice - Answers 8007; Motion 12787 Railways Midland-Fremantle Service - Petition 8796 Pemberton-Northcliffe Tramway - Traffic Rules 8501 Police Officers Rostered for Duty 11434 Rail Safety - Expenditure 10717 Stations - Car Stealing and Burglary 11698 Roads Country - Multanova Use 8001 Kwinana Freeway - Multanova Use 8000 Logging Roads - Traffic Rules 8501 Pemberton Tramway Company - Collision on Privately-owned Logging Road 7778 Road Safety Accidents - Company Cars 9138 Australasian Spinal Research Trust - Funding 3348 Black Spots - Funding 9089 Confiscation of Vehicles 10591 Council - Regional Representation 8005 Double Demerit Point System 11624 Driver Fatigue - Parliamentary Sitting Hours 6813 Drug-impaired Drivers 13523 Duncraig 8115 Expenditure 10717 Implementation of Strategy 8002 Leader of the National Party - Claims 515 Resources - Matter of Public Interest 8017 Road Aware Program 1463 School Areas 1868 Speed and Red Light Cameras - Revenue 7361 Speed Campaign 10280 Speed Limits on Local Government Roads - Grievance 8701 Test of Motorists for Drugs 12326 Underspending of Budget 8003, 8183 Speed Limits - Increase - Remote Areas 403, 517 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers 5088, 8929 Scarborough Beach Car Park - Antisocial Behaviour - Grievance 12829 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 505

ROBERTS, HON MICHELLE HOPKINS (continued) Schools Children’s Crossings and Traffic Wardens - Review 4107, 4108 Crossing Attendants - Travel Allowance 10051 Road Safety 1868 Truants - Police Powers 3711 Sentencing Legislation - Changes - Improvements 14253 Transport Air - Regional Airports - Removal of Front-line Emergency Response Crews 5241 Cyclists - Use of Bells 8513

SCOTT, HON BARBARA MARY (South Metropolitan) (Lib) Aborigines - Gordon Inquiry Additional Child Protection Workers 3875 Interim Report 8 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Legislation Committee 4231 Second Reading 4288, 4346 Address-in-Reply Motion Blessing of the Fleet, Fremantle 1647 Children 1648-1650 Kwinana Iron Project 1646 Rare Map and Drawing Collection for Auction - French Explorer, Freycinet 1646, 1647 Southern Rail Link 1644-1646 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 4004 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Committee 5305 Arts and Culture Arts Awards - Statement 10928 Fremantle Arts Centre - Review 10115, 10479 His Majesty’s Theatre - Statement 14618 Performing Arts Centre - Statement 10484 Perth Entertainment Centre 39, 3733, 4934, 13011 ScreenWest - Screen Industry Partnership Fund 5777 Small to Medium Performing Arts Companies - Review 10922 Visual Arts - Myer Report 10751 Western Australian Academy of Performing Arts 2914, 2915 Western Australian Conservatorium of Music - Reorganisation 2914 Western Australian Institute of Music - Reorganisation 2914 Year 12 Perspectives Program - Regional Tour 10092 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9935 Children and Young People’s Policy, Office of - Staff 4454 Children’s Court - Rights of Representation - Petition 13843 Committees and Boards - Appointments - Women 2512 Community Development ABC Learning Centres Ltd - Child-care Centre Hilton 1006 Child Abuse and Maltreatment Notifications 11042, 12007 Child-care Centres Statement 6594 Supervision and Breaches of Regulations 12268 Child Care Services Board 6959, 10249 Child Death Review Committee - Reporting Process 11042 Child Protection “‘Caring Well - Protecting Well’ Investing in Systemic Responses to Protect Children in WA” Project Brief 12924 Unit - Funding 12557 Children in Care - Placement Breakdowns 6300 Children’s Week - Statement 12564 Commissioner for Children - Appointment 2483; Adjournment Debate 474 Custody of Children - Legal Representation for both Parents 12292 Early Childhood - National Consultation Document - WA Submission 13145 Kids Cove Child Care Centre, Mandurah 6581 506 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SCOTT, HON BARBARA MARY (continued) Community Development (continued) Kids Help Line 9027, 9847, 9974 National Child Protection Week - Statement 11050, 11180 Out of School Care - Regulations 1137 Wards of the State - Government Responsibility 5024 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Third Reading 12511 East Perth Power Station Site - Expressions of Interest - Future Plans 13011 Education Children with Special Needs - Educational Aides 3439 Department Amalgamation with Department of Training 11837, 12143 Central Office Structure - Reform 594 Early Childhood Education - Training and Exp erience of Personnel 246 Robson Report - Recommendations 164, 594 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers Arts 9156 Education Literacy and Numeracy 9154 Class Sizes 9155 Rockingham - Mangles Bay Marina 9156-9157 Government Departments and Agencies - Common Boundaries - Adjournment Debate 474 Health Community Child Health Team - Full-time Equivalents 13593 Early Development Survey - Statement 14619 Joondalup Child Development Centre - Waiting List for Therapy 14608, 14637 Meningococcal Meningitis Vaccine - Adjournment Debate 474 North Metropolitan Health Service Survey 13860, 14032 Industrial Development - Kwinana - Cumulative Risk Study 3613 Members of Parliament Overseas Travel 4202; Incorrect Information 4528; Personal Explanation 4241 Personal Explanation - Fremantle Eastern Bypass 1639 Minister for Education and Training - Answers to Questions - Statement 13012 Planning Hope Valley-Wattleup Redevelopment - Garland International Report 9360, 10778 Lots 595 and 596 Stakehill Swamp 11177 Mangles Bay, Rockingham - Marina Proposal 4905 Port Catherine Project - Reclaimed Land 9560 Stakehill Rural Landowners Group - Land in Baldivis 11208 Wireless Hill Park Excision from Class A Reserve 29813 - Motion for Disallowance 14706 Land Excision 12437; Petition 10735 Ports and Harbours Fremantle - Freight Trains Leaving Port 14717 Mangles Bay Marina - Feasibility and Impact Statement 13473 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Child Protection Unit - Additional Funding 11039 Prostitution - Children - Adjournment Debate 5030 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3274 Committee 3319, 3321, 3322, 3327, 3328, 3330 Railways Fremantle - Freight Trains Leaving Port 14717 Southern Rail Link Lots 595 and 596 Stakehill Swamp - Acquisition 11177 Rockingham High-tech Local Transit System 1952 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass High Street, Fremantle - Widening 4027, 4343 Personal Explanation 1639 Private Properties or Residences Acquired 4449 Select Committee - Motion 1534, 1632; Amendment to Motion 2114 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 507

SCOTT, HON BARBARA MARY (continued) Roads (continued) Fremantle Eastern Bypass (continued) Urgency Motion 4898 High Street, Fremantle - Widening 4027, 4343 Roe Highway Stage 8 4449 Rockingham Central City Transit Service - Steering Committee 3175 Schools Breakfast Clubs 9557 Carine Senior High - Bullying 4396 Class Sizes 1660 Fremantle Primary 5194, 5409 Hand Washing that Includes the Use of Soap - WorkSafe Guidance Notes 14838 Kindergartens Class Sizes 12668, 13009, 13067, 14723 Early Childhood Teachers 13009 Rural Areas - Early Childhood Support Officer 3025 Melville High and Primary - Sale 4259 Non-government - Funding - Petition 3990, 8525 Out of School Care - Regulations 1137 Preprimary and Primary Class Sizes 2229, 2763 Secret Harbour Middle - Construction 7479 South Fremantle Senior High - Music Centre Funding 351, 7179 Select Committee into the Fremantle Eastern Bypass Motion 1534, 1632 Amendment to Motion 2114 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children (Appointment of a Commissioner for Children) Appointment of Members 9319 Establishment Motion 7623 Amendment to Motion 8549 Motion, as Amended 8555 Proposal to Travel - Special Report 13844 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5296-5299, 5636-5639 Sewerage - Kwinana Waste Water Recycling Plant - Cost 1263, 1420 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3158 Training, Department of - Amalgamation with Department of Education 11837, 12143 United States of America - Support for Military - Urgency Motion 1414 Voluntary Euthanasia Bill 2002 - Second Reading 11037 WA Museum Access 8674 Closure because of Asbestos Scare 5052 Funding for Relocation 8362 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13885 Youth Children’s Week - Statement 12564, 12675 Office for Children and Young People’s Policy - Establishment 2483

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (South Metropolitan) (GWA) Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14581 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Legislation Committee 4228 Second Reading 4348 Co mmittee 4508-4523 Address-in-Reply - Motion Electricity Reform 149 Insurance Industry 149-155 Adjournments of the House - Complimentary Remarks 14848 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Chemical Use - Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Inquiry - Motion 10906; Amendment to Motion 10906 508 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Agriculture (continued) Dairy Industry - Overseas Farmers and Investors 2126 Genetically Modified Crops Gene Technology Agreement 466 Marketing Strategy 10481 Genetically Modified Foods - Dispensing of Medicines and Vaccines 1006 Herbicides - Roundup - Environmental Guidelines for Use 10814 Lactanz Dairy Farm - Waste Water Discharge into D’Entrecasteaux National Park 4057 Livestock Transport - Fatigue Management Regulations 11603 Alcoa World Alumina Australia Wagerup Alumina Refinery Future Tripartite Group 13006 Operating Licence No 6217/7 12924 Output Expansion 7479 Waste Oil as a Dust Suppressant 5959 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Order of Business - Amendment to Motion 2724 Second Reading 2759, 2766 Committee 2877-2879, 2884 Ascot Waters - Adjournment Debate 4486 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Second Reading 13055 Committee 13089-13103 Business of the House - Order of Business Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Amendment to Motion 2724 Motion 8525 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 9601 Committee 10073 Third Reading 11334 Canning River - Licences to Discharge Waste 13024 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10463 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Committee 3039, 3040 Cockburn Sound Cockburn Sound Management Council - Establishment 6464 Dolphin Population - Studies 3024 Draft Environmental Protection Policy - Implementation 6465 Environmental Protection Policy - Completion 6123 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Second Reading 11048, 11335, 11437 Committee 11584-11586, 12386-12392 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Committee 12511-12516 Education - Teachers - Pay Rise - Appointment of Conciliator 14798 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14809 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14809 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14809 Environment Acid Sulfate Soils Companies Accredited to Test 4056 Risk Maps - Development for Western Australia 1560 Ascot Waters Development, Belmont 11836, 14048 BP Kwinana Refinery 12037, 12145 Domestic Fires - Burning of Painted Wood 10801 Environmental Protection Policies - Completion 2779 Environmental Recovery Services Ltd 2347, 3337 Government Departments and Agencies - Annual Environmental Performance Reporting 12036 Green Stamp Program - Accreditation 2913 Greenhouse Gas Emissions Adjournment Debate 1038 Kyoto Protocol - Premier’s Opposition to Signing 1261 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 509

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Environment (continued) Greenhouse Gas Emissions (continued) Reduction 12042 State Strategy - Completion 11374 Industrial Projects - Post-approval Monitoring 11889 James Point Live Sheep Export Facility - Odour Modelling 2763 Kwinana Air Quality Buffer - Review 1738 Cumulative Risk Study 1136 Emission Scrubbing Devices - Bypass Incidents 1744 Kwinana International Motorplex - Impact of Noise on Hope Valley Residents 14770 Leschenault Estuary Development - Petition 13554 Mallee Seed Bartle, Mr John 14607 Forrest Nursery Pty Ltd Order 14196 Manjimup Seed Centre 13864 Statement 14206 Supplies 14031 Midland Railway Workshop Site - Soil Stockpiles and Air Monitoring 2483, 3903, 7008 Ship-blasting Abrasive High Pressure - Environmental Impact 1842 Smoky Vehicle Reporting Program 11889 South Beach Urban Redevelopment, South Fremantle Ground Water Monitoring Bores 7009 Heavy Metal Contaminants Clean-up 735 Noise Management Plan 12313 Site Investigation and Management Plan 12313 Site Remediation and Validation Report 7010 Swan Coastal Plain Lakes Environmental Protection Policy - Completion 11886 Thomsons Lake and Lake Kogolup - Swans 12040 Waste Discharge into Marine Environment 6460, 13024 Wetlands - Nominations under Ramsar Convention 12036 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4915 Third Reading 11573 Environmental Protection Authority - Project Development Proposals 5818, 7848 Environmental Protection, Department of Air Quality Branch - Senior Staff Resignations 2511 Cockburn Cement Ltd - Review of Audit Findings 737 Waste Control Fire in Bellevue - Review of Audit Findings 737 Fire and Emergency Services Body Bags Purchase 11208 Chemical Fires - Emergency Response Plan 11040 Nuclear Accidents 4397, 4526 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 1256 Fisheries Dolphins - James Point, Cockburn Sound 3024 West Coast Rock Lobster Fishery Management Plan Amendment 2003 - Disallowance 12124 Forests and Forestry Jarrah Sawlogs - Allocation - Companies Short-listed 14799 Ludlow Tuart Forest Inclusion on the Endangered Places List 3475 Tabling of Agreement 5076 Tuart Trees South of Mandurah - Decline and Death - Impact of Bauxite Mining 13915 Freedom of Information Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9319 Second Reading 9319, 11027 Committee 11030 Third Reading 11031 Fremantle Artillery Barracks - Statement 12440 Fremantle Cemetery - Transfer of Management to the Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Inquiry - Motion 11338 510 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Fuel and Energy Oil and Gas Resources - Future Use 1660 Renewable Energy in Rural Areas - Reduction 12042 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14164 Committee 14626-14633, 14643-14649 Third Reading 14728 Government Departments and Agencies Annual Environmental Performance Reporting 12036 Recycled Products - Purchase 11887 Waste Disposal Policy 6098; Targets for Waste Reduction and Recycling 12040 Government Vehicles - Liquid Petroleum Gas Powered - Conversion Policy 12162 Greens (WA) - Protest in Federal Parliament - Statement 12673 Health Autism - Statistical Occurrences 10801 Chemical Fires - Emergency Response Plan 11040 Chiropractors - Workers Compensation 12966 Dental - City of Cockburn 10797 Domestic Fires - Burning of Painted Wood 10801 Medicines and Vaccines - Dispensing Via Genetically Modified Foods 1006 Mustac, Dr - Medical Assessment Panel 14711 Organ Donation - Pre-transplant Testing 14049 Thimerosol - Use as a Preservative in Vaccines 10801 Health Act 1911 - Amendments - Amending Legislation 9562 HMAS Orion - Dive Site - Location 3288 Housing - Hilton - Redevelopment 13144 Industrial Development BP Kwinana Refinery - Diesel Fuel Leak 12037 Brickworks Industry - Monitoring of Stack Emissions 737 Cockburn Cement Ltd Air Quality Monitoring Stations 2601, 4050, 13471 Community Consultative Committee 13066 Department of Environmental Protection Licences 162 Environmental Audit and Revie w 7, 737 Licence Non-compliance 4901 Sulfur Dioxide Emissions 9583 Environmental Approval of Projects - Post-approval Monitoring 11889 Industry Assistance - Grant and Subsidy Programs and Loan Assistance 2511, 2649 Jervoise Bay Development Dolphin Population 3024 Heavy Fabrication Facility 1417, 3065, 4964; Adjournment Debate 1673 Kwinana Air Quality Buffer - Review 1738 Cumulative Risk Study 1136, 2872; Adjournment Debate 3632 Emission Scrubbing Devices - Bypass Incidents 1744 Project Development Proposals - EPA Approval 5818 Iraqi War Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 2859, 3011 Effect on Iraqi People - Adjournment Debate 5215 Justification - Adjournment Debate 5436 Student Rally - Adjournment Debate 5031 Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 2002 - Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to the Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Motion 855 Kelly, Hon Garry Kenneth - Condolence Motion 29 Kwinana International Motorplex - Impact of Noise on Residents 14770 Live Sheep Export Ban on Export of Ewes 10090 Cormo Express 11175 James Point Facility 2763 Market, Cultural and Religious Factors 12666 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 511

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Live Sheep Export (continued) Petition 12634 Replacement with New Processed Meat Markets 11890 Sabotage of Feed 13593 Local Government Belmont, City of Chief Executive Officer - Resignation 12267 Inquiry 9553, 10920; Statements 8569, 9557, 11048, 12566 Legal Work 11363 Lots 5 and 49 Great Eastern Highway, Belmont 7176 Bus Stop Infrastructure - Grants 14209 Chief Executive Officers - Use of Discretionary Accounts 4256 Melville, City of - Reduction in Councillor Numbers 349 Rockingham City Council Height Restriction Policy 4200 Ramada Development 4200 Save Our Suburbs Advertisements - Use of Discretionary Accounts 4256 South Perth, City of - Inquiry - Statement by Minister for Local Government and Regional Development 13587 Stirling, City of Domestic Waste Contract 9848 Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme 9625 Waste Diverted to Atlas Calingiri Farm 13120 Waste Management System 12003 Western Australian Local Government Superannuation Plan - Cedar Property Group 593 Mining Beenup Mineral Sands Mine - Acid Sulfate Ground Water Plume 735 Greenfields Mineral Exploration Inquiry - Advertising Costs 2153 Jangardup Mineral Sands Mine 735, 736, 739, 1042, 1560, 2156 Tuart Trees South of Mandurah - Decline and Death - Impact of Bauxite Mining 13915 Ministers of the Crown Minister for Planning and Infrastructure - Power to Direct WA Planning Commission 11478 Statutory Obligations - Power of Minister to Direct 11478 Motor Vehicles LPG Conversion Policy 12162 Smoky Vehicle Reporting Program 11889 Ningaloo Reef - Rally - Adjournment Debate 3768 Northbridge Tunnel - Air Quality Monitoring 5679 Nuclear Accidents - Response Measures 4397, 4526 Occupational Safety and Health Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4535 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10106 Parks and Reserves Beeliar Regional Park - Management Plan 11888 D’Entrecasteaux National Park - Waste Water Discharge from Lactanz Dairy Farm 4057 Tuart Forest National Park - Management Plan 4364 Planning Ascot Waters Development, Belmont 11836, 14048 Beaches - South Metropolitan Area - Impact of Population Growth 3470 Clontarf Hill - Transfer of Management to City of Fremantle 10814 Commission - Membership 7461 Egerton Estate, Ellenbrook - Boundary Extension 1966 Fremantle-Rockingham Controlled Access Highway - Beeliar Regional Park Cockburn 42 Heathcote Site Advice to Government 2152 Lower Parkland - Rezoning 6325 Lot 502 Sudlow and Phoenix Roads, Bibra Lake - Subdivision 2910 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments No 1019/33 - Townsites in Stoneville and Parkerville - Disallowance 5790, 5800 No 1020/33 - Egerton Estate, Ellenbrook 553 No 1028/33 - South East Districts Omnibus (No 5) - Disallowance 4458,4467 Opposition 6325 512 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Planning (continued) Mindarie Marina - Zoning 2249 Port Catherine Project 2153, 8396, 12039 Public Open Space - New Residential Developments 1169 Pyrton Site Development Proposals 8363 Management 9624 Railway Reserves - Reclassification under MRS 5969 Rockingham Foreshore - Height Restrictions on Buildings 863 South Beach Urban Development, Cockburn/Fremantle Buffer Zone 12046 Landfill 8576 Methane Gas Trap 9622 Petition 11960 Planning Commission Approval 8413 Remediation of Off-site Contamination 9625 Site Remediation and Validation Report 8425, 13366 South West Metropolitan Corridor - Recreational Needs 7458 Stakehill Rural Landowners Group - Land in Baldivis 10247 WA Planning Commission - Power of Minister to Direct 11478 Wattleup - Reduction of Population 10939 Wireless Hill Park Land Excision 10363; Petition 9926, 10055, 10327 Woodman Point-South Fremantle Coastline - Zoning 3633 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 257, 361-363, 366, 371, 372, 470 Pollution Air Perth Air Quality Management Plan - Development 11887 Wood Smoke Problems 11887 Amcor Contaminated Site Bibra Lake 1951, 3338 Brickwords Industry - Monitoring of Stack Emissions 737 Chemical Storage Facilities High Risk - Completion of Inspections 2156 Contaminated Sites - Proposed Legislation 1746 Domestic Smoke - Amending Legislation 9562 Omex Site - Remediation Costs 3176, 5819 Port Coogee - Remediation of Contamination 9080 Two Rocks Marina - Fuel Contamination 3437 Wesfarmers CSBP Ltd - Ashfield Site - Pollution Abatement Notice 6082 Port Kennedy Development Project Agreement Act - Tabling of Variations 1968 Costs 1966 Deed of Covenant 4341 Environmental Impact 1842 Facilities Consultation and Residential Housing 6329 Funding and Public Consultation 2151 Ownership of Freehold Lots 1968 Priority Public Works 9560 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 Second Reading 1032, 1264, 5045 Committee 5065, 5070, 5071, 5204 Assembly’s Message 5917; Progress 5919 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 Second Reading 7272 Committee 7277, 7279, 7284-7286 Questions without Notice - Answers 4026 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8540 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8540 Committee 8652-8670 Recommittal 8681 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8540 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 513

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 8540 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 2504, 2633 Second Reading 3297 Committee 3319, 3320, 3322, 3324, 3326 Railways Perth Urban Rail Development - Tabling of Questions and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment to Motion 5951 Reserves - Reclassification under MRS 5969 Southern Rail Link - Stakehill Rural Landowners Group - Land in Baldivis 10247 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Second Reading 7972 Committee 7979, 7980, 7985 Assembly’s Message 8371-8391 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 9171; Amendment to Motion 9182 Roads Causeway - Vehicle Numbers 2913 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Adjournment Debate 5324 Sale of Land 10114 Select Committee - Motion 1634, 1920; Amendment to Motion 2218 Urgency Motion 4893 Value of Highway Reserve 12044 Fremantle-Rockingham Controlled Access Highway - Beeliar Regional Park Cockburn 42, 10748 Funding - Condemnation of Government - Motion 9349 Garratt Road Bridge - Vehicle Numbers 10939 Great Eastern Highway, Ascot - Traffic Volume 13483 High Street, Fremantle - Road Reserve 2229 High Street-Stirling Highway, Fremantle - Turning Lanes 10938 Mitchell Freeway - Exit to Riverside Drive - Closure 14211 Narrows Bridge - Vehicle Numbers 14046 Northbridge Tunnel 2913, 10154 Orrong Road - Traffic Volume 4358 Regional Road Groups - Funding - Urgency Motion 5402 Riverside Drive - Ve hicle Numbers 2913 Roe Highway Extension - Route 12275 Stage 7 - Local Impact Committee 4365 Stage 8 - Route 12041 Shepperton Road Causeway, Victoria Park - Vehicle Numbers 8413 South Street, Melville-Fremantle - Coordinated Traffic Lights 10939 Wellington Street - Vehicle Numbers 2913 William Street - Reduction in Lanes 14211 Salinity - Methods to Reduce Escalating Problems - Motion 13461 Schools Coolbellup - Closure of Primary Schools 10797 Wattleup Primary - Student Numbers 10798 Select Committee into the Fremantle Eastern Bypass Motion 1634, 1920 Amendment to Motion 2218 Select Committee into Water Services - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 6453 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5286-5299, 5638 Sessional Orders - Continuation and Amendment Motion 14845 Sewerage Canning River - Leakage 12037 Infill Sewerage Program - Prosecutions for Failure to Connect 11614 Sittings of the House - Extended after 6.00 pm - Amendment to Motion 2755 Speakers’ Steps - Forrest Place - Police Activity 5023 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel - Motion 4493 514 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs (continued) Petition Opposing the Gnarabup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Third Report 4316 Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 2328 Sewage Pumping Station, Busselton - Petition - Fourth Report 5001 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 6270 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73- Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3999 Standing Orders - No 230 - Amendment - Motion 14700 State Finance - Financial Assistance or Incentives to Companies 3066 Swan River Fish Deaths - Autopsy and Chemical Analysis Report 13358 Licences to Discharge Waste 13024 Water Quality Investigation - Elevated Levels of Contaminants 10800 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 13433 Committee 13443, 13445, 13446, 13475, 13560, 13561, 13571, 13573 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Adjournment Debate - Cumulative Risk Study 3632 Transfer of Land Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 5419 Transport Bicycles - Medical Exemptions for the Wearing of Helmets 2153 Buses Gas Fuelled and Fuel Cell Trials 6464 Local Government Grants for Bus Stop Infrastructure 14209 Cyclists - Number and Accidents 2250 Department 1995 Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 1170 Winzer, Mr Neil - Public Interest Claim 14636 Driver Fatigue - Review of Regulations and Codes 12556 Livestock - Fatigue Management Regulations 11603 TravelSmart Budget Allocation 5970 Extension to New Metropolitan Areas 9563 Funding and Operation 2249 Two Rocks - Marina - Fuel Contamination 3437 United States of America Bush, President - Senators Brown and Nettles - Behaviour - Statement 12673 Support for Military - Urgency Motion 1410 Warships - Cost of Police Protection 5969 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2625 Waste Disposal Atlas Waste City of Stirling 9848, 13120 Noranda - Planning Permission for Digester 8676, 11182 Weighbridge Dockets for Waste Delivery to Tamala Park Landfill 734, 1738 Weight of Water and Contaminants 1563 Barrow Island - Incinerator 9359 Brookdale Community Reference Group - Membership 9023 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility Conflict of Interest - Department of Environmental Protection 5219 Fugitive Emissions 6279 Grease Trap Waste 9059 Inventory and Site Inspection Report 9987 Records of Toxic Materials 5049 Reviews 5535 Waste Taken Without Approvals and Closure 5315, 6605 Cardup Shale Road Landfill Tip 10795, 10796 Cleanaway Technical Services - Brookdale Facility 5196 Compost Trials - South Metropolitan Regional Council 8428 Discharge into Marine Environment 6460, 7018, 13024 Global Olivine Waste-to-energy Plant, Kwinana - Joint Venture 734 Government Departments and Agencies - Targets for Waste Reduction and Recycling 12040 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 515

SCOTT, HON JAMES ALAN (continued) Waste Disposal (continued) Government Policy 6098 Hazardous Waste Solutions Site, Bellevue - Environmental Audit and Review 737 Henderson Landfill Facility - Ground Water Monitoring and Landfill Liner 13358 Marine Environment - Licences to Discharge Waste 10798 Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme 6301; Report No 7 - Tabling 7848 Shale Road Class 3 Landfill Cardup - Licence Conditions 1847 Stephenson and Ward Biomedical Incinerator - Emission Scrubbing Devices - Bypass Incidents 1846 Stirling, City of - Waste Management System 12003 Thomas Road Waste Mound - Expansion 3289 Total Waste Management Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Evaporation Ponds 7823 Tox Free Solutions - Waste Processor at Kwinana 246, 13348 Truck Tyres - Reuse as Lawn Top Dressing 1274 Waste Management and Recycling Fund - Review 8427 Waste Management Authority - Establishment 8429 Waste-to-Landfill Levy - Review 8428 Waste Tyres - Disposal and Recycling 5679 Waste Management Bill - Introduction 2159 Water Resources Canning River - Sewage Leakage 12037 Ground Water 900 Rockingham Road, Henderson 12431 Hydrocrabon Contamination 1848 Lefroy Brook - Contamination Prevention 5774 Marine Environment - Licences to Discharge Waste 10798 Murray and Serpentine Rivers - Water Quality 9057 Samson Brook Dam - Expansion 13915 Select Committee - Establishment - Amendment to Motion 6453 Yarragadee Aquifer - Extraction Rate 10798-10800, 12162 Western Australian Local Government Superannuation Plan - Investment in Cedar Property Group 593 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13881 Western Power - Emergency Line - Inquiries - Time Limit to Respond 14668 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7491 Workers Compensation Chiropractic Profession 12966 WorkCover WA - Review of Legislation - Motion 12132 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation (Acts of Terrorism) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3047 WorkSafe Western Australia - Driver Fatigue Regulations and Codes - Review 12556

SHARP, HON CHRISTINE, BA (Hons), MA, PhD (South West) (GWA) Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5783 Committee 5930-5933, 6044-6050 Assembly’s Message 12393, 12394 Address-in-Reply Motion - Issues Confronting the South West 715 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 3864, 3875 Agriculture Department - Staff Appointments of Level 5 and Above 1739 Genetically Modified Canola - Trials 12140, 12960 Genetically Modified Crops - Gene Technology Legislation - Adjournment Debate 1836 Ord River Stage 2 - Interim Joint Proponents 3288 Alcoa World Alumina Australia Wagerup Alumina Refinery - Licence Conditions 12558 Water Allocation at Wagerup and Pinjarra Refineries 12434 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Committee 9535 Beck, Mr Tinsley Manning - Petition for Relief - Motion 4955, 4965 Business of the House - Order of Business 6414 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 9821, 9930 516 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SHARP, HON CHRISTINE (continued) Cannabis Control Bill 2003 (continued) Committee 10069, 10071, 10740-10745, 10752-10770, 10883-10900 Third Reading 11332 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5783 Colleges of TAFE Performance Delivery Agreements - Tabling 592 Student-Teacher Ratios 592 Conservation and Land Management Act - Amendment - Ecologically Sustainable Forest Management 1801 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3466, 3604 Committee 3607, 3620-3627, 3726, 3734-3744 Conservation and Land Management, Department of Budget for Containment of Introduced Species 4048 Prescribed Burning Program 7204, 9619, 10813 Drugs Cannabis - Changes to Legislation 1167 Drug and Alcohol Strategy - Urgency Motion 233 East Perth Power Station Site - Future Use 1167 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision - Urgency Motion 1800, 1808 Environment Environmental Education Discussion Paper - Cabinet Endorsement 4239 Flora and Fauna - Rare and Presumed Extinct - South West 11890 Introduced Species - Budget for Containment 4048 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4912 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 6415 Second Reading 4923 Committee 10134-10141, 10207-10225, 10329-10360, 11142-11159, 11196-11204, 11212-11235, 11320-11329 Third Reading 11568 Clearing Regulations 6583, 7311, 14615 Environmental Protection Authority - Consultants - Number and Cost 3440 Food Irradiation - Regulatory Controls 9555 Forests and Forestry Alco, Yornup and Thornton Forest Blocks - Post-logging Audit 13008, 14620 Australian Forestry Standard - Certification 2761 Butler Forest, Nannup - Hot Regeneration Burn - Monitoring 4049 Craft Wood Licensing System 1954 Draft Forest Management Plan 351, 1008, 1801 Farm Forestry Training - Departmental Responsibility and Fees 1450 Forest Management Plans - Area for Logging 12571 Forest Products Commission Sale of Marri Woodchips to Overseas Companies 9654 Sawlogs from Mine Sites 4958, 5776, 5956 State Native Forest - Claiming as an Asset 9203 Greenbushes Timber Mill - Conditions on Allocation of Resources 1840, 9055 Jarrah and Karri Logging Statistics 2902, 8413 Sawlog Volumes 11182, 12906 Jarrah, Karri and Wandoo Production Forest 1561, 1562 Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736 - Motion for Disallowance 14023 Log Prices - Review 1533 Logging Area and Volume 1560, 9619 Meetings with Former Burke Government Ministers 6958, 7175, 8418, 9203 Recording in Forest Product Commission’s Accounts 5025 Timber Residue - Access for Craft Wood Industry 7323 Logging Buffers Review - List of References 3473 Ludlow Tuart Forest - Mining 10746, 12668, 14715 Marri Clear-felling and Gap Creation 2228, 3473 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 517

SHARP, HON CHRISTINE (continued) Forests and Forestry (continued) Marri (continued) Woodchips 7323, 9358 Nannup Timber Mill - Conditions on Allocation of Resources 1840, 9055 Native Forest and Plantation Stumpages 11206 Old-growth Forest - Social and Economic Impact of Policy - Urgency Motion 542 Pentarch Forest Products Pty Ltd - Stumpage Rates and Log Specifications 5662 Pine Plantations - Resource Plans - Statement by Minister for Agriculture 12660 Regional Forest Agreement - Mapping - Old-growth Area and Logging 12155 Richardson, Mr Trevor - Native Forest Log Sales Contracts 8676, 9628 Sawlogs from Mine Sites 6286, 6287 Sawmills - Registration - Number and Type 3772 South West Area Burnt in Wildfires 13023 Sawmills - Resource Security Commitment 14776 Timber Contracts - Financial Security Beyond the Forest Management Plan 13860, 14198 Warren Forest Region - Logging Roads 8413 Wespine Industries Pty Ltd - Pine Sawlogs 6282 Wood Processing (WESFI) Agreement Act 2000 - Schedule H 3028 Fuel and Energy - Reduction Targets 10366 Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 50 Gene Technology Bill 2001 - Referral to Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs 50 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14599 Committee 14633, 14643-14649 Third Reading 14727 Government Departments and Agencies - Energy Reduction Targets 10366 Heavy Haulage Transport Units - Enforcement of Road Detours 10250 Iraq War Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3424 Opposition - Adjournment Debate 5675 Land Clearing Regulations 6583, 7311 Road Verge Vegetation 3336 Satellite Imagery 8364 Statistics 8688 Legislative Council - Temporary Chamber - Statement 7836 Lobbyists - Former Burke Government Ministers - Meetings on Logging 6958, 7175, 9203 Mining Jangardup Mineral Sands Mine - Environmental Impact 14641 Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining 10746, 12668, 12669, 14715 Sawlogs from Mine Sites - Forest Products Commission Role 4958 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 1236 Parks and Reserves Cape Arid National Park - Fires 3339 Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736 - Motion for Disallowance 14023 Parliament House - Security Upgrade - Statement 10255 Planning Margaret River - WA Planning Commission’s Inquiry by Design 36 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment No 992/33 - Clarkson-Butler - Disallowance 14822 Peel Region Scheme Adjournment Debate 5558 Disallowance 5537 Riverslea Gardens, Margaret River - Subdivision Approval 3292 Sussex Locations 2143, 2144, 2149, 2150, 2153, and Lots 14 and 15 Margaret River - Rezoning 3177 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2245 Premier - Visit to Japan - Meeting with Marubeni Corporation 3868 Railways - Pine Sawlogs - Amount of Unused Resource 9627 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Second Reading 7976 Assembly’s Message 8386-8393 518 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SHARP, HON CHRISTINE (continued) Road Verge Vegetation Clearing for Roadworks 3336, 8412 Schools Expenditure 592 Newton Moore High - Aboriginal Children - Retention Program 3610 September 11, 2001 - Adjournment Debate 732 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 Extension of Time 9011 Proposal to Travel - Report 4011 Petition Opposing the Gnarabup Waste Water Treatment Plant - Third Report 1792, 4003 Petition Presented by Mr Barry Granville Waller Seventh Report 8756, 9550, 10076 Special Report 3991 Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 1521 Sewage Pumping Station in Heseltine Park, Glenlea Road, Busselton - Petition - Fourth Report 5004 Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 5005, 6265-6271 Training Farm Forestry Training 1450 Industry Training Advisory Bodies - Funding 2127 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5783 Walpole Waste Water Treatment Plant - Audit Report 10811 Waste Management and Recycling Fund - Expenditure 247 Water Resources Alcoa, Wagerup and Pinjarra Refineries 12434 Harris River Dam - Allocation of Water 734 Stream and River Logging Buffers - Review 3473 Yarragadee Aquifer - Extraction Rate 10922, 12044 Wedge-tailed Eagles - Number 9026 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14002 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12231 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 3159 Second Reading 3159, 7497, 7805 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1546 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7428

SPEAKER OF THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY (Hon Fredrick Riebeling) Adams, Ms Brenda - Condolences to Member for Avon 8436 Address-in-Reply - Presentation to Governor 4110 Adjournment of the House Complimentary Remarks 4153, 9466, 14305 Special 14916 Australian Senate - Expiry of Notice of Motion - Statement 13203 Bali Bombings Anniversary - Personal Explanation - Ruling 11894; Statement 11892 Statement 1747 Victims Condolence Book - Statement 2930 Business of the House - Notices of Motion - Removal from Notice Paper Statements 5560, 8163, 8278, 8692, 8874, 8931, 11114, 11499, 12047, 12742, 13816 Committees of the House - Confidentiality - Statement 1714 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Annual Report 2002-03 - Corrections - Statement 12864 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Ruling 14896 Divisions - Privacy of Documents - Statement 6493 Eastern Goldfields Regional Prison - Tabling of Report 608 Economics and Industry Standing Committee - Report on Sustainability of the Dairy Industry in WA Statements 11114, 14886 Governor’s Speech - Distribution of Copies 16 Health Mental Health System - Funding - Petition - Statement 12047 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” - Amendment to Motion - Ruling 1313 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 519

SPEAKER OF THE LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY (continued) Justice, Department of - Annual Report - Correction - Statement 3355 Legislative Assembly Acting Speakers - Appointment 19; Statement 1714 Conscience or Free Votes - Recording of Pairs in Hansard - Statement 12742 Daily Business Program on the Internet - Statement 5079 Laptops - Volume - Statement 2518 Record-keeping Plan - Statement 2171 Speaker - Entrance into Chamber - Statement 11531 Unparliamentary Use of the Word “Corrupt” - Statement 11778 Matter of Privilege - Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal - Statement 12705, 12804. 13202 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Statement 10817 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion - Ruling 4870 Member for Warren-Blackwood - Suspension from the House 211, 6341 Parliamentary Privilege - Statement 5082 Private Documents on Desks in the Chamber - Statement 14286 Standards of Behaviour - Statement 9426 Ministers of the Crown Minister for Housing and Works - Allegations of Ministerial Impropriety - Standing Orders Suspension - Ruling 9214 Statements - Time Allotted 11619 Parliament - Premises Rented or Leased 6041 Parliament House - Allocation of Smoking Room 12909 Petition - Ruling 8691 Public Accounts Committee - Statements 2653, 12166 Questions on Notice - Answers - Statement 11375 Racing, Gaming and Liquor, Department of - Report - Correction 14915 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments - Ruling 3678 Rulings Bali Bombings - Anniversary 11894 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 14896 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4870 Matter of Privilege - Public Accounts Committee - Information Divulged - 1178 Minister for Housing and Works - Allegations of Ministerial Impropriety - Standing Orders Suspension 9214 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” - Amendment to Motion 1313 Petition 8691 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 3678 Standing Order No 279 14217 Swan River - Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion 8807 September 11, 2001 - Statements 744, 11077 Sittings of the House - Days and Hours 19 Standing Orders No 279 - Ruling 14217 Procedure and Privileges Committee Report on Minor Amendments - Statement 66 State Budget - Presentation - Statement 7034 Suspension of Member for Warren-Blackwood 211, 6341 Swan River - Matter of Public Interest - Amendment to Motion - Ruling 8807 Tabled Paper 1450 - Error - Statement 11629 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7514 United States of America - Anniversary of Terrorist Attack - Statement 11077 Water Resources - Management - Expiry of Notice of Motion - Statement 13368 Wheeler, Ms Kylie - Statement 596 Workers’ Compensation and Rehabilitation Commission - Report - Correction 14915

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY, BA, JP, Minister for Housing and Works (to 27 June); Local Government and Regional Development; the Kimberley, Pilbara and Gascoyne; Heritage (from 27 June); Goldfields-Esperance (from 27 June) (Mining and Pastoral) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission Act - Rate Exemptions 13065 Aboriginal Cultural Materials Committee Chairperson - Conflict of Interest 13165 520 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Aborigines (continued) Aboriginal Cultural Materials Committee (continued) Portman Iron Ore Ltd - Koolyanobbing Mine Expansion 6604 Section 18 Applications 5665, 9649 Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council 3868 Bringing them Home Report - Implementation of Recommendations 9656 Conservation Reserves - Transferring of Ownership 13349 Dampier Public Wharf - Engravings 10262 Electricity Supply Cost - Remote Communities 8422 Government Programs 7654, 8402 Heritage Issues - Aboriginal Heritage Sites 9552 Mt Henry Bridge - Aboriginal Site Clearance 9651 North West - Programs 8401 Reserve 24574 - Drilling Activity 10381 Rock Art - Burrup Peninsula - Assessment of Impact of Emissions 7014 Roebourne - Neglected Children 4452 Sites of Significance Assessment and Deletion from Register 11832 Heritage of WA Act 12146, 12965 Protection 12006 Southern Rail Link - Heritage Sites 11054 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Number at Henley Brook Camp 9024 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14788, 14791, 14792 Agriculture Environmental Protection Act Draft Regulations - Consultation 11838 Lactanz Dairy Farm - Waste Water Discharge into D’Entrecasteaux National Park 4057 Livestock Transport - Fatigue Management Regulations 11603 Roundup - Environmental Guidelines for Use 10814 Albany Cemetery - Funeral Services 11057 Alcoa World Alumina Australia Wagerup Alumina Refinery 7479, 12558, 12924 Waste Oil as a Dust Suppressant - 5959 Water Allocation at Wagerup and Pinjarra Refineries - 12434 Amity House, Albany - Funding - Petition 8525 Animal Welfare Dogs - Docking of Tails 2479; Statement 2851 Inspectors - Appointment 6299, 6460 Local Government Laws Controlling the Welfare of Cats 6467 Unit - Membership 7012 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Second Reading 2773 Committee 2774, 2775, 2876-2889 Third Reading 2890 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 4) 2002 - Second Reading 6262 Articled Clerks - Employment 13591 Australian Labor Party State Conference Energy Platform 12026 Western Australian Aboriginal Native Title Working Group - Attendance 43, 164 Australian Wildlife Conservancy Ningaloo Development - Briefing 5814, 5971, 5972 Wilson, Dr Barry Conflict of Interest 1002, 1257, 1657, 3433, 3434, 3440, 4198 Directorship 350, 462 Baudin, Commander Nicolas - Bicentenary of Expedition to Australia - Statement by Hon Barry House 11368 Baxter, Hon Norman Eric - Condolence Motion 13315 Building Industry BGC Construction - Government Contracts 7645 Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Numb er and Value of Contracts Awarded Advice 7642 Consultation 6956, 7165, 9193 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 521

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Building Industry (continued) Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded (continued) Exemptions 7825 Letter to Director General of Department of Housing and Works 6953 Newspaper Report 7826 Premier’s Directive 7822 Statement 6944, 9315 Urgency Motion 7296, 7318 Industry Construction Panel - Nominations, Selection and Remuneration 2651 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 - Third Reading 13431 Business of the House - Order of Business - Motion 6242 Canning River - Licences to Discharge Waste 13024 Cockburn Sound Draft Environmental Protection Policy - Implementation 6465 Environmental Protection Policy - Completion 6123 Management Council - Establishment 6464 Conservation and Land Management Act - Amendment - Ecologically Sustainable Forest Management Provisions 1801 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3606 Committee 3607, 3622-3627, 3742-3744 Third Reading 3745 Conservation and Land Management, Department of Budget for Containment of Introduced Species 4048 Kimberley - Charter Flights 9373 Prescribed Burning Program 3615, 7204, 9619, 10813, 14641 Prosecution of Landholders - Cost 14774 Whales and Marine Mammals - Fee for Films and Photographs 2605, 3474 Yandle, Mr Alan - Sea Groatt Reserve 12146, 12438 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Committee 11584-11586, 12386-12392 Third Reading 12511 Convention and Exhibition Centre - Completion Date 6298, 6304 Coral Bay - Coral Coast Marina Development Pty Ltd Carew-Hopkins, Mr Derek 3726, 4023, 4198 Minister’s Appeal 3284 Viability 4024 Debits Tax Assessment Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 3760 Second Reading 3760 Debits Tax Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 3760 Second Reading 3760 Electoral - One Vote, One Value - Mid West 1807 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 First Reading 13844 Second Reading 13844 Cognate Debate 14649 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14811 As to Committee 14820 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 First Reading 13851 Second Reading 13851 Cognate Debate 14649 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14811 Order of the Day 14820 Committee 14832-14835 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 First Reading 13846 Second Reading 13846 Cognate Debate 14649 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14811 522 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 (continued) As to Committee 14820 Environment Acid Sulfate Soil 1560, 4056 Ascot Waters Development, Belmont 11836, 11839, 14048 Barrow Island ChevronTexaco - Breach of DEP Licence Conditions 14042 Demolition Work - Waste Disposal 12016 Fauna Road Kills 9626 BHPB Briquette Shiploader - Boodarrie Iron HBI/DRI Plant - Notification of Incident 4433 Bio-Gene Bioprospecting Ltd - Agreement with CALM 14211 Blair Fox Generation WA Pty Ltd - Poultry Litter-fired Electricity Plant, Muchea 4398 BP Kwinana Refinery 12037, 12145 Brickworks Emissions - Consultant’s Report 9630 Bringo Motocross Track - Relocation 1262 Burns Beach Property Trust - Appeal 1567 Burrup Peninsula - Archaeological and Ethnographic Surveys 7996 Chittering - Application for Planning Consent for Water Supply System 9635 Conservation Estate - Grazing Impacts 9845 Craft Wood - Exemption for Use of Trees from Private Properties 12008, 12291 Dampier Public Wharf Expansion - Impact 463 Environmental Education Discussion Paper - Cabinet Endorsement 4239 Environmental Enforcement Unit - Establishment 7006 Environmental Protection Act Clearing Permits - Regulations 13145 Draft Regulations 11838 Environmental Protection Policies - Completion 2779 Environmental Recovery Services Ltd - Inventory of Chemicals 3337 Firewood Draft Regulations 11211 South West 10382, 10923 Supplies and Collection 10806 Flora and Fauna - Rare and Presumed Extinct - South West 11890 Four-wheel-drive Vehicles - Advertising Depicting Damage to Environment 1140, 1848 Gnangara Land Use and Water Management Strategy - Draft Environmental Protection Policy 1742 Gnangara Mound - Threatened Species 1845, 6302 Gnangara Park Management Plan - Finalisation 1743 Goats - Feral - Damage to Conservation Estate 12016 Government Departments and Agencies - Annual Environmental Performance Reporting 12036 Green Stamp Program - Accreditation 2913 Greenhouse Gas Emissions Kyoto Protocol 1134, 1261 Reduction 12042 State Strategy - Completion 11374 “Western Australia and Greenhouse” Issues Paper 4450, 4942 Heinrich, Mr and Mrs - Compensation for Loss of Earnings 14030, 14639 Industrial Projects - Post-approval Monitoring 11889 Introduced Species - Budget for Containment 4048 James Point Live Sheep Export Facility - Odour Modelling 2763 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Community and Industry Reference Committee 10258, 11373 Kalgoorlie Cement Works Acoustic Consultant and Stormwater Run-off 7837 Compliance with Departmental Instruction 7507 Dust Complaints 5970, 9652 Letter from Acting Minister for the Environment and Heritage 9646 Licensing under the Environmental Protection Act 9632 Noise Levels 469, 5676, 7003, 9649 Non-compliance with Department of Environmental Protection Orders 5678 Soil Contamination and Toxic Dust 13015 Vexatious Complaints 7653 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 523

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Environment (continued) Kalgoorlie Cement Works (continued) Video of Worker Spraying a Diesel-engine Oil Aerosol Solution 4903 Website - Investigations 5677 Kwinana - Emission Scrubbing Devices - Bypass Incidents 1744 Kwinana International Motorplex - Impact of Noise on Hope Valley Residents 14770 Mallee Seed 14031, 14196 Mid West and Murchison Rangelands - Management 4943 Midland Railway Workshop Site - Soil Stockpiles and Air Monitoring 2483, 3903, 7008 Mt Gibson Station - Field Report on Endangered Flora 11879 Narembeen Deep Drainage Project - Impact on Wetland Reserves 551, 1741 Nelson Locations 12889 and 12890 - Forest Conservation Area 9844 Plastic Bags - Levy 1804, 3335 Regional Herbarium Project - Funding 4431, 6084 Ship-blasting Abrasive High Pressure - Environmental Impact 1842 Smoky Vehicle Reporting Program 11889 South Beach Urban Redevelopment, South Fremantle 735, 7009, 7010, 12313 Swan Coastal Plain Lakes Environmental Protection Policy - Completion 11886 Thomsons Lake and Lake Kogolup - Swans 12040 Waste Discharge into Marine Environment 6460, 13024 Wetlands Nominations under Ramsar Convention 12036 Protection - Funding 9637 Whitlock Creek - Dredge Spoil 12038 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4910 Second Reading 5019, 5027 Committee 10128-10141, 10210-10225,10330-10360,11142-11159, 11196-11204, 11213-11233, 11321-11330 Third Reading 11566, 11578 Clearing Regulations 7311 Environmental Protection Authority Consultants - Number and Cost 3440 Formal Assessment Process 8420 LeProvost, Mr Ian - Conflict of Interest 1271 Project Development Proposals - Assessment and Approval 5818, 7848 Regulations - Draft Exemptions 14195 Reports - Use of Appeal Committees in Appeals 13913 Environmental Protection, Department of Air Quality Branch - Senior Staff Resignations 2511 Cockburn Cement Ltd - Review of Audit Findings 737 Code of Conduct and Public Sector Code of Ethics 7992 Industrial Pollution Monitoring - Budget 10805 Kalgoorlie Regional Office 8782, 9653 Keating, Ms Fiona - Employment Details 14192 Mistakes 7003 Waste Control Fire, Bellevue - Review of Audit Findings 737 Water and Catchment Protection - Records of Decisions and Actions 9062 Equal Opportunity Commission - Gay and Lesbian Liaison Officers - Appointment 13595 Estimates Committees - Correction to Answer - Water and Rivers Commission 9027 Fines, Penalties and Infringement Notices Enforcement Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6258 Fire and Emergency Services Backpacker Hostels - Fire Safety 1260 Communications Systems 12433 Prescribed Burning - Target 14641 Fisheries Kimberley Prawn Farm 1531, 1806 Whales and Marine Mammals - Fee for Films and Photographs 2605, 3474 Forests and Forestry Alco, Yornup and Thornton Forest Blocks - Post-logging Audit 14620 Butler Forest, Nannup - Hot Regeneration Burn - Monitoring 4049 Draft Forest Management Plan - Amendments to Conservation and Land Management Act 1801 524 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Forests and Forestry (continued) Forest Management Plans - Area for Logging 12571 Gnangara Pine Plantation - Logging 4448, 4991 Jarrah, Karri and Wandoo Production Forest 1561, 1562 Logging Buffers Review - List of References 3473 Meetings with Former Burke Government Ministers 8418 Ludlow Tuart Forest 3475, 5076, 10746 Marri - Clear-felling and Gap Creation 3473 Nelson Locations 12889 and 12890 - Forest Conservation Area 9844 Regional Forest Agreement - Mapping - Old-growth Area and Logging 12155 Sawlogs from Mine Sites - Volume 6287 South West - Area Burnt in Wildfires 13023 State Forest No 56 - Partial Revocation - Assembly’s Resolution - Motion to Concur 13029 Timber Fellers - Wildlife Conservation Act, Section 23D Exemptions 12925 Tuart Trees South of Mandurah - Decline and Death - Impact of Bauxite Mining 13915 Fremantle Cemetery - Transfer of Management Savings 8366 Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance Inquiry - Motion 10916; Motion, as Amended 11339 Fuel and Energy Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline - Management and Maintenance 9373 Electricity Aboriginal Communities 8422 Cost of Generation 13861, 13866 Country Power Supplies 4960 Gnowangerup, Jerramungup and Ravensthorpe Area 12923 Reform - Implementation 5019 Report on Options for Development in Western Australia 1662, 2482, 2511 Personal Explanation 2485 South West Interconnected System 13347 Tabling of Frontier Economics Pty Ltd Study 8567 Field Use and Unaccounted for Gas - Emissions 12952 Kwinana Power Station - Picket Line 13065 Mains Power Cable - Cost to Reconnect when Broken by a Storm 4939 Mumbida Wind Farm Proposal - Request to Proceed 11372 Narrogin Integrated Wood Processing Plant 14712 Oil and Gas Resources - Future Use 1660 Petrol - Legislative Requirements in WA 12035 Poultry Litter-fired Electricity Plant, Muchea 4398 Renewable Energy Access Regime - Introduction 9374, 13349 Renewable Energy in Rural Areas 712, 12042 Waste-to-energy Projects - Maddington 2765 Waterloo-Busselton Transmission Line - Route 1009 West Kimberley Power Project 14777 Wyndham - Power Failures 3286 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) (Reviews) Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 5205 Second Reading 5205 Government Contracts AOT Consulting Pty Ltd 12165 Cemetery Records System - Tender Details 13071 Panel Contracts - Number and Cost 13025, 13167-13169, 13363, 13891, 13892 Tender No 12603 - Stationery Contracts for Government Agencies - Two Per Cent Levy 14197 Government Departments and Agencies Aborigines - Programs 7654, 8401, 8402 Annual Environmental Performance Reporting 12036 Budget Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9985, 10260 Bunbury Tower 7308, 7473 Court Action or Litigation 7185, 7186, 7190, 7192, 12289 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 525

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Government Departments and Agencies (continued) Functional Review Taskforce Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 9984, 10260 Partnerships 9555 Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 11057, 11183, 11866, 11868, 11875-11877, 12014 Recycled Products - Purchase 11887 Register of Intellectual Property 6103, 6107-6110 Voluntary Severance Schemes 7308 Waste Disposal Policy 6098 Waste Reduction and Recycling - Targets 12040 Government Employees Housing Authority - Failure to Provide Housing in Regional Areas 554 Health Broometime Lodge - Cost 5660 Kimberley Dialysis Centre 5192 Heritage Duncraig House - Use 467 Fund and Register 11877 Legislation - Introduction 14840 Midland Inn 11172 Payment for Work Undertaken within Government Departments 4431 Places and Projects - Priorities 2762 Projects - New and Continuing - Funding 875 Rawlinna Precinct - Funding 12288 Shark Bay World Heritage Interpretive Centre - Delays 11052 WA Heritage Council - Development Applications - Negotiation and Approval 4432 Heritage of Western Australia Act 1990 Aboriginal Sites of Significance 12965 Review 738, 12146 Homeswest 28 and 30 Phoenix Place, Kalgoorlie - Completion 7476 6 Farr Avenue, North Perth - Renovation 2227 Bogle Way, Geraldton - Fence Height 5195 Brownlie Towers - Resolution of Issues 1422 Buckland Hill Properties - Undertaking to Purchase Properties 3338 Discrimination Complaints 866 Kalgoorlie - Antisocial Behaviour 5054, 7476 Kimberley Dialysis Centre - Location 5192 Manjimup - Low-income Families 2874 Plants - Type and Quantity 7475 Rental Stock and New Construction - Expenditure 5974 Seniors - Fire Alarms, Security Screens and External Lighting 5975 Solar Hot-water Heaters - Installation 6303 Transfer of Properties to Community Housing Providers 5975 Homosexuality Discrimination - Community Education 13473 Gay and Lesbian Liaison Officers at Equal Opportunity Commission - Appointment 13595 Lesbian and Gay Law Reform - Ministerial Committee 13473 Hospitals Derby Regional - Specialist Staff - Relocation to Broome District Hospital 35, 42 Geraldton Regional - Construction Contract 12433, 13474, 14197 Housing Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council 3868 Albion Town, Henley Brook - Development 5661 Backpacker Hostels - Fire Safety 1260 Doric Constructions Pty Ltd - Contract for Mindarie High School 159 Maniana - Aircraft Noise Restrictions 863 People Who Care - Government Suppport 1138 Public Housing in the Western Suburbs of Perth - Tabling of List 1662 Regional Areas - Government’s Failure to Provide 554 Swanbourne Senior High School Site - Public Housing 3613 Housing and Works, Department of Better Risk Management and Best Practice Contracting - Policy Framework 6944, 6953, 6956 526 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Housing and Works, Department of (continued) Broometime Lodge - Cost 5660 Chief Executive Officer - Salary Package 552 Construction Contracts Policy Advice 7642 Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded Consultation 6956, 7165, 9193 Exemptions 7825 Letter to Director General of Department of Housing and Works 6953 Newspaper Report 7826 Premier’s Directive 7822 Statement 6944, 9315 Urgency Motion 7296, 7318 Hamilton Hill Town House Construction - Eligibility to Tender 8368 Heritage Work - Payment 4431 Non-residential Building Budget - BGC Construction Contracts 7645 Pre-qualified Contractors 9195 Register of Intellectual Property Assets 4907 Warren-Blackwood Call Centre 3617 Industrial Development BHP Billiton - Port Hedland - Iron Ore Dust Contamination 14198 BP Kwinana Refinery - Diesel Fuel Leak 12037 Brickworks Industry - Monitoring of Stack Emissions 737 Burrup Peninsula Archaeological and Ethnographic Surveys 7996 Native Title Agreement 5771, 6304, 9585, 9846, 13124, 13141 Native Title Approvals 549, 9020 Rock Art - Monitoring Reference Committee 7014 Cockburn Cement Ltd Air Quality Monitoring Stations 2601, 4050, 13471 Breach of Licence Conditions 11882 Community Consultative Committee 13066 Department of Environmental Protection Licences 162 Environmental Audit and Review 7, 737 Licence Noncompliance 4901 Sulfur Dioxide Emissions 9583 Environmental Approval of Projects - Post-approval Monitoring 11889 Gorgon Project ChevronTexaco - Breach of DEP Licence Conditions 14042 Environmental Evaluation 13020 GTL Resources PLC - Methanol Proposal - Environmental Assessment 1271 Industry Construction Panel - Nominations, Selection and Remuneration 2651 Kwinana - Emission Scrubbing Devices - Bypass Incidents 1744 North West Shelf Project - China - LNG Contract - Motion 699, 714, 830 Project Development Proposals - EPA Approval 5818 Industrial Relations Doric Constructions Pty Ltd - Mr Kevin Reynolds 159 Kwinana Power Station - Picket Line 13591 Information Technology - Government Contracting and Purchasing - Compliance Reviews - Statement 1403 Iraq War - Opposition - Adjournment Debate 5670 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation - Powers of Entry and Powers to Make Local Laws that Affect Private Land under the Local Government Act 1995 - Seventh Report 11162 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Community and Industry Reference Group - Chairperson 10804 Land Clearing Block CG 3819, North of Old Plain Road 8417 Bush Rural Land 1801, 1949 Derby-West Kimberley Shire 10789 Liveringa Station, Camballin 11044 Regulations 7311 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 527

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Land (continued) Clearing (continued) Road Verge Vegetation 3336 Satellite Imagery 8364 Margaret River - Land Swap 1135 Land Tax - New Assessments 2483 Live Sheep Export - James Point Facility 2763 Local Government Act Definition of Emergency 7177 Review 13470 Amalgamations - Financial Assistance Grants 12437 Amendment Bill - Introduction 11602 Appeals - Delays 6606 Belmont, City of Authorised Person’s Report of Inquiry 10920 Chief Executive Officer - Resignation 12267 Inquiry 41, 553, 2762, 4257, 9553, 13474; Statement 6543 Investigation of Complaints 10750 Legal Work 11363 Busselton, Shire of - Legal Costs - Disputed Planning and Development Matters 9657 Chief Executive Officers - Use of Discretionary Accounts 4256 Derby-West Kimberley, Shire of - Permits to Clear or Maintain Road Verges 10789 East Pilbara, Shire of - Boundary Change 13467, 14801 Executive Officers - Guidelines for Employment 4534 Joondalup, City of Chief Executive - Qualifications 7478 Mayoral Chain 13594 Meeting - Police Presence 14194 Report of Governance 14193 Suspension 13858, 14718; Statement 14574 Kojonup, Shire of - Regional Investment Fund Applications 468 Laws Controlling the Welfare of Cats 6467 Melville, City of - Reduction in Councillor Numbers 349 New Nullarbor Shire - Establishment 11834 One Vote, One Value - Mid West 1807 Port Hedland, Town of - Boundary Change 13467, 14801 Rates - Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission Act 13065 Rating System and Distribution of Funds - Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Motion 11352, 11979; Amendment to Motion 11986 Regional Road Group Funding Grants 5660 Roebourne, Shire of - Correspondence from Mrs Weightman 11362 Save Our Suburbs Advertisements - Use of Discretionary Accounts 4256 South Perth, City of Council Elections 3733 Inquiry - Statement 2722 Stirling, City of Domestic Waste Contract 9848 Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme 9625 Waste Management System 12003 Unauthorised Demolition of Buildings - Upgrading of Powers 9633 Valuations - Removal of Subsidy 10251 Vincent Town Council - Inquiry 1806 Wanneroo, City of - Mayoral Chain 13594 Western Australian Local Government Superannuation Plan - Investment in Cedar Property Group 593 Westonia, Shire of - Yilgarn Location 162 - Sale - Councillors’ Disclosure of Interests 14028 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of Reserve 41812 - Lakeside Resort Development 13028 Town Reserves 740 Local Government Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 13988 528 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Local Government Amendment Bill 2003 (continued) Second Reading 13988 Drafting 2605 Personal Explanation 14034 Local Government (Official Conduct) Amendment Bill - Statement 14725 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 14152 Second Reading 14152 Maritime Museum Opening 3441, 3630 Mining Aboriginal Sacred Sites - Protection 12006 Beenup Mineral Sands Mine - Acid Sulfate Ground Water Plume 735 BGC (Australia) Ltd - Open-cut Mining at the Lakes - Impact on Water Resources 584 Bulong Nickel Mine - Tailings Dams 4053 Fimiston Site Contamination of Water 9077 Depth, Width and Length of Super Pit 6332 EPA Service Unit Investigation 10809, 10810 Licence Conditions 1269, 1270, 1556, 5021, 5819, 8780 Monitoring 1272 Works Approval 652 12955 Gidgi Site - Licence Conditions 1269, 1270, 1272, 1556 Jangardup Mineral Sands Mine Acid Sulfate Soil 1560 Audit Report 1042 Environmental Impact 14641 Flocculant Use 736, 739 Revegetation 735, 2156 Jubilee Gold Mine - Licence Conditions 1269, 6466, 9651 Jundee Gold Mine - Licence Conditions 1556 Kalgoorlie Consolidated Gold Mines Pty Ltd Acoustic Noise Consultant 9647 Asbestos in Open Pit 4056, 7001 Breach of Licence Conditions 1273, 1454, 4054, 4055, 10794, 10808, 13015 Licence Conditions 7508, 7993 Realignment of Eastern Bypass Road - Petition 4052 Removal of “Cyanide” from Licence Conditions 8780 Super Pit Mining Operations 1273, 1566, 4051, 5806 Kundana Gold Mine - Breach of Licence Conditions 7839 Lease No 26/261 - Reserve 24574 - Drilling 10381 Loongana Lime Breaches of Licence Conditions 11881 Burning of Waste Oil 7995 Complaints 7005, 13016 Kiln Temperature Readings 9631 Licence Conditions 7005, 8431, 8777, 8779 Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining 10746; Statement 12269 Mt Pleasant Gold Mine - Licence Conditions 1270, 7000 Oroya Tailings Dam 5801-5805, 7652, 8780, 8781 Parks and Reserves - Prohibition on Mineral and Petroleum Exploration and Mining 11883 Portman Iron Ore Ltd Cockatoo Island - Breach of Licence Conditions 9620 Koolyanobbing Mine 6604, 8423, 9585 Windarling and Jackson Ore Deposits - Archaeological Survey Report 5665 Tailings Dams - Kalgoorlie and Geraldton - PVC Plastic Liners 6999 Tuart Trees South of Mandurah - Decline and Death - Impact of Bauxite Mining 13915 Williamstown - Visit by Appeals Convenor 7203 Windimurra Vanadium Mine - Waste Material 11880 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 529

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Ministers of the Crown Attorney General Facsimile Application of Signature 5020 Legal Practitioner Qualifications 13468, 13591 Minister for Health - Recipient of Fax Sent to the WA Christian Community 1949, 1955 Minister for Housing and Works Administrative Staff 5659 Cost of Faxing 1801 Personal Explanation - Question without Notice 2485 Reprimand by the Premier 702 Minister for Local Government and Regional Development Air Charter 1800 Local Government Amendment Bill 2003 - Personal Explanation 14034 Minister for the Kimberley, Pilbara and Gascoyne Christmas Wish List 14778 Office Budget 865 Office Location and Refurbishment and Staff - 2903, 2904, 3192 Portfolio Changes - Statement 9517 Motor Vehicles Four-wheel-drives - Advertising Depicting Damage to Environment 1140, 1848 Smoky Vehicle Reporting Program 11889 Native Title Act - Review 2478, 2915 Burrup Peninsula Agreement Details 9585, 9846, 13124, 13141 Approvals 549 Management Plan for Non-industrial Land 9020 Tabling of Agreement 5771, 6304 Claims - Statistics 1736 Combined Metropolitan Working Group’s Application - Mediation 10803 Derby-West Kimberley Shire 10788 Kununurra - Claims 10785 Legislation - Amendments 548 Litigation 1043, 2510 Mindi Mindi Aboriginal Corporation - Bungle Bungle National Park - Decision 1004 Office of Budget 348; Adjournment Debate 269 Funding 462, 860 Pilbara - Alcohol Consumption 4452 Pilbara Termination of Proceedings in National Native Title Tribunal 9020 Up-front Payment 8395 WA Aboriginal Native Title Working Group - Attendance at ALP State Conference 43, 164 Wand Report - Recommendations 4028 Yaburarra and Mardudhunera Claim 9847 Ningaloo Reef Ningaloo Station - Briefing on Tourist Accommodation 5814, 5971, 5972, 6120, 6121 Permanent Dive Site Moorings 11879 Northbridge Tunnel - Air Quality Monitoring 5679 Nuclear Power Stations - Prohibition Legislation 164 Ocean Gardens (Inc.) Bill 2003 First Reading 13847 Second Reading 13847 Onslow Seawall - Reconstruction 3292 Parks and Reserves Beeliar Regional Park - Management Plan 11888 Bungle Bungle National Park - Mindi Mindi Aboriginal Corporation 1004 Cape Arid National Park - Fires 3339 Conservation Reserves - Transferring Ownership to Indigenous Persons 13349 D’Entrecasteaux National Park - Waste Water Discharge from Lactanz Dairy Farm 4057 Gascoyne-Murchison Region - Goats - Damage 12016 530 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Parks and Reserves (continued) Jurien Bay Marine Park Order 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 14664 Marine Parks and Reserves Authority Dr Barry Wilson - Conflict of Interest 350, 462, 702, 1002, 1257, 1657, 3434, 3440, 4198 Minutes of Meeting 3433 Point Spring Nature Reserve - Fencing of Boundaries 12922, 13912 Prohibition on Mineral and Petroleum Exploration and Mining 11883 Scott River National Park - Inclusion of Reserves 13858 Tuart Forest National Park - Management Plan 4364 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of - Town Reserves 740 Pastoral Leases Liveringa Station, Camballin - Land Clearing 11044 Mt Gibson Station - Field Report on Endangered Flora 11879 Windimurra - Purchase by CALM 11880 Pay-roll Tax Assessment Bill 2001 - Cognate Debate 3759 Pay-roll Tax Bill 2001 - Cognate Debate 3759 Payroll Tax Reform - Tax-free Threshold 5662 Perth Airport - Aircraft Noise Restrictions - Maniana 863 Perth International Centre for Application of Solar Energy Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 6262 Second Reading 6263 Planning Ascot Waters Development, Belmont 11836, 11839, 14048 Burns Beach Lot 2 - Rezoning and Development 5956 Property Trust - Appeal 1567 Bushplan-Bush Forever - Protection of Sites 1737 Heathcote Site 467, 4432 Mauds Landing Development Carew-Hopkins, Mr Derek 4023, 4198 Gascoyne Development Commission 2601 Minister’s Biased View 3433, 3440, 3608, 4434 Minister’s Support 2479 Viability 4024 Wilson, Dr Barry 350, 462, 702, 1002, 1257, 1657, 3433, 3434, 4198 Riverslea Gardens, Margaret River - Subdivision Approval 3292 Separation Point Marine Precinct - Consultation 8577 South Beach Urban Development, Cockburn/Fremantle 9622, 9625, 8425 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands 552, 1007, 3471, 3472 Swanbourne Senior High School Site - Public Housing 3613 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of - Reserve 41812 - Planning Approvals Inconsistent with Town Planning Scheme 13028 Police Augusta Station - Staffing 12430 Joondalup - Police Presence at Council Meeting 14194 Lesbian and Gay Pride Parade - Officers Marching in Uniform 12432 Multi-function Police Sites 14836 Non-metropolitan Districts - Staffing Levels 12432 Officers - Active Duty - Number 13471 Royal Commission - Submissions 14836 Speakers’ Steps Forrest Place - Recording of Information 5023 Pollution Air - Perth Air Quality Management Plan 11887 Amcor Contaminated Site, Bibra Lake - 3338 Brickworks Industry - Monitoring of Stack Emissions 737 Chemical Storage Facilities High Risk - Completion of Inspections 2156 Contaminated Sites BHP Billiton, Newman 8367 Proposed Legislation 1746 National Pollutant Inventory - Pollution Emission Figures 7019, 8410 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 531

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Pollution (continued) Omex Site - Remediation Costs 5819 Port Hedland - Iron Ore Dust Contamination 14198 Two Rocks Marina - Fuel Contamination 3437 Wesfarmers CSBP Ltd Ashfield Site - Pollution Abatement Notice 6082 Water Licensing Exemption 7179 Port Kennedy Development Project Costs 1966 Environmental Impact 1842 Golf Course - Ground Water Use 4062 Ports and Harbours Bunbury - Fees Paid 866 Dampier Public Wharf Expansion 463, 10262 Geraldton Port Authority Data from Seagrass Monitoring Sites 11889, 13145 Dredging Operations 8567, 10116 Photosynthetic Active Radiation 9022, 9986 Port Upgrade 9588, 9849 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 First Reading 7142 Second Reading 7142 Questions on Notice Answers 1141, 2875, 6305, 8569, 11178, 14778 Unanswered 10924 Racing - Golden Mile Trotting Club - Notification from City of Kalgoorlie-Boulder 743 Railways Loopline Tourist Railway, Boulder-Kalgoorlie - Environmental Assessment 1274 Southern Rail Link - Aboriginal Heritage Sites 9552, 11054 Regional Development Buy Local Policy - Nature of Local Business 2650 Commissions - Board Members - Names and Places of Residence 11884 Financial Assistance Schemes - Double-dipping by State Government Agencies 10113 Fund Applications and Distribution of Fund 243, 584 Kojonup Shire 468 Gascoyne Development Commission - Mauds Landing Development 2601 Implementation of Government’s Policy 13589 Regional Economic Perspectives - Cost of Production and Distribution 13069 Regional Headworks Scheme - Review 3287 Regional Policy Statement for Western Australia - Statement 3269 Western Australian Regional Manufacturers - Web Site Development 555 Regional Development Commissions Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - 5320 Roads Kalgoorlie Eastern Bypass Road - Realignment - Petition 4052 Mt Henry Bridge - Aboriginal Site Clearance 9651 Regional Road Groups - Funding 5660 Road Verge Vegetation - Applications to Clear 3336 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Submissions by Police Personnel - Restrictions 14836 Salinity Engineering Evaluation Initiative Projects - Funding 12435 Funding - Engagement of the Community and Framework for Regional Drainage Planning 9637 State Salinity Action Plan - Incentive Schemes for Farmers to Improve Remnant Vegetation Management 9638 WA Channel Management Group - Funding 10795 Schools Mindarie High School - Doric Constructions Pty Ltd - Contract 159, 1423 Woodbridge Primary - Temporary Relocation 5774 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5297-5299 Seniors - Geraldton - Airconditioning Rebate 864 532 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 First Reading 3763 Second Reading 3764 Sewerage Canning River - Leakage 12037 Walpole Waste Water Treatment Plant - Audit Report 10811 Sittings of the House Extended after 6.00 pm -Amendment to Motion 2754 New Sitting Arrangements - Adjournment Debate 5670 Southern Brush-tailed Phascogales - Mortalities 1260 Speakers’ Steps - Forrest Place - Police Activity 5023 Sport and Recreation Boxwood Hill Sporting Complex - Electricity Supply 14031 Kwinana International Motorplex - Impact of Noise on Hope Valley Residents 14770 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Swimming Pool Fencing - Sixth Report 4889, 5006 Standing Committee on Procedure and Privileges - Standing Order No 73 - Time Limits on Speeches - Fifth Report 3999 State Budget - Recurrent Expenditure and Capital Works Programs - Deferment or Cancellation 6989, 6992, 6993 Superannuation - Local Government Superannuation Plan - Investment in Cedar Property Group 593 Swan River Fish Deaths - Autopsy and Chemical Analysis Report 13358 Licences to Discharge Waste - 13024 Trust Development Applications - Number 9634 Management Program 9553, 10247 Water Quality Investigation - Elevated Levels of Contaminants 10800 Swimming Pools Isolation Fencing - Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Report - Statement 4889 Leonora - Government Funding 2764 Taxation Administration Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 3745 Second Reading 3745 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 3745 Second Reading 3745 Taxation Administration (Consequential Provisions) (Taxing) Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 3745 Second Reading 3745 Tourism Lake Kununurra and Ord River - Landing Rights 12031 Loopline Tourist Railway, Boulder-Kalgoorlie - Environmental Assessment 1274 Ningaloo Station - Briefing 5814, 5971, 5972, 6120, 6121 Northcliffe - Unsealed Roads 13469 Regional Investment Fund - Infrastructure Funded 13022 Wildlife Interaction Permits - Number Issued 1840 Transport Qantas Air Services - Melbourne-Broome - Statement 3575 Livestock - Fatigue Management Regulations 11603 Shark Bay Airport - Power Supplies 11862 Skywest Airlines Pty Ltd - Fokker F100 Jet 4530 Two Rocks - Marina - Fuel Contamination 3437 Voluntary Euthanasia Bill 2002 - Second Reading 11032 Wambengers - Mortalities 1260 Warren-Blackwood Area - Call Centre - Department of Housing and Works 3617 Waste Disposal Atlas Waste Calingiri - Ground Water 3613, 4547 City of Stirling 9848 Weighbridge Dockets for Waste Delivery to Tamala Park Landfill 734, 1738 Weight of Water and Contaminants 1563 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 533

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Waste Disposal (continued) Barrow Island - Incinerator 9359 Brookdale Community Reference Group 9023, 9645, 9983, 11880 Brookdale Liquid Waste Treatment Facility Conflict of Interest - Department of Environmental Protection 5219 Department of Environmental Protection - Mistakes 7003 Grease Trap Waste 9059 Inventory and Site Inspection Report 9987 Records of Toxic Materials 5049 Reviews 5535 Waste Taken without Approvals and Closure 5315, 6605 Cardup Shale Road Landfill Tip 10795, 10796 Cleanaway Technical Services - Brookdale Facility 5196 Compost Trials - South Metropolitan Regional Council 8428 Discharge into Marine Environment 6460, 7018, 13024 Global Olivine Waste-to-energy Plant, Kwinana - Joint Venture 734 Government Departments and Agencies - Targets for Waste Reduction and Recycling 12040 Government Policy 6098 Hazardous Waste Solutions Site, Bellevue - Environmental Audit and Review 737 Henderson Landfill Facility - Ground Water Monitoring and Landfill Liner 13358 Kalgoorlie-Boulder Yarri Road Waste Disposal Ponds and Tip Facility - Licence Conditions 4053 Kalgoorlie Liquid Waste Disposal Companies - Breach of Licence Conditions 5678 Marine Environment - Licences to Discharge Waste 10798 Mungari Industrial Estate - Waste-to-energy Plant 7996 No 5 Greenfield Street, South Hedland Rural Estate - Licence for Waste Disposal 9643 No 972 Leehey Street, Wedgefield, Port Hedland - Licence for Waste Disposal 9622 Nufarm Ltd - Licence fo r Disposal of Chemicals 13896 Resource Recovery Rebate Scheme Provisions 6301 Report No 7 - Tabling 7848 Shale Road Class 3 Landfill, Cardup - Licence Conditions 1847 Stephenson and Ward Biomedical Incinerator - Emission Scrubbing Bypass Incidents 1846 Stirling, City of - Waste Management System 12003 Thomas Road Waste Mound - Expansion 3289 Total Waste Management, Kalgoorlie-Boulder Depth to Ground Water 9650 Enforcement of Licence Conditions 7002 Evaporation Ponds 7823 Licence Agreement 4959 Licence Conditions 11071, 12953 Monitoring Bores 7001 Odours 7840 Solid Waste Treatment 9060 Toxic Waste from Brookdale Waste Facility 7002 Tox Free Solutions - Waste Processor at Kwinana 246, 13348 Truck Tyres - Reuse as Lawn Top Dressing 1274 Waste-to-landfill Levy - Review 8428 Waste Management and Recycling Fund 247, 2226, 8427 Waste Management Authority - Establishment 8429 Waste-to-energy Projects - Maddington 2765 Waste Tyres - Disposal and Recycling 5679 Waste Management Bill - Introduction 2159 Water and Rivers Commission Budget 2002-03 - Unspent Moneys 9642 Discretionary Powers 5194 Estimates Committee - Correction to Answer 9027 Ground Water Management Areas - Target for Excess Use 9640 Improving Rivers and Estuaries - Partnerships 9638 Major Initiatives for 2003-04 9636 National Action Plan/Natural Heritage Trust - Budget 9640 Penalties for Breaches of Licence Conditions 9644 534 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Water and Rivers Commission (continued) Policy for Public Drinking Water Source Areas 9642 Report of Mr Carew-Hopkins - Tabling 11360 Rural Water Supply Assistance - Budget 9638 Water Allocation Policies - Unspent Money 9643 Yarragadee Aquifer - Advice 6297 Water Boards Amendment Bill 2002 First Reading 5215 Second Reading 5215 Water Corporation - Computer Sciences Corporation Information Technology Contract 1140 Water Resources Alcoa Wagerup and Pinjarra Refineries 12434 Aquifers - Extraction Rate 4251 Avon River - Tamarix Parviflora 10779 Bores - Water Users’ Charge 7477, 7642 Canning River - Sewage Leakage 12037 Catchment Areas - Protection 2765 Chittering - Application for Planning Consent for Water Supply System 9635 Community Water Forums - Kununurra 4433 Deep Drainage - Assessment of Downstream Impact 1418 Desalinated Seawater - Piping from Esperance to Kalgoorlie-Boulder 13593 Farm Dams - Management Charges - Community Consultation Groups 10112 Farm Water Grants Scheme 6456, 6458 Farms and Mines - Management Fee 7642 Gascoyne River - Tamarix Aphylla 10779 Gnangara Land Use and Water Management Strategy - Draft Environmental Protection Policy 1742 Gnangara Mound East of Yanchep Caves - Pine Plantation Clearing 8416 Gnangara Park Management Plan - Finalisation 1743 Gnangara Water Mound Extraction Rates and Logging Impact 4448, 4991 Threatened Species and Ecological Communities 6302 Ground Water 900 Rockingham Road, Henderson 12431 Hydrocrabon Contamination 1848 Perth Region - Increased Water Extraction 14192 Sustainable Yield - Perth Region 13071 Hough Brook 345,1139, 1745 Kununurra - Water Source Protection Plan 10786, 10787, 14633 Lake Kununurra and Ord River - Control, Maintenance and Management 12031 Lefroy Brook - Contamination Prevention 5774 Legislation - Review 465 Marine Environment - Licences to Discharge Waste 10798 Mathews, J.B. - Ground Water Area Well Licence 1421 Murray River - Water Quality 9057 Narembeen Deep Drainage Project - Impact on Wetlands 551, 1741 Newman - Ground Water Contamination 8367, 11174 Nilgin Service Co Ltd - Licensing of Employees 4940 Perth Integrated Water Supply Scheme - Licence Allocation 13467 Port Kennedy Golf Course - Ground Water Use 4062 Quinninup 13125 Rainwater Tanks - Installation 40 Scott Coastal Plain - Test Hole for Water Bore Licence 14769 Secret Harbour Golf Course - Ground Water Use 4062 Serpentine River - Water Quality 9057 State Water Strategy - Estimates of Water Resources 13857 Stream and River Logging Buffers - Review 3473 Water and Energy-efficient Homes - Environmental Building Code 40 Water Management District Committees 9357, 9655 Water Regulation, Office of 9639-9641 Water Services Coordination Act - Review 8368 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 535

STEPHENS, HON THOMAS GREGORY (continued) Water Resources (continued) Wellington Dam - Rewriting of Major Hydrological Model 9637 Whitlock Creek - Dredge Spoil 12038 Yarragadee Aquifer City Supply 7312 Extraction Rate 10798-10800, 10922, 12044, 12162 South West 12010, 12961, 12962, 14769 Water and Rivers Commis sion Advice 6297 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 First Reading 14153 Second Reading 14153 Wedge-tailed Eagles - Number 9026 Western Power Access Requirements - Regulations for Entry to Grid 4030, 5772 Average Unit Cost - Publication 4303 Boxwood Hill Sporting Complex - Electricity Supply 14031 Disaggregation Information Technology Services 12025 Sustainable Energy Branch 10809 Eiszele, Mr David - Employment Contracts 4201, 4448, 4533, 5050; Personal Explanation 4889 Emergency Line - Inquiries - Time Limit to Respond 14668 Forest Hill Vineyard - Electricity Supply 4025, 4030, 8579 Kwinana Power Station - Picket Line 13591 Kyoto Protocol - Impact 1261 Shark Bay Airport - Power Supplies 11862 Wyndham - Electricity Meter Readings 4902, 5438 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7493 Wonthella House, Geraldton - Extension 1953

STRETCH, HON WILLIAM NOEL (South West) (Lib) Aborigines - Gordon Inquiry - Retention and Disposal Schedule 13470 Address-in-Reply - Motion Bail Tragedy 2233 Contracting 2238 Health 2237 Kodja Place, Kojonup 2234, 2235 Telstra 2239, 2240 Agriculture Department Economic Analysis Capability 11599 Land Conservation Officers 3872 Drought Assistance - Payroll Tax Reductions and Stamp Duty Exemptions 2868 Employment of Underage Children on Farms 12270 Lamb - Definitions of Meat 7450 Livestock Transport - Cost Impact of New Regulations 11599 Midland Saleyards - Relocation 2873 Persons Under 18 Years Operating Machinery on Private Property - Regulations 12556 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 Second Reading 2773 Committee 2877, 2882 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7963, 9029 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Third Reading 3745 Conservation and Land Management, Department of Prescribed Burning Program - Review 3615, 4341 Prosecution of Landholders - Cost 14774 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Committee 11584-11586 Personal Explanation 12227 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14674 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14674 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 14674 536 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

STRETCH, HON WILLIAM NOEL (continued) Environment Controls on the Rural Sector - Motion 12541 Heinrich, Mr and Mrs - Compensation for Loss of Earnings 14030, 14639 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Discharge from Notice Paper and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 4913 Second Reading 5010 Committee 11148-11159, 11231-11234, 11323-11325, 11330 Third Reading 11570 Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure - Consideration of Tabled Papers Agriculture 8528 Southern Railway 8526, 8527 Water Supplies 8530-8532 Yarragadee Formation 8529 Forests and Forestry Draft Forest Management Plan - Release - Statement by Leader of the House 10472, 11588 Old-growth Forest - Government’s Policy 7166 Pine Plantations - Resource Plans - Statement by Minister for Agriculture 12662 Pinetec Pty Ltd Relocation and Timber Resource 1743 Timber Resource 710, 1262 Timber Industry Worker Assistance Package - Funding 3611 Wesbeam Pty Ltd - Timber Resource 1262 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 14598 Committee 14626-14633 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading 13344 Multipurpose Health Service Country Hospitals - Elderly Permanent Care Patients 4344, 4399 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5647 Occupational Safety and Health - Amendment Regulations (No. 3) 2003 - Disallowance 10108 Payroll Tax - Reductions for Drought-affected Farmers 2868 Peel Region Scheme Disallowance 5549 Statement by Minister for Racing and Gaming 13576 Personal Explanation - Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 12227 Port Authority Boards - Members’ Names and Places of Residence 12030 Private Property Rights - Protection - Petition 8639 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Committee 7278 Railways - WA Government Railways Commission - Coach Contracts - Motion 12254, 12259 Regional Development - Commissions Board Members - Names and Places of Residence 11884 Western Australian Regional Manufacturers - Web Site Development 555 Roads - Gibbs Street, Boyup Brook - Road Alignment 7475 Schools Cadet Progra ms - Adjournment Debate 2775 Non-government - Funding - Petition 4377 Select Committee on Rules, Orders and Usage of the House - Final Report 5299 Stamp Duty - Exemptions for Drought-affected Farmers 2868 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel - Motion 4494 Water Resources Charges - Penalty Rates 2872 Water Management District Committees 9357, 9655 Western Power - Forest Hill Vineyard - Electricity Supply 4025

SWEETMAN, MR RODNEY NOEL (Ningaloo) (Lib) Address-in-Reply - Motion - Aborigines 3971-3975 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3392, 3395 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7247 Department - Select Committee - Motion 7247 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 537

SWEETMAN, MR RODNEY NOEL (continued) Agriculture (continued) Drought Assistance Exceptional Circumstances Aid 3779 Grain Licensing Authority Statement 12196 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Aboriginal Heritage and Cultural Centre 7708 Budget Deficit 7669-7671 Carnarvon Regional Hospital 7689 Gascoyne Region 7706 GTL Resources (Australia) Pty Ltd 7708, 7709 Health Services 7690, 7691 Homeswest 7707 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7689, 7706 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1496 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6702 Casino (Burswood Island) Agreement Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9864 Dangerous Goods Safety Bill 2002 Second Reading 8812 Consideration in Detail 8821, 8822 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5130 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13655 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Second Reading 13227 Consideration in Detail 13507-13510, 13514, 13515, 13528, 13529, 13684, 13687-13691 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 - Second Reading -Cognate Debate 13655 Festivals in North of State - Statement 10673 Fisheries Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 13411 Palmer, Jeff and Gail - High Court Appeal Case 2929 Fuel and Energy Dampier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline - Motion 6829; Amendment to Motion 6839, 6842 Epic Energy - Regulator’s Draft Ruling 6492 Fuel Prices - Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection’s Lack of Action - Matter of Public Interest 926 Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator - Ruling 6492 Gas Pipelines Access (Western Australia) (Reviews) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9131 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 8837 Council’s Amendments 14915 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1496 Consideration in Detail 1580, 1582, 1695-1703, 1714-1721 Third Reading 1722 Housing and Works, Department of Carnarvon - Antisocial Behaviour - Petition 12445 Tenants - Antisocial Behaviour - Amendment to Motion 8623 Industrial Hemp Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14082 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13981 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13954 Mauds Landing Development - Rejection Decision - Motion 9910 Members of Parliament Chamber of Minerals and Energy - Tour for Opposition Members - Statement 6642 Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion, as Amended 10577 Stephens, Hon Tom - Carnarvon Electorate Office - Statement 7880 Minister for Consumer and Employment Protection - Lack of Action on Fuel Prices - Matter of Public Interest 926 Mt Magnet District High School - Second Deputy Principal 5722 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3489 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1904 Police Carnarvon - Antisocial Behaviour - Petition 12445 538 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

SWEETMAN, MR RODNEY NOEL (continued) Police (continued) Yalgoo, Shire of - Aboriginal Police Liaison Officer 2391 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6373 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6373 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6373 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6373 Railways - Safety Mechanisms on Locomotives and Rail Crossings - Petition 6471 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 7902 Consideration in Detail 7906, 7910, 7911 Salinity Bilateral Agreement with the Commonwealth Government 7228, 7229 Funding New State Money 6342 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality Motion 6530 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7247 Sewerage Infill Program - Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 2694 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 11405 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13954 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11305 Zimbabwean Farmers - Statement 1305

TEMPLEMAN, MR DAVID ALAN, DipTchg, BEd (Mandurah) (ALP) Address-in-Reply - Motion Alcoa 316 Education 315 Emergency Services 318 Health 317 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Community Groups 7713 Education 7710 Health 7709 Infrastructure Projects 7711, 7712 Policing 7714 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7709 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 7346 Community Development Advisory Council on the Prevention of Deaths of Children and Young People 8600 Peel Visiting Community Mothers Program - Statement 10413 Community Development and Justice Standing Committee Annual Report 2001-02 1685 Annual Report 2002-03 - Tabling 14217 Disability Services - Supporting Our Seniors and Disabled - Statement 2811 Education - Teachers’ Pay Rise - Motion 11423 Environmental Enforcement Unit - Establishment 4857 Forests and Forestry - Old-growth Forest - Leader of the Opposition’s Comment 5240 Government Contracts - Tendering Process - Impropriety under Previous Government 9234 Health Breastfeeding Welcome Here Project - Statement 6180 Dental - Aged-care Oral Health Program 7360 Government’s Commitment to Improved Services 1322 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petitions 6608 Pneumococcal Disease - Immunisation Program - Grievance 8696 Stroke Strategy Plan 3979 Homelessness - Mandurah 1867 Housing and Works, Department of - Tenants’ Antisocial Behaviour - Amendment to Motion 8631 Insurance - Regulation of Industry 1308 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 633 Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week - Petition 13367 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Education 10441 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 539

TEMPLEMAN, MR DAVID ALAN (continued) Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading (continued) Environment 10440 Health Services 10439 Mandurah Population Growth 10438 Safety and Policing 10439 Mandurah Cancer Fundraising Association - Statement 8962 Mandurah City Choral Society - Statement 8962 Mandurah Concert Band - Statement 11531 Mandurah Historical Society - Statement 8305 Minister for Police and Emergency Services - Parliamentary Questions - Motion 12801 New MetroRail - National Party Cost Claims 8005 Nuclear Waste - Importation into Western Australia - Petition 12327 Peel Health Campus - Accessibility 2009 Peel Region Scheme Disallowance 4141 Statement 4853 Peel Schools Fest 2003 - Statement 12603 Police Major Sporting Events - Allocation of Resources 9743 Red-light Cameras - Locations 11005 Volunteers - Checks at Reduced Rates 10962 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Third Reading 6477 Questions on Notice - Answers - Motion 12801 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6372 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 905 Railways New MetroRail - Cost Claims by National Party 8005 Southern Rail Link Budget Details 9874 Cost Comparisons 10163 Cost Savings 10025 Leader of the Opposition’s Policy 14072 Leasing Contracts 11625 Opposition’s Attitude 2519, 2670 Opposition’s Policy 11900 Passenger Numbers 13920 Premier’s Support 14877 Timetable for Completion 14879 Regional Development - Peel Development Commission - Grievance 11746 Retirees WA Inc - Administration Concerns 9008 Roads Mandurah Bypass - Statement 7355 Peel Deviation 6679, 12069 Seminole Avenue and Gordon Road Intersection - Petition 2351 Safer WA Community Security Program - Mandurah - Funding 1782 Schools Mandurah - Environment Projects - Statement 912 Peel Schools Fest 2003 - Statement 12603 Seniors Mandurah City Senior Citizens Centre - Ms Jan Lauder- Statement 13806 Supporting Our Seniors and Disabled - Statement 2811 Standing Committee on Community Development and Justice - Emergency Services Legislation in Western Australia Second Report 2790 State Finance Federal Budget Weaknesses - Implications for Western Australia 5719 Tobacco Franchise Fees - High Court Decision 512 Tourism - Federal Government’s White Paper 13612 540 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TEMPLEMAN, MR DAVID ALAN (continued) Transport South Metropolitan Region - Improvement 5369 Transperth - Mandurah 11392 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Mandurah and Peel Region - Needs 9124 Volunteers Peel Volunteer Resource Centre - Statement 12195 Police Checks - Reduced Rates 10962 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11289 Youth 1867

TOMLINSON, HON DERRICK GORDON, BA, MEd (East Metropolitan) (Lib) Aborigines Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation - Inquiry into Funding - Establishment of Select Committee - Motion 14007; Amendments to Motion 14018 Aboriginal Heritage Act - Prosecutions 5438 Aboriginal Housing Infrastructure Council - Construction Program 12005 Bungalbin, Windarling, Boondine Hill and Mt Jackson - Sites of Cultural Significance 5317 Child Protection Workers - Placement 11481, 12924; Personal Explanation 11484 Family Violence Prevention Support Service - North West 11481; Personal Explanation 11484 Housing - Construction Program 12005 Saunders Street Settlement - Statement 8683 Sites of Significance Cities of Perth and South Perth 7478 Perth Urban Rail Development 7647, 8362 Southern Rail Link - Heritage Sites 11054, 12045 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Number at Henley Brook Camp 9024 Urban Settlements - Closure 9360 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 4400 Committee 4506-4523 Address-in-Reply Motion Frank Serpico 1240 Police Corruption 1242 Amendment to Motion - Government’s Failure in Administering the State 4387 Adoption Laws - Petition 4181 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 5206 Committee 5304-5309 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Committee 2880-2889 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Committee 9534, 9535 Arts and Culture - WA Ballet and WA Opera - Merger 10478 Beck, Mr Tinsley Manning - Petition for Relief - Motion 4949 Building Industry - Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Newspaper Report 7826 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 9612, 9813 Committee 10069-10071, 10074, 10740-10745, 10757-10770, 10884-10900, 11021-11025 Capital Punishment - Offenders Convicted of Heinous Crimes - Motion 12999 Child Protection - Appointment of Officers in Aboriginal Communities 12924 Child Welfare Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 470 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Committee 14756-14769,14779-14782, 14826-14832 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 14749-14753 Crime Community Safety and Crime Prevention Council - Funding Allocation 12289 Safer WA - Funding Allocation 12289 Dogs - Docking of Tails - Petition 2851 Domestic Violence - Appointment of Eight Specialist Police Officers 12924 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 541

TOMLINSON, HON DERRICK GORDON (continued) Education Early Development Survey - Joondalup West Coast and Swan Education Districts 14195, 14802 Teachers - Appointments to Non-teaching Positions 14717 Electricity Reform Implementation Committee - Consultants’ Report - Tabling by Leader of the House Motion 12421 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3462 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 10343-10360 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2001 Second Reading 1253 Committee 1434-1441, 3042, 3043 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Deputy President’s Ruling 3447 Second Reading 3447 Committee 3596-3599 Government Contracts - Construction - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Newspaper Report 7826 Gordon Report Implementation Group - Question without Notice - Personal Explanation 11484 Health Aborigines Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA - Funding - Establishment of Select Committee - Motion 14007; Amendments to Motion 14018; Motion, as Amended 14018 Building Solid Families Program - Funding 163 Services Purchased by Department - Payments 10790 Bunbury Health Task Force - Report 4904 Early Development Survey - Joondalup West Coast and Swan Education Districts 14195 Mental Health Nurses 4202 Mental Health System - Funding Cuts 12434, 14040 Psychiatrists 4202 Regional Health Services 4990 South West Mental Health Service Advice Line 4959 Clinical Director 4343 Dr David Lord 4397 Hospitals Fremantle - Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner - Petition 337 King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women - Suits for Negligence 1041 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children - Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner - Petition 337 Housing Albion Town, Henley Brook - Development 5661 Swanbourne Senior High School Site - Public Housing 3613 Housing and Works, Department of Aborigines - Rental Homes 9849 Construction Contracts Policy - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Newspaper Report 7826 Ecoscape (Australia) Pty Ltd - Albion Town Development Environmental Assessment 9844, 12143 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Regional Offices - Closure 6580 Joint Standing Committee on the Anti-Corruption Commission Annual Report 2001-02 - First Report 1920 Annual Report 2002-03 11007 Fifth Report - Motion 11586 Hearings with the Anti-Corruption Commission Fourth Report 6943, 10465 Sixth Report 12511 Integrity Within the Public Sector - Review of the Anti-Corruption Commission Second Report 4490 Third Report 6044 National Conference of Parliamentary Oversight Committees of Anti-Corruption/Crime Bodies 2003 - Seventh Report 14149 Justice, Department of Mr Darryl Beamish - Cost of Appeal 4531 Mr John Button - Cost of Appeal 4531 Kelly, Hon Garry Kenneth - Condolence Motion 30 542 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TOMLINSON, HON DERRICK GORDON (continued) Local Government Belmont, City of Inquiry 41, 553, 2762, 4257 Investigation of Complaints 10750 Perth, City of - Aboriginal Sites 7478 South Perth, City of - Aboriginal Sites 7478 Minister for Education and Training - Motion 6076 Planning Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments No 1019/33 - Townsites in Stoneville and Parkerville - Disallowance 5796 No 1028/33 - South East Districts Omnibus (No 5) - Disallowance 4463 Nicholson Road and Thornlie Road Railway Station Precincts - Study of Land Use and Transport Integration 464 Swanbourne Senior High School Site - Public Housing 3613 Planning Appeals Amendment Bill 2001 - Committee 259, 260, 264, 267, 362-369, 459, 460 Police Access to Records - Personal Explanation 8394 Child Protection and Family Violence Officers - Appointment 12924 Firearms - Number 10249 Forrestfield Station 13010, 13119 Greer, Mr Arthur Secure Storage of Forensic Material 2227 Trial Evidence 3436, 6083, 7202 Kalamunda Station 13010, 13119 Mason, Sharon - Murder Secure Storage of Forensic Material 2227, 3436, 3731 Trial Evidence 6083 Numbers - Western Australia 6283, 6958 Officers - Annual and Long Service Leave 3066 Recruits - Number 6958 Royal Commission - Submissions 14638, 14836 Stations - Unmanned 13010 Police Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 5421 Committee 5552, 5553 Premier and Cabinet, Department of the - Vehicle Speeding Fines 9973 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8763 Public Interest Disclosure Bill 2002 Second Reading 5056 Committee 5070, 5071 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 2635, 2900, 3048 Railways Nicholson Road and Thornlie Road Railway Station Precincts - Study of Land Use and Transport Integration 464 Perth Urban Rail Development - Aboriginal Sites 7647, 8362 Southern Rail Link - Aboriginal Heritage Sites 8673, 11054, 12045 Regional Economic Perspectives - Cost of Production and Distribution 13069 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Second Reading 7975 Committee 7986, 7987 Assembly’s Message 8375-8391 Personal Explanation 8394 Roe Highway Stages 4 to 8 - Cost 4027 Royal Commission into Whether there has been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Submissions by Police Personnel - Restrictions 14638, 14836 Schools Armadale Primary - Structural Faults 3290 Non-government - Funding - Petition 3990, 8525 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 543

TOMLINSON, HON DERRICK GORDON (continued) Schools (continued) Pupil-free Days - Death of 12-year-old in High Speed Vehicle Collision 10365 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children (Appointment of a Commissioner for Children) - Establishment Amendment to Motion 7639 Sewerage Infill Program - Re-prioritising of Works 2875 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs Gene Technology Bill 2001 and Gene Technology Amendment Bill 2001 - Proposal to Travel Motion 4496 Petition Presented by Mr Barry Granville Waller Motion 10369 Seventh Report - Motion 14156 State Administrative Tribunal - Task Force Report 3874 Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 - Review 13860 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2616 Committee 2630, 2631, 2632 Water Resources Gnangara Land Use and Water Management Strategy - MRS Amendment 6304 Water Services Coordination Act - Review - Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12421 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14003 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13882

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER, Parliamentary Secretary, State Development; Tourism (to 27 June); Small Business (to 27 June); Planning and Infrastructure (from 27 June) (North Metropolitan) (ALP) Aborigines Aboriginal Housing Development Authority - Unacquitted Grant 5026 Belang Aboriginal Corporation - Living Area Excision in Shire of Murchison 14710 Mungullah Community Aboriginal Corporation - Chairperson 6281 Pastoral Leases - Number Held 14214 Reserve 24574 Drilling Activity 4300, 6999, 9363 Dumping of Waste Rocks up to Boundaries 4301, 6122 Rock Art - Burrup Peninsula Assessment of Impact of Emissions 4298 Evaluation 10931 Minimisation of Emissions 7203 Monitoring Committee 8688; Funding 8576 Murujuga Rock Art Estate - Monitoring Committee 2766 Sites of Significance - Perth Urban Rail Development 9356 Southern Rail Link - Heritage Sites 12045 Urban Settlements - Closure 9360 Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10756, 14581 Acts of Parliament - Partially Proclaimed 14798, 14851 Agriculture Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd - Narrakine Storage Facility - Road Safety 11206 Cotton Industry, West Kimberley - Western Agricultural Industries Pty Ltd 9195, 9970 Grain Carting - Shortage of Drivers 12004 Ord River Stage 2 - Interim Joint Proponents 2869, 3288 Western Agricultural Industries - Memorandum of Understanding 11039 Western Australian Export Grain Transportation and Handling Agreement 10154 Arts and Culture Palaeontologic Objects and Other Fossils - Protection from Removal from Western Australia 5773 Perth Entertainment Centre - Future Plans 13011 ScreenWest - Screen Industry Partnership Fund 5777 Small to Medium Performing Arts Companies - Review 10922 Visual Arts - Myer Report 10751 Australian Labor Party - Energy Platform - Variations to Alumina Agreements 12027 Australian Wildlife Conservancy - Ningaloo Development - Briefing 5972, 5973, 6276 Barrow Island Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 12250 Second Reading 12250, 13073 544 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Barrow Island Bill 2003 (continued) Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes 12984 Committee 13089-13103 “Building Future Prosperity: Creating Jobs and Wealth Through Industry Development” - Statement 10207 Building and Construction Industry Training Fund - Ministerial Review of Levy 12291 Chemistry Centre (WA) 7825, 8675, 14636 Colleges of TAFE - Joondalup Regional Performing Arts Centre and Hospitality Training Centre - Collocation 9358 Commerce and Trade - South Korea - WA Trade Office Closure 1415 Dangerous Goods Safety Bill 2002 Receipt and First Reading 9047 Second Reading 9047 Derby Regional Hospital - Specialist Staff - Relocation to Broome District Hospital 35 Diamond Tree Sky Lift - Funding 13008 Disability Services - Alternatives to Employment - Funding 6280 Drivers Licences - Waiting Time for Practical Test 13080 Drugs - Sobering-up Centres - Funding 9362 East Perth Power Station Site - Expressions of Interest - Future Plans 13011 Eastern Goldfields Transport Board Act 1984 - Machinery of Government Report 10930 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Order Discharged and Referred to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance 6546 Education Department - Amalgamation with Department of Training 4906, 5026 Joondalup Regional Performing Arts Centre and Hospitality Training Centre - Collocation 9358 Post-compulsory Courses of Study - Support Materials 7474 Electricity Reform Implementation Committee - Consultants’ Report - Tabling by Leader of the House Motion 12415; Amendment to Motion 12427 Employment and Training Training, Department of - Amalgamation with Department of Education 4906, 5026 Vocational Education and Training - Courses and Support Materials 7474 Environment Approval Process - Transparency 9207, 10774, 10776 Kwinana - Cumulative Risk Study 1136 Perth Airport - High Conservation Value Land 14713 Estimates Committees - Appointment - Amendment to Motion 7148 Fisheries - Master Class 5 Ticket - Changes 11834 Forests and Forestry Greenbushes Timber Mill - Conditions on Allocation of Resources 9055 Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736 - Motion for Disallowance 14023 Logging - Meetings with Former Burke Government Ministers 9203 Ludlow Tuart Forest - Mining 14715 Nannup Timber Mill - Conditions on Allocation of Resources 9055 Pinetec Pty Ltd - Relocation and Timber Resource 9191 Timber Industry Restructure Plan 6277 Timber Mills - Business Exit Assistance 43 Wood Processing (WESFI) Agreement Act 2000 - Schedule H 3028 Woodchips - Transport - Manjimup-Bunbury Railway Line 13351 Fuel and Energy Barrow Island - Oil Production Facilities 9557, 9566 East-west Infrastructure Corridor - Mt Margaret, Geraldton - Land Acquisitions 2158 Petroleum Resource Rent Tax 10745 Government Contracts - Panel Contracts - Number and Cost 13483, 13892 Government Departments and Agencies Budget Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 10153 Court Action or Litigation - Involvement 7198, 7199 Functional Review Taskforce Savings - Schedule of Cost Reductions 10151, 10152 Public Relations-Community Awareness Expenditure 11868, 11874 Public Sector Management Administrative Instruction 728; Tabling 12023 Register of Intellectual Property 6987, 6988 Health Allied Health Taskforce - Work Force Issues Report 5778 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 545

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Health (continued) Dental - City of Cockburn 10797 Repatriation Private Patient Scheme 7449 Tetrahydrocannabinol - Test - Cost 7453 War Widows - Treatment as Private Patients 7449 Warren Blackwood Health Service - Podiatrist 5776 Housing Aboriginal Housing Development Authority - Unacquitted Grant 5026 Northbridge Railway Line Sinking - Allocation of Land to Parks and Affordable Housing 10803 Housing and Works, Department of - Fremantle Eastern Bypass and Roe Highway Stage 8 - Land Reservations 10366 Industrial Development Bauxite Deposit - Mitchell Plateau, Kimberley 14837 BHP Billiton - Radioactive Material Disposal 10115 “Building Future Prosperity: Creating Jobs and Wealth Through Industry Development” - Statement 10207 Burrup Fertilisers - Commencement of Operations 10935 Burrup Peninsula Burrup Fertilisers Pty Ltd - Ammonia-urea Plant 4532 Development 10930 Infrastructure Funding - Breakdown 4366 Native Title Affidavits 2480 Projects and Map of Locations 3609 Service Corridors 10773 Use of Intercourse Islands or Maitland for Industrial Purposes 4299 Woodside Petroleum Ltd - LNG Plant - Emissions 8420 Drilling Platforms - Radioactive Material 37, 162 East-west Infrastructure Corridor - Mt Margaret-Geraldton - Land Acquisitions 2158 Funding - Budget Breakdown 12017 Gorgon Project Carbon Sequestration Program - Monitoring 13019 Conservation Projects Contribution 10919 Date of Development Advice 13020 Development 9975 Dupuy Aquifer 12921 Tabling of Correspondence 10918 Industry Assistance - Grant and Subsidy Programs and Loan Assistance 2511, 2649 Jervoise Bay Development Breakdown of Expenditure on Infrastructure 12027 Heavy Fabrication Facility 1417 Marketing and Advertising Expenditure 3065 Karratha - PKK Environment and Infrastructure Pty Ltd - Report 10935 Kwinana - Cumulative Risk Study 1136, 2872, 3613; Statement 3421, 3990, 4181 Methanex Corporation - Development on Burrup Peninsula 1531 North West Shelf Project China - LNG Contract - Motion 442 Royalties Agreement 12144 Resource Exploration - Native Title Act - Impediment to Land Access 2760 Resource Projects - Funding - Breakdown 12020 Shark Lake Industrial Site, Esperance - 11209 Worsley Alumina Pty Ltd - Harris River Dam Water Allocation 4905 Industry and Resources, Department of Advice to Magistrates - Statement 7319 Political Recommendations by Officers 12023 Records of Decisions and Actions 10143 Iraq War - Justification - Adjournment Debate 5673 Iron Ore Processing (Mineralogy Pty. Ltd.) Agreement Bill 2002 Discharge of Order of the Day and Referral to the Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Motion 851 Second Reading 867 Third Reading 1013 Iron Ore (Yandicoogina) Agreement Act 1996 - Amendment - Statement 2108 Land Administration, Department of - Revenue Sharing Arrangements 11053 546 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Legislative Council - Refurbished Chamber - Statement by President 11607 Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week - Petition 14623 Lobbyists - Former Burke Government Ministers - Meetings on Logging 9203 Local Government Bus Stop Infrastructure - Grants 14209 Derby-West Kimberley, Shire of - Pastoral Lease Exclusions 11053 Joondalup, City of - Chief Executive - Adjournment Debate 4483; Statement 6592 Melville, City of - Lot Sizes 12558 Rating System and Distribution of Funds - Referral to Standing Committee on Public Administration and Finance - Amendment on the Amendment 11994 Roads Funding 10942 Swan, City of - Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment No 1048/33 - Addition to Urban Zoning - West Parade, South Guildford - Statement 14149 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of - Reserve 41812 - Lakeside Resort Development 13895 Mineral and Petroleum Resources, Department of Breaches of Mining Act - Non-prosecution Policy 4370, 7652, 9207, 10142, 10774, 13911 Director General - Letter to Editor 10146, 10147 Incorrect Information Cooke Review 4933 Statement 3270 Inspections and Prosecutions 12954 Records of Decis ions and Actions 8430, 10144 Mining 12-hour Shifts - Review 4936 Answers to Questions on Notice - Breach of Standing Orders 6998, 7000, 7013 Australian Prospectors and Miners Hall of Fame - Access Road 6998, 9206, 10775, 10936 Bauxite Deposit - Mitchell Plateau, Kimberley 14837 Big Bell Mine - Tailings Storage Facility 1674 Bowler Report into Mineral Exploration - Government’s Response 3284, 11240 Bulong Nickel Mine - Mining Leases and Prospecting Licences - Approval for Exploration Activity 4361 Coalition Government’s Policy Paper - Treatment of Prospectors’ Ore 4368 Croesus Shaft - Site Visit - 8399, 8400, 10143 Dallhold Resources Management Pty Ltd - Tailings Dam - Monitoring Bores 4369 Drilling Platforms - Radioactive Material 37, 162 East-west Infrastructure Corridor - Mt Margaret-Geraldton - Land Acquisitions 2158 Exploration and Mining Tenement Holders - Expenditure Exemptions 9562 Exploration and Mining Title Applications 873, 7474, 8426 Exploration Prospecting and Mining Licences - Number Surrendered 14801 Fimiston Site - Unconditional Performance Bond 4369, 6122 Fimiston Tailings Dams 10777, 13017 Gnangara - Status of Applications 3023, 3906 Goldfields Ltd - Kundana Gold Mine 13900-13902, 13898, 13899 Greenfields Mineral Exploration Guidelines 8435, 10144 Inquiry 2153, 4374, 4376, 6607 Policing of Expenditure Conditions 4375 Rewards for Small Operators and Extension of Exclusion Zones 4376 Hazards of Old Workings 7328 Kalgoorlie - Town Site Boundaries 1559 Kalgoorlie-Boulder 1565 Kalgoorlie Consolidated Gold Mines Pty Ltd Blast Hole Drill Rigs 1557 Breaches of Mining Act 1564, 3905 Closure Plan for Mt Charlotte Mine 1558 Cooke Review - Submissions 4364 Environmental Bond 8429, 10142 Fimiston Tailings Dams - Seepage 13906-13910 Mr B. Hounslow’s Complaints 1557 Prospecting Licence 26/2665 4362 Realignment of Eastern Bypass Road 4360, 4373 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 547

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Mining (continued) Kalgoorlie Consolidated Gold Mines Pty Ltd (continued) Rehabilitation of Tenements 7203 Relocation of Railway Line 3904 Super Pit Mining Operations 1564, 7000 Waste Dump Proposal - Environmental Bond 4368 Lake Yellowdine - Discharges 13902 Lease No 26/261 - Reserve 24574 - Drilling 4300, 4301, 6122, 6999, 9363 Lease No 26/353 - Complaints 12022, 13905 Lease No 26/383 Notice of Intention to Clear Land 10938 Tenement Conditions 10936 Lease No 36/7 Aboriginal Heritage Site 7328 Sand Mining Operations 9206, 10773 Lease Nos 24/352, 24/ 390, 24/39, 24/40 and 24/41 - Original Owners 10772, 12953 Lease Nos 25/32, 25/19 and Prospecting Licence 25/525 - Original Owners 10774, 12953 Lease Nos M25/19 and M25/32 - Clearing of Vegetation 1558 Leases - Standard No Mining Condition - Validity 4367 Lennard Shelf Zinc and Lead Mines - Closure 12265 Ludlow Mineral Sand Mining - Licence 14715 Mineral and Gold Deposits - Determination of Economic Viability 3905 Minerals Environment Liaison Committee - Membership 7329 Mt Charlotte-Fimiston Overland Conveyor - Approval to Build 1559 Mt Charlotte Site Complaints 4372, 10148, 10149, 12024 Departmental Inspection Procedure 4371 Mr Brian Hounslow’s Property 4374 Mt Gibson Integrated Iron Ore Deposit - Photographs of Exploration or Drill Pad Lines 10932 Open Pit - Calculation of Bonds 3905 Optimum Resources Magistrate’s Decision 9208 Request for Provision of Information to Warden 6959 Portman/HWE Iron Ore Operations, Cockatoo Island - Breach of Tenement Conditions 8678 Prospecting Licence P25/525 - Clearing of Vegetation 1558 Regulation - Answers to Questions 8429 Resource Exploration - Native Title Act - Impediment to Land Access 2760 Rio Tinto Exploration Pty Ltd - Lease 45/695 4992 Tailings Dams - Review 2511 Tenements P26/1848 and P26/1858 - Dangerous and Unsafe Working Conditions 11241, 12952 Uranium Applications to Convert Leases into Mining Tenements 7012 Mining Leases 5663, 5775 Yeelirrie 242, 3729 Western Metals Closure of Lennard Shelf Zinc Operations 12265 Export Facility Derby 1137, 1423 White Foil Project 11236-11239 Williamstown - Incorrect and Misleading Information from Department to Residents Committee 4932 Windimurra Vanadium Mine 7651, 9554, 12021 Molecular Inventory Systems Pty Ltd - Dealings with Department 6081 Native Title Act - Impediment to Land Access 2760 Burrup Peninsula Affidavits 2480 Assessment of Impact of Emissions 4298 Use of Intercourse Islands or Maitland for Industrial Purposes 4299 Exploration and Mining Title Applications - Heritage Surveys and Agreements 873 Ningaloo Station Briefing on Tourist Accommodation 5972, 5973 Ecotourism Facility 6276 548 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Nuclear Activities (Prohibition) Bill 2002 Second Reading 7807 Impact on Mining and Exploration Leases 4367 Introduction and Purpose 246 Mining of Uranium 1563 Prohibition on Uranium Mining from Leases 350 Offshore Minerals Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 5921 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5923 Committee 5924-5927 Third Reading 5928 Offshore Minerals (Consequential Amendments) Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 5921 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5923 Third Reading 5928 Offshore Minerals (Registration Fees) Bill 2001 Cognate Debate 5921 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5923 Third Reading 5928 Parker, Mr Ron - Australian Interaction Consultants - Ethnographic Survey 14636, 14712 Parks and Reserves - Kojonup Location 9212 - Amendment of Class A Reserve 1736 - Motion for Disallowance 14023, 14689 Pastoral Leases Aboriginal Interests - Number Held 14214 Amendments to Exclusion Document 13024 Derby-West Kimberley, Shire of - Pastoral Lease Exclusions 11053 El Questro Station - Excisions 10934 Exclusions - Freehold Land 10934 International Agreements and Covenants - Impact 13164 Rangeland Reports 12015 Windimurra Correspondence with Pastoral Lands Board 11372 Mining Leases and Exploration and Miscellaneous Licences 1806 Youanmi Downs, Sandstone - Status 11602 Planning Absolon Street, Palmyra - Closure at Both Ends 13147 Augusta-Walpole Coastal Strategy - Consultancy Tender 12147 Canal Rocks Pty Ltd versus Shire of Busselton - Consultation 10488 Clontarf Hill - Transfer of Management to City of Fremantle 10814 Developer Contributions to Infrastructure Costs Associated with Land Development 12553 Fitzroy Crossing Release of Residential Land 10788 Strategic Plan 11054 Garland International Pty Ltd Report 9360 Gingin Coast Structure Plan 12926 Hope Valley-Wattleup Redevelopment - Garland International Report 10778 Karratha - PKK Environment and Infrastructure Pty Ltd - Report 10935 Kununurra 10784, 10933 Lendich, Mr Vladimir - Bullsbrook Land 11054 Lennard Brook Easement, Gingin 9972 Lot 587 Herbert Street, Broome 13004 Lots 595 and 596, Stakehill Swamp 11177 Mangles Bay, Rockingham - Marina Proposal 4905 Mauds Landing - Development Economic and Social Benefits of Proposal 11204, 12569, 14769 Rejection Decision - Motion 9966 Urgency Motion 4186 Melville, City of - Lot Sizes 12558 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments Clarkson-Butler Amendment - Statement 11822 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 549

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Planning (continued) Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendments (continued) Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Correction of Answer 14779 No 1039/33 - Victoria Quay, Port of Fremantle - Statement 10076 Nos 1043/33, 1044/33 and 1049/33 - Statement 12911 No 1048/33 - Addition to Urban Zoning - West Parade, South Guildford - Statement 14149 No 1055/33 - Fremantle Eastern Bypass Statement 13355 Tabling of Documents 13350, 14194, 14195 No 992/33 - Clarkson-Butler - Disallowance 14824 Moore River Estuary Development - Land Subdivision 12006 Peel Region Scheme - Statement by Minister for Racing and Gaming 13577 Planning Control Area No 75 - Lot 7 Absolon Street and Stock Road, Palmyra - Upgrading 12926 Port Catherine Project - Legal Entitlements 12039 Scarborough Senior High School Site - Future Use 14775 Shark Lake Industrial Site, Esperance 11209 Smiths Beach Development - Number of Units and Sites Approved 13357 South Beach Urban Development Cockburn/Fremantle Buffer Zone 12046 Site Remediation and Validation Report 13366 Stakehill Rural Landowners Group - Land in Baldivis 10247, 11208 Town Planning Appeal Tribunal - BGC (Australia) Pty Ltd - Hearing Process 13081 Town Planning Scheme Amendments - Kununurra and Environs 10783 WA Planning Commission - Membership 13862 Wattleup - Reduction of Population 10939 William Street Bridge - Demolition 9846, 9975 Wireless Hill Park Land Excision 10363, 10748, 10922, 12437, 12669; Statement 11320 Tabling of Document 11045 Wyndham-East Kimberley, Shire of - Reserve 41812 - Planning Approvals Inconsistent with Town Planning Scheme 13895 Ports and Harbours Black Rocks, King Sound - Port Development 11372 Fremantle - Freight Trains Leaving Port 14717 Geraldton Port Authority - Dredging Operations 11363 Hillarys Boat Harbour Cross-subsidisation of Operating Costs 14212 Jetties 13474 Pen Fees 13144, 13595, 14034 Wave Attenuator and Breakwater Extension 13351 Pen Fees - Income 13144 Port Authority Boards - Members’ Names and Places of Residence 12030 Rockingham Marina - Government’s Support 14609, 14643 Wyndham - Ord River District Co-op Plant and Buildings 10933 Ports and Marine Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 9518 Second Reading 9518, 12240 Committee 13991-13994 Third Reading 13994 Questions on Notice Answers 2875, 4534, 6086, 6122, 6305, 9028, 11179, 12147, 13911, 14778, 14841 Breach of Standing Orders 6998, 7000, 7013 Relevance - Provision of Answers 4301 Tabling with Production of Documents - Motion 12410 Railways Doodlakine Station - Closure 10093, 10811 Fremantle - Freight Trains Leaving Port 14717 Kalgoorlie - Relocation of Line for Mining Purposes 3904 Loch and Grant Streets Stations - Partial Closure 10749; Statement - Motion 12253, 12254 Manjimup-Bunbury Line - Woodchips Transport 13351 Northbridge Railway Line - Sinking - Allocation of Land to Parks and Affordable Housing 10803 550 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Railways (continued) Perth-Albany Line - Reintroduction 13071, 13147 Safety at Night 9626 Security Personnel - Number 13021 Southern Rail Link Aboriginal Heritage Sites 9356, 12045, 13011 Cost Details 13358 Horseshoe Bridge 10150 Lots 595 and 596, Stakehill Swamp - Acquisition 11177 Murray and Wellington Streets Land Resumptions 11210 Passenger Numbers and Greenhouse Gas Emissions 11610 Risk Assessment Reports - Tabled Papers - Motion 11604 Stations Car Parking Spaces 11042 Car Stealing and Burglary 11042 WA Government Railways Commission - Coach Contracts - Statement - Motion 12254, 12256, 12259 Wubin Rail Line 9848 Road Traffic Amendment Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 12915 Second Reading 12915 Roads Albany Highway - Mt Barker Bypass 11835, 12007 Australian Prospectors and Miners Hall of Fame 6998, 9206, 10775, 10936 Brookton Highway - Kondinin-Corrigin Section 14771 Cape Leveque Road East of Broome to One Arm Point Community 11055 Co-operative Bulk Handling Ltd, Narrakine Storage Facility - Road Safety Concerns 11206 Fremantle-Rockingham Controlled Access Highway - Beeliar Regional Park, Cockburn 10748 Fremantle Eastern Bypass Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme Correction of Answer 14779 Tabling of Documents 14194, 14195 Documents Tabling 13350; Statement 13355 Land Reservations 10366 Sale of Land 10114 Urgency Motion 4895 Value of Highway Reserve 12044 Funding Local Government 10942 Mining and Pastoral Region 10248 Garratt Road Bridge - Vehicle Numbers 10939 Great Eastern Highway, Ascot - Traffic Volume 13483 High Street-Stirling Highway, Fremantle - Turning Lanes 10938 Kalgoorlie Eastern Bypass Road - Realignment - Geotechnical Stability Report 4360 Old Mine Workings 4373, 7328 Leach Highway-Stock Road Intersection Absolon Street, Palmyra 13147 Upgrading 12926, 13024 Mitchell Freeway - Exit to Riverside Drive - Closure 14211 Narrows Bridge - Vehicle Numbers 14046 Northampton-Port Gregory-Kalbarri 12288 Northbridge Tunnel - Daily Average Number of Vehicles 10154 Old Perth Road, Bassendean - Reopening 13125 Roe Highway Extension - Route 12275 Roe Highway Stage 7 - Route 11176 Stage 8 Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme 12009 Land Reservations 10366 Route 12041 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 551

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Roads (continued) South Street, Melville-Fremantle - Coordinated Traffic Lights 10939 Tom Price-Karratha - Funding of Upgrade 10788 William Street - Reduction in Lanes 14211 Rottnest Island Authority Boat Torque Cruises - Outstanding Landing Charges 3727 Funding 4023, 7820 Hotel - Leasing Arrangements 4023 School Bus Services 13357, 13469 Small Business - Improvement Program - Closure 6278 Sport and Recreation Noalimba Recreation Camp - Sale 11361 Pemberton Sports Club - Government Property Purchase 11194 Speedway Commission Western Australian - Statutory Authority 5023 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Sessional Report on Inquiries and Petitions - Second Report 2330 Standing Order No 230 - Amendment - Motion 14695 State Budget - Recurrent Expenditure and Capital Works Programs - Deferment or Cancellation 6995, 6996 State Development, Minister for Letter from Mr K. Bartle, Kalgoorlie - Response 3907 Office Location and Refurbishment and Staff 3064, 3065 Overseas Trips 1969 Visits to South Korea 1969 State Finance Financial Assistance or Incentives to Companies 3066 Tabled Paper 3029 Swan Valley Planning Act 1995 - Review 13860 Tabled Paper No 1450 - Error - Statement 11566 Taxation - Petroleum Resource Rent Tax 10745 Taxi Amendment Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 11579 Second Reading 11579, 13438 Committee 13441-13449, 13475-13477, 13555-13574 Recommittal 13855, 13856 As to Remaining Stages 13990 Third Reading 13990 Taxis Additional Plates - Increases in Categories 9843 Deregulation of Industry - Communication with Commonwealth 10260 Telecommunications - Needs Assessment 12267 Teller and Associates - Dealings with Department 6081 Tourism Long-range Aircraft - Perth Stopovers 2484 Ningaloo Station - Briefing 5972, 5973 United States Servicepersons - Figures of Dollar Worth 10921 Transport Air Long-range Aircraft - Perth Stopovers 2484 Perth International Airport - High Conservation Value Land 14713 Travel Costs - Statement 11607 Buses Contract - Review 13469 Local Government Grants for Bus Stop Infrastructure 14209 School Bus Service Contractors’ Back Pay Arrangements 13357 Replacement of Old Buses 4905 Cycleways - East Perth-Maylands 13359 Department - Mr Neil Winzer- Public Interest Claim 14636 Driver Fatigue - 30 Minute Rest Breaks 9588 Eastern Goldfields Transport Board - Act - Machinery of Government Report 10930 552 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TRAVERS, HON KENNETH DUNSTAN ELDER (continued) Transport (continued) Heavy Haulage Transport Units Enforcement of Road Detours 10250 Escort Pilots 12029, 13078, 13079 Shortage of Drivers for Grain Carting 12004 Mitchell Corporation - Road Trains Compliance with Regulations 12028, 12029 Permits 12028 Safety at Night 9626 Western Australian Export Grain Transportation and Handling Agreement 10154 United States of America Servicepersons’ Worth to Economy of WA 10921 US Navy Sea-swap Operations - Minister’s Visit to United States 9193 Vinnicombe, Dr Patricia - Statement 5760 Waste Control Pty Ltd, Bellevue - Breaches of Dangerous Goods Regulations 13903, 13904 Water Resources Gnangara Park Management Plan - Mining Applications 3023, 3906 Gnangara Water Mound - Ground Water Protection Policy 14026, 14034 Harris River Dam - Worsley Alumina Pty Ltd - Water Allocation 4905 Water Services Coordination Act - Review - Tabling by Leader of the House - Motion 12415; Amendment to Motion 12427 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 11823 Second Reading 11823 Western Australian Planning Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13885 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 Receipt and First Reading 9048 Second Reading 9048 Wittenoom Clean-up Operations 6278 Purchase of Properties 3471 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 Receipt and First Reading 1033 Second Reading 1033, 1655, 1663 Third Reading 1665

TRENORDEN, MR MAXWELL WAYNE, Leader of the National Party (Avon) (NPA) Aborigines - Mental Health Services - Funding Cuts 11905 Address-in-Reply Motion Health 313 Liquefied Natural Gas Contract 311 Northam PCYC 312 Regional Investment Fund 313 Rural Western Australia 311 Speed Limit 313 Young, Hamish 311 Amendment to Motion - Water Shortages 222 Adjournment of the House - Complimentary Remarks 4152 Agriculture Department - South Perth 4701 Midland Saleyards - Position Paper 3707 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Health 7715 National Action Plan for Salinity and Water Quality 7721 Perth-Mandurah Rail Line 7715 Police 7721 Roads 7719 Taxes 7714 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 553

TRENORDEN, MR MAXWELL WAYNE (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7714 Auditor General, Office of the 11715, 12331 Australian Labor Party - Election Policy - Regional WA 10028 Bali Bombings - Condolence Motion - 1749 Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Second Reading -11930 Bateman, Mr Thomas Henry - Condolence Motion 11893 Bills Lapsed Restoration to Notice Paper 73 Council’s Message - Amendment to Motion 389 Council’s Message - Motion 387 Broome Port - Upgrading 3495, 3496 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1509 Business of the House Closing Days of Session - Standing Orders Suspension - Motion 13679 Private Members’ Business - Standing Orders Suspension 14078 Cabinet - Meetings - Government’s Election Promise - Motion 6020 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6739 Consideration in Detail 6876, 6889; Dissent from Deputy Speaker’s Ruling 6899 Third Reading 6929 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 7382 Civil Liability Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1087 Cole Royal Commission - Matter of Public Interest 5842 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 Declaration as Urgent 3104 Introduction and First Reading 2259 Second Reading 2284, 3129 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 4619 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5110 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Receipt - Speaker’s Ruling - Motion 14901; Standing Orders Suspension 14897 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8165 Country Alliance - Matter of Privilege - Motion 1185; Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1193 Country High School Hostels - Fee Gap 4702 Crane, Mr Albert Victor - Condolence Motion 10156 Cunningham, Mr Edward Joseph - Condolence Motion 13178 Drought Assistance 1198, 1199, 2927 Economic Impact 3930 Electricity Charges - Reduction 3931 Dental Prosthetists Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 13681 Second Reading 13722 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 Second Reading 5133 Consideration in Detail 5357, 5359, 5361, 5375, 5376 Electoral Legislation - Supreme Court Decision - High Court Challenge 2927 Reform - Solicitor General’s Advice 2005 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 Second Reading 13246 Consideration in Detail 13507 Emergency Services Levy Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2201 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 531 Report of Legislation Committee 2415 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2201 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Deletion from MRS - Amendment to Motion 13622 Fuel and Energy Cockburn Gas-fired Power Station 9663, 9664 Country Power Supplies 5449 554 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TRENORDEN, MR MAXWELL WAYNE (continued) Fuel and Energy (continued) Damp ier-Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline 10286, 10287; Motion 6833 Epic Energy 7520, 7521 Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator 7225, 7226, 10163 Gallop Labor Government - Failure to Govern - Motion 3517 Government Departments and Agencies - Staff - Redundancy Packages 694 Government Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 12331 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 1581, 1717, 1718 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1509 Hancock, Mr Lang - Statement 4111 Health Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA Former Minister for Health - Matter of Public Interest 9680 Select Committee - Motion 10311 Budget - Spending Levels 5172 Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11913 Country Health Services Review - Budget Allocation 9501 Crisis in System - Matter of Public Interest 5100 Department Annual Reporting Procedures - Investigation 7360 Annual Reports and Auditor General’s Qualified Audit Opinion 13274 Key Performance Indicators and Annual Reports 5086 District Health Advisory Councils - Consultation Program 6490 Esperance Doctor to Provide Services to Norseman - Budget Allocation 9503 Funding Cuts 11959, 12611 Health Reform Committee - Budget Allocation 9501 Management of Health System - Matter of Public Interest 11638 Medical Services Agreement - Signing 7923 Mental Health System Aboriginal Services - Funding Cuts 11905 Funding Matter of Public Interest 11262 Programs 10822, 10823 Health Consumers’ Council of WA - Funding Cuts 12203 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petitions 6344 Nurses Additional Positions 7676 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” - Motion 1213 Priority Issues - Matter of Public Interest 6820 Reform Committee - Cost and Reports 10495 Regional Areas - Prevention and Promotion Programs - Budget Allocation 9503 Rural and Regional Services - Budget Allocation 9497, 9503, 9504 South West Health Service - Staff 11111 Wheatbelt District Health Advisory Council - Meetings - Reimb ursement of Costs 12065 HIH Insurance Collapse - Costs to the State 5171 Home Building Contracts Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Message - Motion 1495 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Motion 387; Amendment to Motion 389 Hospitals Country Closure or Downgrading 4862, 4863 Geraldton Regional 13199, 13200, 13610 Moora District - Matter of Public Interest 13209 Northampton District - Services 10963, 11624 Wheatbelt - Fundraising Proceeds 14075 King Edward Memorial Hospital for Women - Medical Legal Actions - Cost 5172 Princess Margaret Hospital for Children -Medical Legal Actions - Cost 5172 Royal Perth - Norrish, Mrs Sanchia - Death - Motion 13723 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 12754-12757 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 555

TRENORDEN, MR MAXWELL WAYNE (continued) Industrial Development Burrup Peninsula - Development 917, 918 Projects at Risk Due to Southern Rail Link Budget Blow-out 917, 918 Industrial Relations Cole Royal Commission Findings - Matter of Public Interest 5842 Government Leadership - Matter of Public Interest 10976 Information Commissioner - Matter of Public Interest 12331 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 622 Consideration in Detail 638-663, 1098-1120 Referral to Public Accounts Committee 1121 Iraq War - Support for Australian Defence Personnel - Amendment to Motion 5443; Standing Orders Suspension 5440 Law and Order - Matter of Public Interest 3687 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2012 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Matter of Public Interest 12696 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate - 13961 Matters Appearing in Hansard - Personal Explanation 6934 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion 10543 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4868; Standing Orders Suspension - Amendment to Motion 4865 Metropolitan Region Scheme Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Amendment to Motion 13622 Michael, Dr Ken - Ministerial Advice 7225 Ministers of the Crown Attorney General - Visits to the UK and Elsewhere in Europe - Statement 498 Minister for State Development - Overseas Trips 2056 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4580 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No.2) 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5472 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 5472 National Competition Council - Payments - Standing Orders Suspension 12471; Motion 12480 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12345 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3502 Owen, Mr Raymond Cecil - Condolence Motion 4549 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations - Matter of Public Interest 12331 Police Community Operations - Motion 4775 Northam Station - Grievance 5685 Pay Dispute - Matter of Public Interest 10976 Pollution - Chemicals - Quantities Storage Transportation and Disposal 12808 Public Accounts Committee Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14220; Standing Orders Suspension 14221 Matter of Privilege - Motion 1185; Dissent from Speaker’s Ruling 1193 Questions on Notice - Unanswered 3353 Questions without Notice - Standing Orders Suspension 13389 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6363 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6363 Consideration in Detail 7075-7089, 7210-7220 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6363 Consideration in Detail 7231, 7233 Third Reading 7234 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6363 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 960 Council’s Amendments 3507, 3508, 3509 Railways Southern Rail Link Cost and Annual Value of Community Service Obligation 399, 400 Cost Blow-out - Amendment to Motion 13939 Matter of Public Interest 1592, 2938 Rolling Stock 279, 280 556 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

TRENORDEN, MR MAXWELL WAYNE (continued) Railways (continued) Southern Rail Link (continued) State Debt Structure 917, 918 William Street Buildings 1050, 1051 Urban Rail Development - Acquisition of Property 604, 605, 1465, 1588 Regional Development Government’s Policy 512 Projects and Services - Matter of Public Interest 13209 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Declaration as Urgent 7900 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours 8179, 8180 Small Business Development Corporation - Deregulation of Retail Trading Hours 8179, 8180 State Budget - Surplus - Review of the Effective Delivery of Government Priorities 1710 State Finance Commonwealth Grants Commission - Funding Cut 4747 Taxes and Charges - Increases - Matter of Public Interest 7037 Teachers Pay Rise - Matter of Public Interest 10976 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3534 Transport - Country and Metropolitan - Funding 4802 Trowbridge, Rear Admiral Sir Richard John - Condolence Motion 7514 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion 387; Amendment to Motion 389 Council’s Message - Motion 1495 Water Corporation - Forecast Dividend 87 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13961 Western Power Bowey Property Kulin 10028 Electricity Supplies - Contingency Arrangements 12686, 12687 Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5455 Inquiry into Infrastructure and Customer Service - Motion 12492 Wheatbelt Community Drug Service Team 6647, 6648 Woodchip Mill - Donnybrook 2522 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 943 Yallingup Foreshore Land Bill 2002 Reinstatement on Notice Paper - Council’s Message - Motion 387; Amendment to Motion 389 Council’s Message - Motion 1495

WALDRON, MR TERRENCE KEITH (Wagin) (NPA) Acts Amendment (Carbon Rights and Tree Plantation Agreements) Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2280 Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10186 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2533 Consideration in Detail 2802, 2804 Address-in-Reply - Motion Seasonal Conditions 196 Water Resources 196 One Vote, One Value 197 Roads 197 Mental Illness 198 Police 198 Education 198 Sport 199 Volunteers 200 Adjournment of the House - Complimentary Remarks 9465, 14304 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1895 Agriculture Agriculture Protection Board - Select Committee - Motion 7243 Department - Select Committee - Motion 7243 State Budget Initiatives 9787 Wagin Electorate - Agricultural Shows and Festivals - Statement 13807 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 9129 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 557

WALDRON, MR TERRENCE KEITH (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Education 7579 Health - Funding 7583 Infill Sewerage Program - Regional Towns 7582 Police Services 7584 Road Funding 7581 Sky Jetty Project 7582 Sport and Recreation Facilities Fund 7584 Water Shortages 7582 Wellington Dam - Salinity 7583 Third Reading Health Budget 8476 Power Supplies - Country Areas 8476 Road Funding 8477 Southern Rail link 8475 Stamp Duty 8475 Taxes and Charges - Increases 8475 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7579 Australian Broadcasting Corporation - Broadcasting Studio Wagin - Statement 10021 Bulk Handling Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1574 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6713 Consideration in Detail 6875 Council’s Amendments 11663, 11667, 11668 Carbon Rights Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2280 Colleges of TAFE Corporate Services - Centralisation 3780 Lecturers Certified Agreement 14486 Constitution Acts Amendment (Voting Ability in the Houses of Parliament) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3104 Contaminated Sites Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 5566, 5567, 5570, 5571, 5587 Third Reading 6670 Crime Prevention Structures Review Report - Statement 8961 Drugs Life Education Preventive Health Program - Funding Cut 12761 Regional Areas - Drug Teams 8893 East Perth Power Station Site - Funding - 13812 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5386 Education Compulsory Schooling for Years 11 and 12 9784 Duty of Care for Students Policy 14485 Languages other than English Program - Grievance 7331 State Budget Initiatives 9783 Teachers Language other than English 6339 Pay Rise - Motion 11418 Permanency 11396; Grievance 3197 Relief Teachers in Country Schools 11703 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13231 Environment - Landcare Conference - Statement 12197 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1470 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 Referral to Community Development and Justice Standing Committee 2267 Fire Management in the Western Australian Environment - Motion 2711 Forests and Forestry Forest Products Commission Plantation Forestry - Strategic Afforestation in Agricultural Zone 9788 Treasury Performance Indicators 5622 Jarrah, Karri and Marri - Total Quota Request 5892 Social and Economic Impact of WA Forests Report - Alterations 5622 558 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WALDRON, MR TERRENCE KEITH (continued) Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 8832 Consideration in Detail 8841-8845 Council’s Amendments 14914, 14915 Gordon Inquiry 10053, 11815 Grain Marketing Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 1574 Health Escalating Crisis - Matter of Public Interest 3789 Funding Association of Relatives and Friends of the Mentally Ill 11254 Continence Aids 13309 Life Education Preventive Health Program 12761 Matter of Public Interest 14889 Mental Health System - Petition 12166 Regional Areas 8791, 8792 Health Reform Committee - Membership Terms of Reference and Report 9510 Mental Health Web Site 8967 Heritage - William and Wellington Streets Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12090 Higher Education Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8849 Hospitals Admissions - Percentage from Regional Areas 9511 Bed Crisis 9422 Country - Improved Facilities 9087 Dumbleyung District Memorial 13521, 13698 Elective Surgery - Waiting Times - Matter of Public Interest 14889 Port Hedland 14881 Teaching - Limit on Number of New Patients 8442 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11758 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 628 Consideration in Detail 646 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation - City of Perth Local Laws - Fourth Report 1726 Loan Bill 2003 Second Reading Drugs 10977 Road Funding 10978 Tourism 10979 Sport and Recreation 10979 Machinery of Government (Water Resources) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate - 13963 Matthews, Frederick Noel - Statement 14248 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion, as Amended 10558; Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10683 Member for Avon - Leave of Absence 8875 Member for Swan Hills - Leave of Absence 746 Motor Vehicle Dealers Amendment Bill (No.2) 2002 - Council’s Amendment 14137 Motor Vehicle Repairers Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 8947, 8948 MRS Amendment - Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Motion 423; Motion for Disallowance 14121 O’Donnell, Mrs Anne - Churchill Scholarship - Statement 9416 Plant Pests and Diseases (Eradication Funds) Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 12177 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 5864 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6378 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6378 Consideration in Detail 7082, 7084 Council’s Amendments 8905-8907 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6378 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6378 Rail Link, Southern Openness and Accountability - Matter of Public Interest 1596 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 559

WALDRON, MR TERRENCE KEITH (continued) Rail Link, Southern (continued) William and Wellington Streets Heritage Precinct - Amendment to Motion 12090 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 1062 Standing Orders Suspension 1335 Consideration in Detail 1344, 1346, 1347 Third Reading 1375 Roads Collie-Darkan and Corrigin-Hyden - Safety Concerns - Grievance 12167 Fremantle Eastern Bypass - MRS - Motion 423; Motion for Disallowance 14121 Road Safety - Resources - Matter of Public Interest 8016 Schools Country High School Hostels Authority - Fees 3675 Darkan District High - Vision Day - Statement by Member for Wagin 6180 District High - Review 5582 Level 3 - Staffing Formula Changes 773 Maintanance - Budget Allocations 5622 Program Maintenance Works Funds - Cuts 4106 Regional Areas 5369, 11703 Yearlering Primary - Statement 4100 Select Committee into Department of Agriculture and Agriculture Protection Board - Motion 7243 Sewerage - Infill Sewerage Program - Select Committee - Establishment - Motion 2305 Sport and Recreation Australian Football League - Statements 4845, 8721 Narrogin Leisure Centre - Statement 1705 Noalimba Recreation Camp 2818 Panizza, Mr Darrell - Statement 11776 State Budget Agriculture Initiatives 9787 Education Initiatives 9783 Tourism Heartlands Regional Tourism Awards - Statement 507, 10672 Portfolio - Elevation of Status - Matter of Public Interest 2831 Tree Plantation Agreements Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 2280 Volunteers (Protection from Liability) Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 2840, 2841 Wagin Historical Village - Statement 2001 Wandering Festival - Statement 7356 Water Resources AQ2 Pty Ltd - Awards for Excellence - Statement 3224 Wellington Dam - Cost-benefit Analysis of Sending Water to Metropolitan Area 6812 Water Resources Management (Administration) Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13963 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11289 Western Australian Meat Marketing Co-operative Limited (Shares) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5393 Western Australian Tourism Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8879 Western Power Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5456 Inquiry into Infrastructure and Customer Service - Motion 12501

WALKER, MS SUSAN ELIZABETH, BJuris, LLB (Nedlands) (Lib) Aborigines - Onslow - Protection of Children and Women 8178 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 Second Reading 4601 Consideration in Detail 8987-8991 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3960 Consideration in Detail 3963-3967 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 Second Reading 2546 Consideration in Detail 2834, 2839, 2943, 2947, 2948, 2958 Third Reading 2975 560 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WALKER, MS SUSAN ELIZABETH (continued) Address-in-Reply - Motion Bali Bombing 2184 Heritage Issues - Subiaco 2184-2188 Sunset Hospital Site - Sale 2184 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3239-3244 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate Mental Health Services - Lack of Funding 7576-7579 Premium Property Tax - Government Attitude 7573 Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital - Insufficient Funding 7573 Sunset Hospital Site - Sale 7573-7576 Taxes and Charges - Increases Under Gallop Government 7574, 7575 Underground Power 7579 Third Reading - Child Abuse 8473 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 7573 Australian Labor Party - Lawrence, Dr Carmen - Election to Federal Presidency 13202 Beachside Cafe, Albany - Investigation 2169 Cannabis Decriminalisation - Cultivation of up to Two Cannabis Plants 6646 Youth Suicide 6815 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6656 Consideration in Detail 6753, 6754, 6772-6775, 6793-6807, 6850, 6857-6862, 6867, 6872- 6875, 6878-6880, 6894, 6903, 6911, 6915 Dissent from Deputy Speaker’s Ruling 6899 Council’s Amendments 11662-11667 City Beach High School - Special Education Unit - Grievance 11499 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 - Council’s Amendments 12594 Commonwealth Powers (De Facto Relationships) Bill 2003 Second Reading 14065 Third Reading 14079 Community Development Child Abuse Government Inaction - Matter of Public Interest 9091 Select Committee into Child Abuse in Western Australia - Establishment - Motion 2295; Amendment to Motion 2286 Child Card - Funding 9085 Commissioner for Children - Appointment 8603 Department - Funerals 9512 Family Violence - Police Reports 9089 Community Development and Justice Standing Committee - Annual Report 2001-02 1689 Coral Bay Bills Bay - Protection of Environment 818 CALM Rangers - Number 816 Commercial Marine Nature-based Tourism Licences 815 Land Vested in CALM 816 Leach Drains and Sewerage Ponds - Impact 1395 Marine Parks and Reserves Authority Responsibility 818 Moorings - New 817; Number 817 Ningaloo Marine Park - Damage from Mooring and Anchoring Activities 819 Public Meeting and Fish and Coral Deaths 820 Rehabilitation 820 Rubbish Dump, Sewerage Outlets and Community Fishing Tables 820 Visit by Minister for the Environment and Heritage 819 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 10947 Consideration in Detail 10956-10960, 11127-11134, 11137, 11138 Criminal Code Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Consideration in Detail 14263-14271 Criminal Injuries Compensation Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 9858 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 561

WALKER, MS SUSAN ELIZABETH (continued) Criminal Injuries Compensation Amendment Bill 2003 (continued) Second Reading 9890 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 Second Reading 12352 Consideration in Detail 12354-12367, 12370-12373 Third Reading 12599 Criminal Law (Procedure) Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendments 1389 Domestic Violence Grievance 9389 Involvement of Children - Police Reports 9089 Electricity Corporations Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13650 Electricity Legislation (Amendments and Transitional Provisions) Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13650 Fines, Penalties and Infringement Notices Enforcement Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 3959 Health Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11912 Neurotrauma Research Program - Petitions 6344 North Metropolitan Population Health Division - Funding Cut 12688 Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation Select Committee - Amendment to Motion 10613 Heritage - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 521 Hollywood Functional Rehabilitation Clinic - Statement 10413 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11761 Division of Bill - Motion 11770 Consideration in Detail 12730, 12732 Indigenous Affairs, Department of - Regional Offices - Closure 8005 Industrial Relations Legislation - Tourism Industry 1590; Motion 1603 Information Commissioner - Amalgamation with Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations 12199 Inspector of Custodial Services Bill 2003 Second Reading 12707 Consideration in Detail 12715-12718 Jolliffe, Mr Ted - The Samaritans - Statement 11106 Juries Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 5999 Consideration in Detail 6008, 6009, 6189-6191 Third Reading 6496 Justice, Department of High-risk Offenders - Review of Management Practices 12605, 12607, 12608 Parole Board Matters - Portfolio Responsibility 14073, 14074 Parole Conditions 10282 Breaches 10283, 10415, 12608 Mitchell, Mr Russell James 10494, 10495 Parolees High-risk - Motion 11408 Reduced Imprisonment Strategy 12606 Serious Offenders - Forensic Psychiatric Assessments 10416; Imprisonment 10415, 10417 Justices of the Peace - Elsegood, Mr John - Grievance 480 Legal Practice Bill 2002 Second Reading 4591 Consideration in Detail 5733-5752, 8887, 8888, 8897-8901, 8960, 8961, 8971-8983 Council’s Amendments 13543-13545 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2018 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11809 Aged Care 11810 Live Sheep Exports to Saudi Arabia 11810 Mental Health Funding 11812 Nannup Flower and Garden Festival 11811 Rio Tinto WA Future Fund 11809 Small Business Registration Cost 11809 Sunset Site Sale 11810 “The Kids’ Science State” 11809 562 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WALKER, MS SUSAN ELIZABETH (continued) Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11809 (continued) Use of Corporate Credit Cards by Depart ment of Justice 11811 Local Government Heritage Areas - Rights of Landowners - Matter of Public Interest 521 Seniors’ Rate Rebates - Grievance 5333 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion, as Amended 10580; Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10605 Leader of the Opposition - Censure Motion 4875 Personal Explanations Fraudulent Behaviour by Members of Parliament 9395 Member for Perth’s Comments 9426, 9442 Mickelberg Case Appeal - Minister for Health - Evidence 2009, 2010, 2276 Lewandowski Affidavit Attorney General - Documents Given to Minister for Health 600 Government Discussions 516 Letter from the Director of Public Prosecutions to Raymond Mickelberg 914 Minister for Health Discussions with and Copies to Staff 1306 Use of Ministerial Office 1312 Reassessment by Special Interagency Unit 7029 Police Royal Commission - Reopening of Investigation 767, 769 Ministers of the Crown Attorney General Decisions on Matters Involving Allegations of Criminal Behaviour by Cabinet Members - Motion 785 Visits to the United Kingdom and Europe - Statement 497 Minister for Tourism - Attendance at Tourism Functions 3928, 3929 Ningaloo Marine Park CALM’s Responsibility 815 Damage from Mooring and Anchoring Activities 819 Northbridge - Curfew for Juveniles 6809 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations - Amalgamation with Office of the Information Commissioner 12199 Planning Mabel Talbot Park and Henderson Park Reserves - Grievance 3200 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands - Petitions 6345, 7206, 8931, 9669, 11259 Police Family Violence - Reports to Department for Community Development 9089 Government’s Pre-election Promises - Motion 14093 Prosecutions - Reassessment by Special Interagency Unit 7029 Warnbro Shooting Incident - Parole Conditions 10281, 10282 Police Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3924, 3933 Consideration in Detail 3941-3946, 4082 Prisons Acacia - Alert List 6487, 6489 Bandyup - Alert List 6487, 6489 Broome Regional 13815 Hakea Alert List 6487, 6489 Drug Management Strategy 6683 Enoch, Mr Jeff 7885, 7886 Nyandi Prison Redevelopment Motion 5276, 5593, 5618 Swan Village of Care 5580 Policy to Reduce Prison Population - Risk to Community - Matter of Public Interest 10502 Video Games - Review - Motion 11408 Prisons Amendment Bill 2002 - Council’s Amendment 6500, 6501 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8707 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 563

WALKER, MS SUSAN ELIZABETH (continued) Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 7904-7911 Council’s Amendments 8031-8033, 8038 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13785 Ripley, Mr Julian Further Information on Conviction 25, 86, 282 Letter from Mr Rupert Gerritsen 2926 Reassessment of Prosecution by Special Interagency Unit 7029 Royal Commission Into Whether There Has Been Any Corrupt or Criminal Conduct by Western Australian Police Officers - Government’s Pre-election Commitment 3494 Select Committee into the Western Australian Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation Amendment to Motion 10613 Seniors - Council Rebates - Grievance 5333 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 Second Reading 2664, 2686, 2981 Consideration in Detail 3245-3255, 3635-3640, 3643-3645, 3648-3668, 3692 Third Reading 3694 Sentencing Legislation - Six-year Sentences - Parole 2674 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 Second Reading 2665, 2676 Consideration in Detail 3635, 3696, 3699-3702 Third Reading 3703 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 10009, 10012, 10013, 10016, 10017, 10035-10048 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Consideration in Detail 10294-10298, 10395-10397 State Law Publisher - Internet Site - Petition 1053 Sustainability Strategy - Agencies 11253 Swan River Matter of Public Interest 8808 Riverplan - Management Plan 8890 Swan Village of Care - Nyandi Prison Redevelopment 5580; Motion 5593, 5618 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3539 Consideration in Detail 3550, 3552, 3553 Tourism Lack of Government Support - Motion 1603 Licences - Coral Bay 815 Portfolio - Elevation of Status - Matter of Public Interest 2825 Workplace Relations Legislation - Impact 1590; Motion 1603 Transport Licensing Centres - Shenton Park - Closure - Grievance 10641 Universities - Guild Fees - Compulsory - Petition 2930 US Navy Sea-swap Operations - Petition 5559 Victims of Crime Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 9295 Consideration in Detail 11087-11098 Third Reading 11407, 11508 Volunteers - Consultation on Government Policy Decisions 11900 Water Resources - Management - Auditor General’s Report 11252 Wellington Surplus Stores - Sale of Knives - Statement 5713 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 - Consideration in Detail 11407 Youth Suicide - Cannabis Use 6815

WATSON, HON GIZ, BSc (North Metropolitan) (GWA) Aborigines Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA - Inquiry into Funding - Establishment of Select Committee - Motion 14016; Amendments to Motion 14017 Aboriginal Health, Office of Budget and Expenditure 2647 Funding Cut 4345 Management Review 2779 Statement 10098 564 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WATSON, HON GIZ (continued) Aborigines (continued) Aboriginal Health, Office of (continued) Xanthis, Mr Colin - Legal Fees 1659, 2484, 9583 Aboriginal Visitors Scheme in Prisons - Budget Cut 712 Bringing Them Home Report 9193, 9648, 9656 Homelessness 1263, 2157 Mental Health Services - Derbarl Yerrigan Health Service - Closure 12008 Sorry Day - Statement 8570 Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Closure 7825 Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13136 Committee 13154-13163 Acts Amendment (Equality of Status) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6245 Address-in-Reply - Motion Climate Change 1536, 1538 Commonwealth Parliamentary Association - Paper Delivered 1535 Governor’s Speech 1535 Greenhouse Emissions 1540-1542 Kyoto Protocol 1538, 1539 Pacific Island Communities 1537 Adjournment of the House - Complimentary Remarks 4542 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 Second Reading 5213, 5299 Committee 5305-5307 Airport - Perth - High Conservation Value Land 14713 Animal Welfare Local Government Laws Controlling the Welfare of Cats 6467 Unit - Membership 7012 Animal Welfare Bill 2001 - Order of Business - Amendment to Motion 2726 Anzac Day Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13340 Australian Labor Party - Northbridge Retailers - Donations 10365 Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13058 BHP Billiton - Radioactive Material Disposal 10115 Building Industry - Government Construction Contracts - Urgency Motion 7302 Burswood Property Trust - Corporatisation - Statement by Minister for Racing and Gaming 12263 Cat Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 14753 Second Reading 14753 Censorship Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6556 Child Support (Adoption of Laws) Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 3464 Child Welfare Amendment Bill 2001 - Third Reading 471 Conservation and Land Management Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 3735-3744 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Whales and Marine Mammals - Fee for Films and Photographs 2605, 3474 Coroners Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6088 Corporal Punishment - Convicted Offenders Amendment to Motion 10231 Statement 10256 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Committee 14763-14769 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment Bill 2003 - Committee 14749-14753 Corruption and Crime Commission Bill 2003 - Instruction to Committee of the Whole 9368 Criminal Injuries Compensation Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13332, 13867 Criminal Law (Procedure) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1022 Curfew for Juveniles in Northbridge 7175, 9849, 9974, 10365, 10923 Cycleways Cyclists Riding on Roads Adjacent to Shared Cycleways 10380 Perth Bicycle Network - Completion 8414 Disability Services - Labour Relations Reforms - Impact 467 Domestic Violence Unit, Joondalup - Reduction in Numbers 2873, 3175 East Perth Power Station Site - Future Use Proposals 1167-1169 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 565

WATSON, HON GIZ (continued) Enright, Mr Nick - Statement 6283 Environment Bushland Management - Adjournment Debate 4986 Environmental Health Foundation - Establishment 11177, 11205 Environmental Health Standards 10782 Four-wheel-drive Vehicles - Advertising Depicting Damage to Environment 1140, 1848 Gnangara Land Use and Water Management Strategy 1742, 1844 Gnangara Mound - Threatened Species 1845 Gnangara Park Management Plan - Finalisation 1743 Perth Airport - High Conservation Value Land 14713 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Committee 10212-10225 Equal Opportunity Commission WA - Gay and Lesbian Liaison Officers - Appointment 13595 Family Court Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 568 Fines, Penalties and Infringement Notices Enforcement Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 6257 Fisheries Commercial - Licences to Trap Herring on South Coast 6955 Cottesloe Reef - Fish Habitat Protection Area 10812, 12666 Dusky Whaler Sharks - Conservation Status 1843, 3439 Fish Habitat Protection Area - Volunteer Program - Funding 10812 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2002 - Clause 5 - Disallowance Motion 1643 Fish Resources Management Amendment Regulations (No 8) 2003 - Disallowance Motion 14583 Houtman Abrolhos - Green Paper 3286 Shark Fishing 8675, 13120 Turtle Exclusion Devices on Vessels 11041 Whales and Marine Mammals - Fee for Films and Photographs 2605, 3474 Gnangara Land Use and Management Plan 1742, 1743, 1844 Government Construction Contracts - Limit on Number and Value of Contracts Awarded - Urgency Motion 7302 Greens (WA) - Salary Increases - Adjournment Debate 871 Health Aborigines Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation, WA - Funding - Establishment of Select Committee - Motion 14016; Amendments to Motion 14017 Derbarl Yerrigan Health Service - Closure 12008 Benlate Systemic Fungicide 11479 Biala Psychiatric Hostel - Licensing 9 Community Midwifery Program 4048, 14035, 14724, Environmental Health Foundation - Establishment 11177, 11205 Environmental Health Standards 10782 HIV Strategy - Implementation 8415 Mental Health Funding - Petition 13088 Government Commitment 10093 System 9564 Multiple Chemical Sensitivity - Petition 229 National Maternity Action Plan - Adjournment Debate 1446 Non-government Health Organisations - Review 13350 Not-for-profit Organisations - Funding Cuts 12142, 12290, 13143 Occupational Therapists - Prohibition under the Act from Displaying Accreditation 3194 Patient-assisted Travel Scheme - Interstate 13008 Phoenix 8363, 9198 Prisoners - Transfer of Responsibility 4398, 4447 Q Fever - Number of Cases 10250 Sexual Health - Funding 11603 Smoking Cost to Health System of Smoking-related Diseases 9565 Enclosed Public Spaces 10747, 11075, 11837, 12965 NOHSC Guidance Note on the Elimination of Environmental Tobacco Smoke in the Workplace 12269 Regulations Cabarets, Nightclubs, Hotels and Bars 14211 Exemptions 9359, 11242 566 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WATSON, HON GIZ (continued) Health (continued) Smoking (continued) Regulations (continued) Marketplace Inequity 10815 Review 9565, 9567, 10381, 10481 Smoke-free Workplaces 10790 Heritage Duncraig House - Sale - Petitions 537 Payment for Work Undertaken within Government Departments 4431 Places and Projects 875, 2762 WA Heritage Council - Development Applications - Negotiation and Approval 4432 Heritage of Western Australia Act 1990 - Review 738 Homeswest Buckland Hill Properties - Undertaking to Purchase 3338 Discrimination Complaints 866, 3772 Homosexuality Discrimination - Community Education 13473, 14608, 14610 Gay and Lesbian Liaison Officers at Equal Opportunity Commission - Appointment 13595 Lesbian and Gay Law Reform 13473, 14608, 14610 Hospitals Derby Regional - Staffing Arrangements 1419 Graylands - Murchison Ward Patients 13072, 14046 Medical and Surgical Registrars - Impaired Performance Risk 5051 Teaching - Overspending 4345 Housing Homelessness 1263, 2157, 14048 Northbridge Railway Line Sinking - Allocation of Land to Parks and Affordable Housing 10803 Housing and Works, Department of Chief Executive Officer - Salary Package 552 Construction Contracts Policy - Urgency Motion 7302 Heritage Work - Payment 4431 Industrial Relations Reforms - Impact on Agencies 467 Inspector of Custodial Services Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14578 International Human Rights Day - Statement 14719 Iraq War Australia’s Support for United States Military Action - Motion 3137, 3423 Opposition - Adjournment Debate 5670 Islamic Schools - Education Standards 5810 Juries Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6948 Labour Relations Reform Bill 2002 -Impact on Agencies 467 Law Reform (Contributory Negligence and Tortfeasors’ Contribution) Amendment Bill 2001 - Second Reading 6317 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 13136 Legislative Assembly and Legislative Council - Recurrent Funding 14774 Local Government Cats - Laws Controlling the Welfare of 6467 Executive Officers - Guidelines for Employment 4534 Joondalup, City of Chief Executive - Smith, Mr Denis Ian 4293, 4344, 6583, 7478 Meeting - Police Presence 14194 Suspension 13858 Motor Vehicles - Four-wheel-drive - Advertising Depicting Damage to Environment 1140, 1848 Murphy Interest - Petition 537 Native Title Combined Metropolitan Working Group’s Application Mediation 10803 Wand Report - Recommendations 4028 Nuclear Activities (Prohibition) Bill 2002 Introduction and First Reading 1144 Second Reading 1144, 7819 Introduction and Purpose 246 Mining of Uranium 350, 1563 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 567

WATSON, HON GIZ (continued) Nuclear Activities (Prohibition) Bill 2002 (continued) Statement 7833 Nuclear Power Stations - Prohibition Legislation 164 Nuclear Waste Storage (Prohibition) Act - Loopholes in Legislation 42 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5642 Offshore Minerals Bill 2001 - Committee 5924-5927 Parks and Reserves Jurien Bay Marine Park Order 2003 - Motion for Disallowance 14663 Neerabup National Park 6299, 8398, 8414, 8578, 8579 Parliamentary Counsel’s Office - Legislative Drafting Professionals 14637 Pine Plantation - Resource Plans - Statement by Minister for Forestry and Fisheries - Motion 12263 Planning Burns Beach, Lot 2 5956, 6082, 6089, 7837, 8414 Bushplan-Bush Forever 1737, 1839 Heathcote Site 537, 4202, 4257, 4343, 4432 Metropolitan Region Scheme - Amendment No 992/33 - Clarkson-Butler - Disallowance 14820 Sunset Hospital, Nedlands 552, 3471, 3472, 3713, 7271, 1007 Wireless Hill Park - Land Excision - Petition 12634, 12968 Police Cyclists Riding on Roads Adjacent to Shared Cycleways 10380 DNA Testing - Budget Allocation 877 Joondalup - Police Presence at Council Meeting 14194 Police Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 5426 Prisons Aboriginal Visitors Scheme - Budget Cut 712 Bandyup - Restraints on Prisoners Attending Medical Appointments 7311 Banksia Hill - Staff and Detainee Numbers 7008 Biometric Identification System - Trial 7011 Death in Custody 7451 Indigenous Prisoners - Homelessness 1263 Nyandi - Aboriginal Women 10940 Prisoners Health - Transfer of Responsibility 4398, 4447 Payment of Funeral Expenses 10778 Rangeview Remand Centre 7008, 10935 Roebourne Regional - Inspector of Custodial Services Report 5313 Prisons Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 6057 Committee 6295, 6296 Prostitution - Soliciting in Public Places - Fremantle 7648 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8766 Railway Line - Northbridge - Sinking - Allocation of Land to Parks and Affordable Housing 10803 Refugees - Unaccompanied Minors - Memorandum of Understanding 9026 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 - Assembly’s Message 8392 Residential Tenancies Act 1987 - Review 3027 Rottnest Island - Boating Community - Grey and Black Water Disposal 13069 Select Committee on Advocacy for Children (Appointment of a Commissioner for Children) - Establishment Amendment to Motion 7642, 8547 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 Second Reading Discharged and Referral to Legislation Committee 4501 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9166 Committee 9363-9367 Sentencing Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2002 Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 4500 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9166 Sewerage Rottnest Island - Boating Community 13069 Subiaco Waste Water Treatment Plant - Sewage Outfall at Swanbourne Beach 1456 Smoke-free Workplaces - Government Policy 9628 Standing Committee on Environment and Public Affairs - Swimming Pool Fencing - Adjournment Debate 4986 568 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WATSON, HON GIZ (continued) Standing Committee on Legislation Sentencing Bills - Report - Extension of Time 4994, 6944 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 - Extension of Time 6944; Report 8348 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 - Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 11196 State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Order Discharged and Referral to Standing Committee on Legislation 11196 Statutes (Repeals and Minor Amendments) Bill 2001 - Second Reading 12245 Stephenson Highway Road Reserves 3612, 3871, 4935 Swimming Pools - Isolation Fencing - Adjournment Debate 4986 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Report of Standing Committee on Uniform Legislation and General Purposes - Amendment to Motion 3856 Standing Orders Suspension 3864, 4304 Second Reading 4330 Tourism - Wildlife Interaction Permits - Number Issued 1840 US Navy Sea-swap Operations 5024, 5537, 6282, 8397, 9556 Uranium Mining 5663, 5775, 7012 Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Bill 2002 - Second Reading 573 Volunteers - Not-for-profit Health Organisations - Funding Cuts 12142, 12290, 13143 Waller, Mr Barry Granville - False Allegation - Petition 537 Wildlife Conservation (Fauna Protection) Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 7481

WATSON, MR PETER BRUCE (Albany) (ALP) Address-in-Reply - Motion Albany - Limited Water Supply 302, 303 Australian Constitution 301 Driving - First Aid Courses for New Drivers 301; Use of Lights on Country Roads 301 Live Sheep Trade - Impact on Local Abattoirs 300 Teachers - Police Clearance 299, 300 Agriculture, Department of - Locust Control Campaign Award 914 Albany City Band - Statement 11530 Albany Regional Hospital - Surgeons 3262, 3985 Albany Roads - Impact of Grain and Woodchip Trucks - Grievance 13494 Albany Surf Life Saving Club - Statement 8722 AlintaGas - Albany - Fee to Find Gas Line 14969 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 and Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Albany Electorate 7556-7558 Budget - Positive Aspects 7555-7557 Gordon Inquiry - Impact on Funding 7557 Parliament - Regional Sitting - Albany 7558 Arts and Culture Entertainment-culture Centres - Bunbury, Mandurah, Kalgoorlie and Geraldton 3008 “Unhiding Visibility” Project - Statement 2812 Australian Football League - Statement 9414 Banks - Branch Closures - Petition 744 Bicycles - Bells - Compulsory Use 8513; Statement 5714 Car Rental Industry - Review 5583 China - Trade Developments 12682 Consumer and Employment Protection - Wealth Creation Seminars - Property Investment Adviser Regulations 11627 Courts - Albany - New Complex 7881 Cycleways - Infrastructure Funding 5450 Delta Electricity and Access Economics Investment Monitor 7222 Drivers Licences - Replacement Licences - Fee 10565 Albany District Education Awards - Statement 12603 Firefighting Aircraft - South Coast 7117 Fitzgerald River National Park - Controlled Camp Fires - Petition 2171 Fuel and Energy Albany Wind Farm 6788, 10880, 10881 Fuel Prices - Differential between City and Country 1052 Wind Power - Great Southern 11958 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 569

WATSON, MR PETER BRUCE (continued) Gilbert’s Potoroo - Statement 4854 Gorgon Project - Development 8892 Health Crisis in System - Matter of Public Interest 5103 Obesity in Children - Grievance 10647 Pit Stop Program - Albany 3262 Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome - Impact on Tourism 6343 Home Indemnity Insurance - Albany Building Industry - Grievance 885 Housing - BHP Billiton Ltd - Port Hedland and Newman 10963 Housing and Works, Department of - Albany - Security Doors 8146 Industrial Relations - Beachside Cafe, Albany - Investigation 2169 Iraq War - Impact on Tourism 6343 Joint Standing Committee on Delegated Legislation - City of Perth Code of Conduct Local Law - Fourth Report 1726 Justice, Department of - Charges against Australian Citizens by People from Overseas 5757 Legal Aid - Albany 1519 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2026 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Petition 12327 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading Albany Senior High School 10436 Albany Surf Life Saving Club 10436 Anzac Day Service in Schools 10437 Juvenile Justice System 10434 Major Developments in Albany 10435 Telstra - Business Survey 10437 Vietnam Veterans’ Memorial 10438 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10601 Mt Romance Australia Pty Ltd - Statement 12853 Nathan Drew Memorial Trust for Coastal Safety - Statement 13515 Ningaloo Reef - Pastoral Release Exclusions 3677 Olympic Games - Government Assistance to Athletes 6681 Planning - Community Dialogue Planning Initiative - Newman and Port Hedland 10963 Police Albany - New Complex 7881 Lesbian and Gay Pride Parade - Officers Marching in Uniform 12432 Vehicle Searches - Legislative Authority 9751 Prisons Albany Regional - Night Shift Security Procedures 3008 Harding, Mr Richard - Report 2576 Racing - Great Southern - Government Assistance 2314 Railways - Albany - Grain and Woodchip Transport - Grievance 13494 Regional Parliament - Albany Sitting - Motion 14061 Regional Port Authorities - Appointments 10494 Retail Trading - Deregulation of Hours 7358, 9662 Safer WA Community Security Program - Albany - Funding 1782 Salinity Funding - Catchment Demonstration Initiative 12063 Steering Committee to Evaluate Engineering Projects - Establishment 517 SARS - Impact on Tourism 6343 Schools Albany - Allegations of Sexual Abuse 9235 Albany Primary Telegraph - Statement 7879 Albany Senior High - Bali Schools Education Initiative - Statement 10671 Technology Upgrades 3781 Simpson, Donna and Vikki - Statement 6641 Skill up for the Burrup 12606 Swan River Trust - Scientific Patrol Boat 14077 Vexatious Proceedings Restriction Bill 2002 - Charges against Australian Citizens by People from Overseas 5757 Waste Disposal - Trucks - Wash-out Facilities 7406 Water Resources Albany and Great Southern - Expenditure on Infrastructure 10880 570 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WATSON, MR PETER BRUCE (continued) Water Resources (continued) Water Tanks - Incentives to Install 3417 Western Power Albany - Buy Local Policy for Cars 4691 Bremer Bay - Power Supplies 12200 Pensioner Rebates 1760 Reconnections - Albany, Denmark, Katanning and Mt Barker 10875 Wheatbelt - Power Supplies 12200

WHITELY, MR MARTIN PAUL, BCom, DipEd (Roleystone) (ALP) Aborigines - Swan Valley Nyungah Community - Role of Department of Indigenous Affairs 8174 Address-in-Reply - Motion Bali 1906 One Vote, One Value 413, 1906 Police 1908 Roleystone Electorate 1907 Agriculture Elevated Work Platforms - Safety Regulations 10166 Neglected Orchards Working Group, Hills Area - Statement 7356 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 3) 2002 - Second Reading Hancock, Mr Lang - Eulogy 4123 Solid Waste-to-energy Recycling Facility - SWERF 4125-4127 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Budget - Effects 7870-7872 Maddington-Kenwick Sustainability Project 7870 South-east Corridor 7871 Unemployment 7872 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Budget - Effects 7870-7872 Maddington-Kenwick Sustainability Project 7870 South-east Corridor 7871 Unemployment 7872 Australian Broadcasting Corporation - Funding Cuts - Statement 11105 Australian Football League - Funds for Football Development in WA 6814 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 6735 Canning and Pickering Brook National Parks - Statement 14249 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Prescribed Burning Program - Update 8965 Dangerous Goods Safety Bill 2002 - Second Reading 8815 Disability Services Deery, Mr Aden - Petition 5328 Palmer, Mr Nathan - Petition 14052 Ryback, Mr Wilfred - Petition 12572 Education Australian Education Union - Pay Demand 11253 Literacy and Numeracy Programs 7229 Teachers Enterprise Bargaining Agreement 9878 Pay Rise 11253; Motion 11422 Recruitment Drive 1048 Environmental Protection, Department of - Pollution Response Squad - Training 12612 Fire and Emergency Services Bushfire Risk - Preparedness by State Government 2519 Fires in the USA and Canada - WA Contribution 10678 Flags Protection Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8216 Health Attention Deficit Disorder and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder Drug Free Attention Deficit Support - Statements 8961, 1705, 12197 Petition 4066 Referral to Education and Health Standing Committee - Motion 6845 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” - Motion 1229; Amendment to Motion 1230 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 571

WHITELY, MR MARTIN PAUL (continued) Housing and Works, Department of - Tenants - Antisocial Behaviour - Amendment to Motion 8632 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11711 Consideration in Detail 12732, 12769-12773, 12845, 12846, 12865, 12866 Industrial Relations Australian Education Union - Pay Demand 11253 Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union - Claims by Hon Tony Abbott in the Sunday Times 8729 Insurance - Public Liability - Premiums - Petition 477 Iraq War - Support to School Students 5996 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2020 Liquor Stores - Seven Days a Week - Petition 12572 Mantraps - Serpentine-Jarrahdale Hills 1587 Members of Parliament Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly - Motion 10541 Leader of the Opposition - Travel Allowance 13694 Member for Roleystone - Behaviour - Personal Explanation 12315 Mining Permit - Iluka Resources - Statement 2383 Native Wildlife - Smuggling 12319 Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Motion 5617 Planning Lot 30231 Canning Location 32 - Petition 2525 Maddington and Kenwick - Urban Renewal Partnership - Statement 13807 Mundijong Town Site - Town Planning Scheme Amendment 4560, 5339 Police Pay Dispute - Opposition’s Pay Offer 11108 Pollution Air - Smoke Haze 2816 Pollution Response Squad - Training 12612 Public Accounts Committee Annual Report 2001-02 - Tabling 489 Auditor General’s Annual Report 2001-02 - Review 7859 Inquiry into Hospital Trust Accounts - Tabling of Papers 14225 Visiting Medical Practitioners - Tabling of Papers 4075 Racing and Gambling Legislation Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6376 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6376 Racing and Wagering Western Australia Tax Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6376 Racing Restriction Bill 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate 6376 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 936 Rally Australia - Agreement to Stay in Western Australia 4561 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13781 Roe Highway Stage 4 3672, 4101 SAFER WA Community Security Program - Gosnells, City of - Funding 3009 Schools Bus Service - Lesmurdie and Kalamunda Schools - Grievance 12577 Roleystone District High - Statement 10021 Serpentine Primary 2524, 3225 Support to Students on War in Iraq 5996 State Accounts Figures 599 Swan Village of Care - Nyandi Prison Redevelopment - Motion 5617 Tourism - Perth Hills Area - Statement 6181 Waste Disposal Total Waste Management Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion 5268 Waste-to-Energy Projects 1866, 2000 Western Power - Inquiry into Infrastructure and Customer Service - Motion 12504

WOOLLARD, DR JANET MAY, RN, BAppSc, MEd, PhD (Alfred Cove) (Ind) Acts Amendment and Repeal (Courts and Legal Practice) Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 8989, 8990 Acts Amendment (Reserves and Reserve Boards) Bill 2003 - Second Reading 10187 Acts Amendment (Student Guilds and Associations) Bill 2002 - Second Reading 2545 Address-in-Reply - Amendment to Motion - Health Services 113 Adoption Amendment Bill (No. 2) 2002 - Second Reading 1892 Alfred Cove - Reserves Sold or Leased 228 572 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WOOLLARD, DR JANET MAY (continued) Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 1) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Education 7876 Health 7873 Law and Order 7874 Occupational Safety and Health Act - Smokers 7874 Prostitution 7872 Appropriation (Consolidated Fund) Bill (No. 2) 2003 - Second Reading - Cognate Debate Education 7876 Health 7873 Law and Order 7874 Occupational Safety and Health Act - Smokers 7874 Prostitution 7872 Barrow Island Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11941 Business Names Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 11519 Cabinet Meetings - Government’s Election Promise - Motion 6028 Cannabis Control Bill 2003 Second Reading 6710 Consideration in Detail 6755, 6764, 6800-6806, 6848-6850, 6860, 6872-79, 6891, 6905, 6907, 6913, 6915 Dissent from Deputy Speaker’s Ruling 6898 Referral to Joint Select Committee 6764 Third Reading 6926 Council’s Amendments 11661-11664, 11667-11669 Civil Liability Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 7349 Consideration in Detail 7379-7383, 8753, 8994, 9000-9003 Council’s Amendments 12593-12596, 12598 Civil Liability Bill 2002 Consideration in Detail 1985-1987, 1989-1991, 1995-1997, 1999, 2033, 2036, 2172, 2176-2178, 2181, 2182 Ramifications for Claimants 2007 Cockatoos - Baudin’s White-tailed and Forest Red-tailed Black - Research into Conservation 1396 Committees of the House - Appointment 70 Community Development, Department of - Child Abuse Allegations 8182 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Prescribed Burning Program - Health Impact 5509 Consumer Credit (Western Australia) Amendment Bill 2002 - Referral to Select Committee 5500 Corruption and Crime Commission Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 - Motion 14907 Criminal Code Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 10954 Consideration in Detail 10957-10959 Dangerous Goods Safety Bill 2002 Second Reading 8815 Consideration in Detail 8818-8820 Disability Services Cooksley, Ms Janice - Petition 5836 Ewers, Mr Ken - Petition 9669 House, Ms Melinda - Petition 4708 Economic Regulation Authority Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5358, 5361 Electoral Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Political Parties - Funding 12862 Electricity Industry Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13381, 13391 Environmental Protection Amendment Bill 2002 - Second Reading 1476 Fire and Emergency Services Legislation (Emergency Services Levy) Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 2369, 2370, 2376, 2404, 2407, 2408, 2411 Forests and Forestry Forest Management Plans 24, 4690 Old-growth Forest 10424, 11256, 11257 Fremantle Cemetery - Amalgamation of Board with Metropolitan Cemeteries Board - Motion 8919 Genetically Modified Crops Free Areas Bill 2003 Second Reading 8836 Consideration in Detail 8841-8843, 8846 Government Departments and Agencies - Public Service Functional Review - Report 7749 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 573

WOOLLARD, DR JANET MAY (continued) Health Auditor General’s Report - Stroke Management 10168 Centre for Mental Health Services Research - Funding 8523 Community-based Health Services - Funding Cuts - Matter of Public Interest 11915 Conservation and Land Management, Department of - Health Impacts of Prescribed Burning Program 5509 Department - Staff and Salaries Increases 14256 Duncraig House - Proceeds from Sale 11909 Escalating Crisis - Matter of Public Interest 3796 Funding - Matter of Public Interest 14895 Improved Services - Government’s Commitment 1317 Management of Health System - Matter of Public Interest 11639 Mental Health System 11269, 13274 Nurses Aged Care - Statement 2383 Agency - Wage Parity 2821 “National Review of Nursing Education 2002” - Amendment to Motion 1231 Parkinson’s Disease Nurse Specialists - Grievance 12579 Recruitment Campaign - Advertisements - Grievance 2788 Use of Personal Care Assistants 1313 Wage Parity 2821 Workloads - Exceptional Matters Order 2002 1711 Priority Issues - Matter of Public Interest 6823 Smoking Playgrounds and Schools 7027, 7028 Regulations - Review - Tabling 8896 Smoke-free Enclosed Public Places - Review 7886, 7887 Stroke Strategy Plan 1466 Health (Smoking in Enclosed Public Places) Amendment Bill 2003 Introduction and First Reading 7659 Second Reading 7691 Heathcote Hospital Site (Reservation) Bill 2001 - Restoration to Notice Paper 183 Heritage Duncraig House 65, 512, 513, 11909 WA Heritage Council - Raffles Hotel Site - Unlawful Actions 6186 Hospitals Elective Surgery - Waiting Times - Matter of Public Interest 14895 Fremantle 209, 775, 3261, 11704 Teaching - Funding 11540 Human Reproductive Technology Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 11688 Consideration in Detail 12735, 12737 Industrial Relations Legislation - Tourism Industry - Motion 1626 Insurance Commission of Western Australia Amendment Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 639-643, 650-653, 658 Justices of the Peace - Age of Termination of Commissions 7945 Legal Practice Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 5740-5744, 5748-5752, 8902-8904, 8961, 8970, 8975-8983 Legislative Council - President - Deliberative Vote - Matter of Public Interest 2026 Liquor Licensing - Changes to Laws - Amendment to Motion 12702 Loan Bill 2003 - Second Reading 14299 Melville, City of - Sale of Primary School Land 9423; Statement 11777 Members of Parliament - Code of Conduct for Members of the Legislative Assembly Motion, as Amended 10556; Amendment to Motion, as Amended 10654 Minister for the Environment and Heritage - No-confidence Motion 4583 Natural Heritage Trust - Grants 8869 Noalimba Recreation Camp - Sale 3000 Nurses Amendment Bill 2002 Second Reading 3490, 3501 Consideration in Detail 3804-3816, 3820, 3821 Third Reading 3825 Parliament House - Allocation of Smoking Room 12909 Parliamentary Commissioner for Administrative Investigations - Recommendation on Compensation - Rejection by Attorney General 8602 574 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES]

WOOLLARD, DR JANET MAY (continued) Planning Commission - Raffles Hotel Site - Unlawful Actions 6186 Heathcote Site 65, 512. 513 Mauds Landing Development - Re jection Decision - Motion 9915 Raffles Hotel Site Artist’s Impression 3353, 3500, 4110 Construction of 17-storey Building 1051, 3092 Grievance 7335 Heritage Council and WA Planning Commission - Unlawful Actions 6186 Meeting 5090 Multiplex’s Drawings - Accuracy 4691 Petition 8157 Redevelopment 4563 Residential Codes 5584, 5585 Swan River Foreshore - Petition 8157 Wireless Hill Park - Excision from Class A Reserve 29813 Grievance 11081 Motion for Disallowance 14295 Petitions 11260, 11497, 13676 Police Fremantle Regional District - Officer Numbers 9794 Government’s Pre-election Promises - Motion 14100 Motorists - Testing for Drugs 12326 Prostitution - Soliciting in Public Places 7362 Prostitution Amendment Bill 2003 Second Reading 7071 Consideration in Detail 7074 Prostitution Control Bill 2003 - Second Reading 8711 Public Transport Authority Bill 2003 - Second Reading 5855 Railway (Jandakot to Perth) Bill 2002 Second Reading 1063 Referral to Joint Select Committee 1302 Consideration in Detail 1342, 1343, 1353, 1355, 1361-1369 Third Reading 1370 Railways - Southern Rail Link Cost Blow-out - Amendment to Motion 13940 Cost Estimates 2168, 2391 Land Resumptions - Cost 280 Reserves (Dampier to Bunbury Natural Gas Pipeline Corridor) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3835 Consideration in Detail 3838-3841 Reserves (Reserve 43131) Bill 2003 Declaration as Urgent 7901 Council’s Amendments 8031, 8032, 8038, 8040, 8042-8044 Retail Shops and Fair Trading Legislation Amendment Bill 2003 - Second Reading 13761 Reviews, Committees, Inquiries and Task Forces - Establishment 5893 Roads Fremantle Eastern Bypass - Deletion from Metropolitan Region Scheme Motion 418; Amendment to Motion 13623 Motion for Disallowance 14127 Murdoch Drive Leach Highway and South Street - Petition 744 Road Safety - Test of Motorists for Drugs 12326 Schools Mel Maria Catholic Primary - Traffic Zone 1276, 1306 Melville Primary - Sale of Land 9423, 9665, 13676 Non-government - Funding - Petition 6344 Sentence Administration Bill 2002 - Consideration in Detail 3250-52 State Administrative Tribunal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9694 Consideration in Detail 10010-10018, 10034-10039, 10043, 10048, 10049 [INDEX TO QUESTIONS AND SPEECHES] 575

WOOLLARD, DR JANET MAY (continued) State Administrative Tribunal (Conferral of Jurisdiction) Amendment and Repeal Bill 2003 Second Reading - Cognate Debate 9694 Consideration in Detail 10398-10401 State Taxes and Charges - Increases - Matter of Public Interest 7042 Swan River - Petition 8157 Taxis - Industry Reform - Motion 10634 Terrorism (Commonwealth Powers) Bill 2002 Second Reading 3547 Consideration in Detail 3555, 3556 Third Reading 3556 Total Waste Management Kalgoorlie-Boulder - Motion 5272 Tourism - Lack of Government Support - Motion 1626 Treasurer’s Advance Authorisation Bill 2003 - Second Reading Crime - Increase 9114 Disability Services - Funding 9114 Hospitals Dedicated Stroke Units 9112 Fremantle - Magnetic Resonance Imaging Scanner 9112 Nurse Practitioner Legislation 9111 Power Blackouts 9114 Western Australian College of Teaching Bill 2003 Second Reading 11302 Third Reading 11774 Western Power - Electricity Supply to Regional Western Australia - Matter of Public Interest 5463 Wood Processing (Wesbeam) Agreement Bill 2002 - Second Reading 950, 956, 957

______