o o o \ o o •■-•) :ig § CD ct (D MO' 5 ® o* iccGS refereince only - ^ X ' w ^ CO o ■R »

' 1 :i w "AN HISTORICAL SKETCH OP

THE CARTNELL PIONEERS"

By William P« Cartmel

C. C. C. FAMILY QUARTERLY

P. O. BOX 101 PORT TOWNSEND,WA 983«8UJ.A.

First Printing, Summer 1977 Second Printing (Revised), STunmer 1978 a Reprinting anjr portion of this hook without the bitten permission of the author is expressly forbidden. The reader of this hook will notice that through- out the text, whenever refer to the

/ mell" spelling* However, i in those cases, my inten- ^H||^^B|p^|g|||M tion is to encompass all ■ especially individual "Cartmel" spellings, and

^k "Cartmill." was to avoid The having purpose to '■ ■ various spel- -j lings when speaking of the " ^■ ■'' '-^01 stirname only in passing or "'■ in reference to a matter ■■ of more importance. This hook is the culmination of seven years of research on the Cartmell family. However, I make no pretense that my own research is completed. I will always he interested in discovering other branches of the family and hope to learn more from the readers of this work. If the input is great enough, another volume will he forthcoming. Prior to this hook, the largest printed history of the Cartmell family was a nine-page sketch of the Vir ginia clan, included in the hook, "Shenandoah Val ley Pioneers and Their Descendants," by Thomas Kemp Cartmell. Doing research on this family has heen a most enjoyable experience, as any genealogist will tell you. Occasionally in this hook I will refer to the difficulty and ensuing confusion involved in trac ing the family history. However, in one way it was more successful than attempts made by researchers tracing another surname. That is, the name itself is quite uncommon compared to others. Today, there are only 3^5 Cartmel, Cartmell and Cartmill famil ies listed in the telephone hooks of the major cities of the United States. This, in itself, helps to eliminate the problem of encountering m- merous individuals having the same name, hut with no connection to the family in vihich you are in terested. As I prepare this introduction,- I remain hopeful that the genealogical information provided in this hook will be of interest and assistance tc these researching the Cartmell surname as well as to those who merely desire to know a little more about their roots* The primary objective of this book is to encour age others to discover their own ancestors and ex perience the rewards which come with the search* As you will see, the descendants of the Cartmell family have an interesting cast of ancestors to contend with*

William Patrick Cartmel Summer, 1977 CONTENTS

1 History of the sorname 3

2 Cartmely England 8

3 The Virginia Gartmells 10

4 The Ohio Gartmells 21 5 The Illinois Gartmells 26

6 The Kentucky Gartmells 29

7 The Gartmel family 32

8 The Gartmill family 47 HISTORY OF THE SURNAME

The Gartmell surname is not one without inter est—in facrt, it has a certain amount of intrigue to offer the researcher tracing its history. The name itself is a combination of two separate word forms, kartr, from Norwegian dialect meaning "rough stony ground," and melr, which refers to a sand bank. The translation of the cabined forms is "sandbank by stony (or rocky) ground." For those who are dissatisfied with the transla tion, early British records offer a different one, claiming that its origin is found in the British words Kert,^ a camp^ and mell,'^ a small mountain. Hence, tho translation, "fortress on a hill" which is an apparent reference to the Cartmel Priory Chiirch of Lancashire County, England. (A history of the Cartmel Church is presented in the following chapter.) An Irish Surname dictionary lists the name as Cartmill, but indicates its origin to be from the English township. This same source documented^JohiT' ■*-Sertmel, : who was a Drogheda juror in 1306, and still others (named deKertmel) who were involved in the rescue of a nnirderer. The events are rather sketchy, but they are important in that they offer examples of the earliest recorded spellings of the name itself. Another source presented various spellings of the surname, including Cartmell,«Gartmel, Cartmail, Cartmale and Carpmile. A footnote includes the following information:

Robert Gartmell, of Claughton, 1578t Lancashire Wills at Richmond (1457- 1680), p.58. Elizabeth Cartmail, of Claughton, 1716: ibid. (1681-1748), p.53. Ann Gartmell, of Pullgarth, in Gart mell Pell, 1701> ibid. Thomas Cartmell, of Chester, l64'8s Wills At Chester (I62I-50), p,44, John Cartmell, of Simondston, l673i ibid. (1660-80), p.51. London, 2,1,0,0,2,0; MDH;(co. Staf ford), 0,0,1,1,,0,1; Philadelphia (Cart mell), 1*

Marriage records found in the Cartmel Church in England first record the event of this surname in 1571 upon the marriage of a William Cartmell and his wife. The ceremony was performed on the l8th of January. Later occurrences of the surname are spelled-" Cartmel - and are found in the years I669, 1696 and 1702. Although the major portion of the descendants presently living in England spell their name as Cartmell, the township and church are spelled Cart mel, with hut a single "1." Canon T.C. Ledgard of the church explains: "In days gone by it varied (the spelling) and there was no hard and fast rule." And that simple explanation seems to be quite applicable when discussing the variations in spelling which occurred once members of the family were spread out into the American States. Shire records found in Westmoreland County, Eng land include mention of Nathaniel Cartmell who re portedly sold his belongings and took sail with his family and certain others of the Sect of Friends to seek homes in the North American Colonies. Direct descendants of Nathaniel Cartmell, who were first found in New Jersey in 1724 and later in Frederick County, Virginia in 1735> were freely adopting a number of modified versions of the original spel ling. Birth, marriage, death and probate records of different members of the family were signed and recorded as Cartmel, Cartmelle, Cartmil and Cart- mill. Later attempts to trace family lines have been confused by a separate family of Cartmills which was descended from a Nathaniel Cartmill and his wife Dorothy. This family reportedly came from Ireland to Pennsylvania in 1685. It has been difficult to separate the two famil- ies since members of "both families have been found living in the same regions of the ooiintry and have adopted similar first names amongst the two, nota bly Nathaniely Martin and Thomas. Compounding the situation is evidence that Nathaniel Gartmell's wife may also have been named Dorothy—presenting an unusual set of oiroumstanoes which may oause some to believe that the two were actually one and bhe same person. As for a personal account^ I do laiow that my own great-great-great grandfather, John, spelled his last name both as Gartmel and Gartmell and that it was not until his son, Russel Thornton Gartmel, that my branch of the family finally settled on the single **1** spelling. It seems that while most of the Gartmelle of Virginia who remained there throu^out: the 1800*e commonly spelled their name Gartmell or Gartmill, those who moved into the neighboring states of Kentucky, Indiana and Ohio generally settled on either Gartmel or Gartmell. It would be inaoeurate to say that all American Gartmell families are descended from the Virginia clan, althou^ one must assume that all or most share English Ancestry. Extensive research indi cates that a large percentage of Gartmells living today have both England and Virginia runhing through their veins. It was 134 years after Nathaniel and family ar rived that another Gartmell family crossed the At lantic. The "Illinois Historical and Bond County Historical" states that in 1858, Isaac Gartmell and his family left Manchester, England and settled in New York. Since the first printing of mar book, we have learned that others made the same journey inbetween those years. We have a limited nomber of personal fsunily records to doctiment that informa tion. Hbwever, finding the same information in a genealogical manuscript will be certain to keep someone busy. Nevertheless, we have been able to aoourately trace several hundred Gartmels and Gartmells (and even some Gartmills) to the original Virginia fam ily. Undoubtedly, many others will be able to do the same with thei.v own families. CARTMEL, ENGLAND

Centered in Lancashire County,. England in the region ^^3— ^ known as the Lake District, ' I "" i lies the old and peaceful township of Cartmel# Here I il each year during the spring and late summer weekends, the normal population is many times increased "by the influx of visitors to the nearby steeplechase races* The site of Cartmel was given to St. Cuthbert in 677, by Egfrid, King of Northum- berland, with all the Britons inhabiting it. In II88, Wil- liam Mareschall, Earl of Pem- fe) broke, founded a priory for |W||| regular canons of the order of St. Augustine, dedicated | to the Blessed Virgin, and ^nnTA/iri PPIADY endowed it with all his lands rKlUKI at "Kertmell." The church, which still attracts visitors today, is notable for its stained glass windovjs, carved misericords on the choir stalls and many mediaevel manuscripts and documents. Other sites within the scenic Lake District which would be of special interest to Cartmells, include Cartmel Wharf, Cartmel Sands and Cartmel Pell. Brochures on the Cartmel Priory Chiirch can be purchased for a small fee by writing to Canon T.C. Ledgard, Cartmel Priory, Grange-Over-Sands, Lanca shire, England. Printed material and other material pertaining to the toxims and geography can be re ceived by writing to the offices of the Council Todbusk, Springfield Road, Ulverston, Lancashire, England, Be sure to ask for a copy of "Southern Lakeland." Other leaflets pertaining to the area can he purchased at 2 l/2 pense each from the Lake District National Park Information Service, Bank House, High Street, Windermere, England.

^ubXalL* THE VIRGINIA CARTMELLS

The Cartmell family of Virginia provides us with the most revealing picture of our ancestors that we can expect or hope for. The abundance of family records available through the foederick County courthouse is too extensive to detail. Records cover fhmily willsy deeds9 land claimsy births9 deaths9 marriages9 ooxuct settlements9 military ser-> vice9 etc. Therefore9 my intention in this chapter is to discuss briefly9 the original Virginia Caarts- mells and the families which were descended fl*om them during the 170 or more years they inhabited Frederick County. Frederick County9 Virginia9 located in the Shen- andoah Valley9 is where the ilnerican Cartmell famr- ily began. Those Gartmells who are certain their own ancestors were ampng the founding fathers ofi this nation9 are likely to trace their individual 'lines to this part of the country. ^ It is not enough to say that Gstrtmells simply lived out their lives in Virginia. The Cartmell family was tremendously involved in shaping Virgin ia's early history. Cartmells were Virginia mili tary officers. Cartmells were judges9 sheriffs and county officials. Cartmells helped to write the laws and defend them9 the land and the people who lived there. It is no secret that the Cartmell family of this southeastern state was quite weal thy9 owning huge plantations which were worked by negro slaves. Of course9 there is no pride to be found in the knowledge of this9 but it cannot be denied that the plantation system was extremely im portant to southern industry and to this day its effects ban be seen on the economic structure of the South. It was in 1735 that the family first requested that several large tracts of land be surveyed for them. All surveys9 which Wtere not reported until March9 17379 were in the name of Martin Cartmell,

10 the oldest son of ITathaniel Cartmell of Westmore land County, England. Nathaniel Cartmell, who brought his family to New Jersey about 1724, appar ently died in New Jersey, His widow and sons Mar tin, Edward, Nathan and Nathaniel and several un named daughters, journeyBd to Virginia after his death, The surveys of land located the individual fam ilies of Martin and his brothers living on both sides of Opeckon Creek and near the site of Middle- town. (Note: The volume referred to for this in formation speaks of the father, Nathaniel, as Na thaniel of England and the son, Nathaniel, as Na.- thaniel I. To save confusion, the same will be done in these chapters,) The widow, her dau^ters and son Edward made their home on a tract of land on the south side of the creek. Adjoining this property was the 70O- acre plot on which Martin and his wife Esther re sided along with their own children named Nathan, Edward and Nathaniel, Early records rarely list the names of the daughters in a family and it is not known for this reason if Martin had any, Martin also owned 1,100-acres on the North side of the Opeckon, Brothers Nathan and Nathaniel are believed to have settled somewhere on this land al though in later years they settled on property not far outside of this particular site. Although Nathan and Edward were apparently never married, their two brothers Nathaniel I and Martin were accredited with many descendants. Most of these families and short biographical sketches of them are found in, '^^The Shenandoah. Valleys Pio-!^ heers and Their Descendants," by Thomas K, Cart mell, The book, which is basically a histoEy»<:£ Frederick County, includes a nine-page sketch of the Virginia Cartmells, Rather than repeat the in formation which this book provides, I will include on the following pages the "family tree" diagrams of each major family, accompanied by relevant ma terial on each individual. This is most definitely a more helpful and informative undertaking since the family information provided by T,K, Gartmell*s book is not quite clear without the assistance of

11 other references to help separate the families he writes ahout. There are two important reasons why "Shenandoah Valley Pioneers" cannotibe^^onsidered; a-^fundamentaj • information on the Cartracll family* First, it was not written as a history of the Cart«- mell family. It was essentially a history of the prominent people and events of early Frederick Gonnty. Second, there are so many Cartmells with the same first name and little is done in his book to make a distinction between each of them. Fur thermore, Mr. Gartmell only surveyed one or two families outside of Virginia because he was not able to locate all the families who moved away. The fsunily chart on pages 1A^13 should be self- explanatory. The chi't illustrates the relation ship of the major families and is followed by addi tional information on the families which developed out of them. l..,ilathaniel CartmelTbf Westmoreland County, Eng land, was the first and only known Cartmell to make the journey across the Atlantic Ocean to America during the early years of pur country's., history. His wife's name is not known for' certain although there is some evidence that her name may have been Dorothy. Nathaniel and his family settled in New Jersey and records from that state indicate they were living there in-1724 - and for several years thereafter. Apparently, Nathaniel died in New Jer sey before, 1735.^as it is reported that only the wi dow and her sons settled in the Shenandoah Valley that year.

2. Nathan Cartmell, one of the'younger sons of Na thaniel Gartmell of England, settled on the north side of the Opeckon River in Virginia. There is no evidence to show that he ever married. T.K. Gart mell's book states that Nathan and his brother Na thaniel, who vrere both minors upon their arrival in Virginia, had trouble with the laws of that time concerning the property they were seated on. This is reportedly due to the fact that the property was listed in the name of their brother Martin instead of in their own names.

12 3* Although Nathaniel Cartmell I of Virginia was reportedly a minor in the year he came with his family to this state, it is said that he was al ready married. He left no will and therefore the name of his wife is unknown. It is kno\^n that his sons v;ere named Nathaniel I died in I765. 4". Little is known ahouta^a^dT^iemglW Upon coming to Virginia, he lived with his mother for some time and subseouently settled on the survey near Middletown. It is said that he later plunged deeper into the wilderness and made his livlihood "by trading with the Indians.

5»"Martin Gartmeli ^as the oldest son of Nathaniel of England. It was he who probably made the deci sion to move the family from New Jersey to Virgin ia. All of the land his family was living on, in- cluding that of his mother's and his brothers', was recorded in his name. Martin's wife's name was Es ther and his three sons were named Nathan, Edward and Nathaniel. Again, the same family names which make it difficult to separate one generation from another. Martin, who lived to be an old man, died in 1749- -His son Nathan died, unmarried, in 1755. Son Nathaniel remained in Virginia, living on the south side of the Opeckon. Edward was married tviice, the first time to a Miss Baily. Their chil dren includ^:.Qeprjg!^ who was living in Berkely County, Virginia in 1815; Harrison, Martin, Regina, Elizabeth, Jane, Parthenia and Rachael."Their chil dren seem to have lost their identity with the Fre derick County kin," reported T.K. Cartmell in his book. "They have been traced to Illinois, Kansas, Missouri, California, and into several nor^m states." 6. £ 8. Nothing at all is known b1^«^s©i!BPs and^^hn Cart mell except that they were assigned small tracts of land by their father Nathaniel I of Virginia. There is nothing to show that they ever lived on this land or whether they departed to regions unknown. No proof that they vjere ever married is available.

13 OF

10 HOTEi H0MBERS COBBSSFOSD TO CARTHSLL BIO(mAPHIOAL DE3CHIPTI0BS AKD FAMILY IHFOHMATION PROVUfflD ENaiiAin) Oir THE MEZT PAGE,

EDWARD MARTIN GARTMELL GARTMELL (unwed)

4. 5.

JOHN GARTMELL

8.

JOHN JACOB OARTMELL CARTNELL GARTMELL

These four Brothers moved out of Virginia and into EentuoliT'y Ohio and Indiana* 7* It should he noted here that information regard ing the succession of Nathaniel IjIX and III is more than likely confused in certain instances, es pecially the dates pertaining to their hirths. This is because the resources available are oftentimes vague and misleading and occasionally lead to inac curate guesses on the part of the researcher. For example, military records indicate that Nathaniel Cartmell II was born in 1725» I^" this is true, then he was born in New Jersey, ten years before his- fa ther came to Virginia. This factor would not sup port the contention that Nathaniel I was not legal age at the time he came to Virginia, a claim made by T.K. Cartmell in his book and reported herein. The events attributed to Nathaniel II should be considered in this light. The military service records of Nathaniel II show that he served as a private in the Revolution ary War and was cited for patriotic service. He and his wife Sarah had twelve children which in cluded four daughters and the eight sons illustra ted on the proceeding family chart. The daughters were n^ed Elizabeth, Sarah, R^hel and Mary. Eli zabeth was married to Michael Archdeacon. Shrah Cartmell was wed to James Cochran. Thomas Crist (or Christ) became the husband of Rachel Cartmell. And, on January 15, 1789j Mary Cartmell became the bride of Nathaniel Willis. They and their son Na thaniel P. Willis resided in Martinsburg, Virginia. As for Nathaniel Cartmell II, he died October 6, 1795 and his wife Sarah died in the Spring of 1815.

9. The youngest son of Nathaniel II was Martin Cartmell, born about 1772 in Virginia. He married Ann Ball on July 10, 1808, and they had tvro chil dren, Eliza Ball Campbell and Thomas K. Cartmell. (This is not the same Thomas K. Cartmell who wrote a history of Frederick County, Virginia.) Son Thomas was born about I809 and died at the age of thirty-three on September 16, 1842. Thomas, who was never married, was described as being "handsome ...and a gentleman of the pure Virginia type." Mar tin, by the will of his father, inherited the large home and plot of land known as "Homespun." This

16 land was first claimed "by his ^andfather ITathaniel I and the house was erected in 1771 by Nathaniel II. Kartin died February 3, 1843 at the age of 71 years.

10, Solomon Gartmell was one of the sons of Nathan iel Cartmell II vrho remained in Virginia, settling near his old "Homespun" home. On January 26, 1792, he was vred to Elizabeth Haife (or Rife or Ralph.) Their children include^T and Nary. Solomon died just prior to 1304 and his widow married James Leach, Karch 5, 1805, The children were dissatisfied vrith this second marriage of their mother and the sons left Virginia at an early age, seeking homes in Tennessee and Texas. Nathaniel, son of Solomon, married Isabella Gleaves and lived at Lebanon, Tennessee until his death in 1880, His children were William H., James, Thomas, Mary, Rachael, Sophia and Eliza. Nathan and his wife also resided in or near Lebanon^gTeimessea and raised a large family there. The children of this union were 'Jennie" Cartmell Soodmyer, 'Rober.iL-.O., .S^Ms^^P.artmelX," Thomaff and Cartmell Barrow. The childreh of Mary lived in Wilson County, Tennessee, Solomon's son Martin was born in Virginia in 1797 and was married twice, the first time to Miss Neal who bore two children, Sally and Ann. Martin, Mho served as a private in thg, Tennessee-^Militia diiring the War of 1812, later married Jemima Sharp. Martin died neaj^ Jackson,'><-*Tennessee in I864. His children by his*second wife were* Robert U., - Hary;'^ tert:to.and William. Robert married Mary J. Baldwin and raised four childrenj Lizzie, Gooton, Robert and Harry. Martin's daughter Mary wed Mr, John D. Bond. 'Jr.-was twice Sophia V/illiams, his first wife, mothered Lena and Martin.III. His second v;ife had three of his childrenr *RQbgg^ TCartmel'l^ndftJ^Seabds William Cartmell, son of Martin Sr., was killed in battle at the age of twenty-one. Henr:;^ a., son of Solomon, went to upon leaving Virginia. In 1360, he was living in V/ash-

17 ington, Texas. He served as an officer during the nar between Mexico and the U.S.^ and was later en gaged in operating steamboats on the Brazos River. He had two children by his first wife. They were named Mary Cartmell Wilson and Tom Cartmell who lived in Austin. Mary, the only daughter of Solomon, was raised by her uncles in Virginia after her father's death. Later, she married Stephen Pritchard, a prosperous farmer near Kernstown, Virginia. They had seven childrent Reese, Cornelius, Elizabeth R., Mary, Ann, James, Henry and Solomon.

11. Thomas Cartmell was living on the Greenfield farm in Virginia in 1770| with his wife Ann Kite. Thomas served as a private in the Revolutionary War and passed away in 1808. His will, which was pro bated that year, listed his children: Rachel Ihitt, Sarah Morris, John, Eleanor, Thomas, William Kite,:: Jacob, Nathaniel and Betsy. Most of these children became the 0artmells of-"Ohi^and will be traced further in the chapter pertaining tc families in that state.

12. Nathaniel Cartmell III was born November 20, 1753, and died in Virginia on August 4, 1826. His first wife, Elizabeth Proman, died in 1789 and left him no children. He did not remarry until April 27, 1807* His second wife, Sarah Bean, came to live with him at his Virginia home called "Retirement." Nathaniel had resided there since 1773* They had two children, Mordecai Bean Cartmell (born 2-13-1808, died 1-20-1870) and Mai-tin Cart mell (born 1-29-1809, died July, I815.) A family cha3*t of Mordecai Bean Cartmell and sons Nathaniel M. and Thomas £. were included in the book, "The Life and Family of John Bean of Exeter and his Cousins," by Bernie Bean. These charts are repro duced below, as they appeared in Mr. Bean's book:

MORDECAI BEAN CARTMELL b. 2-13-1808, Fre derick Co., Va., d. I-2O-I87O, Frederick Co., bur.in Roimd Hill Gem. with his wife, m. 4-5"i827, Frederick Co.,Eliza Campbell.

18 Children:; Myy E#R> Carbmell< b.12-26-1827, d. 6-22- 1690, unnT" Nathaniel Martin Cartmell, b. 3-23-1829. Sallie Cartmell, b» A-'SA-lSBO, bur. Round Hill Gen., Winchester, Va., she was unm. William Ccgtmell. b. 8-24-1832, d. in in-

Robert M. Cartmell. b. 3-7-1834, d. 12-17- 1902, iinm* He is bur. in Frederick Cc. He was a Deputy Sheriff several terms in 1858. Ann Bliza Oartmell. b. 5-4-1836, d. in in fancy* lyhomas K. Cartmell. b. 1-28-1838. Hordecai Bean Oartmell, b. 12-23-1839, d. 12-17-1863.

NATHANIEL M. CARTMBLL b. 3-23-1829, Fre derick Co., Va., d. 7-7-1898, in Califor nia, bur. in Ht. Hebron Gem., Winchester, Va., m.12-5-1854, Frederick Co., by Dr. A. H. Boyd to Ellen Moore Sydnor, b. . d. 2-21-1901. He was Sheriff of Frederick Co. Va., before the Civil War. Had 8 ch. Children: Fannie 3. Cartmell. b. . m. 1st, John Caartmell of Springfield, Ohio, m. 2nd, Clark, m. 3rd, David Shanks. She Iv. in Calif, and was an author. She had 2 oh. by 1st. m. Jack Cartmell, b. . Sarah Cartmell, b. , d. 1-25-1891, bur. Mt. Hebron Gem. Winchester, Va. Robertina K. Cartmell. b. , m.. Horace G. Brown. Nbllie F. Cartmell. b. , m. Capt. Anderson. William C. Cartmell. b. . He d. in Calif, leaving 7 ch. Lidie Cartmell. b. , d. Capon Springs, W. Va. Katherine Cartmell. b. . m. , Wilks- boro. Pa., John Graham.

19 Nathaniel Cartmell, hw » m. 1st, Nora Gentry, 2nd, Anita Collins* Had 3 ch. hy 2nd m* (7heir children:) Nathaniel H* Cartmell, h* * Iv* in Texas*^ Katherine Csartmell, h* * m* George Heath* Rich ard A* Cartmell, h* * he was a minis ter. Roger M* Cartmell. h. 3-7-1834, d. 12-1?- 1902, Winchester, 7a*, bur* in Round Hill Cem*

THOMAS K. CARTMELL h* 1-28-1038, Frederick Co*, Va*, m* 11-22-1866, Frederick Co*, Va*, Annie Glass Baker, h* . d* 1-18- 1907, Winchester, Va., hur. in Mt. Hebron Cem. Thomas was Clerk of Court for Fre derick Co., Va. He and Annie were m. by Rev. Foote. (He was the author of "Shen- andoah Valley Pioneers and Their Besoen- dants.**) Children: Robie M. Cartmell. b. 4-7-1868, d. in in fancy, Round Hill Cem. Annie Lyle Cartmell. b. .Frederick Co., d* 4-11-1962, m* 11-7-1904, Ingleside, W. Va., B. Coupland Randolph, d. 12-17-1959* m* by Rev. Graham* Had no ch.

13., 14., 15. & 16* The following information is provided on these fotir sons of Nathaniel Cartmell II in the book, **Shenandoah Valley Pioneers and Their Bescendantsi** "Four sons of Nathaniel mentioned in his will,1795, i*e., Nathan, Jacob, John and Elijah, two of whom, as previously stated, were in Kentucky and Ohio prior to their father's death; and the other two, Nathan and Jacob, were there in 1002* Most diligent effort has been made to follow these four sons* We have every evidence of their residence in those two states, and of three large families; and many de- aoendants of those families have in many ways as sured the writer of their connection, yet in no case has it been possible to trace the lines to a conclusion*" (My research is found in ch*6 & oh.7*)

20 THE OHIO CARTMELLS

Most of the Cartmell families x-/hich were living in Ohio during the early and middle 1800*s were de scended from Thomas Cartmell, son of Nathaniel Cartmell II. This Cartmell family and others which settled in Ohio multiplied so numerously that hy 1850 there x^rere 22 individual families v/ith the Cartmell (mel, mill) sxirname living there. The dis tribution by county in that year was: Clark County, 8 families; Madison, 6 families; Champaign, 6 fam ilies; and Gallia, 2 families. Between 1828 and 1899> there were 24 Cartmell marriages recorded in Clark County alone. To pro file each of these families xrould require an entire volume in itself and would be impractical for oxir purposes here. Furthermore, it would require more facts and information than is presently at hand to tie all these families together. Historical facts become confusing from the off set. An account of the original Ohio family is re corded in Thomas K. Cartmell*s book, "Shenandoah Valley Pioneers and Their Descendants." A para graph from his book is reprinted here in order to demonstrate the near hopelessness that comes with attempting to make sense of his xijritings regarding this Ohio family.

"Thomas, son of Nathaniel 2d, was found on the Greenfield farm in 1770, with his young vjife Ann Kite. (Family tradition says she was the daughter of Kaj. Isaac Hite of Belle Grove. This is erroneous, as Maj. Hite was not married until just prior to the erection of Belle Grove in 1793*) She might have been a daughter of Isaac Hite of Long She was the daugh Meadovjs, father of Major Isaac. The ter of Joseph Hite, recital of a deed recorded in 1790,

21 speaks of Thos. GartmeXl's wife Anne the daughter of Joseph Hite. They are one and This must be the Thomas that tra the same* There is dition says married a cousin of no reason to be Dolly Madison;and was the 3th ohild lieve this was a of the owner of Greenfield farm* different Thomas The ohildren of Thomas^ Sr*y by his Gartmell and Ann will i^robated in 1808 were two mar Hite* ried dau^ters Rachel Ratt and Sa rah Morris9 John^ Rleemory Thomas^ Km* HitSy Jacoby Nathaniel, and a daughter Betsy wife of John Lupton* It will be observed that one son is Yes, his wife's mentioned as Wm* Bite,—evidently there was some Hite cozmeotion, and name was Hite* it is safe to assume that the widow named in the will as Nancy, was Ann Hite* This Thomas, Jr*, died in Virginia; left a widow and 2 chil dren, one daughter Shrah married Hamilton and settled on the Ohio, near Cincinnati; the son died at an early age* The writer often heard the family mention his two Her brother-in- children, but is unable to report law Nathaniel re anything more* The widow Ann Hite mained in Virgin removed to Ohio with her brother- inr-law Nathaniel Gartmell in 1803, ia* It was her and died August 10, 1821* The wri son that she came with to Ohio*** ter is informed that her tombstone in Vernon Cemetery near Gatawba, She was not a wi dow until 1808 and fixes the date and says she was the the family moved "consort of Thomas Gartmell*" The to Ohio about widow of Thomas, the father, was 1810***She died in living in Frederick County, Va* in 1821, not in 1811* 1811, and died soon thereafter, ad vanced in years*"

It should also be noted that Thomas Gartmell*s will included mention of a son named Joseph, which T*K*Cartmell did not list as one of his children or heirs* A Clark County will, dated August 30, 1821 and probated May 26, 1823 is signed by Ann Gartmell and

22 lists the following heirs: "daughter Rachel, wife of John Mill? daughter Ellen, wife of James Hunter; daughter Sarah Morris; John Lupton who married my daughter Blizaheth; sons Jacoh P. Cartmell; Nathan iel; Joseph; John; and Thomas." This is ohviously the same family which T.K. Cartmell writes ahout. However, this will offers evidence that Ann Cart mell, the mother of these children and the \d.fe of Thomas Cartmell, Sr., died in Ohio after 1821, not in Virginia in 1811. Nathaniel Cartmell, the son of Thomas and Atiti Cartmell, was "born in 1773 in Virginia. Nathaniel and his wife, Re'becca Van Metre, came to Ohio "be tween I805-I8IO, settling in Pleasant township. In 1822, Nathaniel "built a flouring-mill on the south "branch of Buck Creek. Later, he added to it a woolen-mill and distillery. A profile of the children of Nathaniel and Rebec ca Cartmell is included here: Thomas J. Cartmell. who was born about I8O5 in Virginia, lived v/ith his wife Amanda in Catawba, Ohio. Thomas J. died July 22, 1822, at his Ohio home. He and his wife had eight children. Eliza, born 1841; Rebecka, born 1844; Thomas, born 1845? Madison, born 1847? William, born I85O; Sylvester, born 1852; Charles, born 1855? and Hughes, born 1858. Jacob Van Metre Cartmell was born in September of 1811, and died July 29> I896. He married Sarah Baldwin, twelve years younger than himself, Novem ber 26, 1844* They had four sons and two daughters. In i860, the children were listed as being of the following ages: John, 14; Henry, 12; Joseph, 8; George, 5? Mary, 2; and Ellen, four months of age. Henry and George were often referred to as Van and Dawson, their respective middle names. Nathaniel Madison Cartmell was born November 24, 1817 in Clark County, Ohio and died April 4> I889. Mary Loffland became his i^ife on December 29, 1843. (Another source lists the marriage date as January 2, 1844•) In i860, they had seven children in their family: Sarah, aged 15; Perly Martin, 11; Ann, aged 9? Marietta, aged 7; Henry Clay, 5; and John, aged 2 years. Son Perly Martin Cartmell, who was born

23 July 8,1848, "became an influential citizen of Ohio. In 1872, he graduated from the University of Woos- ter. Aftenmrds, he taught school for six years until he entered business for himself, esta"blishing the Cartmell and Brter Beikery. Mary A. Cartmell is believed to have married William Roberts in Ohio. The date of the Clark County marriage was January 27, 1831. Other children of Hathaniel Cartmell and Rebecca Van Metre include John, Ellen M. and Martin R. Nothing is known for certain about the lives of these individuals.

^ Another Ohio will, dated July 5> 1824, belonged to Jacob P. Cartmell, son of Thomas Cartmell, Sr., and Ann Hite. The will suggests that Jacob was unmarried as it did not list a wife or children as any of his heirs. His estate was divided between his brother Nathaniel, his nephew John Cartmell, his sister-iiwlai^ Re'ftecca Cartmell and John H. Cartmell. The will, which is also recorded in Clark County, was probated December 8, 1824* Other Clark County families residing there in i860 included John W. Cartmell, aged 27f and his wife Elizabeth. Samuel Cartmell, aged 37, lived with his wife Sarah and their children Martha, Jo seph and Elijah. John L. Cartmell, 42, and his wife Mary, 33, were found residing with their six children Elizabeth, Sarah, Martha, Eliza, Oliver and William. Another Jacob P. Cartmell, aged 39» a saddler by profession, was the head of his six- member family which included his wife Sarah and their children Virginia, David, Jacob and James. y n At the beginning of this chapter, it was men tioned that 22 Cartmell (mel, mill) families were living in Ohio and recorded in the 1850 U.S. Cen sus of Ohio. The following is a list of the heads of these families and the township and county they resided in:

CLARK COUNTY J.H. Cartmel. Pleasant township J.S. Cartmell Pleasant township

24 J.7* Cartmell**.**...**.... .Pleasant township N.M. Cartmell.••••••••••••••••••••Pleasant township Nathaniel Csirtmell •••••••••••Pleasant township Cartmell.•••••••••••••••••••.Pleasant township W.H* Cartmell* Pleasant totmship J»P. Cartmill**...••••••••••••••••Pleasant township MADISON COUNTY Alfred Cartmell .Pleasant to\fnship John Cartmell Pleasant township John J« Cartmell.••••••••• Somerford Samael Cartmell.•••••••••• •••••••••• Range Nm. Cartmell. .Range Wm. Cartmell..••• .•••••••• .Union CHAMPAIGN COUNTY John J. Cartmell. ••.••••••••• .Union Joseph Cartmill. ••••••.Union Nathaniel Cartmill ••••• Union Rosannah Cartmill..•••••• •••••• .Union Sophia Cartmill. .Goshen Thomas Cartmill. .Union GALLIA COUNTY David N. Cartmel. •••• ••••....HUntington Lucinda Cartmel....••• •••••••••••.Addison

MX W

Madison County, Ohio records list the birth of twelve Cartmell children between 1868 and I905. Five of these children are nnnaraed. The remainder, as listed, are Alfred Pearl, born 12-14-18815 Bes sie, 1-1-1883? Hellen, 5-30-1393? Hosa, 12-6-1870? Elizabeth Cartmill, 4-6-I904? Marcia Cartmill? 3-1- 1872? and Margaret Cartmill, 5-27-1905. In addi tion, nine Cartmell death records are recorded be tween 1865-1906 in Madison County. They include, Rosa Cartmell, 3-24-1871? Thomas, 10-17-1892? Nm., II-I7-I875? Alfred, 5-23-1865? Henry Cartmill, 1- 15-1895? John C. Cartmill, 10-13-1895? Margaret Cartmill, 9-26-1905? Mary Margaret Cartmill, 6-18- 1906? and Walter N. Cartmill, 6-21-1900. Those Cartmells who desire further information regarding their Ohio ancestors should address cific questions to the author of this book. A great many other Cartmells are listed amongst Ohio papers in the writer's possession.

25 THE ILLINOIS CARTMELLS

The Illinois Cartmells became established in Rural toiinship, Shelby County, Isaac .^hatCartmell year. and Isaac his waswife another brought Cartmell their family immigrant, there with his family some time later in New York City, where they lived until they departed for Illinois. Isaac prospered as a farmer, spending the rest of his life in Illinois. He died in 1900. Children of Isaac were: Jennie, who married Justin Nright, and lived in Assumption, Illinois; Ann, who died as a young girl; Ida, who became the wife of Frederick Cochrane, a Shelby County farmer; Robert, a West Point Military Academy graduate; Gertrude, who wed Prof. E.H. Gavins of Normal, Illinois; and Robert W. Cartmell who was two years old when he came vjith his father and family to Am erica. Thomas W» Cartmell was a New York City newsboy until the time he accompanied his parents to Illi nois. After marrj'ing Margaret Harper, he took on some property adjacent to land belonging to his fa ther, vrhere he labored as a farmer. His children were Harry D,, Mary, Jennie, Isaac, Samuel and Nel lie. Further information on this Illinois family can be found in the"Illinois Historical and Bond County Biographical," a genealogical text. To v7hat extent it can be said that Cartmells currently residing in the United States are de scended from this family is presently unknown. It is interesting to note that this is one of the few Cartmell families in America vjhich did not emerge from the Virginia clan. The Cartmill name also appears in early Illinois records, as early as 41 years before the arrival of Isaac Cartmell. =This was the-f am 11';^- bt'A^dr^^ ^^wEi^^Oartrai11 7-and-r.his'wife Nancy D. Brown.;\; A concise

26 history of this family first appeared in a book, dated I876, and titled, "The History of the Early Settlers of Sangamon Co., Illinois," by John Power. A section of the book, reprinted below, indicates another example of how the spellings get confused!

•^flnd^ew"' Qartmelt v7aS^bbrfl[ March, . 177^6^ Greenbrier Oount^-'^aC^. ..He went to -Bathi^ «^^Cpunty, Ky., when he was a young man. Nan cy D. Bro^-m was born Oct., 1772, in Cul- pepper County, Va.,, .j.nd.^n.17^0.was'taken*' '^C^rtmeiri Und. Nancy D, Brown were married and had eight children in Kentucky, and they moved to Sangamon County, Illinois, arriving- Gotv»-iOf"l829, x^ six miles north east of Springfield, Of their children— Wv^ born Oct., I8OO, in Bath County, Ki)--.,married there in 1832, to Mary Crockett, moved to Sangai^n County, and from there raised a family of six children, and lives near Merton, Grundy County, Ko. LUCINDA married in Kentucky to John Rudder, had two children, and died there. Her children came to Shngaraon County with their grandfather Cartmell. LUCRETIA mar ried Samuel Houston. THOMAS was a sol dier in the 4th 111, Inf., and was killed in 1847» in the Mexican war. August in Bath- ■^^Gouhty; was married there March 23, 1829, to Mildred R. Tacket, and came with his parents to Sangamon in the fall of that year. They had five children. AMAIJBA A., born April 29, 1830, married March 2, 1852, to James Black. JOHN W., born May 19, 1833, married in Missoxiri to Mary E, Chipps, have four children, and reside near Merton, Ko. He served three years in Co. C, 23d Ko. Inf., from Aug., 1861, JiTOS H., born Oct. I4, 1837, mar ried Martha Crane, vrho died April I9, 1871, leaving foua* children. He married

27 Nov. 19j 1872, to Mrs. Zilpha Halbert, whose maiden name was Taylor. They live four miles east of Springfield. ELIZA A. horn August 30, 1842, married James Black. MARION, horn July 19, 1845, married Feb ruary 1, 1872, to M.O. James, have one child, Annie E., and live six miles north east of Springfield. Mrs. M.R. Cartmell died April 14, 1875, aud John M. Cartmell Itlives is sixwhere mil^^^^r^gl^g^f^^^^ngfield* his father settled in 1830.

married there to Elizabeth Buval. He died in Sangamon County, July 17, 1839, and his widow returned to Kentucky. E7ELINE, born July 22, I807, in Ken tucky, married in Sangamon County, Oct. 25, 1830, to Charles Harper. They had one child, and she died Kay 6, 1845« Her son ULYSSES lives in Texas. NANCY, born August 11, I8IO, in Bath County, Ky., married there to WillisChs- sity. ELIZA, born in Kentucky, married in Sangamon County, to Alex.Rigdon, who died, leaving a widow and seven children near Mt. Pulaski. MARY A., born in Kentucky, married in Sangamon County to Samuel Harper, has four children, and lives in Caldwell County, Texas• -^^'^ AlCraWvSw^-born^ i County^ came to Sangamon County vrith his parents, married in Logan County, iai 1843, "to Nancy Edwards. They had six children. LOUIffl[ANA married P. O'Brannon, and resides near Mt. Pulaski. PERMELIA P., born Nov. 29, I846, married Walter C. Black. MARY E. married George Hickman, and lives near Lincoln. ,JAMES .H. lives near, lit.Pulasklv TIMOTHY L. lives near Williamsville. 'AL-VIN residee^^i^ r>^^ear,V.::Mt,.i.--Pul^l5i:Vi^ Mrs• Nancy Gantrall died Sept. 6, and her husband Oct. 20, 1856, both in Logan County."

28 THE KENTUCKY CARTMELLS

Pour sons of Nathaniel Cartmell II of Vir ginia hiwe "been found in several Kentucky counties including, Payette, Harrison, Bullitt and Nelson. Their names aftd Difficulty arises in attempting to vjrite their U- ographies because there were a number of Cartmill families also living in Kentucky at that time, and oftentimes in the same county. In I8IO there were eleven Cartmell and Cartmill families recorded in the Kentucky Federal Census. Only three of them can be reliably traced to the Virginia clan. Some of them may have come from the Greenbrier County, Vir ginia family but that is not knox^ for certain. In any case,it is now known that Elijah Cartmell, son of Nathaniel Cartmell II, was living in Payette County as early as February, 1790 where he was in cluded on a tax list under Cartmill. After 18C0 all Payette County records listed him as Elijah Cart mell. After moving from Virginia, where he was born February 25, 1763, he remained for the rest of his life in his Kentucky home. His wife, vrho went by the names Polly and Mary (he may have had more than one wife) was born in 1765- They had seven children named Asa, John, Elizabeth, Margaret G., S&lly, Polly and Ann. Asa was born January 6f^^^pand died,unmarried, June 6, John Cartmell, son of Elijah, also died unwed on November 29, $83^9^ He vias born October Both men are buried in Lexington, Kentucky. Elizabeth Cartmell was born April 28, 1797 and died August 14> 3>Sft8pB» Her husband was George V/. Brown. Margaret G. Cartmell was born February 28, and became the bride of Joseph Bryan, Sr., who vjas a nephew of Daniel Boone. (His grandmother was Dan iel Boone*s sister.) Joseph was born October 30, 1797, and died August 6, 1837. His wife Margaret died September 29j 1874-

29 Sally Cartmell was wed to Robert Kenny; Polly Cartmell to Lewis Bryan; and Ann Cartmell to James Gay- Elijah died Aufjust 26, l831j and his vrife died August 8, 1832. Most of the family is "buried in the Lexington Cemetery. *** w Jacob Cartmell,son of Nathaniel Cartmell II, was first found in Kentucky in 1800. In the U.S. Census of that year, his name vras spelled Cartmill as it was in the 1820 Census. The I8IO Census of Nelson County listed him as Cartmell. While information relating to Jacob*s family is still forthcoming from Nelson County researchers, little is presently known about him. It is knora that on April 18, 1795> Jacob Cartmill was witness to the marriage of Nicholas Crist, Jr. and Ruthy Briscoe. On December 29, I807j his daughter ^lly married Moses Lane. Another daughter Elizabeth mar ried James Nelson on August 24> 1815- All of these marriages took place in Nelson County. Here for the first time is almost certain evidence of a Cartmell whose descendants adopted the Cartmill spelling. v;?, 'Nathan Gartihell. has been the most difficult son of Nathaniel Cartmell II to trace. Although it is known that he was living -dn Bullitt County^Kentucl^ between the nothing else is pre sently known. "Tner^ are no records indicating a Cartmell marriage_ in Bullitt County during those years and other records of this time ':^eriod are tept outside the county and are in the possession of the Kentucky, state Historical Sooi-etyr Trying to obtain vital records from this organization is like sear ching for an orange grove in the Yukon. So it seems that further information on Nathan Cartmel> will have to come from any descendants he may have had.

««« Further information regarding John Cartmel, son of Nathaniel Cartmell II, and his children is pre sented in chapter seven of this book.

30 It was stated earlier that there were several other Cartmells and Cartmills in Kentucky "between I79O-I82O, not all of vjhich have "been aooounted for. They include the following list of people from the corresponding census years:

1T90 Samuel Cartmill ..Fayette County

1800 Andrew Cartmill Montgomery- County Thomas Cartmill.••••••••••••••••• .Montgopery County

1810 Susanah Cartmell. .Harrison County John Cartmell Montgomery County Elijah Cartmale Bullitt County John Cartmill. Harrison County Andrew Cartmil. Montgomery County Samuel Cartmil. .Montgomery County Thomas Cartmill. .Montgomery Cotinty Thomas Cartmill .Montgomery Coiinty Wm. Cartmill. .Montgomery County John Cartniell. ..Harrison County

1820 Nicholas Cartmill Nelson County Thomas Cartmill. Nelson County -Ana3Sm.Ja3gtmlll. - Baldi Coimty David Cartmill...... Bath County John Cartmill... Bath County Thomas Cartmill Bath County

31 THE CARTMEL FAMILY

RuBsel Thornton Cartrael*s achievements and civic duties can still be read about today in a number of historical volumes and yet what emerges most clear ly is a portrait of a man who lived by modest means and held high religious values under which he raised two large families. Russel was Kentucky, the son of John Cartmel and the grandson of Nathaniel Cartmell II, both of Frederick County, Virginia. Russel*s father made the journey from his Virginia homeland to Harrison County, Kentucky and is recorded by the J.S, Census as a resident of that county in the /ear 1800. It was here that John raise

^ffiSSi^and four females. John Cartmell later moved his family to Rush County, Indiana and died in 1843 while interstate from his Indiana home. Some thirteen years after his death, his estate was still in the courts being settled. During this time, the estate settlement went through the changing hands of a number of judges and administrators. Under the circumstances, this appears rather odd since his estate was valued at only $900 and after debts left his heirs no more than $22.72 apiece. Apparently he left no formal will and his estate was divided by other legal means. The administration of John"s estate names his children, to wit: Preston, Sanford, Russel T., Milton P., Barton W., Louisiana Anderson, Polly S. Gillen, Martha D. Cones, L. (probably Laurie)Ja- meso^5*^^d one bthj|^p|^errYi{^oseviname-"l#'"i'ldsgiMei And once again the family witnessed its members spreading out as some of these sons and daughters made homes in various parts of Indiana, Kentucky and Missouri. Russel Thornton Cartmel was li'Wing in Rush Cotinty, Indiana in I84O, already married at the age

32 RUSSEL THORNTON CiUfiTMElr 1818-1892 of twenty-two and the father of a two-year-old daughter named Mary S, (Mollie) Cartmel. His wife, Evelyn (Viola) Gfbbs, was horn in 1022 in Ohio. For many years his family traveled about, not re maining for long in any particular region. They made homes in the Indiana oounties of Rush, and Wa- bash. They were also found residing in a number of Miosonri oounties including Vemon, Moniteau, and finally in Btrton County. Children by his first wife included Majry S. Cartmel, born about 1039 ia Indiana and wed to H. Hart; Justine (Tine) Trueblood Cartmel, born Novem ber 7» 1041 in New Salem, Indiana, married to Jen nie Orier in 1060 and died February 20, I906 in Oolden City, Missouri; John L. Cartmel, born about 1044 in Indiana; Sarah J. Cartmel, born about 1047 in Indiana and wed to Frank DeWitt Arnold on Janua^ ry 1, 1067; Cerilda Cartmel, born about 1049 in In diana; William Ovid Cartmel, born September 20, 1891 in Wabash County, Indiana and married to Jen nie Helen Davis on November 20, 1007 in Grand Junc tion, Colorado, and died April 2, 1914 in Mariposa, California; Henry Clinton Cartmel, born April 10, 1039 in Tipton, Missouri and married to Minnie M. in 1006; Edgar Franklin Cartmel, born March 17, 1062 in Missouri and married to Ida Adaline Loback on July 49 1009 in Grand Junction, Colorado, died September 22, 1930 in Price, Utah. During his early yeeurs, ^ssel T. Cartmel worked as a farmer and merchant, but into his adult life he held several government offices in the state of Missouri, including County Court Judge of Barton County. In 1066, he founded the town of Barton, Missouri. He owned a great deal of property in that area and was successful in gathering interes ted parties to relocate there. A town square was platted but remained a paper design. The community later became known as Barton City and was in compe tition for the County Seat which was bestowed upon the city of Lamar, some fifteen miles southeast of the town of Barton. In 1067, Russel Thornton Cartmel was elected to the 24th General Assembly of the Missouri Legisla ture, becoming the first person to serve Barton

34 Coim*ty as a state representative on an exclusive "basis. Others, including himself, had served as a part-time representative earlier, but the office had never required the talents of an exclusive and full-time legislator up until that time. On July 1, 1871, he became the co-founder of the Barton County Agricultural and Mechanical Society which was established under order or restriction of the local county court. In later years, he was ap pointed postmaster of Barton City, Missouri, the town which he had founded. His daughter-in-law, Jennie Grier Cartmel, (who is featured on page 4I of this book) was well-known throughout Barton County for her newspaper articles which appeared in The Weekly Sentinel, a Lamar newspaper, and the Golden City Herald. Prom her writings it becomes apparent that her father-in-law was quite popular as a public speaker, oftentimes addressing the Methodist Church vihich he helped to build. Music was another of his great loves and he participated in organizing a number of musical con certs and events, once saying in a speech, "I have never seen a community that cultivated a taste for music that was a very bad one." In 1878, his wife Viola died and two years later he married the widow Mrs. Elvisa Leonard. She had seven children by a previous marriage. Russel took upon himself to raise these children as his own. They were named William A. Leonard, John M.,. Craig, Melissa B., Latira B., Oscar and Julia M. Only one child was born to Russel and Slvisa Cartmel, a son named Charles fiussel Cartmel. Charles was born on June 27> 1885 in Pratt County, Kansas and was to wed Edith Agnes Goodyear in I905 in Paonia, Colora do. They had two surviving sons, named Charles Willard Cartmel and Robert Addison Cartmel, both of whom are still living in the Los Angeles area at the time of this publication. Charles was born January 4, 1909 in Cedar Edge, Colorado and Robert was born in Marion, Iowa on March 9, I9II. Their brother Kenneth Cartmel died at birth in Colorado. As mentioned earlier, 'b»D-tifesap#'-and four sisters who also have been found in courthouse and federal government records as

35 living outside of their Kentucky hone. His oldest "brother, Preston Cartmel, v/as born in I805 in Ken tucky and was married to Harriet (last name un- knovm,) She v/as born in 1821 in Indiana. Preston had at least two childrenj Melissa, v/ho was born in 1846 and Harrison G., who was born in 1849, both in Rush County, Indiana. Sanford Cartmel was born in 181Q#3. also in Ken tucky, and V'/as married to Martha Wilson on November 19j 1833 in Rush County, Indiana. Their children, who were all born in Indiana, included Luvicy J. (female), born in 1835; Ino (male), born in 1836^ Debra A., born in 1839; Dulphus 3. (male), born in 1845; Mary E., born in 1847 and Pinckuey B. (male), born in 1849* (All birthdates are relative to the ages given in the I850 U.S. Census.) , Barton W. Cartmel was born about 1828 in Indiana and took Eliza A. Johnson as his wife on November 19» 1833 in Rush County, Indiana. Russel*s sister Martha D. Cartmel was born a- bout , l8,iQ^in Indiana and v/as married to Samuel Cones. Louisiana Cartmel married I^r. Anderson and Polly S. Cartmel married Mr. Gillen. Louisiana and Polly were also sisters of Russel T. Cartmel. There is some confusion as to what happened to L» Cartmel. another sister of Russel Cartmel. Her father's estate settlement lists her married name as Jameson and furthermore lists a Thomas P. Jame son as administrator of his estate. Interestingly enough, marriage records from Harrison County, Ken tucky (the birthplace of most of these children of John Cartmel) records the marriage of Laurie Cart- mi^ and Thomas Jameson, which took place on Novem ber 2, 1826. Whether or not these are the same two people is not quite certain, as there was another large family living in that same county v/hich had officially adopted the Cartmill surname. Most of them were the sons and daughters of John Cartmill, Sr. and his wife Susannah. Milton P. Cartmel is probably the same person viho was living in District 97 of Rush Counter, In diana and recorded as Palmer Cartmel in the I85O U.S. Census. In that case, he v/ould have been born

36 in Kentucky in 1323* His wife Elizabeth, who was born in Indiana, vnis 19 years old at the time of this census. The family lines of all of these children, vxith the exception of Russel, cannot be reliably traced any further than the middle 1800* s. With the added inimt of other American Cartmels, it may be possi ble to one day compile a more complete history of this particular family and its descendants. As for Russel Thornton Cartmel, he died in Mis souri in 1892, at the age of 73> leaving several children and step-children. His last born, Charles Russel Cartmel, was only seven years old at the time of Russel's death. Nothing additional is known about Mary S. and Cerilda Cartmel, two of the daughters of Russel T. Cartmel by his first marriage. However, his daugh ter Sarah J. Cartmel was married to Prank DeWitt Arnold, a prosperous businessman from New York State. The couple established their home in Lamar, Missouri. As a young man of sixteen. Prank Arnold enlisted to serve with Union forces engaged in the Civil War against the South. Arnold was enrolled as a pri vate in Company 1, Third Wisconsin Volunteer Caval ry. He participated in the battles of Prarie Grove, Cane Hill, Cabin Greek, Baxter Springs, Dripping Springs and other minor engagements. On October 6, l863j at Baxter Springs, Arnold's company, which vias led by Major General Blunt, was met by Quantrill's Raiders, the notorious outlaws who had gained a reputation for looting Northern tovins, murdering the men and raping the women. Al though these men did little to promote the Southern cause, their leader William Clarke Quantrill had been authorized as an officer in the Confederate Array. The encounter between these two enemies be came knoTrm as the Quantrill Massacre and resulted in Blunt*s company being cut to pieces. After having his horse shot from under him, Ar nold surrendered, having been assured that he would be treated as a prisoner of war. After handing over his revolver to a Confederate guerilla, he was shot with the tvjo remaining loads. As ho still showed

37 signs of life, ano- jjjUBSKtb' s ther of the band shot him several times at short m ra^e, utterly rid- ',4^ dling his head and .* face. Seven differ- ent times he vjas

untilgiven" the "no nextattention mor ning when it was discovered that life PRAKK DBWm ARHOLB ^ ^ his body, Ama- zingly, he survived his wounds and was placed on detached service as a scout until his discharge in Karch of 1865, He and his wife Sarah Jane Cartmel were married in Port Scott, Kansas in I867 and settled in Lamar, Missouri (the birthplace of President Harry S, Tru man,) The Arnolds became cuite vjealthy through many successful business ventures. Prank Arnold established the Lamar House, a for ty room hotel, given over to first-class fxirnish- ings. The hotel was used for the wedding ceremony of the local sheriff Wyatt Earp and his bride Vlilla Sutherland, Unfortunately, this structure was razed about 1972 in order to construct a newly styled bank. Prank Arnold was also the publisher of the VJeekly Sentinel, a newspaper printed in Lamar, and he served as chairman of the Town Board in 1873, He held monetary interests in the stage lines from Lamar to Port Scott, Kansas as vjell as interests in the local fairgrounds and in the tovm bakery. At one time. Prank Arnold ovmed over 1,300 acres of land in Barton and Stone Counties and was a large stockholder and president of the Marhle Cave Mining Company of Stone County, Missouri. Although he and his viife never had any children of their oi^n, they raised a group of children who had been born into a circus family which had become well-known for its high-^Tire act. While serving as a director of the Barton County Pair Association, Prank Arnold arranged to take charge of the welfare of these children and they came to live with the Arnolds in their hotel. Prank Arnold lived to be 37 years old. He died in Lamar on March 14y 1932 and was accorded a mil itary flag burial. As for the sons of Russel Thornton Cartmel, there is substancial information regarding them and their lines have been traced to the present day with the exception of John L. Cartmel who seems to have disappeared from all family records during the Civil War period. The writer is still attempting to determine whether he was a casualty for the Nor thern Cause. As for the remaining sons, a short biography and family profile is herein accorded to each of them:

JUSTINE TRUEBLOOB CARTMEL, called "Tine" by his family and friends, was born in New Salem, Indiana on November 7, 1841 and was married in 1868 to Jen nie Grier, the daughter of (Judge, Captain,. Publish er and) Senator William C. Grier. Justine labored in his flour mill which he owned and operated in Golden City, Missouri. He also served for many years as the local preacher. His wife Jennie was equally industrious, serving on countless community projects as well as witing as a columnist for a few local newspapers, one of which was owned by her father. Writing on numerous subjects, from social affairs to politics, it was not long before she became knovm locally as a prom inent figure in early women's rights. Justine's v/ife Jennie was also an accomplished musician and artist, giving lessons in both these arts to the local citizenry. Together with her husband, she organized the Golden City Debating Society of which Justine Cartmel served as the club

39 president. They had three children, named Edna Viola, horn August 5» 1873; Harry True, horn September, I8785 and Gertrude Beatrice, horn November 11, I879. Edna Viola Cartmel married Lewis Edward Heath in Lamar, Missouri and had two children, a hoy named Gaylord Heath, who passed away March 25, I975 at the age of 65, and a daughter named Barrell Heath. Darrell is still alive and currently lives in Eu gene, Oregon. Harry True Cartmel became a successful engineer, establishing a sugar factory which he operated in Grand Junction, Colorado. He married Viola Marshall Stephenson in Florence, Colorado on October 10, 1902. They had only one child, a daughter, named Gertrude and nicknamed, "Bbbbie." She was married to Elmer E. Meyers, a graduate of Anapolis Naval Academy. Mr. Meyers died during the Second World War. Mrs. Meyers established a number of art gal leries in the Carmel-Monterey, California area and is currently retired and residing in Carmel. Gertrude Beatrice Cartmel toured the country for a short time as a concert pianist before settling down with her husband in Grand Junction, Colorado, where she gave piano lessons to local children. She was married on June 8, 1904: in Golden City, Miff- souri to Claude BeNel Smith, a prosperous drug wholesaler who owned and operated his own pharmacy. The Smiths had three sons and one daughter born to them: Burrell Douglas, born September 13, I905, maa^ried to Ruth Helen Tucker on June 28, I931 in Warren, Massachusetts, died December 1, 1972; Melba Irene Smith, born January 14, I908, married to Mar quis Rightmire Schmidt on August 3, 1932 in Grand Junction, Colorado; Claude DeNel Smith, Jr., born July 1, 1915> married to Dorothy BoxTman in May of 19395 and Sterling True Smith, born March 24, I9I8, wed to Mildred Tebbetts in Whittier, California in May of 1939.

WILLIAM OVID CARTMEL was featured in a book, t i t - led, "Progressive Men of Western Colorado," which was published in Chicago in 1905 by A.W. Bowen and

40 Mrs. J^pie CatttnelJ Wrrt^^^Her^-Impressions- JEMIE ORIER CARTMEL ot;5enatocvM66re*s:;;Ad-r. d re&s^^p oli^jTh pj:0rigi ir;"' of;^ittie^'Species^ the:.Senatef.Is renter- •"^►<►.'5- ' ' l\ ■ ' « - tainingr'-Biit the-Sub-" ject^r^V Npt Really Foisonoua Philosophy- of JfeppEtant^'Itv" ils ,/Parwin Still in Our Pub-• th^r.Present; She lio Schools—'Indirectly ^ Sa£s;- and ,Not Produced the Present Great- War v and- Its Refutatioit \ Vitally Golden City,^Moi rmportant -to -"the 8-2&-16. Rising Generation FROM B'AR'rd'^r CITY.'

A^L^V. FOR, >VOMAN. 15"^^ l^eminlscences- 3 Whj--is it that assoon'as'woinan P tries ,educate .hcrsc past the t ' ■ • of the iricidenta ' i ^rulcofthree,' as^inoldcii time, that ♦ • in the life of . •' 1 ; she becomes the target for every I ; Ilk. | »".mbuth,-picce in her neighborhooil?

.If after mature 'deliberation, she I " . . • . 4 . become^' ct>nvinccd: that it is her (By,Mrs. Jennie Cartmel.) ' '.'diity to'prcacli the gospel and lift /INSTALLMENT XXVI mankind out of the sloughs o(! vice '.thatT'-they- .havefallen into'*' No 'sooner dues she dQ,this, than she ! Music School:^ ■Js'i^-jargncd bcTorcI aUiigh church Mri. J.T. Cartmei, assisted by..Jier 'tnbutinl,.and.told that: she should diuifhtori, has opened n echoul ror^t'In-; iga witls covered head and learn of siraotion in ro usib in Golden City. PU'. plla Biicnitted at auy time. Terms ' res- her husband instead of-making, a Boasbie. ' "p'trbllc exhibition of herself. Should Co, The following "biographical sketch of William was printed in the volume and is reprinted heres

"Notwithstanding the enormous output of the mines in Colorado and the great amount of capital and number of persons interes ted in the mining operations of the state, the stock business continues to be one of the leading industries in these parts, and the men who are engaged in it are impor tant contributors to the general weal in a number and variety of ways. One of these is W,0, Cartmel, of Mesa County, whose ranch is located seven miles northwest of QtaaA. Junction, and is the seat of a thriving and profitable cattle business which he has built up from a small begin ning, Mr, Cartmel was born at Wabash, In diana, in 1832, and is the son of R,T, and "Viola (Oibbs) Cartmel, the former a native of Kentucky and the latter of Ohio, In the childhood of their son William 0, they settled in Vernon County, Missouri, and in the election of i860 the father was the only man in that county who voted for Lin coln for President, He was a merchant dur ing the greater pazi: of his mature life and died in Missouri in I892,aged seventy- three years. His wife died in I878, at the age of fifty-eight. William 0. Cartmel passed his boyhood and early manhood in Missouri, receiving a good coimnon—school education there, and remaining at home un- "til after the death of his mother. In 1879, when he was twenty-seven years old, he came to Colorado and settled at Baton, where he remained a "fee u;t two years on a cattle and sheep ranch. In 1882 he trans ferred his energies to Grand Valley and there took up a preemption claim of one hundred and sixty acres, on which he is still living and of which he has made a fine, productive and attractive fetrm. In 1887 he was married to Miss Jennie Davis,

42 a native of Pennsylvania. They have six children. Jean, Albert, Gertrude, Zena, John and William 0«, Jr. Mr. Cartmel is comfortable and prosperous, and in public affairs, as in him own business, is enters- prising and progressive. He has been a potent factor in the development of his portion of the county and had an influen tial voice in reference to all local mat ters of importance. He is generally spected and has many warm friends."

It should be noted here that the family of Wil liam Ovid Cartmel and Jennie Helen Davis relocated in Moore, Idaho in I908 after poor soil conditions attributed to high alkaline content forced them to abandon their farming efforts in Colorado. William Ovid Cartmel died on April 2, 1914» a pro longed illness of which he was attended to by Ms mother-in-law in Hariposa, California. His wife Jennie, who was born November 10, I8d8 in Harford, Pennsylvania, passed away at the age of 87 years on Kay 19, 1956, in Port Townsend, Washington. A his tory of their cMldren is forthwith:

Naomi Jean Cartmel was born on March 4> 1889,. in Grand Junction, Colorado, and was married to Saren Rasmus Nielson on September 10, 1923 in Challis, Idaho. They had one child, Albert Clinton Nielson, who was born in 1925 in Challis and died in Kel— logg, Idaho. Naomi died July 11, 1936 in MacKay, Idaho and is buried in the Lost River Cemetery in Moore, Idaho. Albert Russell and Gertrude Evelyn Cartmel were twin-born on June 11, I89I, in Grand Junction, Col orado. Albert was the owner of a bakery store for some time during the course of his first marriage to May Fischer and worked in several occupations after taking his second wife on October 10, 1923 in Jarbridge, Nevada. His second wife, Blanche Edna HayiTard, was born July I8, I89& in Port Bridger, Wyoming and had been married previously to Prank Elias Banning in Haley, Idaho in 1915* Albert and Blanche Cartmel lived in a niimber of locations dur-

43 ing their lifetime, including Chiloquin, Oregon; Mountain Home, Idaho; and Port Townsend, Washing ton. They had two children, hoth boys, named Al bert Russell Gartmel, Jr., and T^ddy John Cartmel* Albert Jr. was born December 19> 1925 in. Chiloquin, Oregon, and his brother Ted was born July 12, 1934) in Mountain Home, Idaho. The children of Albert Jr. were all born in Port Townsend and include Michael Douglas, born March 16, 19475 Barbara Jean, born February 10, 1948; Bruce David, born June 3, I95O; Walter Lee, born December 28, 19515 and Timo thy John, born January 17, 1956. All of the chil dren of Teddy John Gartmel were also born in Port Townsend and include the viriter of this book, Wil liam Patrick, born September 18, 1952; Deborah JC, born December 9) 19545 Thomas Teddy,, born September 20, 1957; and Susan Maohelle, born April 24) 1968. Gertrude Evelyn Gartmel was married to Forest Havener on Christmas Day, 1910, in Moore, Idaho and died on July 4» 1942, in Jacksonville, Oregon. Saiv ah Granella was born to the Ravenor couple on De cember 13) 1911) in Moore, Idaho and was married in 1932 to George Oliver Hollingsworth. Zena Mae Gartmel, the youngest daughter of Wil liam Ovid Gartmel, was born August 21, 1894) in Grand Junction, Colorado and was married to William Arby Jones on December 25, 1912, in Moore, Idaho vjhere they still are both residing at the time of this publication. They had three sons, including Victor Arby, born May 20, 1919; Irvin Harding, born February 20, 1921; and John Clyde, born June 18, 1933. All three boys were born and graduated from high school in Moore, Idaho. John DeWitt Gartmel was born in Grand Junction, Colorado on November 11, 1897, &ud was married to Mary "Marie" Louise Bolen. They presently reside near Bard, California. No children were born to this union. 'William Ovid Gartmel. Jr. was the youngest mem ber of the Grand Junction family and was born July 30, 1900* He met with a tragic death at the tender age of twelve, vjhile preparing to go on a sage hen hunting trip with his brother John. Upon attempting to mount his horse, the shotgun he was handling in-

44 advertently fired, inflicting a bullet vround in the child*s chest, killing him instantly. The date of his death was Hovember 3, 1912, in Koore, Idaho.

HEMRT CLIITON CARTMEL registered as an attorney of law vjith the Barton County courthouse of Missouri on April 26, 1382, and practiced law for several years in Lamar and Washington, Missouri. Henry 0#, who ifas called "Clinton" by family and friends, was born in Tipton, Missouri on April 10, 1859> T^utl left with his parents in i860 to live in Vernon County, Missouri on a plot of land adjacent to the Drywood Creek. He was married in 1886 to Minnie M. (maiden name unknown) but later divorced her after she had given birth to three of his children. Their children included Brandon Donald, who was born in August of 1888; Beatrice Honey Bee, who was born in March of I8965 and Dudley T., who was born December 18, 1897j in Galena, Missouri. Dudley vras married to Mary Katherine Vanice in Kansas City, Missouri on November 5> 1928. They had a daughter named Dona A. Cartmel, who vras born August 13, 1929 in Kansas City and still resides there. She mar ried Mr. Jacobson and had three children by this union, including Larry, who was born in 1950? Diana Cathleen, \Tho was born July 1953; and Daniel Ed ward, vjho was born February I6, 1957• Henry Clinton Cartmel later moved to Grand Junc tion, Colorado where it was reported that he mar ried a childhood sweetheart and resumed his law career after successfully fighting a bout with al coholism. His ex-wife, Minnie M., was also remar ried to a man named Mr. Bramer.

EDGAR FRANKLIN CARTMEL was the youngest child of Russel Thornton Cartmel, being born March 17, 1362, in Missouri. He was a farmer all of his life, liv ing his adult years in Grand Junction, Colorado; Pullman, Washington; and later in Price, Utah. On July 4, 1889, he married Ida Adeline Loback in Grand Junction. They had three daughters and one son,all born in Colorado. Constance Ccrilda wan born August 25, 1891, and was married to Kenneth Asbel VJilson on

45 Decem'ber 20, I9II, in Grand Junctionj Ethel Sarah was horn on April 4, I893, and was wed to Harold Enisley Sharp on March 23, 1913; Thomas Everett Cartmel, the only son of Edgar P, Cartmel, was horn Septemhcer 13, I896, and died Octoher 13, 1971 in Los Angeles, California, married to Ester Russell in Price, Utah on April 20, I9I8, and had one daughter named Vivian Maxine Cartmel, horn Peh- ruary 28, 1925; and Mary Juanita, the youngest child of Edgar P,, was horn April 26, 1900 and died November 9, 19^4 in Santa Monica, California*

46 THE CARTMILL FAMILY

There is most certainly ah ohligation on the part of this hook to offer all information avail able on the Cartmill families* However^ the ques tions may remaiu for some time to oome* Host im portantly, to what extent are the Cartmells inter related to the Cartmills? Shedding additional light on this question, and hopefully others, will he the point of this chap ter. Without repeating all the information already provided on the Cartmill family as it appeared in the other chapters, this section will he devoted to offering additional leads to individual research ers* Reports have come from all over which demonstrate that families have switched spellings of their sur- ziame* One interesting story was told to me recent ly hy a lady- whose maiden name v/as Cartmill* As she told it, one of her father's relatives decided to change his name to Cartmell after enrolling in a school where negroes with the Cartmill surname also attended* Apparently he was emharrased ahout sharing his surname with Cartmills who were hlack* While other family members argued against this ir^ rational move, he held firm on his decision* His descendants continue to use the Cartmell spelling. However, to verify a relationship to one ances tor or original family, common to all Cartmells and Cartmills living today is a near impossibility* Es pecially since early writers and historians, who were not particularly concerned with the distinc tive spellings, did little to eliminate the confu- fion* The earliest reference to a. Cartmill immigrating to jlmerica v/as that of Nathaniel and Dorothy Cart mill. According to this account, Nathaniel's family departed from Ireland in I685 and settled in Pennsylvania, within the limits of the "Neviark Mon thly Meeting." Their son Martin was horn January

47 195 16855 while at sea on the voyage to America. Their second son Thomas was "born Fe"bruary 29, 1689. Thomas, who was married in 17155 was disowned by his father for marrying outside of their Quaker So ciety. It is still unsettled whether this Nathan iel was the same Nathaniel Cartmell who emigrated from England in 1724. Mr. Cartmell also had a son named Martin and his wife was believed to have been named Dorothy also. In fact, there is a will on file in Predierick County, Virginia (dated November, 1750), the home of the descendants of Nathaniel Cartmell, which was written by a Dorothy Cartmell. Quot ing from her will, "I give unto my son Thomas Cartmell the sum of five; pounds Fennsilvania money." She also leaves portions of her estate tos son-in-law, Chester A. Bond; her daughter, Sarah Chester; grandson, Nathaniel Cartmell; grandson, Nathan Cartmell; grandson, Thomas Smith;grand- daughters Lydia, Mary, Elizabeth and Sarah Smith; grand-daughters, Mary and Susannah Chester; grand sons, Thomas and David Chester; grandsons, Joseph, Thomas and William Csirtmell; grand-daughters, Sarah and Hannah Cartmell; grandson, Edward Cartmell and grandson Edward Cartmill. Further connection between the two Nathaniels is evidenced by their religious faiths. Mr. Cartmill was reportedly a Pennsylvania Quaker and..-^tgr..-^---iGa^^g ®s?«?meil waB a meiaber of the Seot ^of-Eriehds^hiich^TOe writer understands-to be of. Quaker vorigin. Cartmill families did reside in Virginia, out side Frederick County. Three different families were headed by gentlemen all named Henry Cartmill in the 1820 U.S. Census of Virginia. They lived in the count ie s of Botetourt, Kanawha and Cabell. Other early Cartmills have been found in early re cords of Madison County, Ohio; Bath County, Ken tucky; Montgomery County, Ky; Nelson County, Ky; Harrison County, Ky; Clark County, Ohio; Champaign County, Ohio; Madison County, Ohio; Fayette County, Ky; and in parts of Delaware. A revealing book, titled,"Chronicles of the Scotch-Irish Settlement in Virginia," documents several Cartmill individuals, all living in Augusta County, Virginia. The book contains numerous re-

48 cords of the county court and places the family*s existence there as early as 1747. A Samuel Cartmill was documented as producing certificates for hemp, commonly known today as marajuana. Apparently he grew the plant for the fibers which were used for making rope# In 1780, a John Cartmill was promoted to Captain in the army, according to the Augusta County court# In 1811 he departed for Botetourt County. This text includes mention of these Cartmills: Ann, Marv and Mary. But what is most intriguing about this volume is the mention of a Thomas Cartmill and his wife Ann Kite, involving them in the circuit court case, Kite vs# Snapp. This same source, dated September, 1796, declares Joseph Hite, deceased, to be the fa ther of Ann, John and William Hite. Tou will re member that in chapter four, a Thomas Cartmell and his wife Ann Hite vxere discussed. There is no doubt that these couples were actually one and the same. Those researchers who are attempting to trace their individual Cartmill line, should note that in Augusta County, Virginia, on page 187 of the Novem ber, 1773 Abstract of Wills (Book No. 5) there is a record of a will written by John Cartmill. The viriter has not yet acquired a copy of this 1^.11 but nevertheless, this document should pro vide addi tional clues for the genealogist# Another will, written December 27, 1807, is held in the files of the Harrison County,Kentucky court house. The will, by another John Cartmill, mentions his wife Susanah, his sons William, John and Thomas and his daughters Elizabeth, Peggs, Nancy, Mary, Martha, Jenny and Nelly. This document can be found in Will Book A, Page 86. Mr. Cartmill also filed 12 deeds with the county court, dating from 1795 to 1818. Three deeds are listed under William Cartmill, dating from I8IO to 1812. Susan Cartmill has one deed, dated I8l8. Cartmill marriages are also recorded in Harrison County, Kentucky files. They include: Mary Cart mill and John Wall, July 25, 1794; Jenny Cartmill and Peter Barrett, married December 12, 1797; Wil- 49 liam Cartmill who wed Polly Anderson Seoember 31 > and Gare*fc"fc Wall who became "the husband of Eleanor Cartmill on October 16, 1803.

50 BIBLIOGRAPHY

Shenandoah Valley Pioneers and Their Descendants, Thomas ICemp Cartmell, Latest Printing, 1963, Ches apeake Book Company. Berryville, Virginia. Progressive Men of Western Colorado, A.W. Bov/en and Company. 1905- Chicago.

Town and Country Regional Library. Assistance pro vided by Librarian Goldia Geeslin. Lamar, Missouri. The Story of Barton County^ Marvin L. Van Gilder. Carthage Press. Carthage, Missouri.

Hist;Dry of Hickory. Polk, Cedar, Bade and Barton Counties. Bade County Historical Society. Green field, Missouri. History of the Sarlv Settlers of Sangamon County, Illinois, John Carroll Povjer. 1876. History of Clark County. Ohio, W.H. Beers. 1881. Chicago.

Kentucky Pioneer and Court Records, Mrs. Harry K. McAdams•

Nelson County. Ky. Marriage Bonds, Mary Barrel Stancliff.

First Census of Kentucky, 1790, Heinermann.

Second Census of Kentucky, 1800, G. Glen Cliff.

Chronicles of the Scotch-Irish Settlement in Va., L^^-man Chalkley. 1965- Cenealogical Publishing Co.

The Life and Family of John Bean of Sxeter and His Cousins, Bernie Bean.

51 I would like to thank the following people who have contrihuted information for this "book:

Constance Cartmel Wilson* Price, Utah* Ethel Cartmel Sharp* Pruita, Colorado* Gertrude Cartmel Meyers* Carmel, California* Charles Willard Cartmel* Rancho Palos "Verdes, Ca* Ro"bert Addison Cartmel* Running Springs, Ca* Mel'ba Schmidt* Grand Junction, Colorado* Zena Cartmel Jones* Moore, Idaho* Mahle R* Mortensen* Mesa, Arizona* Darrell Heath Welch* Eugene, Oregon* Ruth H* Heath* Kansas City, Missouri* Rona Cartmel Jacohson* Kansas City, Missouri* George Leker* Irwin, Missouri* Helen Owens* Rushville, Indiana* Canon T*C* Ledgard* Cartmel, England. Mrs* G*W* Olson* Springfield, Ohio* Rushville Pu'blic Li"brary. Rushville, Indiana* George B. l^hitacre* Winchester, Virginia* Mrs* LeCompte Beard* Lexington, Kentucky* James B* Evans* Owingsville, Kentuclqy* Grand Junction Chamiber of Commerce* Colorado* Ro'bert W* Murray* London, Ohio* Mrs* K*B* Skardon* Ur'bana, Ohio* Oherlin College Li'brary* 0"berlin, Ohio* Hazel E* Johnson. Greeley, Colorado* C*T* Cotterill* Maysville, Kentucky* Earl Sawyer* Grand Junction, Colorado* Othal Gardner* Lamar, Missouri* Mary Hizar* Lamar, Missouri* Special thanks to Albert Russell Cartmel, Sr., and Blanche Hayward Cartmel* This book is to their memory* '■■:{W'-'

' CAHTMELL Family

Donated by Jo Perry ' #;r: :

r- ■ , • ^ - . y.;.: ^v' y.''' . ''

- iy.«sy

SOOOO .1 i) ^y i J 18 ti ^.1 19

lAX LIST TAX LIST TAX UST TAX UST MA1JR couwiy DATE IIAIS COOHXY OATS K&JS COUHTT DATE KAUB COUNTY DATE

CAde, Ciiarla« faysttA 1/11/1790 Cac^bell, Jas* Linooln 4A5A790 Carlile, James Woodford 7AA790 Case, Kat-ianiel Nelson 11/8A7S2 Cahey, Jno. Fftyette 1/11/1790 Campbell, Joanna Fayette 6/30/1739 Carlile, Thomas Woodford 7/30/1790 Case, Samuel Nelson 11/28/1792 Cain, Sdaund Bourbon 3/1*^91 Campbell, Joanna Woodford 5/29/1790 Caroan, Joseph 7/12/1789 Case, Seprate Bourbon sA791 Cain, Uawhlsa Relaon 11/1/1792 Campbell, John Fayette S/22A789 Carssm, Joshua Helson 11/9A792 Case, Wm., Sr. Nelsffii 11/8/1792 Cain, Patrlolc Kelson 11/24/1792 Campbell, John Fayette 8/4A739 Carpenter, Adam Linooln 5/12/1790 Casebeer, lb, Nelson il/24/1792 Caim, Echmr-i Fayotto 3/19/1790 Campbell, Jno, Fayotte 2/27/1790 Carpenter, Conrod Linooln 5A3A790 Casey, Join Linooln 4/15A79O Calbert, Daniel JeCforscn 9/7/l7b9 Cas^bellj Jno. Fayette 3/19/1790 Carpenter, Dan. Fayette 12/2A789 Cash, John Linooln 4/15/1790 Calden, "Vllliaa Bourbon 3/1791 Campbell, John Jefferson 7/16A789 Carpenter, Elizabeth Liuooln 5/13/1790 Cash, Warren F,^yette 7/2/1739 Caldnell, ^lemuder Bourbon 3/1791 Campbell, John Jeffersca 9/4A790 Carpenter, John Bourbcn 5A791 Casl&y, Bobart Bourbon 6/1791 Cald?rell, .Anderson Bourbco 3/1791 Caz^bell, John Masca 7A790 Carpenter, John Uadismi 1789 Caslny, William Bourbon 6A791 Cald'nell, D^vid Bourbon 3/1791 Campbell, John Woodford 5/26/1790 Carpenter, Hathan Uason 7A790 Cass, Darid Nelsoi 10/27/1792 Cald-vell, David Llnooln 6/23/1790 Campbell, John Woodford 3/26/1790 Carpetar, John BourbcsL 6A791 Cass, William Nelson U/8A792 Cftldwell, Isaao Fayotte i/nA79o Can^bell, John Woodford 6/iA791 Carr, Edeard Fayette 2/27A790 Cassedy, Jno. Fayette 1A1A790 Cal+rfoll, Joaooh Fayetto i/iiA'so Campbell, Johnson Uason 8/5/1790 Carr, Hanah lbscm 1790 Cassity, Uiohael Uason 1790 Caliwell, Philips Ueroer 3/10/1789 Canqabell, Joseph Fayette 2/27/1790 Carr, Joseph Bourbcc 3/1791 Cascsi, John Bourbon 6/1791 CaliwoH, Willtnn Bourbon 3/1791 Campbell, Joaiah Fayette 7/23/1789 Carr, Joseph Fayette 2/27A790 Casteelman, Lewis Fayette 5/9/1789 Caldwoll, Wn. Woodford 5/22/1790 Campbell, Patrick Fayette 12/3/1789 Carr, Patrlok Bourbon 3/1791 Caswell, John Linooln 4/3/1790 Call, Jaaaa Vi'oodforl 5/29/1790 Campbell, Robt. Fajiette 2/27/1790 Carr, Peter Woodford 4/25A790 Cat, George Jeffers<3i 10/3/1739 Callahan, Jaates Jefrerson 9/3/1790 Campbell, Vhn. Fayette 5/22A739 Carr, Walter, Fayette 2/27A790 Cat, George Jeffersm 7/24/1790 Galloway, Cnarley Fayatte 2/27/1790 Campbell, William Fayotte 5/22/1789 Carrol, John Woodford 5/29/1790 Gathers, Edward Fayette 6/b/i799 Galloivay, Edaond Fayette 2/27/1790 Can^bell, Ito. Fayotte 11/10/1789 Carrell, Daniell Bourbon 3/1791 Cattoa, Jessey Fayette 5/19/1769 Cailonay, Flandis Fayette 2/27/1790 Campbell, Wm. Fayotte 12/8A789 Carll, Samuel Woodford 5/28/1790 CaturmuB, Jefferson 7/30/1790 Galloway, Raohael Jefferson 4/29/1789 Campbell, Wm, Fayette 12/13/1789 C&rsar, Biohard Jefferson 6A4A790 Caturmus, Elisha Jefferson 9/3/1790 Callo»ay, banuel Jefferson 4/30/1759 Campbell, Wnu Fayotte 1/11A79O Carson. Elex. Linooln 3/29/1790 Catifaan, Abram Bourbon 3A791 Gallo»»y, Wm. Fayebte 2/27/1790 Campbell, Wia., Capt Fayette 1/UA790 Carter, Friend Uaroer SAoA789 Caulbert, Jno. fayette 1AiA790 Gallaess, Marquess Woodfori 5/29^790 Campbell, Wa, Fayette 2/27/1790 Carter, George Fayotte 2/27A790 Cauldwell, Robt. Fayette 3/19/1790 Galon, Luther Uasoa 8/21/1790 Campbell, Wn. Fayette 3/19/1790 Carter, George Woodford 5/29A790 Caulk, Thonxs Ward Neleoa 12/6/1792 Calverb, Jno. Linooln 5/18/1790 Campbell. Wm. Woodford 5/26/1790 Carter, Henry Woodford 3/2SA790 Cauth, Benja. Fayotte z/i9/n9o Ganble, John Mason 1790 Campbell, Wm., Jr. Woodford 5/26/1790 Carter, John Fayette 12/3/1789 Cave, Daniel Woodford 5/22/1790 Gaaip, ^vld Fayette Il/IOA'QS Caapor, Henry Fayette 12/5/1739 Carter, Jno. Fayotte 2/27/1790 Cave, James Uadison 3/27/1789 Garipbell, ^lax. Fayette lA^A^^® Camper, Robt. Fayott* 12/13/1799 Carter, John Fayette 2/27A790 Cave, James Madisem 3/27A739 Ga;.ipbell, Aroliabald Fayotte s/z/naa Camper, Telmon Fayette 12/5A789 Carter, William Woodford 3/23/1790 Cave, John Fayette 5/25/1739 CajnpbeH, Daniel Fayette 11/27/1769 Capo, John Fayette 3/19/1790 Cary, Darmla Bourbon SA791 Caw, Ibiu Fayette 12/23/1739 Ga-apboll, Cfcniel Woodford 5/23/1790 Caphart, Jno. Fayotte 1/11/1790 Gary, Edmcmd Fayette 2/27/1790 Cave, William, Jr. Fayette 5/23/1739 Ganpbell, George Fayette 5/22A789 Caphart, Jno. Fayette I/IIA790 Cary, Joseph Nelson 10/22/1792 Cave, Vb., Jr. Fayette 6/2A789 Ca-ipbell, George Fayette 8/4A799 : Carada, John Fayotte 12AA799 Casady, ha. Lincoln 6/2/1790 Cave, Wb. Woodford 3/19/1790 Case, Goldsmith Carapbell, George Fayette 12/27/1739 Caraday, Daniel Fayette 3/19A790 Bourbon 3/1791 Cave, Wm., Jr. Woodford 3/26/1790 Campbell, George TJoodford 5/27/1790 Caradwoll, Jtunoa Ueroer 3/10/1739 Case, Jaoob Nelson 11/12A792 Cave, Vb., Jr. Woodford 3/26/1790 Campbell, Georgt Woodfori 5/5/1790 Carethers, 9onJa. Fayotte 3A9A790 Case, James Nelson 11/9A792 Cavens, Robt. Fayette 6/7A789 Campbell, Henry Fayette 7/22/1799 ^ Cariagton, Wm. Fayotte 1/11/1790 Case, John Nelson 11/8A792 Caver, James Uadison 1789 Case, Joseph Ciimpbell, Hugh Fayette 1/11/1790 , Carlile, George F yotte 7/21A799 Bourbon 3/1791 Cavlne, Thcraas Fayotte 1/11/1790 5/22/1790 CaTpbell, James Fayette 8/4/1759 : Carlile, George 'i^ftolford ^ae, Uiohal Bourbon 3/1791 Cavirvson, George Jefferson 5/28/1769 It

CAOTEO JOHN MONB 201 NO T»P L CABY, DANltL MERC 009 NO Two L CASTta. CONHOO C»OTEO JOHN ADA I 012 NC T MP L CAPY, earNtzeB p. HAOn 0 76 I I TTL' ' MFBC 099 NO Two L lASTEH. ELIZABETH BkAC 0 I 5 Nil TWF 1 CARTEO, J 1>< N OOOB O'R* NO TMP L CAPV, EDWARD CUMH 131 NO Two L CA9TEB. J t)H N LASTING, HFNMY • O.IC I I 9 NO TWE I FAVE ORR NC TmB L CABY. EVENE7EB MERC 089 NO Tw" L JOHN LASTINE. PAUL HARD 0 7 7 I I TTlF ' CAPtef. CUMiT 151 NO TmP I CABY. HENRY CUMtl 121 NO TWP . CASTLE. ABRAHAM C ABTf"• JOHN NELS 193 NC TWP L C ARY, JAMES JESS 08 T NO T»F I CHRl 042 NO TWO . CASTLE. PA/lL CAPTEJ. HQPK 230 NO TkP L CABY. JAMES H, ELOr 036 NO T«t" l CAP TEP. '!0L« I I 6 NO TWP L CASTLE. DAVID rATf 106 NO T»P t J'>HN FRAN I*6 LAMBf NCr C AFY. JUHN MFBC 092 NO Two I C4 :> TL E • HEOI K 1 AH FLOY 0?4 ND TV® I CAB fE IJ , JOHN FLEM OJO NC TUP L CAPY, MILES MUK. 143 NO TWO L CASTLE. JOHN Floy 924 ni' r»® ' CAPteo. JOHN NELS 205 NC Two L CABY. NAlHANieU CUMIl 1 50 NO TwP L CAP TCP. CASTLE. JOHN wean 069 NO r«®i JOHN fl. •OCO ORB NO TWO L CASA. t.HAORICK OR AC 004 NO TwP L CAP TEP. J IMN EK. CASTLE. NATHAN Fl tiv 0 36 NO T.r . WAYN 304 NC TWO L CA5ADV. JEREMt ALLE 122 N(! TwP L CABTE-i. JOHN JR, CASTLE. RilBFBT HrND 01? MFNOFes^ □OUN 009 NO TWP L CASAOY. JESSE Ft OY 006 NU Tw= L CAS ILEBL BUY. JAMES HOPK ?18 Nl) T«6 • CARTES. JOHN JH, NICH I 22 NO TWP U CASAl. CAVIO CAB TfB. MFkC 090 NO TW° L CASTLEDFRRY. WiLllAN CALD 0 3? NO T'" ' J )HN N. WOOD C-JB NO Two CASCNIS. EDWARO P. CAB TK -J , LINC 071 NO TwP L t-VSlLEDINE, JOHA MONT 24 1 Nl. T»P I JOHN K. JEF-F 01* MIODLEin C ASOV . Ll 1/AUETH 84 TH I 90 OW INC. SVI CABTF P. JOHN ,SB. □CON 010 NC Two L CAirLEM*N. AUGUSTUS hcnR 2o4 no rwP I CASE. CENJAHIN WASH 050 NO TWP L LAS TLEMAN. Gl ORGE CABTEP. JOSEHH t'L-ON 000 NO Two L FBAN 16* F"»N*fr9 CASE 1 DEL ILA BDLP 1 06 NO Tw" L CASTLEMAN. JAMES HARD 020 1 ITTl' ' CAP TEP. JOStHH rtpF.C 2«S NC Two L CASE. EDWARD HWAC 009 Nil TWP L CASTLEMAN. JOHN FRAN 1354 I AWRFaC CARTER. JOSEPH PATH 100 NO Two L CASE, GEORGE MONT 237 NO Twn L CAR TEB. CASTLEMAN. LEWIS FBAN 054 FkANK'OA JOSr PH WASH 05B NC Two L CASf. HUBATlO MB AC 023 NO TwP L CABTFB. LASTLY. OAVID f,ATH no n« iNr.6>r JOSF OH MONR 201 NO Two L CASF. JAHFr. MB AC 020 NO TWP L CABTEP. CASTO. ABIJAH MA--.D OTP PAflVSVll JOSJ.PH SHEL 150 SHFLHY C CASE. JAMFS HAon 090 L1TTLE V CAR Tf R , JOSEPH CASTS, HDBERT r.l. AB 060 Nl ' t«Pl GAOB 004 LANCASTfc CASE. JOl'iN CASE 214 NO TWP L CAB TEB. CASWELL. FLTJAH ALLE 0 96 NU Tw® I JOSCPH 0BAC 003 NO TWO L CASE. JOHN BQDN 006 Nil TWP L CAR TE". LA S WE LL. JOHN HA9T 156 NO TWPI JOSEPH GBEE 175 NO Two L CASE. JOSEPH BO L« I 06 NO TwP L CAB TER. JOSEPH CASWELL. JOHN 59. HAST 1 55 Nil Til' I CU"(3 154 NO TWP L CASE. JOSEPH CAPTEP, OH la Oil HARTFCiao CASwELLi SAMUEL HACp . 9 J N'T Twl' I JOSfOH GREE C6I NO TWP L CASE. JOSEPH 8"AC 009 NO TWP L CABTEB. JOSEPH JCN PATH IBO OWlNGSVl CASWELL. THOMAS HART 1 54 N.I rwP I CASE. THEOPHILUS MDNT 231 NO TWP L CASWELL. WILLIAM GP AY 13 3 NO Tw" • CAB TFB. JOSHUA JESS 06B NO Two u CASE, wILL I AH MASO 073 NO TWP L CATALCr. NATHANIFL HAop 064 LITILF ' CARTER. JOSHUA 0. FHAN 156 LAwOFNCf CASEblER. JACOB CAR TFB . MUK. 141 NO TWP L LATANGER. SALLY WASH 087 NO Tw® I JOillllA 0. FBAN 150 LAWPENCF CASEtllER. WILLIAM CAB TFB , MUK. 141 NO TwP L CATCHING. HENJAMIN KNO* 23d NO Tw® I JOS I AH CUMR 137 NO Two L CASEb. BENJAMIN GTl I 70 NO TWP L CAB TE R , LFV I ROAC 014 NO Two L C4 ICHlNG. LAVMOPE KNOW 2A8 NO TwP I C ASfHAN. wILL I AH JF SS 066 NO TwP L CATE5. ABNfl. CAB TE-P. "APGARtT NELS 205 NC TWP I HiJPK 236 NU r»P I CASESINGEH, JACOB OHlrj 006 HABTfnaO CATE.S. ALFKANDEB HOPK 235 NO rw I CAB TE" I PAP T I N MERC 0S>2 NC TwP L CASETY. JACOB BA TH I 00 Nu TW" L GATES. UEN.IAMIN HOPK 2J5 NU rtP I CAR TER. MASHAF BULL 160 NO TWO u CASFY. ABCHIOALO HARB 219 HO Twn L CAB TfP , UA THI A S FBAN 146 LAWBENCe CaTES. inuM HOPK 2J6 H - TwC I CASEY, UDRBIOGE .IF EF 054 NO T »P L CAIES. JOHN COEF 069 N. rw® 1 C AP Tf r. , « )PT S HOOK 230 NO Two I CASEY. CLAPFAN CL AR 09 6 NO T WP L CATESi JCHN SR. hfiPK 2 18 NU tw® ! CAB Tf p, •JANCY CUMa 154 NO TwP L C ASfV , DAW ID GRAY I 32 NO Twn L CA TCS . i< I CHA "D E'.TI 04? wAvFnn* CABTFP. NASL Y MUIL 1 IB NO TWP U C ASEY , DAVI 0 SR . CAB I( . N!C HOC A 5 &H AY 152 NO TwP L CATHALL. JOSHUA ir I f 0*4 Ml DiK ' NELb I 06 NO TWO L CASEY, GREEN ADA! 014 NO rWP L CAR Tpn ■ CA I HE V. ANOBF W iJNin 149 Mf.HGAN" or Tt R LlNC OOB NO Two L CASFY. HENRY GH AY I 32 NO TWP L CAB Tr p. "f T r B t , LA THE V. WlLLI AM LOGA 0 39 kUSSFLVl LINC 061 NO TWP L CASEY. JAMFS HAPB 2O0 NO TWP L CA r l.e T . FRANC I S FhAN 1 .16 I- AWOFMtf CAR TFR , "HILIO eAue 007 NO TWP L CASEY, JCHN CAPTEB. GH AY 133 NO TWP L CATLET. JAMES JESS 0'»6 NU T»P ' "IC HABO SHEL 128 NO Two L CASEY, JOHN WARR 071 NO TWP L CAP IE R, R I ChABO GAkM 097 NO TWP L CATLETi JOHN JESS 069 NU TwP V CASEY. JOHN BRfC 247 HO TWP L CATLET, PETER CAB TE n , B I C H A fl tl F. HBEC 245 NO Two L HOON 0 I 0 N'T TwP 1 CASEY, JOHN HFNO 012 HENPEHSO CAlLtll. C4LMFS4 CAB TEP , pITCHfc HABU 166 NC TWP I UNir 146 U'lBf.AN^I CASFY. JOHN D. GH fF 050 NO TwP L CATLETT. ELI JAM SHfL 1*5 5HF1 BY f C AB T{> , P OH f P T GREE 066 NO TwP U CASFY, JOSEPH CAMP Oil NO TWP L CATLETT. eilSHA OATH I 56 UW lN„fVl CABTFP, ■' OH E n T CLA" 00J NO T WO L CASET. jnSIAH FBAH 082 LAWRENCE CABTFH, CAILETT. FANNY F AYE 0 70 Nil TwP I BflHSB T BOON 010 NO Two L CASEY, LEV! GARB 120 HO TWP L CARTER. CA TLE TT . r.EC"aE UN ID 146 MORGANl I BO Itn T FAYE 094 NO TwP L CASEY. MOSES P. FAYE oai NO TWB L C AP TF P, Jll-UMT JB. CAILETT. GEkOGE F. UNin 1*9 ■llur.A-l'i HAUT 156 NO Two L CASEY. QHN CLAB 072 NO TWP L CAB Tf P. HCTU B T SB . HART 156 NO TWP L CATLETT, HTOMAS B. SCUT I 25 "in IWI' I CASEY. PfTER UN 10 146 MURCANFI CATlEtr. JOHN CAP TEP. f.AHUCl, CUMH 138 NCI TWP L Fl Fm 036 NO TwP ' CASEY, RADNOLPH L t Vi 013 SALEM CATLETT, PETFR CAPTf . SAHutL HARR 176 NO TwP L UNIT |4ft MuOGANf.' CASEY. RlLEY JE fF 062 HD TwP L CATHNi DORY WASH 066 N'T TwP I C AR TF P , S* 'lit L HABO 0B2 L1TTlC Y CASFY, SAMUEL WARM OTl NO twn L CATLIN. OOOY r AB Tf P, SAPUt L HARD 070 LITTLE Y W ASM 0 33 Nl. T »'• I CASFY. STEPHEN GaRO 1 00 NO Twl' L CATLIN. JOHN T. C AB TI C. •-.A'JOOM BAUB 007 NO TwP L WASH 031 Nil IwP 1 CASEY. THOMAS MARR 190 NO TwP L C* TLI N. NANC Y CABTFP, .,A)AH MRS. CLAW I 06 NC TWP L WASH 01.1 NU tw® I CASEY. WILLlAM B. MONT 253 NO TwP L CATLlN. WILLIAM CAB TCP. SOC OHON FNC* 200 NO IWP L WASH 068 NO r«® I CAB TFB , CASH. ARCHIBALD CL Art 103 NO TWP L CAIMAN, TUBMAN t'LAO 059 Nil TW>' I SOLOMON LINC 013 NO TW" L CASH. El t/ABETH WASH 073 NO TwP L CAB TCP. Sn.CHON CABB 113 NO TwP I CATO, HENRY rolG 014 Nil TwP 1 CAB TE", CASH. ISAIAH MUK. 1*2 HO TwP L CATCIN. GECIfiOC 0. MERC 090 NT rwP . SOlUMON no AC 014 NO TWP L CASH. JAMES NELS 197 HO TWP L CABTEP. CATCN, JEMIMA MF9C 090 NO TW"I SOL OMON MONT 22S NO IWP L CASH. JAHtS PULA 045 NO TwP L CAPTE". Tho a 5 CATRCK. PETFR WAYN 061 Nil To" I aOUR 070 NO TWP L CASH, JOHN PULA 046 NO TwP L CATTERSON, JAMES G4I L I 20 NO TW" ' CAB TC P. •THOMAS FAYE 094 NC TWP L CASH. JOHN MA SO 033 NO TWP L CAk Ti P i Th jma S CATTERSON. WILLIAM GALL 120 NO r«0 1 MASO 050 NC TWO L CASH. JOHN NELS 197 NU TwP L CABTF". Thiima S CAT TICU r. MABRISON ADAI 023 NO TwP I C4L0 032 NO TWP L CASH, JOHN MUK. 1*2 NO TWP L CABTFP. TH lMA S CATTRILL. THOMAS JR. NICH IC5 NU T»o 1 FBAN 092 LAwPFNCE CASH. LAkXIN PULA 045 Nil TwP L CAPTfB. CA T T V£ , WILL 1 AH BRAf oil Nil Tw" I THOMAS GOEE 060 NO TWP L CASH, LAWSON CALO 0.10 NO TWB 1. C AB TE B, Th jma S CAUDRY, MABY FATE 076 NO rw® I OWEN lOl NO TwP L CASH, NELSON SHEL 162 SHELRV C CABTE-'. TIL MAN CAUGFORO. NANCY BOCK 051 N'' rw® I MFBC 091 NO T WP L CASH, SAMUEL LOGA 014 BU5SELVI CABTE". tAUGHEY. DAVID BUTL 319 NT rw® I •ALKEO JEFF 020 LOUlSVII. CASH, THOMAS CUMB 164 NO TW" L CARTES. • Al.RtP JEFT 020 LOUISVIL CAUGHMAN. DAVID FAY? 093 Nil TwP I CASH, WARREN HARD 06* L I TTl. E Y CAB TFB, HA SHI NO TCN CAUGhRAN. JOHN MADI 174 NP rwP I OULL 169 NO TM O L CASH, WILLIAM PULA 048 NO TwP L CASTF B, kiLl GARB 006 NC TWP L CAUGMRAN. SAMUEL MAiii 112 sn rw" I CASH, WILLIS CAID 044 NO TwP L CAUIFar, BADF OPO CAB TF B, « t LLI AM 9PAC 022 NO TWP L PUL A 04 4 Nil TW® I CASH, WIN gray 132 NO TwP L CAURV. JDHN CAB TES. A1..L 1 AH HAQI i10 NO TWP L FBAN 060 FOANKFII" CASHAniCUH. MARTIN OB EC 247 NO TWP L CAUStiT. JOHN WASH 006 NO TW® I CAB TFB. • lUl I AH CUMO 119 NO T WP L CASHDROOKE. JOHN MA 50 0 58 NO TWP L CAUSY, REBECCA f AO TE o. ■ III I am CU"B 140 NO TWP L FAYC 078 NO TwP I CAS'TMAN. PETER BBEC 247 NO TWP L CAT TFB , ■ T L L I A M OHIO 005 MABTFilRD CAVAKAH. CHARLES CHBI 0 35 NO TW? ' CASHUN, THOMAS DA TH 102 NO TWP L CA VANAH, DAV ID CAB TE B. ■ III I AN HONH 201 NO TwP L HIIPK 2 33 NC Tw® 1 CASHIJT, EEL IK T . NELS 176 HA IDS CAVANAH, WILLIAM CAB ie«. ■ III I am MONT 241 NO TWP L FHR I 0 35 Nil T W® I CASHWtLL. JOHN LINC 009 NO TwP L Cab TEP. ■ 111 1 AH CAVAHAUuM. PHILLY 3. FAYE t I ! Nf fw" I HABU 005 NC TwP 1. CASIDY. PETER FL EM 045 NO Tw" L CAB TFB • ■ ILL I AH CAVE. AHNFP GP5E 053 ND TW® I W4YN 092 NC TWP L CASINGER. ANDREW □UTL 319 NO TWP L CARTER. • II L I AM A . MONT 279 NO TwP L CAVE. JEREMIAH nODN 0 10 Nl. r wP 1 CASITV, ISAAC HA TH 200 OWlNGSVl LAVE. FCLLY CAP TF u , H ILL I A U C . PUL4 056 SDHf.RSr.T ROCk 0 10 un Tw" i CASITY, ISAAC BATH 214 OWlNGSVl CAVE. THOMAS CAPTE". /At MAP I AH JEFF 051 NO TWP L GBEF 07A NC TWP I CASITY, JOHN OAIH 200 OWINGSVt CAVE. THOMAS GBEF 0S9 NT TwP I IBTIS ■ III IAN HULL 102 NO TWP L CASITY, JOHN SA TM 214 nw INC. SVI CAVE, URIEL BOCN 910 NO 'w® L CASITY. JOHN QATH 21* OWlNGSVl CAVE. WILLIAM MOnT 257 NCI Twfl t CASITY, PETER BA TH 2 14 OWINGSVI CA VE. WILLIAM "ONT 24 I NU TwP I B4TH 220 nwlNCSVl CASITY. REUBEN BA IH 2 14 OwiNG SVI BA TH I 60 NC TWP U CAVE, HILLI AM JEFF 057 Nd TwP L CASITY. STEPHEN BATH 214 OWlNGSVl CAVE. WILLIAM JR. BOTN 046 HUOlInG' NELS 210 NO TWP L CASITY, STEPHEN BATH 196 OWlNGSVl BATH I 74 NO TWP L CAVE. WILLIAM SR. BQilN 0 10 Nl) TwP L CASKEY. JOHN WA SH 034 NO TWP L CAVEN. THOMAS GBt E 059 NT YWP I NELS 209 NO TWP L CASREY, JOHN FlGT 006 NO TwP L CAVENAUGM, FI ELDING JFFE 044 JEFFERSO FAYE III Nil 'WP I CASREY, THOMAS FLOY OOS NO TwP L CAVEnAUCh, LEROY CLAB 077 Nf Tw" I TABTNEf MUHL 135 NO TWP L CASRV. ROBERT CAOTON. ar:hihald AOAI 012 NO TWP L LAVENDER. JAMES SCOT I 13 N® TW® '. tSIl 045 BAVfNNA CASKV, BQBERT ADA! OSO NO Twn L CABTBIOMT. CHPISTIANNA CHRl 045 NO TwP L CAVENOCR. JAMES SCOT 1 1 J Nl T,P L CASLE. JOHN FBAN 120 LAWRENCE avENQEH. JOSFPH Chs1 033 NU fw" L CABTI! rOHT . FL I JAF GBEE 173 HO IWP I CASLEV. JUFiN CAB TB I l,HT , JO SEPM CASE 216 NU TWP L AVENOtR . NANCY FAYE 075 N' TwP L ADA I 010 NC TWP L CASLIN. ANDREW CAB TS ICHT. LF V I JEFF 055 NO TWP L CAVCNS. ABSOLUM SCOT lOA N'- TWP I GBEE I 71 NO TWP L CASON. GRANVILL CAP TO 1 OH T. OF TEP MABR 132 NO TWP L CA VENS. WILL t A M SCilT 106 N® Two I CHBI 045 NO fwP I CASON. JOHN CAP TR ItiH T , THIlMA S HARR 142 NO TWP L CAVLRN S. Will I AM SCOT 10 2 Nl. TwP I GBEE 173 NO TwP L CASON. NtLSUN HARR 160 NO TwP L CABTwFlL. ELIJAH CaverY. john ■ ARB 031 Nil TwP I FA YH 101 NO TWP L CASON, WILLIAM SCOT 133 NO TwP L CAB TdELL. OEOBGE BBAC 019 NO TWP U CAVET, DEAOOICM CASF ? 1 8 NCI TwP I CASPfcH. JOHN CL AH 090 NO TwP L CAVIN. *ILLI AM CABTt. ILL. . THOMAS BATH 166 NO T WP L GALL I 25 Nl TwP I CASPER. PETER CLAR 098 NO TwP L CAVINS. JOHN FAYE 100 NU TwP L CABTbOICHT, BENNETT E. CALP 03O DANVILLE CASS, SAMUEL WABR 063 NO TwP L CA V1 T T. THOMAS gall 131 NO TwP CABTXBIOHT. JUST IAN CALO 052 DANVILLE C ASSACAY. HART IN PULA 046 NU TwP L CAVLEBT, JOHN HnuR 102 NU TwP I CABTY. JAMLS CUMB 140 NO TWP L CASSACY. CANIEl. MERC 092 NO TWP L CAWHI RO . REUftEN SHFL I 52 S HR, PY C CABTT. JONATHAN BATH 200 OWlNGSVl CASSADT. JOEL. AOAI 018 NO TwP L CAWIN. HANNAH WAYN 090 NC TUP 1 CABTY. BlLLlAM CltM-J I 40 NO TWP L CASSAL. JACOB CABTY, BlLLlAM MERC 09O NO TwP L CAWKINS. ISAAC MA9n 042 L 1 TTLf » CAMP 017 NO TWP L CASSEOAV. THOAM5 JEFF 047 JEFPERSO CABJTHCHS, HUGH LiVl 010 SAl.EH CAMLET. RICHARD SHFL 158 AHFLRY C CASSELL. ABRAMIN FAYE 066 NO TWP L CA WLEt. 8ALLATHIEL CABVEN. ■ILLIAH LI VI 015 B 01! I SONS GBFF 068 NU TwP I CASSELL. HENRY FATE 066 NO TWP L CAWOnO, PERRY MABl I 06 Nil TW® 1 CABVER. AOCHILUS MACI 104 NC TWP L CASSELL. JACOB CARVER, SAOTHOLCME" FA YE 070 NO TWP L CAWOOO. JOHN HARL 104 NU TWP I BARB 007 NO TWP L CASSETV. WILLIAM CABvGB, CQBNELlcS MICH 1 IT NO TWP L CAwOOO. JOSEPH H4BL 104 N® TwP I aAtin 007 NO TwP L CASSEY. HENRY CAMP 007 NO twP L CABVEO, ISA AC GAHR 111 NO rwP L cawscy, jnsEPM CASE 204 wn TwP I CASSIDY, JAMES NICH 109 NCI TWP L CAtoTHCRN. ASA • CL 4fl 09 1 ND TwP I CABVER. JAMES MA'JI 104 NO TWP L CASSIOY. JEREMIAH CARVER. JAMES NlCH II* NO TWP L CAwrHORM. TARLTON JEFF 024 LODISY'L FAYE 091 NC TWP L CASSIOY. THOMAS CABVER. JAMfS FL EM 0*6 NO TWP L CAwniHON. BENJAMIN JEFF 039 JFFFFOSO MONB 209 NO TWP L CASSITY. WILLIAM e* TH 200 OWlNGSVl CARVER. JOHN DAHH 007 NO TWP L CA TCE . CHAUI.f S SHFL 140 NO TwP I CAST. AHON Cl AR 070 NO TWP L CAVER. UILEV SHFL 141 NO TwP l CARVER. JOHN GABR til NO TWP L CAST. JAMES Carver, johnson CLAR 096 NU TWP L CATION. ABEL WAOB 040 NU TWP I Oflte I 7* NO TWP L CASTEAL. ZACHARIAH CARVER. HOMAN HARD 020 L r TTLE T CAYTON. PHILILP GAIL 121 NO TWP I MADI 104 NO TwP L CASTECL. JOHN CL AY I 14 NO TWP L CABVER. SO.OMON GABB 113 NO TWP L CAYTON. WILLIAM WABR 040 Nf> TW" I CABVSB. THOMAS CASTEEL, JOHN MJNR 193 NO TWP L C4YT0R, WILLIAM ALLf I 32 SrOTTSVl FRAN 128 LAWRENCE CASTEEL. JOSEPH MONR 105 NO TWP L CABVER. THOMAS FBAN 160 LAWRENCE CAYWOOO. AQUILLA BATH I 84 Nfl TwP I CASTELDERRY. FLEMIN CALO 034 NO TwP L CAY WOOD. ISAAC BllUP 066 NO TWP L CAfiVEB, VlLLIAH BARR 007 NO TWP L CAST ELaEr

PAGE CITY/TOWN HEAD OF HOUSEHOLD FREI WH. TE f"JALEJ REE WHITE FEMALE H" H to u •o CD H 0 U1 o 0 0 Ln U1 o O o 0 0 O 1 1 j 1 1 1 1 o H M u> •o to UJ ui CD + Ul O o o o 7 TysT'C Id', o o O o O o b / / / 1051- / z / A//^ or AdiJcrr'^ 5-10 v' /A7A^C7— C iA' 90001- 08-70 8009- 5006-

1i40 05-

7 :>

— ^ //J^ x-yy Z". <"X' -,z cZ> .

/7 7 c y Z-,^ -r? Z' <£

OCCGS FORM #17 ORANGE COUNTY CALIFORNIA GENEALOGICAL SOCIETY, PO BOX 1587, ORANGE, CA 92668 BMIMIiHWawi!5

■■ r 1 •! ranm^ m mHUH immmam

W fV fte missm mwrnn II iiiiiiinrnm BBHBi WHinMnHiaHB

%r-- "f ~ IA in*ro HHtibiliili

d^/uek =2^/-[5d>L^^ I

ikhsD U4r|<^^ ^WTT SiZilSilMIHBBI i # !■ i 'U:'|^^N*<^V;

t.A

2*rw ;i

ifi-r-.-i,-'. - 0- r2.L^ 5

fl

im j Married vithin Cm — I y-r Auendd 'Beiwel .. \ j.:.-_t...j within the year.

s §; g ^ is- ^?• r3 ^g- U 9 * t/'vi-e:?

UJJL LmkitdLcJ^ 2U!X^

//v Jf /--K^ ^2^ /{> ,v /

Z£Z2 /JyT^f.y-A

tr,t,A 9^ - //'i

t /aC

,\((i- Jj'^t : ' .AfJi ^vtxg f^yfi .^4^ lA

O a A A fHH r/J-.5^- .1.

a.rfi

•-<■<

IVAl OlU . iOayy^ir^

d^Jnt^ a—t^.,:iv

Guaeuil<£-f fi f7 d tf ^

Mm n». ecniTlM*

.t . ..-^{iA., '• • ^1> 1 Page if ■*^ Dwellinf; Nu. X ' 1 eA v ' 1 V :b^ N 5sl 1 fe> Sl\ >> \ "T r w /\V^ 3n f fty 0 :< ^15 1 (a T ^ 1 u f o 1 o \ Color i\ 5x X Sex (> /> x Age prior to * Bh. 55- June Ist Month of birth if > < bom in census yr.

Cj W X 0^ Relationship to X « h 4"^ > head of house z CO 1 »\ C 1"1 1 r 1 Single X — ------. X V X Married z

Widowed w Divorced D

Married in census year —H <> 1 W CO $ Occupation h IS t'- 1 1A Miscellaneous Information

Cannot read X X X X X X or write ! X X X Place of birth O 0 a % s 1^ 1

n 0 Place of birth

of father e

Place of birth • of mother

Fjiumerntion Date

" 7)St sr o/^ jV^ar^ y^/(2,/^/o^?<^^ peo. // ^<^G:/%?T:/7U 7^ (/>^ X. P/oyA'. 7777' 7/ (s') zf/ei/^o^s 7-. cr52:?t /7fc f (3) r¥/v^a. //f-r^r

(?j^/7r7~f^^ ^^ yv/ —5o /^'/s /f A//5 *!!^ ^SlLo A^/^h- ¥

C>^e

/•/

4^/iT^ /3 /»/ c^- ?l^/M // ^z" // "3^ O . ^jzJ^/?73 7 // /n^— ¥

\ ^ (U^/gW

/cy/^ . ^'iSi^juu \ /jD- OOfL^A^siy^

.6^0 s'1/ y^cw^) ^ c v; V-' ^o' >, Xo* &_5^ i /o /^£> o ^tiA/ (2o.

^ 9 my^ J> /?W y^

c r „ /f /y. IS" 3 3 pft. i^Y/Z£j, -J, fWo Ho. 55 /fy || PaAoCi.y..yj^ J2-/ /f7j- : P£yL.ci.-eC- /glf ^JLy(yCA.^^ /c /f/5

•CP-. C-- /?

/ c jLA / ^ ^ c=:> /Z^ / - e stoa/ &P^a/ y^7f/e__ /V 9^ 9^/^^'^:/— 5'

2^ -' ' r-A/ sr Va. ppb

^y/^2> "2^ /V o /fs^

//4^^y ^ Xf df^A G /F-r/ ^■4A9G'S 4/. /-S"^ Af40. /W <■/ <7 ^/ /V^ ISPf 9^tMA/'rcr Ai, ^C Mo- /na /^/Situ 99a a/ // p Ifw ^aA.9/9e.9r- X /XK ^i/9)9,sr\/ 77 p mi /fir^

c , /87^

9^lS'SS9^ /V. -lAZ^ /Fzr ^/1 'IG ✓/ /FFc:?

/ A/ fo )//« /^IaG /f // 9^X fi3Q '^

Part One famtlvof The Indiana Cartmel families 154 years of Cartmel Hoosiers

Whether or not you are polis, Indiana; and Geral- Cartmel of Seymour, India. lucky enough to trace your dine Cartmel Perkins, also Our next issue will con ancestors to a satisfactory of Indianapoli s. clude this current series on conclusion, you can almost The combined data which the Cartmel genealogy with a always count on finding some they have supplied comes review of the remaining sons "cousins" along the way. just in time to supplement and daughters of John Jr. Speaking for myself, one of our continuing series on the • the biggest joys has been in descendants of John Cartmel/ When you speak of the discovering my fellow Cart Cartmel1, Sr. of Harrison "sons of the pioneers" you mel descendants who share Co., Kentucky (who we at must include the name Pres that common goal. tempted to link with the ton Cartmel. His father, In the space of Just a Frederick Co., Virginia fam- John Jr., and grandfather, few weeks, back in 1982, I ily in our last issue). John Sr., were among the made contact with three avid In this issue we will al early settlers of Kentucky, genealogists who were all so highlight the family and coming to Harrison County descended from Preston Cart descendants of John David prior to 1795' mel, the brother of my g.g. Barton Warren Stone Cartmel, In 1805, just thirteen grandfather. Up until this one of the brothers of Pres years after Kentucky became time, I had very little in ton Cartmel. Both men were the fifteenth state to enter formation about Preston and sons of John Cartmel, Jr. the Union, the first-born of his family. But thanks to who established his family John Jr. and Mary "Polly" all three of these fine la in Harrison Co., Kentucky, Scott Cartmel emerged to dies, we can all share the and later in Rush Co., In take his first breath of the research which they have diana. Our information re pure Bluegrass State air. compiled. garding J.D. Barton W.S. Nine children would follow, My new-found cousins In Cartmel comes from the fami leaving Preston to carry 0^ clude Mary Dawson Rahe of lies of Thomas Oliver Cart his expected responsibili Shelbyville, Indiana; Doro mel of Indianapolis, Indi ties as the elder brother. thy Cartmel Boyd of Indiana ana, and Jerry Patterson (A list of Preston's younger sibl ings can be found in is sue no.17.) Between the time that THE C.C.C. FAMILY QUARTERLY Preston was born and while EDITOR & PUBLISHER, WILLIAM PATRICK CARTMEL he was still living with his P.O. BOX 101. PORTTOWNSEND, WASH. 98368 U.S.A parents, the family was * * * found living at various in SUBSCRIPTION PRICE- $18.95 PER YEAR. BACK ISSUES $5 EACH. tervals in Bourbon County,

* * * just south of Harrison Coun ty. And when his father England's scenic Lake District can best be charac moved to Rush Co., Indiana terized as a blend of its most famous creations — Sir Walter Scott, William Wordsworth and Peter Rabbit Cover Photo Therein lies the picturesque village of Cartmel and the architectural wonder of Cartmel Priory Church. But long This rare 5"generation before the legends of Lakeland came to pass, the photo from 19^7 shows four ancestor's of today's Cartmel, Cartmell, and Cartmill direct-line descendants of families were establishing themselves as the original Preston Cartmel, son of John Cartmel, Jr., of Harrison Co., family of Cartmel, England. Their descendants now Kentucky and Rush Co., Indi inhabit various parts of Great Britain, Canada, ana. They are, from left to Australia, New Zealand, Ireland, South Africa right, Sarah Jane Isley and the United Statea The C.C.C. Family Cartmel Wilder (wife of H onolher rison G. Cartmel), Vern A. senes Quarterly is our official family publication, from dedicated to the pursuit of genealogy and to Cartmel, Joy Juanita Cartmel mmiLY Barlow, her baby Linda R. puBucfinons promoting the virtue of our homeland. Barlow, and Scott Clifford Cartmel. around I83O, Preston must have left with him, or Joined up with the family '''^er. Although he was the ol dest, Preston waited until at least four of his other siblings had married before taking a spouse of his own. And when he finally did mar ry, he followed in the tra dition of the Cartmel/Cart- mell clan by selecting a wife much younger than him self. Born in 1821 in Indi ana, Harriet (maiden name unknown) was sixteen years his junior. Their first child, Melis sa, was born in I8A5. She was followed by Harrison G. who was born November 23, I8A8. About a year later the family appeared on the 1850 U.S. Census of Rush County in District 97- At that time, Preston was en gaged in farming and owned a ^izable piece of property in 3t region. In I85I, Sam uel A. was born. Their fourth and last child, Win- field Scott, was born Febru ary 9, iBsA. Preston left us little else that would help to piece together the story of his life. So far, we have been unsuccessful in loca ting his will, if one ex ists. His date of death, Maude "Minnie" Manship, born circa 1882, was the and that of his wife, remain first wife of Vern A. Cartmel. After her death in a mystery. However, we must 1918, Vern married her sister Lura May Manship. assume that both spent their last days in Rush County, book. We have condensed the As mentioned earlier, where the family continued complete list somewhat by Preston had three sons: Sam to l ive through several gen excluding some of the female uel A., Winfield Scott, and erations. Our three sup 1ines. Harrison G. Cartmel. Samuel pliers of information have Interestingly, and again A. was married to Mary R. promised to carry on the somewhat in the tradition of (maiden name unknown). She search of locating their our C.C.C. clan, this parti was born in 185^ and died in final resting places. cular Cartmel line produced 1910, the same year as her In the meantime, we can a larger proportion of fe husband. Both are burled in certainly appreciate the males, thereby contributing Rush County's Vienna Ceme /-^traordinary work that to the much smaller number tery. They are not positiv 3se three Indiana genealo of descendants still bearing ely known to have produced gists have done in preparing the family name. Out of a any children. However, we a list of Preston's descen total of 32 documented des have learned that a Thomas dants. As one might expect cendants of Preston born Cartmel, a farmer and later over such a long period of with the Cartmel surname, postmaster in Waldron, Indi time, the names could fill a only twelve have been males. ana, was probably the son of died in 1957' She had nine children, including Walter Dawson who was the father of our correspondent Mary Daw^^ son Rahe. Toi lie (or perhaps Til lie or Toilie?) was the youngest child of Harrison, born in 1896. She was married to a Mr. Coen, and died in 1975' Vern A. Cartmel is an In teresting case study in the Cartmel genealogy. Having married twice, first to Maude "Minnie" Manship, and later to her sister Lura May Manship, he produced two large families totall ing eleven children. (Only two of them were males.) From his first wife he had five offspring, and then another seven by her younger sister. These two sets of children were therefore not only ' half-brothers and sisters, but might also be considered cous i ns as wel11 Vern was born March 28, 1878, presumably in Rush County. In I90O he marrieu Maude "Minnie" Manship, born circa 1882. Their children included: Flossie Pearl , b. 1900, m. Floyd Barbee; Scott Clifford, b. April 6, 1902, m. Ruth Anita Mowbray on April 3, 1926, d. April 15" 17, 1977; Maisie Del l, b. 1904, m. Thomas Garrlty; Scott Clifford Cartmel and his wife, Ruth Anita Edith lamo (Imogene), b. Mowbray (both on the right), pose with friends in 1906, m. Henry Moreland; this wedding photo taken on April 3, 1926. Roxie Faye, b. I908, m. Nor man Cooper; and twins Clara Samuel or his brother Win- by 48 years. Harrison, who Marie b. 1916, m. Fred Mar field. was a swimming instructor, row, Chris Stomoff, and Winfield Scott, the youn drowned In Flat Rock River Jack Holland, and Mary Lou gest of Preston's children, on June 23, 1900 and was ise, b. 1916, m. Lewis Mc- is not known to have ever buried in the family plot in Guire. Clara Marie and Mary married. He died at the age Rush County. Afterwards, Louise are still al ive, and of 70 on July 1, 192^, and Sarah was remarried to a Mr. residing in Dayton, Ohio. is also buried in the Vienna Wilder. She too was buried Maude Cartmel, Vern's Cemetery. in the same cemetery upon first wife, died on August Harrison G. Cartmel was her death on July 18, 1948. 12 or 13, in 1916-1919- (Our 27 years old when he married Harrison and Sarah had at correspondents have clalm^^fc^ Sarah Jane Isley on June 11, least three children during both those dates and ever> 1876, in Rush County. She their 24-year marriage. year inbetween as the year - was eleven years younger They included: Vern A., of her death.) Vern then than him, having been born Minnie, and Toilie (sp?). married his wife's younger August 31, 1859. As it Minnie was born in I88O, sister Lura May Manship, who turned out, she outl ived him married Charles Dawson, and was born January 19, I896. Their marriage lasted 56 Ruth, who was born September ley J., b. March 9, 1958, years, up until Lura's death 2, 1909 in Roslyn Heights, m. Steven J. Neeley; Tina January 3, 1952. Eight New York, had two daughters, M., b. December 30, 1959, nths later, on October k, followed by a son who came m. John Lee Sanders; and i953> Vern also died and was almost 21 years after the Ricky A., b. October 20, buried in the Ogden Cemetery birth of their second daugh i960, m. Jalie Mae E. King. (also known as the Van Pelt ter. These offspring inclu Richard's third wife was or Valley Cemetery) in Og ded: Joy Juanita, b. April Marsha (maiden name un den, Shelby County, Indiana. 5, 1927, m. April 27. 19^6 known). They had no chil The children of Vern and to Floyd Thomas Barlow; Ger- dren of thei r own. Lura included: Fern El iza aldine "Jeri", b. August 31, Finally comes the most beth, b. April A, I92A, m. 1928, m. May 6, 19^7 to recent additions to the l ist Curtis E. McGinnis, Ralph Frederick J. Perkins; and of descendants of Preston Manual, d. November I8, Robert Allen, b. February 5, Cartmel. Ricky A. Cartmel 1955; Richard A. Cartmel, b. 19^9, m. December 31, 1977 and his wife Jal ie have had May 29, 1926, m. Violet Bel- to Karen McGee. Robert has three children so far, all more, Margaret Keith, Marsha three children of his own. in the 1980's. They are (maiden name unknown); Lil They are Heather McGee, b. Ricky A., Jr., b. July 15, lian Freida, b. January 9, August 30, 1979; Matthew I98O; Jayla R., b. November 1928, m. Lawrence E. Ford Robert, b. November 6, 1980; 6, 1981; and Brandon E., b. (5-30-19^5), Ed Murray, Lou and Christopher Earl, b. May January 13, 1983- is Stevens; Dorothy Cather 26, 1982. • ine, b. May 20, 1929, m. Vern's son by his second Our three suppliers of January 19, 19^9 to John wife, as listed earlier, was information for this article Marshall Boyd; and Norma Richard A. Cartmel. Richard include: Mary Rahe, R.R. May, b. October 21, 1933, m, was married three times. His #16, Box 313, Shelbyville, Leon Robertson (11-8-1952), first wife, Violet Belmore, Indiana, 46176; Geraldine John Snyder (1-15-1970). gave birth to Darlia (sp?), Perkins, 4110 Standish Dr., Scott Clifford Cartmel, b. March 22, 19^8, m. Rich Indianapolis, Indiana, irn's only son by his first ard Di lk. His second wife, 46241; and Dorothy C. Boyd, wife, had three children of Margaret Keith, gave him 124 W. Troy Ave., Indiana his own. He and his wife three more children: Shir polis, Indiana, 46225-

Scott Clifford Cartmel poses with four of his sisters in this 1908 photo. L to R: Maisie, Edith, Flossie, and baby Roxie. Scott's daughter, Geraldine C. Perkins, shows off her three sons in the photo on the right taken in 1981, Their names are Bill, Dennis, and John. Tracking tombstones in Indiana

By Mary Dawson Rahe

In November 1982, I wrote a letter to my father's cou sin, Scott Clifford Cartmel, asking for information on the Cartmel family. I used an address from the Indianapol is telephone book in my attempt to reach him. I received an answer from Geraldine Per kins, Scott's daughter, say ing that her father died— but that she too was interes ted in the Cartmel history! Geraldine introduced me to Dorothy Boyd by mail, and we discussed our ancestors. Dorothy is a half-sister to The Vienna Cemetery in Rush Co., Indiana i i Scott, and both were children the final resting place for several members of c of Vern A. Cartmel, and the Preston Cartmel family. Many descendant grandchildren of Harrison G. have remained in the area for an unbroken per [ Cartmel and Sarah Jane Isley. iod lasting more than ISO years. In fact. In (Harrison was a son of Pres diana is the ancestral home of the majority o i ton and Harriet Cartmel.) Cartmel families living in the U.S. today. The three of us correspon i ded and talked by telephone, and decided to meet for lunch sign of any sort. is known by three names— on August 21, 1983' Geral In addition to the graves Ogden, Van Pelt, and Valley. dine, her sister Joy, Doro of Harrison and Sarah, we The official name, and the thy, and I visited two ceme were also able to locate the name on the sign however is teries that afternoon. tombstones of three other Van Pelt. As the Vienna Cemetery is children of Preston Cartmel. The four of us searched near one of the former Cart They were Winfield Scott the cemetery, but could not mel farms, I decided that Cartmel , Mel issa Cartmel, find a gravestone for Vern. was a good place to start and Samuel A. Cartmel. Sam Later, the caretaker came looking. I had checked it uel's wife, Mary R., was al by, and after checking out a out earlier in the surrener so buried there. cemetery map, he took us and found Harrison and Sa We left Vienna Cemetery right to it. We were also rah's graves, so I knew this and drove to Van Pelt Ceme able to find four other fam was the place to take my tery, which is in Shelby ily members buried here, in new-found cousins. County, approximately five cluding Venn's sister Toilie The Vienna Cemetery is miles south of the small C. Coen, his first wife located on the east side of town of Waldron, Indiana, on Maude, their daughter Edith, the Rush-Shelby county line a bluff overlooking the and my grandmother Minnie C. road in Rush County, Indi junction of Conns Creek and Dawson, daughter of Harrison ana. There was once a Flat Rock River (where my Cartmel. church at this location, but great-grandfather Harrison I feel that in finding it had since been torn down. Cartmel drowned in 1900). these graves of our ances The land where it stood is Dorothy had gone to the tors, I am a step closer to now part of a farm field. funeral of her father (Vern finding the resting places For a time, the cemetery was A. Cartmel) and remembered of my g.g.grandparents, overgrown with weeds and going through Waldron, but Preston and Harriet Cartmej^.^ bushes. Now it has been didn't quite remember the I had to abandon my search mowed and is very neat, des cemetery, though Ogden did during the winter months, pite the fact that it is sound familiar. It is con but intend to resume the very small and without a fusing since this cemetery search again this spring. Barton Cartmel has many descendants

When Barton Cartmel was a young boy, he must have had a tough time learning to spell his full name. This son of John Cartmel, Jr., and brother of Preston, was born on December 29, 1827 in Cynthiana, Kentucky, and christened John David Barton Warren Stone Cartmel. His descendants tell us he was named after Barton I Warren Stone, one of the founders of the Disciples. John, of course, was a name also shared by his father and grandfather. The name David was probably bestowed upon him in honor of his ma ternal grandfather, David Scott. In 1850, at the age of 22, he was living with or near his sister and brother- in-law, Samuel and Martha D. ''^^nes, in District 97 of .jsh Co., Indiana. Two of his brothers, Preston and Sanford, were also living in this particular area at that time. The U.S. Census of that year showed him to be a A grandson of Barton, Oliver Roland Cartmel was laborer, probably working born in 1904 in Andersonville, Indiana. His two for his brother-in-law who sons, Thomas 0. and Jerry P., and their families, was a carpenter. still reside in the Hoosier State. Two years later, on No vember 11, 1852, Barton was their chiIdren. Their re Roxie, b. November 9, 1874, married to Eliza Ann John maining three children are d. September 1, I876. ston, who was born February now interred in the East It appears that Barton's 16, 1831. She was the Hill Cemetery in Rushville, son Atwell Roland never mar daughter of Atwell Johnston Indiana. ried. Of the other sons, and Marsha Lorinda. The These above-mentioned only Oliver Montz lived long family remained in Indiana children included: Scott enough to raise a family of for several generations, and B., b. April 19, I856, d. h i s own, wh i ch he did. descendants can still be March 27, 1872; Atwell Rol Ol iver M. Cartmel and his found in the state to this and, b. October 25, I858, d. wife Ida were probably mar very day. March 30, 1905; 01iver ried in Rush County. She Barton lived to the age Montz, b. December 12, i860, was born November 23, I87O, of 59 years and 10 months, m. Ida Maria Greer, d. April in Salt Creek Twp., Franklin passing away on September 14, 1916; Lorinda Pearl, b. Co., Indiana, the daughter 17, 1887 in Andersonvi1le, February I866, m. George Val of Will iam Vincent Greer and idiana. His wife died 30 Conway, d. 1925; Frank B., Tamson Throckmorton. Ol iver years later in Andersonvi1le b. March 11, I868, d. Sep died April 14, 1915- Ida on February 1, 1917- Both tember 17, 1876; Australia passed away in May 1964. were buried in the Hopewell (Trella), b. May 14, 1854, Both are buried in Rush Cemetery where they were m. Wi ll iam H. Reese, d. 1930 ville. joined later by four of (lived near Greenfield); and The children of Oliver M. and Ida Greer Cartmel inclu riet was also married at one maintaining their Indiana ded: Marguerite, b. January time to Sylvan Tackitt. roots. 9, 1895, m. May 6, 1916 to William and Harriet had no Thomas Oliver Cartmel Omar Hurton Issacs; Oliver children of their own as far born September 10, 1933 Ir. Roland, b. July 7, 190^, m. as we are able to determine. Rushville, Indiana. For January 21, 1928 in Dayton, Oliver Roland Cartmel, quite some time he was the Ohio to Ina Ruth Patterson, the only other son of Oli head of a prestigious law d. August 12, 1950; Will iam ver M., was married to Ina firm in Indianapolis, known Barton, b. April 8, 1909, rri. R. Patterson, daughter of as Cartmel, Carvey, Latimer, August 5, 19^7 in Franklin, Normal Vorhess Patterson and Howard, and McLin, Attorneys Indiana to Harriet Clark Lillian May Cloud. She was at Law. However, judging by Martin, d. February 1967 in born May 17, 1905 in Brook- the letterhead of a recent Martinsvi1le, Indiana; and vllle. Franklin Co., Indi correspondence, it now ap Elizabeth Carolyn, b. Octo ana. pears he is associated with ber 2k, 1915, m. Robert Had it not been for Oli the law firm known as Cart McDonald— on March 16, ver R., the male line des mel & Sellmer of the same 193^. cended from Barton Cartmel city. William Barton Cartmel would have ended many years His first wife was Anne married at the age of 38. ago. However, this misfor Louise Stahly of Berne, In His wife, Harriet, was born tune was avoided by the diana. Their children in May 1, 1909 in Frankl in, In births of Thomas Oliver and cluded: Thomas Frederick, diana. She was the daughter Jerry Patterson Cartmel— b. August 30, 1963; Cynthia of Harry Jackson Martin and both of whom are living to Anne, b. October 15, 1965; Estelle Collins Clark. Har day and quite content in and Todd Barton, b. July 30,

Although we are not fortunate enough to have a photo of Barton, the progen itor of this Cartmel line, his wife Eliza Ann Johnston is shown above. She is flanked by daughters Lorinda Cartmel Conway on the left, and Australia Cartmel Reese on the right. 197^* Thomas was married later to Barbara L. (mai- name unknown). Unfor- Cartmel .CaTvejp,latimer Thomas O. Cartmel JOHN C. Carvey .nately, we are unable to Horoarl) -ot^ TUdin Robert w. Latimer provide the names of the Robert A. Howard children of this union, al ATTORNEYS AT LAW William C. McLin

though a photograph of the 9333 North Meridian combined families accompan Suite 110 Eugene G. Ziobron Sam Stoehr ies this article. Indianapolis. Indiana 46260 Jerry Patterson Cartmel, the second son of Oliver R., was born July 2^, 1936, in Dianne include: Scott Pat the Cartmel ancestry. It Rushville, Indiana. A den terson, b. July 30, I96O; was with their help that I tist by profession, l iving Jul lanne, b. July 31, 1962; was first able to substan In Seymour, Indiana, Jerry David Stuart, b. April 13, tiate my connection with Is married to Dianne Johnson 1965; and James Patrick, b. their Kentucky and Indiana of Indianapolis. The couple September 30, 1968. ancestors. was married December 21, • They may be contacted by 1958 in Seymour. Dianne, we I would like to take this writing to either Thomas 0. are happy to say, has been opportunity to thank and Cartmel, 9333 N. Meridian very helpful in researching commend Thomas and Jerry St. #110, Indianapolis, In various aspects of the Cart Cartmel and their famil ies diana, A626O, or Jerry P. mel 1 i ne. for all the research they Cartmel, A7I Lasher Drive, The children of Jerry and have done over the years on Seymour, Indiana, 4727^.

A new generation of Cartmels is seen here in a photograph taken during the 1983 Christmas season. This marvelous looking group belongs to Attorney Thom as Oliver Cartmel and his wife Barbara of Indianapolis, Indiana. It looks like there is little danger of this line disappearing. LD. Cartmill is sweet on snakes

The fonowing article his snakes, he works as a the subject of lectures he's about Larry D. Cartmil l of guidance counselor at Hun- given at the school and Barboursvilie, West Virginia tington High School. And other institutions in vari first appeared in the Hevaid even there the snakes are ous parts of the country. Dispatcht and was written by often a part of what he "My goal is to educate reporter Mara Rose. We does. He has used them as people about snakes," he would like to thank Mr. Wal ter Hatten of Norwich, Con necticut for sending it to us. • A guard dog may provide great security against burg lars, but Larry Cartmill says he doesn't need guard dogs and he doesn't worry about intruders. Cartmill swears by his 12-foot python. And if by chance that should fail, he has backups, another large python, a rat tlesnake, a boa constrictor, and five other species, which he keeps in glass ac- quariums in his Barbours vi 1 le home. Cartmill, a spare-time herpetologist, has a fascin ation for the limbless rep- tiles. Snakes are better to have around than dogs or cats, Cartmill said. "They don't bark or make any noise at all. They don't have any odor. They don't have fur so they don't get fleas or ticks. A snake is easy to care for." "As far back as I can re member 1 was always catching them and putting them in bottles. 1 can't ever re member not being interested in them," Cartmill said. "1 don't keep them just to have an unusual pet. Snakes don't make good pets. A snake does not become af fectionate. It doesn't know its owner. It is not an an imal you can cuddle up Larry D. Cartmill of Barboursville, West Vir with," he said, as a 10-foot ginia, is one of the world's most avid snake lov python coiled about his neck ers. He was recently seen on the front page of a and shoulders. local newspaper with this 10-foot python wrapped When Cartmill is not with precariously around his neck. sa id. said. "Most often what they like we are having now, It is the lack of know die from is a heart attack quite a few people find ledge many people have about or shock." snakes in their homes be ''^em, along with their trust It is not instinctive for cause snakes can't tolerate ..I movies which exploit the snakes to attack humans, extreme temperatures," he animal as a man eater that Cartmill said. "A snake said. leads so many to fear will run first if it can. Larry takes the time to snakes, Cartmill suggests. Most often a snake will see retrieve the animals from "I have neighbors and you before you see him." his neighbors' homes because friends who won't come in "Although snakes are he doesn't want to see them the house. They will come deaf, they can feel vibra killed for any reason, es to the door, but they won't tions on the ground." That pecial ly not for the use of come in because they are way they're able to surprise thei r ski ns. terrified of snakes," he thei r prey, he said. "I am 100 percent against said. Cartmill's snakes are fed the exploitation of the ani Pausing a moment and smi live mice and rats twice a mal ," he said. ling, Cartmill recalled a month. "Sometimes I feed I do not buy snake skin time when a salesman came to the pythons chickens," he belts or boots. I hate to the house and wouldn't said. "The snakes stretch see the native population leave. their jaws and swallow the destroyed," he added. "My wife went into the rodents and the chickens "Most people would say room and took out a few whole." that the only good snake Is snakes and let them go in Cartmill says it is very a dead snake. That is not the hallway. She told the unl ikely that a snake could true. They have their place salesman that we exercise actually swallow a man. in the ecology and they them every evening." "Although the jaws of the would much rather just be "It was just seconds be animal do stretch a great left alone," he said. fore the salesman packed up deal, it is not likely that Cartmill has had as many things and took to the they would be able to as 25 snakes in his home at or," Cartmi ll laughed. stretch enough to allow the one time. "I have friends He added, however, that shoulders of a full-grown across the country and we it is not his practice to man to pass through." trade snakes." use the snakes to frighten Observing his snakes ly But he doesn't often keep people. "If someone is ing motionless in their ac- them for very long. "I ob really terrified by snakes, quariums, Cartmi l l pointed serve them and I experiment I won't force the snakes on out that the stretching of with them," he said. "I them," he said. their jaws is not their only have learned to give them But the fear Is learned, remarkable feature. Each of injections and vitamins." he believes. "There are them is unique in Its skin Cartmill's snakes are his more people struck by light pattern and texture. hobby. "I spend a lot of ning than bitten by snakes, "They are pretty," Larry time with them. But I'm not and most of those who are said. "And they are escape crazy for having snakes. I bitten are people who keep artists. When you keep like them. I just like snakes in their homes." snakes you learn that fast," them. I always have." "A snake is more afraid he added. • of a human than a human is "A snake can get in and For our Cartmi ll genealo of a snake," he said. out of almost anything," he gists, we are unable to of Cartmi ll claims that a sa i d. fer any information about snake will bite only when it Cartmi 1 1 said he has Larry's family history. How is cornered or senses Its spent evenings searching the ever, fellow snake lovers life is threatened. homes of neighbors who have may contact him at 170A Cen In the many years he has called him about snakes that tral Avenue, Barboursvi1le. handled snakes, Cartmi ll has have gotten into their West Virginia, 2550A. His only been bitten once—by a houses. telephone number Is 30A-736- ,-^pperhead. "When we have weather 3678. "More people In this "^untry are bitten by cop perheads than any other ven omous snake. But only one person out of 1,000 dies from a copperhead bite," he coaches were known locally as "dillies" and held a doz en passengers inside and Grange and more on top as well as 1m,^N gage.

Cartmel CARK

Prior to 1781 described A Practical Guide as "one of the prettiest ru for Visitors ral villages in northern ttl England, with whitened, Compiled by "Cumbria" rush-thatched cottages, a Illustrated by J. J. Thomlinson running stream, a corn mill, a cloth fulling mill, a pa per mi ll, an antiquated RAVENSTOWN A more fortunate survival forge and a comfortable lit is nearby Canon Winder, un tle inn beside the bridge." Known at the time of Its til recently known as Chanon After this date the vil building during the first Winder. This Tudor building lage became one of the very world war as Flookburgh stands in a superb setting few places In Cartmel to be West. It was intended as an on the edge of the Leven es affected by the early indus estate for workers at an ad tuary, Its glorious isola trial revolution. A large joining airship factory, but tion only disturbed by the cotton mill, workers' cotta no sooner had the works been sighing of the wind in the ges, workshops and engine constructed than the scheme surrounding marshes and the houses were erected by the was cancelled. occasional walker on foot. Stockdale family, who also Messrs. Vickers of Barrow The outbuildings feel the founded shipbuilding yards took over the houses, which brunt of westerly gales. The on the estuary of the Eea. are now mainly owner-occu house retains an enormous The public house near pied. Southwards the road circular chimney at the bridge over this river was leads to Raven Winder, for back, a spiral staircase and (and still Is) called the merly one of the great farm- much oak panell ing. Both Eng-tne Inn after James halls of the district and Raven and Canon Winder are Watt's newly-invented pump dating back to at least the part of the Holker Estates. ing engine. One of these 13th century. A century ago Close by Is Sandygate engines was used to pump the it was partially pulled down which coaches used to ap water out of the mill dam to make it more habitable, proach the Leven estuary back into the tail race. and the stones were used for when journeying from Lancas A brewery and a pottery improving farm buildings. ter to Ulverston. These were also erected at this time, but Cark's phase of industrialization was extre mely short-lived and today only the Industrial arch aeologist is likely to be instantly aware that it ever existed. A pale shadow of the past is seen In the shrimp factory, which was opened in the early 1950's at the head of the vil lage. Cark Hall, not to be con fused with the less archi tecturally prepossessing building of the same name at High Cark near Field Brou Cark Hall doorwa; ton, tends to be overlookeci- because of its nearness to "On the imposing doorway is the now sadly the showplace of Holker weathered coat-o£-arms o£ Robert Rawlinson." Hall. It is the much older building of the two, the re- cords going back to 1582. and furniture was entirely 10:30 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. Originally the seat of the destroyed by fire. The sub There is a gift shop, chil famous Curwen family, the sequent reconstruction gave dren's farm and an adventure -'^^11 was later held by the Holker a solid, Victorian playground. A hot air bal dwlinsons for nine genera look, but the hall is never loon makes ascents on Bank tions extending through 300 theless a pleasing amalgam Holidays and alternate Sun years. On the imposing of architectural styles. days, weather permitting. A doorway is the now sadly Guests in recent times major event in the Hall weathered coat-of-arms of have included the late Queen grounds is the Lakeland Rose Robert Rawlinson, granted in Mary, the Duke and Duchess Show, generally held on the 1662 when he became a Jus of Gloucester, and Princess second weekend in July. It tice of Charles 1 1. Margaret who stayed with the is noted for its displays of Notable features of the present owners—Mr. and Mrs. roses, carnations, sweet building are the pointed ga Richard Cavendish—in 1958. peas, fuchsias and floral bles, circular stepped chim Holker's gardens are art. neys, a passage which was sheltered from the cold One of the outstanding formerly battlements, and a winds, and l ike those at walks in the area starts al priest hole connected to a -Grange contain many trees most opposite the entrance "secret" staircase descen and shrubs rarely found in gates to the hall and winds ding to the malt house, as the north. Early scarlet up through the Holker plan well as much fine woodwork. rhododendrons in February tations to Cartmel Park and There is reputed to be a give way to camel ias, magno Cartmel village. On the re tunnel leading to Cartmel lias and flowering cherries, claimed low-lying land to Priory. which in turn are followed the north of Holker roads by roses, lil ies, hydrangeas and tracks lead towards HOLKER and heathers. A herd of Frith and the remains of the fallow deer in the park is ancient Frith Hall. Beyond An estate village com one of the largest and old this point, and overlooking pletely dominated by Holker est establ ished in the coun Greenodd in Furness, is ^^11, seat of the Cavendish- try. Roudsea Wood Nature Reserve, for over 200 years and The whole of this book owned by the Holker Estates one of the very few stately could be filled with a de but closely l inked with homes open to the publ ic in tailed description of Holker Merlewood research station. the north-west. and its many art treasures, It was originally a coppice The hall was erected at but fortunately a room-by- wood, although the aim is to the end of the l6th century room guide is available at bring it back to the status by George Preston on land the hall which is open daily of a high forest and at the belonging to Cartmel Priory; except Saturdays from Easter same time study the process the close connection between to the end of September from of natural regeneration. the two best-known buildings in the district has always been maintained. The estate passed by mar riage to Sir William Lowther who demolished the original hall and rebuilt "in a more elegant style." Additions were made by Lord George Ca vendish in the late l8th century, but in iBAO the house was entirely rebuilt in a style closely resem ■«*%I bling the original building I"" : '

still Owns Land 1858," I wonder if you meant items as you mentioned, but that Martin R. purchased it would welcome the Initiative I would like to offer then, or If you meant to say of one of our readers. We some Information which t your brother Charles bought are printing the obituary have regarding the John H. it in 19581 If you were you sent us below. For fur Cartmell, Sr. who was l isted speaking of Martin, as it ther information on this in Profiles of Other Knaim seems you are, then he evi Australian family, turn to Johns, in the Winter 1983 dently paid for the land in our Spring 1983 issue. issue. advance of his arrival in I DEATHS Tisl He was born in Frederick this state in 1859 as you CAHTMHO^ Roy Clvkerke Of 23 Saint Acha St. Nudoee. Co., Virginia in 1802 and already pointed out. away at princ.rince Cnv'es HMpltal on 27tn Mai*, 1983. Beloved Husb^dib^d of vlda, .Father. Father-tn-law •d Grandfather of MarllyTt and Doii^aa. Barttara and died circa 1866 in White Trev<^. CIvke and Ann. Irene and Albert and their Famiiiee, Brother of Harold Bowen C^mill (dec'd) Co., Indiana. These dates George Edwin Cartmlll (dec'd) and William John Canmlll. Privately Interred at Toowong Cemetery on Coat-of-arms Soih May. idS^ At Rest '. correspond to those of my ALEX Cow NEW8TEAD PH SB 1601 Great-Grandfather, Martin Do you think members of Reynolds Cartmell, who came the C.C.C. families would be to White County from Clark interested enough to have Missouri Obit Co., Ohio in I859. He was copies of the Cartmel coat- I thought you might be accompanied by his brother, of-arms made as stickers for interested in this obituary John H. Cartmell. Both took cars or some other form? which appeared in our locak land close to Monticello, Also, does the coat-of-arms newspaper on May 9, 1984. and my brother Charles M. carry any motto? What about Maida Whitten, Editor Cartmell still owns most of a badge? Kansas City Genealogist Martin R.'s home place which I would also like to sub Kansas City Public Lib. he bought in April I858 and mit a recent obituary for 311 E. 12th Street which he added to later. Roy Clarke Cartmi11. Kansas City, MO 64106 From Harold Carter's Wi 1 1iam L. Cartmi11 write-up in no.6 of The WILLIAM E. CAFTTMELL kS Wade Street William E. Cartmell. 88, Eagle Rock, C,C,C» Family Quarterly, I'm Nundah Apt. Ij012 Mo., formerly of Kansas City, died Mon sure the above John H. was day at a hospital in Monett, Mo. He was Brisbane, Queensland bomin Bloomington, 111., and lived in Kan the father of Harold's Austral la sas City before he moved to Eagle Rock 21 grandmother, Mary Ann Cart NOTE: Although a coat-of- years ago. Mr. Cartmell was a shoe sales man for Showalter's Foot Health Shoe mell, who married Edwin R. arms belongs solely to the Store for 27 years before he retired in 1962. Carter here in Monticello He was a Methodist. He was an Army vet family to which it is gran eran of World War I. He leaves his wife, in 1866. ted, and to the oldest son Mrs. Audrey Cartmell of the home; a son. I do hope this will help Thomas F. Cartmell, Pierce City. Mo.; a thereafter, most of us are txDther, Phillip Cartmell,Prairie Village: someone who wanted informa content to identify with and thr^ grandchildren. Cremation. The tion on John H. Cartmell, family suggests contributions to the Ea^e the arms displayed within Rock Ambulance Service or to the Eagle Sr. Anyone needing help the Cartmel Priory Church in Rock Fire D^iartment. from White County records, I Cartmel, England. They were will be glad to correspond reproduced in our Winter Hunting Hattons with them! 1981 issue. The same arms, Frieda Cartmell Brown or very similar ones, were I am a direct descendant 807 Fairwood Drive granted to James Austen- of Samuel Hatton/Hatten, Sr. Monticel lo, IN ^7960 Cartmell, Esquire, of 100 who came to America before NOTE: You're right about Lexham Gardens, Kensington, the Revolutionary War. Hi>-v John H. Sr. being the father and New Square, Lincoln's son, Phillip Hatton, Sr., of Mary Ann Cartmell. Our Inn, London, date unknown. married Jane Cartmlll, and records indicate the same The accompanying family mot my Hatton line descends di thing. Regarding the Monti to is Immer frey which means rectly from them. cello property which you "always free." We have no I have the date of Jane's said "he bought in April plans to market any such birth as June 15, 1788 or 1790. Phillip was born Botetourt and Augusta Co., Walton. C.W. Cartmell had June 20, 1785 in Washington Virginia. According to our his name changed from Cart- JgO. y Maryland. The couple correspondent Rev. C. Clif mitl. He was the son of "^s married in 1805 in Law- ford Caverlee of 1275 Hun- Will iam Marion Cartmill and 1 ence Co., Kentucky. Their tington Ave., Huntington, Serepta Ellis, and the children, all born in Cabell West Virginia, there was a grandson of James Henry Co., West Virginia, included: Jane who was the daughter of Cartmill, Sr. and Lucinda Cartmel Hatton, b. iBH, m. Henry Cartmill, son of John Stephens. James H. was the IB37 in Lawrence Co., Ohio and grandson of Henry, Sr. son of Henry Cartmill and to Mary Wellman, d. lB35"37; John's brother, Henry Jr., Isabel 1 Bogan. In turn, Samuel Carpenter, b. Feb had a son named Thomas who Henry was the son of John ruary 20, IBI6, m. 1840 in might very well be the fa Cartmill, and the grandson Lawrence Co., Kentucky to ther of your Jane. For more of Henry Cartmill, Sr., Sarah Cyrus, d. September information, please read the I7I6-I786. Rev. C. Clifford 22, 1901 in Bethany, Mis next two letters! Caverlee, mentioned earlier, souri; Lorenzo Dow, b. IB18, claims this line is origin m. Mary (Ana?) Riggs, d. Hatton Hound ally from Kings County Ire Texas; Miriam (Myra), b. land, although we have been IB20, m. Lance (or Lane) 1 saw your ad in the Gen- unable to trace it beyond John Shannon; Edward (or Ed eaZogicaZ Helper and since Chester Co., Pennsylvania. win), b. 1B2^, m. Mary Jane some of my Hatton relatives We will attempt to sort this Hines; Eliza, b. 1827, m. married Cartmil ls in West out further at another time. George Gilkerson, Joseph Virginia and Kentucky, I Shannon; Phillip, Jr., b. thought I'd check to see if Chasin' Nathan IB32, m. Rhuehamma Riggs, you know of them. Mary F. Jarrell; and Jane, The one marriage which I I have a copy of the in b. 183^, m. William Shannon. can find at the moment is ventory of Nathar)^ Carlmell^.. I have come to the con- that of Phillip Hatton, Sr., deceased on the 7th day of Jusion that the only logi- and Jane Cartmill. Her fa January I805, together with 1 link between the early ther was Thomas Cartmill. the sale of some of his pro cartmelIs on your chart on There are CartmelIs in my perty. It was signed by.,^a- pp. 14-15 of CartmelZ hometown area of Huntington, cob Cartn^H and^atharins,?,^ P" ioneers is through Thomas Cabell Co., West Virginia, "Cartmel 1 Administrators, Cartmel 1, listed as #6, the and Wayne County, as well as and filed at a county court son of Nathaniel Cartmell I Boyd and Lawrence Co., Ken for Bul litt Co., Kentucky on of Frederick Co., Virginia. tucky. the 12th day of August. The Vera Hatten Scott There are other Hattons County Clerk says there was 2719 Tenth Street who married Cartmells. I no wil l, but the inventory Baker, OR 97814 would be happy to swap quer Is in Will Book A, page 18. WTE: I have to tel 1 you ies. Sales were made ta^Ca.thia&LOiet-^ that is a very broad assump Walter E. Hatten, Director Cartme 11 ^ El.i La.h.-. CartiTielJ., tion since there is no evi Hatton Heritage Assoc. and Mrs. among dence that this Thomas ever 8 Ash Road manVotliers. This is prob- married. However, you will Norwich, CT 06360 see in the following letter I el I I. that another Hatton resear Illinois Inquiry •""""^''^^CTsoT I found a marriage cher agrees her father was bond which indicates that my named Thomas Cartmill. I I am the grandson of ^ was born can tell with fairly reliable Charles Warren Cartmell who in Bull itt-^o., Kentucky in certainty that your Jane was born July 17» I870 at 1831 • Cartmill probably was tied Lodi, Iroquois Co., Illi J.J. Mitchener, Jr. in somehow with the Putnam nois. I recently learned of 11285 Black Forest Co., West Virginia Cartmill your quarterly. Since I'm a Colorado Springs, CO clan. Cabell County and Cartmell descendant, I would 80908 /-^tnam County are neighbors like to learn more about the far western section your newsletter. Our letters are pi l ing up, uf that state. This Putnam Luckey Walton so look for an expanded sec County family is apparently 7500 S. 234th East Ave. tion in the next issue. Also, descended from Henry Cart Broken Arrow, OK 740l4 a new Cartmi l l series begins mill, Sr., of Chester Co., NOTE: We have forwarded the with our Fal l 1984 edition. Pennsylvania and later of requested information to Mr. ♦♦♦>4 ♦♦♦♦ ♦-f ♦-f f Then when I was quite few raids and stole horses. young, before Mother died, With the horses having been I Reminiscences I spiritualism was engrossing taken, my uncle had to re i of the incidents i the mind of the world. The sort to an ox team to do h in'the life of 4 Fox sisters with their rap- farm work. They were slow I Mrs: Jiiiinie-Gricr Gartiiiel | pings were attracting great and ungainly, but "necessity ♦ ♦-^♦♦♦♦♦♦4^»-»^4444444^^^4^ interest with the reading is said to be the mother of public. When the papers invention," and someone in INSTALLMENT XV! 1 1 came Father would read them vented a yoke that supplied aloud to Mother, not think the place of a harness. It There was a scary story ing I suppose that i paid was remarkable how sagacious going the rounds of the the least attention. I these dumb brutes were. neighborhood that a headless would be playing with my They were named Tom and Jer man was often seen in the dolls, but I was listening ry. twil ight, riding in the to their reading, and their My uncle would lay the woods nearby. One night my comments, and it left an im yoke on Tom's neck and say, uncle was standing out in pression on my mind that "come under Jerry," and to the yard after dark and nothing but time effected. one's astonishment he would heard a scream like a cry of walk up and offer his neck a woman, when again it to be yoked. Where does in screamed. He hurried into stinct leave off and intel the house to see if we were ligence begin is a question all there. He said he never one might ask now. Then to heard anything more real. see them turn to the right There was a stream of wa or left by the word of ter close by with timber for mouth, gee and haw, gee to quite a ways on each side the right and haw to the and he supposed it was some left. wild animal, as he did not It seemed as wonderful tCL^ give credence to the head me as the milk coming out less story, but I had always the cow was to my little been afraid of ghosts, and nephew, Harold Corkhill, all kinds of hobgobblins. when he made us a visit and The negroes are great on JENNIE 6RIER CARTMEL went with his uncle to milk. telling children these stor 1844-1926 He came in and told his mam ies and the old women of the ma he had always thought mountains can entertain you for an evening with weird milk came out of a can, so One should be very careful we have to learn by experi stories of bears, panthers, what they say before chil ence. and other ferocious animals dren. They are more acute The ox team did very well that infested the country in than they are given credit to prepare the ground for the early day. for. the corn, but I do not think I remember one told me. I have digressed some and they would have answered to The mother was left alone gone back to early childhood plow the corn, but fortune one night with her baby. She memories, but tell ing of the favored, and a blind horse heard the panther's scream skeleton started a train of was procured. Dr. Hepler coming closer and closer— thought that reached to the found her somewhere in Kan what would she do? She subconscious mind and un hugged the babe in her arms; sas and sent her to the locked that store house of ranch. She proved a trea she was sitting by the fire times savings I wi11 now re sure. She was larger and place. The panther came sume. strong and could plow the nearer, finally to the very 1862 was another good corn seemingly as well as if door, but not succeeding in crop year. It seemed the she could see. making an entrance he began weather man was trying to I would mount her even to climb the chimney. Hor make up for the terrible ings with only a girth for^rfKy rors, horrors! What would punishment he had inflicted saddle and go in a lope ov she do? She threw on some on us in i860. the prairie rounding up the dry wood making a hotter The greatest trouble we blaze, and finally succeeded had was some who had gone cattle for the night. Oh, but it was fun. She seemed in keeping the vicious ani south, organized into bands mal at bay. of bushwhackers, and made a to know I had eyes for her. / ) '■^ iki Jrif ja ■

)

) jSZ_

/ /

Lv-z:^:--^ /< Iff ^iLMJ-l} C-'^^ (po-t c^/

— /- ^

/■^ A^c) lAY u/fpe S'UJh H OnAnh^u ds.L £!5_3^. B/ATA/ - cy y/^'s_

y^ c^y^// 7 8A TH CoU/m{

7oJiN_7BAl.H e L/- - 7^ t,.. ^ AT ^ ^L y I'BctnI o<^l<\A (^fs-

"^/sz ')

^aJ

/y^-x^ op ^ ^ ^

^yfy-.^y' '3^ R-f^ R-Afi-TMeLt- Oa^^lc

/f^ Zi 7^//^/ (2^ ti ^ iM

AA dA. 5c7 At^/

^ ^ ^ ^'Atcc.' Cdi .^-2 c'tRC^cJ-l

r/r )

X^cc^ Xa Mo

/^J(X '^- M MX 9

// f/0o /^•577z?/^ 3^/ -O O^—<0